Fact-checked by Grok 2 weeks ago

Divine Intervention

Divine intervention is the theological and philosophical concept denoting the direct, influence of a on worldly events, often portrayed as suspending or overriding natural laws to achieve a divine purpose, such as aiding believers or demonstrating power. Prevalent in Abrahamic faiths, it encompasses purported like healings, deliverances, or providential coincidences attributed to God's responsive action, distinct from ongoing general that sustains . Theological proponents argue for "special divine acts" that manifest intent amid apparent regularities, while critics question the coherence of a intervening selectively, raising issues of and —why persists absent constant aid. Scientific scrutiny, including randomized trials on intercessory for healing, reveals no consistent empirical support for efficacy, with outcomes aligning more closely to chance, responses, or statistical variation than verifiable causation. Philosophical analyses emphasize that claims of intervention rely on interpretive frameworks prone to , where improbable events are retroactively deemed miraculous without falsifiable criteria distinguishing them from natural anomalies.

Definition and Conceptual Foundations

Core Definition and Distinctions

Divine intervention refers to the direct and extraordinary action of a in the material world or human affairs, typically involving the suspension, alteration, or override of laws to produce outcomes unattainable through ordinary causal processes. In monotheistic traditions, this is frequently attributed to God's sovereign will responding to , fulfilling , or demonstrating , as seen in biblical accounts where divine agency halts natural events like the sun's movement or parts seas. The concept presupposes a transcendent being capable of primary causation, distinct from secondary causes governed by physical laws, emphasizing causal wherein input disrupts expected uniformities. A key distinction lies between and : the latter denotes God's continuous governance and sustenance of creation through natural means and secondary causes, preserving order without overt disruption, as in the regular provision of rain or biological reproduction. operates subtly and universally, aligning events to moral or teleological ends via probabilistic or deterministic chains, whereas entails episodic, detectable anomalies that signal direct agency, such as instantaneous healings defying medical . Theological sources like Reformed traditions highlight this by classifying as "" (concurrent with nature) versus intervention's "extraordinary" mode, avoiding conflation to uphold empirical observations of regularity in non-miraculous contexts. Further distinctions separate intervention from mere or human agency: empirical verification challenges naturalistic dismissals, requiring attribution to divine cause only when events exceed probabilistic bounds and align with doctrinal criteria, such as authentication by prophetic fulfillment on specific dates like the claimed circa 30-33 . Unlike deistic views positing a non-intervening post-creation, interventionist theologies assert ongoing capacity for action, critiquing non-intervention as incompatible with scriptural precedents of dated interventions, e.g., plagues around 1446 BCE per some chronologies. Miracles, often equated with intervention, represent its evidential subset—verifiable anomalies like the 2,000-year-preserved exhibiting unexplained image formation defying replication—distinguished from providential "near-misses" by their impossibility under uniform .

Etymology and Historical Evolution

The term "divine intervention" derives from the combination of "divine," originating in Latin divinus, meaning "of or belonging to a god," which entered English via Old French devin by the 14th century to denote qualities or actions pertaining to deity. "Intervention" stems from Late Latin interventio, denoting "a coming between" or interposition, adapted from the verb intervenire ("to come between, interrupt, or hinder"), and first appeared in English around the early 15th century in senses of intercession or mediation, often in legal or ecclesiastical contexts. The full phrase "divine intervention" emerged in English theological discourse during the late 17th and early 18th centuries, reflecting providentialist interpretations of historical events as God's direct involvement, as seen in clerical writings interpreting national affairs through biblical lenses of sovereignty and judgment. The underlying concept of supernatural entities altering human events traces to prehistoric and ancient civilizations, where oral traditions and early texts described gods or spirits influencing natural disasters, battles, and personal fates to enforce moral order or divine will; for instance, Mesopotamian epics like the Enuma Elish (circa 18th–16th century BCE) depict deities such as intervening in cosmic conflicts to establish kingship over humanity. In , from Homer's (8th century BCE), Olympian gods like and Apollo routinely descended to aid heroes or thwart enemies in the , embodying a where divine agency explained inexplicable outcomes without implying but rather capricious patronage. Roman adaptations preserved this motif, as in Virgil's (19 BCE), where orchestrates Rome's founding through prophecies and omens, transitioning the idea toward state-sanctioned piety. With the rise of monotheistic Abrahamic faiths, the concept evolved toward a singular, omnipotent deity's purposeful acts, distinct from polytheistic whimsy; Jewish scriptures record Yahweh's interventions, such as the plagues (circa BCE per traditional dating) and prophetic fulfillments, framing history as covenantal response rather than arbitrary meddling. Early , building on this, centralized the of Christ (circa 4–6 BCE) as the paradigmatic intervention, redeeming humanity through historical incarnation rather than episodic miracles alone, as articulated in accounts and patristic writings. Medieval integrated Aristotelian causality, viewing divine acts as compatible with secondary natural causes, while Reformation emphases on scripture revived providential readings of events like the 1588 defeat as direct godly favor. Enlightenment rationalism and scientific advances from the 17th century onward prompted critiques, with figures like (1748) questioning miracle reports as violations of uniform experience, shifting perceptions from frequent to rare or metaphorical interventions. Nonetheless, 18th–19th century evangelical movements, including , reaffirmed the concept through personal testimonies and historical analogies, as in John Wesley's 1749 response to deistic challenges emphasizing God's ongoing historical agency. In the , amid world wars and , theological debates persisted, with some traditions positing subtle providential guidance over overt miracles, while empirical relegated claims to unverifiable assertions.

Theological Perspectives Across Religions

Abrahamic Traditions

In Abrahamic traditions, divine intervention refers to God's direct involvement in worldly affairs, ranging from providential of natural processes to extraordinary that suspend or override them, primarily to authenticate prophets, deliver the faithful, and manifest divine will. These acts are distinguished from general —God's sustenance of creation—by their rarity and evidentiary purpose, as articulated in theological analyses across , . While scriptural accounts portray such interventions as historical realities within faith frameworks, theological discourse emphasizes their role in reinforcing monotheistic covenants rather than routine occurrences. In , divine intervention features prominently in the Tanakh as otot (signs) and mofetim (wonders), such as the ten plagues on ( 7-12), the parting of the ( 14:21-31), and the daily provision of in the wilderness ( 16:4-35), which sustained the during their circa the 13th century BCE per traditional chronology. These events underscore God's liberation of the from bondage and establishment of the covenant at , serving as paradigms of hashgachah pratit (particular ) where God actively alters natural order for redemptive purposes. extends this to hidden miracles in daily life, though overt nissim (miracles) are tied to prophetic eras, with post-biblical views varying between literal acceptance and metaphorical interpretations emphasizing moral lessons over empirical suspension of laws. Christian theology centers divine intervention on the and Christ, whose —enumerated as approximately 37 acts including healing the blind (John 9:1-7), feeding the 5,000 (Matthew 14:13-21), calming the storm (Mark 4:35-41), and raising Lazarus from death (John 11:38-44)—demonstrate authority over nature, illness, and mortality to validate his divine sonship and inaugurate the Kingdom of God. The (circa 30-33 CE) stands as the pivotal intervention, enabling and the indwelling Holy Spirit's ongoing work, though perspectives diverge: cessationists maintain miracles authenticated the apostolic foundation and largely ceased post-first century, while charismatics affirm continued manifestations like healings today as extensions of . In , divine intervention manifests through mu'jizat (irresistible miracles) granted to prophets (anbiya) as proofs of their veracity, with the citing examples like Abraham's survival in fire ( 21:69), Moses' staff devouring serpents ( 7:107-108), and Jesus' creation of a bird from clay and healing the lepers ( 5:110). For (circa 570-632 CE), the eternal serves as the supreme, inimitable miracle challenging humanity to replicate its linguistic and prophetic precision ( 2:23), supplemented by physical signs such as the moon's splitting ( 54:1-2) and the night journey ( 17:1). These acts align with qadar (divine decree), where Allah's absolute sovereignty permits interventions without negating human agency, though post-prophetic miracles are rare, emphasizing submission () over expectation of spectacle.

