Fact-checked by Grok 2 weeks ago

Carter Page

Carter Page (born June 3, 1971) is an American energy consultant and former naval officer with specialized knowledge of Russian energy markets. A graduate of the , he served as a lieutenant in the U.S. Navy from 1993 to 1998, including active duty as a surface warfare officer with deployments to the and , followed by reserve service until 2004. After leaving active duty, Page worked for seven years as an investment banker at Merrill Lynch, including postings in where he focused on energy sector deals involving Russian entities such as . In 2008, he founded Global Energy Capital, LLC, a New York-based firm providing advisory services and investment opportunities in the energy industries of emerging markets, particularly and . Page briefly advised Donald Trump's 2016 presidential campaign on foreign policy matters from March to September 2016, during which he traveled to Moscow and met with Russian officials, including a speech at the New Economic School. These activities drew attention from U.S. counterintelligence efforts, culminating in the FBI obtaining Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Act (FISA) warrants to monitor Page starting in October 2016 as part of the Crossfire Hurricane investigation into potential Trump campaign-Russia ties. The warrants were renewed three times, but a 2019 Department of Justice Inspector General review identified at least 17 significant errors, omissions, and unsupported assertions in the applications, including failures to disclose exculpatory evidence that Page had been a CIA operational contact providing information on Russian intelligence activities. Subsequently, the Justice Department conceded a lack of probable cause for two of the four warrants, leading the FISA court to invalidate them, while the Mueller investigation concluded no criminal conspiracy involving Page or the Trump campaign.

Early Life and Education

Childhood and Family Background

Carter Page was born on June 3, 1971, in , , to Allan Robert Page and Rachel (née Greenstein) Page. His mother hailed from , providing Midwestern roots to the family, while his father originated from , , and worked at Central Hudson Gas & Electric, a utility company serving the region. Page was raised in Poughkeepsie, New York, in a middle-class household shaped by his father's career in the energy sector. Public records offer scant details on his family's internal dynamics or early personal influences, with Page himself noting in later interviews a youthful emphasis on amid limited disclosures about private . This environment preceded his formal education and military path, fostering an initial awareness of practical economic structures through his father's utility employment, though no verified accounts detail specific childhood experiences with global events or at that stage.

Academic Achievements and Degrees

Carter Page graduated from the in 1993 with a degree, earning distinction as a Trident Scholar and ranking in the top 10% of his class. In 1994, while on in the Navy, Page completed a degree in national security studies at . Page later pursued advanced business education, obtaining a from New York University's Stern School of Business in 2001. He received a PhD from the of Oriental and (SOAS) at the in 2012, with a dissertation examining Russia's strategic influence on Central Asia's post-communist economic transitions, including energy sector dynamics and the balance between and . The thesis, initially submitted in 2008 and revised after two rejections by examiners who described it as verbose and conceptually vague, was ultimately approved under the supervision of Akiner following allegations by Page of examiner bias.

Military Service and Early Career


Carter Page graduated with distinction from the in 1993, ranking in the top 5% of his class and earning selection as a Scholar. Commissioned as a in the U.S. Navy, he served five years on from 1993 to 1998 in operational intelligence roles, focusing on threat analysis. His service included sea assignments and worldwide billets that honed analytical skills essential for assessing geopolitical risks.
During his tenure, Page contributed to intelligence efforts in the Western Pacific and regions amid post-Cold War transitions and regional instabilities of the . He also spent 18 months at as the Navy's representative on nuclear nonproliferation working groups, applying disciplined reasoning to strategic assessments. These experiences developed his capacity for rigorous, evidence-based evaluation of threats, free from later politicized scrutiny. Page received an honorable discharge upon completing , maintaining an unblemished service record with no disciplinary actions. His naval exemplified the and precision required in operations, laying a foundation for subsequent professional endeavors in energy and policy analysis.

Transition to Private Sector

Following his service as a U.S. Navy intelligence officer, which concluded around 2000 after five years of active duty post-graduation from the United States Naval Academy in 1993, Page transitioned to the private sector by entering investment banking. He joined Merrill Lynch's capital markets group in London in 2000, where he focused on mergers and acquisitions in emerging markets. Over the next seven years, Page's roles at the firm expanded to include positions in New York and Moscow, building his professional foundation in finance amid post-Cold War economic opportunities in Eastern Europe and Asia. Page's work at Merrill Lynch emphasized energy sector transactions, particularly in natural gas and liquefied natural gas (LNG) projects, with involvement in advisory roles for clients like Russia's state-owned on key deals. From 2004 to 2007, he served in Merrill Lynch's office, handling transactions in and that honed his expertise in resource extraction and infrastructure financing in volatile regions. This period marked his pivot toward energy consulting, leveraging analytical skills from naval intelligence to assess geopolitical risks in commodity markets, though specific performance metrics from these engagements remain limited in public industry records. By 2007, Page had relocated to as of Merrill Lynch's energy and power department, solidifying his shift from general emerging markets banking to specialized energy advisory before departing to establish his own firm. His Merrill Lynch tenure demonstrated competence in navigating complex international deals, as evidenced by sustained client engagements in high-stakes sectors, despite the firm's broader challenges during the .

Professional Career in Energy Consulting

Founding Global Energy Capital

Carter Page founded Global Energy Capital LLC in 2008, shortly after leaving his position at Merrill Lynch, creating a and targeted at opportunities in emerging markets.) Incorporated in , the firm functions as a entity and advisory service, with Page serving as managing partner alongside co-founder Sergei Yatsenko, drawing on expertise in infrastructure and related sectors. The business model of Global Energy Capital emphasizes specialized guidance for clients navigating volatile energy landscapes, including (LNG) projects and the economic consequences of geopolitical sanctions. This approach relies on empirical evaluation of market forces and risk factors, facilitating strategic decisions such as asset repositioning in response to regulatory pressures and international tensions. By focusing on pragmatic assessments rather than prescriptive ideologies, the firm has positioned itself to support divestitures and investment reallocations in high-uncertainty environments, reflecting a core emphasis on causal drivers of energy market outcomes.

Key Business Engagements and Expertise

Carter Page founded Global Energy Capital LLC in following a from Merrill Lynch, establishing it as a specialized and focused on opportunities in emerging Eurasian markets, including natural gas development and projects in . The firm advises clients on strategic entry into these regions, emphasizing and deal structuring to enable Western capital flows into undervalued assets amid geopolitical and regulatory complexities. Page's approach prioritizes empirical of market dynamics, such as capacities and export volumes, to identify viable commercial pathways independent of dominant state players. Prior to launching his firm, Page served as an investment banker at Merrill Lynch from 2004 to 2007, primarily in , where he contributed to transactions exceeding several billion dollars in value, involving transactions with Russian firms like and facilitating equity stakes for international investors in upstream and midstream projects. His roles included advising on mergers, acquisitions, and financing in the former Soviet republics, drawing on on-the-ground knowledge of local regulatory frameworks and resource endowments to bridge U.S. and European institutional investors with regional opportunities. This experience honed his expertise in Eurasian , including the assessment of LNG potentials and diversification strategies to counter supply concentration risks. Page's professional engagements extend to consulting for institutional clients on broader Eurasian energy strategies, providing data-driven insights into market liberalization and investor protections in Central Asia and the Caucasus.) He has emphasized practical facilitation of U.S. capital into these markets, citing historical transaction volumes—such as over $10 billion in deals he influenced at Merrill—as evidence of successful cross-border value creation without reliance on unsubstantiated threat narratives. His analyses often incorporate verifiable metrics like Gazprom's export shares (around 25% of Europe's gas supply in the mid-2010s) to argue for competitive reforms over isolationist policies, positioning his work as a counter to alarmist assessments lacking causal grounding in commercial realities.

