Fact-checked by Grok 2 weeks ago

Rob Schenck

Robert Leonard Schenck (born 1958) is an American evangelical minister and former leader in the pro-life movement who, for over three decades, organized protests, clinic blockades, and policy advocacy against abortion, including as a key figure in Operation Rescue and founder of the Washington, D.C.-based Faith and Action ministry.^[1]^[2] Ordained for more than 40 years with advanced degrees in theology and ministry, Schenck converted to evangelical Christianity as a teenager from a Jewish family background and built a career ministering to political elites, delivering Capitol prayers, and facilitating interfaith dialogues, such as a 2006 evangelical-Muslim exchange with Moroccan leaders.^[1]^[3] His activism included arrests for civil disobedience and founding groups like Operation Higher Court to bolster conservative judicial appointments, but in his 2018 memoir Costly Grace, he described a profound shift—his "third conversion"—prompted by regret over manipulative tactics, such as staging graphic fetal displays for emotional impact rather than factual persuasion, leading him to publicly endorse Roe v. Wade, support gun restrictions, and criticize fusionist alliances between evangelicalism and partisan politics as distortions of faith.^[1]^[2]^[4] Now heading the Dietrich Bonhoeffer Institute, Schenck's trajectory highlights tensions within evangelical circles over tactics, influence, and doctrinal application to public policy.^[1]

Early Life and Education

Family and Upbringing

Robert Schenck was born in 1958 to a Jewish father and a mother who had converted to Judaism.^[5] He has an identical twin brother, Paul, with whom he shared a close sibling bond during their formative years.^[3] The family maintained a nominally Jewish household, characterized by limited religious observance and greater alignment with secular cultural norms prevalent in mid-20th-century American Jewish communities.^[6] Schenck and his brother were raised primarily in Grand Island, New York, near Buffalo, an environment that exposed them to the industrial and suburban dynamics of upstate New York during the post-World War II era.^[6] This setting, distant from orthodox religious centers, contributed to a childhood steeped in mainstream American secularism rather than intensive faith practices, fostering an initial worldview oriented toward cultural Judaism without deep theological engagement.^[3] Specific family socioeconomic details remain sparsely documented, but the context suggests a typical middle-class stability amid regional economic shifts.^[6]

Religious Conversion and Theological Training

Schenck, born into a nominally Jewish family, underwent a born-again conversion to evangelical Christianity in 1974 at age 16 in Montclair, New Jersey. Influenced by his twin brother Paul, who had already embraced the faith, Schenck began attending Bible studies and youth services at a local Methodist church, where he encountered the straightforward evangelical message of God's universal love as presented in the Gospel of John.^[6] ^[7] This personal pivot, driven by doctrinal appeal rather than overt crisis, led him to accompany his brother to prayer meetings and ultimately to baptism in the Niagara River, solidifying his commitment to Bible-believing Christianity.^[3] Following his conversion, Schenck sought formal theological preparation to equip himself for ministry. He enrolled at Faith Evangelical Seminary (now Faith International University) in Tacoma, Washington, where he earned a Doctor of Ministry degree, alongside bachelor's and master's qualifications in Bible, theology, religion, and Christian ministry.^[8] ^[9] His advanced studies emphasized strategic leadership with a concentration in the theology of church and state, reflecting early fundamentalist interpretations that prioritized scriptural absolutism on moral and societal issues.^[1] These influences fostered a worldview viewing evangelical faith as demanding uncompromising application to public life, setting the stage for his subsequent activism without yet delving into practical outreach.

Initial Ministry and Activism

Early Religious Affiliations and Preaching

Schenck affiliated with evangelical Pentecostal networks following his conversion to Christianity in the late 1970s, attending evangelical Bible college and seminary for theological training.^[8] In 1982, he was ordained as a minister by the New York District Presbytery of the Assemblies of God, a denomination emphasizing spiritual gifts, biblical inerrancy, and evangelistic outreach.^[10] He later transferred his credentials to the Independent Assemblies of God International in 1986, maintaining ties to independent evangelical circles focused on charismatic worship and moral reform.^[10] Early in his ministry during the 1980s, Schenck undertook pastoring responsibilities and evangelistic preaching in pulpits across the United States, often as a guest speaker in local churches.^[1] His sermons emphasized personal salvation through repentance and faith in Christ, underscoring moral absolutes such as the inherent sinfulness of humanity and the necessity of biblical obedience for righteous living.^[5] These messages drew from a literal interpretation of Scripture, portraying divine judgment and redemption as urgent realities demanding immediate response. Schenck's preaching style emerged as prophetic and forthright, emulating biblical figures who issued bold rebukes against ethical compromise to provoke conviction and change.^[11] Rooted in evangelical literalism, this unyielding rhetoric prioritized direct confrontation of spiritual failings over accommodation, fostering a pattern of public moral exhortation that characterized his initial ministerial approach.^[12]

Founding of Faithwalk and Street Evangelism

In 1988, Reverend Robert Schenck, then an Assembly of God minister, founded Operation Serve International and launched the Faithwalk, a 2,000-mile trek from Buffalo, New York, to the U.S.-Mexico border.^[13] This mobile initiative sought to draw national awareness to the extreme poverty faced by Mexican migrants and residents, including those scavenging in garbage dumps, through public demonstrations and on-the-ground advocacy.^[13] The six-month journey embodied Schenck's commitment to hands-on evangelism, aligning with evangelical emphases on active witness as derived from scriptural calls to proclaim the gospel amid human suffering.^[11] Faithwalk's tactics emphasized direct, confrontational outreach: Schenck halted along routes to engage travelers and communities with personal testimonies, impromptu preaching, and appeals for support, innovating beyond traditional pulpit ministry by leveraging mobility and spectacle to interrupt daily life and compel response.^[13] These street-level interventions—conducted roadside and in public spaces—prioritized unmediated encounters over institutional channels, fostering immediate conversions and volunteer commitments during stops.^[14] The effort's dramatic scale, traversing diverse urban and rural terrains, amplified its visibility, generating recruitment for missionary teams and laying groundwork for sustained operations.^[13] The initiative yielded tangible outcomes, including the dispatch of four mission teams to Mexico City by OSI in subsequent years and formal evaluations for expanded fieldwork by 1991, marking early validation of Schenck's public confrontation model.^[13] While not yet focused on domestic policy battles, Faithwalk's fusion of peripatetic preaching and advocacy prefigured Schenck's later escalations in visibility-driven activism, demonstrating efficacy in mobilizing adherents through bold, embodied witness.^[11]

