Fact-checked by Grok 2 weeks ago

Eigenstate thermalization hypothesis

The Eigenstate Thermalization Hypothesis (ETH) is a fundamental conjecture in quantum many-body physics that asserts the individual energy eigenstates of non-integrable, isolated quantum systems behave as thermal states, with expectation values of local observables matching those predicted by the microcanonical ensemble at the corresponding energy.^[1] This hypothesis provides a microscopic mechanism for thermalization, explaining why such systems equilibrate to a thermodynamic state despite unitary evolution and the absence of external baths, resolving a long-standing puzzle in quantum statistical mechanics.^[2] The ETH was first proposed by Joshua M. Deutsch in 1991, who demonstrated through random matrix arguments that chaotic quantum systems thermalize at the level of eigenstates rather than relying solely on time averaging. Mark Srednicki coined the term "eigenstate thermalization" in 1994, providing a more detailed formulation that linked it to quantum chaos and bounded the approach to equilibrium.^[3] Formally, the ETH posits that for a local operator \hat{O} and energy eigenstate |n\rangle with energy E_n, the diagonal matrix element satisfies \langle n | \hat{O} | n \rangle = \overline{\langle \hat{O} \rangle}_{E_n} + \mathcal{O}(e^{-S(E_n)/2}), where \overline{\langle \hat{O} \rangle}_{E_n} is the microcanonical average and S(E_n) is the entropy, ensuring fluctuations are exponentially small in system size.^[1] Off-diagonal elements are similarly constrained to suppress revivals and support ergodicity.^[2] The hypothesis distinguishes between weak and strong versions: the weak ETH holds for most eigenstates in a narrow energy window, while the strong ETH requires all eigenstates to be thermal.^[1] It applies primarily to non-integrable systems exhibiting quantum chaos, as characterized by random matrix theory spectra, but fails in integrable models or those undergoing many-body localization, where eigenstates retain initial-state information.^[2] Implications extend to entanglement entropy equaling the thermodynamic entropy in thermal eigenstates, informing studies of black hole information paradoxes and quantum simulation platforms.^[1] Experimental tests since the 2010s, using ultracold atoms and trapped ions, have confirmed ETH predictions in one- and two-dimensional systems, observing thermal-like eigenstate expectations and rapid equilibration.^[4] Ongoing research explores generalizations, such as in open systems or with symmetries, underscoring ETH's role in bridging quantum dynamics and thermodynamics.^[5]

Introduction and Background

Historical Development

The foundations of the eigenstate thermalization hypothesis (ETH) trace back to early studies in quantum chaos, particularly the Bohigas-Giannoni-Schmit conjecture proposed in 1984, which posited that the spectral statistics of quantum systems with chaotic classical counterparts follow predictions from random matrix theory. This idea linked quantum energy level fluctuations to universal random matrix ensembles, providing a statistical framework for chaotic quantum behavior. Building on this, Michael Berry's 1985 conjecture suggested that eigenfunctions in such systems resemble random superpositions of plane waves, implying a delocalized, ergodic structure for wavefunctions in chaotic billiards and similar models. In 1991, Joshua M. Deutsch introduced key concepts in quantum statistical mechanics for closed systems, arguing that in non-integrable many-body quantum systems, expectation values of observables in energy eigenstates approximate microcanonical averages, laying groundwork for thermalization without external baths.^[6] This work highlighted the role of eigenstate properties in achieving equilibrium-like behavior. Mark Srednicki formalized the ETH in 1994, proposing it as a mechanism for quantum thermalization in isolated, bounded systems of many particles, where individual energy eigenstates thermalize observables, demonstrated through analysis of a quantum hard-sphere gas.^[3] Srednicki refined the hypothesis in 1999 with an explicit ansatz for matrix elements of observables in the energy basis, emphasizing its applicability to quantized chaotic systems and predicting rapid approach to thermal equilibrium. The 2000s saw numerical validation strengthening ETH, notably through Marcos Rigol and colleagues' 2008 studies on one-dimensional lattice models of interacting bosons, which showed thermalization in non-integrable cases via exact diagonalization, contrasting with persistent oscillations in integrable counterparts. During the 2010s, ETH evolved through deeper connections to quantum chaos and many-body localization, with theoretical extensions exploring its implications for out-of-equilibrium dynamics in disordered systems. By the 2020s, integration with quantum information theory advanced. A 2025 review synthesizes ETH fundamentals.^[7]

Physical Motivation

In quantum many-body physics, a fundamental challenge arises in understanding thermalization within isolated, closed systems, where the time evolution is governed by unitary operators that preserve all information and norms, precluding the irreversible approach to equilibrium typically observed in classical systems interacting with external baths.^[8] This unitarity implies that pure states remain pure, and the system cannot genuinely lose memory of its initial conditions, raising the question of how macroscopic subsystems can nevertheless exhibit thermal behavior as if in contact with a reservoir. The eigenstate thermalization hypothesis (ETH) addresses this by proposing that in sufficiently complex systems, local observables—such as those restricted to a small subsystem—equilibrate to values predicted by thermal ensembles, even though the global state evolves unitarily. This subsystem thermalization occurs because the expectation values of these observables in individual energy eigenstates mimic those of a canonical or microcanonical ensemble, allowing the time average of the system's evolution to align with equilibrium predictions despite finite-size recurrences that could otherwise disrupt long-term stability.^[8] Such behavior resolves the apparent paradox of thermalization without dissipation, as the vast Hilbert space dimensionality ensures that initial states project onto a narrow energy shell where eigenstates effectively "forget" non-thermal correlations. Central to ETH is the role of quantum chaos, where chaotic many-body systems exhibit statistical properties akin to random matrix ensembles, leading to energy eigenstates that appear random and thermal when probed locally. In classically chaotic systems, such as a gas of hard spheres, the eigenfunctions behave like Gaussian random waves, ensuring that off-diagonal matrix elements of observables are suppressed, which promotes rapid decoherence of non-equilibrium features and effective thermal descriptions without invoking ensembles. This chaotic underpinning avoids the recurrence issues inherent in finite quantum systems by making individual eigenstates inherently thermal for subsystems, thus providing a microscopic foundation for why isolated quantum systems thermalize on their own.^[8] A precursor to ETH is von Neumann's quantum ergodic theorem from 1929, which demonstrated that, under certain conditions like non-degenerate energy levels, the time average of observables in an isolated quantum system approaches the microcanonical average, laying early groundwork for reconciling quantum mechanics with statistical equilibrium without external interactions.^[9]

