Fact-checked by Grok 2 weeks ago

PAL

PAL (Phase Alternating Line) is a color encoding system developed for analog television broadcasting, which alternates the phase of the color information from line to line to ensure stable and accurate color reproduction.^[1] Developed in the early 1960s in Germany as an improvement over the NTSC standard to address issues like signal instability,^[2] PAL became the dominant television format in much of Europe, Australia, New Zealand, parts of Asia, Africa, and South America.^[3] Technically, it features 625 total scan lines (576 visible), a frame rate of 25 frames per second, and a vertical frequency of 50 Hz, making it compatible with the 50 Hz electrical power systems prevalent in those regions.^[1]^[3] Compared to NTSC, which uses 525 lines and about 30 frames per second for 60 Hz regions like North America, PAL offers higher resolution and built-in error correction through phase alternation, resulting in superior picture quality and reduced color distortion.^[4] It differs from SECAM, another 625-line system used in France and some Eastern countries, by employing a different color encoding method that is incompatible without conversion.^[1] Although largely superseded by digital standards like DVB and ATSC in modern broadcasting, PAL remains relevant for legacy DVD playback, video equipment compatibility, and archival content in supported regions.^[3]

Fundamentals

Definition and Purpose

PAL (Phase Alternating Line) is a color encoding system for analog television, designed to transmit chrominance information alongside luminance signals in a manner compatible with existing monochrome broadcasts. Developed for use in 625-line television systems operating at 50 fields per second, PAL modulates the color subcarrier using quadrature amplitude modulation, where the blue-luminance (B-Y) and red-luminance (R-Y) components are encoded onto a suppressed carrier at approximately 4.433 MHz.^[5] This approach ensures that the composite signal can be received and displayed correctly on both color and black-and-white receivers without requiring modifications to monochrome equipment.^[6] The primary purpose of PAL is to achieve stable and accurate color reproduction by mitigating transmission-induced distortions, particularly hue errors caused by noise, phase shifts, or amplitude variations in the signal path. In PAL, the phase of the R-Y (or V) color-difference signal is inverted by 180 degrees on every alternate line, while the B-Y (or U) signal remains unchanged; this line-by-line phase alternation allows the decoder to average the signals over two lines, effectively canceling out differential phase errors that would otherwise shift colors.^[6] A color burst reference, with its own phase swing of ±135 degrees relative to the reference phase, synchronizes the receiver's oscillator to track these alternations, enabling simple and robust demodulation without complex phase-locking circuitry.^[5] PAL was introduced as an enhancement to address the phase instability inherent in the earlier NTSC standard, where consistent hue errors could arise from transmission noise without such corrective mechanisms. By incorporating line-by-line phase inversion, PAL averages out these errors during decoding, resulting in more reliable color fidelity.^[6] It is specifically tailored for 625-line, 50 Hz interlaced systems—common in Europe and many other regions—contrasting with NTSC's 525-line, 60 Hz format used primarily in North America, which offers a different balance of vertical resolution and motion smoothness but is more susceptible to color phase issues.^[5]

Key Technical Features

The PAL (Phase Alternating Line) colour television system is defined by a 625-line resolution per frame, with 50 fields per second and 2:1 interlaced scanning to facilitate efficient transmission of high-resolution images at a standard broadcast frame rate.^[7] This configuration ensures compatibility with European broadcast infrastructures while supporting a nominal picture aspect ratio of 4:3.^[7] Central to PAL's colour encoding is a subcarrier frequency of 4.43361875 MHz for standard variants (Systems B, G, H, and I), which carries the chrominance information modulated via suppressed-carrier amplitude modulation of two subcarriers in quadrature—effectively quadrature amplitude modulation (QAM)—for the U and V colour-difference signals.^[7] The luminance (Y) signal occupies a bandwidth of up to 5.5 MHz, while the chrominance components are confined to approximately ±1.3 MHz around the subcarrier; separation of these signals in receivers typically employs a comb filter, which exploits the quarter-line offset of the subcarrier phase between adjacent lines to notch out cross-interference without significant loss of detail.^[7]^[8] A defining feature of PAL is the phase alternation of the V-axis reference signal, where the colour burst phase inverts by 180° (specifically ±135° relative to the subcarrier) every line, enabling decoders to average signals from consecutive lines and thereby cancel out phase errors introduced during transmission—such as those from propagation delays—resulting in more stable colour reproduction compared to non-alternating systems.^[7] Colour information in PAL is derived from weighted RGB-to-YUV conversion using specific coefficients to align with human vision sensitivities: the luminance signal is formed as Y = 0.299R + 0.587G + 0.114B (with gamma-corrected primaries E'_R, E'_G, E'_B), while the colour-difference signals U and V are modulated onto the subcarrier to preserve perceptual uniformity in the transmitted spectrum.^[7] This matrix ensures backward compatibility with monochrome receivers, as the Y component alone reconstructs a viable black-and-white image.^[7]

Development and History

Origins in Europe

The PAL color television system was invented by Walter Bruch, an engineer at Telefunken in Hannover, West Germany. PAL was patented by Bruch on December 30, 1962, following an initial filing on July 17, 1961 that was later withdrawn. Developed as a direct response to the color instability problems observed in NTSC signals during European tests, particularly hue shifts caused by phase errors in transmission, PAL introduced a novel approach to color encoding that addressed these NTSC limitations. Bruch's work built on earlier NTSC concepts but incorporated modifications to ensure more reliable color reproduction across varying signal conditions.^[9]^[10] Bruch presented the system to a group of experts from the European Broadcasting Union (EBU) on January 3, 1963, generating initial interest among broadcasters. The key innovation of PAL lay in its line-sequential phase alternation, which reversed the phase of the color-difference signals on every alternate line, thereby mitigating hue shifts resulting from signal interference or phase drift without requiring complex adjustments at the receiver.^[10]^[11] Early adoption gained momentum through evaluations by major European broadcasters, including the BBC, which tested PAL alongside competing systems like SECAM in the mid-1960s. These assessments, conducted by the BBC and the UK's Television Advisory Committee, confirmed PAL's superior color stability and compatibility with existing monochrome infrastructure. Consequently, West Germany officially adopted PAL as its national color television standard in 1967, with the first regular broadcasts commencing on August 25 of that year during the International Radio Exhibition in Berlin, showcased using modified NTSC equipment to highlight its improvements. This decision paved the way for widespread European implementation, solidifying PAL's role in the continent's transition to color broadcasting.^[12]

