Fact-checked by Grok 2 weeks ago

Pashtunization

Pashtunization refers to the deliberate policies and cultural processes pursued by Pashtun-led governments in Afghanistan to integrate non-Pashtun ethnic groups—such as Tajiks, Uzbeks, Turkmen, and Hazaras—into Pashtun linguistic, cultural, and demographic frameworks, often through forced or incentivized settlement of Pashtun populations in peripheral regions. This phenomenon, rooted in state-building efforts to centralize authority and secure frontiers, has manifested as land redistribution favoring Pashtuns, promotion of the Pashto language alongside Dari, and the extension of Pashtunwali (the Pashtun tribal code) as a de facto national ethos. The process originated in the late under (r. 1880–1901), who, with British support amid rivalries, initiated mass resettlement of into northern () to counter Russian influence and suppress local autonomy. Policies included confiscating fertile lands from indigenous and , exiling resistors (e.g., 12,000 Uzbek families southward after an 1888 ), and offering migrants tax exemptions, free transport, and land grants, swelling the Pashtun settler population from 3,500 families in 1885 to approximately 40,000 by 1888. These measures transformed ethnic demographics in areas like and , where Pashtuns shifted from marginal presence to political and economic dominance by the mid-20th century, fostering agricultural development but displacing locals and entrenching tribal hierarchies. Subsequent rulers, including and , perpetuated Pashtunization by codifying Pashtun-centric governance and expanding military recruitment from Pashtun tribes, while 20th-century reforms under Daud Khan emphasized in education and administration to forge a unified "Afghan" identity aligned with Pashtun norms. The Taliban's Pashtun-heavy leadership has revived these dynamics post-2021, prioritizing Pashtun appointees in governance and exacerbating exclusion of minorities, as evidenced by border tensions with and limited ethnic power-sharing. Defining characteristics include causal links to ethnic resentments—non-Pashtuns often frame it as internal —contributing to revolts, civil war factions, and persistent instability, as centralized Pashtun dominance clashed with regional tribal . Despite aims of national cohesion, empirical demographic shifts have intensified sub-national identities, underscoring Pashtunization's role in Afghanistan's fractured polity.

Definition and Framework

Core Definition and Etymology

Pashtunization refers to the cultural, linguistic, and demographic assimilation whereby non-Pashtun populations in regions of and northwestern adopt Pashtun ethnic identity, the language, and elements of , the unwritten Pashtun tribal code emphasizing hospitality, revenge, and honor. This process often involves intermarriage, voluntary cultural adoption, or coerced integration through migration and land settlement, leading to shifts in local power dynamics and ethnic composition. Historically, it has been driven by Pashtun tribal expansions and state policies favoring Pashtun settlers, as seen in Abdur Rahman Khan's initiatives from 1880 to 1901, which resettled tens of thousands of Pashtun families in northern to dilute non-Pashtun influence and secure central authority. The term "Pashtunization" functions analogously to other assimilation descriptors like "" or "," combining the "Pashtun" (also rendered Pakhtun or Pathan) with the "-ization" to denote transformation into Pashtun-like attributes. "Pashtun" derives from self-designations rooted in ancient Iranian linguistic forms, potentially linked to terms like Pakthas in Vedic literature (circa 1500–1200 BCE), reflecting the group's Indo-Iranian heritage in the and surrounding areas. The emerged in 20th-century scholarship to characterize deliberate demographic engineering, particularly under Abdur Rahman Khan's rule, where Pashtun nomads (Kuchis) were incentivized to occupy lands previously held by , , and , fostering long-term cultural dominance.

Relation to Pashtunwali and Cultural Codes

Pashtunization, as a process of cultural assimilation, centers on the adoption of Pashtunwali, the traditional unwritten code governing Pashtun social, ethical, and legal conduct, which functions as a core marker of ethnic identity and group cohesion. This code, predating Islam and emphasizing principles such as hospitality (melmastia), asylum (nanawatai), revenge (badal), and honor (nang and ghayrat), distinguishes Pashtuns from neighboring ethnic groups and requires assimilating individuals or communities to internalize these norms for social acceptance. Groups undergoing Pashtunization often integrate Pashtunwali to resolve disputes tribally, foster alliances through marriage and hospitality, and align with Pashtun tribal hierarchies, thereby transitioning from outsider status to recognized kinship within Pashtun society. The adoption of facilitates assimilation by providing a framework for and mutual obligations that supersede prior cultural affiliations, as seen in historical migrations where groups in Pashtun areas conformed to these codes to secure and . For instance, melmastia mandates unconditional to guests, enabling economic and social exchanges that embed newcomers into Pashtun networks, while badal enforces retaliatory justice, binding participants to collective defense mechanisms essential for survival in tribal environments. Non-Pashtun groups, upon prolonged exposure in Pashtun-dominated regions, have historically incorporated these elements, leading to a hybridized where Pashtunwali overrides original customs, as evidenced in ethnographic accounts of frontier integrations. Pashtunwali's role extends beyond mere behavioral adoption to ideological alignment, where adherence signals loyalty to Pashtun and resistance to external , reinforcing Pashtunization as a voluntary yet coercive cultural imperative in contested territories. This code's oral and adaptive nature allows flexibility for assimilants, but its stringent demands on honor and often marginalize those unable or unwilling to fully conform, perpetuating ethnic boundaries even as linguistic and marital ties form. Empirical observations from Pashtun tribal areas indicate that full Pashtunization correlates with internalization of , as partial adoption risks or reinterpretation as subservience rather than equality.

