Fact-checked by Grok 2 weeks ago

Pine Tree Flag

The Pine Tree Flag, also known as the Appeal to Heaven flag, is a colonial American maritime ensign displaying a green pine tree centered on a white field with the motto "An Appeal to Heaven" inscribed above it. First commissioned by George Washington in October 1775 for a squadron of six schooners tasked with patrolling the Massachusetts coast and disrupting British supply lines, the flag embodied early Revolutionary resolve.^[1]^[2] In April 1776, the Massachusetts Provincial Council formally adopted it as the official ensign for the state's naval forces, distinguishing American privateers from British vessels.^[3] The pine tree emblem drew from New England's logging heritage and longstanding colonial grievances against the British Crown's White Pine Acts, which from 1691 reserved the tallest white pines for Royal Navy masts, restricting local timber use and sparking resistance including the 1772 Pine Tree Riot in New Hampshire.^[4] This symbol predated the Revolution, appearing on provincial currency and seals as a marker of regional identity and economic autonomy. The flag's design thus fused practical naval utility with ideological defiance, predating the Stars and Stripes and serving as one of the earliest distinctly American banners.^[5] The motto originates in John Locke's Second Treatise of Government (1689), where he posits that when earthly appeals against tyranny fail, individuals possess a natural right to "appeal to heaven" through force to reclaim violated liberties, providing philosophical underpinning for colonial independence.^[6] Post-Revolution, pine tree motifs persisted in state heraldry, influencing flags of Massachusetts, Maine, and Vermont into the 20th century, while the full design has seen periodic revival in historical commemorations.^[4]

Historical Origins

Colonial Context and the Pine Tree Symbol

In the late 17th century, the British Crown sought to secure superior timber for its Royal Navy amid growing naval demands, enacting policies that reserved the tallest and straightest white pines in New England for mast production. The 1691 Massachusetts Charter included a mast preservation clause designating any white pine tree measuring 12 inches or more in diameter at 12 inches from the ground as Crown property, prohibiting colonial harvest without permission.^[7] Subsequent White Pine Acts in 1711, 1722, and 1729 expanded these restrictions across colonies like New Hampshire and Maine, fining violators heavily and deploying surveyors to mark reserved trees with the broad arrow symbol.^[8] These measures clashed with local economies reliant on lumber for shipbuilding, housing, and trade, fostering widespread resentment as colonists frequently ignored markings and smuggled timber, viewing the laws as arbitrary interference in resource use.^[9] Tensions culminated in the Pine Tree Riot on April 14, 1772, in Weare, New Hampshire, where approximately 40 colonists, their faces blackened for anonymity, confronted enforcement agents attempting to seize illegally cut pines. The group raided the home of deputy sheriff Benjamin Whiting, beat him and surveyor John Quigley, then proceeded to fell over 30 marked white pine trees on nearby properties as a direct rebuke to royal authority.^[10] Though no fatalities occurred, the incident prompted Crown reprisals, including militia mobilization, but trials in September 1772 resulted in minimal fines of 20 shillings each for the few identified participants, reflecting judicial leniency amid colonial sympathies.^[11] This event, predating the Boston Tea Party by 18 months, exemplified early organized defiance against perceived economic overreach, galvanizing anti-British sentiment in New England without broader violence.^[12] The white pine thus evolved into a potent emblem of New England regionalism and autonomy, rooted in practical lumber interests rather than abstract ideals, distinguishing it from icons like the Liberty Tree associated with urban protests in Boston. By the 1770s, the tree symbolized defiance against resource extraction policies that prioritized imperial needs over colonial self-sufficiency, appearing in local currencies such as the 1652 Pine Tree Shilling issued by Massachusetts Bay Colony.^[10] This economic grievance underscored causal pressures for independence, as Britain's enforcement alienated timber-dependent communities, fostering a distinct identity tied to forested independence rather than metropolitan grievances.^[13]

