Fact-checked by Grok 2 weeks ago

Notgeld

Notgeld, German for "emergency money," denotes privately or locally issued that circulated as in , , and adjacent regions during acute shortages of official coinage, spanning through the Weimar Republic's from 1914 to the mid-1920s. Triggered by wartime of precious metals for industrial use and reparations-driven fiscal strains, these notes filled gaps left by the Reichsbank's inability to supply small-denomination coins, enabling everyday transactions in rural and urban locales alike. Issued by municipalities, trade associations, and merchants without central authorization, Notgeld proliferated to billions of pieces, often redeemable in official marks or goods, though many devolved into worthless paper amid 1923's peak inflation when prices doubled hourly. Distinct for their artisanal —showcasing regional , historical vignettes, and allegorical motifs—such notes embodied economic adaptation but also highlighted the fragility of systems unanchored by sound money principles. Their cessation followed the 1923 stabilization, yet enduring varieties, including leather and wood-backed experiments, underscore Notgeld's role as a of monetary collapse and local resilience.

Definition and Characteristics

Etymology and Core Purpose

The term Notgeld combines the German words Not, denoting necessity or emergency (derived from Old High German nōt), and Geld, meaning money (from Old High German gelt, referring to income or value). This etymology reflects its role as a makeshift financial instrument rather than standard currency. Notgeld's primary function was to bridge gaps in circulating money during crises, such as coin shortages triggered by public hoarding of metal specie amid wartime depreciation of paper notes. Local issuers—including towns, trade associations, and businesses—produced it without central bank authorization to sustain small-scale trade, averting local economic stagnation when national supplies faltered. Typically redeemable in official currency or goods upon crisis resolution, it operated as scrip accepted within defined communities, not as universal legal tender. First issued in on August 4, 1914, following the outbreak of and a decree limiting note exchanges to curb , Notgeld proliferated to replace withdrawn small coins, whose silver and values exceeded face amounts. By enabling barter-like exchanges in essentials, it preserved market functionality until metallic coin production ramped up post-1918, though renewed issuance occurred during the 1921–1923 when lost viability.

Physical Forms and Design Elements

Notgeld was predominantly issued as banknotes, typically printed on low-grade due to wartime shortages, with denominations ranging from 10 pfennigs to several marks in the early periods, escalating to billions during . These notes were often small in size for practicality in daily transactions and featured simple lithographic printing to enable rapid local production by municipalities, banks, or private firms. Alternative physical forms emerged from resource constraints, including metal tokens— or aluminum pfennig pieces struck from 1916 onward by cities and internee camps—and non-metallic variants such as discs, wooden chips, and cloth-based issues in , , or , particularly in POW facilities or during acute metal hoarding. Notgeld, for instance, utilized unglazed bisque in denominations like 10 or 50 s, produced as a substitute when metals were diverted to armaments. Overstamped postage stamps or vouchers served as makeshift small change in some locales, redeemable for goods or official . Design elements emphasized local identity to foster acceptance and discourage , incorporating motifs such as regional landmarks, historical figures, scenes, or town coats of arms, often in vibrant colors to enhance appeal and visual distinction from notes. Elaborate illustrations, including allegorical depictions of or anti-war sentiments, appeared on later issues, alongside basic measures like handwritten signatures, communal seals, or guilloche patterns to deter basic counterfeiting amid limited production capabilities. These artistic flourishes transformed utilitarian emergency into collectible artifacts reflecting municipal pride.

Economic Underpinnings

Triggers: Currency Shortages and

The primary triggers for Notgeld issuance were severe shortages of small-denomination and widespread public at the start of . In late July and early August 1914, as war began, panic withdrawals from banks depleted circulating currency, particularly 5, 10, 50 , and 1 , which were essential for daily transactions. Hoarding intensified because these coins contained valuable metals—copper, , and silver—sought for armaments , leading citizens to them for their intrinsic worth amid rising and economic disruption. On August 4, 1914, the German government prohibited payouts from reserves to stabilize the , which further restricted access to metallic and amplified the small-change crisis. Minting responses proved inadequate: production of copper 1 and 2 pfennig coins ceased in 1915–1916, silver 1 mark coins ended in 1916, and surviving denominations shifted to low-value alloys like iron and zinc, failing to meet demand. Merchants and banks could not provide change for larger notes, halting commerce and necessitating local emergency scrip; initial issuances occurred in East Prussia as early as 1914, with 450 authorized offices distributing Notgeld by 1915 to restore transaction fluidity. Ongoing , fueled by fears of military defeat and persistent material scarcities, prolonged these shortages into 1916–1921, authorizing 580 additional issuers including banks, municipalities, and firms.

Hyperinflation Dynamics and State Fiscal Failures

typically emerges from governments financing chronic fiscal deficits through unchecked , bypassing taxation or borrowing constraints. When expands far beyond real economic output, erodes rapidly, often exceeding 50% monthly rates, as prices adjust to the surplus liquidity. This dynamic intensifies via feedback loops: anticipated further accelerates money velocity, with holders spending cash quickly to avoid losses, exacerbating price surges. In the , state fiscal failures post-World War I—stemming from war debts, territorial losses reducing tax bases, and reparations under the —drove reliance on note issuance to cover shortfalls. Political instability hindered tax enforcement and austerity, while passive resistance in the region after the French-Belgian halted industrial revenues, prompting more printing; by July 1923, monthly inflation hit 300%, with the U.S. dollar exchange rate soaring from about 17,000 marks in January to over 350,000 by July. Real tax collections plummeted due to collection lags on fixed nominal rates amid rising prices (the Olivera-Tanzi effect), widening deficits and fueling the spiral. These failures disrupted official currency circulation, as hoarding and foreign currency preferences created shortages of small denominations for local trade, while rendered high-value notes impractical for daily use. Municipalities and businesses responded by issuing Notgeld, with up to 4,000 entities producing it in to maintain transactional ; initially redeemable in or official , much Notgeld escalated to million-mark denominations as eroded its value, mirroring the broader monetary collapse.