Peak Anti-Abortion Advocacy

Leadership in Operation Rescue and Clinic Blockades

Schenck assumed a prominent leadership role in Operation Rescue during the late 1980s and early 1990s, directing activists in non-violent civil disobedience tactics centered on physically obstructing access to abortion clinics to halt procedures.^[2] As part of this strategy, he organized training sessions emphasizing disciplined, prayerful blockades where participants would sit, kneel, or link arms at clinic entrances, accepting arrest as a moral witness against abortion.^[11] These efforts aligned with Operation Rescue's founding principles under Randall Terry in 1986, scaling up from local protests to coordinated national campaigns that prioritized direct intervention over legislative advocacy.^[15] A focal point of Schenck's involvement was the 1992 "Spring of Life" demonstrations in Buffalo, New York, where he coordinated blockades targeting multiple clinics to force temporary shutdowns.^[2] On April 21, 1992, Schenck was arrested after displaying a preserved 19-week fetus to counter-protesters outside a High Street clinic, an act intended to visceralize the stakes of abortion.^[16] Two days later, on April 23, approximately 194 demonstrators, including Schenck's associates, were arrested during a mass blockade attempt, with protesters marching and occupying entrances in hopes of preventing patient access.^[17] Schenck's brother Paul was also arrested alongside him in related actions, highlighting familial coordination in these high-stakes operations.^[18] These blockades achieved short-term disruptions, such as delayed appointments and reinforced security measures at targeted facilities, but clinics in Buffalo persisted in operations despite the pressure.^[19] Nationwide, Operation Rescue actions under leaders like Schenck contributed to over 2,000 arrests in similar 1991 Wichita blockades, amplifying media coverage and public contention over abortion access, though empirical data shows no permanent closures directly attributable to these specific tactics in Buffalo. The arrests and confrontations underscored the movement's reliance on saturation protests to impose operational costs on clinics, fostering conditions that deterred some providers amid escalating legal and physical risks.^[11]

National Pro-Life Campaigns and Capitol Events

Schenck directed the annual National Memorial for the Pre-Born and Their Mothers and Fathers, a large-scale pro-life event held indoors at the U.S. Capitol complex in Washington, D.C., which he described as the only major Capitol-focused gathering of its kind.^[8] This event, organized through his leadership in pro-life advocacy, featured speeches by figures such as Fr. Frank Pavone and drew participants to commemorate aborted fetuses and advocate for legislative protections, occurring yearly during the era of heightened national debates on abortion restrictions.^[20] In conjunction with broader events like the March for Life rally, Schenck emphasized shifting social and political momentum toward life-affirming policies, appealing directly to lawmakers present in the Capitol.^[21] Parallel to these Capitol gatherings, Schenck launched the Ten Commandments Project in 1995, distributing over 400 plaques bearing the biblical text to members of Congress as symbolic appeals for restoring moral foundations to public policy, including abortion regulation.^[22] The initiative aimed to defend religious expression in government settings, framing the Commandments as a cultural bulwark against moral decay, with Schenck personally presenting monuments and advocating for their placement in public venues.^[23] He supported efforts like the 2003 rally for Alabama Judge Roy Moore's courthouse Ten Commandments monument, positioning such displays as essential to legislative integrity on issues like abortion.^[24] These campaigns coincided with a surge in state-level abortion restrictions during the late 1990s and early 2000s, including parental notification laws enacted in 28 states by 2000 and partial-birth abortion bans in over a dozen states following federal advocacy pushes. While direct causation to Schenck's events is unestablished, his appeals to federal legislators aligned with this trend, as pro-life groups lobbied for measures like waiting periods and clinic regulations that saw adoption in states such as Ohio, where he backed related monument defenses as part of a broader cultural strategy.

Advocacy for Religious Symbols and Monuments

Schenck actively supported Alabama Chief Justice Roy Moore's installation of a 5,280-pound granite Ten Commandments monument in the state judicial building rotunda in 2001, viewing it as an acknowledgment of the moral foundation of American law rooted in Judeo-Christian principles.^[25] In 2003, following a federal court order for its removal on grounds of endorsing religion, Schenck recruited congressional co-sponsors for resolutions defending Moore and led protests at the Alabama Judicial Building in Montgomery to protest the monument's extraction.^[26] He argued that such displays transcended specific religious endorsement, serving instead as a universal moral code underpinning U.S. legal traditions, and contended they were constitutional based on historical precedents of religious influence in the nation's founding documents and public acknowledgments of God.^[27] Through his organization Faith and Action, Schenck spearheaded the placement of an 850-pound Ten Commandments monument on private property adjacent to the U.S. Capitol in Washington, D.C., unveiled on June 7, 2006, in collaboration with activist Patrick Mahoney, to symbolize the biblical roots of American governance amid growing secular challenges.^[23] The initiative aimed to preserve cultural heritage by visibly linking public institutions to Judeo-Christian ethics, drawing on arguments that America's founding reflected providential religious assumptions rather than strict secularism.^[28] The monument endured initial legal scrutiny but faced vandalism in September 2013, when intruders bent its steel frame; Schenck's group repaired and re-dedicated it on October 28, 2013, angling it toward the Capitol to reinforce its symbolic orientation toward legislative authority.^[29]^[30] These efforts highlighted Schenck's broader campaign to counter court rulings like the 2003 Alabama decision by emphasizing empirical historical ties between biblical law and U.S. jurisprudence, such as the Decalogue's influence on early legal codes, while navigating First Amendment constraints through private installations to avoid direct government endorsement claims.^[31] Outcomes included sustained visibility for the D.C. monument post-repair, contrasting with Moore's removal, and reflected public sentiment where polls showed majority support for Ten Commandments displays in government buildings as non-coercive heritage markers, though such metrics varied by region and framing.^[27]