Non-Abrahamic Religious Views

In , divine intervention is conceptualized as the active role of deities in preserving cosmic order (), often through avatars or direct manifestations of gods like and . 's descents, such as in the to defeat the demon king around the traditionally dated events of circa 5000 BCE in scriptural chronology, exemplify restoration of righteousness amid human moral decline. Similarly, Krishna's intervention in the , including his counsel to on the battlefield as detailed in the (composed circa 400 BCE to 200 BCE), provides ethical guidance and miraculous feats like the Sudarshana Chakra's deployment against adversaries. These accounts underscore a causal framework where divine action counters without negating individual karma, as deities respond to devotees' or societal . Ancient Greek polytheism portrayed gods as anthropomorphic entities who frequently intervened in mortal lives, driven by personal whims, alliances, or oaths rather than abstract justice. In Homer's Iliad (circa 8th century BCE), Zeus enforces a divine balance by weighing fates, while Athena aids Odysseus and Diomedes with strength and strategy during the Trojan War, enabling feats like wounding Aphrodite. Apollo similarly protects Hector and Aeneas, shooting arrows at Greek forces, reflecting a worldview where gods' caprice shapes outcomes, as evidenced by over 200 divine appearances or actions in the epic. Such interventions, often via disguise or omens, were expected by practitioners, who offered sacrifices to influence outcomes, aligning with archaeological evidence of votive offerings at sites like Delphi from the 8th century BCE onward. Buddhist traditions minimize divine intervention, prioritizing karma's inexorable causality over supranatural overrides, with no dictating events. Devas (celestial beings) may occasionally assist practitioners, as in the Buddha's biography where Sakka urges circa 5th century BCE, but their aid is constrained by accumulated karma and lacks salvific power. The , compiled around the 1st century BCE, depicts Buddhas and bodhisattvas offering guidance limited by recipients' conditions, emphasizing self-reliant path to enlightenment via the rather than petitionary prayer. This non-theistic stance, articulated in texts like the (circa 3rd century BCE), rejects miracles as ultimate solutions, viewing apparent interventions as karmic fruits or illusions distracting from nirvana. In , intervention by deities or immortals occurs through alignment with the Tao's natural flow, rather than coercive miracles, as gods in the celestial hierarchy respond to rituals fostering harmony. Texts like the (circa 6th-4th century BCE) advocate (non-action), implying divine forces manifest indirectly via cosmic balance, with immortals granting longevity elixirs to adepts like those in Ge Hong's (circa 320 CE). Folk practices integrate ancestor veneration for auspicious aid, but scholarly analyses note interventions as extensions of yin-yang dynamics, not personal petitions overriding causality.

Historical and Scriptural Accounts

Key Examples from Abrahamic Texts

In the , divine intervention manifests prominently in the narrative, where God inflicts ten plagues on —including the transformation of the to blood, swarms of locusts, and the death of firstborn sons—to compel to release the from slavery, as detailed in 7–12. This culminates in the parting of the : stretches out his hand at God's direction, driving back the waters with a strong to create dry ground for the ' crossing, after which the sea returns and drowns the pursuing Egyptian chariots and army ( 14:21–28). Another instance is the daily provision of , a bread-like substance from , along with , to feed approximately 600,000 men plus families for 40 years in the , ceasing only upon entry into ( 16:4–35). Further examples include Elijah's confrontation with 450 prophets of on , where fire from heaven consumes a water-soaked and in response to Elijah's , affirming Yahweh's supremacy (1 Kings 18:20–40), and the divine protection of in a blazing , where they emerge unharmed despite flames killing their guards, as decreed by King Nebuchadnezzar (Daniel 3:19–28). In the , divine intervention is exemplified through ' miracles, such as turning water into wine at the wedding in —approximately 120–180 gallons from six stone jars—to avert embarrassment for the host (John 2:1–11). also multiplies five loaves and two fish to feed over 5,000 men plus women and children, with twelve baskets of leftovers collected (:13–21), and raises from death after four days in the tomb, commanding him to emerge bound in grave clothes before witnesses (John 11:38–44). The resurrection of Jesus constitutes a central event, with the empty tomb discovered by women followers on the third day and post-resurrection appearances to disciples, including Thomas verifying wounds, over 40 days before ascension (John 20:1–29; Acts 1:3–9). The Quran recounts parallel interventions, such as God commanding Moses to strike the sea with his staff, splitting it into two towering parts like mountains to allow the Israelites' escape while Pharaoh's forces drown (Surah ash-Shu'ara 26:63; Surah Ta-Ha 20:77–78). It describes the moon splitting as a sign for Prophet Muhammad, witnessed by Meccans who dismissed it as sorcery (Surah al-Qamar 54:1–2). Among prophets' miracles, () speaks from the cradle to defend Mary's honor (Surah Maryam 19:27–33) and, by God's permission, forms birds from clay, breathes life into them, heals the blind and lepers, and raises the dead (Surah 5:110).

Instances in Other Religious and Mythological Narratives

In , as depicted in Homer's , divine intervention frequently shapes the Trojan War's outcome, with gods acting on behalf of favored mortals. For instance, , mother of Achilles, persuades to favor the Trojans temporarily by withdrawing divine support from the , leading to their setbacks until Achilles' honor is restored. Apollo intervenes by sending a upon the Greek camp in response to Agamemnon's mistreatment of Chryses, the of Apollo, which forces the return of and escalates internal conflicts. aids by granting him temporary god-like strength and vision to wound and , illustrating gods' direct physical involvement in human combat. In the , divine figures guide ' journey home, underscoring themes of fate intertwined with godly favor. repeatedly hinders due to the blinding of his son , causing shipwrecks and delays, while intervenes by disguising him and inspiring allies like to counter suitors in . These narratives portray gods as anthropomorphic entities with personal agendas, intervening proactively to advance plans or exact retribution, rather than adhering to impersonal cosmic laws. Hindu epics feature divine avatars intervening to uphold amid human moral crises. In the Mahabharata, Krishna, as an of , serves as 's charioteer during the and delivers the , advising detachment from outcomes and fulfillment of duty to resolve 's ethical paralysis before battle. Krishna's role extends to miraculous acts, such as displaying his cosmic form to and protecting the through strategic and supernatural means, including saving Parashurama's arrow aimed at . These interventions emphasize restoration of cosmic order over arbitrary favoritism, with avatars manifesting when prevails. In ancient , gods intervened in pharaonic affairs to affirm ma'at (cosmic order), often manifesting as oracles, dreams, or battlefield aid. and other deities supported rulers like Ramses II at the around 1274 BCE, where temple inscriptions claim divine manifestations routed Hittite forces, though historical analysis attributes partial success to diplomacy and tactics. and assisted mortals in myths, as in the cycle, where reassembles and revives through magic, symbolizing fertility renewal and pharaohs' divine kingship. Egyptians viewed such acts as reciprocal, with rituals compelling gods' favor, reflecting a where divine will permeated daily governance and warfare. Norse mythology, per the Poetic Edda and Volsunga Saga, depicts gods like intervening in heroic lineages to influence fate-bound events. appears disguised to bestow wisdom or weapons, such as advising on dragon-slaying or selecting warriors for via Valkyries during battles, thereby weaving human destinies into Ragnarok's inexorable tapestry. These interventions align with a of predetermined doom, where gods act within (fate) rather than altering it fundamentally. In , deities like intervene in creation and catastrophe. repairs the sky after Gonggong's flood-causing clash with Mount Buzhou by melting five-colored stones and using turtle legs as pillars, restoring order and preventing human extinction. Similarly, Jiang Yuan, a matriarchal figure, conceives the ancestor Houji through divine treading on a , initiating the Zhou dynasty's lineage via heavenly mandate. These acts underscore cyclical renewal through imperial favor, with gods enforcing harmony (he) amid chaos. Buddhist occasionally involve devas (heavenly beings) aiding the in past lives, such as Sakka ( equivalent) influencing moral choices or providing succor in trials, though emphasis lies on karmic causation over capricious divinity. For example, in certain narratives, devas reveal truths or avert harm to exemplify virtues like , reinforcing enlightenment's self-reliant path while acknowledging supramundane support.

