Fact-checked by Grok 2 weeks ago

Paul Maynard

Paul Maynard (born 16 December 1975) is a British Conservative Party politician who served as the Member of Parliament for Blackpool North and Cleveleys from 2010 until 2024. Diagnosed with cerebral palsy shortly after birth, which impacts his speech and coordination, Maynard worked as a political adviser and speechwriter prior to entering Parliament. Educated at St Ambrose College in Altrincham and University College, Oxford, where he studied history, he was elected in the 2010 general election, securing a marginal seat and becoming the first Conservative MP with cerebral palsy. During his tenure, Maynard held junior ministerial positions, including Parliamentary Under-Secretary of State for Transport (2016–2018 and 2019–2020), for Justice (2019), as a government whip (2018–2019), and for Pensions at the Department for Work and Pensions (2023–2024). He has advocated for improved adult care transitions and awareness of cerebral palsy, drawing on personal experience, and contributed to the government's Inclusive Transport Strategy as the first minister with the condition. In 2024, Maynard faced an investigation by the Independent Parliamentary Standards Authority for using taxpayer-funded resources for campaign printing, resulting in a finding of breach and repayment of over £3,000, though he was cleared on broader expense claims. He lost his seat in the 2024 general election and contested the reformed Blackpool North and Fleetwood constituency.

Early life and education

Childhood and family background

Paul Maynard was born on 16 December 1975 in , . At birth, he suffered and a speech defect caused by being strangled by the , resulting in lifelong mobility challenges that necessitate adaptations such as specialized vehicles and assistance for physical tasks. These conditions emerged immediately, shaping his early experiences with physical limitations while he learned to navigate independence despite them.

Academic and early professional experience

Maynard attended , a state-funded grammar school in , . He then pursued higher education at , where he studied Modern History from 1994 to 1997, graduating with a first-class honours degree. Following university, Maynard entered professional roles aligned with Conservative policy circles. He worked in management consultancy before serving as a for and as a political adviser to member . These positions involved drafting communications on economic reform, defence, and welfare policy, providing early exposure to empirical critiques of state dependency and advocacy for market-oriented self-sufficiency. His advisory work with Fox, a proponent of intervention, contributed to shaping perspectives on reducing welfare traps through evidence-based incentives, as evidenced in contemporaneous Conservative policy papers emphasizing personal responsibility over expansive public provision.

Political career

Entry into politics and 2010 election

Paul Maynard entered formal politics through advisory roles prior to seeking elected office, serving as a political adviser and speechwriter in Conservative circles. In the lead-up to the 2010 general election, he was selected as the Conservative Party candidate for the marginal constituency of Blackpool North and Cleveleys, a priority target seat held by Labour since its creation in 1997. His placement on the party's A-list of priority candidates, which included provisions to promote disabled individuals among other diversity goals, facilitated this selection; Maynard, who has cerebral palsy, became the first MP with the condition upon election. The campaign occurred against the backdrop of the , with the Conservative platform emphasizing fiscal responsibility, deficit reduction, and local economic renewal to address Blackpool's challenges as a tourism-dependent area with high deprivation. Maynard's platform aligned with these themes, highlighting the need for welfare reforms to encourage employment amid rising and public debt accumulated under 13 years of governance. On 6 May 2010, Maynard secured victory in the general election, gaining the seat from Labour's Penny Martin with 16,964 votes (41.8% of the valid vote), a 4.5% to the Conservatives. This resulted in a of 2,150 votes (5.3 percentage points), on a turnout of 61.5% from an electorate of 66,017. The win reflected broader national trends favoring Conservative pledges for economic stabilization over Labour's incumbency.