Foreign Policy Views and Russia Engagements

Advocacy for U.S.-Russia Energy Cooperation

Carter Page has long positioned as a pivotal energy supplier, emphasizing its substantial production capacity and potential for collaborative ventures with the West. In a July 2016 speech at Moscow's New Economic School, he highlighted 's role as the world's largest oil producer in 2009, alongside rapid output growth in partnership with neighboring states like from 2000 to 2010, underscoring the economic rationale for integrating Russian resources into broader market dynamics. Page criticized U.S. sanctions imposed after Russia's 2014 annexation of as counterproductive, arguing they disrupted efficiencies and heightened risks of supply instability for by curtailing cooperative diversification. He contended that such measures, rooted in "sanctimonious expressions of moral superiority," impeded pragmatic bilateral engagement and failed to advance global stability, instead limiting firms' expansion into innovative production and efficiency improvements. In the same address, he noted that recent sanctions policy had "to a large extent limited these possibilities" for energy initiatives, advocating instead for mutual respect and equality to align competing economic models through private-sector incentives. Central to Page's rationale was the view that energy interdependence incentivizes cooperative behavior and diminishes conflict drivers, as evidenced by historical patterns of stabilized relations via resource linkages. He promoted lifting regulatory barriers to joint U.S.-Russia ventures, citing reduced vulnerability to supply shocks—such as Europe's pre-sanctions gas imports from averaging over 150 billion cubic meters annually—as a verifiable of integrated markets over isolationist policies. This approach, Page argued, prioritizes empirical economic gains, like enhanced efficiency and lower emissions through cross-border innovation, over ideological confrontations.

Public Statements and Criticisms of Western Policies

Carter Page has consistently criticized NATO's eastward expansion as a provocative policy that undermined post-Cold War stability. In June 2016, he publicly likened the addition of multiple new NATO members along Russia's borders to excessive force, stating, "Just as five police officers ganged up on [Eric] Garner, over a half-dozen new NATO members have expanded to Russia's border," framing the expansion as an aggressive encirclement rather than defensive necessity. Page argued this approach ignored historical assurances against such expansion given to Soviet leaders in the early 1990s, empirically contributing to heightened tensions without enhancing European security. Page has highlighted policy failures in as evidence of flawed Western strategies, pointing to the 2014 Maidan Revolution and subsequent conflict as outcomes of interventionist pressures that prioritized over pragmatic diplomacy. He contended that U.S. and EU support for Ukrainian alignment with the West exacerbated divisions, leading to Russia's annexation of and ongoing eastern hostilities, which disrupted regional energy supplies and economic ties without achieving or resolution. These critiques emphasized causal links between NATO's aspirations and retaliatory actions, contrasting with mainstream narratives attributing sole blame to Russian aggression. On sanctions, Page has opposed U.S. measures against as counterproductive moral posturing that disregards market realities. In a May 2014 analysis, he described Western sanctions—imposed following Crimea's annexation—as "sanctimonious expressions of moral superiority" that inflicted by inflating global prices and hindering cooperative in and Siberian resources. He argued these policies ignored empirical data on Russia's role in stabilizing Eurasian flows, advocating instead for pragmatic engagement to mitigate disruptions, a view he expressed in pre-2016 writings and interviews as a non-partisan alternative to hawkish .

Interactions with Russian Officials and Academics

In 2013, Page served in an informal advisory capacity to , Russia's state-owned oil company, focusing on reforms amid a potential stock deal involving . During this period, he met with , Rosneft's chief executive and a close associate of , to discuss these business matters; Page later described the interaction as brief and professional, occurring prior to his involvement with the . In a 2013 letter to the for Political Assessments, Page highlighted his role as an informal advisor to staff on economic policy preparations, including recommendations for transparency and anti-corruption measures in the energy sector, which he framed as constructive input for Russian reforms. Page's engagements extended to academic and policy discussions, reflecting his long-standing interest in U.S.- energy cooperation. Earlier experiences, such as his time studying in during the early 1990s as a U.S. officer, informed his later professional outreach, but specific interactions with academics were limited and publicly oriented. In July 2016, while affiliated with the Trump campaign, Page delivered a public lecture on global economic trends at the New Economic School in , an independent academic institution known for its economics programs. Following the speech on July 8, 2016, he met briefly with , 's Deputy Prime Minister overseeing energy and trade, to exchange views on bilateral investment opportunities; Page reported this encounter to Trump campaign officials, including and J.D. Gordon, emphasizing its overt and non-sensitive nature. These interactions, spanning business advisory work and academic exchanges, predated Page's formal role in March 2016 and involved no exchange of , as corroborated by subsequent investigations. Page's communications with contacts were consistent with his energy consulting background and advocacy for policy resets, often conducted transparently through professional channels rather than covert means. Post-campaign engagements remained sporadic and focused on similar themes, with no evidence of coordinated political activities.

Role in the 2016 Trump Campaign

Appointment as Foreign Policy Advisor

In March 2016, Carter Page was recruited by Sam Clovis, a senior policy advisor in Donald 's presidential campaign, to join the campaign's nascent team amid efforts to assemble expertise and counter criticisms of 's limited experience in international affairs. On March 21, 2016, publicly announced Page as one of several advisors during an interview with The 's editorial board, listing him alongside figures such as , , and . Page's inclusion highlighted the campaign's interest in advisors with specialized knowledge in energy and emerging markets, reflecting his background as a . Page's role remained low-profile and centered on providing input related to and U.S. economic interests abroad, consistent with the campaign's emerging "America First" orientation that emphasized restraint in overseas military engagements and prioritization of domestic priorities over expansive foreign interventions. He participated sporadically in campaign calls and meetings but held no formal staff position or authority over policy formulation. Campaign records and subsequent investigations, including the , indicate Page operated as an unpaid volunteer with peripheral involvement, attending only a handful of group discussions without direct access to senior leadership. There is no documented evidence that Page exerted influence over campaign strategy or decisions; Trump campaign officials consistently downplayed his contributions, and Page himself confirmed he had no direct communication with Trump during his tenure. This limited scope underscored the advisory team's function as a loose network of external voices rather than a centralized apparatus, with Page's expertise serving mainly to bolster the campaign's credentials in niche areas like global energy dynamics.

Moscow Trip and Subsequent Departure

In July 2016, Carter Page undertook a private trip to , where he delivered a public lecture at the New Economic School on July 7. The speech emphasized the need for mutual respect in U.S.- relations and critiqued aspects of Western sanctions policy, framing energy sector cooperation as a pathway to improved bilateral ties; it contained no references to 's presidential strategies or operations. Page funded the travel and accommodations himself, without any financial support or reimbursement from the Trump . Prior to departure, Page briefed senior campaign officials—including foreign policy advisor J.D. Gordon and, subsequently, campaign chairman Paul Manafort—on the itinerary, which centered on the scheduled academic address and related discussions with Russian energy experts and academics. Campaign leadership raised no objections and issued no instructions tying the visit to political activities, consistent with Page's informal advisory role, which involved no salary or formal directives. During the trip, Page engaged primarily with New Economic School affiliates and energy sector contacts; he later confirmed a brief, incidental greeting with Russian Deputy Prime Minister Igor Dvorkovich at an event but denied substantive meetings with senior intelligence or government figures beyond academic or professional exchanges. Media reports in September 2016 amplified questions about Page's prior professional contacts in , prompting heightened scrutiny of his advisory position despite the trip's non-campaign nature. On September 25, Page voluntarily resigned from the Trump campaign to mitigate distractions, stating in his announcement that the decision aimed to refocus attention on policy issues rather than personal associations. The resignation occurred without any internal campaign directive or allegation of misconduct related to the Moscow visit.