Global Standardization Efforts

The global standardization of the PAL (Phase Alternating Line) color television system gained momentum through the efforts of the International Telecommunication Union (ITU), building on earlier work by its predecessor, the Comité Consultatif International des Radiocommunications (CCIR). In 1970, ITU-R Recommendation BT.470 was first issued, formally recognizing PAL as a viable international option for 625-line color television systems, alongside NTSC and SECAM. This recommendation outlined the characteristics of conventional analogue television systems, including parameters for signal encoding, transmission bandwidths, and compatibility requirements, which helped harmonize PAL's implementation for cross-border broadcasting and equipment interoperability. By establishing PAL within a unified framework, BT.470 facilitated its promotion as a reliable standard for regions transitioning to color television, emphasizing its advantages in phase stability and color fidelity. The expansion of PAL into Asia and Africa during the 1970s was propelled by exports of television equipment and infrastructure from leading European manufacturers, particularly in Britain and Germany, which sought to capitalize on their technical expertise in PAL technology. These exports aligned with colonial and economic ties, enabling rapid deployment in former British territories and other developing markets where 625-line monochrome systems were already prevalent. For instance, full color broadcasts commenced in the United Kingdom in 1967 using PAL System I, setting a precedent that influenced adopters like Australia, which initiated nationwide PAL color services in 1975. Similar patterns emerged in Africa, where countries such as Nigeria launched PAL-based color transmissions in 1977, supported by imported British and German transmitters and receivers that ensured compatibility with existing infrastructure. This export-driven approach, combined with ITU endorsements, accelerated PAL's uptake in over 50 documented regions by the late 1970s, as listed in subsequent updates to BT.470.^[13]^[14] Standardization faced challenges, including debates over subcarrier frequencies and modulation parameters, which resulted in regional variants to accommodate varying channel allocations and national bandwidth preferences. These issues were addressed through key CCIR meetings, notably the 1966 Oslo assembly, where comparative tests on NTSC, PAL, and SECAM systems led to agreements on core encoding principles, and the 1965 Vienna plenary, which refined specifications for international harmony and resolved discrepancies in frequency stability for PAL implementations. Such deliberations ensured that PAL's core 4.433618 MHz color subcarrier remained consistent while allowing flexibility for local adaptations, preventing fragmentation in global equipment trade. By the 1980s, these efforts culminated in PAL variants being adopted in over 100 countries, underscoring the system's dominance in 625-line regions due to its technical robustness, economic accessibility via European exports, and alignment with ITU guidelines that prioritized program exchange and backward compatibility.^[14]^[13]

Signal Encoding and Transmission

Color Encoding Mechanism

In the PAL color encoding process, the initial step involves converting the red (R), green (G), and blue (B) primary color signals into a luminance-chrominance format for compatibility with black-and-white television systems. The luminance signal E_Y' is formed as a weighted linear combination of the gamma-precorrected primary signals:

E_Y' = 0.299 E_R' + 0.587 E_G' + 0.114 E_B',

where the coefficients reflect the human visual system's sensitivity to each color component, and the gamma correction (with \gamma \approx 2.8) accounts for display nonlinearities.^[7] The chrominance signals are then derived as color-difference components:

E_U' = 0.493 (E_B' - E_Y'), \quad E_V' = 0.877 (E_R' - E_Y'),

with E_U' representing the blue-luminance difference and E_V' the red-luminance difference; these are low-pass filtered to limit bandwidth and reduce crosstalk with the luminance.^[7] The chrominance signals E_U' and E_V' are subsequently modulated onto a color subcarrier using quadrature amplitude modulation (QAM) to form the color subcarrier signal, which interleaves with the luminance spectrum for efficient transmission. This involves suppressing the carrier itself to minimize visible dot patterns, resulting in a modulated chrominance component where E_U' modulates the in-phase (sine) carrier and E_V' modulates the quadrature (cosine) carrier, with the subcarrier angular frequency \omega = 2\pi f_{sc} and f_{sc} \approx 4.43361875 MHz.^[7] The key innovation of PAL lies in the phase alternation: on even lines, the color signal is E_U' \sin(\omega t) + E_V' \cos(\omega t), while on odd lines, it becomes E_U' \sin(\omega t) - E_V' \cos(\omega t), introducing a 180-degree phase shift specifically to the E_V' component.^[7] This alternation mitigates hue errors caused by phase distortions in transmission by allowing the receiver to average signals across lines, effectively canceling out inconsistencies.^[15] To provide a stable phase reference for demodulation, a color burst signal is inserted immediately following the horizontal synchronizing pulse at the start of each line. This burst consists of 10 cycles of the unmodulated subcarrier, with its phase referenced at 135° relative to the E_U' axis and inverted by 180° on alternate lines to match the line-specific phase alternation.^[7] The burst amplitude is typically 20-40% of the chrominance peak-to-peak value, ensuring it is detectable without significantly impacting the picture.^[7] Finally, the modulated chrominance is additively combined with the luminance signal to produce the composite video signal E_M:

E_M = E_Y' + E_U' \sin(\omega t) \pm E_V' \cos(\omega t),

where the \pm denotes the line-alternating phase inversion.^[7] This composite signal is then low-pass filtered to constrain the overall bandwidth, typically to about 5.5-6 MHz for the luminance and 1.3 MHz for chrominance sidebands, before transmission.^[7]

Signal Specifications and Colorimetry

The PAL signal employs vestigial sideband amplitude modulation (C3F negative) for the luminance component, which allows efficient use of the transmission bandwidth by transmitting the full upper sideband and a portion of the lower sideband.^[5] The audio carrier utilizes frequency modulation (F3E), positioned at offsets of 5.5 MHz (systems B, G, H), 6.0 MHz (system I), 6.5 MHz (systems D, K), and 4.5 MHz (systems M, N) from the vision carrier, depending on the specific system variant.^[5] The total video bandwidth for PAL is specified at 5 to 6 MHz, with the luminance signal occupying up to 5 MHz in most systems (e.g., B, G, H, N/PAL) and 5.5 MHz in system I.^[5] To mitigate interference between the luminance and chrominance signals, a notch filter is applied at the color subcarrier frequency of approximately 4.43361875 MHz, attenuating the luminance energy in the chrominance band.^[16] PAL colorimetry is defined using the EBU primary chromaticities in the CIE 1931 color space: red at (x=0.64, y=0.33), green at (x=0.29, y=0.60), and blue at (x=0.15, y=0.06), with reference white at illuminant D65 (x=0.313, y=0.329).^[5]^[17] The encoding process incorporates gamma correction with a value of 2.8 to approximate the nonlinear response of the human visual system and display characteristics.^[5] The color difference signals are scaled for transmission as follows:

\begin{align*} U &= 0.493 (E'_B - E'_Y), \\ V &= 0.877 (E'_R - E'_Y), \end{align*}

where E'_R, E'_G, E'_B are the gamma-encoded red, green, and blue signals, and E'_Y is the luminance signal.^[5] These scaling factors ensure the chrominance signals fit within the available transmission amplitude without exceeding the luminance dynamic range.^[5]

