Fact-checked by Grok 2 weeks ago

Pierre's Hole

Pierre's Hole, now known as Teton Valley, is a high mountain basin primarily in Teton County, eastern , with towns such as Driggs and , situated west of the and encompassing approximately 20 miles in length and 5 to 12 miles in width at an elevation exceeding 6,000 feet. The valley features streams, aspen groves, and willow thickets, providing a fertile oasis amid the surrounding rugged mountains and arid landscapes, and it was rich in populations that attracted early 19th-century fur trappers. The name "Pierre's Hole" derives from Pierre Tevanitagon, an freeman trapper employed by , who first located and trapped in the beaver-rich valley around 1818 while working in the Rocky Mountain fur trade. Tevanitagon later defected to American trapping parties in 1825 and achieved notable success by selling 100 beaver skins at that year's , though he was killed by Blackfoot warriors in 1827 near the in . During the height of the era, the valley served as a key gathering point for British, American, and Native American trappers, including , , and Flathead peoples, who utilized its resources for trapping and trade. The site's most prominent historical event was the 1832 Pierre's Hole Rendezvous, a major assembly attended by around 1,000 trappers, traders, and Native allies, organized by partners of the Smith, Jackson, and Sublette company including William Sublette, which highlighted the competitive dynamics between American and British interests in the region. This rendezvous culminated in the Battle of Pierre's Hole on July 18, 1832, when a (Atsina) band of about 200, including around 50-60 warriors, entered the valley, leading to intense fighting that resulted in approximately 19 deaths according to contemporary accounts (including 4 trappers, 6 allies, and 9 ), though estimates of losses vary up to 26, and numerous wounds, marking one of the larger clashes between fur traders and Native American forces in the . Today, the area retains much of its 19th-century appearance, with archaeological evidence such as artifact scatters and rock rings, and a 400-acre portion is listed on the National Register of Historic Places for its role in American frontier .

Geography and Etymology

Location and Physical Features

Pierre's Hole is a shallow valley located in Teton County, eastern , situated west of the in . This high mountain basin lies at elevations exceeding 6,000 feet above sea level, with specific areas such as the historic site measured at approximately 6,109 feet. The valley encompasses a broad, open area historically known for its grassy prairies extending nearly 30 miles along the headwaters of the Teton River, flanked by lower ridges that define its southern, eastern, and western boundaries, while the northern rim remains more open. The physical landscape of Pierre's Hole features a collection of streams and meadows within the basin, supporting vegetation such as aspen groves, willows, and expansive range meadows, with some swampy zones transitioning to pasturelands. Surrounding the central valley are uplands and coniferous forests on the adjacent slopes, contributing to a diverse environmental context less arid than the lands to the west. As the primary gathering point for the headwaters of the Teton River—a 64-mile that flows northward through the basin before joining the Henrys Fork of the —this area forms part of the larger watershed. In contemporary terms, Pierre's Hole integrates into the broader Teton Basin, or , traversed by Idaho State Highway 33, which runs north-south through the region connecting communities like and Driggs. The valley supports agricultural activities, including hay and potato farming, alongside recreational pursuits such as and viewing, reflecting its adaptation to modern land uses while preserving its natural basin characteristics.

Naming and Early Exploration

Pierre's Hole, a broad valley in eastern nestled between the to the east and the Snake River Range to the west, was utilized by Native American tribes such as the and primarily as a seasonal hunting ground prior to contact, though evidence suggests their presence was limited compared to more central territories. The first documented European-American exploration of the valley occurred in 1807–1808, when , a member of the who remained in the region as a trapper for Manuel Lisa's Missouri Fur Company, traversed the area during a solo journey. Colter crossed from into Pierre's Hole, becoming the first white man to enter the valley, and continued northward, describing geothermal features that later contributed to early accounts of the "geysers" in what is now . The name "Pierre's Hole" derives from Pierre Tevanitagon, an trapper who first located and trapped in the beaver-rich valley around 1818 while employed by . Known as "Le Grand Pierre" for his stature and prowess, Tevanitagon later joined the after its 1821 merger with , defected to American trapping parties in 1825, and was killed by Blackfoot warriors in fall 1827 near the headwaters of the in .

