Fact-checked by Grok 2 weeks ago

Assef Shawkat

Assef Shawkat (c. 1950 – 18 July 2012) was a Syrian military officer and intelligence director who served as deputy minister of defense in the regime of President Bashar al-Assad, to whom he was related by marriage as the husband of Assad's sister Bushra.^[1]^[2] Born to an Alawite family in Tartus province, Shawkat advanced through the Syrian armed forces to lead the military intelligence directorate, a position that positioned him as a central enforcer in the Ba'athist security apparatus responsible for suppressing internal threats.^[3]^[4] Shawkat's tenure involved coordinating intelligence operations that maintained regime control, including reported liaisons with foreign intelligence post-9/11 and facilitation of militant transit through Syria, though such activities drew international sanctions for supporting destabilizing elements.^[1]^[5] Appointed deputy defense minister in 2011 amid rising unrest, he played a pivotal role in the military response to the Syrian uprising, which escalated into civil war, overseeing crackdowns that consolidated Assad family power despite internal regime frictions.^[2]^[6] His assassination in a suicide bombing at Damascus's National Security Bureau headquarters—alongside other senior officials—marked a significant blow to the regime's inner circle, with the attack claimed by opposition elements amid claims of regime infiltration, highlighting vulnerabilities in Syria's command structure.^[7]^[8] Shawkat's career exemplified the fusion of familial loyalty and institutional ruthlessness in sustaining authoritarian rule, though accounts of his precise influence vary due to the opacity of Syrian intelligence operations and potential biases in external reporting from adversarial or sanctioned entities.^[2]^[6]

Personal Background

Early Life and Education

Assef Shawkat was born on 15 January 1950 in the village of Al-Madehleh in the Tartus Governorate of Syria, to an Alawite family of the minority sect that has historically dominated the country's security apparatus under Ba'athist rule.^[3] His parents were Mahmoud Shawkat and Khadija Salih, and he had several siblings, including an older brother Muhammad (born 1947) and younger brother Haydar (born 1956).^[4] The family was described as middle-class, originating from coastal regions where Alawites formed a significant portion of the population.^[9] Little is publicly documented about Shawkat's formative years, reflecting the opacity surrounding figures in Syria's intelligence elite, but records indicate he enrolled in Damascus in 1968, pursuing studies in history at the University of Damascus prior to admission to the Military Academy, which marked the onset of his professional trajectory.^[4]

Marriage and Family Ties to the Assad Regime

Assef Shawkat married Bushra al-Assad in 1995, establishing direct familial ties to Syria's ruling Assad dynasty. Bushra, the sole daughter of President Hafez al-Assad and sister to his successor Bashar al-Assad, had been widowed from her prior marriage to Assef Dureid, a Syrian Army officer killed in Lebanon in 1981. The union occurred amid initial familial opposition from Hafez al-Assad, who reportedly viewed Shawkat's Alawite background and military profile unfavorably, though it proceeded following the death of Hafez's favored heir Bassel al-Assad in a 1994 car accident.^[10]^[11] The marriage produced five children and elevated Shawkat's status within the regime, transforming him from an outsider military officer into Bashar al-Assad's brother-in-law and a core member of the inner security circle upon Bashar's ascension to power in 2000. This connection facilitated Shawkat's rapid promotions, including his role as head of military intelligence by 2001, underscoring how familial bonds in the Assad system intertwined personal relations with control over state repression apparatus. Shawkat maintained these ties until his death in a 2012 Damascus bombing, after which Bushra relocated abroad with their children.^[4]^[12]^[3]

Military and Intelligence Career

Rise Through the Ranks

Assef Shawkat entered the Syrian Army from a modest background in Tartous province, steadily advancing through its ranks during Hafez al-Assad's presidency.^[3]^[13] His early career involved service in military intelligence, where he rose to the position of deputy chief under Hafez al-Assad, leveraging demonstrated loyalty within the regime's security apparatus.^[13] Shawkat's marriage to Bushra al-Assad, sister of Bashar al-Assad, in 1995 marked a pivotal elevation in his status, overcoming initial familial opposition and solidifying his integration into the inner circle of power.^[3]^[14] This union facilitated further promotions, reflecting the intertwining of familial ties and military hierarchy in Syrian governance. Under Bashar al-Assad, Shawkat continued his ascent, receiving a series of military promotions that positioned him as a key figure in the armed forces.^[14] In 2005, he was appointed director of Military Intelligence, Syria's most potent security service.^[13]^[4] By July 2009, he was promoted to lieutenant general and deputy chief of staff of the armed forces, a role he held until 2011.^[4]^[15]

