Fact-checked by Grok 2 weeks ago

Grade 22

Grade 22, formally designated as Basic Pay Scale 22 (BPS-22), constitutes the apex echelon of the Pakistani hierarchy, reserved for the most senior bureaucrats who oversee critical administrative functions at the federal and provincial levels. This grade represents the culmination of career progression for civil servants, typically recruited through the competitive (CSS) examination and advanced via merit-based promotions, though the process has faced scrutiny for political influences in selections. Officers in Grade 22 wield substantial authority, often outranking junior ministers in policy execution and bureaucratic decision-making. Key positions occupied by Grade 22 incumbents include federal secretaries heading ministries, chief secretaries in provincial governments, and chairpersons of major regulatory or autonomous entities, enabling them to shape implementation and . Attainment of this grade is rare, with promotions approved by the High-Powered Selection Board under the , reflecting its elite status amid a vast apparatus spanning BPS-1 to BPS-22. Recent reforms have tightened eligibility criteria, limiting consideration for promotion to twice annually to enhance efficiency and curb delays. While emblematic of administrative prowess, the grade has been critiqued for entrenching a powerful bureaucratic cadre that sometimes resists political oversight, underscoring tensions in Pakistan's structure.

Overview

Definition and Scope

Grade 22, designated as Basic Pay Scale 22 (BPS-22), constitutes the highest attainable rank within Pakistan's hierarchy, marking the apex of bureaucratic career advancement. This scale caps the progression for officers inducted through the (CSS) examination and subsequent allocations to occupational groups such as the (PAS), Police Service of Pakistan (PSP), and (FSP). Attainment of this grade typically follows decades of service, culminating in promotions from BPS-21 via rigorous evaluations by high-powered selection boards. The scope of Grade 22 positions extends to the most senior executive roles in federal and provincial governance, including Federal Secretaries, Provincial Chief Secretaries, Principal Secretaries to the or Chief Ministers, and Directors General of autonomous federal agencies or corporations. These officers oversee the formulation and implementation of national policies, manage ministerial divisions, coordinate inter-governmental affairs, and provide strategic advice to elected officials. In practice, such roles demand expertise in administrative leadership, often influencing the operational efficacy of government functions across diverse sectors like finance, interior, and . Promotions remain highly competitive; for example, only 22 officers advanced to this grade in March 2023, followed by 36 in March 2025, reflecting the limited vacancies at this . Eligibility for Grade 22 is confined to senior officers demonstrating exceptional performance, integrity, and leadership, underscoring its role as the terminus of merit-based ascension in Pakistan's framework, which structures compensation from BPS-1 (entry-level clerical) to BPS-22. While the grade unifies top-tier pay and perquisites, its occupants span multiple services, ensuring specialized oversight in areas like (via ) or (via FSP), thereby delineating the breadth of bureaucratic influence at the national level.

Significance in Pakistani Governance

Grade 22, designated as Basic Pay Scale 22 (BPS-22), constitutes the pinnacle of Pakistan's hierarchy, occupied by a select cadre of senior officers who direct core governmental operations. These individuals typically hold positions such as federal secretaries overseeing ministries and divisions, provincial chief secretaries managing regional administrations, and principal secretaries advising on high-level coordination. With promotions to this grade approved by the and occurring infrequently—such as the elevation of 36 officers in March 2025 from services including the , Police Service of Pakistan, and Foreign Service—the total number of BPS-22 incumbents remains limited to a few dozen at any given time amid a exceeding 500,000 personnel. In Pakistani , Grade 22 officers exert substantial influence through their mandate to formulate, implement, and monitor policies across federal and provincial domains, from to security coordination. As heads of administrative units, they serve as the primary interface between elected officials and the executive machinery, offering specialized expertise that sustains during periods of political flux, including multiple government changes since in 1947. This continuity is particularly pronounced in a where civil servants outlast transient political appointees, enabling consistent application of laws and despite electoral cycles. Their significance extends to bridging policy intent with ground-level execution, where federal secretaries, for instance, draft cabinet summaries, oversee budgetary disbursements, and liaise with international bodies on implementation. Empirical assessments highlight their role in evidence-informed decision-making, as evidenced by training initiatives for senior civil servants emphasizing data-driven governance tools since 2025. However, causal factors such as political interference in promotions—often prioritizing loyalty over performance—can undermine this efficacy, leading to inefficiencies in service delivery and policy outcomes, as documented in reform analyses.

Historical Development

Origins in Colonial Administration

The (ICS), the precursor to Pakistan's elite civil bureaucracy including Grade 22 positions, emerged as the administrative instrument of British colonial rule in , designed to maintain order and extract revenue through a cadre of generalist officers wielding extensive executive authority. Established effectively under the Charter Act of 1853, which introduced competitive examinations in for recruitment—initially favoring British candidates—the ICS replaced earlier systems with a merit-based (though geographically restricted) entry, enabling the British to govern a vast territory with a small number of officers who rotated between district fieldwork and policy formulation in provincial and central secretariats. The of 1886–1887 further structured the colonial civil services by classifying them into imperial (encompassing the for superior roles), provincial, and subordinate tiers, reserving the highest positions—such as secretaries to government and commissioners—for officers who exercised near-absolute control over districts, judiciary, and revenue collection, often unchecked by elected bodies. This hierarchy emphasized loyalty to the colonial regime over local representation, with officers forming the "" of administration that prioritized stability and imperial interests, recruiting primarily from until Indianization accelerated post-1919 under Montagu-Chelmsford reforms, though remained underrepresented. At the 1947 partition, received a scant allocation of ICS personnel—approximately 81 officers opting for service, supplemented by initial British holdovers—insufficient for its territories yet sufficient to transplant the ICS model into the of (CSP), where senior roles akin to modern Grade 22 (federal and provincial secretaries, chief secretaries) were filled by these officers, perpetuating colonial-era generalist dominance over specialized functions and political oversight. The system's resilience stemmed from its proven efficacy in centralized control, though adapted minimally to the new state's needs, with pay and rank structures evolving from 1949 prescribed scales into the Basic Pay Scale (BPS) framework by the 1960s–1970s, culminating in BPS-22 as the apex for those tracing direct lineage to ICS seniority.

Post-Independence Evolution

Following independence on August 14, 1947, inherited a nascent from the British , comprising approximately 95 senior officers and 300 Class-I gazetted officers who opted to serve the new dominion. These personnel, reorganized under the Civil Service of (CSP), filled top administrative roles, including positions equivalent to federal and provincial secretaries, which later aligned with the apex Basic Pay Scale (BPS)-22 grade. The service retained a , elitist structure amid political instability, enabling bureaucrats to exert significant influence in governance and policy implementation during the and , as elected institutions struggled to consolidate. The hierarchical pay framework, standardized into 22 Basic Pay Scales (BPS-1 to BPS-22) by the late , formalized progression pathways, with BPS-22 reserved for senior-most roles such as secretaries to government divisions and chief secretaries of provinces, typically attained after 25-30 years of service. This system emphasized tenure-based promotions within the CSP cadre, supported by mandatory training at institutions like the Civil Services Academy, though early post-independence shortages necessitated rapid indigenization and recruitment through competitive examinations. The pivotal 1973 Civil Services Reforms, enacted under Prime Minister , dismantled the unified CSP elite by introducing 12 specialized occupational groups—including the precursor to the modern (PAS)—and a common training program to foster and curb bureaucratic dominance. These changes, which dismissed over 1,300 civil servants and devolved some powers, preserved the BPS-22 apex for cross-group promotions to secretarial posts but shifted emphasis toward functional specialization, reducing the generalist monopoly while increasing political oversight and vulnerability to interference. Subsequent decades saw incremental evolutions, including expansions in BPS-22 positions—from fewer than 50 in the to over 100 by the —driven by proliferating ministries and autonomous bodies, alongside periodic pay revisions (e.g., 15% increase in 2022 scales effective July 1) to address and wage disparities. Reforms under General Pervez Musharraf's 2001 Devolution Plan altered district-level administration but reinforced central secretariats' role, with BPS-22 officers retaining authority in federal decision-making despite rising militarization and politicization. Efforts like the 2020 revisions to efficiency rules aimed to enhance accountability, yet persistent challenges include quota-based promotions and limited lateral entry, constraining merit-driven ascent to Grade 22.

