Fact-checked by Grok 2 weeks ago

Bastion Point

Bastion Point (Māori: Takaparawhau) is a coastal promontory on the southern shore of Waitematā Harbour in Auckland, New Zealand, overlooking Ōkahu Bay and historically utilized for defense purposes.^[1] The site achieved national prominence as the location of a 507-day occupation initiated on 5 January 1977 by the Ōrākei Māori Action Committee, representing the Ngāti Whātua Ōrākei iwi, in opposition to the Crown's announcement to develop the remaining reserve land into high-income housing subdivisions.^[1]^[2] Led by Joe Hawke, the protest encampment drew widespread support and spotlighted the iwi's dispossession from ancestral lands originally gifted to the Crown for military use during the 1860s Russian scare but subsequently alienated without adequate compensation or return.^[1] The occupation concluded on 25 May 1978 with a large-scale eviction involving over 600 police and military personnel, resulting in 222 arrests, yet it catalyzed public discourse on Māori land rights and contributed to the Waitangi Tribunal's 1985 recommendation that facilitated the land's return to Ngāti Whātua Ōrākei in 1987 for establishment as a public reserve under iwi trusteeship.^[1]^[3] Today, Bastion Point encompasses the Michael Joseph Savage Memorial Park, Orakei Marae, and serves as a symbol of successful non-violent resistance against state-led land sales, while hosting cultural events like the annual Manu Aute Kite Day.^[1]

Geography and Etymology

Location and Physical Description

Takaparawhau, commonly known as Bastion Point, constitutes a coastal headland situated in the Ōrākei suburb of Auckland, New Zealand, positioned above Tāmaki Drive and proximate to Mission Bay.^[4] ^[5] The site lies at approximately 36°50′39″S 174°49′27″E, forming the western boundary of Ōkahu Bay and extending into the Waitematā Harbour.^[6] It encompasses part of the Michael Joseph Savage Memorial Park, a public reserve administered by Auckland Council.^[7] Physically, Bastion Point features a promontory with rugged cliffs, steep slopes, and stepped ridges characteristic of Auckland's volcanic isthmus terrain, elevating to 24–36 metres (80–120 feet) in places amid an average height of 11 metres above sea level.^[8] ^[9] The landscape includes expansive grassy lawns, a central ridgeline, and historical modifications such as the removal of Bastion Rock—a former beacon—and remnants of World War II coastal defence emplacements built between 1942 and 1944.^[10] These elements provide panoramic vistas across the Waitematā Harbour toward the Hauraki Gulf and central Auckland skyline.^[11] Adjacent water bodies, including Biddicks Bay to the east and Ōkahu Bay to the south, accentuate its peninsular form and exposure to maritime influences.^[1]

Māori and European Naming

The Māori name for the headland is Takaparawhau, referring specifically to the western promontory at the eastern end of Ōkahu Bay in Auckland.^[12] This name is traditionally associated with the Ngāti Whātua Ōrākei hapū, who regard the area as ancestral whenua with deep cultural significance, including as a site for fishing, pā, and spiritual practices.^[1] Earlier references sometimes apply the name Kohimarama to the broader point, but Takaparawhau has been reaffirmed by iwi authorities as the primary designation.^[1] The European name, Bastion Point, derives from the military fortifications constructed there, originally termed Fort Bastion.^[1] In 1886, during the "Russian Scare"—a period of perceived threat from Imperial Russian naval expansion—the Crown acquired the 13-acre site from Ngāti Whātua specifically for coastal defense purposes, leading to the installation of gun emplacements and searchlight positions overlooking Waitematā Harbour.^[1] Prior to this, European surveyors, including Felton Mathew in 1841, had mapped it as South Head, denoting its position at the southern entrance to the harbor.^[13] The bastion nomenclature reflects its strategic role in 19th-century colonial defense infrastructure, which included earthworks and artillery batteries completed by the 1940s.^[1]

Pre-20th Century History

Traditional Māori Association

Takaparawhau, an elevated coastal headland in the Ōrākei area of Tāmaki Makaurau, formed a core part of the ancestral whenua rangatira of Ngāti Whātua Ōrākei, who trace their settlement in the region to migrations from the north involving tūpuna such as those from Wairotī and Wairotā.^[14] The site's strategic promontory position overlooking the Waitematā Harbour made it ideal for a pā, providing defensive fortifications against rival iwi incursions while enabling surveillance of sea routes for waka navigation and resource procurement.^[2]^[15] Adjacent lowlands in Ōkahu Bay supported traditional mahinga kai practices, including fishing in the harbor and kūmara cultivation on fertile soils.^[2] The Takaparawhau ridge hosted key communal and cultural sites, such as the Ōrākei marae, serving as a hub for whānau gatherings, rituals, and decision-making central to iwi cohesion and identity.^[14]^[16] Bastion Rock, a prominent toka on the headland, functioned as a navigational beacon guiding waka into the harbor, underscoring the site's integral role in pre-European maritime and territorial control.^[2] These associations reflect Ngāti Whātua Ōrākei's longstanding ahi kā—continuous occupation and stewardship—over the landscape, predating European contact and shaping their hapū's social and economic structures.^[17]

Cession to the Crown in 1886

In 1886, amid the 'Russian Scare'—a period of heightened anxiety in New Zealand over potential invasion by Russian forces—the Crown acquired approximately 13 acres (5.3 hectares) of land at Takaparawhau / Bastion Point for defence purposes. This portion formed part of the diminishing Orākei Block, a native reserve established for Ngāti Whātua Ōrākei under the Orākei Native Reserve Act 1851, which had already been subject to significant erosion through sales and leases. The acquisition was effected through proclamation under the Public Works Act 1882, empowering the government to compulsorily take private or Māori land for public utilities, including military fortifications, with provision for negotiated compensation rather than outright purchase or voluntary cession.^[18]^[19] Ngāti Whātua Ōrākei chief Pāora Tūhaere, who held interests in the block and had intended to subdivide the Bastion Point area for urban residential allotments to generate tribal income, vehemently opposed the taking. He promptly lodged a compensation claim for £5,000, citing the land's strategic harbour-front value and proximity to Auckland city, though the eventual award was considerably lower, aligning with patterns of undervaluation in public works takings from Māori reserves during the late 19th century.^[18]^[19] The defence reserve status facilitated the construction of searchlight emplacements and batteries overlooking the Waitematā Harbour, but the land was never developed for active military use beyond initial surveys. Some contemporary and later narratives frame the transfer as a voluntary gift by Ngāti Whātua in support of national defence, yet legislative records and Tūhaere's documented resistance substantiate it as a compulsory alienation, exacerbating the iwi's progressive dispossession from their central Auckland estate.^[18]^[1]

