Fact-checked by Grok 2 weeks ago

Project Nimbus

Project Nimbus is a strategic initiative by the government to deliver public services, including infrastructure and capabilities, to its ministries, offices, and affiliated entities through commercial providers. Awarded via competitive tender in 2021 to Google Cloud and in a joint contract valued at approximately $1.2 billion over multiple years, the project seeks to modernize government operations by migrating workloads to secure, scalable cloud platforms while ensuring and compliance with standards. The agreement emphasizes integration of advanced technologies for efficient and across civilian agencies, with Google winning initial tenders for core services and both firms committing to customized solutions tailored to Israel's regulatory and cybersecurity requirements. Despite official descriptions limiting scope to government ministries under commercial that prohibit direct military offensive use, disclosures have revealed indirect access by Israeli defense-related entities, including state-owned arms firms mandated to utilize Nimbus infrastructure. Project Nimbus has faced significant internal opposition from employees at and , who organized protests and petitions arguing the deal enables and applications amid Israel's conflicts, resulting in firings and clashes within the companies; maintains the services adhere to its acceptable use policies and are not intended for weaponry development. These disputes highlight tensions between commercial tech expansion and geopolitical sensitivities, particularly as the project advances Israel's goals post-2021 tender.

History

Inception and Bidding Process

Project Nimbus originated in early 2019 as an initiative by the to develop a unified infrastructure for operations, encompassing ministries, the sector, and other state entities. The project was spearheaded by the Ministry of Finance's Administration, which announced preparations for a large-scale that year to facilitate the of and services to the cloud, addressing longstanding needs for enhanced digital capabilities and . The bidding process constituted a multi-stage, competitive procurement effort spanning roughly three years, involving rigorous evaluation of proposals from major cloud providers to ensure technical compliance, security standards, and cost-effectiveness. Requirements emphasized scalable infrastructure capable of supporting sensitive applications, including those for the , which contributed to shaping the tender specifications due to the project's defense-related scope. In March 2021, reports indicated that (AWS) and had advanced in the key tender for core provisioning—one of four planned tenders under —overcoming competition from and , with the selection limited to global hyperscalers for this segment. On April 21, 2021, the authorities officially named AWS and as joint winners of the initial contract phase, valued at 4 billion (approximately $1.2 billion), for delivering platforms over an initial seven-year term with potential extensions up to 23 years. The agreement included commitments from the providers for reciprocal investments in equivalent to 20% of the contract value, fostering local industrial cooperation. Formal signing occurred on May 24, 2021, following completion of bidder obligations in the tender process, marking the transition from procurement to implementation planning while subsequent tenders addressed ancillary services like support.

Contract Award and Timeline

The tender for Project Nimbus was awarded to Google Cloud and (AWS) on April 22, 2021, following a competitive process initiated by the Israeli . The , valued at 4 billion (approximately $1.2 billion), aims to migrate government data and workloads to commercial cloud infrastructure provided jointly by the two companies. Formal signing of the agreement occurred on May 24, 2021, between the Israeli government and the winning bidders. Officials from the indicated that initial to the would commence approximately two months thereafter, around July 2021, though the system would not operate as a fully centralized platform. The contract spans an initial term of seven years, with options for extensions that could extend the total engagement up to 23 years, allowing for phased implementation of services across government ministries and associated entities, including the Ministry of Defense. This timeline supports Israel's broader strategy, prioritizing secure, scalable adoption without reliance on legacy on-premises systems.

Implementation Phases

Project Nimbus is structured around four primary implementation phases, as outlined in the contract awarded to and (AWS) in May 2021. The first phase focuses on the procurement and construction of the core , including the establishment of local centers within Israel's borders to ensure and compliance with requirements. This involves deploying hyperscale capabilities tailored for government and military workloads, with an emphasis on and redundancy. By late 2022, initial rollout had begun supporting early migrations, aligning with the government's broader goals. The second phase entails the formulation of government policies and frameworks for systematic migration to services, addressing regulatory, legal, and operational guidelines for data handling across ministries and entities. This includes developing standards for environments and protocols to minimize disruptions during transitions from legacy on-premises systems. Policies prioritize maintaining data locality, with restrictions on exporting sensitive information outside , as stipulated in the contract terms. In the third phase, emphasis shifts to and assimilation programs for personnel, aiming to build internal capacity for adoption. This encompasses workshops, initiatives, and hands-on support to upskill thousands of employees, with projections that the project could create up to 4,000 jobs in through local hiring by the providers. focuses on practical applications such as secure , tool integration, and with cybersecurity protocols, ensuring sustained operational readiness. The fourth and ongoing phase involves the operation and maintenance of the cloud ecosystem, providing continuous support, updates, and scalability for evolving needs over the contract's initial seven-year term, extendable up to 23 years. This includes 24/7 monitoring, incident response, and enhancements to handle increasing workloads, such as those from applications, while adhering to performance agreements. By 2023, operational elements were actively enabling public services for units, marking progress in full-scale deployment.

