Fact-checked by Grok 2 weeks ago

Spolia

Spolia, from the Latin spolium meaning "spoils" or "plunder," refers to the deliberate reuse of architectural elements—such as columns, capitals, friezes, and inscriptions—from earlier structures in new constructions, a practice rooted in antiquity and persisting through the medieval period.^[1]^[2] This method encompassed both utilitarian recycling of materials amid shortages and ideological appropriation, often transforming pagan artifacts into components of Christian edifices to signify cultural or religious dominance.^[3]^[4] The phenomenon emerged prominently in late antiquity, as Roman imperial decline led to the spoliation of public buildings for fortification walls, churches, and civic structures, exemplifying pragmatic adaptation to economic constraints while embedding historical layers into the built environment.^[5] In Byzantine contexts, spolia from classical temples adorned ecclesiastical sites, as in the 5th-century church at Sardis incorporating elements from the Temple of Artemis, blending aesthetic continuity with symbolic reconfiguration of antiquity.^[6] Similarly, early Christian basilicas in Rome and Ravenna repurposed marble from imperial monuments, highlighting a causal interplay between material scarcity, labor limitations, and the assertion of ecclesiastical authority over disused pagan infrastructure.^[3] Prominent instances underscore spolia's dual role in preservation and reinvention, such as the integration of Roman porphyry statues like the Portrait of the Four Tetrarchs—looted from Constantinople during the Fourth Crusade—into Venice's St. Mark's Basilica, where they served as corner reinforcements evoking imperial legitimacy.^[7] In fortifications like Istanbul's Theodosian Walls or Thessaloniki's Heptapyrgion, inscribed blocks from Hellenistic and Roman eras were embedded for structural reinforcement, revealing empirical evidence of adaptive reuse across successive empires without reliance on fabricated narratives of uninterrupted cultural harmony. Scholarly analyses, drawing from archaeological and epigraphic data rather than ideologically skewed institutional interpretations, affirm that spolia's persistence stemmed from first-order economic incentives—quarrying costs exceeded disassembly expenses—over romanticized notions of heritage continuity, though interpretive biases in modern academia occasionally inflate symbolic dimensions at the expense of material causation.^[8]^[9]

Definition and Etymology

Origins and Terminology

The term spolia originates from the Latin spolium (plural spolia), denoting the physical spoils of war—such as arms, armor, or the stripped hide of a slain enemy—captured as trophies symbolizing victory and domination over adversaries.^[10]^[11] In Roman military tradition, these items held legal and ritual significance, with elite categories like spolia opima reserved for personally retrieved enemy leaders' gear, underscoring personal agency in conquest and serving as dedications to gods or displays of prowess.^[11] This core connotation of plunder and appropriation provided the metaphorical foundation for extending the term to architectural contexts. By the early 4th century AD, spolia began encompassing repurposed building materials—columns, inscriptions, and sculptural fragments—from dismantled or conquered structures, integrated into new constructions to evoke martial triumph and imperial continuity.^[7] This semantic shift rooted in Roman practices of resource extraction during civil and external conflicts, where reuse of elite pagan or prior imperial monuments asserted causal dominance by materially subjugating the past to the present regime, as evidenced in dedicatory inscriptions framing such acts as extensions of battlefield success.^[12] Texts from Constantine's era (circa 312–315 AD) exemplify this linkage, employing triumphal language to justify appropriation as a legitimate inheritance of predecessors' authority, grounded in the empirical reality of limited new quarrying amid wartime exigencies.^[13] Scholars further refine the concept through distinctions like spolia in se—actual, unaltered elements reused for their indexical, material presence—and spolia in re—modified, recarved, or stylistically evoked forms that operate metaphorically to invoke historical precedents without physical transfer.^[14] This framework, articulated by Richard Brilliant in 1982, highlights how spolia functioned dually as tangible artifacts and symbolic claims, with the former prioritizing evidentiary reuse and the latter causal reinterpretation to legitimize power, independent of original intent.^[15] Such categorizations derive from philological analysis of Latin sources and archaeological patterns, emphasizing that architectural spolia inhered meaning from their provenance as "booty," not mere recycling for utility.^[16]

Historical Contexts

Late Antiquity and Early Christian Reuse

The practice of spolia emerged systematically during the reign of Emperor Constantine I (r. 306–337 CE), particularly evident in the Arch of Constantine, constructed between 312 and 315 CE to commemorate his victory over Maxentius at the Battle of the Milvian Bridge. This monument incorporated reused relief panels from earlier structures honoring emperors such as Marcus Aurelius (from an arch dedicated in 176 CE), Trajan, and Hadrian, strategically repurposed to associate Constantine's rule with the virtues and successes of these predecessors, thereby legitimizing his authority amid civil strife.^[12]^[17] Such reuse served imperial propaganda by invoking historical continuity, reflecting a causal intent to bridge pagan imperial traditions with Constantine's emerging Christian patronage without fully rejecting Roman heritage.^[18] In parallel, early Christian architecture under Constantine and his successors increasingly drew on spolia from pagan structures, driven by both ideological shifts and practical necessities as the empire faced economic strain and urban decay. Constantine's basilicas, such as the original St. Peter's, integrated columns and marbles from dismantled Roman buildings, marking a transition where materials from disused civic and religious sites supplied rapid church construction amid resource constraints.^[5] This pattern intensified in the late 4th century under Theodosius I (r. 379–395 CE), whose edicts from 391 CE onward prohibited pagan sacrifices and facilitated temple closures, leading to the systematic quarrying of sites like Rome's Temple of Jupiter Capitolinus for Christian edifices.^[19] By the 5th century, amid invasions and quarry exhaustion, spolia reuse addressed material scarcity through pragmatic urban recycling, as seen in the incorporation of amphitheater stones into defensive walls and basilica foundations, prioritizing functionality over new production costs. This era's records, including senatorial decrees and archaeological strata, document the stripping of pagan temples for churches like Santa Sabina, where antique columns were adapted without alteration, underscoring efficiency in a declining economy rather than purely symbolic intent.^[5]^[20]

