Fact-checked by Grok 2 weeks ago

Lengua

Lengua, a term derived from Spanish meaning "tongue," historically denotes two Mascoian languages spoken by indigenous groups in Paraguay's Gran Chaco region: Enlhet, also called Northern Lengua, and Enxet, known as Southern Lengua.^[1]^[2] These languages belong to the Enlhet-Enenlhet (formerly Maskoy) family, a small group of Chacoan tongues characterized by agglutinative grammar and a reliance on oral traditions among hunter-gatherer and semi-nomadic communities.^[3] Enlhet is primarily used by the Enlhet people in northern Chaco settlements, while Enxet serves the southern Enxet communities, with both maintaining vitality through community efforts despite pressures from Spanish dominance and land encroachment.^[4]^[5] The languages feature distinct phonological inventories, including ejective consonants in some dialects, and play a central role in preserving cultural narratives tied to the region's ecology and cosmology.^[2]

Names and etymology

Origin of the exonym "Lengua"

The exonym "Lengua," meaning "tongue" in Spanish, originated from observations by early Spanish colonists and explorers of the Gran Chaco region, who noted the indigenous practice of inserting wooden or bone labrets (known as barbotes) into the lower lip, causing it to protrude in a manner resembling an extended tongue. This descriptive term was applied starting in the late 16th century, as documented in colonial chronicles detailing expeditions into the Chaco Boreal, where such piercings were common among Mascoian-speaking groups inhabiting the area west of the Paraguay River.^[6] Historical records indicate the name's first attestations in 17th-century Jesuit accounts, such as those by missionaries interacting with Chaco tribes during attempts at pacification and conversion, though its application was inconsistent and often extended beyond a single ethnic group to various nomadic bands exhibiting similar adornments or speech-related traits.^[7] For instance, the term encompassed peoples later classified under the Lengua-Enlhet and Lengua-Enxet subgroups, reflecting a broad, non-ethnic categorization rather than a precise tribal identifier derived from self-designations like Enlhet or Enxet.^[8] While the label carried potential pejorative undertones due to its emphasis on physical modification—possibly evoking mockery in European eyes—primary sources emphasize its utilitarian role in distinguishing "barbote-wearing" hunter-gatherers from neighboring Guarani or Toba groups without such customs, without evidence of deliberate derogatory intent in early usages. By the 18th century, "Lengua" appeared in missionary vocabularies and reports, such as those compiling Mascoian linguistic data, further entrenching it as a regional exonym despite varying clan-specific applications.^[9]

Shift to endonyms and modern terminology

In the mid-20th century, particularly following increased ethnographic documentation after the 1950s, members of the indigenous groups historically termed "Lengua" began favoring endonyms that reflect dialectal and cultural distinctions, with "Enlhet" adopted for northern communities and "Enxet" for southern ones.^[1] This shift emphasized self-identification over the Spanish exonym "Lengua," which originated from colonial perceptions of linguistic traits but was increasingly viewed as external and imprecise.^[10] The transition aligned with broader patterns of indigenous self-assertion in the Paraguayan Chaco, where groups sought terminology rooted in their own linguistic systems to distinguish subgroups and assert autonomy amid ongoing land disputes and cultural documentation efforts. Linguists and anthropologists, through fieldwork in the 1970s to 1990s, played a key role in formalizing these endonyms via rigorous phonetic and sociolinguistic analysis, prioritizing native consultants' preferences over prior colonial classifications.^[5] Institutions like the Enlhet Institute, established in 1995 by researchers including Ernesto Unruh and Hannes Kalisch, further promoted "Enlhet" documentation, producing grammars and oral histories that embedded self-names in academic outputs.^[11] Similarly, Enxet-focused studies highlighted the term's internal usage, rejecting amalgamations like "Lengua-Maskoy" deemed pejorative by community members.^[10] Despite the preference for endonyms, "Lengua" persists in historical records, legal documents, and some international references, such as Inter-American Court rulings identifying groups as "South Enxet and North Enlhet Lengua."^[12] Population estimates reflect continuity under new nomenclature: a 2012 census recorded 8,167 Enlhet Norte and 7,284 Enxet Sur speakers and affiliates, comprising distinct yet related communities within the Mascoyan language family.^[5] This dual usage underscores the practical retention of exonyms for archival precision while endonyms gain traction in contemporary advocacy and revitalization initiatives.

History

Pre-contact origins and inter-tribal dynamics

The Lengua people, speakers of a Mascoian language, trace their pre-contact origins to the central Gran Chaco region of Paraguay, where Mascoian tribes including the Mascoi, Lengua proper, and related Enimaga groups shared closely related dialects suggestive of a common ancestral stock adapted to semi-arid conditions through mobile hunter-gatherer economies focused on seasonal foraging, fishing, and small-game hunting.^[6] Ethnographic reconstructions indicate these groups maintained high mobility, with composite bands of 50 to 200 individuals relocating seasonally or following deaths to avoid spiritual contamination, carrying lightweight mats and possessions without fixed villages or monumental architecture due to the terrain's demands and lack of sedentary agriculture.^[6] Archaeological traces, such as scattered potsherds showing limited external influences like Guarani ceramics, underscore this nomadic pattern rather than centralized settlements, with no evidence of large-scale polities or state-like organizations.^[6] Internal social organization centered on extended family units within bands, led by non-hereditary chiefs selected for demonstrated wisdom, oratory skill, or shamanic abilities, who mediated disputes and redistributed resources but held no coercive authority, reflecting egalitarian tendencies constrained by resource scarcity.^[6] Bands operated autonomously, forming temporary alliances for hunts or defense based on kinship ties and mutual benefit, yet lacked formalized clans or descent groups, with prestige accruing to warriors and shamans through prowess in raids rather than inherited status.^[6] This structure facilitated adaptability to the Chaco's unpredictable water sources and game migrations but precluded unified political entities, as leadership dissolved with the chief's death or band fission. Inter-tribal dynamics were characterized by chronic raiding and skirmishes rather than harmony, with Mascoian groups like the Lengua and Enimaga engaging in surprise attacks against neighbors to capture women and children for integration as laborers or spouses, a practice that sustained band sizes amid high mortality from environmental stresses.^[6] Conflicts with Guaicuru-speaking Mbayá along southern frontiers involved territorial displacements, while pressures from Toba and Pilagá tribes drove Enimaga migrations northward from the Pilcomayo River area to the upper Rio Verde, fragmenting populations and fueling retaliatory cycles.^[6] Tactics emphasized mobility, such as signaling war parties with red-dyed arrows or exploiting seasonal gatherings for ambushes, yielding captives who bolstered servile elements in some bands without developing ritualized mass violence or fortifications, as evidenced by the absence of defensive earthworks in Chaco surveys.^[6] These patterns, reconstructed from oral accounts and early explorer observations cross-referenced with linguistics, contradict notions of pre-contact pacifism, revealing instead a landscape of opportunistic aggression tied to demographic and resource competition.^[6]

European contact and early colonial interactions (16th-18th centuries)

