Kate Forbes
Kate Elizabeth Forbes (born 6 April 1990) is a Scottish politician who serves as Deputy First Minister of Scotland and Cabinet Secretary for Economy and Gaelic, positions she has held since May 2024.[1] A member of the Scottish National Party (SNP), she has represented the Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch constituency as a Member of the Scottish Parliament since her election in 2016 at the age of 26.[2] Previously, Forbes served as Cabinet Secretary for Finance and the Economy from 2020 to 2023, where she presented multiple annual budgets and managed fiscal policy during the COVID-19 pandemic and subsequent economic recovery.[1] Forbes gained prominence as a candidate in the 2023 SNP leadership election to succeed Nicola Sturgeon, securing second place amid discussions over her evangelical Christian beliefs, which include opposition to same-sex marriage on religious grounds—a stance that highlighted tensions between traditional values and the party's progressive elements.[3] In April 2024, she endorsed John Swinney's successful bid for leadership, leading to her appointment as Deputy First Minister.[4] In August 2025, Forbes announced she would not seek re-election as an MSP in the 2026 Holyrood election, citing a desire to prioritize family after dedicating her formative years to public service.[5] Raised partly in India by missionary parents and fluent in Scottish Gaelic from her early education, Forbes studied history at the University of Cambridge before entering politics, bringing a background in accounting and economic analysis to her roles.[6] Her tenure has been marked by advocacy for pragmatic economic growth, investment in Highlands infrastructure, and balancing fiscal responsibility with devolved priorities, though her departure raises questions about continuity in SNP economic strategy.[7]
Early life and education
Family background and upbringing
Kate Forbes was born on 6 April 1990 in Dingwall, in the Scottish Highlands.[3] Her parents were adherents of the Free Church of Scotland and served as missionaries, with her father engaging in Bible teaching and accounting while aiding rural communities in northern India.[8] [9] As the eldest of four siblings, Forbes experienced an itinerant childhood marked by her family's two extended trips to India for missionary work.[10] [3] The family first relocated to India when Forbes was an infant, returning to Scotland briefly before undertaking a second, longer stint where she attended school during her formative years.[8] [11] These periods abroad were interspersed with residence in Glasgow and the Highlands, reflecting her parents' commitment to evangelical outreach among underserved populations.[1] [12] Forbes has described this environment as one of sacrifice driven by faith rather than worldly ambition, shaping a worldview centered on service.[6]Academic achievements
Kate Forbes earned a Bachelor of Arts degree in history from Selwyn College at the University of Cambridge, completing her studies in 2011.[13][14][15] She then pursued postgraduate education at the University of Edinburgh, obtaining a Master of Science degree in diaspora and migration history in 2013.[6][3] Forbes later qualified as a chartered accountant through professional studies, achieving this designation in 2016.[6]Pre-political career
Professional roles in finance and data
Prior to her election to the Scottish Parliament in 2016, Kate Forbes qualified as a chartered accountant in 2016 after completing her professional training.[6] She was employed as an accountant in the banking sector, working for Barclays, a multinational investment bank.[16][13] This role involved financial analysis and accounting duties typical of the industry, providing her with expertise in fiscal structuring and economic data handling that she later applied in public office.[1][17]Involvement in Christian advocacy
Kate Forbes was raised by parents who served as missionaries affiliated with the Free Church of Scotland in northern India, where her father taught the Bible and managed finances for a mission hospital serving marginalized communities. Born on April 6, 1990, she spent her early childhood there, returning to Scotland at age 15 around 2005. During her time in India, at approximately age 11, she experienced the 2001 Gujarat earthquake, an event that prompted existential questions about life and death, leading to her personal conversion to evangelical Christianity and a deepened commitment to biblical faith.[18][19] Upon resettling in Scotland, Forbes affiliated with the Free Church of Scotland, a small evangelical denomination originating from the 1843 Disruption, emphasizing scriptural authority, Sabbath observance, and traditional views on marriage and sexuality as outlined in confessional standards like the Westminster Confession. Her involvement centered on regular attendance and adherence to the church's doctrines, which include opposition to same-sex marriage and ordination of women to eldership, positions she has consistently upheld. While public records do not detail formal roles such as leadership or organized advocacy efforts in the church prior to 2016, her sustained membership reflected a personal dedication to promoting evangelical principles through private and communal practice.[20][21] This faith foundation informed her pre-political professional life as a chartered accountant at Deloitte in London and later in Inverness, where she balanced career demands with church commitments, viewing her work as an opportunity to glorify God through excellence and integrity. Forbes has later reflected that her early experiences instilled a worldview prioritizing sacrificial service and truth-seeking, akin to her parents' missionary ethos, though explicit pre-2016 public advocacy remains undocumented in available sources.[18]Entry into politics
2016 Scottish Parliament election
Kate Forbes was selected as the Scottish National Party (SNP) candidate for the Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch constituency for the 2016 Scottish Parliament election, succeeding Dave Thompson who had held the seat since its creation in 2011.[22] The election occurred on 5 May 2016, amid a national context where the SNP retained a majority of constituency seats despite losing its overall parliamentary majority due to changes in the regional list vote.[22] Forbes secured victory with 17,362 votes, representing 47.6% of the valid votes cast, achieving a majority of 9,043 over the runner-up.[23][24] This result represented a hold for the SNP in the constituency, with Forbes' vote share increasing by 1.4 percentage points compared to 2011.[23] The full results were as follows:| Candidate | Party | Votes | Percentage |
|---|---|---|---|
| Kate Forbes | Scottish National Party | 17,362 | 47.6 |
| Angela MacLean | Scottish Liberal Democrats | 8,319 | 22.8 |
| Robbie Munro | Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party | 5,887 | 16.1 |
| Linda Stewart | Scottish Labour Party | 3,821 | 10.5 |
| Ronnie Campbell | Independent | 1,116 | 3.1 |
Initial backbench tenure (2016–2018)
