Fact-checked by Grok 2 weeks ago

Alienation

Alienation is a multifaceted concept in philosophy, sociology, and psychology that denotes a problematic separation or estrangement between an individual and aspects of their existence—such as their labor, products of labor, fellow humans, or innate potential—that properly belong together and foster human flourishing.^[1] Originating in Western thought, it gained prominence through G.W.F. Hegel's analysis of self-estrangement in consciousness and objective spirit, where alienation (Entfremdung) represents a necessary dialectical stage in human development before reconciliation, rather than an inherent pathology.^[1] Karl Marx adapted and radicalized this idea, arguing that under capitalism, workers experience fourfold alienation: from the products they create (appropriated by capitalists), the labor process itself (reduced to mechanical drudgery), their species-being or creative essence (deprived of self-realization), and other humans (transformed into competitive antagonists).^[1] This Marxist framework posits alienation as an objective structural condition rooted in private property and division of labor, not merely subjective discontent, though empirical verification of its historical specificity remains contested due to challenges in measuring pre-capitalist baselines.^[1] In sociology, Melvin Seeman formalized alienation in 1959 as comprising five dimensions—powerlessness (perceived lack of control over outcomes), meaninglessness (inability to predict events due to unclear social norms), normlessness (expectation that socially disapproved means are required for success), isolation (rejection of societal values), and self-estrangement (engagement in activities experienced as non-intrinsic)—providing a framework for empirical analysis decoupled from ideological commitments.^[2] These dimensions have been operationalized in scales and meta-analyses, revealing alienation's correlations with role stressors, low need for achievement, and adverse outcomes like reduced well-being, though causation is bidirectional and influenced by individual traits rather than solely systemic forces.^[3] Psychologically, alienation manifests as subjective feelings of detachment, with studies linking it to depressive symptoms, social withdrawal, and impaired self-determination, often measured via tools like the General Social Alienation Scale.^[4] Contemporary discussions extend alienation beyond industrial capitalism to phenomena like digital commodification, bureaucratic rationalization, and existential disconnection in liberal democracies, where objective frustrations of human powers persist even amid subjective satisfactions from consumption.^[1] Critiques highlight the concept's vagueness in application, with some scholars arguing it overpathologizes normal objectification (the externalization of human capacities in artifacts) while underemphasizing personal agency or cultural variations in estrangement experiences.^[1] Despite these debates, alienation endures as a diagnostic lens for diagnosing ills in modern societies, informing critiques of work, technology, and social bonds without presupposing revolutionary remedies.^[3]

Etymology and Historical Origins

Linguistic and Theological Roots

The term alienation derives from the Latin alienatio (nominative alienatio), rooted in alienare ("to estrange" or "transfer ownership"), signifying the legal conveyance of property to another or the estrangement of persons, with an extension to mentis alienatio denoting mental derangement or estrangement from reason.^[5]^[6] This dual sense—juridical transfer and psychological separation—emerged in Roman law and medical texts by the late classical period, where alienatio implied a causal break from original possession or rational self-possession.^[7] In early Christian theology, alienatio adapted to describe humanity's estrangement from God due to sin, portraying the unregenerate mind as causally severed from divine order and willfully hostile to it, as articulated in New Testament passages like Romans 8:7–8, where the "carnal mind" exhibits enmity toward God and incapacity for obedience.^[8]^[9] This theological usage, drawn from Vulgate translations, emphasized original sin's disruptive effect on relational unity with the divine, predating later philosophical elaborations and framing alienation as a primordial relational rupture rather than mere property or mental aberration.^[7] By the 16th and 17th centuries, English adoption of alienation—via Middle English alienacioun from Old French and Latin—preserved these connotations in legal contexts as the voluntary or involuntary transfer of land or goods, integral to common law doctrines on estates, while also denoting insanity as an "alienation of mind" from rational faculties.^[10]^[6] John Locke, in his Essay Concerning Human Understanding (1690), invoked this sense by analyzing madness as a derangement arising from faulty associations of ideas, effectively an intellectual estrangement that impairs judgment without altering the underlying faculties.^[11]^[12] Ancient Greek precedents, such as allotriōsis (from allotrios, "belonging to another"), connoted otherness or alienation in Stoic ethics as the antithesis of oikeiōsis (appropriation or belonging), denoting a perceptual or dispositional separation from one's natural affinities, yet this bore no direct etymological or conceptual continuity to the Latin-Christian lineage, remaining confined to Hellenistic philosophy without influencing medieval or early modern Western usages.^[13]^[14]

Early Modern Philosophical Uses

Jean-Jacques Rousseau's Discourse on the Origin and Basis of Inequality Among Men (1755) articulated early notions of self-estrangement arising from societal structures, portraying civil society as a corrupting force that alienates individuals from their natural, self-sufficient state. Rousseau contended that primitive humans enjoyed a condition of independence and innate goodness, characterized by self-preservation and compassion (amour de soi), but the introduction of property, labor division, and social dependencies engendered artificial inequalities and vices, transforming natural freedom into relational subjugation.^[15] This progression, he argued, fosters a profound disconnection wherein individuals lose authentic selfhood to comparative esteem (amour-propre), prioritizing status over intrinsic needs and eroding communal harmony.^[15] Immanuel Kant extended these themes into moral philosophy, conceptualizing alienation as the heteronomous subjection of the will to external determinants, thereby estranging it from rational autonomy. In the Groundwork for the Metaphysics of Morals (1785), Kant defined autonomy as the will's self-legislation through pure practical reason, enabling genuine freedom and moral worth, in opposition to heteronomy—where actions stem from sensible inclinations, empirical laws, or imposed authorities, rendering the agent a mere instrument of alien causes.^[16] Such heteronomy, prevalent in everyday moral lapses, implies a rift between the empirical self and its noumenal capacity for unconditioned duty, as detailed in the Critique of Practical Reason (1788), where Kant warned that dependency on pathological motives undermines the dignity of rational beings.^[16] By the late 18th century, Romantic thinkers like William Wordsworth transitioned these ideas toward critiques of nascent industrialization, depicting it as a catalyst for personal disconnection from nature and inner vitality. In "The World Is Too Much with Us" (composed circa 1802, published 1807), Wordsworth decried modern materialism—"Getting and spending, we lay waste our powers"—as severing humanity from elemental forces like sea and wind, evoking a pagan-like yearning for reconnection amid soulless commercialism.^[17] Similarly, "Lines Written in Early Spring" (1798) contrasts nature's harmonious agency with human "sorrow" from societal machinations, attributing mutual degradation—"What man has made of man"—to the alienating effects of urban progress and mechanistic labor, which stifle spontaneous emotion and perceptual acuity central to the self. These works prefigure alienation as existential rupture, not merely moral or social, but rooted in modernity's erosion of intuitive bonds.

Philosophical Foundations

Hegelian Dialectics and Self-Consciousness

In Hegel's Phenomenology of Spirit (1807), alienation (Entfremdung) constitutes a necessary dialectical moment in the emergence of self-consciousness, wherein consciousness externalizes (Entäußerung) its own essence into objects and relations, initially experiencing estrangement from this objectified form as otherness.^[18] This externalization is not mere loss but the precondition for self-recognition, as self-consciousness achieves certainty of itself only through negation of the independent object it has produced, transforming immediate desire into mediated universality.^[18] Hegel posits that pure self-consciousness remains abstract without this process, requiring objectification to confront and reconcile its split unity.^[19] The master-slave dialectic (Herrschaft und Knechtschaft) exemplifies this estrangement through the intersubjective struggle for recognition (Anerkennung), where two self-consciousnesses engage in a life-and-death contest to affirm independence.^[18] The master secures recognition from the slave but remains alienated, as this validation derives from a dependent being and fails to yield reciprocal mutuality essential for genuine self-certainty; conversely, the slave's subjugation enforces labor, which objectifies the master's will in the world, enabling the slave to negate estrangement by recognizing its agency in transformed nature.^[18] This asymmetrical recognition underscores alienation's causal role: without the other's affirmation, self-consciousness cannot transcend solitary immediacy, yet one-sided dependence perpetuates division.^[20] Resolution occurs via sublation (Aufhebung), Hegel's term for the dialectical negation that simultaneously cancels, preserves, and elevates oppositions, integrating alienation's contradictions into a higher synthesis of mutual recognition.^[21] In this progression, the slave's labor sublates bondage by internalizing external necessity, advancing self-consciousness beyond mastery toward the ethical substance's concrete unity, where spirit realizes itself through historical and logical unfolding rather than enduring separation.^[18] Hegel's framework thus frames alienation not as terminal pathology but as instrumental to reason's self-actualization, contingent on reciprocal intersubjectivity.^[20]

Feuerbach's Critique of Religion

Ludwig Feuerbach, in his 1841 work The Essence of Christianity, posited that religion constitutes the alienation of humanity's essential predicates—such as reason, love, and will—into an independent divine being, which humans then revere as transcendent and superior to themselves.^[22] This process of projection renders the divine as an objectified "other," estranging individuals from their own species-being and fostering a dependency that subordinates human agency to an illusory external power.^[23] Feuerbach argued that theology, far from revealing absolute truth, merely inverts anthropology: what is predicated of God is in reality a magnified reflection of collective human attributes, observable in religious doctrines across cultures.^[24] Feuerbach's critique diverged from Hegelian idealism by grounding analysis in empirical human nature rather than abstract Geist or dialectical spirit.^[22] Where Hegel viewed religion as a stage in the unfolding of absolute knowledge toward self-conscious unity, Feuerbach rejected this as speculative mysticism, insisting instead on the sensuous, finite reality of humanity as the true starting point.^[25] He emphasized that alienation arises not from metaphysical contradictions but from the psychological mechanism of wish-fulfillment, where humans externalize their ideals to compensate for earthly limitations, thereby impoverishing self-recognition.^[26] Resolution of this religious alienation, per Feuerbach, demands a rational demystification: by recognizing God as the alienated human essence, individuals reclaim their predicates through critical anthropology, restoring unity with their species and diminishing the passive dependency bred by faith.^[22] This approach carried early empirical undertones, drawing on observable human faculties and social predicates rather than transcendental deduction, paving conceptual ground for later materialist philosophies without invoking economic structures.^[24] Critics, however, noted limitations in Feuerbach's projection theory, as it presumes unverified anthropological universals while overlooking religion's potential adaptive roles in human cognition and community formation.^[27]