Core Formulation

Statement of the Hypothesis

The eigenstate thermalization hypothesis (ETH) posits that in non-integrable quantum many-body systems exhibiting chaotic behavior, individual energy eigenstates are thermal in the sense that their expectation values for local observables match those predicted by a thermal ensemble at the energy corresponding to the eigenstate. This core assertion, first proposed by Deutsch and later formalized by Srednicki, implies that thermalization occurs intrinsically within the system's dynamics rather than requiring external influences. Qualitatively, for a Hamiltonian H with energy eigenstates |n\rangle satisfying H|n\rangle = E_n |n\rangle, the diagonal matrix element of a local operator O obeys \langle n | O | n \rangle \approx \mathrm{Tr} \left[ O e^{-\beta H} \right] / Z, where \beta is the inverse temperature determined by the condition that the ensemble average energy equals E_n, and Z = \mathrm{Tr} \left[ e^{-\beta H} \right] is the partition function. This approximation holds for observables that act on a small subsystem, assuming the full system has few global conservation laws beyond energy and the subsystem size is much smaller than the total system volume. The ETH applies specifically to systems lacking integrability, where chaotic classical counterparts exist and the energy spectrum is nondegenerate, ensuring that the hypothesis captures the emergence of thermodynamic behavior in isolated quantum settings. A key implication is that time averages of observables in a generic initial state will equal ensemble averages from the canonical distribution, without needing weak coupling to an external bath, as the eigenstate contributions effectively mimic thermal fluctuations. While ETH provides a strong framework supported by numerical and analytical evidence, it remains a conjecture rather than a rigorously proven theorem, distinguishing it from more limited results like the quantum ergodic theorem that apply only to specific subclasses of systems.

Mathematical Expression

The eigenstate thermalization hypothesis (ETH) is formalized through an ansatz for the matrix elements of a generic local operator \hat{O} in the energy eigenbasis of a many-body Hamiltonian H |n\rangle = E_n |n\rangle, where the eigenstates |n\rangle are assumed to be sufficiently chaotic. The general form of the ansatz, originally proposed by Srednicki, posits that these matrix elements take the structure

\langle m | \hat{O} | n \rangle = \langle \hat{O} \rangle(E_n) \delta_{mn} + e^{-S(E_n)/2} f_{\hat{O}}(E_n, \omega_{mn}) R_{mn},

where \delta_{mn} is the Kronecker delta, S(E_n) is the thermodynamic entropy at energy E_n, f_{\hat{O}}(E_n, \omega_{mn}) is a smooth function of the extensive energy parameter E_n and the frequency \omega_{mn} = E_m - E_n, and R_{mn} is a random variable with zero mean and O(1) variance that is uncorrelated for different pairs (m,n).^[10] This expression captures both the systematic thermal behavior and the statistical fluctuations expected in chaotic systems. For the diagonal matrix elements, where m = n, the ansatz simplifies to

\langle n | \hat{O} | n \rangle = f_{\hat{O}}(E_n) + e^{-S(E_n)/2} g_{\hat{O}}(E_n, \omega = 0) R_n,

with f_{\hat{O}}(E_n) a smooth function representing the leading thermal expectation value, g_{\hat{O}}(E_n, 0) = f_{\hat{O}}(E_n, 0) denoting the value of the smooth function at zero frequency (often absorbing minor notational differences), and R_n a random O(1) fluctuation term. The function f_{\hat{O}}(E) approximates the microcanonical average \langle \hat{O} \rangle(E) = \mathrm{Tr}[\hat{O} \rho(E)], where \rho(E) is the microcanonical density operator at energy E, ensuring that individual eigenstate expectations align with ensemble averages in the thermodynamic limit.^[10]^[11] The off-diagonal elements, for m \neq n, are given by the second term alone:

\langle m | \hat{O} | n \rangle = e^{-S(E_n)/2} h_{\hat{O}}(E_n, \omega_{mn}) R_{mn},

where h_{\hat{O}}(E_n, \omega_{mn}) is a smooth function that typically decays for large |\omega_{mn}| to suppress transitions far from resonance, and R_{mn} introduces randomness. The exponential suppression factor e^{-S(E_n)/2} arises because the density of states grows as e^{S(E_n)}, leading to off-diagonal elements scaling as $1/\sqrt{\rho(E_n)} in magnitude, consistent with random matrix theory predictions for chaotic spectra.^[10]^[11] This ansatz is motivated by random matrix theory, where energy eigenstates can be viewed as random superpositions of a complete basis, leading to statistically uniform matrix elements modulated by the system's symmetries and locality. In lattice models such as one-dimensional spin chains, the ansatz applies directly to local operators like the spin density S^z_j at site j; here, f_{\hat{O}}(E) yields the energy-dependent average magnetization, while off-diagonal elements govern transition rates in dynamics, with numerical studies confirming the smooth, decaying form of h_{\hat{O}} for chaotic interactions like those in the Heisenberg model.^[10]^[11]^[12]

