Fact-checked by Grok 2 weeks ago

Second work of grace

The second work of grace, also known as the second blessing or entire sanctification, is a central doctrine in Wesleyan-Holiness theology, describing a transformative experience subsequent to initial justification and conversion, in which the Holy Spirit purifies the believer's heart from the root of inbred sin, enabling a state of Christian perfection characterized by perfect love for God and neighbor.^[1] This experience, articulated by John Wesley in the 18th century, involves an instantaneous crisis moment of full surrender and faith, often preceded by gradual growth in holiness, resulting in the eradication of willful sin and the infilling of divine love, though it allows for ongoing maturation in grace rather than absolute flawlessness.^[2] Originating in the Methodist revival led by Wesley (1703–1791), the concept draws from his interpretation of Scripture, such as 1 Thessalonians 5:23 and 1 John 4:18, emphasizing that believers "may and should seek a subsequent work of God where through grace imparted by the Spirit, they are made full of the love of God."^[2] Wesley described it as "the loving [of] the Lord our God with all our heart, mind, soul, and strength," a renewal in Christ's image that delivers from "all filthiness both of flesh and spirit," achievable in this life through faith rather than human effort alone.^[1] In the broader Holiness movement of the 19th century, this doctrine influenced denominations like the Church of the Nazarene and the Wesleyan Church, where it is viewed as both a crisis event and a progressive journey toward holy living, distinct from initial salvation but essential for full devotion to God.^[3] Proponents stress its biblical basis in experiences like those in Acts, while acknowledging it as a gift that can be lost through neglect but regained by faith, underscoring themes of purity, empowerment for service, and victory over sin.^[2]

Overview

Definition and Core Concept

The second work of grace, also termed entire sanctification or the second blessing, refers to a distinct, instantaneous crisis experience in the life of a believer, occurring subsequent to justification (the first work of grace), by which the Holy Spirit cleanses the heart from all inbred or original sin, enabling Christian perfection characterized by pure love for God and neighbor.^[4] This doctrinal concept emphasizes heart purity as the eradication of the Adamic sin nature—the inherited carnal mind—while preserving the believer's human will and capacity for growth in grace.^[5] Received solely by faith following full consecration, it is not achieved through human effort but as a divine act of purification, distinct from ongoing moral development.^[4] Central to this experience are its instantaneous nature and the complete removal of sinful dispositions, resulting in freedom from willful sin and the empowerment for a life of holiness.^[2] The term "second blessing" was initially coined by John Wesley in his writings, such as A Plain Account of Christian Perfection (1766), to describe this post-regenerative work of grace.^[2] Later, Phoebe Palmer popularized the phrase "second work of grace" in the 19th century through her teachings on the "altar theology," framing it as an immediate baptism of the Holy Spirit accessible to all believers.^[6] The outcomes of this second work include not only inward cleansing but also the ability to love God with all one's heart, soul, mind, and strength, and one's neighbor as oneself, fostering victorious Christian living without the dominion of sin.^[5] This perfection is relational and dynamic, marked by humility and ongoing reliance on divine grace, rather than sinless impeccability.^[2]

Distinction from First Work of Grace

The first work of grace, known as justification, occurs instantaneously at the moment of faith in Christ, providing forgiveness for sins and imputing divine righteousness to the believer while leaving the inherited sin nature, or carnal mind, intact.^[4] This initial act restores the individual to a right relationship with God, absolving guilt and breaking the dominion of sin over the life, but it does not eradicate the internal root of self-centeredness or inbred depravity that persists after conversion.^[2] In contrast, the second work of grace represents a subsequent crisis experience of purification, where the Holy Spirit removes the carnal mind entirely, cleansing the heart from all sin and enabling a state of holiness free from ongoing internal conflict with sinful tendencies.^[7]^[4] Theologically, these works form a progressive sequence in the ordo salutis, with justification serving as the foundational pardon from sin's guilt and penalty, and the second work providing the empowering purification from sin's pollution and power.^[4] John Wesley illustrated this progression through the analogy of salvation as a house: justification lays the foundation by securing entry and basic structure, while sanctification fully furnishes the interior, completing the dwelling in holiness. This distinction underscores that the first work initiates salvation by delivering from condemnation, whereas the second equips for victorious Christian living, culminating in entire sanctification as its outcome.^[7] Practically, the first work saves the believer from the eternal penalty of hell through Christ's atonement, establishing peace with God but requiring ongoing growth amid residual sin.^[2] The second work, however, liberates from sin's polluting influence, shifting the heart's disposition toward perfect love for God and others, thus enabling consistent holiness without the previous inward strife.^[4]

