Fact-checked by Grok 2 weeks ago

Clapping Music

Clapping Music is a minimalist composition by American composer Steve Reich, written in 1972, performed entirely by two musicians clapping a repeating rhythmic pattern that shifts out of phase over time.^[1] The work uses no instruments, relying solely on the human body to produce sound, which Reich developed as a response to the logistical challenges of transporting electronic equipment for his earlier phasing pieces.^[2] The structure centers on a fixed 12-beat ostinato pattern consisting of eight claps and four rests, initially played in unison by both performers.^[3] One performer maintains this pattern throughout, while the second shifts forward by a single eighth note after every 12 repetitions, creating 12 distinct phasing sections that highlight rhythmic displacement and auditory illusions.^[1] Once the maximum phase shift is reached, the second performer abruptly returns to the original alignment, and both conclude by repeating the unison pattern several times.^[2] This abrupt shifting technique marks a departure from Reich's earlier gradual phasing, emphasizing sudden changes to achieve similar perceptual effects.^[3] As a cornerstone of musical minimalism, Clapping Music demonstrates Reich's fascination with repetition, pulse, and the evolution of simple motifs into complex textures through process-based composition.^[1] Its accessibility and portability have made it one of Reich's most performed works, influencing percussion ensembles, educational settings, and even digital adaptations, while underscoring the potential of everyday actions as musical material.^[2]

Development

Inspiration and composition

In 1972, during a European tour with his ensemble, Steve Reich attended a flamenco performance at a nightclub in Brussels, Belgium, where the rhythmic clapping by accompanying women captivated him and sparked the idea for a composition relying solely on handclaps.^[4] This encounter occurred shortly after a concert, leading Reich to experiment with clapping patterns himself amid the foggy night outside, resulting in an epiphany about creating music without any instruments.^[4] The piece, completed that same year, addressed a practical concern: the need for a portable work that could be performed anywhere, even if electrical equipment failed during a gig.^[5] Reich drew the rhythmic foundation from a traditional sub-Saharan African bell pattern, structured in 12/8 time and closely resembling the Yoruba clave timeline from West Africa, which he had encountered during a 1970 trip to Ghana.^[6]^[7] This pattern, with its eight onsets over twelve pulses and inherent syncopation, was chosen for its repetitive nature, ideal for exploring gradual shifts in alignment between performers.^[6] By limiting the work to two clappers producing a strict canon, Reich sought to embody minimalist principles through unadorned, human-generated sound, free from melody, harmony, or technological aids.^[5]^[7] As Reich later reflected, "I wrote Clapping Music out of a desire to create a piece of music that would need no instruments at all beyond the human body."^[5] This approach highlighted the body's percussive potential while maintaining the composer's focus on process-driven repetition.^[7]

Premiere

Clapping Music premiered on November 13, 1973, at the Contemporary Arts Museum in Houston, Texas, as part of a concert series organized by Rice University's Institute for the Arts and the Menil Foundation.^[8] The performance featured two members of Steve Reich and Musicians, with percussionist Russell Hartenberger among the ensemble participants, delivering the work's rhythmic phasing solely through hand claps.^[8]^[9] The premiere occurred within a program showcasing Reich's evolving minimalist repertoire, including Four Organs (1970), Phase Patterns (1970), Music for Mallet Instruments, Voices and Organ (1973), and Drumming (1971), which collectively emphasized repetitive structures and gradual processes.^[8] This event highlighted a pivotal development in Reich's approach, as Clapping Music—composed in 1972 specifically to require no instruments beyond the human body—introduced a highly portable, performer-only format that contrasted with his earlier tape-loop and ensemble-based experiments.^[10] The piece's design enabled spontaneous execution without setup, though its debut in a museum venue accentuated its innovative simplicity, transforming a gallery space into an acoustic arena for unamplified rhythm.^[8]

