Fact-checked by Grok 2 weeks ago

Jewish apocrypha

Jewish apocrypha refers to a body of ancient Jewish texts composed mainly during the Second Temple period, from approximately the 3rd century BCE to the 1st century CE, that were not included in the canonical Hebrew Bible (Tanakh) but were part of the Septuagint, the Greek translation of Jewish scriptures used by Hellenistic Jews and early Christians.^[1] These works, often termed deuterocanonical by some Christian traditions, encompass a diverse range of genres including historical accounts, wisdom literature, novels, and prophetic writings, providing essential evidence of Jewish religious, cultural, and social developments in the intertestamental era.^[2] Key texts include Tobit, a moral tale emphasizing piety and divine providence; Judith, a heroic narrative of deliverance from foreign oppression; 1 and 2 Maccabees, historical chronicles of the Jewish revolt against Seleucid rule and the rededication of the Temple; Wisdom of Solomon, a philosophical reflection on righteousness and immortality; Sirach (Ecclesiasticus), a collection of ethical teachings; Baruch, attributed to Jeremiah's scribe and containing prayers and exhortations; and additions to books like Daniel (such as Susanna and Bel and the Dragon) and Esther.^[1] In Jewish tradition, these texts hold no divine inspiration or canonical authority, as the Tanakh's canon was finalized—according to tradition—by the Anshei Knesset Hagedolah around the 5th–4th centuries BCE, after the prophetic era ended with Malachi, excluding later compositions.^[2] However, modern scholarship views the canonization of the Hebrew Bible as a more gradual process, likely spanning from the 2nd century BCE to the 2nd century CE, with no definitive consensus on the exact timing or mechanisms.^[3] While some apocryphal works, like Sirach, are occasionally quoted in rabbinic literature such as the Talmud for ethical insights, others are critiqued for contradictions with core Jewish teachings or historical inaccuracies, and they are generally not afforded sacred status.^[2] Manuscripts of these texts have been preserved in Greek, Latin, and Syriac translations, with fragments discovered in the Dead Sea Scrolls and the Cairo Genizah, underscoring their circulation among ancient Jewish communities despite their non-canonical position.^[2] The apocrypha's historical significance lies in bridging the gap between the Hebrew Bible and post-biblical Judaism, illuminating themes such as resistance to Hellenization, the evolution of messianic expectations, and the diversity of Jewish theology under foreign domination.^[1] For instance, the Maccabean books document the origins of Hanukkah and the Hasmonean dynasty, offering a rare Jewish perspective on events around 167–160 BCE.^[1] In contrast to the pseudepigrapha—another category of extracanonical Jewish writings like 1 Enoch and Jubilees, which are more apocalyptic and often attributed pseudonymously—the apocrypha were more integrated into liturgical and scriptural use in certain diaspora communities.^[1] Today, these texts remain valuable for scholars studying Second Temple Judaism, influencing understandings of early rabbinic thought, the roots of Christianity, and the broader Hellenistic Jewish diaspora.^[2]

Definition and Scope

Etymology and Terminology

The term "apocrypha" derives from the Greek verb apokryptein, meaning "to hide away" or "to conceal," reflecting its original connotation of secret or esoteric writings.^[4] In the context of Jewish literature, it came to denote a collection of ancient texts from the Second Temple period (circa 516 BCE–70 CE) that were not included in the canonical Hebrew Bible (Tanakh), often due to questions about their authorship, prophetic status, or doctrinal alignment with rabbinic Judaism.^[2] This usage emerged primarily in early Christian scholarship, where church fathers such as Jerome applied the term to Jewish works outside the emerging biblical canon, distinguishing them from both protocanonical scriptures and later pseudepigrapha, which were often forgeries attributed to biblical figures.^[5] In Jewish tradition, the equivalent concept predates the widespread adoption of "apocrypha" and is expressed through the rabbinic Hebrew phrase sefarim chitzonim, or "external books," referring to non-canonical writings deemed outside the sacred corpus.^[6] This terminology appears in Talmudic sources, such as Babylonian Talmud Sanhedrin 100b and Jerusalem Talmud Sanhedrin 50b, where reading such texts is discouraged to avoid heretical influences, though some wisdom elements not contradicting Torah could be valued.^[6] Unlike the Greek-derived "apocrypha," which implies concealment, sefarim chitzonim emphasizes spatial or categorical externality from the authoritative Tanakh, highlighting a pragmatic rabbinic boundary rather than secrecy.^[7] The terminology evolved significantly with Christian developments, particularly during the Reformation, when Protestants aligned their Old Testament canon with the Jewish Tanakh and labeled these texts simply as "Apocrypha," rejecting their inspirational status.^[5] In contrast, Catholic and Orthodox traditions introduced the term "deuterocanonical" in the 16th century—coined by Sixtus of Siena in 1566—to denote books accepted as a "second canon" based on their presence in the Septuagint and early church usage, while still distinguishing them from protocanonical texts.^[8] This Christian nomenclature underscores a hierarchical inclusion absent in Jewish usage, where sefarim chitzonim maintained a consistent exclusion from halakhic and prophetic authority.^[2]