Biblical and Theological Foundations

Scriptural Basis

The scriptural basis for the second work of grace draws primarily from passages that describe a divine act of complete sanctification and purification following initial conversion. In 1 Thessalonians 5:23, Paul prays, "Now may the God of peace Himself sanctify you entirely; and may your spirit and soul and body be preserved complete, without blame at the coming of our Lord Jesus Christ," which is interpreted as a call for entire sanctification—a holistic cleansing of the believer's inner life by God's power, achievable in this present life through faith.^[8]^[9] This verse depicts a post-conversion crisis of full consecration, where God removes the root of sin, distinct from the forgiveness of initial salvation.^[8]^[9] Romans 6:6-7 further supports this concept, stating, "knowing this, that our old self was crucified with Him, in order that our body of sin might be done away with, so that we would no longer be slaves to sin; for he who has died is freed from sin." These verses portray the crucifixion of the "old man" or inbred sin nature as an instantaneous divine work subsequent to regeneration, requiring the believer's full surrender and faith for its realization.^[8]^[9] This cleansing liberates from sin's dominion, emphasizing a definite experience of eradication rather than mere restraint.^[8] Acts 15:8-9 provides additional evidence, where Peter declares, "And God, who knows the heart, testified to them giving them the Holy Spirit, just as He also did to us; and He made no distinction between us and them, cleansing their hearts by faith." This passage illustrates heart purification as a distinct act of grace through faith, following the initial bestowal of the Spirit, and underscores the Holy Spirit's role in fully cleansing believers from indwelling sin.^[8]^[10] Supporting this framework, Matthew 3:11 describes the baptism with the Holy Spirit and fire as a sanctifying agent: "He will baptize you with the Holy Spirit and fire," interpreted as a post-conversion purifying event that consumes the carnal nature, separate from regenerative salvation.^[8]^[10] Likewise, Matthew 5:48 commands, "Therefore you are to be perfect, as your heavenly Father is perfect," presenting perfection as an attainable state of holiness through divine grace and faith, not human effort.^[8] Additionally, 1 John 4:18 states, "There is no fear in love, but perfect love casts out fear; for fear has to do with punishment, and whoever fears has not been perfected in love." In Wesleyan theology, this verse is understood to affirm that the second work of grace enables a state of perfect love for God, expelling servile fear and inward sin, as the heart is fully cleansed and filled with divine love.^[11] Across these texts, the emphasis lies on faith as the sole means of receiving this grace, excluding works or gradual moral improvement.^[8]^[9]^[10] In Wesleyan theology, these passages collectively affirm entire sanctification as a second crisis experience of cleansing.^[9]

Key Theological Principles

The second work of grace, often termed entire sanctification in Wesleyan theology, builds upon the initial work of justification by extending God's prevenient grace to enable a believer's response toward deeper holiness. This grace, operative after justification, awakens the soul to the reality of inbred sin and empowers the individual to seek cleansing through the Holy Spirit's transformative action.^[2]^[4] Central to receiving this second work is the role of faith, characterized by simple surrender and trust in Christ's atoning blood rather than any meritorious human effort. This act of faith results in an instantaneous reception of entire sanctification, distinct from the gradual processes of spiritual growth that follow.^[12]^[13] The doctrine posits Christian perfection not as sinless impeccability or absolute flawlessness, but as freedom from the inward dominion of sin, wherein the heart is purified to love God and neighbor perfectly. This state allows for continued growth in graces such as humility and patience, fostering progressive maturity without implying eradication of human frailty.^[2]^[4] Furthermore, the second work deepens the believer's assurance through a more profound witness of the Holy Spirit, confirming the reality of inward holiness beyond the initial assurance of pardon at justification. This experiential testimony underscores the Spirit's ongoing role in affirming sanctification.^[12]^[13]

