Fact-checked by Grok 2 weeks ago

Mars program

The Mars Exploration Program (MEP) is NASA's ongoing initiative to investigate the planet Mars through a series of robotic missions aimed at determining whether life ever existed there, characterizing the planet's climate and geology, and preparing for potential human exploration.^[1] Launched in 1993, the program has encompassed more than three decades of orbital, landing, and rover-based explorations, building on earlier U.S. efforts that began with the Mariner 9 orbiter in 1971, which provided the first detailed maps of the Martian surface.^[1] Key missions include the Viking 1 and 2 landers in 1976, the first successful U.S. spacecraft to touch down on Mars and search for signs of life; the Mars Pathfinder mission in 1997, which deployed the Sojourner rover for surface analysis; and the Spirit and Opportunity rovers launched in 2003, which operated for years beyond their planned lifetimes and confirmed evidence of past liquid water on the planet.^[1] More recent highlights feature the Curiosity rover, which landed in 2012 and continues to study habitability in Gale Crater, and the Perseverance rover, which arrived in 2021 to collect rock and soil samples for future return to Earth in collaboration with the European Space Agency.^[1] Currently active missions, including the Mars Reconnaissance Orbiter (2006–present) for high-resolution imaging, the MAVEN orbiter (2014–present) for atmospheric studies, and the ESCAPADE mission, launched in November 2025 and en route to Mars to study its magnetosphere and atmosphere, support these goals while laying groundwork for human missions targeted for the 2030s.^[1]^[2] Notable achievements encompass the Ingenuity helicopter, which completed 72 flights on Mars before its mission ended in January 2024, demonstrating powered flight in the thin atmosphere, and the program's role in advancing technologies like sample collection and autonomous navigation.^[3]

Historical Development

Origins in the Space Race

The Soviet Union's Mars program originated amid the intensifying Space Race, driven by a post-Sputnik imperative to assert technological supremacy and interplanetary prestige following the 1957 launch of Sputnik 1. This momentum built on preliminary studies from the mid-1950s, notably Mikhail Tikhonravov's 1956 proposals for crewed Mars expeditions, which envisioned multi-stage rocketry capable of supporting human missions to the Red Planet and outlined conceptual designs for such ventures.^[4] Tikhonravov's work, conducted within Sergei Korolev's OKB-1 design bureau, represented an ambitious extension of Soviet rocketry ambitions beyond Earth orbit, emphasizing the strategic value of planetary exploration in Cold War competition.^[5] The announcement of the U.S. Mariner program in 1959, aimed at unmanned Mars flybys, further galvanized Soviet efforts, prompting accelerated planning to match or surpass American interplanetary capabilities. In response, the Soviet program formalized its first dedicated Mars project that year, with initial development under the Lavochkin design bureau (OKB-301) focusing on lightweight flyby probes to demonstrate feasibility.^[4]^[5] Sergei Korolev, as chief designer of OKB-1, played a pivotal role in this inception by integrating Mars objectives with parallel lunar initiatives, advocating for heavy-lift vehicles like the N1 rocket to enable both endeavors while coordinating resources across bureaus.^[4]^[5] Parallel U.S. efforts, such as the successful Mariner 4 flyby in 1965, highlighted the competitive landscape and influenced Soviet priorities toward reliable deep-space technology. From the outset, the program grappled with significant technical hurdles, including limited launch vehicle performance reliant on R-7 derivatives, which offered insufficient payload capacity and reliability for deep-space trajectories—early tests in 1960, including the failed launches of Mars 1960A and 1960B due to third-stage malfunctions, highlighted these issues and jeopardized mission timelines.^[5] Additionally, profound gaps in deep-space communication technology posed risks, as rudimentary telemetry systems struggled with signal attenuation over interplanetary distances, necessitating innovations in orientation and data transmission that were still in nascent stages by decade's end—as evidenced by the loss of contact with Mars 1 in 1962.^[4] These challenges underscored the program's ambitious scope amid resource constraints, setting the stage for more structured development in the ensuing decade.^[5]

Evolution Through the Cold War Era

Following the series of early setbacks in the Soviet interplanetary efforts during the early 1960s, the program underwent significant reorganization at the end of 1965. Overloaded with multiple high-priority projects, OKB-1 under Sergei Korolev relinquished responsibility for robotic planetary exploration, which had accumulated numerous failures, to OKB-301 (later NPO Lavochkin).^[6] This shift allowed NPO Lavochkin to become the primary design bureau for Mars probes, focusing expertise on automatic spacecraft development while OKB-1 concentrated on human spaceflight and launchers.^[5] The successful U.S. Apollo 11 Moon landing in July 1969 profoundly influenced Soviet priorities, marking a pivotal humiliation that prompted a reevaluation of ambitious crewed interplanetary plans. In response, Soviet leadership de-emphasized manned Mars missions, redirecting resources toward more achievable orbital stations and Earth-orbit operations, though robotic exploration of Mars persisted as a key scientific endeavor.^[4] This strategic pivot reflected broader Cold War dynamics, where the lunar race loss underscored the risks and costs of direct competition in human spaceflight beyond low Earth orbit. Funding for the Mars program experienced notable fluctuations amid these changes, peaking in the early 1970s before leveling off as economic pressures mounted.^[7] However, following the easing of U.S.-Soviet tensions during the détente period in the mid-1970s, space allocations faced cuts and military priorities shifted, leveling off overall space expenditures after the rapid growth of the 1960s.^[8] Throughout this era, Soviet Mars efforts operated under stringent secrecy policies characteristic of the Cold War, with mission details often classified to maintain strategic advantages and prevent technology leakage to the West. This approach limited international collaboration to occasional exchanges within the socialist bloc via programs like Interkosmos, in stark contrast to later multinational simulations such as Mars 500 in the 2010s. A key enabler of more ambitious probes was the development of the Proton launcher by 1965, originally designed for heavy military payloads but adapted as a four-stage vehicle capable of delivering up to 17 metric tons to low Earth orbit, facilitating larger and more complex Mars spacecraft.^[9] Early flyby attempts served as critical testing grounds for propulsion and guidance technologies that informed these advancements.^[10]

