Fact-checked by Grok 2 weeks ago

GRECE

The Groupement de recherche et d'études pour la civilisation européenne (GRECE), founded on January 17, 1969, by , is a French intellectual organization dedicated to the study and defense of through metapolitical strategies that prioritize cultural influence over direct political engagement. As the central of the movement, GRECE has promoted ideas emphasizing ethnic and cultural differentiation, Indo-European heritage, and critiques of egalitarian ideologies including , , and aspects of , advocating instead for hierarchical structures, pagan spiritual traditions, and a federalist vision of rooted in distinct peoples. Its publications, such as the journals Éléments and Krisis, have disseminated these perspectives, influencing debates on identity, immigration, and globalization while rejecting both American and universalist humanism. GRECE's approach, often described as a "right-wing Gramscianism," seeks long-term ideological by reframing traditionalist and identitarian concepts in Gramscian terms adapted to European particularism, though it has faced accusations of underlying racialism despite its explicit endorsement of —the principle of preserving cultural differences without hierarchy among groups. Key figures beyond de Benoist, including and Pierre Vial, contributed to its evolution, with notable divergences such as Faye's later archeofuturism highlighting internal debates on modernity and technology.

History

Founding and Early Years (1968–1977)

The Groupement de recherche et d'études pour la civilisation européenne (GRECE) was established in 1968 in by , then aged 25, along with associates including Giorgio Locchi, , Jean-Claude Rivière, Pierre Bérard, Pierre Vial, and Jean-Claude Valla, many of whom had prior involvement in far-right organizations such as Europe-Action and the Fédération des étudiants nationalistes. The initiative emerged amid the perceived failures of direct political activism on the right following events like the and the rise of left-wing cultural dominance, prompting a shift toward metapolitical influence—focusing on long-term ideological and cultural groundwork rather than electoral or street-level engagement. Officially declared on January 17, 1969, at its headquarters, GRECE positioned itself as a dedicated to research and advocacy for civilization, drawing on themes of , , and of egalitarian . In its formative phase, the group prioritized intellectual output over public proselytizing; it launched the annual publication Nouvelle École in 1968, which served as a platform for essays on Indo-European origins, pagan traditions, and anti-modernist perspectives. Early activities involved seminars, study circles, and collaborations among roughly several dozen activists, emphasizing first-principles analysis of civilizational decline and the need for cultural renewal. The approach was influenced by de Benoist's prior writings, such as his 1965 book Les Indo-Européens, which explored mythological and historical roots of . Through the early 1970s, GRECE maintained a low public profile, with its first notable press mention appearing in December 1972 in the satirical weekly Le Canard enchaîné, which alleged ties to neo-Nazi elements—a charge that highlighted emerging tensions with mainstream narratives but did not derail internal development. By 1973, the bimonthly magazine Éléments was introduced, expanding dissemination of ideas on ethnopluralism and opposition to mass immigration, while internal debates solidified critiques of Christianity's role in egalitarianism and advocacy for a federated Europe of differences. Membership grew modestly among intellectuals disillusioned with post-1968 leftist hegemony, fostering networks that laid groundwork for broader Nouvelle Droite influence, though the period remained marked by consolidation rather than widespread outreach.

Growth Amid Opposition (1978–1993)

Following the 1977 publication of Alain de Benoist's Vu de droite, which earned the Prix de l'Essai from the Académie Française in 1978, GRECE's intellectual profile rose amid expanding activities. The organization consolidated its metapolitical approach through journals such as Éléments (launched 1973) and Nouvelle École (1968), alongside the establishment of the Copernic publishing house in 1976, facilitating broader dissemination of critiques against egalitarianism and mass democracy. Annual summer universities and seminars, held from the early 1970s onward, fostered networking among European intellectuals, contributing to organizational growth despite limited formal membership structures. In 1979, mainstream media coverage, often from left-leaning outlets like , spotlighted the as an emerging intellectual force, triggering accusations of veiled and —a portrayal that conflated GRECE's advocacy for with , despite the group's explicit rejection of in favor of cultural preservation. This "summer of the " marked the onset of sustained opposition, including polemics dismissing the movement's ideas as a "shoddy ," yet GRECE reported steady expansion, with de Benoist noting in 1980 that its concepts were permeating public discourse. Such critiques, emanating from academia and media institutions prone to left-wing bias, aimed to marginalize the group but inadvertently amplified its visibility. Through the 1980s, GRECE claimed around 2,500 full members by 1985–1986, influencing a wider network estimated at 5,000 to 8,000 adherents, while de Benoist authored prolific works like Les Idées à l'endroit (1979) challenging progressive ideologies. Internal tensions arose, notably the 1986 departure of following his book La Colonisation de l'Europe: Le bilan (1985), which explicitly warned of demographic shifts and led to his expulsion for deviating from the group's nuanced cultural strategy. External pressures persisted, but GRECE maintained operations via lectures, international collaborations, and publications critiquing and American hegemony. By the early , renewed media scrutiny in 1993–1994 reiterated charges of " with a face," reflecting ongoing institutional resistance to differentialist thought. Nonetheless, the solidified GRECE's role in shaping identitarian discourse, with sustained output ensuring persistence amid adversarial environments.

Adaptation and Persistence (1994–Present)

In the aftermath of intensified media scrutiny and political marginalization in the early , GRECE shifted emphasis toward a more explicit critique of post-Cold War and European supranationalism, exemplified by the 1999 Manifesto for a European Renaissance, co-authored by and Charles Champetier to mark the organization's thirtieth anniversary. This document diagnosed the erosion of European identities under liberal , economic homogenization, and unchecked , advocating instead for a confederated preserving ethnopluralist diversity and rooted in pre-Christian Indo-European spiritual traditions. It represented an by integrating earlier metapolitical strategies with responses to Maastricht-era , rejecting both Atlanticist and undifferentiated in favor of differentialist cultural . GRECE's colloquia, such as the 1993 gathering on environmental stakes, further evolved to address ecological critiques of industrial modernity, positioning pagan-inspired against egalitarian . Despite systemic exclusion from academic and media establishments—where left-leaning institutional biases often conflate differentialist analysis with extremism—GRECE demonstrated persistence through sustained intellectual output. De Benoist, as central figure, produced dozens of works post-1999, including critiques of democratic homogenization (Les Démocraties selon Tocqueville, 2008) and religious (L'Identité, ongoing series into the ), while editing journals Nouvelle École and Krisis to disseminate ideas on identity preservation amid demographic shifts. Internal debates, such as those with former associate over radical anti-Islamism, underscored GRECE's commitment to metapolitical restraint over activist confrontation, with Faye's 1986 departure highlighting tensions between cultural strategy and direct identitarian mobilization. By the , this approach influenced European networks critiquing and EU , maintaining GRECE's role as a laboratory without electoral entanglement. Into the and , GRECE adapted to digital-era fragmentation by leveraging de Benoist's engagements with international counterparts, including dialogues on conservative multipolarity with Russian thinkers, while critiquing neoliberal responses to crises like the 2008 financial downturn and 2015 migration surges. Annual gatherings and publications continued, with de Benoist authoring over 100 volumes by 2020, emphasizing causal links between egalitarian ideologies and civilizational decline—claims empirically grounded in demographic data showing Europe's native population stagnation against non-European inflows exceeding 1 million annually in peaks like 2015. This endurance reflects causal realism: outlasts ephemeral opprobrium, as evidenced by GRECE's indirect permeation into broader critiques of , even as mainstream sources, prone to ideological filtering, understate its analytical contributions.