Historical Development

Origins in Early Methodism

The concept of the second work of grace, known as entire sanctification or Christian perfection, emerged in the teachings of John Wesley during the 1730s and 1760s as a distinct experience following justification, wherein the heart is cleansed from all inward sin and filled with perfect love toward God and neighbor. Wesley's foundational influences began in the 1720s with readings such as Thomas à Kempis's The Christian's Pattern and Jeremy Taylor's Rules and Exercises of Holy Living, which emphasized inward religion and full conformity to Christ. His pivotal Aldersgate Street experience on May 24, 1738, provided an initial assurance of justification—"my heart was strangely warmed"—marking the first work of grace, but this evolved over subsequent years into a doctrine of a subsequent, instantaneous second blessing achievable through faith, often years after conversion.^[1]^[14] Wesley's formulation of this doctrine crystallized in key writings and sermons from the 1740s to 1760s, distinguishing justification as pardon from sin from entire sanctification as deliverance from its power. In his 1767 A Plain Account of Christian Perfection, Wesley traced the doctrine's scriptural roots and personal development, affirming it as "not so early as justification; for justified persons are to 'go on unto perfection'" (Hebrews 6:1), an instantaneous work by faith that removes the "carnal mind" while allowing for growth in knowledge and holy tempers. This was elaborated in his 1765 sermon "The Scripture Way of Salvation," where he described salvation's twofold nature: justification as the "porch" of forgiveness, and entire sanctification as the "door" to full renewal, stating, "In that hour it is done... the soul is purified from all sin." Early Methodist conferences from 1744 onward further refined this teaching, emphasizing its availability in this life through divine grace.^[1]^[15] Within early Methodist societies, the second work of grace was promoted through structured class meetings and hymnody, fostering accountability and spiritual growth toward heart cleansing. Introduced in 1742, class meetings—small groups of 10-12 members led by lay leaders—served as primary venues for mutual encouragement in pursuing sanctification, where participants shared experiences of grace and confessed sins to support one another in "working out" salvation. The Wesley brothers' hymns, published in collections like Hymns and Sacred Poems (1739), reinforced this emphasis, with lyrics such as John Wesley's "Unclean, of life and heart unclean, / How shall man in Thy sight appear?" pleading for divine purification, and Charles Wesley's "O for a Heart to Praise My God" (1742) praying for a "pure and sinless mind" as the goal of Methodist piety. These practices integrated the doctrine into daily life, making entire sanctification a communal pursuit rather than an isolated experience.^[16]^[17]^[18] Throughout the 18th century, Wesley's teaching on Christian perfection sparked debates with Calvinist contemporaries, who viewed it as unattainable or potentially antinomian, prompting refinements to the doctrine. Tensions escalated in the 1770s during the "Minutes Controversy," where Calvinist leaders like George Whitefield criticized Wesley's 1770 conference minutes for implying sinless perfection, leading Wesley to clarify in publications like Thoughts upon Necessity of the New Birth (1770) that perfection meant loving God fully without willful sin, not impeccability. These exchanges, rooted in broader Arminian-Calvinist disputes over free will and grace, ultimately strengthened Methodist identity around the second work as a hopeful, scripturally grounded possibility. This early Methodist emphasis laid the groundwork for later holiness movements.^[19]^[20]

Evolution in 19th-Century Revivalism

In the 1830s, Phoebe Palmer articulated "altar theology," a practical framework that democratized the Wesleyan doctrine of entire sanctification by stressing immediate, wholehearted consecration to God as the pathway to this second work of grace, distinct from gradual moral improvement.^[21] Drawing from biblical imagery of the altar sanctifying offerings, Palmer taught that full surrender and faith in Christ's atonement would instantaneously cleanse the heart from inbred sin, making holiness accessible to all believers post-justification.^[21] The Tuesday Meetings, initiated by her sister Sarah Lankford in 1836 in the Palmer home in New York City as a women's prayer gathering for spiritual purity, rapidly evolved into an influential forum for promoting this crisis experience of sanctification, with Phoebe assuming leadership after her own 1837 experience.^[22] By the 1840s, these weekly sessions opened to men and attracted clergy, laypeople, and international visitors, disseminating altar theology through personal testimonies and Palmer's writings, such as The Way of Holiness (1843), which sold over 50,000 copies and sparked revivals across North America.^[21] Concurrently, the Oberlin-Holiness movement emerged in the 1830s at Oberlin College in Ohio, where evangelist Charles Finney and president Asa Mahan integrated revivalistic fervor with a theology of crisis sanctification, positioning it as a definite second blessing subsequent to conversion.^[23] Finney, influenced by his own 1836–1837 spiritual renewal in Boston—marked by profound consecration and a "baptism of the Holy Spirit"—preached that entire sanctification involved a volitional crisis of self-renunciation, enabling believers to attain perfect love toward God and neighbor through faith.^[23] This emphasis on immediate holiness as an obtainable state in this life, rather than solely eschatological, aligned with Palmer's ideas and fueled campus revivals, drawing abolitionists and reformers who saw sanctification as essential for social and personal transformation.^[22] The concept proliferated through national camp meetings and tent revivals from the 1860s to the 1880s, transforming localized experiences into a widespread movement that emphasized the second work of grace amid post-Civil War spiritual hunger.^[22] The inaugural National Holiness Association (NHA) camp meeting in 1867 at Vineland, New Jersey, organized by Methodist leaders like John S. Inskip, convened hundreds to seek entire sanctification through preaching and altar calls, setting a model for itinerant evangelism.^[24] Subsequent gatherings, such as the 1868 event in Manheim, Pennsylvania, drew over 20,000 participants and were hailed as a modern "Pentecost," with tent revivals extending the message to rural areas and urban fringes across multiple states.^[22] This revivalistic surge strained relations within American Methodism, where the insistence on instantaneous sanctification as a normative second work clashed with mainline views of gradual growth, prompting schisms and the rise of independent holiness bodies.^[24] The NHA, formalized in 1867, served as a pivotal alliance for promoting these doctrines outside denominational constraints, coordinating annual camps that led to the founding of groups like the Church of God (Anderson) and precursors to the Church of the Nazarene by the 1890s.^[24] These developments not only preserved the second work emphasis amid growing institutional resistance but also briefly connected to the emerging Keswick Convention in England from 1875, which reframed the second blessing for broader evangelical audiences seeking victory over sin.^[13]