Fur Trade Context

The Rocky Mountain Rendezvous System

The Rocky Mountain Rendezvous system consisted of annual gatherings held between 1825 and 1840 in remote valleys of the central , where fur trappers exchanged pelts for supplies from eastern traders and engaged in social activities. These events served as a practical alternative to fixed trading posts, allowing mountain men—primarily independent trappers and employees of fur companies—to avoid the dangers and costs of transporting goods over long distances through hostile territory. The rendezvous facilitated the collection of pelts and other furs, which were highly valued in eastern markets for hat-making and , while providing trappers with essential resupplies and a rare opportunity for camaraderie after months in isolation. The system was pioneered by William Henry Ashley, a entrepreneur who co-founded the in 1822 with Andrew Henry. Initially, Ashley organized supply caravans that met trappers at temporary sites, such as the first in along the Henry's Fork of the in present-day . By 1826, the model evolved to fixed annual locations advertised in advance via company networks, enabling larger assemblies and competition from rivals like the under . This shift reduced logistical burdens for traders, who hauled wagons of merchandise from over the precursors, and concentrated economic activity in the wilderness, with sites rotating among valleys like Pierre's Hole to accommodate grazing for pack animals and access to water. Economically, the rendezvous bridged the gap between frontier trappers and distant markets, with pelts typically traded at ratios of one beaver skin for items like a pound of tobacco, a flask of alcohol, or basic firearms and ammunition. Prices reflected the high risks of overland transport, often marking up goods by 500 percent or more, which generated substantial profits for companies while sustaining the trappers' operations. Socially, these gatherings fostered a transient of diverse participants, including Native tribes who supplied furs and , promoting intercultural exchanges through , , and competitions, though they also amplified tensions from alcohol-fueled rivalries and transmission. By the late 1830s, declining beaver populations and shifts to in fashion led to the system's end, marking the close of an era in expansion.

Selection of Pierre's Hole as a Rendezvous Site

The selection of Pierre's Hole for the 1832 was influenced by several logistical and strategic factors that made it particularly suitable for the gathering of trappers and traders. The valley offered abundant grass for sustaining the large numbers of horses and mules essential to the fur trade expeditions, as well as reliable water sources from the Teton River, which also supported in the surrounding streams. These natural resources ensured that the site could accommodate the expected crowds without straining local forage or water supplies. Strategically, Pierre's Hole provided a central location accessible to trappers operating in diverse regions of the , from the country to the north and the Wind River area to the south, facilitating convergence from multiple directions. Its position west of the offered relative safety from eastern tribes such as and , whose raiding parties more frequently threatened sites on the open plains; the rugged terrain acted as a , reducing to surprise attacks from that quarter, though proximity to Blackfeet territory remained a risk. The deemed the area a "pleasant place" overall, balancing accessibility with defensive advantages provided by the surrounding mountains and valleys. The decision was promoted through coordination efforts led by William Sublette, who as the contracted supplier for the ensured alignment between organized fur brigades and free trappers, streamlining the logistics of supply delivery and pelt collection at this remote location. This planning helped draw over 1,000 participants, including Native American allies. In comparison to prior rendezvous sites like the Wind River valley used in , Pierre's Hole presented advantages in resource abundance and relative seclusion, mitigating some risks associated with more exposed locations nearer Blackfeet hunting grounds while still allowing for large-scale gatherings. Although the Wind River site's openness had exposed earlier assemblies to potential interceptions, Pierre's Hole's enclosed minimized such threats from the east, though it did not eliminate dangers from northern tribes. These attributes made it a pragmatic choice for the event amid intensifying competition in the fur trade.