FBI Surveillance and the Steele Dossier Controversy

Origins of the FISA Warrants

The (FBI) first sought and obtained a (FISA) warrant targeting Carter Page on October 21, 2016, from the Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Court (FISC), designating him as an "agent of a foreign power" under 50 U.S.C. § 1801(b)(2)(E). This surveillance authorization arose within the FBI's investigation, launched in July 2016 following a tip about Trump campaign advisor George Papadopoulos's knowledge of Russian possession of damaging material on Hillary Clinton, with an individual case file on Page opened in August 2016 due to his prior Russia contacts. The initial application relied on unverified intelligence to assert probable cause that Page was knowingly engaging in clandestine intelligence activities for , though subsequent reviews highlighted procedural deficiencies from the outset. Page's FISA surveillance was extended through three renewals approved by the FISC in early 2017 (January, April, and June), each requiring a demonstration of ongoing , yet the Department of Justice later conceded that the final two renewals lacked sufficient evidentiary basis under its own standards. These extensions proceeded without substantial new corroborating evidence of Page's alleged foreign agency, amplifying concerns over the warrants' foundational reliance on preliminary suspicions rather than verified developments. The FISA applications breached the FBI's Woods procedures, established in 2002 to ensure accuracy by mandating supporting documentation for every factual claim in requests; a of Justice review identified 17 significant errors or omissions across the four Page applications, including at least seven in the initial October 2016 filing. Notably, the FBI omitted Page's prior cooperation with U.S. agencies, including his role from 2008 to 2013 as a CIA operational contact who voluntarily provided detailed information on officers' attempts, which had been deemed useful and briefed to senior officials—facts that undercut assertions of Page as a knowing asset. Such nondisclosures violated verification protocols and deprived the FISC of material context for assessment.

Role of the Steele Dossier in Applications

The , a series of reports compiled by former British intelligence officer beginning in June 2016, alleged that Carter Page had been offered a brokerage on a potential sale of a 19 percent stake in , Russia's state-owned oil company, during a July 2016 meeting in with , Rosneft's CEO and a close associate of . The reports further claimed Page discussed compromising the U.S. position on sanctions against and arrangements tied to Moscow's election interference. These assertions positioned Page as a potential Russian agent facilitating backchannel influence on the Trump campaign. Financed initially by and later by —a firm retained by the law firm on behalf of Hillary Clinton's 2016 presidential campaign and the —the constituted with an inherent adversarial bias toward the Trump campaign. The Clinton campaign and misreported payments to as "legal services," leading to a $113,000 fine in 2022 for improper disclosure of the funding used to produce the . Steele's work product reflected this political motivation, as he was compensated for delivering intelligence adverse to one side of the election. In the FBI's October 2016 FISA warrant application targeting Page—and its three renewals through June 2017—the dossier's allegations served as central evidence to establish that Page was a , despite the FBI's inability to corroborate any specific substantive claims against him prior to or during the applications. FBI officials incorporated Steele's reporting without fully disclosing to the FISA court its uncorroborated status, Steele's potential biases as a paid , or exculpatory information about Page, such as his prior cooperation with the CIA on matters. Declassified footnotes from the 2019 Department of Justice report by Michael Horowitz revealed that the FBI knew of significant credibility issues with the dossier's primary sub-source, —including his history of providing unsubstantiated rumors and fabricating certain sub-sources—yet proceeded with the applications without adequate verification or disclosure. Danchenko, a with ties to U.S. contacts, later faced in 2021 for allegedly lying to the FBI about the origins of his information fed to Steele, underscoring the dossier's reliance on unvetted hearsay that undermined its evidentiary weight.

Key Investigation Findings

Mueller Report Conclusions on Page

The Special Counsel's investigation, detailed in Volume I of the report released on March 7, 2019, found insufficient evidence to establish that Carter Page conspired or coordinated with the Russian government in its efforts to interfere in the 2016 U.S. presidential election. This assessment encompassed Page's prior professional contacts in Russia and his activities during the campaign period, including his July 2016 trip to Moscow, but yielded no basis for criminal charges against him. Page's Moscow meetings with officials such as of and Sergey Ivanov, a advisor, were scrutinized for potential links to election interference, yet the report determined these interactions occurred independently of any directive or knowledge from the that would constitute coordination. Page had informed advisors Sam Clovis and J.D. Gordon about the planned trip in advance and shared afterward, including a briefing to senior officials, but investigators uncovered no that the tasked Page with advancing interests or that his actions advanced a joint effort to influence the election. The report's examination of Page's conduct implicitly undermined unsubstantiated allegations from the —such as claims of Page securing a brokerage fee or equity stake in —by noting the absence of corroborating evidence for such transactions or their connection to campaign objectives. Overall, the lack of findings tying Page's behavior to or knowing assistance in Russia's interference activities led to his exclusion from indictments, highlighting the investigation's determination that his role did not meet the threshold for prosecutable offenses.

Horowitz IG Report on FISA Abuses

In December 2019, the U.S. Department of Justice Office of the Inspector General (OIG), under Michael Horowitz, released a report examining the FBI's investigation, with a focused review of the four (FISA) applications targeting Carter Page between October 2016 and September 2017. The report identified at least 17 significant inaccuracies and omissions in these applications—seven in the initial and accumulating to 17 across all renewals—violating internal FBI verification procedures known as Woods procedures, which require factual support for every claim in FISA submissions. These flaws included repeated failures to disclose contradictory or exculpatory information about Page, such as his prior role as an approved CIA operational contact who had provided information on intelligence efforts, which contradicted portrayals of him as a potential asset. Central to the applications was unverified reporting from the , which alleged Page served as an intermediary for bribery schemes; the OIG found the FBI lacked any corroboration for these specific claims against Page at the time of reliance, despite internal awareness of Steele's potential biases and the dossier's partisan funding origins. One documented alteration involved an FBI attorney modifying a CIA to falsely indicate Page had never been a CIA , obscuring exculpatory details that could have weakened assertions and breaching the FBI's duty of candor to the FISA Court. Additional omissions encompassed Page's denials of during FBI interviews and inconsistencies in handling, contributing to applications that omitted material facts undermining the dossier's credibility. While the OIG concluded there was no documentary or testimonial evidence of or improper motivation in initiating or seeking Page's FISA warrants, it emphasized egregious performance lapses, including inadequate supervisory oversight and verification, that eroded the integrity of the process. These institutional shortcomings persisted across renewals, with errors compounding despite opportunities for correction, revealing deficiencies in FBI compliance rather than isolated . The report rejected claims of a politically motivated "" in the probe's origins but substantiated misconduct in FISA handling, as the inaccuracies collectively rested the applications' foundation on unvetted and incomplete evidence. To address these failures, the OIG issued recommendations for FBI reforms, including mandatory performance reviews for personnel involved in FISA preparation and approvals, enhanced on candor obligations, and systemic improvements to Woods procedures for documenting and verifying factual assertions. Empirical analysis in the demonstrated that, absent the flaws, the applications' claims—predominantly reliant on the uncorroborated —lacked sufficient independent validation, prompting subsequent FISA directives for the FBI to re-interview sources and broader .

Senate Intelligence Committee Assessment

The bipartisan Senate Select Committee on Intelligence (SSCI), in Volume 5 of its report on active measures and interference in the 2016 U.S. election, released on August 18, 2020, examined threats and vulnerabilities associated with the Trump campaign, including Carter Page's role as a advisor announced on March 21, 2016. The assessment, drawing from over 200 witness interviews, more than a million pages of documents, and raw U.S. rather than primary reliance on the Steele dossier, detailed Page's prior ties—such as his 2003–2007 residence in , work with via Merrill Lynch, and 2013 interactions with officers identified in a 2015 U.S. —but found no definitive evidence that he served as a witting or cooptee. Page's pro- views and expertise positioned him as a likely target of interest, creating notable vulnerabilities for the campaign due to inadequate vetting of personnel. The report confirmed Page's July 2016 Moscow trip involved a brief exchange with Deputy Prime Minister at the New Economic School and meetings with executive Andrey Baranov, alongside a December 2016 dinner with Dvorkovich, but uncorroborated U.S. assessments of higher-level contacts with ( CEO) or Sergey Divyekin ( internal affairs official) as alleged in unverified reports. Page's accounts exhibited discrepancies, including denials of significant interactions, vague references to "incredible insights" from officials, and incomplete itineraries, which fueled suspicions but lacked resolution through committee review. Despite these contacts and a April 10, 2016, Skype discussion with on Russia outreach, the SSCI found no evidence of Page providing substantive contributions to the Trump , sharing sensitive information with entities, or engaging in coordinated election influence efforts. Critiquing FBI procedures under (opened July 31, 2016), the report highlighted overreliance on uncorroborated allegations in FISA applications for Page, procedural errors, and incomplete documentation in renewals, as later echoed in the DOJ General's findings, though it affirmed an independent basis for initial concerns stemming from Page's pre-campaign history with Russian approaches dating to 2008–2013. Overall, while Page's activities presented attractive targets for foreign influence and justified scrutiny, the committee concluded there was no corroborated coordination or conspiracy between Page, the Trump campaign, and to interfere in the election. This balanced view, grounded in primary and testimony, contrasted with media narratives amplifying dossier claims without similar verification.

