Fact-checked by Grok 2 weeks ago

Liminal being

A liminal being is a or undergoing the transitional of a , existing in an ambiguous, in-between state detached from prior social structures and not yet incorporated into a new status. This concept, rooted in , describes individuals who are ritually marked by special symbols, names, practices, and attire to signify their temporary suspension from everyday norms. The term derives from Arnold van Gennep's foundational 1909 analysis of rites of passage, which structured such rituals into pre-liminal (separation), (transition), and post-liminal (incorporation) phases, with the liminal stage embodying threshold ambiguity. Anthropologist further developed this in the mid-20th century, portraying liminal beings as "neither here nor there; they are betwixt and between the positions assigned and arrayed by law, custom, convention, and ceremonial," often evoking both potential danger and creative potential within society. In this phase, participants experience a symbolic death of their former identity, fostering —a sense of undifferentiated equality and solidarity among neophytes—under the guidance of elders or ritual specialists. Beyond traditional rituals like initiations, marriages, or funerals, the notion of liminal beings has influenced fields such as and , where it explains states of existential uncertainty, such as or , marked by dissolution and rebirth. Turner's highlights how these beings challenge social hierarchies, promoting anti-structure and renewal, though their ambiguous status can also provoke societal anxiety or control mechanisms.

Definition and Origins

Etymology

The term "liminal being" derives from the Latin word limen, meaning "," which forms the root of "" to denote states or entities positioned on the between categories. This linguistic foundation entered anthropological discourse in the early through Arnold van Gennep's 1909 work Les Rites de Passage, where he described the transitional phase of rituals as the limen or , marking a period of ambiguity between social states. The specific application to "liminal being" emerged in Victor Turner's seminal 1969 book The Ritual Process: Structure and Anti-Structure, where he expanded van Gennep's framework to characterize individuals or entities in the phase of rites of as "liminal beings" who exist "betwixt and between" established positions, stripped of prior status and embodying transitional ambiguity. This usage built on Turner's earlier 1967 essay "Betwixt and Between: The Liminal Period in Rites de ," which similarly portrayed liminal entities as neither fully one thing nor another, yet potentially both, highlighting their role in ritual transformation. In the 1970s, scholars extended this concept to broader anthropological analyses of ambiguous entities, with Mary Douglas's 1966 providing foundational implications through her examination of "matter out of place" and categorical , which prefigured liminal beings as sources of societal unease and . While "liminal space" refers to physical or environmental thresholds—such as doorways or transitional locales that evoke a sense of in-betweenness—"liminal being" distinctly applies to animate entities that blur existential or categorical boundaries, embodying the threshold rather than merely occupying it.

Anthropological Foundations

The concept of liminal beings finds its roots in anthropological studies of rites of passage, particularly through the foundational work of Arnold van Gennep. In his 1909 book Les Rites de Passage, van Gennep outlined a tripartite structure for such rituals: separation from a prior social state, a transitional "liminal" phase marked by ambiguity and suspension of normal structures, and reincorporation into a new status. This middle liminal phase, often termed the "threshold" or marge, involves individuals existing in a state of indeterminacy, isolated from everyday society through taboos, seclusion, or symbolic acts like fasting and instruction, allowing for the gradual shift between statuses such as birth, initiation, marriage, or death. Victor Turner built upon and expanded van Gennep's framework in his 1969 book The Ritual Process: Structure and Anti-Structure, defining liminal beings as entities "betwixt and between" established categories during the liminal phase of rites. These beings lack fixed social or existential status, property, rank, or insignia, often symbolized by humility, nakedness, or a "uniform condition" that strips away prior identities; as Turner described, "Liminal entities are neither here nor there; they are betwixt and between the positions assigned and arrayed by law, custom, convention, and ceremonial." This ambiguity applies initially to human initiates, such as neophytes in tribal rituals, who are treated as neither fully part of their old group nor the new one, embodying a temporary anti-structure that challenges societal norms. Turner further extended the notion of beyond human participants to entities in his 1974 work Dramas, Fields, and Metaphors: Symbolic Action in Human Society, applying it to mythical figures that disrupt binary classifications, such as those blurring human/divine or alive/dead boundaries. These entities, like monsters or spectral beings in myths, operate in symbolic "fields" of action where fixed categories dissolve, fostering creative social dramas and metaphorical reinterpretations of reality. Central to Turner's model is the concept of communitas, which emerges among liminal beings as a spontaneous, egalitarian bond that contrasts with the hierarchical "structure" of ordinary society. During liminality, participants—reduced to equality without distinctions of rank or role—experience a "generalized social bond" that promotes solidarity and undifferentiated community, often described as a "rudimentarily structured and relatively undifferentiated comitatus, community, or even communion of equal individuals." This communitas, arising precisely where structure is absent, serves as a regenerative force, enabling reflection on social values and facilitating the transformative potential of the rite, though it is transient and gives way to reintegration.