Key Reforms and Changes

The 1973 administrative reforms under marked a pivotal shift by abolishing the elite Civil Service of Pakistan (CSP) cadre, which had dominated apex positions, and replacing it with a unified Basic Pay Scale (BPS) system ranging from BPS-1 to BPS-22, alongside the creation of occupational groups such as the (PAS). These changes aimed to broaden access to senior roles but facilitated greater political patronage in promotions to BPS-22, as eligibility shifted toward service length and group quotas rather than a singular elite track. The reforms reduced the CSP's influence, with BPS-22 posts—typically held by federal secretaries—now allocated across groups like , Police Service of Pakistan, and others based on seniority and performance evaluations conducted by the Establishment Division. During General Zia-ul-Haq's regime in the late and , military officers were inducted into the civil on a quota basis, including placements directly into BPS-19 and higher, which extended to influencing BPS-22 appointments through lateral entry and advisory roles in key ministries. This altered the composition of apex-grade officers, prioritizing ex-military personnel for strategic positions, such as secretaries in defense-related departments, amid a broader pattern of civil-military . The triggered by the 18th Constitutional Amendment in April 2010 abolished the concurrent legislative list, transferring subjects like and to provinces and eliminating over 40 federal ministries, which contracted the pool of BPS-22 positions from approximately 100 in the early to around 70 by 2015. This reform centralized fewer but more specialized apex roles under remaining federal secretariats, emphasizing inter-provincial coordination while exposing BPS-22 officers to heightened scrutiny over policy implementation amid fiscal constraints. Subsequent proposals, such as those in the 2008 National Commission for Government Reform led by Dr. , recommended performance-linked promotions to BPS-22, including mandatory evaluations and fixed tenures of three years for secretaries to curb stagnation, though implementation remained partial due to resistance from entrenched interests. Compensation adjustments in the and , including pay scale revisions under the 7th Pay Commission in 2016, enhanced BPS-22 emoluments by 20-30% but did little to alter structural eligibility, which continues to require 25-30 years of service from BPS-17 entry.

Structure and Promotion

Hierarchical Position and Eligibility

Grade 22, designated as Basic Pay Scale (BPS)-22, represents the highest tier in Pakistan's civil service hierarchy, encompassing elite positions that oversee major governmental functions at federal and provincial levels. Incumbents typically hold roles such as secretaries to federal ministries, chief secretaries of provinces, inspectors general of police, and chairmen or directors general of autonomous corporations and regulatory bodies, where they exercise substantial authority in policy execution, resource allocation, and inter-departmental coordination. This grade caps the career progression for officers inducted primarily through the Central Superior Services (CSS) examination into BPS-17, with only a fraction advancing through successive promotions amid a bureaucracy exceeding 500,000 personnel. Eligibility for Grade 22 is restricted to promotion from BPS-21, conducted on a selection basis rather than seniority-cum-fitness alone, as stipulated in promotion policies applicable to senior scales. Candidates must demonstrate exceptional performance via annual confidential reports (now performance evaluation reports or PERs), professional competence, and leadership suitability, assessed by high-powered selection boards convened under the Establishment Division. No direct recruitment occurs at this level, ensuring incumbents possess at least 25-30 years of service, often reaching the grade in their mid-50s after rigorous departmental examinations, postings, and evaluations from initial entry. Promotions to Grade 22 are infrequent and merit-driven, with boards prioritizing officers from occupational groups like the , Police Service of Pakistan, and Foreign Service, while accounting for vacancies and national requirements. For example, on March 5, 2025, a selection board approved 36 such promotions across multiple services, including from additional secretary and roles in BPS-21. This process underscores a competitive filter, where not all BPS-21 officers qualify, reflecting the emphasis on proven administrative efficacy over mere tenure.

Promotion Criteria and Process

Promotion to 22 in the Pakistani occurs from Grade 21 and is governed by the Civil Servants (, Promotion and Transfer) Rules, 1973, as amended. The process emphasizes merit over strict seniority, with selections made by the High-Powered Selection Board (HPSB), chaired by the and comprising senior government officials. The board reviews a of eligible Grade 21 officers, submitted by the Establishment Division in order of seniority, assessing overall fitness for top bureaucratic roles such as secretaries to federal ministries. Eligibility requires a minimum of 25 years of service in Basic Pay Scale (BPS) 17 and above, including at least 2 years in BPS-21. Candidates must also hold at least three "very good" or higher Performance Evaluation Reports (PERs) in the last 6 years, with no penalties under the Civil Servants (Efficiency and Discipline) Rules, 1973, recorded during their BPS-21 tenure. The HPSB evaluates additional factors, including the breadth of experience—such as a mix of field assignments and postings—and overall professional competence to ensure suitability for strategic positions. In March 2025, amendments to the Civil Servants Promotion Rules limited consideration of an officer's case to two presentations before the HPSB; if not selected after these reviews, further submissions are prohibited to expedite the process and prevent indefinite delays. Approvals by the HPSB are formalized through notifications from the Division, with promotions often announced in batches—for instance, 36 officers were elevated on , 2025. charge of Grade 22 duties may be assigned temporarily to eligible juniors pending formal , counting toward seniority and increments if held for 6 months or more.

Compensation and Perquisites

Officers in Basic Pay Scale 22 (BPS-22), the apex grade for civil servants in , receive compensation comprising basic pay, multiple allowances, and extensive perquisites that often exceed the cash component in value. Under the revised pay scales, basic pay ranges from a minimum of PKR 96,870 to a maximum of PKR 235,000, inclusive of annual increments based on length and . Subsequent adjustments, including a 10% ad-hoc relief allowance (ARA) and 30% disparity reduction allowance (DRA) effective , 2025, applied to the running basic pay of 2022 scales, elevate gross monthly emoluments to between PKR 280,000 and PKR 500,000 or more for senior incumbents, factoring in seniority, house rent allowance (if applicable), medical allowance, and conveyance benefits. Allowances typically constitute over 70% of total income for BPS-20 to BPS-22 officers, with disparity reduction measures aimed at addressing pay compression from repeated ad-hoc hikes rather than structural reforms. Perquisites for BPS-22 officers include government-provided housing, such as Type-VII or equivalent bungalows in or provincial capitals, often with maintenance and utility costs borne by the state, including unlimited telephone, electricity, and gas connections at official residences and offices. Official transport comprises cars with drivers, fuel allowances, and maintenance, alongside personal staff like orderlies and details, particularly for secretaries and equivalent posts. entitlements cover the officer, spouse, and dependent children for hospitalization and treatment at government facilities or recognized hospitals, with no reimbursement caps specified for top grades. Travel allowances during official duties include daily subsistence at rates scaled for seniority (historically Rs. 530 for BPS-22, adjusted upward over time) plus tripled hotel accommodations. Post-retirement benefits feature pensions at 70% of last drawn pay after 25 years of service, often supplemented by retained perks like coverage and potential advisory roles with stipends. These non-cash elements, while shielding officers from market inflation in and utilities, contribute to fiscal burdens estimated in billions annually across grades, with critiques highlighting opacity in valuation and potential for abuse. Overall, total compensation packages for BPS-22 officers prioritize in-kind benefits over increments, reflecting a system where perks sustain status amid stagnant basic pay growth relative to economic pressures.