Historical Development

Origins in Pashtun Tribal Expansions

The earliest documented expansions of originated from their core settlements in the , with the first historical reference to (an early term for ) appearing in 982 AD, describing communities inhabiting this rugged region south of . These tribes, characterized by pastoral-nomadic lifestyles and structures, began radiating outward during the medieval period, driven by factors such as resource scarcity, intertribal conflicts, and opportunities for raiding or . Initial movements were incremental, involving small-scale migrations into adjacent valleys and plateaus in present-day southern and northwestern , where encountered and interacted with Indo-Iranian, Dardic, and Turkic groups. By the late 10th and early 11th centuries, Pashtun warriors gained prominence as recruits in Mahmud of Ghazni's campaigns against northern , numbering in the thousands and establishing footholds through military garrisons and land grants in conquered territories. This integration into Ghaznavid armies facilitated proto-Pashtun settlements east of the , where tribal contingents intermarried with local populations and imposed elements of —the honor-based tribal code emphasizing hospitality, revenge, and autonomy—on subjugated communities. Such interactions laid foundational patterns for , as non-Pashtun locals, facing demographic pressures from incoming clans, began adopting nomenclature and customs to secure alliances or avoid marginalization, marking the nascent stages of identity shift. A pivotal phase in these expansions unfolded in the 15th and 16th centuries, exemplified by the mass migration of the tribe (part of the confederacy) from via and into the Peshawar Valley, Swat, Bajaur, and Buner regions. Under leaders like Malak Ahmad Khan, tens of thousands of Yusufzai fighters and families displaced earlier inhabitants, including Dilazak Pashtuns, Indo-Aryan , and residual Hindu principalities, through sustained warfare culminating in the late 1500s. These conquests involved strategic alliances with forces against rivals, followed by systematic land redistribution via tribal jirgas (councils), which entrenched Pashtun dominance and compelled local elites to affiliate with Pashtun lineages for protection and status. These tribal incursions initiated Pashtunization by altering regional demographics—shifting Pashtun populations from minorities to majorities in fertile valleys—and fostering via marital ties, , and the of as a in and trade. Non-Pashtun groups, often outnumbered and militarily subdued, underwent gradual , claiming Pashtun ancestry to access tribal resources and evade outsider status, a dynamic rooted in the causal mechanics of conquest-driven rather than centralized . from genealogical records and linguistic shifts in these areas underscores how such expansions, unencumbered by modern state structures, organically propagated Pashtun cultural templates across diverse substrates.

Pre-Modern Assimilation Processes

Pre-modern assimilation processes unfolded through tribal expansions in which dominant Pashtun groups incorporated weaker neighbors into their kinship-based systems or displaced them entirely, a dynamic prevalent in the eastern Afghan highlands and extending into what is now northwestern . Pashtun pastoral nomads, leveraging mobility and martial prowess, settled in valleys occupied by Dardic-speaking or other Iranic populations, enforcing via adherence to —the honor code prioritizing hospitality, asylum, and vengeance. Incorporated individuals or clans typically adopted as their primary language and Pashtun tribal genealogies to legitimize status within the , often over multiple generations. By the , Pashtun communities had established presence in the valley, inhabiting areas depopulated by Mongol invasions alongside residual Tajik settlements, where initial coexistence gradually shifted toward Pashtun cultural influence through intermarriage and social alliances. Non-Pashtun locals, seeking protection or economic ties in Pashtun-dominated locales, voluntarily embraced elements of to navigate tribal politics, facilitating linguistic shifts as native dialects eroded in mixed households. These mechanisms intensified with the Durrani Empire's formation in 1747 under , as Pashtun rulers from integrated diverse groups across a vast domain from to , promoting Pashtun norms in administration and military service. Assimilation remained decentralized and kinship-driven, contrasting later state policies, with non-Pashtuns in peripheral zones adopting Pashtun identity for mobility along trade routes spanning the and Indian frontiers over a . This era's processes underscore causal links between demographic pressure, territorial conquest, and cultural adaptation, yielding hybrid identities without uniform ethnic purity.

Mechanisms of Assimilation

Demographic Shifts and Settlement

Demographic shifts in Pashtunization primarily occur through organized migrations and state-sponsored settlements of into regions historically dominated by non-Pashtun ethnic groups, such as , , and . These movements alter local population balances, often facilitated by land redistribution and military garrisons, enabling Pashtun cultural dominance over generations. In , this process intensified under Emir Abdur Rahman Khan from 1880 to 1901, who systematically relocated to northern provinces to consolidate central authority and counter external threats, with support aimed at buffering influence. These settlements involved granting fertile lands previously held by local non-Pashtuns, leading to displacement and gradual ethnic reconfiguration in areas like and . Subsequent Pashtun-led governments perpetuated this policy, resulting in steady increases in Pashtun populations in the north by the late . Contemporary dynamics under Taliban rule since 2021 have accelerated these shifts through the relocation of Pashtun families to northern regions, often tied to operations and ideological alignment, exacerbating tensions with communities via seizures and demographic . In Pakistan's northern areas, Pashtun migrations over the past 150 years, driven by economic opportunities and conflict, have similarly transformed ethnic compositions in formerly non-Pashtun mountainous zones. Such settlements not only elevate Pashtun numerical presence but also leverage higher fertility rates and tribal networks to sustain influence, fostering conditions for linguistic and cultural assimilation among minorities.

Linguistic and Cultural Adoption

Linguistic assimilation in Pashtunization entails the gradual supplanting of non-Pashtun languages by Pashto among subordinate or intermixed communities, often driven by demographic dominance and institutional incentives. In Pashtun-settled regions of Afghanistan, such as parts of the north following 19th-century migrations under rulers like Abdur Rahman Khan (r. 1880–1901), local groups including Tajiks and Uzbeks have experienced language shift, with Pashto emerging as the vernacular for daily interactions, trade, and local governance. This process accelerated in the 20th century through state policies promoting Pashto in administration and education; for instance, under Prime Minister Mohammed Daoud Khan (1973–1978), efforts to standardize Pashto as an official language encouraged its adoption in schools and bureaucracy, leading to bilingualism or monolingual Pashto use among urban non-Pashtuns in mixed areas. Empirical data from linguistic surveys indicate that small indigenous groups, such as speakers of Ormuri and Parachi in southeastern Afghanistan, have largely abandoned their Iranic languages for Pashto over the past two centuries due to intermarriage and economic integration into Pashtun tribal economies. Cultural adoption complements linguistic change by incorporating elements of —the unwritten Pashtun ethical code emphasizing hospitality (melmastia), revenge (badal), and asylum (nanawatai)—which non-Pashtuns embrace for social cohesion and protection within Pashtun-majority locales. Historical records from the (1747–1823) document non-Pashtun elites in conquered territories, such as former administrators in , adopting Pashtun tribal affiliations, attire (e.g., and caps), and poetic traditions like landay verses to signal and facilitate alliances. In Pakistan's former , Baloch and Hindkowan settlers have historically integrated by claiming fictitious Pashtun genealogies and observing Pashtunwali dispute resolution, enabling land access and dispute mediation under councils. This voluntary or pragmatic uptake is evidenced in ethnographic accounts, where cultural markers like Pashtun naming conventions (e.g., appending tribal suffixes) and honor-based kinship norms replace prior customs, though resistance persists in enclaves with strong pre-existing identities. Such integrations often reflect causal pressures from Pashtun numerical superiority and resource control rather than ideological conversion, with source analyses noting state-backed settlements as accelerators.

