Fact-checked by Grok 2 weeks ago

Regular space

In topology, a regular space is a Hausdorff topological space in which open sets can separate any point from any closed set not containing it; specifically, for every closed subset F of the space X and every point x \notin F, there exist disjoint open sets U_x and V_x such that x \in U_x and F \subseteq V_x. This separation axiom, often denoted as T_3 when combined with the Hausdorff condition, ensures a level of "niceness" in the topology that allows for stronger continuity properties and embedding results. Regular spaces form a key part of the hierarchy of separation axioms, positioned strictly between Hausdorff (T_2) spaces and (T_4) spaces, where the latter requires disjoint closed sets to be separable by disjoint open sets. Equivalent formulations include the property that every open neighborhood of a point contains a closed neighborhood of that point. Notably, is preserved under subspaces and arbitrary products, making it a stable property for constructing more complex spaces from simpler ones. However, not all spaces are ; counterexamples exist, though every second-countable space (e.g., with a countable basis) is . Examples of regular spaces abound in familiar settings: all spaces are (in fact, ), including Euclidean spaces \mathbb{R}^n with the standard and any manifold, as their local Euclidean structure induces a . The real line \mathbb{R} under the usual is , as balls around points and complements of closed sets can be separated by disjoint intervals. plays a crucial role in advanced theorems, such as , which guarantees continuous real-valued functions separating points from closed sets in spaces (extending to contexts), and the Urysohn metrization theorem, stating that every second-countable, is metrizable. These properties underpin much of and analysis, ensuring spaces support continuous extensions and approximations essential for studying embeddings and .

Definitions and Terminology

Formal Definition

In , a space is defined as follows: Let (X, \tau) be a , where \tau denotes the collection of open sets. The space X is if, for every point x \in X and every C \subseteq X such that x \notin C, there exist disjoint open sets U, V \in \tau with x \in U and C \subseteq V. An equivalent point-set formulation states that X is , for every C \subseteq X and every point x \in X \setminus C, there exists an open neighborhood U \in \tau of x such that the \mathrm{cl}(U) (with respect to \tau) satisfies \mathrm{cl}(U) \cap C = \emptyset. This separation condition constitutes the core regular axiom, often denoted R_2, and serves as the initial motivation for the T_3 separation axiom in the absence of the Hausdorff (T_2) assumption. A T3 space is a topological space that is both and T1, meaning that for every point x not contained in a closed set F, there exist disjoint open sets U containing x and V containing F. This separation property ensures that points can be distinguished from s not containing them via open neighborhoods, building on the regular condition while incorporating the T1 axiom for finite set closures. The terminology for T3 spaces exhibits variations across texts; some definitions include the T0 or T1 axiom instead of or alongside , but the standard modern usage specifies regular plus (Hausdorff) to guarantee the implications hold without ambiguity, as regular + T1 implies . To circumvent these inconsistencies, the phrase "regular " is often preferred in contemporary literature, emphasizing the combined properties explicitly. The notion of T3 spaces traces its origins to early 20th-century developments in , with spaces first defined by Vietoris in 1921 and the T-notation for separation axioms formalized by Alexandroff and Hopf in their 1935 textbook to resolve terminological ambiguities. Mathematicians like Kuratowski contributed related foundational work on operators in 1922, influencing the precise articulation of these axioms amid evolving understandings of separation in topological structures. In contrast, preregular spaces weaken the Hausdorff condition, requiring only that topologically distinguishable points—those not sharing all neighborhoods—can be separated by disjoint open sets, whereas in T3 spaces, all distinct points are separable regardless.

Separation Axioms Framework

Comparisons with Other Axioms

A space, as defined in this article (a satisfying the point-closed set separation axiom, equivalent to the T3 axiom), implies the preregular axiom (also denoted R1 or T_{3.5}), which requires that any two topologically distinguishable points can be separated by disjoint open neighborhoods. Since spaces are (T2), they also imply the T1 and T0 axioms. As a separation property, regularity occupies a position between the Hausdorff axiom (T2, which it includes) and normality (T4). Specifically, a regular space is T3 by definition in this convention, implying T2, T1, and T0. Note that in some modern sources, "regular" refers only to the point-closed set separation without Hausdorff, but here it includes it to align with traditional usage where regular is synonymous with T3. The key implications involving regularity and adjacent axioms can be summarized as follows:
From \ ToPreregular (R1)T0T1T2 (Hausdorff)T3T4 (Normal + T1)
RegularYesYesYesYesYesNo