Contract Details

Scope and Financial Terms

Project Nimbus is a initiative valued at NIS 4 billion (approximately $1.2 billion USD as of 2021 exchange rates), awarded jointly to Google Cloud and in April 2021 following a competitive process. The contract spans an initial seven-year term, with options for extensions that could extend the total engagement up to 23 years, enabling long-term infrastructure support for needs. The scope focuses on delivering comprehensive public services to Israeli ministries, public entities, the , and affiliated organizations, with the primary objective of digitizing operations through and application migration to environments. These services support enhanced operational efficiency, secure storage, and scalability, utilizing data centers within to maintain and compliance with national regulations. Google has publicly stated that the agreement excludes provisions for highly sensitive, classified workloads, particularly those involving intelligence services or weapons-related applications, positioning the project as aligned with and non-offensive governmental digitization efforts. However, internal documents and investigative reports have raised questions about the delineation of versus uses, with some suggesting broader sector integration despite these stated limitations.

Participating Entities

The Government of Israel serves as the primary client and overseer of Project Nimbus, with the leading the initiative to modernize across approximately 30 ministries, offices, and agencies, including elements of the establishment while explicitly excluding sensitive and classified workloads in the initial phases. The project stems from a 2019 tender process managed by the Accountant General in the , aiming to provide scalable to support government digitization without reliance on foreign-hosted data. Google Cloud, a subsidiary of Alphabet Inc., was selected alongside Amazon Web Services as a co-provider in May 2021, responsible for delivering public cloud services including infrastructure-as-a-service (IaaS), platform-as-a-service (PaaS), and software-as-a-service (SaaS) tailored to Israeli government needs. Under the joint contract valued at roughly $1.2 billion over ten years, Google contributes expertise in AI integration and data analytics, with services commencing rollout in phases starting in 2022. Amazon Web Services (AWS), a division of Amazon.com Inc., shares the contract responsibilities with Google, focusing on secure, hybrid cloud capabilities compliant with Israeli data sovereignty requirements, such as local data storage options. AWS's role emphasizes high-availability infrastructure and integration with existing government systems, with both providers competing internally for workloads to optimize costs and performance. No additional primary contractors beyond Google and AWS were awarded the core tender, though secondary integrations with Israeli tech firms for compliance and customization have been noted in implementation.

Exclusions and Safeguards

The Project Nimbus contract imposes few explicit exclusions on the of or systems to and Amazon's cloud services, allowing clients to transfer "vital systems of high sensitivity level" without restrictions from the providers. Leaked documents indicate that the agreement deviates from Cloud's standard , which typically prohibit uses involving harm to individuals or violations of , thereby omitting such baseline exclusions for this deal. has publicly maintained that the project "is not directed at highly sensitive, classified, or workloads relevant to weapons or intelligence services," though internal assessments acknowledged limited ability to enforce or verify this limitation due to restricted visibility into client usage. Safeguards in the contract are correspondingly narrow, granting the right to suspend services for policy violations but excluding specific protections against applications in or weapon-related , despite recommendations from consultants to bar sensitive uses by entities. The agreement operates under jurisdiction, permitting client uses unless they violate applicable law, with providers required to notify and resist foreign government data access requests but facing challenges in monitoring for risks given the government's unilateral authority to amend terms. Data localization requirements ensure information remains within Israel's borders under government-defined security protocols, though these do not extend to usage oversight by the providers. Internal documents from 2021 highlighted concerns over inadequate and potential enablement of rights abuses, leading to the omission of 's principles from the final terms.