Early European Use and Legal Transfers

In 1886, the Crown acquired approximately 13 acres (5.3 hectares) at Takaparawhau / Bastion Point under the Public Works Act 1882 for defensive purposes, amid heightened fears of a potential Russian naval incursion known as the Russian Scare.^[18] This acquisition formalized control over the promontory, which had been identified as a strategic site overlooking the Waitematā Harbour.^[20] The primary European use of the land in the late 19th century was military, integrating it into Auckland's coastal defense network established from 1885 onward. Fortifications were initiated at Bastion Point alongside other sites like North Head, with infrastructure such as a mine store completed in Torpedo Bay in 1886 to support submarine minefields extending toward the point.^[20]^[21] These measures aimed to protect the harbor entrance, though active deployment remained limited to contingency planning rather than immediate conflict. No evidence indicates civilian settlement or non-military development on the acquired portion during this period. Legally, the 1886 taking represented the key transfer of title from Ngāti Whātua Ōrākei to the Crown, with no subsequent alienations or reallocations recorded before 1900. The land retained its status as a military reserve, contributing to the broader reduction of the iwi's holdings in the Ōrākei Block, which by the late 1890s were confined primarily to adjacent areas like Ōkahu Bay.^[2] This reservation for defense purposes delayed further European encroachment until the early 20th century.

20th Century Land Use and Encroachment

Urban Development Pressures

As Auckland's population grew from approximately 82,000 in 1901 to over 220,000 by 1945, urban expansion exerted pressure on peripheral reserve lands including Takaparawhau (Bastion Point), which was held as a Māori reservation for [Ngāti Whātua](/page/Ngāti Whātua) Ōrākei. Early infrastructure developments, such as the construction of a sewer line along Ōkahu Bay in 1910, encroached on adjacent areas and foreshadowed broader integration into the city's utilities network.^[22] These projects facilitated suburban growth, with surrounding Ōrākei lands subdivided for housing in the 1920s and developed as state housing from 1938 onward.^[23] To enable further alienation, Auckland City Council policies restricted Ngāti Whātua's ability to maintain or expand their papakāinga settlement on the reserve. From the 1930s to 1950s, the council denied permits for home repairs or new construction without Native Department approval, contributing to the physical decline of the site and justifying subsequent takings.^[24] In 1952, the Crown legislated to confiscate the remaining five hectares of the Ōrākei Block, though the Bastion Point headland was partially preserved as public reserve amid ongoing urban demands.^[22] By the 1970s, with Auckland's population exceeding 800,000 and acute housing shortages, pressure intensified on the remaining 60 acres at Bastion Point for residential development. In 1976, the National Government under Robert Muldoon announced plans to subdivide the site for high-income housing and parks, aiming to capitalize on its prime waterfront location for affluent buyers.^[18] This proposal reflected decades of cumulative urban expansion priorities, where economic development and public access trumped Māori retention of ancestral lands, setting the stage for the 1977 occupation protest.^[25]

Establishment of the Savage Memorial

Michael Joseph Savage, New Zealand's first Labour Prime Minister who served from 1935 until his death on 27 March 1940, was temporarily interred on 31 March 1940 in an adapted harbour defence gun emplacement at Bastion Point, a former military fortification site overlooking Waitematā Harbour.^[26]^[27] The choice of Bastion Point for the initial burial reflected its strategic prominence and scenic views, originally established as a coastal battery during the 1885 Russian scare, with the gun bunker repurposed for the purpose.^[27] ![Michael Joseph Savage Memorial Park.jpg][float-right] In response to public demand for a permanent tribute to Savage, known for implementing the nation's welfare state foundations, the government pursued formal establishment of a memorial site. The Reserves and Other Lands Disposal Act 1941 designated portions of Bastion Point as the Savage Private Burial-ground and Memorial Park, enabling the conversion of military reserve land into a public memorial area.^[28] This legislative step formalized the site's transition from defence use to commemorative purpose, amid wartime constraints that initially raised concerns over resource allocation.^[29] Construction commenced in June 1941, undertaken by Fletcher Construction Company using pre-cast concrete, Oamaru stone, and Dunedin quartz, resulting in an obelisk mausoleum, sunken gardens, and a reflecting pool atop the existing bunker.^[29]^[26] The project was completed by March 1942, with Savage's remains transferred to the new mausoleum shortly thereafter.^[29] The memorial was officially opened to the public in March 1943, drawing immediate widespread visitation that surprised officials and affirming Savage's enduring popularity as one of New Zealand's most beloved leaders.^[29] The 49-hectare park encompassing the memorial has since served as a public reserve, preserving the site's historical and commemorative significance.^[30]