Hierarchy and Implications

In the hierarchy of separation axioms, spaces (T3) occupy a position between spaces (T2) and spaces (T4). A topological space is (T3) if and only if it is (T2) and satisfies the regularity separation axiom. A space becomes (T4) if it satisfies additional conditions such as paracompactness. Regular spaces link to complete regularity (T3.5), where points and closed sets are separated not just by disjoint open neighborhoods but by continuous real-valued functions; every completely regular Hausdorff space is regular (T3), but the converse does not hold, as there exist regular spaces that are not completely regular. A significant metrizability implication arises via the Urysohn metrization theorem: every second-countable regular space admits a compatible , rendering it metrizable. Regarding , older texts often use "" to mean what is here called (including Hausdorff, i.e., T3), while some modern sources distinguish the pure separation property from T3; this article follows the former for consistency. spaces support constructions where, for a closed , the resulting inherits separation properties like Hausdorffness from the original structure.

Properties

Elementary Properties

In a regular space, every point possesses a local base consisting of closed neighborhoods. This means that for each point x and every open neighborhood U of x, there exists a closed neighborhood V of x such that V \subseteq U. To see this, consider the closed set C = X \setminus U, which does not contain x. By the definition of regularity, there exist disjoint open sets G containing x and H containing C. Define W = G \cap U, which is an open neighborhood of x contained in U. The closure \overline{W} satisfies \overline{W} \subseteq \overline{G} \subseteq X \setminus H \subseteq U, since \overline{G} \cap H = \emptyset. Thus, \overline{W} is a closed neighborhood of x inside U. This construction shows that the closed neighborhoods form a fundamental system at x. The product of any collection of spaces, equipped with the , is itself . This holds for both finite and infinite products, as the separation property for points and closed sets can be lifted componentwise using the projections and the tube lemma for finite cases or diagonal arguments for infinite ones. Closed subspaces of spaces are . More generally, every of a space inherits regularity, since closed sets in the subspace are intersections with closed sets in the ambient space, and the applies relative to the .

Advanced Characterizations

In a topological space, a regular open set is defined as an open set U such that U = \operatorname{int}(\operatorname{cl}(U)), where \operatorname{int} denotes the interior and \operatorname{cl} the closure. This property ensures that regular open sets are "doubly open" in a sense, capturing sets that are stable under taking the interior after closure. The collection of all regular open sets forms a complete Heyting algebra with respect to inclusion, closed under arbitrary intersections, where the meet is set intersection and the join is the interior of the closure of the union. A key characterization of regular spaces involves these regular open sets: a topological space is regular if and only if every open set can be expressed as a union of regular open sets. More precisely, for any open set V, V is the union of all open subsets U \subseteq V such that \operatorname{cl}(U) \subseteq V, and each such U is regular open. In regular spaces, the regular open sets thus form a basis for the topology, providing a structured way to approximate arbitrary open sets while preserving separation properties. Regarding relations to stronger separation axioms, in spaces, specific types of open covers admit refinements that are . For instance, if a space is paracompact, every open cover has a locally finite open refinement, which, combined with the availability of disjoint closed neighborhoods, yields a refinement separating disjoint closed sets; this implies that paracompact spaces are . Regular open sets and the structure of spaces play a role in constructing paracompact spaces, as regularity facilitates the refinement of covers into locally finite families using closed neighborhoods.

Examples

Positive Examples

Euclidean spaces provide fundamental examples of spaces. The \mathbb{R}^n equipped with the standard induced by the is , as it satisfies the T3 , allowing disjoint open sets to separate any point from a not containing it. Specifically, the real line \mathbb{R} with its standard is a one-dimensional instance of this, where open intervals serve as a basis for separating points and s. More broadly, any that is Hausdorff is . In such spaces, the induces a where balls of sufficiently small around a point and around points of a can be made disjoint, ensuring the regularity condition holds. This includes all metrizable Hausdorff spaces, which inherit regularity from the underlying structure. The on any set furnishes another straightforward example of a space. In this , every subset is open (and closed), so singleton sets—being both open and closed—naturally separate any point from a disjoint , satisfying the regularity . Finite products of spaces also yield spaces under the product topology. For instance, the product of finitely many copies of \mathbb{R}^n remains , preserving the separation properties through projections and slices of open sets. Examples from completely spaces, which are a strengthening of regularity, further illustrate the axiom. Topological manifolds, being locally Euclidean and Hausdorff, are completely and thus . Similarly, compact Hausdorff spaces are normal—and hence —due to their ability to separate disjoint closed sets with disjoint open sets via compactness arguments.