Lawsuits Against Media Outlets

In September , Carter Page filed a lawsuit in against Inc., the parent company of and , alleging that eleven articles published between September 2016 and January falsely depicted him as a asset seeking to influence the 2016 U.S. . The complaint asserted that the reports, which referenced unverified allegations from the , constituted reckless falsehoods by implying Page had met with officials to discuss lifting sanctions and compromising material on , leading to severe reputational damage, professional ostracism, and death threats. Page sought compensatory and exceeding $75,000, arguing the outlets failed to verify sources and amplified defamatory claims despite his public denials. Oath Inc. moved to dismiss under Delaware's anti-SLAPP statute, which protects against strategic lawsuits aimed at chilling protected speech, and contended the articles were or fair reporting on matters of public concern. In February 2021, Karsnitz granted the motion, ruling that Page, as a limited-purpose on Russia-related issues, had not met the heightened pleading standard under New York Times v. Sullivan by alleging facts showing —knowledge of falsity or reckless disregard for the truth. The judge further found the articles non-actionable as they relied on attributed sources and subsequent events, including FISA warrants, lent initial plausibility to the claims at the time of publication. Page appealed to the , which heard oral arguments in October 2021 and affirmed the dismissal in January 2022. The high court held that the lower court's anti-SLAPP application was proper, the articles were protected opinion or neutral reportage, and Page's pro se amended complaint still failed to plead with particularity, emphasizing First safeguards for reporting on government investigations. No further appeals against Oath Inc. were reported, though Page has cited the case in subsequent advocacy to critique media amplification of unvetted intelligence allegations later undermined by inspector general findings. A related 2019 federal lawsuit by Page against the U.S. Agency for Global Media, encompassing , alleged over 2017 reports echoing dossier claims of Page's Russian ties; it was dismissed in federal court for similar failure to state a claim, with no successful . These outcomes reflect judicial deference to journalistic protections amid public-figure status, despite post hoc validations of Page's innocence in official probes.

Suit Against DNC and Fusion GPS Associates

In October 2017, Carter Page filed a defamation lawsuit in the U.S. District Court for the Western District of Oklahoma against the Democratic National Committee (DNC), alleging that the organization funded opposition research through the law firm Perkins Coie, which retained Fusion GPS to produce the Steele dossier containing false claims about Page's Russian ties. The suit contended that this effort constituted a coordinated hoax aimed at influencing the 2016 U.S. presidential election by disseminating unverified smears portraying Page as an unregistered foreign agent. The complaint specified that , hired by the and the campaign, subcontracted —a firm specializing in —which then engaged to compile a series of memos alleging Page's involvement in illicit dealings with officials, including discussions of sanctions relief and energy deals. Page argued these allegations were fabricated or recklessly false, forming part of a racketeering-like pattern of partisan interference, with associates playing a central role in propagating the material to media outlets and government entities despite lacking corroboration. The Oklahoma court dismissed the case in January 2019 for lack of over the defendants, ruling that Page failed to establish sufficient ties to the forum. Undeterred, Page refiled a similar defamation action on January 30, 2020, in the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of Illinois, again targeting the and partners and for orchestrating the funding chain to and enabling the spread of dossier claims. U.S. District Judge dismissed the 2020 suit on August 17, 2020, on grounds of insufficient for , deeming "stateless" for diversity purposes and the claims too attenuated from activities. The Seventh of Appeals affirmed the dismissal on June 21, 2021, emphasizing that Page's state-law claims did not invoke and lacked adequate venue ties. The U.S. denied on January 10, 2022, ending the litigation without reaching the merits of the or allegations. Although procedural barriers precluded substantive rulings, the suits empirically documented the dossier's origins as DNC-funded opposition research via Perkins Coie to Fusion GPS, underscoring its partisan commissioning rather than independent verification, with Steele's memos relying on unconfirmed hearsay that targeted Page as a vulnerability in the Trump campaign. This chain of custody revealed tactics centered on amplifying unvetted narratives to shape public and official perceptions during the election.

Claims Against DOJ, FBI, and Officials

In November 2019, Carter Page initiated a Bivens action in the U.S. District Court for the District of Columbia against former FBI Director , former Deputy Director , and several other FBI officials, including and Lisa Page, alleging and Fourth Amendment violations stemming from the FISA surveillance warrants obtained against him in 2016 and 2017. The complaint asserted that the defendants knowingly included false statements and omitted material exculpatory information in the FISA applications, resulting in unwarranted electronic surveillance and disclosure of private communications without , which the U.S. Department of Justice later conceded for the final two warrant renewals in a January 2020 filing to the Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Court. Page sought compensatory and , arguing the actions constituted intentional overreach beyond protections. The district court dismissed Page's second amended complaint in early 2023, ruling that his FISA unauthorized-disclosure and misuse claims were time-barred under the statute's two-year limit, that Bivens remedies did not extend to the alleged FISA and violations due to alternative remedial schemes and separation-of-powers concerns, and that the abuse-of-process claims failed to state a viable . Page appealed to the U.S. Court of Appeals for the D.C. Circuit, which on May 23, 2025, affirmed the dismissal in a per curiam opinion, upholding the time-bar on FISA claims (accrued from warrant issuance dates in 2016–2017) and rejecting extension of Bivens liability for national-security surveillance contexts, while noting the complaint's allegations of procedural irregularities but deeming them insufficient for constitutional relief absent congressional authorization. On September 30, 2025, Page filed an application with the U.S. for a 75-day extension to petition for a writ of certiorari, arguing that the FISA abuses—corroborated by the Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Court's findings of Procedures violations and inaccurate certifications—warranted review to establish accountability mechanisms for executive-branch surveillance overreach lacking , potentially extending Bivens precedents like to deter future constitutional infringements. The application emphasized that without judicial redress, officials face no personal consequences for misleading FISA courts, as evidenced by the government's admissions of deficiencies in the Page warrants. As of October 2025, the extension request remained pending, with Page contending it addresses a on remedies for FISA-related rights deprivations.

Publications and Ongoing Advocacy

Scholarly and Policy Writings

Carter Page earned a PhD in international relations from the School of Oriental and African Studies (SOAS) at the University of London in 2012, with a dissertation examining the economic transitions of Central Asian states from communism to capitalism. The work, initially submitted in 2008 and revised after examiners cited issues with verbosity and vagueness, analyzed post-Soviet market reforms, resource dependencies, and geopolitical implications for energy sectors in the region. Page's thesis emphasized empirical data on trade patterns and investment flows, arguing that heavy-handed external interventions often exacerbated economic distortions rather than fostering sustainable growth. In the 2010s, Page contributed policy-oriented articles to the Global Policy Journal, focusing on energy geopolitics and realist critiques of Western sanctions regimes. In a 2015 piece ahead of the Paris climate talks, he advocated for market-driven approaches to sustainable energy, critiquing supply-side restrictions as counterproductive to global resource allocation. Another article that year, titled "New Slaves, Global Edition: Russia, Iran and the Segregation of the World Economy," applied first-principles analysis to U.S.-led sanctions, positing they segmented global markets and hindered efficient energy trade without achieving policy goals. Page drew on primary trade data and historical precedents to contend that such measures reinforced state monopolies in sanctioned economies, echoing themes from his dissertation on interventionist pitfalls in transitioning markets. Page's writings consistently reflected a realist orientation, prioritizing causal links between energy resources, state power, and international stability over ideological sanctions. In a post-2014 analysis for Global Policy Journal, he attributed conflict dynamics to expansion and energy disputes rather than unilateral aggression, citing declassified diplomatic cables and commodity price indices as evidence. This body of work demonstrated continuity in his empirical skepticism toward coercive economic tools, informed by granular data on Eurasian pipelines and investment flows, which he argued often backfired by entrenching adversarial alliances.

