Fact-checked by Grok 2 weeks ago

Deep Valley

Deep Valley is a drama film directed by , starring as a shy, stammering girl, as an escaped , and as a highway engineer. Based on the 1942 of the same name by Dan Totheroh, the film explores themes of isolation, forbidden romance, and redemption in a remote setting. The plot follows Libby Saul, who lives reclusively with her dysfunctional parents on a secluded , until a constructing a nearby highway introduces her to the rugged world beyond her home. When Libby encounters Barry Burnett, a volatile prisoner who escapes during a heavy rainstorm, she hides him and their intense relationship unfolds amid pursuit by authorities. Supporting roles are filled by as Libby's mother Ellie and as her father Cliff, highlighting the family's strained dynamics. Produced by Henry Blanke for Warner Bros. Pictures, Deep Valley was released on September 1, 1947, with a runtime of 104 minutes in black-and-white. Cinematography by Ted McCord captures the film's moody, naturalistic locations, while Max Steiner composed the score. Filming took place on location in Big Sur and Big Bear, California, partly due to a studio strike that delayed production. Originally intended for a different cast including Humphrey Bogart and Ann Sheridan in 1942, the project was shelved until post-war revival. Notably, it marked Ida Lupino's last film under her Warner Bros. contract before she transitioned to directing.

Background

Source Material

Deep Valley is adapted from the 1942 novel of the same name by American author, , and Dan Totheroh. Published by L.B. Fischer in , the first edition spans 321 pages and marks Totheroh's notable entry into fiction amid his career in theater and . Born on July 22, 1894, in , , Totheroh (1894–1976) drew from his roots for the novel's setting in the rugged region along the coast. A self-taught writer who left high school early to pursue creative endeavors, Totheroh gained early recognition with his play Wild Birds, which won first prize in a 1923 contest for California playwrights and had its production in 1925, launching his professional career there. By the 1940s, he had transitioned into , contributing to films like (1934), while Deep Valley represented his shift toward prose narratives exploring themes of isolation and human connection in rural America. The novel centers on Libby Saul, a shy and uneducated young woman living in isolation on her family's dilapidated farm with her estranged, silent parents. Her life changes when a of convicts arrives to build a through the nearby wilderness; she falls deeply in love with Barry Burnett, a , leading to a and his subsequent escape during a storm. Libby flees to aid him, hiding in a remote as they navigate pursuit by authorities and her own internal conflicts, emphasizing motifs of forbidden love, personal liberation, and the harsh beauty of the coastal landscape. Critics praised Totheroh's evocative for immersing readers in the story's moody, atmospheric tension from the outset. The film's screenplay, credited to Stephen Morehouse Avery and , faithfully captures the novel's core narrative while condensing its elements for cinematic pacing. Totheroh's work, though not his most prolific, influenced mid-20th-century depictions of marginalized rural life in and .

Development

The development of Deep Valley began with the publication of Dan Totheroh's novel of the same name in 1942, a story set in the rugged terrain of and inspired by the author's familiarity with the region. quickly acquired the rights, announcing the project as an under Benjamin Glazer, with an initial cast featuring , , and . However, the production was shelved amid constraints on resources and personnel, delaying progress for several years. The project was revived in 1946 primarily to fulfill obligations under Ida Lupino's contract with , as the studio sought to avoid paying her $20,000 weekly salary during idle periods. Henry Blanke took over as producer, and the screenplay was crafted by and Morehouse Avery, who adapted Totheroh's narrative of isolation, forbidden love, and redemption into a taut emphasizing emotional depth and atmospheric tension. contributed uncredited revisions to the script, enhancing its psychological nuances and dialogue, drawing on his experience with projects during the era. Key decisions during development included casting Lupino in the lead role of Libby Saul, a reclusive farm girl, to leverage her dramatic range after earlier successes like High Sierra (1941), while Dane Clark was selected for the convict Barry to echo the brooding intensity originally envisioned for Garfield or Bogart. Jean Negulesco was assigned as director for his skill in handling intimate character studies, as seen in films like The Mask of Dimitrios (1944). The script's focus shifted toward location authenticity, anticipating on-site filming to capture the novel's remote, foreboding landscapes.