Description

Instrumentation and form

Clapping Music is scored exclusively for two performers who produce sounds solely through hand claps, without the use of any instruments or additional body percussion.^[1] This minimalist setup emphasizes the raw acoustic qualities of clapping, creating a percussive texture derived entirely from human bodies in rhythmic synchronization.^[3] The work is a single-movement composition lasting approximately 4 to 5 minutes, structured as an initial unison section, followed by 12 phased variations via abrupt shifts, an abrupt return to unison, and a concluding unison repetition.^[2] This architecture provides a cyclical framework centered on rhythmic interplay and realignment.^[11] At its core, Performer I maintains a fixed 12-beat pattern in 12/8 time throughout the piece, serving as the rhythmic anchor.^[11] Performer II abruptly shifts their identical pattern forward by one eighth note after every 12 repetitions, cycling through 12 discrete shifts to reach maximum offset, followed by an abrupt return to the original alignment.^[2] This progression ensures the piece returns to its starting point, reinforcing the cyclical nature of the form. Each phase consists of 12 repetitions of the pattern before the next shift.^[3] The notation employs a straightforward score format that highlights repetition and rhythmic precision, using standard symbols for claps and rests without any notated pitches or melodic elements.^[12] Each performer's part is presented in a linear, bar-by-bar layout to guide the discrete shifts, underscoring the work's reliance on temporal alignment over harmonic or tonal development.^[12]

Phasing technique

In Clapping Music, the phasing technique serves as the central mechanism for generating rhythmic complexity from a single repeating pattern, achieved through deliberate abrupt offsets between two performers. One performer maintains a fixed 12-beat rhythm throughout, while the second performer displaces their identical pattern by advancing it one eighth note at a time. This displacement occurs every 12 repetitions during the forward-phasing, creating a series of interlocking canons that evolve without any change in underlying tempo.^[13]^[14] The core rhythmic pattern, notated in 12/8 time, features claps on eighth-note pulses 1, 2, 3, 5, 6, 8, 10, and 11, with rests on 4, 7, 9, and 12. As the second performer's pattern shifts cyclically forward by one eighth note per transition (after 12 repetitions), the relative alignment produces canons at intervals ranging from unison to a full 12-beat offset, resulting in emergent polyrhythms such as perceived 3:2 or 4:3 ratios between claps. These shifts highlight the pattern's internal periodicities, transforming simple repetition into a dynamic texture of syncopation and echo effects.^[3]^[11] Mathematically, the process forms a complete cycle of 12 discrete phases, with each phase comprising 12 repetitions of the 12 eighth-note beats, yielding a total of 144 beats before the patterns realign in unison via abrupt return; this cyclic permutation (modeled as a 12-element rotation in the symmetric group S_{12}) generates auditory illusions of acceleration and deceleration as overlapping claps align and diverge. The forward section requires 12 shifts to complete the cycle, after which the second performer abruptly realigns, balancing the overall duration at approximately five minutes.^[3]^[15] This approach marks an evolution in Steve Reich's phasing methodology, transitioning from mechanical tape-loop displacements in works like It's Gonna Rain (1965)—where slight speed variations caused organic phase shifts—to a controlled, performer-driven process that emphasizes precise synchronization and human agency in live execution via abrupt changes.^[16]^[17]

Performance practice

Original setup

Clapping Music is performed by two performers using only their hands to produce rhythmic patterns, with no additional instruments required. One performer, often referred to as the fixed or steady performer, repeats a consistent 12/8 pattern throughout the piece without alteration. The other, known as the phasing or shifting performer, begins in unison with the fixed performer but abruptly shifts the pattern by one eighth note after every 12 repetitions, creating 12 distinct phases before returning to unison. This setup demands intense concentration from both, as the shifting performer must maintain precise synchronization despite the sudden changes, while the fixed performer provides a stable rhythmic anchor.^[2]^[18] The execution relies on natural body percussion, where performers produce sounds through hand claps, with flat hands yielding sharper tones and cupped hands softer ones; both must use the identical timbre for consistency. Performers typically face each other to maintain eye contact, which serves as a non-verbal cue for synchronization, eliminating the need for a conductor. In larger venues accommodating 200 or more people, amplification is recommended using either a single omnidirectional microphone for both or two directional microphones, one per performer, to ensure audibility. The piece is performed at a steady tempo, typically around 120-140 beats per minute, emphasizing rhythmic accuracy over speed.^[19]^[20]^[19] Challenges arise primarily from the risk of desynchronization due to human error, particularly during the abrupt shifts, which require unwavering focus and endurance over the approximately five-minute duration. The fixed performer must resist the urge to adjust to the shifting one, while the phasing performer navigates the evolving offsets without losing the underlying pulse. Steve Reich's score instructions stress the use of natural, unamplified body sounds in intimate settings and highlight the piece's culmination in a final unison after the return phase, restoring harmony through disciplined execution.^[18]^[19]^[21]