Spanish expeditions into the Gran Chaco region during the 1530s and 1540s, led by explorers such as Juan de Ayolas in 1537–1539 and Domingo Martínez de Irala in 1540, 1542, and 1548–1549, marked the initial European incursions into territories inhabited by nomadic groups including ancestors of the Lengua (Maskoy) peoples. These forays, aimed at resource extraction and territorial scouting from the newly founded Asunción settlement, encountered Chaco tribes skilled in archery and evasion tactics, who utilized the region's dense forests and rivers to avoid sustained engagement or capture.^[6] Direct interactions with Lengua groups were limited and often hostile, with reports noting their use of bows and poisoned arrows in skirmishes against intruders, though no large-scale settlements or reductions were established in core Lengua areas during this period.^[6] By the 17th century, Jesuit missionaries extended limited outreach from Guarani reductions founded in 1609, attempting sporadic contacts with Chaco border groups, but Lengua mobility and resistance confined these to frontier trade rather than permanent missions. European-introduced diseases, particularly smallpox epidemics documented in nearby Jesuit outposts like Santos Reyes Magos by 1626, precipitated demographic collapses across Chaco populations, with overall indigenous numbers in the region declining by estimates of 80–90% from pre-contact levels by the early 18th century due to recurrent outbreaks lacking immunity.^[6]^[13] Lengua groups selectively engaged in exchanges for metal tools and iron implements via intermediaries, acquiring these through raids on Spanish outposts or trade with allied tribes, which facilitated adaptations in hunting and warfare without full subjugation.^[13] Encomienda-driven labor raids intensified in the late 16th and 17th centuries, prompting organized resistance from Lengua and related Maskoy bands through guerrilla tactics and counter-raids against Paraguayan settlers, as evidenced by persistent warfare patterns extending into the 18th century. By the late 1700s, archival accounts such as those by Félix de Azara in 1794 recorded Lengua populations reduced to mere dozens (e.g., 22 individuals), attributing this to combined effects of disease, intertribal conflict exacerbated by colonial pressures, and encomienda extractions rather than isolated epidemics.^[6]^[13] These episodes of defiance, including ambushes on encomendero parties, underscored the Lengua's strategic use of terrain for evasion and retaliation, preserving autonomy amid encroaching colonial frontiers.^[13]

19th-century missions and forced relocations

In the aftermath of the Paraguayan War (1864–1870), which devastated Paraguay's eastern regions but left the western Chaco relatively insulated, the Lengua (part of the Maskoy linguistic group) continued semi-nomadic lifestyles centered on hunting for skins and rhea feathers, with limited direct involvement in the conflict.^[14] Initial European contacts intensified around 1870, when Qom refugees introduced Maskoy groups to criollo labor demands, particularly in emerging tannin extraction operations along the Paraguay River, drawing some Lengua into wage labor while displacing others from traditional territories through land clearances for estancias.^[15] Missionary expansion accelerated in the late 1880s, beginning with the British South American Missionary Society establishing the first station in the Paraguayan Chaco, followed by Salesian explorations from 1892 onward under figures like Ángel Savio, who targeted Lengua communities near Concepción and sedentarization efforts among nomadic groups via gift exchanges such as food and religious medallions to secure cacique alliances.^[16]^[17] Salesian records describe these interactions as voluntary inducements rather than overt coercion, though broader state land concessions to foreign companies post-war facilitated indirect pressures on indigenous mobility, with some Lengua groups experiencing territorial encroachments that prompted partial relocations toward mission outposts and labor sites.^[17]^[15] State interventions remained sporadic, prioritizing eastern reconstruction over Chaco control, but by the 1890s, census efforts like the 1886–1887 national count indirectly highlighted indigenous presence through total population figures (329,645), underscoring underenumeration of remote groups like the Lengua amid growing factional tendencies—some subgroups integrated into criollo economies via trade and labor, while others resisted mission overtures, maintaining autonomy in the interior Chaco. No comprehensive Lengua-specific census data from the decade survives, but missionary ethnographies note divisions in responses to sedentarization, with voluntary adherents gaining access to goods contrasted against wary holdouts viewing missionaries as threats to traditional raiding and mobility.^[17] These dynamics reflected causal pressures from land scarcity and economic incentives rather than unified forced relocations, though tannin industry demands imposed de facto coerced labor on segments willing to engage.^[15]

20th-century developments: Mennonite settlements and state policies

The aftermath of the Chaco War (1932–1935) strengthened Paraguay's sovereignty over the Gran Chaco region, enabling the establishment and expansion of Mennonite colonies that had begun in the late 1920s. The Fernheim colony was founded in 1930 by around 1,500 Russian Mennonite refugees fleeing Soviet persecution, while the Menno colony originated from Canadian Mennonites arriving between 1927 and 1931; these groups acquired large land concessions from the Paraguayan government to assert territorial claims against Bolivian ambitions.^[18]^[19] Such settlements introduced advanced agriculture, including dairy farming and beef production, creating limited wage labor opportunities for local indigenous groups like the Lengua (also known as Maskoy), but primarily resulted in territorial encroachments on untitled ancestral lands used for hunting and gathering.^[20]^[21] During Alfredo Stroessner's dictatorship (1954–1989), state policies framed indigenous integration as developmental progress while treating groups like the Lengua as impediments to modernization, thereby endorsing further colonization, land privatization, and evangelical missions in the Chaco.^[22] The regime's 1973 Bilingual Education Program initiated transitional instruction in indigenous languages alongside Spanish, ostensibly to facilitate assimilation and access to national institutions, though it prioritized cultural homogenization over preservation.^[23] This approach correlated with expanded Mennonite economic influence, including informal land transactions and joint agricultural ventures that displaced Lengua communities from traditional territories without adequate compensation or recognition of customary usage rights.^[21] Stroessner's overthrow in 1989 ushered in democratic reforms, culminating in the 1992 Constitution's explicit acknowledgment of indigenous peoples' rights to communal land ownership "in quantity and quality sufficient for the conservation and development" of their communities, as well as cultural and economic autonomy (Article 64).^[24] Despite this legal framework, enforcement remained inconsistent, with 2000s documentation revealing continued informal encroachments by Mennonite settlers and other actors into Lengua territories amid rising commercial pressures from soy and cattle expansion.^[21]^[25] These dynamics underscored a tension between formal rights recognition and practical territorial vulnerabilities.

Language

Linguistic classification and dialects

The Lengua languages form part of the Mascoian language family, a small indigenous language group native to the Gran Chaco region of northern Paraguay, encompassing varieties such as Enlhet, Enxet, and Sanapaná.^[26]^[27] This family is characterized by close genetic relations among its members but lacks robust evidence for inclusion in broader proposed phyla like Macro-Waikurúan, despite occasional suggestions of distant ties to Guaicuruan or Matacoan families based on limited lexical comparisons.^[28] Within the Lengua varieties, Enlhet (Northern Lengua) and Enxet (Southern Lengua) represent the primary dialects historically associated with the exonym "Lengua," spoken by distinct subgroups in the Paraguayan Chaco.^[29] These dialects exhibit low mutual intelligibility, reflecting sufficient linguistic divergence to support separate ethnolinguistic identities, as evidenced by distinct phonological inventories, grammatical structures, and lexical choices that hinder comprehension between speakers.^[29] Enlhet is primarily used in northern areas, while Enxet predominates in southern communities, with both showing influences from prolonged contact, including post-1950s incorporation of Spanish loanwords for modern concepts and trade items.^[30] Speakers of these dialects, totaling an estimated 10,000 to 15,000 individuals as of the 2020s, are concentrated in the departments of Boquerón and Presidente Hayes, where the languages maintain vitality amid bilingualism with Spanish and Guarani.^[3]^[26]