Production

Casting

Ida Lupino was cast in the lead role of Libby Saul, a socially isolated young woman living with her parents on a remote ranch, marking her final film under her after a series of scheduling delays that necessitated rapid production to avoid further penalties. The studio had paid Lupino $20,000 in May 1946 to extend her obligations and faced another deadline in August, prompting the project to commence filming in September 1946 with her assignment to the part. Dane Clark portrayed Barry Burnette, the escaped convict who forms a romantic bond with Libby, representing Clark's first leading role after a string of supporting parts at Warner Bros., such as in Hollywood Canteen (1944). played Jeff Barker, the kind-hearted engineer overseeing the chain gang and harboring unrequited affection for Libby. The supporting cast included Academy Award winner as Ellie Saul, Libby's protective mother, and as Cliff Saul, her reclusive father, both bringing established dramatic credentials—Bainter from her Oscar-winning performance in Jezebel (1938) and Hull from his iconic role in Tobacco Road (1941). appeared as the prison warden, with as a fellow convict. Originally announced in 1942, the film was slated to star , , and in the principal roles, but these plans were shelved amid production priorities and did not materialize in the final version released five years later.

Filming

for Deep Valley began in September 1946 and concluded on January 25, 1947, running 40 days behind schedule. The production was rushed to commence filming ahead of contractual deadlines for lead actress , marking her final film under her Warner Bros. contract. A studio backlot strike prompted the cast and crew to shoot entirely on location, aligning with the story's depiction of a constructing Highway 1 along the coast. Primary filming occurred in and , with additional scenes at Hermosa Beach, Surfboard Point in Palos Verdes, and Bartlett Cedar Lake. For the isolated farmhouse setting, two cabins were constructed by local innkeeper Deetjen, which were later incorporated into Deetjen's Big Sur Inn. Filming presented several physical challenges for the cast, particularly in the rugged coastal terrain. Ida Lupino contracted a cold from the chilly mountain air during summer sequences and suffered a serious toe infection after slicing it on rocks at Bartlett Cedar Lake, leading to swollen ankles; she persisted through the pain to complete her scenes. Later, Lupino experienced a bronchitis flare-up and back strain before Christmas, requiring medical intervention including a painkiller injection and transport via stretcher. Cinematographer Ted McCord captured the dramatic landscapes in black and white, emphasizing the film's themes of isolation and natural beauty.

Synopsis

Plot

Libby Saul, a shy young woman who stutters, lives a isolated and unhappy life on her family's remote farm along the coast with her estranged parents, Cliff and Ellie, who have not spoken to each other in years and use as an unwilling in their silent . While tending to farm chores, Libby encounters Barry Burnett, a tough but vulnerable serving on a constructing a nearby highway under the supervision of Jed Barker. Drawn to Barry's rough charisma and sensing a kindred spirit in his own , Libby begins visiting the work site, where their interactions spark a passionate romance despite the dangers of his situation. During a fierce rainstorm that floods the area and disrupts the chain gang's operations, seizes the opportunity to escape, injuring a in the process. Lost and desperate in the woods, he stumbles upon Libby's hidden cabin and collapses inside, where she discovers him and, driven by love, decides to shelter him rather than turn him in. As days pass in secrecy, Libby and grow closer, sharing dreams of a life together in , far from her stifling home and his criminal past; she steals food and supplies from the farm to sustain him, while he teaches her to overcome her insecurities. Tension mounts when Libby briefly confronts in a moment of fear, leading him to nearly attack her with a before recognizing her and stopping, underscoring the volatility of their bond. With a posse, led by Barker and including Libby's father, closing in on the escapee, Libby devises a plan to help Barry flee by distracting her parents and gathering essentials for their getaway. In the chaos, Barry hides in the family barn, where Cliff and Ellie, alarmed by their daughter's disappearance and the crisis, finally reconcile and end their long silence, finding common ground in worry for Libby. Barry and Libby make a desperate dash toward freedom on horseback, but the pursuing posse catches up during a shootout in the rugged terrain; Barry is fatally wounded while protecting Libby and dies in her arms as they reach the ocean's edge, his last words affirming their love. Devastated but transformed by the experience, Libby returns home to find her parents united; she begins a tentative new chapter with the kind-hearted Barker, who has long shown interest in her, leaving behind the valley's shadows for a chance at normalcy.