Notgeld in Germany

World War I Era (1914-1918)

The onset of triggered a severe shortage of small-denomination coins in due to mass by the population, who sought to preserve the intrinsic metal value amid fears of . On July 31, 1914—the day mobilized for war—the Bürgerliches Brauhaus brewery in issued the earliest recorded Notgeld, consisting of paper notes in 1-mark, 2-mark, and 2.5-mark denominations to facilitate local payments. This private initiative reflected the immediate breakdown in circulating specie, as and silver coins vanished from everyday use. On August 4, , the Imperial government formalized the suspension of gold convertibility through legislation, while the began issuing non-redeemable Reich treasury notes, further eroding confidence in official currency. Municipalities, businesses, and organizations received authorization to produce emergency , primarily for low values like pfennigs, to sustain . By late , 452 localities had issued approximately 5,500 varieties of such notes, often featuring local scenery, historical figures, or wartime to build community trust and . These were typically paper-based, stamped or printed hastily, and backed by the issuer's promise of redemption in official money once supplies normalized. Throughout the war, coin shortages worsened as and —key materials for coins—were requisitioned for munitions, leading to halted minting of 1- and 2- pieces by 1915–1916 and silver 1-mark coins by 1916; silver persisted due to . Local authorities responded by expanding Notgeld production, including metal tokens from or iron for durability in small transactions. Examples persisted into 1918, such as the 50- note from Burghausen, illustrating ongoing reliance on decentralized issuance amid constraints. This system underscored the war economy's vulnerabilities, with Notgeld serving as a pragmatic stopgap rather than a long-term solution, often redeemed post-issuance but increasingly retained as mementos for their designs.

Hyperinflation Period (1921-1923)

As the German Papiermark's value plummeted amid escalating —driven primarily by the government's reparations payments under the and unchecked deficit monetization—local authorities revived Notgeld issuance to address acute shortages. By early 1922, had surged following the French-Belgian on January 11, 1923, exacerbating production halts and fiscal strain, prompting municipalities, businesses, and even private entities to print emergency notes for local circulation when supplies lagged. Up to 4,000 issuers operated during this peak, far exceeding levels, as the central bank's printing presses could not match the demand amid monthly rates exceeding 300% by mid-1923. ![10 Million Mark Notgeld note from the hyperinflation era][float-right] Denominations escalated dramatically to reflect the Papiermark's devaluation, starting from modest and values in 1921 but reaching billions and trillions by late ; for instance, the town of issued a 100 billion note in , while others printed in billion-mark increments to facilitate everyday transactions like groceries that required wheelbarrows of official currency. These notes, often valid only within issuing locales and sometimes redeemable for goods or capped in usage to curb , featured intricate designs depicting regional landmarks, historical figures, or allegorical scenes of economic distress, blending functionality with for community resilience. Unlike earlier wartime Notgeld, variants prioritized rapid production over durability, using cheap paper that deteriorated quickly in circulation. Economically, provided essential for small-scale in a collapsing , mitigating immediate transaction frictions where official notes were scarce or devalued too swiftly for pricing stability, yet it marginally amplified the money supply without addressing root fiscal failures. Circulation volumes, while significant locally, remained dwarfed by the Reichsbank's trillions in printed , suggesting Notgeld's role was responsive rather than causal to the hyperinflation's core dynamics of excessive state borrowing and printing. Issuance ceased abruptly after , , when the was introduced at a 1 trillion Papiermark to 1 Rentenmark conversion, rendering surviving Notgeld valueless and shifting focus to stabilization under the .

Post-World War II Revivals

In the immediate aftermath of II, faced severe economic disarray, including hyperinflationary remnants of the , widespread hoarding of coins, and disruptions from Allied occupation, prompting some municipalities to issue local emergency akin to historical Notgeld. These revivals were limited in scope compared to World War I-era emissions, occurring mainly from 1945 to 1948 in the western occupation zones, where small-denomination notes facilitated everyday transactions amid coin shortages. Such issues addressed practical gaps in circulating ; for example, metal were scarce due to wartime destruction, melting for industrial use, and public distrust in the devalued , leading towns to print provisional paper alternatives redeemable in goods or official money. Stuttgart, under Allied oversight, emitted Reichsmark-denominated Notgeld in values from 1 to 10 marks during 1945–1946 to support local commerce until stabilization measures took hold. Similar provisional notes appeared in other locales, such as Münden, where 10-pfennig issues circulated post-1945 to bridge shortfalls. These revivals ceased abruptly with the western currency reform of June 20, 1948, which introduced the and invalidated remaining Reichsmarks, effectively ending the need for local expedients as economic confidence returned under the new pegged system. In the Soviet zone, analogous but distinct emerged under centralized control, though not typically classified as traditional Notgeld due to over issuance. Overall, post-war Notgeld volumes were modest, reflecting shorter durations of crisis and faster Allied interventions, unlike the prolonged of the .

Notgeld in Austria

Early Instances: 1848 Revolution

During the –1849, the faced acute financial strain from widespread uprisings in , , , and , compounded by military expenditures in conflicts such as the against Sardinia-Piedmont. These pressures depleted state coin reserves, creating shortages of small-denomination silver and copper coins essential for everyday transactions. Municipal authorities, unable to rely on imperial mints disrupted by political instability, began issuing provisional coinage to sustain local economies. Such emergency coins, retrospectively termed Notgeld, were primarily struck in base metals like or billon, often in denominations of or heller, and circulated within specific towns or regions. For instance, the city of in issued 6- pieces to address the coin famine, guaranteeing redemption in official currency once supplies normalized. Similar issuances occurred in (Czech) municipalities, where revolutionary fervor and administrative breakdowns intensified the scarcity; local councils and guilds stamped tokens on available metal blanks, sometimes incorporating civic seals or provisional designs to build trust among users. These measures facilitated barter-like exchanges in markets and for wages, preventing total economic paralysis amid the empire's fiscal crisis. While the central government responded with paper "Cassa-Anweisungen" notes authorized by the Reichstag to fund war efforts, public skepticism—rooted in prior experiences with depreciating assignats during the —limited their acceptance, hoarding of specie persisted, and local Notgeld filled the void for low-value payments. Issuances ceased as imperial forces suppressed the revolutions by mid-1849, restoring centralized minting under Franz Joseph I, though some provisional coins lingered in circulation until official recalls. This episode marked an early, decentralized response to disruptions in Habsburg territories, predating the more widespread Notgeld phenomena of the .