Phonology, grammar, and vocabulary

The Mascoian languages, including those referred to as Lengua varieties such as Enlhet and Enxet, feature phonological systems characterized by simple consonant inventories lacking ejective consonants, which are uncommon in the family despite their presence in some neighboring Chaco languages.^[31] Consonant clusters are generally avoided, with nasals, stops, fricatives, and approximants forming the core set; for instance, Enenlhet includes bilabial, alveolar, and velar places of articulation without glottalized variants.^[32] Vowel systems are typically reduced, ranging from three contrastive vowels in Enlhet (/i, a, u/) to five in related varieties like Sanapaná (/i, ɪ, a, o, u/), often accompanied by nasalization and harmony effects that condition alternations between oral and nasal forms.^[31]^[33] Stress placement tends to be suffix-oriented, with primary accent falling on the final or penultimate syllable in agglutinated forms, contributing to rhythmic predictability in longer words.^[34] Grammatically, these languages are agglutinative and polysynthetic, incorporating extensive verbal inflection for person, number, evidentiality, and aspect through suffixation, often resulting in complex predicates that encode multiple arguments.^[33] Basic constituent order is verb-subject-object (VSO), diverging from the subject-verb-object (SVO) patterns prevalent in Spanish and some areal Chaco influences, with nominative-accusative alignment augmented by classifiers that distinguish animacy hierarchies and nominal shapes.^[31] A masculine-feminine gender system operates indirectly via agreement markers on verbs and classifiers rather than inherent nominal gender, reflecting sensitivity to human reference without pervasive noun class proliferation.^[31] Nominal derivation employs prefixes for possession and incorporation, while predicates incorporate spatial and temporal particles, as documented in Sanapaná descriptions.^[33] The vocabulary of Mascoian languages emphasizes environmental specificity, with dense lexicons for Chaco flora and fauna adapted to the region's semiarid ecology, including terms for over 150 distinct tree species in Enxet corpora derived from ethnographic documentation.^[35] Contact with Guaraní has introduced calques, such as compound expressions for agricultural concepts, preserving semantic structures while adapting to indigenous substrates; for example, hybrid forms for "bitter manioc" mirror Guaraní patterns but retain Mascoian classifiers.^[36] Core lexicon resists heavy Romance borrowing, prioritizing retention of autochthonous roots for kinship, hunting, and cosmology, as evidenced in comparative Chaco wordlists.^[35]

Documentation, endangerment, and revitalization

The Enlhet and Enxet languages, spoken by indigenous groups in Paraguay's Gran Chaco region, are classified as threatened according to Ethnologue assessments, indicating that while adults maintain use in some domains, transmission to children is no longer the norm and fluency among youth remains limited, with surveys from documentation projects showing intergenerational gaps in proficiency.^[3] UNESCO-aligned metrics place Enlhet in the "definitely endangered" category, where speakers are primarily from older generations and children adopt Spanish or Guaraní as primary languages, while Enxet faces severe endangerment risks due to similar patterns of reduced child acquisition, though some varieties retain pockets of vitality among adolescents. These statuses reflect broader pressures from bilingualism and economic necessities, yet critiques note that alarmist focuses on imminent loss often overlook how adaptive Spanish-Enxet code-switching facilitates labor market integration without fully eroding cultural transmission in hybrid forms.^[37] Documentation efforts began with limited colonial-era records but advanced significantly in the late 20th century through missionary and academic work, including grammatical sketches and lexical compilations that captured core phonological and morphological features.^[2] Key modern contributions include the Endangered Languages Documentation Programme's Enxet project, which since the early 2010s has produced annotated audio-video corpora covering narratives, conversations, and rituals to preserve genres at risk of loss. Comprehensive grammars, such as the first detailed description of Enxet Sur syntax and semantics based on fieldwork, provide foundational references for analysis, emphasizing predicate-initial structures and evidential systems unique to the Enlhet-Enenlhet family.^[2] Revitalization initiatives, largely community-driven since the 2000s, include bilingual education programs in indigenous schools and digital resources like mobile apps for vocabulary building, though outcomes show mixed success with persistent low fluency rates under 50% among those under 20 in 2010s evaluations. Religious translations, such as the full Enxet Bible completed in 2016 after decades of collaborative effort, have bolstered literacy and ritual use, serving as tools for both preservation and identity reinforcement.^[38] However, these efforts prioritize pragmatic bilingualism over monolingual purism, enabling socioeconomic adaptation—such as employment in Mennonite colonies—while sustaining core linguistic functions, countering narratives that frame shift solely as cultural erosion without acknowledging its role in resilience.^[3]

Society and culture

The Lengua (also known as Maskoy) kinship system is characterized by bilateral descent, with certain matrilineal tendencies observed in residence patterns and group identification.^[14] ^[6] Post-marriage residence is typically uxorilocal (matrilocal) initially, allowing couples to reside with the wife's family, though it may shift to the husband's band if the paternal group is small or for pragmatic reasons.^[6] Kinship terminology varies regionally, with western groups employing an Iroquois-type system (distinguishing lineal and collateral relatives) and eastern groups a Hawaiian-type (generational classification); teknonymy (naming parents after children) and mourning names further structure relations.^[14] Extended family networks form the core of social units, facilitating resource sharing and mutual support in bands of 50–200 individuals, often composed of related families named after animals, plants, or objects.^[6] Social organization centers on exogamous bands that aggregate into endogamous subtribes, with decisions reached through consensus among elders rather than hereditary chiefs.^[14] Leadership emerges informally from influential men, frequently shamans selected for wisdom, courage, or oratory skill, whose authority relies on personal charisma and community approval rather than formal institutions.^[6] ^[14] Shamans exert significant influence in dispute resolution, healing, and ritual matters, often overlapping with leadership roles, as documented in mid-20th-century ethnographic fieldwork.^[6] Bands maintain flexibility, adapting to environmental pressures through alliances and mobility, prioritizing pragmatic cooperation over rigid hierarchies.^[6] Gender roles traditionally divide labor along complementary lines, with men responsible for hunting, fishing, and warfare—using spears for game like eels and lungfish—while women focus on gathering wild fruits and tubers, weaving, pottery, and household construction.^[6] ^[14] Women also mediate kinship ties, participating in rituals such as puberty ceremonies where they perform dances and preparatory roles, underscoring their centrality in family networks.^[6] These divisions have shown adaptability, with women's roles in gathering ensuring subsistence stability amid male absences for raids or hunts, though external influences like missions introduced shifts toward nuclear families in individual huts.^[14] Shamans are predominantly male but can include women, blending spiritual authority across genders.^[14]

Traditional economy and adaptation to modernity

Traditionally, the Lengua people of the Paraguayan Chaco subsisted primarily through hunting, gathering, and fishing, characterized by seasonal nomadism across family bands. Men conducted hunts targeting larger game such as peccaries, tapir, deer, and rheas using bows, arrows, spears, and later horses, while women gathered algaroba pods, fruits, roots, and palm shoots, contributing significantly to caloric intake.^[14] Limited horticulture supplemented foraging, but the economy relied on exploiting the Chaco's semiarid resources without fixed settlements.^[39] Post-contact pressures from missionary activities and land encroachment prompted a gradual shift toward pastoralism, with sheep herding emerging in the 19th century for wool trade in ponchos and sashes.^[14] By the mid-20th century, cattle ranching supplanted sheep as the dominant adaptation, with many Lengua serving as cowhands or laborers on expanding ranches amid broader Chaco commercialization starting in the 1960s.^[40]^[14] On reduced communal lands secured through 1980s struggles, Lengua communities integrated small-scale cattle herding since the 1970s, marketing livestock to regional buyers while supplementing income through wage labor on Mennonite colonies, which employ indigenous workers in dairy and beef operations.^[41]^[42] Urban migration has further diversified livelihoods, with remittances from Asunción and Ciudad del Este supporting rural households, enabling investments in herd expansion and basic infrastructure.^[43] Community cooperatives, such as those processing native products like carob derivatives in allied Chaco groups, demonstrate resilience by channeling market sales into sustainable revenues, averaging annual incomes of approximately 5-10 million guaraníes per household in successful ventures, countering narratives of perpetual dependency through self-managed economic nodes.^[44] This integration reflects causal adaptation to land constraints, leveraging labor mobility and niche commodities for viability amid dominant agribusiness.^[45]