Philosophical and Theological Debates

Compatibility with Free Will and Natural Laws

Theological and philosophical discussions on divine intervention often address its potential tension with human , which posits that individuals possess the capacity for undetermined choices. Proponents of compatibilist views, such as those articulated by , argue that God's occasional interventions—such as responding to prayers—do not negate free will, as they can align with or sustain the libertarian freedom required for , without coercing human decisions. Plantinga contends that divine action operates within a framework where God continuously upholds the created order, allowing free agents to act while permitting targeted interventions that do not predetermine outcomes. Critics, including some libertarians, counter that any supernatural override of natural causal chains could implicitly limit alternative possibilities, though empirical evidence for such overrides remains absent, leaving the debate reliant on logical possibility rather than observation. Regarding natural laws, defined as descriptive regularities observed in physical phenomena, divine intervention raises questions of whether miracles constitute violations or exceptions. proposes that miracles function as non-repeatable counter-instances to these laws, serving as signs of divine intent rather than disruptions of an immutable system; laws, in this view, summarize God's habitual governance, permitting purposeful deviations without logical contradiction. This perspective aligns with causal realism, where laws emerge from underlying powers rather than rigid necessities, allowing a transcendent cause to act exceptionally while preserving scientific predictability in ordinary events. Opposing arguments, echoing David Hume's 18th-century critique, assert that testimony for law-violating events is inherently outweighed by uniform experience, rendering miracles improbable unless corroborated by extraordinary evidence, which historical claims often lack. Theologians like those at the Henry Center maintain compatibility by reinterpreting laws as probabilistic or contingent on divine sustenance, avoiding conflict with empirical science that documents regularities but does not preclude rare anomalies. In reconciling both aspects, some frameworks invoke occasionalism, where God directly causes all events, rendering interventions indistinguishable from natural processes in kind, though differing in intent; this preserves free will by attributing human choices to divinely enabled agency. Empirical scrutiny, however, finds no verifiable instances where interventions demonstrably suspend laws or bypass free choices, with studies on prayer efficacy showing results consistent with chance or psychological factors rather than supernatural causation. Thus, compatibility hinges on metaphysical assumptions about divine omnipotence and the non-necessary status of natural regularities, debated without resolution through observation alone.

The Problem of Non-Intervention and Evil

The problem of non-intervention posits that the absence of observable divine action to prevent widespread undermines claims of a possessing both unlimited power and perfect benevolence, particularly in contexts where intervention could avert harm without apparent cost to greater goods. This challenge, intertwined with the broader , questions why an omnipotent permits instances of intense, seemingly pointless if capable of miraculous or providential acts as described in religious texts. Philosophers argue that selective or total non-intervention in natural disasters, diseases, and moral atrocities implies either divine impotence, indifference, or a moral framework incompatible with human intuitions of goodness. Ancient formulations, such as the attributed to (341–270 BCE), highlight the incompatibility: if wills to prevent evil but lacks power, fails; if power exists but will is absent, benevolence is absent; if both exist, evil's origin remains unexplained; if neither, the term "" misapplies. This riddle, preserved through later writers like (c. 250–325 CE), targets the logical tension between divine attributes and observed non-intervention in evils like famines or plagues, which afflicted millions historically without evident cessation. In modern evidential terms, William 's 1979 argument emphasizes "gratuitous" evils—instances of profound suffering an omnipotent, omniscient, wholly good being could prevent without sacrificing equal or greater goods. Rowe cites the hypothetical case of a fawn severely burned in a forest fire on a windy day in , writhing in agony for days before dying, with no discernible purpose or benefit to any entity, natural or moral. Such examples extend to animal predation and natural calamities, like the 2004 Indian Ocean and that killed approximately 227,898 people across 14 countries, where non-intervention appears to lack justification beyond vague appeals to mystery. Rowe concludes that the probable existence of such pointless evils provides strong against , as a benevolent would preclude them. The issue intensifies for doctrines of occasional divine intervention, as sporadic miracles (e.g., biblical resurrections or healings) render consistent non-intervention in mass atrocities—like , where six million Jews perished between 1941 and 1945—arbitrarily selective, suggesting caprice rather than principled restraint. Critics contend this selectivity exacerbates the evidential case, as it implies prioritizes certain interventions over averting systemic horrors, challenging causal explanations rooted in (which falters against natural evils predating human agency). While theistic responses invoke soul-making or eschatological compensation, these do not empirically resolve the prima facie improbability of non-intervention amid quantifiable global , estimated at billions of animal deaths annually from predation and alone.

Empirical Evidence and Scientific Evaluation

Studies on Intercessory Prayer and Healing

Intercessory prayer involves third parties petitioning a deity on behalf of others, typically without the recipients' knowledge to minimize placebo effects, in controlled studies assessing health outcomes such as recovery rates or complications. Early research, including a 1988 double-blind trial by cardiologist Randolph Byrd at San Francisco General Hospital, examined 393 coronary care unit patients randomized to receive or not receive intercessory prayer from Christian groups; prayed-for patients showed statistically significant improvements in metrics like fewer cases of congestive heart failure, pneumonia, and diuretic use, with no adverse effects noted. However, the study employed a non-standard composite scoring system for outcomes, lacked full blinding of pray-ers to patient identities, and has faced criticism for potential selection biases and inability to replicate under stricter controls, limiting its evidential weight. Subsequent larger-scale investigations have yielded null or negative results. The 2006 Study of the Therapeutic Effects of Intercessory Prayer (STEP), a multicenter randomized led by Harvard's involving 1,802 cardiac bypass surgery patients, found no benefit from intercessory provided by three Christian congregations; complication-free recovery rates were similar between prayed-for (52%) and non-prayed-for groups (51%). Notably, patients aware of receiving prayer experienced higher rates of complications (59%) compared to those uncertain (52%), suggesting possible stress from performance anxiety or expectation effects rather than divine causation. Funded partly by the Templeton Foundation, STEP addressed prior methodological flaws like inadequate and blinding, yet its findings align with causal , where unobserved variables fail to demonstrate measurable impact amid controlled variables. Meta-analyses reinforce the absence of robust effects. A 2006 review by Masters and Spielmans of 14 distant intercessory studies reported an overall of g = 0.100, statistically indistinguishable from zero, attributing apparent positives in smaller trials to or Type I errors rather than genuine . Similarly, a 2009 Cochrane of 10 trials encompassing 7,646 patients found insufficient evidence of benefit for mortality or clinical state, with heterogeneous results likely due to variations in protocols, patient populations, and outcome measures; while some individual studies hinted at positives, aggregation showed no consistent pattern supporting intercessory over chance. These syntheses highlight systemic challenges, including pray-ers' inability to adhere strictly to blinded protocols and the improbability of detecting subtle divine influences amid factors like medical interventions, underscoring that empirical data privileges naturalistic explanations over unverified claims. Despite occasional for further from sources with potential religious affiliations, rigorous evaluations consistently fail to isolate as a causal agent in .

