Ghostlights
Ghostlights is the seventh studio album by Avantasia, the symphonic power metal project founded by German musician Tobias Sammet of the band Edguy.[1] Released on January 29, 2016, by Nuclear Blast Records, the album serves as a concept rock opera that continues the narrative from Avantasia's previous release, The Mystery of Time (2013), following a group of megalomaniac scientists led by a misanthropic occultist who seek to manipulate individual perceptions of time and impose control on society.[2][3] The protagonist, a young agnostic scientist, grapples with themes of morality, faith versus knowledge, power, and spirituality amid a fast-paced, disillusioned modern world.[3] Composed, written, and produced entirely by Sammet—with musical contributions from guitarist Sascha Paeth, orchestrator Michael Rodenberg, drummer Felix Bohnke, and bass by Tobias Sammet and Sascha Paeth—the album blends symphonic elements, heavy riffs, and melodic hooks characteristic of power metal, while incorporating diverse influences ranging from gothic atmospheres to bombastic epics.[3][1] It features 12 tracks on the standard edition, including the title song "Ghostlights" and extended pieces like the 12-minute "Seduction of Decay," with a runtime of approximately 70 minutes; a digipak edition adds a bonus track, "Wake Up to the Moon."[2][3] A hallmark of Avantasia's albums, Ghostlights boasts an all-star lineup of guest vocalists, enhancing its operatic scope with performances from Jørn Lande (on "Let the Storm Descend Upon You"), Michael Kiske (on "Unchain the Light"), Ronnie Atkins (on multiple tracks including "The Haunting"), Geoff Tate ("Seduction of Decay"), Dee Snider ("Isle of Evermore"), Herbie Langhans ("Draconian Love" and "Master of the Pendulum"), Bob Catley ("A Restless Heart and Obsidian Skies"), Marco Hietala ("Mystery of a Blood Red Rose"), and Sharon den Adel (on "Unchain the Light").[1] These collaborations draw from prominent acts in the metal genre, such as Masterplan, Helloween, Pretty Maids, Queensrÿche, Twisted Sister, Sinbreed, Magnum, Nightwish, and Within Temptation, creating a dynamic vocal interplay that underscores the album's theatrical narrative.[1] Upon release, Ghostlights received positive critical reception for its ambitious storytelling, production quality, and musical variety, debuting at No. 2 on the German Albums Chart and achieving top-10 placements in several European countries, including No. 8 in Switzerland.[1][4] It marked a commercial success for the project, leading to the Ghostlights World Tour, which featured live performances of the album's material alongside earlier Avantasia songs, further solidifying Sammet's reputation as a key figure in symphonic and power metal.[1]Background and development
Concept and storyline
Ghostlights is the seventh full-length album by Avantasia, the metal opera project created by Tobias Sammet. Released in 2016, it serves as the conclusion to the narrative arc begun in the 2014 album The Mystery of Time, extending the project's tradition of conceptual storytelling within the power metal genre.[5][6] The album's storyline revolves around a young agnostic scientist who unwittingly draws the attention of a group of mad scientists intent on manipulating time and space to exert control and reshape the world in their image. This protagonist embarks on a profound journey, aligning disparate personalities among the group to counter external forces of domination while confronting personal and philosophical dilemmas. The narrative draws on dystopian motifs of control, where the scientists' ambitions lead to ethical conflicts over power and reality itself.[7][8] Central to the plot are themes of free will, seduction, and existential struggle, as the protagonist grapples with the seductive allure of forbidden knowledge and the brevity of human life amid accelerating temporal experiments. Inspired by Faustian bargains, the story explores the temptation to transcend mortal limits, questioning whether such pursuits liberate or ensnare the soul. The 12 tracks function as pivotal moments in this saga, weaving a tapestry of introspection and conflict without resolving into a traditional climax.[6][7] Ultimately, Ghostlights culminates in an open-ended resolution, leaving the protagonist's fate and the scientists' endeavors ambiguous to invite listener interpretation. Sammet has described this conclusion as philosophical rather than fairy-tale definitive, emphasizing universal questions about ideals and distractions in life.[6][8]Announcement and pre-production