The 1832 Rendezvous

Organization and Activities

The 1832 Pierre's Hole rendezvous was organized by brothers Milton and William Sublette of the , who coordinated the annual gathering as a key hub for operations. William Sublette led a supply expedition from , arriving on July 8, 1832, with a including over 100 men, 180 mules laden with merchandise, and 450 gallons of whiskey for distribution. The event unfolded over approximately two weeks in the valley, with formal trading activities commencing upon the supply train's arrival and concluding by July 17, allowing trappers to exchange their season's pelts before dispersing. Central to the rendezvous were the commercial exchanges, where mountain men and Native American allies traded beaver pelts—totaling 168 packs valued at around $58,305—for essential goods such as , lead balls, knives, hatchets, kettles, blankets, and horses. Social and recreational elements dominated the daily operations, fostering camaraderie among participants through around campfires, on games of chance, organized foot races and horse races, and widespread alcohol consumption that often led to raucous revelry. These non-combat activities created a festive atmosphere in the sprawling encampments, where lodges and tents dotted the valley floor. As one of the largest gatherings in the system, the event drew over 400 mountain men, alongside allied Native groups including approximately 108 lodges and 80 Flathead lodges, contributing to a total attendance exceeding 1,000 individuals. The scale was further evidenced by more than 3,000 and mules present for trading, , and , underscoring the rendezvous's role as a vital economic and cultural nexus before the eventual shift away from such remote assemblies.

Participants and Key Figures

The 1832 rendezvous at Pierre's Hole brought together a diverse assembly of participants from various backgrounds in , primarily centered around the fur trade. The core groups included trappers affiliated with the , who formed the backbone of the event's commercial activities, numbering around 100 individuals. Independent mountain men, often free trappers unaffiliated with larger firms, also attended in significant numbers, contributing to the event's vibrant trading atmosphere. Allied Native American tribes, notably the and Flathead (, participated as trading partners and allies, with estimates of several hundred warriors and families present to exchange furs, horses, and goods. This gathering highlighted the multicultural nature of the frontier fur trade, featuring a mix of American frontiersmen, French-Canadian , and Native participants who intermingled through shared economic interests. French-Canadian trappers, many of whom had migrated from the or earlier ventures, brought expertise in river navigation and trapping techniques, enriching the group's collective knowledge. The inclusion of Native groups underscored the cooperative alliances formed against common rivals like the Blackfeet, fostering a temporary sense of community amid the rugged Teton Valley landscape. Among the key organizers were brothers and Milton Sublette, prominent merchants who led the after its split from the Missouri Fur Company in 1830; , in particular, orchestrated the logistics and supplied trade goods valued at over $20,000. , a seasoned guide and trapper renowned for his explorations of the Yellowstone region, served as a vital scout and participant, leveraging his intimate knowledge of the terrain to aid the group's movements. Thomas Fitzpatrick, the company's clerk and a veteran of earlier expeditions, managed inventories and negotiations, drawing on his experience from Ashley's 1820s ventures. Notable non-trapper figures added layers of ambition and exploration to the rendezvous. Nathaniel Wyeth, a Boston-based and entrepreneur, arrived with a supply caravan from the East, aiming to establish a rival trading network and introducing capital to the western . Captain Benjamin de Bonneville, a U.S. Army officer on leave, led a large exploratory expedition of about 110 men, funded through his own ventures, to map the region and trap beaver, marking one of the earliest organized military-style forays into the Rockies.

Battle of Pierre's Hole

Prelude and Initial Encounter

As the 1832 rendezvous in Pierre's Hole drew to a close in late July, participants began dispersing for the fall trapping season, with tensions already high due to ongoing conflicts between fur trappers and Blackfeet-aligned tribes. On the morning of July 17, a scouting party led by Robert Campbell, part of Milton Sublette's group, spotted a large (Atsina) encampment descending from the Palisade Range into the valley, consisting of approximately 200 warriors along with horses, tipis, and families; the party initially mistook the distant figures for buffalo or whites but soon identified them as hostiles flying a British flag. The discovery prompted an immediate response from nearby trappers, including about 13 men under Sublette, 10 from Nathaniel Wyeth's expedition, and 15 free trappers, who confronted the vanguard. An unarmed chief named Baihoh rode forward under a flag of truce to , but on Sublette's orders, he was shot dead by Iroquois trapper Antoine Godin and a Flathead ally seeking revenge for prior Blackfeet attacks on their people. This killing shattered any chance of peaceful negotiation, leading to a chaotic initial skirmish where the trappers and their Native allies charged the camp, forcing the warriors to abandon their tipis and retreat southward into a nearby wooded and swampy thicket. Amid the escalating violence, alliances quickly formed among the trappers, approximately 200 Flathead (Salish), and 300 warriors, who had been trading partners at the and shared enmity toward the due to their with the Blackfeet in broader intertribal wars. These groups coordinated to pursue the retreating , who hastily fortified their position by digging rifle pits and erecting a breastwork of logs within the timber for defense. The participants, including prominent figures like William Sublette and Thomas Fitzpatrick, rallied to the scene upon hearing of the clash, shifting the gathering's festive atmosphere to one of urgent hostility.