Program Objectives

Scientific Exploration Goals

The scientific exploration goals of the Mars program have centered on unraveling the planet's geological history, climatic dynamics, and potential for past habitability, with primary objectives including the mapping of Martian topography to understand surface features and evolution.^[11] Early efforts focused on high-resolution imaging to reveal craters, volcanoes, and canyons, providing foundational data on the planet's tectonic and erosional processes. Analysis of atmospheric composition has been a core aim, targeting the dominance of carbon dioxide (approximately 95%) alongside trace gases like nitrogen and argon to model weather patterns and escape mechanisms.^[11] Detection of water ice evidence, particularly in polar caps and subsurface deposits, has sought to trace the history of liquid water and its implications for environmental stability.^[11] Instrumentation has played a pivotal role in achieving these goals, with spectrometers employed for precise gas analysis to quantify atmospheric layers and seasonal variations, cameras for detailed surface imaging to identify geological formations, and seismometers to probe internal structure and seismic activity. These tools have enabled in-situ measurements to complement remote observations, enhancing accuracy in assessing volatile distribution and crustal composition. The long-term objective has been to facilitate sample return missions, allowing laboratory analysis of meteorology through isotopic studies, geological samples for mineralogy, and searches for organic compounds to evaluate biosignatures.^[11] A key overarching goal is to prepare for human exploration by evaluating the Martian environment, resources such as in-situ resource utilization potential, and hazards to support future crewed missions.^[11] The evolution of these goals reflects advancing capabilities, transitioning from basic flyby photography in the 1960s—aimed at initial topographic surveys and atmospheric density profiling—to in-situ lander experiments in the 1970s focused on soil composition and direct environmental sampling.^[12]

Technological and Engineering Aims

The development of reliable deep-space propulsion systems for the Mars program emphasized the use of hypergolic fuels in upper stages to enable precise trajectory corrections during interplanetary transit. Hypergolic propellants, such as monomethylhydrazine (MMH) and nitrogen tetroxide (NTO), ignite spontaneously upon contact, providing reliable, storable bipropellant performance without the need for ignition systems, which is critical for long-duration missions where precise mid-course adjustments are required to account for launch dispersions and gravitational perturbations.^[13] These fuels were selected for their high reliability in vacuum environments, supporting efficient orbit insertion and attitude control maneuvers essential to reaching Mars.^[14] Advancements in communication systems for Mars exploration involved transitioning from low-bandwidth S-band radio frequencies (2-4 GHz) to higher-frequency X-band (8-12 GHz) and eventually Ka-band (27-40 GHz) systems, enabling greater data relay capacities for real-time transmission. Early missions relied on S-band for basic command and telemetry due to its robustness over vast distances, but the shift to higher frequencies in the 1990s and beyond increased bandwidth dramatically, allowing for data rates up to several megabits per second and supporting more complex relay architectures via orbiters. This evolution facilitated the integration of scientific instruments as payloads, ensuring efficient downlink of imagery and sensor data despite the 4- to 24-minute light-time delay between Earth and Mars.^[15] Landing technology for Mars missions focused on parachute-aerobraking hybrid systems combined with soft-lander designs to manage entry into the planet's thin atmosphere, which provides only about 1% of Earth's atmospheric density at sea level. Aerobraking via ablative heat shields decelerates spacecraft from hypersonic velocities (around 5-6 km/s) during atmospheric entry, followed by large supersonic parachutes—such as disk-gap-band or ring-sail types—that deploy to further slow descent rates to survivable levels for surface impact.^[16] These designs, scaled from Viking-era configurations since the 1970s, incorporate redundant deployment mechanisms and terminal retropropulsion or airbags to achieve soft landings, addressing the challenges of low drag and high entry heating in Mars' CO2-dominated atmosphere.^[17] Key innovations in propulsion included the development and testing of ion thrusters during the 1990s, offering higher specific impulse (up to 3,000 seconds) compared to chemical systems. The NASA Solar Electric Propulsion Technology Application Readiness (NSTAR) program, initiated in the early 1990s, developed gridded ion engines using xenon propellant to generate thrust via electrostatic acceleration, reducing propellant mass needs by factors of 5-10 for deep-space maneuvers.^[18] These systems were flight-demonstrated on interplanetary missions like Deep Space 1 in 1998, paving the way for their potential application in future Mars missions by providing continuous low-thrust efficiency for aerobrake augmentation and station-keeping.^[19] Reliability efforts for Mars missions significantly improved success rates by the 1970s, achieving near 100% for NASA's attempts like the Viking missions, through the implementation of redundant systems and extensive ground simulations, marking a substantial improvement from earlier ~50% failure rates in the 1960s. Innovations like dual-string avionics, backup propulsion modules, and environmental testing protocols reduced overall system failure probabilities, ensuring mission-critical functions such as propulsion firing and communication links could tolerate single-point failures.^[20] This approach, validated through Viking successes in 1976, emphasized fault-tolerant designs to handle the harsh radiation and thermal extremes of deep space.^[21]

Uncrewed Spacecraft Missions

Early Flyby and Launch Attempts (1960-1969)

The Soviet Union's initial efforts to explore Mars began in the early 1960s as part of its broader planetary program, focusing on uncrewed flyby probes to achieve interplanetary trajectories and gather preliminary data on the space environment en route to the planet. These missions relied on newly developed launch vehicles like the Molniya rocket, which aimed to impart the necessary hyperbolic escape velocity of approximately 11.2 km/s from Earth to enable Mars-bound paths. However, high failure rates due to upper-stage malfunctions plagued the era, with only partial successes in cruise-phase telemetry providing insights into interplanetary conditions.^[22]^[23] The Mars 1M series marked the program's debut, with two probes launched in October 1960 using the Molniya 8K96 rocket. Intended as flyby missions to photograph Mars and study its environment, both attempts—on October 10 and 14—failed when the third stages of the rockets malfunctioned, preventing escape from Earth orbit. These setbacks highlighted early challenges in reliable upper-stage performance for deep-space injections.^[23]^[24] A partial advancement came with Mars 1962, designated Mars 1 and launched on November 1, 1962, aboard a Molniya 8K78 rocket, which successfully achieved the required hyperbolic trajectory toward Mars. The probe, equipped with a camera for the first attempted interplanetary photographs, aimed to conduct a flyby while measuring magnetic fields, radiation, and the Martian atmosphere and surface. Contact was lost on March 21, 1963, at about 107 million km from Earth due to an orientation system failure, preventing any Mars imaging but allowing cruise-phase telemetry on solar wind particles and cosmic rays before communications ceased.^[23]^[22] By 1969, the Soviet program shifted toward more ambitious orbiter designs using the heavier-lift Proton-K rocket, but launch failures persisted. Mars 1969A, launched on March 27 aboard a Proton-K/D vehicle, was intended as an orbiter with cameras to map the Martian surface and atmosphere; it failed to escape Earth orbit when the upper stage failed to ignite due to a sensor malfunction. Just days later, on April 2, Mars 1969B met a similar fate on another Proton-K/D launch, with the upper stage unable to separate properly, again stranding the spacecraft in low Earth orbit. These incidents underscored ongoing issues with sensor reliability in the Proton's attitude control systems during interplanetary attempts.^[23]^[25] Despite the predominance of failures, the cruise-phase data from Mars 1 provided valuable early measurements of solar wind flux and cosmic ray intensities, contributing to foundational understanding of the interplanetary medium and informing refinements in subsequent probe designs.^[22]