Following her election to the Scottish Parliament on 5 May 2016 as the Scottish National Party MSP for Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch, Kate Forbes served as a backbench member until her appointment to government in June 2018.[2] During this period, she focused on constituency-specific issues including rural development, environmental protection, and the promotion of Gaelic language and culture, reflecting the Highland and Islands characteristics of her seat. Forbes was appointed to the Rural Economy and Connectivity Committee on 8 June 2016, where she contributed to scrutiny of policies on agriculture, fisheries, transport infrastructure, and rural broadband access until 19 April 2018.[2] She joined the Environment, Climate Change and Land Reform Committee on 7 November 2017, participating in examinations of land ownership reforms, climate targets, and natural resource management.[2] [25] Additionally, she served on the Standards, Procedures and Public Appointments Committee and the Devolution (Further Powers) Committee, addressing parliamentary ethics, procedural reforms, and the devolution of additional powers from Westminster. [26] In May 2016, shortly after her election, Forbes lodged a parliamentary motion (S5M-00247) urging extension of post-study work visas to rural areas to retain international graduates and support economic vitality in regions like the Highlands, which was debated on 16 June 2016.[27] She advocated for Gaelic medium education expansion in her constituency to preserve linguistic heritage amid declining native speakers. Forbes launched the "Final Straw" campaign in January 2018, partnering with the Marine Conservation Society to advocate for a nationwide ban on single-use plastic straws due to marine pollution impacts on coastal ecosystems in her region; the initiative prompted the Scottish Parliament to eliminate plastic straws from its premises by 2 February 2018. [28] On 29 March 2018, as chair of the Scottish Parliament's cross-party group on Gaelic, she delivered a full plenary speech in the language during a debate on UNESCO recognition, emphasizing Gaelic's contemporary relevance beyond historical preservation.[29] [30]Ministerial service under Nicola Sturgeon (2018–2023)
Appointment as finance minister
Kate Forbes was appointed Cabinet Secretary for Finance on 17 February 2020 by First Minister Nicola Sturgeon, following the resignation of Derek Mackay four days earlier.[31][32] Mackay had stepped down on 11 February amid revelations in the Sunday Mail of his exchange of over 270 text messages with a 16-year-old boy, including invitations to meet, which breached the ministerial code.[33][31] The appointment came during a limited cabinet reshuffle prompted by Mackay's exit, with Sturgeon splitting his former Finance and Economy portfolio: Forbes took finance, while Fiona Hyslop assumed economy.[31][33] Forbes, then 29, became the youngest cabinet secretary in the Scottish Government's history and the first woman to hold the finance role.[32][34] Prior to the appointment, she had served as Minister for Public Finance and Employment since June 2018 and had stepped in to deliver the Scottish Government's 2020-21 budget statement on 12 February in Mackay's absence, earning praise from Sturgeon for her performance.[31][32] The selection elevated Forbes from a junior ministerial position to one of the most senior cabinet roles, second only to the Deputy First Minister in influence over fiscal policy.[31][35] Official records list her formal start as Cabinet Secretary for Finance on 18 February.[2]Fiscal policies and budgets
As Cabinet Secretary for Finance and the Economy, Kate Forbes presented the Scottish Government's budgets for the financial years 2020-21, 2021-22, and 2022-23, emphasizing progressive taxation, sustained public service investment, and green economic priorities within the constraints of the devolved fiscal framework.[36][37][38] Her approach balanced immediate recovery needs post-Brexit and amid COVID-19 with medium-term fiscal planning, as outlined in the 2021 Medium Term Financial Strategy, which provided a multi-year perspective on public finances to inform budget formation and evaluation.[39] In the 2020-21 budget, delivered on 6 February 2020, Forbes announced no increases to income tax rates, with basic and intermediate rate thresholds adjusted for inflation while higher and top rate thresholds were frozen, generating an additional £51 million in revenue.[36] Capital spending highlighted £1.8 billion for low carbon infrastructure, a £500 million increase from the prior year, alongside £800 million for affordable housing and £220 million seed funding for the Scottish National Investment Bank.[36] Total health and care funding exceeded £15 billion, and social security expenditure saw a £3 billion uplift following new devolved powers.[36] A new 2% Land and Buildings Transaction Tax band was introduced for non-residential leases with net present value over £2 million, effective from 7 February 2020.[36] The 2021-22 budget, presented on 28 January 2021, incorporated COVID-19 response measures, with income tax adjusted so all Scottish taxpayers paid slightly less than in 2020-21 to promote stability.[37] Non-domestic rates relief totaling £185 million was extended for retail, hospitality, leisure, and aviation sectors, alongside a reduced poundage rate saving businesses £120 million.[37] Public sector pay policy provided a minimum £750 increase (equivalent to 3%) for those earning up to £25,000, with 1% for higher earners capped at £800 for those above £80,000.[37] Spending prioritized £16 billion-plus for the NHS, including £11.9 billion for health boards, £1.9 billion for primary care, and £1.1 billion for mental health; £883 million for social care; and £2.7 billion for education with £125 million to address attainment gaps.[37] Infrastructure allocations exceeded £6 billion, including £667.6 million for affordable housing, while social security received £3.5 billion, with £68 million boosting the Scottish Child Payment.[37] Forbes highlighted UK fiscal constraints and anticipated £500 million in additional funding pending clarity from the UK Budget.[37] For 2022-23, announced on 9 December 2021, income tax rates remained unchanged, with starter and basic rate bands rising with inflation and higher/top rates frozen; Land and Buildings Transaction Tax rates were maintained, and Scottish Landfill Tax rates increased from 1 April 2022 to advance a circular economy.[38] Non-domestic rates included 50% relief for retail, hospitality, and leisure (capped at £27,500 for the first three months), a 49.8p poundage, and £745 million in annual reliefs, extending the Small Business Bonus Scheme for properties under £15,000 rateable value.[38] Health and social care funding reached £18 billion, with a £2.5 billion front-line increase planned by 2026-27; other allocations comprised £831 million for affordable housing, £1.95 billion for Adult Disability Payment, £200 million for the Scottish Attainment Challenge, £2 billion for low carbon capital, £336 million for energy efficiency, £1.4 billion for rail decarbonisation, £205 million for the Scottish National Investment Bank, and £225 million for skills.