Gradual Alienation from Ngāti Whātua

Throughout the early 20th century, the Crown continued to diminish the Ōrākei reserve, including areas adjacent to Takaparawhau (Bastion Point), through a combination of negotiated sales and compulsory acquisitions under the Public Works Act 1908, primarily to facilitate urban infrastructure and expansion in Auckland. By 1914, the Crown had acquired approximately 460 acres, targeting productive farming portions of the reserve despite Ngāti Whātua Ōrākei's resistance to voluntary sales; where negotiations stalled, the government invoked compulsory taking powers, often providing inadequate compensation relative to the land's value and cultural significance.^[18] These acquisitions included sewer infrastructure along Ōkahu Bay toward Takaparawhau as early as 1910, enabling residential development while eroding the iwi's economic base and territorial integrity.^[18] Military and public domain uses further alienated portions of Takaparawhau itself. In 1941, land previously taken for defence purposes in 1886—13 acres at the point—was transferred to Auckland City Council control, and by 1944, searchlight emplacements were constructed there as part of wartime fortifications, restricting iwi access without consent or benefit.^[18] Concurrently, evictions intensified: in 1939, the last 14 adults and 10 children were removed from village lands at Ōkahu Bay, and in 1951, the Crown compulsorily acquired the remaining 12.5 acres of residential holdings, demolishing homes and the wharenui (meeting house), leaving Ngāti Whātua Ōrākei with negligible land beyond a cemetery and the diminished headland reserve.^[18] These actions, justified as serving public needs, systematically fragmented the reserve, reducing it from hundreds of acres post-1886 to a fragmented remnant by mid-century. By the 1970s, cumulative compulsory acquisitions had shrunk the Ōrākei reserve to less than 1 hectare in effective iwi control, with Takaparawhau's approximately 60 acres threatened by a government proposal for high-income housing development announced in 1976.^[3] This gradual erosion, spanning over five decades of piecemeal takings for roads, utilities, defence, and urban amenities, effectively severed Ngāti Whātua Ōrākei's practical mana whenua (authority over land) despite the reserve's original designation as inalienable, prompting the iwi's direct challenge through the 1977 occupation.^[3]^[18]

The 1977-1978 Occupation

Government Housing Proposal and Protest Initiation

In 1976, the New Zealand National Government under Prime Minister Robert Muldoon announced plans to subdivide and sell portions of the Bastion Point reserve for high-income private housing development.^[31]^[24] The proposal targeted open Crown-owned land on the Takaparawhau peninsula, which had been designated as a reserve for the benefit of Ngāti Whātua Ōrākei since 1886, though the iwi had been progressively dispossessed of access and control over the preceding decades.^[32]^[33] This development was intended to provide exclusive residential sections for affluent buyers, despite ongoing Māori claims to the ancestral territory and without consultation yielding iwi consent.^[24]^[34] The announcement provoked strong opposition from Ngāti Whātua Ōrākei, who viewed it as a further erosion of their remaining rights to the land, which had already been reduced to a fraction of its original extent through prior alienations for public works, military use, and the Michael Joseph Savage Memorial Park.^[31]^[25] In response, local leader Joe Hawke, a fisherman and community organizer from the hapū, formed the Ōrākei Māori Action Committee to coordinate resistance.^[35]^[36] The committee argued that the sale violated the reserve's purpose and ignored historical grievances stemming from the 1951 Orakei Act, which had evicted the last resident families from the area.^[24] On 5 January 1977, Hawke and approximately 30 committee members and supporters marched onto Bastion Point, erected tents, and established a hīkoi camp to physically block surveyors and developers from proceeding.^[35]^[25]^[36] This occupation marked the formal initiation of the protest, with the stated goals of halting the housing subdivision, asserting Ngāti Whātua's mana whenua (tribal authority) over the site, and pressuring the government to return the full reserve lands without compensation demands.^[25]^[37] Initial activities included raising a tino rangatiratanga flag and constructing basic structures, drawing immediate media attention and framing the action as a defense against cultural erasure rather than mere opposition to urban expansion.^[35]

Occupation Activities and Public Support

The occupation of Takaparawhā (Bastion Point) commenced on 5 January 1977, when members of the Ōrākei Māori Action Committee, led by Joe Hawke, established a presence on the site to halt the government's planned luxury housing development on former Ngāti Whātua reserve land. Protesters constructed temporary buildings, including a communal meeting house, and dug vegetable gardens to provide food and demonstrate sustainable use of the land, thereby sustaining a community of up to several dozen residents over the 507-day duration.^[36]^[38] These activities emphasized nonviolent resistance, cultural continuity through hui (gatherings) and waiata (songs), and self-sufficiency, with some building materials sourced informally from sympathizers.^[39] The protesters presented multiple petitions to Parliament, amassing 59, 243, and 4,800 signatures respectively, demanding the land's return to Ngāti Whātua control for a marae rather than commercial sale. Daily life involved communal labor, maintenance of the camp, and defensive vigilance against potential encroachment, though the occupation remained peaceful despite government warnings.^[36] A tragic incident occurred on 30 September 1977, when 9-year-old Joanna Hawke died in an accidental fire at the site, underscoring the personal hardships endured.^[36] Public support broadened the protest's impact, with trade unions imposing a "green ban" in early 1977, whereby workers refused to provide labor, materials, or services for the development, effectively stalling construction and pressuring the government.^[40]^[39] This solidarity from groups like the Auckland Trades Council and Northern Drivers' Union was pivotal, as union members also participated in site activities and fundraising. National media coverage, including television broadcasts, drew widespread attention to historical land grievances, while endorsements from Māori activist organizations such as Ngā Tamatoa and Citizens Association for Racial Equality (CARE) mobilized further petitions and donations.^[36]^[40] The occupation's visibility extended internationally, framing it as a stand against ongoing Māori dispossession and contributing to momentum for Treaty of Waitangi reforms.^[38]

Police Eviction and Casualties

On May 25, 1978, following 506 days of occupation, New Zealand police and military personnel executed a large-scale eviction operation at Bastion Point (Takaparawhau), removing 222 protesters who had established a makeshift village to oppose government plans for housing development on the land.^[38] ^[24] The operation involved approximately 800 officers from the New Zealand Police and New Zealand Defence Force, who advanced in coordinated formation, using trucks and personnel to dismantle structures and clear the site.^[41] Protesters, led by Ngāti Whātua activist Joe Hawke, maintained a policy of non-violent resistance, sitting in place as they were physically carried or walked off the promontory by authorities.^[42] The eviction proceeded with minimal reported physical harm, as occupiers offered passive compliance despite the scale of the force deployed, which included army engineers to bulldoze buildings after arrests.^[38] No fatalities occurred, and contemporary accounts do not document significant injuries among protesters, police, or military personnel, though the action was characterized by some observers as militaristic and intimidating due to the overwhelming numbers and equipment used.^[43] All 222 individuals arrested were charged with trespass, but charges were later dropped or resulted in light penalties, reflecting the operation's focus on clearance rather than punitive escalation.^[24] The event drew widespread media coverage, amplifying public sympathy for the Māori land rights cause and contributing to the government's eventual policy reversal.^[38]