Leadership of Military Intelligence

Assef Shawkat served as director of the Syrian Military Intelligence Directorate from 2005 to 2009, having previously held the position of deputy director from 2000 to 2005.^[2]^[1] His appointment to the directorship came under President Bashar al-Assad, succeeding General Hassan Khalil, and positioned him at the helm of Syria's most influential security apparatus, responsible for military counterintelligence, internal security operations, and liaison activities with external entities.^[2]^[1] During Shawkat's tenure, the directorate maintained broad authority over surveillance, detention, and suppression of perceived threats to the regime, including coordination with Palestinian militant groups and other organizations designated as terrorist entities by Western governments.^[1] In April 2006, the U.S. Department of the Treasury designated Shawkat as a Specially Designated National under Executive Order 13338, citing his oversight of a branch managing relations with terrorist groups such as Hamas, Palestinian Islamic Jihad, and Popular Front for the Liberation of Palestine-General Command, as well as facilitation of safe passage for foreign fighters into Iraq.^[1] This designation highlighted allegations of the directorate's role in destabilizing regional security under Shawkat's leadership, though Syrian officials denied such claims.^[1] Shawkat's directorship ended in 2009 when he was promoted to head the newly formed National Security Bureau, a body coordinating Syria's intelligence agencies, amid reports of internal regime tensions and his perceived failure to preempt certain security lapses.^[3]^[7] Under his command, the Military Intelligence Directorate expanded its operational reach, including reported involvement in cross-border activities and regime protection efforts, solidifying Shawkat's reputation as a key enforcer within Assad's inner circle.^[2]^[3]

Political Roles and Appointments

Positions Under Bashar al-Assad

Following Bashar al-Assad's ascension to the presidency in June 2000, Assef Shawkat was appointed head of the Syrian Military Intelligence Directorate in 2005, a role in which he wielded significant influence over the regime's internal security operations until his reassignment in 2009.^[2]^[16] In this capacity, Shawkat directed efforts to suppress dissent and maintain loyalty within the military and Alawite community, drawing international sanctions from the U.S. Treasury in 2006 for his leadership of the agency.^[1] In July 2009, Shawkat was promoted to lieutenant general and named deputy chief of the General Staff of the Armed Forces, serving in that position until 2011 and focusing on intelligence and security coordination across military branches.^[3]^[15] This appointment reflected his deepening integration into the regime's high command, where he advised on countering perceived threats amid growing regional tensions.^[7] Shawkat's roles underscored his status as a core member of Assad's inner security circle, leveraging familial ties to consolidate power.^[2]

Deputy Minister of Defense

Assef Shawkat was appointed Deputy Minister of Defense in August 2011, serving under Minister Dawoud Rajiha, who assumed the defense portfolio on August 8.^[4]^[7] This appointment occurred amid escalating unrest in Syria, following the outbreak of protests in March 2011 that evolved into armed conflict, prompting regime reshuffles to consolidate control over military and security operations.^[2] Shawkat, previously head of military intelligence until 2009 and deputy chief of staff, retained significant influence in this role, leveraging his familial ties to President Bashar al-Assad as his brother-in-law.^[3] In his capacity as deputy, Shawkat was part of the regime's inner security circle, coordinating intelligence-driven military responses to opposition forces, including oversight of counterinsurgency tactics and suppression of dissent.^[13]^[3] The position allowed him to operate behind the scenes, integrating military intelligence with defense strategy, though specific operational directives under his deputy tenure are documented primarily through regime announcements and post-assassination analyses rather than detailed public records.^[7] He held the rank of lieutenant general at the time, reflecting his senior status within the Syrian Arab Army hierarchy.^[4] Shawkat served in this post until his death in a July 18, 2012, bombing in Damascus, which also claimed the lives of Rajiha and other high-ranking officials.^[2]^[7]

