Fact-checked by Grok 2 weeks ago

Totem and Taboo

Totem and Taboo (German: Totem und Tabu) is a seminal 1913 work by in which he extends psychoanalytic principles to , examining the psychological underpinnings of totemism, taboos, and early forms of religion and social organization in "primitive" societies. The book consists of four essays originally published as articles in the psychoanalytic journal between 1912 and 1913, drawing on ethnographic studies by scholars such as to draw parallels between the mental lives of so-called savages and neurotics. Freud posits that totemism—a system where clans identify with and revere a specific animal or plant as their —originates from a prehistoric "primal " scenario inspired by , in which a dominant father monopolizes access to females, leading to his murder and devouring by his sons. This act of generates profound guilt and remorse among the brothers, resulting in the establishment of totemic taboos: prohibitions against killing the totem (a father substitute) and against uous relations with former horde women, thereby instituting and the foundations of morality. In the essays, Freud explores these themes sequentially: the first addresses the dread of and its parallels to the ; the second delves into the ambivalence underlying taboos, akin to obsessional neuroses; the third connects and magic to the "omnipotence of thoughts" in primitive mentality; and the fourth links the return of totemism to childhood development, reinforcing phylogenetic inheritance of guilt. The work's significance lies in its attempt to trace the evolution of through unconscious drives, portraying as a collective defense mechanism against the trauma of the primal , with emerging as an idealized . Though controversial for its reliance on now-outdated Lamarckian ideas of inherited and speculative , Totem and Taboo profoundly influenced Freud's later theories on civilization, such as in , and sparked interdisciplinary debates in , , and .

Publication and Context

Historical Background

Sigmund Freud composed Totem and Taboo during 1912 and 1913, initially publishing it as four independent essays in the journal Imago, a periodical he co-edited with Otto Rank and Hanns Sachs that debuted in March 1912 to apply psychoanalytic insights to cultural and literary analysis. The essays appeared sequentially: the first in the inaugural volume of 1912, followed by the others through 1913, marking Freud's deliberate effort to serialize his exploration of psychoanalytic principles in non-clinical domains. This writing process reflected Freud's growing ambition to integrate psychoanalysis with emerging fields like ethnology, driven by his observation of parallels between neurotic behaviors and the mental lives of "primitive" peoples. The essays were compiled into a single volume titled Totem und Tabu: Einige Übereinstimmungen im Seelenleben der Wilden und der Neurotiker, published in 1913 by Hugo Heller & Cie. in and . Freud dated the preface from in September 1913, acknowledging the work's preliminary nature while emphasizing its role in bridging with . The first English translation, authorized by Freud and rendered by A. A. Brill, appeared in in 1918 under the title Totem and Taboo: Some Points of Agreement between the Mental Lives of Savages and Neurotics. In the broader socio-cultural milieu of early 20th-century , was ascending as a revolutionary discipline amid intellectual ferment, with the Vienna Psychoanalytic Society—founded by Freud in 1902—serving as a key hub for theoretical development by 1912. This period coincided with heightened anthropological interest in totemism and taboo practices, fueled by ethnographic reports from colonial expeditions and syntheses like Wilhelm Wundt's Elements of Folk Psychology (1912), prompting Freud to extend psychoanalytic methods beyond individual therapy to interpret the origins of social institutions in "primitive" societies. Freud's motivations stemmed from a desire to uncover universal psychic structures, viewing these cultural phenomena as residues of early human mental processes akin to those in childhood and neurosis.