Organizational Framework

Structure and Operations

GRECE functions as a metapolitical , emphasizing long-term cultural and ideological influence over electoral politics, operating through intellectual research, debate, and dissemination rather than hierarchical party structures. Its organizational framework is decentralized, comprising a core group of coordinators in and affiliated "camps" (camps régionaux) across and , which serve as local forums for discussions and networking among members. This loose allows flexibility in operations, prioritizing idea generation over rigid , with decisions guided by key figures rather than formal voting mechanisms. Leadership centers on influential thinkers, with as the foundational ideologue and ongoing director since 1968, while successive presidents handle administrative duties; for instance, Jean-Claude Valla preceded Pierre Vial, who assumed a leading role by 1983 to reinforce metapolitical focus amid external pressures. Membership remains selective and non-public, limited to invited intellectuals, academics, and cultural figures vetted for alignment with its civilizational research mandate, avoiding mass recruitment to preserve analytical depth; access involves subscriptions to outputs rather than open enrollment. Core operations revolve around publishing and events: key journals include Nouvelle École (launched 1968 as a quarterly on ) and Éléments (established 1973 for broader cultural analysis), alongside books and essays critiquing modernity. The group organizes periodic national colloquia—such as the ninth documented in historical accounts—and seminars to explore themes like and , fostering debate without partisan endorsements. Funding sustains independence through private means, primarily sales of publications, event fees, and donations from sympathizers, eschewing public subsidies to evade institutional biases prevalent in state-aligned academia. This model, critiqued by opponents as elitist but defended by participants as essential for uncompromised inquiry, has enabled persistence despite marginalization by mainstream outlets.

Leadership and Membership

Alain de Benoist has been the central figure in GRECE's leadership since co-founding the organization on January 8, 1968, in , . As its primary intellectual architect and director, de Benoist shaped its metapolitical orientation and remains its most prominent spokesman, authoring key manifestos and directing editorial output. During a period of internal reorganization, Jacques Marlaud served as GRECE's from 1987 to 1991, marking a brief shift in formal while de Benoist retained authority. The emphasizes decentralized "circles" of discussion rather than hierarchical political structures, aligning with GRECE's strategy of influencing culture over direct governance. Membership in GRECE has historically been limited to a selective group of around forty at its legal incorporation in , prioritizing quality over quantity to foster elite philosophical engagement. Recruited by invitation, members include academics, writers, and thinkers such as co-founder Pierre Vial, who edited the journal Éléments until 1986, and Giorgio Locchi, an early collaborator focused on . The organization experienced notable departures, including that of in the late 1980s following disputes over ideological direction, particularly Faye's advocacy for more confrontational positions. Other associated figures, like Jean-Yves Le Gallou, contributed to affiliated publications but operated semi-independently. GRECE's elitist model avoids mass membership, viewing broad as counterproductive to its long-term cultural influence goals.

Intellectual Foundations

Metapolitics and Cultural Strategy

GRECE's framework prioritizes the transformation of cultural paradigms and intellectual discourse as prerequisites for viable political change, viewing direct electoral or partisan efforts as futile without underlying shifts in societal values. articulated this as operating on a plane where ideas indirectly cause political effects by altering collective mental structures and representations, rather than substituting for politics itself. Emerging in the 1970s amid the Nouvelle Droite's reassessment of post-1968 dynamics, the approach rejected traditional right-wing activism—deemed marginalized by dominant egalitarian ideologies—in favor of long-term influence on to erode liberal hegemony. Influenced by Antonio Gramsci's analysis of secured through cultural institutions, de Benoist proposed a "right Gramscianism" in which intellectuals propagate counter-narratives to challenge universalist and individualist dominance, fostering organic consensus around differentialist and identitarian principles. This entails cultivating "organic intellectuals" to intervene in , , and , promoting critiques of Americanism, , and homogenization while reviving pre-Christian European traditions as foundations for a federated, hierarchical order. The strategy assumes causal primacy of culture: only by normalizing such views can political movements gain traction, avoiding the pitfalls of isolated ideological purity. Implementation relies on sustained publication and dissemination, with GRECE producing journals like Éléments (initiated 1973 for geopolitical and ) and Krisis (launched 1988 for epochal critiques), alongside over 200 books by affiliated authors since 1968. These vehicles target elite opinion-formers, hosting seminars and debates to embed ideas on and anti-egalitarianism into broader discourse, evidenced by citations in academic works on despite institutional resistance. Outcomes include indirect shaping of debates on and , though mainstream sources often attribute persistent marginalization to the framework's association with exclusionary themes.