Legal Aftermath and Resolution

Waitangi Tribunal Inquiry

The Ōrākei claim, designated Wai 9, was lodged with the Waitangi Tribunal on 21 February 1984 by Joe Hawke and twelve others representing Ngāti Whātua o Ōrākei, alleging Crown breaches of the Treaty of Waitangi in the alienation of approximately 700 acres of ancestral land in the Ōrākei block, including the Takaparawhau (Bastion Point) peninsula.^[44] The claim encompassed events from the 1852 Native Reserves Act through to 20th-century urban developments and the 1976 government proposal to subdivide Bastion Point for middle-income housing, which had prompted the 1977–1978 occupation.^[18] With the 1985 Treaty of Waitangi Amendment Act extending the Tribunal's jurisdiction retrospectively to 1840, the Ōrākei inquiry became the first historical claim to be formally investigated, involving hearings, witness testimonies from Ngāti Whātua descendants, and archival evidence on land transactions, reserves management, and Crown policies.^[25] The Tribunal examined specific grievances, such as the Crown's failure to honor 1840s promises of inalienable reserves, inadequate compensation for compulsory acquisitions under public works legislation (e.g., 1912 and 1951 takings totaling over 500 acres), and the erosion of the iwi's economic base through urbanization without equivalent redress.^[18] In its report released on 31 August 1987, the Waitangi Tribunal concluded that the Crown had repeatedly breached Treaty principles of active protection and reciprocity by not safeguarding Ngāti Whātua's rangatiratanga (chieftainship) over their lands, allowing piecemeal alienation without sufficient alternatives or compensation, and prioritizing non-Māori development interests.^[45] The Tribunal recommended vesting 13.9 hectares of Bastion Point land (excluding the Michael Joseph Savage Memorial) in a trust for Ngāti Whātua, subject to continued public access and reserve status, alongside $3 million in financial compensation to address cumulative losses estimated in the millions adjusted for inflation and opportunity costs.^[3] These non-binding recommendations emphasized restorative justice over punitive measures, acknowledging evidential gaps in pre-20th-century records but prioritizing empirical patterns of Crown inaction.^[45]

Land Return in 1987 and Compensation

In November 1987, the Waitangi Tribunal released its report on the Orakei claim (Wai-9), investigating the historical alienation of Bastion Point lands from Ngāti Whātua Ōrākei under public works legislation and urban development pressures.^[45] The Tribunal concluded that the Crown had breached its Treaty of Waitangi obligations by failing to protect Māori proprietary rights and interests in the land, recommending the return of Bastion Point—approximately 13.8 hectares (34 acres)—to the iwi, along with adjacent areas previously acquired compulsorily.^[45]^[3] This recommendation emphasized restoring customary tenure where feasible, rejecting full commercialization in favor of iwi management to address intergenerational dispossession.^[45] The Fourth Labour Government, led by Prime Minister David Lange, accepted the Tribunal's findings and implemented the return on 1 July 1988, vesting the land in the Ōrākei Māori Trust Board without requiring repayment of development costs, unlike the rejected 1978 proposal that demanded $200,000 from the iwi for 13 acres and 27 state houses.^[3]^[25] As part of the settlement, the Crown provided $3 million in financial redress to support housing, marae development, and economic initiatives for Ngāti Whātua Ōrākei, acknowledging cumulative losses from prior takings that had reduced the original reserve from over 250 hectares in 1852 to less than 1 hectare by the 1970s.^[45] This compensation was not framed as full restitution for historical value but as targeted assistance to enable iwi self-determination, with the returned land designated as a reserve under joint Crown-iwi administration to preserve public access while prioritizing Māori cultural and spiritual values.^[45] The 1988 return marked a policy shift toward negotiated Treaty settlements, influencing subsequent claims processes, though critics noted it fell short of comprehensive reparations for all alienated Ōrākei lands, leading to further litigation and the Ōrākei Act 1991 for trust board governance.^[46] No additional monetary claims were immediately pursued, as the settlement focused on land restoration over cash equivalents, aligning with Tribunal emphasis on retaining taonga (treasures) like Bastion Point for future iwi generations rather than alienating it through sales.^[45]

Current Status and Management

Reserve Designation and Iwi Role

In 1988, the New Zealand government returned approximately 51.8 hectares of land at Takaparawhau (Bastion Point), excluding the Michael Joseph Savage Memorial, to Ngāti Whātua Ōrākei as recommended by the Waitangi Tribunal's 1987 inquiry into the Ōrākei claim.^[3]^[45] The returned area was vested as Takaparawhau Reserve under the Reserves Act 1977, classified primarily for recreation and local purposes, ensuring public access while recognizing iwi ownership and requiring management "for the benefit of all."^[47] This designation formalized the site's role as a public open space integrated with adjacent parks like Ōkahu Domain, prohibiting residential or commercial development beyond reserve-compatible uses. The reserve's administration is governed by the Ōrākei Act 1991, which established the Ngāti Whātua Ōrākei Reserves Board in 1991 as a joint entity between the iwi and Auckland Council to oversee Takaparawhau alongside other Ōrākei lands.^[48] The board, comprising iwi and council representatives, approves annual budgets exceeding $1 million for maintenance, funded partly by council grants, and directs activities such as cliff stabilization, drainage improvements, and signage installation as of 2025.^[49] Ngāti Whātua Ōrākei holds ownership and exercises kaitiakitanga (guardianship) over the reserve, prioritizing ecological restoration through eco-sourced planting in the Tāmaki district, habitat protection, and cultural preservation, including the Ōrākei Marae and wharenui (meeting house) Tumutumuwhenua.^[50]^[51] The iwi organizes public events like the annual Manu Aute Kite Day on the first Matariki weekend, fostering community engagement while embedding Māori tikanga (customs) in site management, such as installing pou (posts) symbolizing ancestral beacons in 2019.^[52]