Decoding and Reception

Analog Decoding Techniques

In analog PAL receivers, the basic decoding process begins with separating the luminance (Y) and chrominance (C) components from the composite video signal using a comb filter. This filter exploits the 180° phase shift in the chrominance subcarrier between consecutive lines, achieved by adding the undelayed signal to a one-line-delayed version to extract luminance, while subtracting them to isolate chrominance. A phase detector then uses the color burst—a reference signal transmitted during the horizontal blanking interval—to regenerate the local subcarrier oscillator, ensuring phase alignment for accurate demodulation. To correct for the phase alternation inherent in PAL encoding, where the V-axis component inverts on alternate lines, the decoder averages the chrominance signals from successive lines, reducing hue errors and improving color fidelity.^[8]^[18] Early PAL decoders commonly employed a delay line architecture for further U/V separation, incorporating a one-line delay (approximately 64 μs) to process the chrominance signal. The non-inverting U component aligns across lines, while the inverting V component allows separation by adding and subtracting delayed and undelayed signals, minimizing crosstalk between color difference signals. This method, prevalent in consumer television sets from the 1960s onward, provided effective color decoding with reduced bandwidth requirements for the chrominance channels, though it introduced some vertical resolution loss in color details.^[8]^[18]^[19] Advanced analog techniques enhanced precision through crystal-locked oscillators, where a stable quartz crystal at 4.43361875 MHz serves as the subcarrier reference, phase-locked to the incoming burst via a phase detector circuit. This approach minimizes frequency drift and provides stable regeneration, particularly in noisy environments, by integrating the phase error signal to control the oscillator voltage. For error handling, automatic phase correction circuits, often integrated with the delay line, detect and compensate for tint shifts by continuously adjusting the subcarrier phase reference, averaging over multiple lines to mitigate residual errors from transmission imperfections. These circuits ensure robust performance without manual intervention, maintaining color accuracy across varying signal conditions.^[20]^[21]^[22]

Compatibility with Black-and-White Systems

The PAL color television system was engineered to ensure full backward compatibility with existing black-and-white receivers, allowing monochrome televisions to display color broadcasts as standard grayscale images with negligible degradation. This compatibility is achieved through frequency interleaving, where the color subcarrier—operating at approximately 4.433 MHz—is positioned within the luminance spectrum in such a way that it falls into a natural attenuation notch in the intermediate frequency (IF) filters of monochrome receivers. As a result, the chrominance signal manifests as low-level, high-frequency noise or a fine dot pattern on black-and-white screens, which is largely imperceptible to the human eye due to its high spatial frequency and the limited bandwidth of typical monochrome displays.^[9]^[23] Forward compatibility ensures that monochrome transmissions can be received without issue on PAL color televisions. In these cases, the absence of the color subcarrier and color burst signals prompts the receiver to process only the luminance component, rendering the image in black and white as intended, while maintaining the full dynamic range and detail of the original signal. This bidirectional compatibility was a core design principle, preserving the existing monochrome infrastructure during the transition to color broadcasting.^[7] Early simulations and transmission tests in the 1960s confirmed the effectiveness of these mechanisms, demonstrating minimal interference from color signals on black-and-white reception. For instance, subjective assessments using protection ratios around 19-24 dB showed that chrominance contributions caused only slight impairments, often imperceptible or equivalent to less than 3 dB additional degradation compared to monochrome-only signals, well within tolerable thresholds for viewers. These results underscored the robustness of PAL's compatibility design.^[24] International standards further reinforce this compatibility by mandating identical luminance bandwidth specifications for both monochrome and color PAL systems. According to ITU recommendations for 625-line systems, the nominal video bandwidth is 5 MHz in both cases, ensuring that the core luminance signal remains unchanged and fully receivable across receiver types without requiring modifications to monochrome equipment.^[7]

Broadcast Variants

European and Asian Standards (B/G/D/K/I)

The European and Asian standards for PAL encompass several variants defined primarily by differences in channel bandwidth and RF channel allocations, as standardized under CCIR (now ITU-R) recommendations for Region 1 (Europe, Africa, Middle East) and parts of Asia. These systems share the core PAL color encoding with a subcarrier frequency of 4,433,618.75 ± 5 Hz and a line frequency of 15,625 ± 0.02% Hz, operating at 625 lines and 50 fields per second to ensure compatibility across diverse broadcast infrastructures. Audio is modulated using frequency modulation (F3E) in all variants, with the carrier positioned relative to the video signal based on system-specific channel widths.^[5] Systems B and G, often implemented together as B/G, utilize a 7 MHz channel bandwidth for VHF (System B) and 8 MHz for UHF (System G), supporting a video bandwidth of 5 MHz. This configuration was widely adopted across Western Europe, such as in Germany (where System B was used for VHF broadcasting) and many other countries including Austria, Belgium, and Italy for both VHF and UHF. In Asia, B/G variants appeared in nations like Bahrain, Indonesia, and Saudi Arabia, facilitating efficient spectrum use in densely populated broadcast environments while maintaining PAL's phase-alternating line for color stability. The primary distinction from other systems lies in the narrower VHF channels of System B, optimized for early European VHF allocations under CCIR guidelines. All these analog broadcast variants were phased out in favor of digital standards like DVB by the 2010s in Europe and Asia.^[5]^[25] Systems D and K, collectively known as D/K, employ an 8 MHz channel bandwidth for both VHF (System D) and UHF (System K), also with a 5 MHz video bandwidth, making them suitable for broader channel spacing in Eastern European and Asian networks. These were prevalent in countries like China and Mongolia (System D for PAL), while Russia, Ukraine, and Kazakhstan used D/K with SECAM. Some Eastern European countries transitioned to PAL-D/K from SECAM in the 1990s, reflecting CCIR adaptations for Region 1's eastern extents, emphasizing compatibility with wider guard bands to minimize interference in large-scale terrestrial broadcasting. All these analog broadcast variants were phased out in favor of digital standards like DVB by the 2010s in Europe and Asia.^[5]^[25] System I stands out with an 8 MHz channel bandwidth and an extended video bandwidth of 5.5 MHz, enabling higher horizontal resolution primarily on UHF bands. It was specifically developed for the United Kingdom and Ireland in Europe, and extended to Asian territories like Hong Kong and Macau, where it provided enhanced picture quality within the 625-line framework. This system's RF allocation prioritized UHF deployment to accommodate the increased video demands, aligning with CCIR specifications for regions requiring superior image fidelity in analog transmission. All these analog broadcast variants were phased out in favor of digital standards like DVB by the 2010s in Europe and Asia.^[5]^[25]