Adaptations

One prominent adaptation of Clapping Music appeared in the dance realm through Anne Teresa De Keersmaeker's 1982 choreography Fase: Four Movements to the Music by Steve Reich, where performers execute choreographed clapping sequences synchronized with the piece's phasing rhythm.^[22] Instrumental reinterpretations have translated the clapping patterns to various timbres, such as Simon Rackham's authorized 2012 solo piano arrangement, which maps the claps onto keyboard strikes while preserving the original phasing structure.^[23] Percussion ensembles have also expanded the work, as in the Harvard Undergraduate Drummers' 2010 remixed version for multiple performers, incorporating drums to evoke the clapping motif in a group setting.^[24] In digital and media contexts, Touchpress released a free iOS app in 2015, developed with the London Sinfonietta and Queen Mary University of London, enabling users to interactively engage with the phasing through touch-based clapping simulations and rhythm training games.^[25] The piece's rhythm has been sampled in popular music, notably forming the foundational clap pattern in Imagine Dragons' 2012 track "On Top of the World," where a brief excerpt drives the song's upbeat percussion.^[26] Similarly, James Murphy's 2013 remix of David Bowie's "Love Is Lost" (titled "Hello Steve Reich Mix") features looped samples from a new recording of Clapping Music performed by Murphy and collaborators, integrating it into an electronic dance framework.^[27] Other expansions include vocal adaptations, such as Georgina Brett's 2015 Qualial Coalition, a non-verbal vocal rendition that cycles through the 12-beat variations using voice and clapping.^[28] In educational settings, choirs like the Christ Church Cathedral Choir adapted it for virtual performance in 2020, substituting claps with choral elements to teach phasing concepts remotely.^[29] Ensemble versions have appeared in public events, including a 2022 flash mob by the University of Michigan's Contemporary Directions Ensemble in the Brehm Pavilion, where participants spontaneously phased the rhythm in a communal outdoor setting.^[30] Juggling troupe Gandini Juggling has created adaptations incorporating the clapping patterns into choreographed juggling routines, with performances documented in videos from 2007 onward, including a 2020 version.^[31]

Cultural impact

Reception

Upon its world premiere on April 27, 1973, at New York University in New York, Clapping Music received praise for its accessibility and ingenious simplicity, allowing performers to execute complex phasing without electronic equipment, a notable shift from Reich's tape-based works that highlighted the live energy of human interaction.^[32]^[33] Critics appreciated how the piece distilled minimalism to its rhythmic essence, making avant-garde techniques approachable for broader audiences while retaining hypnotic intensity.^[34] In the 1970s, reviews in The New York Times lauded the work's mesmerizing quality and its role in emphasizing rhythm's centrality in Reich's oeuvre, describing it as a pure illustration of interlocking patterns that captivated listeners through repetition and subtle shifts.^[34] Later critical analyses positioned Clapping Music as a pinnacle of phasing minimalism, with Reich himself calling it "perfect" for its organic innovation and departure from mechanical aids, influencing perceptions of the genre's potential for mainstream appeal akin to earlier modernists like Stravinsky.^[33] However, early critiques of minimalism, including Harold C. Schonberg's dismissal of the style as "wallpaper music" in The New York Times, sometimes extended to the piece's apparent simplicity, though such views were overshadowed by its growing recognition.^[33] The work's audience impact has been significant in live settings, where its interactive clapping fosters engagement and communal participation, often described as a "mesmerizing wave of complex, pulsating rhythms" that draws performers and viewers into rhythmic hypnosis.^[35] Despite occasional early dismissals as overly simplistic, it achieved cult status in avant-garde circles for its deceptive depth, becoming a concert staple that broadened minimalism's reach.^[33] While Clapping Music garnered no specific awards, its inclusion in the influential 1997 Nonesuch Records box set Works: 1965–1995, a comprehensive retrospective of Reich's output, significantly boosted its recognition and enduring legacy.^[36]

Uses in other works

Clapping Music has been sampled in popular music, notably in the 2013 remix of David Bowie's "Love Is Lost" by James Murphy for the DFA, where the clapping pattern directly incorporates Reich's rhythmic motif from the original piece.^[37] In choreography, the piece serves as one of four movements in Anne Teresa De Keersmaeker's seminal 1982 work Fase: Four Movements to the Music of Steve Reich, a cornerstone of postmodern dance that translates the phasing technique into synchronized and offset bodily movements.^[22] The composition is widely integrated into music education for teaching rhythm and phasing concepts, with curricula like Carnegie Hall's We Make Music program using it for activities such as clapping ostinatos and analyzing pattern shifts to build synchronization skills in students.^[1] Interactive applications, including the 2015 Touchpress app developed with the London Sinfonietta, promote audience participation by gamifying the piece, allowing users to practice the clapping patterns against a digital counterpart to improve rhythmic accuracy.^[38] Beyond direct adaptations, Clapping Music has inspired body-percussion techniques in contemporary compositions, exemplifying minimalism's emphasis on simple, accessible elements that encourage performer and listener engagement.^[39] It is often referenced in discussions of how minimalist works democratize music-making by relying on everyday actions like clapping, thereby broadening participation in classical and experimental traditions.^[33]