Backbench and select committee roles

Maynard was appointed to the Transport Select Committee on 12 July 2010, serving until 5 November 2012, during which he participated in inquiries scrutinizing the Department for Transport's policies on rail investment, aviation, and public spending efficiency. The committee's work focused on assessing value for money in major projects, such as and franchise competitions, highlighting instances of waste and recommending measures to enhance accountability in government expenditure. In this backbench capacity, Maynard contributed to debates emphasizing evidence-based reforms to curb inefficiencies, aligning with broader Conservative efforts to reduce the structural deficit inherited in 2010, which stood at 9.9% of GDP. As a backbench , Maynard engaged in discussions on , speaking in support of the 2012 Welfare Reform Bill to introduce time limits on incapacity benefits and cap household benefits at £26,000 annually, arguing these changes were necessary to incentivize work and address projections of spending reaching £220 billion by 2016 without intervention. He linked such reforms to fiscal realism, contending in a 2014 debate that deficit reduction—achieved through spending controls that lowered borrowing from £155 billion in 2009-10 to £86 billion by 2014-15—was essential for sustaining support for vulnerable populations amid rising national debt exceeding 80% of GDP. Maynard's interventions prioritized data-driven arguments over expansive entitlements, critiquing prior policies for contributing to a £1.4 trillion accumulated deficit. Maynard demonstrated consistent party alignment in parliamentary votes, recording only 16 instances of opposing the Conservative majority across 2,838 divisions from 2010 to , a rate reflecting restraint in dissent compared to more ideological colleagues. This record underscores a preference for collective fiscal discipline, as evidenced by his adherence to government positions on measures that correlated with reduction from 10% to under 4% of GDP by , enabling targeted investments without unchecked borrowing. Later, as a before his 2017 junior ministerial appointment, he joined the Justice Select Committee, further contributing to oversight of spending and procedural efficiencies.

Ministerial appointments and responsibilities

Maynard was appointed at the on 16 July 2016, serving until 9 January 2018. In this capacity, he oversaw rail operations, including interventions to address disruptions on Southern Rail and networks, and contributed to the management of major infrastructure projects aimed at enhancing transport efficiency. He returned to the same role on 30 July 2019, holding it until 13 February 2020, with responsibilities encompassing HS2, , transport security, and accessibility improvements. From 9 May to 26 July 2019, Maynard served as at the . His duties included oversight of provision, such as facilitating expanded access for separated migrant children in matters, and elements of services reform. Maynard was appointed Parliamentary Under-Secretary of State for Pensions at the on 13 November 2023, remaining in post until 5 July 2024. He managed pensions policy implementation, including the launch of the Small Pots Delivery Group on 7 February 2024 to advance consolidation of multiple small pension pots, progression of the Mansion House reforms to channel investments into productive assets, and adjustments to automatic enrolment parameters, such as the 2024/25 earnings trigger review.

Policy positions and contributions

Pensions and welfare reform

As Minister for Pensions from November 2023 until the 2024 general election, Paul Maynard prioritized expansions to automatic enrolment (AE) into workplace pensions, a policy leveraging behavioral inertia to increase private savings without direct coercion. Introduced in 2012, AE has enrolled over 11 million workers, raising private sector participation rates from 42% in 2011 to 86% in 2022, while generating an additional £114 billion in real-terms pension savings over the subsequent decade. Maynard described AE as a successful yet "incomplete structure," advocating for lowering the earnings trigger from £10,000 to capture more low-paid and younger workers, thereby promoting defined contribution schemes as a complement to the state pension's limited replacement rate of around 30% of pre-retirement earnings. Maynard's parliamentary record reflects consistent support for occupational pensions, including expansions in defined contribution arrangements that shift responsibility from employer-guaranteed defined benefit models to accounts, aligning with that DB schemes' underfunding risks necessitate greater personal provision for long-term sustainability. He endorsed related reforms, such as encouraging funds to invest in productive assets like private markets to enhance returns for savers, rather than low-yield options, while addressing small pot proliferation through consolidation measures to reduce administrative drag on DC pots. On welfare reform, Maynard voted repeatedly against uprating benefits in line with , prioritizing incentives for self-reliance over expansions that could perpetuate dependency. He critiqued Labour-era policies for fostering a "something-for-nothing ," which correlated with incapacity benefit claimants rising to 2.26 million working-age recipients by August 2009, creating traps where outflow rates stagnated below 1% annually for long-term claimants, as high effective marginal tax rates discouraged re-entry into work. Maynard argued for targeted alternatives to broad uplifts, such as integrated credit systems under , to mitigate without inflating rolls, drawing on data showing post-2010 reforms reduced claimant numbers through conditionality.