Interpretations in Christian Traditions

Wesleyan-Holiness Tradition

In the Wesleyan-Holiness tradition, the second work of grace is understood as entire sanctification, a post-conversion experience where the Holy Spirit eradicates the root of original sin from the believer's heart, enabling perfect love for God and others through faith.^[25] This doctrine, rooted in John Wesley's emphasis on Christian perfection, posits that entire sanctification cleanses the inward nature of inbred sin while empowering holy living, distinct from initial justification.^[2] It is received instantaneously by grace through faith following full consecration, marking a crisis moment that purifies the heart and redirects affections toward divine love.^[26] Practices within this tradition often center on facilitating this experience through communal worship. Altar calls, typically at the conclusion of services, invite believers to consecrate themselves fully at the altar, seeking the Holy Spirit's transformative work in entire sanctification.^[27] Testimony services complement this by providing opportunities for individuals to share personal accounts of the second blessing, reinforcing communal faith and accountability in pursuing holiness.^[27] These elements underscore the tradition's focus on experiential grace, where the Holy Spirit's witness confirms the inner cleansing.^[25] Variations appear in denominations that uphold entire sanctification as a doctrinal cornerstone. The Free Methodist Church, founded in 1860, emerged partly to reaffirm this teaching amid perceived dilutions in broader Methodism, viewing it as essential for redirecting the heart from self to God through the Holy Spirit's filling.^[28] Similarly, the Church of the Nazarene, organized in 1908, enshrines entire sanctification in its Articles of Faith as a second work of grace that remedies original sin and fosters Christian holiness.^[25] Contemporary Wesleyan perspectives integrate the crisis dimension of entire sanctification with ongoing growth, recognizing it as both an instantaneous event and a progressive journey toward deeper holiness.^[2] This balance is evident in practices like discipleship programs that emphasize the initial "flip" to Spirit-directed living followed by maturation in love and service.^[29] Such views maintain the doctrine's vitality by framing it within lifelong fellowship, disciplines, and sacraments that cultivate ever-increasing purity of heart.^[2]

Keswick and Higher Life Movement

The Keswick and Higher Life Movement emerged in the late 19th century as a distinct theological stream emphasizing a post-conversion experience of sanctification known as the "second work of grace" or "second blessing." This movement originated at the first Keswick Convention held in July 1875 in Keswick, England, organized by Canon Thomas D. Harford-Battersby following his exposure to holiness teachings at earlier conferences. Key early proponents included Robert Pearsall Smith, an American Quaker evangelist, and William E. Boardman, whose 1858 book The Higher Christian Life laid foundational ideas for the "higher Christian life" by promoting a deeper spiritual empowerment beyond initial salvation.^[13]^[30] Central to Keswick theology is the teaching that the second work of grace involves a crisis moment of full surrender to Christ, enabling believers to enter a life of victory over the dominion of sin through the filling of the Holy Spirit. This experience, achieved by faith and consecration, allows for Spirit-filled living where known sins are overcome, but the sin nature itself persists and must be continually counteracted by reliance on divine grace rather than eradicated. Unlike the Wesleyan-Holiness tradition's model of instantaneous cleansing from inbred sin, Keswick emphasizes "rest in Christ" as an ongoing, moment-by-moment dependence on God's provision for sanctification, countering perfectionist tendencies with a focus on practical holiness and separation from willful sin.^[13]^[30] The movement's principles, often summarized as "let go and let God," underscore complete abandonment of self-effort in favor of faith in Christ's sufficiency, promoting categories of "carnal" versus "spiritual" Christians to highlight the need for this second blessing. Its influence rapidly spread to American Bible conferences, such as those at Northfield, Massachusetts, where it shaped evangelical practices and impacted prominent figures like D.L. Moody, who integrated Keswick ideas into his revival campaigns to emphasize post-conversion Spirit baptism for empowered living.^[13]^[30]