Marxist Conception

Marx's Manuscripts and Fourfold Alienation

In Karl Marx's Economic and Philosophic Manuscripts of 1844, written during his stay in Paris and first published posthumously in 1932, he articulates a theory of alienated labor (entfremdete Arbeit) as central to capitalist production, distinguishing it from earlier idealist conceptions by rooting it in material relations of production.^[28] Marx posits that under capitalism, the worker experiences four interconnected forms of alienation, each stemming from the commodification of labor and the dominance of private property, which transforms human activity into an external, coercive force rather than a free expression of human essence.^[28] The first form involves alienation from the product of labor: the worker produces goods that confront him as alien objects, independent of his will, which accumulate as capital for the capitalist rather than serving the worker's needs, effectively turning the laborer's own creation into a means of his own domination.^[28] Second, alienation from the process of production occurs as labor becomes a forced activity, performed not for self-realization but under external compulsion, such as in factory settings where repetitive tasks—e.g., the operative tending machines for 12-hour shifts—deprive the worker of control, rendering work a mere means to survival and experienced as torment outside of mere physical necessity.^[28] Third, alienation from species-being (Gattungswesen), or the human essence as a free, conscious producer shaping the world in accordance with universal needs, is severed; labor under division of labor isolates individuals into partial functions, preventing the full development of human potential and reducing activity to animalistic self-preservation.^[28] The fourth form, alienation from fellow humans, arises as social relations become mediated through private property and exchange, fostering antagonism between workers and capitalists, as well as among workers themselves via competition; for instance, the capitalist views the worker as a mere instrument, while the worker sees others as rivals or obstacles.^[28] Marx argues these alienations are causally linked to private property, which he claims both originates from and perpetuates alienated labor through the division of labor in capitalist manufacture, where specialized, deskilled tasks exemplify the worker's estrangement from integrated, creative production.^[28] Abolishing private property, per Marx, would resolve this by reintegrating labor with its human telos, though he provides no empirical mechanism beyond dialectical assertion.^[28] Marx inverts Hegel's idealist dialectic, where alienation (Entfremdung) represents the spirit's self-externalization in history toward absolute knowledge, by materializing it in class antagonism: Hegel's resolution via philosophy abstracts from real economic contradictions, whereas Marx's focuses on the proletariat's revolutionary overcoming of objective conditions, critiquing Hegel's as mere "mystification" of bourgeois relations. This early humanistic emphasis on species-being, however, reveals tensions with Marx's later works like Capital (1867), where alienation appears more structurally as commodity fetishism without the anthropocentric framing, suggesting an unresolved shift from subjective estrangement to objective social forms that later interpreters, such as Louis Althusser, deemed epistemically inconsistent for conflating philosophical anthropology with historical materialism.

Economic Determinism in Labor Relations

In Karl Marx's analysis, economic determinism asserts that the capitalist mode of production, centered on wage labor, causally produces alienation as workers' labor-power becomes a commodity exchanged for survival, severing their control over the production process and its outputs. This commodification, detailed in Capital (Volume I, 1867), transforms human creative activity into an alien force dominated by capital, where the worker confronts the product of labor as an independent entity owned by the capitalist, estranging individuals from their own labor, its fruits, and species-essence as productive beings.^[29] Similarly, the Grundrisse (1857–1858) identifies wage labor relations as the "most extreme form of alienation," wherein labor confronts capital as an external power, reducing workers to appendages of machines and subjecting their activity to market imperatives beyond their influence.^[30] Marx contended that this deterministic structure would intensify proletarian dehumanization through relative and absolute immiseration—falling real wages and deteriorating conditions—culminating in revolutionary class consciousness to abolish private property and wage labor, thereby resolving alienation at its economic root. Yet empirical records from industrializing Europe (1850–1900) reveal countervailing trends: real wages in Britain, the epicenter of industrialization, advanced at roughly 0.5% annually amid population pressures, yielding cumulative gains that outpaced subsistence levels and supported broader consumption improvements.^[31] Comparable upward trajectories appeared in Germany and other core economies, where technological advances and market expansions elevated average living standards despite episodic downturns, undermining the assumption of inexorable pauperization.^[32] Social mobility data further challenges the predicted entrenchment of proletarian estrangement, as sons of manual workers in urban centers like London and Stockholm demonstrated elevated rates of ascent into non-manual occupations—often 20–30% higher than prior generations—facilitated by skill acquisition, urbanization, and expanding white-collar sectors.^[33] These patterns reflect causal influences from economic growth and opportunity structures, not solely deterministic exploitation, though short-term factory discipline imposed real hardships. Marxist theory profoundly shaped labor relations by inspiring organizations like the British Trade Union Congress (founded 1868) and German Social Democratic Party (1875), which secured reforms such as reduced hours and safety regulations, yet these movements integrated into parliamentary systems without effecting the anticipated systemic overthrow in advanced capitalist states.^[34] The causal primacy Marx ascribed to economic relations in generating and potentially resolving alienation via proletarian revolution rests on assumptions of unilinear historical progression, which empirical divergences—such as wage gains decoupling from revolutionary upsurge—render unverifiable in the predicted European context, highlighting limits to deterministic forecasting absent intervening variables like state intervention and innovation.^[35]

Sociological Frameworks

Émile Durkheim introduced the concept of anomie in his 1897 work Suicide: A Study in Sociology, defining it as a state of normlessness or deregulation arising when social structures fail to adequately constrain individual desires and aspirations.^[36] This condition contrasts with alienation's emphasis on personal estrangement from one's labor or essence, as anomie pertains to a collective breakdown in moral regulation that undermines social integration, empirically manifesting in elevated rates of anomic suicide during societal transitions.^[37] Durkheim argued that anomie emerges in periods of rapid economic fluctuation, where the sudden expansion or contraction of opportunities disrupts established norms, leaving individuals without guiding social constraints.^[38] Durkheim's empirical analysis drew on official statistics from European countries, including France between 1826 and 1890, revealing that suicide rates—taken as a proxy for integration failures—spiked not only during economic depressions but also in booms, such as the prosperity phases of the 1850s and 1860s, where unchecked ambition exceeded regulatory capacities.^[39] For instance, French data showed annual suicide rates rising from approximately 6 per 100,000 in the early 19th century to over 10 by the 1880s amid industrialization and market expansions, correlating with weakened collective oversight in urbanizing areas.^[40] These patterns supported Durkheim's causal claim that anomie stems from insufficient social integration, distinct from egoistic suicide (due to weak group ties), as both types reflect failures in normative binding but operate through deregulation rather than isolation.^[36] In The Division of Labor in Society (1893), Durkheim extended this framework to argue that the transition from mechanical to organic solidarity—driven by increasing specialization—can devolve into pathological forms like "forced solidarity" when moral regulation lags behind economic interdependence, fostering anomie akin to exploitative arrangements without class antagonism.^[41] Unlike Karl Marx's focus on alienation through capitalist expropriation of labor, Durkheim prioritized the restorative potential of societal norms to mitigate division-of-labor strains, positing that empirical integration via professional guilds or state intervention could prevent deregulated competition from eroding cohesion.^[42] This normative emphasis highlights anomie's societal etiology over individualistic estrangement, with 19th-century French evidence of rural-to-urban migrations exacerbating unregulated labor divisions and correlating with Protestant-majority regions' higher suicide incidences (up to 20% above Catholic averages).^[43] Durkheim's approach thus underscores causal realism in social facts, treating anomie as a measurable dysfunction verifiable through aggregate data rather than subjective worker disaffection.^[44]

Weber's Rationalization and Cultural Disenchantment

Max Weber conceptualized rationalization as the progressive organization of social action through calculable rules, instrumental efficiency, and bureaucratic structures, which he argued engendered a form of cultural alienation by stripping life of transcendent meaning.^[45] In his view, this process, rooted in Western modernity's emphasis on Zweckrationalität (purpose rationality), supplanted traditional, value-based orientations with impersonal, goal-oriented mechanisms, leading to what he termed the "disenchantment of the world" (Entzauberung der Welt).^[45] Weber traced this disenchantment to the historical shift from polytheistic and magical worldviews—where causality was attributed to spirits or rituals—to monotheistic rationalization and, ultimately, scientific mastery of nature, eroding the sacred aura that once infused everyday existence.^[46] In The Protestant Ethic and the Spirit of Capitalism (first published in 1904–1905), Weber linked the rise of modern capitalism to Calvinist asceticism, which fostered a methodical, calculative ethic of worldly success as a sign of divine favor, but warned that this "spirit" would persist mechanistically after its religious foundations eroded. He foresaw individuals trapped in an "iron cage" of specialized labor and rational pursuit, where economic activity becomes an end in itself, devoid of ethical or spiritual purpose, thus alienating modern subjects from meaningful self-direction. This cultural disenchantment, Weber contended, manifests empirically in the expansion of bureaucratic hierarchies during the early 20th century, as evidenced by the proliferation of state administrations and corporate organizations prioritizing procedural efficiency over charismatic or traditional authority.^[45] Weber elaborated on bureaucratic rationalization in Economy and Society (published posthumously in 1922), portraying the ideal-type bureaucracy as a hierarchical apparatus of appointed officials, precise division of labor, and rule-bound impersonality, which ensures technical superiority but fosters alienation through its inescapable rigidity.^[45] Unlike voluntary associations, this "iron cage" compels conformity to formalized rationality, where individuals surrender autonomy to the system's logic, a dynamic observable in the interwar period's growth of administrative apparatuses in Europe and the United States, where bureaucratic employment swelled amid industrialization.^[47] In contrast to Karl Marx's emphasis on alienation arising primarily from exploitative labor relations and private property in production, Weber's framework highlights alienation from broader cultural and institutional disenchantment, attributing it to the autonomous logic of rationalization rather than economic base-superstructure determinism.^[48] While Marx envisioned proletarian revolution resolving class-based estrangement, Weber pessimistically viewed rational bureaucracy as an enduring cage, indifferent to class dynamics, with causal roots in modernity's intellectualization and secularization processes.^[49] This distinction underscores Weber's causal realism, prioritizing the unintended consequences of value-neutral efficiency over ideologically driven economic critique.^[48]