Civil service and government efficiency

In August 2020, following his tenure as at the from July 2019 to February 2020, Paul Maynard advocated for a "hard reset" of the , arguing that the had demonstrated insufficient bandwidth and agility to handle complex challenges at pace, particularly in light of the response. He cited empirical observations from his ministerial experience, including frequent staff rotations that prevented sustained project ownership and a lack of specialized expertise despite individual capabilities, which contrasted with ministers often possessing deeper policy knowledge than their briefers. Maynard emphasized the need to address administrative bloat through structural incentives aligned with , drawing on historical patterns of to under previous administrations, where temporary initiatives failed against entrenched departmental silos and oversized ministerial committees. He proposed relocating key decision-making functions outside —such as claims to regional hubs like —to disrupt bureaucratic inertia and enable resource reallocation toward tax reductions and enhanced public services. This approach challenged the normalized acceptance of a permanent as inherently benign, favoring instead mechanisms like Canadian-style " letters" for civil servants and the appointment of cross-government thematic ministers within the to prioritize outcomes over institutional preservation. His critique highlighted short ministerial tenures—averaging around 18 months—and denied requests for specialized training to scrutinize delivery bodies, underscoring misaligned incentives that perpetuated inefficiency rather than delivery-focused metrics. Maynard positioned these reforms as essential to break cycles of reform fatigue, asserting that without radical intervention, the would continue to resist structural changes needed for fiscal discipline and improved governance.

Transportation and justice policy

As for from July 2016 to January 2018, and briefly as Rail Minister in 2019, Paul Maynard managed operational rail matters, including franchise awards that expanded capacity. In 2016, under his oversight, new Northern and franchises were granted, introducing 500 new carriages and over 2,000 additional daily services to boost reliability and shift passengers from roads, thereby alleviating congestion pressures. These reforms built on franchising's core aim of leveraging to cut subsidies and improve , as franchised operators had delivered passenger growth from 760 million journeys in 1995–96 to over 1.7 billion by 2016. Maynard emphasized integrated operations in franchise competitions, such as the Eastern process, requiring winners to coordinate with for extended trains, more seats, and faster journeys to enhance reliability and passenger satisfaction. Amid the 2016 Southern rail dispute, which disrupted services for millions, he offered government mediation between the operator and unions to prioritize service resumption over . His tenure also advanced , including the Inclusive to ensure disabled users' through better station infrastructure and vehicle adaptations. In justice policy, Maynard served as at the from May to July 2019, with responsibilities including administration. He engaged directly with practitioners via the 'Take Your MP to Work' initiative, shadowing lawyers to assess frontline delivery and identify efficiencies in case handling. As Chair of the on Penal Affairs, he scrutinized sentencing and , critiquing systemic failures in youth offender management. On youth sentencing, Maynard highlighted evidence-based alternatives in a 2011 address, noting pilots yielded a % reoffending drop compared to standard processes, advocating integration to address root causes while upholding accountability over lenient dispositions that ignore risks. This stance reflected broader concerns with youth custody's high reoffending—around 75% within a year—pushing for targeted interventions grounded in pilot outcomes rather than unproven expansions of community sanctions.

Controversies

Parliamentary expenses investigation

In January 2024, allegations surfaced that Paul Maynard, the MP for North and , had used his taxpayer-funded constituency office and IPSA-supported equipment for campaigning activities, including printing overtly political materials. These claims, initially reported by , highlighted Maynard's high claims of £106,036 for printing and stationery costs since 2010, the largest among , prompting scrutiny amid renewed focus on MPs' expenses following prior scandals. On 8 January 2024, the Compliance Officer for the Independent Parliamentary Standards Authority (IPSA) opened an into Maynard's use of office costs and equipment under the MPs' expenses scheme, following a referral from IPSA's Chief Executive. The probe examined whether IPSA-funded resources, such as a high-end printer, were improperly used for non-parliamentary purposes, including partisan printing that breached rules prohibiting such expenditure. The investigation concluded on 15 May 2024, with the Compliance Officer finding that Maynard had breached the scheme by using IPSA-funded equipment to produce and print materials deemed "overtly political" for distribution, rather than solely for parliamentary duties. Maynard accepted the findings without appeal and agreed to repay £1,367 to cover the ineligible costs, with no further sanctions imposed and no criminal proceedings initiated. As of October 2025, the matter was resolved through this administrative process, separate from broader parliamentary conduct inquiries, and Maynard retained his ministerial position.