Key Influences

Sigmund Freud's Totem and Taboo (1913) was profoundly shaped by James George Frazer's The Golden Bough (1890–1915), which provided a rich comparative framework for understanding totemism and ritual practices across cultures. Frazer's extensive documentation of totemic exogamy, sacrificial rites, and magical prohibitions influenced Freud's exploration of incest taboos and the symbolic killing of the totem animal, which Freud reinterpreted as manifestations of repressed Oedipal guilt and ambivalence toward authority figures. For instance, Frazer's analysis of the Arunta tribe's totemic customs and ritual enactments of primal myths supplied ethnographic examples that Freud adapted to argue for a universal psychological origin in the "primal horde" scenario, where sons collectively murder the father. However, Freud critiqued Frazer's evolutionary anthropology for its overreliance on superficial cultural parallels without delving into unconscious motivations, transforming these rituals into evidence of neurotic-like mechanisms in primitive societies. Wilhelm Wundt's Elements of Folk Psychology (1912, originally published in German as Völkerpsychologie, 1900–1909) offered Freud a structural for conceptualizing mentality as a precursor to modern psychic life. Wundt's examination of , , and collective mental processes in "primitive" peoples influenced Freud's comparisons between "savages" and neurotics, particularly in framing totemism as an early form of bonding rooted in shared illusions and projections. Freud adopted Wundt's idea of folk psychology as a bridge between individual and group mind but critiqued its methodological limitations, such as its avoidance of and reliance on speculative historical reconstructions, instead integrating it with psychoanalytic tools to reveal underlying libidinal drives and emotional ambivalences. This adaptation allowed Freud to posit that thought patterns, like the " of ideas" in , mirrored obsessional neuroses, thereby extending Wundt's framework into a theory of universal psychic development. Contributions from Carl Jung's early work, notably The Psychology of the Unconscious (1912, German Wandlungen und Symbole der Libido), informed Freud's engagement with mythological symbols and the archaic layers of the , precursors to Jung's later concept. Jung's analysis of as a broader, non-sexual energy manifesting in myths and totems encouraged Freud to explore parallels between primitive rituals and unconscious , such as the father-imago in totemic figures. Yet Freud critiqued Jung's emerging views for diluting sexual , adapting these ideas selectively to reinforce his own emphasis on incestuous wishes and repression while dismissing Jungian as insufficiently grounded in individual conflict. William Robertson Smith's The Religion of the Semites (1889) exerted a significant influence on Freud's understanding of religious practices, particularly the communal feast as a sacrificial that binds the through shared consumption of the divine . Smith's that such rituals originated in the killing and eating of a god-representing to affirm ties shaped Freud's central hypothesis of the primal , where the meal commemorates the murder of the primal father and establishes social taboos. Freud adapted this ethnographic insight to psychoanalytic purposes, interpreting the as a resolution of Oedipal through guilt and , but he critiqued Smith's historical focus for overlooking the psychological dynamics of and . Overall, Freud synthesized these sources—Frazer's rituals, Wundt's mental stages, Jung's , and Smith's sacrifices—into a cohesive of cultural origins driven by unconscious forces, while highlighting their shortcomings in addressing repressed instincts.

Content Overview

The Horror of Incest

In the first essay of Totem and Taboo, Sigmund Freud examines the universal prohibition against incest, emphasizing its manifestation in primitive societies through exogamy and totemism, particularly among Australian Aboriginal tribes. Exogamy mandates marriage and sexual relations outside one's own clan or group, serving as a primary mechanism to prevent incestuous unions. Freud draws heavily on ethnographic accounts, such as those compiled by James George Frazer, to illustrate how totem clans—social units identified with a sacred animal, plant, or natural phenomenon—enforce these rules by prohibiting intra-clan marriages, often under threat of severe punishment, including death. Among Australian Aboriginals, totemism structures in intricate ways, with clans tracing descent matrilineally and viewing the as an ancestral protector that must not be harmed or consumed, except in contexts that reinforce communal bonds. Freud highlights the Arunta as a key example, where societal organization into clans limits potential marriage partners dramatically—for instance, reducing eligible women from nearly all (11/12) to only about one-quarter for any given . This system extends to "matrimonial classes," a series of subdivided groups (often four or eight in total) that further regulate alliances, ensuring by assigning individuals to specific classes at birth and prohibiting unions within the same class or subclass. These classes function as protective barriers against , transforming natural inclinations into rigidly enforced social norms. Freud parallels these primitive safeguards with protective measures observed in modern civilized families and among individuals suffering from obsessional neuroses. In contemporary households, subtle prohibitions and emotional barriers deter incestuous impulses, much like the overt clan restrictions in Aboriginal societies; similarly, obsessional neurotics erect elaborate mental defenses—such as rituals and avoidances—to repress forbidden desires toward family members. These neurotic symptoms, Freud argues, reveal the persistence of incestuous wishes in the unconscious, akin to the "horror of incest" that permeates primitive taboos. Central to Freud's analysis is the contention that taboos originate not merely from their social utility in promoting group cohesion or preventing , but from deeply rooted unconscious wishes and the internal conflicts they provoke. Rather than an instinctive revulsion, the prohibition arises as a reaction-formation against repressed desires, amplified by emotional toward —manifesting as both attraction and dread. This psychological dynamic underscores the taboo's intensity across cultures, positioning it as a bridge between savage life and neurotic .