Technical Components

Cloud Infrastructure Provided

Project Nimbus delivers scalable public infrastructure primarily through (GCP) and (AWS), supporting compute, storage, networking, and database services for Israeli government ministries, defense entities, and public organizations. The platform enables dynamic resource provisioning, permitting elastic scaling of virtual machines, , and managed databases without requiring upfront procurement of physical hardware, licenses, or software. This infrastructure operates under a model that integrates on-premises systems with environments, facilitating secure data transfer and workload portability. A core element is the establishment of a dedicated Cloud region in , announced in 2021, which hosts data centers within national borders to minimize , ensure , and comply with local privacy and security laws. This region connects to GCP's global footprint of over 25 regions and 76 zones, providing redundancy and for mission-critical applications. AWS complements this with its own regional infrastructure tailored for sensitive repositories, emphasizing encrypted and controls for defense-related . Both providers offer built-in tools for workload optimization, including automated , management analytics, and integration with existing government IT systems to reduce operational overhead. The provided infrastructure prioritizes resilience and compliance, with features for continuous service availability even under extreme conditions, such as geopolitical disruptions, through geo-redundant backups and mechanisms. Migration services include assessment tools, automated lift-and-shift processes, and refactoring support to modernize legacy applications into -native architectures, thereby enhancing processing efficiency for public services in areas like healthcare and . Overall, the setup supports of adoption across entities, reducing silos and enabling for data analytics and .

AI and Data Analytics Integration

Project Nimbus enables the integration of (AI) and data analytics tools from Google Cloud and (AWS) into Israeli government workflows, primarily for civilian ministries handling sectors like healthcare, , and . These capabilities support , processing, and analysis to facilitate informed decision-making and operational efficiencies, with services deployed via dedicated cloud regions in for low-latency performance. Google Cloud's contributions include Vertex AI for model training and deployment, alongside for scalable data warehousing and real-time analytics, allowing government entities to process large datasets for applications such as predictive modeling in public services. AWS complements this with for end-to-end ML workflows and services like Amazon for querying petabyte-scale data lakes, enabling ad-hoc analytics without upfront infrastructure management. These tools are accessible under the contract's terms, which emphasize compliance with commercial usage guidelines excluding classified or applications. Implementation involves phased for personnel on these platforms, fostering skills in AI-driven insights, such as optimizing through and . For instance, integrations aid in aggregating citizen for evaluation, though official limits details to non-sensitive use cases to maintain protocols.

Security and Compliance Features

Project Nimbus mandates the use of local within Israel's borders to ensure , with all government information processed and stored domestically in adherence to national laws. This localization prevents data from leaving the country, providing a foundational safeguard for sensitive public-sector and economic data against external access or jurisdictional conflicts. The contract's tender conditions establish precedent for information sovereignty, requiring providers to maintain stable, local sites that support functional continuity even during disruptions. Security measures operate under rigorous guidelines from authorities, including the strictest standards for stability and of . activated Israel's first local cloud zone under the project on August 1, 2023, enabling advanced services like while enforcing these protocols to shield against unauthorized access. Cloud complements this by deploying a dedicated in , which facilitates faster, more reliable, and secure handling tailored to governmental needs. Both providers integrate features such as assured workloads to align with regional , ensuring residency and operational resilience without reliance on extraterritorial storage. Compliance extends to Israeli regulatory frameworks, with the project's prioritizing protection of non-classified through encrypted, repositories that domestic repositories for public-sector entities. Initial exclusions for highly classified applications underscore a tiered approach, focusing civilian and administrative workloads on verifiable, auditable rather than universal or specifics like ISO 27001, which are standard but not explicitly detailed in contract disclosures. This structure supports digitization while mitigating risks associated with hybrid cloud environments, though internal provider documents have highlighted challenges in fully monitoring downstream usage for compliance.