Medieval Applications

In medieval architecture spanning the 6th to 15th centuries, spolia facilitated construction amid scarce access to new marble due to disrupted quarries and served to assert cultural continuity, imperial prestige, and dominance over prior religious sites in both Christian Europe and the Islamic world.^[4]^[21] Byzantine builders in Italy employed spolia to blend classical heritage with Christian innovation, as in Ravenna's Basilica of San Vitale, consecrated in 548 CE, where interior columns of Greek marble were reused from earlier Roman edifices, enhancing the structure's octagonal design and symbolic layering of Justinianic authority over pagan antiquity.^[22]^[23] This tradition influenced Carolingian projects, exemplified by Charlemagne's Palatine Chapel in Aachen, built circa 792–805 CE, which integrated ancient columns sourced from Rome and Ravenna as spolia to revive Roman imperial splendor and legitimize the Frankish empire's Christian lineage.^[24]^[25] In early Islamic architecture, spolia underscored conquest and appropriation, notably in Jerusalem's Dome of the Rock, erected 691–692 CE, incorporating Herodian ashlars from the Temple Mount platform alongside marble columns and carved elements from Hellenistic, Roman, Persian, and Byzantine origins to visually supplant Jewish and Christian holy sites under Umayyad rule.^[26] Umayyad expansion in Iberia followed suit, with Córdoba's Great Mosque, begun in 784 CE, assembling approximately 850 columns from dismantled Roman temples and Visigothic churches into its hypostyle prayer hall, reflecting resource pragmatism and the ideological overlay of Islamic sovereignty on pre-conquest structures.^[27]^[28]^[29] Later medieval instances included Crusader-era transfers, such as the 4th-century Porphyry Tetrarchs statue looted from Constantinople during the Fourth Crusade in 1204 CE and embedded in Venice's St. Mark's Basilica, embodying trophy reuse that proclaimed Venetian power amid Byzantine decline.^[30]

Renaissance and Post-Medieval Developments

During the Renaissance, the reuse of spolia evolved from primarily pragmatic medieval applications—driven by material scarcity—into a deliberate antiquarian strategy, as humanists and architects sought to revive classical forms through selective integration of ancient fragments, thereby asserting cultural continuity with imperial Rome. This shift reflected a growing emphasis on virtù and scholarly engagement with antiquity, where spolia were prized not just for durability but for their evocative power to confer prestige and authenticity on new commissions. Architects like Donato Bramante employed granite columns and pilasters salvaged from Roman ruins in early projects, such as the Palazzo Cancelleria (completed around 1513), adapting them to create facades that mimicked antique proportions while obscuring their recycled origins through refined placement.^[31]^[32] The Palazzo Farnese exemplifies this intentional revival, with construction beginning in 1514 under Antonio da Sangallo the Younger for Cardinal Alessandro Farnese and continuing under Michelangelo until 1589; its courtyard and facade incorporate ancient granite shafts, sarcophagi, and friezes sourced from Roman excavations, transforming disparate spoils into a cohesive evocation of classical grandeur. This approach marked a departure from medieval spoils-of-war symbolism toward intellectual appropriation, as patrons amassed collections of antiquities that blurred lines between reuse and curation, influenced by the era's antiquarian circles in Rome around 1500, where the term spolia itself emerged among artist-scholars to denote repurposed ancient artifacts.^[31]^[33]^[34] Extending into the Baroque era, Gian Lorenzo Bernini perpetuated this tradition by blending spolia with innovative design, as seen in his baldacchino (1624–1633) over St. Peter's altar, which reused twisted Solomonic columns from the Constantinian basilica—believed to originate from Solomon's Temple—to symbolize ecclesiastical continuity while integrating them into a bronze framework that heightened dramatic effect. In St. Peter's Square colonnades (1656–1667), Bernini further incorporated ancient fragments amid new travertine, balancing restoration of papal heritage with Counter-Reformation spectacle, thus sustaining spolia's role in asserting power through historical allusion rather than mere utility.^[35]^[36]^[32]

Modern and Contemporary Practices

In the post-World War II era, reconstruction in war-devastated European cities often involved repurposing rubble and damaged building materials, marking a pragmatic extension of spolia practices amid material shortages. In Düren, Germany, the Church of St. Anna (rebuilt 1948–1951) incorporated stones and fragments from the city's wartime ruins directly into its walls and structure, prioritizing functionality over aesthetic uniformity.^[37] Similar approaches appeared in other sites, such as the use of salvaged masonry in British post-war housing, where vernacular structures integrated reclaimed elements to expedite rebuilding while conserving resources.^[38] Contemporary architecture has evolved this reuse toward intentional sustainability, linking historical spolia to circular economy principles through empirical lifecycle assessments. The Resource Rows project in Copenhagen, designed by Lendager Group and completed in 2019, constructed 92 housing units using over 85,000 salvaged bricks and modular panels from demolished rural buildings, achieving a 70% reduction in embodied carbon emissions compared to conventional new materials.^[39]^[40] This modular approach sourced 90% of facade elements from deconstructed structures, demonstrating verifiable environmental gains via cradle-to-gate analyses that account for transportation and processing emissions.^[41] Scholarship in the 2020s has theorized these practices as "modernist spolia," emphasizing deliberate material fragmentation to evoke historical continuity while addressing resource depletion. A 2025 study applies this framework to Resource Rows, arguing that such reuse generates experiential depth in architecture by juxtaposing aged and new elements, distinct from mere recycling through its narrative layering.^[42] Broader analyses extend spolia conceptually to evaluate contemporary designs' potential for reducing waste, with proposals for hybrid structures that blend salvaged fragments to foster adaptive, low-impact urbanism.^[43]^[44]