Social and Marital Integration

Social integration in the context of Pashtunization primarily occurs through the adoption of Pashtunwali, the customary code emphasizing values such as hospitality (melmastia), asylum (nanawatai), and tribal solidarity, which non-Pashtuns in Pashtun-dominated regions must embrace to gain acceptance and protection. Outsiders seeking refuge via nanawatai—a provision allowing enemies or strangers temporary sanctuary—can transition to full tribal affiliation by demonstrating adherence to these norms, effectively absorbing them into Pashtun social networks and decision-making bodies like the jirga (tribal council). This process is evident in areas of historical Pashtun expansion, where subordinate groups, such as Dardic speakers, integrate by participating in communal dispute resolution and economic exchanges governed by Pashtun customs, leading to gradual identity shifts. Marital practices reinforce this integration, though interethnic marriages remain infrequent due to entrenched and taboos against crossing ethnic lines, with consanguineous unions—predominantly intra-ethnic—accounting for 46.2% of across as of surveys from the early . Strategic alliances through marriage, particularly between Pashtun elites and non-Pashtun families, have historically consolidated , as seen in tribal expansions where Pashtun men married local women, ensuring patrilineal transmitted Pashtun tribal and cultural practices to subsequent generations. Such unions, while rare (comprising a minority amid high endogamy rates), contribute to by raising children within Pashtun households, where linguistic and normative occurs organically; for instance, mixed offspring often identify as Pashtun, blurring ethnic boundaries over time. In regions like eastern , where Pashtun settlement has intensified, social and marital ties facilitate one-directional cultural flow, with non-Pashtuns adopting Pashtun attire, naming conventions, and to access resources and avoid marginalization, though full reciprocity in intermarriage remains limited by Pashtun preferences for intra-tribal matches. This dynamic underscores Pashtunization's reliance on social dominance rather than symmetric exchange, as evidenced by persistent ethnic distinctions despite occasional blurring through alliances.

Key Regional Examples

Pashtunization of the Khalaj Turks

The Khalaj, a Turkic nomadic originating from , migrated southward into eastern during the 9th and 10th centuries CE, settling primarily in regions such as and . Initially known for sheep herding and seasonal migrations, they maintained a distinct Turkic and tribal structure amid a diverse population that included Pashtun groups. By the 11th to 13th centuries, demographic pressures from Pashtun tribal expansions and inter-tribal interactions led to gradual , with many Khalaj adopting as their primary language and integrating into Pashtun social frameworks. This process, termed Pashtunization, involved linguistic replacement of their Oghuz-derived Turkic dialect, adherence to codes, and tribal realignment, particularly under Ghaznavid and Ghurid rule when Pashtun confederations gained dominance. Historical accounts indicate that Khalaj nomads in intermarried with local , facilitating cultural absorption and the erosion of Turkic identity markers. Scholars posit that this assimilation contributed to the formation of the Pashtun tribal confederation, with the Khalaj likely providing a foundational nucleus through partial descent and cultural fusion. By the Mongol invasions of the early , surviving Khalaj groups had largely Pashtunized, as evidenced by their participation in Pashtun-led military formations and the absence of distinct Turkic Khalaj references in later regional chronicles. While some Khalaj remnants retained nomadic Turkic elements in isolated areas, the majority's integration underscores Pashtun demographic resilience in absorbing smaller Turkic inflows without reciprocal Turkicization.

Rohilkhand and Indian Subcontinent Cases

In the 18th century, Pashtun migrants known as Rohillas established dominance in the Rohilkhand region of northern India, renaming the former Katehar tract after their community and creating a semi-independent kingdom that exemplified Pashtun settlement patterns in the subcontinent. These settlers, primarily from tribes such as the Yusufzai, Khattak, and Afridi, arrived in waves starting in the late 17th century, initially as Mughal auxiliaries and mercenaries, with Daud Khan founding key settlements around 1705 after receiving jagirs from Emperor Aurangzeb. By 1721, under Ali Muhammad Khan, a Rohilla chieftain of Barech descent, the group consolidated power, establishing Bareilly as the capital and expanding control over approximately 12,000 square miles through military conquests against local Jat and Rajput zamindars. The kingdom, peaking under Hafiz Rahmat Khan from 1749 to 1774, featured Pashtun tribal governance structures overlaid on a diverse local of and non-Pashtun Muslims, fostering limited Pashtunization through elite integration and administrative influence. Rohilla rulers granted lands to Pashtun kin and allies, drawing in an estimated several thousand migrants, but comprised only a minority amid the region's agrarian base, leading to intermarriages and incorporation of local revenue farmers into Rohilla ranks, diluting pure Pashtun demographics while spreading tribal loyalties among Muslim elites. Pashtun cultural elements, including martial codes akin to and emphasis on Afghan genealogy, permeated the ruling class, with some local converts or allies adopting Rohilla identities to access power, as evidenced by the dynasty's self-presentation as Afghan-derived despite mixed origins in certain lineages. The process faced reversal after the 1774 Rohilla War, when an alliance of Awadh's Shuja-ud-Daula and British forces defeated Hafiz Rahmat Khan, killing him and annexing much of the territory, though Rampur survived as a princely state under Faizullah Khan until 1949. Post-conquest, surviving Pathan communities—numbering around 966,000 in Uttar Pradesh by early 21st-century estimates—retained Pashtun tribal affiliations but underwent linguistic assimilation to Urdu, abandoning Pashto due to immersion in Hindustani-speaking environs, with cultural Pashtunization confined largely to genealogy, cuisine, and occasional honor codes among descendants rather than widespread local adoption. Beyond Rohilkhand, smaller Pashtun enclaves in subcontinental areas like Malihabad (settled by Afridi and Shinwari tribes under Nawab Shuja-ud-Daula in the 1760s) showed similar patterns of elite settlement without broad demographic or linguistic shifts, highlighting Pashtunization's constraints in densely populated, non-tribal Indian contexts.

Khyber Pakhtunkhwa in Pakistan

Khyber Pakhtunkhwa, formerly known as the , exhibits Pashtunization through the gradual cultural, linguistic, and demographic dominance of groups over indigenous non- populations, particularly Hindko-speaking concentrated in urban centers like and the Hazara region. Pashtun migrations into the area intensified after 1000 AD, displacing earlier Dardic tribes and establishing tribal structures that favored Pashtun social norms such as the system and code. By the early , comprised the provincial majority, with non-Pashtuns—often landless artisans and peasants—forming about one-third of the population, creating economic dependencies that facilitated . In , pre-Partition demographics reflected a Hindko-speaking urban majority, with Pashto predominant in rural surroundings; however, post-1947 rural-to-urban Pashtun migration reversed this, confining original Peshawari Hindko communities to the historic walled city while became the demographic core. The influx of Afghan Pashtun refugees following the 1979 Soviet invasion further accelerated this shift, swelling urban Pashtun numbers and embedding in , , and media. Social integration via intermarriage and adoption of Pashtun tribal affiliations has also contributed, though maintain distinct Indo-Aryan linguistic roots tied to pre-Pashtun substrates. Linguistic evidence underscores ongoing Pashtunization: studies document a shift among younger speakers (aged 16-24) toward in , driven by its status as the provincial for , despite Hindko's persistence in Hazara households. Political developments, including the 2010 renaming to to emphasize Pashtun , provoked resistance from Hindko advocates in Hazara, who viewed it as marginalizing their cultural distinctiveness amid broader Pashtun nationalist policies. This process has yielded a cohesive Pashtun-majority identity in the province, though minority groups report cultural erosion without formal reversal mechanisms.