Orbiter and Lander Operations (1971-1973)

The Soviet Union's Mars program reached a significant milestone in 1971 with the launch of the twin Mars 2 and Mars 3 spacecraft on May 19 and May 28, respectively, each comprising an orbiter and a lander capsule designed for deployment at Mars. Built by NPO Lavochkin on the 3MS platform, these 4,650 kg vehicles featured a cylindrical orbital module with solar panels spanning 5.6 meters, telephoto cameras with focal lengths of 52 mm and 350 mm, and a propulsion system using liquid propellants for midcourse corrections and orbit insertion maneuvers requiring a delta-v of approximately 1 km/s.^[5]^[26] Mars 2 arrived at Mars on November 27, 1971, marking the first human-made object to reach the planet when its 1,210 kg lander impacted the surface at high velocity due to a guidance malfunction during atmospheric entry. The orbiter successfully performed its insertion burn, entering a highly elliptical orbit with a pericenter of 1,350 km and an 18-hour period at 48.9° inclination, from which it relayed scientific data—including surface images—to Earth for eight months before contact was lost. Mars 3 followed on December 2, 1971, achieving the program's first soft landing in the southern region near Ptolemaeus crater after deploying its heat shield, parachute, and retro-rockets; however, the lander ceased transmitting after just 20 seconds, likely due to a dust storm or internal failure, providing only partial panoramic imagery. Its orbiter entered a 12-day orbit with a pericenter of 1,500 km and operated similarly for eight months, contributing to the missions' total of about 60 images captured by the twin orbiters.^[5]^[23]^[27] In 1973, the program continued with Mars 4 and Mars 5, launched on July 21 and July 25 aboard Proton rockets, as dedicated orbiters without landers to build on the prior imaging capabilities. Mars 4 failed its orbit insertion on February 10, 1974, due to an engine shutdown during the burn, resulting in a flyby at 1,936 km altitude that yielded 8 low-resolution images through its 52 mm camera. Mars 5 succeeded in entering orbit on February 12, 1974, in a 1,760 km by 21,500 km ellipse with a 25-hour period, operating for 22 days and completing 22 revolutions to return 60 high-resolution images covering about 35% of the Martian surface, primarily via its panoramic and telephoto systems, before a power subsystem failure ended communications. These orbiters used a high-gain parabolic antenna for direct relay to Earth ground stations, transmitting data at rates up to 6.4 kbit/s during optimal alignments.^[23]^[5]^[28] Complementing the orbital efforts, Mars 6 and Mars 7 launched on August 5 and August 9, 1973, as lander-focused missions with attached flyby modules for data relay. Mars 6 reached Mars on March 12, 1974, with its lander descending into the Hellas Planitia region; it successfully transmitted atmospheric pressure and temperature profiles during parachute-assisted entry but sent no surface signals after touchdown, possibly due to impact damage, while the flyby module provided additional telemetry. Mars 7 arrived on March 9, 1974, but a navigation error caused the lander to separate prematurely, missing the planet by 1,300 km; the flyby module passed at 1,600 km and returned limited spectral data on the atmosphere. Each lander, weighing around 600 kg, incorporated a propulsion system with solid-fuel retrorockets for final descent control, and operations emphasized autonomous relay through the flyby bus to Soviet tracking stations, capturing descent science without surface imaging success. These missions, despite partial failures, advanced understanding of Martian entry dynamics through the data returned during descents.^[27]^[5]^[23]

Advanced Probes and Sample Return Efforts (1988-2011)

The Soviet Phobos program represented a significant advancement in Martian moon exploration, launching two nearly identical spacecraft in 1988 to study Phobos, the larger of Mars' two moons. Phobos 1, launched on July 7 from Baikonur Cosmodrome, was lost en route on September 2 due to a software error that deactivated its attitude control system, causing loss of orientation and solar power.^[29] Phobos 2, launched on July 12, successfully entered Mars orbit on January 29, 1989, after a trajectory correction maneuver, and conducted observations of Mars' surface, atmosphere, and the interplanetary medium using its suite of 25 instruments.^[30] However, on March 27, 1989, during its approach to Phobos for a close flyby and planned landing, the probe suffered a failure in its attitude control or radio transmitter, preventing the rendezvous and leading to mission termination.^[29] Despite these setbacks, Phobos 2 achieved partial success by returning valuable imaging data of Phobos' surface, capturing 38 images that covered approximately 60% of the moon and revealed prominent craters and linear grooves, providing early insights into its irregular topography at resolutions up to 40 meters per pixel.^[31] These observations highlighted Phobos' heavily cratered terrain and enigmatic groove patterns, which suggested possible tectonic or impact-related origins, though the mission's abrupt end limited further analysis.^[32] The program's design incorporated advanced autonomous navigation systems for precise orbital maneuvers around Mars and Phobos, building on heritage from 1970s lander technologies to enable closer approaches than prior flybys.^[30] Subsequent Russian efforts shifted toward more ambitious sample return objectives, as seen in the Mars 96 mission launched on November 16, 1996, aboard a Proton rocket from Baikonur. This complex probe, with a total mass of over 6,800 kg, aimed to deploy an orbiter for global Mars observations, two small soil analysis landers equipped with airbags for soft landings in the Amazonis Planitia region, and two penetrators designed to burrow 4-6 meters into the surface for subsurface measurements.^[33] Tragically, the mission failed shortly after launch when the Fregat upper stage malfunctioned during its second burn, imparting only 20 m/s of velocity in the wrong direction and stranding the spacecraft in low Earth orbit, where it reentered and disintegrated over the Pacific Ocean on November 17.^[33] The international collaboration, involving instruments from 14 nations, underscored the mission's scope, but the failure highlighted persistent challenges with upper-stage reliability in deep-space launches. Design evolutions in these later probes emphasized propulsion and autonomy innovations to support sample return ambitions, particularly for Phobos missions. The Fobos-Grunt spacecraft, launched on November 9, 2011, via a Zenit-2M rocket from Baikonur, incorporated Hall-effect plasma engines for efficient station-keeping and trajectory adjustments during its planned three-year journey, along with advanced autonomous navigation systems to enable precise landing and sample collection on Phobos without real-time ground control.^[34] The probe targeted collecting up to 100 g of Phobos regolith using a robotic arm and scoop, storing it in a return capsule for Earth delivery after a four-month surface stay, marking the first such extraterrestrial sample return since Luna 24 in 1976.^[35] It also carried the Chinese Yinghuo-1 orbiter, a 110-kg microsatellite for Mars atmospheric studies, to be released upon arrival.^[34] However, hours after launch, the main engines failed to ignite due to non-space-qualified components and inadequate testing, leaving Fobos-Grunt in Earth orbit; it reentered uncontrolled over the Pacific on January 15, 2012, with no data returned.^[36] These missions collectively advanced probe technologies for high-risk Phobos operations, prioritizing plasma-based propulsion for fuel efficiency and AI-driven autonomy for regolith sampling in Phobos' low-gravity environment, though repeated launch and operational failures delayed sample return goals until later international efforts.^[37]