Material culture, arts, and oral traditions

The Lengua, also known as Enlhet-Enxet, traditionally employed bows and arrows crafted from local hardwoods such as palm for hunting and warfare in the Gran Chaco region, with arrow points often tipped with bone or poisoned materials derived from natural toxins.^[46] Basketry techniques involved coiled or twined constructions from riverine reeds and fibers, used for storage and carrying, as evidenced by specimens in ethnographic collections from early 20th-century expeditions.^[47] Featherwork, including decorative headdresses and ornaments from ostrich or rhea plumes, served utilitarian and status purposes, with examples preserved in South American indigenous artifact inventories.^[47] Oral traditions among the Lengua include ancestral legends recounting migration and leadership origins, such as narratives of a female ruler descending from northwestern mountains to guide the people, transmitted through generations to encode historical migrations and social hierarchies rather than supernatural etiologies.^[5] These stories, documented in ethnographic surveys from the early 20th century, prioritize pragmatic lessons on adaptation and group cohesion amid environmental hardships, as recorded during expeditions in the Chaco by explorers like Erland Nordenskiöld, whose fieldwork yielded comparative accounts of regional indigenous narratives.^[48] In contemporary settings, Lengua artisans produce hybrid woven goods, such as ponchos from introduced sheep wool dyed with vegetal extracts, marketed to tourists and settlers for economic adaptation, reflecting a fusion of pre-contact weaving methods with post-colonial materials while maintaining geometric patterns symbolizing territorial knowledge.^[5] Collections in institutions like the Museo Etnográfico Andrés Barbero in Asunción house such transitional artifacts, illustrating the shift from subsistence tools to commodified crafts amid Mennonite influences since the 1930s.^[49]

Religion and worldview

Indigenous spiritual practices and cosmology

The cosmology of the Lengua (Maskoy) people envisions a multi-layered universe comprising the earthly realm, a western land of the dead where souls of deceased kin group together, and elevated spiritual domains such as the Milky Way, which serves as the abode for shamans' souls after death.^[14] Ordinary souls typically transform into animals, particularly birds, reflecting an animistic framework where natural elements and fauna possess inherent spiritual agency rather than deriving from a singular monotheistic creator.^[14] Animal spirits, often conceptualized as owners or masters of species, directly influence practical activities like hunting success, with shamans invoking them to ensure prey availability based on observed environmental patterns and ritual efficacy.^[14] This worldview lacks a supreme deity, emphasizing instead diffuse, pragmatic interactions with spirits tied to empirical outcomes such as resource procurement and illness resolution. Shamanic practices form the core of Lengua spiritual life, with shamans—predominantly male but including potent female figures in oral accounts—serving as intermediaries who heal through chanting, soul-sucking techniques, and recapturing lost souls afflicted by evil spirits.^[14] These rituals address illnesses empirically linked to spirit intrusions or soul wanderings, often manifesting as observable symptoms like sudden weakness or unnatural deaths among the young, with shamans employing chants to diagnose and expel malevolent forces while averting broader threats like storms or infertility.^[14] Funerary rites underscore this pragmatism, involving skull mutilation, insertion of a glowing stone into the corpse (believed to manifest as a meteor targeting murderers), and destruction of the deceased's possessions or village relocation to evade vengeful souls, thereby restoring communal balance.^[14] Inter-tribal variations exist among Lengua subgroups, such as differences in chant repertoires and spirit invocation methods, with ethnographic records indicating pre-contact syncretic influences from neighboring Chaco peoples like the Mataco, who shared tobacco-mediated rituals for spirit communication despite Lengua emphasis on vocal and somatic techniques over intoxicants.^[14] These practices prioritize causal linkages between ritual actions and tangible results—such as regulated rainfall for agriculture or repelled predators—without essentialist supernatural commitments, as shamans' authority derives from demonstrated proficiency in averting empirically verifiable harms like failed hunts or epidemics.^[14] Documented in early 20th-century accounts, such traditions persisted amid environmental pressures, adapting to seasonal cycles observed in the Gran Chaco's arid ecology.^[14]

Missionary impacts and religious syncretism

Missionary activities among the Lengua (Enlhet) people of the Paraguayan Chaco began with sporadic Jesuit contacts in the 1700s, involving limited baptisms and evangelization efforts amid broader explorations of the region, though without establishing permanent reductions like those among the Guaraní.^[6] These early interactions yielded few conversions, as nomadic Chaco groups including the Lengua resisted sustained settlement, with records noting occasional baptisms during expeditions rather than mass incorporations.^[50] Conversion accelerated in the 20th century through Salesian Catholic missions established in the Chaco from the 1930s onward, alongside Protestant efforts by groups like the South American Missionary Society and later evangelicals, leading to widespread baptisms often tied to provision of medical aid and refuge from epidemics and settler encroachments.^[51] By the 2000s, approximately two-thirds of Enlhet identified as Christian, predominantly Roman Catholic with a growing evangelical minority, reflecting mission records of voluntary baptisms motivated by both spiritual appeals and pragmatic benefits such as food distribution and protection from violence.^[52] ^[53] Analyses of these records critique claims of outright coercion, emphasizing that while contextual pressures like population decline from diseases (reducing Lengua numbers to around 2,000 by 1920) incentivized affiliation, many conversions involved active participation, with missionaries documenting indigenous initiative in seeking baptism for community stability.^[5] ^[53] Religious syncretism emerged prominently, blending Lengua shamanic elements—such as spirit mediation and healing rites—with Christian frameworks, particularly evangelical interpretations recasting traditional spirit possession as demonic affliction amenable to exorcism and prayer.^[54] In evangelical communities, former shamanic practices persist covertly behind church rituals, where ancestral spirits are reframed as biblical entities, allowing continuity of cosmological agency while adopting prohibitions on overt sorcery. Debates persist on these dynamics, with high Christian retention rates—evidenced by sustained church attendance and low apostasy in mission-founded settlements—indicating a perceived cultural fit, as converts integrated Christian moral codes with adaptive reinterpretations of indigenous worldview, fostering resilience amid modernization.^[53] Conversely, ethnographic accounts highlight losses in ritual knowledge transmission, where suppression of shamanic initiations under missionary influence eroded esoteric traditions, though syncretic survivals mitigate total displacement.^[54]

Demographics and current status

Population estimates and geographic distribution

The Enlhet and Enxet Sur populations, historically grouped under the ethnonym Lengua, totaled 18,063 individuals according to Paraguay's 2022 IV Censo Nacional de Población y Viviendas para Pueblos Indígenas conducted by the Instituto Nacional de Estadística (INE), with 9,874 Enlhet and 8,189 Enxet Sur.^[55] These figures represent official counts but may undercount due to seasonal mobility, remote community access challenges, and temporary urban relocations for labor, as noted in prior censuses and ethnographic reports on Chaco indigenous groups.^[5] Geographically, both groups are concentrated in the western Paraguayan Chaco, primarily within the departments of Presidente Hayes and Boquerón, along tributaries of the Paraguay River such as the Monte Lindo and Verde.^[55] The Enlhet occupy approximately 14 communities in these departments, while the Enxet Sur are distributed across about 17 communities, often in rural settings with limited infrastructure.^[56] Smaller numbers extend into Concepción department for northern Enlhet subgroups.^[4] Urban migration affects distribution, with an overall 12% of Paraguay's indigenous population residing in urban areas per the 2022 census, including Enlhet and Enxet individuals drawn to Asunción and Encarnación for wage labor amid rural economic pressures.^[55] This mobility contributes to fluid demographics, as families maintain ties to ancestral communities while seeking opportunities in eastern urban centers.^[56]

