Fact-checked by Grok 2 weeks ago

The Alternative Factor

"The Alternative Factor" is the twenty-seventh episode of the first season of the American science fiction television series Star Trek: The Original Series. Written by Don Ingalls and directed by Gerd Oswald, it originally aired on NBC on March 30, 1967, with a runtime of approximately 50 minutes.^[1] In the story, set on stardate 3087.6, the USS Enterprise crew experiences a brief, inexplicable period of non-existence across the galaxy caused by a gravitational anomaly on a barren planet, leading Captain James T. Kirk (William Shatner) and his team to discover Lazarus (Robert Brown), a deranged scientist who travels between a positive-matter universe and an anti-matter parallel universe via a handheld device and a corridor of suspended animation, in pursuit of his monstrous alter ego whose unchecked actions risk annihilating both realities.^[1]^[2] The episode features the core cast including Leonard Nimoy as Spock, DeForest Kelley as Dr. Leonard McCoy, and James Doohan as Chief Engineer Montgomery Scott, with Lazarus's internal conflict forcing Kirk to confront ethical dilemmas involving the Enterprise's critical dilithium crystals, which power the ship's warp engines and become pivotal to resolving the inter-universal threat.^[1] It explores themes of duality, madness, and the fragility of existence, introducing Star Trek's concept of matter-antimatter interactions extending to parallel dimensions, where contact between opposing forms could trigger universal destruction.^[3] Despite its innovative premise involving cosmic-scale stakes, "The Alternative Factor" has been critiqued for uneven pacing, repetitive dialogue, and an abrupt resolution, earning a C- grade in retrospective reviews that praise its ambition but note the execution's shortcomings, such as overreliance on visual effects like static distortions to depict the "Alternative Factor."^[4] The episode holds a 5.7/10 rating on IMDb based on over 4,300 user votes, reflecting mixed reception among fans for its bold ideas amid production constraints typical of mid-1960s television.^[1]

Episode Overview

Production Credits

The episode "The Alternative Factor" was written by Don Ingalls, who submitted the original teleplay in 1966.^[1] Gerd Oswald directed the episode, overseeing principal photography in late November 1966.^[1] Robert Brown was cast as the guest star Lazarus after John Drew Barrymore, originally selected for the role, failed to appear for filming, resulting in his suspension by the Screen Actors Guild for six months.^[5] The score was composed by Alexander Courage, with cinematography handled by Gerald Perry Finnerman.^[6] This first-season installment of Star Trek bears production number 20 and was filmed from November 16 to 23, 1966, before airing as the 27th episode on March 30, 1967.^[1]^[7]

Broadcast and Release

"The Alternative Factor" originally aired on NBC on March 30, 1967, as part of the first season of Star Trek: The Original Series, in the network's Thursday 8:30–9:00 p.m. ET time slot.^[1]^[8] The episode drew a Nielsen household rating of 17.0 with a 27.3 share, translating to approximately 9.33 million viewers.^[9] The episode has been released on various home media formats over the decades. It was first made available on VHS in the United States as part of Paramount's early 1980s tape series, with fuller season compilations following in 1986.^[10] Laserdisc editions appeared in 1991, offering higher-quality analog video of the episode paired with others from the series.^[11] The first widespread digital release came with the 2000 DVD box set for season 1, which included restored visuals and bonus features.^[12] In 2009, a Blu-ray remaster of the complete series provided enhanced effects and high-definition transfers from the original film elements.^[13] Following its network run, "The Alternative Factor" entered local syndication in 1968, with repeats airing on independent stations across the U.S. after the full first season concluded.^[14] It became a staple of syndicated packages in the 1970s, contributing to the show's cult following, and remains accessible on streaming services, including Paramount+ where the remastered version has been available since the platform's 2021 launch.^[15] Internationally, the episode received its first United Kingdom broadcast on BBC One on December 6, 1969, as part of the network's initial run of the series that began earlier that summer.^[16]