Characteristics

Ambiguity and Categorical Blurring

Liminal beings embody a core trait of , existing in states that defy straightforward within established social or cultural categories. As describes in his analysis of ritual processes, such entities are "neither here nor there; they are betwixt and between the positions assigned and arrayed , , , and ceremonial," rendering their characteristics inherently ambiguous as they traverse thresholds without fully belonging to either side. This inability to fit neatly into singular categories—such as fully human or animal—stems from the dissolution of social structures during liminal phases, where individuals or entities temporarily lose defined roles, statuses, and attributes. Philosophically, this categorical blurring aligns with Mary Douglas's concept of "matter out of place," where anomalies that pollute boundaries evoke a mix of fear and fascination by challenging the order of classification systems. In her examination of purity and pollution, Douglas argues that entities defying expected categories—such as those ambiguously positioned between life and death or sacred and profane—threaten social coherence, as anomalies disrupt the cultural order. For instance, corpses or transitional states like initiation rites represent such blurrings, where the undefined nature disrupts norms and prompts ritual responses to restore boundaries, yet also holds a potent allure through its association with transformative power. Culturally, beings function as potent symbols of , embodying that interrogates and subverts societal norms. By existing outside rigid categorizations, they highlight the fluidity of and , fostering reflection on the provisional nature of social orders and encouraging during periods of change. This role underscores their significance in maintaining cultural , as the ambiguity they introduce ultimately reinforces the value of established categories upon reintegration.

Transformative Abilities

Liminal beings exhibit transformative fluidity, involving symbolic modifications of their , roles, or , enabling them to navigate between structured realms and anti-structural . In anthropological theory, this fluidity manifests as a symbolic of fixed attributes, where neophytes in rituals are reduced to a , malleable state akin to "human ," stripped of markers, clothing, and privileges to facilitate reshaping by communal forces. This process involves role reversals and inversions, such as inferiors adopting superior positions or patients embodying afflicting spirits, allowing the entity to bridge categorical boundaries without permanent fixation in one form. Temporal transformation further defines these abilities, with liminal beings undergoing changes aligned to threshold moments, such as , , or seclusions that suspend normal time. Such shifts occur during periods, inverting everyday hierarchies to reveal underlying social tensions, as observed in Ndembu healing rituals where participants experience spirit presences that alter perceptual and metaphysical states. These transformations are not continuous but episodic, tied to "moments in and out of time," emphasizing the ephemeral nature of as a of potential rather than enduring alteration. The primary purpose of these transformative abilities lies in , enabling liminal beings to resolve or accentuate tensions between opposing worlds, such as and anti-structure, by embodying ambiguity that fosters and social renewal. However, such changes often prove involuntary or ritual-bound, leading to inherent instability; neophytes endure vulnerability and submissiveness without personal control, as the process demands communal oversight to prevent dissolution into . This lack of underscores liminality's role as a controlled flux rather than empowered mastery.