Recent Developments and Public Commentary

In 2024, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the D.C. Circuit heard arguments in Page's lawsuit against former FBI Director James Comey and other officials, alleging violations of his privacy rights through flawed FISA surveillance applications, with judges appearing receptive to reviving the $75 million claim previously dismissed by a lower court. On May 23, 2025, the D.C. Circuit issued an opinion affirming the district court's dismissal of Page's second amended complaint for failure to state a claim under the Privacy Act and related statutes, prompting Page to seek Supreme Court review. By September 30, 2025, Page filed an application for an extension to petition the Supreme Court, framing the case as emblematic of unaddressed government overreach in warrant processes. These developments highlight enduring disputes over accountability for intelligence abuses, with Page publicly positioning them as evidence of incomplete institutional reforms. Page has sustained advocacy via social media, using his X (formerly ) platform to critique perceived shortcomings in post-Horowitz FBI restructuring, asserting that incremental measures like enhanced verification protocols do not sufficiently deter politicized investigations or restore constitutional safeguards. His posts emphasize repairing trust through rigorous adherence to , often referencing the FISA errors in his as a cautionary example of broader "" encroachments on , without facing institutional repercussions for involved agents. In this vein, Page has called for empirical scrutiny of reform efficacy, arguing that absent fundamental changes—such as mandatory independent audits of politically sensitive probes—recurrences remain probable based on historical patterns of non-compliance. Amid the ongoing conflict, Page has reiterated data-informed realist perspectives on U.S.- relations, contending that interventionist policies overlook verifiable geopolitical incentives and risk escalation without proportional strategic gains, drawing from prior analyses of energy dependencies and post-Cold War dynamics. This stance contrasts with prevailing narratives in mainstream outlets, which Page attributes to biased framing that downplays empirical failures in sanctions and support efficacy, as evidenced by stalled territorial outcomes and economic interdependencies persisting into 2024. His commentary underscores causal factors like 's resource leverage over , advocating grounded in observable bilateral trade data rather than ideological commitments.