Counterexamples

The line with two origins, also known as the doubled origin line, is constructed as the quotient space of two disjoint copies of the real line \mathbb{R}, where points are identified except at the origin, resulting in two distinct origin points o_1 and o_2. This space is T_1 (points are closed) but neither Hausdorff nor , as the point o_1 cannot be separated from the closed set \{o_2\} by disjoint open neighborhoods, since any neighborhood of o_1 intersects every neighborhood of o_2. The K-topology on the real line, denoted \mathbb{R}_K, is the topology generated by the standard open sets together with sets of the form U \setminus K, where U is open in the standard topology and K = \{1/n \mid n \in \mathbb{N}\} is the fixed compact set. This space is Hausdorff, since the standard topology is Hausdorff and the additional basis elements refine separations, but it is not : the point $0 cannot be separated from the closed set K by disjoint open neighborhoods, as any neighborhood of K in \mathbb{R}_K must include points arbitrarily close to $0. On an infinite set X with the finite complement topology (also called the cofinite topology), where open sets are those with finite complements (or the empty set), the space is T_1 because singletons are closed (their complements are cofinite, hence open), but it is not regular: for distinct points x, y \in X and the closed set \{y\} not containing x, any open neighborhood of \{y\} is cofinite and thus intersects every cofinite neighborhood of x, preventing disjoint separation. The Sorgenfrey line, or on \mathbb{R}, has basis consisting of half-open intervals [a, b) for a < b. This space is regular (in fact, T_3), as closed sets are F_\sigma and can be separated from points using countable unions of basis elements to ensure disjointness, but its square, the Sorgenfrey plane, fails normality despite being regular, illustrating that regularity does not imply higher separation properties like normality in products. The Zariski topology on an affine algebraic variety over an infinite field, such as \mathbb{A}^1_k = k with closed sets as finite subsets (zeros of polynomials), is T_1 since singletons are closed, but not regular: for a point x and closed set C = \{y\} with y \neq x, any open neighborhood of C is cofinite and intersects every cofinite neighborhood of x, so no disjoint open sets exist to separate them.

