Fact-checked by Grok 2 weeks ago

Giant Arc

The Giant Arc is a vast crescent-shaped structure composed of galaxies, galactic clusters, gas, and dust, spanning approximately 3.3 billion light-years (about 1 gigaparsec) across the sky in the constellation . Located at a of around 0.8, it lies roughly 9.2 billion light-years from , making it one of the largest known cosmic structures and a potential challenge to the , which posits that the is homogeneous and isotropic on large scales. Discovered in 2021 through observations of magnesium II absorbers in spectra, the arc's near-symmetrical form and immense scale suggest it formed early in the 's history, possibly through gravitational interactions or large-scale density fluctuations. This megastructure, which subtends about 10 degrees on the , encompasses hundreds of galaxies and is comparable in size to other debated cosmic anomalies like the , though its arc-like morphology distinguishes it. Its discovery has prompted reevaluation of cosmic models, as simulations under the standard Lambda-CDM framework predict such features to be exceedingly rare, with probabilities as low as 0.003% for structures of this magnitude. Analyses as of 2025 estimate it occupies about 1/15th of the observable universe's diameter, but recent studies, including a May 2025 analysis, question its coherence as a genuine filamentary structure, suggesting it may instead be a common pattern in large-scale structure simulations rather than an observational artifact or rarity. Further studies using advanced telescopes continue to probe the arc's composition and distribution, aiming to clarify its role in understanding the universe's large-scale architecture. While some researchers question the of such "giant" features due to incomplete sky surveys, the Giant Arc remains a pivotal example of how observations can test foundational cosmological assumptions.

Discovery

Initial Detection

The Giant Arc was first announced in June 2021 by , a student at the Jeremiah Horrocks Institute, , during a presentation at the 238th meeting of the (AAS). This discovery highlighted a novel application of absorption line to map large-scale structures, building on established techniques for tracing cosmic web filaments and walls. The full analysis was published in 2022. The detection relied on analyzing spectra of distant quasars from the (SDSS), where intervening magnesium II (MgII) absorption lines serve as proxies for foreground galaxies and intergalactic gas clouds. Lopez identified a coherent of these absorbers forming an arc-like , specifically 44 MgII systems in the principal agglomeration that spanned approximately 10 degrees on the sky. This pattern emerged serendipitously during visual and statistical examinations of MgII catalogues compiled by Zhu & Ménard, confirming the structure's non-random nature through tests like the Cuzick-Edwards statistic and minimal analysis. The structure lies at a mean of z \approx 0.8, placing it at a of approximately 9.2 billion light-years (look-back time ≈ 7.2 billion years), when the was about half its current . Initial findings indicated a depth of around 340 Mpc along the , with the absorbers clustered in a way that suggested an overdensity of \delta \rho / \rho \sim 1.3 \pm 0.3, underscoring the arc's significance as a potential filamentary feature in the cosmic web.

Observational Methods

The detection of the Giant Arc relies on spectroscopic surveys of distant quasars to identify intervening absorption features that trace foreground gas associated with galaxies. The primary data source is the (SDSS), particularly Data Releases 7 and 12, which provide spectra for over 123,000 quasars. These spectra reveal Mg II absorption doublets at rest-frame wavelengths of 2796 and 2803 , produced by magnesium ions in cool gas clouds (typically at redshifts z ≈ 0.4–2.2) along the line of sight. Strong absorbers, defined by equivalent widths W_r ≥ 0.6 for the 2796 line, are particularly indicative of galaxy-scale structures and were cataloged in the Zhu & Ménard (2013) database containing 63,876 such systems. Mapping the Giant Arc involved analyzing the spatial distribution of these Mg II absorbers in angular coordinates ( and ) and redshift space to identify coherent alignments. The structure was identified by clustering of absorbers symmetric around approximately RA 14^h and declination +40° in , subtending an angular scale of approximately 10 degrees on the sky. This pattern emerged from visual inspection of absorber maps combined with automated cross-matching of quasar sightlines, processing thousands of lines of sight to highlight non-random groupings at z ≈ 0.8. Clustering techniques for aided in sifting through the large dataset to detect filamentary overdensities amid noise from unrelated absorbers. To assess the statistical significance of the alignment and reject hypotheses of random distribution, the analysis employed multiple complementary methods. The 2-point correlation function measured excess clustering compared to isotropic expectations, while the Cuzick-Edwards test evaluated linear coherence along the arc's axis, yielding a 3.0σ deviation. A 2D version of the P(s) test further quantified planar symmetry, achieving 4.8σ significance. Although Bayesian inference was not the primary tool, elements of probabilistic modeling informed redshift binning and absorber association probabilities to refine the structure's coherence. These approaches collectively confirmed the Giant Arc as a genuine large-scale feature rather than a projection artifact. The initial announcement of the Giant Arc was made by Alexia Lopez in 2021, highlighting its detection through these Mg II-based techniques.