World War I and Interwar Period

During , Notgeld issuance commenced in in 1914, driven by severe shortages of minor coins as precious metals were requisitioned for military production and hoarding intensified due to wartime inflation eroding the krone's value relative to coin intrinsic worth. The Austro-Hungarian Bank authorized municipalities, towns, and villages to produce small-denomination paper notes, typically in values of 10, 20, or 50 heller, to facilitate everyday local transactions amid the disruption of official minting. These early issues featured simple designs often incorporating local landmarks or imperial motifs, serving as temporary substitutes until metallic currency could be restored. The collapse of the in 1918 exacerbated economic instability in the newly formed Republic of , where from 1919 onward—fueled by massive money printing to cover war debts and reparations—prompted continued Notgeld production into the early 1920s. 's money supply surged 14,250% between 1919 and December 1923, propelling the from 1,640 in to 1,183,600 by , while the U.S. dollar deteriorated from 16.1 crowns in January 1919 to 70,800 crowns in May 1923. Local authorities and even private entities, such as merchants in St. Pölten, issued colorful notes depicting regional scenes or to address persistent small-change deficits and sustain amid national currency . By 1920–1921, Notgeld evolved into serienscheine—elaborate series sets produced for both circulation and emerging collector interest—featuring styles and denominations like 50 heller from regions such as Blindenmarkt or . Issuance tapered off around 1923 following stabilization efforts, including a League of Nations-supervised loan in 1922 that imposed fiscal austerity and currency reform, reducing reliance on local emergency . These notes, while not immune to inflationary pressures, provided causal continuity in local economies by bridging gaps in official supply chains disrupted by geopolitical fragmentation and fiscal mismanagement.

Great Depression and Schwundgeld Experiments

In the early 1930s, amid the Great Depression's severe economic contraction, Austrian municipalities facing acute unemployment and currency hoarding experimented with Schwundgeld, a form of demurrage currency designed to accelerate circulation by imposing a periodic fee on holding notes. These local scrip issues, often classified under Notgeld traditions, drew from economist Silvio Gesell's Freigeld theory, which posited that depreciating money would discourage hoarding and stimulate spending without relying on central bank liquidity. In Tyrol's Wörgl, a town of approximately 4,500 residents with unemployment exceeding 30% by 1931, Mayor Michael Unterguggenberger initiated the most documented such program on July 5, 1932, issuing "Certified Compensation Bills" backed by a 100% reserve of Austrian schillings deposited at the local branch of the Oesterreichische Nationalbank. The Wörgl scrip functioned as stamped money: each note, denominated from 1 to 10 schillings, required affixing a stamp equivalent to 1% of its face value monthly at designated outlets, rendering unstamped bills invalid after 60 days. This mechanism, costing holders about 12% annually, incentivized rapid velocity; the initial 32,000 schillings in scrip reportedly circulated over 400 times in 13 months, generating an effective economic multiplier far exceeding official currency. Funds financed public works, including road repairs, a ski jump, and aqueducts, employing hundreds and reducing local unemployment to near zero by mid-1933, while tax arrears dropped 80% as the scrip accepted for payments. No significant inflation occurred, as the scrip's depreciative design limited hoarding and the full backing prevented over-issue. The experiment's success prompted emulation; by June 1933, over 200 Austrian communities sought to issue similar regionally valid Schwundgeld, viewing it as a pragmatic response to federal under . However, the intervened, deeming the parallel currency a threat to monetary and the schilling's stability, revoking Wörgl's authorization on , 1933, after legal challenges upheld the ban. Critics, including central authorities, argued it undermined state control, though proponents like Unterguggenberger attributed termination to competitive pressure on deflationary policies rather than inherent flaws. Subsequent Alpine regional trials were curtailed, limiting Schwundgeld's Depression-era footprint to sporadic, short-lived issues, though the Wörgl case demonstrated local currencies' potential to mitigate traps via incentives.

International Instances

Pre-Modern Examples: Ireland and Sweden

In Ireland, during the Williamite-Jacobite War of 1689–1691, deposed King James II authorized the production of emergency coinage known as gun money to finance his campaign against William III's forces. These brass coins, struck primarily in Dublin from melted-down artillery and other scrap metal, included denominations such as crowns, half-crowns, shillings, and sixpences, with over 40 varieties dated by month from August 1689 to March 1690. Intended as token money redeemable in silver upon victory, the irregular hammered coins bore inscriptions promising exchange at face value in good money, but following James II's defeats at the Battle of the Boyne in July 1690 and the Battle of Aughrim in July 1691, they lost official acceptance. Under the Treaty of Limerick in October 1691, holders received partial redemption, typically at 10–14% of nominal value in silver or clipped coins, rendering gun money a classic case of wartime necessity currency that depreciated sharply post-conflict. In , emergency coins (nödmynt) were issued amid the fiscal strains of the (1700–1721) under King Charles XII to sustain military expenditures after conventional revenues proved insufficient. From 1716 to 1719, over 40 million round copper coins, each nominally valued at 1 daler silvermynt, were minted as credit instruments rather than intrinsic-value pieces, facilitated by advisor Heinrich von Görtz to circumvent minting constraints on base metals. These nodmynt circulated parallel to standard copper dalers but faced skepticism due to their fiat nature, contributing to inflationary pressures; following Charles XII's death in November 1718 and Görtz's execution in March 1719, subsequent monetary reforms under the devalued them significantly, exchanging them at reduced rates by 1720 to stabilize the economy. This episode exemplifies pre-modern state recourse to depreciative emergency issuance during prolonged warfare, echoing patterns of fiscal desperation observed elsewhere in .