Scope and Classification

Jewish apocrypha refer to a collection of ancient Jewish writings composed during the Second Temple period, roughly spanning 200 BCE to 100 CE, that were excluded from the 24-book canon of the Hebrew Bible.^[9] These texts, authored by Jews and often addressing theological, ethical, or historical themes, reflect the diverse intellectual and spiritual life of Judaism in that era but did not achieve canonical status in rabbinic tradition. The corpus is distinct from the prophetic writings considered authoritative, marking a shift toward interpretive and expansive literature post-Ezra.^[10] Classification of these works distinguishes between deuterocanonical books and broader extracanonical materials. Deuterocanonical texts, such as Tobit, Judith, and 1–2 Maccabees, appear in the Septuagint—the Greek translation of Jewish scriptures—but are absent from the Masoretic Text, the standardized Hebrew version finalized later. These are viewed as "second canon" in some Christian traditions but remain non-canonical in Judaism due to their later composition or linguistic origins.^[9] In contrast, pseudepigrapha encompass a larger set of extracanonical writings pseudonymously attributed to biblical patriarchs or prophets, including apocalypses like 1 Enoch and legal expansions like the Book of Jubilees.^[11] Inclusion in the apocrypha hinges on criteria such as demonstrable Jewish provenance, thematic ties to biblical motifs, and historical or devotional significance, yet ultimate exclusion stemmed from their post-prophetic dating and lack of endorsement in the emerging rabbinic canon.^[10] Rabbinic Judaism, particularly after the destruction of the Second Temple in 70 CE, consolidated the canon through consensus, prioritizing texts deemed inspired and excluding those composed in the Hellenistic or early Roman periods.^[12] This process ensured the Hebrew Bible's fixed scope, rendering apocryphal works supplementary rather than authoritative.

Historical Background

Second Temple Period Context

The Second Temple Period, spanning from 516 BCE to 70 CE, marked a transformative era in Jewish history characterized by successive foreign dominations over Judea that profoundly shaped religious and cultural expressions. Following the Babylonian exile, Persian rule under Cyrus the Great enabled the rebuilding of the Temple in Jerusalem around 516 BCE, initiating a phase of relative autonomy and restoration that lasted until Alexander the Great's conquest in 332 BCE.^[13] This Persian period (538–332 BCE) fostered the consolidation of Jewish identity through scriptural interpretation and communal practices, setting the stage for literary developments amid imperial oversight. The subsequent Hellenistic era (332–63 BCE), under the Ptolemaic and Seleucid empires, introduced tensions between Jewish traditions and Greek influences, while Roman control from 63 BCE onward imposed direct governance, taxation, and military presence, culminating in heightened socio-political instability.^[13] A pivotal event within this framework was the Maccabean Revolt (167–160 BCE), sparked by Seleucid king Antiochus IV Epiphanes' decrees banning Jewish practices and desecrating the Temple, which acted as a catalyst for the production of historical apocryphal literature documenting resistance and renewal.^[14] Led by Judas Maccabeus and his family, the uprising restored Temple worship and established the Hasmonean dynasty, briefly granting Jewish independence until Roman intervention.^[15] The period's end came with the Roman destruction of the Second Temple in 70 CE during the First Jewish-Roman War, an event that dismantled the central religious institution and propelled Judaism toward rabbinic adaptations.^[16] Religious diversity flourished amid these upheavals, with distinct sects emerging that contributed to multifaceted textual traditions reflecting varied interpretations of law, prophecy, and community life. The Pharisees emphasized oral traditions and resurrection beliefs, influencing broader Jewish thought; the Sadducees, aligned with Temple aristocracy, adhered strictly to the written Torah and rejected afterlife doctrines; and the Essenes, a ascetic group, withdrew to communal settlements, prioritizing purity and apocalyptic visions.^[17] This sectarian pluralism is evidenced by the Dead Sea Scrolls, discovered at Qumran in the 1940s, which preserve fragments of biblical texts, sectarian rules, and apocryphal works from the late Second Temple era, likely authored or collected by Essene-like communities.^[18]

Hellenistic Influences

The conquest of Judea by Alexander the Great in 332 BCE initiated the Hellenistic era, integrating Greek culture, language, and governance into Jewish life under successive Ptolemaic and Seleucid rule.^[19] This event exposed Jewish communities to broader Mediterranean influences, fostering a period of cultural exchange that permeated religious and literary expressions during the Second Temple period.^[20] Jewish apocryphal writings reflect this synthesis through the adoption of Greek literary forms, such as the dramatic structure and romantic elements in the Book of Judith, which parallel Hellenistic tragedy and novelistic styles while adapting them to narrate Jewish heroism.^[21] Similarly, philosophical concepts from Stoicism appear in the Wisdom of Solomon, where ideas of universal providence, the rationality of the cosmos, and the soul's immortality echo Stoic doctrines, reinterpreted through a Jewish lens to affirm monotheism.^[22] In response to intensifying Hellenization, particularly under Seleucid king Antiochus IV's policies of cultural assimilation in the 2nd century BCE, the Hasmonean dynasty emerged as a force for resistance and adaptation, reasserting Jewish autonomy and traditions.^[23] This dynamic is captured in 1 Maccabees, which portrays the Maccabean revolt as a defense of Jewish identity against Hellenistic impositions, emphasizing military and religious revival under Hasmonean leadership.^[24]