Taboo and Emotional Ambivalence

In the second essay of Totem and Taboo, explores the concept of as a fundamental prohibition in primitive societies, deriving its origins from Polynesian terminology where it denotes both the sacred and the dangerously forbidden. Freud describes as a word that encapsulates an object or action as consecrated and thus untouchable, yet simultaneously uncanny, perilous, and unclean, with its opposite being "noa," meaning ordinary or accessible. This dual nature enforces strict social restrictions, where violations are believed to trigger automatic punishments, such as death or misfortune, without requiring human intervention. For instance, in Polynesian cultures, touching a chief's possessions or food could lead to the offender's immediate demise due to the inherent ""—a mysterious, transmissible power—embodied in the tabooed item. Freud draws on examples from Melanesian societies to illustrate taboo's pervasive influence, particularly around authority figures and sacred rites. Chiefs and priests, such as those on the Islands or in the Banks Islands, live under severe constraints: they may not touch the ground with their bare feet, lie down fully, or interact freely with others, as their bodies are infused with that renders them both revered and hazardous. A notable case involves a Maori slave who died after eating from a chief's meal, attributed to the taboo's violation offending the chief's spirit. These prohibitions extend to everyday interactions, like mourners avoiding contact with widows or the possessions of the deceased, underscoring taboo's role in maintaining through fear of . Central to Freud's analysis is the psychological mechanism of emotional underlying taboos, where individuals harbor simultaneous feelings of and toward the tabooed object or person. This arises from repressed desires to transgress the , which persist in the unconscious, fostering a persistent tension that manifests in rituals and observances. For example, the of in societies masks underlying and , as the tabooed figure is both idealized and resented, leading to elaborate avoidance ceremonies that project these ambivalent emotions outward. Freud posits that such duality is not merely cultural but rooted in universal human impulses, where the sacred allure draws one closer even as danger repels. Freud links this ambivalence to neurotic phenomena, particularly obsessional neurosis, where taboo-like prohibitions evoke intense guilt upon imagined or actual violation, mirroring the compulsive reactions seen in modern patients. In primitive minds, breaching a taboo induces a sense of uncleanness and remorse akin to the guilt experienced by neurotics over forbidden thoughts, both stemming from repressed aggressive or libidinal urges. This parallel suggests that taboos function as externalized defenses against internal conflicts, with violations provoking obsessive rituals for purification, much like hand-washing compulsions in neurosis to alleviate unconscious guilt. taboos, as a specific instance, exemplify this by channeling familial ambivalence into broader social norms. Historically, Freud traces taboo's evolution from the primitive notion of —a diffuse, potency residing in persons or objects—to the structured moral restrictions of civilized societies. Initially, represented an impersonal force that sanctified and endangered, enforced through emotional dread rather than rational ; over time, as societies advanced, this evolved into codified prohibitions separating sacred from secular realms, with spiritual yielding to ethical imperatives. This progression reflects a psychological maturation, where the attributed to thoughts and spirits diminishes, giving way to internalized guilt and societal as the enforcers of taboo.

Animism, Magic, and the Omnipotence of Thoughts

In the third essay of Totem and Taboo, examines the psychological origins of pre-religious belief systems, positing that human mental development progresses through distinct stages: , , and . In the animistic stage, primitive humans attribute souls and agency to inanimate objects and natural forces, reflecting a profound narcissistic overestimation of their own psychic powers. Freud describes this as a phase where "man ascribes to himself," viewing the external world as an extension of his inner mental life. This evolves into the religious stage, where is transferred to gods, akin to a child's dependence on parents, and culminates in the scientific stage, marked by submission to objective reality and renunciation of delusional beliefs. Central to , according to Freud, is , which operates on the principle of the "omnipotence of thoughts," where mental wishes are believed to directly control external events. He distinguishes two primary techniques of : imitative magic, which mimics the desired outcome to produce it, and contagious magic, which assumes that objects once in contact retain a connection allowing influence at a distance. For instance, among Aboriginal groups, rituals involve imitating behaviors to ensure successful hunts, while Melanesian practices use personal items like hair or nails to harm enemies remotely. Freud argues that predates animism proper, emerging from an even earlier "animatism" phase characterized by undifferentiated life force in objects, as proposed by anthropologist R. R. Marett. This of thoughts stems from a narcissistic phase in mental , where acts are overvalued due to their emotional , particularly unmet wishes repressed into the unconscious. In societies and neurotics alike, repression transforms these wishes into delusional beliefs, as "the high of acts... may now appropriately be brought into relation to ." Freud links this to practices, noting that restrictions like warriors' temporary chastity before battle serve both magical (to enhance potency) and repressive functions, compensating for forbidden impulses. He observes that while suppresses this , it persists in attenuated forms, such as the "magic of ," where artistic allows fulfillment of wishes without direct control. Freud critiques as a projective , whereby individuals externalize their inner emotional life onto the world, creating spirits and demons as personifications of repressed impulses. Drawing on ethnographic reports, he illustrates this with examples like the Aino people of , who perform rain-making by pouring water through a sieve to imitate rainfall, or ancient Egyptian rituals using effigies to symbolically injure foes. Similarly, children's phobias—such as fear of animals—represent projected anxieties, displacing deeper conflicts like paternal authority. These projections mirror the delusions of paranoiacs, as in Daniel Paul Schreber's visions of divine rays, where internal perceptions are attributed to external forces. Ultimately, Freud views not as a error but as a universal stage in psychic development, retained in traces within modern neuroses.