Judicial and Political Engagement

Establishment of Faith and Action

In 1995, Rob Schenck established Faith and Action in Washington, D.C., after relocating from Buffalo, New York, to launch a dedicated evangelical outreach aimed at influencing government officials and policymakers through personal ministry rather than public protests.^[32] The organization functioned as a nonprofit ministry, structured to integrate direct evangelism—such as Bible studies and pastoral counseling—with advocacy on issues aligned with conservative Christian values, positioning itself strategically near key power centers including the U.S. Capitol and Supreme Court to facilitate access to elites.^[1]^[32] Unlike Schenck's prior involvement in street-level activism with groups like Operation Rescue, Faith and Action emphasized discreet, relational engagement with politicians and judicial figures, framing its mission as applying biblical principles to the decision-making processes of those in authority. This model prioritized long-term spiritual influence over confrontational tactics, operating as a "missionary outpost" in the capital to pastor individuals in positions of power.^[33] The group's operational framework included hosting private events and providing resources for faith-based networking among conservative leaders, distinguishing it from broader grassroots pro-life efforts by focusing on insider access and personal conversion as pathways to policy impact.^[34] Schenck led the organization until 2018, during which it raised significant funds to sustain its D.C.-centric activities.^[35]

Supreme Court Influence Strategies

Schenck established Operation Higher Court in 2000 under the auspices of Faith and Action to forge personal ties between affluent conservative donors and sympathetic Supreme Court justices, with the objective of reinforcing conservative judicial resolve through moral and spiritual support aligned with evangelical values.^[35] ^[33] The initiative formalized recruitment efforts beginning in 2001–2002, targeting independently wealthy couples from evangelical networks, such as business owners encountered at church events, to serve as informal intermediaries.^[32] ^[33] Approximately 20 such couples participated over the program's two-decade span, which concluded in 2018.^[32] ^[36] Participants received verbal briefings on engagement protocols, emphasizing subtle encouragement via rehearsed affirmations like affirming the justices' providential role, while avoiding direct discussion of judicial matters.^[32] ^[33] Strategies encompassed donor-hosted retreats at private estates, including out-of-town properties for extended hospitality; upscale dinners at Washington venues; personalized gifts such as engraved Ten Commandments plaques presented as early as 2006; and recreational outings like hunting or fishing expeditions.^[32] ^[33] Schenck personally facilitated private audiences, including chamber visits accompanied by prayers, to nurture these connections.^[33] Empirical indicators of sustained access included donors' reports of rapport-building successes, such as repeated invitations and interactions spanning years, as relayed to Schenck.^[32] ^[33] A 2008 reception hosted by Schenck for 40 leading donors underscored the network's scale, integrating high-level supporters into the influence ecosystem.^[33] These methods, drawn from Schenck's congressional testimony and contemporaneous accounts, reflect a deliberate, donor-leveraged approach to judicial enculturation.^[37] ^[33]

Role in Key Legal Cases and Lobbying Efforts

Schenck, through his organization Faith and Action, engaged in targeted lobbying to support religious liberty claims in Burwell v. Hobby Lobby Stores, Inc. (2014), where the Supreme Court ruled 5-4 that closely held corporations could claim religious exemptions from the Affordable Care Act's contraception mandate. He mobilized evangelical donors and coordinated private receptions attended by court insiders, which facilitated advance knowledge of the decision's favorable outcome approximately six weeks prior to its June 30, 2014, announcement; this information, relayed via a major donor connected to Justice Samuel Alito's family, enabled Schenck to secure commitments from figures like Hobby Lobby president Steve Green to fund pro-life initiatives post-ruling.^[33]^[38] Such efforts exemplified his strategy of donor cultivation tied to anticipated judicial victories, amplifying financial resources for broader anti-abortion advocacy.^[35] In Dobbs v. Jackson Women's Health Organization (2022), Schenck's lobbying contributed to the 6-3 decision overturning Roe v. Wade by embedding advocacy language into Justice Alito's majority opinion, including phrases like "the Constitution makes no reference to abortion" that mirrored arguments from his group's Capitol Hill briefings and amicus-style inputs to conservative networks.^[39] He organized prayer vigils and private sessions on Supreme Court grounds with Justices Alito, Clarence Thomas, and John Roberts, urging bolder interpretations of fetal personhood and state authority over abortion regulation; these interactions, spanning years, built relational influence absent from formal amicus curiae filings.^[40] Post-decision on June 24, 2022, Schenck publicly credited the outcome to decades of sustained pro-life pressure, including clinic blockades and legislative pushes, which eroded Roe's precedential weight through empirical demonstration of public opposition and state-level restrictions.^[41] These efforts yielded verifiable policy shifts: following Dobbs, 14 states enacted near-total abortion bans by mid-2023, with Guttmacher Institute data showing a 2023 national abortion rate drop to 11.0 per 1,000 women aged 15-44 from 13.5 in 2020, reflecting causal impacts from judicial deference to state interests over federal privacy rights. Schenck's donor mobilization also funneled millions into allied groups, sustaining litigation that challenged remaining restrictions and advanced religious exemptions in subsequent cases.^[33]

Evolution of Views and Later Activities

Response to Sandy Hook and Gun Reform Advocacy

The Sandy Hook Elementary School shooting on December 14, 2012, in which 20 children and 6 adults were killed by a gunman using a semiautomatic rifle, served as a pivotal catalyst for Rev. Rob Schenck's reevaluation of evangelical support for unrestricted gun ownership.^[42] Previously aligned with conservative positions favoring broad Second Amendment rights, Schenck described being horrified by the massacre's scale and the use of high-capacity firearms, prompting him to question the consistency of a "pro-life" ethic that tolerated such vulnerabilities in gun culture.^[42] ^[43] This event led him to visit a rifle range, where the crack of gunfire evoked the tragedy and intensified his concerns about the normalization of lethal weapons in American religious communities.^[43] Schenck's introspection extended to critiquing evangelical gun culture, noting its statistical overrepresentation among white Christians who owned firearms at higher rates than the general population and resisted reforms despite empirical evidence of mass shooting frequencies—such as the 300-plus incidents annually by the mid-2010s, often involving legally purchased weapons.^[3] ^[44] He argued that churches, as moral authorities, bore responsibility for addressing this disconnect, urging pastors to preach against idolatry of guns over human life based on data showing preventable deaths from accessible high-powered arms.^[45] ^[46] In 2015, Schenck participated in the documentary The Armor of Light, directed by Abigail E. Disney and premiered at the Tribeca Film Festival, which chronicled his emerging advocacy alongside gun control activist Lucy McBath, mother of a teen killed in a 2012 shooting.^[47] ^[48] The film highlighted his initial media engagements challenging fellow evangelicals to reconcile pro-gun stances with biblical sanctity-of-life principles, framing gun violence as a public health crisis demanding ecclesiastical intervention rather than political deflection.^[47] ^[49]