Analyses of Alleged Modern Miracles

The analysis of alleged modern miracles emphasizes empirical scrutiny, including medical documentation, histopathological examination, and exclusion of naturalistic explanations such as or psychological factors. Criteria often require instantaneous, complete, and durable recovery from verified organic pathology, with independent expert to rule out prior treatments or misdiagnosis. Despite thousands of claims, few withstand such evaluation, highlighting the rarity of verifiable anomalies. At the Lourdes sanctuary, the Medical Bureau, established in and comprising physicians from diverse backgrounds including non-Catholics, has assessed over 7,000 reported healings since , approving only 70 as scientifically inexplicable by 2023—a validation rate under 1%. Cases must demonstrate pre-existing objective disease confirmed by multiple diagnostics, abrupt remission post-immersion without intervention, and sustained health over years, excluding remediable conditions or . For instance, the 1947 cure of Jeanne Fret of tuberculous involved rapid resolution of and adhesions, deemed beyond known pathology by panels; similarly, the 2018 case of Sister Bernadette Moriau reversed decades of with restored neural function absent surgical traces. Critics contend that "inexplicable" reflects evidential gaps rather than causation, citing potential undiagnosed remissions or subjective elements, though the Bureau's protocols minimize these by mandating pre- and post-event imaging and biopsies. Eucharistic miracles, such as those in Buenos Aires (1992–1996), have undergone forensic analysis revealing transmuted hosts as myocardial tissue exhibiting live cardiomyocytes and inflammatory markers indicative of recent myocardial infarction, despite refrigeration and no human contamination. Serological tests across multiple sites, including Lanciano (8th century) and recent 21st-century events, consistently yield AB blood type with human cardiac proteins, resistant to degradation. A 2024 peer-reviewed study standardized evaluation protocols, noting DNA amplification challenges but confirming biological anomalies defying putrefaction norms. Skeptics highlight custody chain vulnerabilities and absence of blinded, replicated controls, attributing results to possible bacterial artifacts or fraud, yet independent pathologists like Frederick Zugibe reported viable white blood cells incompatible with preserved samples. The 1917 Fatima "," witnessed by 30,000–100,000 under rainy conditions, involved reports of the sun oscillating, emitting multicolored rays, and plummeting earthward before stabilizing, with ground drying instantly. Eyewitnesses, including atheists and journalists kilometers distant, described uniform phenomena without collective delusion indicators like varying accounts. Proposed natural explanations—retinal fatigue from sun-gazing, parhelia, or dust lenses—fail to account for shared drying or distant visibility, as typically require specific alignments absent here. Photographic evidence shows no orbital deviation but captures spectral effects; a 2021 analysis in Scientia et Fides posits electro-optical interactions or plasma discharges, yet concludes the simultaneity exceeds probabilistic coincidence. These cases persist as outliers resisting full naturalistic reduction, with empirical data showing physiological impossibilities under controlled review, though non-reproducibility precludes on causation. Institutional biases in religious-affiliated bodies may inflate claims, but involvement of secular experts and peer-reviewed anomalies suggest genuine evidential challenges to strict , warranting further interdisciplinary probe over dismissal.

Modern Claims and Cultural Interpretations

Contemporary Testimonies and Events

The maintains a rigorous process through the Lourdes Medical Bureau, comprising physicians of various faiths, to evaluate reported healings at the Sanctuary of in . As of 2025, out of over 7,000 documented cases since 1858, 72 have been officially declared miraculous, meaning the recovery was sudden, complete, permanent, and inexplicable by medical science at the time of declaration. Recent 21st-century examples include the 2016 healing of Sister Bernadette Moriau, a nun paralyzed for decades by and urinary issues despite multiple surgeries; after immersion in waters and participation in , she experienced immediate relief, later confirmed as the 70th miracle following neurological examinations ruling out natural remission. In April 2025, Italian teacher Antonietta Roca's 2020 recovery from a ruptured cerebral and paralysis—deemed terminal by neurologists—was recognized as the 72nd miracle; post-baptismal immersion, she regained full mobility without residual deficits, with the International Medical Committee validating the cure as scientifically unexplainable after four years of review. Eucharistic miracles, where consecrated hosts reportedly transform into visible human tissue, have also been documented and investigated in the 21st century, often involving forensic pathology. In Sokółka, Poland, on October 12, 2008, a dropped host developed red stains that microscopic analysis by independent pathologists identified as myocardial (heart) tissue interwoven with bread fibers, showing signs of distress as in a dying heart; the local bishop approved the event in 2009 after Church commission review. Similarly, in Legnica, Poland, in December 2013, a host that fell during Mass formed a reddish substance later confirmed by Warsaw Medical University labs as striated heart muscle from a trauma victim, with no microbial growth; Pope Francis authorized public veneration in 2016 following episcopal recognition. More recently, in Kerala, India, during a 2013 Mass, a consecrated host displayed the image of Christ's face, which persisted and was authenticated by the Vatican in May 2025 after scientific imaging and ecclesiastical inquiry deemed it authentic. Beyond Catholic contexts, Protestant and evangelical testimonies often involve personal accounts of survival or healing attributed to during crises. For example, in the , which killed over 200,000, missionary leader Troy Livesay reported multiple instances of individuals shielded from debris collapse, crediting communal ; however, these remain anecdotal without independent corroboration. In settings, pediatrician Craig Keener documents cases like a 2000s U.S. infant's spontaneous recovery from severe vomiting and cramps, peer-reviewed in as defying expected outcomes, though not formally linked to divine causation by investigators. Such reports, compiled in works like Keener's 2011 book Miracles, draw from thousands of eyewitness claims across denominations, emphasizing patterns of timing with but acknowledging the challenge of empirical verification outside institutional frameworks.

Skeptical and Psychological Explanations

Skeptics argue that modern claims of , such as sudden healings or providential coincidences, typically fail to withstand rigorous empirical scrutiny, with natural explanations accounting for observed phenomena without invoking causation. Investigations into purported often reveal incomplete medical documentation, retrospective reinterpretation of symptoms, or outright , as seen in analyses of high-profile cases where initial diagnoses were later revised upon re-examination. For instance, a medical review of hundreds of claimed prayer-induced healings found none meeting criteria for inexplicable recovery, attributing outcomes to diagnostic errors or baseline rates of in diseases like cancer, which occur in approximately 1 in 60,000 to 100,000 cases annually across global populations. Psychological research identifies cognitive biases as primary drivers behind attributing ambiguous events to divine , rather than random chance or human factors. Humans exhibit a hyperactive agency detection , an evolutionary for that predisposes individuals to infer intentional causation—such as godly —in patterns where none exists, a phenomenon akin to . This is compounded by , wherein believers selectively recall and amplify events aligning with theological expectations (e.g., a recovery following ) while discounting counterexamples (e.g., unheeded prayers or worsening conditions), fostering illusory correlations that reinforce without probabilistic accounting. In perceived healings, the placebo effect provides a verifiable naturalistic , where expectation of divine aid triggers neurophysiological responses, including endorphin release and immune modulation, mimicking recovery independent of input. Studies on religious rituals demonstrate that faith-enhanced placebos enhance and symptom relief, as measured by reduced pain reports and improved mood scales, but controlled trials show no outcomes exceeding what alone produces in secular contexts. Attribution errors further amplify this, with emotional salience from crises prompting post-hoc rationalizations of divine involvement, as schema-based inferences link personal narratives to schemas absent falsifiable tests. Skeptical analyses emphasize that while these processes yield real subjective experiences, they do not necessitate ontological claims of intervention, aligning with favoring simpler causal chains.