South American Variants (M/N)

South American countries adapted the PAL color encoding system to their existing monochrome television infrastructures during the 1970s, resulting in hybrid variants known as PAL-M and PAL-N. These adaptations combined PAL's phase-alternating line color modulation with parameters influenced by North American NTSC standards, such as channel widths and audio carrier spacings, to minimize the need for overhauling broadcast equipment. PAL-M, adopted in Brazil, utilized a 525-line resolution and 60 Hz field rate to align with the country's pre-existing System M monochrome framework, which had been in place since the 1950s. The system employed a color subcarrier frequency of 3.579611 MHz, closely matching NTSC's 3.579545 MHz for compatibility in color encoding, while maintaining a video bandwidth of 4.2 MHz and an audio carrier offset of 4.5 MHz within a 6 MHz channel. Official adoption occurred on February 19, 1972, with the first color broadcast airing the Festa Nacional da Uva parade in Caxias do Sul, marking Brazil as the first South American nation to implement color television. This customization allowed seamless integration with imported NTSC-compatible equipment, though the hybrid nature necessitated specialized tuners capable of handling the PAL color signal on a 60 Hz frame structure. All these analog broadcast variants were phased out in favor of digital standards like DVB by the 2010s in Europe and Asia.^[26] In contrast, PAL-N, implemented in Argentina and Uruguay, retained the 625-line, 50 Hz field rate of standard PAL to match European-style monochrome systems but adapted to a narrower 6 MHz channel bandwidth typical of the Americas. Key parameters included a color subcarrier of 3.582056 MHz, a video bandwidth of 5 MHz, and the NTSC-like audio spacing of 4.5 MHz, enabling broadcasts within existing VHF/UHF allocations without major spectrum reallocation. Development began in the mid-1970s, formalized in Argentina by Resolution No. 100 ME/76 in 1976, which specified the standard to ensure compatibility with local infrastructure while incorporating PAL's superior color fidelity. Full rollout occurred in 1978, coinciding with Argentina's hosting of the FIFA World Cup, and Uruguay followed suit shortly thereafter; the variant's hybrid design required dedicated receivers and transmitters, as it deviated from both pure PAL and NTSC norms. All these analog broadcast variants were phased out in favor of digital standards like DVB by the 2010s in Europe and Asia.^[27]

Other Regional Adaptations (A/L)

System A, designated by the CCIR as the original United Kingdom broadcast standard, served as a monochrome base with 405 active lines per frame at a 50 Hz field rate, operational from 1936 until its phase-out. Although experimental overlays of PAL color encoding were tested on this system to add color compatibility without disrupting existing black-and-white receivers, the approach was not adopted for regular broadcasting due to limitations in resolution and bandwidth for color subcarriers. Instead, the UK transitioned to a 625-line PAL variant (System I) on UHF frequencies starting in 1967, with full cessation of 405-line transmissions by January 1985 to complete the shift to higher-definition color standards. All these analog broadcast variants were phased out in favor of digital standards like DVB by the 2010s in Europe and Asia.^[28]^[29] System L, tailored for France, utilized a 625-line, 50 Hz interlaced format with amplitude modulation (AM) for the audio signal and a 10.4 MHz sound carrier frequency to minimize interference between luminance and chrominance components as well as with adjacent channels. This system supported a positive video modulation polarity, distinguishing it from the negative modulation common in other European variants, and was primarily paired with SECAM color encoding until the widespread adoption of digital broadcasting in the 1980s prompted its obsolescence. A PAL-L adaptation, using the standard PAL color subcarrier at 4.43361875 MHz but retaining System L's audio specifications and channel bandwidths, emerged for specific applications to ensure compatibility in regions like Monaco for some UHF broadcasts, while France primarily used SECAM-L.^[25]^[11] Regional adaptations of these systems often involved subcarrier frequency tweaks to align with local RF allocations and avoid co-channel interference; for instance, PAL-L employed a widened guard band and adjusted intercarrier spacing compared to standard PAL-B/G, facilitating smoother integration in VHF/UHF environments with dense spectrum usage. By the 1990s, both System A and System L had become largely obsolete, supplanted by digital television transitions that rendered analog PAL variants unnecessary across Europe. All these analog broadcast variants were phased out in favor of digital standards like DVB by the 2010s in Europe and Asia.^[25]

Consumer Devices and Compatibility

Television Receivers

Early PAL television receivers, introduced in the late 1960s, relied on vacuum tube-based decoders incorporating glass ultrasonic delay lines to process the phase-alternating color signals, ensuring accurate color reproduction by delaying the luminance signal by one line period.^[30] These sets, such as the Telefunken PALcolor 708T released in 1967, required dedicated intermediate frequency (IF) stages tuned to the 625-line, 50 Hz PAL standard to handle the broadcast signals effectively following the system's commercial debut in West Germany.^[11] The delay line technology, developed by Philips in the mid-1960s, was essential for compensating phase errors inherent in the PAL modulation scheme, marking a key advancement in analog color decoding for consumer devices.^[31] By the 1980s, the rise of home video recording with VCRs spurred the development of multisystem television receivers capable of switching between PAL, NTSC, and SECAM standards, allowing compatibility with diverse international video sources without manual adjustments.^[32] These VCR-era models often featured user-selectable standard modes via front-panel switches or remote controls, catering to growing consumer needs for global media playback in regions with mixed broadcast environments.^[33] Patents from the period, such as those for dual-standard SECAM/PAL receivers, laid the groundwork for integrated circuits that enabled smoother transitions between formats.^[34] Key features in PAL-compatible receivers included SCART connectors, standardized in Europe from the early 1980s to facilitate high-quality RGB video and audio connections between TVs and peripherals like VCRs, promoting interoperability across the continent.^[35] Later models incorporated auto-detection circuits to automatically identify and adapt to incoming PAL or NTSC signals, simplifying operation for users.^[34] The standard resolution supported by these receivers was 576i, delivering 576 active interlaced lines at 50 fields per second, as defined in ITU specifications for analog PAL systems.^[36] PAL receivers dominated consumer markets in Europe, Asia, and other regions through the 1990s and into the early 2000s, with cathode-ray tube (CRT) models remaining prevalent until the mid-2000s transition to flat-panel LCD technologies, which began supplanting CRTs around 2005 as prices fell and digital broadcasting advanced.^[37] This shift marked the end of widespread analog PAL hardware in homes, though legacy support persisted in some hybrid devices during the digital migration.^[38]

