Fact-checked by Grok 2 weeks ago

Muhammad's first revelation

Muhammad's first revelation denotes the foundational event in Islamic tradition circa 610 CE, when Muhammad ibn Abdullah, a 40-year-old Meccan merchant engaged in meditative seclusion, encountered the angel Jibril (Gabriel) in the Cave of Hira on Jabal al-Nour, receiving the inaugural verses of the Quran that launched his role as prophet. According to accounts in early hadith compilations like Sahih al-Bukhari, the angel seized Muhammad, demanding "Iqra' (Recite!)," and upon his protest of illiteracy, conveyed the words: "Recite in the name of your Lord who created, created man from a clinging substance. Recite, and your Lord is the most Generous—who taught by the pen, taught man that which he knew not" (Quran 96:1-5), establishing monotheistic themes of creation, knowledge, and divine instruction. Distressed and trembling, Muhammad fled the cave, convinced of madness or demonic influence, but his wife Khadijah bint Khuwaylid reassured him, and her Christian relative Waraqah ibn Nawfal interpreted the experience as genuine prophecy comparable to Moses', urging perseverance amid ensuing revelations over 23 years that formed the Quran. This episode, documented in 8th-century sira literature and hadith rather than contemporary records, underpins Islam's origin narrative, though modern scholarship notes variances in early transmissions and questions precise historicity due to the oral tradition's evolution.

Background and Pre-Revelation Context

Muhammad's Early Life and Spiritual Seeking

ibn Abdullah was born circa 570 CE in to the clan of the tribe, which held custodianship over the and profited from regional trade. His father, Abdullah, died before his birth, and his mother, , died when he was about six years old, leaving him an orphan in a tribal society where such status often meant vulnerability. Thereafter, he was raised by his grandfather until age eight, then by his uncle Abu Talib, under whose protection he entered commerce as a and later a , accompanying caravans to and gaining a reputation for honesty that earned him the title (the trustworthy). At around age 25, married , a wealthy widow approximately 15 years his senior who had employed him in ; their union produced several children, including , and lasted until her death. Traditional accounts, drawn from sira literature like Ibn Ishaq's compiled over a century later, portray his early adulthood as marked by introspection amid Mecca's polytheistic practices, economic disparities, and social customs such as , fostering a toward . These sources, while devotional in nature, align with scholarly consensus on a historical core of his life as a navigating Arabian tribal dynamics. In his late 30s, began periodic retreats to Mount Hira outside , engaging in tahannuth—a form of pre-Islamic Arabian involving , , and contemplation of the divine—to escape societal corruption and seek existential answers beyond idol worship. This practice, described in collections and early biographies, reflected a monotheistic yearning amid pervasive , preparing the ground for his reported prophetic experiences around age 40, though non-Muslim contemporary records for this phase remain absent, relying instead on later Muslim testimonies subject to hagiographic tendencies.

Retreats to Mount Hira and Pre-Islamic Practices

Prior to the onset of revelations around 610 CE, Muhammad ibn Abdullah, then in his late thirties or early forties, adopted the practice of taḥannuth, involving periodic retreats to the Cave of Hira on Jabal al-Nur, a mountain about 3 kilometers northeast of Mecca. This seclusion entailed remaining in the cave for several consecutive nights engaged in worship and reflection, descending only when provisions ran low, which were supplied by his wife Khadija bint Khuwaylid. Traditional Islamic sources, including narrations attributed to Aisha bint Abi Bakr in Sahih al-Bukhari, describe Muhammad worshipping Allah alone during these retreats, emphasizing monotheistic devotion amid Mecca's polytheistic milieu. Taḥannuth represented a form of ascetic isolation known in pre-Islamic Hijaz, where individuals withdrew to remote sites for spiritual devotion, often rejecting idolatrous practices prevalent among tribes. Scholarly analysis of early sources like Ibn Ishaq's Sira Rasul Allah (compiled 767 ) indicates this custom involved turning towards the high God , paralleling hanif tendencies of figures like who eschewed . While primarily documented in later Islamic traditions, the practice's roots in Arabian spirituality suggest it as a response to societal moral decay and tribal idol worship, with Muhammad's retreats serving for of and divine . These pre-revelation sojourns, lasting days to weeks, underscore Muhammad's inclination towards and , habits that early biographers link to his for trustworthiness () and dissatisfaction with Meccan commercialism and paganism. Accounts consistently portray the cave's austere environment—narrow, about 3.7 meters long and 2.5 meters wide—as conducive to such withdrawal, though archaeological or non-Islamic corroboration remains absent due to the era's and lack of contemporary records. The practice's emphasis on exclusive devotion to prefigures Quranic , distinguishing it from broader pre-Islamic rituals tied to or .

Traditional Islamic Account of the Event

The Encounter with Gabriel in Cave Hira

According to the traditional Islamic accounts preserved in major hadith collections, Muhammad ibn Abdullah, then approximately 40 years old, was in seclusion for devotional purposes in the Cave of Hira on Jabal al-Nur, a mountain approximately 2 miles from Mecca. This practice involved retreating for several nights with provisions before returning home. Narrated by Aisha, his wife, the encounter began when the angel Jibril (Gabriel) suddenly appeared and commanded Muhammad, "Iqra'" ("Read" or "Recite"). Muhammad responded that he was unlettered and did not know how to read. The angel then embraced him firmly, squeezing him with such force that he felt overwhelmed and repeated his inability to recite. This pressing occurred three times, each instance prompting the same command and response, until on the third embrace, the angel released him and conveyed the initial verses: "Read in the name of your Lord who created—created man from a clinging substance. Read, and your Lord is the most Generous—who taught by the pen—taught man that which he knew not." (Quran 96:1-5). The same core narrative appears in Ibn Ishaq's Sirat Rasul Allah, the earliest extant biography of , compiled in the 8th century CE from earlier oral reports, describing the angelic visitation and physical intensity of the encounter similarly, though with minor variations in phrasing. Parallel accounts in and other collections corroborate the sequence of the command, Muhammad's denial of literacy, the triple embrace, and the revelation of al-Alaq's opening verses as the first Quranic disclosure. These traditions emphasize the event's abrupt and physically demanding nature, marking the inception of Muhammad's prophetic mission.