Techniques of Reuse

Sourcing and Extraction

The extraction of spolia from ancient ruins required labor-intensive manual techniques, primarily employing iron chisels, hammers, picks, levers, and wooden or metal wedges to pry apart blocks while minimizing damage to reusable elements.^[45] These methods are evidenced by characteristic tool marks—such as linear grooves from chisels and fracture lines from wedging—observed on marble fragments from late Roman and early Byzantine sites, including those in Constantinople where systematic quarrying targeted architectural members like columns and capitals.^[46] Heavy blocks, often weighing several tons, were then maneuvered using rollers, ramps, and draft animals such as oxen for overland transport, with logistical traces like rutted paths and temporary staging areas documented in excavations at sites like Palmyra during late antiquity.^[47] Practices ranged from selective dismantling of standing structures, which involved careful deconstruction to preserve high-value materials, to opportunistic scavenging amid rubble from naturally collapsed buildings.^[48] Archaeological data from Roman villas and urban sites indicate a preference for premium stones like red porphyry—sourced from Egyptian quarries and valued for its exceptional hardness (Mohs scale 6.5–7) and imperishability—over abundant but less durable local tuffs or limestones, with porphyry comprising up to 20–30% of elite spolia assemblages in early medieval contexts despite its scarcity post-antiquity.^[49] This selectivity is quantified in site inventories, such as those from Monte Sorbo church in Italy, where reused marbles show minimal breakage consistent with intentional extraction rather than random foraging.^[50] Extraction carried inherent risks, including structural instabilities that could precipitate collapses during partial dismantling, as inferred from stratigraphic evidence at Roman sites where layers of tumbled debris overlie extraction phases, indicating failed supports or overloaded remains.^[51] Medieval accounts, such as those describing quarry-like operations on imperial ruins, note inefficiencies like material waste from imprecise cuts—up to 15–20% loss in some marble recoveries—and occasional worker injuries from falling masonry, though quantitative records remain sparse due to the era's limited documentation.^[52] These hazards underscore the pragmatic trade-offs in spoliation, balancing resource scarcity against the physical dangers of exploiting weakened edifices.^[53]

Adaptation and Incorporation

Architects frequently modified spolia to address dimensional mismatches, such as varying column heights and shaft diameters sourced from disparate ancient structures, by recutting ends or fabricating custom bases and plinths to ensure even load distribution and vertical alignment. In Byzantine architecture, for example, columns incorporated into new compositions often exhibited non-uniform sizes, with adaptations like sinking certain bases into stylobates or elevating others to compensate for height discrepancies, as evidenced in archaeological surveys of monuments where uniformity was subordinated to practical integration.^[6] This approach maintained structural stability despite the absence of original proportional harmony, prioritizing empirical fitting over aesthetic consistency.^[54] Capitals and bases underwent similar alterations, including partial recarving to align with new entablature heights or to remove incompatible decorative elements, resulting in observable asymmetries in medieval arcades where ancient Corinthian or Ionic forms were truncated or refaced for bearing capacity. In Romanesque buildings, such interventions addressed the causal challenges of reusing shafts from pagan temples, where mismatched proportions could otherwise induce uneven stress; forensic examination of joints reveals targeted chiseling to fit arches, ensuring the spolia contributed to rather than compromised load-bearing integrity.^[23] Structural reinforcements complemented these modifications, such as embedding spolia columns into walls with thick mortar bedding to distribute forces and conceal irregularities, as seen in Syrian fortifications like Bosra where Ionic shafts were inset flush with facing masonry.^[1] For larger assemblies like domes or vaults, builders integrated spolia fragments into composite masonry, using iron clamps or lead pouring at joints—techniques inherited from Roman engineering—to enhance tensile strength and prevent shear failure, with mortar layers masking transitions between reused and new elements. In late antique Ravenna structures, such as the Baptistery of Neon (ca. 458 CE), polychrome marble columns of varying provenance were adapted via plinth additions and precise leveling, allowing the octagonal framework to support the central dome without original contextual supports.^[3] These methods underscored a pragmatic focus on causal mechanics, where adaptations like polishing surfaces for better adhesion or insetting for facade continuity blended visual eras while upholding engineering viability, as confirmed by material analyses of mortar compositions and tooling marks.^[55]

