Fact-checked by Grok 2 weeks ago

Nukie

Nukie is a 1987 South African science fiction adventure film directed by Sias Odendaal and co-directed by Michael Pakleppa. The story depicts two alien siblings, Nukie and Miko, whose spacecraft malfunctions during a visit to Earth, leading to Miko's capture by the U.S. Space Foundation while Nukie crash-lands in the African savannah and enlists the help of two local boys to effect a rescue. Featuring actors such as Glynis Johns as a nun and Steve Railsback as a scientist, the film was produced as a family-oriented extraterrestrial tale explicitly modeled after E.T. the Extra-Terrestrial. Despite its intentions, Nukie has achieved notoriety for its technical deficiencies, including amateurish effects, stilted dialogue, and incoherent plotting, earning it aggregate user ratings as low as 1.8 out of 10 on IMDb from over 1,500 votes. It is frequently listed among the worst films ever made, with critics and viewers decrying it as a plagiaristic failure that lacks originality or competence.

Production

Development and scripting

Nukie originated from an original story conceived by South African filmmaker Sias Odendaal, who sought to craft a family-oriented adventure featuring two extraterrestrial siblings separated after crash-landing on Earth—one in and the other captured by a U.S. space agency. Odendaal, serving as writer, co-director, and co-writer, drew direct inspiration from Steven Spielberg's (1982), modeling the narrative around themes of alien-child bonding and intergalactic rescue to capitalize on the earlier film's global success and appeal to international audiences. The screenplay was developed by Ben Taylor, who expanded Odendaal's initial plot beats into a full script, emphasizing a light-hearted tone with gremlin-like aliens named Nukie and . Pre-production occurred in amid the apartheid era's economic isolation, which constrained the low-budget project and prompted strategic inclusions like American actor in the cast to enhance prospects for U.S. distribution and broader across 26 countries. Pakleppa joined as co-director and producer, later addressing script-related issues such as inconsistent and plot logic through additional South African footage, though these stemmed from the haste to emulate E.T.'s formula without robust revisions. Limited funds further hampered creative decisions, restricting to rudimentary elements like glowing rocks after production setbacks, including a studio's disappearance with allocated resources.

Filming challenges

Principal photography for Nukie took place primarily in , where logistical constraints and crew shortages plagued the production. Co-director Michael Pakleppa recounted assembling a small, overworked team for reshoots after initial footage proved unusable, extending the schedule from an intended three months to nine. A director of photography endured a 40-degree fever during shoots in the South African , conducted from a , while a freelance vanished after delivering exterior shots, further disrupting . The film's practical effects for the alien characters exemplified amateurish execution due to the low budget and lack of expertise. Alien suits and were constructed without adequate knowledge of puppeteering or , rendering them too small and inflexible; child actors inside could barely move their limbs, with visible seams exposing the construction flaws. One child reportedly suffocated after three to four minutes from insufficient breathing space, highlighting the hazardous improvisation that prioritized cost over safety. Reshoots compounded these issues, necessitating multiple return trips to where child actors had aged by 2.5 years, leading to evident errors in their appearances. The special effects studio responsible for elements like glowing rocks and comet-like objects disappeared amid fears of lawsuits over substandard work, forcing Pakleppa to salvage what he could with minimal resources. These on-set exigencies, driven by financial limitations and inexperienced personnel, directly contributed to the film's technical deficiencies, such as awkward movements and mismatched scenes.

Post-production issues

Post-production for Nukie encountered severe setbacks, primarily due to the collapse of the contracted special effects studio, which absconded with the budget after delivering only rudimentary elements like glowing rocks, a static Earth shot, and a comet animation. Co-director Michael Pakleppa noted that the studio had "overestimated their power by a 1000 per cent," leaving the production without viable visual effects integration for key sequences such as alien crash landings and telepathic communications, which appeared unpolished and disjointed in the final film. Dubbing and sound mixing further compounded deficiencies, with mismatched in laboratory scenes where narrations and character dialogues failed to synchronize, alongside high-pitched, inconsistent alien vocalizations that undermined immersion. These issues stemmed from limited access to professional post-production facilities in , resulting in erratic accents and audio layers that clashed with the narrative's elements, such as alien telepathy rendered through simplistic, unrefined beams. The editing process involved drastic cuts, reducing raw footage to approximately 40 minutes by excising unusable segments—including content deemed racially problematic—to salvage a coherent storyline, followed by supplemental shoots in for new dialogues. Despite evident pacing flaws, such as protracted efforts and abrupt transitions, the final cut was rushed to approval in 1987 after extending from a planned three months to nine, prioritizing international market timing over iterative refinements; twelve critical shots remained absent until a hasty reshoots resolved them. This haste amplified unresolved technical shortcomings, including poorly integrated that posed safety risks during but persisted in subpar on-screen execution.