Canonical Status

Exclusion from Hebrew Bible

The exclusion of Jewish apocrypha from the Hebrew Bible, or Tanakh, resulted from rabbinic processes that prioritized texts aligned with Pharisaic traditions during the late Second Temple and early post-Temple periods. Rabbinic criteria emphasized composition in Hebrew (or Aramaic for certain portions), origin in the land of Palestine, authorship or finalization before the era of Ezra (c. 450 BCE), and conformity to Pharisaic theology, which viewed prophetic inspiration as having ceased after the prophets Haggai, Zechariah, and Malachi.^[2] These standards, retroactively articulated in later rabbinic literature, effectively sidelined apocryphal works that did not meet them, as they were seen as lacking the divine authority of earlier scriptures canonized by the Anshei Knesset Hagedolah (Men of the Great Assembly).^[2] Discussions among rabbinic scholars in Yavneh (Jamnia) around 90 CE, following the destruction of the Second Temple in 70 CE, played a role in clarifying the boundaries of the canon, with debates focusing on the status of borderline texts like Ecclesiastes and the Song of Songs rather than formally excluding apocrypha, which were already outside the consensus. By the second century CE, these processes culminated in the standardization of the 24-book Tanakh, reflecting a Pharisaic-dominated tradition that sought to unify Jewish scriptural authority amid emerging challenges.^[25] The apocrypha's exclusion stemmed primarily from their late composition during the Hellenistic era (mostly 3rd–1st centuries BCE), often in Greek rather than Hebrew, which signaled foreign influences incompatible with the rabbinic emphasis on indigenous prophetic tradition. Additionally, perceived doctrinal divergences further disqualified these texts from canonical status, though they retained value for historical or ethical insights in non-scriptural contexts.^[2] Despite this exclusion, fragments of apocryphal works survived through quotation in rabbinic literature or preservation in other traditions.

Preservation in Jewish Tradition

Despite their exclusion from the Hebrew Bible canon, many Jewish apocryphal texts were preserved through the Septuagint, the Greek translation of Jewish scriptures undertaken in Alexandria between the third and second centuries BCE, which incorporated several such works alongside the protocanonical books. This translation facilitated their circulation among Hellenistic Jewish diaspora communities, ensuring survival in Greek manuscripts even as Hebrew originals were largely lost. Further transmission occurred through medieval manuscript collections, notably the Cairo Genizah, a storeroom in the Ben Ezra Synagogue in Fustat, Egypt, containing over 300,000 fragments of Jewish documents from the ninth to nineteenth centuries CE.^[26] Among these, apocryphal materials include Hebrew fragments of Ben Sira (Sirach), providing rare evidence of Second Temple-era literature in Jewish hands long after canonization.^[27] In medieval Jewish communities, select apocryphal texts saw practical application despite their noncanonical standing. The Book of Sirach, for example, influenced liturgical poetry, serving as a source for piyyutim in the Mahzor, the High Holy Day prayer book, and was recited in some synagogues for its moral guidance.^[28] It was also studied in yeshivas for ethical instruction, valued for teachings on piety, family, and conduct that aligned with rabbinic values.^[29] The 19th- and 20th-century revival of apocryphal studies within Judaism stemmed from key scholarly discoveries, particularly Solomon Schechter's 1896 identification of a medieval Hebrew fragment of Ben Sira from the Cairo Genizah, which enabled partial reconstruction of the text's original language.^[30] Schechter's broader curation of the Genizah collection at Cambridge University advanced the incorporation of these texts into Jewish historical research, underscoring their role in illuminating postbiblical Jewish thought.^[30] This effort marked a shift toward viewing apocrypha as vital resources for understanding Jewish diversity beyond the rabbinic canon.^[27]