Ethnopluralism and Identity Preservation

, a foundational concept in GRECE's intellectual framework, advocates for the preservation of distinct ethno-cultural identities through the principle of non-interference and spatial separation among peoples. Coined and developed by , a leading GRECE thinker, it rejects universalist ideologies that promote cultural homogenization, instead positing that human diversity thrives when each ethnic group maintains within its historical territories. This approach frames and mass as threats to organic cultural continuity, arguing that prolonged contact leads to inevitable dilution or conflict rather than enrichment. De Benoist articulated as an extension of the "right to ," initially drawing from earlier differentialist ideas but evolving in the to emphasize cultural rather than strictly biological boundaries. Within GRECE, serves as a metapolitical strategy to counter liberal and by promoting a federated of homogeneous regions, where identity is rooted in pre-modern, folk-derived traditions rather than abstract citizenship. The group critiques the nation-state as an artificial construct that erodes deeper ethno-cultural ties, favoring instead ethno-regionalism that aligns political units with historical ethnies. Key GRECE publications, such as those in Éléments, disseminated these ideas by highlighting empirical examples of cultural erosion in immigrant-heavy urban areas, like demographic shifts in French banlieues during the late , where native populations fell below 50% in some districts by the . Proponents argue this preserves not only European heritage but global diversity, extending support to anti-colonial movements in the Third World as bulwarks against Western homogenization. Identity preservation under entails active resistance to policies that facilitate ethnic mixing, including opposition to intercontinental flows that have accelerated since the 1960s, with receiving over 20 million non-European immigrants by 2000 according to data. GRECE thinkers like de Benoist emphasize endogenous , drawing on anthropological evidence of kinship-based societies' stability versus the fragility of deracinated . While critics from academic circles often label this as covert —reflecting a prevailing institutional toward differentialist views—'s causal logic rests on observable patterns of in diverse settings, as documented in studies of ethnic enclaves worldwide. In practice, it informs GRECE's advocacy for incentives and cultural repatriation policies to restore demographic balances, positioning defense as a pragmatic for civilizational .

Critique of Egalitarian Ideologies

GRECE intellectuals, led by , fundamentally reject egalitarian ideologies as distortions that deny inherent human differences and impose a homogenizing "sameness" antithetical to cultural vitality. This critique targets both liberal , with its emphasis on abstract individual and extended to sameness in outcomes, and socialist doctrines that seek economic and social leveling across classes and peoples. De Benoist traces these ideologies to roots, which prioritize universal salvation and equality in the eyes of a singular , evolving into secular forms that erode hierarchies and particular identities in favor of interchangeable individuals. Central to this perspective is de Benoist's concept of the idéologie du Même (ideology of the Same), articulated in works such as his 2022 publication Qu'est-ce que l'idéologie du Même?, which posits modernity's drive toward uniformity as a of true , reducing —the true of humanity—to quantitative equivalence. Under this ideology, differences in , , and capability are pathologized as inequalities to be rectified, leading to policies like unrestricted and supranational governance that dissolve distinct communities into a borderless mass. De Benoist argues this process not only fails empirically, as evidenced by persistent cultural clashes and social fragmentation in multicultural experiments, but also contradicts causal realities of human organization, where hierarchies and separations foster and . In opposition, GRECE promotes differentialism, valuing qualitative inequalities as foundational to societal health, drawing from pagan Indo-European traditions that celebrated stratified orders over egalitarian abstractions. This stance critiques egalitarian regimes for their historical outcomes, such as the Soviet Union's forced homogenization yielding stagnation or globalization's exacerbation of loss, urging instead a recognition of natural variances to preserve ethnicultural . While academic sources often frame this anti-egalitarianism as reactionary, GRECE thinkers substantiate it through first-principles analysis of historical patterns and observable disparities in group achievements, cautioning against ideological overreach that ignores biological and historical contingencies.

Archeofuturism as Forward-Looking Paganism

Archeofuturism, a concept developed by Guillaume Faye—a former contributor to GRECE's Nouvelle Droite intellectual milieu—posits a synthesis of advanced techno-scientific progress with the archaic values of Indo-European traditions, as outlined in his 1998 book Archeofuturism. Faye defined this framework as envisioning a future society where technological innovations, such as genetic engineering and high-speed transport systems, coexist with hierarchical social structures, warrior ethics, and ethnic folk traditions derived from pre-Christian European paganism. These archaic elements emphasize biological kinship (ethnos), ritualized sensuality subordinated to order, and a rejection of egalitarian humanism, drawing on influences like Georges Dumézil's tripartite Indo-European social model. Central to archeofuturism's pagan dimension is its advocacy for a vitalist rooted in polytheistic, nature-aligned worldviews, contrasting with Christianity's perceived and loss of militancy post-Vatican II. Faye critiqued overt pagan revivalism in circles as semantically clumsy, favoring instead an implicit permeation of ideology by pagan inner strength, inspired by Nietzsche's valorization of Homeric epic values. In his post-catastrophic vision, neo-pagan cults—blending , Germanic, , and traditions with elements like druidic brotherhoods and solstice rites—flourish alongside technological elites, enabling a "neo-archaic" mindset necessary for mastering tools like biotronic enhancements without succumbing to modernist fragility. This forward-looking manifests in Faye's proposed , where 80% of the inhabits neo-traditional communities resembling 13th-century baronies, governed by pagan-inspired hierarchies and priestly organizations, while a techno-scientific (20%) drives innovations like Mars and nuclear advancements. Such a structure, Faye argued, restores cosmic and organic order through differentialist , aligning society with primal human potentiality rather than linear progress narratives. By 2073, this model anticipates a of diverse neo-pagan forms, from sophisticated Hellenic-inspired rites to folkish solstice celebrations, integrated into resilient, inegalitarian polities resistant to demographic collapse.

Key Contributors

Alain de Benoist and Central Figures

, born on December 11, 1943, in Saint-Symphorien near , , founded GRECE in January 1968 alongside Pierre Vial, Giorgio Locchi, and approximately 40 other intellectuals in , with the aim of advancing a metapolitical strategy for cultural renewal. As the group's enduring intellectual leader and most authoritative voice, de Benoist has authored over 100 books and essays critiquing liberal modernity, , and economic while promoting structures, pagan spiritualities, and the right to cultural . His work emphasizes empirical observation of civilizational declines, such as demographic shifts and loss of organic communities, over ideological abstractions. Pierre Vial, born December 25, 1942, co-founded GRECE and served as its secretary-general, bringing his expertise as an agrégé in history to focus on Indo-European , pagan traditions, and within the group's publications. Vial directed the journal Éléments from 1986 onward and later established the Terre et Peuple association in 1995 to preserve rural European folk cultures and ancestral customs. Guillaume Faye (1949–2019), an early key contributor joining in the , advanced GRECE's discourse through writings on , , and a synthesis of values with futuristic technologies, termed archeofuturism, but departed in 1987 amid disputes over the group's avoidance of explicit identitarian and its critique of . Faye's exit highlighted tensions between de Benoist's and more confrontational approaches to and . Giorgio Locchi (1923–1992), an journalist and philosopher among the original founders, shaped GRECE's mythological framework by integrating Nietzschean suprahumanism and Indo-European heroic narratives to counter Abrahamic monotheisms and egalitarian materialism. Locchi's emphasis on as a constitutive force for communal vitality influenced early colloquia and texts advocating vitalistic, anti-decadent European self-assertion.