World War I Contexts: Belgium, France, and Occupied Territories

During the German invasion and occupation of beginning in , the rapid withdrawal of official Belgian banknotes by the retreating government, combined with widespread hoarding amid economic disruption, created acute shortages of small-denomination currency for everyday transactions. In response, over 800 municipalities issued their own emergency money, termed Notgeld or monnaie de nécessité, consisting primarily of low-value paper notes and zinc or other base-metal tokens redeemable in official francs post-war. These local notes, often printed by communes, private banks like the , or even individual firms, circulated alongside German-issued occupation marks and helped sustain local commerce despite the occupier's control over larger monetary flows. Specific examples include 1-franc notes from the dated 1917 and emergency coinage such as Ghent's 2-franc pieces struck in 1918 but redeemed as late as 1920. In the occupied territories of northern , particularly departments like and from 1914 onward, similar currency scarcities prompted local issuances of necessity money (monnaie d'obligation or emergency tokens) to replace hoarded coins and notes, intensified by the state's requisitioning policies. Municipalities, chambers of , and cooperatives produced these substitutes, often in denominations of 5 to 50 centimes, to facilitate trade in war-torn industrial areas under German administration. Notable cases include scrip notes for and in the region, valid for 1 and backed by local merchants, as well as communal bonds issued jointly by Rimogne and approximately 25 nearby communes to cover essential payments. These instruments, while unofficial, were generally accepted locally due to the absence of alternatives and were redeemed after liberation in , though their proliferation highlighted the occupiers' inability to fully stabilize monetary circulation. Across both regions, such emergency issuances totaled hundreds of varieties, reflecting decentralized adaptations to wartime exigencies but also exposing vulnerabilities like potential counterfeiting and uneven redemption post-armistice. German authorities tolerated these local currencies for pragmatic reasons, as they reduced administrative burdens, yet the practice underscored the limits of occupation finance reliant on forced requisitions and parallel circulation.

Spanish Civil War and Other 20th-Century Cases

During the (1936–1939), severe economic disruptions, including coin hoarding, metal shortages for military production, and fragmented control over territory, led to extensive issuance of emergency known as moneda de necesidad by municipalities, regional governments, and both and Nationalist authorities. These notes facilitated local trade and small transactions where official peseta coins were scarce, often denominated in centimos or pesetas and backed by promises of redemption in national currency once stability returned. Both factions produced such issues, though zones saw more decentralized local experimentation due to anarchic control in areas like and . In Republican-held territories, the central government addressed fractional currency shortages in 1938 by issuing "stamp money"—small, circular cardboard tokens valued at 5, 10, 20, 25, or 50 centimos, featuring the Spanish coat of arms on one side and an affixed postage stamp for validation on the other. Produced amid copper and nickel diversions to the war effort, these were distributed via banks and circulated briefly before the Nationalist victory rendered them obsolete. Regional bodies amplified this: the Generalitat of Catalonia authorized 773 of its 1,075 municipalities to emit low-denomination bills, enabling localized economies to function independently; examples include Totana (Murcia) notes of 25 centimos, 50 centimos, 1 peseta, and 2 pesetas issued around 1937–1938, and Riudoms scrip dated June 15, 1937. Nationalist areas issued similar emergency notes in 1938, such as those from Lobon (Badajoz) redeemable for goods like 25 loaves of bread, reflecting acute supply constraints near war's end. Beyond Spain, analogous emergency scrip emerged in other 20th-century crises, particularly under occupation or wartime duress. In prisoner-of-war camps across Europe, including those in and German-controlled territories, lagergeld—camp-specific tokens—served as notgeld equivalents, paying wages to Allied captives and circulating internally to prevent black markets; a 1915 Hungarian example denominated 10 filler exemplifies this controlled issuance. During , Nazi-occupied regions like Poland's (1940–1944) saw forced scrip systems, where residents exchanged valuables for ghetto marks to buy rations, mimicking emergency money but under coercive central planning rather than local initiative. These cases highlight 's role in isolated economies amid broader monetary collapse, though often tied to authoritarian oversight rather than voluntary municipal response.

Collecting and Numismatic Aspects

Emergence of Collector Series

Following the stabilization of the German economy with the introduction of the Rentenmark in late 1923, vast quantities of Notgeld lost their function as legal tender, redirecting interest toward their aesthetic and historical value among numismatists. The intricate designs, often incorporating local folklore, architecture, and vignettes, had already garnered attention during their issuance periods from 1914 to 1923, but the post-hyperinflation era amplified collecting as a pursuit. Entrepreneurs recognized this potential shortly after , initiating the production of Serienscheine—series notes—around 1919-1920, distinct from issuances as they were crafted primarily for collectors rather than economic utility. These notes were manufactured in cohesive sets, typically featuring thematic unity such as depictions of animals, beverages, or regional motifs, with matching serial numbers to encourage complete acquisitions. Issued by firms and some municipalities, often without official authorization for circulation, Serienscheine capitalized on the novelty of Notgeld's visual appeal, with limited redemption windows to preserve scarcity. For example, a 1-mark note from Holnis in 1920 represents an early collectible variant in this burgeoning category. By 1920-1921, such series proliferated across , with varieties numbering in the hundreds, transforming Notgeld into a structured numismatic specialty. Private issuers like Gustav Habeck in produced themed sets around 1921, printed on repurposed materials such as backs, further diversifying the market. This deliberate orientation toward collectors laid the foundation for dedicated catalogs and sustained interest, distinguishing Serienscheine from prior functional Notgeld and establishing a precedent for thematic ephemera. The numismatic market for Notgeld remains niche but active, primarily attracting collectors focused on Weimar-era and emergency currency, with transactions occurring via online platforms, specialized dealers, and auction houses. Common paper issues from prolific issuers, such as municipal notes in standard denominations and conditions, typically sell for €1 to €20 on retail sites like , reflecting their abundance from print runs often exceeding thousands of units per locality. Rarer variants, including those on alternative substrates like porcelain, silk, or foil, or limited-edition series with unique designs, fetch significantly higher values at auctions, where prices frequently surpass catalogue estimates due to competitive bidding from institutional and private buyers. Examples include a 1921 Stuttgart white porcelain gilt-rim 5 Mark note graded MS62 by PCGS, which realized $75 in September 2022, and other graded silk-cloth issues noted for their scarcity. Auction platforms such as NumisBids and CoinArchives report realized prices for select lots ranging from €24 to €200 or more in 2024 sales, with scarcer pieces outperforming expectations. Market trends indicate gradual price appreciation since the early , driven by sustained European demand—particularly in —and burgeoning international interest in hyperinflation artifacts amid modern economic analogies, though overall volumes stay modest compared to mainstream categories. Specialized valuation services, such as those offered by notgeld.com, highlight strong performance for high-quality or thematically significant items, with premiums for uncirculated condition and . The global banknote collecting sector, encompassing Notgeld, expanded from $1.2 billion in 2024 toward projected $2.4 billion by 2033, underscoring broader growth that bolsters secondary markets for historical emergencies.