Symbolic Meanings

Assertions of Power and Continuity

Spolia functioned as tangible assertions of conquest, repurposing materials from defeated predecessors to legitimize new rulers by visually subjugating past powers to the present regime. In Roman practice, this echoed the tradition of displaying military trophies, such as captured arms and standards erected on columns by victorious generals to proclaim dominance over enemies.^[56] The Arch of Constantine exemplifies this, constructed between 312 and 315 CE to commemorate his victory over Maxentius at the Milvian Bridge, incorporating spolia including Dacian statues from Trajan's era, reliefs from Hadrian and Marcus Aurelius, and recut heads resembling Constantine himself. These elements from Rome's esteemed "Five Good Emperors" symbolically positioned Constantine as their successor, restoring imperial glory amid civil strife.^[57] Early Christian rulers adapted this mechanism to claim inheritance of Roman imperium, integrating pagan spolia into sacred structures to transfer secular prestige to the new faith. Constantine's basilica in Rome featured eight red-porphyry columns as spolia, evoking the eternal city's architectural legacy while subordinating it to Christian authority. Eusebius, in his Vita Constantini (ca. 337 CE), lauds these edifices for surpassing pagan precedents in splendor, underscoring their role in affirming the emperor's divine mandate and continuity with Rome's grandeur.^[58] Cross-cultural parallels appear in Islamic contexts, where spolia from conquered Roman, Byzantine, or local antecedent sites signaled unbroken succession and political supremacy. The Umayyad Great Mosque of Córdoba, initiated in 784–786 CE by ʿAbd al-Rahman I, incorporated pre-Islamic capitals and shafts from Roman and Visigothic buildings, thereby legitimizing caliphal rule as the rightful heir to prior empires' authority and resources.^[59] Ottoman conquerors similarly employed spolia in post-1430 CE fortifications, such as the Heptapyrgion in Thessaloniki with embedded Greek inscription fragments, to materialize victory over Byzantine predecessors and project enduring imperial lineage.^[60]

Aesthetic and Functional Transformations

The incorporation of spolia facilitated functional transformations by leveraging the inherent durability of ancient materials, which often surpassed that of contemporaneous local stones in load-bearing capacity and resistance to environmental degradation. Fine-grained marbles quarried in antiquity, such as those from Carrara, featured compact crystallization that minimized porosity and enhanced longevity under exposure, allowing reused columns and blocks to support new structures with proven structural reliability derived from their original engineering.^[61]^[62] This reuse obviated the need for on-site carving of inferior substitutes, streamlining construction while capitalizing on materials that had already withstood centuries of stress without significant compromise.^[9] Aesthetically, spolia engendered layering effects reminiscent of a palimpsest, wherein overlaid motifs and inscriptions from disparate eras created visual stratifications that underscored temporal continuity and material history. The deliberate juxtaposition of heterogeneous elements—varying in style, scale, and provenance—produced dynamic compositions that rejected uniformity, fostering interpretive depth through evident discontinuities rather than seamless integration.^[63] The patina accrued on spolia surfaces further amplified these aesthetic shifts, as natural weathering processes— including lichen growth, mineral leaching, and surface oxidation—imparted subdued hues and subtle textures absent in freshly hewn stone, thereby conferring an immediate sense of venerability. Architectural analyses highlight how this causal progression from exposure enhanced luminous qualities and perceptual value, distinguishing spoliated facades from monochromatic new builds and aligning with precepts in historical treatises favoring appropriated antiquity for enriched visual resonance.^[7]^[4]^[64]

Notable Examples

Roman and Byzantine Instances

The Arch of Constantine, dedicated in 315 AD in Rome to commemorate Emperor Constantine I's victory over Maxentius at the Battle of the Milvian Bridge in 312 AD, prominently features spolia from earlier Roman monuments.^[12]^[17] These include eight large roundels and four river-god reliefs originally carved during the reigns of Trajan (98–117 AD) and Hadrian (117–138 AD), as well as friezes from the era of Marcus Aurelius (161–180 AD).^[12] The spolia depict scenes of imperial hunts, sacrifices, and victories, repurposed to link Constantine's triumph to the legacies of these "good emperors" without major alterations to the figures.^[12] This selective reuse, set into the arch's attic and intercolumniations, measured 21 meters high and 25.9 meters wide, underscored continuity amid political transition.^[17] In Constantinople, the Hagia Sophia's reconstruction under Justinian I, initiated after the Nika riots of 532 AD and completed in 537 AD, incorporated spolia columns from dismantled pagan temples and other antique structures to support its expansive dome and arcades.^[65] The church features 107 columns in total, with green Thessalian marble, red porphyry from Egyptian quarries like Heliopolis, and white marbles traced via isotopic analysis to sources including Proconnesus and Thasos.^[65]^[66] These diverse provenances, confirmed by stable oxygen and carbon isotope ratios in marble samples, reflect empire-wide sourcing for accelerated building during Justinian's military campaigns, including those led by general Narses against Gothic forces in the 530s AD.^[67]^[68] Such empirical tracing via archaeometric methods verifies the spolia's origins, distinguishing reused elements from newly quarried stone.^[69]

Medieval and Islamic Structures

The Palatine Chapel in Aachen, constructed between 792 and 805 under Charlemagne, incorporated ancient marble columns and other spolia transported from Rome and Ravenna to evoke the Roman Empire's architectural splendor and legitimize Carolingian authority.^[24] These elements, including bronze railings and doors described by Einhard as solid bronze adornments, were selected for their imperial associations, with transfers facilitated by papal permissions during Charlemagne's Italian campaigns.^[30]^[70] In al-Andalus after the Umayyad conquest, the Great Mosque of Córdoba, founded by Abd al-Rahman I in 784, reused approximately 856 columns from Roman and Visigothic structures to form its hypostyle hall, where double-tiered arches masked irregularities in column heights and capitals for rhythmic visual effect.^[71] This pragmatic yet symbolic reuse drew from local ruins, including potential villa remnants, to rapidly erect a monument asserting Islamic supremacy over prior Roman and Christian heritage.^[27] Following the 7th-century Arab conquest of Jerusalem, Umayyad builders on the Haram al-Sharif integrated spolia like Herodian ashlars, marble columns, and wooden beams from Hellenistic, Hasmonean, and Roman eras into structures predating the current Al-Aqsa Mosque, positioning these visible ancient fragments to claim continuity with and dominance over conquered histories.^[26] Such displays under caliphs like Abd al-Malik emphasized political victory through the repurposing of pre-Islamic monumental remains, distinct from mere economic expediency.^[72]

