Procol's Ninth
Procol's Ninth is the eighth studio album by the English progressive rock band Procol Harum, released in 1975 on Chrysalis Records.[1][2] Produced by the acclaimed songwriting duo Jerry Leiber and Mike Stoller, known for their work with artists like Elvis Presley, the album features original lyrics by Keith Reid and music primarily composed by Gary Brooker.[2] It represents a return to the band's classical-influenced rock sound following experimental efforts in prior releases.[3] The album was recorded at Ramport Studios in Battersea, London, utilizing the band's stable lineup at the time: Gary Brooker on piano and lead vocals, Keith Reid on lyrics, B.J. Wilson on drums, Chris Copping on organ, Alan Cartwright on bass, and Mick Grabham on guitar.[2][4] Comprising eight tracks, the record blends progressive elements with pop sensibilities, including covers like "I Keep Forgetting" by Leiber and Stoller.[1] The track listing is as follows: These timings are from the original vinyl release.[1] Upon its release, Procol's Ninth received mixed reviews from critics, with some praising its strong opening tracks and melodic compositions, such as the marimba-driven "Pandora's Box," while others noted a lack of innovation and undistinguished songs compared to the band's earlier masterpieces like A Salty Dog.[5][3] The album has since been reissued multiple times, including expanded editions with bonus tracks from the sessions, such as "Typewriter Torment" and a cover of The Beatles' "Eight Days a Week," enhancing its appeal to longtime fans.[2] Despite not achieving major commercial success, it remains a notable entry in Procol Harum's discography for its polished production and the involvement of Leiber and Stoller.[6]Background
Development
Procol's Ninth marked Procol Harum's eighth studio album and ninth overall release, counting the 1972 live album Procol Harum Live: In Concert with the Edmonton Symphony Orchestra. Following the orchestral opulence of Grand Hotel (1973) and the transitional Exotic Birds and Fruit (1974), the band pursued a deliberate pivot to a simpler, rock-oriented sound, aiming to escape creative stagnation and reconnect with their roots in straightforward rock 'n' roll.[7] Central to this evolution was the decision to engage producers Jerry Leiber and Mike Stoller, legendary figures in rock 'n' roll for their songwriting and production credits on hits by Elvis Presley and The Coasters. Selected for their expertise in revitalizing acts—evident in their recent success with Stealers Wheel's "Stuck in the Middle with You"—Leiber and Stoller were brought on to infuse the project with commercial vitality and a back-to-basics edge, departing from the symphonic flourishes of prior works. Their involvement steered the album toward an earthier, more accessible aesthetic while preserving the band's melodic core.[7][8] Gary Brooker, as pianist, vocalist, and primary composer, drove key creative choices by championing the revival of early material, notably the 1966 composition "Pandora's Box," which dated to the band's formative period and had been initially recorded in 1967. Brooker adapted such pieces to align with the album's refreshed direction, often tailoring music to complement Reid's words for structural cohesion. Leading into the sessions, the lineup had solidified around Brooker, lyricist Keith Reid, organist Chris Copping, bassist Alan Cartwright, drummer B.J. Wilson, and guitarist Mick Grabham, who replaced Dave Ball post-Grand Hotel.[8][7] Keith Reid sustained his essential partnership with Brooker, delivering lyrics that delved into mythological motifs and introspective themes, as seen in allusions to Pegasus and personal turmoil. This approach refined the band's signature literary style into a more concise form suited to the rock-leaning framework.[8][9]Songwriting
The songwriting for Procol's Ninth centered on the longstanding partnership between pianist and vocalist Gary Brooker and lyricist Keith Reid, who co-authored the album's seven original tracks. Reid typically composed lyrics first, delivering them in batches to Brooker, who then crafted melodies at the piano to match their phrasing and emotional tone, a process akin to that of Elton John and Bernie Taupin. For this album, Reid's contributions adopted a pithier, more universal style compared to the band's earlier, more ornate works, emphasizing concise structures that aligned with the record's shift toward a streamlined rock sound.