Crewed Mission Proposals

Initial Manned Concepts (1960s)

During the early 1960s, amid the Space Race, both the United States and the Soviet Union developed conceptual designs for crewed missions to Mars. Soviet engineers, led by figures such as Mikhail Tikhonravov and Sergei Korolev at OKB-1, proposed architectures utilizing the N1 super-heavy launcher for orbital assembly and interplanetary transit.^[38]^[39] One foundational Soviet proposal from Tikhonravov in 1960 envisioned a six-person crew assembled in Earth orbit via multiple N1 launches to form a Martian Piloted Complex (MPK) weighing approximately 1,600 metric tons. This design targeted a round-trip mission lasting about two years, using chemical propulsion for transit and modular elements for landing and surface operations. Korolev refined these in 1962 with the TMK (Heavy Interplanetary Spacecraft) series, advocating nuclear propulsion for a direct ascent 400-day mission with a three-person crew, exploring flyby and landing variants.^[40]^[41] In the U.S., early studies by NASA and industry, including Wernher von Braun's team at Marshall Space Flight Center, outlined crewed Mars expeditions. Von Braun's 1969 plan, published in Collier's magazine extensions and NASA reports, proposed a fleet of ten Saturn V-launched spacecraft carrying 12-16 crew for a 1969 launch window, though later adjusted for the 1980s, emphasizing chemical propulsion and orbital assembly for a 400-day transit with surface stays. These concepts shared challenges with Soviet designs, including radiation shielding of at least 10 g/cm² against galactic cosmic rays and solar events, and life support to counter microgravity effects like muscle atrophy.^[42]^[43] Both programs integrated Mars ambitions with lunar efforts, but resource prioritization for the Moon—coupled with the Soviet N1's four failed tests from 1969 to 1972—shifted focus. Soviet leadership deemed full Mars expeditions prohibitively expensive, leading to shelving by 1969 in favor of robotic missions. U.S. plans similarly yielded to Apollo priorities.^[44]^[41]

Refined Designs and Simulations (1970s-2010s)

In the 1970s, Soviet engineers refined early concepts through the TMK-MARS project, proposing Earth-orbit assembly of two interconnected spacecraft via multiple N1 launches for a three-person flyby and observation mission lasting about three years, with 260-day transits each way and aerobraking for Mars arrival. The design stressed modular construction, redundancy, and radiation shielding for crew safety.^[40]^[45]^[39] By the 1980s, Soviet planning pivoted to the Energia super-heavy-lift rocket, capable of over 100 tons to low Earth orbit, for habitat modules and infrastructure. A 1987 proposal by NPO Energia chief Valentin Glushko integrated nuclear electric propulsion to shorten transit and reduce propellant, envisioning a multi-launch campaign for a two-year piloted mission with a roughly 400-ton spacecraft, preceded by unmanned tests.^[46]^[47] Ground-based simulations advanced preparation in the late 2000s via the Mars-500 experiment, run by Russia's Institute for Biomedical Problems with the European Space Agency and involving a Chinese participant, from 2007 to 2011. The 520-day isolation phase (June 2010–November 2011) housed six multinational crew in a 550 m³ Moscow facility, simulating round-trip transit with a 30-day surface analog. Findings underscored psychological issues like stress and interpersonal tensions, validating protocols for autonomy and informing countermeasures.^[48]^[49]^[50] International efforts in the 1990s and 2000s incorporated European Space Agency inputs into manned Mars frameworks, emphasizing in-situ resource utilization (ISRU) for propellants like methane and oxygen from Martian CO₂ and water ice via the Sabatier reaction. Evolving from U.S. Design Reference Missions, these reduced Earth-launched mass significantly. ESA focused on resource extraction demos for sustainability.^[51]^[52]^[53] As of November 2025, Roscosmos targets crewed Mars missions in the late 2030s, advancing nuclear propulsion and reusable technologies. While Russia collaborates with China on the lunar International Lunar Research Station, Mars plans remain primarily independent, though broader international cooperation is explored.^[54]^[39]