Broader Implications and Criticisms

Impact on and

Belief in divine intervention correlates with enhanced prosocial behaviors, as evidenced by studies linking such beliefs to moral foundations and altruistic actions. For instance, research indicates that individuals endorsing divine intervention are more likely to exhibit prosocial tendencies, potentially due to perceived accountability to a . Religiosity, often intertwined with expectations of divine action, predicts prosociality particularly when assessed via self-reports and behavioral measures, though effects are moderated by context and measurement type. Priming concepts related to divine oversight, such as or holiness, has experimentally increased and in controlled settings. On , expectations of divine involvement can mitigate the adverse effects of stressors, fostering especially among those with lower levels. Longitudinal data show that maintaining in divine post-stress preserves psychological , whereas declines in such exacerbate distress for less-educated individuals. Perceived divine , a facet of beliefs, positively influences emotional health by reducing guilt and promoting . in miracles, as a form of anticipated divine action, buffers against depressive symptoms by reframing adversity as purposeful, with effects cascading to heightened divine support perceptions. However, reliance on divine intervention can impede practical , particularly in contexts. Surrogates holding expectations for terminally ill patients are six times more likely to pursue aggressive end-of-life treatments, prolonging without improving outcomes. This pattern reflects a broader tendency where strong faith in aid delays medical interventions, as seen in cases of communities reporting higher from treatable conditions like . Such behaviors stem from prioritizing over empirical treatments, leading to verifiable harms. Societally, shared convictions in bolster communal ties and , enhancing group cohesion during crises. In surveys, over 70% of respondents attribute life events to divine influence, correlating with reinforced social networks in religious communities. Yet, this can foster , reducing incentives for systemic reforms; historical analyses link high attributions to lower rates in pre-modern societies, where events were deferred to rather than human . Empirical reviews attribute religion's benefits more to behavioral —like from substances—than to intervention itself, underscoring that societal gains arise from induced habits, not causation by the divine. In aggregate, while promoting and , unchecked emphasis on divine intervention risks passivity toward solvable problems, as evidenced by persistent correlations between intense providentialism and suboptimal adherence.

Critiques of Over-Reliance on Divine Intervention Claims

Over-reliance on claims of divine intervention has been associated with fatalistic beliefs that undermine perceived personal control, correlating with diminished mental well-being and reduced engagement in proactive health behaviors. Religious fatalism, often rooted in expectations of divine providence overriding human action, acts as a barrier to adopting preventive health measures, such as screening or vaccination, thereby contributing to adverse health outcomes like delayed treatment and higher chronic illness rates. For instance, studies indicate that individuals endorsing strong religious fatalism exhibit lower adherence to self-care practices, mediating worse symptom management in conditions like cancer. In medical contexts, excessive dependence on or in lieu of evidence-based treatment has resulted in documented preventable deaths, particularly among children. A review of cases from 1975 to 1995 identified 172 child fatalities linked to religion-motivated medical , with 140 attributable to conditions treatable by routine medical interventions like antibiotics or had they been pursued. These outcomes stem from exclusive reliance on spiritual remedies, as seen in communities like the , where faith-based exemptions from standard care have repeatedly led to lethal complications from infections, , or . Critics argue this pattern reflects a causal disconnect, where attribution of to divine means discourages empirical verification and timely action, exacerbating mortality risks verifiable through and medical records. Such reliance extends to processes beyond health, potentially biasing rational evaluation of evidence. In legal settings, jurors incorporating biblical interpretations of into deliberations risk subordinating factual testimony and forensic data to unverified claims, fostering unfair verdicts. This critique highlights how over-emphasizing intervention narratives can induce passivity, as individuals may defer to anticipated providential outcomes rather than addressing causal factors through mechanisms. Empirical patterns suggest this dynamic perpetuates selective , where successes are credited to intervention while failures are rationalized away, reinforcing unsubstantiated beliefs without accountability to consistent natural s.