Narrative and Characters

Plot Summary

The USS Enterprise, under Captain James T. Kirk, detects a massive energy distortion that briefly causes all matter in the galaxy to cease existing for a fraction of a second, prompting a red alert and a Code One alert from Starfleet Command.^[17] The crew traces the anomaly to a nearby lifeless planet and beams down a landing party, including Kirk, Spock, and Dr. Leonard McCoy, where initial sensor scans detect no signs of life. Suddenly, a disheveled man named Lazarus materializes, bandaged and frantic, claiming to be a human scientist pursued by a monstrous entity that destroyed his research outpost; he identifies himself as the inventor of a device capable of traversing time and space.^[17] Aboard the Enterprise, Lazarus recounts how his experiments opened a corridor between parallel universes—one composed of matter like their own, and the other of anti-matter—allowing him to encounter his exact duplicate, a deranged counterpart intent on annihilating the matter universe to end their eternal feud. Each crossing through the corridor by either Lazarus triggers another galaxy-wide pulse, and transporter malfunctions begin occurring as the rifts destabilize, stranding crew members temporarily.^[17] The matter Lazarus warns that his anti-matter counterpart steals the ship's dilithium crystals to power his crossing into their universe, where direct contact between the duplicates would annihilate both realities due to matter-antimatter interaction.^[7]^[18] As the anti-matter Lazarus sneaks aboard the ship, he kills Lieutenant Charlene Masters by injecting her neck while she works in engineering on the dilithium crystals. The dimensional crossings by the two Lazaruses cause additional galaxy-wide blips that erase brief segments of local history, leaving witnesses with false memories of events that never occurred.^[7]^[18] Kirk confronts the two Lazaruses in the corridor, visualized as an endless hall of mirrors reflecting infinite versions of themselves, where the matter Lazarus begs for help to stop his counterpart. In the climax, after Kirk learns the truth from the matter Lazarus, they return to the Enterprise, which fires phasers at the anti-matter Lazarus's ship on the planet, destroying it and sealing the corridor, trapping the warring duplicates in perpetual combat within the limbo between universes, thereby preventing further pulses, though at the cost of Masters's life and the Lazaruses' eternal banishment.^[7]^[18] The Enterprise resumes its mission, with the galaxy restored to stability.

Cast and Roles

William Shatner stars as Captain James T. Kirk, who leads the Enterprise crew's investigation into a mysterious spatial disturbance and ultimately makes the profound ethical decision to isolate the antagonists within an interdimensional corridor to preserve reality.^[19] Leonard Nimoy portrays Mr. Spock, offering precise logical analysis of the anomalous events threatening the galaxy.^[19] DeForest Kelley plays Dr. Leonard "Bones" McCoy, voicing critical medical concerns about the risks involved in beaming down to the affected planet.^[19] Guest star Robert Brown embodies Lazarus, a disheveled and frantic scientist whose portrayal carries dual implications as both the tormented inventor and his malevolent anti-matter counterpart from a parallel universe.^[19] Janet MacLachlan appears as Lieutenant Charlene Masters, the engineering officer who encounters a fatal confrontation with the intruder aboard the Enterprise.^[19] Richard Derr as Commodore Robert Barstow, Starfleet officer who briefs Kirk on orders to treat the anomaly as potential invasion bait.^[7] The episode also features minor roles such as Eddie Paskey as Lieutenant Leslie, alongside uncredited extras depicting the security team responding to the onboard threat.^[20] Originally, John Drew Barrymore was cast in the role of Lazarus for his renowned dramatic intensity, but he failed to report for filming without notice, prompting a last-minute replacement by Robert Brown; the hurried circumstances led to criticism that Brown's performance, while committed, lacked the envisioned depth and fervor.^[21]^[22]