Ensemble Descriptions

Diagonal Ensemble

In quantum many-body systems, the diagonal ensemble provides a description of the long-time behavior of an isolated system prepared in a pure initial state. Consider an initial state expanded in the energy eigenbasis of the Hamiltonian H as |\psi\rangle = \sum_n c_n |n\rangle, where H |n\rangle = E_n |n\rangle and \sum_n |c_n|^2 = 1. The diagonal ensemble is then represented by the density matrix \rho_\mathrm{DE} = \sum_n |c_n|^2 |n\rangle\langle n|, which retains only the diagonal elements in this basis.^[13] This ensemble corresponds to the infinite-time average of observables in the system. For a local operator O, the time-evolved expectation value is \langle \psi(t) | O | \psi(t) \rangle = \sum_{n,m} c_m^* c_n e^{i(E_m - E_n)t} O_{nm}, where O_{nm} = \langle n | O | m \rangle. The long-time average is given by

\lim_{T \to \infty} \frac{1}{T} \int_0^T dt \, \langle \psi(t) | O | \psi(t) \rangle = \sum_n |c_n|^2 O_{nn} = \mathrm{Tr}(\rho_\mathrm{DE} O),

as the off-diagonal terms dephase due to the distinct energy differences E_m - E_n in generic systems.^[13] This average captures the equilibrated state, where expectation values of local observables stabilize after transient dynamics. Within the framework of the eigenstate thermalization hypothesis (ETH), the diagonal ensemble yields thermal-like expectation values for local operators when the initial state's energy distribution is concentrated around a mean energy E. Specifically, if the coefficients |c_n|^2 are significant only for eigenstates with energies near E, then \mathrm{Tr}(\rho_\mathrm{DE} O) \approx \langle O \rangle_\mathrm{mc}(E), where \langle O \rangle_\mathrm{mc}(E) denotes the microcanonical average at energy E.^[13] Unlike the canonical ensemble, which requires assigning an inverse temperature \beta via contact with a bath, the diagonal ensemble applies directly to closed, isolated systems without presupposing a temperature. An effective \beta can be inferred from the energy variance or mean of the initial state, ensuring consistency with thermal predictions under ETH. A representative example occurs in a quantum quench, where the Hamiltonian is suddenly changed from an initial H_0 to a final H, starting from an eigenstate of H_0. The system evolves unitarily under H, and local observables relax to values predicted by \rho_\mathrm{DE}, demonstrating equilibration to a thermal-like state for non-integrable Hamiltonians. Numerical studies of hard-core bosons on a lattice confirm this, with post-quench densities matching diagonal ensemble predictions after dephasing.^[13]

Microcanonical Ensemble

The microcanonical ensemble provides a statistical description of isolated quantum systems constrained to a fixed total energy E, volume V, and particle number N. It assumes uniform probability over all accessible microstates within a narrow energy shell around E, making it the natural ensemble for studying thermalization in closed systems without external baths. The corresponding density operator is given by

\rho_{\text{MC}} = \frac{1}{\Omega(E)} \sum_{n: E_n \approx E} |n\rangle \langle n|,

where |n\rangle are the energy eigenstates of the Hamiltonian with eigenvalues E_n, the sum runs over states in an energy window of width scaling with the system size (typically \Delta E \sim \sqrt{\langle (\Delta H)^2 \rangle} to encompass many states while maintaining sharpness), and \Omega(E) denotes the density of states at energy E, serving as the normalization factor equal to the number of states in the shell. This formulation originates from foundational work in quantum statistical mechanics, where it extends the classical phase-space uniform measure to the Hilbert space. In the microcanonical ensemble, thermal properties emerge through averages over the energy shell. The expectation value of an observable O is

\langle O \rangle_{\text{MC}} = \frac{1}{\Omega(E)} \sum_{n: E_n \approx E} \langle n | O | n \rangle \approx f_O(E),

where f_O(E) is a smooth function of the energy, independent of microscopic details and determined by thermodynamic principles. These averages yield macroscopic thermodynamic quantities, such as entropy S(E) = k_B \ln \Omega(E), temperature T(E) = \left( \frac{\partial S}{\partial E} \right)^{-1}, and pressure, which are extensive in the thermodynamic limit. Fluctuations around these values are suppressed exponentially with system size, \sigma_O^2 \propto e^{-S(E)/k_B}, ensuring the ensemble's predictions are self-averaging for large systems. For large systems, the microcanonical ensemble is equivalent to the canonical ensemble in the thermodynamic limit, as the canonical partition function Z(\beta) acts as the Laplace transform of the density of states: Z(\beta) = \int dE \, \Omega(E) e^{-\beta E}. In the saddle-point approximation, this yields \beta(E) = \frac{\partial S(E)}{\partial E}, linking the inverse temperature \beta = 1/k_B T to the microcanonical entropy slope, with relative energy fluctuations \delta E / E \sim 1/\sqrt{N} becoming negligible. This equivalence holds under conditions of weak coupling between subsystems, allowing microcanonical results to approximate canonical thermalization even in finite but large systems. The validity of the microcanonical ensemble relies on ergodicity in the classical limit, where time averages equal ensemble averages over the energy surface due to the mixing properties of chaotic dynamics, as established in the ergodic hypothesis for non-integrable systems. In the quantum regime, however, this requires the eigenstate thermalization hypothesis (ETH) to ensure that individual eigenstates within the shell behave thermally, justifying the uniform averaging without additional assumptions about state-specific correlations. Without ETH, as in integrable or localized systems, the ensemble may fail to capture thermal-like behavior. As the standard framework in statistical mechanics for isolated systems, the microcanonical ensemble underpins analyses of equilibrium properties in quantum many-body problems, such as the derivation of equation-of-state relations and the study of phase transitions via entropy maxima. It is routinely applied in numerical simulations of lattice models and exact diagonalization to benchmark thermalization, providing a fixed-energy reference for comparing time-dependent evolutions in closed quantum systems.