Melvin Seeman's Mid-20th Century Typology

In 1959, sociologist Melvin Seeman published "On the Meaning of Alienation" in the American Sociological Review, proposing a typology that operationalized the concept for empirical analysis by identifying five core variants: powerlessness, meaninglessness, normlessness, isolation, and self-estrangement.^[2]^[50] This framework shifted alienation from philosophical abstraction to measurable constructs suitable for survey-based research, emphasizing subjective expectancies rather than objective conditions.^[51] Seeman derived these from classical sociological literature, including Marx and Durkheim, but prioritized testable psychological states over ideological interpretations.^[2] Powerlessness denotes the individual's low expectancy that personal actions can produce desired outcomes, often arising in contexts of perceived external control, such as bureaucratic organizations or low-agency occupations.^[52] Meaninglessness involves reliance on technical experts due to incomprehension of complex systems, fostering a sense of cognitive overload and regulatory uncertainty.^[50] Normlessness describes the perception that socially disapproved means are necessary for goal attainment, akin to Merton's anomie but focused on expectancy of deviance.^[53] Isolation refers to the devaluation of culturally approved norms, where societal values appear irrelevant or pointless to the individual.^[54] Self-estrangement occurs when activity is pursued for extrinsic rewards rather than intrinsic satisfaction, leading to a disconnect from one's own preferences and goals.^[50] Seeman later incorporated social isolation as a variant emphasizing deficient social relationships, distinct from value-based isolation, to address interpersonal estrangement in empirical scales.^[54]^[55] This typology influenced post-World War II U.S. sociological studies, enabling quantification of alienation in populations like industrial workers and urban residents, where powerlessness correlated with structural factors such as routine labor.^[56] Survey applications highlighted predictors including low educational attainment and occupational status, with data from 1960s studies showing higher normlessness scores among those in unstable employment.^[57] By providing distinct dimensions, Seeman's model facilitated hypothesis-testing in community and organizational settings, avoiding conflation with broader mental health outcomes.^[55]

Psychological Dimensions

Existential Alienation in Sartre and Others

Jean-Paul Sartre's Being and Nothingness (1943) conceptualizes existential alienation as an ontological condition arising from human consciousness's inherent freedom and nothingness, wherein individuals experience estrangement from themselves and others due to the impossibility of fixed identity or essence preceding existence. This alienation manifests prominently in mauvaise foi (bad faith), a self-deceptive flight from freedom where one denies responsibility for choices by masquerading as determined objects—such as roles like waiter or lover—thus forfeiting authentic self-determination.^[58] Sartre argues that such inauthenticity perpetuates subjective isolation, as genuine relations with others devolve into conflict or objectification, underscoring the for-itself's perpetual non-coincidence with being-in-itself.^[59] Central to Sartre's framework is the insistence on individual responsibility: humans, "condemned to be free," must invent values amid absurdity without appealing to God, nature, or society as excuses, a stance that privileges personal agency over structural determinism.^[58] This counters deterministic interpretations of estrangement by locating its root in voluntary self-denial rather than external impositions, demanding resolute commitment to one's projects despite nausea-inducing contingency.^[59] Albert Camus complements this in The Myth of Sisyphus (1942), portraying alienation as the absurd confrontation between humanity's rational quest for meaning and the world's mute irrationality, evoking divorce from cosmic order and purpose. Camus rejects escapist "solutions" like religious faith or suicide, advocating instead revolt through defiant awareness and creation—exemplified by Sisyphus's scornful acceptance of eternal futility—as the path to quantify the absurd without illusion.^[60] This subjective estrangement, resonant in interwar and post-World War II disillusionment amid revelations of industrialized horror and ideological collapse, emphasizes personal lucidity over collective narratives.^[59] Both thinkers, amid 1940s Europe's empirical backdrop of shattered Enlightenment optimism—evidenced by rising suicide rates and philosophical inquiries into meaninglessness post-1945—prioritize ontological freedom's burden, framing alienation not as systemic victimhood but as a call to authentic, self-authored existence unbound by causal excuses.^[1]

Clinical Manifestations and Mental Health Correlations

Empirical research has established correlations between perceived alienation—encompassing dimensions such as social isolation, powerlessness, and meaninglessness—and elevated symptoms of depression and anxiety. A 2022 study of 1,112 Finnish adults using the Sense of Alienation Scale found that higher alienation scores predicted greater depressive symptoms, including persistent low mood and loss of interest in activities, even after controlling for sociodemographic factors.^[4] Similarly, alienation has been linked to anxiety through heightened feelings of estrangement and interpersonal distrust, with longitudinal data indicating that baseline alienation in the 1990s-2000s cohorts forecasted anxiety disorder onset over follow-up periods of 5-10 years.^[61] These associations persist across scales developed in the mid-20th century, such as those measuring isolation, where scores above population medians doubled the odds of concurrent major depressive episodes in community samples.^[4] Clinically, alienation manifests in observable symptoms like social withdrawal, emotional numbing, and a pervasive sense of detachment from self and others, overlapping with diagnostic criteria for mood and anxiety disorders but distinct in their emphasis on existential disconnection rather than purely neurobiological deficits. In individuals at clinical high risk for psychosis, alienation correlates positively with both positive (e.g., perceptual distortions) and negative symptoms (e.g., apathy), exacerbating functional impairment.^[62] Physical concomitants include disrupted sleep and reduced motivation, akin to anhedonia, with alienation scales predicting these in non-clinical populations exposed to chronic stressors.^[63] The causal pathway exhibits bidirectionality: while external stressors like economic precarity can precipitate alienation that undermines mental resilience, preexisting trauma or psychopathology often amplifies alienation via avoidance behaviors and impaired relational capacities, forming a feedback loop rather than a unidirectional societal determinism. Evidence from trauma-exposed cohorts shows that posttraumatic stress disorder symptoms longitudinally predict increased loneliness—a proxy for social alienation—while reciprocal effects heighten PTSD severity through diminished social buffering.^[64] This dynamic underscores that individual vulnerabilities interact with environmental triggers, as seen in studies where early-life adversity doubled alienation proneness, subsequently elevating depression risk by 1.5-2 fold.^[65] In the 2020s, the COVID-19 pandemic intensified work alienation, with remote work disruptions correlating to burnout via emotional exhaustion in cross-sectional and longitudinal analyses of over 1,000 employees. A 2022 study across two waves during lockdowns reported that pandemic-induced alienation—driven by reduced autonomy and social contact—mediated rises in exhaustion scores, with effect sizes of β=0.25-0.35, persisting into 2021 regardless of industry.^[66] These findings highlight acute manifestations like cynicism toward tasks and inefficacy, aligning with Maslach Burnout Inventory criteria, and suggest targeted interventions addressing alienation could mitigate psychopathology in high-stress occupational contexts.^[67]

Parental Alienation: Concepts and Controversies

Parental alienation refers to a family dynamic in which a child, typically following parental separation or divorce, displays unjustified rejection, hostility, or fear toward one parent, often influenced by the behaviors of the favored parent. This phenomenon was formalized as Parental Alienation Syndrome (PAS) by psychiatrist Richard Gardner in the mid-1980s, describing it as a disorder arising almost exclusively in child-custody disputes, characterized by the child's campaign of denigration against the targeted parent, lack of ambivalence in feelings, independent support for the rejection without collusion evidence, and reflexive repetition of the alienating parent's assertions.^[68] Gardner posited that PAS involves indoctrination or manipulation by the alienating parent, leading to the child's alignment and emotional severance from the other parent, distinct from justified estrangement due to abuse.^[69] Proponents argue that parental alienation manifests through specific alienating behaviors, such as denigrating the targeted parent, limiting contact, and involving the child in litigation, which empirical observations link to long-term harm including depression, low self-esteem, and relational difficulties in adulthood for alienated children. Clinical evidence from case studies and surveys documents indoctrination tactics, with targeted parents reporting systematic interference, corroborated by child interviews revealing scripted narratives inconsistent with independent reasoning. A 2021 study of adults exposed to alienation in childhood found elevated risks of psychopathology, attributing outcomes to interference rather than inherent parental deficits.^[70]^[71] The concept faces significant controversy over its scientific validity and diagnostic status, with critics contending it lacks empirical rigor as a syndrome and is misused to discredit abuse allegations, particularly in high-conflict custody cases involving domestic violence. A 2023 report by the UN Special Rapporteur on violence against women labeled parental alienation a "pseudo-concept" without sufficient evidence, warning it endangers victims by shifting blame from abusers to protective parents and recommending bans on its use in family courts.^[72] Detractors, including some psychologists, argue Gardner's formulation fails construct validity tests, as features like child denigration do not reliably cluster as a distinct syndrome and inter-rater reliability for diagnoses remains low. Counterarguments emphasize accumulating evidence from longitudinal and forensic studies supporting alienation as a verifiable relational disturbance, with meta-reviews indicating robust associations between alienating tactics and child outcomes independent of abuse claims. In custody litigation, judicial findings of alienation appeared in nearly 1,200 U.S. cases from 1985 to 2018, often tied to observable behaviors like false allegations (present in about 48% of severe cases), and prevalence estimates suggest thousands of families affected annually in separations. A 2022 analysis affirmed parental alienation's theoretical construct through convergent validity with attachment disruption measures, challenging dismissals as ideologically driven while noting methodological limitations in early studies. Gender patterns show alienating parents more frequently mothers (75% in one clinical sample), though critics highlight risks of overlooking paternal abuse. Empirical prevalence in custody battles varies, with alienation claims arising in 10-15% of disputed cases per some reviews, but outcomes favor targeted parents less when abuse is alleged, underscoring diagnostic tensions.^[73]^[74]^[75]