Roles and Responsibilities

Principal Positions Held

Grade 22 officers, the highest rank in Pakistan's Basic system, hold apex administrative roles in federal and provincial governments, typically after from Grade 21 based on seniority, performance, and selection board approval. These positions involve policy implementation, inter-departmental coordination, and advisory functions to elected officials. At the federal level, principal positions include secretaries to the government in ministries and divisions, such as the Secretary Cabinet Division or Secretary Establishment Division, who manage operational execution and bureaucratic oversight. For instance, promotions to Grade 22 often precede or accompany appointments as federal secretaries in sectors like education, commerce, and food security. The Principal Secretary to the Prime Minister, a Grade 22 role, coordinates between the Prime Minister's Office and federal bureaucracy, with historical occupants including officers like Fawad Hasan Khan in 2019. In provincial administrations, the serves as the principal Grade 22 position, acting as the top civil servant responsible for provincial governance coordination and implementation of directives from the . Examples include promotions enabling such roles, as seen in recent selections across officers. Additional Grade 22 assignments may occur in autonomous bodies or as additional chief secretaries in specialized provincial departments, such as home and tribal affairs in . Officers from services like the Police Service of Pakistan or Foreign Service can also attain Grade 22 for equivalent principal roles, such as in provinces or additional secretaries elevated to secretarial status. These appointments emphasize administrative expertise over political alignment, though selection processes have faced scrutiny for potential favoritism.

Decision-Making Authority

Grade 22 officers, typically appointed as Federal Secretaries, Principal Secretaries, or Chief Secretaries, serve as the administrative heads of ministries, divisions, or provincial governments, wielding substantial authority over routine and delegated decision-making functions. They oversee the implementation of policies approved by political executives, managing departmental operations, resource distribution, and compliance with legal frameworks such as the Civil Servants Act, 1973. This role encompasses approving administrative actions, including personnel transfers within delegated limits and procedural matters not reserved for ministerial or approval, ensuring continuity and efficiency in governance despite political transitions. In practice, their authority extends to exercising in case disposals, with the power to summon files for personal review, consultations on specific issues, and enforce disciplinary measures across subordinate staff. Secretariat Instructions explicitly grant secretaries oversight to intervene in proceedings to uphold administrative standards, preventing delays or irregularities in ministry workflows. This centralized control aligns with the broader structure of Pakistan's , where Grade 22 positions handle high-level coordination, often bridging policy formulation with execution through advisory inputs to ministers and the . Financial decision-making falls under their purview as principal officers, authorizing expenditures within budgetary ceilings defined by the Finance Division and subject to external audits by the . They approve processes, development projects at operational levels, and re-appropriations of funds, directly influencing sectoral outcomes in areas like , , and . However, such powers are constrained by the Rules of Business, 1973, requiring escalation of politically sensitive or high-value decisions to elected officials, reflecting the constitutional subordination of to democratic oversight. In provincial contexts, Chief Secretaries in Grade 22 exercise analogous authority, coordinating inter-departmental affairs and implementing directives, with added responsibilities for law-and-order coordination through linkages with and local administrations. Empirical analyses of operations highlight this authority's role in maintaining institutional stability, though over-centralization has been noted to bottleneck minor decisions, as evidenced in evaluations.

Interaction with Political Leadership

Grade 22 officers, typically serving as federal secretaries or equivalent positions, function as the administrative heads of ministries and divisions, directly interfacing with political leaders such as federal ministers, the , and committees to translate directives into actionable . Their interactions emphasize advisory roles, where secretaries furnish ministers with technical assessments, draft legislative summaries, and coordinate inter-ministerial alignment, ensuring compliance with executive priorities while safeguarding institutional continuity. Under established protocols, secretaries are obligated to submit all substantive cases to the minister-in-charge for decision, facilitating a structured flow of information that balances political oversight with bureaucratic expertise. This relationship positions secretaries as key implementers of politically determined agendas, yet it is inherently hierarchical, with ministers holding ultimate authority over policy formulation and , often leading to dependencies on political goodwill for tenure stability. Frequent transfers of secretaries—averaging less than two years per posting in recent decades—stem from prime ministerial discretion, enabling alignment with shifting coalitions but disrupting long-term planning. For example, in 2023, promotions to Grade 22 required approval from a High Powered Selection Board chaired by , underscoring executive dominance in career advancement. Tensions frequently emerge from political efforts to exert control over bureaucratic operations, including demands for preferential postings or policy interpretations favoring electoral bases, which erode perceived neutrality. Academic analyses highlight how such interference, intensified since reforms under in the 1970s, fosters alliances between politicians and select officers, compromising merit-based decision-making and contributing to inefficiencies. Proposals to formalize ministerial input in secretaries' appointments, floated in , reflect ongoing debates over enhancing accountability without undermining bureaucratic independence. In instances of discord, secretaries may delay or adapt directives through procedural channels, prompting accusations of obstructionism from political quarters. These dynamics, while enabling responsive administration, risk prioritizing short-term political gains over evidence-based outcomes.

Notable Grade 22 Officers

Serving Officers

Serving Grade 22 officers, the highest echelon of Pakistan's Basic Pay Scale (BPS) system, primarily hold positions as federal and provincial secretaries, chief secretaries, and directors-general of major regulatory bodies, wielding significant administrative authority over policy implementation and resource allocation. These officers, drawn from cadres such as the (PAS), Police Service of Pakistan (PSP), and (FSP), number approximately 150-200 across federal and provincial levels, though exact figures fluctuate with promotions, retirements, and postings. As of October 2025, many continue to serve in critical roles amid ongoing bureaucratic expansions and political transitions, with recent promotions bolstering the cadre's capacity. Kamran Ali Afzal, a PAS officer, serves as , a pivotal role coordinating federal cabinet operations and advising on administrative matters, having assumed the position on August 7, 2023. Akbar Hussain Durrani (), also from PAS, holds the post of for Interior and Narcotics Control, overseeing , coordination, and counter-narcotics efforts as a BPS-22 appointee. These assignments reflect the cadre's dominance in core executive functions, where PAS officers often predominate due to their generalist training and seniority advantages over specialized services. In March 2025, the Establishment Division promoted 36 officers to BPS-22, enhancing the pool of serving personnel; PAS promotees included Waseem Ajmal Chaudhry, Ambreen Raza (subsequently posted as Special Secretary in Cabinet Division), , Usman Akhtar Bajwa, and Muhammad Arshad Chaudhry. PSP elevatees encompassed B.A. Nasir (Additional Secretary Commerce, later reassigned), Ghulam Nabi Memon (), and Muhammad Farooq Minhas, underscoring the service's role in security-related apex posts. FSP promotions featured Ahmed Naseem Warraich and Rizwan Saeed Sheikh, bolstering diplomatic leadership. These elevations, notified after delays attributed to administrative bottlenecks, addressed vacancies in key ministries, though critics note persistent cadre imbalances favoring PAS in non-technical domains. Provincially, serving Grade 22 officers include chief secretaries like those in and , often PAS alumni with decades of district and divisional experience; for instance, recent federal-provincial postings have seen promoted officers like Zubair Hashmi deployed to high-stakes roles. Overall, serving officers' tenures emphasize continuity in execution, with average ages around 55-60 and service lengths exceeding 30 years, though frequent political interference in transfers has led to shorter effective stints in sensitive positions.