Themes

Deep Valley explores themes of profound and emotional repression within a unit, portraying the household as a microcosm of bitterness and stagnation. The , Libby , endures a life of on a remote farm, where her parents' seven-year estrangement has rendered communication impossible, forcing her to act as an intermediary while suffering abuse from her father due to her stammering speech. This setup underscores the film's examination of how familial discord perpetuates personal torment, with Libby's only companionship coming from her , emphasizing her detachment from . Central to the narrative is the theme of transformative as a catalyst for redemption and self-discovery, particularly through Libby's romance with the escaped convict Burnett. Their forbidden relationship, born amid the rugged wilderness, awakens Libby from her emotional numbness, enabling her to overcome her stutter and assert her independence, while confronts his violent past and finds momentary peace. This bond contrasts sharply with the stability offered by a more conventional suitor, highlighting the tension between passionate, redemptive and societal expectations, ultimately leading to partial reconciliation within the Saul family as Libby's actions prompt her parents to end their silence. The film portrays not as a fairy-tale resolution but as a fleeting force that exposes vulnerabilities, aligning with melodramatic traditions while infusing noir-like in its doomed trajectory. The story also delves into themes of social outcast status and the yearning for from oppressive circumstances, using the characters' marginalization to critique rural and class constraints. Both and exist on society's fringes— she as a stigmatized, uneducated farm , he as a chain-gang — their symbolizing a rebellion against rigid norms, though pursued through criminal means that seal their tragic fate. Atmospheric elements, such as the encroaching and chain-gang labor, amplify feelings of , evoking emotional in the portrayal of quiet amid despair.

Release and Reception

Premiere and Distribution

Deep Valley had its premiere and opening on August 22, 1947, at the Strand Theatre amid contemporary reviews noting its dramatic intensity. The film then entered general release in the United States on September 1, 1947, following a by , Inc. on August 29, 1947 (LP1181). Distributed domestically by , Inc., the studio handled all aspects of the film's rollout, including marketing that emphasized its rural setting and star pairing of and . While specific international distribution records are limited, managed global exhibition through its established network, aligning with the studio's post-World War II expansion of overseas markets for American films. The release occurred during a period of industry recovery, with prioritizing dramatic features like Deep Valley to capitalize on theater reopenings.

Critical Response

Upon its release, Deep Valley received mixed reviews from critics, who often praised the performances while critiquing the melodramatic plot and its perceived similarities to earlier films like High Sierra (1941). of described the story as a "highly incredible, and even somewhat ludicrous, attempt at tempestuous drama," noting the reliance on "dreadful coincidences" and implausible resolutions, such as the protagonist miraculously overcoming her stammer upon falling in love. However, commended the acting, particularly Ida Lupino's "nice shadings of emotion" in portraying the stammering Libby Saul and her convincing early scenes, alongside strong turns from , , and . James Agee, writing for TIME magazine, was more harshly critical, likening the film to "solemn little-theater plays of the early '20s" that were "lost in mawkishness and pseudopoetic feeling masquerading as art." Agee found the overall tone overly sentimental and artistically contrived, reflecting a broader contemporary skepticism toward Hollywood's rural melodramas. Despite such reservations, other reviewers highlighted the film's emotional depth and production values. More favorably, Variety hailed Deep Valley as a "first-class melodrama marked by distinctive performances," crediting director Jean Negulesco's sensitive handling and the leads' chemistry for elevating the material. Lupino's portrayal in particular drew acclaim as one of her finest, with critics noting her ability to convey vulnerability and quiet intensity in a role that contrasted her typical tough-cookie characters. The film's atmospheric cinematography by Ted McCord and Max Steiner's score were also appreciated for enhancing the isolated, brooding mood, though some felt the narrative's predictability undermined its potential impact.