Production Process

Development and Writing

The script for "The Alternative Factor" originated from an original story by Don Ingalls, a longtime friend of series creator Gene Roddenberry and a former Los Angeles police officer who had transitioned into television writing. Ingalls submitted his story outline on August 29, 1966, drawing on multiverse concepts common in science fiction literature to depict parallel universes clashing through matter and anti-matter forces. Following the initial outline, Ingalls revised it on September 12 and again on September 14, 1966, before delivering the first draft teleplay on October 14. A second draft arrived on November 7, with final revisions by the production staff, including input from Roddenberry, completed between November 14 and 18—just days before filming began. Roddenberry directed the removal of a romantic subplot between a crew member and Lazarus to avoid repetition with the episode "Space Seed." The episode's thematic intent centered on an obsessive interdimensional chase to prevent universal annihilation, though the writing process was expedited due to the grueling pace of first-season production. Casting decisions influenced late-stage script tweaks when John Drew Barrymore, initially selected for the dual role of Lazarus on November 10, 1966, was suspended by the Screen Actors Guild after breaching the contract for this episode by withdrawing during the first day of shooting, November 16. Robert Brown, a stage actor with a more restrained performance style, stepped in as a last-minute replacement, prompting minor adjustments to dialogue and scenes to align with his subtler interpretation of the character's manic duality.^[21] Budget constraints shaped the script's design from the outset, with writers incorporating reused standing sets—such as the rocky planet surface from earlier episodes like "The Naked Time"—to minimize expenses. Production memos highlighted concerns over potential costs.

Filming and Technical Aspects

Filming for "The Alternative Factor" occurred from November 16 to November 26, 1966, primarily on Desilu Stages 9 and 10 in Hollywood, California, with exterior planet scenes captured at Vasquez Rocks Natural Area Park in Agua Dulce, California.^[1] Stage 9 hosted initial bridge sequences excluding the character Lazarus, while Stage 10 accommodated interior planet sets and additional Enterprise interiors.^[23] The episode's special effects team, led by Edward K. Milkis, crafted the iconic corridor sequence—depicting the negative magnetic corridor between parallel universes—through optical compositing techniques combined with strategic mirror shots to evoke an infinite regression effect.^[23] Footage of the Trifid Nebula, sourced from Palomar Observatory archives, was integrated to visualize the galaxy-wide disruptions and universe shifts triggered by the antagonist's movements.^[24] Phaser fire effects were repurposed from prior episodes like "The Enemy Within" to streamline production within the series' tight budget constraints.^[23] Technical hurdles arose in lighting the corridor set, where diffused illumination was essential to maintain the illusion of endless depth without revealing mirror edges or casting unintended shadows.^[23] Set designer Rolland Anderson modified the existing Enterprise engineering section to construct Lazarus's makeshift lab, incorporating modular panels for rapid assembly.^[23] For the dual portrayals of Lazarus, makeup artist Fred Phillips applied basic aging prosthetics—gray hair streaks and facial wrinkling—to differentiate the anti-matter counterpart, relying on subtle alterations rather than elaborate transformations.^[23] Director Gerd Oswald emphasized tight close-ups during confrontation scenes involving the dual Lazaruses to amplify psychological tension and duality themes, though the overall pacing was compromised by abbreviated rehearsals amid the demanding seven-day schedule.^[23]