[38] Under the Bute House Agreement with the Scottish Greens, the Scottish Child Payment doubled to £20 per week from April 2022.[38] Forbes criticized the UK Government for withdrawing COVID funding and Brexit impacts, framing the budget as progressive and focused on inequality reduction, fair work, and green recovery.[38] Forbes' fiscal stance within the SNP leaned toward economic liberalism, advocating free enterprise, wealth creation, and caution against excessive tax rises that could deter business, as evidenced by her later signals to end habitual tax increases to restore Scotland's business-friendly reputation.[40][41] Budgets under her tenure maintained higher income taxes on top earners compared to the rest of the UK but avoided broad hikes, prioritizing targeted reliefs and investments amid fiscal risks noted by independent analyses, such as evolving spending pressures and forecast uncertainties.[42] Some claims by Forbes regarding "Scotland-specific shocks" in budget shortfalls faced scrutiny from parliamentary researchers, who questioned the attribution to UK policy rather than broader factors.[43]Economic response to COVID-19
As Cabinet Secretary for Finance and the Economy from February 2020, Kate Forbes oversaw the Scottish Government's fiscal measures to mitigate the economic fallout from COVID-19, which included rapid deployment of emergency funding amid lockdowns and business closures. The government allocated £15.5 billion in total pandemic-related spending between 2020 and 2022, with £14.5 billion expended by March 2023, largely comprising UK Government consequentials under the Barnett formula.[44][45][46] In early response, Forbes announced a £320 million business rescue package on 14 March 2020, featuring grants for affected sectors and a £50 million hardship fund for individuals facing job losses.[47] This built into broader schemes, including the £1 billion Coronavirus Business Support Fund, which issued 91,500 grants totaling £1.022 billion to small and micro-businesses ineligible for other UK aid.[48][49] Overall, business support encompassed £4.4 billion in grants and non-domestic rates relief from March 2020 to October 2021, prioritizing hospitality, retail, and aviation sectors hit hardest by restrictions.[50] Forbes presented iterative budgets integrating COVID allocations, such as the 2021-22 plan on 28 January 2021, which dedicated £1.1 billion to jobs, skills, and apprenticeships for recovery.[51] Additional £330 million flowed to local authorities for localized measures by August 2020.[52] Audit Scotland's review commended the "scale and pace" of distribution—often within days of announcements—but identified gaps in ongoing assurance, audit trails, and fraud prevention due to urgency, with £6 billion in consequentials formally allocated by late 2020.[53][42] Forbes also engaged UK counterparts for supplementary aid, writing to Chancellor Rishi Sunak on 15 December 2021 to request consequentials for Omicron impacts, and emphasized transitioning to sustainable recovery in subsequent statements.[54] These efforts aligned with devolved powers, supplementing UK-wide schemes like furlough while focusing on Scotland-specific vulnerabilities in tourism and exports.[55]2023 SNP leadership bid
Campaign launch and platform
Kate Forbes announced her candidacy for the SNP leadership on 20 February 2023, entering the contest to succeed Nicola Sturgeon as party leader and First Minister of Scotland.[56][57] The 32-year-old MSP, who had recently returned from maternity leave, launched her bid via an online video statement, positioning herself as a candidate with the "vision, experience and competence" to deliver results amid Scotland's challenges.[58][59] Her platform centered on restoring competence and unity within the SNP, pledging to listen to party members and ensure all voices felt valued, in contrast to perceptions of Sturgeon's more centralized style.[60] Forbes highlighted her economic credentials as former Finance Secretary, advocating for policies that would "unleash the talent" of the party and the pro-independence movement by emulating successful small independent nations through growth-focused governance.[60] She identified immediate priorities including tackling the cost-of-living crisis, reforming the NHS, and advancing Scottish independence via a strategic "reset" that prioritized practical persuasion over rigid timelines.[58] Forbes framed her approach as bold and trustworthy, appealing to Scots across demographics by committing to integrity-driven leadership at a "major crossroads" for the nation and its independence aspirations.[60] While emphasizing delivery on core SNP goals, she signaled willingness to engage in "adult conversations" with the UK government on divisive issues, underscoring a pragmatic stance over confrontation.[58]Key policy proposals
Forbes proposed a pragmatic approach to Scottish independence, rejecting fixed timelines or de facto referendums in favor of building majority support through "gentle persuasion" and effective governance to demonstrate the benefits of separation.[61] She pledged to create an "Independence Delivery Plan" to address perceived myths about independence's economic viability, such as affordability and currency arrangements, aiming to convert No voters by prioritizing delivery on public priorities over divisive mandates.[62][63] On economic policy, Forbes emphasized accelerating growth as essential to funding public services and reducing poverty, criticizing the SNP's recent record under Sturgeon as one of "mediocrity" that failed to inspire confidence or attract investment.[64][65] Her platform called for a competence-driven reset, with commitments to invest in the NHS and eradicate child poverty by linking fiscal decisions to growth outcomes rather than perpetual tax increases, which she implied risked stifling enterprise.[62] This positioned her as favoring a more pro-business orientation within the party, though without specifying measures like income tax reductions during the campaign.[66]Religious and social views scrutiny
During her 2023 SNP leadership campaign, Kate Forbes faced significant scrutiny over her membership in the Free Church of Scotland, a conservative Presbyterian denomination that opposes same-sex marriage and abortion on biblical grounds.[67][68] Forbes, who joined the church in her youth partly due to its proximity to her home, has described her faith as influencing her personal ethics, including a belief that marriage is between a man and a woman and reservations about sexual activity outside marriage.[69][70] Critics within the SNP and media outlets questioned whether these views aligned with the party's socially progressive image, particularly given Scotland's legalization of same-sex marriage in 2014 and ongoing expansions of abortion access up to 24 weeks.[70][71] The controversy intensified when Forbes confirmed on 20 February 2023 that she would have voted against the Marriage and Civil Partnership (Scotland) Act 2014 as a matter of conscience, had she been an MSP at the time, though she affirmed she would not seek to repeal it and supported civil partnerships and LGBT equality in practice.