The pre-production phase for Ghostlights began in October 2014, shortly after the completion of Tobias Sammet's previous Avantasia project, The Mystery of Time, with Sammet handling the initial songwriting for the album's twelve tracks.[9] This period focused on developing the material at Gatestudio in Wolfsburg, Germany, where Sammet composed the lyrics and music to continue the rock opera format established in prior works.[9] During pre-production, Sammet began considering guest vocalists to enhance the album's ensemble style, reaching out early to Meat Loaf for a feature on the title track, "Ghostlights," though the collaboration ultimately did not materialize due to scheduling conflicts.[10] This outreach reflected Sammet's vision for high-profile contributions that would align with the album's dramatic, theatrical elements, building on the guest-heavy approach of The Mystery of Time. The official announcement of Ghostlights as Avantasia's seventh studio album and a direct sequel to The Mystery of Time came on November 13, 2015, via Nuclear Blast Records, revealing the January 29, 2016, release date and initial tracklist details.[11] To build anticipation, Nuclear Blast hosted an exclusive listening party in Wolfsburg on November 10, 2015, inviting select media and fans to preview the album and engage directly with Sammet about its conceptual storyline.[12] Fan engagement escalated with the digital release of lead single "Mystery of a Blood Red Rose" on December 11, 2015, accompanied by a lyric video, followed by a Christmas teaser trailer on December 25 featuring snippets from five tracks to heighten excitement ahead of the full reveal.[13][14]Production
Recording process
The recording of Ghostlights spanned from October 2014 to November 2015 at Gatestudio in Wolfsburg, Germany, where the album was written, tracked, produced, mixed, and mastered.[15] This extended timeline allowed for the integration of complex layered arrangements, including orchestral elements orchestrated by Michael Rodenberg, alongside the core heavy metal instrumentation featuring aggressive guitar riffs and dynamic rhythms.[16] Production was spearheaded by Tobias Sammet and Sascha Paeth, with Paeth serving as engineer and mixer to capture the album's symphonic scope and vocal intensity.[17] Rodenberg handled mastering at the same studio, ensuring a polished balance between the bombastic orchestral swells and the raw power metal drive.[16] The standard edition clocks in at a total runtime of 70:03, emphasizing the project's ambitious fusion of cinematic orchestration and heavy riffing without filler.[18] A key logistical challenge involved coordinating the international roster of guest vocalists, many of whom recorded their parts remotely or during brief in-person sessions due to demanding schedules.[19] For instance, Geoff Tate's contributions to "Seduction of Decay" required squeezing in time around his commitments, while others like Dee Snider and Sharon den Adel delivered performances that fit the conceptual narrative through targeted collaborations.[19] This approach enabled the diverse vocal textures central to Avantasia's sound but demanded precise communication to align takes with the overarching production vision.[20]Personnel and contributions