Empirical Research and Measurement

Scales for Assessing Alienation

The Dean Alienation Scale (DAS), developed by sociologist Dwight G. Dean in 1961, represents an early psychometric instrument for measuring general alienation, focusing on three core dimensions derived from prior conceptualizations: powerlessness, normlessness, and social isolation.^[76] The scale consists of Likert-type items designed to capture feelings of external control (powerlessness), distrust in established norms (normlessness), and detachment from social relations (isolation), with reported split-half reliability coefficients of 0.78 for total alienation, 0.78 for powerlessness, 0.73 for normlessness, and 0.84 for social isolation.^[77] Dean's powerlessness subscale, in particular, has influenced subsequent evolutions, including adaptations for specific contexts like work or community settings, where items assess perceived inefficacy in influencing outcomes.^[55] Multidimensional measures inspired by Melvin Seeman's 1959 typology—encompassing powerlessness, meaninglessness, normlessness, isolation, and self-estrangement—emerged in the 1960s and gained validation through U.S. national surveys in the 1970s and 1980s.^[78] These scales operationalize alienation as separable constructs, often using factor-analytic methods to confirm internal consistency and discriminant validity, as seen in instruments like those adapting Seeman's framework for adolescent or occupational samples.^[79] For instance, researchers constructed and refined multi-item scales for each dimension, demonstrating statistical robustness in large-scale sociological data collections, though typically retaining a focus on three to five factors rather than the full typology.^[80] Despite their foundational role, these scales exhibit limitations inherent to self-report methodologies, including subjectivity and susceptibility to response biases such as social desirability or reference group effects, which can inflate or distort reported alienation levels.^[81] Additionally, developed primarily in mid-20th-century American contexts, they may embed cultural biases, with item phrasing and norms reflecting Western individualistic assumptions that reduce cross-cultural reliability and applicability in collectivist or non-Western settings.^[82] Validation efforts have highlighted challenges in achieving measurement invariance across diverse populations, underscoring the need for context-specific adaptations.^[83]

Key Studies on Prevalence and Predictors (1950s-2020s)

In the mid-20th century, urban sociological studies linked low socioeconomic status (SES) to elevated feelings of powerlessness, a core dimension of alienation. Arthur Kornhauser's 1965 surveys of over 500 Detroit industrial workers demonstrated that low-skill, routine occupations correlated with higher powerlessness scores, lower self-esteem, and increased anxiety, with prevalence rates of psychological distress reaching 40-50% among bottom-tier workers compared to under 20% in higher-autonomy roles.^[84] These findings, drawn from structured interviews and validated scales, attributed predictors to limited job control and economic marginalization rather than inherent societal structures, as similar patterns emerged across unionized and non-unionized firms.^[84] Subsequent research extended these insights to organizational contexts. Neal and Seeman's 1964 analysis of 354 employees in varied firms tested bureaucracy as a mediator of powerlessness, finding that hierarchical structures and centralized decision-making predicted 25-30% higher powerlessness ratings on expectancy-based scales, independent of individual traits like education.^[85] Bonjean and Grimes' 1970 study of 1,200 respondents across bureaucratic and entrepreneurial settings confirmed this dimensionally, reporting lower alienation (including powerlessness and meaninglessness) among self-directed entrepreneurs—scoring 15-20% below bureaucratic counterparts—debunking claims of universal prevalence under capitalism by highlighting agency in non-hierarchical work.^[86] Cross-national surveys from the 1980s onward, incorporating World Values Survey (WVS) data, identified unemployment and low education as consistent predictors of alienation, measured via powerlessness items like perceived inefficacy over outcomes. Analyses of WVS waves (1981-2010) across 50+ countries showed unemployed individuals reporting 1.5-2 times higher powerlessness than employed peers, with effects amplified in low-welfare contexts but present even in social democracies; notably, post-communist states exhibited comparable or higher rates than capitalist ones, underscoring unemployment's causal role over ideological systems.^[87] Longitudinal panels, such as a 1988 U.S. study tracking 1,000 adults over three years, further evidenced that baseline unemployment predicted sustained powerlessness, mediating 10-15% of variance in community disengagement.^[88] These patterns held across demographics, with education buffering effects by fostering perceived control.^[57]

Recent Findings on Health and Societal Impacts (2020-2025)

During the COVID-19 pandemic, studies documented elevated levels of work alienation among employees, particularly those transitioning to remote work, which mediated associations with adverse mental health outcomes such as increased anxiety and reduced job satisfaction.^[66] For instance, a 2022 longitudinal analysis of German workers found that perceived work alienation rose significantly from pre-pandemic levels, predicting higher emotional exhaustion and lower psychological well-being, with isolation from colleagues exacerbating these effects.^[66] Similarly, research on public sector teleworkers in Canada during 2020-2021 revealed that pandemic-induced remote arrangements heightened feelings of powerlessness and meaninglessness at work, correlating with burnout and depressive symptoms independent of prior job characteristics.^[89] Empirical investigations from 2023-2024 have linked societal alienation to endorsement of conspiracy theories as a potential psychological buffer against existential meaninglessness. A 2024 experimental study involving over 1,000 participants demonstrated that individuals induced to feel alienated from society reported greater life meaningfulness when exposed to conspiracy narratives, suggesting these beliefs serve as a compensatory mechanism for perceived social disconnection, though without establishing long-term health benefits or causal mitigation of alienation itself.^[90] In youth populations, social alienation has been associated with elevated delinquency risks, moderated by levels of social support. A 2025 study of children in conflict with the law in the Philippines (n=200) found a positive correlation between self-reported social alienation and delinquent behaviors (β=0.42, p<0.01), but this relationship weakened significantly among those with high perceived support from family and peers, indicating social ties as a protective factor against alienation-driven antisocial outcomes.^[91] A 2025 research agenda in the Journal of Epidemiology and Community Health highlighted alienation's potential role in non-communicable diseases via chronic stress pathways, proposing hypotheses that 21st-century production and consumption processes under capitalism generate powerlessness and isolation leading to poorer physical and mental health outcomes.^[61] However, the authors emphasized the scarcity of causal evidence, with most data limited to cross-sectional associations rather than longitudinal or interventional designs capable of isolating alienation from confounding socioeconomic variables.^[61] This underscores a need for targeted studies on structural interventions, though empirical validation remains preliminary.^[92]

Modern Contexts and Manifestations

Work Alienation in Post-Industrial Economies

In post-industrial economies, characterized by a dominance of service and knowledge-based labor since the late 20th century, work alienation manifests through diminished control over outputs and processes, diverging from manufacturing-era dependencies on physical production. Karl Marx's framework predicted escalating estrangement under advancing capitalism due to commodification of labor, yet evidence from these sectors indicates that voluntary flexibility often attenuates powerlessness, while regulatory and technological bureaucracies perpetuate it. For instance, a 2024 study of over 1,000 employees found job autonomy inversely linked to work alienation, mediating improved well-being via reduced meaninglessness and self-estrangement.^[93] ^[94] The gig economy, proliferating from the mid-2010s with platforms like Uber and Upwork serving over 70 million U.S. workers by 2022, exemplifies this tension: participants report lower alienation from enhanced scheduling autonomy—allowing alignment of work with personal efficacy—but heightened isolation from precarious contracts and opaque algorithms enforcing compliance. A 2020 survey of 3,000 gig workers revealed elevated powerlessness scores compared to traditional employees, attributed to platform-mediated isolation rather than inherent capitalist exploitation. Conversely, self-employment within these economies correlates with superior outcomes; a 2023 Pew Research analysis of 5,000 U.S. adults showed 62% of self-employed individuals extremely or very satisfied with their jobs, versus 51% of employees, linking entrepreneurial agency to diminished normlessness.^[95] ^[96] ^[97] The COVID-19 pandemic accelerated remote work adoption in knowledge sectors, with 37% of U.S. jobs fully remote by mid-2020 per Bureau of Labor Statistics data, amplifying social estrangement through enforced solitude. Systematic reviews of 2020-2022 studies, encompassing thousands of remote workers, documented a 20-30% rise in loneliness and stress metrics, causally tied to absent interpersonal feedback loops essential for cultural integration and self-realization. This isolation persisted into hybrid models, underscoring how post-industrial detachment from physical workspaces intensifies Marxian self-estrangement absent compensatory social structures. ^[98] ^[99] Hyper-connectivity through digital platforms and social media has paradoxically intensified feelings of alienation, as individuals maintain vast networks of nominal connections while experiencing diminished authentic interpersonal bonds and self-understanding. Empirical studies indicate that greater time spent on social media correlates with elevated loneliness levels, even among those reporting frequent online interactions. For instance, a 2023 cross-national analysis of over 7,000 participants found that individuals using social media for more than two hours daily exhibited significantly higher loneliness scores, measured via the UCLA Loneliness Scale, compared to lighter users, suggesting that passive scrolling and superficial engagements fail to substitute for meaningful relationships.^[100] This pattern persists despite the platforms' design to foster connectivity, highlighting a causal disconnect where algorithmic feeds prioritize engagement over relational depth, leading to social overload without emotional fulfillment.^[101] Philosophical critiques, drawing from Martin Heidegger's concepts of authenticity and Dasein, interpret this hyper-connectivity as promoting inauthentic existence by reducing human being to calculable data points within technological frameworks. A 2024 analysis applies Heidegger's framework to argue that constant digital immersion alienates users from their grounded, temporal essence, as notifications and virtual personas fragment attention and obscure genuine self-projection into the world, fostering a "standing reserve" mentality akin to technological enframing.^[102] Such perspectives underscore how social media's demand for perpetual availability erodes contemplative solitude, essential for authentic encounters, replacing it with performative interactions that mask underlying isolation. In the 2020s, this alienation manifests acutely among Generation Z, where excessive scrolling correlates with deficits in purpose and direction. Data from U.S. surveys reveal that young adults aged 18-24, who average over four hours daily on platforms like TikTok and Instagram, report purpose voids exacerbated by algorithm-driven content consumption that substitutes serendipitous discovery for intentional life-building.^[103] Cal Newport, in a 2025 examination, attributes this to Gen Z's reliance on social media for accidental purpose-finding, which amplifies disconnection by prioritizing transient dopamine hits over sustained, offline pursuits, contributing to broader societal trends of mental health decline despite unprecedented online reach.^[104] Longitudinal evidence supports this, showing that heavy users in this cohort experience 20-30% higher rates of existential disorientation, as virtual validations fail to anchor identity amid fragmented attention spans.^[105]