Socioeconomic conditions and integration challenges

The Lengua people, also known as Enxet-Lengua and part of the broader Maskoy-Enxet indigenous groups in Paraguay's Chaco region, exhibit literacy rates of approximately 73% among adults aged 15 and older, reflecting an illiteracy rate of 27.1% that significantly exceeds the national average of 6%. Average years of schooling for this demographic stand at 4.6 years, with bilingual programs incorporating Lengua language materials providing some support, though implementation is uneven. In remote Chaco communities, educational access remains constrained by infrastructure deficits, such as school closures due to water shortages affecting over 100 children in areas like Pozo Colorado as of July 2024, and high dropout rates driven by familial demands for child labor in subsistence agriculture and seasonal ranch work.^[57]^[1]^[10] Poverty affects roughly 66.2% of Paraguay's indigenous population, including the Lengua, with rates climbing to 68% in rural Chaco settings and extreme poverty impacting 34.4%; child and adolescent poverty reaches 73.7%, exacerbated by limited access to nutritious food despite programs like "Zero Hunger." Economic reliance on low-wage agricultural labor for Mennonite or rancher employers predominates, supplemented by NGO aid and sporadic state assistance, though self-initiated cooperatives or enterprises remain rare amid land constraints and historical dispossession. Youth employment hovers at 38.5%, with over half outside the labor force, underscoring structural barriers like skill mismatches and geographic isolation.^[57]^[58]^[1] Integration into broader Paraguayan society poses challenges balancing cultural preservation with economic necessity, as many Lengua individuals subsist as day laborers under exploitative conditions, facing discrimination and limited upward mobility. Yet, instances of agency are evident in growing political organization, such as community advocacy through groups like the Enlhet Institute, and select successes in education and health roles that counter assimilationist critiques emphasizing passive victimhood. Persistent issues including youth substance abuse, domestic violence, and suicide rates—26 cases among those under 30 in 2022—highlight the toll of rapid modernization without adequate support, though international NGO involvement has bolstered legal and cultural resilience.^[10]^[57]^[1]

Land rights and conflicts

Historical dispossessions and legal battles

The territories traditionally occupied by the Lengua (also known as Enxet-Lengua), a Chaco indigenous group, underwent significant shrinkage from the late 19th century onward due to encroachment by cattle ranchers and missionaries establishing outposts, which fragmented hunting and gathering ranges without formal recognition of indigenous claims.^[21] By the early 20th century, these pressures intensified as state assertions of sovereignty facilitated non-indigenous settlement, reducing Lengua access to ancestral areas encompassing dry forests and waterways essential for subsistence.^[59] Mennonite colonies, established starting in 1927, acquired vast tracts—up to 2 million hectares across the Chaco—through purchases from ranchers, often on lands overlapping Lengua territories, resulting in displacement and labor recruitment of indigenous families.^[60] This expansion continued into the mid-20th century, with further land sales and resettlements in the 1960s eroding traditional mobility and leading to the uprooting of approximately 2,000 Lengua individuals as colonies prioritized mechanized agriculture and ranching.^[40]^[19] Paraguay's 1981 Indigenous Communities Statute (Law 904/81) mandated land titling and protection for groups like the Lengua, yet implementation faltered amid bureaucratic delays and private landowner resistance, prompting international litigation.^[61] In the landmark 2005 Inter-American Court of Human Rights ruling on Yakye Axa v. Paraguay—concerning an Enxet-Lengua community—the court found violations of property rights under Article 21 of the American Convention, ordering the state to delimit and restore 12,500 hectares of claimed ancestral land within three years, a directive unmet until partial enforcement.^[59]^[62] Subsequent 2010s rulings reinforced these obligations, with Paraguay's 2012 acquisition of 12,312 hectares for Yakye Axa marking a key restitution amid ongoing state failures to demarcate claims promptly.^[63] Aggregate recoveries across Chaco Lengua-related communities exceeded 100,000 hectares by mid-decade, including expropriations upheld by Paraguay's Supreme Court in 2014 against rancher appeals, though mapping assessments indicate retention of only about 20% of broader ancestral domains due to persistent untitled overlaps.^[64]^[65]

Contemporary disputes with agribusiness and conservation efforts

In the Paraguayan Chaco, Lengua communities, also referred to as Enxet-Lengua or subgroups within the Maskoy linguistic family, have encountered persistent territorial encroachments from agribusiness operations, primarily large-scale cattle ranching and soybean cultivation, which have accelerated deforestation and displaced traditional livelihoods. By 2021, Paraguay recorded heightened incidents of violent indigenous dispossessions, with agribusiness expansion cited as a primary driver, affecting Chaco groups including Lengua descendants who rely on forested lands for hunting, gathering, and subsistence agriculture.^[66]^[12] A prominent case involves the Sawhoyamaxa Indigenous Community, comprising approximately 63 Enxet-Lengua families, whose ancestral territory—spanning about 14,000 hectares—was occupied by a private cattle ranch since the 1980s, forcing community members to live in roadside camps with elevated child mortality rates from malnutrition and disease. The Inter-American Court of Human Rights ruled in 2006 that Paraguay violated the community's rights to communal property, judicial protection, and life, mandating land restitution and reparations; full implementation occurred in 2014 via presidential decree, though subsequent reports indicate ongoing boundary disputes and restricted access to resources amid neighboring agribusiness activities.^[12]^[67]^[43] Conservation initiatives in the Gran Chaco, South America's second-largest forest ecosystem, intersect with these disputes by prioritizing habitat preservation against agribusiness-driven deforestation, which has cleared over 20% of the region's woodlands since 2000 for soy and beef production, directly impacting Lengua territories historically dominant in central Chaco until the mid-20th century. Organizations such as the World Wildlife Fund identify agricultural expansion as the foremost threat to Chaco biodiversity, advocating for indigenous land titling to enable sustainable management, yet implementation lags, with fewer than 10% of claimed indigenous territories fully demarcated by 2023, exacerbating conflicts where conservation zones overlap with untitled Lengua lands contested by ranchers.^[68]^[69]^[70] These tensions highlight a pattern where agribusiness lobbying has repeatedly blocked expropriations for indigenous restitution, arguing economic productivity—Paraguay's soy sector contributes over 10% of GDP—outweighs ancestral claims, while conservation efforts, though aligned with indigenous calls for territorial integrity, face resistance from both sectors when restricting short-term exploitation. Lengua advocates, supported by international rulings, emphasize that secure land rights are essential for ecological stewardship, countering narratives from agribusiness sources that portray such claims as impediments to national development.^[71]^[70]