Release and distribution

Initial theatrical release

Nukie premiered theatrically in on July 1, 1987. The film was positioned as a adventure involving stranded extraterrestrials and human children, drawing parallels to popular imports while leveraging local production to serve domestic audiences. Producers incorporated American performers, including and , to enhance international appeal, particularly toward U.S. markets amid 's cinematic isolation from global sanctions. Despite these efforts, the absence of major studio confined early theatrical exposure primarily to , with subsequent limited releases in territories such as the on October 19, 1988. In the United States, no widespread theatrical rollout materialized, reflecting constraints from independent financing and challenges.

International markets and home video

Nukie received limited international distribution beyond its South African premiere, primarily through formats in select European and North American markets. In , theatrical release occurred in 1990 via Esteban Alenda Distribución, while saw a 1989 distribution by Alliance Releasing . In the , a rental edition was issued around 1990 by 20/20 Vision, marking one of the few structured entries into European consumer markets. These sparse releases, often via independent or budget distributors, contributed to the film's rapid obscurity outside niche audiences, as it lacked major studio backing or promotional campaigns to sustain visibility. Home video, particularly , emerged as the film's dominant dissemination channel by the late , with tapes appearing in limited U.S. runs under budget labels such as VidMark Entertainment. These releases frequently employed echoing E.T. the Extra-Terrestrial's aesthetic—featuring stranded aliens and child protagonists—to capitalize on audience familiarity with Spielberg's success, despite no affiliation. The format's accessibility in discount bins and rentals provided primary exposure but hastened the film's fade from mainstream awareness, as physical copies dwindled without replenishment from major retailers. As of , Nukie has seen no official DVD or Blu-ray release, with listings indicating unavailability for physical upgrades. Streaming options remain absent from major platforms, following prior temporary appearances on services like and that have since lapsed. This stagnation in digital and higher-quality formats has preserved the scarcity of original tapes, fostering their status as rare collectibles among enthusiasts rather than broadening general access.

Reception and analysis

Critical reviews

Critics and audiences have lambasted Nukie for its derivative storytelling, which apes E.T. the Extra-Terrestrial without originality, featuring aliens stranded on Earth amid government capture and child rescuers, but resolving conflicts through illogical conveniences like sudden telepathic fixes and improbable escapes. The film's pacing suffers from protracted, aimless sequences, including repetitive voice-over narrations that irritate rather than clarify, exacerbating a narrative disjointed by poor editing and non-sequiturs, such as abrupt shifts from alien distress to unrelated animal interactions without causal linkage. Acting performances draw particular scorn, with child leads delivering lines in monotone, stilted fashion—exemplified by unnatural pauses and emotionless recitations during key emotional beats—while adult supporting roles fare little better, conveying wooden incompetence that undermines any intended . Special effects amplify the ineptitude, relying on visibly dangling wires for "flight" scenes, crudely puppeteered suits with evident seams, and low-budget props like foil-wrapped helmets that fail to evoke otherworldly credibility. Aggregate user assessments reflect this consensus, with IMDb scoring the film at 1.8/10 from 1,531 votes, often citing it as emblematic of amateur production flaws over mere taste. Retrospective critiques, such as Brad Jones's review under the Cinema Snob persona, dissect implausibilities in alien —like batteries sustaining life or microwaves effecting miraculous heals— as symptomatic of causal oversight, where biological and technological elements contradict without narrative justification, rendering world-building incoherent. These elements collectively evidence a failure to ground sci-fi premises in verifiable logic or empirical consistency, prioritizing unchecked over coherent execution.