Public Repudiation of Evangelical Activism

In 2018, Schenck began publicly disavowing the militant tactics of his prior anti-abortion activism, describing them as manipulative and counterproductive to genuine moral persuasion. In a July NPR interview, he expressed regret for blockading clinics and other aggressive confrontations, asserting that abortion decisions should be left to "an individual and his or her conscience" rather than enforced through bans or coercion.^[11] This shift marked a departure from his decades-long role in Operation Rescue, where he had orchestrated direct-action protests involving hundreds of arrests.^[11] Schenck elaborated on these reversals in his June 2018 memoir Costly Grace: An Evangelical Minister's Rediscovery of Faith, Hope, and Love, framing his evolution as a third spiritual conversion that rejected the political instrumentalization of evangelical faith for partisan ends.^[50] He argued for conscience-driven resolutions over legislative prohibitions, critiquing the movement's reliance on fear-based rhetoric and insider influence as ethically compromised.^[50] By May 2019, in a New York Times op-ed, Schenck endorsed Roe v. Wade, warning that its overturn would drive abortions underground, increase maternal risks, and fail to save lives—contradicting the "pro-life" label he once championed.^[2] These positions elicited backlash from former evangelical allies, who branded Schenck a "traitor" for aligning with pro-choice advocacy and undermining core doctrinal stances on fetal personhood.^[6] Critics within conservative circles questioned the consistency of his reversal, viewing it as a late-career pivot influenced by personal regret rather than scriptural fidelity, which exacerbated fractures in pro-life coalitions already strained by tactical debates.^[6] Schenck's repudiation highlighted broader evangelical divisions, with some factions defending absolutist bans while others, like him, prioritized relational ethics over confrontational absolutism.^[9]

Academic and Interfaith Pursuits

In 2023, Schenck was appointed as Visiting Scholar of Christianity and Religious Leadership at the Miller Center for Interreligious Learning and Leadership of Hebrew College, a pluralistic Jewish seminary in Newton, Massachusetts.^[51]^[52] In this capacity, he engages in interfaith dialogues, including discussions on evangelical-Jewish relations and the challenges of religious pluralism in contemporary society, as evidenced by his participation in the Hebrew College's Speaking Torah podcast series.^[53] His work at the institution emphasizes fostering mutual understanding across faith traditions while addressing authoritarian distortions of religion.^[54] Schenck founded the Dietrich Bonhoeffer Institute in Washington, D.C., in 2015, serving as its president to advance an anti-authoritarian interpretation of Christian theology modeled on the writings of Dietrich Bonhoeffer, the German Lutheran pastor who resisted Nazism.^[1]^[55] Post-2018, the institute has focused on critiquing the conflation of evangelical faith with political power, promoting Bonhoeffer's emphasis on "costly grace" and ethical witness against state idolatry, through seminars, publications, and public lectures.^[56]^[57] Schenck's writings and speeches in this period have centered on repudiating Christian nationalism, arguing that it subordinates gospel ethics to partisan ideology and erodes religious liberty. In a September 2024 article for Mother Jones, he detailed his prior involvement in such movements and advocated for a return to apolitical discipleship.^[25]^[58] He reiterated these themes in an October 2024 episode of the Reveal podcast titled "A Christian Nationalist Has Second Thoughts," where he reflected on evangelical complicity in authoritarian tendencies and called for interfaith coalitions to defend democratic norms.^[15] These efforts align with his addresses at events like the 2023 Parliament of the World's Religions in Chicago, where he urged religious leaders to prioritize pluralism over nationalist agendas.^[54]

Congressional Testimony and Media Appearances

In December 2022, Rev. Robert Schenck testified before the U.S. House Judiciary Committee during a hearing titled "Undue Influence: 'Operation Higher Court' and Politicking at SCOTUS," where he detailed a covert evangelical strategy known as Operation Higher Court aimed at recruiting wealthy donors to cultivate personal relationships with Supreme Court justices to sway rulings on abortion and other social issues.^[33] ^[59] Schenck described how he orchestrated donor access to justices, including instances of pre-decision leaks, such as a 2014 dinner where a major donor learned from Justice Samuel Alito that the Court would rule in favor of Hobby Lobby in Burwell v. Hobby Lobby Stores, Inc. before the opinion was public.^[41] ^[37] He also recounted Justice Clarence Thomas praising his anti-abortion activism and encouraging persistence, highlighting what Schenck portrayed as ethical boundary-pushing in conservative influence operations.^[60] ^[61] Schenck's testimony emphasized the lack of enforceable ethics rules for the Supreme Court, arguing that such donor-justice interactions compromised judicial impartiality, though he acknowledged these tactics were not unique to one ideological side.^[62] Committee Democrats cited his account to advocate for legislative reforms like binding ethics codes, while Republicans questioned the veracity and timing of his disclosures, given his prior alignment with the causes he critiqued.^[61] Schenck maintained that his revelations stemmed from a personal moral reckoning rather than partisan motives.^[63] In subsequent media appearances, Schenck has critiqued evangelical entanglement with Donald Trump's presidency, urging churches to disengage from partisan nationalism to preserve spiritual integrity. In a June 2020 PBS interview, he accused Trump of using the Bible as a "prop" during a photo-op amid protests, reflecting what Schenck saw as manipulative symbolism over genuine faith.^[64] By 2024, in outlets like Reveal News and Mother Jones, he warned against Christian nationalism's risks, describing Trump's appeal to evangelicals as rooted in power-seeking rather than theology and calling for clergy to prioritize scriptural principles over political loyalty.^[15] ^[25] These interventions positioned Schenck as a dissenting voice, advocating for evangelical self-examination amid ongoing debates over church-state separation.^[65]