Physical Characteristics

Size and Morphology

The Giant Arc is a vast cosmic structure spanning a of approximately 3.3 billion light-years (1 Gpc) at the present epoch, determined through calculations employing the at a of z ≈ 0.8 under the standard ΛCDM cosmological model with parameters Ω_M0 = 0.27, Ω_Λ0 = 0.73, and H_0 = 70 km/s/Mpc. This length represents the longest dimension of the structure, which was serendipitously detected via clustering of intervening Mg II absorbers in spectra. In terms of width, the Giant Arc measures about 100 Mpc (330 million light-years), manifesting as a thin, elongated band rather than a complete . Its overall shape is that of a or partial , characterized by a coherent filamentary of absorbers that suggests an organized, stream-like distribution across the . The structure exhibits nearly mirror-symmetric properties across its central axis, with the distribution of absorbers showing balanced clustering on either side, though minor asymmetries appear in and profiles. This symmetry underscores its geometric coherence. Notably, the Giant Arc's scale surpasses the theoretical maximum size of approximately 1.2 billion light-years (~370 Mpc) anticipated for large-scale structures in a homogeneous according to standard , as derived from homogeneity scales like those proposed by Yadav et al. (2010).

Composition and Location

The Giant Arc is primarily composed of and galaxy clusters, along with intergalactic gas and distributed across its vast extent. These components are not directly imaged but inferred through intervening MgII absorption systems observed in the spectra of distant background quasars. The MgII lines, arising from singly ionized magnesium, trace the presence of neutral and metals in the circumgalactic media and intergalactic medium of the structure's galaxies, providing a for the underlying distribution. The arrangement of these absorbers reveals a filamentary within the cosmic web, with the main arc featuring 44 prominent MgII systems, each likely associated with multiple galaxies, leading to an estimated total of hundreds of galaxies populating the feature. This composition highlights the Giant Arc as a coherent overdensity of baryonic , where the gas and contribute to the signatures while the galaxies and clusters form the gravitational scaffolding. Positioned in the constellation , the Giant Arc lies at a comoving distance of about 9.2 billion light-years from , corresponding to an observed of z \approx 0.80. It occupies a low-density void region in the large-scale structure of the , distinct from denser environments and showing no alignment with nearby superclusters such as the Hercules-Corona Borealis Great Wall at higher .

Cosmological Implications

Challenge to Homogeneity

The , a foundational assumption in modern cosmology, posits that the is homogeneous and isotropic on large scales, meaning matter distribution appears uniform when averaged over sufficiently vast distances. This homogeneity is expected to hold on scales greater than approximately 100 Mpc, beyond which fluctuations from the early , smoothed by cosmic , should average out to uniformity. The Giant Arc, however, spans roughly 1 Gpc (about 3.3 billion light-years), a scale far exceeding this threshold and suggesting potential non-uniformity in the distribution of galaxies and gas on cosmic scales. Statistical analyses of the Giant Arc's indicate a low probability of it arising by chance in a homogeneous . Using single-linkage on MgII absorber data, researchers found the structure's corresponds to approximately 4.5σ significance, implying a chance occurrence probability on the order of 0.003%. This level of points to possible real , where matter is clumped in ways not anticipated under standard homogeneity assumptions. While the detection relies on two-dimensional projections from line-of-sight quasar spectra, the inclusion of information in clustering methods provides a three-dimensional that supports the arc's spatial rather than dismissing it as a projection artifact. This discovery builds on a history of observed anomalies that hint at large-scale fluctuations exceeding inflation's predictions for a smooth . For instance, the () cold spot, a region of anomalously low temperature spanning about 5° on the sky, has been interpreted as evidence of enhanced or supervoids, challenging the expected Gaussian distribution of early universe perturbations. The Giant Arc adds to this pattern, potentially signaling that cosmic variance or unknown processes introduce deviations from homogeneity on gigaparsec scales, prompting reevaluation of how we interpret the 's large-scale structure.