Retired Officers and Legacy

Retired Grade 22 officers in Pakistan's frequently extend their influence beyond active duty through advisory roles, authorship of memoirs, participation in think tanks, and public commentary on and challenges. These contributions often draw on decades of experience in federal secretariats, where they shaped administrative continuity amid political transitions. However, their post-retirement legacies vary, with some praised for institutional insights and others critiqued for alignment with establishment interests that perpetuated inefficiencies or undemocratic practices. Roedad Khan (1918–2024), who joined the in 1949 and held positions including Chief Secretary of , Governor of the , and Interior Secretary, became a prominent voice after retirement. In interviews and writings, he reflected on civil-military imbalances and bureaucratic overreach, advocating for stronger civilian oversight based on his service under multiple regimes from to . His longevity—spanning to contemporary critiques—positioned him as a historical witness, though some analyses highlight his role in sustaining elite networks rather than driving systemic reform. Khan's death in April 2024 at age 101 marked the end of an era for veteran bureaucrats who bridged Pakistan's foundational and modern administrative phases. Ghulam Ishaq Khan (1915–2006), an officer who opted for in 1947, served as Finance Secretary in the 1950s and later as Governor of the , contributing to early fiscal stabilization and nuclear program advocacy during his bureaucratic tenure. Post-retirement from core service, he ascended to political roles, including (1988–1993), where he dissolved two elected assemblies under Article 58(2)(b) of the , actions that entrenched presidential powers but eroded democratic norms according to contemporary assessments. His legacy underscores the pathway from administrative ranks to national leadership, influencing economic policy frameworks that prioritized state-led development amid security imperatives. Salman Bashir, from 2008 to 2012, continued shaping discourse on regional relations after retirement. He has publicly urged structured India-Pakistan dialogue, emphasizing rooted in his experience negotiating post-26/11 processes and serving as to (2012–2014). Bashir's interventions, including analyses of the 1999 , highlight retired officers' roles in continuity, often through forums like diplomatic networks and media op-eds that inform Track-II efforts. Other retired federal secretaries, such as Ghulam Muhammad Sikandar, who ended his career as and Works Secretary, have left marks in and social welfare initiatives, mentoring successors and supporting educational reforms in underserved regions. Collectively, these figures illustrate how Grade 22 retirees sustain bureaucratic expertise, though their influence is tempered by criticisms of and limited push for in a system prone to .

Criticisms and Controversies

Allegations of Corruption and Nepotism

In Pakistan's civil service, Grade 22 officers, occupying apex positions such as secretaries and chief secretaries, have faced recurring allegations of involving abuse of authority in sectors like revenue collection, public welfare programs, and resource allocation. highlights a high risk of in the public services sector, exacerbated by inefficient and weak enforcement mechanisms, with ranking 135th out of 180 countries in the 2024 . These claims often center on in contract awards and regulatory decisions, though prosecutions remain infrequent due to institutional protections. A notable 2025 case involved the , where investigations revealed Grade 22 officers allegedly registering their spouses for biometric-linked cash transfers designated for impoverished households, diverting funds from intended beneficiaries. Similarly, the , staffed by senior bureaucrats including Grade 22 officers, has been cited for entrenched corruption in tax administration, including overstaffing and evasion facilitation, as noted in independent analyses of governance reforms. The Establishment Division has periodically scrutinized Grade 20-22 officers for extended service tenures, leading to forced retirements in cases flagged for or underperformance since at least 2020. Nepotism allegations frequently arise in promotion processes to Grade 22, where discretionary marking by the Central Selection Board—up to 30 marks out of total assessment—has been criticized for enabling favoritism over merit-based criteria. In 2009, a mass promotion of 51 officers under Yousaf Raza Gilani's administration drew accusations of and political patronage, replacing key secretaries in interior, information, and other ministries. The intervened in at least one instance, overturning 54 such promotions for breaching principles of fairness and , underscoring judicial concerns over politicized elevations. Broader critiques, including from domestic analysts, attribute persistent to bureau-political alliances that prioritize loyalty networks, undermining accountability in hiring and advancements.

Bureaucratic Inertia and Resistance to Reform

Bureaucratic in Pakistan's , particularly among Grade 22 officers who hold apex positions such as secretaries to the , manifests as a persistent resistance to structural changes that could disrupt established hierarchies and privileges. This inertia stems from vested interests developed over decades, where senior bureaucrats prioritize maintaining the to safeguard their authority, perquisites, and influence over policy implementation. Reform attempts since the , including those aimed at enhancing and , have repeatedly stalled due to this internal opposition combined with political discontinuities. Historical episodes underscore this resistance; for instance, during Zulfikar Ali Bhutto's tenure in the 1970s, administrative reforms sought to redistribute power but faced backlash from civil servants who viewed them as threats to their , leading to widespread non-compliance and eventual reversal post-Bhutto. Similarly, General Pervez Musharraf's initiatives in the early 2000s encountered bureaucratic pushback, as Grade 22 officers resisted that diminished central control, resulting in reforms lacking permanence after his ouster. More recently, efforts under Khan's from 2018 to 2022, such as performance-based promotions and at age 65 for underperformers, provoked opposition from entrenched elites who leveraged procedural delays and legal challenges to dilute implementation. Causal factors include , where Grade 22 officers influence postings and shield allies, fostering a culture averse to merit-based evaluations that could expose inefficiencies. Institutional fragmentation exacerbates this, as fragmented oversight allows bureaucrats to exploit gaps in accountability, such as in tax collection where weak incentives perpetuate low performance despite repeated directives. Critics argue that political interference compounds the issue, but primary obstacles remain internal, with senior officers often welcoming regime changes that restore their prerogatives, as seen after Bhutto's fall. The consequences are evident in stalled governance improvements; for example, despite recommendations in 1998 for incentive-aligned reforms, bureaucratic resistance has sustained inefficiencies, contributing to 's low rankings in effectiveness metrics. Recent analyses, including a 2025 Pakistan Institute of Development Economics seminar, highlight that without addressing this inertia through insulated reform commissions, continuity remains elusive, perpetuating a cycle where Grade 22 officers' short tenures—averaging under two years in key posts—prioritize survival over innovation. This dynamic not only hampers execution but also undermines , as evidenced by persistent corruption perceptions indices placing below regional averages.

Overreach Relative to Elected Officials

Grade 22 officers, serving as secretaries to federal ministries and divisions, have faced accusations of overreach by exerting over execution, often delaying or obstructing directives from elected ministers and prime ministers under the of administrative or institutional expertise. This dynamic stems from their permanent tenure contrasting with transient political leadership, enabling them to leverage departmental control to resist changes perceived as disruptive to established practices. In November 2021, the federal government issued show-cause notices to 29 BS-20 and higher bureaucrats, including some approaching senior grades, for non-compliance with rotation and transfer policies mandated by the Establishment Division under Khan's administration, highlighting defiance of on postings. Such refusals to adhere to transfers, which are lawful directives from elected authorities via the , undermine ministerial authority and perpetuate bureaucratic entrenchment in preferred roles. Further instances include systematic stonewalling of ministerial initiatives, where files vanish or approvals stall, leaving elected officials unable to enforce agendas despite constitutional oversight. For example, during policy reforms aimed at , Grade 22 officers have resisted resource transfers to local governments, prioritizing central control over mandates enshrined in the 18th Amendment of 2010. Critics, including former policymakers, attribute this to an elitist culture inherited from colonial-era civil services, where bureaucrats view themselves as policy guardians superior to elected transients. In response to proposed efficiency drives, such as those under the government in 2015, senior bureaucrats threatened a "pen-down strike" against alterations to promotion and service rules, signaling collective pushback against elected-led restructuring. While proponents argue such resistance safeguards institutional integrity against politicization, detractors contend it constitutes overreach by subverting democratic accountability, as civil servants are obligated to implement, not , lawful political directives. This tension has prompted calls for enhanced political oversight, though entrenched practices persist amid mutual accusations of interference.