Quaker and Friends Theology

In Quaker theology, concepts paralleling a second work of grace find historical roots in the 17th-century teachings of George Fox, the founder of the Religious Society of Friends, who emphasized the "divine seed" as an indwelling Christly presence that enables believers to achieve holiness by overcoming sin.^[31] Fox described this seed, drawn from Genesis 3:15, as the eternal aspect of God planted in every human heart, which, when illuminated by the inward Light, empowers progressive victory over the "seed of the serpent" or sinful nature, paralleling the transformative empowerment seen in other traditions' notions of a second blessing.^[31] This divine seed is not merely a passive gift but an active force calling for obedience, fostering a life of purity and alignment with God's will without reliance on external rituals.^[31] During the 19th-century holiness revival, some Quakers adapted these foundational ideas by incorporating elements of Wesleyan crisis experiences, as seen in figures like John Wilbur, who navigated tensions between traditional Quaker quietism and emerging evangelical influences that highlighted a distinct moment of full consecration.^[32] This adaptation involved interpreting the yielding to the Inward Light as a pivotal, experiential breakthrough akin to entire sanctification, though Wilbur and like-minded Friends resisted overly programmatic expressions, preferring integration with Quaker simplicity.^[33] Such influences arose amid broader revivalist currents, where Quakers encountered Methodist emphases on a post-conversion crisis leading to perfection, briefly paralleling their own stress on the seed's full realization.^[32] At its core, the Quaker understanding of the second work of grace centers on a complete yielding to the Inward Light—also termed the divine seed or Christ within—culminating in sinless obedience and a state of spiritual perfection achieved through ongoing communion rather than dramatic altars or public professions.^[34] This process involves the Light's illumination dispelling inner darkness, enabling believers to live in unspotted purity by heeding its guidance in daily life, distinct from outward sacramental forms.^[34] Unlike more structured traditions, Quakers view this yielding as an intimate, mystical surrender that transforms the heart progressively toward holiness, rooted in silent discernment and communal worship.^[31] In contemporary Quaker thought, the second work receives less emphasis as a singular crisis event and more as an ongoing sanctification process facilitated by silent waiting and attentive obedience to the Inward Light, reflecting a shift toward inclusive, experiential spirituality across diverse branches of Friends.^[32] Modern Quakers, as articulated in faith and practice statements, prioritize the Light's continual guidance for personal and communal transformation, viewing perfection as a dynamic journey rather than a fixed attainment.^[34] This perspective aligns with broader 20th- and 21st-century developments, where the emphasis lies on the Light's universal accessibility fostering ethical living and peace testimony in everyday contexts.

Pentecostal Perspectives

In Pentecostal theology, particularly within Holiness Pentecostalism, the second work of grace is understood as entire sanctification, an instantaneous crisis experience subsequent to justification that cleanses the heart from the inbred sin of original depravity, restoring the believer to a state of holiness and purity.^[35] This doctrine, rooted in Wesleyan traditions, positions sanctification as essential preparation for the third work of grace—the baptism in the Holy Spirit, which empowers for witness and is evidenced by speaking in tongues as the initial sign.^[36] For example, the Church of God (Cleveland, Tennessee) teaches that this second work, wrought by the Holy Spirit through Christ's blood, eradicates the carnal nature, making the believer eligible for the indwelling Holy Spirit, as outlined in their doctrinal statements referencing scriptures like 1 Thessalonians 4:3 and Hebrews 13:12.^[35] Key figures in maintaining this sequential understanding include A.J. Tomlinson, who organized the Church of God in 1903 and emphasized entire sanctification as a distinct experience following conversion, drawing from his own personal testimony of sanctification prior to his leadership in early 20th-century Pentecostal holiness circles.^[37] Tomlinson's influence helped preserve Wesleyan roots amid the broader Pentecostal movement, where groups like the Church of God upheld the second work against emerging "finished work" theologies that merged sanctification with initial salvation.^[36] These early Pentecostal holiness adherents, emerging from 19th-century revivalism, integrated the doctrine into their ecclesiology to stress progressive spiritual crises.^[36] Practices in Holiness Pentecostal churches often involve sequential altar experiences, where believers first seek salvation through repentance and faith, then consecration for entire sanctification to achieve heart purity, and finally the baptism in the Holy Spirit for empowerment.^[38] These altar calls, central to worship services, facilitate ecstatic encounters—such as confession, prayer, and anointing—leading to the instantaneous reception of each grace, as seen in historical accounts from Azusa Street and subsequent revivals where seekers progressed through these stages in a single meeting or over time.^[38] Variations exist among Pentecostal groups, particularly in Oneness Pentecostalism, where some blend the second work with baptismal regeneration in Jesus' name (Acts 2:38) as the initial cleansing act, yet retain an emphasis on entire sanctification as a subsequent crisis for deeper holiness before Spirit baptism.^[39] Organizations like the United Pentecostal Church International uphold strict holiness standards, viewing sanctification as a progressive work of grace following initial salvation through repentance, baptism in Jesus' name, and Holy Spirit infilling, rather than a distinct second crisis experience.^[39]^[40]