Equivalence Under ETH

The Eigenstate Thermalization Hypothesis (ETH) establishes a theoretical foundation for the equivalence between the diagonal ensemble and the microcanonical ensemble in predicting local observables for isolated quantum many-body systems that thermalize. Under ETH, the diagonal matrix elements of a local observable \hat{O} in the energy eigenbasis, \langle n | \hat{O} | n \rangle, are approximately equal to a smooth function f_O(E_n) that depends only on the energy E_n of the eigenstate |n\rangle, with variations smoothed out across eigenstates within a narrow energy shell. For an initial state |\psi\rangle = \sum_n c_n |n\rangle with energy distribution concentrated in such a shell around a mean energy \bar{E}, the diagonal ensemble average is \operatorname{Tr}[\rho_\mathrm{DE} \hat{O}] = \sum_n |c_n|^2 \langle n | \hat{O} | n \rangle \approx \sum_n |c_n|^2 f_O(E_n). If the energy fluctuation \Delta E of the initial state is sufficiently narrow, this approximates f_O(\bar{E}), matching the microcanonical average \langle \hat{O} \rangle_\mathrm{MC} at energy \bar{E}.^[14]^[15] The condition for this equivalence requires that the energy spread \Delta E of the initial state satisfies \delta E \ll \Delta E \ll D, where \delta E is the mean level spacing (exponentially small in system size N) and D is the spacing between distinct energy shells (much larger, on the order of the total energy width). ETH ensures that f_O(E) varies slowly over scales of \Delta E, smoothing any eigenstate-to-eigenstate fluctuations that might otherwise prevent the approximation. This holds for generic non-integrable Hamiltonians where eigenstates exhibit random-like properties, as posited in ETH.^[14]^[15] Off-diagonal matrix elements \langle m | \hat{O} | n \rangle (with m \neq n) play a crucial role in the time evolution but are suppressed under ETH. The ETH ansatz implies these elements decay rapidly with the energy difference \omega = E_m - E_n and are typically of magnitude e^{-S(E)/2} h_O(E, \omega), where S(E) is the thermodynamic entropy (scaling as N) and h_O is a smooth function. This suppression leads to rapid dephasing in the time-dependent expectation value \langle \psi(t) | \hat{O} | \psi(t) \rangle, rendering finite-time corrections to the infinite-time (diagonal ensemble) average negligible for local observables.^[15]^[16] Quantitatively, the difference between the diagonal and microcanonical averages satisfies |\langle \hat{O} \rangle_\mathrm{DE} - \langle \hat{O} \rangle_\mathrm{MC}| \sim e^{-S/2} times fluctuation terms, which is exponentially small in the system size N. This exponential suppression arises from both the variance in diagonal elements and the off-diagonal contributions, ensuring the ensembles agree to leading order.^[15]^[16] The implications of this equivalence are profound: in systems where ETH holds, such as chaotic many-body quantum systems, the microcanonical ensemble provides a reliable tool for predicting equilibrium properties of local observables, independent of the specific initial state details beyond its average energy. This justifies the use of thermodynamic ensembles in closed quantum systems, bridging quantum dynamics and classical statistical mechanics.^[14]^[15]

Empirical Validation

Numerical Tests

Numerical tests of the eigenstate thermalization hypothesis (ETH) have primarily relied on exact diagonalization of finite-sized many-body Hamiltonians, allowing computation of eigenstate expectation values and comparisons to thermal predictions. Early investigations focused on spin chain models, where Srednicki demonstrated in 1994 that for a non-integrable spin-1/2 chain with nearest-neighbor interactions, the diagonal matrix elements \langle n | \hat{O} | n \rangle of local observables \hat{O} in energy eigenstates |n\rangle closely match microcanonical averages at corresponding energies, supporting thermalization in chaotic systems.^[17] These calculations, performed on chains up to length 16, revealed smooth energy dependence of the diagonals with small fluctuations, consistent with the ETH ansatz. Lattice models provided further validation, particularly for bosonic systems. In 2008, Rigol et al. studied one-dimensional hard-core bosons under the Bose-Hubbard Hamiltonian with nearest- and next-nearest-neighbor hopping, showing that non-integrable cases exhibit rapid entanglement growth and equilibration to a generalized Gibbs ensemble via exact diagonalization of systems with up to 20 sites. In contrast, integrable limits displayed slower relaxation and persistent oscillations, highlighting ETH's dependence on chaos. These tests confirmed that diagonal elements \langle n | \hat{n}_i | n \rangle for density operators align with microcanonical expectations in the chaotic regime, with relative errors below 1% for mid-spectrum states. Comparisons to random matrix theory (RMT) have been a cornerstone of numerical verification, assessing the "chaotic" nature of eigenstates. For non-integrable Hamiltonians like perturbed spin chains or SYK-like models, level spacing statistics follow the Wigner-Dyson distribution of the Gaussian Orthogonal Ensemble (GOE) for time-reversal symmetric systems, while the inverse participation ratio (IPR) \sum_n |\langle n | \psi \rangle|^4 of eigenstates in a fixed basis remains exponentially small (\sim e^{-L} for system size L), indicating delocalization akin to GOE/GUE ensembles. Such matches, observed in simulations of up to 18-qubit systems, underscore ETH's link to quantum chaos, with deviations signaling integrability. Recent advances extend these tests to disordered and circuit models. Numerical studies of the Sachdev-Ye-Kitaev (SYK) model, a benchmark for maximal chaos, verify the ETH for off-diagonal elements \langle m | \hat{O} | n \rangle (with m \neq n), showing exponential suppression |\langle m | \hat{O} | n \rangle| \sim e^{-S/2} where S is the entropy, through exact diagonalization of N \leq 28 Majorana fermions. In 2025, simulations of small-scale interacting quantum circuits (up to 12 qubits) probed full ETH in ergodicity-breaking scenarios, confirming spectral form factors and matrix element fluctuations align with RMT predictions despite partial localization.^[18] Key metrics in these tests include the relative entropy S(\rho_{\rm diag} || \rho_{\rm micro}) between the diagonal ensemble \rho_{\rm diag} = \sum_n |c_n|^2 |n\rangle\langle n| and the microcanonical state, which approaches zero for ETH-compliant systems, and the variance \sigma^2_{\langle n | \hat{O} | n \rangle} across eigenstates in an energy window, scaling as e^{-S} for smooth thermalization. These quantify closeness to thermal expectations without full state tomography. Finite-size effects pose significant challenges, as accessible system sizes (L \lesssim 20) can introduce artificial fluctuations or mimic non-thermal behavior due to boundary conditions and incomplete ergodicity sampling. For instance, in spin chains, IPR values may appear larger than GOE predictions for small L, requiring extrapolations to infinite size via finite-size scaling analysis to robustly confirm ETH.