Criticisms and debates

Anthropological representations and stereotypes

Early anthropological accounts of the Lengua people (also known as Enlhet), residing in the Paraguayan Gran Chaco, depicted them as participants in frequent intertribal warfare and raiding, contradicting later pacifist interpretations of indigenous harmony. W. Barbrooke Grubb, a missionary-ethnographer active in the region from the 1880s to 1910s, documented in detail the Lengua's martial practices, including organized raids for captives and resources, which were integral to their social structure and survival strategies amid scarce resources.^[72] These observations, drawn from direct fieldwork, highlighted a society marked by aggression and vengeance cycles rather than innate pacifism, as evidenced by Grubb's records of conflicts involving bows, arrows, and poisoned weapons. Such early ethnographies challenged romanticized "noble savage" tropes that portrayed Chaco indigenous groups, including the Lengua, as inherently peaceful stewards of nature uncorrupted by civilization. This idealization, popularized in broader Western discourse from the 18th century onward, often overlooked empirical evidence of pre-colonial violence, such as Lengua-Mocoví hostilities documented in regional accounts, where warfare served economic and status functions.^[6] Grubb's work, based on prolonged immersion, provided causal insights into how environmental pressures and resource competition drove these behaviors, privileging observed realities over ideological projections of primordial innocence. In modern representations, left-leaning academic and media sources frequently emphasize Lengua victimhood amid colonization and land dispossession, sidelining evidence of adaptive agency and economic resilience. This selective focus aligns with institutional biases favoring narratives of perpetual marginalization, as critiqued in analyses of Chaco ethnography where indigenous complexity is flattened into dependency models.^[73] Counterexamples include Lengua/Enlhet involvement in craft production and commercialization, with communities producing and marketing woven goods through cooperatives, integrating traditional skills into market economies despite historical disruptions.^[74] These ventures, documented ethnographically since the 2010s, demonstrate entrepreneurial adaptation, such as seasonal crafting tied to tourism and local trade, fostering self-sufficiency beyond aid-dependent stereotypes.^[75]

Debates on cultural authenticity vs practical adaptation

Among the Lengua peoples, now primarily identified as Enlhet and Enxet groups in Paraguay's Chaco region, debates on cultural authenticity versus practical adaptation revolve around balancing the retention of traditional knowledge systems with selective incorporation of external technologies and institutions to address contemporary challenges like poverty and marginalization. Advocates for authenticity emphasize the risks of erosion in linguistic and customary practices amid ongoing colonization pressures since the 19th century, arguing that dilution undermines communal cohesion and spiritual ties to ancestral lands. In contrast, community pragmatists contend that rigid preservationism limits access to essential services, citing empirical evidence from bilingual initiatives that hybrid competencies yield measurable improvements in individual and group resilience.^[10]^[76] Quantitative data from Chaco indigenous populations, including Enlhet-Enxet subgroups, demonstrate that bilingual proficiency in native languages and Spanish correlates with enhanced educational attainment and health metrics; for example, higher education levels among bilingual youth are linked to reduced tuberculosis incidence in children, as access to formal schooling facilitates preventive knowledge and service utilization. Intercultural bilingual education models implemented since the 1990s have shown pertinence in boosting retention rates and cultural relevance, with indigenous organizations reporting greater community engagement where hybrid curricula integrate traditional ecology with modern literacy. These outcomes challenge purist stances by illustrating causal pathways from adaptation to tangible socioeconomic gains, such as lower malnutrition rates in adapted households compared to isolated traditionalist ones.^[77]^[78] External activism, often led by international NGOs and anthropologists, faces critique for prioritizing stasis-oriented narratives that romanticize pre-contact lifeways, potentially hindering local priorities like infrastructure development; Enlhet community reflections highlight how such interventions sometimes overlook endogenous demands for adaptive strategies, as evidenced in participatory forums where leaders favor land claims paired with skill-building over isolationist preservation. This perspective aligns with broader Chaco patterns where overreliance on external advocacy delays self-determined progress, per qualitative accounts from affected groups.^[10]^[79] Practical adaptations have enabled political advancements, including Enxet-Lengua representation in national dialogues since the 1980s, exemplified by leaders like Rene Ramirez advocating for Maskoy interests in labor and land forums, culminating in Inter-American Court rulings such as Yakye Axa v. Paraguay (2005), which affirmed territorial rights through hybridized legal strategies blending customary evidence with international human rights frameworks. These gains, absent in non-adaptive contexts, underscore adaptation's role in amplifying indigenous agency without forfeiting core identities.^[62]^[79]