Contemporary Relevance and Debates

Modern Applications

In contemporary worship within Wesleyan-Holiness churches, such as those in the Church of the Nazarene, testimony-sharing continues as a vital practice, allowing congregants to recount personal encounters with God's sanctifying grace during services and retreats. These sessions often emphasize gradual spiritual formation over instantaneous experiences, with participants using modern, individualized language to describe heart cleansing and empowerment for holy living, rather than traditional terminology like "second blessing." Prayer lines, adapted from historical altar calls, provide spaces for seekers to receive intercessory prayer for entire sanctification, fostering communal support in settings like holiness camps and church gatherings.^[41] Personal testimonies of receiving heart purity persist in educational contexts within Holiness traditions, where individuals share accounts of transformative encounters with sanctifying grace. These narratives highlight entire sanctification as a lived reality that equips believers for daily challenges.^[41] Globally, the second work of grace finds adoption in African Methodist churches, where it undergirds social holiness initiatives that extend personal sanctification to communal justice and mercy. In the Free Methodist Church of the Democratic Republic of Congo, for example, entire sanctification motivates outreach programs addressing HIV/AIDS, poverty, and conflict through hospitals, schools, and advocacy, embodying Wesley's vision of perfect love expressed in service to the marginalized. Similar emphases appear in Asian Methodist contexts, such as Singapore's Methodist congregations, where sanctifying grace inspires ethical discipleship and community engagement amid urban challenges.^[42]^[43]

Criticisms and Variations

Reformed theologians have critiqued the doctrine of a second work of grace as semi-Pelagian, arguing that it overemphasizes human cooperation in sanctification and undermines the sufficiency of divine grace in justification. B.B. Warfield, for instance, warned that positing a "second work of grace" or "second conversion" experience diminishes the integrity of initial justification by implying an additional crisis that separates sanctification from regeneration. He viewed such teachings as promoting an anti-scriptural perfectionism, where the eradication of the sinful nature is claimed in this life, contrary to his belief that sanctification is a gradual process from regeneration to glorification. Warfield further accused elements of the holiness movement of Pelagian tendencies by prioritizing a distinct crisis experience over ongoing divine enablement, seeing crisis and process as mutually exclusive.^[44] In contrast, some Arminian perspectives emphasize a gradualist approach to sanctification, portraying it as a lifelong process without a definitive second crisis. Jacobus Arminius described sanctification as a progressive renewal of the inner person, where sin is weakened daily through the Holy Spirit's work, rather than instantaneously removed. This view aligns with broader Arminian theology that rejects a second blessing leading to sinless perfection, focusing instead on continual growth in holiness empowered by grace.^[45] Scholarly analyses have highlighted limited exploration of psychological dimensions in traditional accounts of the second work of grace, often interpreting the associated experiences as forms of emotional catharsis rather than purely spiritual events. In holiness traditions, the expectation of an instantaneous "big event" sanctification—described by some as a "lightning bolt" release—can lead to psychological ambivalence, guilt, and unmet expectations when perfection proves elusive, fostering a focus on self-evaluation over relational growth. Such interpretations suggest these experiences may serve as cathartic outlets for repressed emotions, potentially stunting emotional maturity if rigidly tied to doctrinal benchmarks.^[46] Gender dynamics in 19th-century testimonies of the second work of grace reveal women's prominent roles in promoting sanctification narratives, often leveraging these experiences to challenge patriarchal restrictions on ministry. Figures like Phoebe Palmer shared testimonies of entire sanctification to advocate for women's preaching, influencing thousands and defending spiritual equality under the Pentecostal outpouring promised in Joel 2:28. Similarly, Catherine Booth and Maggie Van Cott used their sanctification accounts to convert audiences and secure licenses, navigating gender-based opposition through emphatic declarations of divine empowerment. These testimonies underscore how women in the holiness movement reframed personal spiritual crises as calls to public leadership, though broader discussions of such gendered influences remain underexplored.^[47] Post-2000 theological debates within holiness circles have increasingly questioned the eradication model of sanctification—positing the instantaneous removal of the sinful nature—against suppression or relational alternatives that emphasize ongoing moral transformation. In the Church of the Nazarene, for example, scholars like Mildred Bangs Wynkoop argued that sin is not "eradicated by a second work of grace" but addressed through a process of love and relationship, influencing 1980s-2000s systematic theologies. The 1985 General Assembly's retention of "eradicate" in doctrinal statements after heated debate, alongside 1999 critiques urging a return to traditional cleansing, highlights persistent tensions, with relational models gaining traction for their alignment with Wesley's gradualism. These discussions, while intra-denominational, reflect broader ecumenical shifts toward process-oriented views of holiness. As of 2025, similar debates continue in denominations like the Church of God, where discussions question traditional emphases on the second blessing in favor of integrated grace teachings.^[48]