Recent Developments and Proposals

In 2019, Ngāti Whātua Ōrākei installed a pou at Takaparawhau, designed by artists Lenard Philips and Te Aroha Witika, featuring the shape of a taurapa (stern of a waka) on a concrete plinth symbolizing the historic Bastion Rock that served as a navigational beacon. This cultural marker commemorates the site's significance to the iwi while integrating with the reserve's landscape. The Ngāti Whātua Ōrākei Reserves Board, in partnership with Auckland Council, has prioritized enhancements to public access and cultural programming. In July 2025, proposals were advanced for upgrading informal tracks across Takaparawhau to improve safety and visitor experience without altering the natural terrain.^[53] By September 2025, the Takaparawhau Events Ground was highlighted as essential for hosting significant iwi-led gatherings, including the Matariki Hautapu ceremony, underscoring its role in contemporary Māori cultural revitalization amid ongoing reserve management.^[54] In November 2024, thousands participating in the Hīkoi mō te Tiriti were formally welcomed to Bastion Point, reinforcing the site's status as a focal point for discussions on Treaty of Waitangi interpretations and iwi rights.^[55] No large-scale commercial development proposals have emerged since the 1987 land return, with management emphasizing ecological restoration, recreational use, and prohibition of alienation to preserve whenua rangatira under the iwi's co-governance framework.^[56]

Significance and Debates

Role in Māori Rights Activism

The occupation of Takaparawhau (Bastion Point) by Ngāti Whātua Ōrākei from January 1977 to May 1978 marked a pivotal moment in Māori rights activism, protesting the Crown's proposed sale of 55 hectares of land for housing development that the iwi regarded as ancestral territory alienated through historical breaches of the Treaty of Waitangi.^[3] Led by Joe Hawke of the Ōrākei Māori Action Committee, the 506-day non-violent occupation drew widespread public sympathy by highlighting systemic land confiscations dating back to the 19th century, including the 1951 compulsory acquisition of the Ōrākei Block under the Public Works Act.^[57] This action amplified calls for Treaty redress, mobilizing support from urban Māori, trade unions, and international observers who viewed it as emblematic of indigenous resistance to colonial dispossession.^[1] Bastion Point's strategies, including building a marae, planting gardens, and hosting cultural events, transformed the site into a symbol of self-determination and cultural revitalization, fostering iwi cohesion and challenging government narratives of land as a commodity for public housing.^[58] The protest garnered extensive media coverage, with daily broadcasts exposing the eviction's scale—over 600 police officers deploying on May 25, 1978, resulting in 10 injuries—which galvanized broader Māori activism and pressured the establishment of the Waitangi Tribunal's investigative powers.^[1] By framing the dispute as a test case for Treaty obligations, it influenced subsequent claims, such as those at Raglan and Pakaitore, and contributed to legislative reforms expanding Tribunal jurisdiction to historical grievances in 1985.^[57] The occupation's legacy endures as a catalyst for the Māori Renaissance, demonstrating that sustained protest could compel policy shifts, as evidenced by the 1987 return of 12 hectares to Ngāti Whātua and $3 million in compensation following the Tribunal's Orakei Report.^[3] It underscored the efficacy of direct action in countering bureaucratic inertia, inspiring a generation of activists to pursue legal and political avenues for land restitution while critiquing state overreach in Māori affairs.^[18] Though critics from property rights perspectives argued it disrupted urban development, proponents credit it with restoring iwi mana and advancing causal accountability for past Crown actions.^[57]

Economic and Property Rights Perspectives

The occupation of Bastion Point from January 5, 1977, to May 25, 1978, represented a direct challenge to the Crown's legal property rights over the site, which had been vested as a public reserve following the alienation of the Ōrākei block in the late 19th century. Under New Zealand law at the time, the land was Crown property, and protesters' presence constituted trespass, leading to a High Court injunction in April 1978 prohibiting occupation, use, or interference with the site. The eviction, involving approximately 600 police officers and resulting in 222 arrests, underscored the enforcement of statutory title against unauthorized use, with no reported casualties but significant deployment of public resources to restore legal control. From a property rights standpoint, this highlighted tensions between formal ownership—rooted in colonial-era legislation and public vesting—and historical claims tracing to Ngāti Whātua's pre-1840 interests, where secure, alienable title is seen as foundational to investment and development, yet state acquisition without enduring compensation had eroded iwi economic bases. Economically, the 506-day occupation halted proposed government plans for high-income housing development, which aimed to generate revenue through sales, rates, and infrastructure improvements in a prime Auckland location overlooking the Waitematā Harbour. Critics of such protests argue that prolonged disruptions impose opportunity costs, including foregone taxes and jobs from private or public development, while favoring direct action over judicial or treaty-based remedies that respect existing titles. However, the subsequent Waitangi Tribunal inquiry into the Ōrākei claim (Wai 9) identified Crown breaches of Treaty principles, including inadequate protection of Māori proprietary interests, leading to the 1987 return of approximately 13 hectares (about 32 acres) of Bastion Point land plus $3 million in compensation to Ngāti Whātua Ōrākei. This resolution enabled the iwi to pursue strategic land repurchases, particularly in Auckland's central business district, transforming initial assets into a portfolio valued at over $1 billion by 2021 through commercial leasing and development, demonstrating how rectified property rights can foster long-term economic self-sufficiency when aligned with market incentives. In causal terms, the occupation's success in catalyzing policy change illustrates how public contention can compel restitution for historical expropriations, but it also raised questions about the efficiency of communal versus individualized property regimes; Ngāti Whātua's post-settlement model integrated iwi governance with private-sector partnerships, yielding dividends for beneficiaries that outperformed fragmented reserves under prior Crown management. Nonetheless, empirical patterns in Māori land tenure suggest that insecure or collectively held titles historically contributed to underutilization and poverty, with Bastion Point's return marking a shift toward empowering iwi corporations to exercise de facto private rights, albeit within treaty frameworks that prioritize group entitlements over absolute individual alienability.^[3]^[59]^[60]