Specific Verses Revealed and Their Content

According to traditional Islamic sources, the first revelation to consisted of the opening five verses of Surah Al-Alaq ( 96:1-5), delivered by the angel during the encounter in the Cave of Hira. These verses commence with the imperative iqra' ("recite" or "read"), directed at , emphasizing divine and as foundational themes. The verses state: "Recite in the name of your who created—created from a clinging substance. Recite, and your is the most Generous—who taught by —taught that which he knew not." In , the text reads: Iqra' bismi rabbika alladhi khalaq. Khalaqa al-insana min 'alaq. Iqra' wa rabbuka al-akram. Alladhi 'allama bil-qalam. 'Allama al-insana ma lam ya'lam. Traditional exegeses interpret these as initiating the Quranic message with monotheistic affirmation: invoking as the creator who formed from a rudimentary clot ('alaq, denoting a leech-like or congealed blood form), underscoring human origins from humble biological . The of iqra' highlights the command for proclamation or through divine aid, contrasting Muhammad's reported illiteracy and attributing to God's via as a of recorded . This content establishes core Islamic tenets of (divine unity), human dependency on , and the value of learning, with no explicit prophetic in these initial lines but an implicit call to disseminate the message. Scholarly consensus in Sunni and Shia traditions upholds these as the inaugural , predating other s in chronological .

Immediate Aftermath and Initial Reactions

Muhammad's Personal Distress and Return Home

Following the angelic encounter in the Cave of Hira, experienced intense physical and emotional turmoil, characterized by a severely pounding heart and overwhelming fear. He descended from the mountain in haste and returned directly to his home in , where he sought immediate refuge from his wife bint Khuwailid. Upon arriving, he exclaimed, "Cover me! Cover me!"—a plea reflecting acute terror and disorientation, prompting Khadija and her household to envelop him in garments until his agitation subsided. In this state of distress, Muhammad conveyed the details of the revelation to , recounting how the figure had commanded him to "read" or "recite" despite his illiteracy, physically squeezing him thrice before imparting the initial verses of Surah al-Alaq ( 96:1-5). He expressed profound apprehension about his mental state, stating, "I fear for myself," amid concerns that the experience might indicate possession by , poetic madness, or demonic influence—fears rooted in pre-Islamic Arabian cultural understandings of supernatural visitations. These accounts, preserved in early collections like (narrated via bint Abi Bakr), depict Muhammad's reaction as one of uncharacteristic vulnerability for a man of his reputed composure, underscoring the event's disruptive impact on his psyche. Traditional sources emphasize that this initial terror persisted briefly, with Muhammad's return home marking the immediate transition from solitary retreat to communal reassurance, though no precise duration for the distress is specified beyond the covering episode. Later biographical traditions, such as those in Ibn Ishaq's Sirat Rasul Allah (as transmitted by ), similarly portray him trembling and collapsing into Khadija's lap upon entry, reinforcing the narrative of raw, unmediated panic without embellishment of heroic resolve at this juncture.

Role of Khadija and Consultation with Waraqa ibn Nawfal

Upon returning home from the Cave of Hira in a state of intense fear and trembling, sought refuge with his wife , exclaiming "Cover me, cover me!" as he lay down. , aged approximately 45 at the time and married to for about 15 years, immediately covered him with a blanket and reassured him by citing his honorable character—known for truthfulness, kindness to kin, and aid to the needy—as evidence that would not disgrace or harm him. Her prompt affirmation positioned her as the first person to accept 's prophetic claim, providing emotional stability amid his initial doubt and physical exhaustion. Recognizing the gravity of the experience, then escorted to her paternal cousin Waraqa ibn Nawfal ibn , a elderly Meccan who had embraced during the period and possessed knowledge of scriptures in Hebrew and scripts. Waraqa, by then blind and frail, urged to have recount the event, after which he declared the visitor to be al-Namus (the trustworthy angel, identified as ), the same entity sent to with revelation. He affirmed 's prophethood for the people, warning of impending rejection and persecution akin to that faced by earlier prophets. Waraqa expressed regret at his advanced age, wishing he could remain alive to support Muhammad against his kin's opposition, but he died shortly afterward, within days or weeks of the consultation. This encounter with Waraqa, drawing on his familiarity with traditions, lent early external validation to Muhammad's experience in the traditional narrative, bridging pre-Islamic Meccan monotheistic inclinations with the emerging Islamic message. Khadija's initiative in seeking Waraqa's counsel underscored her pivotal supportive role, sustaining Muhammad through the revelation's immediate psychological aftermath.

Dating and Chronological Issues

Traditional Islamic Dating and Calendar Considerations

The first revelation to Muhammad is traditionally dated by Sunni scholars to the month of Ramadan, approximately 13 lunar years before the Hijra (migration to Medina in 622 CE), aligning with the solar year 610 CE. This timing is linked to the "Night of Power" (Laylat al-Qadr), described in Quran 97:1–5 as occurring in Ramadan and surpassing a thousand months in value, with the 27th night of Ramadan being the most widely accepted date based on hadith narrations attributing the event to an odd-numbered night in the last ten days of the month. Shi'i traditions diverge, often placing the revelation on the 27th of (the seventh lunar month), reflecting interpretive differences in prophetic chains and biographical accounts (sira). These variations stem from reliance on oral transmissions compiled centuries later, such as in Ibn Ishaq's Sira (d. 767 CE) and Bukhari's hadith collections (d. 870 CE), without contemporaneous documentary evidence. The Hijri calendar, formalized under Caliph Umar ibn al-Khattab around 637 CE, provides the framework for these dates but introduces retrospective challenges, as it anchors events to the Hijra rather than Muhammad's birth or revelation, omitting fixed numbering for pre-Hijri years (denoted as "before Hijra" or BH). Pre-Islamic Arabs employed a lunisolar system influenced by Quraysh customs, with intercalation (nasi') occasionally added to align with seasons, but this was discontinued post-revelation per Quran 9:37, enforcing a strictly lunar reckoning of 354–355 days per year. This results in the Hijri calendar drifting about 11 days annually relative to the Gregorian solar calendar, complicating precise conversions; for instance, Ramadan 610 CE likely spanned late July to late August by Julian reckoning, though exact moon-sighting determinations remain approximate absent archaeological corroboration. Such dating relies on prophetic biography (seerah) traditions, which prioritize Muhammad's reported 40 lunar years (roughly 38–39 solar years from his ~570 birth in the "") over astronomical back-calculation, potentially introducing minor discrepancies due to variable month lengths (29 or 30 days) and the absence of standardized before Umar's reforms.

