Fact-checked by Grok 2 weeks ago

Bazaar

A bazaar is a , or a group of shops where goods and services are exchanged or sold, particularly common in the , , and . The term originates from the word bāzār, from wāzār, derived from Old Iranian roots meaning "" or "". Bazaars originated as public districts in ancient Persian towns and spread across the , often featuring covered streets lined with small stalls or shops specializing in various goods, such as spices, textiles, and jewelry. They served as vital economic, social, and cultural hubs, vividly depicted in literature like . In larger cities, bazaars were organized by merchandise type and typically bustled during the day before closing at sundown. Notable examples include the Grand Bazaar in , , and Khan el-Khalili in , . In modern Western usage, the term also refers to a temporary or sale of miscellaneous items, often organized for .

Terminology and Etymology

Core Definition

A bazaar is a permanent or semi-permanent consisting of multiple small stalls or shops that offer a diverse array of goods, typically situated in urban settings and characterized by direct vendor-customer interactions, including over prices. This setup fosters a vibrant economic and where shoppers negotiate deals on items ranging from spices and textiles to household wares and artisanal crafts. The term "bazaar" derives from Middle Persian bāzār, signifying "trade" or "marketplace," rooted in Old Iranian vaha-carana meaning "sale" or "traffic." It entered European languages via Italian bazarra or Middle French bazar in the 16th century, with the earliest recorded English use dating to 1588 in a translation referencing Eastern markets. Unlike modern supermarkets or shopping malls, which rely on fixed pricing, self-service displays, and standardized retail formats, bazaars highlight informal operations managed by individual vendors and emphasize social exchanges that build community ties and cultural experiences. The word has spread linguistically from Persian into Turkish (pazar), and beyond, while Arabic employs sūq as a synonymous term for market, though of independent Semitic origin.

Regional Terms and Variations

In the , the term "sūq" serves as a direct for bazaar, referring to a typically characterized by covered passages roofed with vaults or domes to provide shade and protection from the elements. These markets are often segmented into specialized sections based on categories, such as the gold sūq for precious metals and jewelry or the spice sūq for aromatic goods, facilitating organized commerce within urban settings. In , particularly and , the concept appears as "haat," denoting periodic rural markets held weekly in open-air settings that emphasize agricultural products like fresh produce, grains, and . These haats function as vital hubs for local farmers and villagers to exchange goods, often combining with social gatherings, and serve as primary outlets for daily necessities such as and household items in remote areas. Central Asian variants use "bazar," exemplified by Uzbekistan's in , where the market's domed architecture and layout reflect historical influences, promoting trade in spices, textiles, and dried fruits across routes. This term underscores a continuity of multicultural exchange, with bazaars structured around to accommodate diverse merchants and goods from distant regions. In and the , influenced by traditions, "pazar" refers to semi-open weekly markets focused on fresh produce like fruits, , and , while "çarsı" denotes more enclosed, permanent structures for varied . Pazars typically operate in open spaces for seasonal harvests, fostering direct farmer-consumer interactions, whereas çarşıs emphasize artisanal and everyday items in urban cores. Across regions, bazaars vary in scale and merchandise: iterations tend to be expansive, hosting items like silks and jewelry alongside everyday essentials, while rural ones remain compact, prioritizing affordable agricultural outputs and local crafts to meet community needs. These adaptations highlight functional tweaks to local climates, economies, and cultural practices without altering the core role.

Historical Development

Ancient and Pre-Islamic Origins

The earliest precursors to bazaars appeared in ancient around 3000 BCE, where Sumerian city-states like developed centralized trading areas characterized by barter stalls and exchanges of goods such as , woolen textiles, and metals. These markets operated primarily through barter systems, supplemented by silver as a , and were integral to urban economies that lacked natural resources, necessitating imports from regions like the and the . Archaeological evidence from , including administrative tablets, reveals organized commercial districts where merchants facilitated local and long-distance trade, laying the foundation for structured marketplace practices in the . In the Achaemenid Empire (c. 550–330 BCE), these Mesopotamian traditions evolved into more formalized bazaars along key trade routes, such as the Royal Road connecting Susa to Sardis, under direct royal oversight to ensure efficient taxation and security. King Darius I standardized economic practices, introducing the gold daric coin (weighing approximately 8.4 grams of pure gold) to facilitate transactions and tribute collection, marking a shift from barter to monetized exchange in these markets. Bazaars in Persian cities like Persepolis served as hubs for commodity specialization, with dedicated sections for textiles, spices, and metals, reflecting imperial policies that promoted regional production and levies on trade volumes to fund the vast satrapy system. Eastern prototypes, such as the marketplaces of the Indus Valley Civilization (c. 2500 BCE), further influenced pre-Islamic trading norms through organized commercial streets and ports like , where barter stalls handled exports of beads, , and in exchange for Mesopotamian imports. While agoras and forums emphasized civic assembly alongside commerce from the BCE onward, the Eastern bazaar model prioritized linear corridors and , as seen in Indus sites with dedicated artisan workshops for shell and copper processing. These pre-Islamic systems established enduring concepts of market taxation—such as tolls of 2-10% on transported goods in Persian territories—and currency integration, fostering economic interdependence across Asia Minor and the .

Islamic and Medieval Expansion

With the rapid expansion of Islamic rule following the conquests of the 7th and 8th centuries , bazaars evolved from pre-existing market forms into more structured commercial hubs, integrating religious principles such as —the obligatory almsgiving tax instituted in the early Islamic period to support community welfare—and endowments, which provided perpetual funding for including market facilities. These mechanisms ensured and in newly conquered territories across the , , and beyond, where bazaars served as centers for collecting and distributing while revenues maintained covered market spaces and related amenities. During the from the 8th to 13th centuries, emerged as a premier example of this development, with its expansive souks functioning as organized districts that facilitated the exchange of textiles, spices, and other goods essential to the empire's economy. Guilds known as asnaf played a crucial role in regulating these souks, grouping artisans and merchants by to enforce quality standards, pricing, and ethical practices, thereby fostering a collaborative network that often centered around shared mosques for communal activities. The proliferation of bazaars extended through key trade networks like the and routes, disseminating Islamic commercial models to regions including , , and , where local adaptations blended with indigenous traditions to create vibrant marketplaces. A notable instance is Cairo's , established in the 14th century during the era as a major caravanserai-turned-bazaar that exemplified this expansion, serving as a nexus for spices, textiles, and precious metals traded from across the . Architecturally, these bazaars were often integrated with mosques through features like covered alleys that allowed traders to pause for prayers, while the hisba system—embodied by market inspectors ()—enforced moral and commercial regulations drawn from medieval manuals to maintain order and fairness in transactions.