Associated Thinkers and Collaborators

emerged as a principal collaborator in GRECE during its formative years, serving as its second-leading ideologue from 1970 until his exit in 1986 amid ideological divergences over and . He co-authored early works advancing the group's metapolitical critique of and contributed to journals like Éléments, emphasizing a rejection of in favor of differentialist cultural preservation. Post-departure, Faye's independent development of archeofuturism retained echoes of GRECE's pagan-inspired futurism, though he critiqued the organization's perceived moderation on racial demographics. Pierre Vial participated actively in GRECE's intellectual output, editing the 1979 collective volume Pour une renaissance culturelle: le G.R.E.C.E. prend la parole, which articulated the group's vision for revitalizing European civilization through pagan roots and anti-egalitarian thought. His involvement highlighted an emphasis on historical and ethnic , but Vial later diverged by prioritizing explicit Indo-European identitarianism, founding Terre et Peuple in 1995 to pursue uncompromised cultural advocacy beyond GRECE's broader metapolitical framework. Jean-Yves Le Gallou functioned as a key operative linking GRECE's theoretical innovations to practical political dissemination, notably through his role in Carrefour de l'Horloge, where he propagated concepts like into conservative nationalist circles. As a former member, Le Gallou advanced GRECE-adjacent ideas on during his tenure as a European Parliament deputy from 1989 to 1994, focusing on resistance to mass and supranational erosion of . Other collaborators included , a co-initiator of GRECE in 1968 whose historical essays reinforced the group's anti-Christian, Indo-European revivalism before his later independent activism. Figures like Robert Steuckers extended GRECE's influence transnationally, founding the Belgian-affiliated journal Vouloir in 1984 to adapt principles against Atlanticist liberalism. These associations underscored GRECE's network of intellectuals prioritizing causal analyses of civilizational decline over normative egalitarian interventions.

Publications and Outreach

Core Journals and Books

GRECE's primary journals have served as vehicles for disseminating its metapolitical ideas, emphasizing cultural critique and European identity. Nouvelle École, established in 1968 and directed by among others, functions as an annual publication dedicated to in-depth studies in , , and Indo-European traditions, positioning itself as the foundational periodical of the group. Éléments, launched in September 1973 as a bi-monthly , critiques and while exploring civilizational themes, remaining the official organ for GRECE's ongoing discourse. Key books emerging from GRECE's intellectual circle include Alain de Benoist's Vu de droite (1977), a three-volume compilation of essays challenging post-1968 leftist through right-wing perspectives on and , which solidified his role as the movement's theorist. De Benoist co-authored Manifesto for a Renaissance (1999) with Charles Champetier, outlining GRECE's vision for identitarian renewal against and homogenization, marking the group's thirtieth anniversary. These works, often published via affiliated imprints like Copernic, prioritize theoretical depth over partisan advocacy, influencing subsequent literature.

Events, Media, and Dissemination Channels

GRECE disseminated its metapolitical ideas through intellectual gatherings, including seminars and colloquia designed to foster discussion among aligned thinkers. These events served as forums for exploring themes central to the group's of and advocacy for preservation, aligning with its strategy of cultural influence over direct political action. Key figures from GRECE, particularly founder , engaged mainstream media to broaden reach. De Benoist appeared on the influential television program Apostrophes on September 29, 1979, debating the alongside figures like Henry de Lesquen and Jean-Pierre Apparu, hosted by . He has described himself as a regular guest on radio and television programs, leveraging these platforms to articulate positions on identity, , and anti-egalitarianism. Dissemination extended to public lectures and international conferences. De Benoist delivered talks on and at the "End of the Present World" conference in on October 12, 2013. He also spoke on at a event in the United States, reflecting GRECE's influence on transatlantic identitarian circles. Associated contributors like and Jean-Yves Le Gallou participated in similar outreach, amplifying the group's ideas through speeches and interventions.

Societal Impact

Influence on European Identitarianism

The concepts developed by GRECE, particularly ethnopluralism and the metapolitical strategy of cultural influence, provided intellectual foundations for the European Identitarian movement, which emphasizes the preservation of ethnic and cultural identities against perceived threats from mass immigration and globalization. Ethnopluralism, articulated by Alain de Benoist in the 1970s as a rejection of both racial hierarchy and universalist mixing in favor of distinct, territorially separated ethno-cultural groups, was reframed by Identitarians to advocate "remigration" policies without explicit supremacist rhetoric. This idea influenced groups like France's Bloc Identitaire, founded in 2002 as a successor to earlier New Right initiatives, which drew personnel and themes from GRECE circles to promote identity-based activism. Guillaume Faye, a key GRECE collaborator until his 1986 departure over disagreements on immigration radicalism, exerted direct influence through his later works, which radicalized ideas into Identitarian . Faye's 1998 book Archeofuturism proposed a synthesis of archaic European pagan roots with technological to counter "," concepts echoed in Generation Identity's (founded 2012) campaigns against demographic replacement and its emphasis on youth mobilization for cultural defense. His predictions of inevitable , detailed in La Colonisation de l'Europe (1998), were cited by Identitarian leaders as justification for proactive , diverging from GRECE's more theoretical restraint but building on its critique of egalitarian universalism. Beyond France, GRECE's diffusion via the network shaped Identitarian branches in (Identitäre Bewegung, est. 2012) and , where —influenced by GRECE's Éléments journal—informed strategies of warfare, street actions, and to shift public discourse on identity. Figures like Jean-Yves Le Gallou, a former GRECE member, bridged to practical by promoting "differentialist" arguments in French identitarian outlets, contributing to the movement's growth to over 10,000 activists across by 2017. However, tensions persist: de Benoist has critiqued Identitarians for excessive activism over intellectual depth, while Faye's expulsion from GRECE highlighted splits over confronting explicitly, yet these debates underscore GRECE's role in seeding a resilient, adaptive identitarian framework.