Impact on Standard Models

The ΛCDM model predicts that coherent large-scale structures larger than approximately 370 Mpc are rare, as the scale of homogeneity is around this size, beyond which density fluctuations average to uniformity according to the primordial power spectrum and cosmological evolution. The Giant Arc, spanning about 1000 Mpc at z ≈ 0.8, exceeds this scale, creating a tension with the model's expectations for the maximum size of overdensities. If confirmed as a genuine , the Giant Arc implies potential directional dependence in the distribution, challenging the assumed in uniform cosmic expansion within ΛCDM. This could signal violations of large-scale homogeneity on gigaparsec scales, prompting reevaluation of the Cosmological Principle's foundational role in the model. Possible resolutions include modified gravity theories that allow enhanced clustering on large scales, or primordial non-Gaussian initial conditions that amplify rare fluctuations beyond standard predictions. Additionally, expanded survey volumes might reveal comparable structures, reducing the apparent rarity and aligning observations with ΛCDM statistics. Recent 2025 simulations, such as those using the FLAMINGO suite, have yielded conflicting results on the expected frequency of gigaparsec-scale structures like the Giant Arc in ΛCDM, with some analyses suggesting they are rare ( & Clowes 2025) while others argue they are commonplace (Sawala et al. 2025). The arc's existence highlights quantitative tensions, necessitating refinements to power spectrum models in cosmological simulations such as FLAMINGO to better capture gigaparsec-scale clustering and resolve discrepancies with observed large-scale structure.

The Big Ring

The Big Ring is a colossal ring-shaped large-scale structure in the universe, discovered in January 2024 by Alexia Lopez and her team at the University of Central Lancashire using data from the Sloan Digital Sky Survey (SDSS). It was identified through the same method employed for the Giant Arc, analyzing magnesium II (Mg II) absorption lines in the spectra of distant quasars to trace underlying galaxy distributions. The structure spans a diameter of approximately 1.3 billion light-years (about 400 megaparsecs) and has a circumference of roughly 4 billion light-years, appearing as a nearly perfect circle at a redshift of z ≈ 0.8. This places it about 9.2 billion light-years away in comoving distance, corresponding to a time when the universe was roughly half its current age. The Big Ring is composed of galaxies and galaxy clusters, delineated by Mg II absorption systems that indicate intervening matter along quasar sightlines, forming an annulus-like configuration distinct from the more common filamentary structures in the cosmic web. Unlike elongated filaments or walls, its circular morphology suggests a unique formation process, potentially involving spherical collapse or other non-standard dynamics on gigaparsec scales. The detection achieves a statistical significance of up to 5.2 sigma using algorithms like the Convex Hull of Member Spheres and the Cuzick-Edwards test, highlighting its robustness against random alignments. However, 2025 simulations suggest such gigaparsec-scale patterns may not be as rare as initially thought under the standard ΛCDM model. Located in the constellation Boötes, the Big Ring resides in the same sky region as the Giant Arc, separated by about 12 degrees, which translates to a physical separation of approximately 400 megaparsecs at their shared redshift. This proximity implies they may belong to a connected "neighborhood" of megastructures, further questioning the uniformity of matter distribution on scales smaller than the Giant Arc itself. The Big Ring's size slightly exceeds the theoretical limit of ~1.2 billion light-years for coherent structures under the standard cosmological model, reinforcing challenges to the Cosmological Principle on intermediate scales.