References

[1]
A Plain Account of Christian Perfection - The Wesley Center Online
A Plain Account of Christian Perfection. The Works of John Wesley (1872 ed. by Thomas Jackson), vol. 11, # 29, pp. 366-446.
[2]
Wesleyan-Holiness Theology | www.asbury.edu
... second work of grace or the gradual working of the Spirit. Is it crisis or process? In fact, Wesley said it is both. Wesley consistently argued that ...
[3]
Models of Sanctification - The Gospel Coalition
Wesley labels this second work of grace as not only Christian perfection but salvation from all sin, entire sanctification, perfect love, holiness, purity ...
[4]
H. Orton Wiley: Christian Theology - Chapter 29
... second work of grace. Entire Sanctification as Subsequent to Regeneration. Theologians of the Wesleyan type frequently speak of the incompleteness of ...
[5]
[PDF] The Role of the Holy Spirit in Entire Sanctification in the Writings of ...
entire sanctification as a definite second work of grace. rV. The Witness of the Holy Spirit in Entire Sanctification. Wesley regarded "the witness of the ...
[6]
[PDF] Holiness of Heart & Life - Duke Divinity School
a second work of grace before they can be expected to live holy lives. As one example put it,. “The Christian may, and is required by God, to be perfect ...
[7]
How entire is entire sanctification? Meditations and audio sermons
... second work of grace, second-blessing, and heart holiness. At times, Holiness theologians seem to say that all these terms refer to exactly the same ...
[8]
[PDF] Bible Proofs of the Second Work of Grace
“After that the kindness and love of God our Saviour appeared” unto me, in removing the veil of ignorance and deep prejudice from my heart; enabling me to ...
[9]
Complete Sanctification for the Whole Person: 1 Thess. 5:23
Nov 9, 2022 · Romans 6:6, 2 Corinthians 7:1, and 1 Thessalonians 5:23 all indicate that entire sanctification is possible before death and that this ...Missing: basis Acts 15:8-9
[10]
[PDF] Conflicting Concepts Of Holiness - MEDIA SABDA
Acts 15:8-9 ... In summary, then, we observe that the baptism with the Spirit and entire sanctification are, at most, two aspects of a work of divine grace which ...
[11]
Articles of Religion - The Wesleyan Church
The crisis of entire sanctification perfects the believer in love and empowers that person for effective service. It is followed by lifelong growth in grace and ...<|control11|><|separator|>
[12]
Wesleyan and Keswick Models of Sanctification - Bible.org
May 25, 2004 · Wesley asserted the primacy of justification, and the assurance the believer could have based upon the righteousness of Christ.
[13]
John Wesley and Faith at Aldersgate - The Gospel Coalition
A rediscovery of both the doctrine and the experience that John Wesley articulated at Aldersgate in 1738 would be highly salutary for the spiritual health of ...
[14]
Sermon 43 - The Scripture Way Of Salvation
The Scripture Way of Salvation. "Ye are saved through faith." -- Ephesians 2:8. 1. Nothing can be more intricate, complex, and hard to be understood, ...
[15]
The History and Significance of the Wesleyan Class Meeting
Oct 23, 2020 · The Class Meeting was a system of discipleship and accountability, designed by John Wesley, which was used by God to bring revival to eighteenth-century ...Missing: cleansing | Show results with:cleansing
[16]
History of Hymns: Wesley hymn speaks language of the heart
“O For a Heart to Praise My God” was introduced in the book Hymns and Sacred Poems in 1742, published by John Wesley, originally with eight stanzas. The ...
[17]
Unclean of life and heart unclean - Hymnary.org
Unclean, of life and heart unclean, How shall I in His sight appear? Conscious of my inveterate sin. I blush and tremble to draw near;
[18]
[PDF] Wesley's Understanding of Christian Perfection - Duke Divinity School
Fletcher is clearly sensing here that he meant more by the “infancy” of Christian Perfection than John Wesley intended by the. “infant” degree of Christian life ...
[19]
[PDF] Theory and Practice in John Wesley's Critique of Calvinism
On more than one occasion, John Wesley found himself engaged in debate with Calvinists in the. Methodist revival. In this article, I philosophically ...
[20]
Phoebe Palmer: Mother of the Holiness Movement - CBE International
As a premier proponent of “the holiness way,” Palmer functioned as teacher, writer, social activist, theologian and evangelist for the cause of Christ.
[21]
Christian History Timeline: The Holiness Movement
1867 The first National Holiness Association (NHA) camp meeting is held at Vineland, New Jersey. 1868 The second NHA camp meeting attracts over 20,000 people to ...Missing: 1880s tent
[22]
[PDF] Charles G. Finney's Doctrine of Sanctification
Chapter four reveals the theology of Charles G. Finney as fotm.d in his teaching, preaching, and 'ttJriting. The revivalist r s doctrines of. God, man, sin ...Missing: 1830s | Show results with:1830s
[23]
[PDF] Schisms and Their Healing in American Methodism.
The belief in sanctification as a second, instantaneous work of grace had always had its opponents. The emergence of groups insisting upon certain ...Missing: Association | Show results with:Association
[24]
What We Believe - Church of the Nazarene
Entire sanctification is provided by the blood of Jesus, is wrought instantaneously by grace through faith, preceded by entire consecration; and to this work ...