Development of the "An Appeal to Heaven" Motto

The phrase "An Appeal to Heaven" originates in John Locke's Second Treatise of Government (1689), where he describes the remedy available to people when rulers violate natural rights and no impartial earthly judge exists to adjudicate the grievance: "The People have no other remedy in this, as in all other cases where they have no Judge on Earth, but to appeal to Heaven."^[14] Locke frames this appeal—drawing on the biblical example of Jephthah in Judges 11—as legitimizing resistance against tyrannical power that undermines the social contract's purpose of preserving life, liberty, and property. This concept posits that ultimate recourse lies beyond human institutions, invoking divine authority to validate corrective action when government dissolves into arbitrary rule.^[15] In the American colonial context, Locke's idea provided a philosophical rationale for challenging British policies perceived as infringing on inherent rights, shifting from legal petitions to moral imperatives rooted in natural law.^[6] Colonists adapted the phrase to articulate that persistent earthly appeals failing against systemic abuses necessitated higher adjudication, emphasizing self-preservation as a causal consequence of unremedied violations rather than mere declarative protest.^[16] Early documentary evidence of the phrase's circulation appears in Puritan-influenced writings, blending Lockean theory with providential theology. Isaac Backus employed it in his 1773 pamphlet An Appeal to the Public for Religious Liberty, contending that oaths invoking divine vengeance underscored the right to resist civil impositions on conscience, as "appeal to heaven by oaths, and to invoke assistance from thence to avenge the cause of the injured upon the guilty."^[17] Reverend Jonas Clark further integrated it into revolutionary discourse in his April 19, 1776, sermon on the Lexington engagement, stating "The sword is an appeal to heaven," to portray armed defense as providentially endorsed retribution against unprovoked aggression.^[18] These instances illustrate the motto's evolution from abstract treatise to a concise emblem of justified defiance, prioritizing verifiable grievances over rhetorical flourish.^[19]

Design and Symbolism

Visual Elements and Specifications

The Pine Tree Flag features a white field with a central green pine tree and the motto "AN APPEAL TO HEAVEN" inscribed in black capital letters above the tree.^[3]^[20] The design originates from a description in correspondence dated October 20, 1775, by Colonel Joseph Reed, aide to General George Washington, who proposed a white background distinguished by a green pine tree for use on colonial cruisers.^[13]^[21] No original flags survive, leading to reconstructions based on textual accounts; these typically depict the pine tree as an evergreen with a trunk and branches, though variations range from realistic foliage to stylized forms.^[3] The motto appears in all caps, often arched or horizontally aligned across the upper portion of the field, with the tree occupying the central vertical space.^[20] Historical specifications lack precise proportions, but contemporary reproductions commonly adhere to a 2:3 aspect ratio, reflecting standard ensign dimensions of the era.^[22] This differs empirically from contemporaneous pine tree flags, such as those on blue grounds used by British forces, by its white field and motto placement.^[23]

Philosophical and Practical Meanings

The pine tree emblem on the flag signified colonial resistance to British Crown policies that restricted access to natural resources essential for local economies and self-sufficiency. Enacted through the White Pine Acts starting in 1691, these laws reserved straight white pines over 24 inches in diameter for Royal Navy masts, marking trees with the broad arrow symbol and prohibiting colonial logging or export, which colonists viewed as exploitative overreach infringing on property rights.^[24] Practical defiance manifested in events like unauthorized tree felling, transforming the pine into a symbol of sovereignty over timberlands vital for shipbuilding and trade, thereby representing economic independence from monarchical extraction.^[25] This imagery underscored a causal link between resource control and broader liberty, where denial of utilitarian forest use fueled arguments for self-governance rooted in empirical grievances over arbitrary authority.^[10] The motto "An Appeal to Heaven" derived from John Locke's Second Treatise of Government (1689), articulating that when earthly judges or governments fail to redress tyranny—due to corruption or dissolution of legal recourse—individuals retain a natural right to self-defense and resistance, invoking divine justice as the ultimate arbiter.^[6] Locke posited this appeal not as fanaticism but as a reasoned escalation after exhausted petitions, aligning with causal realism in governance where persistent institutional failure justifies reversion to first principles of consent and self-preservation.^[16] In the flag's context, it philosophically justified revolutionary action against perceived British violations of colonial charters and assemblies, emphasizing unalienable rights over subjection to distant rule.^[26] Collectively, the flag embodied a synthesis of practical utility and philosophical imperative: the pine tree's defiance against resource tyranny paired with the motto's endorsement of higher moral authority for redress, prioritizing verifiable Lockean influences on colonial thought over unsubstantiated providential narratives. This dual symbolism promoted a truth-oriented framework where liberty stemmed from empirical protection of life, liberty, and property, rather than deference to imperfect human institutions.^[27]