Effects on Policy Debates and Cultural Discourse

GRECE's metapolitical approach, emphasizing the long-term transformation of rather than immediate electoral gains, has shaped debates on European identity by prioritizing implicit values over explicit policy advocacy. This strategy, inspired by Antonio Gramsci's concepts but adapted to right-wing ends, sought to undermine the dominance of egalitarian and universalist ideologies in intellectual circles, fostering a that views cultural homogeneity as a threat to organic differences. By 1979, GRECE publications like Éléments had popularized critiques of and individualism, influencing subsequent discussions on the erosion of traditional European roots amid . In policy debates on , GRECE-associated thinkers introduced —or ethno-differentialism—as a framework opposing both and , arguing that unrestricted movements lead to cultural dilution and conflict rather than enrichment. articulated this in works like Vu de droite (1977), positing that preserving distinct ethnic and cultural identities geographically prevents "" while rejecting in favor of cultural incompatibilities. This perspective permeated French political rhetoric by the 1980s, providing intellectual cover for arguments against ; for instance, it echoed in National Front (later ) platforms emphasizing national preference, though GRECE distanced itself from the party's biologism. Across , similar ideas influenced radical-right parties in and , framing restrictions as defenses of "ethnocultural" continuity rather than . Culturally, GRECE contributed to a resurgence of identitarian , challenging the post-1968 consensus on by rehabilitating pre-Christian European and as antidotes to centralized, . De Benoist's advocacy for "the right to difference"—repurposed from leftist slogans—shifted conversations toward recognizing irreducible cultural hierarchies, impacting movements like Generation Identity, which adopted metapolitical tactics such as viral media campaigns on . By the , this had normalized terms like "" in online and academic fringes, influencing broader critiques of supranational entities like the as facilitators of homogenizing migration. Empirical analyses note that such ideas correlate with rising support for ethno-pluralist policies in polls, where cultural preservation concerns outpace purely economic ones in voter priorities on immigration.

Controversies and Rebuttals

Charges of Racism and Extremism

Critics have accused GRECE of harboring ideologies, particularly through its advocacy of ethnopluralisme (), a doctrine positing that ethnic groups should preserve their distinct identities by inhabiting separate geographic territories to avoid cultural mixing and homogenization. This framework, central to the Nouvelle Droite's thought since the , is alleged to represent a "cultural turn" in , replacing overt with differentialist arguments that justify under the guise of respecting "the right to ." Scholars such as José Brunner contend that this shift, while disavowing explicit , perpetuates exclusionary outcomes akin to traditional by framing as a to identities. Alain de Benoist, GRECE's founder and primary ideologue, has been specifically charged with intellectual right-wing extremism for synthesizing far-right concepts into a metapolitical strategy that influences extremist movements. Academic analyses, including those by Tamir Bar-On, describe this as "neo-fascism with a human face," tracing Benoist's evolution from early affiliations with racially explicit groups like Europe-Action in the 1960s—which promoted Indo-European racial superiority—to a post-1968 pivot toward cultural particularism while retaining anti-egalitarian and anti-immigration stances. French critics, such as those in Ethnies journal, have linked GRECE's pagan revivalism and Indo-European mythology to underlying racialism, arguing it revives völkisch traditions that equate cultural heritage with ethnic purity. Extremism allegations extend to GRECE's broader influence, with organizations like the Anti-Defamation League documenting its ideas' appeal among international white supremacists, despite Benoist's public repudiations of racism in works like Vu de droite (1977). Pierre-André Taguieff, in analyses of Nouvelle Droite origins, attributes a racist heritage to GRECE via its inheritance from Europe-Action's synthesis of biological racism and anti-colonialism, claiming the group's rejection of "universalism" fosters xenophobic policies. These charges, often voiced in left-leaning academic and media outlets, portray GRECE's critique of mass immigration and globalism as coded appeals to ethnic nationalism, potentially inciting societal division.

Empirical and Philosophical Defenses

GRECE proponents counter by emphasizing a rejection of biological hierarchies and racial superiority, framing their ethnopluralist framework as a defense of cultural particularism rather than dominance. , the group's intellectual leader, has explicitly described the notion of a superior as an "aberration," arguing since the that such ideas contradict the recognition of qualitative differences among peoples without implying inequality in value. , as articulated by de Benoist, posits that human diversity is best preserved through the spatial and cultural separation of ethno-cultural groups, preventing the erosion of identities via mass mixing or universalist . This approach draws on anthropological observations of historical tribal and ethnic , where proximity fosters cohesion and conflict arises from imposed proximity, rather than innate aggression. Philosophically, GRECE defends its positions through a of egalitarian , which de Benoist contends amounts to a form of "" by denying the right to difference and enforcing homogeneity under the guise of anti-discrimination. In this view, modern ideologies like promote a cultural by subordinating local traditions to abstract , leading to the dominance of a single (often Western-liberal) model. De Benoist invokes thinkers such as and Nietzsche to argue for rooted identities as organic expressions of human variation, rejecting both hierarchical and the "anthropological nullity" of global sameness. This differentialist stance prioritizes among peoples—each sovereign in its domain—over individualist , which they claim empirically correlates with identity loss and social fragmentation, as seen in historical empires like where cultural dilution preceded decline. Empirically, GRECE-associated arguments highlight observable patterns of and social breakdown in diverse, unmanaged polities, attributing these to incompatible value systems rather than prejudice. De Benoist points to post-colonial migrations and urban enclaves in , where parallel societies emerge, citing data on higher inter-ethnic tensions in high-immigration areas as evidence of cultural mismatch, not mere . For instance, they reference statistics from French suburbs (banlieues) showing elevated rates and , interpreting these as outcomes of rapid demographic shifts disrupting organic bonds, supported by sociological studies on erosion in heterogeneous neighborhoods. Against extremism charges, GRECE stresses its commitment to metapolitical influence—shaping through ideas, not or state power—drawing a Gramscian parallel but inverted to counter liberal hegemony without totalitarian means. De Benoist has rebutted fascist labels by underscoring pagan and , arguing that accusations often stem from ideological intolerance rather than substantive analysis of their non-hierarchical, anti-universalist proposals. These defenses maintain that empirical realities of group differences necessitate realistic policies of preservation, not exclusionary hatred.