[67][72] This disclosure prompted immediate backlash, with several high-profile supporters, including former SNP MP Joanna Cherry, facing pressure to withdraw endorsement, and rival candidate Humza Yousaf pledging no rollback on equal rights legislation.[72][73] Forbes responded by emphasizing the separation between personal beliefs and governance, arguing that politicians should not be compelled to abandon faith-based convictions and that voters deserved candid answers rather than evasion.[67][74] Forbes also drew attention for her cautious stance on abortion, expressing in interviews a belief that the procedure should be "safe, legal, and rare," and opposing buffer zones around clinics that might restrict silent prayer, while clarifying she would not reverse existing laws.[70][71] These positions fueled perceptions of social conservatism incompatible with SNP priorities, amplified by outlets highlighting potential tensions with coalition partners like the Scottish Greens, who criticized her views on LGBT rights.[75] Supporters, including some conservative-leaning figures outside the SNP, defended her right to hold such views without professional repercussions, citing hypocrisy in public tolerance for diverse beliefs.[76] The scrutiny contributed to a narrative that her faith posed risks to party unity, ultimately influencing her campaign's momentum as liberal members coalesced around alternatives.[77][78]Election outcome and aftermath
In the final round of the 2023 SNP leadership election, held on 27 March, Humza Yousaf secured victory over Kate Forbes with 26,032 votes (52.1%) to her 23,890 (47.9%), following the elimination of Ash Regan and redistribution of preferences; first-preference votes had been Yousaf 24,336 (48.2%), Forbes 20,559 (40.7%), and Regan 5,599 (11.1%), from a turnout of 70% among 72,169 eligible members casting 50,494 valid votes.[79][80] Yousaf was formally elected SNP leader that day and confirmed as First Minister by the Scottish Parliament on 28 March, with no opposition nomination mounted against him.[81] Forbes publicly congratulated Yousaf and pledged her support for his leadership, emphasizing the need for party unity amid ongoing challenges like financial scrutiny and independence strategy.[82] However, she declined Yousaf's offer of a cabinet position—reportedly in rural affairs or economy—citing personal reasons tied to her pregnancy, announced during the campaign, and instead opted to return to the parliamentary backbenches while resuming maternity leave arrangements.[82][83] This decision underscored tensions from the contest, where Forbes's socially conservative views and economic focus had drawn both acclaim and criticism, leaving a portion of the membership—evident in her near-48% final share—aligned with her positions rather than fully transferring to Yousaf.[84] The narrow margin fueled perceptions of SNP internal divisions, with some Forbes backers expressing reservations about Yousaf's policy continuity on issues like gender reform and fiscal prudence; in early April, Forbes herself warned of a "critical moment" for the party amid reported financial irregularities, urging decisive leadership action without directly critiquing her successor.[85] Yousaf's initial cabinet formation proceeded without her, prioritizing a majority-female lineup to signal renewal, though the leadership race's scrutiny of ideological differences persisted in media and party discourse.[82]Interim period under Humza Yousaf (2023–2024)
Return to opposition backbenches
Following Humza Yousaf's election as SNP leader and First Minister on 27 March 2023, he offered Kate Forbes the position of Cabinet Secretary for Rural Affairs and Islands, a role regarded as a demotion from her prior tenure as Cabinet Secretary for Finance and the Economy.[86] Forbes declined the offer, announcing on 29 March 2023 that she was resigning from the Scottish Government to return to the backbenches, citing personal reasons amid ongoing maternity considerations after the birth of her daughter Naomi in August 2022.[82][87][3] She affirmed her support for Yousaf's government and committed to contributing from the backbenches as MSP for Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch.[86] During her time on the backbenches from March 2023 to May 2024, Forbes maintained a lower public profile, prioritizing family during an extended maternity period while fulfilling constituency duties in the Highlands.[83] Limited parliamentary interventions were recorded, reflecting her focus on personal recovery and child-rearing rather than active policy advocacy or party internal debates.[3] Despite this, she retained substantial backing within the SNP membership, positioning her as a potential future leader.[88] In October 2024, Yousaf publicly acknowledged mishandling the portfolio offer, stating he should have proposed a more senior role to better utilize Forbes's expertise and leadership contest performance, describing the rural affairs position as an error in judgment.[89] This reflection underscored tensions in post-leadership transition dynamics within the SNP government.[90]Party internal dynamics
Following her narrow defeat in the SNP leadership contest on 27 March 2023, Kate Forbes declined Humza Yousaf's offer of the Deputy First Minister position, stating personal reasons, and reverted to the opposition backbenches as MSP for Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch.[82] [91] This decision came amid the lingering divisions from the leadership race, where Forbes had publicly questioned Yousaf's competence in handling portfolios such as transport and justice, prompting backlash but which she defended as necessary honesty.[92] [93] Yousaf proceeded to form a majority-female cabinet excluding Forbes, explicitly aiming to move beyond the contest's bitterness.[82] Forbes, who had taken maternity leave after giving birth to her daughter Naomi in August 2022, largely stepped back from frontline party activity during Yousaf's tenure, prioritizing family and constituency duties.[94] [83] However, in April 2023, as police investigations under Operation Branchform intensified scrutiny of SNP finances—including undeclared donations and motorhome purchases—Forbes publicly cautioned that the party faced a "critical moment," with voters viewing developments "with astonishment" and describing financial revelations as "mind-blowing."[95] [85] She called for decisive leadership action to address the crisis, underscoring frictions between backbench concerns over accountability and the executive's handling of scandals that eroded party trust.[95] These remarks amplified perceptions of factional strains within the SNP, pitting Forbes's economically focused, rural constituency perspective against Yousaf's emphasis on social justice priorities and the Bute House Agreement with the Scottish Greens.[96] Despite this, Forbes avoided direct challenges to Yousaf's authority, maintaining distance as the party grappled with declining polls and internal recriminations over independence strategy and governance.[97] When Yousaf resigned on 29 April 2024 following the collapse of the Green coalition, Forbes declined to enter the leadership race, endorsing John Swinney on 2 May 2024 to facilitate rapid unification and avert further infighting.[98] [99] Yousaf later expressed regret in October 2024 for not integrating Forbes more effectively, acknowledging missed opportunities to bridge divides and utilize her expertise.[89]Return to government under John Swinney (2024–present)