The Return of Totemism in Childhood

In the fourth essay of Totem and Taboo, proposes a speculative origin for totemism rooted in a Darwin-inspired primal horde scenario, where early human consisted of a violent, jealous who monopolized all females and expelled his growing sons. This patriarchal structure, Freud argues, inevitably led to rebellion as the expelled brothers united in a collective act of , killing and devouring the father to seize access to the women and dismantle his dominance. The profound and following this primal crime—combining triumph with guilt—gave rise to the animal as a symbolic substitute for the father, embodying both reverence and the forbidden impulse to repeat the murder. Freud interprets the totem meal, a central in totemistic societies involving the ceremonial killing and consumption of the totem animal, as a reenactment of this original . This communal feast serves to commemorate the deed, renew fraternal bonds among the participants, and expiate the enduring guilt through shared participation, while also establishing by prohibiting marriage within the totem clan as a reaction against the incestuous desires unleashed by the father's removal. Traces of matrilineal descent in totemistic systems, Freud suggests, stem from this event, as the sons' victory temporarily elevated the status of mothers and sisters before patriarchal order was symbolically restored. Freud draws explicit parallels between this mythological narrative and the observed in childhood psychology, positing totemism as the societal equivalent of the individual's unconscious repression of patricidal and incestuous wishes. Just as the child harbors ambivalent feelings toward the father—love mingled with rivalry and hostility—leading to the formation of the superego through guilt, the primal horde's manifests in totemic taboos that protect the father-substitute and enforce moral constraints. This "return of totemism in childhood" underscores Freud's broader thesis that the psychic life of "savages" mirrors the neuroses of individuals, with totemism representing an stage of cultural development. The implications of this hypothesis extend to the evolution of religion, as Freud views totemism as the foundational kernel from which later belief systems emerge. The totem evolves into gods and sacrificial rites, where the killing and eating of the divine representative perpetuates the original atonement, ultimately giving rise to moral systems that sublimate the primal guilt into ethical and social orders. In this way, the essay synthesizes anthropological observations with psychoanalytic principles to trace the phylogenetic origins of religion back to a singular, traumatic event in human prehistory.

Theoretical Foundations

Core Psychoanalytic Concepts

In Totem and Taboo, Sigmund Freud applies the psychoanalytic mechanism of repression to explain the persistence of taboos in primitive societies, positing that unacceptable impulses—such as aggressive or incestuous desires—are banished from conscious awareness into the unconscious, where they retain their force and demand ongoing inhibition. This process ensures that the original prohibition, initially imposed externally on a generation, becomes internalized, with the repressed impulses manifesting as compulsive observances or ceremonial restrictions to maintain psychological equilibrium. As Freud elaborates, the strength of the taboo derives precisely from this unconscious opposition, where tenderness or anxiety amplifies to counteract the hidden hostility, preventing its breakthrough into action. Freud further extends the concept of unconscious wishes to primitive behaviors, arguing that these repressed desires operate much like those uncovered in the analysis of dreams and slips, propelling actions through indirect, outlets in mental life. In primitive thought, such wishes underpin phenomena like and , where the "omnipotence of thoughts" allows affectively charged ideas to influence reality, mirroring the neurotic's immersion in a world governed by unconscious motivations rather than empirical . These wishes, often rooted in primal longings, persist beneath conscious prohibitions, driving collective practices that echo individual psychoanalytic dynamics. Central to Freud's framework is the role of narcissism in ego development, which he traces from the infant's primary self-love and sense of omnipotence to its projection onto the external world in animistic beliefs. This narcissistic stage, where the ego and libidinal impulses remain undifferentiated, evolves into the primitive's overvaluation of psychic acts, attributing to thoughts and intentions a controlling power over nature and objects. Animism thus represents a narcissistic residue, with the ego extending its boundaries outward in a bid to master an indifferent reality, a process that scholarly interpretations link to Freud's broader metapsychology of libidinal withdrawal and reinvestment. Freud delineates a key distinction between , centered on personal conflicts and neuroses, and group psychology in societies, where inhibitions and identifications forge structures through shared unconscious processes. While taboos resemble obsessive compulsions in their personal enforcement, amplify repression across the , binding members via mutual guilt and totemic obligations that transcend solitary pathology. This psyche, as Freud theorizes, emerges from events internalized en masse, differentiating it from the isolated ego's struggles.