Afghanistan and Northern Settlements

Pashtun settlements in northern began systematically under Emir Abdur Rahman Khan (r. 1880–1901), who relocated Pashtun tribes from southern and eastern regions to non-Pashtun-dominated areas such as Qataghan-Badakhshan to consolidate central authority and secure the Afghan-Russian frontier against potential incursions. These migrations involved granting land to Pashtun settlers, often at the expense of local Tajik, Uzbek, and populations, fostering gradual adoption of Pashtun customs, language, and tribal governance structures among assimilated groups. Successive rulers expanded these efforts; Amanullah Khan (r. 1919–1929) formalized Pashtun colonization through the 1922 "Settlers to Qataghan Act," a decree legitimizing land distribution in fertile northern territories to southern Pashtun migrants and Waziristani groups, enabling permanent settlements that shifted demographics in provinces like Kunduz and Takhar. Nadir Shah (r. 1929–1933) further promoted Pashtun influx into Kunduz as part of ethnic consolidation policies, resulting in Pashtuns comprising a growing minority—estimated at 20–30% in some northern districts by mid-20th century—amid originally Persian- and Turkic-speaking majorities. In contemporary dynamics, the regime since August 2021 has intensified settlements, evicting hundreds of Shia Hazara families from and reallocating their lands to Pashtun groups, while supporting the relocation of approximately 700 Kuchi (Pashtun nomad) families from Pakistan's North to Takhar's Khwaja Bahauddin and Dasht districts along the Kokcha . These actions, including a reported plan to resettle up to 72,000 Tehrik-i-Taliban Pakistan members and families in northern provinces like Takhar, Jawzjan, and Faryab, have sparked local resistance from Uzbek and Tajik communities, with enforcers imposing 10-day eviction deadlines and providing security for newcomers. The project, spanning 285 km across , Jawzjan, and Faryab since 2022, facilitates irrigation for expanded Pashtun farming settlements from the south, accelerating cultural Pashtunization through land control and nomadic sedentarization. Such policies have led to inter-ethnic tensions and clashes, as in Takhar where settled Kuchis impose Pashtunwali dispute resolution, but also contributed to administrative unification by embedding Pashtun networks in previously fragmented northern governance. Reports from local observers indicate forced land handovers exacerbate language barriers and property disputes, with non-Pashtun residents viewing the influx as a deliberate strategy to alter ethnic balances in favor of Taliban-aligned Pashtuns.

Modern and Contemporary Dynamics

Post-Colonial Policies and Nationalism

In , post-1919 independence policies under successive monarchs and republican leaders emphasized Pashtun cultural elements as foundational to , promoting alongside as an from 1936 onward to foster unity amid ethnic diversity. This linguistic policy, intensified during Mohammed Daoud Khan's premiership (1953–1963) and presidency (1973–1978), mandated instruction in schools and bureaucracy, particularly in non-Pashtun regions like the north, where it encouraged adoption among Tajik, Uzbek, and communities through state incentives and demographic pressures from Pashtun settlements. Such measures aligned with Pashtun irredentist nationalism, including advocacy for "," but internally accelerated by associating codes and language with Afghan statehood, often marginalizing Persian-influenced traditions deemed external. In Pakistan, following in , central government policies initially prioritized for national cohesion, suppressing regional separatist sentiments like the movement led by figures such as , yet provincial administrations in the (later ) countered this by establishing institutions like the Pashto Academy at the in 1953 to standardize and propagate literature, education, and media. These efforts, supported by Pashtun-dominated political parties, reinforced ethnic in mixed areas, where non-Pashtun groups such as speakers and smaller tribal communities increasingly adopted and Pashtun customs via intermarriage, land settlement, and economic integration, transforming linguistic minorities into Pashto-dominant populations by the late . thus adapted to Pakistani , channeling demands for into cultural preservation policies that facilitated without formal . Nation-building in both countries intertwined Pashtunization with anti-colonial , portraying Pashtun and tribal structures as bulwarks against foreign , though this often overlooked from assimilated minorities who viewed it as ethnic dominance rather than inclusive . In , Daoud's regime explicitly linked Pashto promotion to modernization, allocating resources for its standardization while sidelining in official domains, a strategy critiqued by non-Pashtun elites for eroding . Similarly, in , post-1971 provincial reforms devolved language powers, enabling Pashto's expansion in curricula and broadcasting by the , which bolstered Pashtun identity amid Islamist currents but deepened divides with Urdu-centric elites. These policies yielded measurable outcomes, such as rising Pashto proficiency in urban non-Pashtun enclaves, yet fueled ethnic tensions by prioritizing one group's traditions in state narratives.

Taliban Era and Recent Policies (Post-2001)

The , a predominantly Pashtun Islamist movement originating in southern Afghanistan's Pashtun heartlands, seized control of in September 1996, establishing the Islamic Emirate and implementing policies that favored Pashtun cultural and administrative dominance during their initial rule until 2001. Their governance emphasized , the traditional Pashtun ethical code, as a foundational element of Afghan identity, often extending it beyond ethnic boundaries while sidelining non-Pashtun groups like , , and through marginalization in appointments and enforcement of uniform Islamic practices interpreted through a Pashtun lens. Following the U.S.-led intervention in October 2001 that ousted the , the subsequent (2004–2021) adopted a promoting multi-ethnic representation, with official languages and , and power-sharing mechanisms to counter historical Pashtun dominance; however, Pashtun figures retained significant influence in and rural southern governance, while insurgents, drawing core support from Pashtun communities, framed their resistance as defense against non-Pashtun or foreign-imposed centralization. By the Taliban's resurgence and recapture of on August 15, 2021, their leadership structure remained heavily Pashtun-skewed, with estimates indicating over 80% of key positions held by Pashtuns, including supreme leader and most cabinet members from Pashtun tribes like the and Ghilzai. Post-2021 Taliban policies have reinforced Pashtun-centric elements, such as mandating in official communications and decrees from the outset of their administration, which has disadvantaged non-Pashto speakers in bureaucratic access and signaling a elevation of Pashtun linguistic norms despite claims of ethnic neutrality. This approach, coupled with limited of non-Pashtuns in high-level roles—often appointments under external —has exacerbated ethnic tensions, with reports of disproportionate Pashtun recruitment into apparatus and favoritism in resource allocation to Pashtun-majority provinces like and Helmand. Critics, including Afghan minority advocates, argue this constitutes informal Pashtunization by prioritizing tribal loyalties over merit or inclusivity, potentially fueling resistance in northern non-Pashtun areas, though spokespersons maintain their rule transcends in pursuit of unified Islamic . In parallel, Pakistan's post-2001 policies in Pashtun regions, particularly , have involved state-sponsored settlement and infrastructure projects that bolster Pashtun demographic consolidation, such as the 2010s FATA merger integrating tribal areas with incentives for -medium education and cultural preservation, aligning with military strategies to stabilize against militancy but criticized for diluting local non-Pashtun influences. These measures, enacted under successive governments, have accelerated linguistic standardization in , with provincial curricula emphasizing Pashtun history and by 2020, though official frames them as development rather than ethnic engineering.