References

  1. [1]
    The concept of Divine intervention in Christianity
    According to Christianity, Divine intervention represents God's active involvement in human affairs, guiding events to fulfill His intended purposes.
  2. [2]
    What defines divine intervention? - Bible Hub
    Divine intervention refers to instances in which the Creator directly engages with creation to alter circumstances, guide events, or accomplish a purpose ...
  3. [3]
    divine intervention - Dictionary.com
    Apr 3, 2018 · Divine intervention is the interference of a deity in human life, popularly extended to any miraculous-seeming turn of events.
  4. [4]
    Defining the Relationship between Evolution and Divine Intervention
    Mar 13, 2019 · (3) We might understand divine intervention simply as the claim that God does things in the world. God is constantly involved with his creation, ...
  5. [5]
    [PDF] special divine acts: three pseudo-problems and a blind alley - robert ...
    Traditionally, special divine acts have been understood as involving intervention in the course of nature, so as to cause events that nature would not, or could ...
  6. [6]
    Hans Küng and divine intervention - Faith and Theology
    Mar 30, 2006 · When asked about the concept of divine intervention, Küng explains: “The word 'intervene' is not very good because it means to come in between.
  7. [7]
    Prayer and healing: A medical and scientific perspective on ... - NIH
    Prayer has been reported to improve outcomes in human as well as nonhuman species, to have no effect on outcomes, to worsen outcomes and to have retrospective ...
  8. [8]
    Divine intervention? A Cochrane review on intercessory prayer gone ...
    A Cochrane review of ten randomised trials (7646 patients) of intercessory prayer concludes that the evidence justifies further trials.
  9. [9]
    Falling branches: the illusion of miraculous divine intervention
    May 1, 2015 · Claiming that an event was miraculous requires numerous unfounded assumptions that cannot be proven. You have to assume that the supernatural exists.Missing: empirical | Show results with:empirical
  10. [10]
    How Is God Working in the World? Understanding Miracles and ...
    Jan 16, 2014 · Or, as Horton puts it, “Unlike God's ordinary providence, his miraculous intervention involves a suspension or alteration of natural laws and ...
  11. [11]
    What are some undeniable examples of divine intervention?
    Jan 4, 2022 · Divine intervention is, simply put, God intervening in the affairs of the world. Divine intervention can be God causing something to happen ...
  12. [12]
    https://www.zygonjournal.org/article/id/13667/
  13. [13]
    What is divine providence? | GotQuestions.org
    Jan 4, 2022 · Divine providence is the governance of God by which He, with wisdom and love, cares for and directs all things in the universe.<|control11|><|separator|>
  14. [14]
    Divine Providence, or What About Miracles? - The SLJ Institute
    If, he reasoned, everything must have a natural cause, man can no longer believe in divine intervention. Further, granted an uninterrupted natural ...
  15. [15]
    The Providence of God (12): Miracles – The Standard Bearer ...
    The Providence of God (12): Miracles ... Trench makes the distinction between “providential” and “absolute” miracles. ... divine intervention; but, when taking into ...
  16. [16]
    What Is Divine Intervention? | Christianity.com
    It is the belief that God actively intervenes in our time on earth to bring about specific outcomes, fulfill His purposes, or respond to the prayers and needs ...
  17. [17]
    Miracles and Science: A Third Way - Article - BioLogos
    May 16, 2016 · An event like this is due to divine intervention: an act of God which violates or at least suspends the causality inherent in nature and the ...Missing: distinctions | Show results with:distinctions
  18. [18]
    Divine - Etymology, Origin & Meaning
    Originating from Latin divinus, meaning "of or belonging to a god," divine relates to God or gods and also denotes foretelling or soothsaying.
  19. [19]
    Intervention - Etymology, Origin & Meaning
    Originating from late Latin 'interventio' meaning "a coming between," intervention means the act of intervening or interceding, often to interrupt or ...
  20. [20]
    [PDF] Providentialism and Secularization in England, c.1660-1760. A ...
    Jun 4, 2009 · The English clergy of Charles II's reign continued to use the language of divine intervention to explain matters of domestic and foreign ...<|control11|><|separator|>
  21. [21]
    Divine intervention: Significance and symbolism
    Divine intervention in Buddhism encompasses the participation of heavenly beings in Bodhisattvas' births, Sakka's influence on human behavior, miraculous ...
  22. [22]
    Divine Intervention and Fate in Greek Myths - Fiveable
    Divine intervention has its roots in the belief that gods and goddesses actively participate in the lives of mortals · The concept of divine intervention is ...
  23. [23]
    How Has God Intervened in History? - Religious Studies Center
    The nature of God's plan for the salvation of His children helps us to understand under what circumstances and by what means God will intervene in human affairs ...
  24. [24]
    A history of divine intervention - The Catholic Thing
    Feb 24, 2016 · The history of Christianity is the history of a divine intervention in history, and we cannot study it apart from the history of culture in the widest sense of ...
  25. [25]
    John Wesley and Conyers Middleton on Divine Intervention in History
    on Divine Intervention in History. TED A. CAMPBELL. In early January of 1749 John Wesley canceled-a previously scheduled trip to Rotterdam in order to write a ...
  26. [26]
    Divine Intervention after Darwin: An Introduction
    Mar 13, 2019 · On the traditional reading of the Genesis account up until Darwin, God miraculously brought the universe into being through immediate divine ...<|separator|>
  27. [27]
    What Makes Something a Miracle? - TheTorah.com
    Jan 6, 2014 · A miracle is an extraordinary occurrence, attributable to God's hand, which leaves a marked impression in the text.
  28. [28]
    Doctrine of Creation (Part 13): The Collapse of the Belief in Miracles
    Sep 5, 2018 · On a Molinist view, God can, via his middle knowledge, arrange for extraordinary acts which would otherwise be highly improbable coincidences to ...<|control11|><|separator|>
  29. [29]
    Do Jews Believe in Miracles? | My Jewish Learning
    Jewish texts and lore are replete with miracles and wonders, from the shofar blast that brought down the walls of Jericho (Joshua 6:20) to the bush that ...
  30. [30]
    Miracles in the Torah
    Jun 19, 2018 · One of the more well known miracles that constantly took place in the wilderness was the falling of Manna (see Exodus 16:4).
  31. [31]
    What Is Divine Providence? - The Ultimate User Interaction
    In Jewish theology, divine providence means that G‑d not only knows what is going on down here, but is engaged in supervising it as well.
  32. [32]
    The 37 Miracles of Jesus in Chronological Order - Wytheville, VA
    1 Jesus Turns Water into Wine at the Wedding in Cana 2:1-11 2 Jesus Heals an Official's Son at Capernaum in Galilee 4:43-54 3 Jesus Drives Out an Evil Spirit ...
  33. [33]
    Does God Do Miracles Today? - Grace to You
    Aug 11, 1991 · I believe in miracles, and I believe that every miracle recorded in the Bible literally happened exactly as the Bible described it. I believe ...
  34. [34]
    A discussion of the miracles of the prophets and the signs of Allah ...
    Oct 17, 2024 · The miracle of Allah's Prophet Nuh (peace be upon him) was the building of the ark on dry land, which was then able to sail on the waves which were like ...
  35. [35]
    Six Miracles of Prophet Muhammad ﷺ - OnePath Network
    Mar 3, 2022 · 1. Prophet Muhammad's Miracle of the moon splitting · 2. The Miraculous Journey of Isra and Mi'raj · 3. The Tree that Cried · 4. The Miracle of ...
  36. [36]
    Predestination vs. Free Will in Islam: Understanding Allah's Qadr
    Jul 31, 2017 · In Islam, divine decree (qada) is complete judgment, and apportionment (qadar) is its details. Allah's decree is absolute, but human actions ...<|separator|>
  37. [37]
    [PDF] A phenomenological inquiry into sacred time in Hinduism
    for such divine intervention and so linear sacred time could be encountered in several different ways through the Bhagavad-gītā. The Rāmāyaṇa serves a ...<|separator|>
  38. [38]
    Ancient Hindu healing methodologies as cornerstones of health and ...
    May 14, 2025 · This study explored how Hindu beliefs, practices and healing methodologies enables the physical health and mental well-being of individuals and their families.
  39. [39]
    Divine Intervention and Disguise in Homer's Iliad - Brandeis University
    Disguise interventions are when divine beings appear to a mortal undercover in disguise. These disguise interventions fall into two categories: unrecognized ...
  40. [40]
    Four Representational Perspectives on Divine Intervention in Greek ...
    The semantic aspect of “divine intervention” in Greek antiquity, ie the quest for a specific divine message behind a “divine intervention,” is very important ...<|separator|>
  41. [41]
    Divine Intervention | UC - University of Canterbury
    Nov 20, 2023 · The ancient Greeks and Romans expected their gods to meddle in their affairs and to intervene in their daily lives by answering their prayers ...
  42. [42]
    Karma, Causation, and Divine Intervention - jstor
    According to the law of karma, our actions have consequences not only for our dispositions and tendencies (samskairas), but also for the nondispositional.
  43. [43]
    Divine intervention in Buddhism
    Jul 28, 2012 · The Buddhas and Bodhisattvas are always willing to help us as much as they can, but they are limited by the karma of any given situation, and so their ...
  44. [44]
    Buddhism's Perspective on God: A Non-Theistic Approach
    Sep 19, 2023 · The Buddha's teachings offer a path that does not rely on divine intervention but encourages individuals to take responsibility for their own ...