Scholarly Debates on Precision and Evidence

The precise dating of 's first revelation remains contested among scholars, primarily due to the reliance on later Islamic biographical and exegetical traditions rather than contemporaneous documentation. Traditional accounts, drawn from works like Ibn Ishaq's Sīrat Rasūl Allāh (compiled circa 767 CE), position the event in 610 CE, approximately 13 lunar years before the in 622 CE, during the month of when was said to be 40 years old. This chronology hinges on retrospective Islamic calendrical reconstructions and transmissions, which lack external verification from 7th-century non-Muslim sources. Critical scholarship emphasizes the evidentiary gaps, noting that the earliest datable references to appear in inscriptions from 1-2 (622-624 ), postdating the purported revelation by over a decade and offering no direct insight into the event itself. Historians such as have argued that early blends tribal, religious, and secular narratives compiled generations later, potentially introducing anachronisms or idealizations that obscure precise timelines. Similarly, archaeological analyses reveal a scarcity of material evidence for nascent in the first seven decades post-Hijra, complicating claims of a firmly established 610 origin. Alternative datings, such as 608 or 612 , emerge from discrepancies in Muhammad's reported age at prophethood (ranging 40-43 in variant traditions) and cross-references with stylistics, as systematized by Nöldeke's chronological framework. Revisionist approaches, including those by Shoemaker, question the uniformity of early Quranic transmission and suggest that fuller narratives of the may reflect 8th-century consolidations rather than 7th-century events, though they do not outright reject a late-6th to early-7th-century . These debates underscore a broader tension: while internal Islamic sources provide a coherent sequence, their chains of transmission (isnads) are deemed unreliable by skeptics for lacking empirical anchors, favoring probabilistic estimates over definitive precision.

Critical and Alternative Perspectives

Historicity Questions and Hadith Reliability

The detailed narrative of Muhammad's encounter with the angel Gabriel in Cave Hira, including the physical squeezing and command to "read," originates from hadith reports rather than the Quran itself, which references the initial revelation of Surah 96 (Al-Alaq) without describing the circumstances. These hadiths were compiled in collections like Sahih al-Bukhari around 846 CE, over two centuries after the event traditionally dated to circa 610 CE, relying on oral chains of transmission (isnad) spanning multiple generations. No archaeological or epigraphic evidence from the early 7th century confirms the specific incident, and contemporary non-Muslim sources, such as Syriac chronicles, mention Muhammad's prophetic claims by the 630s CE but omit details of the Hira cave experience. The primary on the first revelation is narrated through bint Abi Bakr in (Volume 1, Book 1, Hadith 3), where she recounts Muhammad's distress and return home, but , born approximately 613–614 , could not have been an eyewitness, rendering the account second- or third-hand at best. Other early transmissions, such as those attributed to (d. 712 ), appear in 8th-century biographical works like Ibn Ishaq's Sirat Rasul Allah (d. 767 ), yet these too depend on unbroken oral isnads vulnerable to memory distortion or intentional shaping to emphasize prophetic drama. Islamic scholars developed rigorous criteria for evaluating narrator reliability, including piety and memory, but critics highlight inconsistencies, such as variant reports of the revelation's onset (e.g., some describing a dream-like state rather than a physical visitation), and the absence of cross-verification from companions present in at the time. Western and revisionist scholarship questions the overall reliability of hadith for reconstructing early events, citing the medium's explosive proliferation— from a few hundred in the 7th century to hundreds of thousands by the 9th—suggesting fabrication for doctrinal reinforcement or political legitimacy under Abbasid rule. Historians like those in the tradition of Ignaz Goldziher and Joseph Schacht argue that isnad back-projection, where chains were retroactively constructed to lend antiquity, undermines authenticity, particularly for foundational narratives like the Hira revelation lacking Quranic attestation. While traditional Muslim apologetics, as in works by al-Dhahabi, defend sahih-grade hadiths through matn (content) analysis excluding contradictions with established Sunnah, empirical historians prioritize the lack of contemporaneous documentation, viewing the story as potentially evolving from Muhammad's own retrospective interpretations of visionary experiences into a canonical miracle.

Psychological, Medical, and Neurological Explanations

Some researchers have hypothesized that Muhammad's encounter in Cave Hira, involving sensations of physical compression and auditory commands, may reflect symptoms of (TLE), a neurological condition associated with vivid hallucinations, religious visions, and ecstatic experiences. In TLE, abnormal electrical activity in the temporal lobes can produce complex partial seizures featuring auditory or visual phenomena, a sense of presence, and hyper-religiosity, which proponents like Frank R. Freemon (1976) applied to Muhammad's "inspirational spells" based on later biographical accounts of sweating, trembling, and trance-like states during revelations. Historical figures such as 19th-century orientalist and physician Aloys Sprenger similarly attributed the event to epileptic fits or "cataleptic insanity," interpreting the physical distress and illiteracy denial as seizure-induced disorientation. However, neurological evaluations of hadith descriptions—such as Muhammad's retained awareness, coherent recitation of verses immediately after the squeezing, absence of convulsions, post-event lucidity without confusion, and the structured progression of revelations over 23 years—contradict typical TLE patterns, which often involve , stereotyped automatisms, and declining cognitive function over time. A 2019 neurological review concluded that no epileptic fits, as peri-revelation episodes lack ictal loss of , olfactory auras, or progressive deterioration, instead aligning more with volitional meditative states than pathological . Critics of the epilepsy theory, including modern psychiatric analyses, note its origins in potentially biased 19th-century influenced by theological polemics, which overstated seizure resemblances while ignoring contextual factors like prolonged and . Psychologically, the cave seclusion—entailing days of , minimal sustenance, and intense reflection—could induce hypnagogic hallucinations or altered states of akin to those in , where sleep-wake transitions produce vivid sensory intrusions without underlying pathology. Such experiences, documented in , involve pressure sensations and imperative voices from REM-like intrusions during wakefulness, potentially exacerbated by pre-Islamic Arabian stressors like tribal and personal reported in early sources. Muhammad's initial of madness or possession, as recounted to , mirrors acute stress responses or transient dissociative episodes rather than chronic , though no evidence supports , given the absence of disorganized thought or in subsequent productive output. These explanations remain speculative, reliant on retrospective interpretation of 7th-8th century oral traditions compiled decades or centuries later, with no contemporaneous medical records or autopsies to verify neurological substrates. Empirical challenges include the event's singularity for the first versus ongoing verbal clarity in later ones, underscoring that causal attribution favors naturalistic hypotheses only insofar as they account for all attested details without adjustments.