Impacts and Evaluations

Achievements in Regional Stability and Unity

Ahmad Shah Durrani's establishment of the in 1747 unified disparate Pashtun tribes and incorporated diverse ethnic groups including , , and , imposing order on regions previously marked by rebellion and lawlessness, which fostered initial regional cohesion across modern Afghanistan's territory. This Pashtun-led consolidation extended Afghan influence into parts of present-day , and , creating a multi-ethnic sustained until 1823 through tribal alliances and military campaigns that prioritized stability over fragmentation. Subsequent rulers like Abdur Rahman Khan from 1880 to 1901 advanced centralization by suppressing internal revolts and resettling Pashtun populations in northern non-Pashtun areas, thereby extending Kabul's administrative control and mitigating ethnic divisions that had fueled prior civil strife. This policy of Pashtun settlement and governance reinforced a unified state structure, enabling the monarchy's endurance until 1973 and marking the longest era of relative domestic tranquility in Afghan history, during which infrastructure and border defenses were fortified against external threats. The Pashtunwali code, emphasizing honor, hospitality, and dispute resolution via jirgas, further underpinned social order by providing customary mechanisms for conflict mediation in tribal settings, sustaining communal stability amid weak formal institutions. In Pakistan's , -majority demographics and cultural integration have bolstered national cohesion, with comprising key military leadership—such as General Waheed Kakar as Army Chief in 1993-1996—and contributing to counter-terrorism operations like Zarb-e-Azb (2014) and Radd-ul-Fasaad (2017 onward), which reduced militancy along the Afghan border and enhanced provincial security. State-driven development, including the Gomal Zam Dam completed in 2013 irrigating 190,000 acres and generating 17.4 MW of power, has integrated areas economically, countering instability from cross-border dynamics and promoting unity within Pakistan's federation.

Criticisms from Minority Perspectives

Ethnic minorities in Afghanistan, particularly , , and , have voiced strong objections to Pashtunization as a process entailing political marginalization, cultural suppression, and territorial encroachments that perpetuate Pashtun . , constituting approximately 20-25% of 's population and predominantly Shia Muslims, report historical subjugation under Pashtun rulers, including genocidal campaigns launched by Emir Abdur Rahman Khan between 1891 and 1893, which resulted in the deaths or enslavement of up to 60% of the male Hazara population and forced conversions or migrations. Pashtun nomads, known as Kuchis, progressively seized control of pasturelands in the region during the late 19th and 20th centuries, exacerbating land disputes and economic displacement that Hazaras attribute to deliberate Pashtun expansionism. Under rule since August 2021, which is overwhelmingly Pashtun-dominated, Hazaras face intensified discrimination, including targeted bombings—such as the November 2021 Daikundi mosque attack killing over 50—and exclusion from , reinforcing perceptions of as a structurally hostile Pashtun-centric . Tajiks, estimated at 25-30% of the population and concentrated in the north and east, criticize Pashtunization for fostering that undermines and equitable power-sharing, with leaders advocating decentralized governance to counter Kabul's historical Pashtun bias. Post-2021 Taliban policies have strained identity through linguistic impositions favoring over and marginalization in appointments, prompting cross-border concerns from about cultural erosion. representatives argue that Pashtun dominance, evident in the 's cabinet lacking substantive non-Pashtun roles despite promises, perpetuates cycles of resentment stemming from events like the 1992-1996 , where Pashtun forces were accused of in non-Pashtun areas. Uzbeks, comprising about 9% of and residing mainly in the north, express frustration over exclusion from meaningful political influence under Pashtun-led regimes, including the era, where they hold only symbolic positions amid broader disenfranchisement. In regions like Maidan Wardak and northern provinces, Uzbeks report forced evictions favoring Pashtun Kuchis and economic collapse exacerbating discrimination, leading some communities to arm against forces by early 2022. These grievances echo broader minority fears of Pashtun destabilizing multi-ethnic cohesion, as articulated in analyses of state policies since the that prioritize Pashtun representation in security and administration. In Pakistan's , non-Pashtun groups such as (Punjabi- and Hindko-speakers) have raised concerns over Pashtun cultural dominance in provincial institutions, including language policies favoring in and since the province's renaming in 2010, which some view as eroding linguistic diversity in multi-ethnic districts like and . However, these criticisms are less pronounced than in , often intertwined with broader grievances against central influence rather than Pashtunization per se.

Demographic and Cultural Outcomes

In Afghanistan's northern provinces, state-sponsored resettlement policies from the late onward significantly altered ethnic demographics, elevating Pashtun proportions from an estimated 2-4% under Emir Abdur Rahman in 1880 to higher shares by the mid-20th century through land redistribution favoring southern Pashtun migrants. This process intensified during the and under Daoud and subsequent communist regimes, which allocated northern agricultural lands—previously held by , , and others—to Pashtun settlers, resulting in localized Pashtun majorities in areas like parts of and Takhar by the 1990s. Such shifts contributed to non-Pashtun displacement and perceptions of engineered , exacerbating ethnic tensions amid civil conflicts. In Pakistan's , reinforced an already dominant ethnic presence, with forming over 73% of the population by 1998, as reflected in Pashto's prevalence as the primary language and the consolidation of Pashtun tribal structures across former integrated into the province post-2018. This homogeneity stemmed from historical migrations and administrative policies prioritizing Pashtun identity, reducing non-Pashtun (e.g., Hindkowan) cultural enclaves through intermarriage and urban expansion in cities like . Culturally, Pashtunization prompted linguistic assimilation, with non-Pashtun groups in mixed regions adopting as a and elements of —the Pashtun honor code emphasizing hospitality, revenge, and tribal loyalty—supplanting local customs. Among the Khalaj Turks, migration into Pashtun heartlands from the medieval period led to gradual abandonment of Turkic dialects in favor of , alongside integration into Pashtun clans, effectively erasing distinct Turkic nomadic traditions by the . In India's region, 18th-century Pashtun settlements yielded a syncretic outcome, where descendants retained tribal genealogies but shifted to and Hindu-influenced practices, diminishing pure Pashtun and usage to under 10% by modern estimates. For persistent minorities like and northern , cultural outcomes included resistance to imposed Pashtun norms, such as Pashto primacy in and since the 1930s, preserving and local Shia rituals despite periodic suppression, though at the cost of socioeconomic marginalization. These dynamics fostered identities in centers but entrenched rural cultural silos, with empirical surveys post-2001 indicating sustained non-Pashtun linguistic vitality amid ongoing Pashtun demographic pressures.