Comparison to Other Megastructures

The Giant Arc, spanning approximately 1 Gpc at a of z ≈ 0.8, is significantly smaller than the (HerCrB GW), which extends 2–3 Gpc (possibly up to ~4.6 Gpc per a preliminary 2025 analysis) at z ≈ 1.6–2.1, yet both structures challenge the cosmological homogeneity scale by exceeding the expected maximum size of ~1.2 Gpc for large-scale fluctuations under the standard ΛCDM model. Unlike the filamentary, wall-like morphology of the HerCrB GW, which appears as an elongated of galaxies traced by gamma-ray bursts, the Giant Arc exhibits a more symmetrical, crescent-shaped form composed of galaxies, clusters, gas, and dust. In contrast to the , a linear filamentary structure measuring ~0.43 Gpc in length at a low of z ≈ 0.08, the Giant Arc's pronounced arc and higher position it as a probe of earlier cosmic epochs, highlighting differences in between nearby and distant regimes. The Sloan's sheet-like arrangement of superclusters forms a vast planar overdensity, whereas the Giant Arc's curved suggests a distinct assembly process influenced by primordial density perturbations. The Giant Arc shares a filamentary nature with the , a complex of superclusters at z ≈ 0.47 spanning ~0.3–0.5 Gpc, but differs markedly in its pronounced curvature and apparent isolation within a cosmic void, contrasting the BOSS structure's interconnected of rich superclusters. This isolation underscores the Giant Arc's uniqueness among intermediate-redshift megastructures, potentially indicating localized enhancements in early clustering. The discovery of the Giant Arc aligns with a broader trend of identifying structures exceeding 1 Gpc, such as the (~0.43 Gpc but part of larger filamentary networks) and the nearby Big Ring at similar redshifts, suggesting revisions to timelines of large-scale in the . These findings, including the Giant Arc's proximity to the Big Ring, imply that the universe's homogeneity may emerge later than previously thought, prompting reevaluation of inflation-era predictions.

Debates and Future Research

Statistical Validity

The detection of the Giant Arc relies on statistical analyses of MgII absorption systems cataloged from (SDSS) data, specifically DR7 and DR12 releases, which trace intervening galaxies along sightlines. Using single-linkage with a of member spheres , the structure achieves a of approximately 4.5σ, corresponding to a probability of less than 0.001 that a similar alignment occurs by random chance in mock catalogs derived from 1000 simulations. Complementary tests, such as the Cuzick-Edwards permutation method, yield a p-value of 0.0027, while two-dimensional power spectrum analysis indicates 4.8σ at clustering scales around 270 Mpc, collectively suggesting a low likelihood—under 0.003%—of random alignment in the observed SDSS footprint. Potential biases in the detection include projection effects, where the three-dimensional of quasars and absorbers may create apparent two-dimensional coherence along sightlines due to non-uniform sampling. Simulations of random absorber highlight that such projections can mimic large-scale , with the original estimating the odds of a comparable structure at roughly 1 in 1000, though broader cosmological mocks suggest these patterns are not exceedingly rare. Criticisms from some astronomers posit that the Giant Arc may represent a statistical exacerbated by the incomplete sky coverage of SDSS, which spans only about one-third of the and is prone to selection biases favoring certain ranges and absorption strengths. Without independent confirmation through direct imaging or —such as resolved maps from deeper surveys—the structure's coherence remains unverified, potentially arising from over-interpretation of sparse tracer data. Counterarguments emphasize the consistency across multiple absorption tracers in the same redshift regime, including potential alignments with Lyman-α forest features, which bolster the case for a genuine large-scale structure over an observational artifact. This multi-tracer agreement, when cross-checked against overdensities, supports the detection's robustness despite coverage limitations.