Controversies and International Allegations

Implication in Rafik Hariri Assassination

Assef Shawkat, as director of Syrian military intelligence, was implicated in the February 14, 2005, assassination of former Lebanese Prime Minister Rafik Hariri by the initial United Nations International Independent Investigation Commission (UNIIIC) report led by Detlev Mehlis.^[17] The bombing, executed via a truck packed with approximately 2,500–3,000 kilograms of explosives, targeted Hariri's motorcade in downtown Beirut, killing him along with 22 others and injuring over 200.^[18] The Mehlis report, released on October 20, 2005, determined that the attack bore "the hallmarks of a sophisticated operation" requiring coordination among Syrian and Lebanese intelligence elements, with Syrian officials—including Shawkat—possessing "full knowledge" of the plot and failing to prevent it despite awareness of threats against Hariri.^[19]^[20] Witness testimonies cited in subsequent UNIIIC updates specifically linked Shawkat to operational aspects, including allegations that he coerced Ahmad Abu Adass—a Palestinian shopkeeper who disappeared post-attack—into recording a fraudulent video claiming responsibility on behalf of a nonexistent group, "Victory and Jihad in the Levant," approximately 15 days before the bombing in Damascus.^[21] Shawkat's role was highlighted due to his oversight of Syrian intelligence networks in Lebanon, where Syria maintained significant influence until its military withdrawal in April 2005 following international pressure spurred by the assassination.^[22] As Bashar al-Assad's brother-in-law and a central figure in Syria's security apparatus, Shawkat was described by anonymous diplomats as a "prime suspect" based on "evidence in abundance," including intercepted communications and defector accounts pointing to high-level Syrian authorization.^[23]^[24] Syrian authorities categorically rejected the UNIIIC findings, with officials dismissing them as politically motivated fabrications by Hariri's opponents and Western powers seeking to undermine Damascus's regional role.^[25] Shawkat himself was not interrogated by the commission, and Syria obstructed aspects of the probe, including the destruction of intelligence documents related to Hariri's security, as noted in later UNIIIC assessments.^[26] The implications against Shawkat waned in focus as the investigation transitioned to the Special Tribunal for Lebanon (STL), established in 2009, which in 2011 indicted four Hezbollah members—Salim Ayyash, Hassan Oneissi, Assad Sabra, and an unidentified fourth—for executing the attack but did not pursue charges against Syrian officials due to jurisdictional limits and evidentiary shifts emphasizing Hezbollah's operational role under broader Syrian-Lebanese-Iranian influences.^[27] No conclusive evidence has publicly tied Shawkat directly to ordering the hit, though the early UNIIIC reports positioned him as a pivotal enabler within Syria's chain of command.^[28]

Sanctions and Accusations of Human Rights Abuses

In May 2011, the United States imposed sanctions on Assef Shawkat under Executive Order 13573, targeting individuals responsible for or complicit in human rights abuses linked to the Syrian regime's response to protests.^[29] These measures froze his assets and prohibited U.S. persons from transactions with him, citing his role as Deputy Chief of Staff for Security and Reconnaissance in the Syrian Armed Forces, where he directed security operations against demonstrators during the early unrest.^[29] The U.S. Treasury Department specifically noted Shawkat's key involvement in managing the crackdown, which involved widespread arbitrary detentions, torture, and killings by intelligence and military units under his oversight.^[29] The European Union followed with sanctions against Shawkat in May 2011, imposing asset freezes and travel bans for his leadership in suppressing the Syrian uprising through military intelligence apparatuses.^[3] EU measures accused him of orchestrating violent repression, including orders for security forces to use excessive force against civilians, resulting in documented patterns of beatings, enforced disappearances, and deaths in custody.^[30] These actions aligned with broader international designations framing Shawkat as a central figure in the regime's security apparatus, responsible for coordinating intelligence operations that facilitated systematic abuses against protesters and detainees.^[7] Accusations of human rights violations centered on Shawkat's prior command of Syrian Military Intelligence (Shu'bat al-Mukhabarat al-'Askariyya), which reports from U.S. and EU authorities linked to torture centers and extrajudicial executions during interrogations.^[13] As deputy defense minister from August 2011, he oversaw forces implicated in the escalation of violence, including the siege of protest hubs like Daraa, where security branches under his influence conducted mass arrests and reported instances of severe mistreatment.^[3] While Shawkat denied personal involvement in abuses, sanctioning bodies emphasized command responsibility, arguing his strategic directives enabled the regime's coercive tactics amid the 2011 protests.^[30]