Adoption and Use in the American Revolution

Initial Naval Deployment

In October 1775, George Washington authorized the arming of six schooners to intercept British supply vessels supplying Boston, forming an early colonial naval force amid the Siege of Boston.^[28] These vessels, crewed primarily by skilled fishermen from ports like Marblehead, Massachusetts, operated under Washington's direct commission to disrupt Royal Navy logistics despite lacking formal congressional authority.^[29] The Pine Tree Flag served as the ensign for this squadron, with its design outlined in a letter from Washington's aide, Colonel Joseph Reed, to Colonel John Moylan on October 20, 1775, specifying a white field bearing a green pine tree and the motto "An Appeal to Heaven."^[13] John Glover's Marblehead Regiment provided key personnel for ships such as the Lynch and Franklin, leveraging their seafaring proficiency to execute raids effectively.^[30] This deployment yielded tangible results, including the capture of British transports like the Nancy on November 29, 1775, which supplied gunpowder to the Continental Army, underscoring the flag's association with initial maritime successes against superior British naval power.^[28] The ensign facilitated identification among allied vessels, fostering coordinated action and signaling resolute colonial independence to both crews and adversaries in asymmetric coastal warfare.^[27]

Association with Key Figures and Colonies

The Massachusetts Provincial Council, successor to the Provincial Congress, formally adopted the Pine Tree Flag as the official ensign for its naval vessels on April 29, 1776, resolving that it feature a white field with a green pine tree and the motto "An Appeal to Heaven" to distinguish state cruisers from British merchant ships.^[31]^[20] This endorsement replaced earlier provisional colors used by colonial forces and symbolized New England's unified resistance to British naval dominance, galvanizing maritime efforts in the early Revolutionary War.^[32] Prominent Massachusetts revolutionaries, including Samuel Adams, a key delegate in the Provincial Congress and advocate for colonial autonomy, contributed to the flag's promotion as an emblem of republican virtue and defiance against monarchical overreach, drawing on longstanding New England traditions of using the pine tree to represent economic independence and liberty.^[33] John Adams, similarly engaged in congressional deliberations on independence, echoed these ideals in writings influenced by John Locke's natural rights philosophy, which underpinned the flag's motto and framed appeals to divine justice over earthly tyranny as a moral imperative for self-governance.^[33] Their involvement in bodies endorsing such symbols helped embed the flag in the broader narrative of New England exceptionalism and resistance. The flag's adoption extended regionally, with Connecticut and Rhode Island privateers employing variants during 1776–1777 operations, as evidenced by contemporary accounts of New England vessels capturing British prizes under pine tree ensigns, which facilitated mustering crews and signaling allegiance before the Continental Congress's June 1777 shift toward striped precursors to the Stars and Stripes.^[34]^[35] These uses underscored the flag's role in coordinating inter-colonial naval actions, though documentation like prize logs and Admiralty reports confirms its prevalence waned post-1777 as unified national standards emerged.^[31]

Influence on Later American Symbols

Integration into State Flags

The pine tree motif from the revolutionary Pine Tree Flag persisted in Massachusetts state iconography well into the modern era, symbolizing regional heritage and colonial resistance to external control. The state's naval ensign, adopted as a variant of the 1775 design, continues to feature a green pine tree on a white field, serving as the official flag for Massachusetts maritime forces and reflecting unbroken continuity with pre-independence naval traditions. On the civil flag, the reverse side from 1908 to 1971 displayed a blue shield with a green pine tree, distinct from the obverse coat of arms, until a 1971 legislative redesign mandated the arms on both sides for uniformity, though the pine retained prominence in state seals and naval usage.^[36] In Maine, statehood in 1820 as a separation from Massachusetts prompted adoption of symbols evoking shared New England lumber heritage without direct revolutionary mottos. The 1901 state flag featured a green pine tree centered on a buff field with a blue North Star in the canton, legislated as the official banner to honor the white pine's economic and symbolic role in the state's forestry industry, which had been central to colonial grievances over British mast laws.^[37] This design endured until 1909, when it was replaced amid debates over visibility and aesthetics, but the pine tree motif reemerged in Maine's naval ensign and influenced later seal elements, underscoring post-independence adaptation of anti-authoritarian symbolism into civic identity. This pattern extended across New England, where pine tree elements in state seals and auxiliary flags—such as Vermont's 1777-1923 designs incorporating pines amid rural motifs—reinforced a collective ethos of self-reliance and defiance rooted in 17th- and 18th-century resource disputes, evolving into emblems of regional autonomy rather than transient rebellion.^[7]