References

  1. [1]
    GRECE: A Legacy of Cultural Renaissance - Arktos Journal
    Jan 17, 2025 · Officially founded on January 17th, 1969, via declaration at their Alpes-Maritimes headquarters amidst the upheavals of a rapidly changing world ...
  2. [2]
    6 Guillaume Faye and Archeofuturism - Oxford Academic
    During the first of these he was a member of GRECE (Groupement d'Études et de Recherches de la Civilisation Européenne) between 1970 and 1986, and is considered ...
  3. [3]
    The Nouvelle Droite in the 1980s and 1990s: Ideology and Entryism ...
    Aug 10, 2025 · GRECE was intended to function as a sort of metapolitical "laboratory" where far-right ideas and theories were re-framed in ways that spoke ...
  4. [4]
    Alain de Benoist, ethnopluralism and the cultural turn in racism
    Nov 23, 2021 · This led him to become one of the founding members of the think tank Groupement de Recherche et d'Études pour la Civilisation Européenne (GRECE, ...<|separator|>
  5. [5]
    The French New Right's Quest for Alternative Modernity
    GRECE is the French acronym for the key ND think-tank Groupement de recherche et d'études pour la civilisation européenne (Research and Study Group for European ...
  6. [6]
    Le G. R. E. C. E. (groupement de recherche et d'études sur la ...
    Le G. R. E. C. E. A été fondé en 1968 par des jeunes gens appartenant à la génération de la guerre d'Algérie et issus de l'extrême droite.
  7. [7]
    Alain de Benoist and the New Right
    Jul 24, 2019 · He is considered the main thinker of the so-called French New Right (nouvelle droite), an intellectual movement established in France in 1968 in ...
  8. [8]
    Origines et métamorphoses de la nouvelle droite - Persée
    Membre du Conseil national du REL, A. de Benoist avait constitué autour de lui un groupe informel, avec des militants de la FEN et certains membres de l'équipe ...
  9. [9]
    GRECE: A Legacy of Cultural Renaissance - Arktos.com
    Jan 24, 2025 · Officially founded on January 17th, 1969, via declaration at their Alpes-Maritimes headquarters amidst the upheavals of a rapidly changing world ...
  10. [10]
    La « nouvelle droite » entre printemps et automne (1968-1986)
    The Group for Research and Study on European Civilization (GRECE), founded in 1968, was at the heart of the « new right » phenomenon in France, much-discussed ...Missing: early | Show results with:early
  11. [11]
    Alain de Benoist - KeyWiki
    "In 1968, in Nice, several dozen far-right activists created the Research and Study Group for European Civilization, better known by its French acronym, grece.
  12. [12]
    Alain de Benoist le théoricien de la Nouvelle droite - Libération
    Jan 16, 2019 · ... Grece (Groupement de recherche et d'études pour la civilisation ... fondé en 1968. Le bimestriel y accueille des intellectuels de ...
  13. [13]
    [PDF] Grander Narratives - New Left Review
    Born to conservative parents in the Loire Valley, de. Benoist gravitated in his teenage years to the post-Vichy activist right, sworn at the time to the defence ...
  14. [14]
    Le fascisme dans les textes de la Nouvelle droite - Persée
    Comment se fait-il que la ND fasse parler d'elle à la suite de ce qu'il convient d'appeler « l'été de la Nouvelle droite » (1979) et du matraquage des médias ?
  15. [15]
    La Nouvelle Droite estime que ses idées " font leur chemin "
    Jul 28, 1980 · L'organe du GRECE étaye cette vision optimiste sur une sélection d'extraits d'articles et de points de vue parus dans le Monde, le Nouvel ...
  16. [16]
    Origins and Metamorphoses of the New Right An Interview with ...
    Pierre-André Taguieff: GRECE claimed to have 2500 full members in 1985-86. There were between 5000 and 8000 people in the movement (these figures come from ...
  17. [17]
    Manifesto for a European Renaissance - Google Books
    It was written in 1999 by Alain de Benoist, GRECE's founder, and Charles Champetier on the occasion of GRECE's thirtieth anniversary.Missing: publications | Show results with:publications<|control11|><|separator|>
  18. [18]
    Socio-Ecology of the French Far Right - illiberalism.org
    Aug 16, 2022 · This essay puts forward a reflection on the socio-ecological rhetoric of part of the French revolutionary far right, that is, its identity politics.
  19. [19]
    Textes - Les Amis d'Alain de Benoist
    Oui au socialisme ! Entretien à Boulevard Voltaire · Rébellion · Entretien Zur Zeit · Entretien avec Alain de Benoist sur le Traité transatlantique · Nouvelle ...
  20. [20]
    [PDF] Archeofuturism: European Visions of the Post-Catastrophic Age
    * * *. For reasons explained in the first chapter, Faye quit GRECE in 1986. During the next dozen years, he worked in the 'media' as a radio personality, ...
  21. [21]
    Conservative Values as a Bridge between Russia and the West
    Jul 1, 2023 · Two movements of the New Right can be singled out: the Research and Study Group for European Civilization (GRECE), with Alain de Benoist as its ...
  22. [22]
    Les Amis d'Alain de Benoist – Le site de l'association des Amis d ...
    Qu'il ait été un précurseur est incontestable. Il est l'un des premiers à théoriser la question sociale et la sociologie critique, à démystifier les prétendues ...
  23. [23]
    [PDF] The Post-Fascist Legacies of the Current Western European Far Right
    Jan 31, 2023 · Groupement de recherche et d'études pour la civilisation européenne (GRECE). The FEN was banned in May 1958 and recreated in October, the ...
  24. [24]
    GRECE - Wikipedia
    GRECE was founded in Nice, Provence in January 1968 by European – mostly French – nationalist activists, and officially launched on 17 January 1969. Among the ...
  25. [25]
    Le GRECE affirme sa volonté d'indépendance politique et d'esprit ...
    Dec 1, 1981 · " Quant à la mission des intellectuels de son courant de pensée, M. Pierre Vial la définit ainsi : " Prendre du champ par rapport à l ...
  26. [26]
    The French Origins of “You Will Not Replace Us” | The New Yorker
    Nov 27, 2017 · One of its founders, and its most influential member, was Alain de Benoist, a hermetic aristocrat and scholar who has written more than a ...
  27. [27]
    Metapolitics and the Battle for Europe's Future
    Dec 5, 2024 · De Benoist advocated for the creation of intellectual platforms, journals, and think tanks to gradually insert far-right ideas into mainstream ...Missing: activities | Show results with:activities
  28. [28]
    The Nouvelle Droite and “Tradition” - jstor