Tobias Sammet served as the creative force behind Ghostlights, handling lead vocals on all tracks, additional bass and keyboards, and co-producing the album alongside Sascha Paeth.[21] The core instrumental lineup featured Sascha Paeth on rhythm and lead guitars, bass, and additional keyboards; Michael Rodenberg on keyboards and orchestration; and Felix Bohnke on drums.[21] Oliver Hartmann contributed lead guitars and backing vocals, while Bruce Kulick provided notable lead guitar solos, including on "Babylon Vampyres," "Lucifer," and "A Restless Heart and Obsidian Skies."[21][11][9] The album's production was managed at Gatestudio in Wolfsburg, Germany, with Sascha Paeth engineering and mixing the recordings, and Michael Rodenberg handling the mastering.[21] Backing vocals were provided by Oliver Hartmann, Clara Habekost (on "The Haunting"), and Cloudy Yang.[17] Ghostlights showcased an extensive roster of guest vocalists, each appearing on specific tracks to enhance the rock opera's dramatic narrative. Jørn Lande performed on "Let the Storm Descend Upon You," "Ghostlights," and "Lucifer"; Ronnie Atkins on "Let the Storm Descend Upon You" and "Unchain the Light"; Dee Snider on "The Haunting"; Geoff Tate on "Seduction of Decay"; Michael Kiske on "Ghostlights" and "Unchain the Light"; Herbie Langhans on "Draconian Love"; Marco Hietala on "Master of the Pendulum"; Sharon den Adel on "Isle of Evermore"; Robert Mason on "Let the Storm Descend Upon You" and "Babylon Vampyres"; and Bob Catley on "A Restless Heart and Obsidian Skies."[21] These contributions drew from prominent figures in the metal and rock scenes, emphasizing Avantasia's supergroup ethos.[11]Music and composition
Musical style and influences
Ghostlights is a power metal opera that blends symphonic metal, hard rock, and progressive elements, characteristic of Tobias Sammet's Avantasia project.[22] The album's sound emphasizes melodic structures with soaring choruses and theatrical vocals, rooted in the rock opera tradition while incorporating heavy riffs and orchestral arrangements.[3] Tobias Sammet has cited influences from classic rock and metal acts such as Magnum, Helloween, Dio, and Meat Loaf, which contribute to the album's epic scope and timeless quality.[3] These draw from Sammet's admiration for dramatic, narrative-driven compositions, echoing the bombastic style of Meat Loaf's 1970s and 1990s works.[6] Additionally, the project's evolution from earlier Avantasia albums like The Mystery of Time incorporates a darker mood and gothic touches, enhancing the orchestral depth and song cycle format.[19] Key sonic features include dynamic shifts between introspective ballads and intense heavy sections, achieved through layered multi-vocalist performances that amplify the operatic feel.[3] This diversification allows for exploration across a 70-minute runtime, marking Ghostlights as Avantasia's most varied entry in the genre.[3]Individual tracks and themes
"Mystery of a Blood Red Rose" opens the album with a bombastic, Broadway-inspired pop-pomp structure, featuring layered vocals and quasi-Broadway hooks that evoke Meat Loaf's theatrical style, clocking in at 3:51. Tobias Sammet handles all vocals, delivering soulful performances over shimmering strings and a majestic chorus, setting a frilly, theatrical tone with embedded hooks that grow on listeners despite some finding it campy or out of place. The track's lyrical content introduces the album's overarching narrative of mystery and intrigue, with imagery of a enigmatic rose symbolizing hidden dangers in the protagonist's journey, though specific themes remain tied to the broader story without deep individual exploration in analyses.[23][24] "Let the Storm Descend upon You" is a sprawling 12:09 epic blending metallic swagger with pop and hard rock sensibilities, structured as a Kamelot-like symphonic powerhouse with midpaced metal verses building to a titanic-sized chorus and complex passages that shift from heavy rock to power metal. Guest vocalists Jørn Lande, Ronnie Atkins, and Robert Mason contribute standout performances, with Lande's raspy delivery stealing the show amid emotive choirs and kick-ass riffs that culminate in a storming crescendo. Lyrically, it explores themes of turmoil and confrontation, reflecting the protagonist Aaron Blackwell's internal storm as he grapples with supernatural visions, emphasizing resilience amid chaos. Unique features include its natural flow and outstanding songwriting that balances catchiness with progressive elements.