[10][8] A notable example of this collaborative evolution is "Pandora's Box," the album's opening track and a UK Top 20 single. Originally sketched by Brooker and Reid as early as 1967 during the band's formative years, the song was initially abandoned when its elements did not coalesce but was revived and revised for Procol's Ninth, incorporating a harder rock edge with a Ravi Shankar-inspired riff enhanced by marimba and brass overdubs recorded in New York. This revision allowed the track to fit the album's more direct, earthy aesthetic while retaining Reid's evocative imagery of mythological chaos, such as references to Pegasus and Snow White.[8][11][6] The album marked a departure for Procol Harum by including the cover song "I Keep Forgetting" by Jerry Leiber and Mike Stoller (a 1962 hit for Chuck Jackson), encouraged by the producers to fill gaps where prepared originals did not suit the album's vibe, ensuring the cover blended seamlessly with the new material through Brooker's soulful arrangements.[8][12][1] Thematically, Reid's lyrics drew on mythological and literary references, reflecting his penchant for abstract, poetic narratives that underscored a blend of mythic grandeur and personal reflection on loss, doubt, and creativity.[8][9]Recording and Production
Studio Sessions
The recording of Procol's Ninth took place primarily at Ramport Studios in Battersea, London, during a concentrated period in early 1975. A demo for "Without a Doubt" was recorded at Phillips Studio near Marble Arch.[8][13] Some overdubs, such as brass sections, were completed later in New York.[8] The sessions lasted approximately three weeks, from late March to mid-April 1975, with the band working seven-hour days and taking weekends off to maintain focus and energy through live band takes.[8] This efficient schedule emphasized capturing the group's raw performance dynamic, minimizing extensive layering during the initial tracking phase.[8] Logistical challenges arose from the band's desire to break from prior production routines, leading to the selection of Jerry Leiber and Mike Stoller as producers after considering others like Bob Ezrin; their structured, business-oriented approach sometimes conflicted with Procol Harum's more intuitive creative process.[8] Additionally, the shift toward a simpler rock sound required balancing the group's established classical elements with a stripped-back R&B influence, adapting to evolving musical trends.[8] Key timeline events included rehearsals in early 1975 to refine material, followed by full band tracking starting late that month.[8] Overdubs and finalization wrapped by mid-April, allowing time for the album's release on August 1, 1975.[8]Production Approach
The production of Procol's Ninth marked a deliberate shift toward minimalism, stripping away the orchestral grandeur that characterized earlier Procol Harum albums like Grand Hotel. Producers Jerry Leiber and Mike Stoller, renowned for their work on 1950s rock 'n' roll classics such as "Hound Dog," encouraged a starker rock aesthetic by prioritizing the core rhythm section—piano, guitar, bass, and drums—while downplaying the Hammond organ and forgoing full orchestral arrangements. This approach emphasized Gary Brooker's vocals and B.J. Wilson's dynamic drumming, creating a taut, rhythmic sound that evoked a live-band energy with sparse instrumentation, including bass marimba and string synthesizers on select tracks.[14][15] Leiber and Stoller's influence drew heavily from their rock 'n' roll and R&B roots, infusing the album with tighter arrangements and subtle bluesy inflections to counter the band's previous expansive "sound-wall" effects under producer Chris Thomas. They focused on clarity and precision in the mix, ensuring each instrument received distinct emphasis without overcrowding, which resulted in a "viciously exact" and understated sonic palette that highlighted the band's five-piece configuration. This philosophy was applied to both original material and covers, adapting tracks like The Beatles' "Eight Days a Week"—recorded spontaneously as a lighthearted experiment—without significant alterations to preserve Procol Harum's stylistic integrity, while their own composition "I Keep Forgetting" integrated seamlessly with blues-tinged horns.[16][14][17] A pivotal decision was the reworking of "Pandora's Box," originally a brief 1967 instrumental, which Leiber and Stoller extended to over three minutes with dynamic builds, incorporating marimba, acoustic guitar, high string synthesizers, and a flute solo by a New York session musician to enhance its gothic calypso feel. This track exemplified the producers' emphasis on varied sound palettes and emotional depth, ultimately becoming the album's lead single and reaching No. 16 on the UK charts. Overall, these choices fostered a warm, analog-recorded vibe that prioritized natural interplay over heavy overdubs, with Leiber and Stoller supervising elements like brass additions in New York.[15][18][17]Composition