Commercial performance

Nukie achieved negligible box office earnings, with its theatrical release limited primarily to and select international markets, where it failed to compete effectively against established sci-fi franchises. No gross figures have been publicly reported for the , underscoring the film's absence from major Western theatrical circuits amid dominance by higher-profile productions like those from Hollywood's genre slate in the late . Home video distribution via VHS similarly underperformed, with low initial sales reflected in the abundance of discarded copies available cheaply or for free decades later, rather than driven by collector demand. This scarcity in pristine condition today stems from widespread audience rejection and physical degradation over time, not original commercial viability for family or sci-fi markets. The film's producers did not recoup costs through contemporary sales, as evidenced by the negligible resale values until ironic appreciation emerged. Any subsequent financial outlier, such as a sealed VHS copy auctioned for $80,600 on January 6, 2023, by YouTube channel Red Letter Media for charity after destroying over 100 others, represents cult-driven speculation rather than indicative of break-even from primary markets. This event highlights the film's market failure, as profitability materialized only through meme-fueled rarity, not organic revenue streams.

Comparisons to E.T. and originality debates

Nukie exhibits numerous structural and thematic parallels to (1982), including an extraterrestrial craft malfunctioning and crashing on , the stranded forming a bond with human children who aid in evading military pursuit, and telepathic elements facilitating communication between the and its sibling counterpart. In Nukie, the titular crash-lands in the South African veld, where it is rescued by local children amid government agents' efforts to capture it, mirroring E.T.'s sequence of the alien's separation from its ship, sheltering with suburban kids, and federal quarantine threats. However, Nukie's execution relies on a rudimentary foam-rubber suit for the alien, contrasting sharply with E.T.'s sophisticated and that enabled expressive facial movements and fluid interactions. Debates over originality center on whether Nukie's , credited to Sias Odendaal as an original story, predates significant E.T. influence or constitutes deliberate imitation driven by the earlier film's commercial triumph. E.T. premiered on June 11, 1982, grossing over $792 million worldwide and spawning a wave of similar children's sci-fi tales, while Nukie entered production in the mid-1980s and released theatrically in on July 1, 1987, suggesting causal timing where E.T.'s proven formula incentivized replication for profitability rather than coincidental convergence. No documented evidence indicates Odendaal's core narrative—two siblings, Nukie and , separated after a crash with one exhibiting abilities—was fully conceived prior to E.T.'s impact, though the absence of legal suits affirms Nukie as an independent production rather than direct theft. While Nukie introduces elements absent in E.T., such as the dual-alien premise with Miko held captive by authorities, enabling a subplot, these additions fail to innovate meaningfully and instead exacerbate narrative weaknesses through dangling threads and illogical resolutions. The sibling dynamic promises emotional depth but collapses under inconsistent plotting, where Miko's plight receives minimal causal progression toward reunion, unlike E.T.'s streamlined cause-effect chain from discovery to departure. This results in Nukie's inferior mechanics, prioritizing superficial mimicry over coherent world-building or character-driven causality.

Legacy

Cult following and "so-bad-it's-good" status

Nukie gained ironic appreciation within bad movie enthusiast communities starting in the early 2010s, primarily through online video reviews that highlighted its technical and narrative shortcomings as sources of unintentional comedy. In a November 2011 episode of The Cinema Snob, reviewer Brad Jones described the film as "the worst movie he has reviewed," critiquing its sluggish pacing, inept , and amateurish effects, which he cataloged as emblematic failures rather than redeemable quirks. This analysis contributed to its visibility among fans of "so-bad-it's-good" cinema, where the film's objective deficiencies—such as mismatched audio syncing and plodding child-alien interactions—were dissected for humorous effect. Subsequent coverage amplified this status, with Red Letter Media's December 2022 video "We Finally Watched Nukie" examining a rare copy and emphasizing production causal factors like low-budget shortcuts leading to rudimentary and disjointed storytelling. These reviews framed Nukie's terribleness as empirically derived from resource constraints, including hasty errors that created absurd tonal shifts, appealing to audiences who value such artifacts over . By 2025, appeared in curated lists of obscure failures, such as 's ranking of "10 Worst Movies You've Never Heard of," where its "atrociousness" was noted for fostering a small ironic centered on communal mockery of its flaws. Community persistence is evident in ongoing forum discussions, where enthusiasts in spaces like Reddit's r/badMovies and r/CultCinema analyze Nukie's empirical without idealization, often referencing review-derived insights into budget-driven effects like static props and erratic pacing as entertaining case studies in filmmaking incompetence. has attributed this niche endurance to the film's "so-bad-it's-good appeal," stemming from verifiable production lapses rather than subjective offensiveness, sustaining group viewings that prioritize dissecting causal chains of failure over .