Links to Broader Theories

In Totem and Taboo, Freud posits the primal horde scenario—where sons collectively murder the tyrannical to access the women—as a foundational phylogenetic event that encodes the in human psychic inheritance. This serves as an inherited trace, recapitulating the child's Oedipal of with the and desire for the , thereby linking primitive social origins to universal childhood dynamics. The resulting toward the figure, manifested in reverence and prohibitions, thus represents a resolution of Oedipal tensions through guilt and identification. Freud's exploration of these primal mechanisms in Totem and Taboo anticipates his later application of psychoanalytic principles to historical and cultural narratives, most notably in Moses and Monotheism (1939), where the murder of Moses by his followers echoes the totemic patricide as a catalyst for ethical monotheism and Jewish cultural identity. This work extends the phylogenetic framework to explain the emergence of religion as a defensive structure against unconscious guilt, demonstrating Freud's intent to broaden psychoanalysis beyond individual psychology to encompass societal evolution. The text also prefigures Freud's structural model of the , introduced in (1923), by tracing the superego's origins to the unconscious guilt arising from the primal father's murder, which internalizes moral prohibitions and paternal authority. In this schema, the embodies the unchecked instincts of the horde's rebellion, the mediates through totemic rituals and social bonds, and the superego enforces via inherited remorse, forming the that regulates toward authority. Furthermore, Totem and Taboo's emphasis on instinctual as the price of social cohesion directly informs (1930), where Freud elaborates how the Oedipal-derived guilt and system underpin civilization's demands, generating pervasive discontent through the suppression of aggressive and libidinal drives. This connection highlights not merely as a primitive survival mechanism but as an ongoing cultural force that shapes modern neuroses and ethical structures.

Reception and Legacy

Early Reviews and Responses

Upon its publication in 1913, Totem and Taboo elicited a range of responses from contemporaries, reflecting both enthusiasm for its bold interdisciplinary synthesis of and and concerns over its speculative nature. The novelist expressed particular admiration for the work's mythic and psychological depth, describing it as a profound exploration of humanity's primal psychic history that carried "such magnificent effect" in illuminating the origins of and . Among the early criticisms, Carl Furtmüller, a former member of the Psychoanalytic Society, published a negative review in 1914 in the Zentralblatt für Psychotherapie, objecting to Freud's reliance on unverified anthropological assumptions and his selective use of sources like Darwin's theories on primitive societies. Furtmüller argued that Freud disregarded existing critiques of totemism and treated phylogenetic speculations as established fact, likening the to an unsubstantiated "original sin" of , which undermined the work's scientific credibility. Within Freud's inner circle, the book initially received support from Carl Gustav Jung, whose own research on the and archaic had directly influenced Freud's essays, as acknowledged in the text itself. Freud credited Jung's and publications with providing the primary stimulus for applying psychoanalytic concepts to cultural phenomena, signaling a shared enthusiasm for extending analysis beyond individual to collective origins before their personal and theoretical split later in . The essays comprising Totem and Taboo first appeared in the journal , founded in 1912 by Freud and colleagues and Hanns Sachs to promote the interdisciplinary application of to , , and . This venue highlighted the work's innovative boldness in bridging clinical theory with ethnographic studies, garnering positive attention in circles for its attempt to trace universal psychic structures across "savages" and neurotics, though it also sparked debates on the limits of such extensions.