Deputy First Minister nomination
Following her withdrawal from the SNP leadership contest on 2 May 2024 to support John Swinney's unopposed candidacy, Kate Forbes was selected by Swinney as his Deputy First Minister upon his assumption of the role.[100] Swinney, elected SNP leader on 6 May 2024 and subsequently endorsed as First Minister by the Scottish Parliament on 7 May before being sworn in on 8 May, announced his cabinet appointments later that day.[101] [102] Swinney nominated Forbes for the position of Deputy First Minister alongside the Cabinet Secretary for Economy and Gaelic portfolios, marking her return to frontline government after over a year on the opposition backbenches during Humza Yousaf's tenure.[103] Forbes accepted the nomination, describing it as "a moment of extraordinary privilege" and emphasizing her commitment to economic growth and national unity.[103] [104] The Scottish Parliament approved Forbes' appointment on 9 May 2024, despite opposition from the Scottish Greens, who cited her socially conservative views on issues such as same-sex marriage and gender recognition as incompatible with progressive equality standards.[105] The Greens' vote against her nomination highlighted ongoing tensions within the pro-independence coalition, though the SNP's parliamentary arithmetic ensured the approval proceeded.[105] This selection underscored Swinney's strategy to incorporate Forbes' fiscal expertise and broaden the government's appeal amid party divisions.[106]Economic portfolio responsibilities
As Cabinet Secretary for the Economy since her appointment on 8 May 2024, Kate Forbes holds responsibility for formulating economic policy to foster prosperity, including support for business, industry, and manufacturing sectors.[1] Her portfolio includes oversight of enterprise agencies, entrepreneurship programs, and the Scottish National Investment Bank to stimulate innovation and job creation.[1] She also coordinates long-term labour market strategies and, jointly with the Cabinet Secretary for Climate Action, advances the green industrial strategy.[1] Forbes manages infrastructure investments, encompassing city and regional growth deals, such as the Falkirk and Grangemouth Growth Deal signed to enhance regional economic development and create jobs.[107] [1] Additional duties cover investment and regeneration initiatives, including city deals, town centre revitalization, and the City Centre Recovery Taskforce.[1] Targeted government investments under her purview support strategic industries, such as aviation at Prestwick Airport, shipbuilding at Fergusons, and offshore engineering at BiFab.[1] Forbes leads implementation of the National Strategy for Economic Transformation, a 10-year plan prioritizing productivity, fair work, and net zero transitions to outperform prior decade growth rates.[108] [109] In September 2024, she launched a dedicated net zero economy strategy to attract investment in renewables and secure supply chain opportunities across Scotland.[110] She promotes public-private collaboration, emphasizing private sector investment to deliver inclusive growth benefiting all regions.[111]Gaelic and cultural initiatives
As Deputy First Minister and Cabinet Secretary for the Economy, Kate Forbes has overseen funding allocations supporting Gaelic language preservation and promotion, reflecting her fluency in the language and representation of the Gaelic-speaking constituency of Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch. In May 2025, she announced £500,000 in targeted funding for Gaelic publishing, education, arts, and community projects, aimed at enhancing resources for learners and cultural practitioners.[112] This included support for digital tools and media to broaden accessibility. Complementing this, Forbes confirmed a £35.7 million investment for Gaelic initiatives in the 2025-26 budget, focusing on education expansion and community revitalization to counter language decline.[113] Forbes has advocated for legislative measures to bolster Gaelic-medium education, stating in June 2025 that proposed amendments to education laws would strengthen parental rights to request such provision, addressing shortages in rural areas where demand exceeds supply.[114] She led parliamentary debate on the Scottish Languages Bill in September 2024, which designates areas of linguistic significance and mandates Gaelic strategies, including standards for public bodies to integrate the language.[115] The bill, passed with cross-party support, extends protections to both Gaelic and Scots, prioritizing regions with historical usage.[116] Broader cultural efforts under her influence include a £100,000 boost for Scots language projects announced in August 2025 during a visit to a Glasgow printworks, funding new orthographic guides and educational materials to promote vernacular literature.[117] These initiatives align with Forbes' emphasis on economic integration of cultural assets, such as leveraging Gaelic for tourism and business differentiation, as highlighted in her comparisons to Canadian models where indigenous languages drive local enterprise.[118] Critics, including some unionist MSPs, have questioned the fiscal prioritization amid budget constraints, arguing for evidence-based impact assessments on learner uptake and economic returns.[114]Recent policy decisions and international engagements
In November 2024, Forbes signed the £100 million Falkirk and Grangemouth Growth Deal alongside UK Secretary of State for Scotland Ian Murray, committing funds to infrastructure, skills training, and green energy projects aimed at creating over 1,000 jobs and transitioning the Grangemouth industrial cluster toward net-zero operations.[119][120] The agreement, finalized at the Rosebank Distillery in Falkirk, emphasized collaboration between Scottish and UK governments to bolster regional economic resilience amid the closure of the Grangemouth refinery.[121] Forbes oversaw the publication of the third annual progress report on Scotland's National Strategy for Economic Transformation in September 2025, highlighting 135 foreign direct investment projects secured in 2024—the second-highest annual total—and advancements in innovation hubs and supply chain development.[108] In the same month, she delivered a keynote speech at Scotland's National Innovation Summit, advocating for increased public-private partnerships to accelerate commercialization of research and address productivity gaps.[122] She also urged UK Chancellor Rachel Reeves to replace the oil and gas windfall tax with a regime supporting North Sea investments, arguing it would sustain jobs and revenues without undermining energy security.[123] On Gaelic policy, Forbes announced £35.7 million in funding for 2025-26 to expand language promotion, including learner pathways and community immersion programs, building on the Scottish Languages Bill's passage in June 2025, which granted official recognition to Gaelic and Scots while enhancing educational protections.