Controversies and Criticisms

Allegations of Judicial Impropriety

In November 2022, Rob Schenck alleged that he learned the outcome of the Supreme Court's 2014 decision in Burwell v. Hobby Lobby Stores, Inc. prior to its public release, claiming that a major donor to his organization, who had dined at the home of Justice Samuel Alito, relayed details including the favorable ruling for Hobby Lobby and Alito's authorship of the majority opinion.^[35] Schenck stated this advance knowledge, obtained through an intermediary identified as the donor's wife, enabled his group to coordinate a public relations response in anticipation of the contraception mandate exemption for religious employers.^[41] He disclosed these details in a letter to Chief Justice John Roberts and during testimony before the House Judiciary Committee on December 8, 2022, framing them as part of broader "undue influence" via his "Operation Higher Court" initiative, which involved recruiting affluent evangelical donors to cultivate relationships with conservative justices through private events and hospitality.^[33]^[66] Schenck further described arranging luxury trips and entertainment for justices including Clarence Thomas, Samuel Alito, and the late Antonin Scalia, such as golf outings and retreats funded by donors, which he later characterized as crossing ethical boundaries by fostering an appearance of impropriety through undisclosed access and potential quid pro quo dynamics.^[67] These practices, he testified, extended to pre-decision "briefings" where allies received strategic insights, raising concerns among critics about violations of judicial canons prohibiting ex parte communications and the appearance of bias in cases like Hobby Lobby and subsequent rulings.^[68] Justice Alito denied leaking any information, asserting through a Supreme Court spokesperson that neither he nor his wife disclosed case details, while the implicated donor's wife refuted conveying such specifics to Schenck.^[36]^[69] Defenders of the justices, including Republican members of Congress during Schenck's 2022 testimony, countered that such interactions constituted legitimate advocacy and free speech by interest groups, comparable to left-leaning organizations' longstanding efforts to influence judicial outcomes, and did not equate to impropriety without evidence of vote alteration.^[70] They argued Schenck's allegations, emerging amid heightened scrutiny following the May 2, 2022, leak of the Dobbs v. Jackson Women's Health Organization draft opinion, lacked corroboration and reflected his personal ideological evolution rather than systemic ethical lapses, emphasizing that justices' recusals or disclosures were not required for social engagements absent direct case involvement.^[62] The Supreme Court Marshal's investigation into the Dobbs leak concluded without identifying a perpetrator, and no formal ethics probes into Schenck's specific claims against Alito or others have resulted in substantiated findings of misconduct as of 2023.^[71]

Internal Evangelical Backlash

Following his public expressions of regret over aggressive anti-abortion tactics in a 2018 NPR interview and subsequent evolution toward supporting abortion rights, Schenck encountered sharp rebukes from former pro-life allies, who branded him a "traitor" for abandoning core doctrinal commitments.^[6] Emails from erstwhile evangelical contacts labeled him "toxic" and accused him of forsaking foundational principles, with one correspondent stating, "I don’t feel very good about you, no matter what you are today."^[6] Public confrontations ensued, including an instance where a woman accosted him at an event, declaring, "You did a lot of bad stuff. You hurt a lot of people."^[6] These reactions reflected perceptions of betrayal within networks tied to groups like Operation Rescue, where Schenck had once been ordained and active, contributing to severed personal ties and the eventual dissolution of his Faith and Action organization by 2019.^[6] Schenck's advocacy for gun control measures post-Sandy Hook in 2012 drew further doctrinal critiques from conservative evangelicals, who argued that equating fetal protection with restricting firearms undermined a consistent "pro-life" ethic that encompassed self-defense rights.^[72] Christian commentators contended that his position ignored biblical precedents for personal armament, viewing it as a capitulation to secular fears rather than fidelity to scripture.^[72] This stance parted him from many fellow ministers, exacerbating isolation as he prioritized community discernment over individual gun ownership.^[3] Opposition to Christian nationalism and Donald Trump intensified the rift, with Schenck's 2020 endorsement of Joe Biden serving as the "final straw" that led to outright banishment from evangelical circles.^[15] Former allies, perceiving his rejection of Trump as idolatry and a denial of cultural warfare imperatives, ostracized him, rendering him persona non grata in conservative speaking venues and fracturing longstanding networks.^[73] By reframing evangelical political engagement as compromising gospel priorities, Schenck faced charges of apostasy, resulting in diminished invitations to address traditionalist audiences and a broader exile from the religious right.^[74]

Questions on Ideological Consistency

Critics, particularly from conservative and evangelical circles, have questioned the sincerity of Schenck's ideological evolution, suggesting opportunism rather than profound reflection as the primary driver. During a December 8, 2022, House Judiciary Committee hearing on Supreme Court influence, Republican members such as Chairman Jim Jordan labeled Schenck a "pathetic grifter" and dismissed his testimony as self-serving, implying his public recantations served to attract attention and funding from new audiences rather than genuine contrition.^[62]^[75] Similarly, figures like Rep. Andy Biggs argued his claims lacked credibility, portraying the shifts as a bid for relevance amid declining influence in traditional evangelical networks.^[76] A timeline of Schenck's positions underscores the abruptness of his changes, fueling doubts about causal triggers. From the 1980s through the 2010s, Schenck embodied militant conservatism, leading Operation Rescue protests and lobbying for anti-abortion rulings, including efforts around Gonzales v. Carhart in 2007. His pivot began with gun ownership views post-2012 Sandy Hook shooting, evolving into broader repudiations of absolutist stances by 2018, such as deeming abortion bans counterproductive to life preservation.^[77]^[2] While Schenck attributes this to theological reevaluation inspired by Dietrich Bonhoeffer's "costly grace"—prioritizing personal conscience over political coercion—skeptics note the shifts coincided with opportunities in progressive media, including a 2015 documentary The Armor of Light and his 2018 memoir Costly Grace, which garnered acclaim in outlets like NPR and Mother Jones.^[11]^[78] Empirical tensions arise between Schenck's former moral absolutism—insisting fetal life warranted uncompromising opposition—and his later relativism, where overturning Roe v. Wade is framed as potentially "destructive of life" due to socioeconomic harms, without equivalent emphasis on prenatal protections.^[2] Evangelical detractors have branded him a "traitor" and "turncoat" for aligning with pro-choice positions, arguing this reflects careerist adaptation to a receptive liberal ecosystem rather than consistent first-principles ethics on human dignity.^[6] Such views posit that reputational and financial incentives—evident in book sales, speaking engagements, and interfaith affiliations—outweigh claims of introspective transformation, especially given the absence of similar shifts during peak activist years.^[79]