Strategic Benefits for Israel

Government Digitization Efforts

Project Nimbus supports the Israeli government's modernization of its by enabling the migration of ministry workloads to commercial public cloud platforms operated by and , fostering scalable and efficient digital operations. The project, tendered in 2019 under the of Finance's leadership, awarded contracts valued at approximately $1.2 billion in May 2021 to provide these services exclusively to government ministries and affiliated units, excluding direct military intelligence applications. A core objective is to transition legacy on-premises systems to environments located within Israel's borders, ensuring residency and while complying with international export controls and provider . This shift, activated with Google's initial local zone on October 20, 2022, allows ministries to leverage elastic computing resources for routine administrative tasks, reducing dependency on outdated and enabling faster deployment of services. The initiative enhances government digitization by facilitating centralized data management, advanced analytics, and integration of tools for non-classified functions, such as optimizing portals and internal workflows. As a flagship component of Israel's national policy, Nimbus promotes across agencies, potentially accelerating initiatives like electronic record-keeping and citizen-facing applications, though full implementation remains ongoing as of 2024.

National Security Enhancements

Project Nimbus supplies public services to Israel's defense establishment, including the (IDF), enabling the migration of workloads to scalable infrastructure that supports operational demands. This shift modernizes legacy systems, allowing for more efficient handling of large-scale essential for military logistics and intelligence operations. A core enhancement lies in bolstering command, control, and cyber capabilities across government IT systems, including those tied to . By leveraging advanced cloud protocols, the project fortifies defenses against cyber threats, which have intensified amid regional hostilities, through features like encrypted storage and real-time threat monitoring integrated into Cloud and AWS platforms. The initiative preserves information by hosting services within Israel's borders under national , minimizing risks of data leakage to foreign entities and ensuring with stringent classifications. This localized approach, combined with mechanisms, guarantees service continuity during disruptions, such as severances or wartime scenarios, thereby enhancing operational resilience for applications. Furthermore, integration of and tools via the cloud providers' platforms enables advanced data analytics for predictive modeling and threat assessment, positioning Israel's apparatus at the forefront of technological adaptation. These capabilities facilitate faster decision-making in dynamic environments, drawing on the $1.2 billion contract's emphasis on AI-driven efficiencies for and entities.

Economic and Operational Efficiencies

Project Nimbus facilitates economic efficiencies for the Israeli government by reducing expenditures on , , and licenses, shifting to a scalable model that minimizes capital outlays for on-premise . This approach also potentially lowers costs associated with development, allowing ministries to leverage pre-built services instead. Broader economic impacts include an estimated addition of approximately 7.6 billion USD to Israel's GDP from 2022 to 2030 through enhanced digital capabilities and ecosystem growth, alongside the creation of over 21,000 new jobs by 2030 in related tech sectors. Operationally, the project upgrades government service efficiency by enabling faster digitization of processes, optimizing IT asset management, and standardizing workflows across ministries, which simplifies lateral operations and accelerates adoption of . It shortens response times for provisioning services to citizens and businesses, improving overall productivity and through advanced data analytics and flexible . Additionally, Nimbus enhances command, control, and cyber defense capabilities, supporting more agile government operations without the constraints of legacy systems. These improvements position to lead in accessible public services, though realizing full benefits requires targeted optimizations beyond basic migrations to achieve intended cost savings.

Controversies

Internal Employee Protests

In April 2024, employees at organized protests at the company's offices in and , as part of the "No Tech for Apartheid" campaign opposing Project Nimbus. The demonstrations, involving dozens of workers, highlighted concerns that the $1.2 billion cloud contract with the enables military applications, including and data analytics potentially used in conflicts. intervened, arresting nine protesters who refused to leave the premises after being asked to do so. Google responded by terminating at least 28 employees directly involved in the protests, citing violations of its code of conduct and policies on harassment, discrimination, and retaliation. Organizers from No Tech for Apartheid claimed the firings numbered around 50, including some managers, and accused the company of suppressing dissent. The Alphabet Workers Union-CWA condemned the actions as retaliatory, noting that the protests disrupted operations minimally but drew attention to broader employee opposition that had persisted since the contract's 2021 award. At , internal protests were less widespread but included notable individual actions. In September 2025, software engineer Ahmed Shahrour, a Palestinian employee in 's Whole Foods division, was suspended after distributing flyers urging colleagues to oppose Project Nimbus and publishing an criticizing the company's ties to . terminated Shahrour's employment on October 13, 2025, stating it violated policies on workplace conduct. This incident reflected ongoing but sporadic employee pushback at , often channeled through s or small-scale organizing rather than large sit-ins.