Involvement in Syrian Uprising

Initial Response to Protests

In March 2011, protests erupted in Daraa province after security forces arrested and tortured teenagers for writing anti-government graffiti, sparking demands for political reform amid the Arab Spring.^[31] The regime's initial response involved deploying branches of military intelligence, police, and army units to conduct mass arrests, beatings, and shootings, resulting in at least 61 protester deaths by March 27. Assef Shawkat, serving as deputy chief of the armed forces general staff since 2009, played a coordinating role in this suppression as part of the regime's security apparatus.^[15] The United States Treasury Department sanctioned him on June 29, 2011, asserting that Shawkat "played a key role in dealing with demonstrations" through oversight of violent operations against civilians.^[29] European Union measures similarly designated him for directing the military's engagement in quelling unrest, citing his authority in deploying forces to Daraa and surrounding areas.^[7] Shawkat's involvement drew from his prior leadership of military intelligence (2001–2009), where he built networks used to identify and target protest leaders, including through extrajudicial detentions and interrogations in the early crackdown phase.^[2] Reports from the period indicate that under high-level directives he influenced, security forces shelled residential areas and besieged towns like Daraa city from mid-March, escalating civilian casualties to hundreds by May.^[31] These actions, attributed to Shawkat and figures like his brother-in-law Maher al-Assad, prioritized regime survival over concessions, rejecting early calls for dialogue.^[6] By late March, Shawkat contributed to forming the Central Crisis Management Cell, a body including defense officials to centralize counter-protest operations, though its full structure solidified in April amid spreading unrest.^[32] This entity formalized the strategy of combining force with limited reforms, such as releasing some detainees, but primarily intensified intelligence-led raids to dismantle nascent opposition networks.^[33] International observers, including the UN, later documented the disproportionate use of live ammunition and torture in this period as systematic, with Shawkat's sanctions reflecting Western assessments of his command accountability.^[34]

Operational Role in Counterinsurgency

Assef Shawkat served as Deputy Minister of Defense from April 2011, a position that positioned him at the apex of Syria's military hierarchy during the escalation of the uprising into armed insurgency. In this capacity, he coordinated operational responses to rebel advances, including directing intelligence-driven counteroffensives against opposition-held territories. Western governments, including the United States and European Union, imposed sanctions on Shawkat in May and June 2011, citing his central role in orchestrating the regime's violent suppression of demonstrations and early insurgent activities, which involved deploying military intelligence units to identify and target protesters and defectors.^[29]^[7]^[30] Shawkat's operational involvement extended to on-the-ground assessments of key battlefronts. In mid-2011, he visited Zabadani, a strategic town near Damascus temporarily seized by rebels, to oversee the mobilization of forces for its recapture, which Syrian troops achieved through heavy bombardment and ground assaults by late summer. Similarly, in early 2012, he traveled to Homs—the epicenter of urban insurgency—amid the army's February offensive, where regime forces, under his broader oversight, shelled rebel enclaves, resulting in thousands of civilian and combatant casualties as documented by human rights monitors. These visits underscored his function as a liaison between Assad's inner security circle and field commanders, prioritizing rapid, intelligence-led strikes to reclaim territory from Free Syrian Army units and affiliated militants.^[2] As a member of the regime's "Crisis Cell" formed in 2011 to manage the conflict, Shawkat contributed to strategic planning that integrated military intelligence with conventional army operations, emphasizing infiltration, arrests, and preemptive raids to disrupt rebel supply lines and leadership. U.S. Treasury assessments highlighted his prior management of military intelligence branches focused on external threats, which were repurposed domestically to counter insurgent networks, though critics from opposition sources alleged these tactics included widespread torture and extrajudicial killings to extract intelligence. His death in the July 18, 2012, Damascus bombing—during a meeting of defense officials—halted his direct involvement, but it reflected the regime's reliance on such figures for sustaining counterinsurgency amid mounting rebel offensives.^[1]^[3]^[6]