Debates and Criticisms

Economic Pragmatism vs. Heritage Destruction

In late antiquity and the early Middle Ages, the collapse of centralized Roman infrastructure after 476 CE led to the abandonment of many commercial stone quarries across Europe, creating acute material shortages that drove builders toward spolia as a readily accessible alternative.^[73] This shift was economically rational, as the extraction and long-distance transport of fresh stone from depleted or distant sources imposed costs far exceeding those of salvaging pre-cut elements from urban ruins, where materials could be repurposed with minimal additional labor.^[74] In regions of political instability, such as post-Roman Italy, this pragmatism enabled the construction of defensive walls, churches, and aqueduct repairs using local spolia, averting total halts in building activity amid declining trade networks and labor shortages.^[8] However, this reuse frequently entailed the deliberate dismantling of intact structures, converting architectural elements into aggregate or lime, which left sites in fragmented states and eroded their stratigraphic integrity for later analysis. For example, late antique quarrying of pagan temples often prioritized high-value marble for burning into mortar, resulting in the near-total erasure of decorative facades and superstructures at urban centers like Rome, where systematic extraction from the 6th century onward reduced complexes to foundational remnants.^[3] Such practices causally diminished the evidential value of these loci, as dispersed components severed original spatial relationships and accelerated weathering through exposure. Archaeological scholarship reflects divided assessments: proponents of pragmatic reuse emphasize its role in sustaining material economies during crises, citing evidence from Iberian and Italian sites where spolia comprised up to 70% of new builds, arguing it prevented broader societal collapse by reallocating scarce resources efficiently.^[75] Critics, drawing on comparative surveys of preserved versus exploited sites, contend the irreversible disassembly inflicted net losses to historical continuity, with untouched rural quarries yielding fuller artifact assemblages than urban areas stripped over centuries, underscoring a trade-off where short-term utility undermined long-term evidentiary preservation.^[76] Empirical data from quarry output records indicate that while reuse mitigated immediate deficits, it entrenched dependency on finite ruin stocks, amplifying depletion cycles in famine-prone or war-torn locales.^[77]

Cultural Appropriation and Symbolic Interpretations

The practice of incorporating spolia has sparked debates framing it as cultural appropriation that asserts dominance over prior civilizations or as creative synthesis that reinterprets and integrates disparate elements into novel architectural narratives. Across Roman, early Christian, and Islamic traditions, reuse served as a normative mechanism to harness the inherent prestige of ancient materials, transferring symbolic authority through their deliberate visibility in new structures rather than through notions of illicit seizure.^[78]^[21]^[79] Triumphalist interpretations emphasize spolia's role in displaying power by subsuming conquered legacies into the appropriator's framework, where the physical relocation and prominent placement causally evoked continuity and superiority without requiring destruction of the source culture's essence.^[80] Conversely, synthesist views highlight how decontextualization enabled layered meanings, such as classical motifs repurposed in religious contexts to signify transcendence over pagan origins, though this occasionally elicited iconoclastic alterations to neutralize perceived idolatrous connotations.^[81] Empirically, such integrations fostered hybrid architectural idioms that blended stylistic and ideological elements, evidencing cultural evolution rather than erasure.^[82] Critics of appropriation contend that spolia's removal from original settings inherently disrupts historical authenticity, potentially commodifying sacred or civic symbols and diminishing their causal ties to foundational narratives.^[83] This perspective draws parallels to modern appropriation art, exemplified by Sherrie Levine's 1980s series After Walker Evans, where rephotographing Depression-era images provoked discussions on whether such acts innovate by challenging originality or erode heritage by severing contextual integrity.^[82] Balanced assessments acknowledge pros like adaptive cultural dynamism—evident in spolia's role in evolving aesthetic paradigms—and cons such as the risk of interpretive loss, without privileging preservation over historical pragmatism.^[84]