Achievements, Criticisms, and Viewpoints

The Bastion Point occupation achieved significant public awareness of Ngāti Whātua's historical land grievances, transforming a local dispute into a national symbol of Māori resistance against alienation, which pressured subsequent governments to address Treaty of Waitangi claims more urgently.^[61]^[1] The 507-day protest from January 5, 1977, to May 25, 1978, halted the government's immediate plans for luxury housing development on the site, preserving it from subdivision until legal resolution.^[24] Ultimately, the occupation contributed to the Waitangi Tribunal's 1987 inquiry, which validated Ngāti Whātua's claims of wrongful land loss dating to the 19th century, resulting in the return of 13 hectares of land and NZ$400,000 in compensation by 1988, marking one of the first major post-1975 Tribunal successes.^[62] Critics of the occupation contended that it constituted unlawful trespass on Crown reserve land, justifying the government's decision to evict 222 protesters on May 25, 1978, using over 800 police and military personnel at substantial public expense, estimated in the millions when accounting for operations, overtime, and lost development revenue.^[63]^[35] The action prevented economically productive use of the site for high-value housing intended to recoup Crown investments, forgoing potential taxpayer benefits from land sales or rentals that could have funded public services, as prioritized by Prime Minister Robert Muldoon's administration.^[64] Some observers, including within Māori communities, criticized the tactics for risking escalation and diverting focus from legal avenues, potentially undermining broader iwi unity by associating land rights with confrontational direct action rather than sustained negotiation.^[65] From a Māori rights perspective, the occupation exemplified effective non-violent activism that reclaimed ancestral whenua (land) and catalyzed the Māori Renaissance, inspiring subsequent protests and empowering iwi to pursue Tribunal claims, with Ngāti Whātua leaders viewing it as a fulfillment of intergenerational stewardship against colonial dispossession.^[66]^[67] In contrast, property rights advocates and government officials emphasized the rule of law, arguing that the land had been legally vested as a public reserve since the early 20th century for defense and recreation, rendering the occupation an illegitimate challenge to state authority and democratic land-use decisions, potentially setting precedents for extralegal claims over public assets.^[1] Economic viewpoints highlight a trade-off: while the return advanced iwi self-determination, it prioritized cultural restitution over fiscal pragmatism, as the site's development could have generated ongoing revenue without relying on compensatory settlements funded by general taxation.^[68] These divergent interpretations reflect ongoing tensions between indigenous customary rights and modern statutory frameworks, with mainstream narratives often amplifying activist successes while downplaying the eviction's affirmation of legal boundaries.^[69]