Video Recording and Playback Formats

The PAL video encoding system was adapted for consumer video recording and playback formats to maintain compatibility with 625-line, 50 Hz broadcast standards prevalent in PAL regions. In the Video Home System (VHS) format, PAL recordings operated at a standard play (SP) tape speed of 23.39 mm/s, which supported an effective horizontal resolution of approximately 240 television lines, providing acceptable picture quality for home use while prioritizing longer recording times over broadcast-level fidelity.^[39]^[40] VHS players in PAL territories often included quasi-NTSC or PAL-60 playback capability, allowing NTSC tapes to be reproduced by converting the NTSC color signal to a PAL-compatible subcarrier while retaining the 60 Hz field rate and 525 lines, enabling display on PAL TVs with some compatibility limitations and potential color artifacts, or in some models with frame rate conversion to 25 fps that introduces audio pitch shifts. For optical media, PAL DVDs adhered to region-specific encoding under the DVD-Video specification, utilizing a 576-line resolution in either progressive (576p) or interlaced (576i) modes at 25 fps, contrasting with NTSC DVDs' 480-line format at 29.97 fps; this ensured seamless playback on PAL television sets without the need for frame rate conversion.^[41] Betamax and Video 2000 (V2000) formats underwent similar PAL adaptations, with Betamax employing a tape speed of 18.73 mm/s in its standard mode to align with 625-line signals, and V2000 using 24.4 mm/s for enhanced recording durations on double-sided cassettes. Both systems incorporated Macrovision copy protection in later PAL implementations, which modulated the video signal to deter unauthorized duplication onto VHS or other media by introducing distortions visible during analog copying.^[42]^[43]^[44] In hybrid regions like those using PAL-M, the PAL 60 format emerged as a bridge for playback, combining NTSC's 525-line, 60 Hz structure with PAL's 4.43 MHz color subcarrier to enable native reproduction of NTSC content on PAL-M equipment without significant speed adjustments or color phase errors.^[11]

Adoption and Geographic Use

Current and Former PAL Countries

The PAL television broadcasting standard, encompassing variants such as B/G, D, K, and I, was historically adopted across much of Europe, Asia, Africa, and Oceania for analog transmissions.^[25] In Europe, representative countries include Germany (using PAL B/G) and the United Kingdom (using PAL I), where these systems supported widespread color television until the shift to digital broadcasting.^[25] Similarly, in Asia, India employed PAL B, while Australia utilized PAL B/G; in Africa, Nigeria adopted PAL I. Today, these variants persist primarily for legacy analog equipment and compatibility in these regions, as most over-the-air broadcasting has transitioned to digital standards like DVB-T.^[45] The PAL-M variant, adapted to 60 Hz field rates for compatibility with North American-style power systems, was used in South America, notably Brazil and Paraguay. Brazil implemented PAL-M for color broadcasts starting in 1972 and completed its nationwide analog switch-off in June 2025, fully phasing out the system in favor of ISDB-T digital television.^[46] Paraguay, which also employed PAL-M alongside other formats, began its analog blackout in January 2025 in major areas including Asunción and the Central department, with nationwide completion planned by September 2029.^[47]^[48] PAL-N, another 60 Hz adaptation, was standard in Argentina and Uruguay. Argentina's analog shutdown process began in major cities in the 2010s and continues as of November 2025, with remaining transmissions scheduled to end by 2027 during the ongoing ISDB-T rollout.^[48] Uruguay fully terminated PAL-N analog broadcasts in 2015 as part of its digital migration.^[49] Former PAL users include countries that briefly adopted or tested the system before switching to alternatives like SECAM or directly to digital. France, which primarily used SECAM for analog color television, transitioned to digital standards without widespread PAL implementation. The former Soviet Union (USSR) and its successor states relied on SECAM for broadcasting and later moved to digital formats such as DVB-T, rendering any early PAL experiments obsolete.^[49]

Transition to Digital Broadcasting

The transition from analog PAL broadcasting to digital television standards marked a significant evolution in the 2000s, as countries adopting PAL shifted to more efficient digital formats like DVB-T for terrestrial transmission and DVB-C for cable distribution. This global move was motivated by the need to free up radio spectrum for other services, such as mobile communications, while enabling higher-quality broadcasts including HDTV, which exceeded PAL's limitations of standard-definition 576i resolution.^[50]^[51]^[52] In Europe, the switchover progressed region by region, with Germany initiating the process in Berlin in August 2003—the world's first major city to end terrestrial analog signals—and completing the nationwide terrestrial transition by 2008, followed by full analog cessation including cable by 2012. The United Kingdom began its digital rollout in 2007, culminating in the nationwide shutdown of analog terrestrial signals on October 24, 2012. Similar timelines unfolded in Asia and Oceania; Australia, a key PAL adopter, phased out analog transmissions starting in 2010 and finalized the switchover in remote areas by December 2013. These efforts aligned with broader International Telecommunication Union recommendations to complete analog switch-offs by the mid-2010s in developed regions.^[53]^[54]^[55]^[56]^[57] The primary drivers for this transition included digital technology's superior spectral efficiency, allowing multiple standard- and high-definition channels within the bandwidth previously occupied by a single analog PAL signal, alongside improved resistance to interference and support for advanced features like subtitles and data services. Unlike PAL, which was constrained to 625 lines (576 visible) at 50 fields per second for compatibility with black-and-white systems, digital standards facilitated resolutions up to 1080i or higher, enhancing viewer experience without the color phase errors inherent in analog transmission. By 2025, nearly all former PAL countries in Europe and Asia have fully transitioned to digital broadcasting, with over 50 nations completing analog shutdowns by the mid-2010s; however, some South American countries continue phased transitions.^[51]^[50]^[58]^[52] Despite the widespread adoption of digital TV, PAL's legacy endures in niche applications. The PAL video format remains standard for DVDs and legacy video playback devices in former PAL regions, ensuring compatibility with pre-digital content archived at 25 frames per second. Analog PAL signals persist in limited cable TV reruns and older in-flight entertainment systems on select aircraft, where upgrading to digital is cost-prohibitive. In remote islands and underdeveloped areas, such as parts of the Pacific, analog broadcasts continue due to infrastructure challenges, though digital upgrades are progressing; for instance, Norfolk Island enhanced its systems for digital compatibility in 2025. Broadcast engineers also employ PAL signal simulators for testing legacy equipment and ensuring reverse compatibility in hybrid environments.^[59]^[60]^[61]