Experimental Evidence

Laboratory experiments using quantum simulators have provided compelling evidence for the eigenstate thermalization hypothesis (ETH) by observing thermalization dynamics in isolated many-body systems. In systems of ultracold Rydberg atoms arranged in arrays, a 2022 experiment demonstrated the validity of a generalized ETH in a PXP model, where individual energy eigenstates exhibited thermal-like properties for local observables after accounting for quantum many-body scars. Researchers prepared initial states and monitored time evolution, finding that expectation values approached microcanonical predictions, consistent with ETH predictions from numerical models.^[19] Trapped ion platforms in the 2020s have further supported ETH through measurements of spin observables in long-range interacting spin chains. For instance, studies have compared diagonal ensemble averages to microcanonical ensemble results, revealing close agreement for local magnetization and correlation functions in non-integrable regimes. These experiments, often involving quenches in Ising-like Hamiltonians, show relaxation to equilibrium states that align with ETH expectations, although direct access to pure eigenstates remains challenging. Key experimental signatures reinforcing ETH include the observation of thermal light cones, where information propagates at finite speeds consistent with hydrodynamic descriptions in thermalizing systems, and diminished IPR values signaling the absence of localization in chaotic dynamics. However, challenges persist, such as the difficulty in preparing and isolating pure energy eigenstates, leading most tests to rely on indirect probes like quench dynamics and time-averaged observables to infer eigenstate properties.

Alternatives and Limitations

Many-Body Localization

Many-body localization (MBL) is a dynamical phase of matter that occurs in isolated quantum systems with quenched disorder and interactions, where the system fails to thermalize and instead exhibits insulating behavior even at finite energy densities above the ground state. In this phase, originally proposed in the context of weakly interacting electrons with localized single-particle states, the absence of thermalization arises from the localization of many-body states, preventing the redistribution of energy across the system. Characteristic features include logarithmic growth of entanglement entropy after a quantum quench and the persistence of initial-state memory in local observables over long times. In stark contrast to the eigenstate thermalization hypothesis (ETH), where individual energy eigenstates appear thermal with volume-law entanglement, MBL eigenstates are non-thermal, displaying area-law entanglement entropy that scales with the boundary rather than the volume of subsystems. This non-ergodicity is underpinned by the existence of a complete set of quasi-local integrals of motion (LIOMs), which are approximately conserved operators localized in real space and commuting with the Hamiltonian, effectively rendering the system integrable despite interactions.^[20] These LIOMs constrain the dynamics, suppressing transport and ensuring that expectation values of local operators remain close to their initial values indefinitely.^[20] The transition from the ETH (ergodic) phase to the MBL phase occurs as a function of disorder strength, typically in one dimension where localization is favored. Imry-Ma arguments, adapted from classical random-field models, suggest that sufficiently strong disorder disrupts ordered or delocalized phases by creating domain walls whose energy cost is overcome by the random potential, stabilizing localization against interactions in low dimensions; in clean or weakly disordered chaotic systems, ETH prevails, while strong disorder induces MBL. The critical disorder strength marks a non-equilibrium phase transition, often characterized by critical scaling in entanglement or spectral properties. Diagnostics for identifying the MBL phase include the distribution of energy level spacings, which follows a Poisson statistics in MBL—indicative of uncorrelated levels akin to integrable systems—contrasting with the Wigner-Dyson (random-matrix) statistics of the ETH phase, where levels repel due to chaos.^[21] Additionally, MBL eigenstates fail to satisfy the ETH ansatz, as their diagonal matrix elements do not match thermal averages and off-diagonal elements do not exhibit the expected exponential suppression in the basis of local operators.^[21] Recent studies as of 2025 have highlighted connections between MBL and quantum computation, particularly in the context of error correction, where the non-ergodic nature of MBL phases can stabilize logical qubits against decoherence by leveraging localized states as error-protected subspaces, contrasting with ETH systems that rapidly scramble information. The breakdown of ETH in MBL has profound implications for non-equilibrium dynamics, explaining the emergence of prethermalization plateaus where systems exhibit quasi-conserved quantities leading to long-lived non-thermal states before any slow relaxation, as observed in Floquet-driven systems stabilized by approximate LIOMs.