Major Texts

Deuterocanonical Books

The deuterocanonical books comprise a collection of Jewish writings from the Second Temple period that were incorporated into the Septuagint, the Greek translation of the Hebrew Scriptures, but were ultimately excluded from the rabbinic Hebrew Bible canon. These texts, preserved primarily in Greek, include historical narratives, wisdom teachings, and expansions to existing biblical books, reflecting diverse aspects of Jewish life under Hellenistic rule. Unlike the pseudepigrapha, which are more extracanonical and often pseudonymous, the deuterocanonicals form part of the Catholic and Orthodox Old Testament canons.^[31] The Books of 1 and 2 Maccabees provide detailed historical accounts of the Maccabean Revolt against the Seleucid Empire, spanning the period from 167 to 160 BCE. 1 Maccabees, likely composed in Hebrew around 100 BCE, chronicles the military campaigns led by Judas Maccabeus and his brothers against Antiochus IV Epiphanes' forces, emphasizing themes of Jewish resistance, covenantal fidelity, and the rededication of the Temple, which forms the basis of the Hanukkah festival.^[32]^[14] In contrast, 2 Maccabees, an abridgment of a lost five-volume work written in Greek circa 124 BCE, focuses more on theological interpretations, highlighting divine providence, martyrdom, and resurrection, while recounting similar events with a stronger emphasis on prayers and heavenly interventions.^[24] Both books underscore the heroism of the Hasmonean family and the preservation of Jewish practices amid persecution, serving as key sources for understanding the origins of Jewish independence in the Hasmonean dynasty.^[33] The Books of Tobit and Judith are narrative tales that exemplify piety, moral integrity, and divine intervention in the lives of faithful Jews. Tobit, dated to the third or second century BCE and originally composed in Aramaic or Hebrew, depicts the story of a devout Israelite family in the Assyrian diaspora, where the blind patriarch Tobit and his son Tobias encounter trials of poverty, burial of the dead, and demonic affliction, resolved through the angelic guidance of Raphael and acts of charity.^[34] The narrative promotes ethical living, almsgiving, and trust in God's providence as models for Jewish exiles.^[35] Similarly, Judith, likely written in Hebrew around 150–100 BCE, portrays a courageous widow who uses wit and faith to save her besieged town of Bethulia from Assyrian general Holofernes, beheading him in a bold act of deliverance that highlights themes of prayer, fasting, and God's protection of the vulnerable. Both stories blend folklore elements with religious instruction, illustrating how divine aid rewards steadfast observance of Torah amid foreign domination.^[36] The Wisdom of Solomon and Sirach (also known as Ecclesiasticus) represent prominent examples of Jewish wisdom literature, advocating ethical conduct, reverence for God, and the pursuit of wisdom as pathways to a righteous life. The Wisdom of Solomon, composed in Greek in Alexandria during the first century BCE, personifies Wisdom as a divine attribute accompanying God in creation and guiding the righteous, while critiquing idolatry and injustice to encourage Jewish fidelity in a Hellenistic environment.^[37] It draws on Proverbs and integrates philosophical influences, portraying immortality and divine justice as rewards for the pious.^[38] Sirach, authored by Jesus ben Sira around 180 BCE in Hebrew and later translated into Greek, consists of a structured collection of proverbs, ethical teachings, and hymns that emphasize practical wisdom, fear of the Lord, and social responsibilities, such as honoring parents and avoiding excess.^[38] The book's prologue by the translator's grandson underscores its role in instructing Diaspora Jews on integrating Torah observance with everyday conduct. Together, these works extend the tradition of biblical wisdom books like Proverbs, adapting them to address challenges of cultural assimilation.^[39] The Book of Baruch and various additions to canonical texts, such as those to Daniel and Esther, offer prophetic exhortations and narrative enhancements that expand on themes of repentance, exile, and deliverance. Baruch, attributed to Jeremiah's scribe and likely composed in Hebrew or Aramaic in the second century BCE with Greek versions from the first century BCE, includes a confession of sins, praises of Wisdom, and promises of restoration for exiled Judah, urging adherence to the law amid Babylonian captivity.^[40] The additions to Daniel—Susanna, a tale of false accusation and divine vindication through Daniel's wisdom; the Prayer of Azariah and Song of the Three Young Men, inserted into the fiery furnace episode; and Bel and the Dragon, exposing idol worship—were integrated into the Greek Septuagint around the second to first century BCE to emphasize innocence, prayer, and monotheism.^[41] Likewise, the Greek additions to Esther, comprising six sections including prayers by Mordecai and Esther, heighten the religious dimension absent in the Hebrew version, portraying divine orchestration in the Purim story's salvation of the Jews from Haman's plot.^[42] These expansions enrich the original narratives with explicit Jewish piety and theological reflections.^[43]

Themes and Features

Theological Concepts

Jewish apocryphal texts elaborate on eschatological themes, particularly the concepts of afterlife rewards and punishments, which address theodicy and divine justice in the face of suffering. In 2 Maccabees, the narrative of the martyred brothers underscores belief in bodily resurrection as a reward for the righteous, where God will raise the faithful to new life while condemning the wicked to eternal torment, as articulated in the mother's exhortation that the Creator can restore life from dust (2 Macc 7:22-29).^[44] Similarly, the Wisdom of Solomon portrays the souls of the righteous as immortal, dwelling with God after death, while the wicked face judgment and destruction, emphasizing divine justice (Wis 3:1-9; 5:15-16).^[45] Divine providence emerges as a central theological motif, illustrating God's active intervention in human affairs to guide and protect the faithful amid adversity. The Book of Tobit exemplifies this through the angel Raphael's covert role in orchestrating events—such as healing Tobit's blindness and exorcising the demon Asmodeus from Sarah—demonstrating how divine agents fulfill God's benevolent plan without overt miracles, emphasizing trust in unseen guidance (Tob 3:17; 12:12-22).^[46] This concept reinforces the idea that providence operates through intermediary beings to uphold moral order and deliver retribution against evil.^[35] Apocryphal literature also develops messianism and covenant theology by expanding biblical promises of restoration, incorporating ideas of eternal life and a final judgment day led by a messianic figure. In the Wisdom of Solomon, the righteous sufferer is mocked and persecuted but ultimately vindicated by God, fulfilling covenantal promises through divine justice and the triumph over evil (Wis 2:12-20).^[47] These interpretations portray the covenant not merely as national renewal but as encompassing universal judgment and everlasting reward, linking messianic advent to the ultimate realization of God's faithfulness.^[48]