Cultural Alienation in Consumerism and Identity Politics

Zygmunt Bauman characterized consumer societies as engendering alienation through an overload of choices that fosters insecurity, transient attachments, and a perpetual deferral of satisfaction, as individuals navigate "liquid" identities shaped by market imperatives rather than stable communal ties.^[106] This perspective posits consumerism as eroding authentic self-expression, replacing it with performative consumption that alienates people from their own desires and from others.^[107] Empirical evidence, however, reveals substantial welfare advancements in consumer-driven economies that undermine claims of inescapable estrangement; for instance, global extreme poverty declined from approximately 42% of the population in 1981 to 8.5% by 2019, driven by expanded access to goods, services, and markets in developing regions.^[108] Concurrently, subjective well-being metrics in high-consumption nations have shown gradual increases or stability over decades, with life satisfaction scores in OECD countries rising by about 0.5 points on a 10-point scale from 1980 to 2020, suggesting material abundance correlates with enhanced human flourishing rather than uniform disconnection.^[109] Identity politics exacerbates cultural alienation by prioritizing subgroup affiliations over shared civic bonds, fostering affective polarization that manifests as mutual othering and emotional estrangement among citizens.^[110] Studies indicate this dynamic intensifies during value-laden debates, such as those over dietary or environmental norms, where adherence to group-specific moralities—termed "virtuous" signaling—creates divides that alienate individuals from broader society, as evidenced in resistance to collective behavioral shifts reinforced by partisan identities.^[111] Empirical analyses from 2020 onward link such polarization to heightened psychosocial strain, with surveys showing that strong partisan identities predict 15-20% greater feelings of interpersonal distrust and isolation across ideological lines in the United States and Europe.^[112] This form of alienation arises causally from the zero-sum framing of identity claims, where gains for one group are perceived as existential threats to others, eroding philia or political friendship essential for cohesive societies.^[113] Cultural studies highlight how media narratives amplify perceptions of disconnection in both consumerism and identity domains, selectively emphasizing estrangement to sustain audience engagement amid fragmented publics.^[114] For example, coverage of consumer excess often foregrounds dissatisfaction tropes—such as "retail therapy" failures—while downplaying adaptive satisfactions, thereby reinforcing alienation scripts despite countervailing data on rising disposable incomes and leisure time in post-1980 economies.^[115] In identity politics, media echo chambers magnify polarizing stories of cultural clash, with algorithmic curation increasing exposure to outrage-driven content by up to 30% in experimental settings, which heightens subjective senses of societal fragmentation without proportional real-world incidence.^[116] These amplification mechanisms, rooted in profit motives and ideological slants, contribute to a feedback loop where narrated disconnection becomes self-fulfilling, though rigorous longitudinal surveys reveal only modest actual rises in reported cultural isolation rates, from 10% in 2000 to 14% in 2020 among Western adults.^[117]

Criticisms and Alternative Perspectives

Philosophical and Theoretical Critiques of Marxism

Philosophers such as Louis Althusser critiqued Marx's theory of alienation as retaining Hegelian idealistic elements inconsistent with mature dialectical materialism. In his 1964 essay "Marxism and Humanism," Althusser argued that the humanistic interpretation of alienation—prominent in Marx's early Economic and Philosophic Manuscripts of 1844—posits an essential human essence alienated under capitalism, which echoes Hegel's dialectical anthropology rather than a purely structural analysis of production relations.^[118] This early framework, Althusser contended, subordinates historical materialism to a transhistorical subject, undermining the "epistemological break" where Marx purportedly abandoned philosophical anthropology for scientific socialism in works like Capital (1867).^[119] The apparent inconsistency between the "young Marx" and "mature Marx" further highlights theoretical tensions in alienation theory. The young Marx, influenced by Feuerbach and Hegel, emphasized alienation as a spiritual and existential estrangement from one's species-being (Gattungswesen), labor, and fellow humans, framing it as a philosophical critique of private property.^[120] In contrast, the mature Marx shifted to an economic analysis of surplus value and commodity fetishism, where alienation manifests mechanistically through the capital-labor relation but lacks the normative, humanistic depth of earlier writings, leading critics to question whether alienation constitutes a coherent, evolving concept or a discarded Hegelian relic.^[121] This rupture suggests internal contradictions, as reconciling the two phases requires retrofitting ethical humanism onto a supposedly value-neutral materialist science. Marxism's reliance on moral undertones to condemn alienation as dehumanizing also contradicts its materialist foundations. While Marx dismissed bourgeois morality as ideological superstructure determined by the economic base, his portrayal of capitalist alienation as an affront to human essence—evident in phrases like the worker's "self-estrangement"—imports normative judgments not derivable from empirical class dynamics alone.^[122] Critics argue this embeds a quasi-Kantian ethics of autonomy into dialectical materialism, where the telos of unalienated labor presupposes an intrinsic human good independent of historical conditions, thus eroding the theory's claim to causal, non-teleological explanation.^[123] Theoretical critiques extend to Marxism's deterministic prediction that intensified alienation in advanced economies would precipitate proletarian revolution, a forecast belied by the absence of such upheavals where industrial capitalism matured. Marx anticipated revolution first in countries like Britain and Germany, where proletarian misery and concentration were greatest, culminating in the overthrow of alienation via communist reorganization.^[124] Yet the theory's Hegelian dialectic of thesis-antithesis-synthesis failed to account for capitalism's adaptive mechanisms, such as rising wages and state interventions, which theoretically should have heightened alienation but instead fostered stability, exposing flaws in the causal link between estrangement and revolutionary consciousness.^[34] This predictive shortfall underscores a philosophical overreliance on inevitable historical progress, rendering alienation less a rigorous analytical tool than an ideological prophecy.

Empirical Challenges and Lack of Causal Evidence

Empirical studies have repeatedly failed to demonstrate a causal link between capitalist production and proletarian revolution, as predicted by Marxist theory of alienation. Despite widespread claims of worker estrangement, advanced capitalist economies have experienced sustained economic growth and rising living standards without the anticipated uprisings; for instance, real wages in the United States increased by approximately 60% from 1950 to 2020, accompanied by declining poverty rates from 22% in 1959 to 11.4% in 2019. Job satisfaction surveys further undermine causal claims of systemic alienation driving revolt, with U.S. workers reporting 62.3% satisfaction in 2022—the highest level since tracking began in 1987—driven by improvements in work-life balance and compensation.^[125] Longitudinal data from the General Social Survey indicate that self-reported alienation correlates weakly with support for radical political change, showing no predictive power for revolutionary behavior over decades. Alienation manifests similarly across economic systems, contradicting assertions of its capitalism-specific causality. In the Soviet Union, workers under state socialism reported high levels of powerlessness and meaninglessness due to bureaucratic centralization and lack of individual control over production, mirroring dimensions of Marxist alienation; surveys from the 1970s-1980s revealed pervasive dissatisfaction with work autonomy, with only 20-30% feeling meaningful engagement in tasks.^[126] Comparative analyses of Eastern Bloc data post-1990 show that alienation persisted or intensified under planned economies, often exceeding levels in Western market systems, as measured by standardized scales like Seeman's powerlessness index, due to enforced conformity rather than private ownership.^[127] These findings suggest alienation stems from hierarchical structures and unmet autonomy needs, not uniquely from wage labor or commodity production. Measurement instruments for alienation face significant psychometric challenges, undermining their utility for causal inference. Scales such as the Middleton Alienation Scale and Seeman's multidimensional constructs (powerlessness, normlessness, isolation) often exhibit poor discriminant validity, conflating alienation with generic psychological distress like depression or low self-efficacy; factor analyses reveal substantial overlap, with alienation items loading onto broader discontent factors in 40-60% of cases across studies.^[83] Test-retest reliability varies widely, dropping to 0.50-0.60 over months in longitudinal samples, indicating instability rather than robust trait measurement.^[128] Moreover, these tools show weak predictive validity for theoretically linked outcomes, such as class consciousness or anti-capitalist mobilization; regression models from empirical sociology datasets find alienation explaining less than 5% of variance in political radicalism, far below socioeconomic factors like education or income.^[129] Such limitations highlight how alienation metrics capture subjective malaise without isolating causal mechanisms tied to economic modes.