Examples in Folklore and Mythology

Human-Animal Hybrids

In , centaurs are depicted as half-human, half-horse beings, embodying the tension between primal instincts and civilized order. These creatures, often portrayed as warriors, symbolize the wildness of untamed nature contrasting with human society, as seen in their disruptive behavior during the centauromachy, a battle against the that highlights themes of barbarism and restraint. references centaurs in the (circa 8th century BCE) as "beast men" or "hairy beast men," portraying them as fierce antagonists in the wild fringes of the Greek world, underscoring their role as liminal figures on the boundary of humanity and animality. In ancient , serves as a prominent example of a human-animal hybrid, depicted with the head of a and the body of a man, functioning as the god of and guardian of the dead. This form blurs the boundaries between life and death, as well as human and divine realms, by associating the jackal's scavenging habits with the protection of tombs and the journey. Depictions of date back to the Old Kingdom (2686–2181 BCE), where he was the primary deity linked to funerary practices, overseeing mummification and the weighing of the heart in the . Native American folklore, particularly among the , features skin-walkers, or yee naaldlooshii, as humans who transform into animals through , crossing boundaries between human society and the natural world. These shape-shifters, often malevolent witches who don animal skins to assume their forms, embody the dangers of violating cultural norms and the perils of boundary transgression. Accounts of skin-walkers emphasize their role in Navajo cosmology as figures who disrupt harmony by invoking evil through animal . Across these traditions, human-animal hybrids in frequently represent ambiguity, serving as mediators between the natural and or the civilized and the wild. Such beings illustrate the precarious balance of human amid primal urges, often warning against the consequences of unchecked or . In and contexts, they facilitate transitions like death or battle, while in lore, they highlight the ethical perils of , reinforcing communal taboos through their liminal existence.

Supernatural Intermediaries

In mythological narratives across cultures, intermediaries embody by bridging the human world and otherworldly domains, often emerging during transitional periods to mediate, enforce, or subvert boundaries between realms. These beings facilitate communication, transport , or initiate crossings, reflecting their inherent as neither fully divine nor . Their roles underscore the precarious of transitions, where human fates hinge on encounters with these entities. In Celtic folklore, the sidhe—supernatural fairies inhabiting the Otherworld—serve as key intermediaries between mortal humans and the fairy realm, with interactions intensifying during liminal festivals like Samhain, when the barriers between worlds thin. Medieval Irish and Scottish ballads depict the sidhe kidnapping humans, drawing them into their domain as changelings or permanent residents, a practice tied to the festival's association with the dead and the supernatural. For instance, in the 16th-century ballad Tam Lin, the fairy host abducts the knight Tam Lin, who is only rescued by his lover Janet on Halloween night, highlighting the sidhe's power to enforce otherworldly transitions during such times. Norse mythology portrays valkyries as ethereal intermediaries who traverse the life-death boundary, selecting slain warriors on battlefields to escort them to Odin's Valhalla, thereby mediating the passage from mortality to divine afterlife. Described in the 13th-century Poetic Edda as "choosers of the slain," they appear in warrior guises but also as swan-maidens, symbolizing their fluid, transformative movement between realms. In Völundarkviða, three swan-maidens—explicitly identified as valkyries—descend from the sky with their feathered garments, temporarily joining human society before returning to their supernatural duties, illustrating their role in blurring avian, human, and divine categories. In Yoruba traditions of , the Eshu functions as a intermediary at the , the symbolic juncture of paths where he conveys messages and offerings between humans and the divine of orishas. Pre-colonial oral narratives position Eshu as the essential messenger who opens channels for communication, ensuring rituals reach the gods, yet his unpredictable nature allows him to disrupt harmony if not properly honored. As the guardian of thresholds, Eshu embodies the space of choice and fate, demanding sacrifices to facilitate safe passage between earthly and spiritual worlds. These intermediaries commonly exhibit dual natures—benevolent guides one moment, malevolent disruptors the next—enforcing orderly transitions like transport or efficacy while capable of upending them through , trickery, or fatal selection. This reinforces their essence, as they both enable and endanger human engagement with the otherworldly.