References

[1]
Spolia; repurposing masonry - Architextures
Oct 17, 2024 · Spolia (from the Latin: 'spoils'; singular: spolium) is the name given to a stone taken from an old structure and repurposed for new construction or decorative ...Missing: definition | Show results with:definition
[2]
"Reduce, Reuse, and Recycle: The Spolia of Late Antique and Early ...
Feb 8, 2021 · Spolia refers to the intentional reuse of materials or artifacts in the creation of new structures, and when examined critically it can reveal the history.Missing: definition | Show results with:definition
[3]
Spolia in Churches: Recycling in Late Antique Building Activity
The goal is to identify the processes of spoliation of pagan religious (and occasionally non-religious) buildings and the evidence for the reuse of the material ...
[4]
The use of ancient spolia in Byzantine monuments - ResearchGate
Aug 10, 2025 · In Byzantium incorporation of spolia in new architectural compositions was often a means to convey a specific political message.<|separator|>
[5]
[PDF] The Spolia of Late Antique and Early Christian Rome
scholars its usage has expanded to any reuse of materials or artifacts.1 From Constantinople to. Reims, evidence of repurposed structures can be seen in ...
[6]
[PDF] The Use of Ancient Spolia in Byzantine Monuments - ResearchGate
An example from the early Byzantine period is the cemeterial church attached to the temple of Artemis at Sardis, with the exterior origi- nally stuccoed and ...
[7]
Spolia | recycled elements of ancient buildings - Peter Sommer Travels
Aug 26, 2013 · It describes is simply the reuse of elements from earlier buildings in more recent ones, most typically the reuse of Greek or Roman architectural sculpture.
[8]
Agents of spoliation: spolia value and meaning manufacture in al ...
Jun 17, 2025 · This article examines the growing presence and role played by agents of spoliation during late Antiquity and the early medieval era, ...
[9]
From spolia to recycling: the reuse of traditional construction ...
Jan 1, 2016 · This paper presents a review of the reuse of geomaterials, mainly stone, throughout the Italian history of construction, indicating major ...
[10]
Spolia - Brill Reference Works
The word spolia goes back to Latin spoliare (plunder, strip) and spolium (the arms of a slain foe taken as a trophy).
[11]
Spolia - Oxford Reference
“Booty.”(1) In Roman practice, weapons and armor taken as spoils from defeated enemy soldiers.(2) More generally, anything taken in plunder from an enemy during ...
[12]
Arch of Constantine, Rome - Smarthistory
Until relatively recently, art historians viewed the blocky sculptures and use of spolia in the arch as signs of poor craftsmanship, deficient artistry, and ...
[13]
https://www.degruyterbrill.com/document/doi/10.1515/9780691197494-008/html?lang=en
[14]
Reuse Value: <i>Spolia</i> and Appropriation in Art ... - CAA Reviews
Jan 31, 2013 · He expands Brilliant's binary division of spolia in se (material; indexical) and spolia in re (virtual; metaphoric) to a tripartite division ...
[15]
(PDF) Spolia and the Open Work - ResearchGate
Reincarnated, 25–50. 9. The notions of spolia in se and spolia in re were. advanced by Richard Brilliant ...
[16]
[PDF] Scholarship, Research, and Creative Work at Bryn Mawr College
Whereas spolia in se 1night be co1npared to the components of assen1blage and colJage (and vice versa), spolia in re \\1ould be verbal and visual formulas,.
[17]
Features - A Monumental Imperial Biography - March/April 2022
“I think they used spolia because they wanted to do it quickly and cheaply,” Rose says. While the arch itself was purpose-built for the emperor, the builders ...
[18]
Arch of Constantine
The eight rectangular reliefs in the attic come from an arch erected in AD 176 to celebrate the victories of Marcus Aurelius. Three other panels from the ...Missing: spolia | Show results with:spolia
[19]
The End of the Temples: An Archaeological Problem - Academia.edu
The forced closure, or even physical destruction, of pagan temples played a central role in the christianization of the Roman empire in the fourth and fifth ...
[20]
Prolegomena to an Understanding of Spolia in Early Christian Rome
The reuse of spolia in early Christian Rome marked a significant architectural transformation under Constantine. Spolia's integration into buildings emphasized ...
[21]
[PDF] THE INFLUENCE OF SPOLIA ON ISLAMIC ARCHITECTURE
Spolia, the reuse of older building elements, influenced Islamic architecture by using materials from ancient buildings, such as columns and capitals.
[22]
Gold and Geometry: The Architecture of San Vitale in Ravenna
This design is inspired by Eastern models, especially those of Constantinople, and marks a break with traditional Roman church layouts. It creates a space that ...
[23]
https://www.degruyterbrill.com/document/doi/10.1515/atc-2022-1004/html
[24]
Palatine Chapel, Aachen - Smarthistory
[6:27] From Charlemagne, who's bringing spolia from Rome and Ravenna ... Two important models (the Church of the Holy Sepulchre in Jerusalem and San Vitale in ...
[25]
Aachen Cathedral: UNESCO World Heritage Site Travel Guide
Spolia. Palatine Chapel: The chapel makes use of ancient spolia, conceivably ... example of Carolingian architecture world wide, a truly world class site.
[26]
Spolia – A Conscious Display of History in Seventh-Century Jerusalem
The spolia include Herodian stones, marble columns, carved wooden beams, and decorative stones from the Persian, Hellenistic, Hasmonian, and Roman periods and ...
[27]
The Great Mosque of Córdoba - Smarthistory
The expansive prayer hall seems magnified by its repeated geometry. It is built with recycled ancient Roman columns from which sprout a striking combination ...Missing: spolia | Show results with:spolia
[28]
Historic Centre of Cordoba - UNESCO World Heritage Centre
An example of the material assimilation and the proof of authenticity of the monument is the way old Roman and Visigoth columns were reused in Islamic ...Missing: spolia | Show results with:spolia