VHS auction and destruction controversy

In December 2022, the YouTube channel , known for reviewing obscure films, released a video titled "We Finally Watched Nukie: The VHS Grading Video," in which hosts Mike Stoklasa and Jay Bauman examined the speculative market for graded tapes. They acquired 104 sealed copies of the 1987 South African film Nukie, subjected several to professional grading by Investment Grading Services (IGS), and tested the service's rigor by submitting a sealed disguised as a rare item, which received a high grade despite its fabrication. To demonstrate how drives value in collectibles markets, they destroyed 103 copies using an industrial woodchipper on camera, preserving one graded copy (rated 8.5/9.0 by IGS) for auction. The preserved tape was listed on in late December 2022, with all proceeds pledged to charity—split evenly between and the Wisconsin Humane Society—and the auction concluded on January 6, 2023, after 224 bids, fetching $80,600. This outcome sparked debate over ethics versus charitable , with critics arguing the destruction of physical copies undermined archival efforts for even low-quality films, potentially setting a precedent for manipulating rarity in niche markets. Supporters, including , countered that Nukie's poor reputation and digital availability elsewhere rendered the tapes non-essential artifacts, framing the act as a of hype-driven grading systems akin to non-fungible tokens or graded . Skepticism also arose regarding the grading process's legitimacy, amplified by 's fake tape experiment, which suggested services might prioritize visual appeal over verifiable provenance, though IGS defended its methodologies as industry-standard. Post-auction, the event empirically boosted Nukie's visibility as a collectible, with subsequent ungraded or lower-graded copies listed on commanding premiums far exceeding prior sales—such as a 9.0/9.0 IGS copy marketed as rarer—without altering critical consensus on the film's quality, which remains derided for derivative and flaws. This highlighted dynamics where enforced and publicity can inflate values for intrinsically low-merit items, independent of artistic or , as evidenced by the tape's buyer remaining despite involving figures like Garry Newman. The controversy did not lead to broader regulatory changes in VHS grading but underscored tensions between speculative trading and cultural preservation, with donating the full $80,600 as promised, verified by recipient organizations.