References

  1. [1]
    Who Is Carter Page and Why Is the FBI Surveilling Him? - Newsweek
    Apr 12, 2017 · Carter Page: A Brief History​​ Carter Page was born in Minnesota on June 3, 1971. Raised in Poughkeepsie, New York, he went on to enlist in the U ...
  2. [2]
    10 Things You Didn't Know About Carter Page
    Apr 19, 2017 · 1. Carter Page was born on June 3, 1971, in Minneapolis to Allan and Rachel Greenstein Page. · 2. He is a graduate of the U.S. Naval Academy, and ...
  3. [3]
    [PDF] FISA Warrant Application for Carter Page
    Feb 20, 2020 · Accordh1g to Page's biography on GE C's website, Page is a graduate of the United States Naval. Academy and has a background in investment ...
  4. [4]
    Meet Carter
    In addition to multiple tours in the Middle East and Europe as a U.S. Navy surface warfare officer, Carter previously served as the Navy's working group ...
  5. [5]
    Why Carter Page Was Worth Watching - POLITICO Magazine
    Feb 3, 2018 · He spent five years in the navy and served as a Marine intelligence officer in the western Sahara. During his navy days, he spent lavishly and ...
  6. [6]
    [PDF] TESTIMONY OF CARTER PAGE - House Intelligence Committee
    Nov 2, 2017 · I would like to welcome our witness, Dr. Carter Page. Thank you for being with us today. As a reminder to our members, we are and will ...Missing: biography | Show results with:biography
  7. [7]
    IG Footnotes: Serious Problems with Dossier Sources Didn't Stop ...
    Apr 15, 2020 · That same day, the FISA warrant against Page was renewed for the first time. A similar U.S. intelligence report arrived on February 28, 2017 ...
  8. [8]
    Justice Dept. Admitted it Lacked Probable Cause in Carter Page FISAs
    Jan 23, 2020 · The Justice Department (DOJ) has acknowledged that it lacked probable cause to surveil former Trump campaign aide Carter Page in at least two of four warrant ...
  9. [9]
    Carter Page Biography - Facts, Childhood, Family Life & Achievements
    Nov 14, 2022 · Carter Page was born on June 3, 1971, in Minneapolis, Minnesota, to Rachel Page (Greenstein) and Allan Robert Page. He grew up in ...
  10. [10]
    Carter Page | Military Wiki | Fandom
    Carter Page was born in Minneapolis, Minnesota, on June 3, 1971, the son of Allan Robert Page and Rachel (Greenstein) Page. His father was from Galway, New York ...Missing: family background
  11. [11]
    Carter Page - Politicon
    A graduate of the U.S. Naval Academy and a successful businessman, he even served his country clandestinely as a source for America's intelligence services. But ...
  12. [12]
    Carter Page (2016 Donald Trump presidential campaign staff member)
    Education: •United States Naval Academy •New York ... Carter Page was a Trident Scholar and distinguished graduate of the United States Naval Academy.
  13. [13]
    [PDF] The curious journey of Carter Page, the former Trump adviser who ...
    Page 1. Style. The curious journey of Carter. Page, the former Trump adviser who can't stay out of the spotlight. By Dan Zak November 16. Carter Page ... history ...Missing: biography | Show results with:biography
  14. [14]
    How Did Carter Page Get a PhD from SOAS? - Opinio Juris
    Dec 22, 2017 · Page “knew next to nothing” about social science and seemed “unfamiliar with basic concepts like Marxism or state capitalism,” the professor ...
  15. [15]
    Carter Page's PhD and the silence of SOAS - Kenn Nakata Steffensen
    Dec 30, 2017 · Page's thesis, The influence of semiperipheral powers on the balance between capitalism and socialism in Central Asia: an analysis of Russia's ...
  16. [16]
    Ex-Trump adviser Carter Page accused academics who twice failed ...
    Dec 22, 2017 · Page's 'verbose' and 'vague' thesis was failed twice at University of London before finally succeeding in 2011.
  17. [17]
    'Vague and verbose': Professor who failed Carter Page twice ...
    When former Trump 2016 foreign policy advisor Carter Page's Ph.D. thesis was twice rejected by a London academic committee, he accused them of being biased ...
  18. [18]
    Carter Page: Who is he and why is he important? - USA Today
    Feb 6, 2018 · Born in Minneapolis and raised in Poughkeepsie, N.Y., Page graduated in 1993 from the Naval Academy in Annapolis, Md. He worked for seven years ...Missing: childhood family background
  19. [19]
    [PDF] Page-oath.pdf - Courthouse News Service
    Jul 27, 2020 · Plaintiff Dr. Carter Page is a natural person who is a citizen and domiciliary of the State of Oklahoma. Dr. Page is a distinguished graduate of ...
  20. [20]
    How Carter Page Ended up Under FBI Surveillance on Russia ...
    Jul 23, 2018 · In 1993, Page graduated from the US Naval Academy. He served in the ... He also has degrees from New York University and SOAS University of London ...Missing: Georgetown | Show results with:Georgetown<|separator|>
  21. [21]
    Who is Carter Page and what does he have to do with the Russia ...
    Feb 5, 2018 · He served aboard an ammo ship and a frigate for three years, attended Surface Warfare Officers School in Rhode Island for two stints totaling ...
  22. [22]
    Presidential Campaigns Should Welcome Counterintelligence ...
    The FBI noticed that Page, a former naval intelligence officer, was interacting with Mr. ... That doesn't mean that the FBI was directly spying on Carter Page ...
  23. [23]
    Provocations: Will the other shoe drop? (DAVID NEESE COLUMN ...
    Carter Page was, from the very beginning, an ... Patrick Moynihan. He'd served five years active duty in Naval intelligence with the top security clearances such ...
  24. [24]
    Carter Page: the Saga of a Trump Adviser Who Came in FBI ...
    Apr 20, 2017 · Page lived in Moscow in the early 2000s, when he was an investment banker for Merrill Lynch. ... Navy for five years after graduating from the ...Missing: career Wall Street transition
  25. [25]
    Carter Page - KeyWiki
    Jan 14, 2020 · In 2000, Page took up investment banking, getting a job at Merrill Lynch's capital-markets group in London. After impressing a colleague ...Missing: Wall | Show results with:Wall
  26. [26]
    Who is Carter Page? | CNN Politics
    Mar 4, 2017 · Page worked for seven years as an investment banker at Merrill Lynch, which his biography said took him to London, New York and Moscow ...Missing: Wall | Show results with:Wall
  27. [27]
    Trump Russia Adviser Carter Page Interview - Bloomberg.com
    Mar 30, 2016 · A globe-trotting American investment banker who's built a career on deals with Russia and its state-run gas company, Carter Page says his ...
  28. [28]
    Trump adviser's Russia credentials come under scrutiny | Reuters
    Aug 24, 2016 · Carter Page, who worked in Russia at U.S. investment bank Merrill ... Page also said he worked on deals in central Asia. Two sources ...<|separator|>
  29. [29]
    The Mystery of Trump's Man in Moscow: Carter Page - Politico
    Sep 23, 2016 · Page was a vice president at Merrill Lynch in Moscow, which sounds senior but is a common title in the finance world; a big firm like Merrill ...Missing: Wall navy
  30. [30]
    Trump adviser's public comments, ties to Moscow stir unease in both ...
    Aug 5, 2016 · After he left Moscow, Page worked as chief operating officer of Merrill Lynch's energy and power department in New York. Later, he set up Global ...Missing: transition | Show results with:transition
  31. [31]
    Carter Page, Trump Aide With Russia Ties, Is Also an Energy ...
    Page obtained his PhD at the University of London's School of Oriental and African Studies (SOAS). While there, he wrote a dissertation published in 2011 ...
  32. [32]
    Global Energy Capital - Crunchbase Company Profile & Funding
    Carter Page: Founder & Managing partner. Details. Legal Name Global Energy Capital LLC. Operating Status Active. Company Type For Profit. Founders Carter Page.
  33. [33]
    Carter Page - Wikipedia
    Military service. Allegiance, United States. Branch/service, United States Navy. Years of service, 1993–98 (Navy) 1998–2004 (Navy Reserve). Rank, Lieutenant ...Life and career · Mueller report findings · Horowitz report findings · Lawsuits
  34. [34]
    Trump's Russia adviser criticizes U.S. for 'hypocritical focus on ...
    Jul 7, 2016 · ... sanctimonious expressions of moral superiority stand at the root of many problems seen worldwide today.” Donald Trump's favorite dictators. Page ...
  35. [35]
    Carter Page rips 'sleazeball' spy behind Trump dossier
    Jan 6, 2018 · Carter Page rips 'sleazeball' spy behind Trump dossier. By. Paul ... He explains that slapping sanctions on Russia is “counterproductive ...
  36. [36]
    FBI Interest in Trump Aide Carter Page Predated Campaign
    Sep 19, 2018 · ... U.S.-Russia relations and criticized the U.S. sanctions on Russia as “sanctimonious expressions of moral superiority.” In numerous ...
  37. [37]
    Memos Allege Coordination Between Rosneft, Trump Ally Carter Page
    Jan 27, 2017 · A US official serving in Russia while Page worked at Merrill Lynch in Moscow told Isikoff that Page "was pretty much a brazen apologist for ...
  38. [38]
    A Trump Adviser Once Compared Sanctions Against Russia To ...
    Jun 21, 2016 · Just as five police officers ganged up on [Eric] Garner, over a half-dozen new NATO members have expanded to Russia's border," Carter Page wrote
  39. [39]
    Carter Page Touted Kremlin Contacts in 2013 Letter - Time Magazine
    Feb 3, 2018 · Two months after his meeting with the FBI, Page sent the letter claiming to be a Kremlin adviser. In addition to his work as an energy ...