Colonial Period and Modern Evolution

During the 16th to 19th centuries, European colonial powers significantly disrupted traditional bazaar systems, particularly in under influence. The East India Company's expansion from the early 1600s onward integrated Indian markets into global trade networks, often prioritizing raw material exports like and over local commerce, which undermined the autonomy of bazaars as self-sustaining hubs. This period saw the introduction of fixed-price mechanisms in urban colonial outposts, such as through agency houses and European trading firms, contrasting with the prevalent bargaining culture of indigenous bazaars and gradually influencing hybrid pricing practices in larger markets like those in Calcutta and Bombay. In the , post-World War II urbanization accelerated bazaar transformations across the , driven by population growth and economic modernization. In cities like , the Grand Bazaar evolved from a primary commercial center in the —serving daily needs with over 4,000 shops—to a magnet by the late , as modern malls emerged in the 1960s and 1970s, shifting routine shopping away from traditional sites. influxes, peaking at around 40 million annual visitors to by 2014, revitalized the bazaar by emphasizing artisanal goods like carpets and jewelry, bolstering its role amid rapid urban expansion in the region. Entering the post-2000 era, bazaars faced intensified pressures from and shopping malls, yet demonstrated resilience in developing regions. In post-Soviet , informal bazaars proliferated after 1991, becoming vital for transnational trade in consumer goods and sustaining local economies despite the rise of symbolizing ; by the 2020s, growth to USD 14.7 billion in 2024 has supplemented rather than supplanted these markets, with platforms enabling cross-border sales amid limited infrastructure. In the , bazaars have adapted through initiatives and , responding to global shifts. In , eco-bazaars like Markets promote organic , heirloom seeds, and reduced waste, aligning with national net-zero goals by 2053 and countering climate impacts on traditional farming. Similarly, in the UAE, hybrid souks such as Noon and .ae—likened to bazaars—blend platforms with physical , capturing a projected to reach USD 21.18 billion by 2030 while preserving cultural bargaining elements in apps. Amid 2020-2025 disruptions like , informal bazaars in regions including and the exhibited adaptability, with small vendors pivoting to local sourcing and sales to mitigate global shortages, enhancing overall economic resilience.

Structure and Organization

Architectural Features

Bazaars typically exhibit linear layouts consisting of interconnected alleys and passageways, often covered to shield merchants and shoppers from the elements while facilitating efficient movement and trade. In examples, such as the Bazaar, these layouts incorporate domed halls and vaulted roofs that provide climate control in arid environments by reducing direct and promoting air circulation. Specialized sections, known as timchehs, are organized by type of goods, allowing for focused commercial activity and easy navigation within the complex. Construction in traditional bazaars relies on locally available materials like mud-brick and stone for durability and thermal regulation in ancient designs, with sun-dried bricks and adobe forming the primary components of walls and arches. Over time, baked bricks became prevalent for roofing, enabling the creation of expansive vaulted structures that distribute weight effectively and maintain cool interiors. In hot climates, ventilation is achieved through architectural features like high-arched openings to mitigate heat buildup. Key functional elements include central courtyards that serve as communal gathering spaces, promoting social interaction amid , often adorned with fountains for aesthetic and cooling purposes. Security is ensured through gated entrances, such as the prominent Sabze Meydan gate in Tehran's Grand Bazaar, which control access and protect the interior during non-trading hours. These features collectively support the bazaar's role as a vibrant economic and . In densely populated cities, bazaars adapt with multi-level structures to maximize space, as seen in Tehran's Grand Bazaar, where some sections feature two levels of shops and storage above the main corridors, along with auxiliary buildings like mosques and caravanserais, integrating seamlessly into the urban landscape.

Management and Institutions

Guild systems, referred to as asnaf in the and similar structures in other regions, emerged during the medieval period as self-organizing associations of artisans and merchants operating within bazaars. These guilds played a central role in regulating by enforcing quality standards for goods, preventing inferior products from entering the through inspections and certifications conducted by guild masters. For instance, in trades like jewelry, guilds ensured that materials and craftsmanship met specific criteria, often through communal workshops where members collectively monitored production processes. Additionally, asnaf controlled pricing to maintain fair competition and stability, setting maximum and minimum rates for goods and services to avoid undercutting or exploitation, as documented in Ottoman archival records from the 17th and 18th centuries. Apprenticeships were a cornerstone of these systems, with young trainees progressing through structured stages under the supervision of experienced craftsmen, fostering skill transmission and loyalty to the guild over several years. This framework persisted into the , evolving into professional associations in countries like and , where they continue to influence vocational training and ethical practices in bazaar settings. Regulatory roles in bazaars have transitioned from guild-led oversight to state-backed institutions in contemporary contexts, particularly in and , where dedicated market authorities enforce operational standards. In , the Ministry of Health and , along with local municipal bodies, oversees bazaar hygiene through regular inspections for sanitation, , and compliance, imposing fines for violations to protect . Similarly, in , the Ministry of Trade and provincial directorates regulate bazaar activities, collecting value-added taxes and duties while monitoring vendor licensing to ensure legal operations. These modern equivalents build on historical precedents but incorporate formal legal frameworks, such as Turkey's Commercial Code and Iran's Bazaar and Trade Regulations, to address and needs. Enforcement often involves joint patrols with health and tax officials, reflecting a blend of traditional self-regulation and governmental authority. Conflict resolution within bazaars relies on a mix of informal and formal mechanisms, rooted in historical practices that prioritize community harmony. Elders or leaders often mediate disputes over contracts, payments, or territorial claims through , drawing on customary norms to avoid escalation to external courts. In the period, officials like the kapıcıbaşı served as market overseers, appointed by the to supervise bazaar activities, investigate complaints, and resolve conflicts involving or violence, as evidenced in 16th- and 17th-century court records from Istanbul's Grand Bazaar. Today, this tradition continues informally in many bazaars, supplemented by formal judicial systems; for example, in Iranian bazaars, disputes may be referred to local civil courts or commercial tribunals if mediation fails. These approaches emphasize quick, low-cost resolutions to sustain daily trade flows. Economic institutions supporting bazaar operations include informal credit networks and cooperative structures that enable merchants to navigate financial constraints without relying on formal banking. In South Asian bazaars, such as those in and , the hawala system functions as a trust-based and remittance network, allowing traders to transfer funds across borders or regions through a chain of brokers who settle balances via trade offsets or cash, bypassing bureaucratic hurdles and high fees. This mechanism, originating from medieval Islamic finance principles, facilitates short-term loans and supplier payments essential for . Complementing hawala, buying groups—formed by clusters of merchants—pool resources to procure goods in bulk from wholesalers, negotiating better prices and reducing individual risks, as seen in seasonal trades in Lahore's bazaars. These institutions underscore the bazaar's , providing flexible financing amid economic volatility.