Original Tracks
Procol's Ninth features seven original compositions by Gary Brooker and Keith Reid, showcasing the band's evolution toward a more concise, rhythm-driven sound compared to their earlier symphonic excursions. These tracks blend progressive rock's structural ambition with rhythm and blues grooves, emphasizing Brooker's piano and vocals as the core while incorporating eclectic instrumentation to create varied textures. The album's originals avoid orchestral grandeur, opting instead for taut arrangements that highlight the rhythm section's precision and occasional jazz-inflected harmonies.[15] Pandora's Box opens the album with a sprightly, piano-driven structure that evokes a "Gothic calypso" through its varied sound palette, including marimba, high string synthesizers, strummed acoustic guitar, flanged lead guitar by Mick Grabham, and flute from a New York session musician. The track builds delicately from an initial drone-like motif, contrasting the band's prior louder efforts with its understated fusion of prog rock and exotic rhythms. Clocking in at 3:33, it sets a mythological tone through its rhythmic propulsion and Brooker's emotive delivery.[15] Fool's Gold, lasting 3:58, employs a sparse, muscular arrangement captured in a live studio take with minimal overdubs, featuring prominent piano, brass accents, and a steady drum pulse. Its structure revolves around emotive ambiguity, with Brooker's clear diction navigating Reid's taut, image-rich phrasing over a bluesy undercurrent that fuses R&B swing with progressive restraint. The brass adds a soulful layer without overwhelming the piano-led melody.[15] At 3:35, Taking the Time begins with a bluesy piano prelude incorporating a Bach-like cadence, evolving into a rhythmic, seductive swing driven by organ fills, overdubbed horns, and understated drums. This mid-tempo piece highlights the band's rhythmic tautness, blending jazzy undertones with prog rock's harmonic sophistication while keeping the focus on Brooker's vocal phrasing and the groove's subtle propulsion.[15] The Unquiet Zone (3:34) drives forward with intricate stereo-panned drums by B.J. Wilson and a Hohner D6 clavinet, underpinned by piano and organ, plus brass contributions from David Sanborn. Its structure allows for expansive live interpretations up to 12 minutes, but the studio version remains concise, featuring passionate vocals over jazzy chords that merge R&B energy with progressive builds, emphasizing the bass's steady anchor.[15] The 4:32 The Final Thrust adopts a simple hook at a facetious tango tempo, with double-tracked piano, thin Hammond organ, military snare drums, and prominent bass from Alan Cartwright. This track's instrumentation creates an anemic yet comic ensemble feel, with backing voices adding edge; its stylistic mix of prog rock's irony and R&B's rhythmic snap underscores the band's playful side without dominating guitar elements.[15] Without a Doubt, also known as "The Poet" and running 4:30, presents a monolithic structure with majestic yet ponderous pacing, highlighted by Bösendorfer piano, brass swells, tambourine, and a reggae off-beat. The arrangement contrasts grand delusions with eclectic rhythms, fusing prog rock's scale with R&B's groove through Brooker's rich tonal palette and the rhythm section's disciplined support.[15] Closing the originals at 2:55, The Piper's Tune roams across keys in a careful ensemble structure, led by Lowrey organ drone and subtle guitar accents. Its Caledonian folk-prog style evokes a wandering melody, with drums and bass providing a steady, understated groove that complements Brooker's vocals and Reid's evocative wordplay, maintaining the album's balance of introspection and drive.[15] Across these tracks, common traits include Gary Brooker's commanding piano and vocals as the focal point, Keith Reid's cryptic yet taut lyrics that infuse literary depth, and a fusion of progressive rock's harmonic complexity with R&B's rhythmic vitality. Instrumentation consistently features Chris Copping's organ for atmospheric swells, Alan Cartwright's bass and B.J. Wilson's drums for a steady groove, and Mick Grabham's guitar adding sharp edges without overpowering the ensemble—creating a cohesive yet diverse sound palette distinct from the album's cover songs.[15]Cover Songs