  40. [40]
    Carter Page acknowledges working as informal adviser to Russia
    Jul 22, 2018 · Page acknowledged under questioning from Tapper that “there may have been a loose conversation” with Russian officials about U.S. sanctions ...
  41. [41]
    In angry letter, Page discloses 'brief interactions' with Russian official
    May 9, 2017 · Former Trump campaign adviser Carter Page told Senate investigators that he had “brief interactions” several years ago with a Russian official.Missing: supplier | Show results with:supplier
  42. [42]
    Timeline of Carter Page's Contacts with Russia [Updated]
    Feb 5, 2018 · Politico notes that when Page founded an investment fund called Global Energy Capital in 2008, former Gazprom executive Sergei Yatsenko served ...
  43. [43]
    [PDF] Report on the Investigation into Russian Interference in the 2016 ...
    Mar 7, 2019 · Page, The Lecture of Trump's Advisor Carter Page in Moscow, YouTube ... In July 2016, after returning from Russia, Page traveled to the ...
  44. [44]
    Carter Page met with Russian official during 2016 trip to Moscow
    Nov 4, 2017 · Carter Page met with Russian Deputy Prime Minister Arkady Dvorkovich while in Moscow in July 2016, the former foreign policy adviser to Donald Trump's campaign ...
  45. [45]
    Who is Carter Page? - CBS News
    Feb 2, 2018 · One campaign official said Page was recruited by Sam Clovis, an Iowa Republican operative who ran the Trump campaign's policy shop and is now a ...
  46. [46]
    US Sought to Monitor Trump Adviser Carter Page Last Summer
    Apr 11, 2017 · It's unclear how Page got connected with the Trump campaign. One campaign official said Page was recruited by Sam Clovis, an Iowa Republican ...
  47. [47]
    Donald Trump unveils foreign policy advisers | CNN Politics
    Mar 21, 2016 · Donald Trump on Monday finally named several members of his team of foreign policy advisers in a meeting with The Washington Post's editorial board.
  48. [48]
    Trump names foreign policy team members - Politico
    Mar 21, 2016 · Those named by Trump include counterterrorism expert Walid Phares; Carter Page, a long-time energy industry consultant; George Papadopoulos ("an ...
  49. [49]
    US Election 2016: Donald Trump names foreign policy advisers - BBC
    Mar 21, 2016 · On Monday, Mr Trump named retired Lt Gen Keith Kellogg, Carter Page, George Papadopoulos, Walid Phares and retired Gen Joseph Schmitz.
  50. [50]
    Carter Page Is Latest Ex-Trump Campaign Official Called a ...
    Nov 8, 2017 · "It was a volunteer position. And again, no activity was ever done in an official capacity on behalf of the campaign."" Still, Page and ...
  51. [51]
    Carter Page: I've never communicated with Trump - POLITICO
    Feb 6, 2018 · Page reportedly previously told congressional investigators that he never met the president. Both assertions seem to run counter to comments ...Missing: realism | Show results with:realism
  52. [52]
    Carter Page dodges questions on Russian meddling but maintains ...
    Jun 1, 2017 · Carter Page tells "CBS This Morning" any reports of interactions with Russian agents are "completely false and misleading"
  53. [53]
    Trump Foreign Policy Adviser Calls For 'Mutual Respect' in Moscow ...
    Jul 7, 2016 · Carter Page, an investment banker and specialist in energy policy, is the Republican presidential candidate's chief adviser on Russia and energy ...Missing: cooperation | Show results with:cooperation
  54. [54]
    Trump's foreign policy adviser will talk about his ... - The Guardian
    Jul 7, 2016 · Trump's foreign policy adviser will talk about his foreign policy – just not today. This article is more than 9 years old. Carter Page offered ...
  55. [55]
    Carter Page details 2016 trip to Russia in new book - Axios
    Aug 23, 2020 · "I ran the invitation by Corey Lewandowski to make sure that the campaign didn't see any issues with it..."
  56. [56]
  57. [57]
    Carter Page Coordinated Russia Trip With Top Trump Campaign ...
    Nov 7, 2017 · Former Trump campaign volunteer Carter Page told a House committee he sought permission for a July 2016 trip to Moscow from senior Trump campaign officials.
  58. [58]
    Trump campaign approved adviser's trip to Moscow - POLITICO
    Mar 7, 2017 · Carter Page delivers a lecture in Moscow on July 7, 2016. A White House official said campaign officials did not discuss foreign policy ...
  59. [59]
    Carter Page tells Congress of contact with Russian official during ...
    Nov 7, 2017 · In a statement prepared for the committee, Page insisted that he had no personal information that the Russian government or anyone affiliated ...
  60. [60]
    Trump Campaign Adviser Met With Russian Officials in 2016
    Nov 3, 2017 · Carter Page, a foreign policy adviser to the Trump presidential campaign, met Russian government officials during a July 2016 trip he took to Moscow.<|separator|>
  61. [61]
    Trump Campaign Adviser Steps Down While Disputing Claims Of ...
    Sep 26, 2016 · One of Donald Trump's foreign policy advisers said Monday he was stepping down from the campaign, while pushing back on allegations that he had engaged in ...
  62. [62]
    Former Trump adviser Carter Page has a story that doesn't ... - BBC
    Nov 7, 2017 · Carter Page, a 46-year-old energy industry consultant with longstanding ties to Russia, has become one of the quirkier figures to emerge ...Missing: Fortune 500
  63. [63]
    [PDF] carter page fisa documents - The New York Times
    Oct 7, 2016 · (X) Page's Connections to Russia and the RIS. (SXF) Page, a U.S. citizen, is the founder and managing partner of Global. Energy Capital LLC (GEC) ...
  64. [64]
    [PDF] Review of Four FISA Applications and Other Aspects of the FBI's ...
    Dec 11, 2019 · We also removed redactions throughout the report related to the dates the Carter Page FISA applications were filed and the dates FISA authority ...Missing: timeline | Show results with:timeline
  65. [65]
    DOJ's Inspector General Report: Myths and Facts on Russia Inquiry ...
    Dec 10, 2019 · In July 2018, DOJ disclosed redacted versions of Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Act (FISA) warrant applications for the surveillance of Page.
  66. [66]
    Carter Page FISA warrant lacked probable cause, DOJ admits in ...
    Jan 23, 2020 · The June 2017 Page FISA warrant renewal, which was among the two deemed invalid by the DOJ, was approved by then-Acting FBI Director (and now ...
  67. [67]
    Warrants to Spy on Trump Campaign Lacked Probable Cause, DOJ ...
    Jan 30, 2020 · With respect to the warrants to spy on Page, the first application in October 2016 was signed by then-FBI Director James Comey and then-Deputy ...Missing: origins | Show results with:origins
  68. [68]
    The FBI's FISA Mess | Lawfare
    Oct 5, 2021 · ... probable cause determinations. In other words, unlike the Carter Page renewal applications, none of the approved applications would have ...
  69. [69]
    On the Inspector General Report on Russia Investigation and FISA
    Dec 10, 2019 · ... FBI opened a FISA warrant on Carter Page. ... Another disturbing finding in the report is that the FBI recorded Page and Papadopoulos before the ...
  70. [70]
    Taking a closer look at the 'Steele dossier' and Carter Page's warrant
    Jan 5, 2018 · The dossier claims that Page met with Russians and discussed quid-pro-quo deals relating to sanctions and Russia's interference in the election.
  71. [71]
    Fact-checking Republicans' claims about 'false information' in ... - CNN
    Jun 14, 2019 · How was it used by the FBI? There were also claims in the dossier about Trump campaign adviser Carter Page and his Russian ties. The FBI used ...
  72. [72]
    Carter Page denies FBI claims he was Russian agent - BBC
    Jul 22, 2018 · Documents show the FBI believed Carter Page was "collaborating and conspiring" with Russia in 2016.
  73. [73]
    DNC, Clinton campaign agree to Steele dossier funding fine
    Mar 31, 2022 · Hillary Clinton's 2016 presidential campaign and the Democratic National Committee have agreed to pay $113000 to settle a Federal Election ...
  74. [74]
    FEC fines Clinton and DNC for misreporting Steele dossier funding
    Mar 30, 2022 · The Federal Election Commission (FEC) has fined Hillary Clinton's 2016 presidential campaign and the Democratic National Committee for not properly disclosing ...
  75. [75]
    Clinton campaign, DNC fined by FEC for lying about Steele dossier ...
    Mar 30, 2022 · The Federal Election Commission has fined both Hillary Clinton's 2016 presidential campaign and the Democratic National Committee for lying about how they ...
  76. [76]
    IG's Report Reveals 4 Spurious Allegations as Basis for FBI Spying ...
    Dec 12, 2019 · Horowitz's report exposes 17 flagrant errors, omissions, and misstatements in the four FISA applications related to Page, any one of which ...
  77. [77]
    Newly Declassified Document Indicates FBI Misled Congress on ...
    Aug 9, 2020 · A newly declassified FBI document that indicates the Bureau misled the Senate Intelligence Committee in 2018 about the Steele dossier's Primary Sub-source.
  78. [78]
    Arrest illustrates how Steele dossier was political dirty trick by Hillary ...
    Nov 4, 2021 · Special counsel John Durham's indictment of Igor Danchenko, the principal source for the bogus Steele dossier used by the FBI as a basis for the Trump-Russia ...<|control11|><|separator|>
  79. [79]
    Read the full DOJ inspector general's report on the FBI's Russia probe