Types of Bazaars

Permanent Markets

Permanent markets, also known as fixed bazaars or souks, are enduring commercial hubs characterized by their year-round operations and stable infrastructure, typically featuring fixed stalls and shops within dedicated spaces. These markets facilitate daily trading activities, offering a wide array of ranging from everyday essentials like and textiles to items such as jewelry and spices, serving both local residents and visitors. Their permanence allows for organized layouts, often organized by trade specialties in linear or labyrinthine pathways, integrating seamlessly into city centers as vital economic and social nodes. A prominent example of such a market's scale is Istanbul's Kapalıçarşı, or Grand Bazaar, established in the during the era, which encompasses over 4,000 shops across 61 covered streets and attracts millions of visitors annually as a key urban landmark. This structure exemplifies the enduring nature of permanent bazaars, with its fixed architecture supporting continuous commerce and contributing to the site's recognition within the World Heritage-listed . The permanence of these markets fosters reliable supply chains, enabling merchants to maintain consistent inventory and relationships with suppliers, while generating substantial revenue through their historical and cultural allure. However, permanent bazaars also face challenges, including overcrowding that strains and complicates daily operations, particularly in high-traffic areas where visitor numbers can exceed capacity during peak seasons. Despite these issues, their fixed locations promote by providing year-round and trade opportunities. Globally, this model has spread from traditional Middle Eastern souks to Latin American mercados permanentes, where colonial trade networks introduced similar fixed-market systems influenced by and mercantile practices, adapting local goods and to support ongoing .

Temporary and Seasonal Bazaars

Temporary and seasonal bazaars represent a transient form of assembly, convening periodically—typically weekly, monthly, or annually—in rural, semi-urban, or open spaces to facilitate without fixed . These markets rely on portable stalls, tents, and temporary setups, prioritizing the exchange of perishable items such as fresh produce, , textiles, and artisanal crafts that do not suit permanent . Unlike fixed bazaars, they adapt to local rhythms like harvest cycles or festivals, drawing vendors and buyers from surrounding communities for short durations, often lasting one day. This mobility enables connectivity in remote areas where daily markets are impractical due to sparse population and limited transportation. In , haats exemplify weekly rural bazaars, where farmers, artisans, and traders gather in rotating village locations to sell agricultural goods, household essentials, and handicrafts. Approximately 43,000 haats operate nationwide as of 2023, serving more than 50% of the rural population and generating an average daily turnover of approximately Rs. 2.25 lakhs per market (based on early surveys), with annual sales around Rs. 50,000 crores across all haats. These gatherings, often managed by local panchayats, foster vendor migration via bullock carts or bicycles, allowing small-scale producers in isolated regions to access broader markets and essential supplies without permanent outlets. Women constitute about 40% of visitors, underscoring haats' role in inclusive rural commerce and social exchange. Moroccan weekly souks mirror this model, assembling in rural provinces on designated days where nomadic or semi-nomadic vendors transport goods like spices, grains, and woven items over distances using donkeys or trucks. These markets rotate among communities to accommodate seasonal migrations and agricultural calendars, providing vital economic lifelines in arid, infrastructure-poor areas by enabling and cash transactions for perishables. Economic challenges, including rural-to-urban migration, have reduced participation in some souks, yet they remain essential for sustaining local livelihoods amid declining traditional farming. In , seasonal fairs such as agricultural and harvest festivals function as temporary bazaars, where vendors set up portable displays for produce, dairy, and crafts during events like the Almond Blossom Festival or regional panayirs. These gatherings involve community rotations and vendor travel from nearby districts, supporting remote economies by linking producers to seasonal buyers without year-round facilities. Contemporary adaptations include urban pop-up bazaars, which emerge in cities for short-term events tied to peaks, holidays, or cultural festivals, using modular stalls to showcase local crafts and foods. In , for instance, markets like the Urbanspace Bryant Park pop-up host over 175 vendors in spring and holiday seasons, capitalizing on high foot traffic to boost artisan sales and experiential . These modern iterations blend traditional transience with digital promotion, attracting diverse crowds while echoing the economic flexibility of their rural predecessors.

Economic and Social Roles

Commercial Functions

Bazaars operate through haggle-based systems where prices are not fixed but emerge from negotiations between buyers and sellers, facilitating in environments characterized by and variable quality of . This process, often multidimensional and involving interactions, allows participants to assess value based on perceived costs, conditions, and personal relationships, contrasting with fixed-price models in modern . In regions like , informal credit mechanisms such as chit funds—rotating savings and credit associations—further support by providing accessible financing for merchants and buyers without formal banking, enabling small-scale transactions in daily operations. The diversity of goods in bazaars reflects their role as multifaceted hubs in local supply chains, offering everything from traditional items like spices, textiles, and handicrafts to contemporary products such as and . For instance, Istanbul's Grand Bazaar features sections dedicated to spices, jewelry, and fabrics, while Egyptian souks emphasize , spices, and textiles sourced from regional producers. In developing countries, bazaars integrate into broader supply chains by connecting small producers directly to urban consumers, bypassing intermediaries and ensuring affordability for essential commodities. This diversity sustains local economies by distributing goods from rural farms and workshops to city dwellers, with bazaars handling a significant portion of non-perishable flows. Bazaars contribute substantially to local and regional economies through job creation and informal sector dominance, employing millions in trading, , and related services worldwide. Globally, informal markets like bazaars form part of the , which supports over 2 billion workers, many in and trade activities that drive income generation in developing nations. In , informal —including bazaars—accounts for about 40% of the sector's operations, employing around 8.3 million people across 2.78 million shops and contributing to overall GDP through untaxed but vital economic activity. In the , traditional markets such as souks represent a majority of in several countries; for example, in , they comprise over 70% of grocery trade, underscoring their scale in urban economies. Despite their resilience, bazaars face challenges including counterfeiting, which undermines trust and revenue, as seen in Istanbul's Grand Bazaar where fake like designer handbags and perfumes have proliferated, displacing authentic trades. Competition from modern retail chains, offering fixed prices and air-conditioned environments, erodes bazaar in urban areas, though traditional outlets remain competitive on freshness and flexibility. Post-2020, many bazaars adapted to disruptions by partnering with delivery services and informal platforms to maintain sales, enabling contactless transactions for essentials like groceries and textiles in densely populated regions.