    The leading GRECE figure is the French intellectual Alain de Benoist (b. 1943), a winner of the prestigious Académie française prize for his Vu de droite (Seen ...Missing: documents | Show results with:documents
  29. [29]
    Debating the Intellectual Leader of the French New Right
    Apr 25, 2018 · d) De Benoist is intellectually brilliant, but also nasty, caustic and demeaning.
  30. [30]
    Qu'est-ce que la métapolitique - Revue Éléments
    Apr 8, 2024 · S'il y a un rapport entre la métapolitique et la politique, c'est un rapport indirect, consistant dans l'effet de causalité dont j'ai déjà parlé ...
  31. [31]
    MANIFESTO of the French New Right | The Fourth Political Theory
    Metapolitics is not politics by other means. It is neither a "strategy" to impose intellectual hegemony, nor an attempt to discredit other possible attitudes ...Missing: details | Show results with:details
  32. [32]
    How the Right Hijacked Antonio Gramsci - Jacobin
    Mar 15, 2025 · According to de Benoist, Gramsci had grasped that, in an advanced society, the “transition to socialism” occurs “neither via a coup, nor via a ...
  33. [33]
    The Metapolitics of the Far Right - Fair Observer
    Jan 29, 2020 · ” Alain de Benoist, another one of GRECE's key thinkers, insists on the need for a metapolitical strategy to change the “collective ...
  34. [34]
    Karl Ekeman | On Gramscianism of the Right – Praxis 13/13
    Nov 11, 2018 · Here, I will focus on outlining a trajectory of this concept – ie metapolitics as theory and/or practice – within the context of the radical right.
  35. [35]
    Krisis la revue d'Alain de Benoist en version numérique
    Krisis est une revue d'idées et de débats. Fondée en 1988, un an avant la chute du mur de Berlin par Alain de Benoist, Krisis se veut une revue « de droite et ...
  36. [36]
    Metapolitical Strategies of the Nouvelle Droite - Datacide
    May 17, 2011 · Metapolitical Strategies of the Nouvelle Droite is a short appendix of our article about the New Right's transversal subcultural strategies.
  37. [37]
    Ecology in the metapolitics of the French far right today
    Alain de Benoist fights capitalism on one side but applauds the radical xenophobic actions of the activists of Génération Identitaire on the other (5.5). As the ...
  38. [38]
    [PDF] Alain de Benoist's anti-political philosophy beyond Left and Right
    In the final section I offer some brief reflections on some of the current progressive mobilisations against austerity and their relationship to anti-politics.
  39. [39]
    5 Alain de Benoist and the New Right - Oxford Academic
    This chapter discusses the life and work of Alain de Benoist, a prolific French political thinker and the leading figure of the school of thought known as the ...
  40. [40]
    Alain de Benoist, Ethnopluralism and the Cultural Turn in Racism
    Nov 23, 2021 · The purpose of this article is to analyse critically the idea of ethnopluralism (also known as ethno-differentialism and droit à la difference) as formulated ...
  41. [41]
    Nouvelle Droite - Philosophyball Wiki
    The Nouvelle Droite prioritizes the rights of cultural and ethnic groups over individual rights, opposing multiculturalism and cultural mixing, which it views ...Missing: 1978-1993 | Show results with:1978-1993
  42. [42]
    [PDF] Dr. Tamir Bar-On: „Alain de Benoist: Neo-fascism with a human face?“
    Ignoring the criticisms, de Benoist and GRECE spread their ideas beyond France throughout Europe and beyond through a network of think-tanks and journals.Missing: documents | Show results with:documents
  43. [43]
    [PDF] The Triumph of Ethnos Over Demos in the Nouvelle Droite's Worldview
    ND theorists like Alain de Benoist in France or Marco Tarchi in Italy, who no doubt have their origins in revolutionary right-wing student activism in defense ...
  44. [44]
    Frames of nostalgia and belonging: the resurgence of ethno ...
    ... Nouvelle Droite. The notion of ethno-pluralism states that in order to ... A further theme of ethnopluralism is that different cultures and ethnicities can never ...
  45. [45]
    Some Notes on the European “New Right”
    Jan 1, 1991 · ... Alain De Benoist, Guillaume Faye, Jean Haudry, Julien Freund GRECE, and the journals Nouvelle Ecole, Krisis, and Elements; in Belgium ...
  46. [46]
    [PDF] The Ideological Framework of the French Nouvelle Droite and the ...
    The early texts of Alain de Benoist highlight the Indo-European heritage of Europe and they move the emphasis away from a restrictive French nation- alism to a ...
  47. [47]
    [PDF] THE EUROPEAN NEW RIGHT FORTY YEARS LATER:
    Insofar as it seeks to reduce diversity, which is the only true wealth of mankind, the ideology of Sameness is itself a caricature of equality. In fact it ...Missing: views | Show results with:views
  48. [48]
    Jussi Backman, Radical Conservatism and the Heideggerian Right
    For de Benoist, this modern metaphysics is the root of the “ideology of the Same” underlying the liberal universalism and individualism that he opposes in the ...<|separator|>
  49. [49]
  50. [50]
    Pierre Vial, auteur sur Revue Éléments
    Feb 1, 1980 · Biographie : Pierre Vial, né le 25 décembre 1942, universitaire, agrégé d'Histoire. Il participe à la fondation du GRECE et deviendra son secré ...Missing: born | Show results with:born
  51. [51]
    Guillaume Faye (1949-2019): At the Forefront of a New Theory of ...
    Apr 8, 2022 · These criticisms resulted in Faye being forced to leave GRECE in the spring of 1987, and his broader distancing from the New Right's militancy, ...
  52. [52]
    Vive la New Right - Chronicles Magazine
    Jul 26, 2022 · The story of Faye's progressive distancing from GRECE as given in Truths and Tributes is about both the content of ideas and the crude power ...Missing: expulsion | Show results with:expulsion
  53. [53]
    Giorgio Locchi and the Suprahumanist Myth - The Postil Magazine
    Feb 1, 2023 · Giorgio Locchi (1923—1992) was an Italian philosopher, journalist, and essayist who significantly influenced European right-wing intellectual ...
  54. [54]
    Books by Giorgio Locchi - Arktos Media
    Free deliveryGiorgio Locchi (1923–1992) was an Italian philosopher and journalist who co-founded GRECE (Research and Study Group for European Civilization) in 1968 with ...
  55. [55]
    Archeofuturism and Its Parallels to Militant Accelerationism
    Feb 28, 2022 · In 1986, Faye left GRECE and detached himself from the New Right. It is unclear whether Faye left voluntarily or was expelled for his ...