References

[1]
[PDF] biographical sketch—rev. robert l. schenck, d.min. - Congress.gov
The Reverend Dr. Robert Lenard Schenck is an ordained evangelical minister of 40 years and the former lead missionary for Faith and Action in Nation's ...
[2]
I Was an Anti-Abortion Crusader. Now I Support Roe v. Wade.
May 30, 2019 · I was a leader of Operation Rescue, the activist pro-life group; I helped stage the epic 1992 anti-abortion demonstrations in Buffalo. I ...
[3]
'My Third Conversion': Rev. Rob Schenck On Why He Took On Gun ...
May 27, 2018 · He was born into a Jewish family, but he and his twin brother, Paul, accepted Christianity as teenagers. This is where Reverend Schenck begins ...Missing: biography | Show results with:biography
[4]
https://www.harperacademic.com/book/9780062687913/costly-grace/
[5]
Costly Grace: An Evangelical Minister's Rediscovery of Faith, Hope ...
Rob Schenck was born to a Jewish father and a mother who converted to Judaism. He became a Christian in his late teens, married Cheryl Smith a year after the ...Missing: family background
[6]
An ex-anti-abortion evangelist on life as a pro-choice 'traitor'
Jul 7, 2023 · American Reverend Rob Schenck made a name for himself denouncing 'baby killers'. Then he changed his mind.Missing: biography | Show results with:biography
[7]
My Pilgrim's Progress In And Out Of Christian Nationalism - Patheos
Mar 4, 2025 · My first conversion, in 1974, was in response to a simple, straightforward gospel of God's love for the whole world. It was to a compassionate ...
[8]
Rob Schenck - Sojourners
Rev. Rob Schenck is a former activist on the Religious Right who now identifies as a progressive evangelical. He holds a Doctor of Ministry from Faith ...
[9]
For 30 Years, I Preached that Abortion was Murder | Sojourners
Rev. Rob Schenck is a former activist on the Religious Right who now identifies as a progressive evangelical. He holds a Doctor of Ministry from Faith ...
[10]
Rob Schenck - Alchetron, The Free Social Encyclopedia
Oct 9, 2024 · Robert Lenard Schenck and his identical twin brother, Paul, were born in 1958 in Montclair, New Jersey, to Chaim "Henry Paul" Schenck and ...Missing: background | Show results with:background
[11]
Once Militantly Anti-Abortion, Evangelical Minister Now Lives ... - NPR
Jul 11, 2018 · Schenck describes his change in outlook as one of several "conversions" he has experienced as an evangelical Christian. "Change is a part of the ...Missing: born again
[12]
Rev. Rob Schenck, Author at Truth Revealed - Patheos
Rob Schenck is a dissenting voice and a fierce but loving critic of American ... An ordained evangelical minister, Rob was trained in evangelical ...
[13]
About Operation Serve International
To bring nationwide attention to the plight of the Mexican people, our founder Rev. Robert Schenck walked from Buffalo, NY to Mexico. This FAITHWALK was over ...
[14]
Conversation and Confessions with Reverend Rob Schenck ...
Jun 11, 2023 · ... walk to Mexico to benefit some of the poorest people on earth, and spent 30 years as an influential political activist on the religious ...
[15]
A Christian Nationalist Has Second Thoughts - Reveal News
Oct 17, 2024 · The Reverend Rob Schenck was once one of America's most powerful and influential evangelical leaders. He routinely lobbied legislators to adopt ...Missing: biography | Show results with:biography
[16]
Anti-abortion leader arrested with fetus - UPI Archives
Apr 21, 1992 · Robert Schenck, one of the leaders of Operation Rescue's 'Spring of Life' demonstrations, was arrested at a High Street clinic after showing ...Missing: blockades | Show results with:blockades
[17]
194 Arrested in Protests at Buffalo Abortion Clinics
Apr 23, 1992 · Almost 200 anti-abortion protesters were arrested here today after they staged a mid-morning march on a clinic, hoping to close it down.
[18]
AMID MASS ARRESTS, COUNTER-PROTESTS, BUFFALO ...
Apr 22, 1992 · Paul Schenck, both of whom are Assembly of God ministers, were arrested after Robert waved a 19-week fetus in the faces of his opponents.
[19]
Buffalo Operation Fizzle - Time Magazine
May 4, 1992 · The women who kept their appointments at the clinics, said the Rev. Robert Schenck, were “no one of any consequence, I can assure you.” By ...Missing: blockades | Show results with:blockades
[20]
History of Operation Rescue - Wikipedia
Thousands of anti-abortion protestors flocked to Wichita and were arrested at sit-in protests and blockades of clinic entrances and adjacent streets. The ...
[21]
Annual Indoor Pro-Life Gathering Will Return to US Capitol!
Jan 21, 2009 · This year's National Pre-born Service will feature Fr. Frank Pavone, Rev. Rob Schenck and Pastor Kenneth Barney. They will be joined by Pro-Life ...
[22]
Pro-Lifers Converge in D.C. for Massive Rally | Politics - Christian Post
Jan 22, 2009 · Rob Schenck, president of Faith and Action in the nation's capital. ... The March for Life rally, Pre-born Service, and other pro-life events mark ...
[23]
Pastor spreads message of Ten Commandments; He wants them ...
His Ten Commandments Project is an effort “to reintroduce the American people to the great words of Sinai,” said Schenck, who will lecture at St. Stephen's ...
[24]
Christian Activists to Unveil 850-Pound Ten Commandments ...
Jun 2, 2006 · Christian activists Rob Schenck and Patrick Mahoney are back in Washington, D.C., to display an 850-pound Ten Commandments monument across ...
[25]
One of Montgomery 10 Commandments rally organizers speaks on ...
Jun 27, 2005 · The Reverend Rob Schenck, author of a book advocating for the public display of the Ten Commandments and founder of the National Ten ...
[26]
Confessions of a (Former) Christian Nationalist - Mother Jones
Former Christian nationalist Reverend Rob Schenck spent so much time at the US Supreme Court, he says it felt like a second home.
[27]
Ten Commandments caravan arrives in U.S. Capitol - Gadsden Times
Oct 7, 2003 · Schenck helped lead protests last month at the Alabama Judicial Building in Montgomery, where Chief Justice Roy Moore installed a Ten ...Missing: advocacy symbols
[28]
Commandments debate spans nation - NBC News