Cultural and Social Significance

Bazaars serve as vital social spaces where communities engage in everyday interactions beyond commerce, functioning as meeting points for gossip, news exchange, and social bonding. In traditional settings like those along the , visitors frequent bazaars not only to shop but to connect with friends, share personal stories, and discuss community matters, making these markets central hubs for social life. Similarly, in Iranian bazaars, these venues facilitate casual encounters that foster relationships and cultural continuity through informal dialogues. Festivals often animate bazaars, drawing crowds for celebrations that blend commerce with communal festivities, as seen in Central Asian markets where events promote social cohesion. Regarding gender roles, women play prominent parts as vendors in certain contexts, such as women's markets in , where they challenge traditional norms by managing stalls and interacting publicly, thereby asserting economic and social agency despite restrictive environments. Bazaars contribute significantly to cultural preservation by transmitting traditional crafts, languages, and rituals across generations. These markets host workshops and sales of artisanal goods, enabling craftspeople to pass down skills like and metalwork, which embody as recognized by UNESCO's focus on traditional craftsmanship in local marketplaces. In and , bazaars sustain cultural spaces through activities that include educational sessions on heritage crafts and performances of regional rituals, helping maintain linguistic diversity and customary practices amid modernization. This role extends to broader heritage continuity, where bazaars resist erosion of local traditions by providing venues for the exchange and demonstration of cultural knowledge. In community functions, bazaars support collective welfare through charity events and informal dispute mediation. Traditional markets often host fundraising activities, such as community haat bazaars in Nepal, where proceeds from craft sales aid local development and social initiatives. Bazaar guilds, particularly in Iranian contexts, historically mediate conflicts among merchants, resolving trade disputes and maintaining social order within the community through established institutional mechanisms. For migrant populations, diaspora bazaars in Europe fulfill similar roles; for instance, the Afghan Mandawi Bazaar in Paris serves as a gathering point for exiles to organize charitable efforts and address community needs arising from displacement. In contemporary settings, bazaars symbolize resistance to by preserving local identities while promoting in urban centers. Persistent traditional markets in post-Soviet cities like demonstrate resilience against capitalist homogenization, offering spaces for informal economies that uphold cultural practices over standardized retail. Similarly, diaspora markets such as Berlin's Turkish Market act as multicultural enclaves, blending Turkish traditions with society to foster exchanges and combat cultural dilution in diverse cities. These venues highlight bazaars' adaptability, enabling communities to navigate global influences while reinforcing social ties and heritage.

Depictions in Art and Literature

Visual Representations

Bazaars have been a prominent subject in 19th-century , where Western artists often portrayed them as realms of exotic chaos and vibrant disorder to evoke the allure of the "." French painter exemplified this approach in works like The Carpet Merchant (1887), which depicts a crowded souk scene in with merchants haggling over intricate rugs amid a throng of figures in traditional attire, emphasizing the of spices, textiles, and bustling trade. Similarly, Gérôme's (1879) captures an Orientalist scene of a public performance in an interior courtyard with spectators, blending everyday spectacles to heighten the sense of otherworldly intrigue. These paintings, rooted in the artist's travels and studio reconstructions, reinforced stereotypes of Eastern markets as labyrinthine and untamed spaces. By the late 19th century, artists like Charles Wilda extended these depictions in oils such as (c. 1901), rendering souks as colorful hubs of and cultural display, often with meticulous detail on and attire to underscore the exotic "otherness." Such visual highlighted the vibrancy of bazaars—through rich hues of and —while framing them as symbols of timeless, unchanging Eastern society in contrast to Western modernity. Critiques of these representations emerged prominently in the late , viewing Orientalist art as a colonial that exoticized and essentialized non-Western cultures to justify imperial domination. Edward Said's seminal analysis in Orientalism (1978) argued that such depictions, including bazaar scenes, constructed the East as a passive, sensual domain under Western scrutiny, perpetuating power imbalances rather than authentic portrayal. This perspective has influenced modern scholarship, highlighting how 19th-century visuals served propagandistic ends during European expansion in the . The portrayal of bazaars evolved into 20th-century photography, which maintained Orientalist tropes while capturing real-time dynamism. Photographers like those in the American Colony collection (c. 1898–1930s) documented Jerusalem's souks with staged compositions of vendors and crowds, emphasizing the picturesque chaos through soft lighting and selective framing, much like paintings. This medium shifted focus to documentary realism yet retained an ethnographic lens, as seen in works by Félix Bonfils, who photographed bustling Damascus markets around 1880–1900 to market "exotic" views to European audiences. In modern visuals, and have reimagined bazaars, blending critique with narrative. Early 20th-century photographers such as those featured in Photorientalist archives continued to aestheticize souks as vibrant, labyrinthine spaces, but post-colonial lenses began challenging stereotypes. Films like David Lean's Lawrence of Arabia () prominently feature market scenes in Arabian towns, portraying them as strategic hubs of intrigue and cultural fusion during , with sweeping that amplifies their scale and intensity while echoing earlier Orientalist exoticism.