Themes and Reception

Scientific and Philosophical Concepts

"The Alternative Factor" marks the first depiction of parallel universes in Star Trek: The Original Series, introducing the concept through an interdimensional corridor that connects the Enterprise's reality to an antimatter counterpart universe, predating the more famous Mirror Universe storyline in the episode "Mirror, Mirror."^[25] This portrayal draws loosely from Hugh Everett's 1957 many-worlds interpretation of quantum mechanics, which posits that all possible outcomes of quantum measurements occur in branching, non-interacting parallel realities, though the episode simplifies this into a singular, accessible "mirror" universe without exploring the probabilistic branching inherent to Everett's theory.^[26] Everett's framework, formalized in his PhD thesis and later popularized by Bryce DeWitt, avoids wave function collapse by allowing the universe to split into multiple versions, a concept that has permeated science fiction but is abstracted here to emphasize dramatic conflict over quantum superposition.^[27] The episode's central scientific idea revolves around antimatter as the substance of the parallel universe, where contact between matter and antimatter from opposing realities would trigger catastrophic annihilation, releasing energy equivalent to the combined mass of the interacting particles according to Einstein's mass-energy equivalence principle, E = mc².^[28] In real physics, antimatter particles, such as antiprotons and positrons, possess the same mass as their matter counterparts but opposite charge and quantum numbers; upon annihilation, they convert entirely into photons or other particles, producing up to 100% efficient energy release, far surpassing nuclear reactions.^[29] However, the episode dramatizes this as a destructive "mirror reality" where entire universes could collide, diverging from established physics where such interactions occur only at particle scales in controlled environments like CERN's accelerators, and no evidence supports stable, macroscopic antimatter universes coexisting with our matter-dominated one.^[30] Philosophically, the narrative explores duality through the two Lazarus figures—one a noble scientist from the matter universe and the other a vengeful counterpart from the antimatter realm—embodying a classic good-versus-evil dichotomy that echoes Robert Louis Stevenson's Strange Case of Dr Jekyll and Mr Hyde, where internal conflict manifests as split identities grappling with moral opposites. This setup raises ethical questions about intervention and sacrifice, as Captain Kirk ultimately chooses to contain the interdimensional threat by trapping the evil Lazarus in a perpetual corridor loop, prioritizing the preservation of both universes over destruction, which underscores themes of moral responsibility in averting existential catastrophe.^[25] Despite its conceptual ambitions, the episode contains notable scientific inaccuracies, such as the depiction of a stable, corridor-like bridge between universes, which contradicts quantum mechanics' prohibition on interactions between Everettian branches, as the many-worlds interpretation predicts isolated realities without causal links or portals.^[31] Furthermore, the antimatter universe ignores the baryon asymmetry problem in cosmology, where the observable universe shows a slight excess of matter over antimatter from the Big Bang, with no observed large-scale antimatter domains that could sustain life or stable structures without immediate annihilation upon contact with matter.^[30] As an early television exploration of multiverse tropes, "The Alternative Factor" influenced subsequent science fiction by popularizing the idea of accessible parallel realities in serialized storytelling, paving the way for more nuanced depictions in later Star Trek episodes like "The City on the Edge of Forever," which further integrated quantum-inspired alternate timelines into the franchise's narrative fabric.^[25] This episode's blend of Everett's ideas with dramatic peril helped normalize the multiverse as a staple of speculative fiction, inspiring broader cultural engagement with quantum interpretations long before they gained mainstream scientific traction.^[32]

Critical Response and Legacy

Upon its original broadcast in 1967, "The Alternative Factor" received mixed reviews from contemporary critics, who praised its ambitious exploration of parallel universes but criticized its confusing narrative and slow pacing. In modern assessments, the episode is frequently ranked among the weakest of Star Trek: The Original Series. A 2013 Hollywood.com ranking placed it 77th out of 79 episodes, highlighting its muddled plot and lack of coherence as key flaws. Similarly, The A.V. Club's 2013 review awarded it a C- grade, faulting the repetitive dialogue, circuitous action, and delayed revelation of the story's core concept until the final minutes, though acknowledging the ambition of its cosmic stakes.^[33]^[4] The episode's legacy endures primarily through its introduction of the multiverse concept to Star Trek lore, depicting interdimensional rifts that threaten reality and establishing parallel selves in conflict. This idea influenced later series, notably The Next Generation's "Parallels," where Worf experiences shifts across infinite realities, building on the gateway mechanics first shown here. Fan discussions often emphasize production challenges, such as the last-minute recasting of Lazarus from John Drew Barrymore to Robert Brown, which contributed to uneven acting and a rushed feel.^[25]^[23] Culturally, "The Alternative Factor" is viewed as a flawed yet bold first-season experiment in speculative fiction, with its themes of duality briefly echoing in broader Trek explorations of identity. The 2009 remastered Blu-ray release enhanced its visual effects, slightly improving appreciation for the episode's corridor sequences and corridor gateway, though it did not elevate its overall standing. In syndication, it garnered fewer repeat viewings compared to acclaimed entries like "The City on the Edge of Forever," reflecting its persistent reputation as a lesser highlight of the franchise.^[34]