Box Office Performance

Deep Valley, distributed by Warner Bros., was generally released in the United States on September 1, 1947, but achieved only modest results, grossing $1.4 million in the U.S. The film, budgeted as a mid-level production to utilize Lupino's contract before her departure from the studio, failed to attract significant theater attendance despite its dramatic appeal and in . Contemporary reports indicated that audiences largely stayed away, contributing to underwhelming financial performance relative to ' expectations for a vehicle starring Lupino. The picture's release coincided with a crowded slate of dramas and comedies, diluting its draw among postwar moviegoers seeking lighter fare. While exact gross figures are not comprehensively documented in period trade publications, the film's underscores the challenges faced by introspective melodramas in competing for during that era.

Legacy

Accolades

Deep Valley (1947) did not receive any nominations at the , which honored films from 1947. Similarly, the film earned no recognition from the 5th or other major industry honors during its release year. Despite its commercial success and praise for Ida Lupino's performance, the production lacked formal accolades from contemporary award bodies.

Modern Reappraisal

In the decades following its release, Deep Valley has garnered reappraisal within as a distinctive example of postwar , valued for its departure from the genre's predominant urban milieus in favor of a rugged, rural backdrop that amplifies themes of and . Scholars highlight how the film's natural locations in rural enhance the psychological tension, portraying the protagonists' emotional confinement as mirroring the impenetrable valley terrain. This environmental symbolism distinguishes it from more conventional s, positioning Deep Valley as a bridge between and noir aesthetics. Ida Lupino's portrayal of Libby Saul, a stammering, abused girl who finds fleeting redemption through a doomed romance with an escaped convict, has been particularly acclaimed for its raw emotional authenticity and subversion of the archetype. Critics note Lupino's ability to convey vulnerability without sentimentality, drawing on her own frustrations with studio during a contentious contract that included multiple suspensions for rejecting roles; this period, culminating in Deep Valley, catalyzed her pivot to directing. The film is frequently cited in analyses of Lupino's pre-directorial career as evidence of her versatility in embodying "tough yet vulnerable" women amid noir's moral ambiguities. Retrospectives have further elevated the film's status, including its inclusion in the Museum of Modern Art's 1991 exhibition "Hard, Fast, and Beautiful: Ida Lupino, Filmmaker," which traced her evolution from actress to and showcased Deep Valley alongside her noir credits like High Sierra (1941) and Road House (1948). Similarly, the 1996 Melbourne International Film Festival's Ida Lupino retrospective featured the film to underscore her range, from naive rural figures to urban sophisticates, affirming its enduring relevance in discussions of and in 1940s Hollywood. More recent analyses, such as a 2023 review, continue to affirm its status as rural , emphasizing its suspenseful blend of romance and .

Home Media and Availability

Deep Valley was released on DVD by Warner Home Video as part of the Warner Archive Collection on July 6, 2009. The single-disc edition features the film in its original black-and-white format with a runtime of 104 minutes, presented in standard definition NTSC and region 0 compatibility for broad playback. It includes no supplemental features beyond chapter stops. The DVD remains available for purchase through online retailers such as , , and , often as new or used copies from the Warner Archive line. International versions, including Region 2 imports, are also offered on platforms like for viewers outside . No official Blu-ray Disc edition has been produced or announced by . As of November 2025, Deep Valley is not available for streaming, rental, or digital purchase on major platforms . It was last accessible via on-demand services on until October 2021. thus represents the primary means of home viewing for contemporary audiences.