Personal life

Health and disability

Paul Maynard was born with , which manifests primarily in speech difficulties and some motor impairments, though described as mild. He was diagnosed with at age 22, a development he described as a shock that necessitated giving up entirely, as it serves as a trigger for seizures. Maynard manages these conditions through personal discipline and adaptations, enabling full participation in professional life without evident reliance on expanded state provisions for daily functioning. Elected as MP for North and in 2010, Maynard represented a milestone as parliament's first declared MP with , highlighting individual capacity amid physical limitations via self-reliant strategies such as practiced despite mockery from some quarters over his speech patterns. His experience underscores of functionality in high-demand roles without normalized accommodations beyond standard access. Drawing from personal management of his , Maynard advocates disability policies prioritizing incentives over frameworks that entrench , as evidenced by his in initiatives like the 2016 taskforce to enhance apprenticeship access for those with learning disabilities, aimed at halving the overall disability employment gap. He has chaired the on to advance such pragmatic, work-oriented reforms informed by direct lived realities rather than abstracted welfare expansions.

Family and personal interests

Maynard has maintained strict privacy regarding his family life, with no publicly available information on , partnerships, or children. This discretion aligns with his broader approach to separating personal matters from public scrutiny. The demands of parliamentary service have significantly curtailed his leisure pursuits, which he has noted often "fall by the wayside" as politics consumes one's entire life. In a local interview, he revealed recently the Scandinavian crime series , alongside enjoying short domestic holidays in the and anticipating travel to . He has also expressed a longstanding interest in , the collection of postage stamps, which complements his affinity for Blackpool's local heritage and community involvement outside formal political roles.