[29]
Evidence of column organization during their first construction s. VIII ...
Each column is formed by four parts, summit, capital, shaft and base, all of them taken from Roman and Visigoths buildings prior to the Islamic conquest. The ...
[30]
The Medieval Magazine— The Palatine Chapel in Aachen
Feb 14, 2020 · The Palatine Chapel in Aachen is the most important architectural testimony of the Carolingian era. It combines different architectural influences that ...
[31]
Reviving Antiquity with Granite: Spolia and the Development of ...
Oct 19, 2016 · Arguably the greatest example of this phenomenon is the Palazzo Farnese. Cardinal Alessandro Farnese, who obtained an earlier cardinal's ...
[32]
Notes on the Use of Spolia in Roman Architecture from Bramante to ...
This essay examines the subtle but significant changes in how spolia were placed in new buildings in Rome from Bramante to Bernini.<|control11|><|separator|>
[33]
From Spolia to Collections in the Roman Renaissance - Academia.edu
This paper considers the emergence of antiquity collections in renaissance Rome against the backdrop of medieval traditions of spoliation.
[34]
The Concept of Spolia - A Companion to Medieval Art
Feb 1, 2019 · Spolia was coined as a term for reused antiquities by artist-antiquarians active in Rome around 1500.
[35]
View Article: Bernini's work at St. Peter's - University of Washington
Sep 28, 2004 · In Bernini's bronze canopy, he employs twisted marble columns called "solomonicas" which were thought to have come from Solomon's Temple.
[36]
https://www.nytimes.com/books/first/m/marder-bernini.html
[37]
Study: Reuse in the past | Rubble Works
After World War II, the rubble from ruined cities was used to rebuild them, such as the church of St Anna in Düren, Germany. After the town of Gibellina was ...
[38]
[PDF] Spolia Britannica: The historical use of salvaged building materials ...
The Warminster and Shalbourne examples are small houses of essentially vernacular character of 18th century date that display abnormal features caused by their ...
[39]
Old into new: Recycled bricks form facade of Copenhagen housing ...
Aug 8, 2019 · Lendager Group's Resource Rows project in Copenhagen demonstrates a radical recycling approach to materials that significantly cuts construction's carbon ...Missing: spolia | Show results with:spolia
[40]
Resource Rows - Lendager
Sep 10, 2025 · Resource Rows is the world's first residential project constructed of materials from demolished buildings. Through analyses and collaborations ...Missing: spolia | Show results with:spolia
[41]
https://www.detail.de/de_en/brick-patchwork-for-the-climates-sake-resource-rows-in-copenhagen
[42]
(PDF) The modernist spolia - ResearchGate
Jul 3, 2025 · the renowned project Resource Rows (Resourcerækkerne) by the architectural firm Lendager. The project is analysed through the concept of ...
[43]
Spolia Reuse in Contemporary Architectural Design
Jul 19, 2025 · The aim of the article is to shed light on the importance and effectiveness of using the concept of spolia reuse in the design of modern ...
[44]
(PDF) Spolia revisited and extended: The potential for contemporary ...
Aug 9, 2025 · The article suggests extending the concept of spolia to contemporary architecture and discusses the usefulness of the concept in evaluating experiential values.
[45]
2. Stoneworking Tools and Toolmarks - W. Wootton, B. Russell, P ...
Another tool commonly used in the quarrying process, alongside the pick, is the wedge. [21] Wedges can be either wooden or metal and are used to split stone. ...Missing: spolia | Show results with:spolia
[46]
(PDF) Reconsidering the Use of Spolia in Byzantine Constantinople
This study explores the transition in architectural practices in Byzantine Constantinople, particularly focusing on the utilization of spolia as structural ...
[47]
Reuse of building material and sculpture in late antique and early ...
This article aims to provide the first scholarly overview of the practice of reuse of building material in late antique and early Islamic Palmyra (273-750 ...<|separator|>
[48]
Approaching Architectural Recycling in Roman and Late Roman Villas
Aug 6, 2025 · Table 1: Summary of evidence found at the selected villas. Villa Systematic. Removal Organization Reprocessing Transportation.
[49]
Petrifying Power: The Use of Hard-stone Spolia in Norman Sicily (12th
Norman kings in Sicily used Roman hard-stone spolia, especially porphyry, imported from Rome, to create elaborate decorations and sarcophagi.
[50]
[PDF] The Architectural Reuse of Roman Marble and Stone Spolia in the ...
We present the results of a multi-method archaeometric study concerning the architectural el- ements reused in Monte Sorbo church (Sarsina, central Italy) ...Missing: extraction techniques
[51]
[PDF] Architectural Spolia and Urban Transformation in Rome from the ...
This paper is a historical outline of the practice of reuse in Rome between the th and th century AD. It comments on the relevance of the Arch of ...<|control11|><|separator|>
[52]
[PDF] Spoliation in Medieval Rome - CORE
The study of spoliation, as opposed to spolia, is quite recent. Spoliation marks an endpoint, the termination of a buildlng's original form and purpose, ...Missing: risks | Show results with:risks
[53]
The reoccupation of spaces for productive activities in 5th century ...
Current research has made it clear that these activities can no longer be labelled as the result of occasional squatting and scavenging: rather, in ...
[54]
Visual Literacy and Reuse in the Architecture of Late Imperial Rome
Sep 17, 2018 · For instance, even a casual viewer can spot mismatched, varying, or unevenly sized elements where identical architectural materials are expected ...<|control11|><|separator|>
[55]
These old Roman buildings could unlock how to build in a warming ...
Apr 2, 2025 · San Giorgio is a “spolia” church, in which many of the basic architectural elements were reused from older buildings. Spolia is Latin for spoils ...Missing: adaptation | Show results with:adaptation