Other Non-Thermalizing Scenarios

In integrable quantum many-body systems, the eigenstate thermalization hypothesis (ETH) fails due to the presence of an extensive number of conserved quantities, which prevent individual energy eigenstates from appearing thermal with respect to a canonical ensemble. Instead, such systems equilibrate to a generalized Gibbs ensemble (GGE) that accounts for all integrals of motion, leading to non-thermal steady states where expectation values of local observables deviate systematically from thermal predictions.^[22] For example, in free fermion models, the conservation of occupation numbers for each momentum mode enforces ballistic transport and inhibits diffusive thermalization, as eigenstates retain correlations tied to the underlying integrable structure.^[22] A prominent example is the spin-1/2 XXZ Heisenberg chain at anisotropy parameter \Delta = 1, which reduces to the isotropic XXX model and is fully integrable. Numerical studies using exact diagonalization reveal that eigenstates exhibit volume-law entanglement but display eigenstate-to-eigenstate fluctuations in the reduced density matrix that decay only as L^{-1/2} (where L is the system size), rather than exponentially as expected under ETH; this slower decay signals persistent non-thermal features due to integrability.^[23] Consequently, time evolution from generic initial states shows recurrence to generalized ensembles rather than full thermalization.^[24] Prethermalization represents another scenario where ETH does not hold on long timescales, featuring an intermediate regime of quasi-thermal behavior before eventual heating or recurrence. In periodically driven (Floquet) systems, weak interactions and high drive frequencies stabilize prethermal plateaus where local observables mimic thermal expectations for times exponentially long in the frequency, but the absence of true eigenstate thermalization leads to delayed absorption of energy and algebraic heating at later stages.^[25] This phenomenon arises in nearly integrable setups, where short-time dynamics appear thermal-like due to rapid intra-band scattering, yet conserved quantities or weak chaos prevent complete ergodicity.^[25] Hydrodynamic constraints in systems with weak chaos or near-conformal invariance can also violate ETH by enforcing ballistic or superdiffusive transport, incompatible with the diffusive assumptions underlying thermalization. In such cases, low-energy excitations propagate without sufficient scattering, leading to non-ergodic steady states where eigenstate expectation values reflect hydrodynamic modes rather than canonical thermal ones.^[26] For instance, frustration-free models with scarring exhibit anomalous hydrodynamics, where rare non-thermal eigenstates coexist with mostly thermal ones, resulting in weak ETH violations and persistent coherences that hinder full thermalization.^[26] Near critical points with weak ETH violations, such as those bordering regimes of slow dynamics, thermalization occurs on extended timescales due to power-law decays in correlations and entanglement growth. These regions feature most eigenstates obeying weak ETH (thermal typicality), but subtle deviations cause logarithmic or subdiffusive relaxation, as seen in analyses of random potentials where the transition to ergodicity is marked by critical exponents around \nu \approx 3.2.^[27] This slow thermalization underscores the fragility of ETH in marginally chaotic environments without strong disorder.^[27]

Advanced Considerations

Temporal Fluctuations in Expectation Values

In isolated quantum many-body systems obeying the eigenstate thermalization hypothesis (ETH), the time-dependent expectation value of a local observable O in an initial state |\psi\rangle = \sum_n c_n |n\rangle deviates from its diagonal ensemble average \langle O \rangle_\mathrm{DE} = \sum_n |c_n|^2 \langle n | O | n \rangle due to coherent contributions from off-diagonal matrix elements. Specifically, \langle O(t) \rangle - \langle O \rangle_\mathrm{DE} \approx \sum_{m \neq n} c_m c_n^* \langle m | O | n \rangle e^{i (E_m - E_n) t / \hbar}, where the sum involves phases that cause interference.^[28] Under ETH, these off-diagonal elements \langle m | O | n \rangle for m \neq n are exponentially suppressed as \sim e^{-S(E)/2} f_O(E, \omega_{mn}) R_{mn}, where S(E) is the thermodynamic entropy at energy E, f_O is a smooth function encoding dynamic correlations, and R_{mn} is a random variable of order unity with zero mean. This suppression ensures that the phases dephase rapidly, leading to decay of the fluctuations on the Heisenberg timescale \tau_H \sim \hbar / \Delta(E), where \Delta(E) \sim e^{-S(E)} is the mean level spacing in the energy shell; for large systems, \tau_H becomes exponentially long, effectively establishing equilibration before full recurrence.^[28] Although the Poincaré recurrence theorem guarantees that the system returns arbitrarily close to its initial state after a time scaling as e^{S}, which is practically infinite for macroscopic systems, ETH implies that temporal fluctuations damp sufficiently quickly to yield thermal-like behavior on accessible timescales, with the diagonal ensemble value approximating the thermal expectation.^[29] The variance of these temporal fluctuations can be characterized as \mathrm{Var}[\langle O(t) \rangle] \sim (\Delta E / \hbar)^2 \int |h_O(\omega)|^2 \, d\omega, where \Delta E is the energy spread of the initial state, and h_O(\omega) relates to the Fourier transform of the off-diagonal correlations; this variance decays with increasing system size due to the diminishing role of off-diagonals, ensuring smaller deviations from the equilibrated value.^[28]^[30] Numerical simulations and experiments in trapped-ion quantum simulators have observed this damping behavior, where expectation values of spin observables in non-integrable spin chains exhibit initial oscillations that decay toward diagonal ensemble predictions on timescales consistent with dephasing, before any long-term recurrence effects become relevant.^[31]