[23][24] "The Haunting," lasting 4:42, adopts a creepy, atmospheric structure with a scary piano introduction leading into an energetic power metal chorus, featuring Dee Snider's mature, dark, and ominous vocal delivery that adds a leathery theatrical edge reminiscent of Alice Cooper. The song's brooding verses contrast with its catchy melody, creating a bleak yet infectious mood. Lyrical themes center on fear and supernatural pursuit, depicting Blackwell's haunting by ghostly apparitions that blur reality and nightmare. Highlights include Snider's sweet yet energetic performance, though some critiques note it as mid-paced and pale compared to heavier tracks.[23][24] "Seduction of Decay" runs for 7:18 as a brooding heavy-prog stomper with experimental Queensrÿche-like elements, structured around slow, pounding verses that build tension through dark power/prog riffs before erupting into a strong chorus. Geoff Tate's lively, wailing vocals provide a rejuvenated duet with Sammet, marking one of his best performances since Operation: Mindcrime, though opinions vary on its sluggish pacing. The lyrics delve into themes of temptation and inevitable decline, portraying decay as a seductive force luring the protagonist toward moral ambiguity in his quest for truth. Notable features include its Middle Eastern influences and heavy foundation, making it a divisive yet intriguing mid-album highlight.[23][24][25] "Ghostlights," the 5:43 title track, channels Helloween-esque power metal with blazing speed and aggressive vocal interplay between Michael Kiske's soaring high-pitched delivery, Jørn Lande, and Sammet, structured around classy melodies and a future-classic chorus that shifts from quiet introspection to heavier passages. Its speedy, joyous riffs and addictive hooks evoke power metal nostalgia, with Kiske commanding the pace gloriously. Lyrically, it symbolizes self-discovery and spiritual awakening, representing protagonist Aaron Blackwell's visions of metaphysical truths and ghostly "ghostlights" akin to will-o'-the-wisp folklore, guiding him through a maze of existential doubt. This track encapsulates the album's core theme of illusory enlightenment.[23][24][26][27] "Draconian Love," at 4:58, blends gothic rock with emo/cock rock vibes in a hypnotic structure that transitions from eerie, gothy verses—reminiscent of Type O Negative or HIM—to an explosive, catchy chorus, featuring Herbie Langhans' low, emotional intonations contrasting Sammet's wailing. The song's moody atmosphere and passionate delivery make it one of the album's most addictive cuts. Themes revolve around dark romance and forbidden desire, mirroring the protagonist's entanglement with supernatural seduction amid his search for meaning. Unique elements include its surprising beauty and gothic anthem quality, with Langhans adapting his voice effectively for a power-ballad feel.[23][24] "Master of the Pendulum" clocks in at 5:01 as the album's heaviest track, with a Nightwish-like symphonic metal structure driven by powerful riffs, modern synths, and hypnotic rhythms that match its thematic oscillation between control and chaos, featuring Marco Hietala's shrieking, vitriolic vocals in a darker atmosphere. The catchiest chorus and complex influences akin to Stratovarius highlight its metallic bruiser quality. Lyrically, it addresses themes of fate and manipulation, symbolizing Blackwell's struggle against time's pendulum-like sway in his ghostly encounters. Standout features include Hietala's unusual yet fitting performance and massive riffs that disrupt with an unfitting yet bold chorus.[23][24] "Isle of Evermore," a 4:28 slow moody ballad, employs delicate keys and a haunting refrain with symphonic elements, where Sharon den Adel's sultry vocals harmonize with Sammet in a tame, directionless structure that serves as a mid-album breather, though criticized for cheesiness and wasting her talent. The track's basic melody and New Age influences recall earlier Avantasia ballads. Lyrical content focuses on eternal longing and isolation, evoking the protagonist's yearning for an unchanging paradise amid his restless visions. Despite its unimpressive delivery, den Adel's voice fits the introspective mood effectively.