References

[1]
Bastion Point | NZ History
Police and army personal removed 222 people from Bastion Point, Auckland, ending an occupation that had begun in January 1977. Ngāti Whātua were protesting ...
[2]
Ngāti Whātua Ōrākei: Taking of the land
Takaparawhau. In 1976, Prime Minister Robert Muldoon announces that the Crown will develop the remaining land at Bastion Point as a high-income housing project.
[3]
Bastion Point land returned | NZ History
1 July 1988. Ngāti Whātua occupation ... The Bastion Point occupation became one of the most famous protest actions in New Zealand history.
[4]
Bastion Point - Discover Auckland
Bastion Point, located above Tāmaki Drive in Auckland, is a significant historical and cultural site for Māori and New Zealand history.
[5]
Bastion Point | East Auckland - New Zealand Trip Ideas
Bastion Point is located at the western end of Mission Bay in Auckland, near Downtown. The Point has an expansive grassy reserve and the striking Michael ...
[6]
GPS coordinates of Bastion Point, New Zealand. Latitude
GPS coordinates of Bastion Point, New Zealand. Latitude: -36.8398 Longitude: 174.8212.Missing: elevation terrain
[7]
Michael Joseph Savage Memorial - Auckland Council
Michael Joseph Savage Memorial, also known as Bastion Point, 9-15 Hapimana Street, Orakei. Show on map.
[8]
The Physiography of the Auckland District - Ballance - 1968
Near to the coast many of the ridges are stepped down to 80 to 120 feet, as is shown very well at Bastion Point. Indeed, if one stands on a vantage point in ...Missing: elevation | Show results with:elevation
[9]
Bastion Point topographic map, elevation, terrain
Average elevation: 11 m • Bastion Point, Mission Bay, Ōrākei, Auckland, 1071, New Zealand • Visualization and sharing of free topographic maps.Missing: physical features
[10]
Shining a light on local history - OurAuckland - Auckland Council
Apr 26, 2016 · The emplacements were built in 1942 and 1943 as part of the defence system protecting Auckland during the Second World War. Local board member ...
[11]
Bastion Point | Auckland, New Zealand | Attractions - Lonely Planet
Bastion Point ... Politics, harbour views and lush lawns combine on this pretty headland with a chequered history. An elaborate clifftop garden mausoleum honours ...
[12]
Taka-para-whau - Te Aka Māori Dictionary
1. (location) eastern point of Ōkahu Bay (Auckland).
[13]
[PDF] Fort Bastion Bastion Point/ Takaparawhau Tamaki Drive - Kura
Apr 26, 2018 · Bastion Point headland was named South Head by the first Surveyor-General of New Zealand, Felton. Mathew in 1841. It marks the southern point of ...
[14]
Ngāti Whātua Ōrākei: From the far north
The tūpuna of Ngāti Whātua Ōrākei came from Wairotī and Wairotā across the ocean. They landed in Muriwhenua and over time travelled south and settled in Tāmaki ...
[15]
Tāmaki Drive Coastal Path – Auckland walks
Scenic loop combining Mission Bay coastal boulevard, Takaparawhau / Bastion Point and local history. Enjoy panoramic views of Auckland and the Hauraki Gulf.<|separator|>
[16]
Ōrākei Marae
Takaparawhau (Bastion Point), where the Marae is based, is steeped in rich culture and history, boasting in spectacular views of the Waitematā Harbour and ...
[17]
Ngāti Whātua Ōrākei Whai Rawa - HOME
Whenua Rangatira. Whenua Rangatira is very significant whenua to our hapū and encompasses Takaparawhau (Bastion Point) and Ōrākei Domain (Okahu Bay).
[18]
The loss of the Ōrākei block - Waitangi Tribunal
The response of Ngāti Whātua of Ōrākei. When the land was taken in 1886, the chief Tūhaere immediately lodged a claim for £5,000 compensation, because this was ...
[19]
Tūhaere, Pāora | Dictionary of New Zealand Biography | Te Ara
In 1886 the Crown took for defence purposes land at Bastion Point that Tūhaere had intended for residential subdivision. The 1882 act did not prevent the ...
[20]
Harbour Defences - Auckland 1885-1896
The Mine Store in Torpedo Bay at the foot of North Head, the base for strings of mines to be run across the harbour to Bastion Point, was completed in 1886.
[21]
NZ Coastal Defences - Auckland - Google Sites
Fortifications were begun on Point Bastion and at Takapuna as well as further construction at North Head. Finally in the 1890s the final fort of the period was ...
[22]
[PDF] A brief history of Auckland's urban form
The Tāmaki Makaurau / Auckland urban form changed dramatically in the first three decades of the 20th century. ... Occupation of Bastion Point (1978), Robin ...
[23]
Eastern suburbs: Ōrākei to the Tāmaki River
Mar 2, 2009 · During the 1920s land above the Ngāti Whātua settlement was taken for housing – Ōrākei became a state housing suburb in 1938. Finally, in ...
[24]
Bastion Point: A desperate struggle and a dream fulfilled - E-Tangata
Jun 3, 2018 · Andrew Robb has led an unusual life for a Pākehā, including, for instance, working as a reo Māori journalist on radio and television.Missing: etymology | Show results with:etymology
[25]
Occupation of Bastion Point begins - NZ History
In February 1978, the government offered to return some land and houses to Ngāti Whātua if the iwi paid $200,000 in development costs. The occupiers stayed put, ...Missing: proposal | Show results with:proposal
[26]
[PDF] Michael Savage Memorial, Ōrākei - Kura
He was initially interred on 31 March 1940, in a temporarily adapted harbour defence gun installation at Bastion. Point (formerly Fort Bastion) pending the.
[27]
Savage memorial, Auckland | Memorials and monuments
Mar 14, 2012 · Like Massey, Savage was buried in a gun bunker originally built for the 1885 Russian scare. It was decided to erect a memorial above his grave ...<|separator|>
[28]
reserves and other lands disposal act 1941 - sect 11
RESERVES AND OTHER LANDS DISPOSAL ACT 1941 - SECT 11. Establishing Savage Private Burial-ground and Memorial Park at Bastion Point, Auckland, and provisions ...Missing: acquisition | Show results with:acquisition
[29]
Savage Memorial - NZ History
Nov 6, 2024 · The memorial was officially opened in March 1943. Initial public interest in the site amazed officials, and it continues to attract both ...
[30]
Exploring Michael Joseph Savage Memorial Park: A Scenic ...
Spanning 49 hectares, it sits on the historically significant Bastion Point, a site once used as a coastal fortification in the late 19th century. Whether you' ...
[31]
This week in history: Bastion Point protestors evicted - Waatea News
May 28, 2025 · The occupation lasted 506 days, becoming one of the longest land protests in New Zealand's history. On 25 May 1978, the government deployed over ...<|separator|>
[32]
Bastion Point protest | Record | DigitalNZ - Digital New Zealand
In 1976 the government proposed selling part of the Bastion Point reserve for luxury housing. It was on ancestral land that Ngāti Whātua hoped to get back ...
[33]
The occupation of Takaparawhā Bastion Point, 40 years on
May 26, 2018 · This week marks the 40th anniversary of one of the most pivotal land actions in New Zealand history – the 506 day occupation of Bastion Point.Missing: coordinates elevation terrain
[34]
Land of a Thousand Lovers | Television | NZ On Screen
Land of a Thousand Lovers - In 1885 the NZ Government used legislation to take ownership of sections of Bastion Point (Takaparawhau) for defence purposes.
[35]
Flashback: Final stand of Ngati Whatua begins at Bastion Point in ...
Jan 7, 2016 · On January 5, 1977, Joe Hawke and about 30 other angry Ngati Whatua marched on to Bastion Point, at Orakei, Auckland, set up camp and refused to leave.
[36]
Maoris in New Zealand regain Bastion Point by occupying their land ...