  56. [56]
    Pour une renaissance culturelle: le G.R.E.C.E. prend la parole
    Editor, Pierre Vial ; Contributor, GRECE (Research group : France) ; Publisher, Copernic, 1979 ; ISBN, 2859840494, 9782859840495 ; Length, 288 pages.
  57. [57]
    Pierre Vial : toutes ses citations | CITATIO
    Pierre Vial, né le 25 décembre 1942, est un universitaire et homme politique français. Il fut maître de conférences en histoire médiévale à l'Université ...Missing: structure | Show results with:structure
  58. [58]
    Between 'transmission' and usurpation: (far-)right remapping of ...
    May 31, 2024 · In France, the activities of GRECE and the Institut Iliade are supported and promoted to a larger public through publications such as Nouvelle ...<|separator|>
  59. [59]
    Nouvelle école - Revue Éléments
    Nouvelle Ecole est une luxueuse revue, très illustrée, qui propose dans chaque livraison des études en profondeur dans tous les domaines de la connaissance ...
  60. [60]
    Nouvelle École Archives
    Nouvelle École est la première revue du GRECE, le Groupement de recherche et d'études pour la civilisation européenne, autrement appelé la Nouvelle Droite. D' ...
  61. [61]
    50 ans d' «Eléments»: la Nouvelle Droite mange-t-elle vraiment des ...
    Oct 2, 2023 · La revue a célébré son demi-siècle d'existence avec un colloque à Paris, à la Cité universitaire. Nous sommes allés écouter.
  62. [62]
    Results for "De Benoist, Alain" | Wild Rumpus Books
    View from the Right was originally published in French in 1977, at the time that Alain de Benoist's GRECE think tank was at the height of its influence. The ...
  63. [63]
    Manifesto for a European Renaissance - Amazon.com
    It was written in 1999 by Alain de Benoist, GRECE's founder, and Charles Champetier on the occasion of GRECE's thirtieth anniversary.
  64. [64]
    "Apostrophes" Quelle nouvelle droite? (TV Episode 1979) - IMDb
    Quelle nouvelle droite?: Directed by Jean Cazenave, François Chatel. With Bernard Pivot, Jean-Pierre Apparu, Alain de Benoist, Henry De Lesquen.
  65. [65]
    1979 : Alain de Benoist à « Apostrophes
    Mar 20, 2007 · Le 29 septembre 1979, Alain de Benoist était invité à l'émission de Bernard Pivot « Apostrophes ». Vous pouvez maintenant la visionner sur le ...
  66. [66]
    A Conversation with Alain de Benoist - ResearchGate
    In 1977, I was awarded the Grand Prix de l'Essai de l'Académie française. I am a regular guest on radio and television programs. ... GRECE's so-called number two ...
  67. [67]
    Alain de Benoist: On Geopolitics. The End Of The Present ... - YouTube
    Oct 14, 2013 · The End Of The Present World Conference, that was held on the 12th October 2013, at a prestigious venue in central London, explored alternative ...
  68. [68]
    Alain de Benoist - Wikipedia
    ... GRECE since its foundation in 1968. The successive failures of the far-right movements de Benoist had supported since the early 1960s – from the ...
  69. [69]
    Alain de Benoist: Eurasianism and Liberalism. The ... - Paideuma.tv
    The End Of The Present World Conference, that was held on the 12th October 2013, at a prestigious venue in central London, explored alternative ...Missing: GRECE public
  70. [70]
    Racism rebranded: how far-right ideology feeds off identity politics
    Jan 8, 2023 · At the heart of Benoist's philosophy was the abandonment of racial superiority in favour of cultural difference, and the reworking of the ...<|control11|><|separator|>
  71. [71]
    Raus ! L'idéologie identitaire face aux « migrants musulmans
    ... (GRECE), fondé en 1969. En effet, la Nouvelle Droite est celle qui a le plus théorisé les fondements de l'idéologie identitaire. Plusieurs cadres importants ...
  72. [72]
    Guillaume Faye's legacy: the alt-right and Generation Identity
    Feb 24, 2022 · The voice of Alain de Benoist and key figures of the conservative revolution that informed GRECE's project still echo in his work. Both Faye and ...
  73. [73]
    Guillaume Faye, from New Right intellectual to prophet of the racial c
    He eventually became an influential author within the Identitarian movement, predicting a soon-to-come racial civil war between ethnic Europeans and those ...
  74. [74]
    « Nous sommes ce que vous fûtes, nous serons ce que vous êtes. »
    Dec 20, 2023 · Le GRECE peut d'ailleurs être vu comme l'organisation ayant théorisé l'idéologie identitaire que nous connaissons aujourd'hui17. Ainsi, en 1975, ...
  75. [75]
    Le mouvement identitaire ou la construction d'un mythe des origines ...
    May 1, 2018 · La stratégie métapolitique du GRECE, dès le milieu des années 1980, conduisit la Nouvelle droite à abandonner le racisme hiérarchisant et à ...
  76. [76]
    The French New Right - jstor
    In French,. GRECE means Greece and GRECE thinkers such as Alain de Benoist longed for the values of pagan antiquity against the egalitarian heritage of the ...Missing: adaptations | Show results with:adaptations
  77. [77]
    Intellectual Right -Wing Extremism : Alain de Benoist's Mazeway ...
    De Benoist continued the project GRECE had begun in 1969 of avoiding “outdated vocabulary” ( i. e. openly pro- racism, pro - colonialism, pro ...
  78. [78]
    Paganisme et racisme de la nouvelle droite - Persée
    ... RACISME DE LA NOUVELLE DROITE. 1. La nouvelle droite : son émergence actuelle et ses apparentements. En préambule à l'analyse critique des thèmes de la ...
  79. [79]
    Hate Beyond Borders: The Internationalization of White Supremacy
    Sep 17, 2019 · This report exposes the mutual influence of white supremacists in the United States, Canada and Europe and highlights the danger of these connections.
  80. [80]
    Les inavouables racines de la thématique identitaire - Contretemps
    Jul 6, 2021 · La revue publie cette même année 1955 un article de Nicolas Lavohary dont un texte sera publié en 1974 par le GRECE préfacé par Alain de Benoist ...
  81. [81]
    L'idée d'une race supérieure est une aberration nous écrit M. Alain ...
    Oct 7, 1980 · Dès 1974, je précisais dans le journal Éléments (dans un entretien intitulé : " Contre tous les racismes ") que l'idée d'une race supérieure est ...Missing: racism | Show results with:racism
  82. [82]
    A Response to Alain de Benoist - ResearchGate
    Aug 7, 2025 · egalitarianism and equality. De Benoist states that I am “simply and. plainly lying” when I point out that the Bobbio's right-left ...