References

[1]
Nengvaanemkeskama Nempayvaam Enlhet
History. The Enlhet (formerly known as Northern Lengua) are the largest group in the Enlhet-Enenlhet (also Maskoy) language family in the Paraguayan Chaco, ...
[2]
A Grammar of Enxet Sur - ScholarSpace
This is a reference grammar of Enxet Sur, an indigenous language of the Paraguayan Gran Chaco, and one of six recognized languages in the Enlhet-Enenlhet ...
[3]
Enxet Language (ENX) - Ethnologue
Enxet is a stable indigenous language of Paraguay. It belongs to the Mascoyan language family. Direct evidence is lacking, but the language is thought to be ...
[4]
Enlhet in Paraguay Profile - Joshua Project
Enlhet is a language of Paraguay's Chaco region. The people who speak it are also called the northern Enxet people. They live in the departments of Concepción, ...<|separator|>
[5]
Enxet And Enlhet - Summary - eHRAF World Cultures
The Enlhet (Lengua) language belongs to the Mascoyan linguistic family ... The Enlhet language is separate from neighboring tribes, such as the Angaité ...
[6]
[PDF] Ethnography of the Chaco - Biblioteca Digital Curt Nimuendajú
... name Chaco, which seems to be derived from a Quechua word meaning ... Lengua is a much quoted source on these Indians. By far the best monograph ...
[7]
[PDF] WARFARE, REORGANIZATION, AND READAPTATION AT THE ...
Also scattered about the Chaco were the Mascoian Lengua-Enimagas ... and other Jesuit chronicles that deal with events of the eighteenth century ... language ...
[8]
[PDF] The Lengua Indians of the Paraguayan Chaco
The nanme Lenaua comes from the Spanish and means " a tongue," ths other two are native names ... The. Lengua name of the wood for fire-sticks is hapin. The ...
[9]
[PDF] Inflectional Morphology in the Zamucoan Languages
... the Chaco-Boreal area, in South-East Bolivia and Northern Paraguay. The ... lengua zamuca (Chomé 1958 [ante 1745]), only published in 1958 by Lussagnet ...
[10]
Maskoy and Enxet in Paraguay - Minority Rights Group
The Enxet are often referred to as the Lengua-Maskoy, but this is understood by most – who self-identify as Enxet – as a pejorative term.Missing: endonyms Enlhet<|separator|>
[11]
[PDF] The Enlhet in Paraguay
Jan 25, 2022 · In 1995, Ernesto Unruh and Hannes Kalisch founded the Enlhet. Institute Nengvaanemkeskama Nempayvaam Enlhet (“Growing our language and knowledge ...Missing: endonyms Enxet
[12]
[PDF] Inter-American Court of Human Rights Case of the Sawhoyamaxa ...
Mar 29, 2006 · 23 The South Enxet and the North Enlhet Lengua ethnic groups, as well as the. 19. Cf. statement rendered by Mr. Alberto Braunstein before a ...
[13]
Warfare, Reorganization, and Readaptation at the Margins of Spanish Rule – The Chaco and Paraguay (1573–1882) (Chapter 18) - The Cambridge History of the Native Peoples of the Americas
### Summary of Spanish Interactions with Chaco Tribes (Lengua/Maskoy), 16th–18th Centuries
[14]
Lengua
Traditionally, the Lengua led migratory lives as hunters, gatherers, and fishers. Hunting, the prerogative of men, was the principal food-quest activity, and a ...
[15]
Maskoy - Tierraviva
Feb 10, 2018 · Uno de los primeros contactos fue en 1870 a través de indígenas Qom que se refugiaron en Riacho Mosquito, lugar que aún sigue habitando el ...Missing: misiones salesianas
[16]
[PDF] The South American Missionary Society in the Paraguayan Chaco
Lengua or Lengua-Maskoy,3 who inhabit an area bounded to the east by the Paraguay River, to the south and north by the Rio. Montelindo and Riacho San Carlos ...
[17]
[PDF] Una etnografía salesiana 1890-1930 - HAL-SHS
Jun 20, 2014 · La misión del Chaco no era el primer objetivo de los salesianos al llegar a Paraguay. Hubo discusiones entre la Santa Sede, las autoridades ...Missing: Maskoy | Show results with:Maskoy
[18]
History of Paraguay - Wikipedia
Recurrent epidemics of European diseases had reduced their population by up 50 percent and the forced labor of the encomiendas by the Spanish and mestizo ...Missing: impact Lengua
[19]
Re-Shaping the Chaco | Anabaptist Historians
Mar 29, 2018 · In early 1930, 1500 Russian Mennonite refugees arrived in the Gran Chaco—a semi-arid, lowland region of dense bush on Paraguay's western ...Missing: Lengua Maskoy impact
[20]
[PDF] Ayoreo Relations in the Paraguayan Chaco
Menno Colony was first established in 1927; this group had left Canada fearing that the re- production of their identity would be threatened as the Canadian.
[21]
Mennonites helped turn Paraguay into beef producer indigenous ...
Mar 10, 2020 · Allowing Mennonites to establish settlements in the Chaco reasserted Paraguay's territorial claims but dispossessed many indigenous peoples from ...
[22]
The Indigenous of the Paraguayan Chaco: Struggle for the Land
Mar 24, 2010 · The indigenous group of the Chaco base their land claims on provisions found within Paraguayan law, which offers a relatively strong basis from ...Missing: Maskoy Lengua scouts
[23]
[PDF] The Stroessner Regime and Indigenous Resistance in Paraguay
The Stroessner's regime perceived Indigenous Peoples as obstacles for economic development and thus encouraged agricultural settlements and proselytizing on ...Missing: assimilation education
[24]
With Spanish, Guaraní lives: a sociolinguistic analysis of bilingual ...
Oct 3, 2012 · In 1973, the Stroessner administration enacted transitional bilingual education called the Programa de Educación Bilingüe (Bilingual Education ...
[25]
Paraguay 1992 (rev. 2011) - Constitute Project
Of the Indigenous Peoples and the Ethnic Groups. This Constitution recognizes the existence of the indigenous peoples, defined as groups of [a] culture prior ...
[26]
INDIGENOUS TERRITORY AND ISOLATED COMMUNITIES ...
Mar 4, 2024 · Paraguay's 1992 constitution guarantees the right of indigenous communities to hold land communally, but that right is mainly words on paper.
[27]
Enlhet Language (ENL) - Ethnologue
Enlhet is a stable indigenous language of Paraguay. It belongs to the Mascoyan language family. Direct evidence is lacking, but the language is thought to ...
[28]
Lengua-Mascoy - Glottolog 5.2
Temporal Predicative Particles in Sanapaná and the Enlhet-Enenlhet Language Family (Paraguay): Descriptive and Comparative Study ... Language Information and ...Missing: Mascoian | Show results with:Mascoian
[29]
Mascoian Language Family
The Mascoian languages are spoken in Paraguay. Sponsored Links. Mascoian languages include: Mascoian Languages. Angaite · Kaskiha · Lengua · Sanapana · Toba- ...
[30]
Lengua - Glottolog 5.2
From the perspective of the whole family, the Enlhet and Enxet languages are of equal standing in relation to each other and to the other languages of the ...
[31]
[PDF] Temporal Predicative Particles in Sanapaná and the Enlhet ...
Apr 5, 2018 · At the morphological level, both word classes take the same sets of person-marking prefixes, used on verbs to indicate the person and number ...
[32]
[PDF] Language Contact and Linguistic Change in the Chaco
Three indigenous languages are spoken in MLP in addition to Spanish: Chorote, Nivaclé (also called Chulupí, sometimes Ashluslay), and Wichí (formerly called ...Missing: migration | Show results with:migration
[33]
[PDF] VOWEL DURATION IN ENENLHET
There are no detailed linguistic studies of Enenlhet, and only two phonetic studies of related languages (Enxet and Sanapaná) [2, 3]. ... A grammar of Enxet Sur, ...
[34]
[PDF] Temporal Predicative Particles in Sanapaná and the Enlhet ...
Apr 5, 2018 · In the past, certain authors assumed Enlhet and Enxet to be two dialects of the same language (for example, Brinton 1898: 190), while others did ...
[35]
https://open-research-europe.ec.europa.eu/articles/2-90/pdf
[36]
[PDF] A comparative wordlist for the languages of The Gran Chaco, South ...
Jul 21, 2022 · The collection of basic words was compiled from various sources, mainly dictionaries, but in some cases also from grammatical descriptions. One ...
[37]
[PDF] A Grammar of Paraguayan Guarani - OAPEN Home
... Enxet, Toba Maskoy, Angaité, San- apaná, Toba and Guaná. As previously ... words in the language. The study of these properties is called segmental ...
[38]
Enxet Sur - Glottolog 5.2
AES status: not endangered; Source: David M. Eberhard and Gary F. Simons and Charles D. Fennig 2025; Comment: Enxet (enx-enx) = 6a* (Vigorous).Missing: divergence | Show results with:divergence
[39]
First Bible for Éxnet Sur people of Western Paraguay
May 6, 2016 · The completion of a 25-year translation project has resulted in the first Éxnet Sur Bible translation for the Southern Enxet people.Missing: date | Show results with:date
[40]
Gran Chaco - Summary - eHRAF World Cultures
The Guaraní groups inhabiting the Gran Chaco region initially migrated from Brazil and eastern Paraguay. These migrations started in the fourteenth century, and ...
[41]
Paraguay - Indians - Country Studies
By the late 1970s, the Lengua converts at the Anglican mission were generally in charge of running the settlement. The most serious problems came from ...Missing: etymology | Show results with:etymology