  45. [45]
    2. Confucianism, Taoism and Chinese folk religions
    Aug 30, 2023 · Gods, which are usually viewed as benevolent and having the power to intervene in worldly affairs, are believed to reside in heaven, Earth or ...
  46. [46]
    Taoism | Religious Studies Center
    It is here that we still have the multiplicity of gods, reverence for ancestors, and divination. The heavenly courts resemble that of the emperor on earth.
  47. [47]
    Exodus 14:21 Then Moses stretched out his hand over the sea, and ...
    Moses stretched out his hand toward the sea, and the LORD drove the sea apart by a strong east wind all that night, and he made the sea into dry land, and the ...Audio · Cross · Study
  48. [48]
    Gods and men in The Iliad and The Odyssey - OUP Blog
    Jul 3, 2014 · Barry B. Powell, author of a new free verse translation of Homer's The Odyssey, examines the gods, fate, divine interventions, and what it means ...
  49. [49]
    Notes on The Iliad Themes - BookRags.com
    Divine Intervention 1: Chryses appeal to Apollo causes the god to attack the Greek armies with plague. This intervention leads to the angering of Agamemnon.<|separator|>
  50. [50]
    3.2 Divine intervention and human agency in The Iliad - Fiveable
    The Iliad explores the complex interplay between divine intervention and human agency in ancient Greek mythology. Gods actively shape events, while mortals ...
  51. [51]
    [PDF] Divine Intervention and Disguise in Homer's Iliad
    A proactive intervention is an intervention that occurs because the god wants to help the human carry out a plan.
  52. [52]
    The Mahabharata War: A Saga of Dharma, Duty, and Divine ...
    Mar 18, 2024 · Divine intervention, through characters like Krishna, serves as a guiding light, helping individuals navigate the murky waters of moral dilemmas ...
  53. [53]
    Understanding Avatars in Hinduism Through the Bhagavad Gita
    Jul 19, 2025 · In this form, God does not personally appear, but empowers a soul with divine shaktis (energies) to carry out a specific mission. Examples:.
  54. [54]
    Bhagavad Gita Chapter 4 Gyan Karma Sanyas Yog Explained
    May 11, 2025 · Avatars may take unexpected forms, reminding us to go beyond form and see divine purpose. Faith and surrender invite divine intervention ...
  55. [55]
    "The Will of God and its intervention in human life as expressed in ...
    The study of the texts reveal that the Ancient Egyptians strongly believed in the divine intervention in their daily lives.Missing: mythology | Show results with:mythology
  56. [56]
    (PDF) Divine Wrath in Ancient Egypt - ResearchGate
    Aug 6, 2025 · This article aims at examining the theme of divine wrath according to Egyptian religious beliefs, in connection with deities and worshippers.<|separator|>
  57. [57]
    [PDF] 'Demons' and Divine Intervention in Ancient Egypt
    On the other, the in terms of divine intervention, instead of using 'demon', genuine Egyptian conceptions should be considered. Gods, of any rank, took forms.
  58. [58]
    Is everything about Norse mythology from the poetic Edda? - Reddit
    Feb 1, 2013 · The Völsunga Saga is a great heroic source, where Odin and heroes like Sigurd intervene. ... Norse gods or temples in passing...), like Gesta ...Norse story of creation : r/norsemythology - RedditScript of Poetic Edda : r/Norse - RedditMore results from www.reddit.com
  59. [59]
    The Poetic Edda: A Dual-Language Edition | Open Book Publishers
    Mar 3, 2023 · The Poetic Edda is a source of Old Norse-Icelandic mythology and heroic legend, containing 36 poems about creation, gods, and personal ...
  60. [60]
    Fuxi, Nuwa, and the Creation of Humanity - Ancient Origins
    Mar 10, 2020 · Fuxi (伏羲) and Nuwa (女娲) are a pair of important deities found in Chinese mythology. They are credited with the creation of humanity.
  61. [61]
    https://oxfordre.com/religion/display/10.1093/acrefore/9780199340378.001.0001/acrefore-9780199340378-e-182
  62. [62]
    Alvin Plantinga on Divine Action - Biola Center for Christian Thought
    Feb 12, 2012 · Dr. Alvin Plantinga dives into the nature of miracles. Going into scientific detail, Plantinga shows how science looks at God's action.
  63. [63]
    Plantinga, Divine Action, and Free Will - Thomas Jay Oord
    Apr 15, 2013 · They believe God cannot interfere or intervene in that closed system. Divine action for modern science is only a problem, says Plantinga, ...
  64. [64]
    Foreknowledge and Free Will - Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy
    Jul 6, 2004 · ... compatibility of free will with divine determinism, an unacceptable result for a libertarian. Peter Graham (2008) argues that the consensus ...
  65. [65]
    [PDF] Miracles and laws of nature - University of Oxford
    Abstract: In this paper, I argue that miracles should not be defined as involving violations of natural laws. They should be defined as signs of particular ...
  66. [66]
    MIRACLES AND TWO ACCOUNTS OF SCIENTIFIC LAWS | Zygon
    Jun 2, 2014 · Since early modernity, it has often been assumed that miracles are incompatible with the existence of the natural laws utilized in the sciences.Empiricist Laws, Determinism... · Familiar Theological... · Miracles And Causal Powers
  67. [67]
    Miracles, Science, and the Laws of Nature - Article - BioLogos
    Mar 12, 2018 · A miracle is a violation of the laws of nature, and as a firm and unalterable experience has established these laws, the proof against a miracle, from the very ...
  68. [68]
    The Compatibility of Natural Laws and Miraculous Divine Action
    Jul 13, 2021 · Belief in miracles and free will is perfectly compatible with belief in scientific laws, properly understood.
  69. [69]
    Miracles and Natural Law: Are They Compatible? - ResearchGate
    Sep 17, 2018 · After reviewing the philosophical and theological debate on miracles and natural law, this article proposes a view that allows for the existence ...
  70. [70]
    Logical Problem of Evil | Internet Encyclopedia of Philosophy
    Logical Problem of Evil. The existence of evil and suffering in our world seems to pose a serious challenge to belief in the existence of a perfect God.
  71. [71]
    The Epicurean Paradox - Epicurus Today
    Jun 28, 2018 · The “Epicurean paradox” or “Riddle of Epicurus” is a version of the problem of evil. Lactantius attributes this trilemma to Epicurus in De Ira Dei.
  72. [72]
    [PDF] The Riddle of Epicurus - People | MIT CSAIL
    Oct 11, 2006 · “Epicurus's old questions”, cited by Philo, aptly summarize the problem of evil: “Is he [God] willing to prevent evil, but not able to? then ...
  73. [73]
    [PDF] The Problem of Evil and Some Varieties of Atheism
    In the final part of the paper I discuss and defend the position of friendly atheism. Before we consider the argument from evil, we need to distinguish ...
  74. [74]
    [PDF] William Rowe on the Evidential Problem of Evil - University of Glasgow
    The argument for atheism based on evil: 1. There exist instances of intense suffering which an omnipotent, omniscient being could have prevented without thereby ...
  75. [75]
    [PDF] Rowe's Arguments from Evil - PhilArchive
    Rowe, W. (1986) 'The Empirical Argument from Evil' in R. Audi and W. Wainwright (eds.) Rationality, Religious Belief and Moral ...
  76. [76]
    Positive therapeutic effects of intercessory prayer in a coronary care ...
    These data suggest that intercessory prayer to the Judeo-Christian God has a beneficial therapeutic effect in patients admitted to a CCU.
  77. [77]
    Intercessory Prayer and Patient Outcomes in Coronary Care Units
    Feb 1, 2000 · In a 1988 study, Byrd reported that intercessory prayer had a statistically significant beneficial effect on the hospital course of patients in a coronary care ...
  78. [78]
    Study of the Therapeutic Effects of Intercessory Prayer (STEP) in ...
    Intercessory prayer itself had no effect on complication-free recovery from CABG, but certainty of receiving intercessory prayer was associated with a ...
  79. [79]
    Study of the Therapeutic Effects of Intercessory Prayer (STEP) in ...
    Intercessory prayer is widely believed to influence recovery from illness, but claims of benefits are not supported by well-controlled clinical trials.
  80. [80]
    Study of the Therapeutic Effects of Intercessory Prayer (STEP)
    Nov 5, 2007 · We evaluated whether (1) receiving intercessory prayer or (2) being certain of receiving intercessory prayer was associated with uncomplicated ...
  81. [81]
    [PDF] Are There Demonstrable Effects of Distant Intercessory Prayer? A ...
    The meta-analysis found no scientifically discernable effect for distant intercessory prayer, with an effect size of g = .100, which did not differ from zero.
  82. [82]
    Intercessory prayer for the alleviation of ill health - PubMed Central
    Prayer is amongst the oldest and most widespread interventions used with the intention of alleviating illness and promoting good health.
  83. [83]
    Outcomes of Intercessory Prayer for those who are Ill - NIH
    Scientific studies on intercessory prayer for the ill have yielded mixed results, with some studies showing no effect, while others show some positive results.
  84. [84]
    The Lourdes Medical Cures Revisited - PMC - NIH
    Lourdes cures, from 1858-1976, were often accepted without question, with about 4,516 estimated. Initially, records were crude, and no cures were certified ...
  85. [85]
    (PDF) Unexpected healings in Lourdes catholic sanctuary
    Aug 9, 2025 · The investigations have formalized into a process handled by the Lourdes Medical Bureau and the Lourdes International Medical Association.
  86. [86]
    The relics of Jesus and Eucharistic miracles: scientific analysis of ...
    Nov 9, 2024 · The blood type on all three textiles was found to be AB by serological testing; a similar result was observed for various modern Eucharistic miracles.
  87. [87]
    Scientific Analysis of Eucharistic Miracles: Importance of a ...