Impact and Reforms

Contributions to Policy and Stability

Grade 22 officers, primarily serving as federal secretaries, provincial chief secretaries, and equivalent apex positions, contribute to policy formulation by providing technical expertise and institutional continuity to elected officials. These bureaucrats draft key , regulations, and frameworks for ministries, drawing on decades of administrative experience to ensure policies align with operational realities. For instance, in , they have historically supported the execution of strategies, including early post-independence five-year plans that facilitated initial industrialization and growth. In , Grade 22 officers coordinate inter-ministerial responses to national emergencies, such as natural disasters and economic shocks. During the 2010 floods, which affected over 20 million people and caused damages exceeding $10 billion, senior civil servants led relief distribution, rehabilitation efforts, and international aid coordination, mitigating long-term disruptions to governance. Their role in upholding and administrative neutrality has been noted as a stabilizing factor amid political volatility, where frequent government transitions—Pakistan has seen over 20 changes in prime ministerial leadership since —could otherwise paralyze state functions. The permanence of Grade 22 positions relative to political appointments fosters policy stability, reducing abrupt shifts that might arise from electoral cycles. assessments highlight that minimizing rotations among senior staff enhances accountability and consistent policy execution, a principle reflected in Pakistan's during periods of , including transitions from civilian to military rule. This continuity has preserved core state operations, such as tax collection and delivery, even as political instability persisted.

Proposed Changes and Debates

In July 2025, Prime Minister established a high-level committee chaired by Minister for Planning to formulate comprehensive reforms, directing it to submit proposals within one month following consultations on , promotions, , and structural alignment with contemporary requirements. The committee's recommendations included creating a National Executive Service to facilitate lateral entry of specialists into senior roles, potentially incorporating fixed-term contracts for positions up to Grade 22 to replace lifetime tenures and foster adaptability, while emphasizing merit-based selection over cadre loyalty. These measures aim to address overstaffing and inefficiency, with suggestions to reduce hierarchical tiers from 22 scales, merge redundant divisions, and eliminate posts vacant for over three years, thereby limiting the number of Grade 22 slots to essential functions. Complementing structural changes, compensation reforms for BPS-20 to BPS-22 officers have been proposed to rationalize perks, including abolishing ad-hoc in favor of a voucher-based shared pool system and shifting to contributory pensions with a for incumbents, intended to curb fiscal burdens estimated at billions in lifetime costs per officer while attracting competent talent without excessive privileges. To enhance , the enacted the Civil Servants (Amendment) Bill on June 20, 2025, compelling BPS-17 to BPS-22 officers to publicly disclose movable and immovable assets annually, building on prior mandates but extending them to grades amid documented cases of undeclared accumulation. Debates on these proposals highlight tensions between imperatives and institutional stability. Advocates, drawing from analyses of Pakistan's bureaucratic stagnation—evidenced by low service delivery metrics and resistance to —assert that fixed tenures and performance-linked promotions would enforce causal , reducing the seen in Grade 22 promotions often influenced by seniority over output. Critics, including bureaucratic associations, warn that curtailing permanence risks politicizing appointments, eroding the expertise accumulated over decades in a prone to frequent changes, as historical attempts since the 1998 framework have largely faltered due to vested resistance rather than flawed design. Empirical data from peer-reviewed studies underscore that while incentives like merit pay could boost productivity, implementation hinges on shielding evaluations from interference, a recurring failure in Pakistan's context where political elites leverage postings for loyalty.

Comparative Analysis with Other Systems

Pakistan's Grade 22, the apex of its Basic Pay Scale (BPS) system, is reserved primarily for senior officers in elite cadres such as the (PAS), who serve in roles like federal secretaries overseeing ministries. This generalist structure, comprising 22 hierarchical grades with entry at BPS-17 via the (CSS) examination, emphasizes seniority-driven promotions and lifetime tenure until , often resulting in total monthly compensation exceeding Rs 1 million including monetized perks like housing and vehicles valued at Rs 500,000. In contrast, India's (IAS), a comparable post-colonial generalist service, selects officers through the (UPSC) but incorporates lateral entry from state civil services and limited direct recruitment at senior levels, allowing for greater flexibility than Pakistan's near-exclusive reliance on CSS for PAS induction. Both systems feature apex positions akin to cabinet secretaries, yet Pakistan's quota system—allocating over 90% of CSS allocations by provincial and other criteria—narrows the merit-based selection pool compared to India's more uniformly competitive UPSC process, potentially impacting cadre quality at Grade 22 equivalents. Relative to the United Kingdom's Senior Civil Service, where Permanent Secretaries are appointed through open competition or internal promotion with emphasis on policy advisory roles under ministerial direction and periodic fixed terms to ensure accountability, Pakistan's Grade 22 officers wield implementation powers that frequently overshadow transient political appointees, rooted in the inherited model's emphasis on administrative continuity amid political instability. This contrasts with the UK's doctrine of neutrality, where senior roles prioritize impartial expertise over direct , and performance evaluations can lead to reassignment, unlike Pakistan's rigidity where bureaucratic inertia often resists reform. Similarly, the ' Senior Executive Service (SES) integrates career civil servants with political appointees in tracks, featuring rigorous annual appraisals, recertification, and removal provisions to align with priorities, diverging from Pakistan's seniority-focused ascent to Grade 22 that privileges tenure over demonstrable outcomes. Compensation structures further differentiate: Pakistan's Grade 22 total costs, including non-cash benefits, exceed equivalent local hires by 12% and lag in performance linkages seen in systems like Singapore's, where civil servants receive market-competitive pay with bonuses tied to results rather than automatic perks. Across , Pakistan's model shares generalist elitism with India's IAS and Bangladesh's equivalents but exhibits greater centralization and military-bureaucratic interplay, amplifying Grade 22 influence in policy stability at the expense of adaptability compared to more decentralized or reform-oriented regional peers.