Scientific Contributions

Atmospheric and Surface Data

Infrared spectrometry from the Mars 5 orbiter in 1973 provided detailed orbital remote sensing measurements of the Martian atmosphere's composition, revealing it to be dominated by 95% carbon dioxide (CO₂), with 2.7% nitrogen (N₂) and trace amounts of oxygen (O₂) comprising the remainder.^[55] These findings confirmed earlier flyby data and established the thin, CO₂-rich nature of the atmosphere, with argon later quantified at about 1.6% through complementary analyses.^[56] Surface imaging from early landers and orbiters yielded foundational views of Martian terrain. The Viking 1 and 2 landers in 1976 transmitted the first clear close-up photographs from the surface, depicting expansive dusty plains with scattered rocks and a hazy horizon obscured by atmospheric particles.^[27] Complementing this, the Phobos 2 spacecraft in 1988-1989 captured high-resolution images of the Martian surface and its moon Phobos at up to 40 meters per pixel, enabling detailed mapping of craters and revealing fine-scale surface textures such as layered ejecta and ray systems.^[57] Direct measurements during descent and landing operations illuminated weather patterns and surface conditions. As the Mars 6 lander entered the atmosphere in 1973, onboard sensors detected widespread dust storms that raised atmospheric opacity, while pressure readings averaged around 6 millibars at the surface, underscoring the planet's low-density air and dynamic aeolian activity.^[58] Later NASA missions expanded on these early data. The Mars Pathfinder's entry probe in 1997 measured atmospheric density and temperature profiles during descent, confirming low surface pressures of about 7 millibars and identifying wind speeds up to 20 m/s. The Spirit and Opportunity rovers (2004–2010s) analyzed surface regolith using alpha particle X-ray spectrometers, revealing iron-rich basaltic compositions with silica contents around 45–50%, consistent with volcanic origins and past aqueous alteration. The Curiosity rover (2012–present) has measured atmospheric water vapor fluctuations and dust opacity variations, showing seasonal changes in humidity up to 0.1 precipitable microns.^[1] Observations of Phobos during the Phobos 2 mission in 1988 quantified its physical properties, including a surface gravity of roughly 0.0057 m/s²—far lower than Mars' 3.71 m/s²—due to the moon's small mass and irregular shape.^[59] Regolith composition analyses from the mission's spectrometers suggested a dark, carbon-rich matrix with silicate components, consistent with primitive carbonaceous chondrite materials and potential hydration features in crater walls.^[60]

Insights into Martian Geology and Environment

Mission data from early orbiters have revealed extensive networks of ancient channels across the Martian surface, providing compelling evidence for the presence of liquid water in the planet's geological past. These sinuous, branching features, first imaged by Mariner 9 in 1971, resemble terrestrial river valleys and outflow channels, indicating episodic flows of water that carved landscapes over billions of years, potentially forming vast river systems during a warmer, wetter epoch around 3.5 billion years ago.^[61] Subsequent analysis of these features supports the interpretation of catastrophic flooding events, such as those associated with the formation of Valles Marineris, rather than gradual erosion, highlighting Mars' dynamic hydrological history.^[62] NASA's Spirit and Opportunity rovers provided direct evidence of this past water, identifying hematite spherules ("blueberries") and sulfate-rich outcrops in Meridiani Planum and Gusev crater, formed in acidic, water-involved environments around 3.5–4 billion years ago. Curiosity's investigations in Gale Crater (2012–present) have uncovered clay minerals and organic carbon compounds, indicating a habitable lake environment persisting until about 3.5 billion years ago.^[1] Volcanic processes have profoundly shaped Mars' geology, with the Tharsis region's massive shield volcanoes exemplifying prolonged igneous activity. Mariner 9 images first unveiled Olympus Mons, the solar system's largest volcano, rising approximately 22 kilometers above the surrounding plains, its immense scale inferred from orbital stereo imaging that revealed gentle slopes and a vast caldera complex spanning 600 kilometers.^[63] Crater counting on its lava flows indicates relatively recent activity, with the last major eruptions occurring around 2 million years ago, suggesting that Martian volcanism persisted into the Amazonian period and may imply ongoing subsurface heat sources. The polar regions offer key insights into Mars' volatile inventory and climatic cycles, dominated by seasonal caps of carbon dioxide ice that advance and retreat with the planet's 687-day year. Observations from Mariner 9 in the early 1970s documented these caps' dynamic behavior, showing CO2 frost accumulating in winter to depths of up to 1 meter and sublimating in summer, which drives global atmospheric pressure variations of about 25%.^[64] Beneath the seasonal CO2 layer lies a residual cap primarily composed of water ice, with spectroscopic data confirming a stable core extending several kilometers in thickness, preserving records of past climate shifts through layered deposits that alternate between dust and ice.^[65] The Mars Reconnaissance Orbiter (2006–present) has mapped polar layered deposits in high resolution, revealing obliquity-driven cycles over millions of years that influenced ice deposition and dust trapping.^[1] Mars' radiation environment poses significant challenges for habitability, as measured by particle detectors on spacecraft during interplanetary cruise phases. Data indicate an annual cosmic ray dose equivalent of approximately 200 millisieverts on the surface, far exceeding Earth's levels and primarily from galactic cosmic rays and solar energetic particles unshielded by a global magnetic field. This intense flux penetrates the thin atmosphere and regolith minimally, sterilizing surface layers to depths of tens of centimeters and limiting potential microbial life to subsurface refugia, underscoring the planet's current inhospitable conditions for exposed biology. The MAVEN orbiter (2014–present) has quantified atmospheric loss to space, linking it to the absence of a magnetic field and contributing to the drying of the planet over billions of years.^[66]^[1] Spectral observations of Phobos support its origin as a captured asteroid from the outer solar system. Viking orbiter data from the 1970s revealed reflectance spectra dominated by dark, reddish materials akin to carbonaceous chondrites, with absorption features at 0.7 and 3 micrometers indicating phyllosilicates and organic compounds typical of primitive C-type asteroids.^[67] This composition, combined with Phobos' irregular shape and low density of about 1.9 g/cm³, aligns with the capture hypothesis, where tidal interactions stabilized its orbit around Mars approximately 4 billion years ago, preserving a relic of early solar system debris.^[68]

Legacy and Future Directions

Achievements and Challenges

The Soviet Mars program achieved several pioneering milestones in planetary exploration. In 1962, Mars 1 became the first spacecraft to perform a flyby of Mars, transmitting data on interplanetary space and cosmic rays before contact was lost en route.^[5] The program delivered the first successful orbiter with Mars 2 in 1971, which entered Martian orbit and relayed images and atmospheric data for eight months.^[69] That same year, Mars 3 accomplished the first soft landing on another planet, touching down in the Ptolemaeus crater and briefly transmitting surface data for 14.5 seconds, despite a subsequent failure likely due to a dust storm.^[5] These missions, along with Mars 5 and 6 in 1973, provided a substantial portion of the early scientific data on Mars' atmosphere, surface temperatures, and geology, complementing U.S. efforts like Mariner 9.^[23] Despite these successes, the program faced a high failure rate, with approximately 60% of its 17 missions resulting in total failures, including an initial streak of nine consecutive unsuccessful attempts from 1960 to 1969.^[70] Launch and orbit insertion issues accounted for many losses, often stemming from unreliable upper stages on Proton rockets and prolonged communication blackouts during interplanetary transit.^[71] For instance, Mars 4 missed orbit in 1973 due to a braking engine malfunction, while Phobos 1 and 2 in 1988 failed from software errors and attitude control problems before reaching their targets.^[5] Technological advancements from the program left lasting legacies adopted in global exploration. Lander designs, such as those on Mars 3 and 6, demonstrated survival strategies in Mars' thin atmosphere, incorporating parachutes, retro-rockets, and foam shock absorbers to handle low-density entry conditions.^[5] In human spaceflight preparation, the Russian-led Mars 500 experiment (2010–2011) successfully simulated a 520-day round-trip mission, validating crew psychology, team dynamics, and isolation effects for long-duration flights.^[48] Economic pressures compounded challenges, with cost overruns in ambitious efforts like the 1988 Phobos program—estimated in the hundreds of millions of rubles—contributing to mission failures and a halt in Soviet planetary probes during the early 1990s amid post-Cold War budget constraints.^[29]