References

[1]
[PDF] Steve Reich's Clapping Music - Carnegie Hall
Composer Steve Reich wrote Clapping Music in 1972. He took an ordinary sound—clapping— and turned it into music. Ask students: o What would be another ordinary ...Missing: details | Show results with:details
[2]
Reich: Clapping Music for 2 musicians clapping | Universal Edition
Late in 1971 I composed Clapping Music out of a desire to create a piece of music that would need no instruments at all beyond the human body.
[3]
[PDF] The Mathematics of Steve Reich's Clapping Music
Steve Reich wrote Clapping Music in 1971 as a reaction to the burden of traveling with thousands of pounds of electronic equipment and musical instruments that ...
[4]
How I Wrote... Clapping Music - Steve Reich - Classic FM
Composer: Steve Reich ; Piece: Clapping Music ; Date written: 1972 ; In a sentence or less, how would you describe the music to someone who's never heard it before ...
[5]
Clapping Music - LA Phil
About this Piece. I wrote Clapping Music out of a desire to create a piece of music that would need no instruments at all beyond the human body.Missing: generated avoiding
[6]
[PDF] Steve Reich's Clapping Music and the Yoruba Bell Timeline
Here we compare the Clapping Music rhythmic pattern to an almost identical Yoruba bell timeline of West Africa, which strongly influenced Reich. Reich added.
[7]
Steve Reich: Clapping Music - Minimalist music - AQA - BBC
Clapping Music was composed in 1972. The music has been stripped down to the very basics and contains no melody, harmony, instruments or voices.
[8]
Steve Reich and Musicians, 1973/11/11-13 | The Menil Archives
Concert by Steve Reich. Program was the same for all three shows, and included “Four Organs”, “Phase Patterns”, “Clapping Hands”, “Music for Mallet ...Missing: premiere | Show results with:premiere
[9]
Steve Reich "Clapping Music" App Released | Nonesuch Records
Jul 13, 2015 · (You can hear a recording of Clapping Music performed by Steve Reich and Russ Hartenberger on the 1987 Nonesuch release Early Works.) You can ...
[10]
Clapping Music - Steve Reich Composer
In 1972 I composed Clapping Music to create a piece of music that would need no instruments beyond the human body.
[11]
How Steve Reich's Clapping Music rebooted classical
May 11, 2022 · He'd discovered the technique by way of a musical accident, while looping tapes, and then applied it to different instruments (two pianos, two ...Missing: human- avoiding
[12]
[PDF] Steve Reichss Clapping Music and the Yoruba Bell Timeline
Jan 12, 2006 · Abstract. Steve Reich's Clapping Music consists of a rhythmic pattern played by two performers each clapping the rhythm with their hands.
[13]
None
- **Notation**: Uses standard musical notation with claps represented by "œ" and rests by "."; includes ties (ã) and rhythmic patterns with varying note durations.
[14]
[PDF] A Performer's Guide to the Phase Music of Steve Reich - eScholarship
Reich's process in Clapping Music mirrors the theory of. Punctuated Equilibrium while Drumming and Piano Phase are analogous to gradualism. Perception. In ...
[15]
Phase Shifting - Music Theory for the 21st-Century Classroom
Minimalist composer Steve Reich conceived of phase shifting in his early work in tape music, noting that tape loops of slightly differing lengths containing ...
[16]
What makes rhythms hard to perform? An investigation using Steve ...
Oct 18, 2018 · Clapping Music is a minimalist work by Steve Reich based on twelve phased variations of a rhythmic pattern. It has been reimagined as a game-based mobile ...Missing: composition | Show results with:composition
[17]
[PDF] 1 Periodicity-Based Descriptions of Rhythms and Steve Reich's ...
Following this, I discuss the crucial moment in the early 1970s when Reich formulates his signature rhythm, the basis of Clapping Music, and show how this leads ...Missing: details | Show results with:details
[18]
[PDF] iiq ‰ iq ‰ e ‰ iq ‰
The piece is designed, as Reich succinctly describes it, as “a series of two-part unison canons.”42 The canonic parts repeat cyclically in one of two meters, 4/ ...
[19]
A guide to Steve Reich's music - The Guardian