Regional Variations and Adaptations

In Vermont, flags associated with the Green Mountain Boys militia, formed in the early 1770s under Ethan Allen to contest New York land claims, incorporated pine tree motifs to evoke the state's dense forests and self-reliance. These designs often featured a central pine tree amid a forest backdrop or with 14 branches symbolizing the original resisting settlements, rendered on a green field distinct from the white backgrounds of Massachusetts naval prototypes.^[38] This adaptation emphasized topographic symbolism over maritime appeal, aligning with the group's land-based insurgencies documented in period accounts from 1775 onward.^[4] New Hampshire's early state seal, devised by the First Provincial Congress in 1775, positioned a pine tree beside an upright fish and a bundle of five arrows, underscoring the colony's intertwined timber exports and fishing industries as economic pillars.^[39] Retained in the 1776 constitutional seal, this configuration diverged from singular-tree naval flags by integrating heraldic elements like arrows for unity, with the pine denoting mast-quality white pines reserved under British naval policies until the Revolution. Archival designs confirm the tree's prominence as a static emblem in seals rather than flying banners, persisting into post-independence iconography without revolutionary mottoes.^[40] Maine, after achieving statehood in 1820 from Massachusetts territory, adapted the pine motif in its inaugural state flag of 1901, displaying a green pine tree on a buff field accented by a blue star in the canton to signify northern isolation and endurance. Designed amid efforts to codify distinct identity, this version modified revolutionary precedents by centering the tree without accompanying text or stripes, reflecting archival emphases on the white pine's role in local shipbuilding records from the colonial era.^[41] The flag's use until 1909 highlighted regional customization, prioritizing state-specific celestial markers over broader New England naval heritage.^[42] These variations preserved the pine's core representation of natural abundance and defiance rooted in 17th-century English colonial exemptions for New England mast trees, yet tailored field colors, supplementary icons, and contexts to local militias, seals, or post-federal emblems, eschewing uniform national applications.^[4]

Modern Revival and Usage

20th Century Reappearances

The Pine Tree Flag maintained a presence in official American symbolism through much of the 20th century, notably on the reverse side of the Massachusetts state flag from its adoption in 1908 until the design's revision in 1971, where it appeared as a green pine tree centered on a blue shield.^[43] This configuration evoked the flag's colonial maritime origins while serving as a state naval ensign element.^[44] In 1968, the United States Postal Service featured the flag on a 6-cent stamp as part of its Historic American Flags series, specifically illustrating its use by George Washington's squadron of cruisers in 1775, thereby commemorating its Revolutionary War role for a national audience.^[45]^[46] Such instances reflected sporadic, historically oriented revivals rather than broad cultural resurgence, with replicas occasionally employed by vexillological and heritage organizations for educational purposes, underscoring the flag's niche endurance in pre-digital era commemorations.^[47]

21st Century Political and Cultural Adoption

In the 2010s, the Appeal to Heaven flag gained renewed prominence through the efforts of apostolic leader Dutch Sheets, who published the book An Appeal to Heaven in 2015, framing it as a symbol for intercessory prayer aimed at spiritual and governmental reformation in the United States.^[48] Sheets' initiative, including public rallies and flag distributions, positioned the banner as a call to invoke divine intervention in national affairs, drawing on its Revolutionary-era origins to inspire contemporary activism.^[49] The flag appeared at various political gatherings supporting former President Donald Trump, including a "Trump victory center" in November 2020 and rallies where participants displayed it alongside other historical American symbols. On January 6, 2021, during events at the U.S. Capitol, footage and reports documented its presence among protesters, often carried by individuals invoking themes of resistance and liberty.^[6] Its visibility extended to official settings, such as flying outside U.S. Supreme Court Justice Samuel Alito's New Jersey beach house in 2023, as confirmed by photographs and Alito's statement attributing the display to his wife.^[50] ^[1] By 2024, the flag had surfaced in legislative contexts, with reports of Rhode Island state senators placing it on their desks as a nod to founding principles and resilience.^[51] This adoption reflected a broader cultural revival among groups emphasizing originalist interpretations of American symbolism, though displays varied from private properties to public offices without uniform institutional endorsement.^[52]

Controversies and Debates

Associations with Contemporary Movements

The Appeal to Heaven flag has been embraced by Christian nationalist groups in the 21st century as a symbol of appealing to divine authority against perceived secular overreach, often framed as aligning with biblical governance principles in resisting modern federal authority.^[53]^[54] This adoption draws on the flag's historical motto to underscore themes of ultimate recourse beyond human institutions, appearing at rallies and events promoting religious liberty and limited government.^[55] In broader conservative and patriotic circles, the flag serves as an emblem of defiance against centralized power, with displays at political gatherings including Trump campaign centers in November 2020.^[1] Proponents invoke its Revolutionary War origins to advocate for individual rights and resistance to overregulation, distinct from its religious interpretations.^[6] In Maine, debates over state symbolism in 2023 led to legislative efforts to revive a pine tree design reminiscent of the 1901–1909 flag, emphasizing historical defiance and regional identity without the "Appeal to Heaven" motto, though ultimately rejected by voters in a November 2024 referendum where over 55% opposed the change.^[56]^[57] Fringe elements, such as the eco-fascist Pine Tree Party established in 2017, have appropriated pine tree imagery for accelerationist and environmentally extremist ideologies promoting violence against industrial society, representing a marginal usage with negligible ties to the flag's core revolutionary symbolism.^[58]^[59]