Quantum and Thermal Fluctuations

In the context of the eigenstate thermalization hypothesis (ETH), quantum fluctuations refer to the inherent uncertainties in observables within individual energy eigenstates |n\rangle of a chaotic quantum many-body system. For a local operator O, the quantum variance is given by \operatorname{Var}_n(O) = \langle n | O^2 | n \rangle - \langle n | O | n \rangle^2. Under ETH, this variance arises primarily from the off-diagonal matrix elements O_{nm} for m \neq n, which are posited to follow a random form characterized by exponential suppression scaling as e^{-S(E_n)/2}, where S(E_n) is the thermodynamic entropy at energy E_n. This randomness ensures that the fluctuations in |n\rangle mimic those expected in a thermal state, with the dense spectrum of states compensating the suppression to yield finite, observable-scale variances.^[32] The ETH establishes an equivalence between these quantum eigenstate fluctuations and thermal fluctuations in the canonical ensemble at inverse temperature \beta(E_n), where \beta(E_n) is determined by the energy E_n. For the total energy operator, the thermal variance is \operatorname{Var}(H)_{\rm thermal} = k T^2 C_V, with k the Boltzmann constant, T = 1/(k \beta), and C_V the heat capacity; however, for local operators like density or spin, the eigenstate variance \operatorname{Var}_n(O) matches the thermal susceptibility or response function, \sigma_O^2 \approx \frac{\partial^2 \log Z}{\partial \beta^2}, where Z is the partition function. This mirroring is captured in the ETH ansatz through the function g_O(E_n, \omega), which governs the smooth energy and frequency dependence of the off-diagonal elements, ensuring the integrated variance aligns with ensemble averages without requiring explicit averaging over states. Unlike classical thermal fluctuations, which stem from ergodic exploration of phase space in an ensemble or long-time average, quantum fluctuations in ETH eigenstates incorporate zero-point motion inherent to wavefunction delocalization, even at zero temperature. In chaotic quantum systems, however, ETH aligns these variances with classical thermal ones by suppressing eigenstate-to-eigenstate variations in \langle n | O | n \rangle to negligible levels, \sim e^{-S/2}, while preserving the quantum variance at the thermal scale. This distinction highlights how quantum chaos bridges pure-state descriptions to semiclassical thermodynamics.^[32] The equivalence of quantum and thermal fluctuations under ETH validates the use of semiclassical thermal descriptions for quantum chaotic systems, as it confirms that local observables in individual eigenstates exhibit the same statistical properties as in a grand canonical or canonical bath. This has profound implications for understanding equilibrium in isolated quantum systems, supporting derivations of linear response and fluctuation-dissipation relations directly from eigenstate properties.

Broader Validity and Open Questions

The eigenstate thermalization hypothesis (ETH) holds for generic non-integrable many-body quantum systems, where individual energy eigenstates exhibit thermal properties for local observables, leading to equilibration after quantum quenches.^[33] It fails in integrable systems, which possess extensive conserved quantities preventing thermalization, and in many-body localized (MBL) phases, where disorder induces localization and non-ergodicity.^[33] Partial adherence appears in strongly interacting models like the Sachdev-Ye-Kitaev (SYK) model, which shows ETH-like behavior for certain correlators despite maximal chaos, and in black hole analogs, where holographic duality suggests thermalization aligned with ETH in the large-N limit.^[34] As a conjecture rather than a theorem, ETH remains empirically supported through numerical and experimental tests but is not universally applicable, with exceptions in non-chaotic or constrained systems.^[33] It connects mathematically to quantum unique ergodicity (QUE), a stronger statement that eigenfunctions of chaotic Hamiltonians equidistribute in phase space, proven in specific random matrix ensembles like Wigner matrices with optimal convergence rates.^[35] Key open questions include deriving a rigorous proof of ETH from first principles, such as through concentration inequalities and quantum mixing in chaotic systems, though current strategies provide bounds for equilibration times scaling exponentially with entropy.^[34] Another frontier is its role in open quantum systems, where generalizations of ETH predict thermalization under weak dissipation, but limits arise from "no-go" theorems for certain bath couplings.^[36] In gravitational contexts, holography via AdS/CFT duality supports strong ETH for black hole microstates, yet challenges persist in accounting for wormhole effects on higher-point correlators.^[34] Recent 2025 developments link ETH to quantum computing, enabling efficient preparation of thermal states by leveraging time-averaged expectation values in non-integrable circuits, bypassing explicit wavefunction superposition with polynomial scaling in system size.^[37] Tests in low-dimensional systems, such as small-scale quantum processors simulating SYK-like models, confirm ETH validity for chaotic dynamics while revealing scars in constrained lattices.^[38] Looking ahead, ETH implications extend to quantum simulation of Gibbs states on noisy intermediate-scale devices, reducing overhead via Lindblad engineering under ETH assumptions, and to high-energy physics, where holographic models inform thermalization in quark-gluon plasmas or early-universe dynamics.^[39]^[34]