References

[1]
"Star Trek" The Alternative Factor (TV Episode 1967) - IMDb
Rating 5.7/10 (4,320) Existence itself comes under threat from a man's power-struggle with his alternate self, with the Enterprise's strained dilithium crystals presenting his key to ...
[2]
The Alternative Factor - TOS :: TrekCore
After a disconcerting period of "nonexistence", Kirk finds a man called Lazarus who claims to be the cause of the distortion and is chasing an enemy with ...
[3]
Star Trek: The Original Series (Remastered) - The Alternative Factor
Apr 7, 2022 · Sign up for Paramount+ to stream. ... S1 E28: An alien being fights himself across two realities. Featuring: William Shatner, Leonard Nimoy, DeForest Kelley, ...
[4]
Star Trek: "Errand Of Mercy" / "The Alternative Factor" - AV Club
Apr 17, 2009 · Energy, yeah, pacing, sexiness, action, adventure, two-fisted heroes, all that stuff, sure, that's why we love it.Missing: review | Show results with:review
[5]
"Star Trek" The Alternative Factor (TV Episode 1967) - Trivia - IMDb
John Drew Barrymore was originally cast as Lazarus, but failed to show up for shooting and had to be replaced by Robert Brown causing the episode to go two ...
[6]
"Star Trek" The Alternative Factor (TV Episode 1967) - Full cast & crew
Producers. Edit · Gene L. Coon ; Composer. Edit · Alexander Courage ; Cinematographer. Edit · Gerald Perry Finnerman ; Editor. Edit · James Ballas ; Casting ...
[7]
Building NBC's 1966-1967 Schedule - Television Obscurities
Returning series Laredo was shifted to Fridays at 10:00PM and Star Trek was given the 8:30-9:30PM slot on Thursdays.
[8]
TOS Nielsen Ratings Season 1 | The Trek BBS
Jan 1, 2024 · The TrekBBS is the number one place to chat about Star Trek with like-minded fans. ... 03/30/67 - The Alternative Factor 9.330 million 17.0/ 27.3
[9]
Star Trek on VHS | The Trek BBS
Nov 21, 2012 · The first round of VHS releases of the individual episodes occurred in February 1985, with episodes 1-10 being released (original air dates were between 9/8/66 ...Early 80s TOS VHS Tapes | Page 5 - The Trek BBSOld Star Trek TOS DVD'sMore results from www.trekbbs.com
[10]
Star Trek: The Original Series (LaserDisc) - Memory Alpha - Fandom
The first Star Trek: The Original Series episodes released on LaserDisc ... 1991, in full color. This brought the total number of discs up to 42 for the US ...
[11]
Star Trek - The Original Series, Vol. 10, Episodes 19 & 20: Arena ...
30-day returnsStar Trek - The Original Series, Vol. 10, Episodes 19 & 20: Arena/ The Alternative Factor [DVD] ; Contributor, ‎Bill Blackburn, DeForest Kelley, Eddie Paskey, ...
[12]
Star Trek: The Complete Original Series Blu-ray
730-day returnsJul 17, 2009. Star Trek: The Complete Original Series Blu-ray. $76.99 $64.79 · Buy Star Trek: The Complete Original Series on Blu-ray. Select category (Add ...
[13]
A Look At Star Trek - Television Obscurities
The series was one of only nine new programs ranking above the 50th position in the Nielsen ratings (others included Tarzan, A Family Affair and Iron Horse) [21] ...
[14]
Star Trek Season 1 Episodes - Watch on Paramount+
Star Trek: The Original Series (Remastered) : The Alternative Factor'. The Alternative Factor. S1 E28. Mar 29, 1967. An alien being fights himself across two ...
[15]
Star Trek on the BBC: 1969 - Space Doubt
Oct 25, 2014 · 2)1969-12-06: Memory Alpha lists The Alternative Factor as being broadcast on this date while the BBC Genome site opts for Court Martial.
[16]
"Star Trek" The Alternative Factor (TV Episode 1967) - Plot - IMDb