Assassination and Immediate Aftermath

The 2012 Damascus Bombing

On July 18, 2012, a bombing struck the National Security Bureau headquarters in Rawda Square, Damascus, during a meeting of senior regime security officials convened to address the escalating Syrian uprising.^[35] The explosion killed Assef Shawkat, then serving as deputy minister of defense and a key figure in Syria's security apparatus, along with Defense Minister Dawoud Rajha and National Security Bureau director Hisham Ikhtiyar.^[36] ^[37] Syrian state media attributed the attack to a suicide bomber who infiltrated the meeting, while opposition sources described it as a remotely detonated device planted by an insider.^[35] ^[38] The blast occurred amid intensified rebel advances in Damascus, following days of heavy fighting in neighborhoods like Midan, where Syrian forces had deployed tanks and artillery against opposition fighters.^[39] Shawkat, who had been overseeing counterinsurgency operations, was attending the session as part of the regime's crisis management team; his death represented a significant blow to President Bashar al-Assad's inner circle, given Shawkat's familial ties and operational influence.^[7] Additional casualties included senior military advisor Hassan Turkmani, who succumbed to wounds shortly after, while others such as Interior Minister Mohammed Ibrahim al-Shaar and National Security Bureau deputy Ali Mamlouk sustained injuries.^[36] ^[37] The Liwa al-Islam Brigade, affiliated with the Free Syrian Army, claimed responsibility for the operation, stating it targeted a "security operations room" and aimed to disrupt regime command structures.^[38] Syrian authorities condemned the attack as terrorism orchestrated by foreign-backed insurgents, vowing retaliation, which manifested in subsequent airstrikes and ground offensives in Damascus suburbs.^[35] The incident prompted immediate speculation about internal vulnerabilities, including potential defections or infiltration, though no conclusive evidence of regime complicity emerged from contemporaneous reporting.^[39]

Theories on Perpetrators and Motivations

The Syrian government attributed the July 18, 2012, bombing at the National Security Bureau headquarters in Damascus, which killed Assef Shawkat along with Defense Minister Dawoud Rajha and others, to a suicide attack by "terrorists," implicitly referring to opposition rebels amid the escalating civil war.^[40] State media emphasized the attack's execution by infiltrators linked to armed groups, framing it as external sabotage to destabilize the regime.^[41] The Free Syrian Army (FSA), the primary rebel coalition at the time, initially claimed responsibility, asserting that its special forces had infiltrated the meeting and detonated explosives, targeting a "crisis cell" coordinating the regime's crackdown on protests.^[37] FSA spokespersons described the operation as a strategic strike against key figures overseeing counterinsurgency, motivated by the need to disrupt command structures responsible for suppressing uprisings that had begun in March 2011 and resulted in thousands of deaths by mid-2012.^[42] However, some opposition activists later denied rebel involvement, arguing the group's limited capabilities at the time made such a precise internal penetration unlikely without regime complicity.^[43] Alternative theories center on internal regime dynamics, positing the bombing as a self-inflicted or factional purge to eliminate perceived moderates amid power struggles. Defectors like former Brigadier General Manaf Tlass claimed Shawkat, alongside himself, advocated negotiations with protesters and armed opponents to avert collapse, positioning him as a target for hardliners favoring total war; Tlass suggested the attack stemmed from rifts between the Assad family and security officials pushing for concessions.^[43] Syrian opposition figure Haytham Manaa speculated regime orchestration, citing the unusually rapid and detailed state media disclosure as evidence of staging to rally loyalty or signal resolve to allies like Iran and Russia.^[41] Rumors in Damascus circles pointed to familial rivalry, alleging Maher al-Assad, Bashar's brother and commander of the Republican Guard, harbored longstanding animosity toward Shawkat—stemming from reported personal clashes and an alleged prior shooting incident—and may have exploited the chaos for elimination.^[41] Iranian involvement features in some accounts, with reports indicating Quds Force commander Qassem Suleimani's presence in Damascus around the bombing date, potentially coordinating a counter-intelligence operation against Shawkat to enforce Tehran's preference for unrelenting force over dialogue, thereby preserving Assad's dependence on Iranian support.^[43] A Naame Shaam investigation, drawing on defector testimonies, portrayed the plot as Iranian-directed to neutralize "softliners" like Shawkat, whose negotiation stance threatened the hardline axis sustaining the regime; this aligned with post-bombing escalations, including intensified Iranian advisory roles and a death toll surging from approximately 20,000 in July 2012 to over 60,000 by early 2013.^[43] Bashar al-Assad himself referenced internal divisions to The Wall Street Journal, describing the bombing as arising from tensions between his inner circle and security apparatus favoring talks, though without endorsing external culpability.^[44] The FSA also floated a separate claim of poisoning Shawkat, Rajha, and Hassan Turkmani via a domestic worker over a month earlier, with the bombing announcement serving as regime cover to mask vulnerabilities, motivated by long-term infiltration to erode leadership cohesion.^[41] No conclusive evidence has verified any theory beyond the official and rebel narratives, with investigations hampered by the ongoing conflict and restricted access to the site.^[2]