Theological Critiques from Christian and Jewish Viewpoints

Christian theologians, drawing on Islamic sources such as and Ibn Ishaq's Sirat Rasul Allah, critique the physical and emotional character of Muhammad's encounter in the Cave of Hira around 610 CE as indicative of demonic rather than divine origin. Muhammad described being seized and squeezed repeatedly by a spirit until breathless, responding with terror and fleeing to his wife Khadijah, convinced he was possessed by a or poetry demon—a fear rooted in pre-Islamic Arabian beliefs about poetic inspiration from evil spirits. This initial impression of possession, coupled with subsequent suicidal impulses where Muhammad contemplated throwing himself from cliffs, contrasts sharply with biblical prophetic encounters, such as Moses' commissioning at the burning bush (Exodus 3:1-6) or Paul's vision on the Damascus road (:1-19), which involved awe but not self-destructive despair or doubt of demonic agency. Further Christian analysis points to the revelation's content and Muhammad's career as incompatible with scriptural orthodoxy, invoking New Testament warnings against angels preaching contrary doctrines ( 1:8; 2 Corinthians 11:14). The being's self-identification as is questioned, given the Quran's denial of Christ's (Surah 4:157), (Surah 5:116), and sonship—core Christian tenets affirmed in the Gospels—suggesting a masquerading entity promoting an "antichrist" message (1 John 2:22). Incidents like the "Satanic Verses," where Muhammad briefly recited verses honoring pagan goddesses before retracting them as satanic interpolation (as reported in and ), reinforce claims of occult interference, absent in verified . Early like (c. 675–749 ) labeled Muhammad a influenced by an Arian , whose teachings deviated from apostolic . Jewish theological critiques emphasize that Muhammad's claimed fails the 's explicit criteria for authentic outlined in Deuteronomy 18:15-22, which mandates a prophet arise "from among your brothers"—interpreted by rabbinic tradition as fellow , excluding an Ishmaelite descendant. (1138–1204 CE), in works like the and Guide for the Perplexed, undermines claims of post-biblical outside the Mosaic line, portraying figures like as promoters of yet erroneous innovators whose messages contradict imperatives, such as unaltered law observance, rendering them non-prophetic. The Hira experience lacks the confirmatory miracles or signs demanded by Deuteronomy 13:1-5, and the Quran's abrogation of biblical covenants (e.g., 2:106) and alteration of narratives (e.g., Ishmael's near-sacrifice in 37:100-107 versus in 22) violates the test of consistency with prior , a standard unfulfilled by non- claimants. Rabbinic sources maintain that prophecy ceased after (c. 420 BCE), with no mechanism for foreign validation absent Jewish endorsement or alignment with ; Muhammad's lack of such corroboration, combined with Islam's supersessionist stance toward , positions the revelation as human invention rather than divine. Traditional views, echoed in medieval polemics, reject the event's authenticity due to its divergence from prophetic norms like public theophanies or ethical universality without ethnic exclusivity, as seen in ' Sinai revelation ( 19-20).

Influences, Parallels, and Broader Context

Connections to Hanifism and Pre-Islamic Monotheism

Hanifism refers to a pre-Islamic Arabian movement of monotheists who rejected idolatry and sought to follow the primordial religion of Abraham, distinct from Judaism and Christianity yet influenced by Abrahamic ideas. Adherents, known as hanifs (from Arabic ḥanīf, meaning "one who turns away" from polytheism), practiced asceticism and emphasized devotion to a single supreme deity, Allah, recognized in Arabia as the high god even amid polytheistic practices. Scholarly analyses posit that hunafāʾ formed loose communities of seekers after truth, predating Muhammad by generations, with figures like Zayd ibn ʿAmr exemplifying rejection of Meccan idols in favor of ethical monotheism. Muhammad's pre-prophetic life aligned closely with practices, as he engaged in taḥannuth—periodic retreats for and worship—in the Cave of Hira near , a custom associated with ascetics seeking divine guidance away from urban . Traditional accounts describe as inherently inclined toward monotheism, avoiding pagan rituals and pilgrimages to idols, behaviors consistent with inclinations documented among elites. This background framed his first revelation around 610 CE, where the angel commanded iqraʾ ("recite") in the name of the Lord who created man from a clot, underscoring by one —a echoing affirmation of as sole creator without associates. The Qurʾān explicitly links hanifism to Abrahamic monotheism, portraying Abraham as the archetype ḥanīf who submitted purely to God (millat al-islām), a model Muhammad's revelation invoked to critique contemporary polytheism. Early Islamic sources and some historians suggest Muhammad's nascent movement was initially perceived or self-described as a revival of hanifiyya, bridging pre-Islamic monotheistic undercurrents with the prophetic call to exclusive worship of Allah. Pre-Islamic Arabia exhibited vestiges of monotheism, such as invocations of Allah in inscriptions and oaths, alongside subordinate deities, which hanifs and later Muhammad's message sought to purify by eliminating intercessors. This continuity indicates the revelation in Hira as a culminating divine affirmation of latent monotheistic impulses rather than an isolated innovation, though debates persist on the extent of organized hanif groups versus individual seekers.