Ongoing Observations

Current efforts to confirm and further study the Giant Arc involve multiple upcoming astronomical surveys and missions aimed at mapping its three-dimensional structure and physical properties. The (DESI), mounted on the Mayall 4-meter telescope at , is mapping the positions of tens of millions of galaxies and s across a wide range, including the z ≈ 0.8 region where the Giant Arc resides. DESI's Early Data Release in 2023, Data Release 1 in March 2025, Data Release 2 in October 2025, and subsequent full data releases provide spectroscopic s that will enable 3D mapping of galaxy distributions overlapping the arc's projected location, helping to determine if the observed alignment corresponds to a coherent physical rather than a projection effect. DESI's Data Releases 1 and 2 are beginning to provide relevant datasets, though specific analyses of the Giant Arc are ongoing. The (JWST) plays a key role in high-resolution imaging of the Mg II absorbers associated with the Giant Arc, allowing detailed examination of the intervening galaxies and their gas content at near-infrared wavelengths. By resolving faint structures in the line of sight toward background quasars, JWST observations can identify the host galaxies responsible for the absorption features, providing insights into the arc's composition and potential connections to nearby clusters. Meanwhile, the Euclid space telescope, launched in , utilizes weak gravitational lensing to probe the underlying mass distribution around large-scale structures like the Giant Arc. Euclid's wide-field imaging and spectroscopy, with initial data releases in including Quick Data Release 1 in March and Data Release 1 later in , will map shear patterns in background galaxies, revealing concentrations that could indicate the arc's gravitational coherence over its vast extent. Future goals for these observations include measuring velocity fields through redshift surveys to test the gravitational binding of the arc's components, as well as expanding analyses to full reconstructions that go beyond the current sky projection. These efforts are expected to yield confirmations or refinements by 2026–2028, coinciding with the maturation of DESI's main survey data and further major releases from Euclid's wide survey, potentially resolving ongoing statistical concerns about the arc's filamentary nature.