References

  1. [1]
    [PDF] Normal Spaces, Regular Spaces, Urysohn metrization. Definition.
    NORMAL SPACES, REGULAR SPACES, URYSOHN METRIZATION. Definition. A topological space X is normal if it is Hausdorff and open sets separate disjoint closed sets: ...
  2. [2]
    regular space in nLab
    Nov 30, 2023 · A regular space is a topological space (or variation, such as a locale) that has, in a certain sense, enough regular open subspaces.
  3. [3]
    [PDF] the intersection of topological and metric spaces - UChicago Math
    We can show that all metric spaces are normal. Proof. Take a topological space X with the metric topology defined upon it and two disjoint closed sets C1,C2.
  4. [4]
    [PDF] General Topology
    §2◦1 Definition of Topological Space. Let X be a set. Let Ω be a collection ... A regular space is a Hausdorff space. 14.Q. A space is regular iff it ...
  5. [5]
    Regular Space -- from Wolfram MathWorld
    A regular space is a topological space in which every neighborhood of a point contains a closed neighborhood of the same point.
  6. [6]
  7. [7]
    T_3-Space -- from Wolfram MathWorld
    A topological space fulfilling the T3-separation axiom: fulfils the T1-separation axiom and is regular. According to the terminology of Alexandroff and Hopf ( ...Missing: definition | Show results with:definition
  8. [8]
    T3 space - PlanetMath
    Mar 22, 2013 · A T3 space is a regular space where points and closed sets can be separated by open sets, and it is also a T0 space.
  9. [9]
    [PDF] 9. Stronger separation axioms
    A topological space (X,Τ ) is said to be regular if for any x ∈ X and any closed set C not containing x, there are disjoint open sets U and V such that x ∈ U ...
  10. [10]
    [PDF] MA-231 Topology - IISc Math
    Nov 29, 2004 · This attitude is typified in the Bourbaki school where “regular” means what we call T3, “normal” means what we call T4 and even the definition ...<|control11|><|separator|>
  11. [11]
    Preregular and locally compact implies regular - Math Stack Exchange
    May 8, 2015 · Definition: A topological space X is called preregular if whenever two points x and y do not share all their neighbourhoods, they have two ...Locally compact preregular spaces are completely regularIf a space is covered by two closed preregular subsets, is the space ...More results from math.stackexchange.com
  12. [12]
    Regular implies preregular - Topospaces
    Jan 28, 2012 · This article gives the statement and possibly, proof, of an implication relation between two topological space properties.Missing: T0? | Show results with:T0?
  13. [13]
    [PDF] A survey of Kolmogorov quotients arXiv:1905.01157v2 [math.GN] 2 ...
    Dec 2, 2021 · In section 7, we will see that pseudometric spaces are completely regular, and consequently their Kolmogorov quotients are Tychonoff (see table ...
  14. [14]
    Separation Axioms -- from Wolfram MathWorld
    1. T1-separation axiom: For any two points x,y in X there exists two open sets U and V such that x in U and y not in U , and y in V · 2. T2-separation axiom: For ...
  15. [15]
    [PDF] 15. Urysohn's metrization theorem
    Every second countable T3 topological space is metrizable. Note that even though second countability, separability, and ccc-ness are equivalent in every.
  16. [16]
    [PDF] topology: the journey into separation axioms
    A topological space is said to be T3(defined) if it is regular and points are closed. ... The lower separation properties (T2, T1 and T0) are a source of ...
  17. [17]
    [PDF] Section 31. The Separation Axioms
    Aug 30, 2016 · Recall that a topological space X is Hausdorff if for any x, y ∈ X with x 6= y, there are disjoint open sets U and V with x ∈ U and y ∈ V . In ...
  18. [18]
    [PDF] MA651 Topology. Lecture 6. Separation Axioms.
    Proposition 38.3. If every point x of a topological space X has a closed neighborhood which is a regular subspace of X, then X is regular.
  19. [19]
    [PDF] A First Course in Geometry and Topology - McGill University
    The product of regular spaces is a regular space. Page 93. 3.3. SEPARATION AXIOMS. 85. Proof. Let {Xα } be a family of regular spaces. In particular, every Xα ...<|control11|><|separator|>
  20. [20]
  21. [21]
    General Topology - Stephen Willard - Google Books
    Jul 12, 2012 · Among the best available reference introductions to general topology, this volume is appropriate for advanced undergraduate and beginning graduate students.
  22. [22]
    Between an open set and its closed subset - MathOverflow
    Oct 9, 2021 · A topological space is regular if and only if every open V is the union of those opens U⊆V satisfying ¯U⊆V. Then use that R∖F is regular.
  23. [23]
    regular space in nLab
    ### Summary of Regular Spaces from nLab
  24. [24]
    [PDF] Section 32. Normal Spaces
    Aug 20, 2016 · Every regular space with a countable basis is normal. Note ... Hausdorff by not regular: RK (R under the K-topology; Example 1 of Section.
  25. [25]
  26. [26]
    Regularity is product-closed - Topospaces
    Jul 20, 2008 · Property-theoretic statement. The property of topological spaces of being a regular space is a product-closed property of topological spaces.
  27. [27]
    [PDF] 4 COMPACTNESS AXIOMS
    Theorem 4.7 Every compact Hausdorff space is normal. Proof. Let A and B be disjoint closed subsets of the compact Hausdorff space X. Then A and. B are compact.<|control11|><|separator|>
  28. [28]
    The line with two origins - Math Counterexamples
    Jul 17, 2016 · The line with two origins is the set X topologized by taking as base the collection B of all open intervals in R that do not contain 0.
  29. [29]
    finite complement topology - PlanetMath.org
    Mar 22, 2013 · The finite complement topology is the coarsest T1-topology on a given set. Title, finite complement topology. Canonical name ...
  30. [30]
    [PDF] 0.1 The Zariski topology - Algebraic geometry (Notes)
    — The Zariski topology has very few open sets, and as a result has terrible separation properties. It is not even Hausdorff (except in very small examples).