Criticisms from Media and Opponents

Media outlets including CNN and Rolling Stone have portrayed the Appeal to Heaven flag, also known as the Pine Tree Flag, as a symbol of far-right extremism and Christian nationalism, primarily citing its visibility during the January 6, 2021, Capitol riot and subsequent displays by conservative figures. A May 31, 2024, CNN article highlighted the flag's "controversial" status, linking it to riot participants and its 2023 appearance at U.S. Supreme Court Justice Samuel Alito's New Jersey vacation home, where it was flown amid debates over judicial impartiality.^[6] Similarly, a November 10, 2023, Rolling Stone piece described House Speaker Mike Johnson's office display as emblematic of Christian nationalism, tying it to ties with the New Apostolic Reformation (NAR), a movement critics characterize as promoting "spiritual warfare" and dominionist theology over democratic processes.^[60] These characterizations often extrapolate from selective contemporary associations to infer inherent ideological intent, despite the flag's origins as a Revolutionary War naval ensign invoking John Locke's right to revolution against tyranny.^[6] Critics such as Religion Dispatches contributor Frederick Clarkson have extended this to frame the flag as an "emblem for an extensive spiritual warfare campaign," associating it with NAR's alleged anti-democratic aims following Alito's flag incident on May 22, 2024.^[61] Progressive commentator Steve Ahlquist, in a June 13, 2024, Substack post, questioned its placement on Rhode Island senators' desks, interpreting the Lockean motto as a veiled endorsement of revolutionary rhetoric amid partisan tensions, though without evidence of explicit calls to overthrow governance.^[51] Such critiques frequently overlook the flag's non-exclusive use across ideological lines, including at non-partisan historical reenactments, and rely on guilt-by-association with events like January 6, where it appeared alongside diverse symbols but not as a predominant or coordinating banner. In regional contexts, media coverage has generalized these associations, conflating the Appeal to Heaven flag with distinct designs like Maine's 1901–1909 state pine tree flag, which lacks the motto and evokes lumber industry heritage rather than theological appeals. A May 28, 2024, Bangor Daily News report noted this lumping during Maine's June 2024 flag referendum, where opponents invoked national "Christian nationalist" fears to oppose restoring the historical design, despite vexillological experts affirming their separate evolutions.^[62] This overgeneralization amplified unfounded extremism claims, contributing to the referendum's rejection by 55% of voters on November 5, 2024, as reported by local outlets, though primary voter motivations centered on design preferences over ideological stigma.^[57] Mainstream media's pattern of such linkages reflects broader institutional tendencies toward interpretive framing that prioritizes narrative alignment over granular historical differentiation.

Defenses Based on Historical Precedence

Defenders of the Pine Tree Flag, also known as the Appeal to Heaven flag, emphasize its origins in the American Revolutionary War as a symbol of resistance against perceived tyranny, drawing directly from John Locke's Second Treatise of Government (1689), where the phrase "appeal to heaven" justifies rebellion when earthly remedies fail to protect natural rights.^[62] The flag was commissioned by George Washington on September 13, 1775, for six schooners forming the first vessels of the Continental Navy, featuring a green pine tree on a white field with the motto, representing New England's mast trade defiance of British naval restrictions under the White Pines Act of 1721 and broader appeals for divine sanction in armed self-defense.^[16] Historical advocates, such as Maine State Senate candidate Eric Brakey, argue that the flag's core meaning remains "defiance to tyranny" rooted in colonial texts and Washington's authorization, rejecting overlays from contemporary associations as accretions that ignore verifiable founding intent.^[62] This precedence aligns with Locke's causal framework, wherein symbols of revolution—evident in the flag's use by Washington's cruisers capturing British vessels in 1775—affirm the right to forceful recourse absent corruption of original principles, prioritizing empirical origins over politicized reinterpretations.^[16] Such defenses highlight the flag's role in underscoring Lockean rights to life, liberty, and property, which fueled revolutionary successes like the Declaration of Independence (1776), countering dismissals that conflate historical patriotism with modern extremism by insisting on fidelity to primary sources over biased institutional narratives.^[62]^[16]