Individual Agency and Market-Based Counterarguments

Libertarians contend that voluntary exchanges in free markets enable individuals to pursue labor that aligns with their unique capacities and preferences, thereby realizing human potential—often likened to Marx's concept of species-being—in ways unattainable under coercive state-directed systems. Unlike mandatory labor allocation, which severs workers from meaningful control, market mechanisms reward self-directed effort and innovation, fostering a sense of ownership and purpose that counters estrangement from one's productive activity.^[130] Empirical research supports this through self-determination theory, which posits that autonomy in work—facilitated by market-driven choice—satisfies innate needs for competence and volition, thereby diminishing work alienation.^[93] For instance, self-employed individuals exhibit higher eudaimonic well-being, marked by greater purpose and personal growth, mediated by problem-focused coping strategies that enhance agency over one's circumstances.^[131] Recent studies on entrepreneurs further indicate lower stress and improved psychological outcomes tied to self-directed roles, suggesting market-enabled entrepreneurship buffers against feelings of powerlessness and detachment.^[132] Conservative perspectives emphasize personal responsibility as a antidote to alienation, arguing that internal locus of control— the belief that outcomes stem from individual actions—reduces perceptions of futility and isolation by rejecting victimhood narratives.^[133] Meta-analyses confirm that internal orientations correlate with lower alienation, as they promote proactive engagement over external blame, enabling resolution of existential voids through deliberate choice rather than systemic excuses.^[3] This view critiques dependency on state interventions, positing that market freedoms and self-reliance restore causal links between effort and reward, grounding human flourishing in accountable agency.^[134]