References

[1]
Treasury Designates Director of Syrian Military Intelligence
Assef Shawkat Title: Director of Syrian Military Intelligence ; DOB: 1950 ; POB: Tartus, Syria ; Nationality: Syria ; Address: Al-Akkad Street, Damascus, Syria.Missing: biography | Show results with:biography
[2]
Assef Shawkat, Syria's shadowy enforcer - Reuters
Jul 18, 2012 · After years as deputy head and then chief of military intelligence, he had become deputy defense minister, another position that allowed him to ...Missing: biography | Show results with:biography
[3]
Syrian defence chief Assef Shawkat – profile | Syria - The Guardian
Jul 18, 2012 · Born in 1950 to an Alawite family, he emerged from obscurity to rise up the ranks in the Syrian army but rose to real prominence with his ...Missing: biography | Show results with:biography
[4]
Assef Shawkat - OpenSanctions
In 2005, he was appointed Director of Military Intelligence, which is considered the strongest security service in Syria. In July 2009, Shawkat was promoted to ...Missing: biography | Show results with:biography
[5]
Slain Syrian official supported al Qaeda in Iraq - The Long War Journal
Jul 24, 2012 · Assef Shawkat, a top Syrian official killed in a bomb blast last week, was a key ally of al Qaeda in Iraq (AQI). Leaked State Department ...
[6]
Assef Shawkat and the Assads – Life as an Outsider on the Inside
Apr 4, 2017 · Shawkat was one of the few figures in contemporary Syrian history whose life as an authoritarian elite witnessed so many ups and downs due to his fractious ...Missing: biography | Show results with:biography
[7]
Profiles of security and defence chiefs killed in Damascus blast - BBC
Jul 20, 2012 · On 18 July, state media reported that Gen Shawkat had been killed in a suicide bomb attack at the headquarters of the National Security Bureau.
[8]
3 key Assad officials killed in Damascus blast | The Times of Israel
Jul 18, 2012 · A massive blast struck the National Security building in Damascus on Wednesday morning, killing Syrian President Bashar Assad's most trusted security official.
[9]
Assef Shawkat - The Telegraph
Jul 18, 2012 · He was born in 1950 to a middle-class family in Tartus, on Syria's Mediterranean coast. Though, like the Assads, of the minority Alawite sect, ...Missing: early background
[10]
Inside Bashar Al-Assad's powerful family: His 'ruthless' mother, the ...
Dec 9, 2024 · ' General Asef Shawkat was an Alawite military officer who married Assad's sister Bushra in 1995. He was initially rejected by the Assad family ...
[11]
General Assef Shawkat: Security chief and linchpin of the Assad ...
Jul 20, 2012 · Assef Shawkat was born in 1950 to a middle class Alawite family in the village of Al-Madehleh, Tartus. In 1968 he enrolled in Damascus ...Missing: early life background
[12]
Bushra Al Asad - NGO Report
Bushra al-Assad, daughter of Hafez al-Assad and sister of Bashar al-Assad, was married to Syrian military official Assef Shawkat. They had five children.
[13]
Assef Shawkat, Syria's shadowy enforcer | Reuters
Jul 18, 2012 · Shawkat's marriage into the Assad family brought him mixed fortunes, and his life read in some ways like something out of the soap operas he ...
[14]
The Assads: An iron-fisted dynasty | Features | Al Jazeera
Dec 18, 2012 · Bushra al-Assad was being courted by Assef Shawkat, a man 10 years ... He was steadily awarded a series of military promotions and was ...
[15]
https://www.wsj.com/articles/SB10000872396390444097904577534911915515268