References

  1. [1]
    Deep Valley (1947) - Turner Classic Movies - TCM
    A farmer's daughter helps an escaped convict. Cast & Crew. Read More. Jean Negulesco. Director · Ida Lupino. Libby [Saul] · Dane Clark. Barry [Burnett] · Wayne ...
  2. [2]
    Deep Valley - Rotten Tomatoes
    Rating 65% (7) A shy California farm girl (Ida Lupino) falls in love with a fugitive (Dane Clark) from a chain gang.
  3. [3]
    Deep Valley - Dan Totheroh - Google Books
    Title, Deep Valley ; Author, Dan Totheroh ; Publisher, L. B. Fischer, 1942 ; Original from, the University of California ; Digitized, May 5, 2010.Missing: novel | Show results with:novel<|control11|><|separator|>
  4. [4]
  5. [5]
    Deep Valley by Totheroh, Dan | Search for Rare Books | ABAA
    30-day returnsNew York: L.B. Fischer. Very Good+. (c.1942). First Edition. Hardcover. (lacking the original dust jacket, but encased in a nice-looking facsimile ...
  6. [6]
    Dan Totheroh - IMDb
    Dan Totheroh was born on 22 July 1894 in San Francisco, California, USA. He was a writer, known for The Count of Monte Cristo (1934), Deep Valley (1947) and ...Missing: author | Show results with:author
  7. [7]
    Dan Totheroh - Filmography, Age, Biography & More - Mabumbe
    Dan Totheroh (July 22, 1894- December 3, 1976) was an American author, playwright, and screenwriter. Dan Totheroh was born in San Francisco, CA and raised ...
  8. [8]
    A PRIZE PLAY COMES OUT OF THE WEST - The New York Times
    Totheroh, now just 30, was born in San Francisco and managed to stick to his studies just long enough to complete a high school course. But he had ever been all ...Missing: biography | Show results with:biography
  9. [9]
    Books by Dan Totheroh (Author of The Stolen Prince) - Goodreads
    Dan Totheroh has 47 books on Goodreads with 21 ratings. Dan Totheroh's most popular book is The Stolen Prince: Fantasy in One Act.
  10. [10]
    Dan Totheroh's Fine California Novel -- A New Story by Helen ...
    WITH the opening page of his novel, "Deep Valley, Dan Totheroh reaches out to the reader and draws him into the mood of his story.Missing: plot summary
  11. [11]
    Deep Valley. 1947. Directed by Jean Negulesco - MoMA
    When a chain gang comes through to build a new road, Libby finds herself both attracted to and frightened by a young, uncontrollable convict named Barry.
  12. [12]
    SCREEN NEWS HERE AND IN HOLLYWOOD; Paramount Will ...
    August 6, 1942 ... Deep Valley," an original by Dan Totheroh. Ann Sheridan, Humphrey Bogart and John Garfield have been cast in the film. The studio has announced ...
  13. [13]
    AFI|Catalog
    ... Sheridan, Humphrey Bogart and John Garfield were to star in the film. Scenes ... Based on the novel Deep Valley by Dan Totheroh (New York, 1942).
  14. [14]
    DEEP VALLEY - Monterey County Film Commission
    Deep Valley is about a chain-gang working on Route 1, starring Ida Lupino, Dane Clark, Wayne Morris, & Fay Bainter, and was filmed in Big Sur and Big Bear.Missing: 1947 material
  15. [15]
    Deep Valley (1947) - Filming & production - IMDb
    Filming locations included Surfboard Point, Palos Verdes, and Big Sur, California. Filming and production dates were from September 1946 to January 1947.
  16. [16]
    Deep Valley (1947) - IMDb
    Rating 6.8/10 (1,174) A farm girl falls in-love with a chain-gang convict working at a nearby highway construction site and sets-out to help him when he escapes.
  17. [17]
    Deep Valley - 1947 - Another Old Movie Blog