Analytical Perspectives

Stabilizing Effects and Local Innovations

Notgeld issuance addressed acute cash shortages in local economies during and the early , when metal coins were withdrawn for the and official paper s became insufficient for small transactions. By providing denominations suitable for everyday commerce, such as fractions of a , it facilitated continued trade in municipalities where was critical for sustaining markets and preventing economic paralysis. During the 1923 hyperinflation, Notgeld assumed greater significance as the struggled to distribute devaluing Papiermarks, with local issues comprising up to 50% of circulating paper by November 1923. Unlike the nationally printed subject to unchecked monetary expansion, many Notgeld variants maintained relative stability through municipal backing, limited issuance, and local acceptance, enabling transactions in crisis regions like the occupied and . For instance, businesses such as the Phoenix Mining Corporation in issued 500 million mark notes in , accepted locally to support operations amid national collapse. Some Notgeld incorporated or foreign backing to enhance trust, as seen in Oldenburg's rye-supported notes and Hamburg's dollar-backed marks, which insulated local exchanges from hyperinflationary pressures more effectively than unbacked official . This localized approach not only preserved for essentials but also funded , such as Cologne's Messepalast and Green Ring park projects, by leveraging issuance for investment rather than mere emergency relief. Local innovations in Notgeld design and mechanics further bolstered its utility and appeal. Municipalities produced colorful, illustrated series featuring regional landmarks, , and motifs—such as Hamelin's Pied Piper depictions or Thale's witches—to foster community identity and encourage retention as collectibles, indirectly stabilizing economies through promotion and unreturned note profits. Innovative materials like in Bielefeld's notes and leather variants resisted wear, while mechanisms such as expiry dates, odd denominations (e.g., 75 ), and series tied to local products (e.g., Kahla's porcelain-themed issues) limited hoarding and circulation velocity, promoting controlled local monetary flows. Towns like generated 900,000 Reichsmarks from collectible series to renovate public buildings, demonstrating how these adaptations converted issuance into tangible economic benefits.

Criticisms: Fraud Risks and Economic Distortions

The decentralized issuance of Notgeld by thousands of municipalities, businesses, and other entities created inherent risks of , as the often featured rudimentary designs and lacked uniform security features comparable to . Contemporary observers, such as G. Prange in Das Notgeld (July 1921), documented cases of counterfeiters reprinting valuable older editions for profit, recommending state-level prosecution to curb the threat. Additionally, issuers tampered with issuance dates—such as backdating to —to exploit collector , while unrelated entrepreneurs in regions like produced falsely attributed to specific towns, prompting raids in areas like Hamburg's Wilhelmshalle in 1922. Some municipalities engaged in exploitative schemes, such as Ödenkirchen's issuance of trillions in lent to banks at exorbitant interest rates, blurring lines between emergency and speculative finance. These fraud risks were compounded by lax oversight, as local authorities frequently issued Notgeld without enforceable reserves or central validation, fostering a legal gray area that enabled "wild" or illegal printings, particularly during the 1923 hyperinflation. The Reichsbank's initial of accepting Notgeld at until November 22, 1923 (extended to December 1 in occupied territories), inadvertently facilitated circulation of potentially fraudulent notes, though it later halted such acceptance to stem abuse. While empirical cases of widespread counterfeiting remained limited—likely due to the short-term, local nature of most issuances—the proliferation of varieties (over 200,000 types by 1922) eroded trust, with non-collectors facing practical nuisances like transaction delays from unfamiliar or dubious notes. Economically, Notgeld's unbacked expansion distorted monetary circulation by effectively doubling the Reichsbank's note supply and comprising an estimated 50% of all paper marks in circulation by , according to historian Gerald Feldman—potentially an underestimate given underreporting by issuers. , president, later quantified unbacked Notgeld at 400–500 quintillion paper marks by late 1923, far exceeding official figures of 180 quintillion, as municipalities printed without reserves to fund operations or speculative projects like Cologne's Messepalast exhibition hall. This overissuance acted as a catalyst for the autumn 1923 , accelerating mark depreciation through increased velocity and lack of redeemability, particularly in occupied and areas where notes were exchanged for stable foreign currencies. Further distortions arose from non-emergency motivations: many small hamlets issued notes despite no small-change shortages, prioritizing profits from pre-circulation sales to collectors (e.g., 20,000 marks gained by some towns) over monetary stabilization. The resulting multiplicity of currencies imposed transaction costs, with businesses and banks refusing or charging commissions on deposits, as reported in Mülheim-Ruhr, while industrialists like profited from printing contracts, widening inequality and institutional distrust. By mid-1923, rendered most Notgeld worthless, reducing it to makeshift tokens like funfair tickets, underscoring how localized innovations amplified national monetary chaos rather than mitigating it.