Literary Portrayals

In Orientalist literature, bazaars frequently serve as vibrant settings for intrigue and adventure, particularly in the medieval collection of tales known as (compiled between the 9th and 14th centuries), where bustling markets facilitate plot devices such as chance encounters, deceptions, and magical exchanges among merchants, thieves, and storytellers. These narratives, rooted in Middle Eastern folklore, portray bazaars as labyrinthine spaces of commerce and mystery, often initiating chains of events that drive the episodic structure of the stories. Paul Bowles' 1949 novel depicts Moroccan souks as disorienting realms of sensory chaos and existential alienation, where American travelers confront the limits of their cultural detachment amid the haggling crowds and shadowed alleys. In contrast, Orhan Pamuk's Istanbul-centered works, such as his memoir Istanbul: Memories and the City (2003) and novels like The Black Book (1990), integrate bazaars like the Sahaflar Çarşısı used-book market as nostalgic emblems of intellectual pursuit and urban melancholy, reflecting the city's layered heritage. Bazaars in literature often symbolize bargaining as a for life's negotiations and uncertainties, as seen in James Joyce's "Araby" (1914), where the titular oriental bazaar represents unfulfilled desires and the harsh exchange between illusion and reality. Cultural clashes emerge prominently in these depictions, with Western protagonists navigating eastern markets as sites of otherness and misunderstanding, exemplified by the racial and perceptual tensions in Bowles' portrayal of North African souks. In post-colonial , employs markets in novels like (1995) to evoke hybrid identities and historical palimpsests, where bazaars layer colonial legacies with contemporary flux, underscoring themes of displacement and reinvention. Over time, literary portrayals of bazaars have evolved from exotic backdrops in 19th- and 20th-century Orientalist fiction to symbols of in 21st-century narratives, where traditional markets intersect with modern and , as explored in contemporary works that highlight cultural amid economic transformation.

Notable Examples Worldwide

Grand Bazaar, Istanbul, Turkey

The (Kapalıçarşı) in is one of the world's oldest and largest covered markets, established in 1461 during the . Spanning over 30,000 square meters with more than 4,000 shops, it specializes in jewelry, carpets, spices, and antiques, attracting millions of visitors annually as a tentative candidate.

Khan el-Khalili, Cairo, Egypt

Dating back to the 14th century, is a historic bazaar in 's Islamic quarter, originally built as a and . It features narrow alleys selling gold, spices, perfumes, and souvenirs, serving as a vibrant hub for trade and cultural exchange in the .

Bazaar of Tabriz, Tabriz, Iran

The , founded around the 13th century along ancient routes, is 's largest covered bazaar and a since 2010. Covering 1 square kilometer with numerous sub-bazaars, it trades in carpets, textiles, and handicrafts, reflecting Persian commercial traditions.

Souq Waqif, Doha, Qatar

Renovated in 2008 to preserve traditional architecture, is a modern interpretation of a Gulf bazaar, originally dating to the early . It offers goods, spices, textiles, and gold across 1.25 million square meters, blending commerce with Qatari heritage.

Chandni Chowk, Delhi, India

Established in the by Mughal Emperor , is 's oldest bazaar, known for its silver jewelry (hence "silver square"), spices, and . Stretching 1.5 kilometers along a historic , it exemplifies South Asian market vibrancy amid urban bustle.