    Dec 9, 2019 · The report outlines at least 17 “significant errors or omissions” in FISA ... Carter Page, but does not claim that intentional misconduct occurred ...
  80. [80]
    [PDF] Office of the Inspector General United States Department of Justice ...
    Dec 18, 2019 · Shortly after opening the Carter Page investigation in August 2016, the Crossfire Hurricane team discussed the possible use of FISA-authorized ...Missing: timeline | Show results with:timeline
  81. [81]
  82. [82]
    [PDF] IG Report Confirms Schiff FISA Memo Media Praised Was Riddled ...
    A salacious and unverified dossier formed an essential part of the application to secure a warrant against a Trump campaign affiliate named Carter Page.
  83. [83]
    Former FBI attorney to plead guilty for altering email in Russia probe
    Aug 14, 2020 · A former FBI attorney is preparing to plead guilty to altering an email used to obtain a surveillance warrant on former Trump campaign aide ...
  84. [84]
    Kevin Clinesmith, FBI lawyer accused of altering Carter Page FISA ...
    Aug 14, 2020 · Clinesmith in 2017 altered an email from the CIA that the FBI used to obtain court approval to wiretap Mr. Page. Mr. Horowitz had referred Mr.
  85. [85]
    [PDF] Inspector General report on FBI's FISA abuse tells us one thing
    Sep 4, 2025 · The IG found that FBI agents were “unable to corroborate any of the specific substantive allegations against Carter Page” in the Steele dossier ...
  86. [86]
    'No political bias' in FBI probe of Trump campaign - BBC
    Dec 9, 2019 · A US watchdog has found no evidence of political bias when the FBI launched an inquiry into the 2016 Trump campaign, despite "serious ...
  87. [87]
    How Old Claims Compare to IG Report - FactCheck.org
    Dec 10, 2019 · The report found no “documentary or testimonial evidence that political bias or improper motivation” influenced the opening of the investigation ...
  88. [88]
    Inspector general's report on Russia probe: Key takeaways - Politico
    Dec 9, 2019 · Horowitz found the Crossfire Hurricane team omitted several important details from its applications for a FISA warrant on Page, “including ...
  89. [89]
    [PDF] Statement of Michael E. Horowitz Inspector General, U.S. ...
    Apr 27, 2023 · We identified 17 significant inaccuracies and omissions in the four applications -- 7 in the first FISA application and a total of. 17 by the ...
  90. [90]
    FISA court issues rare order to DOJ, FBI following scathing ...
    Horowitz specifically found instances where potentially exculpatory evidence was not passed on from the FBI to DOJ lawyers, who in turn did not inform the ...
  91. [91]
    Senate Intel Releases Volume 5 of Bipartisan Russia Report
    Aug 18, 2020 · The Committee's investigation totaled more than three years of investigative activity, more than 200 witness interviews, and more than a million pages of ...
  92. [92]
    [PDF] (u)report - Senate Select Committee on Intelligence |
    ... Russia interfered in .the 2016 U.S. election. vi. COMMITTEE SENSITIVE-RUSSIA INVESTIGATION ONLY. Page 7. COMMITTEE SENSITIVE - RUSSIA INVESTIGATION ONLY. (U) ...
  93. [93]
  94. [94]
    A Collusion Reading Diary: What Did the Senate Intelligence ...
    ... Carter Page chronicle: Page and the Trump campaign. The report details that Page joined the Trump campaign through Ed Cox, the chairman of the New York ...
  95. [95]
    Ex-Trump aide Carter Page sues Yahoo, HuffPost for defamation
    Sep 14, 2017 · The suit, which names Oath Inc., the parent company of Yahoo and HuffPost, as a defendant, seeks more than $75,000 in damages. Read More.
  96. [96]
    [PDF] Page v. Oath Inc. - Delaware Courts
    Jan 27, 2021 · Defendant has filed a motion to dismiss the Complaint alleging three defenses. Defendant contends that the Isikoff Article, and the three ...
  97. [97]
    Judge tosses Page defamation suit against Verizon company
    Feb 14, 2021 · A Delaware judge has dismissed a defamation lawsuit filed by former Donald Trump campaign operative Carter Page against the media company ...<|separator|>
  98. [98]
    Delaware court hears appeal in Carter Page defamation suit
    The Delaware Supreme Court heard arguments Wednesday in a defamation lawsuit filed by former Donald Trump campaign operative Carter Page ...Missing: outlets details
  99. [99]
    Delaware court rejects Carter Page case vs. Yahoo, Huff Post - WHYY
    Jan 20, 2022 · Delaware's Supreme Court denied former Trump adviser Carter Page's defamation lawsuit over media reports on his connections to Russian officials ...
  100. [100]
    Page v. Oath Inc. - Delaware Supreme Court Decisions - Justia Law
    Carter Page, a public figure with ties to President Trump's 2016 campaign, claimed that defendant-appellee Oath Inc.'s online news organizations published ...
  101. [101]
    Delaware Supreme Court Rejects Carter Page's Lawsuit Against ...
    Jan 19, 2022 · Delaware Supreme Court Rejects Carter Page's Lawsuit Against Yahoo!, HuffPost & Michael Isikoff · Eugene Volokh | 1.19.2022 5:28 PM. From ...
  102. [102]
    Carter Page loses appeal in defamation suit against media outlets
    He alleged that the outlets had knowingly run false articles about him that led to him receiving death threats. Page, who had lived and worked in Russia for ...
  103. [103]
    PAGE v. UNITED STATES AGENCY FOR GLOBAL MEDIA (2019)
    He raised claims of terrorism under the Anti-Terrorism Act (“ATA”), defamation, and tortious interference. We assume the parties' familiarity with the ...
  104. [104]
    Judge tosses another Carter Page suit against DNC over dossier
    Aug 17, 2020 · Another suit accusing Yahoo, HuffPost and Radio Free Europe of libel for their reports related to Page was dismissed by a federal judge in New ...<|separator|>
  105. [105]
    Carter Page files lawsuit against DNC, Perkins Coie over Steele ...
    Jan 30, 2020 · Former Trump campaign figure Carter Page filed a defamation lawsuit Thursday against the Democratic National Committee and the law firm ...
  106. [106]
    [PDF] 1:20-cv-00671 Document #: 1 Filed: 01/30/20 Page 1 of 23 PageID
    Jan 30, 2020 · Carter Page is a natural person who is a citizen and domiciliary of the. State of Oklahoma. Plaintiff Global Energy Capital LLC (“Global Energy”) ...<|separator|>
  107. [107]
    DNC, Perkins Coie Sued by Ex-Trump Campaign Aide Carter Page (1)
    Jan 30, 2020 · Carter Page, a former campaign foreign policy adviser to Donald Trump, sued the Democratic National Committee and its attorneys at Perkins ...Missing: RICO | Show results with:RICO
  108. [108]
    Page v. Democratic National Committee, No. 20-2781 (7th Cir. 2021)
    Jun 21, 2021 · Page, a former advisor to the Trump Presidential Campaign, sued the Democratic National Committee, a subsidiary DNC Corporation, the Perkins ...
  109. [109]
    Supreme Court turns away Carter Page defamation suit against DNC
    Jan 10, 2022 · The Supreme Court on Monday declined to review a defamation lawsuit brought by former Trump campaign official Carter Page against the ...
  110. [110]
    [PDF] Appendix - Supreme Court
    Carter Page served as a foreign policy advisor to former President Donald Trump's 2016 campaign. In his complaint, Page alleged that Perkins Coie and the. DNC ...
  111. [111]
    Carter Page vs. James Comey Et Al - Complaint | PDF - Scribd
    Rating 5.0 (2) Page earned a Master of Arts degree in National Security from. Georgetown University while on active duty, and subsequently completed the MBA program at.
  112. [112]
    [PDF] Page v. Comey - U.S. Court of Appeals for the D.C. Circuit
    May 23, 2025 · The following day, the Washington Post published a story entitled,. “FBI obtained FISA warrant to monitor former Trump adviser. Carter Page.” ...Missing: biography | Show results with:biography
  113. [113]
    Carter Page v. James Comey, 23-5038 – CourtListener.com
    Nov 27, 2020 · May 23, 2025. PER CURIAM JUDGMENT [2117194] filed that the District Court's dismissal of Carter Page's Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Act ...
  114. [114]
    [PDF] In the Supreme Court of the United States
    Sep 30, 2025 · Page alleged that on July 31, 2016, he became the target of an FBI surveillance program called Operation Crossfire Hurricane. The purpose of ...<|control11|><|separator|>
  115. [115]
    Paris, Supply and Demand: Deep-digging Next Steps Toward ...
    The October 2025 edition of Global Policy contains research articles on, among others, political narratives of 'the global', the SDGs, human rights and the ...
  116. [116]
    DC Circuit Eyes Ex-Trump Aide's Bid to Revive Surveillance Suit
    Sep 6, 2024 · A Washington federal appeals court appeared receptive to a former Trump campaign adviser's bid to revive his $75 million lawsuit over government surveillance ...
  117. [117]
    Page v. Comey, No. 23-5038 (D.C. Cir. 2025) - Justia Law
    Page alleged that the FBI unlawfully obtained four warrants to electronically surveil him under the Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Act (FISA) and leaked ...
  118. [118]
    Carter Page, Ph.D. (@carterwpage) / X
    Working to help repair and restore Houston, via the U.S. Constitution's return route to Due Process and the Rule of Law.Missing: commentary reforms
  119. [119]
    Russia's War Against Ukraine: U.S. Policy and the Role of Congress
    Dec 23, 2024 · After a year of relative stalemate, Russian forces made new gains against Ukrainian forces in the latter half of 2024, capturing an estimated ...