References

[1]
[1805.01616] Eigenstate Thermalization Hypothesis - arXiv
May 4, 2018 · The Eigenstate Thermalization Hypothesis (ETH) states that individual energy eigenstates behave like a statistical ensemble.
[2]
Eigenstate thermalization hypothesis - IOPscience
Jul 2, 2018 · The eigenstate thermalization hypothesis (ETH) states that individual energy eigenstates behave like a statistical ensemble.
[3]
Chaos and quantum thermalization | Phys. Rev. E
Aug 1, 1994 · We call this phenomenon eigenstate thermalization. We show that a generic initial state will approach thermal equilibrium at least as fast ...
[4]
Experimental verification of generalized eigenstate thermalization ...
Jun 28, 2022 · Among the numerous efforts, the eigenstate thermalization hypothesis (ETH), which states that thermalization occurs at the level of a single ...
[5]
Eigenstate Thermalization Hypothesis with Projective Representation
Sep 2, 2025 · The Eigenstate Thermalization Hypothesis (ETH) provides a sufficient condition for thermalization of isolated quantum systems. While the ...<|control11|><|separator|>
[6]
Quantum statistical mechanics in a closed system | Phys. Rev. A
Feb 1, 1991 · A closed quantum-mechanical system with a large number of degrees of freedom does not necessarily give time averages in agreement with the microcanonical ...
[7]
Eigenstate Thermalization Hypothesis: A Short Review - SciPost
Abstract. Understanding how an isolated quantum system evolves toward a thermal state from an initial state far from equilibrium—such as one ...
[8]
https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevA.43.2046
[9]
[PDF] Proof of the Ergodic Theorem and the H-Theorem in Quantum ...
The main notions of statistical mechanics are re-interpreted in a quantum-mechanical way, the ergodic theorem and the H-theorem are formulated and proven ( ...Missing: motivation | Show results with:motivation
[10]
The approach to thermal equilibrium in quantized chaotic systems
Sep 25, 1998 · View a PDF of the paper titled The approach to thermal equilibrium in quantized chaotic systems, by Mark Srednicki ... A 32 (1999) 1163.
[11]
From Quantum Chaos and Eigenstate Thermalization to Statistical ...
Sep 21, 2015 · This review gives a pedagogical introduction to the eigenstate thermalization hypothesis (ETH), its basis, and its implications to statistical mechanics and ...
[12]
Eigenstate thermalization and its breakdown in quantum spin chains ...
The ETH is usually formulated as an ansatz for matrix elements of physical observables in the eigenbasis of the Hamiltonian [17–20] . This ansatz guarantees ...
[13]
https://doi.org/10.1038/nature06838
[14]
https://arxiv.org/pdf/cond-mat/9403051.pdf
[15]
https://arxiv.org/pdf/1505.07627.pdf
[16]
[PDF] Eigenstate thermalization hypothesis
Sep 15, 2023 · This review of the ETH takes a somewhat intuitive approach as to why it works and how this informs our understanding of many body quantum states ...
[17]
[cond-mat/9403051] Chaos and Quantum Thermalization - arXiv
We call this phenomenon {\it eigenstate thermalization}. We show that a generic initial state will approach thermal equilibrium at least as fast as O(\hbar/\ ...
[18]
[2504.08517] Probes of Full Eigenstate Thermalization in Ergodicity ...
Apr 11, 2025 · This paper studies probes of full ETH in ergodicity-breaking quantum circuits, using numerical and analytical results for interacting ...
[19]
Typical thermalization of low-entanglement states - Nature
Jul 17, 2025 · Reimann, P. & Dabelow, L. Refining Deutsch's approach to thermalization. Phys. Rev. E 103, 022119 (2021). Article MathSciNet Google Scholar.
[20]
The Eigenstate Thermalization Hypothesis in a Quantum Point ...
Jan 6, 2025 · We explore this hypothesis when the fermion subsystem is only minimally coupled to a quantum reservoir (in the form of another fermion system) ...
[21]
[1407.8480] Constructing local integrals of motion in the many-body ...
Jul 31, 2014 · Here we report a physically motivated construction of local integrals of motion in the MBL phase. We show that any local operator (eg, a local particle number ...
[22]
Spectral statistics across the many-body localization transition - arXiv
Aug 28, 2015 · We demonstrate that the flow from Wigner-Dyson to Poisson statistics is a two-stage process. ... level statistics belongs to a semi-Poisson ...Missing: MBL ETH ansatz
[23]
Eigenstate thermalization hypothesis (ETH) and integrability ... - arXiv
Sep 22, 2014 · We investigate the eigenstate thermalization hypothesis (ETH) in integrable models, focusing on the spin-1/2 isotropic Heisenberg (XXX) chain.
[24]
Eigenstate thermalization hypothesis and eigenstate-to-eigenstate ...
We investigate the extent to which the eigenstate thermalization hypothesis (ETH) is valid or violated in the nonintegrable and the integrable spin-1 /2 ...
[25]
Eigenstate thermalization hypothesis and eigenstate-to-eigenstate ...
The ETH ansatz in Eq. (3) for the off-diagonal elements requires that all matrix elements should be equivalent statistically within a block submatrix for a ...
[26]
Floquet prethermalization and regimes of heating in a periodically ...
Apr 3, 2017 · The eigenstate thermalization hypothesis (ETH) suggests that generic interacting many-body systems heat up to infinite temperature, thus ...
[27]
Anomalous hydrodynamics in a class of scarred frustration-free ...
Jan 14, 2022 · Moreover, studies of the so-called PXP model revealed that also weaker violations of the ETH are possible, where rare nonthermal states coexist ...
[28]
Strong and Weak Many-Body Localizations
### Summary of Weak ETH Violations Near MBL Critical Points
[29]
[PDF] Random matrix theory and eigenstate thermalization
The ergodic hypothesis says that, if we evolve a system in time, it will visit every region in the accessible phase space, and the time spend in any region of ...
[30]
https://arxiv.org/pdf/2008.09318.pdf
[31]
https://arxiv.org/abs/2007.10347
[32]
Probing eigenstate thermalization in quantum simulators via ... - arXiv
Jul 20, 2020 · The eigenstate thermalization hypothesis (ETH) offers a universal mechanism for the approach to equilibrium of closed quantum many-body systems.
[33]
https://arxiv.org/pdf/2501.07243.pdf
[34]
https://arxiv.org/pdf/2411.09746.pdf
[35]
https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s00220-024-05143-y
[36]
Eigenstate Thermalization Hypothesis for Wigner-Type Matrices
Nov 6, 2024 · We prove the Eigenstate Thermalization Hypothesis for general Wigner-type matrices in the bulk of the self-consistent spectrum, with optimal control on the ...
[37]
[2504.10261] Universality, Robustness, and Limits of the Eigenstate ...
Apr 14, 2025 · The paper investigates the eigenstate thermalization hypothesis (ETH) in open quantum systems, showing its validity and limits, including a 'no ...
[38]
https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0375960125004906
[39]
Testing Eigenstate Thermalization Hypothesis on small-scale ...
The Eigenstate Thermalization Hypothesis (ETH) is a framework for discussing thermal behavior originating from chaotic dynamics in isolated many-body quantum ...
[40]
Lindblad engineering for quantum Gibbs state preparation under the ...
Aug 29, 2025 · Lindblad engineering for quantum Gibbs state preparation under the eigenstate thermalization hypothesis ... Quantum 9, 1843 (2025). Get ...<|control11|><|separator|>