References

[1]
Appeal to Heaven flag: History, symbolism and controversy | AP News
May 23, 2024 · Six schooners outfitted by George Washington to intercept ... “The Appeal to Heaven flag is a critical, important part of American history.
[2]
https://www.americanflags.com/blog/post/an-appeal-to-heaven-flag-meaning
[3]
Appeal to Heaven Flag from Revolutionary War in Headlines
Jul 1, 2025 · Adopted by Massachusetts Navy: Fittingly, the Massachusetts Provincial Council in April 1776 officially adopted the pine tree flag (with the ...<|control11|><|separator|>
[4]
Flags of Bunker Hill: Banners of Liberty - National Park Service
May 30, 2025 · All three flags included a pine tree. New Englanders adopted the pine tree icon to symbolize their independent economic power, which came partly ...
[5]
AN APPEAL TO HEAVEN: The history behind the flag
Oct 3, 2025 · The pine tree symbolized the New England colonists' home. The pine tree had long been used as a symbol of Massachusetts during the colonial ...Missing: origins | Show results with:origins
[6]
The history behind the controversial 'Appeal to Heaven' flag - CNN
May 31, 2024 · As for the pine tree, it became a symbol of American resistance after the Pine Tree Riot, one of several clashes between American colonists ...
[7]
https://www.gettysburgflag.com/blog/the-story-behind-the-pine-tree-flags-of-the-american-revolution/
[8]
The King's Board Arrow Acts: Mast Trees for the Royal Navy
Starting in 1691, the Royal Government restricted the cutting of white pines over 24" in diameter. Subsequent British Parliament Acts in 1711, 1722 and 1772 ...
[9]
Eastern White Pine: The Roots of American Independence - NELMA
Under British law, any white pine tree measuring 24 inches or more in diameter at a foot above the ground was the property of the King. These trees were marked ...
[10]
The Pine Tree Riot of 1772 | Summary & Explanation
The clause stated that all white pine trees in New Hampshire under 24 inches were reserved for the British Crown – and this restriction was later reduced to 12 ...Missing: details | Show results with:details
[11]
The Pine Tree Riot - Chesterfield Historic Society
Their cases were heard in September 1772 before four judges of the Amherst Superior Court. All the plaintiffs humbly plead guilty, and were fined 20 shillings ...Missing: details | Show results with:details
[12]
Forestry Friday: 250th Anniversary of the Pine Tree Riot
Mar 2, 2022 · The Pine Tree Riot happened on April 14, 1772 in the town of Weare, NH on the site where the Quimby Inn once stood in Weare.Missing: details | Show results with:details
[13]
Revolutionary War Early Navy Flags – Pine Tree Flag
Mar 29, 2024 · The Massachusetts Navy sailed under the pine-tree flag. Why would a navy ensign use a pine tree as its prominent symbol? The pine tree flag ...
[14]
Right of Revolution: John Locke, Second Treatise, §§ 149, 155, 168 ...
The People have no other remedy in this, as in all other cases where they have no Judge on Earth, but to appeal to Heaven. For the Rulers, in such attempts ...Missing: exact | Show results with:exact
[15]
Second Treatise Chapters 13-15 - Teaching American History
... appeal to Heaven; for the rulers in such attempts, exercising a power the people never put into their hands, who can never be supposed to consent that ...Missing: exact quote
[16]
The Appeal to Heaven and Our New Revolutionary War - Providence
Feb 23, 2021 · Indeed, it may well be that Locke had more than Jeptha on his mind when he described the appeal to arms as an “appeal to heaven.” Centuries ...
[17]
An Appeal To The Public For Religious Liberty, by Isaac Backus ...
Jan 22, 2013 · ... appeal to heaven by oaths, and to invoke assistance from thence to avenge the cause of the injured upon the guilty. Hence it is so far from ...
[18]
Sermon – Battle of Lexington – 1776 - WallBuilders
Dec 26, 2016 · The sword is an appeal to heaven,—when therefore, the arms of a people are eventually successful, or by the immediate interposition of ...
[19]
[PDF] On the Religious Origins of the Constitutional Right of Revolution
Part of the Legal History Commons. Repository Citation. John M. Kang, Appeal to Heaven: On the Religious Origins of the Constitutional Right of. Revolution, 18 ...
[20]
https://www.usaflagco.com/products/pine-tree-flag
[21]
The U.S. Navy's Jack - Naval History and Heritage Command
Sep 21, 2021 · The Continental Navy Jack: A Documentation. The Pine Tree Flag. Col. Joseph Reed to Col. John Glover and Stephen Moylan, 20 October 1775, ...
[22]