[23][24][25] "The Scarecrow's Wife," lasting 5:02, delivers a fiery epic with over-the-top guitar work in a 7-minute shredder structure full of bonanza leads and riffs, blending Edguy-like energy with power metal pace, featuring Robert Mason's vindictive rock 'n' roll delivery and a highly catchy chorus. Guitar duels involving Bruce Kulick, Oliver Hartmann, and Sascha Paeth provide stellar highlights. Themes explore loyalty and tragedy in a supernatural context, tying into the Scarecrow narrative arc with the wife's perspective on loss and redemption. Its upbeat, energy-boosting quality makes it a natural progression despite its length.[24][25] "The Watchmaker's Dream" spans 7:23 in a complex, atmospheric prog-metal framework with melodic rock elements, building through emotive performances and double choruses that explore dreamlike sequences. Guests like Ronnie Atkins shine in its fluid composition. Lyrically, it delves into themes of time and illusion, portraying the watchmaker as a metaphor for Blackwell's futile attempts to control his fate amid ghostly revelations. Unique features include its long, well-put-together shifts and intricate songwriting that elevates the narrative.[24] "A Restless Heart and Obsidian Skies," at 5:46, starts slow before upbeat progression into a classic retro '80s chorus with heartwarming melodies, featuring Bob Catley's yearning vocals in a well-written rock tune that harmonizes quiet and heavier passages. The structure balances ballad introspection with power elements. Themes center on existential doubt and acceptance, embracing life's uncertainties and dreams despite lacking answers, as Blackwell confronts his restless pursuit under ominous skies. Its heartfelt closeout and guitar solo by Bruce Kulick mark it as a potential standout.[24][28] "Lucifer," closing the standard edition at 7:13, draws Savatage-inspired influences in a dual structure: a dark piano ballad opening that explodes into a kinetic rocker with heavy riffs, where Jørn Lande's emotive vocals carry the heavy lifting in harmony with Sammet, culminating in a spine-tingling duet and Bruce Kulick's solo. The song's natural progression from quiet to explosive highlights its ballad-to-power shift. Lyrical themes invoke temptation and duality, personifying Lucifer as a guide or adversary in the protagonist's spiritual odyssey, blending redemption with infernal allure. This track exemplifies Avantasia's theatrical depth.[23][24]Release and promotion
Singles and marketing
The promotional campaign for Ghostlights began with the release of two singles. The lead single, "Mystery of a Blood Red Rose", was issued as a digital download on December 11, 2015, and included an official lyric video to introduce the album's thematic elements.[13] The second single, "Draconian Love", followed on May 12, 2016, accompanied by an official music clip featuring live footage from the band's shows in Brazil.[29] Marketing efforts were spearheaded through partnerships with Nuclear Blast Records, the album's label, which handled global distribution and promotional materials.[3] Teaser trailers played a key role in building anticipation, including an official "Coming Soon" video released on December 25, 2015, and a snippet trailer featuring previews of five tracks like "Mystery of a Blood Red Rose" and "Let the Storm Descend Upon You", shared on January 6, 2016.[30][31] Social media campaigns amplified the hype across platforms such as Facebook and Twitter, where updates on singles, tour dates, and exclusive content were posted to engage fans directly. Promotional events included pre-order bundles offering limited-edition formats, such as gatefold vinyl and digipak versions with bonus live content, available exclusively through the Nuclear Blast store starting in late 2015. The visual aesthetics centered on the album artwork by Thomas Ewerhard, which depicted ethereal ghost lights illuminating a mystical, otherworldly scene, aligning with the record's supernatural storyline of time manipulation and occult intrigue.[17]Formats and editions