Comparisons with Other Systems

PAL vs. NTSC

One key difference between PAL and NTSC lies in their color encoding methods, which impacts hue accuracy and artifact reduction. PAL employs phase alternation of the chrominance subcarrier every other line, inverting the phase by ±135° relative to the E'U axis, which inherently corrects for phase errors and enhances color stability.^[7] In contrast, NTSC uses a continuous phase without alternation, fixed at 180° relative to the E'B - E'Y axis, making it more vulnerable to hue shifts from transmission errors or interference.^[7] This phase alternation in PAL significantly reduces artifacts such as "dot crawl," a visible crawling effect at color transitions caused by imperfect separation of luminance and chrominance signals in composite video, which is more prominent in NTSC due to its lack of built-in correction.^[7] In terms of resolution, PAL offers higher vertical detail with 625 total lines per frame (approximately 576 visible), compared to NTSC's 525 total lines (approximately 480 visible), resulting in about 20% greater resolution for stationary images.^[62] However, PAL operates at a 50 Hz field rate (25 frames per second), while NTSC uses 60 Hz (approximately 30 frames per second), leading to more noticeable flicker in PAL under certain lighting conditions, such as fluorescent lamps, due to the lower refresh rate.^[62] PAL's advantages come with trade-offs in transmission and decoding complexity. It requires greater bandwidth for the luminance signal—typically 5 MHz compared to NTSC's 4.2 MHz—necessitating wider channel allocations in broadcast systems. Additionally, PAL decoding demands a one-line delay circuit to average the alternating phases for accurate color reconstruction, increasing hardware complexity, whereas NTSC's simpler fixed-phase modulation allows for more straightforward demodulation without such delay lines.^[7] Perceptually, PAL's symmetric and narrower chrominance bandwidth (around 1.3 MHz for both U and V components) contributes to more saturated and stable colors in practice, avoiding the desaturation or bleeding sometimes seen in NTSC's asymmetric I/Q bands (1.5 MHz for I and 0.5 MHz for Q).^[63]

PAL vs. SECAM

PAL and SECAM represent two distinct analog color television encoding systems developed in Europe during the 1960s, differing fundamentally in their approaches to color signal modulation. PAL employs a phase alternation line method, where the phase of the color difference signal (specifically the R-Y component) is inverted on every alternate line to mitigate phase errors, using quadrature amplitude modulation (QAM) to combine the two color difference signals (R-Y and B-Y) onto a single subcarrier.^[64] In contrast, SECAM utilizes frequency modulation (FM) for the color difference signals, transmitting the Dr (R-Y) signal on one line and the Db (B-Y) signal on the next, with each modulated onto separate subcarriers at frequencies of 4.25 MHz and 4.40625 MHz, respectively, requiring a memory circuit to reconstruct the full color image.^[64] This sequential transmission in SECAM avoids the need for simultaneous quadrature modulation, simplifying certain aspects of decoding but necessitating line-by-line storage. Regarding error handling, SECAM's FM-based modulation provides greater resilience to amplitude noise and distortions common in long-distance transmissions, as the frequency deviations remain intact even if the signal amplitude varies, preserving color information at reduced levels without complete loss.^[65] PAL, relying on phase-sensitive QAM, is more susceptible to amplitude fluctuations that can degrade color saturation, though its phase alternation technique inherently corrects for differential phase errors across lines, offering better overall phase stability in controlled environments.^[64] However, in video recording applications like VCRs, SECAM's FM approach proves less tolerant to velocity errors from tape speed variations, which alter the subcarrier frequency and disrupt color decoding, whereas PAL's amplitude and phase modulation allows for more robust correction through delay lines and comb filtering.^[65] Compatibility between PAL and SECAM is limited due to their incompatible color encoding schemes; SECAM signals cannot be directly decoded by PAL receivers, and vice versa, often requiring transcoders or converters to translate between the systems for cross-regional viewing or recording.^[64] SECAM was primarily adopted in France and much of Eastern Europe, including the Soviet bloc countries, while PAL dominated in West Germany and most other Western European nations, leading to a divided market that complicated equipment trade and content distribution across borders.^[66] The historical rivalry between PAL and SECAM was deeply intertwined with Cold War geopolitics, as the Soviet Union and its Eastern bloc allies selected SECAM partly for political reasons to avoid Western-originated standards like the German-developed PAL, fostering technological alignment with France as a counter to U.S. influence through NTSC.^[67] France promoted SECAM aggressively through diplomatic channels and patent-sharing agreements, securing its adoption in the Eastern bloc despite PAL's technical advantages in color fidelity and simpler decoding in some contexts, ultimately allowing PAL to prevail in the broader Western market due to Germany's economic influence and standardization efforts within the European Broadcasting Union.^[66]