[16]
Don't Overthink the Assad-Makhlouf Feud | The Washington Institute
May 22, 2020 · The regime's deputy defense minister at the time, Shawkat had previously served as head of military intelligence from 2005 to 2009, at one ...
[17]
Top Syrian Officials Implicated in Lebanese Assassination | PBS News
Oct 21, 2005 · A report issued Thursday by the United Nations implicates top Syrian officials in the assassination of former Lebanese Prime Minister Rafik ...Missing: implication | Show results with:implication
[18]
Key suspects in al-Hariri killing | News - Al Jazeera
Oct 21, 2005 · ... assassination of former Lebanese prime minister Rafiq al-Hariri ... They include Major-General Assef Shawkat, 55, the head of Syria's ...Missing: implication | Show results with:implication
[19]
U.N. Report Implicates Syria in Lebanon Assassination : NPR
Oct 21, 2005 · Syria is denying claims that it backed the assassination of former Lebanese Prime Minister Rafik Hariri earlier this year. ... Asef Shawkat ...Missing: Assef | Show results with:Assef
[20]
UN Report Findings Damage Syrian Regime - Forbes
Oct 25, 2005 · ... Assef Shawkat, head of Syrian military intelligence, were involved. Damascus has rejected the report's findings. Nevertheless, Syrian ...
[21]
UNIIIC report on Hariri assassination - SecGen letter to SecCo ...
It is the Commission's view that the assassination of 14 February 2005 was carried out by a group with an extensive organization and considerable resources and ...
[22]
Syria rejects UN Hariri report - The Jerusalem Post
Oct 23, 2005 · Shawkat, who is married to Assad's sister Bushra, is the overall head of Syrian intelligence and considered the second most powerful man in the ...
[23]
Top Syrian Seen as Prime Suspect in Assassination
Oct 21, 2005 · Top Syrian Seen as Prime Suspect in Assassination · "There is evidence in abundance," the diplomat said. · The 54-page report said the crime had ...Missing: Assef implication
[24]
Middle East: UN Inquiry Into Hariri Assassination Points Finger At Syria
Oct 21, 2005 · A UN inquiry into the assassination of former Lebanese Prime Minister Rafik Hariri says there is evidence of both Lebanese and Syrian involvement in his death.
[25]
Syria Rejects UN Report on Hariri Assassination - VOA
Oct 28, 2009 · Syria's information minister is rejecting the UN report on the assassination of former Lebanese Prime Minister Rafik al-Hariri. ... Asef Shawkat, ...Missing: Assef implication
[26]
Report Says Syria Interfered in Hariri Probe - Global Policy Forum
Dec 13, 2005 · Syria has interfered with a U.N. probe into the assassination of former Lebanese prime minister Rafiq Hariri by burning intelligence ...Missing: Assef | Show results with:Assef
[27]
https://www.abcnews.go.com/International/story?id=1398754
[28]
PRESS CONFERENCE BY DETLEV MEHLIS ON HARIRI ...
Oct 21, 2005 · Shawkat was mentioned elsewhere in the report in connection with Mr. Abbas, Mr. Mehlis said that he had not decided to delete all names. Pressed ...
[29]
Treasury Sanctions Syrian, Iranian Security Forces for Involvement ...
Jun 29, 2011 · 13553 – which targets those responsible for or complicit in serious human rights abuses ... Assef Shawkat played a key role in dealing with ...
[30]
Profiles: Syria's fallen ministers | News - Al Jazeera
Jul 19, 2012 · General Daoud Rajha, the Syrian defence minister, deputy general commander for the Syrian army and deputy prime minister, was killed on July 18 ...
[31]