Ghostlights was released in multiple formats on January 29, 2016, through Nuclear Blast Records.[21] The standard edition included a single CD with the album's 12 tracks, available in a jewel case packaging, as well as digital download options through platforms like iTunes and Spotify.[17] Additionally, a double LP vinyl edition was offered in a gatefold sleeve, pressed on black vinyl for the standard pressing, with limited colored variants such as blue and orange also available.[21] A special digibook edition was released as a limited two-CD set.[21] This version featured the standard album on the first disc, augmented by the exclusive bonus track "Wake Up to the Moon" (4:43), alongside a second bonus disc titled Avantasia Live, containing 11 live recordings primarily from the Wacken Open Air 2014 festival, including tracks such as "Spectres," "Invoke the Machine," and "Reach Out for the Light."[11] Limited editions expanded on the digibook format with enhanced packaging. The earbook edition included a 68-page photobook (approximately 28.5 x 28.5 cm) and a third CD with karaoke versions of the album tracks, available in numbered deluxe variants.[21] A mailorder-exclusive box set further bundled the earbook with additional collectibles, such as a poster, signed photo card, lanyard with pass, and an exclusive 10" vinyl.[21] Distribution was handled primarily by Nuclear Blast Records worldwide, with regional variations including releases through Avalon in Japan (as a SHM-CD with DVD bonus in some markets) and Scarecrow Records in Mexico.[17] These editions catered to international audiences while maintaining core content consistency across formats.Reception and legacy
Critical reception
Upon its release in January 2016, Ghostlights received strong praise from metal critics, who highlighted its ambitious scope and musical execution. Myglobalmind magazine awarded the album a perfect score of 10/10, lauding Tobias Sammet's songwriting as among the best in metal and emphasizing the bombastic arrangements and catchy melodies.[32] AntiHero Magazine rated it 9/10, describing it as one of Avantasia's strongest efforts to date, with a notably dark atmosphere and standout contributions from guest vocalists.[33] Metal Hammer gave it 6 out of 7 points, commending the varied song structures, emotional pathos, and impressive lineup of guests that blended classic metal with catchy hooks.[34] These scores contributed to an average rating of approximately 8.5/10 across major reviews. Aggregate user scores on sites like Encyclopaedia Metallum averaged 80% from 10 reviews, reflecting broad enthusiasm within the power metal community.[15] Critics frequently praised the album's epic scope, with its 70-minute runtime delivering a cohesive rock opera narrative enriched by orchestral elements and dynamic shifts.[32][33] The guest vocals were a highlight, featuring powerhouses like Michael Kiske, Jørn Lande, and Dee Snider, whose performances added emotional depth and variety to tracks such as "Let the Storm Descend Upon You" and "Seduction of Decay."[32][33] Production quality drew acclaim for its polished, homogeneous sound, with Sascha Paeth's engineering ensuring powerful guitar solos and huge choirs elevated the overall bombast.[34] Reviewers noted the album felt heavier and darker than its predecessors, marking a return to Avantasia's metal opera roots with more aggressive riffs and intense atmospheres.[33][34] While overwhelmingly positive, some critiques pointed to occasional over-reliance on established formulas, such as familiar power metal tropes that might not convert skeptics despite the high quality.[34] The narrative density of the concept album was occasionally cited as a drawback, with certain tracks like "The Haunting" and "Isle of Evermore" requiring multiple listens to fully appreciate due to less immediate choruses or derivative elements reminiscent of symphonic peers.[32][34]Commercial performance and impact