[25]
We Believe - Free Methodist Church USA
This sanctifying relationship with God remedies the divided mind, redirects the heart to God, and empowers believers to please and serve God in their daily ...
[26]
The Tension of Being a Wesleyan Holiness People
Jul 9, 2018 · They expect frequent worship services to end with altar calls. They ... testimonies of entire sanctification. More recently, advocates ...
[27]
Historical Heritage & Perspective
In reality, the primary issue was their proclamation of the basic principles of Methodism, especially the doctrine and experience of entire sanctification.
[28]
Entire sanctification via discipleship - The Wesleyan Church
Sep 1, 2016 · A long-time Wesleyan pastor compares entire sanctification and discipleship, illustrating how it is lived out in his Arizona church.
[29]
[PDF] keswick theology: a survey and analysis of the doctrine of ...
Keswick theology, from the early Keswick movement (1875-1920), refers to the view of sanctification shared by its propagators, and is considered theologically ...
[30]
None
### Summary of George Fox's Teachings on the Seed and Holiness/Sanctification in Quaker Theology
[31]
Revivalist Friends and the Second Quaker Explosion - Friends Journal
Jul 1, 2025 · Along these lines, the Wesleyan emphasis upon a second work of grace—salvation followed by sanctification—fit entirely well with Robert Barclay ...
[32]
Response to Thomas Hamm: Holiness 2.5 Cheers - Quaker Theology
Oct 30, 2009 · Though she loved the spiritual energy of camp meetings, she was not preoccupied with insisting on an instantaneous “second blessing” experienced ...
[33]
The Light Within - Philadelphia Yearly Meeting
In his journal, George Fox referred to “that Inward Light, Spirit, and Grace ... Divine continues to be at the heart of Quaker experience. Through this ...<|separator|>
[34]
Basic Teachings | The Church of God Northeast Region
Sanctification: Sanctification is the second definite work of grace, an instantaneous work ... Church grew and multiplied under the leadership of A.J. Tomlinson ...
[35]
Sanctification Scuffles | Christian History Magazine
Early Pentecostals called it a “second blessing” and regarded it as a necessary preparation for a third experience, the indwelling of the Holy Spirit (that is, ...
[36]
A Brief History of the Church of God (Cleveland, Tennessee).
... doctrine of entire sanctification. Following his sanctification experience, Tomlinson began to minister wherever he saw a need--first in his local ...<|control11|><|separator|>
[37]
The Centrality of the Pentecostal Altar - Daniel Tomberlin
Mar 8, 2016 · Whether these altar calls are noisy and dynamic, or somber and ... The experiences of salvation, sanctification, and Spirit baptism are ecstatic ...
[38]
Holiness as Perceived by Pentecostal Pioneers in the Twentieth ...
Sep 27, 2009 · Today the Pentecostal movement is divided into at least four theological groups: the people who hold to holiness or sanctification as a second ...
[39]
[PDF] Entire Sanctification In Our Modern Time - Didache: Faithful Teaching
28 Believers who testify of their entire sanctification, many times do not use the traditional terminology; they define it using their own terms. This.Missing: testimonies | Show results with:testimonies
[40]
Second Work of Grace - Jack Cottrell
Apr 30, 2013 · This second work of grace is thought of as full sanctification or entire sanctification, and some interpret this as the ability to live above sin from that ...Missing: principles assurance
[41]
Grace enables the power for purity: Lambert talks about the power of ...
We must motivate men to change by the gospel of grace. We can and should change because of who Jesus is what he has done for us. It's very practical to believe ...
[42]
[PDF] the doctrine of social holiness in the free methodist church, drc ...
The second perspective consists in engaging the church in social actions for change (1998:126). The Wesleyan social holiness belongs to the second perspective ...Missing: Asian | Show results with:Asian<|control11|><|separator|>
[43]
[PDF] Nurturing Disciples Of Christ By Singing Wesleyan Hymns In View ...
Feb 16, 2022 · In addition to their sermons, John and Charles Wesley used hymns as the primary vehicle to convey the theology and doctrine of Methodism.
[44]
[PDF] AB and BB: Simpson & Warfield Sanctification Criticized
Warfield warns against a “second work of grace” or a “second conversion” experience as undermining the integrity and sufficiency of justification. For example, ...
[45]
Arminius on the Sanctification of the Believer - Helwys Society Forum
Aug 27, 2012 · Notice the gradual progression that he ascribes to sanctification. He attributes our victory over sin to Jesus' death on the cross.
[46]
None
### Summary of Psychological Interpretations of the Second Work of Grace or Christian Perfection in the Holiness Movement
[47]
[PDF] WOMEN IN THE HOLINESS MOVEMENT - The Wesleyan Church
When John left home, the influence of his mother went with him and he sought her advice to the time of her death. It was her practical counsel to allow ...Missing: Wilbur | Show results with:Wilbur
[48]
[PDF] 1 Mark R. Quanstrom A CENTURY OF HOLINESS THEOLOGY ...
This effort to remove 'eradicate' and 'baptism with the Holy Spirit' was evidence of a dynamic discussion that had been going on the denomination for fifteen ...<|control11|><|separator|>