Dec 15, 2003 · Having the biblical rules on display is not unconstitutional, says Schenck, but rises above all religious traditions and acts as a “moral ...
[29]
Ten Commandments monument moved - Nov. 14, 2003 - CNN
Nov 14, 2003 · Rob Schenck, president of the National Clergy Council. Moore was a circuit judge in Etowah County, northeast of Birmingham, in the late 1990s ...
[30]
Repaired Capitol Hill Ten Commandments Monument to be Re ...
Oct 28, 2013 · The sculpture was given to the Rev. Rob Schenck of Faith and Action, a Washington, DC-based Christian ministry to top federal government ...
[31]
10 Commandments stone vandalized in NE D.C. - WJLA
Sep 23, 2013 · "To bend that kind of steel to the angle, that is a Herculean effort," says Reverend Rob Schenck, who heads the Faith and Action group.Missing: religious | Show results with:religious
[32]
Commandments Display Moved From Rotunda of Courthouse
Aug 27, 2003 · Moore contends the monument is a proper acknowledgment of God. He says the Ten Commandments are the moral foundation of American law and the ...Missing: advocacy symbols
[33]
'Operation Higher Court': Inside the religious right's efforts to wine ...
Jul 8, 2022 · Schenck said the goal was to create an ecosystem of support for conservative justices, as a way of making them more forthright in their views.Missing: International | Show results with:International
[34]
[PDF] 1 Testimony of Rev. Robert Schenck, D. Min. December 8, 2022 U.S. ...
Dec 8, 2022 · Robert Lenard Schenck, an ordained evangelical minister of 40 years and the former lead missionary for Faith and Action in the Nation's Capital, ...
[35]
Showing Faith in Discretion - Los Angeles Times
Sep 27, 2002 · The Rev. Rob Schenck, founder of Faith and Action in the Nation's Capital, a Christian outreach center, said that “the mystique of the ...
[36]
Former Anti-Abortion Leader Alleges Another Supreme Court Breach
Nov 19, 2022 · From 2000 to 2018, when he left Faith and Action, Mr. Schenck raised more than $30 million in pursuit of that goal. His donors ranged from ...
[37]
Reverend who accused Alito of 2014 leak in Hobby Lobby speaks ...
Dec 9, 2022 · Until recently, Schenck ran a 20-year campaign he called Operation Higher Court through which he recruited wealthy donors to befriend and ...<|separator|>
[38]
Advocate tells lawmakers of 'stealth' efforts to influence Supreme Court
Dec 8, 2022 · Evangelical minister Robert L. Schenck recruited wealthy Christian couples to serve as “stealth missionaries” at the Supreme Court for about two decades.Missing: International Faithwalk<|control11|><|separator|>
[39]
Former evangelical activist claims he knew of 2014 Supreme Court ...
Nov 19, 2022 · A 5-4 court held that closely held family-owned corporations like Hobby Lobby could not be required to pay insurance coverage for certain types ...
[40]
Former religious right leader: I saw our phrases in Alito's abortion ...
Jul 20, 2022 · Rev. Rob Schenck outlines his former group's stealth efforts to get conservative justices to 'be bolder.'
[41]
Supreme Court Justices 'Prayed With' Anti-Roe Activist Before Ruling
Jul 6, 2022 · Rob Schenck, who launched the ministry under the name Faith and Action in the Nation's Capital, described how the organization forged ministry ...
[42]
A high-profile leak has heightened questions around the Supreme ...
Dec 8, 2022 · Schenck, who until 2018 led a group known then as Faith and Action, now describes himself as a "dissenting evangelical." He said he recruited ...Missing: International Faithwalk
[43]
Opinion | 'Would Jesus Wear a Sidearm?' - The New York Times
Oct 30, 2015 · Rob Schenck objects to same-sex marriage. He is also vehemently ... Horrified by the murders at Sandy Hook Elementary School nearly ...
[44]
'The Armor of Light' is gripping and a dual portrait in courage
Oct 30, 2015 · Rob Schenck, who is aligned with the far-right wing of the ... Schenck describes how, in the wake of the Sandy Hook shootings, he ...
[45]
Most Evangelical Leaders Favor Stricter Gun Laws, Survey Finds
Sep 21, 2017 · An ardent pro-life activist known for his sometimes confrontational tactics, Schenck became a convert to gun control after his Washington, D.C., ...Missing: reevaluation | Show results with:reevaluation
[46]
A Consistently Pro-Life Ethic Should Include Gun Control | Sojourners
Oct 8, 2015 · The Rev. Rob Schenck has long been a pro-life activist, but after the 2013 shooting at the Washington, D.C., Navy Yard, he expanded the scope ...
[47]
A consistently pro-life ethic should include gun control ...
Oct 7, 2015 · ... Sandy Hook, in December 2012, when six teachers and 20 children were ... Rob Schenck has long been a pro-life activist, but after the ...
[48]
The Armor of Light | Documentary about Gun Violence in the USA
The Armor of Light follows the journey of Evangelical minister Rob Schenck, who is trying to find the courage to preach about the growing toll of gun violence ...
[49]
Tribeca 2015: Sandy Hook-Inspired Doc Isn't "Another Wrestling ...
Apr 14, 2015 · Tribeca 2015: Sandy Hook-Inspired Doc Isn't “Another Wrestling Match About Guns” ... Rob Schenck, a prominent anti-abortion activist. “Rob was the ...<|separator|>
[50]
The Armor Of Light
The Armor Of Light follows an Evangelical minister and the mother of a teenage shooting victim who ask, is it possible to be both pro-gun and pro-life?
[51]
Costly Grace - HarperCollins Publishers
In stock Free delivery over $35An Evangelical Minister's Rediscovery of Faith, Hope, and Love. By Rob Schenck,. On Sale: June 4, 2019. $19.99 Now: $15.99.
[52]
Former Far Right Evangelical Leader Joins Pluralistic Jewish ...
Jun 29, 2023 · The Reverend Dr. Rob Schenck has made an unusual move to join the faculty of Hebrew College as a visiting scholar.Missing: biography | Show results with:biography
[53]
Supreme Court Whistleblower and Former Right-Wing Evangelical ...
Oct 4, 2023 · “It was life-changing for me and forced me to look at myself and my religious community in a way I had avoided for decades,” said Schenck on his ...
[54]
Jewish-Evangelical Conversation - Speaking Torah Podcast
Dec 3, 2024 · My initial conversion to born-again, what we called back then, Bible-believing Christianity 50 years ago this year. And then later, after I ...