Literary Genres

Jewish apocryphal literature encompasses a diverse array of literary genres that reflect the creative and interpretive responses of Second Temple Judaism to contemporary challenges. These works, composed primarily in Hebrew, Aramaic, and Greek between the third century BCE and the first century CE, include wisdom teachings, historical chronicles, apocalyptic visions, and novelistic narratives. Each genre serves to convey moral, historical, or eschatological insights, often blending traditional Jewish motifs with innovative forms.^[49] The wisdom genre features proverbial and poetic teachings aimed at ethical instruction and practical guidance for daily life. Exemplified by the Book of Sirach (also known as Ben Sira or Ecclesiasticus), this text comprises 51 chapters of loosely organized advice, drawing on the style of biblical Proverbs to emphasize humility, fear of God, and adherence to Torah. Poetic sections praise divine wisdom and Israel's history, while proverbial sayings, such as those in Sirach 5:1-8, warn against overconfidence and urge reliance on divine providence. This genre underscores a pedagogical approach, instructing readers in piety and social conduct within a Jewish framework.^[28]^[49] Historical narratives in the apocrypha adopt a chronicle-style format to recount key events in Jewish history, often infusing factual reporting with theological interpretation to highlight divine intervention and covenantal fidelity. The Books of Maccabees provide prime examples: 1 Maccabees offers a detailed, Hebrew-composed account of the Maccabean Revolt (167-164 BCE), chronicling political and military developments while overlaying them with themes of resistance against assimilation and divine support for the faithful. Similarly, 2 Maccabees, written in Greek, expands on these events with dramatic episodes of martyrdom, such as the story of the mother and her seven sons, emphasizing heavenly justice and the rededication of the Temple. These works function as both historical records and inspirational texts for Jewish resilience.^[50]^[49] Apocalyptic literature employs visionary revelations and symbolic imagery to unveil hidden cosmic truths, eschatological judgments, and the ultimate triumph of good over evil. 2 Esdras (4 Ezra) exemplifies this genre through its depiction of Ezra's visions, where he receives revelations about the end times, including the appearance of a messianic figure from the sea who defeats Israel's enemies, and descriptions of paradise, hell, and final judgment (2 Esd 7:26-44; 13:1-13). Sections such as the eagle vision use metaphors to convey prophecies of empires' fall and future redemption, blending prophecy with mystical elements to address themes of divine order amid earthly chaos.^[49] Novelistic elements appear in narrative tales that incorporate romance-like plots, folkloric motifs, and dramatic tension to explore heroism and faith. The Book of Judith stands out as a fictionalized story set against an Assyrian threat, where the protagonist Judith employs seduction and cunning to behead the enemy general Holofernes after gaining his trust through beauty and feigned loyalty over several days. This romance-infused structure, with its chiastic patterns and focus on female agency, creates an engaging tale of deliverance, though laced with anachronisms like portraying Nebuchadnezzar as Assyrian, prioritizing moral allegory over strict historicity.^[51]^[49]

Legacy and Influence

Impact on Rabbinic Judaism

Despite its exclusion from the Hebrew Bible, the Book of Sirach exerted significant influence on rabbinic ethical teachings through the echoing of its proverbs in the Talmud and related texts. For instance, Sirach 5:11 advises, "Be quick to hear, but deliberate in answering," a sentiment paralleled in Pirkei Avot 1:15, where Shammai teaches, "Say little and do much," emphasizing restraint in speech and the priority of actions.^[52] Scholars note that such borrowings reflect the circulation of Ben Sira's wisdom sayings among rabbinic circles, even as the text was not formally canonical, contributing to the ethical framework of post-Temple Judaism.^[53] The Books of the Maccabees played a pivotal role in shaping the observance of Hanukkah within rabbinic tradition, providing the historical foundation for the holiday's rituals as discussed in the Talmud (Shabbat 21b). Although the Maccabean narratives themselves are not directly cited, the events of temple rededication described in 1 Maccabees 4:36–59 underpin the festival's eight-day duration and themes of rededication.^[54] This incorporation demonstrates how apocryphal accounts informed practical religious observance, transforming a military victory commemoration into an enduring rabbinic practice without explicit acknowledgment of the source texts.^[50] Doctrinal concepts from the apocrypha, particularly the resurrection of the dead, left traces in later rabbinic midrashim, building on motifs from 2 Maccabees despite the book's non-canonical status. In 2 Maccabees 7, the martyred mother and her seven sons affirm faith in bodily resurrection as divine recompense, a belief that resonates in midrashic expansions like those in Genesis Rabbah, where resurrection is elaborated as a reward for the righteous amid persecution.^[55] This influence highlights how apocryphal ideas permeated rabbinic theology, reinforcing eschatological hopes in the face of Roman oppression and contributing to the development of resurrection doctrine central to rabbinic Judaism.^[56]

Role in Christianity and Scholarship

In Christianity, the deuterocanonical books—such as Tobit, Judith, Wisdom of Solomon, Sirach, Baruch, and 1–2 Maccabees—were incorporated into the Old Testament canon of both the Roman Catholic and Eastern Orthodox Churches, reflecting their acceptance in early Christian traditions like the Septuagint.^[57] The Council of Trent in 1546 explicitly affirmed these books as canonical Scripture for the Catholic Church, responding to Reformation challenges by declaring their divine inspiration and equal authority with the protocanonical books.^[57] Eastern Orthodox traditions similarly include them, viewing them as part of the broader biblical corpus used in liturgy, though often with a nuanced status of secondary authority compared to the Hebrew protocanon.^[58] In contrast, Protestant reformers rejected the deuterocanonicals as apocryphal, excluding them from their Old Testament canon on the grounds that they were not part of the Hebrew Bible and contained doctrinal elements inconsistent with sola scriptura.^[59] Figures like Martin Luther classified them as useful for reading but not authoritative for doctrine, a position formalized in confessions such as the Westminster Confession of 1647.^[59] The Jewish apocrypha also influenced New Testament writings through conceptual parallels. Similarly, Hebrews 11:35 alludes to Maccabean martyrdom in 2 Maccabees 7, referencing those "tortured, refusing to accept release, that they might rise again to a better life," to illustrate faith amid suffering.^[60] Modern scholarship in the 20th and 21st centuries has elevated the role of Jewish apocrypha in reconstructing intertestamental Judaism, using these texts to illuminate the theological and cultural bridge between the Hebrew Bible and early Christianity.^[61] The discovery of the Dead Sea Scrolls in the 1940s–1950s provided manuscript evidence for apocryphal and pseudepigraphal works, integrating them into analyses of Second Temple Judaism's diversity.^[62] Scholars like Géza Vermes advanced this field through translations and studies that contextualize apocrypha alongside Qumran texts, emphasizing their contributions to themes like eschatology and messianism in the intertestamental period.^[62] Ongoing research, including at the Society of Biblical Literature's Pseudepigrapha section, continues to explore these texts for insights into early Jewish sects and their impact on New Testament formation.^[63]