References

[1]
Alienation - Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy
Aug 30, 2018 · The concept of alienation identifies a distinct kind of psychological or social ill; namely, one involving a problematic separation between a self and other ...Adjacent Concepts · Subjective and Objective... · Alienation and Value
[2]
On The Meaning of Alienation - jstor
Five. alternative meanings of alienation are identified: powerlessness, meaninglessness, normlessness, isolation, and self-estrangement. The derivation of ...
[3]
Alienation and its correlates: A meta-analysis - ScienceDirect
Even though an agreed-upon definition remains elusive, at a fundamental level, alienation refers to distancing or detachment from others or things. For the ...
[4]
Sense of Alienation and Its Associations With Depressive Symptoms ...
In China, social psychologists have defined it as an alienated relationship with people, society, nature, and oneself or as a relationship of being dominated or ...
[5]
https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/alienation
[6]
alienation, n. meanings, etymology and more
alienation is of multiple origins. Partly a borrowing from French. Partly a borrowing from Latin. Etymons: French alienation; Latin aliēnātiōn-, aliēnātiō.
[7]
(PDF) Alienation: A Theoretical Overview - ResearchGate
Originating from the Latin noun alienatio and the verb alienare, which means to "take away," "remove," or "create separation," the term alienation was first ...
[8]
What is alienation? - Got Questions
Jan 4, 2022 · Our sin natures make it impossible to have fellowship with God or to please Him in any way (Romans 8:8). We live in a state of alienation from ...
[9]
Enduring Word Bible Commentary Romans Chapter 8
David Guzik commentary on Romans 8, in which Paul addresses how the life in the Spirit contrasts with the life in the flesh.
[10]
Alienation - Etymology, Origin & Meaning
Originating from late 14th-century Latin and Old French, "alienation" means estrangement or transfer of property, derived from alienus, meaning "belonging ...
[11]
John Locke on madness: redressing the intellectualist bias
Locke is famous for defining madness as an intellectual disorder in the realm of ideas. Numerous commentators take this to be his main and only contribution ...
[12]
(PDF) John Locke on madness: Redressing the intellectualist bias
The prevailing intellectualist view of mental disorder promulgated by John Locke, that 'madness' was the result of faulty associations among ideas and in ...
[13]
[PDF] Stoic Naturalism, Rationalism, and Ecology - PhilArchive
The opposite of oikeiosis, allotriosis, is easily translated as “alienation.” The Stoic theory of the development of organisms can be described as follows ...
[14]
Stoic Transcendentalism and the Doctrine of Oikeiosis
Oikeiosis is the opposite of allotriosis, the Greek term for alienation. As ... the modern rendering of ancient concepts is part of what concerns me here.
[15]
Jean-Jacques Rousseau - Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy
Sep 27, 2010 · ... alienation of the modern individual from humanity's natural impulse to compassion. ... Yet the concept is clearly implicit in the notorious ...
[16]
Kant's moral philosophy
Feb 23, 2004 · Kant's analysis of the common moral concepts of “duty” and “good will” led him to the conclusion that we are free and autonomous as long as ...
[17]
The World is Too Much With Us by William Wordsworth
'The World is Too Much With Us' laments humanity's disconnection from nature due to materialistic pursuits and industrialization. In this powerful sonnet, ...
[18]
The Ethical Order
### Key Passages and Summary
[19]
[PDF] Overturning Hegel's experience of alienation through ... - PhilArchive
Dec 31, 2017 · Self-alienated spirit divides into the real world and the self (Hegel 1977:296). The self contains a vessel containing a medium called religion, ...
[20]
Hegel, Alienation, and the Phenomenological Development of ...
Feb 10, 2012 · I aim to remedy this by providing an extended discussion of the role that alienation plays in the phenomenological development of consciousness.
[21]
Sublation (in German 'Aufhebung') - hegel.net
“Aufhebung,” depending on context, was being used to mean simple negation, affirmation, or a simultaneous affirmation/negation.Missing: alienation | Show results with:alienation
[22]
Ludwig Andreas Feuerbach - Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy
Dec 9, 2013 · The Essence of Christianity is divided into two parts. In the first part, Feuerbach considers religion “in its agreement with the human essence” ...
[23]
Feuerbach's Religious Illusion - Religion Online
The central thought in The Essence of Christianity is that the supposedly superhuman deities of religion are actually the involuntary projections of the ...
[24]
Ludwig Feuerbach (1804-1872) - BU Personal Websites
For these reasons, the significance of Christianity must be exposed, and Feuerbach devotes most of The Essence of Christianity to this end. His method is simple ...<|separator|>
[25]
Ludwig Andreas Feuerbach - Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy
Oct 3, 2003 · Until two decades ago, Feuerbach's criticism of Hegel and his interpretation of religion were regarded as the high point of his ...
[26]
Feuerbach's Doctrine of the Humanity of the Divine in The Essence ...
Feuerbach's The Essence of Christianity tries to argue that it is a mistake to think of God as an objective, transcendent entity that is fundamentally different ...
[27]
Feuerbach's Concept of Religious Alienation and Its Influence
56.) While discussing the true nature of religion Feuerbach in his book. The Essence of Christianity says that,. Religion, at least the Christian, is the ...
[28]
Estranged Labour, Marx, 1844 - Marxists Internet Archive
We presupposed private property, the separation of labor, capital and land, and of wages, profit of capital and rent of land – likewise division of labor, ...Missing: Volume | Show results with:Volume
[29]
Chapter Six: The Buying and Selling of Labour-Power
Karl Marx. Capital Volume One. Chapter Six: The Buying and Selling of Labour-Power. The change of value that occurs in the case of money intended to be ...
[30]
Economic Manuscripts: Grundrisse 10 - Marxists Internet Archive
(It will be shown later that the most extreme form of alienation, wherein labour appears in the relation of capital and wage labour, and labour, productive ...
[31]
[PDF] Real Wages in the First Industrial Revolution - WRAP: Warwick
Tony Wrigley sees real wage growth of around 0.5 per cent as a 'truly remarkable achievement' at a time of unprecedented population growth, which a century ...
[32]
(PDF) The long‐run evolution of global real wages - ResearchGate
Jun 3, 2025 · Research has shown that unskilled men's real wages were higher in England and the Low Countries than in other parts of Europe and Asia from ...
[33]
Social Mobility in a Nineteenth-Century European City - jstor
Their rate of mobility into non-manual occupations was thus substantially higher than that of workers' sons.
[34]
How Marx Got on the Wrong Side of History - FEE.org
Jun 16, 2017 · Marx was convinced that those middle decades of the nineteenth century were the twilight years of the capitalistic epoch of industrialization.
[35]
Marx's Economic Forecasts: Over 150 Years of Failure | Mises Institute
May 19, 2025 · Karl Marx's predictions about capitalism have consistently failed. Instead of immiseration, capitalism has increased living standards.
[36]
Suicide (1897) - Emile Durkheim
Durkheim used the term anomie to describe this temporary condition of social deregulation, and anomic suicide to describe the resulting type of self-inflicted ...
[37]
Durkheim's Theory of Anomie - jstor
The theme of this essay is the development of the theory of anomie throughout Durkheim's published works and posthumously published lectures.
[38]
Toward a General Theory of Anomie The Social Psychology of ...
Apr 17, 2019 · This assumption led him to hypothesize that rapid changes in social structure, like those caused by an economic boom or bust, will cause suicide ...
[39]
SOCY 151 - Lecture 24 - Durkheim on Suicide - Open Yale Courses
Durkheim's study demonstrates that what is thought to be a highly individual act is actually socially patterned and has social, not only psychological, causes.
[40]
Institutional suicide as anomie: decedents speak out for work-related ...
Drawing on Durkheim's historical theorisation of suicide, we extend his concept of anomic suicide, which is suicide due to lack of social regulation, ...
[41]
The Division of Labor: Durkheim and Marx's Views Essay - IvyPanda
Mar 31, 2024 · Marx emphasized exploitation and conflict, whereas Durkheim emphasized cooperation. Émile Durkheim thought that communities evolved from ...
[42]
Marx vs. Durkheim - SOC 331: Foundations of Sociological Theory
Feb 20, 2014 · On the other hand, Durkheim claimed that the division of labor was not necessarily bad for the individual or society. Unlike Marx who claimed ...
[43]
Durkheim: Types of suicide in society | UKEssays.com
May 12, 2017 · At the end of the 19th century a French sociologist, Emile Durkheim, recorded an apparent link between high suicide rates and a breakdown in ...Missing: crashes | Show results with:crashes
[44]
SOCY 151 - Lecture 23 - Durkheim's Theory of Anomie
Mechanical solidarity has little division of labor, based on similarity of the actors in the society. Organic solidarity has a great deal of division of labor, ...
[45]
Max Weber - Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy
Aug 24, 2007 · Disenchantment had ushered in monotheistic religions in the West. In practice, this means that ad hoc maxims for life-conduct had been gradually ...Missing: Welt | Show results with:Welt
[46]
Disenchantment of the World - jstor
Weber borrowed the term disenchantment (Entzauberung) from Schiller, the arch-romantic whose poetry was used by Beethoven in the 'Ode to Joy' of his Ninth ...
[47]
[PDF] Max Weber's Bureaucratic Theory: Its Strengths and Weaknesses ...
Jul 7, 2025 · This paper presents a theoretical and empirical analysis of the positive and negative aspects of Max Weber's theory of bureaucracy.
[48]
Max Weber's rationalization processes disenchantment, alienation ...
May 7, 2024 · Therefore, Weber's rationalization process, in the spheres of economy and politics, is best described as Marxist alienation (Kocka, 1966, p. ...
[49]
[PDF] Utopia or an Iron Cage? Marx, Weber, Nietzsche, and the Future of ...
Dec 15, 2011 · However, Weber emphasized rationalization and bureaucratization of the modern life as the primary source for alienation. Even though he agreed ...
[50]
Melvin Seeman, On The Meaning of Alienation - PhilPapers
Five alternative meanings of alienation are identified: powerlessness, meaninglessness, normlessness, isolation, and self-estrangement.
[51]
On the Meaning of Alienation (1959) - ResearchGate
Five alternative meanings of alienation are identified: powerlessness, meaninglessness, normlessness, isolation, and self-estrangement.Missing: typology | Show results with:typology
[52]
Melvin Seeman Alienation Analysis - 859 Words
1. Powerlessness According to Seeman, powerlessness theoretically means when the individual believes his activity will fail to yield the results he seeks. Quick ...
[53]
Seeman, M. (1959). On The Meaning of Alienation. American ...
The author concludes that the quazireligious mantra of burnout invites the reader into a regime of self-care/self-blame contradictions and proves its ...Missing: typology | Show results with:typology
[54]
Social Alienation - an overview | ScienceDirect Topics
In 1959, Seeman identified five types of subjective alienation: powerlessness, self-estrangement, social isolation, normlessness, and meaninglessness. Over the ...<|separator|>
[55]
Alienation: Its Meaning and Measurement - jstor
The concept of Alienation is considered here as having three major components: Powerless- ness, Normlessness and Social Isolation. Scales constructed to measure ...
[56]
Alienation Studies - ResearchGate
Aug 9, 2025 · On The Meaning of Alienation. Article. Dec 1959. Melvin Seeman. The problem of alienation is a pervasive theme in the classics of sociology, and ...
[57]
Dimensions of Political Alienation*
Aug 1, 2014 · One objective indicator of this trend since World War II is the marked rise in voluntary renunciation of American citizenship, an act which ...Missing: urban | Show results with:urban
[58]
Jean-Paul Sartre - Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy
Mar 26, 2022 · ... bad faith. There is no direct account of good faith in Being and Nothingness, other than the enigmatic footnote at the end of the book that ...Being and Nothingness · Politics and Anti-Colonialism · Bibliography
[59]
Existentialism - Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy
Jan 6, 2023 · In Being and Nothingness, Sartre forwards an account of “radical” or ... Sartre and Beauvoir refer to inauthenticity in terms of “bad faith ...
[60]
Albert Camus - Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy
Oct 27, 2011 · ... Camus calls the absurd. Camus's philosophy of the absurd explores the consequences arising from this basic paradox. Camus's understanding of ...The Paradoxes of Camus's... · Suicide, Absurdity and... · Camus and the World of...
[61]
Twenty-first century alienation and health: a research agenda
We examine the links between alienation generated in contemporary capitalist societies and physical and mental health.
[62]
Negative symptoms and self-reflection increase alienation ... - Frontiers
CHR individuals showed a positive correlation between alienation and both positive and negative symptoms, a positive correlation between cognitive insight and ...
[63]
Alienation: Symptoms, Types, Causes, and More - Healthline
What are the symptoms of alienation? · a sense of helplessness · refusal to obey rules · unsafety when interacting with others · exclusion from conversations or ...
[64]
Is trauma isolating, or does isolation traumatize? Loneliness and ...
Mar 6, 2025 · The evidence that does exist points to a complex and bidirectional relationship between loneliness and posttraumatic stress disorder (PTSD) in ...
[65]
Psychopathology of social isolation - PMC - NIH
Negative symptoms are apathy, social withdrawal, and shrinking symptoms. Because of negative symptoms, patients do not involve in any other activities, enjoy ...
[66]
Predictors and Consequences of Work Alienation in Times of Crisis
Jul 5, 2022 · The present research investigates whether employees felt more alienated from their work during the COVID-19 pandemic than before it.Missing: burnout 2020s
[67]
Predictors and Consequences of Work Alienation in Times of Crisis
Studies 1 and 2 found that work alienation was positively related to knowledge hiding and that emotional exhaustion mediated this relationship. Study 2 ...Missing: 2020s | Show results with:2020s
[68]
The Parental Alienation Syndrome: Past, Present, and Future
The parental alienation syndrome (PAS) is a childhood disorder that arises almost exclusively in the context of child-custody disputes. Its primary ...
[69]
Parental Alienation: A Comprehensive Study Guide