Procol Harum's Procol's Ninth features one cover version that pays homage to the band's musical influences while integrating elements of their signature progressive rock style: "I Keep Forgetting," drawn from the 1962 R&B hit originally recorded by Chuck Jackson and penned by Jerry Leiber and Mike Stoller, the album's producers, who had a hand in shaping its inclusion as a tribute to their own legacy.[19] Jackson's version reached No. 55 on the Billboard Hot 100, characterized by its brassy soul arrangement, but Procol Harum reworks it into a swinging, mid-tempo closer emphasizing Brooker's emotive baritone vocals and a prominent bass groove driven by Chris Copping, creating a more introspective and groove-oriented feel.[20] Minimal alterations are made to the core melody, yet the band's classical influences shine through in understated organ layers and piano embellishments that lend an authentic yet refreshed texture, aligning with the producers' vision for the album's atmospheric shift. At 3:25 in duration, the track was chosen for its stylistic fit with Procol Harum's blues-rock roots, encouraged during studio sessions to honor Leiber and Stoller's songwriting prowess while avoiding overly literal replication.[1][8] This cover represents a deliberate nod to foundational rock and soul influences, with Leiber and Stoller's direct involvement ensuring arrangements that balanced reverence and innovation, though they deviate little from the original's melodic structures to preserve its emotional core.[8]Release
Initial Release
Procol's Ninth was initially released on 1 August 1975 by Chrysalis Records in both the United Kingdom and the United States.[21][1] The album appeared in the format of a vinyl LP, bearing the catalog number CHR 1080.[22][23] Its packaging included a gatefold sleeve containing a black-and-white photograph of the band posed in London's Chinatown, shot by photographer James Cotier.[15] A cardboard insert provided lyrics and credits for the tracks.[22] Initial pressings targeted markets in Europe and North America, while promotional copies distributed to media and retailers often included additional lyric sheets.[1]Promotion
The promotion of Procol's Ninth began with the release of the lead single "Pandora's Box" on July 25, 1975, through Chrysalis Records in the UK.[24] Backed with "The Piper's Tune" on the B-side, the single marked the band's first top-20 hit since the 1972 reissue of "A Whiter Shade of Pale," peaking at No. 16 on the UK Singles Chart after entering on August 23.[25][26] To support the single, Procol Harum appeared on BBC's Top of the Pops on September 17, 1975, performing the track to build anticipation for the album's August launch.[27] The album's marketing emphasized the high-profile production collaboration with songwriting duo Jerry Leiber and Mike Stoller, positioning Procol's Ninth as a return to rock 'n' roll roots amid the progressive rock landscape. This angle was featured in music publications, including a Melody Maker review that highlighted the producers' influence on the album's starker sound and rhythmic drive.[28] Chrysalis distributed promotional press kits containing band photos, biographies, and liner notes to journalists and radio stations, targeting progressive and mainstream rock audiences to underscore the album's blend of original material and covers like "I Keep Forgetting."[15] Touring provided further momentum, with Procol Harum embarking on a UK and European itinerary from September to December 1975, coinciding with the album's rollout. The schedule included television spots in September, a Scandinavian leg in early November (e.g., Helsinki's Finlandia Hall on November 8), mid-month UK university performances (such as Leicester University on November 29), and continental European shows closing the year (e.g., Paris's Salle Pleyel on December 10).[27] Setlists prominently featured Procol's Ninth tracks like "Pandora's Box" and "Fool's Gold" alongside staples such as "A Whiter Shade of Pale," helping to sustain radio airplay and live buzz across the region.[27]Reception
Contemporary Reviews