https://www.gettysburgflag.com/washington-s-cruisers-an-appeal-to-heaven-flag
[23]
Appeal to heaven? There's a much richer history behind the Pine ...
Jun 6, 2024 · Following the riot, the pine tree became a symbol of colonial resistance and independence. A flag depicting a pine tree and a red ensign would ...
[24]
The Tree That Sparked the Revolutionary War: Eastern White Pine's ...
The Eastern White Pine was such a potent symbol for colonists that it became the emblem emblazoned upon the first colonial flag.
[25]
Pine Trees, the Kings Mark, and Revolution! – Pennsylvania Lumber ...
Apr 19, 2025 · The British Government sought to claim all desirable white pine trees for the Royal Navy though a series of White Pine Acts, also known as the ...
[26]
Americans Need to Appeal to Heaven - Crisis Magazine
May 29, 2024 · Its origin is John Locke, who invokes an “appeal to heaven” to ground his claim that men have a right to resist unjust laws—a principle ...<|separator|>
[27]
https://libertyflags.com/blogs/default-blog/a-brief-history-of-the-washington-cruisers-flag
[28]
Washington's Fleet, 1775 and 1776 | Naval History
... flag with a white ground, a tree in the middle, the motto, 'Appeal to Heaven.'” This, the New England pine-tree flag, was used on the floating batteries ...
[29]
America's First Navy Flag Featured the Eastern White Pine Tree
A flag flown by early American ships was the Pine Tree Flag, designed by General Washington's secretary, Colonel Joseph Reed.Missing: sketches | Show results with:sketches
[30]
John Glover: Sailor, Soldier, Patriot (U.S. National Park Service)
Jan 3, 2022 · Born in Salem, Massachusetts, November 7, 1732, John, his mother, and three brothers moved to Marblehead after the early death of his father.Missing: Pine HMS Margaretta<|separator|>
[31]
List of Flags of the American Revolutionary War
Washington's Cruisers Flag 1775 ... In April 1776, the Massachusetts Navy adopted as its flag (naval ensign) a white field charged with a green pine tree.
[32]
Flags of America | Proceedings - June 1936 Vol. 62/6/400
The solemn motto inscribed on the flag first appeared in a resolution of the Provincial Congress of Massachusetts adopted shortly after the battle of Lexington ...<|separator|>
[33]
"AN APPEAL TO HEAVEN" Pine Tree Flag - U.S. Navy, Marines ...
John Glover and his Marblehead fisherman saved the day by rowing Washington and the entire Continental Army, under a providential fog, to escape across the East ...
[34]
[PDF] Origin and History of the American Flag and of the Naval and Yacht ...
colonies,—Fresh Itiver, or Connecticut, Rhode Island and the other islands ... Instances of the use of this pine-tree flag, from October, 1775, to. July ...
[35]
Flags08 - Mother Bedford
This version of the New England Pine Tree flag was noted in the January 1776 issue of the London Chronicle as having been found on a colonial privateer that had ...<|separator|>
[36]
https://www.americanflags.com/blog/post/history-of-the-massachusetts-state-flag
[37]
Maine's Once Forgotten Original State Flag Is Making A Comeback
Feb 13, 2018 · In 1901, Maine adopted its first official state flag. It featured a white pine tree and a blue north star set on a plain, buff background.
[38]
Historical Vermont flags (U.S.) - CRW Flags
May 9, 2015 · The flag of the Green Mountain Boys can be seen below: www.answers ... forest of pine trees and a larger pine tree with 14 branches.
[39]
State Seal | NH.gov
The seal was first created in 1775 by the First Provincial Congress. It comprised a pine tree and an upright fish, on each side of a bundle of five arrows. The ...Missing: adoption | Show results with:adoption
[40]
New Hampshire's State Flag and Seal
Jul 25, 2006 · In preparation of the 1776 state constitution, the First Provincial Congress designed a seal comprised an upright fish and pine tree on each ...
[41]
Pine tree or state seal? Maine voters will decide on state flag design ...
May 17, 2024 · The Legislature was very clear about the design of the new flag and it will be a model of the 1901 state flag with a pine tree and a star on a buff background.Missing: historical | Show results with:historical
[42]
https://flagsforgood.com/blogs/news/a-forgotten-flag-returns-maine-1901-pine-tree-flag
[43]
Massachusetts (U.S.) - CRW Flags
Sep 13, 2025 · The green pine tree was taken off the reverse of the flag and placed on a white field to re-create the Massachusetts maritime flag, just ...
[44]
The Massachusetts State Flag & Its 300 Year History