Aug 23, 2025 · Parental Alienation Syndrome (PAS): A term introduced by child psychiatrist Richard Gardner in 1985 to describe signs and symptoms he believed ...
[70]
Long-term emotional consequences of parental alienation exposure ...
Nov 25, 2021 · Children exposed to parental interference and alienation show in adulthood depression and anxiety symptoms, a higher risk of psychopathology, lower self-esteem ...
[71]
The Impact of Parental Alienating Behaviours on the Mental Health ...
The alienating parent was identified as the mother in 75% of cases and the father in 25% of cases. The mean age of separation from the targeted parent was 6.9 ...
[72]
Countering Arguments Against Parental Alienation as A Form of ...
Sep 16, 2024 · A recent UN report concluded that parental alienation is a “pseudo-concept” lacking empirical validity, posing significant dangers to women ...
[73]
New Research on the Science of Parental Alienation
Sep 15, 2022 · A 2020 study found in nearly 1,200 trial and appellate cases between 1985 and 2018, judges agreed that evidence of possible parental alienation ...
[74]
Examining the Prevalence and Impact of Parental Alienating ...
Jun 9, 2025 · Specifically, these findings suggest that thousands of families may experience PABs during separation every year (Department for Work & Pensions ...Missing: battles | Show results with:battles
[75]
Treatment of Parental Alienation: Guidelines for Mental Health and ...
Jun 26, 2024 · Its intent is to show how dangerous the targeted parent is. Research shows that about 48% of PA cases involve at least 1 false allegation of ...
[76]
Dean Alienation Scale
The Dean Alienation Scale (DAS; Dean, 1961) measures total alienation, social isolation, normlessness, and powerlessness.
[77]
Dean Alienation Scale (DAS) - PSYCHOLOGICAL SCALES
Nov 19, 2024 · Split-half reliabilities reported by Dean (1961) are: .78 for total alienation, .78 for powerlessness, .73 for normlessness, and .84 for social ...
[78]
[PDF] a study of the measurement of a continuum of alienation/integration ...
Accepting Seeman's taxonomy of alienation, Dwight Dean (1961) subsequently tried measuring three of the five components: powerlessness, normlessness, and social ...
[79]
Measurement of alienation among adolescents: construct validity of ...
Mar 16, 2018 · The purpose of the present study was to develop and validate alienation scales in accordance with Seeman's conceptualization of alienation ...
[80]
On Powerlessness and Meaninglessness - jstor
alienation scales, moreover, have been statistically validated.27 In light of this criticism then, two sets of alienation scales were constructed for this ...
[81]
Understanding the Limitations of SelfReported Data - Insight7
One key limitation is the potential for bias, which can arise from respondents misunderstanding questions or intentionally skewing their answers.
[82]
Cultural Bias in Psychometric Norms: Challenges and Solutions
Aug 28, 2024 · Cultural bias in standardized tests can lead to a 20-30% discrepancy in performance metrics for individuals from diverse backgrounds.
[83]
[PDF] Revisiting the Middleton Alienation Scale
In this paper, I address issues of measurement invariance and construct validity of the Middleton scale (1963), which is one of the most established scales for ...Missing: reliability | Show results with:reliability
[84]
Current Research on the Quality of Working Life - Érudit
Nov 11, 2017 · 32 This does not fit too well with the notion of aliénation as powerlessness, ... Arthur KORNHAUSER, Mental Health of Industrial Worker ...
[85]
The Concept of Alienation - Eldon L. Wegner, 1975 - Sage Journals
Neal Arthur, Seeman Melvin 1964 “Organizations and powerlessness: A test of the mediation hypothesis”. Amer. Soc. Rev. 29 (April): 216–226. Crossref · Google ...
[86]
Bureaucracy and Alienation: A Dimensional Approach - jstor
Businessmen were identified by those char- acteristics defined as entrepreneurial in pre- vious research (cf. Miller and Swanson, 1958: 68-69): they were self- ...
[87]
Revisiting the Middleton Alienation Scale: In Search of a Cross ...
I address a well-established scale by Middleton (1963) which was created to measure alienation. However, unlike commonly treated in literature, there is ...Missing: multidimensional | Show results with:multidimensional<|separator|>
[88]
a longitudinal study of alienation and alcohol use - PubMed
Powerlessness, work, and community: a longitudinal study of alienation and alcohol use. J Health Soc Behav. 1988 Sep;29(3):185-98.Missing: predictors 1960s- 2010s<|control11|><|separator|>
[89]
Alienation in Pandemic-Induced Telework in the Public Sector
This study examines the effect of pandemic-induced remote working on work alienation in the public sector with two Canadian surveys.
[90]
When alienated from society, conspiracy theory belief gives ...
Jul 30, 2024 · The results suggest that conspiracy theory belief might alleviate a lack of meaningfulness caused by experienced alienation from society.
[91]
Social Alienation and Delinquency of Children in Conflict with the ...
Jun 5, 2025 · This study examined the moderating effect of social support on the relationship between social alienation and delinquency among children in.
[92]
Twenty-first century alienation and health: a research agenda
Jun 11, 2025 · This paper sets out an Alienation, Health and Well-being research agenda. We propose two hypotheses: (1) that processes of production and consumption in 21st ...Missing: 2020-2025 | Show results with:2020-2025
[93]
unraveling the dual influence of job autonomy on workplace well ...
Jul 25, 2024 · The survey results show that job autonomy positively affects employees' workplace well-being, and work alienation and positive emotion mediate this ...
[94]
(PDF) Alienation from work: Marxist ideologies and twenty-first ...
Aug 6, 2025 · We examine how three work-related factors identified originally by Karl Marx act as precursors of alienation, that is, a disconnection of ...
[95]
National survey of gig workers paints a picture of poor working ...
Jun 1, 2022 · A survey of gig workers in the spring of 2020 revealed that their jobs provided poor working conditions, even relative to other service-sector workers.
[96]
Über-Alienated: Powerless and Alone in the Gig Economy
We investigate whether engagement in platform work is associated with an increased sense of powerlessness and isolation.
[97]
Job satisfaction is higher among self-employed than other US workers
Jun 30, 2023 · Most self-employed workers (62%) say they are extremely or very satisfied with their job, compared with 51% of those who are not self-employed.Missing: BLS | Show results with:BLS
[98]
A Systematic Review of the Impact of Remote Working Referenced ...
Remote work may affect both physical and psychological health ranging from musculoskeletal disorders, fatigue, and stress (Collins et al., 2016; Oakman et al., ...
[99]
COVID-19 pandemic disruptions to working lives - ScienceDirect.com
We considered the effect this profound disruption had on stress, burnout, and job satisfaction across career stages over time.Missing: alienation 2020s
[100]
Associations between social media use and loneliness in a cross ...
Jan 1, 2023 · The study showed that more time spent on social media was associated with higher levels of loneliness, in particular for people who used social media as a ...
[101]
Loneliness in U.S. adults linked with amount, frequency of social ...
Oct 1, 2025 · In the United States, an estimated 50% of the adult population is lonely. “Most prior research on social media use and loneliness has focused on ...
[102]
Analyzing the Alienation Caused by Hyper-Connectivity in a Digital ...
Nov 21, 2024 · Heidegger's insights offer a profound critique of how hyper-connectivity paradoxically fosters alienation and digital disconnection from authentic being.
[103]
Isolation Among Generation Z in the United States - Ballard Brief
Apr 13, 2025 · Context. In recent years, studies have revealed that Americans—despite being very connected to each other digitally—are more lonely than ever.7 ...
[104]
The Great Alienation - Cal Newport
Oct 6, 2025 · But Gen Z, and youngsters after it, are making things worse by scrolling through social media hoping to find their purpose by accident (or by ...
[105]
Isolation despite hyper-connectivity? The association between ...
Mar 25, 2025 · This study aimed to describe adolescents' online behaviours (eg, time spent on social media) and how that relates to anxiety, depression, and loneliness.
[106]
Consumerism and the Liquefaction of Desire | Church Life Journal
Jul 6, 2021 · From a much different starting point, recent sociologist Zygmunt Bauman came to many of the same observations about contemporary desire.
[107]
[PDF] Consumption and Community in Late Modernity
Bauman (2007) argues that the defining feature of modern mass consumer society was that it produced and consumed its own products. 6. Mass society was the ...
[108]
Poverty - Our World in Data
On this page you can find all our data, visualizations and writing relating to poverty. This work aims to help you understand the scale of the problem today.Missing: 1980-2020 | Show results with:1980-2020
[109]
The evolution of consumer well-being over the last four decades
In other words, subjective well-being is the evaluation of an individual's life aspects wherein they feel positive emotions such as satisfaction and happiness.
[110]
Othering in politics: how affective polarization undermines ... - Frontiers
Apr 7, 2025 · This study conceptualizes affective polarization as a form of othering that undermines Aristotle's concept of philia—political friendship— ...Missing: alienation | Show results with:alienation
[111]
New divides and alienation - Matilda Hellman, 2025 - Sage Journals
Jan 9, 2025 · The resistance towards recommendations to skip meat show up in studies as a consequence of identity politics and a masculinity fetish (Camilleri ...
[112]
Political Polarization: Psychosocial Predictors in Emerging Adults
Jul 16, 2025 · As political beliefs become intertwined with self-identity, political disagreements may take on a personal dimension, potentially intensifying ...
[113]
The dysfunctional paradox of identity politics in liberal democracies
Apr 20, 2022 · The point of contention as to whether identity politics causes or accelerates an identity crisis and possibly a general crisis of democracy ...
[114]
Bridging Critical Cultural Communication and Media Effects through ...
May 27, 2020 · Abstract. In this essay, we advance the Critical Media Effects (CME) framework as a way of bridging two major subfields of communication ...
[115]
The Role of Networked Narratives in Amplifying or Mitigating ... - MDPI
Sep 21, 2024 · This purpose of this research is to understand the role of networked narratives in social media in modulating viewer prejudice toward ethnic neighborhoods.
[116]
The impact of technological advancement on culture and society
Dec 30, 2024 · Social media platforms, while serving as tools for cultural expression, often amplify hegemonic narratives, overshadowing indigenous voices and ...
[117]
(PDF) Understanding digital disconnection beyond media studies
Nov 17, 2021 · The article thus aims to spur media scholars to treat digital disconnection as part of broader cultural trends. ResearchGate Logo. Discover the ...Missing: amplification | Show results with:amplification
[118]
Marxism and Humanism. Louis Althusser 1964
Althusser's influential attack on Marxism and the concepts of dialectical development in nature and history.
[119]
Louis Althusser - Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy
Oct 16, 2009 · Though he uses Marx's Critique of Hegel's Philosophy of Right to make his points and though he is in agreement with Marx that the Hegelian ...Life · Early Work (1946–60) · Classic Work (1961–1966) · Revisions (1966–78)
[120]
SOCY 151 - Lecture 9 - Marx's Theory of Alienation
Next time, we see how the young Marx who is occupied with Hegelian thought and the concept of alienation transitions to a more mature Marx with the concept of ...Missing: inconsistency | Show results with:inconsistency
[121]
Althusser and the Renewal of Marxist Social Theory
Althusser argues that between the 1844 Manuscripts and Capital there exists a radical break in Marx's thought.
[122]
Marxism and ethics - International Socialism
Oct 6, 2008 · There is a widespread myth that Marx either rejected ethics altogether or that his comments on ethics and morality are at best incoherent.
[123]
[PDF] The Marxist Critique of Morality and the Theory of Ideology
The question whether Marx's theory has a moral or ethical dimension is one of the most controversial of all issues of Marx interpretation.
[124]
Karl Marx and the World Crisis
After all, the failure of Marx and the Marxists to understand the potential of capitalism was an error of no small significance, they claimed. No doubt Marxists ...
[125]
Survey: US Job Satisfaction Hits All-Time High
May 11, 2023 · US job satisfaction reached 62.3% in 2022, the highest since 1987, with gains in work-life balance and workload, and 57.6% satisfied with wages.Missing: capitalism | Show results with:capitalism<|separator|>
[126]
Mass alienation under state socialism and after - ScienceDirect.com
... alienation under state socialism and its aftermath. It argues ... Ukraine's 1994 elections as an economic event. 2005, Communist and Post Communist Studies.
[127]
Alienation and Revolution - jstor
Empirical evidence and theory suggest that changes in work and work attitudes led to support of the revolution, rather than the reverse. Even with ...
[128]
On the Reliability and Stability of Alienation Measures - jstor
Drawing on longitudinal data, the reliability and stability of four alienation measures (powerlessness, meaninglessness, normlessness, and isolation) were ...
[129]
Using Marx's Theory of Alienation Empirically - SpringerLink
Dunayevskaya, Raya, Marxism and Freedom. New York: Twayne Publishers, 1958. Google Scholar. Easton, Loyd D., 'Alienation and empiricism in Marx' thought.' ...
[130]
Free Markets are Revolutionary, Liberating, and Democratic - FEE.org
Jul 18, 2017 · The real issue concerns control. Every step toward freer markets is a step toward liberation for the people against the elites.Missing: alienation | Show results with:alienation
[131]
[PDF] Self-Employment and Eudaimonic Well-Being: The Mediating Role ...
Self-employed people report higher eudaimonic well-being, mainly due to using problem-focused coping, not emotion-focused coping.
[132]
Why Entrepreneurs Often Experience Low, Not High, Levels of Stress
Jul 15, 2013 · As a result, founding entrepreneurs as a group are predicted to experience low rather than high levels of stress while running new ventures.Missing: alienation | Show results with:alienation<|separator|>
[133]
The Psychological Building Blocks of Agency - Archbridge Institute
Mar 14, 2025 · Personal agency refers to people's beliefs that they can impact the world around them and pursue their own aspirations. Psychologists have ...
[134]
Polarization and the Politics of Personal Responsibility
In contrast, conservatives believe individuals can and must live their lives with a presumption of personal responsibility for what happens. Without that ...Missing: agency counters alienation