Anthropological Critiques

Anthropologist Alfred L. Kroeber offered one of the earliest and most influential critiques of Sigmund Freud's Totem and Taboo in his 1920 review, arguing that Freud's portrayal of totemism as a universal primitive institution was fundamentally flawed. Kroeber contended that totemism was neither the earliest form of nor ubiquitous across cultures, pointing out that it appeared sporadically and often as a secondary development rather than a foundational one; for instance, he noted that many societies lacked totems entirely, and where present, they served diverse functions unrelated to Freud's psychoanalytic interpretations. Furthermore, Kroeber accused Freud of selectively using ethnographic data, drawing primarily from outdated or biased sources like James Frazer's while ignoring contradictory evidence from contemporary that undermined the universality claim, such as the absence of totemism in vast regions of the world. Franz Boas, a foundational figure in American , similarly rejected Freud's framework in Totem and Taboo for prioritizing speculative over rigorous , viewing it as an imposition of universal psychological principles that disregarded . Boas emphasized that Freud's reconstructions of "primitive" social structures, including the primal horde and totemic origins, relied on imaginative hypotheses rather than verifiable fieldwork, failing to account for the immense variability in human cultures and treating diverse societies as mere illustrations of a singular developmental model. This approach, according to Boas and his students, exemplified methodological overreach, as it extrapolated from limited, often misinterpreted ethnographic reports without considering context-specific meanings, thereby undermining the scientific integrity of . Bronislaw Malinowski's fieldwork among the Trobriand Islanders provided later empirical confirmation of significant gaps in Freud's primal horde theory, as detailed in his 1927 book Sex and Repression in Savage Society. Malinowski observed a matrilineal society where authority rested with the mother's brother rather than the father, finding no evidence of patriarchal dominance or the intense father-son rivalry central to Freud's narrative of totemism's origins; he noted, for example, "There is not a single of origins in which a husband or a father plays any part, or even makes his appearance." In this context, the was absent, with affectionate father-child bonds and no traces of sexual attachment to the mother or repressed conflicts, as Malinowski stated: "If… the attitudes typical of the cannot be found either in the conscious or unconscious… there are no traces of it either in Trobriand folk-lore or in dreams and visions." These observations directly contradicted Freud's assumption of a universal primal horde, highlighting instead how family dynamics and psychological structures are shaped by cultural institutions rather than innate biological drives. Critiques from the Boasian school, including Boas himself, further illuminated the Eurocentric embedded in Freud's assumptions about "" minds as analogous to infantile or neurotic states, portraying non-Western societies as arrested in an early developmental stage of European psychic evolution. This perspective treated ethnographic data from colonized regions as evidence of universal psychological immaturity, ignoring the sophisticated cultural logics of those societies and reinforcing colonial hierarchies by equating difference with deficiency. Such were seen as methodological flaws that distorted , prioritizing Freud's armchair speculations over culturally sensitive analysis.

Psychoanalytic and Philosophical Views

Psychoanalyst and anthropologist Géza Róheim provided significant empirical validation for Sigmund Freud's theories in Totem and Taboo through his pioneering fieldwork among Australian Aboriginal communities from 1928 to 1931. Róheim's observations of totemic rituals and kinship structures aligned closely with Freud's hypotheses on the primal horde, incest taboos, and the Oedipal dynamics underlying totemism, demonstrating how these elements manifested in "primitive" societies as psychic defenses against ambivalence and guilt. In his 1925 work Australian Totemism: A Psycho-Analytic Study in , Róheim explicitly praised Totem and Taboo as a foundational text, applying its concepts to interpret ethnographic data as evidence of universal psychoanalytic processes rather than mere cultural artifacts. Within psychoanalysis, offered a pointed critique of Totem and Taboo, accusing Freud of an overreliance on patriarchal assumptions that overlooked the historical primacy of matriarchal societies. Reich argued that Freud's horde narrative, centered on a , ignored evidence from anthropologists like and Lewis Henry Morgan of pre-patriarchal communal structures where sexual freedom predominated, thus distorting the etiology of repression and the as products of later societal transitions. This criticism, elaborated in Reich's essay "Dialectical Materialism and ," emphasized that true liberation from required recognizing matriarchal elements to counter the authoritarian biases in Freud's phylogenetic speculation. Philosophically, Simone de Beauvoir engaged Totem and Taboo in The Second Sex (1949) through a feminist lens, interpreting Freud's concept of emotional ambivalence toward taboos—particularly the exaltation and dread of the maternal figure—as a mechanism of gendered oppression perpetuated by patriarchal myths. She contended that men's projection of women as both sacred (e.g., the totemic mother) and profane (e.g., the incestuous temptress) trapped women in an essentialized, objectified role, denying them existential freedom and subjectivity under the guise of universal psychic laws. Beauvoir's analysis reframed this ambivalence not as neutral anthropology but as a rationalized defense of male dominance, where the "myth of Woman" substitutes illusory contemplation for authentic intersubjective relations. Norman O. Brown, in Life Against Death: The Psychoanalytic Meaning of History (), reinterpreted totemism from Totem and Taboo as emblematic of humanity's flight into repressive social structures, yet holding redemptive potential for liberation from the death instinct's grip. viewed the primal horde and totemic brotherhood as originary responses to existential isolation—"men huddle into hordes as a substitute for parents, to save themselves from independence"—instituting repression to evade the body's unruly desires, but proposed that a non-repressive civilization could reclaim totemism's symbolic vitality by integrating the unconscious into conscious life, transforming into polymorphous . This optimistic reading positioned Freud's text as a blueprint for historical progress toward a "body " free from Oedipal tyranny.