Ghostlights achieved significant commercial success upon its release, debuting at number 2 on the German Albums Chart and spending 13 weeks in total on the chart. In the United States, the album marked Avantasia's second entry on the Billboard 200, peaking at number 101 during its debut week with 2,475 copies sold. Globally, the album sold approximately 31,000 copies in its first week across various markets.[35] It was later certified gold in Germany for exceeding 100,000 units shipped.[36] The album's release was supported by the Ghostlights World Tour, which ran from March to August 2016 and encompassed 45 concerts across Europe and North America, featuring extended three-hour sets with a rotating lineup of guest vocalists performing tracks from the album alongside earlier material.[37] The tour concluded with additional festival appearances, including a performance at Wacken Open Air in 2017, further extending the album's live presence. A limited digibook edition of Ghostlights included bonus live recordings from Avantasia's 2014 Wacken Open Air set, tying the album to the project's ongoing festival legacy.[38] In the years following its release, Ghostlights solidified its place in Avantasia's discography as a pivotal installment in the ongoing narrative arc begun with The Mystery of Time, influencing subsequent albums like Moonglow and A Paranormal Evening with the Moonflower Society through shared thematic and musical elements.[39] The album contributed to the expansion of Avantasia's fanbase within the power metal genre, with its orchestral and symphonic arrangements exemplifying the project's role in blending heavy metal with operatic storytelling, as noted in analyses of the band's evolution.[40] By 2025, tracks from Ghostlights had amassed millions of streams on Spotify, including over 2.7 million for the title track, reflecting sustained digital engagement.[41] Its reception in metal media highlighted its bombastic style as a benchmark for supergroup collaborations, fostering fan covers and discussions in genre communities.[23]Track listing
Standard edition
The standard edition of Ghostlights consists of 12 tracks, with a total runtime of 70:03. All tracks were written by Tobias Sammet.[22]| No. | Title | Duration | Writer |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | "Mystery of a Blood Red Rose" | 3:51 | Tobias Sammet |
| 2 | "Let the Storm Descend upon You" | 12:09 | Tobias Sammet |
| 3 | "The Haunting" | 4:42 | Tobias Sammet |
| 4 | "Seduction of Decay" | 7:18 | Tobias Sammet |
| 5 | "Ghostlights" | 5:43 | Tobias Sammet |
| 6 | "Draconian Love" | 4:58 | Tobias Sammet |
| 7 | "Master of the Pendulum" | 5:01 | Tobias Sammet |
| 8 | "Isle of Evermore" | 4:28 | Tobias Sammet |
| 9 | "Babylon Vampyres" | 7:09 | Tobias Sammet |
| 10 | "Lucifer" | 3:48 | Tobias Sammet |
| 11 | "Unchain the Light" | 5:03 | Tobias Sammet |
| 12 | "A Restless Heart and Obsidian Skies" | 5:53 | Tobias Sammet |
Bonus content
The Digibook edition of Ghostlights includes an exclusive bonus track titled "Wake Up to the Moon," a 4:43-minute song written by Tobias Sammet, featuring guest vocals from Ronnie Atkins, Michael Kiske, Jørn Lande, Bob Catley, and Robert Mason.[22][11] This track, with its melodic rock influences and multi-vocalist arrangement, was crafted as an additional piece to complement the album's thematic exploration of illusion and reality, though it was not included in the standard release.[21] A key feature of the Digibook and certain limited editions is the bonus live CD titled Avantasia Live, containing 11 tracks primarily recorded at the Wacken Open Air festival in 2014.[42] The disc opens with "Spectres" (6:04) and captures the project's symphonic metal energy in a festival setting, with tracks 1 through 9 from Wacken 2014, track 10 ("The Watchmakers' Dream," 4:47) from Masters of Rock 2013, and track 11 ("Another Angel Down," 5:30) from Wacken 2008.[38] These recordings highlight Avantasia's live dynamism, blending operatic elements and guest appearances to recreate the album's epic scope beyond studio confines.[43]| No. | Title | Duration | Recorded at |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | "Spectres" | 6:04 | Wacken Open Air 2014 |
| 2 | "Invoke the Machine" | 5:35 | Wacken Open Air 2014 |
| 3 | "The Story Ain't Over" | 4:45 | Wacken Open Air 2014 |
| 4 | "Prelude" | 1:24 | Wacken Open Air 2014 |
| 5 | "Reach Out for the Light" | 8:04 | Wacken Open Air 2014 |
| 6 | "Avantasia" | 5:16 | Wacken Open Air 2014 |
| 7 | "What's Left of Me" | 5:55 | Wacken Open Air 2014 |
| 8 | "Dying for an Angel" | 4:58 | Wacken Open Air 2014 |
| 9 | "Twisted Mind" | 6:29 | Wacken Open Air 2014 |
| 10 | "The Watchmakers' Dream" | 4:47 | Masters of Rock 2013 |
| 11 | "Another Angel Down" | 5:30 | Wacken Open Air 2008 |