Lessons for Monetary Theory and Policy

The issuance of Notgeld during Germany's from to 1923 demonstrated the fragility of centralized currencies when undermined by excessive to finance and deficits, as the Reichsbank's accommodation of borrowing led to a increase from 6 billion marks in to over 400 quintillion by 1923. This episode underscored that inflation accelerates when rises alongside supply expansion, eroding public confidence and prompting shifts to or foreign currencies, a dynamic formalized in quantity theory models where = holds but breaks under hyperinflationary expectations. Notgeld's local success in maintaining transactions—circulating up to 130,000 varieties by , often backed by pledges of future tax revenues or commodities—illustrated how decentralized monetary instruments can temporarily restore and stabilize micro-economies in the absence of reliable central , filling a regulatory vacuum during crises. However, this plurality also amplified distortions, as uncontrolled proliferation fueled further inflationary pressures and , with many issues losing value rapidly, highlighting the policy imperative for central authorities to reassert control over to prevent fragmented trust erosion. For monetary theory, Notgeld exemplifies the causal link between fiscal-monetary coordination failures and collapse, where governments' inability to tax or borrow conventionally forces reliance on , inverting the typical as holders minimize real balances. Policy lessons include prioritizing independence to enforce hard budget constraints, as evidenced by the 1923 Rentenmark's success—pegged to land assets and limited in issuance—which halted within months by restoring credibility without default. Modern implications caution against deficit monetization, advocating rules-based frameworks like to avert similar spirals, while recognizing emergency local currencies' role only as bridges to systemic reform rather than substitutes.