References

[1]
What are the NTSC, PAL, and SECAM video format standards? - Sony
Jun 4, 2025 · A PAL picture is made up of 625 interlaced lines and is displayed at a rate of 25 frames per second. SECAM is an abbreviation for Sequential ...
[2]
What is PAL Format: Is It the Best Encoding Standard - AnyMP4
Dec 11, 2024 · PAL, the abbreviation for Phase Alternate Line, is a color encoding system for analog television, which is one of the three main standards for ...
[3]
What's the difference between NTSC and PAL? - Smp-ltd.com
Mar 14, 2023 · PAL is the video standard most commonly used in many European and Asian countries. PAL stands for Phase Alternating Line. The main difference ...<|control11|><|separator|>
[4]
None
### Summary of PAL Color Television System from Rec. ITU-R BT.470-6
[5]
[PDF] Conventional Analog Television - An Introduction
This is to reduce color errors that occur from amplitude and phase distortion of the color modulation sidebands during transmission. Saying this more ...Missing: explanation | Show results with:explanation
[6]
None
### Summary of PAL Colour Television System Specifications (ITU-R BT.470-5)
[7]
[PDF] Principles of operation of video encoders and decoders in the ...
EBU Technical Review Summer 1993. EBU TUTORIAL. 3.3. Use of comb filters. 3.3.1. General considerations. It has been seen that the introduction of comb filters ...Missing: specifications | Show results with:specifications
[8]
World Analogue Television Standards and Waveforms
### Summary of PAL Origins and Adoption
[9]
45 Years Anniversary of Walter Bruch's PAL Color Television
May 4, 2008 · The simple PAL (“Volks-PAL”) system, which operated without a delay line and relied on the human eye to average out the phase errors. Flickering ...Missing: explanation | Show results with:explanation
[10]
Pal System - Telecomponents
The majority of countries using PAL have television standards with 625 lines and 50 fields per second, differences concern the audio carrier frequency and ...
[11]
50 years of color TV in Germany – DW – 08/25/2017
Aug 25, 2017 · West Germany had to wait until 1967 for color TV broadcasts. Viewers long remained skeptical - but the new technology eventually caught on.<|control11|><|separator|>
[12]
None
### Summary of PAL Adoption from Rec. ITU-R BT.470-6
[13]
[PDF] 1 The CCIR, the standards and the TV sets' market in France (1948 ...
Indeed from 1948, when black and white television standards were discussed during a meeting in Stockholm to 1966 when color TV standards were debated in Oslo, ...
[14]
How the PAL Colour Video System Works
In the PAL system, the phase of the R-Y component is inverted on alternate lines (hence "Phase Alternating Line"). This has the effect of reflecting the ...Missing: YUV | Show results with:YUV
[15]
Conditioning A/V Signals for RF Modulation - Analog Devices
Jun 23, 2005 · Notch filtering causes color to change by altering the color-subcarrier phase. To correct it, several first-order delay stages must be added. To ...
[16]
[PDF] EBU Tech 3213-1975 EBU chromaticity tolerances for studio monitors
Existing standards for the colorimetry of studio monitors in 625-line/50-field systems are related to the reference white obtained when all three types of ...
[17]
None
### Summary of Analog PAL Decoding Techniques from the Document
[18]
US4343017A - Decoding composite PAL television signals
A composite PAL television signal decoder comprises a first delay device for delaying an input PAL television signal A by one horizontal line scan period ...
[19]
https://patents.google.com/patent/US4343017A/en
[20]
[PDF] PAL Decoder Servicing
Because the subcarrier is suppressed at the transmitter, to be able to demodulate the signal it's necessary to regenerate in the decoder a carrier which is ...
[21]
US4024572A - PAL alternate line color phase detector
In practice, this can be done by controlling the local subcarrier frequency with an APC loop which compares the bursts of the two subcarrier signals. In PAL, ...
[22]
Color Subcarrier - an overview | ScienceDirect Topics
The horizontal and vertical timing is the same as (M) NTSC; color encoding uses the PAL modulation format and a 4.43361875-MHz color subcarrier frequency.
[23]
[PDF] Television co-channel interference: PAL transmissions - BBC
Thi s report is concerned with the effects of co-channel interference with PAL colour trans- missions (on the 625-line standard), with particular.
[24]
[PDF] REPORT ITU-R BT.2043 - Analogue television systems currently in ...
This Report provides information on analogue television systems currently in use throughout the world. An explanation of the signs used in the Table is ...Missing: CCIR BGDKI
[25]
Primeira transmissão em cores na TV brasileira completa 53 anos
Feb 19, 2025 · O desfile da Festa Nacional da Uva, em Caxias do Sul, na Serra Gaúcha, foi a primeira transmissão em cores no país. A Globo exibiu o cortejo, ...
[26]
https://www.gov.br/cultura/pt-br/assuntos/noticias/primeira-transmissao-em-cores-na-tv-brasileira-completa-53-anos
[27]
405 Alive - FAQ - 405-Line Television in History
The 405-line standard was used in the UK, the republic of Ireland, Hong Kong and experimentally in several other countries.
[28]
British Experiments with NTSC Color - Early Television Museum
A black & white telerecording of a BBC Television experimental colour transmission on 31 January 1957, which was broadcast and shown to a large audience of ...Missing: interference | Show results with:interference
[29]
[PDF] A delay line for PAL colour television receivers ..' - Pearl HiFi
If colour errors are to be avoided a delay line that gives an extremely accurate phase delay must be used. The subject of the present article is an ultrasonic ...Missing: 1960s | Show results with:1960s
[30]
[PDF] Ultrasonic delay lines for the PAL colour-television system - Pure
An advantage of the liquid line was the ease with which the delay time could be varied. The first glass delay line was developed during the same period in ...
[31]
TVFAQ: More information about watching NTSC video on PAL systems
Most VHS VCRs had NTSC 4.43 playback, you could get multi-region TVs which had support for PAL, SECAM, NTSC 4.43 and NTSC 3.58. I had a multi-region Daewoo TV ...
[32]
PAL and NTSC 1980s VCRs
Aug 10, 2018 · One thing is multistandard or multisystem VCRs, another is standards conversion. The earliest one I had was a JVC HR -7600 PAL/SECAM /NTSC.Anyone have experience with SECAM VHS?SECAM vs MESECAM - What's the diffrence?More results from www.vintage-radio.netMissing: era | Show results with:era
[33]
US4438451A - Dual-standard SECAM/PAL color TV receiver with ...
Dual-standard (PAL/SECAM) color TV receiver includes circuitry for automatically controlling the receiver's operating mode in accordance with recognition of ...
[34]
The saga of the SCART and how to make it digital! - Canford Audio
This was intended to interconnect a home television system much in the same way that hi-fi systems were interconnected.