References

  1. [1]
    State-building, migration and economic development on the frontiers ...
    The British were to become allies and sponsors of Abdur Rahman's Pashtunization of northern Afghanistan. The 'Yate plan' was for the Pashtuns to dominate the ...
  2. [2]
    The Dilemma of Power and Ethnicity in Afghanistan
    The Pashtunization of Afghanistan through history by Kings and later on by hybrid-democratic regimes also continued in the country. The second goal of Tarzi ...
  3. [3]
    Conflict and peace in Afghanistan: A northern, non-Pashtun ...
    Jun 27, 2018 · Abdur Rahman's mistrust of northern, non-Pashtun communities drove his policy of Pashtun-centred Afghanisation. Communities of Pashtuns were ...
  4. [4]
    "TALIBAN" POLICY OF PASHTUNIZATION AND ITS IMPACT ON ...
    May 15, 2023 · This article analyzes the specific characteristics of relations between different ethnic groups in Afghanistan, which is considered a ...
  5. [5]
    The Demographic Dynamics of Conflict and Violence - IntechOpen
    An important demographic feature of Afghanistan has been its large Pashtun nomad population or Kuchis , estimated at around 1.5 million, that presents a ...
  6. [6]
    [PDF] Pashtunism and Its Role in Afghanistan-Iran Relations
    Nov 11, 2014 · The policy of Pashtunization of Afghanistan not only caused conflicts and backwardness within the geographical ... Pashtu Tulneh published a ...Missing: definition | Show results with:definition
  7. [7]
    Pashtunwali - The Way of the Pashtuns - NatStrat
    May 30, 2023 · The Pashtuns have a unique and defining tribal code called Pashtunwali or the 'way of the Pashtun' that distinguishes them from other ethnic groups.
  8. [8]
    [PDF] An Economic Interpretation of the Pashtunwali - Chicago Unbound
    Pashtunwali is the tribal code of the Pashtuns, a distinctive, harsh, and persistent system that is the primary normative rule in the region.
  9. [9]
    Understanding Pashtunwali and the Manifestation of Pashtun ...
    This study on Pashtun nationalism finds that Pashtunwali is a centuries-old primordial customary code of life of the Pashtuns and it is important in the context ...
  10. [10]
    [PDF] The Role of Pashtunwali Ethnic Tradition in the Historical ...
    Mar 13, 2023 · The results indicate that the intellectual tradition of the Taliban is influenced by the powerful Pashtun culture of the governorate, which ...
  11. [11]
    Understanding Pashtunwali - The Geopolitics
    May 17, 2023 · Under this aspect of Pashtunwali, Pashtuns, particularly first cousins, are asked to get united against external threats. As it was observed in ...
  12. [12]
    [PDF] Pashtuns and the Pashtunwali, Version 2 - Afghanistan - Ecoi.net
    Apr 10, 2024 · Pashtunwali is a code of conduct for Pashtuns, the largest Afghan population, that predates Islam and influences their individual freedoms.
  13. [13]
    (PDF) Understanding Pashtunwali and the Manifestation of Pashtun ...
    Aug 8, 2025 · This study on Pashtun nationalism finds that Pashtunwali is a centuries-old primordial customary code of life and it is important in the context of nationalism.
  14. [14]
    The Rules of Pashtunwali - The Yale Globalist
    Dec 22, 2011 · Pashtunwali are informal, oral tribal values defining social conduct, conflict resolution, and community consensus, emphasizing local decision- ...
  15. [15]
    The Role of Pashtunwali Ethnic Tradition in the Historical ...
    As stated, the Pashtunwali consists of principles shaping the Pashtunwali tradition, including the principles of female honor, courage, respect or pride, ...<|separator|>
  16. [16]
    Pashtun - Summary - eHRAF World Cultures
    The Pashtun inhabit southern and eastern Afghanistan and western Pakistan. Their language is Pushto (Pashto) and, except for a small minority, they are Sunni ...Missing: definition | Show results with:definition
  17. [17]
    AN ANALYSIS OF THE RELATIONS OF BABUR WITH YUSUFZAI ...
    Nov 25, 2023 · After their fall in Kabul, they migrated to Laghman, Peshawar valley, Bajaur and Swat (Panjkora valley) in the leadership of Malak Ahmad Khan in ...
  18. [18]
    YUSUFZAIS IN MUGHAL HISTORY - jstor
    In the present paper an attempt has been made to bring together such scattered information about the Yusufzai tribe of the Afghans. The Yusufzais are the most ...
  19. [19]
    [PDF] The Pashtun constitute the largest tribally organized group in the ...
    Feb 23, 2007 · The Taliban expansion into Pashtun areas was largely peaceful, with tribal leaders and local mujahideen commanders defecting to their cause ...
  20. [20]
  21. [21]
  22. [22]
    Is a Demographic Shift underway in Northern Afghanistan?
    Aug 31, 2023 · The British Empire supported the Pashtun colonization of northern Afghanistan due to Britain's desire to reduce Russian influence in Afghanistan ...
  23. [23]
    The Return of Internally Displaced Persons to Northern Afghanistan
    Jun 1, 2009 · Over a hundred years ago, Pashtuns began arriving in the north as part of a calculated state consolidation strategy by Abdur Rahman Khan, known ...Missing: demographic changes<|control11|><|separator|>
  24. [24]
    Afghanistan's future after the Taliban takeover: Civil war or ...
    Mar 1, 2022 · ... Pashtun population in the north and center steadily increased. Not only did the population of Pashtuns increase in the northern areas, but ...Missing: demographic | Show results with:demographic
  25. [25]
    Changing the demographic context of some Afghan regions
    Dec 21, 2022 · The demographic context in the major cities of Afghanistan has changed significantly due to the migration of villagers and the return of immigrants from abroad.Missing: population | Show results with:population
  26. [26]
    Afghanistan on the Brink of Fundamental Change - WANA News
    Aug 17, 2025 · This process extends beyond demographic change and carries both security and ideological dimensions. The relocated families often have close ...
  27. [27]
    [PDF] Pashtun Migrants in the Northern Areas of Pakistan
    Weinreich first sketches the gradually increasing movements of Pashtuns into the largely mountainous north of Pakistan over the last 150 years, which generally ...Missing: assimilation | Show results with:assimilation