    Jul 16, 2015 · A few particularly great scenes: when Garfield and Lupino lie along the brook and attempt to catch a fish, their exuberance at their success, ...
  18. [18]
    Plot - Deep Valley (1947) - IMDb
    A girl living with her parents on an isolated California farm falls in love with a chain-gang convict working at a nearby highway construction site, and sets ...
  19. [19]
    ' Deep Valley' Warner Film Study of a Mountain Family, With Ida ...
    Ida Lupino is the stammering drudge in a ramshackle mountain home, where her parents have neither seen nor spoken to each other for all of seven years. While Ma ...Missing: plot summary
  20. [20]
    Deep Valley - Chicago Reader
    ### Summary of Themes in *Deep Valley* (1947)
  21. [21]
    The 20th Academy Awards | 1948 - Oscars.org
    Edmund Gwenn. Miracle on 34th Street ; Charles Bickford. The Farmer's Daughter ; Thomas Gomez. Ride the Pink Horse ; Robert Ryan. Crossfire ; Richard Widmark. Kiss ...
  22. [22]
    [PDF] Encyclopedia of Film Noir | Teuwissen
    ... Encyclopedia of Film Noir. Page 3. Page 4. Encyclopedia of Film Noir ... Deep Valley. (1947), Road House (1948), On Dangerous Ground (1952), Beware My ...
  23. [23]
    Hard, Fast, and Beautiful: The Legacy of Director Ida Lupino
    Nov 15, 2019 · Deep Valley was the end of a fraught Warner Brothers contract during ... noir film. It should be noted that the many Mexicans we see ...
  24. [24]
    HARD, FAST, AND BEAUTIFUL--IDA LUPINO, FILMMAKER ... - MoMA
    A retrospective of films tracing the achievements of Ida Lupino, one of ... 1950s, opens at The Museum of Modern Art on February 1, 1991. ... Deep Valley. 1947.
  25. [25]
    Issue 15 (Oct-Nov 1996) - National Library of Australia
    on the Melbourne International Film Festival's Ida Lupino Retrospective. ... isolated naif in Negulesco's Deep Valley (1947); the knowing, blind sister of a.
  26. [26]
    Deep Valley - Ida Lupino - DVDBeaver
    Jul 6, 2009 · Exceptional film - heavy on the melodrama with a stalwart Lupino but we'd have to say a debatable noir despite inclusion in our comprehensive ...
  27. [27]
    Amazon.com: Deep Valley [DVD] [1947] [Region 1] [US Import] [NTSC]
    Deep Valley [DVD] [1947] [Region 1] [US Import] [NTSC] ; Shipped & Sold by. King Video Inc ; Returns. Returnable until Jan 31, 2026 ; Payment. Secure transaction.Missing: international distribution
  28. [28]
    Warner Archives - Deep Valley [DIGITAL VIDEO DISC] - Walmart.com
    In stock $6.99 deliveryLupino gives further proof of her remarkable dramatic range with a sensitive portrayal of an awkward stuttering girl transformed by love. More details ...
  29. [29]
    Deep Valley (DVD, 1947) for sale online - eBay
    In stock Rating 4.7 (3) Find many great new & used options and get the best deals for Deep Valley (DVD, 1947) at the best online prices at eBay! Free shipping for many products!Missing: international distribution
  30. [30]
    Deep Valley - Valle Profundo (Non USA Format) - Amazon.com
    30-day returnsPlayback Region 2 : This will not play on most DVD players sold in the U.S., U.S. Territories, Canada, and Bermuda. See other DVD options under “Other ...Missing: 1947 media<|control11|><|separator|>
  31. [31]
    Deep Valley streaming: where to watch movie online? - JustWatch
    Aug 15, 2021 · Deep Valley is unavailable to stream in United States today. It was last available on Spectrum On Demand until October 2021.Missing: DVD Blu-