Potential Borrowings from Judeo-Christian Traditions

Scholars have proposed that the narrative and thematic elements of Muhammad's first revelation, as recorded in Surah ( 96:1-5), may reflect indirect influences from prophetic traditions circulating in through oral transmission and commercial contacts. Muhammad's annual trade caravans to exposed him to Syriac Christian communities and Nestorian monks, while Jewish tribes in Yathrib (later ) and Christian settlements in contributed to a shared monotheistic milieu among the Hanifs, pre-Islamic seekers of Abrahamic faith. These interactions likely familiarized him with motifs of divine commissioning, as evidenced by parallels between the Quranic command "Recite in the name of your Lord who created" and biblical prophetic calls emphasizing God's creative sovereignty, such as in Isaiah 40:26-28 or Jeremiah 1:4-5. The structure of the encounter— an angelic figure (Gabriel) commanding recitation amid Muhammad's protest of illiteracy, followed by physical empowerment through squeezing—mirrors reluctance and divine enablement in Mosaic and other biblical narratives. In Exodus 4:10-12, Moses demurs due to faltering speech, prompting God's assurance: "Who has made man's mouth? ... Now therefore go, and I will be with thy mouth." Similar patterns appear in Jeremiah 1:6-9, where the prophet claims youth and inadequacy, and God touches his mouth to impart words. While direct textual borrowing is unproven, these formal similarities suggest adaptation of oral prophetic archetypes known in the region, rather than novel invention, as argued by analyses of Quranic engagement with earlier traditions. Thematically, the revelation's focus on creation from a "clot" (alaq) evokes biblical descriptions of human formation in the womb, such as :13-16 ("You knit me together in my mother's womb") or Job 10:8-12, which detail God's molding from base matter. This embryological imagery, emphasizing humble origins to underscore divine authorship, aligns with Jewish midrashic expansions on but diverges in phrasing, potentially indicating selective incorporation via ambient storytelling rather than . Critics of borrowing theories, often from Islamic scholarly perspectives, counter that such parallels stem from shared Abrahamic or coincidental archetypes, correcting prior distortions rather than deriving from them; however, the historical proximity of unorthodox Christian and Jewish informants, including Waraqa ibn Nawfal's identification of the event as akin to ' "" (law/), supports causal influence over pure independence. Western orientalist scholarship, such as that referencing Bell's work, posits that adapted these elements to affirm with prior prophets while asserting a final corrective message, though remains circumstantial, reliant on reports compiled decades later. No verbatim lifts occur, and the revelation's brevity prioritizes monotheistic proclamation over narrative detail, but the convergence in form and content—divine initiative, human frailty, creative fiat—implies borrowings shaped by Arabia's eclectic religious landscape, where and had permeated via migration and trade since the 4th century .

Significance and Long-Term Impact

Role in Forming Islamic Theology of Revelation

The first to in the Cave of Hira around 610 CE initiated the Islamic doctrine of wahy (), establishing it as a direct, verbal transmission from via the angel Jibril, distinct from mere granted to earlier prophets. This event, detailed in traditional accounts as the descent of the opening verses of al-Alaq ("Recite in the name of your who created"), underscored as an imperative command to proclaim divine , despite Muhammad's illiteracy, thereby authenticating the miraculous nature of the as uncreated speech of . In Islamic theology, this inaugural wahy paradigmatically defined Muhammad's role as the seal of the prophets, with subsequent revelations over 23 years forming the complete Quran as the final, abrogating scripture superseding prior Abrahamic texts. The suddenness and physical intensity of the experience—described as Jibril squeezing Muhammad and demanding recitation—shaped the understanding of revelation as an overwhelming divine initiative, not human composition, central to doctrines of prophetic infallibility (isma) and the Quran's inimitability (i'jaz). The Hira event's emphasis on "reading" or reciting God's words formalized revelation as linguistic and book-form (kitab), differentiating Islamic wahy from symbolic or intuitive forms in and , and laying the groundwork for theological assertions that the Quran's preservation in verbatim preserves divine intent without alteration. This foundation influenced later scholastic developments, such as al-Ghazali's classifications of wahy modes, yet remained anchored in the primordial encounter's testimony to God's active intervention in history.

Early Challenges in Propagation and Reception

Following the first revelation in 610 CE, experienced profound personal doubt and fear, interpreting the encounter with the angel Jibril as possible possession by a or indication of madness, which led him to seek reassurance from his wife Khadijah bint Khuwaylid. Khadijah affirmed his experience by taking him to her cousin , a Christian scholar familiar with biblical scriptures, who declared it akin to the prophethood of and predicted opposition from his people. This initial validation enabled to begin propagating the message of , but propagation remained limited to a secretive phase lasting approximately three years, confined to trusted family and close associates to evade scrutiny. Early reception was mixed but predominantly hostile among the tribe of , whose polytheistic practices and economic reliance on to the Kaaba's idols were directly challenged by the revelation's emphasis on a singular and rejection of . Muhammad's first public preaching around 613 provoked ridicule and accusations of sorcery, poetry, or insanity from tribal leaders, including his uncle , who actively campaigned against him. Despite this, a small core of converts emerged, including Khadijah as the first, followed by Muhammad's cousin ibn Abi Talib (aged about 10), adopted son Zayd ibn Harithah, and friend ibn Abi Quhafah, who in turn brought in five others, totaling around 40 believers by the end of the secret period. These early adherents faced social ostracism and physical harassment, particularly vulnerable slaves like , who endured torture for renouncing idols. The Quraysh's opposition stemmed from fears that 's message undermined their custodianship of the , disrupted trade networks tied to pagan rituals, and eroded tribal hierarchies by equating all believers regardless of lineage. Leaders like Abu Jahl ibn Musharif dismissed the revelations as fabrications or demonic influence, urging to produce or worldly proof beyond oral recitation, while rejecting the Quran's linguistic to produce a comparable . Propagation difficulties intensified as public conversion attempts yielded few gains, with most Meccans prioritizing ancestral traditions over the abstract , leading to focus on moral critiques of , , and to appeal to hanifs and the marginalized. Traditional accounts, primarily from Ibn Ishaq's Sirah (compiled 767 from oral reports), document these dynamics but rely on chains of transmission vulnerable to hagiographic embellishment, underscoring the challenges in verifying granular details absent contemporary non-Muslim corroboration.