Representations in Modern Culture

Literature and Fiction

In the Gothic tradition, Mary Shelley's (1818) presents the creature as a quintessential liminal being, existing in a perpetual state of between human and monstrous categories, rejected by society and its creator alike, which underscores themes of isolation and the perils of scientific overreach. This portrayal evolves the archetype of boundary-crossing figures from , such as shape-shifting spirits, into a modern critique of creation and identity, where the creature's undefined status highlights the blurring of natural and artificial boundaries. Ursula K. Le Guin's Earthsea series (1968–2001) further develops liminal transformations through characters like the wizard Ged, whose shapeshifting abilities and confrontation with his shadow self represent a journey of integrating fragmented identities, balancing the self against its darker, otherworldly aspects in a Taoist-inspired framework of equilibrium. Ged's metamorphic experiments, such as assuming animal forms, symbolize the fluidity and risk of liminality, drawing on folklore motifs of human-animal hybrids while exploring personal growth and the dangers of unchecked power in a magical archipelago. Neil Gaiman's (2001) reimagines liminal beings in a contemporary American context, with protagonist Shadow Moon embodying a threshold existence between mortal humanity and divine influences, navigating identity crises amid clashing old-world gods and modern beliefs. Shadow's role as an outsider, caught between life and death, presence and absence, reflects the novel's evolution of intermediaries into symbols of cultural displacement in a globalized society. Post-2000 literature has increasingly employed beings to interrogate and hybrid identities, with characters straddling and everyday worlds to critique cultural fragmentation and in settings. This trend marks a of the , where such figures facilitate explorations of borderless existences, building on earlier literary foundations to address contemporary issues of belonging and transformation, and continues into the with fantasy blending genres to explore ecological and identity issues.

Film and Media

Liminal beings in film and media frequently manifest as monstrous figures that blur boundaries between human and non-human, life and death, or rationality and instinct, often serving as metaphors for societal transitions and identity crises. In horror cinema, these entities embody Victor Turner's concept of , where they occupy ambiguous states that challenge categorical norms. Vampires, for instance, represent intermediaries existing "betwixt sunset and sunrise," a threshold period that underscores their perpetual in-between existence. This portrayal draws from Bram Stoker's Dracula (1897), where the Count navigates liminal spaces like thresholds and twilight hours, requiring invitation to cross into human domains, a motif echoed in early adaptations such as F.W. Murnau's (1922), which depicts the as a shadowy intruder defying life-death dichotomies. Later films like Neil Jordan's (1994) deepen this ambiguity through characters like Louis, whose centuries-long struggle with immortality highlights emotional and existential liminality between human empathy and predatory otherness. Werewolves further exemplify liminal transformation in , hybridizing human form with ferocity to symbolize internal conflicts over and belonging. In a of 20 films from 1980 to 2014, werewolves appear in hybrid states in 85% of cases, physically merging human and animal traits during full moons or emotional peaks, as seen in John Landis's (1981), where David Kessler's shifting eye color and partial transformations during intimate moments illustrate the tension between civilized humanity and primal urges. Similarly, John Fawcett's Ginger Snaps (2000) portrays adolescent Ginger Fitzgerald's curse as a , blending puberty's bodily changes with monstrous evolution, including uncontrollable sexual impulses that culminate in violent loss of agency. The series (2003–2016) extends this to interspecies liminality, depicting werewolf-vampire hybrids like Michael Corvin as beings outside both societies, their romantic unions with vampires like emphasizing blurred loyalties and identities. Beyond classic monsters, beings in media explore broader themes of otherness and , often through shapeshifters that affirm yet oppose human norms. Films like The Hunger (1983) feature that transgress gender and temporal boundaries through themes of and fluid sexuality. Dhampirs, half- figures such as in Stephen Norrington's Blade (1998), further this trope by straddling heritage and human heroism, embodying biopolitical exclusion from both worlds. These representations, prevalent in genres, underscore beings' role in critiquing social structures, with their ambiguous natures evoking both fear and fascination in audiences.