  28. [28]
    [PDF] Ethnicity, Space, and Politics in Afghanistan Benjamin Dubow URBS ...
    He pursued Pushtunization far beyond any of his predecessors. 23. He was the first Afghan to ruler to use Pashto as the language of administration. Before ...
  29. [29]
    AFGHANISTAN vi. Paṣ̌tō - Encyclopaedia Iranica
    Paṣ̌tō is an Iranic language spoken in south and southeastern Afghanistan, by recent settlers in northern Afghanistan, in Pakistan (North-West Frontier Province ...
  30. [30]
    [PDF] Ethnicization Of Politics In Afghanistan - MavMatrix
    Its evidence is that non-Pashtun ethnic groups are more powerful today than they were 20 years before. Both during Afghan resistance against the. Soviet Union's ...
  31. [31]
    Afghanistan - Linguistics Global Associates
    Oct 25, 2022 · Some non-Pashtuns who live in proximity with Pashtuns have adopted Pashtunwali in a process called Pashtunization, while some Pashtuns have been ...
  32. [32]
    [PDF] Nation Building Process in Afghanistan
    The Pashtunization claims rejected since,. Amir's actual policy toward the ... Abdur Rahman Khan: Encyclopedia Britannica, 11th ed, Cambridge. University ...
  33. [33]
    [PDF] Institutional and Structural Changes in Pakhtoon Family and ...
    The proposed deliberation attempts to investigate into the socio-cultural changes in the institutions of Family and marriage.
  34. [34]
    Consanguineous marriages in Afghanistan - PubMed
    The proportion of consanguineous marriages in the country was 46.2%, ranging from 38.2% in Kabul province to 51.2% in Bamyan province.
  35. [35]
    Are interethnic marriages still a taboo for Afghans?
    There are no reliable figures of just how many Afghans today marry outside of their ethnic group, and the practice remains a taboo for many families. Said Noor ...<|control11|><|separator|>
  36. [36]
    Afghanistan - Minority Rights Group
    Previous estimates have put the population at Pashtun 42 per cent, Tajik 27 per cent, Hazara 9 per cent, Uzbek 9 per cent, Turkmen 3 per cent, Baluchi 2 per ...
  37. [37]
    ḴALAJ i. TRIBE - Encyclopaedia Iranica
    May 1, 2015 · Many of the Khalaj of the Ḡazna region became assimilated to the local Pashto-speaking population. Indeed, it seems very likely that they formed ...
  38. [38]
    The Pre-Mongol History of the Khalaj in Eastern Afghanistan
    Apr 14, 2025 · The Khalaj people speak a Turkic language, and first appear in documents around the 9 th and 10 th century.Missing: Pashtunization | Show results with:Pashtunization
  39. [39]
    Ghilzay | Afghan Tribes, Pashtun Culture, & History - Britannica
    Sep 18, 2025 · They are reputed to be descended at least in part from the Khalaj or Khaljī Turks, who entered Afghanistan in the 10th century.
  40. [40]
    Rohillas and Rohilkhand - IASPOINT
    Dec 23, 2024 · The Rohillas primarily consisted of Pashtuns from various tribes, including the Yousafzai, Khattak, and Afridi. They assimilated with local ...
  41. [41]
  42. [42]
    [PDF] 1995 Rise of the Indo-Afghan Empire c 1710-1780 by Gommans s.pdf
    These people were not only Rohillas but also local revenue farmers or others ... comprised indeed the bulk of the Afghan population of Rohilkhand. The ...
  43. [43]
  44. [44]
    Muslim Communities in Uttar Pradesh - newpakhistorian
    Aug 6, 2022 · Muslim Communities in Uttar Pradesh ; 1. Shaikh, 1,340,057 ; 2. Pathan, 966,502 ; 3. Julaha (Ansari), 898,032 ; 4. Rajput, 404,781 ...
  45. [45]
    Pashtuns in Pakistan - Minority Rights Group
    Pashtun culture and tradition were established between the twelfth and fifteenth centuries, and Pashtun folklore was disseminated and Pashtun nationalism ...
  46. [46]
    The strange and little-known case of Hindko - Mint
    Jul 6, 2019 · Prior to Partition, however, Peshawar city was dominated by Hindko speakers. Typically, Pashto speakers were predominant in the rural areas of ...
  47. [47]
    Indigenous Peshawaris: A Saga Of Cultural Diminishment
    Jan 1, 2025 · The influx of Afghan refugees into Peshawar fundamentally transformed its demographic composition. Over the next two decades, the city swelled ...
  48. [48]
    language shift and maintenance: the case study of hindko ...
    (2021) showed that the Hindko speakers aged 16 to 24 years are shifting towards Pashto which is the majority language spoken in Peshawar. In the same manner, ...
  49. [49]
    THE CASE STUDY OF HINDKO COMMUNITY IN PESHAWAR ...
    Jun 29, 2021 · It deals with language attitude and language shift from Hindko to other languages due to social, economic and political factors. This study ...
  50. [50]
  51. [51]
    Settlement of Hundreds of Nomad Families in Northern ... - 8am.media
    Sep 5, 2022 · 150 nomad families are supposed to be settled in this district within few days. Observers consider the relocation of the nomads to the north to ...
  52. [52]
    (PDF) An Analysis of Conflict between Pashto and Dari Languages ...
    Aug 6, 2025 · For the first time a dialect of Persian spoken in Afghanistan was officially renamed as Dari in the 1964 Constitution of Afghanistan. In this ...
  53. [53]
  54. [54]
    Afghanistan: History Of 1973 Coup Sheds Light On Relations With ...
    Jul 18, 2003 · Afghan scholars say Daoud Khan's "Pashtunistan" policies caused so many problems with Islamabad that Zahir Shah removed him from the post of ...
  55. [55]
    [PDF] Language Policy as an Instrument of National Integration - PJHC
    They started to promote the Pashto language as a suitable representation of Afghan nationalism as they associated Persian (Dari) with the domination of Iran.
  56. [56]
    The Taliban in Afghanistan - Council on Foreign Relations
    The Taliban are a predominantly Pashtun, Islamic fundamentalist group that returned to power in Afghanistan in 2021 after waging a twenty-year insurgency.
  57. [57]
    History, Heritage, Hegemony: The Truth About the Taliban Emirate
    Feb 8, 2024 · For the Taliban, the term “Afghan” itself serves as an synonym of “Pashtun.” (The name, “Afghanistan,” meaning, “Land of Afghans,” first ...<|separator|>
  58. [58]
    Instability in Afghanistan | Global Conflict Tracker