Upon its release in August 1975, Procol's Ninth received generally positive to mixed reviews from contemporary music publications, with critics appreciating the album's shift toward a harder, more straightforward rock sound under the production of Jerry Leiber and Mike Stoller, though some noted uneven songwriting and production choices.[16][29] In Sounds, Angus MacKinnon described the album as "in every way an excellent record," praising Leiber and Stoller's production for delivering a "stark and viciously exact" sound that emphasized rhythmic tautness and clarity in instrumentation, marking a beneficial departure from the more expansive style of previous producer Chris Thomas.[16] He highlighted tracks like "Pandora's Box" and "Final Thrust" as particularly resilient, signaling a reinvigoration for the band after the "hesitantly ineffectual" Exotic Birds and Fruit.[16] Rolling Stone's Bud Scoppa echoed this enthusiasm for the production, calling it "wonderfully deft" and noting that Leiber and Stoller seemed to "know Procol better than it knows itself," resulting in the band's "hardest, grittiest recording" in years with exceptional performances from drummer B.J. Wilson, singer Gary Brooker, and guitarist Mick Grabham.[29] However, Scoppa critiqued lyricist Keith Reid's contributions as "resolute redundancy," with fanciful stylizations lacking meaning, making the originals often "deficient" despite Brooker's playful, infectious arrangements; he lauded the cover of Leiber and Stoller's "I Keep Forgetting" as the album's best track.[29] Similarly, Cash Box praised the lead single "Pandora's Box" for its energetic, hook-laden quality, predicting it would be a persistent earworm. In New Musical Express, Tony Stewart viewed the album as "still a good album of music" that showed more positiveness than Exotic Birds and Fruit, crediting Leiber and Stoller's involvement for revitalizing the band's sound, though he questioned certain decisions like the reduced prominence of organist Chris Copping and the use of "weak" synthesized strings that dulled the overall bite.[30] Creem's Ken Barnes found the album encouraging amid the band's recent stagnation, noting intermittent R&B and pop flashes for increased versatility, despite a formulaic and monotonous first side and underwhelming covers.[31] Not all feedback was favorable; Melody Maker dismissed it sourly as background noise suitable only "when you're watching a telly programme and the sound has been turned down."[15] Overall, the consensus positioned Procol's Ninth as a solid effort that refreshed Procol Harum's formula without achieving groundbreaking innovation, averaging around three stars across major outlets for its production strengths and selective highlights like "Pandora's Box."[16][29][30]Retrospective Assessments
In the years following its release, Procol's Ninth has been assessed as a transitional album in Procol Harum's catalog, often praised for its streamlined sound but critiqued for lacking the ambition of earlier works. AllMusic awarded it 3 out of 5 stars in a review that highlights the starker production overseen by Jerry Leiber and Mike Stoller, which enhances accessibility by emphasizing Gary Brooker's vocals and reducing orchestral flourishes, while positioning it as a mid-tier entry in the band's discography.[13] Similarly, Prog Archives users rate it an average of 3.01 out of 5 based on 140 ratings (as of November 2025), with commentators appreciating the effective fusion of blues and progressive elements—such as the flute and organ interplay in tracks like "Pandora's Box"—and suggesting its melodic structures influenced subsequent adult-oriented rock (AOR) developments.[32] Reissues have further illuminated the album's context, particularly through bonus material that underscores the richness of its recording sessions. Coverage of the 2018 expanded edition in Real Gone Music describes the additional tracks, including alternate mixes and outtakes, as elevating an already solid effort into something more compelling, countering detractors by calling it a "decent album" that benefits greatly from the expanded presentation and revealing untapped creative depth.[6] The 2023 Esoteric Recordings three-CD remaster, featuring eight bonus tracks (five previously unreleased) and live 1975 concert recordings, has been noted for its high-fidelity remastering and informative booklet, which draws on interviews to frame the album as an underrated gem in the band's output.[33] Scholarly and biographical works have contextualized Procol's Ninth as a pivotal link in the band's trajectory, bridging the progressive excesses of the early 1970s to their 1991 reformation and 1980s-influenced revival. In Henry Scott-Irvine's 2012 biography Procol Harum: The Ghosts of a Whiter Shade of Pale, a dedicated chapter examines the album's production and songwriting amid lineup changes, portraying it as a stabilizing force that preserved core elements of the Procol Harum sound during a period of flux.Commercial Performance
Chart Positions