References

  1. [1]
    [PDF] Liminality as Pan-Theoretical Model for the Counseling Arts
    Jul 17, 2024 · The person moving through the rites of passage becomes a liminal being, a passage person, and is ritually defined by special names, symbols, ...
  2. [2]
  3. [3]
  4. [4]
    Liminal - Etymology, Origin & Meaning
    Origin and history of liminal​​ "of or pertaining to a threshold," 1870, from Latin limen "threshold, cross-piece, sill" (see limit (n.)) + -al (1). Related: ...
  5. [5]
    [PDF] Turner_Victor_The_Ritual_Proce...
    Victor Turner, The Ritual Process: Structure and Anti-Structurej. Roy Wagner ... strate that as liminal beings they have no status, property, insignia,.
  6. [6]
    Betwixt and Between: The Liminal Period in Rites de Passage - Scribd
    Victor Turner, “Betwixt and Between: The Liminal Period in Rites de Passage,” in The Forest of Symbols (New York: Cornell University Press1967), 338-347.
  7. [7]
    [PDF] Purity and Danger - Monoskop
    Mary Douglas shows that to examine what is considered as unclean in any ... Purity and Danger girls' initiation rites of the Bemba, noted the casual ...Missing: liminal | Show results with:liminal
  8. [8]
    None
    Below is a merged summary of Arnold van Gennep's description of the liminal phase in *Rites of Passage*, consolidating all information from the provided segments into a comprehensive response. To retain maximum detail and clarity, I will use a combination of narrative text and a table in CSV format for key characteristics, examples, and references. This approach ensures all information is preserved while maintaining readability and density.
  9. [9]
    None
    ### Summary of Victor Turner's Definitions from "Liminality and Communitas" (1969)
  10. [10]
    Dramas, fields, and metaphors : symbolic action in human society
    Jul 29, 2010 · Dramas, fields, and metaphors : symbolic action in human society. by: Turner, Victor Witter. Publication date: 1974. Topics: Symbolism, Rites ...
  11. [11]
    Experiencing Ritual: A New Interpretation of African Healing
    Experiencing Ritual is Edith Turner's account of how she sighted a spirit form while participating in the Ihamba ritual of the Ndembu.
  12. [12]
    Gods and mythological creatures in The Iliad in ancient art - OUP Blog
    Dec 7, 2013 · Homer calls the Centaurs “wild beasts,” and it is not clear that he thought of them as half-horse, half-man, as they were always later portrayed ...
  13. [13]
    (PDF) Greek Demons of the Wilderness: the case of the Centaurs
    This paper explores the mythological figures of the Centaurs in the context of Greek wilderness, building on Richard Buxton's analysis of mountains in Greek ...
  14. [14]
    The Story of Anubis - Google Arts & Culture
    Anubis is often depicted holding a crook and flail, symbolizing authority. He was seen as the primary god associated with death during the Old Kingdom until the ...Missing: sources | Show results with:sources
  15. [15]
    (PDF) Three Egyptian Gods: Amentet, Andjeti and Anubis
    Aug 29, 2016 · This paper consists of three monographies, each dealing with one Egyptian god. The gods in question have nothing in particular in common.
  16. [16]
    [PDF] The Significance of Anubis as seen in the Coffin Texts
    ... Anubis during the Middle. Kingdom, as reflected in the Coffin Texts, through a close reading in the original language of the eighty-‐three spells in which ...
  17. [17]
    View of Anglo-American perceptions of Navajo skinwalker legends
    Return to Article Details Anglo-American perceptions of Navajo skinwalker legends Download Download PDF. Thumbnails Document Outline Attachments<|separator|>
  18. [18]
    Skinwalker (mythology) | Research Starters - EBSCO
    Skinwalkers are mythological figures in Navajo culture, regarded as dangerous witches capable of shape-shifting into animals. Known as yee naaldlooshii ...
  19. [19]
    hybrid monsters in the classical world the nature and function of ...
    This thesis examines the significance of hybrid monsters in Greek mythology, literature, and art, focusing on their role in defining human identity and ...
  20. [20]
    [PDF] Neutrosophy Transcends Binary Oppositions in Mythology and ...