Influence on Global Mars Exploration

The Soviet Mars program's pioneering achievements in the 1970s demonstrated the technical feasibility of soft landings on Mars, directly influencing subsequent international efforts. The Mars 3 lander, which touched down successfully on December 2, 1971, marked the first such accomplishment despite operating for only about 14.5 seconds, providing critical validation for surface operations that informed NASA's Viking program. Viking 1, launched in 1975 and landing in 1976, built on this precedent as the first fully successful long-term lander, effectively advancing the baton from Soviet attempts that had encountered challenges like dust storms and communication failures. This demonstration reduced perceived risks for planetary landers, encouraging global investment in Mars surface exploration. Early data-sharing agreements between the United States and Soviet Union further amplified the program's impact, transitioning from Cold War competition to collaborative scientific exchange. In 1971, NASA and the Soviet Academy of Sciences agreed to share data from unmanned Mars missions, including telemetry and imaging from the Mars 2 and 3 orbiters, which helped calibrate international models of the Martian atmosphere and surface conditions. Post-Cold War openness in the 1990s allowed broader access to archived Soviet data, contributing to refined orbital analyses and landing site selections in later missions. The legacy extended to modern international collaborations, particularly through Roscosmos's former partnership with the European Space Agency on the ExoMars program. Launched in 2016, the joint mission deployed the Trace Gas Orbiter, which achieved full operational success and continues to map atmospheric trace gases, while the Schiaparelli Entry, Descent, and Landing Demonstrator experienced a partial failure due to a sensor error during descent. The follow-on Rosalind Franklin rover mission, originally planned with Roscosmos for 2020, faced delays and saw ESA suspend cooperation with Russia in 2022 due to geopolitical tensions following Russia's invasion of Ukraine. ESA has since proceeded independently, selecting Airbus to build a new landing platform, with a launch targeted for 2028. The orbiter's data has supported global studies on methane plumes and habitability. These efforts initially highlighted Russia's expertise in propulsion and entry systems, fostering shared technological advancements despite setbacks. In 2025, ESA awarded Airbus a contract for the new lander, ensuring the mission's continuation.^[72] As of November 2025, Roscosmos is pursuing renewed ambitions for Mars exploration, with conceptual plans for a Phobos sample return mission targeted for the 2030s, reviving elements of the failed 2011 Phobos-Grunt effort through updated designs like the proposed Boomerang spacecraft. This initiative aims to collect regolith from the Martian moon and return it to Earth, potentially integrating with broader international frameworks for sample analysis, though geopolitical constraints have kept timelines fluid. While Russia has not signed the Artemis Accords, Roscosmos officials have signaled openness to cooperative elements, such as data interoperability, aligning with global norms for sustainable exploration. The program's educational impact endures through the cadre of engineers trained during its height, many of whom transitioned into leadership roles at Roscosmos and other post-Soviet agencies, shaping contemporary designs for heavy-lift launchers and interplanetary probes. This human capital legacy ensured continuity in Russian space capabilities, influencing missions like the Luna program and contributing to expertise in cryogenic propulsion still utilized today. Geopolitically, the Soviet Mars efforts exemplified a shift from rivalry to cooperation, as evidenced by Russian contributions to NASA's Mars Reconnaissance Orbiter data analysis. In 2013, Russian space enthusiasts, collaborating with NASA's HiRISE team, identified potential remnants of the Mars 3 lander in orbital imagery, enabling joint verification of historical sites and enhancing mutual understanding of Martian terrain evolution. This partnership reflects broader post-Cold War integrations, including Russian instruments on other NASA Mars missions, underscoring a transition toward shared scientific objectives.