"Star Trek" The Alternative Factor (TV Episode 1967) - Plot summary, synopsis, and more...
[17]
https://www.imdb.com/title/tt0708451/plotsummary/
[18]
The Alternative Factor - Guest Cast | TVmaze
Guest Stars · DeForest Kelley · Nichelle Nichols · Eddie Paskey · Richard Derr · Janet MacLachlan · Arch Whiting · Christian Patrick.
[19]
TODAY IN STAR TREK HISTORY: The Role of Lazarus in "The ...
Nov 16, 2022 · Meanwhile, director Gerd Oswald and the casting staff had to replace Barrymore. Robert Brown had worked with William Shatner on an unsold TV ...
[20]
Star Trek at 50: The Alternative Factor - Bronze Age Babies
Jun 29, 2016 · The original choice to play Lazarus was John Drew Barrymore, son of John Barrymore, future father of Drew Barrymore, and at the time, a ...<|control11|><|separator|>
[21]
Filming of "Alternative Factor" - These are the voyages: tos
John Drew Barrymore was visiting wardrobe on this day for final costume fittings. Before leaving, he was given the revised script. And then he quit the ...
[22]
Trifid Nebula - Memory Alpha - Fandom
(TOS: "The Alternative Factor"). Whenever Lazarus changed universes, a picture of the Trifid Nebula was seen. An image of the nebula, taken by the Hubble ...
[23]
Trek Through The Multiverse! Star Trek's Best Parallel Dimensions
Jan 7, 2025 · In TOS Season 1, "The Alternative Factor" introduced a potentially galaxy-destroying event, caused by inter-dimensional travel. In this episode ...Missing: summary | Show results with:summary
[24]
Hugh Everett: The man who gave us the multiverse | New Scientist
Sep 24, 2014 · Hugh Everett's many-worlds interpretation of quantum mechanics arose from what must have been the most world-changing drinking session of all time.<|separator|>
[25]
The Many-Worlds Theory, Explained | The MIT Press Reader
May 20, 2020 · It was Hugh Everett who introduced the idea of the Universe “splitting” into different versions of itself when faced with quantum choices, ...
[26]
Matter - Antimatter Creation and Annihilation - Nuclear Power
When an electron and a positron collide, they annihilate, resulting in the complete conversion of their rest mass to pure energy (according to the E=mc2 formula) ...
[27]
Ask Ethan: Why do matter and antimatter annihilate? - Big Think
Jun 7, 2024 · Matter and antimatter annihilate due to quantum laws, producing energy and particles, when they interact, rather than forming bound states.
[28]
https://www.nuclear-power.com/nuclear-power/reactor-physics/atomic-nuclear-physics/fundamental-particles/what-is-antimatter/matter-antimatter-creation-and-annihilation/
[29]
What 'Star Trek: Discovery' Gets Right (And Wrong) About Parallel ...
Jan 15, 2018 · The Science: In this episode, the concept of parallel Universes is all the rage. The idea dates back to a particular interpretation of quantum ...
[30]
Quantum culture - CERN Courier
Jul 8, 2025 · Is the many-worlds interpretation the most common theory used in science fiction inspired by quantum mechanics? Many-worlds has become ...
[31]
Ranking All 79 'Star Trek: The Original Series' Episodes from Worst ...
· 78. “Spock's Brain” — · 77. “The Alternative Factor” — · 76. “Wolf in the Fold” — · 75. “The Way to Eden” — · 74. “The ...
[32]
Star Trek: The Remastered Series Seasons 1, 2 & 3 review
May 20, 2009 · Season 1 isn't without its duff moments – The Alternative Factor tells the story of a man named Lazarus who is locked in combat with his ...Missing: reception | Show results with:reception