    After the withdrawal of U.S. troops from Afghanistan in August 2021, the Taliban rapidly regained control of the country and the government in Kabul. Despite ...
  59. [59]
    Factoring Ethnicity in Taliban's Quest for Legitimacy | GJIA
    Apr 17, 2024 · The Taliban must integrate ethnic minorities instead of promoting Pashtun nationalism as currently propagated by the Taliban regime. Their ...
  60. [60]
    Afghanistan's Ethnic Faultlines Under Taliban Rule
    Jul 16, 2024 · The Taliban remain a potent force in Afghanistan. However, their Pashtun-concentrated power distribution allows ethnic fault lines to show up, which may ignite ...
  61. [61]
    Afghanistan dispatches: 'The Taliban are using only Pashtu ...
    Oct 18, 2021 · A lawyer in Kabul offers his observations and perspective on the implications of the Taliban's use of Pashtu (sometimes rendered as Pashto) as an official ...Missing: assimilation | Show results with:assimilation<|separator|>
  62. [62]
    Afghanistan's Necessary Shift in Ethnic Narratives: From Dominance ...
    Mar 21, 2023 · The Taliban, seemingly an Islamist ideological force, actually have a tendency toward ethnic politics. In the past year and a half, since ...
  63. [63]
    [PDF] Afghanistan: Borders, Tribes & Empires – The Past That Shapes the ...
    The Durrani Unification: Weak and Fleeting. Ahmad Shah Durrani is recognized as the founder of modern Afghanistan, as he was able to unite the Pashtun tribes in.
  64. [64]
    Afghanistan: Martial Society Without Military Rule
    Mar 25, 2021 · Ahmad Shah Durrani saw an opportunity and seized control of expansive territories. He then sought to solidify power over these loosely ...
  65. [65]
    [PDF] Understanding the historical role of central governance in Afghanistan
    The efforts of Ahmad Khan Durrani and Abdur Rahman were focused on building an Afghan nation and development of a central government authority that possessed ...
  66. [66]
    A historical timeline of Afghanistan | PBS News
    The land that is now Afghanistan has a long history of domination by foreign conquerors and strife among internally warring factions.
  67. [67]
    Pashtuns: The Pride of Pakistan and Pillars of Regional Stability
    Oct 10, 2024 · Pashtuns are central to Pakistan's national unity, contributing to the country's governance, military, sports, and international reputation.Missing: achievements | Show results with:achievements
  68. [68]
    Hazaras in Afghanistan - Minority Rights Group
    In Hazarajat, Pashtun nomads who participated in the conquest of the region in the 1890s progressively took control of the region's pasturelands and dominated ...
  69. [69]
    [PDF] A Social Dominance Theory Analysis of the Subjugation of Hazara ...
    Dec 31, 2024 · The Hazaras have been historically persecuted by a race that claims to be ethnically and religiously superior; The Pashtuns. Afghanistan, in ...
  70. [70]
    The Hazara community's struggle for justice in Afghanistan
    Feb 11, 2023 · ... Hazara peoples constitute 20-25% of the population in Afghanistan. Historically, the Pashtun ethnic group has dominated political, military ...
  71. [71]
    [PDF] Central Asian Cultural Intelligence for Military Operations Hazara in ...
    This is primarily due to the Hazara view that Afghanistan is a Pashtun-dominated state, which history and experience has shown to be hostile to the Shia Hazara ...
  72. [72]
    Q&A: Afghanistan's Tajiks plea for federalism | News | Al Jazeera
    Feb 6, 2016 · Ahead of new talks with the Taliban, some Afghan leaders think federalism is the only way to secure long-term peace.Missing: criticism | Show results with:criticism
  73. [73]
  74. [74]
    From Identity Crisis to Identity in Crisis in Afghanistan
    Dec 16, 2009 · In the shifting sands of civil war, the Tajiks purged Pashtuns from the military and higher levels of government civil service. Through ...
  75. [75]
    Taliban and Ethnic Discrimination: Uzbeks Frustrated with Symbolic ...
    Oct 6, 2024 · Many Uzbek citizens in Afghanistan argue that the Taliban's ethnic biases have excluded them from political power, denying them a meaningful role in national ...
  76. [76]
  77. [77]
    An Afghan Tragedy: The Pashtuns, the Taliban and the State
    May 25, 2021 · The Pashtun tragedy lies in the fact that in practice, this rejection of state interference has usually amounted to a rejection of the modernising state as ...
  78. [78]
    Afghanistan: The Problem of Pashtun Alienation
    Aug 5, 2003 · A key obstacle is the perception of many ethnic Pashtuns that they lack meaningful representation in the central government, particularly in its ...<|separator|>
  79. [79]
    Khyber Pakhtunkhwa - Wikipedia
    The population of the province forms 16.9% of Pakistan's total population and is multiethnic, with the main ethnic groups being the Pashtuns, Hindkowans, ...Missing: criticisms | Show results with:criticisms
  80. [80]
    Relocating TTP to Northern Afghanistan: From Changing Ethnic ...
    Jun 19, 2023 · The Pashtunization of the North, which is now accompanied and coordinated with the Talibanization of life, will not only benefit the Pashtuns ...
  81. [81]
    Demographics - Government of Khyber Pakhtunkhwa
    The largest ethnic group is the Pashtun, who historically have been living in the areas for centuries. Lower Dir · Upper Dir · Abbottabad · Malakand · Bannu.
  82. [82]
    Pashtun in Pakistan people group profile | Joshua Project
    The majority of Pashtun live in Pakistan. They are concentrated mainly in the northern and western provinces of Khyber Pakhtunkhwa and Baluchistan. The ...
  83. [83]
    The Khalaj and Afghanistan's Cultural Heritage: Pre - Islamic Social ...
    The aim of this study is to examine the interactions of the Khalaj with other ethnic groups in the pre-Islamic period and their effects on cultural changes. It ...Missing: Pashtunization Rohilkhand
  84. [84]
    Pashtun (Pathan) Tribe, People, Culture & History - Utmankhel
    The early precursors to modern-day Pashtuns may have been old Iranian tribes that spread throughout the eastern Iranian plateau. Modern scholars suggest that a ...<|separator|>