References

[1]
Mars Exploration - NASA Science
NASA's Mars Exploration Program will focus the next two decades on its science-driven systemic approach on these strategic goals: exploring for potential life, ...The Mars Future PlanScience GoalsMars Exploration ProgramMars Exploration RoversInSight Lander
[2]
[PDF] Challenge to Apollo: the Soviet Union and the space race, 1945-1974
This book is, in essence, sixteen years in the making. I first attempted to compile a histo- ry of the Soviet space program in 1982 when, encouraged by my ...
[3]
[PDF] The Difficult Road to Mars - NASA
Perminov was the leading designer for Mars and Venus spacecraft at the Lavochkin design bureau in the Soviet Union during the early days of Mars exploration.
[4]
USSR/Russia - Venautics
The OKB Lavochkin, which has become the private company NPO Lavochkin, survives by marketing the Fregat stage, derived from the propulsion block of the ...<|separator|>
[5]
[PDF] National Intelligence Estimate 11-1-73. Soviet Space Programs
Apr 8, 2020 · PRECIS. The USSR will continue to undertake space programs for a variety of reasons: - Supporting strategic military objectives by using ...
[6]
[PDF] COMPARISON OF US AND ESTIMATED SOVIET EXPENDITURES ...
US space expenditures were approximately $16 billion, while Soviet outlays were estimated between $6 and $10 billion through fiscal year 1964.
[7]
Proton Launch Vehicle - Russia and Space Transportation Systems
The Russians announced a weight for the payload of 17 metric tons, reasonably close to the Western estimate of 18 metric tons for the D-l.
[8]
Soviet Interplanetary Propulsion Systems - Don P. Mitchell
The Proton Rocket. Heavier planetary missions use the 4-stage version of the Proton. Completed in 1965, it stands 193 feet tall and develops 2.1 million pounds ...
[9]
Mars Exploration: Science Goals
Nov 18, 2024 · The current Martian atmosphere consists mostly of carbon dioxide. Any discovery of carbonate minerals formed on the Martian surface by chemical ...
[10]
http://mentallandscape.com/V_LaunchVehicles.htm
[11]
Phobos (Fobos) spacecraft - RussianSpaceWeb.com
Apr 28, 2021 · The Phobos mission also prepared scientific foundation for future Russian missions to the Red Planet - Mars-96 and, ultimately the return to ...
[12]
[PDF] AAS 19-033
The liquid engines use a hypergolic bipropellant: a Monomethylhydrazine (MMH) as fuel, and 25% nitric oxide (MON25) as oxidizer.
[13]
[PDF] MISSION TO MARS - NASA Technical Reports Server (NTRS)
The function of the propulsion subsystem is to provide directed impulse, upon command, to accomplish in-transit trajectory corrections, an orbital insertion ...
[14]
[PDF] THE EVOLUTION OF TECHNOLOGY IN THE DEEP SPACE ...
Performance of these antennas at the higher frequencies and the ability to successfully point them were uncertain, however, and these uncertainties would best ...
[15]
[PDF] Mars Entry, Descent, and Landing (EDL) | NASA
Heritage Mars descent approaches include parachutes and retropropulsion systems, thrusters that fire against the direction of travel. • Heritage parachute ...
[16]
[PDF] The Challenge of Mars EDL (Entry, Descent, and Landing)
Mars EDL challenges include a thin atmosphere causing heating, lack of understanding of it, and the need for new tech like large heat shields and precision ...Missing: aerobraking | Show results with:aerobraking
[17]
Ion Propulsion System Wins Discover Magazine Award
Jun 22, 1999 · The NASA Solar Electric Propulsion Technology Application Readiness program began in the early 1990s as a partnership between JPL and NASA's ...
[18]
[PDF] Xenon Ion Propulsion for Orbit Transfer
For more than 30 years, NASA has conducted an ion propulsion program which has resulted in several experimental space flight demonstrations.
[19]
[PDF] Success, Failure, and NASA Culture
innovations such as redundancy and environmental testing, generally reduced system failure rates from around 50 percent to around 5 to 10 percent for ...
[20]
[PDF] Reliability and Failure in NASA Missions
Jul 16, 2015 · Nine out of the first ten missions succeeded, including the Mars Pathfinder. But in 1999, four out of five missions failed, including two ...
[21]
[PDF] On Mars: Exploration of the Red Planet, 1958-1978 - NASA
The Viking 2 orbiter photographed the dawn side of Mars as it approached the planet in early August 1976. The photo has been computer enhanced. At the top,.
[22]
Every mission to Mars ever | The Planetary Society
This infographic shows the location of every successful mission that has landed on Mars. It is free for media and non-commercial use with attribution.
[23]
[PDF] Beyond Earth: A Chronicle of Deep Space Exploration, 1958-2016
... launch period. Because of the repeated failures of the Blok L upper stage during deep space missions, engineers elected to outfit the stage for the Mars.
[24]
[PDF] ISCAP appeal 2011-003-doc1 - National Archives
On 27 March 1969 the Soviets attempted to launch a Mars probe which was probably intended to land. This was the first time the SL-12 was used for a ...
[25]
Mars 2, 3 (Mars M71 #1, #2, #3) - Gunter's Space Page
Jun 2, 2025 · The Mars M71 series was a Soviet series of Mars orbiters with landers. The Mars 2 lander became the first man-made object to reach the surface of Mars.
[26]
ESA - Robotic Exploration of Mars - Missions to Mars
Mars has been the target of orbiters, landers and rovers. More than 40 missions have attempted to reach the Red Planet, with varying degrees of success.
[27]
The Mars 4 & 5 probes - HEASARC
Mars 4 was launched by the USSR on 21 July 1973 and its twin, Mars 5, was launched 4 days later on 25 July. As Mars 4 approached the red planet on 10 February ...Missing: details | Show results with:details
[28]
The Phobos 2 Mission to Mars - HEASARC
Aug 25, 2025 · The primary objective of the mission, as with its sister probe Phobos 1, was to explore the larger of Mars' two moons, Phobos.
[29]
HiRISE observations and comparisons to Mars Pathfinder results
It returned a total of 38 images before it was lost. The best resolution of Phobos by Phobos 2 was 291 m/px and covered approximately 60% of Phobos. The ...
[30]
Beautiful Phobos photos | The Planetary Society
Apr 9, 2008 · The upper panel shows a map of Phobos' grooves based upon Mars Express HRSC, Mars Global Surveyor MOC, and Viking images of the moon. The lower ...
[31]
Mars-96 - RussianSpaceWeb.com
Dec 3, 2020 · Known as Mars-96, this complex spacecraft failed to escape the Earth orbit on its way to the Red Planet due to the rocket failure.
[32]
Phobos-Grunt mission - RussianSpaceWeb.com
Phobos-Grunt was scheduled to embark at the end of 2011, on a three-year mission aimed to land on the surface of the Martian moon Phobos and return samples of ...
[33]
Phobos-Grunt | Russian mission, Mars probe, interplanetary flight
Oct 17, 2025 · After about 200 grams (7 ounces) of soil had been collected, the sample-return module would have spent four months on Phobos and then lifted ...
[34]
Phobos-Grunt Failure Report Released - The Planetary Society
Feb 6, 2012 · It appears that Phobos-Grunt was doomed before it launched on November 9, 2011. Cheap parts, design shortcomings, and lack of pre-flight testing ensured that ...Missing: sample | Show results with:sample