Procol's Ninth experienced moderate commercial success on various international album charts following its August 1975 release, reflecting the band's enduring popularity in Europe and North America despite a shift in musical style. The album's chart performance is summarized below:| Country/Chart | Peak Position | Date Achieved |
|---|---|---|
| United Kingdom (UK Albums Chart) | 41 | August 1975 |
| United States (Billboard 200) | 52 | September 1975 |
| Norway (VG-lista) | 11 | September 1975 |
| Finland (Suomen virallinen lista) | 2 | August 1975 |
| Sweden (Kvällstoppen) | 9 | 1975 |
| Denmark (DR Top 20) | 6 | 1975 |
| France | 5 | 1975 |
Sales Figures
Procol Harum's Procol's Ninth, released in 1975, achieved modest initial commercial success, a figure notably lower than the performance of their preceding album Grand Hotel (1973), which sold 60,000 copies in the United Kingdom alone.[37] Reissues have contributed to the album's enduring commercial viability. In the long term, Procol's Ninth has maintained steady catalog sales bolstered by digital streaming platforms, amid the band's total catalog exceeding 275 million streams on Spotify as of November 2025.[38]Track Listing
Original Album
The original 1975 vinyl release of Procol's Ninth by Procol Harum, issued by Chrysalis Records, comprised ten tracks split across two sides, with production handled by Jerry Leiber and Mike Stoller.[1][2] All songs except the covers were written by Gary Brooker and Keith Reid.[13] The track listing, with durations, is as follows: Side one- "Pandora's Box" (Brooker/Reid) – 3:33[1]
- "Fool's Gold" (Brooker/Reid) – 3:58[1]
- "Taking the Time" (Brooker/Reid) – 3:35[1]
- "The Unquiet Zone" (Brooker/Reid) – 3:34[1]
- "The Final Thrust" (Brooker/Reid) – 4:32[1]
- "I Keep Forgetting" (Leiber/Stoller) – 3:25[1][13]
- "Without a Doubt" (Brooker/Reid) – 4:30[1]
- "The Piper's Tune" (Brooker/Reid) – 4:23[1]
- "Typewriter Torment" (Brooker/Reid) – 4:25[1]
- "Eight Days a Week" (Lennon/McCartney) – 2:54[1][13]
Reissue Additions
The first significant reissue of Procol's Ninth came in 2000 from Repertoire Records in Germany, presented as a remastered edition in a digipak format with new liner notes by Chris Welch and an illustrated booklet featuring previously unpublished photos, but without any bonus tracks.[39] In 2009, Salvo released a UK remastered version (SALVOCD028) that added three bonus tracks derived from the original sessions: "The Unquiet Zone (Raw Track)" (4:23), "Taking the Time (Raw Track)" (4:34), and "Fool's Gold (Raw Track with Guide Vocal)" (3:53), all remastered by Nick Robbins.[32] The most comprehensive reissue arrived in 2018 from Esoteric Recordings (a Cherry Red label imprint), expanded to a three-CD digipak set and remastered from the original tapes; a 2023 repress maintained the same content. The first disc includes the original ten-track album plus eight bonus tracks from the 1975 sessions, five of which were previously unreleased raw instrumental or early vocal takes, such as "Pandora's Box (Raw Track)" (3:10) and "The Final Thrust (Raw Track)" (4:20). The second disc features a previously unreleased complete concert from the band's 1975 Canadian tour at the Capitol Theatre in Ottawa, Ontario, on October 25, 1975, with 12 tracks including live renditions of "Pandora's Box" (6:05) and "Grand Hotel" (6:45). The third disc presents a full BBC In Concert recording from the Paris Theatre in London on October 1, 1975, comprising nine tracks like "Fool's Gold" (4:45) and "A Whiter Shade of Pale" (6:20). The package includes a 28-page illustrated booklet with a new essay by Procol Harum expert Roland Clare, excerpts from 1975 interviews with Gary Brooker and Keith Reid, and session photos.[40][41] Additional formats include a 2018 limited-edition 180-gram gray vinyl double LP repress by Friday Music, replicating the original album without bonuses, and digital streaming versions on platforms like Spotify that incorporate the 2018 expanded content as of 2023.[42]Credits
Musicians
The musicians featured on Procol's Ninth (1975) were the core lineup of Procol Harum, which had remained stable since the band's previous album, Exotic Birds and Fruit (1974). This configuration marked the final studio album with this exact lineup, as bassist Alan Cartwright departed afterward. Drummer B.J. Wilson, who had been a member since the band's inception, continued on the next studio album, Something Magic (1977).[39][1][43] The performing personnel included:- Gary Brooker – vocals, piano[39][1]
- Mick Grabham – guitar[39][1]
- Chris Copping – organ[39][1]
- Alan Cartwright – bass[39][1]
- B.J. Wilson – drums[39][1]
- Keith Reid – lyrics[2]