Modern and Contemporary Interpretations

In the late 20th and early 21st centuries, feminist scholarship has built upon Simone de Beauvoir's foundational critique of Freud's Totem and Taboo as perpetuating patriarchal myths that subordinate women to male developmental narratives. Expanding Beauvoir's arguments from The Second Sex, where she contested Freud's anatomical determinism in explaining gender roles, later thinkers like Luce Irigaray have been invoked to dissect the phallocentric underpinnings of Freud's primal horde theory. Irigaray's framework, applied in post-1990 analyses, highlights how Totem and Taboo erases maternal genealogies through its focus on patricide, positioning woman as an absent or sacrificial figure in the formation of social order and reinforcing a hom(m)osexual economy that marginalizes female desire and subjectivity. Postcolonial readings of Totem and Taboo since the have reframed its totem-taboo dynamics through concepts of , particularly in Homi K. Bhabha's exploration of colonial . Bhabha interprets Freud's prohibitions and identifications as analogous to the racialized taboos imposed on colonized bodies, where emerges from the and disruption of imperial authority, creating unstable identities that challenge the of ruler and ruled. This lens applies totemism's binding to the psychological fragmentation of subjects under , revealing how Freud's archaic myths underpin modern discourses of otherness and cultural prohibition. Contemporary has seen a of interpretations of totemism inspired by Totem and Taboo, with scholars like integrating Freud's ideas into broader ontological frameworks beyond . In works from the 2000s, such as Beyond Nature and Culture (), Descola reconfigures totemism not as a primitive psychological residue but as one of four modes of relationality between humans and non-humans, drawing on ethnographic data from Amazonian groups to emphasize shared interiorities and physicalities that transcend Freud's individual-centric ambivalences. This approach updates Totem and Taboo by embedding its symbolic logic in ontologies, highlighting totemism's role in mediating ecological and social continuities rather than solely intrapsychic conflicts. The enduring cultural legacy of Totem and Taboo manifests in philosophical literature and the within . and Félix Guattari's (1972, with ongoing influence in post-1990 schizoanalytic readings) critiques Freud's totem-taboo origin story as the bedrock of Oedipal repression, repurposing the primal horde myth to expose capitalism's channeling of desire through familial and societal prohibitions, thereby inspiring anti-psychiatric and post-structuralist deconstructions of cultural norms. In , Totem and Taboo has informed the by underscoring how collective symbols and taboos shape individual psyches, as seen in modern cultural sociology's recovery of "primitive" motifs to analyze contemporary identity formations and social rituals.