References

  1. [1]
    Paul Maynard MP - Who is he? - Politics.co.uk
    Born in 1975, Paul Maynard was born in Cheshire and attended Oxford university where he obtained a first class degree. Prior to his election, he worked in ...Missing: biography | Show results with:biography
  2. [2]
    Parliamentary career for Paul Maynard - MPs and Lords - UK Parliament
    ### Summary of Paul Maynard's Parliamentary Career
  3. [3]
    Paul Maynard - GOV.UK
    Paul Maynard was Parliamentary Under Secretary of State at the Department for Work and Pensions from 13 November 2023 to 5 July 2024.Missing: British | Show results with:British
  4. [4]
    Paul Maynard MP: life with cerebral palsy and epilepsy
    Jul 1, 2010 · Maynard's condition is mild and bar some co-ordination issues he is able to get around with few problems. It is also clear that he does not want ...
  5. [5]
    Paul Maynard - UP – The Adult Cerebral Palsy Movement
    Feb 23, 2023 · Probably being the first person with cerebral palsy to become a Government Minister and publishing the Government's Inclusive Transport Strategy ...
  6. [6]
    Minister broke rules on expenses, watchdog finds - BBC
    May 16, 2024 · But Mr Maynard was cleared of wrongdoing over his "higher than average" claim of £106,000 for printing and related costs since 2010. The ...Missing: achievements controversies
  7. [7]
    MPs' expenses watchdog investigates claims against minister
    Feb 22, 2024 · Paul Maynard is accused of using his taxpayer-funded constituency office for Tory campaigning.
  8. [8]
    Paul Maynard | Historica Wiki | Fandom
    Paul Maynard was born in Crewe, Cheshire, England on 16 December 1975, and he worked as a Conservative Party speechwriter before being elected to Parliament ...
  9. [9]
    We should not get too pious about MPs' treatment of Paul Maynard
    Feb 7, 2011 · Paul Maynard, the new Tory MP for Blackpool North, was apparently mocked for his way of speaking. He was born with cerebral palsy.
  10. [10]
    Cerebral palsy: Paul Maynard MP says he is mocked for being drunk
    Mar 31, 2023 · An MP with cerebral palsy has said he regularly receives messages accusing him of being drunk when he speaks in Parliament. Paul Maynard, a ...
  11. [11]
    Paul Maynard - UK Government - LinkedIn
    Experience · Pensions Minister · MP, Blackpool North & Cleveleys · Major Rail Projects, HS2 and Aviation Minister · Rail Minister.Missing: politician biography
  12. [12]
    Election result for Blackpool North and Cleveleys (Constituency)
    Shows the election result of the 2010 General Election ... The seat was last held by Paul Maynard (Conservative) between 6 May 2010 to 30 May 2024.
  13. [13]
    Election 2010 | Constituency | Blackpool North & Cleveleys
    Candidates. Name, Party, Votes, %, +/-. Paul Maynard, Conservative, 16,964, 41.8, +4.5. Penny Martin, Labour, 14,814, 36.5, -9.2. Bill Greene, Liberal Democrat ...
  14. [14]
    Blackpool North and Cleveleys general election - May 2010
    Conservative gain from Labour by Paul Maynard with a majority of 2,150 - 5.3% - on a turnout of 61.5%. An electorate of 66,017, having a valid vote count of ...Missing: victory | Show results with:victory
  15. [15]
    Paul Maynard - Parliamentary career - MPs and Lords - UK Parliament
    Paul Maynard is no longer a Member, but was most recently the Conservative MP for Blackpool North and Cleveleys, and left the Commons on 30 May 2024.Missing: biography | Show results with:biography
  16. [16]
    Contributions for Paul Maynard - Hansard - UK Parliament
    Review the contributions made by Paul Maynard that have been recorded in Hansard. Filter by keyword and date. Optionally also cover historical data.Missing: Accounts | Show results with:Accounts
  17. [17]
    Paul Maynard extracts from Welfare Reform Bill (1st February 2012)
    Paul Maynard contributions to the 1st February 2012 Welfare Reform Bill debate Wed 1st Feb 2012 - Commons - Welfare Reform Bill debate.Missing: cap | Show results with:cap
  18. [18]
    Paul Maynard - Parallel Parliament
    Paul Maynard, Conservative - Former Member for Blackpool North and Cleveleys. First elected: 6th May 2010. Left House: 30th May 2024 (Dissolution).Missing: bio | Show results with:bio
  19. [19]
    Paul Maynard MP, Blackpool North and Cleveleys (24764)
    Interesting Votes ; 9 Jan 2018, Stopped being Parliamentary Under-Secretary (Department for Transport), ; House, Date, Subject ; no rebellions, never teller.
  20. [20]
    Transport Department confirms ministerial portfolios - BVRLA
    Aug 20, 2019 · Paul Maynard MP, Minister for Aviation and Major Infrastructure Projects. This will include responsibility for Northern Powerhouse Rail, HS2 ...<|separator|>
  21. [21]
    Parliamentary Under Secretary of State - GOV.UK
    The Parliamentary Under Secretary of State's responsibilities are: Court services and reform (including Bills); Legal aid; Legal support and fees ...
  22. [22]
    Separated migrant children to access legal aid more easily - GOV.UK
    Jul 22, 2019 · Justice Minister Paul Maynard said: It is absolutely right that legal aid should be available to separated migrant children to resolve their ...
  23. [23]
    Efforts to tackle small pension pots step up a gear - GOV.UK
    Feb 8, 2024 · A new group designed to help savers track their pensions was launched yesterday (7 February) by Pensions Minister Paul Maynard.<|separator|>
  24. [24]
    PLSA 24: Minister Paul Maynard sets out his key priorities for pensions
    Consolidation, the Mansion House reforms and automatic enrolment (AE) are key priorities for the pensions minister as he deals with the plethora of issues.
  25. [25]