“We've Never Seen Such Horror”: Crimes against Humanity by ...
Jun 1, 2011 · This 54-page report is based on more than 50 interviews with victims and witnesses to abuses. The report focuses on violations in Daraa ...Missing: Assef | Show results with:Assef
[32]
Assad's 'Crisis Cell' reveals Syrian regime in crisis - العربية
Apr 20, 2012 · Assef Shawkat. Married to Bashar al-Assad's sister, Bushra, Assef Shawkat was the army deputy chief from 2009 till 2011. ... crisis management.
[33]
Syria assault town, replaces defense minister - The Korea Herald
Aug 9, 2011 · His deputy is Maj. Gen. Assef Shawkat, who is married to Assad's sister, Bushra. The army has played a leading role in the bloody crackdown, ...
[34]
Syrian Civil War - Uprising in Syria, 2011– | Britannica
In his first speech since protests began, Assad is defiant, blaming the unrest on foreign conspirators seeking to destabilize Syria. He offers no concrete ...
[35]
Syria conflict: Ministers 'killed in suicide attack' - BBC News
Jul 18, 2012 · Syria conflict: Ministers 'killed in suicide attack' ... Three men at the heart of President Assad's defence team have died in a suicide bombing, ...Missing: details | Show results with:details
[36]
Syrian TV confirms Assef Shawkat killed in bombing - Reuters
Jul 18, 2012 · Syrian state television said President Bashar al-Assad's brother-in-law and senior military official Assef Shawkat was killed in a bomb attack in Damascus on ...Missing: Bureau | Show results with:Bureau
[37]
Leading Syrian regime figures killed in Damascus bomb attack | Syria
Jul 18, 2012 · Rebels fighting the regime of Bashar al-Assad killed three of his top security chiefs in a devastating bomb attack in the heart of Damascus.<|separator|>
[38]
Syrian Rebels Land Deadly Blow to Assad's Inner Circle
Jul 18, 2012 · Daoud Rajha, left, Syria's defense minister, and Asef Shawkat, President Bashar al-Assad's brother-in-law, were killed on Wednesday in a bombing ...
[39]
Syria crisis: Three of Assad's top chiefs killed in rebel bomb strike
Jul 18, 2012 · Rebels fighting the regime of Bashar al-Assad killed three of his top security chiefs in a devastating bomb attack in the heart of Damascus.<|control11|><|separator|>
[40]
Damascus Bombing Kills Three of Assad's Top Aides - VOA
Jul 18, 2012 · State television says attack at National Security building killed ... Fast Facts About Syrian Suicide Bombing Victims. Syrian Bombing ...Missing: theories perpetrators motivations
[41]
Syrian security attack sparks conspiracy theories - France 24
Jul 19, 2012 · Wednesday's killings of three men at the heart of Syrian President Bashar al-Assad's defence team have sparked a torrent of conspiracy theories and rumours.Missing: rivals | Show results with:rivals
[42]
Damascus blast 'kills' top Assad officials | News | Al Jazeera
Jul 19, 2012 · Syria's defence minister and interior minister are among those killed after an explosion struck the National Security building in Damascus.Missing: internal plot
[43]
If Assad Murdered His Own Brother-In-Law To Survive, What ...
Dec 19, 2014 · Tlass says that he and Shawkat “were among those calling for talks with both peaceful and armed regime opponents,” which buttresses the claim ...
[44]
Syrian Bomb Plot Marked Deadly Turn in Civil War
Dec 21, 2014 · Now, new revelations point to a startling theory about the bombing that killed Assef Shawkat, an army general who was Mr. Assad's brother-in ...Missing: rivals | Show results with:rivals