References

  1. [1]
    Sigmund Freud: Religion | Internet Encyclopedia of Philosophy
    This article charts the evolution of his views on religion from Totem and Taboo (1913), through The Future of an Illusion (1927) and Civilization and its ...
  2. [2]
    Freud, Totem and Taboo - UMSL
    180. Totemic religion arose from the filial sense of guilt, in an attempt to allay that feeling and to appease the father by deferred obedience to him.
  3. [3]
    Imago/American Imago: 1912–2012 Preface - jstor
    The first issue of Imago, under the editorial direction of sigmund Freud and co-edited by otto Rank and Hanns sachs, appeared in Vienna in March 1912.
  4. [4]
    The Project Gutenberg eBook of Totem and Taboo, by Sigmund Freud.
    In this book the attempt is ventured to find the original meaning of totemism through its infantile traces, that is, through the indications in which it ...
  5. [5]
    Totem und Tabu. Einige Übereinstimmungen im Seelenleben der ...
    Feb 14, 2011 · Totem und Tabu. Einige Übereinstimmungen im Seelenleben der Wilden und der Neurotiker. by: Freud, Sigmund, 1856-1939.
  6. [6]
    [PDF] [1913] Totem and Taboo
    As Freud explains in his own preface, the four essays comprised in this volume were originally published in the pages of the periodical Imago (Vienna) under the ...
  7. [7]
    An Introduction and Brief Overview of Psychoanalysis - PMC
    Sep 13, 2023 · In 1902, Sigmund Freud formed the Vienna Psychoanalytic Society, and it quickly became a popular hub for the exploration and development of his ...Missing: 1912-1913 | Show results with:1912-1913
  8. [8]
    (PDF) The many origins of totemism. Critical analysis of theories of ...
    Aug 7, 2025 · The many origins of totemism. Critical analysis of theories of James G. Frazer, Émile Durkheim and Sigmund Freud. September 2018; Maska 40(4):45 ...
  9. [9]
    The Quest for Today's Totemic Psychology: A New Look at Wundt ...
    Investigating Wundt and Freud's totemic psychology definitely enriches personality, social and ethnic psychology and helps us to understand ourselves as human ...
  10. [10]
    Freud, Jung and Boas: the psychoanalytic engagement with ...
    Totem and taboo is a product of Freud's desire to sublimate myth and religion with 'science', that is with reason and the recognition of reality as it was. The ...
  11. [11]
    [PDF] The Fortunate Fall & the Primal Psychoanalytic Myth
    Published in 1913, Totem and Taboo, Freud's Ur-myth was composed during a time when Darwin's natural selection had fallen somewhat out of favor. The recovery of ...
  12. [12]
    Totemism and exogamy : a treatise on certain early forms of ...
    Nov 16, 2015 · The beginnings of religion and totemism among the Australian aborigines. Reprinted from the Fortnightly review, July and September 1905. An ...Missing: Aboriginals | Show results with:Aboriginals
  13. [13]
    The Subject is Taboo - jstor
    As I hope to demonstrate, such dilemmas orient Freud's various approaches to the problem in Totem and Taboo. In his attempts to get a handle on "taboos" his ...
  14. [14]
    FREUD'S SPECULATIONS IN ETHNOLOGY - jstor
    1 Totem and Taboo: Resemblances between the Psychic lives of Savages and Neurotics, by Professor Sigmund Freud. American Translation edited by A. A. Brill.
  15. [15]
    Reading Freud's Concept through Kant's Philosophy - jstor
    In Totem and Taboo (1913 [1912-13]), Freud presents the concept of narcissism in two distinct though related senses. On the one hand, narcissism represents an ...
  16. [16]
    Freud among the Boasians: Psychoanalytic Influence and ...
    And yet, despite his avowed desire to open conversations with other disciplines, Freud saw Totem and Taboo as broadening the theoretical reach of psychoanalysis ...<|separator|>
  17. [17]
    Darwin, Freud, and the Continuing Misrepresentation of the Primal ...
    Sigmund Freud developed his evolutionary theory for the origin of the Oedipus complex in Totem and Taboo, published in 1913.
  18. [18]
    Totem and Taboo (Chapter 2) - Freud and Religion
    May 7, 2021 · First, the book focuses on what Freud thought was the first historical form of a “pre” religion (“totemism”) and the first societal set of laws ...
  19. [19]
    A brief history of the super-ego with an introduction to three papers
    Aug 18, 2020 · Freud describes the super-ego now as one core element of the tripartite psychic structure in its relation to the Ego and the Id. He sees its ...
  20. [20]
    [PDF] Freud‟s Conceptualization of the Social World - Semantic Scholar
    While Totem and Taboo was concerned with explicating the roots of civilization, The ... In Civilization and Its Discontents, Freud explicitly returns to the ...
  21. [21]
    Freud's Conceptualization of the Social World
    Mar 13, 2012 · This paper articulates Sigmund Freud's conceptualization of the social world by surveying and critically examining four of his major sociological works.
  22. [22]
    Totem and Taboo: An Ethnologic Psychoanalysis - jstor
    Second, Robertson Smith's allegation that blood sacrifice is central ... is an original possession of Semitic culture. Fourth, coming to the Freudian ...
  23. [23]
    Freud among the Boasians: Psychoanalytic Influence and ...
    Summarized, the Boasian objection to Totem and Taboo comprised five points: (1) Freud's “anthropology” was based on wild fantasies of “primitive social life” ...<|control11|><|separator|>
  24. [24]
    [PDF] Sex and repression in savage society
    into a detailed critical analysis of the theory. In his book on Totem and Taboo Freud shows how the CEdipus complex can serve to explain totemism and the ...
  25. [25]
    a psycho-analytic study in anthropology and a history of Australian ...
    Mar 15, 2021 · Róheim, Géza, 1891-1953. Publication date: 1926. Topics: Totemism, Ethnology -- Australia, Psychoanalysis, Ethnopsychology, Ethnology, Australia.
  26. [26]
    Psychoanalytic Feminism - Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy
    May 16, 2011 · In Totem and Taboo (1913) Freud outlines the archaic “primal horde ... Somewhat later, Simone de Beauvoir addressed the discourse of ...
  27. [27]
    Simone de Beauvoir - Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy
    Aug 17, 2004 · Beauvoir's liberatory response to women's oppression is a feminism of freedom. The Second Sex argues against the either/or frame of the ...Missing: Totem Taboo ambivalence
  28. [28]
    https://press.uchicago.edu/ucp/books/book/chicago/B/bo18094873.html
  29. [29]
    The cultural turn and the origins of cultural sociology - Sage Journals
    Jul 16, 2021 · The cultural turn in philosophy, aesthetics, and anthropology erased the division between primitive and modern; in sociology, the classical ...