[56]
Roman Architectural Spolia - Medievalists.net
Feb 12, 2012 · Spolia is an arcane term, even to many art historians. The lit- eral meaning of the Latin word is “spoils,” especially spoils of war.Missing: power victory
[57]
Recycling old glory - The Arch of Constantine
Dec 21, 2017 · Located in the Forum Romanum, the triumphal arch of Emperor Constantine is, like the ruler himself, a mixture of the old and the new.
[58]
Basilica Costantiniana | Article Archive - Sacred Architecture Journal
The eight red-porphyry columns were assembled as spolia by Constantine for this building. (The term spolia refers to visibly reused material in buildings.) ...
[59]
https://doi.org/10.1558/JIA.23646
[60]
THe INflueNce Of SPOlIA ON ISlAmIc ArcHITecTure - Academia.edu
Spolia in Islamic architecture demonstrates historical continuity and cultural appropriation of ancient materials. The study examines spoliation's evolution ...
[61]
https://www.unrv.com/economy/marble.php
[62]
https://www.througheternity.com/en/blog/history/ancient-roman-marbles.html
[63]
[PDF] Contemporary Spolia: Afterlives of Ruins in Fragments
“I piedistalli del giardino di Boboli: spolia in se, spolia in re.” Prospettiva 31 (1982): 2-17. Dietrich, Oliver and Jens Notroff. “Beginning social ...<|separator|>
[64]
Reuse Value: Spolia and Appropriation in Art and Architecture from ...
This book offers a range of views on spolia and appropriation in art and architecture from fourth-century Rome to the late twentieth century.
[65]
Hagia Sophia, 532–37 - The Metropolitan Museum of Art
Oct 1, 2004 · Decorative marble columns were taken from ancient buildings and reused to support the interior arcades. Initially, the upper part of the ...Missing: spolia | Show results with:spolia
[66]
The marbles of two early Christian churches at Latrun (Cyrenaica ...
Sixteen samples (59%) originate from Proconnesos, while 8 samples (30%) are assigned to the calcitic quarries of Thasos and 1 to the Docimium quarries near ...
[67]
Alessandra Guiglia, Claudia Barsanti, Spolia in Constantinople's ...
Internal reuse of spolia maintained architectural unity while adapting to changing contexts. The structure's primary additions occurred during the Ottoman era, ...
[68]
A multi-proxy-Approach for the Determination of White Marbles in ...
In Roman antiquity marble was considered to be a valuable building material and an expression of power. Wealth manifested itself in public building projects ...
[69]
Marble trade in the Roman Mediterranean: a quantitative and ...
Jan 23, 2023 · This article presents the results of a quantitative study of the distribution of white marble in the Mediterranean based on an analysis of the available ...
[70]
[PDF] The Politics of Architecture in Charlemagne's Aachen
Constantine's arch makes use of spolia from several monuments commemorating other emperor's victories; the roundels atop the flanking arches have been traced to ...
[71]
Why Visiting Cordoba Mosque is Bittersweet - Sacred Footsteps
Jul 1, 2015 · The hall contains 856 columns, the material for which was recycled from various Roman buildings. The well-known double arches employed by the ...
[72]
[PDF] Spolia – A Conscious Display of History in Seventh-Century Jerusalem
Nov 3, 2022 · The spolia include Herodian stones, marble columns, carved wooden beams, and decorative stones from the. Persian, Hellenistic, Hasmonian, and.
[73]
The Fall of Rome, II: Energy Problems? - LessWrong
Apr 23, 2021 · After the Western Roman Empire fell in the 5th century many of the commercial stone quarries in Europe were abandoned. This led to a consistent ...Missing: shortages | Show results with:shortages
[74]
Reuse of Statuary and the Recycling Habit of Late Antiquity
Sep 24, 2020 · This chapter examines questions about the role of statue reuse and recycling in the building and sculptural economies of Late Antiquity.
[75]
The Architectural Christian Spolia in Early Medieval Iberia - MDPI
May 28, 2024 · In this study, we delve into the intentionality behind the reuse of construction materials, particularly focusing on the second life given ...
[76]
'Spolia' in Fortifications and the Common Builder in Late Antiquity ...
Mar 5, 2018 · It explores the phenomenon of spolia in the context of late antique fortifications in southern Greece, taking walls at Aegina, Sparta and ...Missing: extraction techniques
[77]
(PDF) Circular Economy in the Roman Period and the Early Middle ...
In recent years, studies on reuse practices in premodern societies have multiplied. Nonetheless, a linear model (production – usage – discard) is still widely ...<|separator|>
[78]
ROMAN SPOLIA, APPROPRIATION AND CULTURAL MEMORY
Indeed, one of the most enduring debates on material appropriation has been the question of how much authority Roman generals had over their spoils. One ...
[79]
(PDF) The Architectural Christian Spolia in Early Medieval Iberia
May 24, 2024 · The reuse and display of certain pieces carry complex implications involving symbology, cultural appropriation, or collective memory exercises ...<|separator|>
[80]
Cultural appropriation and the Roman Empire - Matthew P. Loar ...
Jan 19, 2021 · Cultural appropriation is an important topic for the field of Roman archaeology, and a critical area for further research.
[81]
Spolia: use, re-use and abuse of the architectural fragment from ...
Apr 1, 2009 · The mention how through spolia, and iconoclasm, these Pagan symbols were given Christian re-interpretations.
[82]
Reuse Value: Spolia and Appropriation in Art and Architecture from ...
... spolia in re invites application to other forms of non-physical takhlg-over ... Whereas spolia in se might be compared to the components of assemblage ...
[83]
[PDF] Innovating Objects? Spolia and the Question of Appropriation
Written as a critical discussion, it mirrors the rich debates after the two expert meetings and the interpretative questions this volume hopes to instigate.
[84]
https://brill.com/display/book/9789004682702/BP000011.xml?language=en