[42]
[PDF] From sagua'a to Ox-Dollars Cattle and Human Assemblages in the ...
Jul 27, 2022 · Cattle ranches themselves absorbed this power as symbols of economic prosperity. When the. Maskoy, after a long struggle for land in the 1980s, ...
[43]
[PDF] LAND RIGHTS, BEEF COMMODITY CHAINS, AND ...
Extensive cattle ranching began in Paraguay in the 1960s. Over time, as the ... Cattle ranching is expanding in the Paraguayan Chaco, the traditional land of ...
[44]
Paraguay 2001 - Chapter IX
10 times the national ...Missing: period | Show results with:period
[45]
Expanding Economic Opportunities in the Paraguayan Chaco
Thanks to the Internet, the native Nivaclé communities have expanded their carob flour business, improved their savings, and expanded access to educational ...
[46]
The Setting and the Economy of the Enxet - Nomos eLibrary
Across all the Enxet colonies, the most cattle owned by a single person was twenty-two (in Espinillo) and no one else had more than fifteen. To obtain an ...Missing: language | Show results with:language
[47]
https://www.prm.ox.ac.uk/files/southamericantropicalforestmaterialpdf
[48]
[PDF] 1 south american tropical forest material - Pitt Rivers Museum
bows and arrows, blowpipes and their darts, and associated accessories; basketry ... objects – from the Lengua of Paraguay, but these people, from the Gran Chaco, ...
[49]
Fieldwork on the Banks of the Pilcomayo River : The Place of Erland ...
Swedish ethnologist and Americanist scholar Erland Nordenskiöld (1877–1932) became acquainted with the South American Chaco for the first time in 1902 when the ...Missing: Lengua | Show results with:Lengua
[50]
Museo Barbero :: Inicio
El Museo Etnográfico "Andrés Barbero" tiene desde el año 1956 su sede en el ... Andrés Barbero", en la calle España 217 de la ciudad de Asunción. Leer ...Missing: Lengua artifacts
[51]
Robert H. Jackson - The Population and Vital Rates of the Jesuit ...
This essay reexamines the vital rates of the thirty individual Jesuit missions of Paraguay for selected years in the eighteenth century, with emphasis on ...
[52]
Paraguay - Salesian Missions
Salesian missionaries have been working in Paraguay since 1896, beginning their work in the capital Asunción, near the port on the Paraguay River.Missing: Lengua 19th
[53]
Enlhet in Paraguay people group profile | Joshua Project
Enlhet is a language of Paraguay's Chaco region. The people who speak it are also called the northern Enxet people. They live in the departments of Concepción, ...
[54]
View of Salvation? Conversion as Part of the Process of Colonization
The missionaries were certainly aware that the motives inducing the Enlhet to convert might be other than merely spiritual (Klassen, 1991; Wiens, 1989). For ...
[55]
[PDF] A case-study amongst the Enxet of the Paraguayan Chaco
Receiver. A person recetves a message by means of his sensory perceptors. However, it is by no means a foregone conclusion that the sender and receiver.
[56]
[PDF] Viviendas para Pueblos Indígenas 2022 IV Censo Nacional de ... - INE
Nov 24, 2022 · El uso de un lenguaje que no discrimine ni marque diferencias entre mujeres y hombre es una de las preocupaciones del Instituto Nacional de ...
[57]
Enlhet - Wikipedia, la enciclopedia libre
Los enlhet (palabra que significa persona) se distribuyen en 14 comunidades entre los departamentos Boquerón y Presidente Hayes. Según el censo 2002, son 7221, ...
[58]
Enxet - Tierraviva
PUEBLO, Enlhet / Enxet Sur ; COMUNIDADES, 17 ; FAMILIA LINGÜÍSTICA, maskoy ; LENGUA, enlhet / enxet ; POBLACIÓN, en total 13.065; 7.221 los enlhet y 5.844 los enxet.
[59]
The Indigenous World 2025: Paraguay - IWGIA
Apr 25, 2025 · According to the results of the 2022 National Census, there are approximately 140,206 Indigenous inhabitants of Paraguay, representing 2.29% ...Missing: 2020s | Show results with:2020s
[60]
Paraguay Country Report 2024 - BTI Transformation Index
According to Anivid, an umbrella organization representing Indigenous peoples, 66.2% of Indigenous people live in poverty, with 34.4% experiencing extreme ...Missing: Lengua | Show results with:Lengua
[61]
[PDF] Inter-American Court of Human Rights Case of the Yakye Axa ...
The case involves the Yakye Axa Indigenous Community's claim against Paraguay for violating their rights to life, fair trial, property, and judicial protection ...
[62]
Chaco deforestation by Christian sect puts Paraguayan land under ...
Oct 5, 2010 · Wildlife and the world's last uncontacted tribe both at risk as Mennonites turn Chaco forest into prairie-style farmlands.<|separator|>
[63]
Paraguay: Land Titles for Indians? - Cultural Survival
Feb 17, 2010 · Paraguayan law #904/81, the "Estatuto de las Comunidades Indigenas," was created in 1981 to provide land and land title to Paraguay's Indian ...Missing: 1980s Lengua
[64]
[PDF] Inter-American Court of Human Rights Case of the Yakye Axa ...
The Commission filed the application based on Articles 51 and 61 of the. American Convention, for the Court to decide whether Paraguay breached Articles 4. ( ...
[65]
A call to action for land rights now in Paraguay
Seven years after the international sentence, in January 2012, the Government of Paraguay acquired 12,312 hectares of land for Yakye Axa. Over-joyed the ...Missing: restored | Show results with:restored
[66]
Paraguay's Supreme Court issues 'historic' land ruling - The Guardian
Oct 7, 2014 · The Supreme Court of Justice unanimously rejected ranchers' claims that a landmark government decision made earlier this year to expropriate ...Missing: Lengua 2010s
[67]
Paraguay: Land dispute victory for displaced indigenous community
Feb 3, 2012 · In 2005, the Inter-American Court of Human Rights ordered Paraguay to restore the Yakye Axa's lands. Meanwhile the conditions in the ...
[68]
2 - The Elusive Promise of Indigenous Land Rights in Paraguay
Sep 6, 2025 · All are in Paraguay's western Chaco region, where lands were sold without Indigenous consultation and converted to extensive cattle ranching.
[69]
Paraguay: Victory for the Sawhoyamaxa people
Jul 10, 2014 · After a 20-year battle, the indigenous Sawhoyamaxa community have finally won rights to their land. On 11 June 2014, the President of Paraguay enacted a law.Missing: Maskoy Lengua disputes
[70]
The Gran Chaco Forest | WWF - World Wildlife Fund
Extensive Agricultural Expansion. Agricultural expansion, driven by cattle and soy production, is the biggest threat to the natural ecosystems of the Gran Chaco ...
[71]
Full article: Land-cover change in the Paraguayan Chaco: 2000–2011
In fact, until the 1920s, the central part of the Paraguayan Chaco was dominated by the Lengua indigenous people, and the Chaco was approximately 90% woodland ( ...
[72]
Indigenous Peoples and Land-Based Disputes - MDPI
Dec 25, 2023 · This article discusses some of the long-term tendencies of the Paraguayan political economy, focusing, in particular, on impacts on indigenous peoples.
[73]
[PDF] 2 The Elusive Promise of Indigenous Land Rights in Paraguay
Yet, the past two decades show that Parliament routinely rejects expropriation based on four tired arguments: (1) lands are used for agricultural production ...Missing: disputes conservation
[74]
An Unknown People In An Unknown Land - eHRAF World Cultures
An unknown people in an unknown land: an account of the life and customs of the Lengua ... By W. Barbrooke Grubb, edited by H. T. Morrey Jones; LCCN: 44014130 ...
[75]
Between Flood and Drought: Environmental Racism, Settler ...
An unknown people in an unknown land: An account of the life and customs of the Lengua Indians of the Paraguayan Chaco, with adventures and experiences during ...
[76]
Rhythms in the production and commercialization of crafts in Chaco
The research expands upon the production and commercialization process. The article is part of an ongoing investigation started in 2012. The ethnographic method ...
[77]
Indigenous Communities - Chaco Vivo
Chaco Vivo works with 14 Indigenous communities within its Area of Influence (AOI) to improve livelihoods, strengthen cultural heritage, and protect the ...
[78]
Enhlet - Enlhet - ascim.org
Jan 17, 2018 · Their recent history is told through their oral traditions. Economically adapted to the environment of the Central and Lower Chaco, they ...Missing: authenticity | Show results with:authenticity
[79]
(PDF) Social Determinants of Health in Indigenous Population in the ...
Mar 13, 2017 · The data support significant associations between healthcare access and active TB disease in adults and education and active TB in children.
[80]
[PDF] Review of the Indigenous Peoples Program in Paraguay managed ...
It has also contributed to the promotion and recuperation of cultural identity, leadership training and capacity development, and to significant. Page 8. Review ...
[81]
a political ontology analysis of the Paraguayan Maskoy struggle for ...
The contributors answer questions about who speaks for indigenous communities, how indigenous movements relate to the popular left, and how conflicts ...