References

  1. [1]
    Bazaar in Launchpad
    Bazaar is a friendly powerful distributed version control system. Bazaar helps people collaborate on software development, by recording the history of the ...
  2. [2]
    Phasing out Bazaar code hosting - Ubuntu Community Hub
    Jun 4, 2025 · Bazaar is a distributed version control system (VCS), developed by Canonical. For a long time, Bazaar was the only supported VCS on Launchpad.
  3. [3]
    bzr - Bazaar next-generation distributed version ... - Ubuntu Manpage
    Bazaar (or bzr) is a distributed version control system that is powerful, friendly, and scalable. Bazaar is a project of Canonical Ltd and part of the GNU ...
  4. [4]
    Bazaar for version control - Anteru's Blog
    Mar 8, 2010 · Bazaar is a distributed versioning system built by Canonical, the same guys that created Ubuntu. It's written in Python, and runs on Windows, Linux and Mac OS ...<|control11|><|separator|>
  5. [5]
    Bazaar-NG: 7 years of hacking on a distributed version control system
    Dec 13, 2012 · Sometime in 2010, the domain name changed from bazaar-vcs.org to bazaar.canonical.com. The focus for the Bazaar team in Canonical changed from ...
  6. [6]
    MySQL is using Bazaar and Launchpad for their source code | Ubuntu
    Bazaar is a distributed version control system that Just Works and adapts to the workflows you want to use. Bazaar is a GNU project, and Canonical provides ...
  7. [7]
    bzr 1.16 released! - Ubuntu Mailing Lists
    Jun 18, 2009 · ... Bazaar 1.16, codename "It's yesterday in California" is released! This version of Bazaar contains the beta release of the new ``2a ...
  8. [8]
    Bazaar Tutorial - Documentation & Help
    Many Version Control Systems (VCS) are stored on servers. If one wants to work on the code stored within a VCS, then one needs to connect to the server and “ ...
  9. [9]
    bazaar-community/bazaar3: Next generation bazaar VCS - GitHub
    Bazaar (bzr) is a decentralized revision control system, designed to be easy for developers and end users alike.
  10. [10]
    Version Control Systems - GeeksforGeeks
    Sep 24, 2025 · Bazaar is a distributed version control system developed by Canonical, the creators of Ubuntu. Unlike Git or Mercurial, Bazaar supports both ...
  11. [11]
    Canonical is Dropping Bazaar Support from Launchpad
    Jun 6, 2025 · Canonical is sunsetting Bazaar version control on Launchpad in 2025. Learn about the timeline, migration options, and what it means for ...
  12. [12]
    BAZAAR Definition & Meaning - Merriam-Webster
    Oct 30, 2025 · Word History. Etymology. Persian bāzār. First Known Use. 1612, in the meaning defined at sense 1. Time Traveler. The first known use of bazaar ...
  13. [13]
    BAZAAR | definition in the Cambridge English Dictionary
    an open market where people sell things, or any group of small shops or people selling goods. A bazaar is also an event where people sell things to raise ...
  14. [14]
    BAZAAR Definition & Meaning - Dictionary.com
    a marketplace or shopping quarter, especially one in the Middle East. Synonyms: exchange, mart, market · a sale of miscellaneous contributed articles to benefit ...
  15. [15]
    Bazaar - Etymology, Origin & Meaning
    From Italian bazarra, Persian bazar, meaning "a market," originating from Old Iranian *vaha-carana "sale, traffic," derived from PIE roots *wes- "to buy, ...
  16. [16]
    bazaar, n. meanings, etymology and more | Oxford English Dictionary
    OED's earliest evidence for bazaar is from 1588, in a translation by T. Hickock. bazaar is a borrowing from Persian. Etymons: Persian bāzār. See ...<|control11|><|separator|>
  17. [17]
    Bustling Bazaars or Modern Supermarkets? Take Your Pick in Astana
    Apr 8, 2016 · Bazaars offer fresh, farm-direct products and cultural experiences, while supermarkets are convenient, time-saving, and may have deals, but may ...
  18. [18]
    [PDF] TRADITIONAL MARKETS IN ISLAMIC ARCHITECTURE - WIT Press
    There were three types of traditional markets: the market that has a network of roofed roads with fortified gates, a monumental building with a roofed center ...
  19. [19]
    Form and Function in Two Traditional Markets of the Middle East
    Sep 2, 2020 · This paper presents some of the findings of a study comparing the form and function of two traditional markets on the Arabian Peninsula.
  20. [20]
  21. [21]
    [PDF] Reaching Out To the Rural Consumers through Haats - IJBMI
    A haat, is an open-air market that serves as a trading outlet for consumers in rural areas. They are conducted on a regular basis, generally once a week. It is ...
  22. [22]
    [PDF] Historical bazaars of central asia - Neliti
    Crossroads of the main streets of the city will be decorated with domed structures - Chorsu and Tims. Special buildings - Toki and Caravanserai will be built in.
  23. [23]
    Women and Bazaars: Gendering Entrepreneurship in Uzbekistan
    Jul 23, 2024 · The shift from a planned to a market economy, coupled with weakened legal frameworks and a frayed welfare system, drove women into bazaar trade.
  24. [24]
  25. [25]
    The role of wholesale markets in the supply chain for fresh fruit and ...
    Apr 30, 2019 · Turkey has a crucial share of the world market for fresh fruit and vegetables, exporting fresh fruit at a value of 2.393 million dollars in 2014 ...
  26. [26]
    BĀZĀR ii. Organization and Function - Encyclopaedia Iranica
    These types of markets were mainly rural and of a regional nature. They, of course, also were important for urban traders, who went there to sell and/or buy ...
  27. [27]
    The Structure of Prices in the Neo-Sumerian Economy (I): Barley ...
    Although there is no written evidence of barter or local markets in the Ur III economy they must have existed. How else would ordinary people obtain their ...
  28. [28]
    [PDF] TRADE AND TRADERS OF MESOPOTAMIAN UR
    Feb 12, 2012 · They imported copper, precious stones and woods, and ivory and exported woolen clothing and cloth, barley, and locally grown foodstuffs. These ...
  29. [29]
    Role of bazaars as a unifying factor in traditional cities of Iran
    Bazaars have not yet completely emerged. With the emergence of money in the Achaemenid Empire, the city became the center of government, trade, and economics; ...
  30. [30]
    The Persian Empire | Economy, Labor System & Trade - Study.com
    King Darius developed a sophisticated system of weights and measures that enabled trade transactions to be done fairly and consistently. This system of weights ...<|separator|>
  31. [31]
    [PDF] Taxation in the Achaemenid Empire Introduction
    7, 11.3), Darius introduced taxation and, in order to avert the ensuing unpopularity from his own person, had his provincial governors collect a huge amount ...
  32. [32]
    Shipping and Maritime Trade of the Indus People - Penn Museum
    A brisk sea-borne trade between the Indus people and the Sumerians in the late third and early second millenniums BC.
  33. [33]
    [PDF] The Indus Civilization Trade with the Oman Peninsula - Harappa
    In this period, while imports from Mesopotamia and Iran declined, the Indus Civilization emerged as the primary trading partner of the Umm an-Nar communities.Missing: BCE | Show results with:BCE
  34. [34]
  35. [35]
    [PDF] the waqf as a central islamic - IU ScholarWorks
    In short, the waqf was more than just a philanthropic institution—it was a generator of Muslim material and spiritual culture. As a famous historian remarked, “ ...Missing: bazaars 8th
  36. [36]
    [PDF] The Provision of Public Goods under Islamic Law: Origins, Impact ...
    The Islamic waqf appears to have emerged as a credible commitment device to give property owners economic security in return for social services. Through-.