References

  1. [1]
    The Quran | World Civilization - Lumen Learning
    Muhammad first received revelations in 609 CE in a cave on Mount Hira, near Mecca. Muslims regard the Quran as the most important miracle of Muhammad, the proof ...
  2. [2]
  3. [3]
    An Account of the First Revelation to the Prophet
    The following account is drawn from Al-Bukhari's Sahih, and is one of a number of versions that we have of the story of the first revelation to the Prophet.
  4. [4]
    Historical account of Muhammad's first verse revelation in the Quran.
    Feb 27, 2025 · The account of Muhammad's first revelation (being Q 96) seems to go back to the 7th century AD, since it can be found in Urwa's biography, as ...Muhammad's First Revelation was in a Dream? : r/AcademicQuran[Islam]During the first interaction with Gabriel, Prophet Muhammad ...More results from www.reddit.com
  5. [5]
    The Prophet Muhammad and the Origins of Islam
    Early Life​​ Muhammad was born into the most powerful tribe in Mecca, the Quraish, around 570 A.D. The power of the Quraish derived from their role as successful ...
  6. [6]
    The Life of the Prophet Muhammad ﷺ - Human Concern International
    570 CE, a child named Muhammad was born in Mecca. His life, right from the start, was marked by hardship. · orphan child in that society was to be incredibly ...
  7. [7]
    Nine Important Facts about Muhammad - Southern Equip
    Aug 12, 2022 · 1. Muhammad was probably a historical figure. Muhammad was allegedly born in Mecca in AD 570 and died in Medina in AD 632.Missing: scholarly | Show results with:scholarly
  8. [8]
    Chapter 1: Primary Sources on the Life of Muhammad
    The documents most commonly viewed by historians as being primary sources for his life are the Qur'an (the Islamic holy book) and the Constitution of Medina.
  9. [9]
  10. [10]
    Why Did Prophet Muhammad Often Visit Cave of Hira'? - About Islam
    Feb 20, 2024 · Mostly, he was thinking and meditating on the Greatness of God, and seeking to escape the social ills that dominated Meccan society at the time.
  11. [11]
    The Non-Muslim Seventh Century Sources for the Prophet Muhammad
    Oct 15, 2020 · Muslim sources include allusions in the Qur'an, oral traditions (Hadith) collected and written down by Muslim scholars, and later biographies.<|separator|>
  12. [12]
    Cave of Hira - Hajj Council Of North America
    In Ramadan 610 CE, the first revelations of the Holy Quran were received by Prophet Muhammad at the Hira Cave. According to the Quran, this night is called 'the ...<|separator|>
  13. [13]
    Prophet Muhammad worship in Cave Hira - Islam Stack Exchange
    Apr 2, 2024 · He used to go in seclusion in the cave of Hira where he used to worship (Allah alone) continuously for many days before his desire to see his family.Missing: spiritual | Show results with:spiritual
  14. [14]
    [PDF] AL-TAHANNUTH - The works of Prof. Meir J. Kister
    'That tahannuth was a Quraish practice may well be doubted, because of the ... of such a practice in pre-Islamic Arabia, and the fact that the Koran makes.
  15. [15]
    Muhammad's Biography (part 3 of 12): The First Revelations
    Feb 13, 2006 · Cave of Hira (aerial view). Prophet Muhammad used to meditate in this cave frequently. The first revelations of the Quran came to him here.<|control11|><|separator|>
  16. [16]
    Sahih al-Bukhari 3 - Revelation - كتاب بدء الوحى - Sunnah.com
    He used to go in seclusion in the cave of Hira where he used to worship (Allah alone) continuously for many days before his desire to see his family. He used to ...
  17. [17]
    1st Revelation: What shall I read? - Quran Talk Blog
    Dec 22, 2023 · Here is the transcription and translation of the narration according to Ibn Ishaq: Ibn Ishaq said: Wahb bin Kaysan narrated to me, saying: ...
  18. [18]
    What Was the First Revelation to Prophet Muhammad?
    Feb 21, 2012 · " The verses revealed were the first five from Surat Al-`Alaq [Quran 96: 1-5], marking the beginning of prophethood and the Quran. Similar ...
  19. [19]
    Surah Al-'Alaq - 1-19 - Quran.com
    A great majority of the Islamic scholars are agreed that it forms the very first Revelation to be sent down to the Holy Prophet (upon whom be Allah's peace and ...
  20. [20]
    Surah Al-'Alaq 96:1-19 - Towards Understanding the Quran
    These verses were the very first to be revealed to the Prophet (peace be upon him), as is stated in the Hadith reported by Aishah. This first experience was ...
  21. [21]
    Surah 'Alaq, Chapter 96 - Al-Islam.org
    This Surah addresses the holy Prophet (S) and commands him to read or proclaim (the Message). Then, it refers to the creation of Man out of a mere clot.
  22. [22]
    SAHIH BUKHARI, BOOK 1: Revelation
    Then he went to Khadija bint Khuwailid and said, "Cover me! Cover me!" They covered him till his fear was over and after that he told her everything that had ...Missing: distress | Show results with:distress
  23. [23]
    Sahih Muslim 160a - The Book of Faith - كتاب الإيمان - Sunnah.com
    He was very old and had become blind Khadija said to him: O uncle! listen to the son of your brother. Waraqa b. Naufal said: O my nephew! what did you see? The ...
  24. [24]
    The Birth of Islam and the Proclamation by Muhammad of his Mission
    ... Gabriel in the cave of Hira. The traditional Sunni account of this incident is given in an article written by Shaykh Ahmad Zaki Hammad, Ph.D., captioned Be ...
  25. [25]
    The First Revelation of the Quran During Ramadan: Know the Story
    Jun 23, 2025 · The first revelation happened during Ramadan when our beloved Prophet Muhammad ﷺ was in the cave of Hira. The Quran was revealed over 23 years.
  26. [26]
    The Month In Which The Quran Was First Revealed - Quranic
    Apr 13, 2021 · The Quran was first revealed during the month of Ramadan, the ninth month of the Islamic Lunar Calendar. This blessed month is known by many ...The Month of Revelation · Significance of Laylat-al-qadr · Descent of the Quran
  27. [27]
    The Prophet's Spiritual State at the Time of His Mission - Al-Islam.org
    They state that the Mission was announced on the 27th of Rajab. This is what the vast majority or as Majlisi states, the consensus of Shi'i scholars agree with.
  28. [28]
    Chapter 5: Prophethood | Shi'a Islam