References

  1. [1]
    Currency in crisis: German emergency money 1914–1924
    Oct 3, 2019 · Notgeld, or 'emergency money', from the early Weimar Republic, is a powerful illustration of the turbulent years during and after the First World War in ...
  2. [2]
  3. [3]
    WWI - German Emergency Money - American Numismatic Association
    Prior to the outbreak of war, German financial leaders made plans to modify the Imperial monetary system to meet the needs of a wartime economy.
  4. [4]
    The tales emergency currency can tell
    Oct 29, 2020 · In response, cities and towns under German control created their own form of emergency currency, called notgeld, to supplement the limited ...
  5. [5]
    [PDF] Money for Inflation: The German Notgeld, 1914 – 1923
    This thesis is a comprehensive history of the German emergency money issued in the years 1914 to 1923. During the First World War and in the early years of the ...<|separator|>
  6. [6]
    Notgeld: The emergency cash of hyperinflation - The Berliner
    Oct 5, 2023 · To combat the hyperinflation of the 1920s, Berlin started to print its own emergency money. We take a closer look.
  7. [7]
    NOTGELD Definition & Meaning - Merriam-Webster
    German, from not necessity (from Old High German nōt) + geld money (from Old High German gelt income, value). First Known Use.
  8. [8]
    What is notgeld?
    The word not means emergency or necessity and geld means money, so notgeld means emergency money. Notgeld was mass-produced and was a phenomenon that was ...Missing: etymology | Show results with:etymology
  9. [9]
    German Notgeld - American Numismatic Association
    Notgeld was substitute money issued in Germany due to war reparations and hyperinflation, used locally, and not legal tender. It was issued in various forms, ...Missing: etymology | Show results with:etymology
  10. [10]
    Notgeld, emergency money from interwar Europe
    Mar 28, 2014 · Notgeld, German for emergency money, was issued from the start of WWI until 1924. Towns printed their own unofficial currency to supplement ...
  11. [11]
  12. [12]
    Notgeld - Perspectives in Numismatics - Chicago Coin Club
    Metal Notgeld​​ Metal tokens did not appear until 1916, issued by cities and private firms; also they were used in prisoner of war camps and firms employing ...
  13. [13]
    Germany Notgeld – A Collectible Industry Develops
    ### Summary of Notgeld Collecting Development and Emergence of Serienscheine
  14. [14]
    Making money out of natural materials – Porcelain emergency money
    Mar 13, 2024 · Metals such as copper and nickel were needed for the arms industry. Thus arose the idea of making “Notgeld” – emergency money that substituted ...Missing: physical | Show results with:physical
  15. [15]
    Notgeld notes from Germany - The Coins & History Foundation
    Jun 19, 2025 · A collection of vintage German emergency currency notes featuring intricate designs and various denominations.
  16. [16]
    Emergency Money: One Egg for 320 Billion Marks
    The increasing fear of losing the war led to further hoarding of cash, so that the government commissioned a total of 580 banks, savings banks, cities, counties ...
  17. [17]
    Hyperinflation Explained: Causes, Effects & How to Protect Your ...
    Hyperinflation is when a country's inflation rate exceeds 50% per month, causing rapid price increases for goods and services. Excessive money supply not backed ...Missing: deficits | Show results with:deficits
  18. [18]
    The sky's the limit: The economics of inflation and hyperinflation
    Under hyperinflation, governments can stabilize seigniorage revenue by printing money at a steady rate. 3. The Olivera–Tanzi effect worsens the fiscal deficit ...
  19. [19]
    Weimar Problems, 1919-23 - JohnDClare.net
    The cause of the trouble was Reparations – the government paid them by printing more money, causing inflation. In January 1923, Germany failed to make a payment ...<|separator|>
  20. [20]
    Guide to Notgeld Collection 1914-1923 - UChicago Library
    Notgeld were emergency monetary notes from German municipalities, companies, and individuals (1914-1923) to counter currency shortages and hyperinflation.Missing: examples | Show results with:examples
  21. [21]
    Art and Currency in 1920s Germany - Yale University Art Gallery
    Mar 19, 2024 · Specifically, Notgeld allowed independent territories throughout the Weimar Republic to express their own histories, folktales, political ...
  22. [22]
  23. [23]
    Issues (German) - basic - Notgeld.com
    * 5,500 varieties of 1914, issued by 452 places. * 36,000 varieties of 1915-1922, small value notes (kleingeld), issued by 3,658 places. * 5,000 varieties of ...<|separator|>
  24. [24]
    WWI's Emergency Money - The Tontine Coffee-House
    Mar 2, 2020 · As in France, there was a similar hoarding of coins unabated by the abandonment of the gold standard. Though eventually overrun, the Germans ...
  25. [25]
    Hyperinflation in Germany, 1921-1923 - Econlib
    Nov 9, 2023 · Between December 1921 and July 1922, the amount of domestic bills and cheques held by the Reichsbank rose by 616%, from 922 million marks to 6.6 billion.Missing: Notgeld | Show results with:Notgeld
  26. [26]
  27. [27]
    Inflation 1923 Intro. - Notgeld.com
    The peak of the hyper inflation period in Germany was late 1923. Notes were ... By late 1923, notes were being issued in Billion Mark denominations – in Germany ...
  28. [28]
    Currency in Crisis: German emergency money 1914 to 1924 @ the ...
    Feb 13, 2020 · From 1919, towns made a profit by issuing local Notgeld and 'selling' it to collectors all over Germany. The exhibition includes two Notgeld ...
  29. [29]
    1945 - 1948 Notgeld issues | Notgeld.com
    Notgeld issued between 1945 and 1948, on the main from 1947.
  30. [30]
    Introduction to the German notgeld (emergency paper money)
    It catalogs with details all of German paper money issued from 1871 till 1948 by Provinces, States and Territories., (Notgeld der deutschen Lnder), 1871-1948 .
  31. [31]
  32. [32]
    Germany 10 Pennies After 1945 Emergency Money Münden XF 97763
    Find many great new & used options and get the best deals for Germany 10 Pennies After 1945 Emergency Money Münden XF 97763 at the best online prices at ...Missing: currency | Show results with:currency
  33. [33]
    German Notgeld 1947/1948 - Emergency Money - Beate Rauch
    Austria re-introduced the Schilling Currency on 12.12.1945. The lower German denominations of 1, 2, 5 Mark remained in circulation until 3.3.1946.
  34. [34]
    Notgeld of the European states | bavarikon
    In Austria, shattered state finances, high war costs and the revolution of 1848/49 led to a shortage of coins. Municipalities and businesses helped ...
  35. [35]
    6 Kreuzer - City of Braunau (notgeld) - Numista
    City of Braunau (notgeld) (Federal State of Upper Austria) ... Shattered state finances, high war costs, and the revolution of 1848-1849 led to a lack of coins.
  36. [36]
    Paper money in Austria - Bavarikon
    The Reichstag in Vienna therefore decided to issue state banknotes, the "Cassa-Anweisungen". However, the population distrusted these banknotes, so they hardly ...
  37. [37]
    austrian notgeld
    The state bank gave towns and villages permission to issue their own currency and notgeld were issued from 1914 until about 1923.
  38. [38]
    The Great Austrian Inflation - FEE.org
    Apr 1, 2006 · Between 1919 and 1923, Austria's money supply had increased by 14,250 percent. Prices rose dramatically during this period.Missing: Emergency | Show results with:Emergency
  39. [39]
    Austrian notgeld Intro
    Austrian notgeld can come in several forms – paper, card, wood, playing card – to name a few. Here is a lovely looking pair of 95 heller pieces, issued as a ...Missing: 1848 Revolution<|control11|><|separator|>
  40. [40]
    Silvio Gesell and the Wörgl Experiment - The Tontine Coffee-House
    Jun 15, 2020 · The first notable experiment with a taxed currency occurred in Austria amidst the economic slump of the 1930s. The Great Depression deeply ...
  41. [41]
    Freigeld Woergl 1932/1933 - Unterguggenberger Institut
    When he accepted the office of mayor in 1931 the severe economic depression was already on the horizon. It resulted in his enforcement of the Free Economy ...
  42. [42]
    [PDF] The Wörgl Experiment: Austria (1932-1933) | Bernard Lietaer
    One of the best-known applications of the stamp scrip idea was applied in the small town of Wörgl in Austria in 1932 and 1933. When Michael Unterguggenberger ( ...
  43. [43]
    The 'Strange, Unduly Neglected Prophet' - NPR