Nov 29, 2022 · Up until recent times, the Massachusetts State flag was historically double sided with the classic New England Pine Tree featured on the reverse ...
[45]
1345-54 - 1968 6c Historic American Flags - Mystic Stamp Company
$$4.50 In stock $3.50 deliveryThe colonial ships flew a white flag with a pine tree, which represented freedom. These ships were the first Navy of the United States. Bennington ...
[46]
Pine Tree Flag | Archive | wrightsvillebeachmagazine.com
Jun 27, 2024 · It was used to muster troops before the Stars and Stripes was adopted by Congress. The same flag was used by the Massachusetts navy in 1776 on ...
[47]
Raven, volume 30 (2023) - North American Vexillological Association
The so-called “Pine Tree Flag”, with a white field displaying a pine tree and the “Appeal to Heaven” motto, is part of the traditional pantheon of American ...
[48]
An Appeal To Heaven: What Would Happen If We Did It Again
In An Appeal To Heaven, Dutch Sheets takes you on a journey of discovering the role you were designed to play in America's history. This short book is ...
[49]
Dutch Sheets Tells Story Behind the Appeal to Heaven Flag
Jan 27, 2015 · The Appeal to Heaven flag holds great significance as it relates to the founding of our nation, God's eternal covenants, and our present hope ...
[50]
Pine Tree Flag - Wikipedia
The flag, which featured a pine tree with the motto "An Appeal to Heaven", or less frequently "An Appeal to God", was used by a squadron of six schooners ...
[51]
Another Provocative Flag Was Flown at Another Alito Home
May 22, 2024 · The justice's beach house displayed an “Appeal to Heaven” flag, a symbol carried on Jan. 6 and associated with a push for a more Christian-minded government.
[52]
The Pine Tree Flag is popping up on the desks of RI Senators. What ...
Jun 13, 2024 · The words “An Appeal to Heaven,” is taken from a quote by philosopher John Locke, written in defense of the right to revolution.Missing: capitol | Show results with:capitol
[53]
The long history of the flag that flew outside Justice Alito's beach ...
May 23, 2024 · Religious scholar Matthew Taylor explains the history behind the "Appeal To Heaven" flag, which was flown outside US Supreme Court Justice Samuel Alito's beach ...
[54]
Why a Supreme Court justice's embrace of the 'Appeal to Heaven ...
May 28, 2024 · The Appeal to Heaven flag has become a banner of Christian Nationalism ... The banner, also known as the “Pine Tree Flag,” was originally used ...
[55]
LOVELL: The Pine Tree flag | The North State Journal
Jun 14, 2024 · In 1968, the U.S. Postal Service commemorated the Pine Tree flag with a six-cent stamp that included the Locke quote, issued before the ...<|control11|><|separator|>
[56]
The Pine Tree flag: How one symbol at the Capitol riot connects far ...
Feb 24, 2021 · A white flag printed with a bright green pine tree, reading the words, “An Appeal to Heaven,” flew alongside popular right-wing flags.Missing: Loudoun | Show results with:Loudoun
[57]
House advances Paulhus bill to adopt original Maine flag
Jun 7, 2023 · AUGUSTA - After lengthy debate, the Maine House of Representatives voted on Tuesday night to advance legislation sponsored by Rep.
[58]
Mainers reject Pine Tree Flag design, will remain unofficial symbol ...
Nov 6, 2024 · As of Wednesday afternoon, at least 55% of voters rejected a proposal to adopt the old design as the state flag.
[59]
Eco-Fascist 'Pine Tree Party' Growing as a Violent Extremism Threat
Sep 27, 2020 · The Pine Tree Party was established on Nov. 3, 2017, through an Instagram post initiated by Mike Ma, also the leader of the movement by some ...
[60]
EcoFascism and Green Accelerationism: Ghosts of the Past or a ...
Apr 30, 2025 · Eco-fascist activity later shifted primarily to Telegram, where the Pine Tree Party channel, launched in 2020, became among the first major ...
[61]
Mike Johnson Flies Christian Nationalist 'Appeal to Heaven' Flag
Nov 10, 2023 · ... far-right politicians and election deniers like Doug Mastriano ... Mike Johnson Flies Christian Nationalist 'Appeal to Heaven' Flag. An ...
[62]
First it Was an Insurrection Flag, Now Supreme Court Justice Alito is ...
May 23, 2024 · On Wednesday, news broke that the “Appeal to Heaven” flag was flying outside Sam Alito's beach house in New Jersey after the storming of the ...<|separator|>
[63]
Why Maine's pine tree flag gets lumped in with 'Appeal to Heaven' flag
May 28, 2024 · Maine's original flag featuring a pine tree and blue star on a buff background got lumped into the flag discourse because the “Appeal to Heaven” flag.