    At the age of forty, on the 27th of Rajab, 610 AD, in Mecca, the Holy Prophet (S) received his first revelation. The first ones confessing the Holy Prophet's (S) ...
  29. [29]
    The Months Ordained by Allah: Reviving the Islamic Calendar
    Apr 1, 2021 · Muslims chose to date their history from neither Muhammad's birth nor his reception of the first revelation in 610 AH, but from the creation of ...
  30. [30]
    Why Is the Age of Islam Based on the Beginning of Hijrah?
    Jul 29, 2012 · My question is; why do we always leave out the first 13 years of prophethood before Hijrah? I know the year of Hijrah was a great year yet we ...
  31. [31]
    Understanding the Islamic Lunar Calendar - Quranic
    Apr 3, 2023 · The event of the splitting of the moon is seen as a powerful symbol of the truthfulness of the Prophet Muhammad ﷺ, and his prophethood. The ...
  32. [32]
    The Call to Islam | Muhammad
    It was during the month of Ramadan of the year of the elephant (610 A.D.), 13 years before the Hijra, that revelation descended on Muhammad for the first time. ...
  33. [33]
    Emergence of the Islamic Calendar - Last Prophet
    There are several reasons for this choice: the companions did not know the exact dates of the birth and prophethood of the Holy Prophet and the decease date of ...Missing: considerations | Show results with:considerations
  34. [34]
    The Birth of Islam - The Metropolitan Museum of Art
    Oct 1, 2001 · Born in Mecca, in western Arabia, Muhammad (ca. 570–632), last in the line of Judeo-Christian prophets, received his first revelation in 610.Missing: analysis | Show results with:analysis
  35. [35]
    Dated And Datable Texts Mentioning Prophet Muhammad From 1 ...
    Apr 28, 2020 · Dated And Datable Texts Mentioning Prophet Muhammad From 1-100 AH / 622-719 CE.
  36. [36]
    Patricia Crone and the “secular tradition” of early Islamic ...
    Sep 21, 2022 · Patricia Crone famously identified three distinct sub-traditions within early Islamic historiography: a “religious tradition”, a “tribal tradition”, and a “ ...<|control11|><|separator|>
  37. [37]
    [PDF] Archaeology and the History of Early Islam: The First Seventy Years
    Abstract. The rarity of material evidence for the religion of Islam during the first seventy years of the hijra (622-92 CE) has been used to attack the ...
  38. [38]
    [PDF] Chronology of the Qur'an According to Theodor Nöldeke and Sir ...
    The author analyzes the chronology of Theodor Nöldeke and Sir William Muir described in his works. The History of the Qur'an and The Life of Mahomet by using ...
  39. [39]
    The Dating of the Qur'ān: A Review of Richard Bell's Theories - jstor
    They are : (1) The normal unit of revelation is the short passage. (2) The text was " revised " by Muhammad himself. These principles arc fundamental to all the ...
  40. [40]
    Radiocarbon Dating of the Qur'an. Has It Solved the Problem? Guest ...
    Jul 15, 2023 · This is an unusually important post on how to solve the problem of the date of the Qur'an, by my colleague Stephen Shoemaker.
  41. [41]
    [PDF] First-Century Sources for the Life of Muhammad? A Debate - SciSpace
    makes them useless for dating: “On the whole the evidence of the isnads does not present a very compelling case for any connection with ^Abdallah b. Unays ...<|separator|>
  42. [42]
    Authenticating Hadith and the History of Hadith Criticism
    Jun 24, 2021 · How do we know that Hadith is credible? This paper discusses the origins, mechanics, and development of Sunni hadith criticism, from the ...
  43. [43]
    Who Was the Real Muhammad? | Desiring God
    Jan 9, 2024 · According to Muslim traditions, Muhammad was born in Mecca in 570 and died in Medina in 632. (Both Mecca and Medina are located in today's Saudi ...
  44. [44]
    21 Reasons Historians Are Skeptical of Hadith - Quran Talk Blog
    Feb 8, 2023 · Dr. Little presented 21 reasons historians are skeptical of Hadith. In the interview, Dr. Little mentioned that all these points will be in his upcoming book.
  45. [45]
    [PDF] BETWEEN THE CRITICISM OF HADÎTS AND HADÎTS ...
    When early Muslim scholars collected the hadîts, they used two methods. The first method weighed authenticity by testing the chain of the story's transmitters ( ...
  46. [46]
    A Differential Diagnosis of the Inspirational Spells of Muhammad the ...
    The author concludes that if one were forced to make a medical diagnosis, psychomotor seizures of temporal lobe epilepsy would be the most tenable explanation, ...
  47. [47]
    [PDF] A critical evaluation of William Muir's epileptic theory - Ulum Islamiyyah
    Apr 30, 2025 · This theory posits that the Prophet (saw) encountered epileptic seizures and suffered from a mental disorder.
  48. [48]
    Did Prophet Mohammad (PBUH) have epilepsy? A neurological ...
    They suggested probable diagnosis of temporal lobe epilepsy, adding credibility to the historical claims. Material and method: Review of works of some ...
  49. [49]
    Prophetic Visions and the Hypnagogic State: Altered Consciousness ...
    May 4, 2025 · Similarly, some medical scholars have speculated whether Muhammad's experiences had a neurological component (e.g. epilepsy has historically ...<|control11|><|separator|>
  50. [50]
    A Psychiatrist's Defence of the Prophet Muhammad - Rational Religion
    Jun 15, 2025 · The Prophet Muhammad's life experience is completely in contradiction to the life of a sufferer of temporal lobe epilepsy. The Experience of ...<|separator|>
  51. [51]
    A differential diagnosis of the inspirational spells of Muhammad the ...
    An examination of Western civilization's views of Muhammad's spells reveals historical and modern misconceptions about epilepsy.
  52. [52]
    Muhammad And The Demons - Answering Islam
    This explains why Muhammad thought he was demon possessed, or influenced by demons; the Quran in many places reads like poetry. In "Muhammad at Mecca", page 40, ...
  53. [53]
    Comparing the Central Figures of Islam and Christianity
    First, when Muhammad began receiving revelations in the cave on Mount Hira, his first impression was that he had been possessed by a poetry demon.25. Second ...
  54. [54]
  55. [55]
    9 Things You Should Know About Muhammad - The Gospel Coalition
    May 31, 2022 · 2. He was likely influenced by Christians. Muslims believe Muhammad received his revelation directly from Allah through the angel Gabriel and ...
