First Four
The First Four constitutes the preliminary play-in games of the NCAA Division I men's and women's basketball tournaments, comprising four single-elimination contests held in Dayton, Ohio, to reduce the initial 68-team field to 64 for the main bracket.[1][2] Introduced in 2011 alongside the expansion of the men's tournament from 65 to 68 teams, the format pits the four lowest-seeded automatic qualifiers—typically champions of smaller conferences—against each other in two games, with the other two games matching the four lowest-seeded at-large bids.[1][3] Winners of the automatic qualifier matchups advance as No. 16 seeds to face No. 1 seeds in the Round of 64, while at-large winners enter as No. 11 seeds, providing underdog teams an opportunity to extend Cinderella runs, as exemplified by Virginia Commonwealth University's advancement to the 2011 Final Four.[3][4] Traditionally hosted at the University of Dayton Arena since its inception, the First Four kicks off March Madness with heightened atmosphere, though participating teams historically face steep odds of deep tournament progression.[2][3]History
Pre-First Four Opening Round (2001–2010)
In 2001, the NCAA Division I men's basketball tournament expanded from 64 to 65 teams by introducing a single opening round play-in game between the champions of the two lowest-rated conferences according to the NCAA's selection metrics, such as all-time winning percentage and conference strength.[5] This change accommodated the addition of an automatic bid for the Mountain West Conference, increasing automatic qualifiers to 31 without reducing the 34 at-large selections that filled the main 64-team bracket.[5] The play-in winner received a #16 seed and advanced to face a #1 seed in the first round, preserving the bracket's structure while addressing the empirical increase in Division I conference memberships from 31 to 32.[5][6] The inaugural game on March 13, 2001, at University of Dayton Arena featured Northwestern State (Southland Conference) defeating Winthrop (Big South Conference) 71–67, highlighted by Larry Hancock's three-pointer with one minute remaining to secure the victory.[7][8] Northwestern State then lost to #1 Wisconsin 61–47 in the first round.[7] This format persisted annually through 2010, with the game consistently hosted at Dayton Arena and involving automatic qualifiers from smaller conferences, typically those ranked lowest by NCAA criteria.[9] During this period, play-in winners included Siena in 2002 (81–77 over Alcorn State), Austin Peay in 2003 (77–56 over Vermont), Manhattan in 2004 (75–56 over Florida A&M), and others such as UNC Asheville (2005), Florida A&M (2007), and Arkansas Baptist (2010, though typically low-major autos).[9] None of the 10 play-in winners advanced beyond the first round, underscoring the competitive disparity between small-conference champions and major tournament seeds.[7] The structure reflected causal realism in tournament design: it empirically mitigated dilution of higher-quality at-large teams by isolating low-probability advancement to one contested spot among automatic bids, amid Division I's growth to over 300 teams and stable at-large slots.[5]| Year | Winner | Score | Opponent | Conference of Winner |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2001 | Northwestern State | 71–67 | Winthrop | Southland |
| 2002 | Siena | 81–77 | Alcorn State | MAAC |
| 2003 | Austin Peay | 77–56 | Vermont | OVC |
| 2004 | Manhattan | 75–56 | Florida A&M | MAAC |
| 2005 | UNC Asheville | 65–60 | High Point | Big South |
| 2006 | Milwaukee | 68–60 | Holy Cross | Horizon |
| 2007 | Florida A&M | 58–57 | Niagara | MEAC |
| 2008 | Mount St. Mary's | 81–79 (OT) | Coppin State | NEC |
| 2009 | Robert Morris | 77–62 | North Carolina Central | NEC |
| 2010 | Winthrop | 74–70 | Arkansas-Pine Bluff | Big South |