References

  1. [1]
    Over 20 bureaucrats promoted to Grade 22 - Pakistan - DAWN.COM
    Mar 4, 2023 · The promotion of 22 officers from BS-21 to BS-22 was okayed by the High Powered Selection Board (HPSB) headed by Prime Minister Shehbaz Sharif ...
  2. [2]
    36 civil servants promoted to grade 22 - Pakistan - DAWN.COM
    Mar 6, 2025 · The FSP promoted to BS-22 are Ahmed Naseem Warraich, Rahim Hayat Qureshi, Asim Iftikhar Ahmed, Rizwan Saeed Sheikh, Syed Ahsan Raza Shah, Faisal ...
  3. [3]
    Seniority Lists - Establishment Division
    Final Seniority List of BS-18 Officers of Pakistan Administrative Services (PAS). 22-02-2024, PROVISIONAL SENIORITY LIST OF BS-20 OFFICERS OF SECRETARIAT GROUP.
  4. [4]
    11 more officers promoted to Grade 22 | The Express Tribune
    Mar 11, 2025 · The High Powered Central Selection Board on Monday approved the promotion of 11 Grade 21 officers to Grade 22, raising the total number of recently promoted ...
  5. [5]
    Govt tightens rules for Grade 22 promotion-INP
    The federal government on Friday implemented new policy for officers who are desire to seek promotion to BS-22. According to a notification issued by the ...<|separator|>
  6. [6]
    [PDF] A Study on the Civil Service Structure, Civil Servants Training and ...
    The rank hierarchy that divided civil servants into four classes – ranging from officer-level Class-I to menial positions in Class IV – was replaced by a system ...<|separator|>
  7. [7]
    [PDF] March 2025 - NSPP
    He also underscored the critical role senior civil servants play as the vital link between policy-making forums and the operational tiers of government, Dr ...
  8. [8]
    Hierarchy of Civil Services in Pakistan | PDF - Scribd
    Rating 5.0 (1) The highest levels are Grade 22 which includes positions like Principal Secretaries and Federal Secretaries who lead government ministries and divisions. Grades ...
  9. [9]
    CLEAR-PCA and CERP Train Senior Civil Servants in Evidence ...
    Jan 6, 2025 · Senior civil servants from various government agencies in Pakistan explored cutting-edge tools and frameworks for evidence-based governance ...Missing: impact | Show results with:impact
  10. [10]
    [PDF] Civil Service Reform Attempts in Pakistan
    Within the civil service, positions are categorised as Basic. Pay Scales (BPS) 1-22; officers are BPS 17-22. The structure of the service (and recruitment ...
  11. [11]
    The Politics of Civil Service Reform in Pakistan | Columbia
    May 1, 2010 · This paper describes how the fundamental obstacles to civil service reform in Pakistan are primarily political in nature and not due to a lack of technical ...
  12. [12]
    Indian Civil Service, Full Form, History, Types, Role of ICS
    The idea of the Indian Civil Service was proposed by Lord Cornwallis, but it was formally introduced under the Charter Act of 1853 , where candidates were ...
  13. [13]
    Evolution of Civil Services in India During British Rule - Vajiram & Ravi
    Jan 24, 2025 · The Civil Service was brought into existence by Lord Cornwallis (1786-93). From the beginning, East India Company (EIC) carried its trade through servants.<|separator|>
  14. [14]
    Aitchison Commission, 1886 - Modern India History Notes - Prepp
    In 1886, Lord Dufferin established a "Public Service Commission" headed by Sir Charles Aitchison to investigate the problems of India's civil services.
  15. [15]
    [PDF] REFORMING PAKISTAN'S CIVIL SERVICE - Asia Report N°185
    Feb 16, 2010 · The Indian Civil Service, the bureaucratic bulwark of British colonial rule in India and the forerunner of the Civil Service of Pakistan.<|separator|>
  16. [16]
    Hall of fame: The ICS served Pakistan well - Newspaper - DAWN.COM
    Sep 4, 2011 · The eighty-one ICS officers who opted for service in Pakistan helped immeasurably in providing an administrative structure which kept things going in the early ...
  17. [17]
    Various_Schemes_of_Pay_Scales.pdf - Finance Division
    civil servants in BPS 17 – 22 whose Secretariat Allowance/Personal Allowance ... the civil employees in BPS 16 – 22 of the Federal Government paid directly from ...Missing: governance | Show results with:governance
  18. [18]
    [PDF] Civil Service Reform Attempts in Pakistan
    Within the civil service, positions are categorised as Basic. Pay Scales (BPS) 1-22; officers are BPS 17-22. The structure of the service (and recruitment ...
  19. [19]
    [PDF] CIVIL SERVICES REFORMS: A ROAD TO COMPREHENSIVE ...
    On independence, Pakistan inherited 95 civil servants and around 300 class-1 officers. This core group had to meet the challenges with meager resources, not ...
  20. [20]
    https://www.brecorder.com/news/3307958
  21. [21]
    [PDF] A Note on Changes in Real Wages of Government Servants
    A comparison of the real wages of govern- ment servants in the 22 grades in 1971-72 and in 1975-76 with government servants at corresponding levels in 1959-60 ...
  22. [22]
    [PPT] Civil Service Reforms based on Dr Ishrat Hussain Report
    ICS was formed on the recommendations of Aitcheson Commission set up in 1866. The ICS cadre became the Civil Service of Pakistan (CSP), with minor modifications.
  23. [23]
    [PDF] ÿþcircular_01072022 - Finance Division
    Jul 1, 2022 · Part-I (Pay). Revision of Basic Pay Scales: The Basic Pay Scales-2022 shall replace the Basic Pay. Scales-2017 with effect from 01-07-2022 as ...
  24. [24]
    [PDF] Bureaucracy and Pro-Poor Change.
    Zulfikar Ali Bhutto's 1973 Administrative reforms mark a major structural break in the institutional development of Pakistan's civil bureaucracy. Key changes ...
  25. [25]
    [PDF] Pakistan A Framework for Civil Service Reform in Pakistan
    Dec 15, 1998 · Among other initiatives, the program comprised an effort to accelerate and broaden the privatization program, a major exercise to "downsize" ...
  26. [26]
    [PDF] CIVIL SERVICE REFORMS IN PAKISTAN,
    Jul 22, 2011 · Max Weber was the first one to talk about bureaucracy as a big improvement over the administration. Any sensible attempt dealing with ...
  27. [27]
    [PDF] REFORMING PAKISTAN'S CIVIL SERVICE - Asia Report N°185
    Feb 16, 2010 · Pakistan's civil bureaucracy has its origins in the Indian. Civil Service (ICS), often described as the “steel frame” that enabled the ...
  28. [28]
    Reforming the Civil Service Compensation in Pakistan
    ... BPS 20-22. ... Abolish the current transport monetisation and adopt a new system, which involves three parties: banks, the government, and grade 20-22 civil ...Missing: changes | Show results with:changes
  29. [29]
    https://establishment.gov.pk/Detail/M2NjMjQ3OTctOTRlNC00ZDVjLTljYzYtN2U3Yzk5YzNkZDVh
  30. [30]
    [PDF] Pakistani Bureaucracy: Crisis of Governance and Prospects of Reform
    This paper is divided into three parts. The first part provides an overview of literature on how the role and assessment of bureaucracy in the Third World ...
  31. [31]
    [PDF] Updated Civil Servants Promotion (BPS-18 to BPS-21) Rules, 2019
    Jan 21, 2025 · - (1) A civil servant having availed or availing ex-Pakistan leave or leave within Pakistan including extra ordinary leave or study leave shall ...
  32. [32]
    [PDF] Service Rules, 2022 - Federal Ombudsman
    Aug 26, 2023 · -Vacancies in posts in. BPS-16 and above shall be filled on all-Pakistan basis in accordance with the merit and provincial, regional and classes ...Missing: governance | Show results with:governance<|separator|>
  33. [33]
    [PDF] Governance Reform Working Paper Series
    Through which, a candidate joining civil service at the age of 30 shall attain grade 22 at the age of 55. 2. Roy A.M.(1964), Generalists vs Specialists in ...<|separator|>
  34. [34]
    [PDF] A MANUAL ON APPOINTMENT, PROMOTION AND TRANSFER
    Other Officers in BPS 21 and BPS 22 Provided with Services of Private Secretary. On upgradation of the post of Private Secretary from BPS. 16 to BPS 17 with ...
  35. [35]
    None
    Below is a merged summary of the promotion procedures for civil servants in Grade 22 and senior scales, consolidating all information from the provided segments into a comprehensive response. To ensure maximum detail and clarity, I will use a combination of narrative text and tables where appropriate (in CSV format within the text) to represent dense data efficiently. The information is organized by key themes: legal basis, eligibility, service length, performance, selection process, acting charge appointments, training requirements, and departmental promotion committees. All useful URLs from the summaries are included at the end.