References

[1]
Scripture and Canon in Jewish Apocrypha and Pseudepigrapha
Traditionally "the Apocrypha" refers to a collection of Jewish sources included in the Roman Catholic and Eastern Orthodox Bibles, but not in Jewish or ...
[2]
What Is the Jewish Approach to the Apocrypha? - Chabad.org
Here, we are using the term “Apocrypha” to refer to all of these ancient works not included in the Jewish canon of the Bible. 2. Talmud, Bava Batra 14b; Tosefta ...
[3]
APOCRYPHA - JewishEncyclopedia.com
At the Reformation, Protestants adopted the Jewish canon, and designated by the name "Apocrypha" the books of the Latin and Greek Bibles which they thus ...
[4]
Mountains, Salt and Apocrypha « Ask The Rabbi « - Ohr Somayach
These are known in English as Apocrypha and in Hebrew as sefarim chitzonim, which means "external books" (Sanhedrin 100b, Yerushalmi Sanhedrin 50b). These ...
[5]
The Apocrypha and Pseudepigrapha - Jewish Virtual Library
All the Apocrypha and most of the Pseudepigrapha are Jewish works (some contain Christianizing additions). They provide essential evidence of Jewish literature ...
[6]
CATHOLIC ENCYCLOPEDIA: Apocrypha - New Advent
Etymologically, the derivation of Apocrypha is very simple, being from the Greek apokryphos, hidden, and corresponding to the neuter plural of the adjective.
[7]
[PDF] The Significance of Deuterocanonical Writings in Jewish Religious ...
It is hardly possible to form any classification of the Apocrypha that is not open to serious objection. In any case, the classification must be regarded as ...
[8]
[PDF] The History of the Closure of Biblical Texts - Oral Tradition Journal
The Jewish canon came into existence roughly between 200 BCE and 200 CE, a period that is partially synchronous with Second Temple Judaism.
[9]
Pseudepigrapha - Search results provided by BiblicalTraining
The term is the technical designation of a large collection of Jewish writings not included in the OT canon, ranging from 200 b.c. to a.d. 200, some of which ...
[10]
https://journal.oraltradition.org/wp-content/uploads/files/articles/25i/09_25.1.pdf
[11]
Timeline of Judaism after the Babylonian Exile (538 BCE-70 CE)
538-333 B.C.E., Persian Period. 538 B.C.E., Edict of Cyrus (first return from Exile). 520-515 B.C.E., Jerusalem ("Second") Temple rebuilt.
[12]
Modern Scholarship on 1–2 Maccabees in Its Historical Context
Sep 3, 2024 · This brief account of something of modern scholarship on 1–2 Maccabees well illustrates the truism that “all history is contemporary history.”
[13]
The Maccabean Revolt: The Jewish Rebellion Against the Seleucid ...
Aug 21, 2021 · The Maccabean Revolt fought between the Jews of Judea and the Seleucid Empire took place between 167 and 160 BC; it also is the origin of ...
[14]
The Destruction of the Second Temple - Jewish Virtual Library
It was destroyed by the Romans in 70 CE. The site of the ancient Jewish Temple is now occupied, in part, by the “Dome of the Rock” Mosque. In recent times, “ ...
[15]
Ancient Jewish History: Pharisees, Sadducees & Essenes
This sect believed the others had corrupted the city and the Temple. They ... In the early Christian materials, Pharisees are often depicted as leading ...
[16]
JUDAISM AND CHRISTIANITY AND THE DEAD SEA SCROLLS
In addition to the three groups identified by Josephus (Pharisees, Sadducees, and Essenes), Judaism was further divided into numerous religious sects ... Qumran ...
[17]
Political and Social Structures in Hellenistic Judea (332-63 BCE)
In the summer of 332 B.C.E., Palestine was conquered by Alexander the Great. The land and people of Israel were now part of the Hellenistic world.<|control11|><|separator|>
[18]
Hellenism - Jewish Virtual Library
A significant trend in recent scholarship considers much of Jewish literature between Alexander the Great and the conquest of Islam as spiritual or religious ...
[19]
1. The Judith Project - OpenEdition Books
The Book of Judith has been denominated a romance, or even the first Jewish novel, a genre that includes Esther, Daniel, Tobit, and Joseph and Aseneth. The Book ...
[20]
Chapter 11 - The Love of Wisdom: Middle Platonism and Stoicism in ...
Mar 24, 2017 · How should we assess the use of Hellenistic philosophy within the Wisdom of Solomon? Was the author's use of it haphazard or did the author ...
[21]
The Maccabees/Hasmoneans: History & Overview
Initially, he continued to allow the Jews autonomy, but after a stinging defeat at the hands of the Romans he began a program of Hellenization that threatened ...
[22]
The Maccabean Victory Explained: Between 1 and 2 Maccabees
Dec 15, 2022 · 1 Maccabees also narrates at great length the Hasmoneans' military exploits against the Seleucid troops, emphasizing the former's bravery and ...
[23]
The Formation of the Jewish Canon - Yale University Press
In stock Free 20-day returnsTimothy Lim here presents a complete account of the formation of the canon in Ancient Judaism from the emergence of the Torah in the Persian period.
[24]
Cairo Genizah - Cambridge Digital Library
The Taylor-Schechter Cairo Genizah Collection at Cambridge University Library is the world's largest and most important single collection of medieval Jewish ...
[25]
Second Temple Literature and the Cairo Genizah - jstor