References

  1. [1]
    Nukie (1987) - IMDb
    Rating 1.8/10 (1,531) Nukie: Directed by Sias Odendaal, Michael Pakleppa. With Glynis Johns, Steve Railsback, Ronald France, Siphiwe Mlangeni. An alien called Nukie searches for ...Missing: facts | Show results with:facts
  2. [2]
    Nukie | Rotten Tomatoes
    Rating 23% (42) Movie Info. Synopsis Two children and a stranded alien set out to rescue a captured extraterrestrial from evil researchers. Director: Sias Odendal. Rating: PG.Missing: facts | Show results with:facts
  3. [3]
    The Nukie Controversy Explained: Destroying Crappy Movies For ...
    Jan 13, 2023 · "Nukie" has appeared on lists of the worst movies ever made, and is a largely miserable experience. Steve Railsback from "The Stunt Man" and " ...
  4. [4]
    'The worst film ever': the story behind Nukie, the forgotten ET knock-off
    Jan 30, 2023 · A bizarre knock-off of Steven Spielberg's ET, Nukie is a light-hearted children's fantasy about a pair of gremlin-like extraterrestrials who visit Earth.Missing: summary | Show results with:summary
  5. [5]
    Nukie, 1987 – – TYTD Reviews
    Aug 25, 2023 · It never got a retail home video release, and no company has been brave enough to test a DVD or Bluray release of this thing on the open market, ...Missing: facts | Show results with:facts
  6. [6]
    Is Nukie Really The Worst Movie Ever Made? The Controversy ...
    Mar 20, 2024 · Nukie is a South African science-fiction film that is so bad, that a charity based around its destruction has garnered more interest and controversy than the ...Missing: cost | Show results with:cost
  7. [7]
    Film Review: Nukie (1987, dir. Sias Odendal and Michael Pakleppa)
    Sep 5, 2015 · It's a message film chastising America while simultaneously begging for it's help, but just being a total and complete mess of filmmaking instead.Missing: facts cast<|separator|>
  8. [8]
    Nukie | Qualitipedia
    Two aliens named Nukie and Miko land on Earth, and when Miko is kidnapped by the U.S. government, Nukie must rescue him.Missing: summary | Show results with:summary<|separator|>
  9. [9]
    Nukie (1987) - Release info - IMDb
    Release date · South Africa. July 1, 1987 · Portugal. 1988(video premiere) · United Kingdom. October 19, 1988 · Spain. June 29, 1990 ...Missing: initial theatrical
  10. [10]
    Nukie (1987) directed by Sias Odendal, Michael Pakleppa - Letterboxd
    Rating 1.7 (1,369) A space child, lost in the universe, is abducted by the U. S. Space Foundation. In a desperate intergalactic search for the frightened little alien, ...Missing: facts | Show results with:facts
  11. [11]
    Nukie (1987) Trailer - YouTube
    Sep 17, 2021 · ... film nights in London. VHS trailer for the 1987 family sci-fi adventure Nukie, directed by Sias Odendal and Michael Pakleppa. #VHStrailer.Missing: development scripting Odendaal
  12. [12]
    Nukie (1987) - Sci-fi-central.com.
    Miko is quickly captured by an American space agency, while Nukie, who has landed in the middle of the African savannah, wanders about until he befriends two ...Missing: summary | Show results with:summary
  13. [13]
    Company credits - Nukie (1987) - IMDb
    Distributors ; Lars International Pictures. (South Africa, 1987) ; José Esteban Alenda Distribución. (Spain, 1990) ; Alliance Releasing Home Video. (Canada, 1989) ...
  14. [14]
    Opening to Nukie (1988) 1990 VHS (UK) (rental)
    Nukie is a UK rental VHS release by 20/20 Vision. Release date: TBA 1990. Theatrical date: July 1, 1987 (South Africa); October 19, 1988 (UK).
  15. [15]
    vhs NUKIE 1987 VidMark Entertainment STEVE RAILSBACK ... - eBay
    $$122.95 In stock Free deliveryTwo aliens, Nukie and Miko, crash-land on different parts of Earth. CAST includes Glynis Johns, Steve Railsback, Ronald France, Carin C. Tietze (debut), ...Missing: distribution | Show results with:distribution
  16. [16]
    Nukie DVD (Nukie... In Search of America) - Blu-ray.com
    To be notified when Nukie becomes available on Blu-ray, simply submit your email below. * We do not share your email and you'll only be notified once ...
  17. [17]
    Nukie streaming: where to watch movie online? - JustWatch
    Nukie is unavailable to stream in United States today. It was previously available on Hulu and Amazon Prime Video. The last time it was streaming was on Hulu ...Missing: DVD | Show results with:DVD
  18. [18]
    Nukie 1987 A magical space adventure Nukie is a 1987 South ...
    Feb 10, 2021 · Nukie is a 1987 South African science-fiction film directed by Sias Odendaal and Michael Pakleppa. The film stars Anthony Morrison, Steve Railsback, Ronald ...Missing: development scripting
  19. [19]
    Nukie (1987) - User reviews - IMDb