[113][124] Additional initiatives included £2 million for a new Gaelic-medium primary school in Glasgow, set to open in 2026, and £600,000 for Gaelic Officer posts in traditional heartlands to foster local usage.[125] Internationally, Forbes co-attended Scotland's Global Investment Summit in Edinburgh in September 2025, engaging investors on opportunities in renewables and life sciences to attract commitments exceeding prior events.[126] In October 2025, she visited Nova Scotia, Canada, to strengthen transatlantic ties in offshore wind, fisheries, and cultural exchanges, including discussions on mutual trade barriers and Gaelic heritage links, though the trip drew criticism for incorporating personal sightseeing elements funded publicly.[127][128] She participated in the Finance Interministerial Standing Committee with counterparts from Wales and Northern Ireland in Cardiff, focusing on coordinated fiscal responses to UK-wide economic pressures.[129]Announcement of non-re-election in 2026
On 4 August 2025, Kate Forbes, the Deputy First Minister and MSP for Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch, announced that she would not seek re-election to the Scottish Parliament in the May 2026 election.[5][130] In a statement shared via social media and reported widely, Forbes cited the demands of her role conflicting with family priorities, stating she did not "wish to seek re-election and miss any more of the precious early years of family life," referencing the birth of her daughter in 2023.[131][132] She emphasized continuing her duties as MSP until the election and affirmed her ongoing commitment to her portfolios in economy and Gaelic, while expressing no immediate plans to resign from government.[133] The decision aligned with a broader trend among SNP MSPs, as Forbes became one of over 20 colleagues announcing they would not contest the 2026 election, potentially signaling internal party renewal amid electoral pressures.[5] First Minister John Swinney responded positively, describing Forbes as a "formidable talent" and expressing regret at her departure while wishing her well in future endeavors.[5] Forbes later clarified in interviews that she was "not a quitter," framing the choice as a deliberate step to prioritize personal life after over a decade in Holyrood, during which she had risen to senior roles despite maternity leave and leadership bids.[134] She speculated lightheartedly about a potential political return at the 2046 election, underscoring her enduring interest in public service.[135] The announcement drew commentary on childcare challenges in Holyrood, with Forbes noting that current provisions "don't make sense" for working parents in high-stakes roles, highlighting structural barriers that influenced her decision.[136] Political analysts observed that her exit could shift SNP dynamics, given her profile as a fiscal conservative and independence supporter, though she committed to supporting the party's campaign in her constituency.[137] No successor was immediately named for her regional seat, which she had held since 2016 with increasing majorities.[138]Political ideology and positions
Scottish independence stance
Kate Forbes has consistently affirmed her support for Scottish independence as a core element of her political platform within the Scottish National Party (SNP). As Cabinet Secretary for Finance and the Economy in 2022, she allocated £20 million in the Scottish budget specifically for preparations toward a second independence referendum (indyref2), reflecting the SNP government's commitment to pursuing the policy despite opposition from the UK government.[139] In public statements, Forbes has framed independence primarily through an economic lens, arguing in September 2025 that it represents an "economic necessity" to alleviate Scotland's constraints under Westminster control, which she claims hinders fiscal and growth decisions tailored to Scottish needs.[140] Forbes advocates a pragmatic approach to achieving independence, emphasizing persuasion and electoral mandates over rigid timelines for a referendum. During her 2023 SNP leadership campaign, she critiqued the fixation on specific dates for indyref2 as "unhelpful," proposing instead a strategy of "gentle persuasion" to build public support gradually, potentially delaying a vote for years.[61] This realism was underscored in August 2023 when she remarked that events like the "second coming of Jesus" might precede indyref2, highlighting her skepticism toward immediate feasibility amid legal and political barriers from the UK Supreme Court and Westminster.[141] In October 2025, as Deputy First Minister, she endorsed the SNP's updated strategy under John Swinney, which conditions a referendum mandate on securing a majority of seats in the 2026 Scottish Parliament election, aligning with efforts to leverage democratic outcomes rather than unilateral declarations.[142] Her position integrates independence with broader governance priorities, viewing it as enabling greater autonomy in areas like economic policy, while avoiding the divisive brinkmanship of past campaigns. Forbes has suggested using UK general elections to exert pressure on Westminster for referendum consent, as stated in February 2023, positioning independence as a long-term democratic evolution rather than an imminent rupture.[143] This measured stance has drawn commentary from unionist critics as evidence of tempered enthusiasm compared to more fervent SNP predecessors, though Forbes maintains it stems from a focus on sustainable majority support.[144]Economic liberalism and fiscal conservatism
Kate Forbes has demonstrated a preference for economic policies emphasizing growth through private sector incentives over redistributive tax measures. During her tenure as Cabinet Secretary for Finance and the Economy from 2020 to 2023, she presented budgets that prioritized post-pandemic recovery and investment attraction, while expressing reservations about unchecked public spending expansions. Her support for the Scottish National Party's 2018 Sustainable Growth Commission report, which proposed limiting public expenditure growth to 0.5% annually in real terms post-independence (below projected GDP growth), underscored a commitment to fiscal restraint, even as critics like the Institute for Fiscal Studies interpreted it as implying potential cuts equivalent to 4% of GDP over a decade.[145] Forbes defended the report's assumptions of 1.5% annual GDP growth and alternatives to expansive monetary tools like quantitative easing, signaling skepticism toward deficit-financed stimulus.[145] In the 2023 SNP leadership contest, Forbes explicitly opposed further income tax increases on higher earners, arguing instead for policies to expand the tax base via economic expansion rather than punitive rates that could deter investment.[84] She positioned herself as pro-business, critiquing high marginal tax bands for risking behavioral responses like migration to lower-tax jurisdictions south of the border, a concern she reiterated in 2024 by noting the challenges of raising taxes on wealth in a devolved settlement without full fiscal autonomy.