text in several genizah manuscripts, as well as its function as the basis for a variety of "apocryphal" medieval texts, indi- cate that it was in use among ...
[26]
https://cudl.lib.cam.ac.uk/collections/genizah
[27]
The Wisdom of Ben Sira: How Jewish? - TheTorah.com
Sep 27, 2015 · Ben Sira was not canonized, but was once prominent in Jewish communities. It was written too late for divine inspiration and was accepted by ...
[28]
SIRACH, THE WISDOM OF JESUS THE SON OF
SIRACH, THE WISDOM OF JESUS THE SON OF (Hebrew, Ḥokmat ben Sira; Latin, Ecclesiasticus):. (Redirected from JESUS SIRACH.) By: Crawford Howell Toy, Israel Lévi.
[29]
Solomon Schechter (1847-1915): a Jewish polymath with a gift for ...
Nov 20, 2015 · The Jewish scholar Solomon Schechter is best remembered for his work on the Cairo Geniza. A conference this Sunday will explore the wider ...
[30]
Deuterocanonical/apocryphal books (Chapter 17) - The Cambridge ...
“Deuterocanonical/apocryphal” refers to Jewish literature of the Second Temple period found outside of the twenty-four books of the biblical canon of the ...
[31]
https://www.cambridge.org/core/books/cambridge-companion-to-the-hebrew-bibleold-testament/deuterocanonicalapocryphal-books/F176926C06208BD4042A470F22A78D21
[32]
Regional Revolts in the Seleucid and Ptolemaic Empires (Chapter 10)
According to 1 and 2 Maccabees, the Maccabean wars against the Seleucid armies and the neighboring populations resumed in 162. When Judas was killed in the ...
[33]
The Book of Tobit: Life Lessons from an Edifying Tale
He instructs them to give God honor through their ongoing testimony to God's intervention and to persevere in giving alms, after which Raphael ascends again ...
[34]
Suspense, Simultaneity, and Divine Providence in the Book of Tobit
devotion to Jewish piety certainly does provide a model for life in the Diaspora, and the author s concern for righteousness is evident in the ethical ...
[35]
Miraculous healing in the book of Tobit - Ruth Henderson, 2024
Dec 13, 2024 · In their distress, they make their situation known to God with an implicit appeal for mercy and divine intervention (Tob 3:2–6, 11–15). These ...Missing: Judith | Show results with:Judith
[36]
Wisdom of Solomon - Biblical Studies - Oxford Bibliographies
The Wisdom of Solomon (known as the Book of Wisdom in the Latin Bible tradition) is a book about wisdom—its benefits, nature, and role in ancient Israel's ...
[37]
Wisdom Literature (Chapter 7) - Cambridge University Press
Mar 13, 2020 · Two other books, Sirach and Wisdom of Solomon, resemble Proverbs while integrating Jewish traditions from law and prophecy into their teachings ...
[38]
Wisdom in the Jewish and Christian Scriptures: The Hebrew Bible ...
In the Apocryphal writings wisdom or wise occurs some 60 times in Sirach and 40 in Wisdom of Solomon. Wisdom in the New Testament (Greek, sophia) occurs in its ...<|separator|>
[39]
https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/10.1177/0040571X10395465
[40]
Biblical Studies - Additions to Daniel - Oxford Bibliographies
Jul 26, 2017 · The Additions include two additional stand-alone narratives about Daniel—Susanna; Bel and the Dragon—as well as a prayer and song that have been ...
[41]
On the Date of Composition of Additions B and E to LXX Esther
Aug 9, 2025 · Additions B and E to LXX Esther have been variously dated from the second century BCE to the first century CE . This study links the two ...
[42]
[PDF] 26 Deuterocanonical and Apocryphal Books Introduction
Feb 10, 2021 · (The additions to Esther, Daniel, and. Jeremiah are covered in Chapters 18, 20, and 22 in this volume, on Jeremiah, Daniel, and the Megillot.<|control11|><|separator|>
[43]
Apocrypha and Pseudepigrapha - Biblical Studies
Mar 21, 2024 · Apocrypha and Pseudepigrapha are terms used to label a large body of early Jewish and early Christian literature written between the 3rd century BCE and the ...
[44]
The Pseudepigrapha of Second Temple Judaism
Nov 7, 2021 · A consideration of Jewish Pseudepigrapha raises the question whether the New Testament contains books written under a false name.
[45]
The Pseudepigrapha in Current Research - Compass Hub - Wiley
May 24, 2013 · The five books that make up 1 Enoch reflect the various roles Enoch played in Second Temple literature, such as scribe, sage, diviner, and ...
[46]
[PDF] The Book of Enoch and Second Temple Judaism.
The Second Temple period of. Jewish history encompassed a time of great political upheaval and social unrest as a result of the growing military power of Rome ...Missing: timeline | Show results with:timeline
[47]
Book of Jubilees - Biblical Studies - Oxford Bibliographies
Jan 11, 2012 · The Book of Jubilees is a Jewish book from the 2nd century BCE that presents the narrative of Genesis and Exodus 1–20
[48]
Testaments Of The Twelve Patriarchs - The Wesley Center Online
Summary: This is a collection of pseudonymous last testaments of the 12 sons of Jacob. Each testament offers ethical exhortations appropriate to the patriarch.
[49]
8 The Testaments of the Twelve Patriarchs: A Legacy of Ethics and ...
This chapter renews the case for the Jewish (Hasmonean period) origin of the vast majority of the material in the Testaments and for the discernment of ...
[50]
The Transmission of the Testaments of the Twelve Patriarchs ... - jstor