    Aug 27, 2019 · In 1932, in the small town of Wörgl, Austria, a town leader, Michael Unterguggenberger, got Wörgl to issue stamped money as a way to combat ...
  44. [44]
    The Free Economy Experiment of Woergl (1932-1933)
    In June 1933, around 200 Austrian communities like Wörgl wanted to issue regionally valid Schwundgeld to combat the economic crisis. Newspapers everywhere ...
  45. [45]
    The Year of the Freigeld in Wörgl | MünzenWoche - CoinsWeekly
    Nov 7, 2009 · To encourage a rapid circulation the labour certificates were designed as Schwundgeld: each month a token at a fixed percentage of the sum had ...Missing: Notgeld | Show results with:Notgeld
  46. [46]
    Irish Gun Money - The Coins & History Foundation
    May 12, 2021 · A fascinating chapter in the history of Irish coinage occurred between 1689 and 1691 when the deposed King James II authorised the striking of token money made ...
  47. [47]
    17th Century Gunmoney Half-Crown Coin
    'Gunmoney' half-crown from May, 1690. This was an emergency coinage issued by James II during the Williamite-Jacobite War.
  48. [48]
    Gun money and the Irish war for England's throne
    Aug 19, 2021 · Gun money, the emergency coinage issued by James II during the Williamite-Jacobite War (1689-1691), has frequently been found below ground. The ...
  49. [49]
    Irish Gunmoney | MünzenWoche - CoinsWeekly
    Nov 19, 2020 · The latest work by Paul and Bente R. Withers presents a detailed study of Irish gunmoney and the emergency issues of 1689-1691.
  50. [50]
    Emergency coins fund the war | Sveriges Riksbank - Riksbanken
    The wars during the reign of Charles XII cost a lot of money. To fund them, more than 40 million emergency coins were issued. The round copper coins had ...Missing: pre- | Show results with:pre-
  51. [51]
    History of the Swedish Monetary System
    During the Great Nordic war, 1700 - 1721, the King Karl XII issued emergency coins (nödmynt). They were issued between 1716 and 1719. Every emergency coin ...
  52. [52]
    The Swedish Emergency Money of Freiherr von Görtz - CoinsWeekly
    Feb 11, 2010 · His descendants have achieved their goal: up to the present day, the Swedish emergency money of 1715 to 1719 is associated not with Charles XII ...Missing: pre- modern
  53. [53]
    1914-1944: wars and monetary upheavals | National Bank of Belgium
    More than 800 Belgian municipalities began to issue their own “emergency money” or Notgeld to cope with these monetary difficulties.
  54. [54]
    War Finance (Belgium) - 1914-1918 Online
    Oct 8, 2014 · Some local Belgian authorities had printed their own emergency money to cope with the lack of means of payment in the beginning of the war. As a ...
  55. [55]
    Necessity money during World War I in France
    In a context of money shortage exacerbated by the collection of gold by the State and hoarding behaviour, money tokens were issued to replace notes and ...
  56. [56]
    emergency currency, 1 franc, France | Imperial War Museums
    Emergency note issued for use in Roubaix and Tourcoing, Nord, France. Provenance unknown though notes were contained in an envelope with a Zürich post mark ...Missing: occupied | Show results with:occupied
  57. [57]
    Spanish Emergency Money During the Civil War - Moneda de ...
    Jan 1, 2020 · The emergency money issued during the Spanish Civil War is called moneda de necesidad or money of necessity. Both sides in the conflict issued ...Missing: scrip | Show results with:scrip
  58. [58]
    Stamp Money of the Spanish Civil War.
    The solution was small circular disks of cardboard, printed by the Government and distributed by the banks. They featured the Spanish Coat of Arms on one side, ...
  59. [59]
    Local money - Virtual Museum of the Spanish Civil War
    When the Generalitat authorized local governments to issue small denomination bills, 773 of the 1.075 municipalities did so. Some replaced céntimos and pesetas ...
  60. [60]
    Spanish Civil War Emergency Banknotes - Totana Murcia
    Jun 5, 2018 · Shown below are a complete set of banknotes in denominations of 25 Centimos, 50 Centimos, 1 Peseta and 2 Pesetas that were issued by TOTANA ...<|separator|>
  61. [61]
    Local currencies: The wasted opportunities - Resilience.org
    Nov 18, 2017 · Bank note used in Riudoms during Spanish Civil War (15 June 1937). Within alternative movements there is much interest in introducing local ...
  62. [62]
    Authentic Genuine Collectable Coin Emergency ... - Amazon.com
    This rare emergency money was issued by the Spanish nationalists in 1938; At the end of the Spanish Civil War it became more and more difficult to get the ...
  63. [63]
    Greenbacks, Chits, and Scrip | Science History Institute
    May 3, 2022 · The scrip system reappeared in Germany during even darker times. At Poland's Łódź ghetto, the Nazis forced arrivals to exchange their money ...Missing: 20th | Show results with:20th
  64. [64]
    Serienscheine Intro. | Notgeld.com
    The 2 main catalogues available to collectors of notes in this field are by Kai LINDMAN (Lm.) and the other by Hans GRABOWSKI & Manfred MEHL (Gr/Mehl -).
  65. [65]
    Notgeld - Emergen¢y Money - The World of Playing Cards
    Nov 3, 2018 · In Austria the towns of Steyregg and Reichental issued spielkarten notgeld made of playing cards in around 1920-1921. Others may also exist.
  66. [66]
    Notgeld World Paper Money for sale - eBay
    Get the best deals on Notgeld World Paper Money when you shop the largest online selection at eBay.com. Free shipping on many items | Browse your favorite ...
  67. [67]
    1921 Scheuch-551 Stuttgart Notgeld White Porcelain Gilt Rim MS 5 Mk
    Germany – Weimar, 1921 Scheuch-551 Stuttgart Notgeld White Porcelain Gilt Rim MS 5 Mk. Auction Record: $75.00 • PCGS MS62 • 09/19/2022 • eBay. Filter Results.
  68. [68]
    Search All Sales - NumisBids
    Small group of emergency issues (Notgeld) from Weimar... Lot 1371. Starting price: 200 AUD.
  69. [69]
    notgeld - CoinArchives.com Search Results
    Grade: XF Starting price: 24 EUR... 27 Sep 2025, 57 EUR. Your search for 'notgeld' matched 405 lots from auctions added in the last six months. To search our ...
  70. [70]
    Welcome | Notgeld.com
    German notgeld prices have risen gradually over the years and auction prices are very strong. The scarcer pieces can quite often obtain prices higher than their ...Missing: numismatics contemporary
  71. [71]
    Valuations from 'notgeld.com'
    Jan 19, 2021 · I can provide a tailor-made service, depending on your individual needs. I can give you a valuation for a single notgeld piece, a set of notgeld or an album of ...Missing: contemporary | Show results with:contemporary
  72. [72]
    Banknote Collecting Market Research Report 2033
    According to our latest research, the Global Banknote Collecting market size was valued at $1.2 billion in 2024 and is projected to reach $2.4 billion by 2033, ...
  73. [73]
    [PDF] Currency and Community: Labor, Identity, and Notgeld in Inflation ...
    But as this unofficial money, called Notgeld (literally, “emergency money”), became a fixture of local economies, it also became a way of expressing anxieties, ...
  74. [74]
    Hyperinflation: trauma and its reconstruction - European Central Bank
    Jun 20, 2025 · The trauma of 1923 is widely seen as the source of the country's preference for fiscal discipline and stability-oriented central banking.
  75. [75]
    Lessons from money growth and inflation in the US since 2008 and ...
    Mar 30, 2016 · During the German hyperinflation central bank actions reinforced a trend of increase in the velocity of circulation of money (Cagan 1956).Missing: emergency | Show results with:emergency
  76. [76]
    [PDF] The pervasiveness of monetary plurality in economic crisis and wars
    While the Notgeld appeared as an extraordinary and temporary measure in the context of demise of the socio-economic system after a major war, the experiments ...
  77. [77]
    The Debt-Inflation Channel of German Hyperinflation
    Jul 13, 2023 · The absence of a proactive central bank response exacerbated the inflation. Notably, data on the forward exchange premium and anecdotal ...
  78. [78]
    Inflation – lessons learnt from history | Deutsche Bundesbank
    The potential consequences of inflation demonstrate how important it is to keep the value of a currency stable. The German Empire experienced hyperinflation ...
  79. [79]
    Enduring lessons from the German hyperinflation 1923-2023
    Nov 15, 2023 · And that, as a consequence, the central bank had to accommodate the rise in money demand to avoid the collapse of the economy (today we would ...