The Main Engagement and Casualties

The main engagement of the Battle of Pierre's Hole commenced on July 18, 1832, shortly after the initial clash, as roughly 200 American trappers and their allied and Flathead warriors initiated an all-day siege against a Gros Ventre encampment fortified as a makeshift of logs, branches, and pits in a swampy, wooded . The site lay approximately six miles southwest of the rendezvous grounds, near the modern town of Driggs in . Tactics centered on a prolonged , with the attackers exchanging volleys of rifle fire and arrows from the and Flathead allies, while attempting multiple charges to overrun the defenses; however, the band, numbering around 200 warriors with women and children, effectively repelled these assaults from their entrenched positions, inflicting casualties through disciplined musketry. William Sublette led one prominent charge into the thicket, advancing on hands and knees to within close range, but the effort faltered amid heavy return fire and a false report of approaching enemy reinforcements, prompting a temporary to conserve ammunition. As dusk fell, the seized the opportunity to escape , abandoning their fort and carrying away most wounded, though they left behind evidence of significant losses; the trappers and allies, exhausted from the day's fighting, did not pursue immediately. Casualties were heavy relative to the skirmish's scale, with the suffering approximately 26 dead—including non-combatants such as women and children—based on their own later admissions and bodies found at the site. On the opposing side, 5 trappers were killed and 6 wounded, while allied and Flathead forces lost 7 killed and 7 wounded, totaling 12 deaths among the trappers and their Native allies.

Aftermath and Legacy

Immediate Outcomes and Long-Term Impacts

Following the Battle of Pierre's Hole on July 18, 1832, the survivors withdrew under cover of night, carrying their wounded with them and abandoning their improvised fort, while the trappers and their allies briefly returned to the site before dispersing to continue along rivers such as the and Yellowstone. The suffered significant losses, with estimates of up to killed, many dying from wounds after retreating. This dispersal was hastened by the battle's casualties, which included four trappers killed and four wounded, alongside six allied killed and two wounded. In the short term, the engagement heightened tensions with the , who retaliated by killing three trappers in Jackson's Hole and ambushing an party later that summer, further endangering mountain passes and trapping grounds. The battle also caused immediate economic disruption to the fur brigades, as threats from the delayed departures and scattered parties, though William Sublette successfully transported 168 packs of pelts—valued at approximately $85,000—eastward to , representing the final major harvest of the season. On a personal level, the injury of key leaders like Sublette, who suffered a severe wound during the fighting, impaired ongoing company operations. In the long term, the violence at Pierre's Hole exemplified the escalating risks that, combined with over-trapping and depleting beaver populations, contributed to the decline of the system by 1840, as traders faced unsustainable losses and competition from cheaper alternatives like silk hats. The event underscored broader cultural clashes in the fur trade era, where Euro-American expansion intersected with Native resistance, influencing U.S. territorial ambitions in the Rockies by highlighting the need for military presence and formalized treaties to secure trade routes. It also strained Native relations, accelerating tribal dependencies on traded goods like firearms while exacerbating intertribal conflicts and vulnerabilities to introduced diseases.