[55]
The World's Religions Converge in Chicago - A Public Witness
Aug 17, 2023 · Rob Schenck talked about the importance of religious communities advocating for each other. An evangelical minister, Schenck is starting a ...
[56]
Dietrich Bonhoeffer Institute - InfluenceWatch
From 1995-2018, Schenck led Faith and Action, a group which organized twenty meetings between 20 couples and conservative U.S. Supreme Court Justices ...
[57]
Rev. Rob Schenck - Prayers and Action
Dr. Schenck holds a B.A. in Religion, M.A. in Christian Ministry, D.Min in Church and State, and is a senior fellow at the The Centre for the Study of Law ...Missing: Seminary | Show results with:Seminary
[58]
Is Bonhoeffer Too Flawed To Bring Us Together? | Rob Schenck
Mar 4, 2025 · Today Rob splits his time between his duties as Visiting Scholar of Christianity and Religious Leadership at Hebrew College, Newton, MA, and ...<|separator|>
[59]
Confessions of a (Former) Christian Nationalist | Hebrew College
Sep 25, 2024 · In his article, “Confessions of a (Former) Christian Nationalist,” Rev. Schenck recounts his work with Supreme Court Justices, politicians, and ...
[60]
https://ballsandstrikes.org/ethics-accountability/rob-schenck-clarence-thomas-house-judiciary-committee-testimony/
[61]
Clarence Thomas Allegedly Told Rev. Rob Schenck to “Keep Up ...
Dec 13, 2022 · Rev. Rob Schenck's testimony to the House Judiciary Committee revealed the failures of a Supreme Court subject to no binding code of ethics.
[62]
House hearing airs ethics allegations against Supreme Court - Politico
Dec 9, 2022 · Nadler and other Democratic members said Schenck's account underscored the need to pass legislation imposing a binding ethics code on the ...
[63]
Undue Influence: 'Operation Higher Court' and Politicking at SCOTUS
Reverend Robert Schenck is the founder and President of the Dietrich Bonhoeffer Institute, named for a Protestant leader in Nazi Germany who resisted the ...Missing: monuments | Show results with:monuments<|separator|>
[64]
Christian advocate tells Congress of 2014 U.S. Supreme Court leak
Dec 8, 2022 · [1/4]Rev. Robert Schenck testifies during a U.S. House Judiciary Committee hearing entitled "Undue Influence: Operation Higher Court and ...Missing: Senate | Show results with:Senate
[65]
Rev. Rob Schenck: Pres. Trump "Used the Bible as a Prop" - PBS
Jun 16, 2020 · Former anti-abortion activist and evangelical minister Rev. Rob Schenck joins the program.
[66]
US election: Rev Rob Schenck fears evangelical reaction - BBC
Oct 14, 2020 · The US pastor says he fears how evangelicals might react if President Trump loses the election.
[67]
Supreme Court responds to lawmakers on ethics complaints - Politico
Nov 28, 2022 · Rob Schenck, claimed he was alerted in 2014 to the looming conservative victory in the Hobby Lobby case about contraception coverage under ...
[68]
Ex-leader of religious group who prayed with 3 SCOTUS justices on ...
Jul 11, 2022 · Schenck told Rolling Stone he hosted prayer sessions in chambers and on Supreme Court grounds with Justices Samuel Alito, Clarence Thomas and ...
[69]
Supreme Court's silence on most serious ethics issues says it all
Nov 23, 2022 · Rob Schenck – also formerly affiliated with Liberty Counsel – had ... justices' conduct arguably creates an appearance of impropriety.
[70]
The Hobby Lobby leak looks bad for Justice Alito. But that's not the ...
Nov 23, 2022 · Both rulings were penned by Alito. The heart of the Times story is that the alleged leak enabled the Rev. Rob Schenck, at the time a Capitol ...Missing: pre- | Show results with:pre-<|separator|>
[71]
Evangelical minister who sought to influence Supreme Court comes ...
Dec 9, 2022 · A conservative evangelical minister testifying before a House committee Thursday came under fierce personal attacks from Republican members of Congress.<|separator|>
[72]
Supreme Court investigators fail to identify who leaked Dobbs opinion
Jan 19, 2023 · Rob Schenck, who once played a leading role in the anti-abortion movement, said he learned the outcome of the court's decision in Burwell v.
[73]
I Disagree with Rob Schenck. You Can and Should Be Pro-Life and ...
Jan 4, 2016 · I disagree with a recent column Rev. Rob Schenck entitled, “I'm an evangelical preacher. You can't be pro-life and pro-gun.”Missing: criticism | Show results with:criticism
[74]
A Christian Nationalist Has Second Thoughts | Reveal - WNYC
Oct 15, 2024 · In this podcast extra, Schenck sits down with host Al Letson to talk about his conversion into and out of Christian conservatism and what he's ...Missing: religious born again
[75]
Neal Milner: The Risky Business Of Changing Your Mind Politically ...
As he reframed his identity and changed his politics, Schenck went from being at the heart of the religious right to being isolated, even ostracized, by it.
[76]
Ex-Conservative Reverend Testifies That Samuel Alito Leaked ...
Dec 8, 2022 · Rob Schenck repeated under oath his allegation that Justice ... 6 Committee ― tried to depict Schenck as a liar, a fraud and a grifter.
[77]
Evangelical minister who sought to influence Supreme Court comes ...
Rob Schenck “a pathetic grifter” and declined to even ask him any questions about his claims, saying it would be “pointless.” Rep. Andy Biggs, R-Ariz ...
[78]
An Evangelical Leader's Changing Views On Gun Ownership - NPR
Oct 10, 2015 · The Rev. Rob Schenck, president of Faith and Action, is an anti-abortion activist who believes gun ownership and the use of guns is a decision ...Missing: reevaluation | Show results with:reevaluation
[79]
This Evangelical Minister Helped Build the Religious Right. He Now ...
Jun 8, 2018 · ... Rob Schenck. The evangelical minister from Buffalo, New York, gained national notoriety in the 1990s as a fervent anti-abortion activist who ...
[80]
Costly Grace: An Evangelical Minister's Rediscovery of Faith, Hope ...
Rating 4.2 (383) Jun 5, 2018 · If I were to say Costly Grace is just another way of Rob Schenck of achieving what seems to be his lifelong goal—fame & a degree of fortune—it ...Missing: summary | Show results with:summary