  56. [56]
    Two Simple Proofs that Muhammad Was a False Prophet
    The purpose of this essay is to prove, based on Muslim claims (including their appeal to Deuteronomy 18), that Muhammad was a false prophet.
  57. [57]
    DEUTERONOMY 18 - Who is the Prophet? - Jews for Judaism
    Aug 11, 2021 · Rabbi Michael Skobac asserts that many Jews for Jesus, Messianic Jews, and Jewish Christian missionaries claim that the prophet spoken of in Deuteronomy 18 ...
  58. [58]
  59. [59]
    Did Deuteronomy 18:18 Predict the Coming of Muhammad?
    Feb 27, 2022 · In summary, the context indicates that the prophet must be an Israelite, he would speak in the name of Yahweh, he would speak only what he was ...
  60. [60]
    Torah and Muhammad - Din - Ask the Rabbi - Dinonline
    Feb 15, 2011 · Muhammad is not seen as a prophet, but as a leader who founded a new religion. Although Judaism does not accept the Quran as prophecy, and does ...Missing: prophethood | Show results with:prophethood<|separator|>
  61. [61]
    "In the House of Ishmael" | Sefaria
    The Jews rejected Muhammad's claim to prophethood, and further argued that ... Maimonides alleges that Muhammad was a "false prophet and an insane man ...
  62. [62]
    [PDF] The Qur'anic Ḥanīfiyya and its Role as a Middle Nation
    His thesis states that ḥunafā' existed as a religious group of practicing ascetics in the peninsula before Muhammad's time, distinct from Christians or Jews.
  63. [63]
    Pre-Islamic Arabian Prophets | Religious Studies Center
    He was a hanif, a member of an important religious group in pre-Islamic Arabia characterized by ascetic monotheism and rejection of idolatry.
  64. [64]
    Muslims in Mecca | Prophet Muhammad Origins - History of Islam
    2: The emigration to Ethiopia took place in the fifth year of prophethood. 3: The boycott of the clan of Hashim began after the emigration to Ethiopia and ...
  65. [65]
    [PDF] Background article: Sources, The Prophet Muhammad Who was ...
    We call them the hanif, the upright, the seekers after the truth. Page 2 ... There was a cave on Mount Hira where he used to make a spiritual retreat ...
  66. [66]
    How the Quranic revelation began - IslamiCity
    Apr 2, 2007 · The first [kind] of revelation to which the Apostle of God was initiated was the true dream during sleep 1 , and he never saw a dream but it came like the dawn ...
  67. [67]
    Muhammad and the believers: at the origins of Islam - Academia.edu
    For a short while, Muhammad may have called his movement "Hanifism ... Muhammad was a prophet bearing divine revelation is harder to assess. As we ...
  68. [68]
    (PDF) Was Muhammad influenced by Jewish and Christian tradition?
    The Qur'an reflects narratives and themes paralleling Jewish and early Christian texts. Muhammad likely adopted and adapted oral traditions from various sources ...
  69. [69]
    The Qur'an's Engagement with Christian and Jewish Literature
    Feb 28, 2023 · The Qur'an engages with Christian and Jewish literature through intertextuality, confirming and continuing earlier revelations, and sometimes ...
  70. [70]
    Wahy and its types - Mohammaed Omer Rafique
    The first revelation that the Prophet Muhammad (s) received is in the first verses from Sura al-'alaq (96:1-3, according to others 1-5):. 'Read in the name of ...
  71. [71]
    Descent of the first revelation (Wahy) - Islam Guidance - sibtayn.com
    On 27th of Rajab, Gabriel (one of the four superior angels who was ordered by Allah (SWT) to convey revelation to prophets) descended to him.
  72. [72]
    Divine Revelation: An Islamic Perspective on Divine Guidance and ...
    a. The Prophet Muhammad: He is the paradigmatic recipient of wahy as mentioned in the Qur'an and nearly half of the cases in which the term wahy or ...
  73. [73]
    (PDF) Muhammad Hamidullah on the Islamic theology of revelation
    Jul 18, 2021 · ... first revelation had come to the prophet during his sleep, evidently to reduce the. Muhammad Hamidullah on the Islamic theology of revelation.
  74. [74]
    The Night of Power and the Islamic View of Revelation - IMB
    Jun 4, 2018 · The Arabic word wahy, or Islamic revelation, refers to Allah's message in the form of a book or part of a book that he delivered to ...
  75. [75]
    [PDF] Muhammad Hamidullah on the Islamic theology of revelation
    Jul 18, 2021 · Ishaq, the first revelation had come to the prophet during his sleep, evidently to reduce the ... theology of revelation, the Qur‟ānic ...
  76. [76]
    [PDF] Sirat Rasoul Allah by Ibn Ishaq - EMAANLIBRARY
    The translation which follows is the first known English version of Ibn Ishaq's biography, and is here published for the first time. The translator, Edward ...
  77. [77]
    The Secret Call: How Islam Began in Secrecy
    Feb 12, 2025 · How Islam began secretly amid persecution in Makkah. Learn about the struggles of Prophet ﷺ and Sahaba as they spread the message in ...
  78. [78]
    Muhammad and the Rise of Islam | Boundless World History
    Muhammad first received revelations in 609 CE in a cave on Mount Hira, near Mecca. Muslims regard the Quran as the most important miracle of Muhammad, the proof ...
  79. [79]
    (PDF) The persecution of the Muslims in Makkah: Its reasons and its ...
    Initially opposing Islam on a personal level, the Quraysh escalated to organized campaigns following the public proclamation of the Prophet's message, as they ...
  80. [80]
    Chapter 13: Who Were The First Persons to Embrace Islam?
    It is an admitted historical fact that from amongst women Khadijah was the first to embrace Islam and there is no contradictory report on this point.
  81. [81]
    Muhammad as a Religious Leader: Revelations, Preaching and ...
    During the first ten years after his revelation Muhammad was largely ignored by the people of Mecca. He preached about monotheism outside the Kaaba and ...
  82. [82]
    (PDF) Why Quraish disbelievers rejected the Quran - Academia.edu
    ... opposition of the Quraish to the message of the Prophet Muhammad in Mecca has had on Islam. 1.1 The Meaning of word 'Quran' Qur'an is derived from the word ...
  83. [83]
    [PDF] Theological progression in Muhammad's preachings in Mecca and ...
    Rather than conflicting with non-Muslims, he confronted moral and spiritual issues such as human sacrifice, unlimited polygamy, and murdering of female infants ...