Oct 22, 2012 · You hear the classic Reich technique of gradually building up a rhythm by adding notes in successive repetitions, and one of the 12 sections ...
[20]
[PDF] A Performer's Guide to the Phase Music of Steve Reich - eScholarship
statement, I prefer not to slip back into partial unison when phasing; believing that the process should always be moving forward, not backward. The concept ...
[21]
[PDF] STEVE REICH - clapping music for two performers (1972)
signature of 6/4 or 12/8 is not given to avoid metrical accents. To begin the piece one player may set the tempo by counting quietly; "one, two, three, four ...
[22]
[PDF] "Performance Practice in the Music of Steve Reich," by Russell ...
The importance of eye contact and communication on stage are also emphasized, including each performer's positioning. Indeed, a strong ritualistic element ...
[23]
Clapping Music (Chapter 11) - Performance Practice in the Music of ...
Oct 13, 2016 · Clapping Music arose fully formed as an intuitive response unsullied by the composer's usual agonizing about musical principles and contrapuntal complexities.
[24]
Fase, Four Movements to the Music of Steve Reich - Rosas
Fase, Four Movements to the Music of Steve Reich, choreographer Anne Teresa De Keersmaeker's very first performance, premiered in 1982. Fase comprises three ...
[25]
Which Way Is Up? - Simon Rackham
An album of new piano music (from one hand to six hands). Featuring the first arrangement for solo piano of Steve Reich's 'Clapping Music', sanctioned by the ...
[26]
Clapping Music Remixed (adapted from Steve Reich's ... - YouTube
Nov 28, 2010 · The Harvard Undergraduate Drummers (THUD) perform an adaptation of Steve Reich's "Clapping Music" and "Piano Phase" for percussion ensemble.
[27]
Steve Reich's Clapping Music - App Store
Rating 4.8 (1,182) · Free · iOSThe game that improves your rhythm by challenging you to play Steve Reich's groundbreaking work Clapping Music – a piece of music performed entirely by ...
[28]
David Bowie: "Love Is Lost (Hello Steve Reich Mix by James Murphy)"
Oct 11, 2013 · Murphy's remix explicitly references Steve Reich's “Clapping Music”, but it bursts like applause at the end of a Fellini film or a live ...
[29]
Qualial Coalition - (non-verbal vocal, clapping music, Steve Reich ...
This is a vocal version of 'Clapping Music” by Steve Reich. The first section of the piece adhers to the 12 beat, 8 note phrase that cycles around in all it's ...
[30]
Clapping Music by Steve Reich, adapted by the Christ Church Choir
Sep 13, 2020 · "Clapping Music" by Steve Reich, adapted and performed virtually by the Christ Church Choir during the COVID-19 pandemic.Missing: vocal | Show results with:vocal
[31]
Last week, the Brehm Pavilion became a flash mob concert stage as ...
Sep 13, 2022 · Clapping Music at SMTD. Last week, the Brehm Pavilion became a flash mob concert stage as members of the Contemporary Directions Ensemble, ...
[32]
Rock: Steve Reich - The New York Times
Mar 20, 1979 · Things began with his'Clapping Music” (1972), which by reducing his music to pure rhythm serves to illustrate the central role that rhythm plays ...
[33]
MUSIC REVIEW; Breaking Down the Barriers With Hand Clapping ...
Jul 28, 2000 · It was the members of the ensemble as they walked in performing Steve Reich's ''Clapping Music,'' a mesmerizing wave of complex, pulsating ...
[34]
Works: 1965–1995 (A 10-CD Retrospective) | Nonesuch Records
The box set is accompanied by a comprehensive illustrated booklet with background information on Steve Reich, including an interview with the composer by music ...
[35]
Love Is Lost (Hello Steve Reich Mix by James Murphy for the DFA)
"Love Is Lost (Hello Steve Reich Mix by James Murphy for the DFA)" by David Bowie sampled Steve Reich's "Clapping Music". Listen to both songs on ...
[36]
Steve Reich's Clapping Music app - London Sinfonietta
A game based on Steve Reich's iconic Clapping Music, this ground-breaking app lets anyone improve their rhythm.
[37]
(PDF) The Use of Body Percussion in Contemporary Choral Music
May 14, 2025 · Aim of this research is to analyze the use of body percussion in contemporary classical choral music, and then to examine every composition in ...Missing: influence | Show results with:influence