  36. [36]
    Federal government enacts new policy for bureaucrat promotions
    Mar 9, 2025 · On March 6, 2025, the high-powered selection board approved the promotion of 36 officers from BS-21 to BS-22, including those from the Pakistan ...
  37. [37]
    None
    ### Summary of Civil Servants Promotion (BPS-18 to BPS-21) Rules, 2019
  38. [38]
    Civil servants promotion rules amended on PM's directive - samaa tv
    Mar 7, 2025 · A grade 21 officer's case for promotion to grade-22 can only be presented twice before the High-Powered Selection Board. If an officer is ...
  39. [39]
    Govt Changes Rules for Civil Servants' Promotion - ProPakistani
    Mar 7, 2025 · The federal government has introduced key amendments to the Civil Servants Promotion Rules, 1973, following approval from PM Shehbaz Sharif.
  40. [40]
    Govt notifies more changes to selection board rules
    Mar 9, 2025 · Civil Servant Rules notified​​ On March 6, 2025, the high-powered selection board has approved the promotion of 36 officers of Grade 21 from the ...
  41. [41]
    Chart of Salary Increase 2025 (DRA 30% and ARA 10%)
    Jun 10, 2025 · Chart of Salary Increase 2025 with DRA 30% and ARA 10% for the Federal Govt Employees. The employees will get a total 40% increase.
  42. [42]
    Grade Officer Salary in Pakistan – A Comprehensive Overview
    Sep 9, 2024 · The system ranges from BPS-1 (lowest) to BPS-22 (highest), with the salary for each grade officer increasing with rank, seniority, and years of ...<|separator|>
  43. [43]
    Cash poor, perk rich government officials - Business - DAWN.COM
    Apr 11, 2022 · Allowances account for more than 70pc of the overall income for officers in Grades 20-22. Federal workers get in-kind allowances or perks in ...
  44. [44]
    [PDF] Cash Poor, Perk Rich! Civil Service Compensation
    The bureaucracy was combined into a hierarchical framework of 22 pay scales. The service cadres were unified with a uniform pay scale, recruitment, and training ...
  45. [45]
    Perks of top 100 officers cost half a billion
    TRAVELLING: A grade-22 officer, during official travel, is entitled to a daily allowance of Rs530 and (multiplied into three) Rs1,590 as hotel accommodation. So ...
  46. [46]
    The true costs of perks and privileges of government employees
    Jan 22, 2024 · The financial benefits, excluding salaries and pensions, for class-4 employees (BPS 1-4) average around Rs9.7m, with an operational cost of Rs10.8m.
  47. [47]
    Senior Officers of Federal Government - Establishment Division
    1. Cabinet Division ; Mr. Kamran Ali Afzal, Secretary ; Ms. Ambreen Raza, Special Secretary ; Ms. Samar Ihsan, Additional Secretary ; Mr. Haroon-ur-Rafique ...
  48. [48]
    19 PAS officers promoted to Grade 22 - Dunya News
    Mar 5, 2025 · Also, Secretary Education Mohyuddin Ahmad Wani, Secretary Food Security Waseem Ajmal Chaudhry, and Ambreen Raza were promoted, while Chairman ...
  49. [49]
    PM's principal secretary part of board considering promotions ...
    Mar 17, 2019 · In the past, Saeed Mehdi and Dr Usman Ali G. Isani, BPS 22 officers, served as principal secretaries. However, Mr Sharif appointed Fawad Hasan ...
  50. [50]
    List of Administrative Secretaries of Khyber Pakhtunkhwa
    1. Additional Chief Secretary, Home and Tribal Affairs Department · 2. Principal Secretary to Chief Minister Khyber Pakhtunkhwa · 3. Act as Additional Chief ...<|control11|><|separator|>
  51. [51]
    [PDF] The Civil Service Regulations (CSR) - Finance Division
    The Civil Service Regulations (CSR) contain Government instructions for regulating the service conditions (Pay, leave, pension, other allowances, etc.) of the ...
  52. [52]
    Duties and Functions - HUD & PHED
    Secretary is the official head of a department and is responsible for its efficient administration and discipline, and for the proper conduct of business.
  53. [53]
    Federal Structure-Hierarchy of Pakistan | PDF | Secretary - Scribd
    Secretary A Secretary has following roles. He is administrative head of the Ministry/Department. His responsibility in this regard is complete and undivided.
  54. [54]
    Of ministers and secretaries - Opinion - Business Recorder
    Oct 15, 2025 · Bureaucrats are extremely kind to one another; they create enough work for each other. The simplest tasks are converted into complex issues, ...
  55. [55]
    Political Interference and Bureaucratic Performance in Pakistan
    May 18, 2023 · The research reveals that Political leaders and bureaucrats have certain connections, which is why the civil service is deteriorating over time.
  56. [56]
    Ministerial role sought in secretaries' appointment
    Jan 2, 2019 · ISLAMABAD: A proposal seeking ministers' role in transfer or removal of federal secretaries has been submitted to the Cabinet Division by a ...
  57. [57]
    Governance: Bureaucracy And Politicians, Pakistan, Turkey And ...
    Mar 22, 2024 · In Pakistan, the bureaucracy can 'sabotage' policies because political parties lack professional skills and capacity to understand how ...
  58. [58]
    Cabinet Division
    Government of Pakistan ; Mian Muhammad Shehbaz Sharif. Prime Minister of the Islamic Republic of Pakistan ; Kamran Ali Afzal. Cabinet Secretary ; Mian Muhammad ...
  59. [59]
    MINISTRY OF INTERIOR AND NARCOTICS CONTROL
    Akbar Hussain Durrani (TI) is a BPS grade 22 officer and belongs to the Pakistan Administrative Service (PAS). He has the honour of having served at top ...<|separator|>
  60. [60]
    36 officers get promotion to grade 22 - The Nation
    Mar 6, 2025 · A total of 36 bureaucrats have been promoted to grade 22 on Wednesday including 19 officers of Pakistan Administrative Service, 8 officers of the Police ...
  61. [61]
    Roedad Khan - A Man For All Seasons - The Friday Times
    Apr 29, 2024 · Sadly, neither the military, nor the bureaucracy have learned anything from the successive debacles in our history. Roedad Khan remained part ...
  62. [62]
    Roedad Khan – the bureaucrat who witnessed history firsthand - Dawn
    from General Ayub Khan to Nawaz Sharif ...
  63. [63]
    Roedad Khan, veteran Pakistani civil servant with front-row seat to ...
    Apr 21, 2024 · After entering the Pakistan Civil Service in 1949, Khan's distinguished career as a bureaucrat allowed him to serve in many prestigious roles.
  64. [64]
    Ghulam Ishaq Khan passes away - Newspaper - DAWN.COM
    Oct 28, 2006 · Before rising to echelons of power in mid 1950s, during his early years in the government service he served as a treasury officer in Bannu, ...
  65. [65]
    Ghulam Ishaq Khan | Pakistan - The Guardian
    Oct 29, 2006 · As president from 1988 to 1993, Khan earned the dismal distinction of sacking two elected governments, badly eroding the chances of stable civilian rule.
  66. [66]
    Salman Bashir suggests dialogue between India and Pakistan
    Sep 19, 2024 · Bashir is among the top diplomatic voices in Pakistan, serving as the country's foreign secretary from 2008 to 2012 under then prime minister ...Missing: retired contributions
  67. [67]
    Watch | Lahore Declaration and India-Pakistan Relations - The Wire
    Jul 24, 2019 · In this episode, Happymon Jacob speaks with ambassador Rakesh Sood (India) and ambassador Salman Bashir (retired foreign secretary of ...
  68. [68]
    Ghulam Muhammad Sikandar, a former Grade-22 civil servant and ...
    Aug 5, 2025 · His contributions to public administration, education, and social welfare have left a lasting legacy. He is remembered as a visionary, a mentor ...<|control11|><|separator|>
  69. [69]
    Corruption Perceptions Index 2024 - Transparency.org
    The Corruption Perceptions Index 2024 ranks 180 countries by their perceived levels of public sector corruption. Find out the scores and read our analysis.2023 · CPI 2024: Highlights and... · 1995 - CPI · 2013
  70. [70]
    Pakistan country risk report - GAN Integrity
    There is a high risk of corruption in Pakistan's public services sector. Inefficient government bureaucracy together with high-levels of corruption present ...
  71. [71]
    Whispers of Corruption in Pakistan's Bureaucracy - THE AsiaN
    Aug 14, 2025 · No doubt, corruption is rampant in every sphere of life in Pakistan. Not a single government department is free of this curse, and the country ...
  72. [72]
    New corruption scandal hits Pakistan's biometric safety net program
    Sep 2, 2025 · Some of those indicated include Grade 22 officers who reportedly made their spouses benefit from a scheme meant for poor citizens. Grade-22 is ...Missing: allegations | Show results with:allegations