[35]
[PDF] REPORT ITU-R BT.2140-12 - Transition from analogue to digital ...
Dec 31, 2012 · standard resolution pictures, data delivery, interactive communication, portable and mobile services, ... 720×576 (PAL)-standard definition ...
[36]
LCD TV put on market total EU, incl prognoses - ResearchGate
The sales trend in Brazil, Ukraine, Turkey and Russia shows clearly that also in low income countries LCD TVs increasingly start to replace CRTs. Also from the ...
[37]
New life for old TV screens - CORDIS - European Union
Sep 25, 2013 · The GLASS PLUS project recovers CRT glass from old TVs and uses it to make ceramic tiles, reducing waste and creating new value.
[38]
[PDF] Video Cassette Recorder - Sony
Tape speed. SP: PAL. 23.39 mm/s (recording/ playback). NTSC 33.35 mm/s (recording (Line input only)*/playback). LP: PAL. 11.70 mm/s (recording/ playback). NTSC ...
[39]
What Is The Resolution On VHS Tape | AVForums
Oct 22, 2004 · VHS LP may drop to around 180. SVHS LP may drop to around 350. Depends on the machine. More probably, LP will result in increased noise, rather ...
[40]
capturing ntsc tapes from pal-60 vcr - VideoHelp Forum
Feb 23, 2020 · Some Pioneer and Sony DVD-Recorders can record PAL-60 to NTSC DVDs, and also output a NTSC signal when passed a PAL-60 signal.
[41]
DVD video details
MPEG-1 CBR and VBR video is also allowed. 525/60 (NTSC, 29.97 interlaced frames/sec) and 625/50 (PAL, 25 interlaced frames/sec) video systems are supported.<|separator|>
[42]
The Betamax Format - Media College
Technical Specifications ; Tape speed: 1.873 cm/s ; Cassette Size: 156 X 96 X 25 mm ; Record Time: Up to 215 minutes. Most standard Betamax tapes are 60 minutes.
[43]
The V2000 Format
The V2000 Format ; Tape Speed (PAL), 2.44 cm/s ; Video Head Gap, 0.4 microns ; Audio Track Width, 0.65 mm ; Audio Frequency Response, 50Hz - 10kHz ; Cue Track Width ...
[44]
Copy protection akin to Macrovision on Betamax? - Reddit
May 1, 2021 · In this case, Macrovision was used to prevent VHS copies of that Beta tape, much less a VHS to VHS copy.Missing: PAL format adaptations
[45]
What are the video format standards used in different countries ...
Nov 1, 2024 · There are three major video format standards used around the world: National Television System Committee ( NTSC, Phase Alternating Line (PAL), and Sequential ...Missing: specifications | Show results with:specifications
[46]
[PDF] Transition from analogue to digital terrestrial television broadcasting
Dec 31, 2012 · It provides an overview of digital terrestrial sound and television broadcasting technologies and system migration.
[47]
Argentina delays analogue switch-off to mid-2025 - Telecompaper
Jul 4, 2023 · Argentina delays analogue switch-off to mid-2025 ... Argentina has announced a further delay to the process to switch off analogue transmissions ...Missing: shutdown | Show results with:shutdown
[48]
Digital Television - Federal Communications Commission
Aug 9, 2016 · An important benefit of the switch to all-digital broadcasting is that parts of the valuable broadcast spectrum have been freed up for public ...
[49]
Surviving The Switch To Digital TV - Forbes
Dec 4, 2008 · The “digital switchover” brings with it higher image quality, better sound and a level of versatility and flexibility previously unattainable ...
[50]
NTSC vs. PAL: A Comparison of Analog Television Formats - Aiseesoft
Mar 11, 2024 · NTSC and PAL are different analog television broadcast standards that were used to transmit color information.
[51]
The Dawn of Digital TV - IEEE Spectrum
Oct 3, 2005 · In Germany, Berlin killed off analog in 2003, Munich did it this year [see photo, "Getting Ready”], and the rest of the nation is scheduled to ...
[52]
EU Member States on course for analogue terrestrial TV switch-off
Feb 15, 2009 · Switch-off has already been completed in five Member States (Germany ... C (switch-off date: end 2012 or earlier). BE (Brussels capital area) ...
[53]
Analogue TV signals to end in October 2012 - BBC News
Oct 14, 2011 · Analogue TV signals will no longer be broadcast after 24 October 2012 as the UK completes its conversion to digital television.Missing: date | Show results with:date
[54]
Analogue TV to be switched off in October 2012 - The Guardian
Oct 14, 2011 · The UK's analogue TV era will come to an end on 24 October 2012, it has been announced. Eighty years from the first experimental broadcasts.
[55]
Australia's last remaining analogue TV transmitters switched off
Dec 10, 2013 · Australia's last remaining analogue TV transmitters switched off · Tue 10 Dec 2013 at 1:01am · Tue 10 Dec 2013 at 1:01am · Tue 10 Dec 2013 at 12: ...
[56]
Nearly 50 Countries Switch Off Analog TV - ATSC : NextGen TV
Jul 7, 2015 · 48 countries have switched to digital TV, including Luxembourg, Andorra, Finland, Sweden, Switzerland, Germany, and Norway.
[57]
NTSC vs PAL: Which Is Better for YouTube, DVDs, and Streaming?
Oct 2, 2025 · Originally designed as analog television broadcast standards, their legacy still shapes today's digital video, affecting frame rates, ...
[58]
PAL Full Form: What is PAL Format? - VXG
PAL, which stands for Phase Alternating Line, is a color encoding system used in analog television broadcasts and video formats in various parts of the world.
[59]
Upgrade TV Broadcasting Aerials 2025 Mt Pitt - Norfolk Online News
May 30, 2025 · As Australia now has digital broadcasting systems, the Norfolk Island aerials have been upgraded so they can link, via satellite to the new ...
[60]
[PDF] characteristics of systems for monochrome and colour television - ITU
(*) For the SECAM system, it is allowable to apply a correction to reduce interference distortions between the luminance and chrominance signals by an.
[61]
[PDF] Rec. 601 - the origins of the 4:2:2 DTV standard - EBU tech
AA/11 (Mod F): Encoding parameters of digital television for studios” was adopted by the ITU-R/CCIR Plenary Assembly in February 1982. It described the digital ...
[62]
[PDF] NTSC, PAL, and SECAM Overview - Go ELECTRONICS
The hue and saturation information is transmitted using a 3.58-MHz subcarrier, encoded so that the receiver can separate the hue, saturation, and luminance ...
[63]
SECAM Television Broadcasting System - Telecomponents
This is normally done using a delay line like in SECAM (the result is called PAL D or PAL Delay-Line, sometimes interpreted as DeLuxe), but can be accomplished ...<|control11|><|separator|>
[64]
[PDF] European Policies Toward HDTV - Jeffrey Hart
Most of Western Europe adopted the. PAL standard, while France and the Soviet Bloc adopted SECAM (CRANE,. 1979; NOAM, 1991, pp. 294-296). (1) It should be ...
[65]
Cold War techno-diplomacy. Selling French Colour Television to the ...
The SECAM system exemplifies France's Cold War techno-political diplomacy, promoting strategic cooperation with the Soviet Union. French leaders prioritized ...