References

  1. [1]
    'Giant arc' stretching 3.3 billion light-years across the cosmos ...
    Jun 11, 2021 · A newly discovered crescent of galaxies spanning 3.3 billion light-years is among the largest known structures in the universe and challenges some of ...
  2. [2]
    [2201.06875] A Giant Arc on the Sky - arXiv
    Jan 18, 2022 · The Giant Arc (GA) is a large, almost symmetrical structure at z~0.8, spanning ~1 Gpc, discovered using MgII absorbers. It may challenge the ...
  3. [3]
    Giant Arc on the Sky | Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical ...
    The Giant Arc (GA) spans ∼1 Gpc (proper size, present epoch) and appears to be intriguingly symmetrical on the sky. It is one of the largest of a steadily ...
  4. [4]
    Cosmic megastructures: The largest objects in the Universe - BBC
    Mar 3, 2023 · Boötes the Herdsman was found to contain a giant arc of galaxies some 3.3 billion light years across.
  5. [5]
  6. [6]
    Giant Arc Structure 1/15th The Size Of The Observable Universe ...
    Sep 24, 2025 · In 2021, astronomers discovered the "Giant Arc" spanning 3.3 billion light-years in the constellation of Boötes the Herdsman. This almost ...
  7. [7]
    Galaxy Cluster and Giant Arc - NASA Science
    Jun 26, 2012 · The giant arc is the stretched shape of a more distant star-forming galaxy whose light is distorted by the monster cluster's powerful gravity, ...
  8. [8]
    A Giant Structure in Space Challenges Our Understanding of The ...
    Oct 28, 2024 · Astronomers have found a giant, almost perfect ring of galaxies, some 1.3 billion light-years in diameter. It doesn't match any known structure or formation ...<|control11|><|separator|>
  9. [9]
    [PDF] ALEXIA M. LOPEZ Jeremiah Horrocks Institute University of Central ...
    A GIANT ARC. ON. THE SKY. ALEXIA M. LOPEZ. Jeremiah Horrocks Institute ... A GIANT ARC! • 3.3 billion light years long. • 9.2 billion light years away.Missing: discovery June
  10. [10]
  11. [11]
    3.3-Billion-Light-Year-Long Arc of Galaxies Discovered | Sci.News
    Jun 16, 2021 · The Giant Arc: the gray contours represent the Mg II absorbers, which indicate the distribution of galaxies and galaxy clusters; the blue dots ...
  12. [12]
    Discovery of a Giant Arc in distant space adds to challenges to basic ...
    Alexia Lopez has presented her work on the Giant Arc at the 238th virtual meeting of the American Astronomical Society, 7-9 June. Slide 1 of ...
  13. [13]
    [1607.03418] The Homogeneity Scale of the universe - arXiv
    Jul 12, 2016 · In this study, we probe the cosmic homogeneity with the BOSS CMASS galaxy sample in the redshift region of 0.43 < z < 0.7.
  14. [14]
    [1406.3622] The Cold Spot in the Cosmic Microwave Background
    Jun 15, 2014 · Standard inflationary hot big bang cosmology predicts small fluctuations in the Cosmic Microwave Background (CMB) with isotropic Gaussian ...
  15. [15]
    Cosmologists Parry Attacks on the Vaunted Cosmological Principle
    Dec 13, 2021 · So structures like the Giant Arc, which spans billions of light years, are as unexpected as a thick clot of air in an otherwise ordinary balloon ...
  16. [16]
    Fractal Dimension as a measure of the scale of Homogeneity - arXiv
    We have defined the scale of homogeneity to be the scale above which the deviation of fractal dimension from the ambient dimension becomes smaller than the ...
  17. [17]
    [2409.14894] Investigating Ultra-Large Large-Scale Structures - arXiv
    Sep 23, 2024 · In this article we review two recent LSS discoveries: the Giant Arc (GA, \sim 1 Gpc) and the Big Ring (BR, \sim 400 Mpc).Missing: impact | Show results with:impact
  18. [18]
    The Emperor's New Arc: gigaparsec patterns abound in a $Λ$CDM ...
    Feb 5, 2025 · The paper refutes claims that large-scale features contradict the ΛCDM model, showing patterns like the "Giant Arc" are common and expected in ...
  19. [19]
    Gigaparsec structures are nowhere to be seen in $Λ$CDM - arXiv
    Apr 21, 2025 · We do not yet know why there appears to be such a large discrepancy between the FLAMINGO-10K data and the observed LSS in MgII absorbers.
  20. [20]
    Discovery of second ultra-large structure in distant space ... - Phys.org
    Jan 15, 2024 · The Giant Arc, which is approximately 1/15th the radius of the observable universe, shows as an enormous, nearly symmetrical, crescent of ...Missing: observational | Show results with:observational
  21. [21]
    [2402.07591] A Big Ring on the Sky - arXiv
    Feb 12, 2024 · ... MgII-absorber catalogues, following the previously reported Giant Arc (GA). ... absorbers of the BR have departures from random ...
  22. [22]
    A Big Ring on the sky - IOPscience
    Jul 24, 2024 · We present the discovery of A Big Ring on the Sky (BR), the second ultra-large large-scale structure (uLSS) found in Mg II-absorber catalogues.
  23. [23]
    Huge ring of galaxies challenges thinking on cosmos - BBC
    Jan 11, 2024 · The Big Ring was identified by Alexia Lopez, a PhD student at the University of Central Lancashire (UCLan), who also discovered the Giant ...
  24. [24]
    THE SLOAN GREAT WALL. MORPHOLOGY AND GALAXY CONTENT
    We present the results of a study of the morphology and galaxy content of the Sloan Great Wall (SGW), the richest galaxy system in the nearby universe.
  25. [25]
    BOSS Great Wall: morphology, luminosity, and mass
    We study the morphology of the superclusters from the BOSS Great Wall (BGW), a recently discovered very rich supercluster complex at the redshift z = 0.47.
  26. [26]
    [2505.11072] The Giant Arc -- Filament or Figment? - arXiv
    May 16, 2025 · The so-called "Giant Arc" is a sparse pattern of MgII absorbers spanning approximately 740 comoving Mpc, whose discovery has been claimed to contradict the ...
  27. [27]
    Data Release 1 of the Dark Energy Spectroscopic Instrument - arXiv
    Mar 18, 2025 · We present DESI Data Release 1 (DR1), which consists of all data acquired during the first 13 months of the DESI main survey, as well as a ...