The so-called Pseudepigrapha of the Old Testament are generally studied as Jewish writings; they are regarded as sources for the history.
[51]
https://jwa.org/encyclopedia/article/judith-apocrypha
[52]
https://intertextual.bible/text/sirach-5.11-pirkei-avot-1.15
[53]
Resurrection in Early Judaism | Bible Interp
The history of 2 Maccabees, for example, includes resurrection as an integral feature within the faith of the Jewish martyrs who resisted the Hellenistic Reform ...
[54]
Afterlife and Resurrection Beliefs in the Second Temple Period
Jan 14, 2020 · A comprehensive list and description of every resurrection and afterlife belief in the Apocrypha and Pseudepigrapha has been a much-lamented gap in ...<|control11|><|separator|>
[55]
4 All's Well That Ends Well: The Book of Tobit - Oxford Academic
A key message of the book is providence—that God rewards righteousness in his own way, which is often difficult for humans to discern. Keywords: Tobit, Assyria, ...
[56]
Messianism in the Pseudepigrapha in the Light of the Scrolls - jstor
main evidence for belief in a messiah of any kind is contained in only five writings: Psalms of Solomon 17 and 18, 1 Enoch 37-71,.
[57]
Messianism in Jewish Literature Beyond the Bible - Kesher Journal
Jul 5, 2017 · In this article I survey Jewish texts beyond the Bible for their witness to messianism. The survey is limited to texts from 2nd Temple and early rabbinic ...
[58]
[PDF] Chapter Eight The Apocrypha and Post-Exilic Literature
As with the canonical Bible, apocryphal books comprise a variety of genres, including wisdom, history, apocalypse, and even what we might call the novel. Many ...
[59]
Hanukkah, 1 and 2 Maccabees, and the Apocrypha
Dec 26, 2024 · We must look beyond traditional Jewish sources, to the books 1 and 2 Maccabees, most conveniently found in editions of the Apocrypha.
[60]
APOCALYPTIC LITERATURE, NEO-HEBRAIC - Jewish Encyclopedia
That the "Book of Enoch" is the original title is established by a manuscript in the Bodleian Library, and by the fact that the apocalypse is quoted under that ...
[61]
Judith: Apocrypha - Jewish Women's Archive
The apocryphal book of Judith is an imaginative, highly fictionalized romance, portraying an Assyrian invasion of Israel led by a man named Holofernes.Missing: novelistic elements
[62]
Sirach 5:11 | Pirkei Avot 1:15 - intertextual.bible
Rabbinic tradition in Pirkei Avot 1:15 offers similar guidance by urging restraint in words and greater emphasis on actions. Both reflect a common Jewish wisdom ...Missing: parallels | Show results with:parallels
[63]
The Book of Ben Sira in Rabbinic Literature - jstor
The. Palestinian Talmud's paradigmatic example of "external books" is the Book of Ben Sira, and it contrasts the reading of this and other such books with the ...
[64]
Tractate Shabbat: Chapter 2 - Jewish Virtual Library
MISHNA I.: What shall and what shall not be used for lighting (the Sabbath light)? The light shall not be made with (wicks of) cedar hast, raw flax, silk fibre, ...
[65]
The Doctrine of the Resurrection of the Dead in Rabbinical Theology
i. The teaching that there is a blessed life after death, or that the dead will be revived from their graves to a better life, or that.
[66]
Afterlives and Noble Deaths - Oxford Academic
Some scholars have taken 2 Maccabees 7 as the gold standard of Jewish resurrection belief, eliding beliefs in other forms of reembodiment with reincarnation ...
[67]
Did the Church add the Deuterocanonical books to the Bible at the ...
No. The Council of Trent (1545-1564) infallibly reiterated what the Church had long taught regarding the canons of the Old and New Testaments.
[68]
Orthodoxy on the Deuterocanon
Jun 3, 2021 · The “official position” of the Orthodox Church is on the so-called deuterocanon (ie the Wisdom of Solomon, Judith, Tobit, Bel and the Dragon, the History of ...
[69]
Why Were the Books of the Old Testament Apocrypha Rejected as ...
Protestants reject the Apocrypha because it has different doctrines, is never cited in the New Testament, and was never part of the Hebrew canon.
[70]
Is Enoch Also among the Prophets? The Impact of Jude's Citation of ...
Sep 3, 2013 · This illustrates how the attribution of authority to 1 Enoch in Jude poses a problem in subsequent reception history, raising two interrelated ...
[71]
The Canonical Implications of Hebrews 11:35b and 2 Maccabees
Hebrews 11:35b significantly references the Maccabean martyrs from 2 Maccabees 6-7, not an allusion. Canonical scholarship often overlooks substantial indirect ...
[72]
[PDF] on the value of intertestamental jewish literature for new testament ...
We must now face the challenge and responsibil- ity of coming to grips with the apocrypha, pseudepigrapha and other Jewish sources through which new and ...Missing: 21st | Show results with:21st
[73]
[PDF] VERMES, Geza: The Dead Sea Scrolls Forty Years On
GEZA VERMES new chapter in our search for an understanding of the genesis and transmission of ancient Jewish texts, biblical, apocryphal and Essene.
[74]
Fifty Years of the Pseudepigrapha Section at the SBL on JSTOR
This collection of essays by some of the most important scholars in the fields of early Judaism and Christianity celebrates fifty years of the study of the Old ...<|control11|><|separator|>