[35]
https://www.britannica.com/topic/Phobos-Grunt
[36]
Russian Mars Expeditions
In 1959 a group of enthusiasts in OKB-1 Section 3 under the management of G U Maksimov started engineering design of this first fantastic project for manned ...
[37]
Russia's plans for manned Mars missions - RussianSpaceWeb.com
Apr 23, 2025 · OKB 1 Mars mission studies in the 1960s Korolev's giant N-1 rocket, slated for the ill-fated Soviet project to land a man on the moon, was ...
[38]
TMK
This first serious examination in the Soviet Union of manned flight to Mars was initiated by M Tikhonravov's section of Korolev's OKB-1.
[39]
The Forgotten Soviet Plan to Beat the US to Mars
Jul 21, 2025 · In 1956, the project began taking shape with Korolev advocating for the development of the N1 rocket, a heavy-lift launch vehicle designed to ...
[40]
http://www.astronautix.com/t/tmk.html
[41]
TMK-1
The first flight to Mars of the TMK-1 was planned to begin on June 8, 1971, with the crew returning to the earth on July 10, 1974, after a voyage of three years ...
[42]
1987 Nuclear Mars Mission, using Energia - Soviet Space Substack
Sep 15, 2023 · A 1987 proposal from Glushko for an Energia based mission to Mars. I have no idea where they came from, but I set about restoring, translating, and enlarging ...
[43]
Mars 1989
In 1989 yet another Mars project was proposed by NPO Energia. In the place of the nuclear reactor of previous designs power would be generated by huge farms of ...
[44]
ESA - Mars500: study overview - European Space Agency
The purpose of the Mars500 study is to gather data, knowledge and experience to help prepare for a real mission to Mars.Missing: 2007-2011 details
[45]
IBMP - «Mars-500» project
4th of November 2011 is the finish of the experiment on simulation of a manned flight to Mars (“Mars-500” project). After the exit out of the experimental ...
[46]
During the Long Way to Mars: Effects of 520 Days of Confinement ...
Apr 2, 2014 · Mars500 is a high-fidelity ground simulation experiment that involved 520 days of confined isolation for six multinational crewmembers.
[47]
[PDF] Humans to Mars: fifty years of mission planning, 1950–2000
Feb 28, 1983 · This book, 'Humans to Mars: fifty years of mission planning, 1950–2000', by David SF Portree, covers space flight to Mars planning.
[48]
https://www.esa.int/Science_Exploration/Human_and_Robotic_Exploration/Mars500/Mars500_study_overview
[49]
Mars In Situ Resource Utilization (ISRU) with Focus on Atmospheric ...
In the period from 1996 to 2000, NASA JSC funded two important ISRU technology tasks, through the leadership of Jerry Sanders. These included: Demonstration of ...
[50]
Crewed flight to Mars may take place in late 2030s, says Roscosmos ...
An expedition to the Moon will serve as a preparation for the mission to the Mars, according to the space corporation senior official.
[51]
Chemical composition of the atmosphere of Mars - ScienceDirect.com
A historical review and brief outline of the current status of studies of chemical composition of the martian atmosphere are presented.
[52]
The atmosphere of Mars - NASA ADS
... 1973~ and Mars-5 (Moroz and Nadzhip, 1975b). The ground-based observations ... atmosphere of Mars (see Section 5). A definite minimum wind velocity is ...
[53]
Results of TV imaging of Phobos - Experiment VSK-Fregat
These images complement Mariner-9 and Viking data by providing higher-resolution coverage of a laarge region west of the crater Stickney (40-160 deg W) and by ...
[54]
[PDF] 3. Martian Atmosphere and Its Effects on Propagation - DESCANSO
atmospheric pressure averages 6.1 mb (610 Pa); dust storms often increase the atmospheric ... of the descent vehicle of the space probe Mars 6 into the ...
[55]
[PDF] N89-18293
In summary, we propose a mineralogical model for the Mars fine soil that includes as major components smectite clays adsorbed and coated with amorphous iron.
[56]
Composition and Basic Physical Properties of the Phobos Surface
Most craters are of impact origin, although some small craters may be features formed by the penetration of regolith into subsurface fractures [12,46]. Most of ...
[57]
[PDF] PHOBOS ENVIRONMENT MODEL AND REGOLITH SIMULANT ...
Accounting for these considerations, we assume that the regolith structure of Phobos has at least three layers; (1) a thin uppermost layer (<3cm in depth) of ...
[58]
Channels on Mars | GSA Bulletin - GeoScienceWorld
Jun 1, 2017 · By showing that parts of equatorial and mid-latitudinal Mars have a variety of channels and channel-like forms, Mariner 9 photographs ...
[59]
The Kasei Valles, Mars: a unified record of episodic channel flows ...
Oct 29, 2020 · ... channel on Mars. Furthermore, we use these high resolution ... Geological Record of Water and Wind Processes on Mars as Observed by ...
[60]
[PDF] The Reference Mission of the NASA Mars Exploration Study Team
They found intriguing evidence that water played an important role on Mars with channels that bear a striking resemblance to stream beds and clouds of.
[61]
[PDF] Mariner 9 Ultraviolet Spectrometer Experiment:
The polar cap is primarily composed of frozen carbon dioxide and may also contain water ice. The behavior of ozone in the polar region between 50°S and 75°S ...
[62]
Mariner 9 observations of the south polar cap of Mars: Evidence for ...
Feb 10, 1990 · The results provide strong evidence that carbon dioxide frost was present throughout the summer season despite the fact that the residual ...Missing: core | Show results with:core
[63]
The Martian surface radiation environment – a comparison of ...
Mar 4, 2016 · MSL-RAD is the first instrument to provide detailed information about charged and neutral particle spectra and dose rates on the Martian surface.
[64]
The Composition of Phobos: Evidence for Carbonaceous Chondrite ...
The spectral albedo of Phobos bears a striking resemblance to that of asteroids (1) Ceres and (2) Pallas. Comparison of the reflectance spectra of asteroids ...Missing: geology | Show results with:geology
[65]
PHOBOS AS A D-TYPE CAPTURED ASTEROID, SPECTRAL ...
We modeled the OSIRIS data using two models, the first one with a composition that includes organic carbonaceous material, serpentine, olivine, and basalt glass ...
[66]
Red Planet Triumphs and Defeats: A History of Mars Missions - Space
Mar 9, 2016 · Beginning in 1973, the Soviet Union experienced a period of limited successes with its Mars program. The Mars 4 probe reached Mars but ...
[67]
Mars Missions: The Breakdown from 1960-2021 - The Space Report
Success and Failure Rate by Country. The former Soviet Union was the first nation to attempt reaching Mars in 1960, but its first nine attempts failed. In 1971, ...
[68]
Failed Mars missions: A brief History - Astronomy Magazine
Nov 20, 2018 · Half of all Mars missions have failed, usually well before they approached the Red Planet, either because of launch failure or some error on its outward trip.
[69]
[PDF] SOVIET OPTIONS FOR A MANNED MARS LANDING MISSION (SW ...
Dec 1, 1989 · Aerobraking at Mars, however, reduces launch vehicle requirements to a low of 13 and a high of 17 for any propulsion option chosen at any launch ...