    Automatic Enrolment: Earnings Trigger and Qualifying E - Hansard
    Feb 6, 2024 · Since 2012 over 11 million people have been enrolled into a pension and over 2.3 million employers have met their automatic enrolment duties.Missing: consolidation | Show results with:consolidation
  26. [26]
    [PDF] Automatic Enrolment Contributions Briefing Paper
    Jun 20, 2024 · Pension participation in the private sector has increased from 42% of employees in 2011 before automatic enrolment to 86% of employees in 2022.
  27. [27]
    How much are UK workers really saving as a result of pensions auto ...
    Feb 5, 2024 · Ten years of automatic enrolment achieves over 114bn pension savings. The 2022 data further show a £29bn real-terms increase.
  28. [28]
    Auto-enrolment is 'incomplete', says pensions minister - FTAdviser
    Feb 8, 2024 · There is more to be done to improve auto-enrolment, the pensions minister has said, as he called the policy an "incomplete structure".
  29. [29]
    Voting record - Paul Maynard, former MP, Blackpool North and ...
    Consistently voted for increasing the rate of VAT Show votes 8 votes for, between 2010 and 2022. Comparable Conservative MPs almost always voted for. Almost ...Missing: achievements | Show results with:achievements
  30. [30]
    New TPR guidance on private market investments helps trustees ...
    Jan 24, 2024 · Minister for Pensions, Paul Maynard said: “I welcome TPR's guidance encouraging pension schemes to consider investing in private markets.
  31. [31]
    Paul Maynard vs Justin Tomlinson - Debate Excerpts
    It is a pleasure to follow the hon. Member for Glasgow East (David Linden) and I pay tribute to his encyclopaedic survey of the landscape of the Department.Missing: pre- | Show results with:pre-
  32. [32]
    [PDF] First Release - GOV.UK
    Feb 17, 2010 · At August 2009, there were 2.26 million working age claimants of incapacity benefits (Incapacity Benefit or Severe. Disablement Allowance), a ...
  33. [33]
    Paul Maynard: There are better ways to help low-income families ...
    Feb 12, 2021 · Paul Maynard was Parliamentary Under Secretary of State at the Department for Transport from July 2019 to February 2020. He is MP for ...
  34. [34]
  35. [35]
    Transport investment in the north - GOV.UK
    Nov 30, 2017 · In 2016, we awarded new Northern and TransPennine Express rail franchises, which will deliver new trains, 500 new carriages, over 2,000 extra ...
  36. [36]
    [PDF] Rail franchising - Parliament UK
    Feb 5, 2017 · The premise behind franchising was that competition would increase efficiency, reduce the taxpayer subsidy, lower fares and improve services ...
  37. [37]
    Paul Maynard extracts from Rail Franchising (22nd June 2017)
    The winner of the South Eastern franchise will need to work as one team with Network Rail to ensure passengers experience better journeys and provide longer ...
  38. [38]
    Southern rail dispute: Rail minister says government could broker talks
    Jul 20, 2016 · New rail minister Paul Maynard has said the government will consider brokering talks between Southern and the RMT union to try to end their ...
  39. [39]
    [PDF] Sentencing Young Adults: Getting it Right Paul Maynard MP - T2A
    As an MP one of my greatest frustrations and embarrassments is that I am morally responsible for the care of thousands of young people in our criminal justice ...
  40. [40]
  41. [41]
    Compliance Officer for IPSA publishes report following investigation ...
    May 15, 2024 · IPSA allowed Mr Paul Maynard to make occasional use of IPSA-funded equipment and his constituency office for non-parliamentary purposes ...Missing: Committee | Show results with:Committee
  42. [42]
    Paul Maynard: Pensions minister investigated over funding claims
    Feb 22, 2024 · MP Paul Maynard is alleged to have broken rules by using taxpayers' money to pay for campaign work.Missing: achievements | Show results with:achievements
  43. [43]
    Minister investigated by expenses watchdog over claims he used ...
    Jan 6, 2024 · Mr Maynard has reportedly claimed £106,036 for printing and related stationery costs since 2010 – the highest sum of any Conservative MP and ...Missing: commissioner outcome
  44. [44]
    Paul Maynard Closure Report - IPSA's Compliance Officer
    May 15, 2024 · On 8 January 2024, following receipt of a referral from the Chief Executive Officer of IPSA, the Compliance Officer opened an investigation into ...Missing: expenses | Show results with:expenses
  45. [45]
    Pensions minister to pay back £1,367 after expenses breach
    May 16, 2024 · On January 8 2024, IPSA opened an investigation, originally revealed by the Sunday Times, into Maynard and the use of his constituency office ...
  46. [46]
    Disabled MP was 'mocked' in Commons | London Evening Standard
    Apr 11, 2012 · He was diagnosed with epilepsy too when he was 22, an event he says was "a shock" and forced him to give up alcohol. MORE ABOUT. Blackpool.
  47. [47]
    Paul Maynard taskforce recommendations - GOV.UK
    Jul 11, 2016 · The government is committed to reaching 3 million new apprenticeship starts by 2020 and halving the disability employment gap.
  48. [48]
    Paul Maynard MP - Live Blackpool
    Mar 27, 2018 · Your MP is a person who the majority of people wouldn't ever get to know – after all you'd normally seek them out only if you'd got a problem.
  49. [49]
    Recycling Paul Maynard. | AgeWage - Henry Tapper
    Oct 1, 2024 · He fell into the role of Pensions Minister and carried out his duties creditably. He was part of the death star , what remained of a shining ...Missing: early | Show results with:early