Modern Recognition and Preservation

In 1984, the Pierre's Hole 1832 Battle Area Site, encompassing approximately 400 acres south of Driggs in , was listed on the for its significance in and Native American , preserving key features such as streams, aspen groves, and archaeological remnants like mounds and artifacts from the 1832 engagement. Interpretive markers in Teton Valley, including those along State Highway 33 near Driggs, provide public access to the site's , detailing its role as a fur trade hub and the subsequent battle. Following the fur trade era, Pierre's Hole—now known as Teton Valley—transitioned to agricultural settlement in the 1880s, with from establishing communities like Driggs in 1881, drawn to the fertile lands for farming and ranching. Today, the valley's economy blends traditional agriculture and ranching with growing sectors in tourism and , including , , and , supported by proximity to . Local historical societies, such as the Teton Valley Historical Museum, organize annual events like demonstrations and commemorations to educate visitors on the area's past. The site's legacy endures in scholarly and cultural narratives, notably through Washington Irving's 1837 account The Adventures of Captain Bonneville, which vividly describes the 1832 rendezvous and battle, drawing from participant journals to highlight tensions in the Rocky Mountain fur trade. These depictions contribute to education, emphasizing the interplay of European-American trappers, Native American groups like the and , and the broader conflicts over resources in , as explored in regional exhibits and symposia.