  37. [37]
    Baghdad, the fabled city of The Arabian Nights - World History Volume
    Aug 8, 2017 · Baghdad became the imperial capital of the Abbasids. It also became one of the greatest centres of trade in the world.<|separator|>
  38. [38]
    AṢNĀF - Encyclopædia Iranica
    The guilds had their own bazaars, and in some cases they worked closely together for their common wealth. Members of the same guild often used the same mosque ...
  39. [39]
    How Bazaars Shaped Trade in Islamic Cities Before 1900 | Curationist
    Aug 20, 2023 · Baščaršija in Sarajevo is an example, where the name itself derived from the Turkish “'Baš'” or “bazaar." See Alic, Dijana. "Transformations ...<|control11|><|separator|>
  40. [40]
    The Book of the Islamic Market Inspector - Oxford University Press
    Free delivery 25-day returnsThis is a fully annotated translation of a 12th-century manual written for the practical use of the Islamic inspector of markets. Filled with lively detail, ...Missing: bazaars | Show results with:bazaars
  41. [41]
    [PDF] Trading Firms in Colonial India - Harvard Business School
    The aim of this article is to develop a general narrative of the firms that led the growth of trade in nineteenth-century. India, and thus to supply a ...Missing: influence | Show results with:influence
  42. [42]
    economic impacts of british rule in india - NEXT IAS
    Dec 19, 2024 · The British rule in India profoundly transformed the country's economy, dismantling traditional structures and imposing exploitative colonial policies.
  43. [43]
    Istanbul's Old Soul Lives On in the Grand Bazaar - Rick Steves Europe
    The Grand Bazaar remained Turkey's commercial hub through the 1950s, its 4,000 shops bursting with both practical and exotic wares. But then the Grand Bazaar ...
  44. [44]
    Grand Bazaar (Kapalı Çarşı), Istanbul, Turkey
    With a total of 21 entrances and 4,000 shops, the Grand Bazaar is the world's biggest historical covered market. In 2014, with 91 million visitors in a year, ...
  45. [45]
  46. [46]
    Report: State of E-Commerce in Central Asia
    Oct 16, 2025 · Rapid Regional Growth: The Central Asia e-commerce market reached approximately USD 14.7 billion in 2024, up from USD 11.1 billion in 2023, ...Missing: impact malls Soviet
  47. [47]
    Local Markets / Organic Bazaars - GoTürkiye
    Earth Markets in Türkiye are helping to combat the impact of climate change and protect heirloom seeds, promote organic agriculture, and boost the gastronomic ...Missing: 21st century
  48. [48]
    How UAE's E-commerce is Shaping a New Economic Frontier in 2025
    B2C Marketplaces: Amazon.ae and Noon dominate the landscape, like digital souks with millions of daily visitors and catalogues that span everything imaginable.Missing: hybrid | Show results with:hybrid<|separator|>
  49. [49]
    Small businesses and new adaptation capacities in Georgia and ...
    In this article, we inquire how small business owners in Georgia and Kazakhstan adapted to global economic disruption such as those brought on by the Covid-19 ...
  50. [50]
    Role of bazaars as a unifying factor in traditional cities of Iran
    Aug 7, 2025 · This research focuses on the concept of a “traditional city” to determine the role of bazaars in such cities. The results show that bazaars are ...
  51. [51]
    Tehran Bazaar: All You Need to Know Before Visiting! - IranAmaze
    Jan 27, 2025 · Grand Bazaar Tehran Architecture​​ The most striking architectural feature is the brick vaulted ceilings with arched designs, providing both ...
  52. [52]
    [PDF] A Study of the Concept of Iranian Traditional Architecture in Bazaars ...
    Jan 25, 2019 · A study of the concept of Iranian traditional architecture in bazaars and shopping centres. Journal of Construction in Developing Countries, 23( ...Missing: Persian | Show results with:Persian
  53. [53]
    CONSTRUCTION MATERIALS AND TECHNIQUES in Persian ...
    The most frequent building material in Iranian cultural areas has always been mud, which is available everywhere.Missing: bazaar colonial<|separator|>
  54. [54]
    The Tehran Grand Bazaar: a historical and architectural marvel
    Jul 5, 2023 · The architecture of the bazaar is a blend of traditional Persian and Islamic styles, with ornate vaulted ceilings, intricate tilework, and ...<|separator|>
  55. [55]
    Ottoman Guilds in the Early Modern Era* | International Review of ...
    Dec 1, 2008 · This study provides an overview of the history of Ottoman craft guildsFootnote 1 from the seventeenth century to the early nineteenth ...Missing: resolution | Show results with:resolution
  56. [56]
    The Guilds in Iran — an Overview from the Earliest Beginnings ... - jstor
    67 The government can favour retail dealers by controlling the prices of the middlemen and the market distributors (bunakdãr). The retail dealers have to ...Missing: management | Show results with:management
  57. [57]
    [PDF] The Iranian Bazaar as a Public Place: A Reintegrative Approach and ...
    bazaar, Master's thesis, University of Tehran, Faculty of Architecture and Urban Planning. ... (2014b) Iranian bazaar as public space, case study of Tabriz bazaar ...
  58. [58]
    Ottoman Market Regulation and Inspection in the Early Modern Period
    This article looks at Ottoman market regulation policies and practices, by highlighting some turning points in their evolution in the early modern period.<|control11|><|separator|>
  59. [59]
    [PDF] 9781589064232.pdf - IMF eLibrary - International Monetary Fund
    In South Asia and other labor exporting countries, for example, hawala has been and remains either criminalized or outlawed. This means that cer- tain large ...
  60. [60]
    [PDF] MEI Kaleidoscope | Souks: The Heart of Traditional Urban Life in the ...
    Apr 10, 2018 · With the dawn of Islam, souks began to adopt a structure that made them unique from markets elsewhere. Souks across the Muslim world share ...
  61. [61]
    Visit Istanbul's Grand Bazaar - Culture Trip
    Sep 6, 2025 · The Grand Bazaar is the oldest market, a labyrinthine indoor market with 61 covered streets, over 4,000 shops, and known for haggling.
  62. [62]
    Historic Areas of Istanbul - UNESCO World Heritage Centre
    Work carried out at the Grand Bazaar addresses maintenance and repair needs, although there is a danger that loss of original fabric and patina will reduce the ...
  63. [63]
    [PDF] Bazaar: The Persistence of the Informal
    The adversarial nature of bazaar transactions is perhaps more evident in bargaining, which Geertz characterizes as multidimensional (entailing manipulations of ...Missing: characteristics | Show results with:characteristics
  64. [64]
    [PDF] RURAL DEVELOPMENT AND RURAL WEEKLY MARKETS
    Weekly market locally called as, Bazar, Haat,. Periodic market. In recent years, rural weekly markets have acquired significant role, as the overall growth of ...
  65. [65]
    Importance of Odisha′s Haats for Agricultural Marketing
    Sep 22, 2023 · (Kashyap & Raut, 2010).India has 47,000 haats, which serve over 50% of the country's population (Fagerland & Smith, 1970).Each haat draws over ...
  66. [66]
    [PDF] The HAAT of Rural Economy - Rural India's Traditional Supermarkets
    Almost every villager is a regular haat visitor, with over three-fourths visiting one every week. And two in every five visitors here are women. Rural haats are ...
  67. [67]
    The Souks of Morocco: Vibrant Heartbeats of Culture and Commerce
    Jul 27, 2025 · Economic pressures and urbanization also impact weekly souks in rural areas, where declining agricultural yields and migration to cities reduce ...
  68. [68]
    souk | MOROCCO TRAVEL BLOG