[146] This approach aligned with liberal economic principles favoring deregulation and competitiveness, as evidenced by her advocacy for stable tax environments to bolster Scotland's appeal to investors, contrasting with predecessor policies under Nicola Sturgeon that introduced multiple higher-rate bands.[147] Upon returning to government in 2024 as Deputy First Minister and Cabinet Secretary for Economy and Gaelic, Forbes further signaled a pivot toward fiscal conservatism by committing to halt "unexpected tax increases" and acknowledging that continual rises erode business confidence.[41] In February 2025, she stated, "you cannot continually raise tax," emphasizing reputation as a key factor in investment decisions, with recent examples including renewed interest from firms like Copenhagen Infrastructure Partners in Scottish projects.[148] Her calls to replace the UK windfall tax on oil and gas with targeted measures in October 2025 reflected a market-oriented stance supportive of North Sea energy sectors, prioritizing job preservation and transitional growth over ideologically driven levies.[149] Forbes has also welcomed tax reliefs for sectors like hospitality in the 2024 Scottish Budget, framing them as essential for sustaining employment amid fiscal pressures.[150] These positions, while diverging from some SNP traditions of progressive taxation, aim to foster long-term revenue through expanded activity rather than short-term extraction, though left-leaning outlets have criticized them as potentially regressive for lower-income groups.[66]Social conservatism and moral issues
Kate Forbes, a member of the evangelical Free Church of Scotland, holds socially conservative positions rooted in her Christian faith, which she has described as aligning with mainstream biblical teachings rather than fringe extremism.[151] Her views have drawn scrutiny from progressive factions within Scottish politics, particularly during SNP leadership contests, where opponents highlighted potential conflicts with party policy on moral issues.[75] Forbes has stated she would have voted against the legalization of same-sex marriage in Scotland had she been a Member of the Scottish Parliament (MSP) during the 2014 vote, citing her belief that marriage is between a man and a woman as per her religious convictions.[67] [152] She emphasized, however, that equal marriage is now a settled legal right which she respects and would uphold as a public servant, distinguishing personal belief from democratic obligations.[67] This stance prompted backlash from LGBT rights advocates and SNP figures, who questioned her compatibility with progressive governance.[72] On abortion, Forbes maintains that human life begins at conception, reflecting a pro-life perspective informed by her faith and observations from her own pregnancies, where she viewed her child via ultrasound at 12 and 20 weeks.[153] Despite this, she has defended the current legal framework allowing women access to abortion services, stating she would not seek to restrict it legislatively.[153] Critics, including abortion rights groups, have expressed concerns over her potential influence on related policies, such as buffer zones around clinics, fearing dilution of protections amid her early career ties to Christian advocacy organizations opposing expansive abortion access.[154] Regarding gender issues, Forbes opposed the Scottish National Party's Gender Recognition Reform (Scotland) Bill in its 2022 form, citing significant concerns with self-identification provisions that would allow legal gender changes without medical diagnosis.[58] [155] She has "unequivocally" supported maintaining single-sex spaces for women, arguing they are essential for safety and privacy, particularly as a mother.[156] In December 2023, following a UK Supreme Court ruling blocking parts of the bill, she urged the Scottish government against appealing, favoring acceptance of the decision to prioritize clarity over ideological pursuit.[157] These positions underscore her prioritization of biological sex-based protections over expansive self-ID reforms, contrasting with more permissive views in her party.[158]Controversies and criticisms
Backlash over personal faith and views
During the 2023 Scottish National Party (SNP) leadership contest to succeed Nicola Sturgeon, Kate Forbes, a member of the socially conservative Free Church of Scotland, faced significant internal party backlash for her personal religious views, particularly on same-sex marriage.[67] Forbes stated that she would have voted against the Marriage and Civil Partnership (Scotland) Act 2014, which legalized same-sex marriage, had she been an MSP at the time, citing a conflict with her Christian beliefs on marriage as between one man and one woman.[67] [72] She described these positions as aligned with "fairly mainstream Christian teaching" and emphasized that her faith would not override her duty to uphold existing laws or prevent conscience-based votes in parliament.[72] [67] The remarks prompted immediate criticism from SNP members and activists, including a prominent gay SNP figure who withdrew potential support, arguing that her stance undermined equality despite her assurances of non-interference in policy.[72] Several SNP politicians, such as those aligned with progressive factions, distanced themselves, questioning whether her evangelical beliefs—rooted in the Free Church's opposition to same-sex relationships and ordination of women—could coexist with leading a party committed to LGBTQ+ rights.[159] [153] Forbes also drew scrutiny for viewing children born outside marriage as "wrong," a position she attributed directly to her faith, further fueling perceptions among critics that her moral framework clashed with modern Scottish social norms.[160] Forbes expressed being "greatly burdened" by the row, noting it led to lost endorsements and intensified media scrutiny of her faith compared to candidates like Humza Yousaf, whose Muslim beliefs faced less equivalent probing on social issues.[159] [161] She later reflected that the controversy highlighted a broader "illiteracy" about religion in politics, warning that fear of such backlash discourages people of faith from public office and risks excluding diverse viewpoints from governance.[151] [162] Despite defenses from figures like Deputy First Minister John Swinney—who attributed criticism to policy consistency rather than faith itself—the episode contributed to Forbes suspending her campaign on 23 February 2023, before the membership vote, and endorsing Yousaf.[163] [159] Her pro-life stance on abortion, consistent with Free Church doctrine, similarly drew early contest backlash but received less sustained attention than marriage views.[164]Intra-party conflicts and leadership viability