    Nukie is widely regarded as the worst/most painful movie ever made. No one who has seen it denies this assertion. It tops even the infamous Manos: the Hands of ...Missing: reception criticism
  20. [20]
    Nukie (1987) — Alien in Africa - Mutant Reviewers
    Feb 27, 2025 · It features a pair of joyriding aliens who land on earth as a lark. Miko is captured by “The Space Foundation” in the U.S. and studied, while ...Missing: summary | Show results with:summary
  21. [21]
    E.T. Week: Nukie - The Cinema Snob
    Some of the older archived videos of 2009 were brought over from the youtube account before thecinemasnob.com was created, so please forgive the lesser video ...Missing: review | Show results with:review
  22. [22]
    YouTubers said they destroyed over 100 VHS tapes of an obscure ...
    Jan 11, 2023 · After amassing many copies of the obscure '80s movie "Nukie," they said they ruined all but one. Their final tape of the movie sold for $80,600 ...Missing: Europe | Show results with:Europe
  23. [23]
    Red Letter Media Raises $80k for Charity Selling Sealed 'Nukie' VHS
    Jan 13, 2023 · YouTube channel Red Letter Media completed the long-running joke of "Nukie" VHS tapes and sold a mint condition copy for over $80000.Missing: Europe markets
  24. [24]
    VHS copy of forgotten 'E.T.' knock-off 'Nukie' sells for ... - KGUN 9
    Jan 10, 2023 · VHS copy of forgotten 'E.T.' knock-off 'Nukie' sells for $80,600 ... We reported last year that a VHS copy of the classic film "Back to the Future ...Missing: Europe | Show results with:Europe
  25. [25]
    10 Sci-Fi Movie Rip-Offs You Won't Believe Exist - WhatCulture.com
    Oct 7, 2022 · The similarities in premise alone speak for themselves, and indeed, Nukie is what you'd get if E.T. was made on a shoestring budget without the ...
  26. [26]
    Ranking Bad E.T. Rip-Offs From Worst to Watchable - Flickering Myth
    Aug 4, 2025 · Nukie (1987). Nukie is South Africa's answer to E.T., where co-directors Sias Odendaal and Michael Pakleppa follow a story about two aliens ...Missing: interview | Show results with:interview
  27. [27]
    "The Cinema Snob" Nukie (TV Episode 2011) - IMDb
    Rating 9/10 (31) Brad Jones considers Nukie the worst movie he has reviewed, stating that ... Cinema Snob: ...you can't convince me that George Lucas didn't write this ...
  28. [28]
    We Finally Watched Nukie: The VHS Grading Video - YouTube
    Dec 30, 2022 · e-Bay listing for Nukie: https://www.ebay.com/itm/225324479952 There's been a growing trend in VHS collecting, which has created an entirely ...Missing: Europe budget
  29. [29]
    10 Worst Movies You've Never Heard of, Ranked - Collider
    Jan 4, 2025 · The alien design is grotesque too, with Nukie's face resembling a melted candle wax sculpture, and the sound editing makes every word gratingly ...<|control11|><|separator|>
  30. [30]
    Nukie (1987), the worst movie I have ever seen : r/badMovies - Reddit
    Nov 28, 2015 · I love bad movies, the bulk of the 8000 films I've rated on imdb are really bad movies, but I stumbled on this little gem, Nukie, ...
  31. [31]
    "Nukie" (1987) - What can I say about this movie that hasn't ... - Reddit
    Jul 20, 2024 · Speaking of the actual alien suit, I gotta say the decision to make ... Just know that along with all the other issues the movie has it also drags ...Missing: problems | Show results with:problems
  32. [32]
    Red Letter Media Destroys VHS Tapes to Raise Money for Charity
    Jan 14, 2023 · The climax of which saw them destroying all but one of their 104 VHS copies of “Nukie,” an E.T. knock-off so bad it doesn't even warrant a ...
  33. [33]
    YouTubers 'Red Letter Media' donate $80K to St. Jude's Hospital ...
    Jan 13, 2023 · ' So, to find out, they auctioned off a VHS tape of the movie 'Nukie' and announced all the money raised would be split and donated ...
  34. [34]
    Nukie VHS Graded 9.0/9.0 IGS Impossible To Find In This ... - eBay
    In stock Free deliveryA worse graded version sold for over $80,000 this year. Investment Grading.com graded this brand new sealed copy a 9.0/9.0! Don't miss your chance to get a rare ...
  35. [35]
    Do we know who bought the Nukie VHS? : r/RedLetterMedia - Reddit
    Jan 23, 2023 · Last known bid was Garry Newman (of Garry's Mod fame) but the bid increased twice after he confirmed he was the highest bidder, and he hasn't commented on it ...$80,600 Worth of Nukie : r/RedLetterMediaRed Letter Media sells VHS copy of "Nukie" on eBay for ...More results from www.reddit.comMissing: destruction | Show results with:destruction
  36. [36]
    Wisconsin Humane Society on X: "Nobody: @redlettermedia
    Jan 12, 2023 · Nobody: @redlettermedia: let's auction off a 1993 #Nukie VHS & split the proceeds with WHS & @StJude *raises $80000* WHS: ❤ ❤ ❤ Our $40k ...