    Mar 1, 2024 · The hybrid mythical beings, combining human and animal characteristics or blending divine and mortal traits, are viewed as anomalies or ...
  21. [21]
    [PDF] hybrid monsters in the classical world - CORE
    The aim of this thesis is to explore the purpose of monster figures by investigating the relationship between these creatures and the cultures in which they ...
  22. [22]
    [PDF] a study of the fairy abductions and rescues in - Lehigh Preserve
    demeanor of the fairies in the abduction or rescue; TR and. SL represent an innocuous kidnapping and the setting in each conveys a sense of wonder and ...Missing: texts | Show results with:texts<|control11|><|separator|>
  23. [23]
    Chapter Six: The Sidhe/Fairies – Irish Myth
    These taller, otherworldly beings eventually develop into 'the little people,' the fairies and leprechauns of later Irish legend.
  24. [24]
    The Poetic Edda: Völundarkvitha | Sacred Texts Archive
    Valkyries: cf. Voluspo, 31 and note; there is nothing in the poem to identify the three swan maidens as Valkyries except one obscure word in line 2 of stanza 1 ...
  25. [25]
    [PDF] Changing Perspectives: Valkyries in Text and Image Lindsey K ...
    Let us now wind the web of war Where the warrior banners are forging forward Let his life not be taken; Only the Valkyries can choose the slain…. It is ...
  26. [26]
    Elegbara/Elegguá, Eshu/Echú: Messenger of the Gods
    Abstract. This chapter discusses the Messenger of the Gods, Elegbara, who is one of the three most revered orishas in Yorubaland in Africa.
  27. [27]
    Yoruba Eshu Figure - Timothy S. Y. Lam Museum of Anthropology
    Eshu also serves as a messenger between the mortal world of humans and the spiritual realm of orishas and ancestors. He enables communication with deities and ...Missing: gods | Show results with:gods
  28. [28]
    Exploring Liminal Spaces in Gothic Literature: The Role of Transition ...
    Oct 26, 2024 · This paper explores liminality as a key thematic and structural element within Gothic literature, focusing on Mary Shelley's Frankenstein, Bram Stoker's ...
  29. [29]
    [PDF] an archetypal study of ursula k. le guin's earthsea trilogy and ...
    In this book Le Guin portrays Arha's awakening spirituality and her questioning of the "truths" she has always accepted. She not only must free Ged from his.Missing: liminal | Show results with:liminal
  30. [30]
    [PDF] In Absentia Parentis: The Orphan Figure in Latter Twentieth Century ...
    May 1, 2016 · (Barbaranelli 75). In terms of LeGuin's work, this definition of individuation effectively sums up the core of Ged's story in A Wizard of ...
  31. [31]
    Liminality and Interstitiality in Neil Gaiman's Works - Academia.edu
    Gaiman begins American Gods in a way similar to Neverwhere: in the sense that he begins by establishing the protagonist, Shadow as an outsider, a liminal figure ...
  32. [32]
    Outlandish creatures and genre crossover in young adult liminal ...
    Aug 31, 2023 · This study employs Deleuze's concept of “deterritorialisation” to examine how young adult liminal fantasy can blend genre expectations and engage in ...Missing: post- | Show results with:post-
  33. [33]
    [PDF] Science Fiction/Fantasy and the Representation of Ethnic Futurity
    Apr 30, 2014 · In both texts, hybrid identities and multicultural groups are defined as better able to adapt to new environments, connecting the idea of ...
  34. [34]
    [PDF] "Betwixt Sunset and Sunrise": Liminality in Dracula
    turn, instructs the vampire hunters in the liminal ways and means of the dark Lord of the Cemetery. And Van Helsing emphatically recognizes and celebrates ...
  35. [35]
    Full article: Vampires: Outside Life, Outside Control
    Jun 15, 2023 · The vampire film is a well-trodden site of analysis. Through an analysis of vampires as “outsiders”, this article takes two aspects of the work ...
  36. [36]
    [PDF] A Three-Dimensional Content Analysis of Films from 1980-2014
    We can see this in the hybrid werewolf's form – the human side and the wolf side mixed together in one being, physically presenting a liminal state which.
  37. [37]
    Vampirism in Film
    These shapeshifters embody the conditions of liminality, the ... vampires and vampire slayers. In the process, we will pose and attempt to ...