During the 2023 Scottish National Party (SNP) leadership contest following Nicola Sturgeon's resignation, Kate Forbes faced significant intra-party opposition primarily stemming from her socially conservative personal views, which clashed with the party's dominant progressive wing on issues such as same-sex marriage and gender recognition reform. Forbes, a member of the Free Church of Scotland, publicly stated she would not have supported same-sex marriage had she been an MSP at the time of its legalization in 2014, and expressed "significant concerns" about self-identification provisions in the Gender Recognition Reform (Scotland) Bill, arguing they undermined women's rights and safety.[58][72] These positions prompted backlash from SNP activists and figures aligned with the party's gender-critical and LGBTQ+ advocacy groups, with some calling for her withdrawal from the race, viewing her stances as incompatible with leading a party committed to progressive equality policies.[165] Deputy First Minister John Swinney, then a senior party figure, intervened to frame the criticism as centered on her broader suitability to unify and lead the SNP, rather than personal attacks, amid fears that her leadership could exacerbate internal divisions.[165] Forbes responded by issuing an apology for any offense caused and pledging to uphold and protect the rights of all Scots, including those in the LGBTQ+ community, while emphasizing her commitment to tolerance and straight answers on policy questions.[166] Despite this, the controversies contributed to a narrative within progressive SNP circles that her leadership risked alienating key voter demographics and fracturing the party, with commentators warning of potential splits if she ascended to First Minister.[167] Her campaign garnered strong initial support, including a majority of branch nominations over rivals Humza Yousaf and Ash Regan, reflecting appeal among rural and more fiscally conservative members, but she ultimately suspended her bid in March 2023 due to impending maternity leave and endorsed Yousaf, finishing second in the member ballot.[84] These tensions highlighted a broader ideological rift in the SNP between its urban, socially liberal base and more traditionalist elements, with Forbes positioned as a representative of the latter, often drawing comparisons to internal factionalism over economic and independence priorities.[168] Forbes' leadership viability was repeatedly questioned on these grounds, with critics arguing her religious convictions and moral positions rendered her unelectable as a unifying figure for a party increasingly defined by progressive identity politics, potentially costing votes in urban strongholds.[77] SNP sources and analysts noted that while her economic competence as Finance Secretary bolstered her credentials, the faith-related controversies overshadowed this, leading to perceptions of her as a polarizing outsider despite her rapid rise.[15] Her endorsement of Yousaf and subsequent return to government under John Swinney in 2024 as Economy Secretary and Deputy First Minister suggested a temporary rehabilitation, with Swinney praising her skills, yet underlying viability concerns persisted, as evidenced by her August 2025 announcement not to seek re-election as an MSP in 2026, citing family priorities amid ongoing party turmoil.[169][170] This decision was interpreted by some as clearing the path for less contentious leadership contenders, underscoring how intra-party ideological conflicts had limited her long-term prospects within the SNP's evolving structure.[171]Policy implementation critiques
During her tenure as Finance Secretary from 2020 to 2023, Kate Forbes faced criticism for downplaying Scotland's fiscal challenges in public statements. In a November 2021 BBC interview, she asserted that Scotland balances its budget annually by spending only what is raised or received in grants, denying the existence of a deficit for day-to-day operations since borrowing is reserved for capital projects.[172] This claim was challenged by the interviewer citing official government statistics showing a deficit approaching 25% of GDP, with Scottish Conservative MSP Donald Cameron labeling it a "total cop out" and Scotland in Union director Pamela Nash accusing her of evading the realities of post-independence tax rises or service cuts.[172] Forbes' implementation of the 2022 Scottish Government Spending Review drew further scrutiny for lacking transparency and accountability in public sector reforms. The review outlined thousands of civil service job reductions alongside efficiency savings, but Forbes avoided specifying affected departments or roles, opting for a "flexible" approach to workforce planning that critics argued enabled evasion of direct responsibility.[173] She confirmed workforce growth in health but implied cuts elsewhere without detailing targets beyond a vague return to pre-pandemic staffing levels, rejecting Westminster's "arbitrary" metrics while repeatedly attributing constraints to UK Government funding shortfalls rather than owning domestic policy trade-offs.[173] Opposition figures contended this obscured the scale of implementation challenges, potentially undermining service delivery amid rising demands. As Deputy First Minister and Cabinet Secretary for Economy and Gaelic since May 2024, Forbes has been critiqued for rigid application of eligibility criteria in the Redress Scotland compensation scheme for historical child abuse survivors. In August 2024, she declined to amend rules to include approximately 200 women abused at Fornethy House—a Church of Scotland respite facility operational from the 1960s to 1990s—despite a Holyrood committee's recommendation, arguing that changes would undermine the scheme's original policy intent and trigger unintended administrative and financial repercussions for other contributors and survivors.[174] Survivor Marion Reid and advocacy groups expressed outrage, accusing the decision of prioritizing budgetary concerns over justice after years of campaigning, with claims that the government's focus on fiscal limits delayed redress for non-residential care cases.[174] The Law Society of Scotland warned of broader legal implications, highlighting tensions in balancing scheme viability against equitable implementation.[174]Electoral record
Parliamentary elections
Kate Forbes was first elected to the Scottish Parliament as the Member of the Scottish Parliament (MSP) for the Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch constituency in the 2016 election held on 5 May, securing 17,362 votes and defeating the second-placed Liberal Democrat candidate Angela MacLean by a majority of 9,043 votes.[24] The turnout in the constituency was 61.6%.[24]| Candidate | Party | Votes | Percentage |
|---|---|---|---|
| Kate Forbes | Scottish National Party | 17,362 | ~52.1% |
| Angela MacLean | Scottish Liberal Democrats | 8,319 | ~25.0% |
| Robbie Munro | Scottish Conservative and Unionist | 5,887 | ~17.7% |
| Linda Stewart | Scottish Labour | 3,821 | ~11.5% |
| Ronnie Campbell | Independent | 1,116 | ~3.4% |
| Candidate | Party | Votes | Percentage | Change from 2016 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Kate Forbes | Scottish National Party | 24,192 | 56.1% | +4.0% |
| Jamie Halcro Johnston | Scottish Conservative and Unionist | 8,331 | 19.3% | +1.6% |
| Denis Rixson | Scottish Liberal Democrats | 6,778 | 15.7% | -9.3% |
| John Erskine | Scottish Labour | 3,855 | 8.9% | -2.6% |