References

  1. [1]
    [PDF] National Register of Historic Places Inventory — Nomination Form
    Pierre's Hole, now known as Teton Valley, is a high mountain basin west of Grand. Teton, elevation 13,766. Lower ridges define all but its northern rim.
  2. [2]
    [PDF] Iroquois Freemen Trappers in the Rocky Mountain Fur Trade
    A view of the three Tetons in Teton Valley,. Idaho. During the Rocky Mountain fur trade the valley was called Pierre's Hole in honor of the Iroquois Pierre.
  3. [3]
    Pierre's Hole Rendezvous of 1832 - Intermountain Histories
    Pierre's Hole is a valley in Eastern Idaho, located on the west slope of the Teton Mountain Range at an elevation of 6109 feet. Today, the valley is ...Missing: definition | Show results with:definition
  4. [4]
    Mountain Men | Idaho Harvester
    May 23, 2022 · The description of Pierre's Hole reads: That beautiful open valley, spreading its grassy prairies for almost thirty miles along the headwaters ...
  5. [5]
    Focal Areas | Where We Work - Teton Regional Land Trust
    This area contains the shoreline wetlands of Henry's Lake, spring creeks, sage steppe uplands, and conifer/ aspen mixed forests.
  6. [6]
    Teton River Subbasin | Idaho Department of Environmental Quality
    May 5, 2021 · The Teton River subbasin is one of three watersheds that comprise the Henrys Fork Basin. The Teton River drains an area of 806 square miles in Idaho and 327 ...
  7. [7]
    Tag: Teton Valley - Idaho Transportation Department
    State Highway 33 between mileposts 151 and 152 where a new passing lane will be constructed. Two projects are set to begin Monday to create a center ...
  8. [8]
    [PDF] Teton County Historic Preservation Plan July 2024
    Jul 12, 2024 · Idaho in 1818, becoming the namesake for the Teton Valley's early moniker, Pierre's Hole. The western fur trade reached its peak from 1820 ...
  9. [9]
    Native American Indians in Grand Teton National Park
    Mar 1, 2015 · The Shoshone, Bannock, Blackfoot, Crow, Flathead, Gros Ventre, and Nez Perce were the primary tribes residing in the Teton area when Europeans ...
  10. [10]
    The Fur Trade in Wyoming | WyoHistory.org
    Nov 8, 2014 · ... Pierre's Hole, today's Teton Valley, Idaho. Nez Perce and Flathead joined trappers in the ensuing battle. [20]. But Native Americans were not ...
  11. [11]
    Grand Teton NP/Yellowstone NP: Colter's Hell and Jackson's Hole ...
    Still later in 1808 Colter and John Potts (another Lewis and Clark veteran) were captured by Blackfeet on Jefferson River. Potts was killed and dismembered.
  12. [12]
    John Colter: The First Mountain Man? - The History Reader
    Ascending Teton Pass and dropping into Pierre's Hole, he limned the northern edge of Yellowstone Lake—another first for a white man—and temporarily lent his ...
  13. [13]
    Battle of Pierre's Hole - HistoryNet
    Jun 12, 2006 · The valley was called Pierre's Hole. It lay west of the Teton Range and was about 20 miles long and perhaps two miles wide (in present-day Teton County, Idaho).Missing: definition | Show results with:definition
  14. [14]
    Victor, Driggs and Pierre's Hole, Idaho | A Landing a Day
    Nov 17, 2016 · The Teton River flows northward though the mountain meadows of Pierre's Hole [once known as the Big Hole, thus the Big Hole Mountains] and ...Missing: size elevation
  15. [15]
    Road to Rendezvous: The Rocky Mountain Fur Trade in 1834 | WyoHistory.org
    ### Summary of the Rocky Mountain Rendezvous System
  16. [16]
    Tour | American Fur Trade Rendezvous Sites - Intermountain Histories
    The Rocky Mountain Rendezvous were annual meetings organized by fur trade companies between 1825–1840. Fur trappers gathered at these summertime rendezvous ...
  17. [17]
    a history of the fur trade rendezvous, 1825-1840 : Gowans, Fred R ...
    Feb 5, 2013 · Rocky Mountain rendezvous : a history of the fur trade rendezvous, 1825-1840. by: Gowans, Fred R., 1936-. Publication date: 1985. Topics: Fur ...
  18. [18]
    A Rendezvous Revisited – Points West Online
    May 10, 2023 · In reality, mountain men were just trying to make a living. The fur trade was a large capitalist venture, with natural resources leaving the ...
  19. [19]
    Rendezvous - Malachite's Big Hole
    The event had some aspects of an impromptu Olympics and there were horse races, running races, target shooting, gambling and fighting. Whiskey drinking ...Missing: storytelling | Show results with:storytelling
  20. [20]
    Rendezvous Sites | American Western Expansion
    Members of the Shoshone, Crow, Nez Perce, and Flathead nations attended most of the rendezvous. ... The route Sublette used to the Pierre's Hole rendezvous did ...
  21. [21]
    Battle of Pierre's Hole, Idaho - Legends of America
    Pierre's Hole, as it was then called, or Teton Basin, its present name, is one of those valleys that are a veritable oasis in the desert of rugged mountains.Missing: definition | Show results with:definition
  22. [22]
    William Sublette, Facts, History, Fur Trade, APUSH
    Nov 15, 2023 · In 1832, he led a supply expedition to the Pierre's Hole Rendezvous, joined by Nathaniel Wyeth and Campbell. On July 18, he led trappers at ...
  23. [23]
    Pierre's Hole - The Historical Marker Database
    Teton Valley was known originally as Pierre's Hole. Rich in beaver, it was a favorite stamping ground for British and American fur traders and trappers ...Missing: definition | Show results with:definition
  24. [24]
    "The Settlement of Teton Valley, Idaho-Wyoming" by David Brooks ...
    1882 when permanent agricultural settlers entered the valley. Hundreds of people followed, many of whom were Mormons from Utah.
  25. [25]
    Teton Valley Museum – Preserving Past, Present, & Future Legacies
    Besides exhibits of artifacts, Teton Valley Museum includes a library of local history with nearly one thousand life and family histories and thousands of ...Missing: Pierre's Hole commemorations events
  26. [26]
    2022 Rendezvous - Tetons United
    2023 RENDEZVOUS SEPTEMBER 14-17. 190 years ago in 1832 about 1000 mountain men and native Americans gathered in Pierre's Hole (Teton Valley). It was one of ...Missing: reenactment | Show results with:reenactment
  27. [27]
    The Adventures of Captain Bonneville, by Washington Irving
    Fitzpatrick, the partner of the company who was resident at that time beyond the mountains, came down from the rendezvous at Pierre's Hole to meet them and ...
  28. [28]
    2024 National Fur Trade Symposium - Museum of the Mountain Man
    National Fur Trade Symposium 1824 The Eve of Rendezvous at the Museum of the Mountain Man, Pinedale, Wyoming A Bicentennial Event: September 12-15, 2024.Missing: commemorations | Show results with:commemorations