    Mar 22, 2015 · On any day of the week, a market (or souk) will take place somewhere in each Province (a region like a State in the US or a county in the UK).Missing: logistics migration
  69. [69]
    Top Events & Festivals in Turkey (2025)
    The Badem Çiçeği Festivali (Almond Blossom Festival) takes place in February – 13th-16th February 2025. Expect stalls, traditional music, folk dancing and ...Missing: yemeni | Show results with:yemeni
  70. [70]
    Urbanspace is about to open its largest, longest pop-up market in ...
    Mar 27, 2025 · More than 175 local vendors will showcase their handcrafted products, including art, jewelry, food, and more, in Bryant Park this spring as part of the Makers ...
  71. [71]
    The Bazaar Economy: Information and Search in Peasant Marketing
    bazaar bargaining represents. bazaar "price negotiation" takes place to the right of the decimal point. But it is no less keen for that. G. A. Akerlof, "The ...
  72. [72]
    [PDF] Informal Credit Markets in India - Dr. Thomas A. Timberg
    This paper deals with the non-bank urban informal credit market in India and, in specific, with how it contributes to finance in the Indian economy.
  73. [73]
  74. [74]
    Explore the 15 Best Souks and Bazaars in Egypt
    Oct 19, 2024 · With its rich collection of pottery, spices, handmade jewelry, and traditional textiles, the souk invites visitors to explore and cherish the ...
  75. [75]
    More than 60 per cent of the world's employed population are in the ...
    Apr 30, 2018 · Two billion people – more than 61 per cent of the world's employed population – make their living in the informal economy, the ILO said in a report.Missing: bazaars | Show results with:bazaars<|separator|>
  76. [76]
    Pakistan's Informal Economy Projected to Exceed $500 Billion
    Apr 20, 2025 · The retail sector also contributes substantially, with an estimated 40% operating informally, costing the government over Rs1.5 trillion ...
  77. [77]
    Pakistan's Retail Shops: A Key Sector with Opportunities - LinkedIn
    Aug 28, 2025 · 2.78 million retail shops employ 8.3 million people 188,000 wholesale shops employ 0.5 million people ➡️ Together, that's ~9 million workers ...
  78. [78]
    Grocery retail in the Middle East and North Africa - McKinsey
    Oct 22, 2024 · In these markets, modern trade is still in the minority at 21 percent (Morocco), 27 percent (Egypt), and 46 percent (KSA) in 2023. Modern trade ...
  79. [79]
    Fake luxuries supplant tradition in İstanbul's Grand Bazaar
    Jul 17, 2024 · Cut-price branded perfumes and fake designer handbags line the alleys of İstanbul's venerable Grand Bazaar, flooded by luxury imitations.
  80. [80]
    Modern Retailers in Transition Economies: The Case of Vietnam
    ... modern outlets is superior to products sold at traditional stores. Traditional bazaars are still very competitive in terms of price, freshness, and convenience.
  81. [81]
    “Pivoting” by food industry firms to cope with COVID‐19 in ...
    Firms “pivoted” to e‐commerce to reach consumers and e‐procurement to reach processors and farmers. “Delivery intermediaries” copivoted with food firms to help ...
  82. [82]
    Samarkand Square - Commerce - Smithsonian Folklife Festival
    Bazaars along the Silk Road​​ They also come to bazaars to meet friends, exchange gossip, and catch up on news. Small bazaars are the social and economic hubs of ...Missing: matchmaking | Show results with:matchmaking
  83. [83]
    Beyond market: A deep dive into Iran's traditional Bazaars
    Oct 21, 2025 · Over time, the bazaar became an indispensable artery for commerce, social interaction, and cultural exchange. Beyond market: A deep dive ...<|separator|>
  84. [84]
    Busting Taboos: Women's market in Badghis | Afghanistan
    Dec 14, 2017 · Today, this market is active where the majority of female sellers are World Vision Afghanistan producer and saving groups members who today are ...Missing: bazaars | Show results with:bazaars
  85. [85]
    Traditional craftsmanship - UNESCO Intangible Cultural Heritage
    Traditional craftsmanship is perhaps the most tangible manifestation of intangible cultural heritage. However, the 2003 Convention is mainly concerned with ...
  86. [86]
    A Comparative Study of Bazaar Cultural Spaces in Central Asia and ...
    Oct 20, 2024 · This paper compares the bazaar cultural spaces of Central Asia and Chinese from four perspectives: the current state of the bazaar, development overview, user ...Missing: gossip | Show results with:gossip
  87. [87]
    Cultural Continuity of Traditional Bazaars in the Globalized World
    This book covers part of a research on historical architectural traits in two culturally rich cities; Istanbul and Tunis. It addresses the resistance of ...Missing: rituals | Show results with:rituals
  88. [88]
    Crafting Connections and Building Opportunities ... - Planeterra
    Jan 10, 2024 · The Community Haat Bazaar is a traditional open-air market aimed to bring the GCTN Nepal partners together and allow them to showcase their art ...
  89. [89]
    None
    Nothing is retrieved...<|separator|>
  90. [90]
    'Afghan Mandawi Bazaar' cultural and trade fair to be held in Paris
    Aug 2, 2025 · A cultural and business event aimed at supporting Afghan entrepreneurs and fostering solidarity among the Afghan diaspora will take place in ...
  91. [91]
    [PDF] On the persistence of bazaars in the newly capitalist world
    We refer here to the bazaar's capacity to evolve and adapt, providing not only always different demand-driven goods but being able to respond to cultural and ...
  92. [92]
    Turkish Market Maybachufer Berlin (2025) - Airial Travel
    The Turkish Market at Maybachufer is more than just a place to shop; it's a cultural hub in Berlin's Neukölln district, often referred to as 'Little Istanbul'.
  93. [93]
    Bazaars at crossroads. What they reveal about informality ...
    Bazaars also offer a window into globalization; besides who and what moves, how borders are negotiated by traders nuance our understanding of transnationalism.
  94. [94]
    Lawrence of Arabia (1962) - IMDb
    Rating 8.3/10 (335,205) Lawrence of Arabia: Directed by David Lean. With Peter O'Toole, Alec Guinness, Anthony Quinn, Jack Hawkins. The story of T.E. Lawrence, the English officer ...Full cast & crew · Trivia · Lawrence von Arabien · Lawrence da Arábia
  95. [95]
    The Thousand and One Nights – Introduction to World Literature ...
    ... bazaar (night having just set in) and bought a fried fish and bread and ... One Thousand and One Nights on Pioneers of Arabic Modern Plays.” Pizhūhish ...
  96. [96]
    Paul Bowles and the Sheltering Sky - A Sense of Place Magazine
    May 31, 2020 · Morocco was a place of infinite romance; of mystery and magic beyond the veil. It was this side of Morocco that Paul Bowles wrote about so well.
  97. [97]
    Orhan Pamuk's Istanbul - The New York Times
    Jan 31, 2014 · Sahaflar Carsisi, Istanbul's used-book bazaar, has been a magnet for literary types since the Byzantine era. In the early 1970s, Mr. Pamuk, then ...
  98. [98]
    [PDF] Orientalism in James Joyce's “Araby” - UQ eSpace
    The Araby Bazaar. Besides, the visiting 'splendid' (D 32) Orientalist bazaars were the realistic projection of the romanticized ideas about the Orient.
  99. [99]
    The Western Imagination of Morocco - Africa Is a Country
    Feb 17, 2015 · They stirred from the pages of “The Sheltering Sky,” Paul Bowles's existential 1940s novel of the unraveling lives of three Americans traveling ...
  100. [100]
    [PDF] Postcolonial Lack and Aesthetic Promise in Salman Rushdie's The ...
    With the image of the palimpsest, which runs throughout the novel to characterize Bombay, markets, paintings, politics, characters, and the story itself,.