Before the colonization of the land by the British Crown, it provided shelter, rich fishing and farming areas for the Ngāti Whātua people, a Māori iwi (tribe).<|separator|>
[37]
Takaparawhau: The people's story of the Bastion Point occupation
May 24, 2023 · In 1977 Joe Hawke, with the Ōrākei Māori Action Committee, led an occupation to protest the loss of Ngāti Whātua's land rights.
[38]
Bastion Point protesters evicted | NZ History
### Summary of Occupation Activities at Bastion Point (1977-1978)
[39]
The forgotten union green ban that defended Bastion Point
Sep 23, 2025 · Takaparawhau was the site of a watershed Māori protest against the alienation of their land, and the green ban placed to support the land ...
[40]
Bastion Point and the Trade Unions - Open Journal System
Apr 29, 1978 · There is no doubt that Trade Union support was vital to the Ngati Whatua people during their 500 day occupation of Bastion Point. The ...Missing: public marches
[41]
Bastion Point occupiers recall being evicted 44 years ago - 1News
May 25, 2022 · It was 44 years to the day since the Government sent 800 police and NZDF personnel to remove those occupying the land at Takaparawhau. Video ...Missing: casualties | Show results with:casualties
[42]
Remembering Bastion Point | E-Tangata
May 21, 2023 · On 25 May this year, it will be 45 years since police and army personnel invaded Takaparawhau, Bastion Point, and arrested more than 200 people.
[43]
Remembering Bastion Pt: 'Straight out of a Nazi war movie' - RNZ
May 24, 2018 · ... violent passive protest and we were here to be strong and stay staunch to that kaupapa of non-violence." And she was shocked at the military ...Missing: harm | Show results with:harm
[44]
Report of the Waitangi Tribunal on the Orakei Claim (Wai-9).
Claim Wai 9, the Orakei claim, was filed in February 1984 by Joe Hawke and 12 others on behalf of Ngati Whatua and concerned the Orakei block in Auckland.
[45]
Resolving the grievances of the past - Waitangi Tribunal
The Waitangi Tribunal said that the following should be done: Ōkahu Park and the headlands of Bastion Point (apart from the Savage Memorial) should be returned ...Missing: urban | Show results with:urban
[46]
Consequences/Historical Significance - Takaparawhau -Bastion Point
A key legacy left behind by the occupation at Bastion Point was for Māori, a rebirth of Māori identity occurred in order for Māori culture to be preserved. It's ...
[47]
[PDF] Title of project: Tū Whare Ora – Building Capacity for Māori Driven De
In the event, a section of Ngāti Whātua, under the leadership of. Joseph Hawke, protested by occupying Takaparawhau (Bastion Point) for 506 days. On 25. May ...
[48]
[PDF] Combined Reserve Management Plan - Ngāti Whātua Ōrākei
Ōrākei Block at Bastion Point. The 506 day occupation takes place. 7. Page 8 ... Whenua Rangatira (Takaparawhau & Ōkahu). 21. • Implement Ahi Kā plan.
[49]
Ngāti Whātua Ōrākei Reserves Board - Agendas and Minutes
Jul 21, 2025 · Takaparawhau Cliff Stabilisation urgent investigations are now complete, with immediate drainage improvements planned to address environmental ...
[50]
Whenua Rangatira - Ngāti Whātua Ōrākei
Te Ao Manatū: Nestled at the heart of Takaparawhau, Te Ao Manatū, also known as the three rocks close to where Te Arohanui stood during the Bastion Point ...
[51]
Ngāti Whātua Ōrākei Reserves Board
The reserves board is responsible for an expansive area of land lying on the harbour edge between Paratai Drive and Mission Bay, including Ōkahu Bay – the ...Missing: Takaparawhau | Show results with:Takaparawhau
[52]
Connect with the star realm at Manu Aute Kite Day - OurAuckland
Jun 29, 2019 · Connect with the star realm at Manu Aute Kite Day · 10am-4pm; Takaparawhau Reserve/Michael Joseph Savage Memorial Park, 19 Hapimana St, Ōrākei ...
[53]
Ngāti Whātua Ōrākei Reserves Board - Agendas and Minutes
Management recommends that the board approve the payment of Year 1 funds to enable the carrying out of the scheduled works in FY 2025/26.
[54]
Agenda of Ngāti Whātua Ōrākei Reserves Board
Sep 22, 2025 · To support the continued delivery of core services across Pourewa and Takaparawhau, the Reserves Board is asked to approve a total grant payment ...
[55]
Hīkoi mō te Tiriti welcomed on to Bastion Point and Ihumātao | Stuff
Nov 13, 2024 · After crossing the Auckland Harbour Bridge, thousands continued on to Takaparawhau Bastion Point and Ihumātao on Wednesday afternoon.Missing: proposals 2020-2025<|separator|>
[56]
[PDF] TE POU O KĀHU PŌKERE - Ngāti Whātua Ōrākei
This Iwi Management Plan has been produced in partnership with Auckland Council. A series of design workshops were held in 2017 in which resource management ...
[57]
Story: Ngā rōpū tautohetohe – Māori protest movements
Ngāti Whātua Ōrākei occupied their lands at Takaparawhau (Bastion Point), Auckland, for 506 days in 1977–78. The land was later returned. Protesters have ...
[58]
Sit-ins and occupations | Te Ara Encyclopedia of New Zealand
In May 1978, after 507 days, the police arrested 222 protesters and evicted the rest. Following a Waitangi Tribunal report in 1987, much of the land was ...
[59]
How Ngāti Whātua Ōrākei turned a piece of land into a billion-dollar ...
May 1, 2021 · The settlement returned 100 acres of land and $3m, which Ngāti Whātua Ōrākei used to embark on a strategy to buy back as much land as possible ...
[60]
LMT #138: Takaparawhau/Bastion Point, Auckland, New Zealand
Takaparawhau/Bastion Point was the site of a significant 1977-78 Māori land occupation and green ban, supported by unions, against government development plans.
[61]
Bastion Point land occupation - Students - Britannica Kids
In January 1977 members of the Ngāti Whātua iwi peacefully occupied the land in protest. Joe Hawke, who had helped to form the Ōrākei Māori Action Committee to ...
[62]
The 1977 Bastion Point occupation: What happened? - 1News
May 24, 2022 · 1News takes a look back at Takaparawhau/ Bastion Point - one of the biggest land occupations in Aotearoa's history, led by the Ngāti Whātua ki Ōrākei kaumātua.
[63]
On this day in 1978, the Bastion Point occupation came to a violent ...
May 25, 2022 · It was on this day 44 years ago that more than 800 police and soldiers forcefully attempted to end the occupation of Takaparawhau, arresting 222 people.
[64]
Quotes | Bastion Point - The Untold Story | Television - NZ On Screen
Bastion Point - The Untold Story - In 1977 protesters occupied Bastion Point, after the announcement of a housing development on land once belonging to ...Missing: marches | Show results with:marches<|separator|>
[65]
Pathway to Protest - 1977 Bastion Point occupation
Prior to the 1977 Bastion Point occupation, the Maori movement experienced a drastic change. ... She captured too some Maori criticism but often the critics were ...
[66]
Bastion Point Occupation: Māori Land Rights, Political & Cultural ...
Sep 1, 2025 · Revitalisation of Identity: The occupation helped Ngāti Whātua reaffirm their connection to their ancestral land, enhancing iwi pride and mana.
[67]
Bastion Point protest | Auckland places
Apr 15, 2008 · The tribe mounted a 506-day occupation of the site in 1977–78. The protest ended when the government sent in police to clear the protesters and demolish their ...Missing: activities | Show results with:activities
[68]
Roadside Stories: Reclaiming Bastion Point | Ngāti Whātua
... Bastion Point was taken by the Crown for defence purposes. A 1977 government plan to develop expensive housing on Bastion Point prompted a 506-day ...
[69]
40 years on from the Bastion Point occupation: Where are we now?
Jan 4, 2017 · In 1840, Ngati Whatua chief Apihai Te Kawau signed the Treaty of Waitangi and gifted 3000 acres of land to the Crown to establish Auckland city.