  73. [73]
    Glaring loopholes in Civil Servants Act tweaks | The Express Tribune
    Feb 14, 2025 · The independent experts also highlighted the overstaffing in the Federal Board of Revenue and prevailing corruption in the organization. It was ...
  74. [74]
    Govt starts scrutiny of Grade 20-22 officers completing 20-year service
    Jul 16, 2020 · The federal government has started scrutiny of Grade-20 to Grade-22 officers of different service groups who have completed 20 years in government service.Missing: allegations | Show results with:allegations
  75. [75]
    22 senior officers likely to be shown the door - Pakistan - DAWN.COM
    Apr 28, 2021 · The panel of the Secretariat Group of BS-22 for “Directory Retirement Board” includes Aamer Hasan, Dr Imran Zeb Khan, Mohammad Hashim Popalzai, ...
  76. [76]
    Govt allegedly violates international obligations in promotions of ...
    Jan 15, 2023 · Sources said that the merit in civil service promotions has been thrown away by placing 30 marks at the CSB's discretion for promotions to grade ...Missing: allegations | Show results with:allegations
  77. [77]
    51 officers promoted to grade 22, interior, information secretaries ...
    51 officers promoted to grade 22, interior, information secretaries, CCP chief replaced: Massive reshuffle in bureaucracy ... nepotism and outright favouritism.
  78. [78]
    Gilani's massive bureaucracy reshuffle reeks of nepotism, say Pak ...
    ... nepotism and favouritism. In what is being touted as the single largest grade-22 promotion in many years, secretaries of interior, information, industries ...
  79. [79]
    Supreme Court overturns 54 grade-22 promotions - Business ...
    Rejecting government's justification, the Supreme Court on Wednesday overturned promotions of 54 bureaucrats in Grade 22, saying that the object of good ...
  80. [80]
    An Examination Of Bureau-Politic Associations In Pakistan
    Aug 23, 2023 · This article delves into the complex issue of Bureau-Politic associations in Pakistan, highlighting both the reform efforts and the lingering ...
  81. [81]
    Pakistan isn't progressing because of nepotism - The Express Tribune
    Sep 14, 2023 · Giving preferences to relatives (nepotism), abusing power by promoting close friends on advantageous opportunities (cronyism), or favouring ...<|separator|>
  82. [82]
    PIDE calls for urgent civil service reforms in Pakistan
    Sep 12, 2025 · Repeated reform efforts since the 1950s have stalled due to political resistance, bureaucratic inertia, and lack of continuity.
  83. [83]
    Urgent transformation of Pakistan's governance system stressed at ...
    Sep 11, 2025 · He said repeated reform efforts since the 1950s have stalled due to political resistance, bureaucratic inertia, and lack of continuity.
  84. [84]
    Public Administration Reform - The Nation
    Dec 17, 2024 · Systemic resistance, coupled with the entrenched power of bureaucratic elites, has repeatedly obstructed reform efforts. Zulfikar Ali Bhutto, ...<|separator|>
  85. [85]
    Civil service reforms cannot succeed without local government ...
    May 16, 2025 · However, such reforms, including those under Ayub Khan and Musharraf, lacked permanence due to the absence of constitutional backing and the ...
  86. [86]
    Why Pakistan's new plan to fix the bureaucracy won't work - Dawn
    Sep 9, 2020 · The new retirement rules are indicative of the priorities of the government or its desire to aim at low hanging fruit.
  87. [87]
    Pakistan's reform dilemma - The News International
    Jun 23, 2025 · Three forces continue to constrain meaningful reform: bureaucratic inertia, elite capture, and institutional fragmentation. Pakistan's ...
  88. [88]
    Pakistan's reform dilemma - Geo News
    Jun 23, 2025 · Three forces continue to constrain meaningful reform: bureaucratic inertia, elite capture, and institutional fragmentation. Pakistan's ...
  89. [89]
    [PDF] REFORMING PAKISTAN'S CIVIL SERVICE - Asia Report N°185
    Feb 16, 2010 · Decades of mismanagement, political manipulation and corruption have rendered Pakistan's civil service incapa-.<|control11|><|separator|>
  90. [90]
    Finally, someone said it - Editorials - Business Recorder
    Jul 18, 2025 · Files disappeared, delays mounted, and ministers found themselves stonewalled by the very departments they were supposed to lead. The ...
  91. [91]
    Reforming Pakistan's Civil Service - International Crisis Group
    Feb 16, 2010 · Decades of mismanagement, political manipulation and corruption have rendered Pakistan's civil service incapable of providing effective ...
  92. [92]
    Non-compliance of rotation policy: Govt seeks explanation from 29 ...
    Nov 25, 2021 · The federal government has sought explanation from 29 police officers and bureaucrats serving across the country in BS-20 for defying transfer orders.
  93. [93]
    [PDF] GOOD GOVERNANCE IN PAKISTAN - Dr. Ishrat Husain
    Jan 22, 2024 · Naturally, the resistance to empowerment and resource transfer to the local governments comes from these legislators who would lose their power ...
  94. [94]
    BUREAUCRATIC INTERVENTION IN THE POLITICS OF PAKISTAN ...
    Sep 17, 2025 · This paper is about the bureaucratic intervention in politics of Pakistan and the dominant role played by the civil servants in policy ...
  95. [95]
    Breaking ranks: Bureaucrats warn of 'pen-down strike'
    Oct 8, 2015 · When it comes to Grade-22, the highest stratum for a government official, PMS officers have 0% representation. At the meeting, PMS officers ...Missing: elected | Show results with:elected
  96. [96]
    Political Accountability, Not “Interference”: Restoring Constitutional ...
    Sep 19, 2025 · Civil servants are expected to be politically impartial, but they only execute policy on behalf of elected officials. No one would claim that an ...
  97. [97]
    Pakistani Bureaucracy: Crisis of Governance and Prospects of Reform
    Aug 7, 2025 · Bureaucracy in Pakistan provided a lead and received laudatory comments for its role in initiating economic development and political stability ...
  98. [98]
    A deteriorating bureaucracy? - The Express Tribune
    Feb 13, 2025 · The signs of bureaucratic decline are increasingly evident: weakened institutions, rising public frustration, political interference and resistance to modern ...Missing: intransigence | Show results with:intransigence
  99. [99]
    PM Shehbaz tasks Ahsan Iqbal with civil service overhaul - Dawn
    Jul 25, 2025 · Chairing a meeting on civil service reforms, the PM directed the committee to submit comprehensive, reform-oriented proposals within one month ...
  100. [100]
    Panel unveils sweeping civil service reforms - GIDS
    Jul 25, 2025 · ISLAMABAD: Prime Minister Shehbaz Sharif's new committee, headed by Minister Ahsan Iqbal, has proposed national executive service (NES) with ...
  101. [101]
    Reforming the civil service - Newspaper - DAWN.COM
    Aug 4, 2025 · Reduce the tiers in the bureaucratic hierarchy, merge divisions which have proliferated and abolish posts lying vacant for over three years.
  102. [102]
    Senate passes bill to bind civil servants from BPS-17 to BPS-22 to ...
    Jun 20, 2025 · The Senate on Thursday passed the Civil Servants (Amendment) Bill, 2025, which mandates civil servants in grades BPS-17 to BPS-22 to publicly declare both ...
  103. [103]
    reforming pakistan's bureaucracy: enhancing governance ...
    Sep 2, 2024 · This research study investigates the intricate dynamics of governance, institutional quality, and professionalism within Pakistan's bureaucratic framework.
  104. [104]
    Bureaucracy in Pakistan - VoxDev
    Jul 1, 2025 · Implications for the future of Pakistan's civil service. Research featured on VoxDev has documented the extent of bureaucratic inefficiency ...
  105. [105]
    Civil Services Exam in Pakistan: How 'IAS' officers are selected
    Feb 10, 2025 · Civil Services Exam in Pakistan: How 'IAS' officers are selected; Is PAS process same as in India? What is the salary difference? Know Here. In ...
  106. [106]
    Civil service reforms in British India and united Pakistan
    Pakistan inherited and continued with the British administrative system. The Civil Service of Pakistan (CSP) was modelled after the ICS.
  107. [107]
    Are Civil Services on the Decline in India and Pakistan?
    Mar 13, 2025 · Pakistan's bureaucracy has long been viewed as influential, with analysts arguing that it controls much of the political process.