    Nov 13, 2024 · Four of the most scientifically studied Eucharistic miracles have occurred in the twenty-first century, and numerous, lesser-studied events may ...
  88. [88]
    Three Eucharistic Miracles: Which Cases Have Undergone the Most ...
    Jun 11, 2023 · The three apparent Eucharistic miracles that have undergone the most extensive scientific analysis happened in Buenos Aires, Argentina (1992, 1994, 1996).
  89. [89]
    The Lady of Fátima & the Miracle of the Sun | Live Science
    May 2, 2013 · The story of a famous miracle in Fátima, Portugal, began in May 1917, when three children (ages 7, 9, and 10) claimed to have encountered the Virgin Mary.
  90. [90]
    Fatima pictures and testimonials: in-depth analysis | Scientia et Fides
    Mar 14, 2021 · Using photographs and testimonials, we will analyze details of the “miracle of the spinning sun” on October 13, 1917, at solar noon near Fatima.
  91. [91]
    Les miracles de Lourdes
    While more than 7,000 cases of healing have been reported at Lourdes since the apparitions, 70 cases have been recognised as miraculous by the Church2 so far.
  92. [92]
    Lourdes confirms 71st miracle—and the first for an English speaker
    Dec 10, 2024 · The 70th person miraculously cured is still alive, de Franciscis said. She is a French woman religious, Sister Bernadette Moriau, now over 85.Missing: verified | Show results with:verified
  93. [93]
    New miracle confirmed from Lourdes sanctuary - Catholic Review
    Apr 17, 2025 · Bishop Vincenzo Carmine Orofino of Tursi-Lagonegro in southern Italy officially declared the miraculous nature of the healing of Raco April 16.Missing: verified | Show results with:verified
  94. [94]
    4 Approved Eucharistic Miracles from the 21st Century - Magis Center
    Aug 31, 2020 · There is a handful that has taken place in just the past twenty years. Below are four stories of approved and recent Eucharistic miracles.
  95. [95]
    Vatican Recognizes Eucharistic Miracle in India: Christ's Face ...
    May 17, 2025 · The Vatican has officially recognized as a Eucharistic miracle the appearance of Jesus Christ's face on a consecrated host during Mass in Kerala, India.
  96. [96]
    Alive Due to Divine Intervention - C.S. Lewis Institute
    Jun 6, 2013 · Catherine Sanders shows us God's miraculous intervention in her husband Wallace's near-death experience that arose from a seemingly simple ...Missing: contemporary | Show results with:contemporary
  97. [97]
    A Remarkable Case of a Peer-Reviewed Modern Miracle
    Jun 25, 2019 · The case is about a 23-year old white male who experienced intermittent cramping and projectile vomiting at one week of age.Missing: empirical studies
  98. [98]
    Making a case for medical miracles - PMC - NIH
    This book is about the form and identification of medical miracles, the practice of the attending physicians and the manner in which people sought divine help.
  99. [99]
    “Miracles Today?” A Medical Critique of Craig Keener's miracle claims
    Jul 8, 2022 · A recent book presents miraculous healings brought about by prayer, yet there remains no good evidence of even a single Christ-like miracle.
  100. [100]
    A Psychology of the Miraculous
    Mar 1, 1994 · Spontaneous remission is too mystical-sounding; it's like the medieval term "spontaneous generation," when they didn't have enough science ...
  101. [101]
    Implicit pattern learning predicts individual differences in belief ... - NIH
    Sep 9, 2020 · The Belief in Divine Intervention Scale ... Cognitive biases explain religious belief, paranormal belief, and belief in life's purpose.<|separator|>
  102. [102]
    Why do so many people believe in miracles? - Oxford Academic
    Belief in miracles is widespread because humans are cognitively and developmentally biased towards forming and transmitting such a belief.
  103. [103]
    Confirmation Bias In Psychology: Definition & Examples
    Confirmation bias is the tendency to look for information that supports, rather than rejects, one's preconceptions.
  104. [104]
    Placebo Effects in the Context of Religious Beliefs and Practices
    May 6, 2021 · Placebos in the context of religious beliefs and practices can change the experience of emotional salience and cognitive control.
  105. [105]
    Spirituality: an overlooked predictor of placebo effects? - PMC
    Empirical evidence suggests that spirituality may under certain conditions be a predictor of placebo response and effects.
  106. [106]
    A Sign of Divine Intervention: Supernatural Interpretation of ...
    Jul 29, 2025 · We investigate how belief in a higher power (BHP) leads to a supernatural interpretation of a coincidence between a firm's transgression and ...<|control11|><|separator|>
  107. [107]
    An Association of Beliefs in Divine Intervention and Moral Foundations
    Converging lines of evidence suggest that belief in divine intervention is associated with pro- social/moral behavior. The present study tests the hypothesis ...
  108. [108]
    Religiosity predicts prosociality, especially when measured by self ...
    This meta-analysis explores the long-standing and heavily debated question of whether religiosity is associated with prosocial and antisocial behavior at ...Missing: divine | Show results with:divine
  109. [109]
    [PDF] A Force for Good: When and Why Religion Predicts Prosocial Behavior
    lational studies by demonstrating that primed religious concepts (e.g.,. God, divine, holy) also lead to prosocial behavior, such as increased generosity,9 ...
  110. [110]
    Effects of Religious Priming Concepts on Prosocial Behavior ...
    Nov 18, 2016 · Results suggest that priming religious concepts especially the spiritual prime can increase prosocial behaviors. However, no significant effect ...
  111. [111]
    (PDF) The Belief in Divine Control and the Mental Health Effects of ...
    Aug 19, 2020 · In general, decreases in divine control after the experience of stress were found to be harmful for the mental health of the less educated, ...
  112. [112]
    Divine forgiveness and psychological health: The role of divine ...
    Mar 20, 2025 · Divine forgiveness is inversely related to depressive symptoms and positively related to flourishing, but these associations are stronger with  ...
  113. [113]
    Belief in miracles, religious/spiritual struggles, and depressive ...
    This study examines the relationship between the belief that God heals physical illness through miracles with depressive symptoms.Belief In Miracles In... · Data And Methods · Miracles Across Traditions
  114. [114]
    Miracles & medicine: How one's belief in divine intervention impacts ...
    Nov 5, 2019 · First-of-its-kind study reveals that six in ten surrogates believe a miracle may save their loved one from a terminal ailment.Missing: societal effects
  115. [115]
    Praying for a Miracle: Negative or Positive Impacts on Health Care?
    Apr 21, 2022 · We revisit some tendencies in psychological literature about the subject, taking into consideration the various facets of miracle, sociocultural ...
  116. [116]
    Divine intervention? New research looks at beliefs about God's ...
    Mar 9, 2010 · 82 per cent say they depend on God for help and guidance in making decisions; · 71 per cent believe that when good or bad things happen, these ...
  117. [117]
    Spiritual struggles and mental health: New study explores the role of ...
    Sep 6, 2025 · Socially, shared belief in miracles can strengthen communal bonds and reinforce cultural or religious identity.
  118. [118]
    Faith And Health: Divine Intervention Or Good Behavior?
    Oct 30, 1998 · Religion and faith appear to exert positive effects on people's health, but that doesn't necessarily mean divine intervention is at work, ...Missing: empirical impact
  119. [119]
    Belief, Behavior, and Belonging: How Faith is Indispensable in ...
    This study reviews the voluminous empirical evidence on faith's contribution to preventing people from falling victim to substance abuse and helping them ...Missing: divine | Show results with:divine
  120. [120]
    Beyond beliefs: does religious faith lead to a happier, healthier life?
    Dec 3, 2022 · The stress-reducing, life-extending benefits of religion can offer useful strategies even for non-believers, say scientists.
  121. [121]
    The relationship between fatalistic beliefs and well-being depends ...
    Modern social science suggests that fatalistic beliefs are generally detrimental to mental well-being because these beliefs reflect a lack of perceived ...
  122. [122]
    Religious Fatalism and its association with Health Behaviors ... - NIH
    This study examines religious fatalism as a potential barrier to good health and healthy behavior.
  123. [123]
    Effect of religious fatalism and concern about new variants on the ...
    5. Conclusion. It is concluded that religious fatalism has shown a negative effect on the acceptance of the SARS-CoV-2 vaccine.
  124. [124]
    Mediation by Fatalism of the Association Between Symptom Burden ...
    Jan 1, 2025 · Investigators indicate that increased fatalism can detrimentally affect self-care and lead to adverse health outcomes. Thus, our aim was to ...
  125. [125]
    Child Fatalities From Religion-motivated Medical Neglect | Pediatrics
    Apr 1, 1998 · In 15 cases, it could not be established that exclusive reliance on faith healing contributed to the demise. This left 172 children for ...<|separator|>
  126. [126]
    Faith-Based Medical Neglect: for Providers and Policymakers - PMC
    Oct 9, 2020 · Faith-based rejection of medical care has cost the lives of many children and poses challenges to providers. Asser and Swan (1998) reviewed ...
  127. [127]
    United States still too lenient on “faith healing” parents, say ... - NIH
    An investigation led by Asser published in Pediatrics found that between 1975 and 1995, 172 children died following faith healing, 140 from easily curable or ...
  128. [128]
    [PDF] Divine Intervention or Unfair Influence? A Closer Look at Bibles in ...
    Feb 2, 2024 · When jurors put too much weight on the Bible's passages about judgment, jurors risk overlooking the evidence and instead making decisions based ...