Allegations of Military Applications

Critics have alleged that Project Nimbus enables military applications by providing the government, including its Ministry of Defense, with advanced and capabilities that support (IDF) operations. The $1.2 billion contract, awarded in November 2021 to and , encompasses services for government ministries, with procurement documents specifying inclusion of defense-related entities, prompting claims that it facilitates , , and tools for and targeting. Investigative reporting has highlighted connections between the project and Israeli military activities, including the requirement for two state-owned arms manufacturers— and —to migrate workloads to and clouds under Nimbus terms. These firms produce systems like drones and , leading to assertions that the infrastructure indirectly bolsters weapons-related , despite corporate denials of direct involvement in classified military uses. Allegations intensified following the October 7, 2023, attacks, with reports indicating the IDF's use of Cloud for enhancing operational capabilities in , such as AI-assisted for . Internal documents leaked in 2024 revealed pre-contract fears that the company could not oversee Israel's application of the technology, potentially allowing its deployment in ways that enable violations, including in military contexts. Organizations and former employees, including those from the No Tech for Apartheid campaign, have cited these links to argue that Nimbus inherently aids IDF aggression, contradicting Google and Amazon's public statements excluding "highly sensitive, classified, or military workloads relevant to weapons or intelligence that might cause harm." Such claims draw on procurement bids and official Israeli admissions of cloud reliance, though they remain contested by the firms' assertions of contractual safeguards.

Human Rights and Ethical Concerns

Critics of Project Nimbus, particularly employee activists and advocates, have argued that the contract enables the government and military to deploy advanced and technologies for , , and targeting systems that risk facilitating violations against in and the . In an dated October 12, 2021, workers from and condemned the deal, claiming it supplies infrastructure to an military apparatus documented by organizations like as employing discriminatory policies in land administration and settlement expansion. Leaked internal Google documents from 2024 and 2025, as reported by The New York Times and The Intercept, reveal that company executives expressed early concerns over the inability to control or monitor Israel's application of Nimbus services, potentially linking them to activities such as settler violence facilitation or military operations in occupied territories. These documents indicate Google proceeded despite foreseeing risks of complicity in abuses, including inadequate due diligence on human rights impacts prior to the October 7, 2023, Hamas attacks. Following the escalation of conflict in , allegations intensified that Nimbus-supported tools were integrated into Israeli Defense Forces () operations, including for targeting, with public statements from Israeli officials highlighting cloud dependencies for wartime data processing. A Wired investigation in July 2024 documented requirements for major Israeli arms manufacturers to utilize and cloud services, blurring lines between civilian government use and military applications despite company assurances. Google and Amazon have defended the project by stating it excludes "highly sensitive, classified, or military workloads relevant to weapons or intelligence activities," positioning it as supportive of routine government digitization rather than offensive capabilities. However, TIME reporting in April 2024 confirmed deeper post-October 7 negotiations between and Israel's Ministry of Defense, including expanded access, which critics cite as evidence contradicting these limitations and raising ethical questions about indirect enablement of disproportionate force without verifiable safeguards against misuse. Broader ethical concerns focus on the dual-use potential of scalable infrastructure for in asymmetric conflicts, where empirical from prior Israeli systems—like facial recognition in the —suggests amplification of power imbalances absent robust export controls or third-party audits. Proponents of the concerns, often aligned with campaigns like No Tech for Apartheid, emphasize the absence of Google's principles in the contract terms, as flagged by internal consultants, potentially prioritizing commercial interests over causal accountability for downstream harms.

Company Defenses and Fact-Checks

Google has repeatedly asserted that Project Nimbus provides cloud computing services exclusively for civilian Israeli government ministries, operating under its standard commercial terms of service and excluding highly sensitive, classified, or military workloads related to weapons or intelligence services. In response to employee protests and external criticisms, Google Cloud leadership, including CEO Thomas Kurian, emphasized in 2021 that the $1.2 billion contract supports digitization efforts for public sector entities like health, education, and transportation, with no direct ties to the Israeli Defense Forces (IDF). The company has also committed to reciprocal investments in Israel amounting to 20% of the contract value, framing the deal as a mutual economic partnership rather than a security-focused initiative. However, leaked internal documents and investigative reports have contradicted these assurances, revealing that Project Nimbus operates under "adjusted" negotiated specifically with the government, bypassing standard Google policies on prohibited uses such as or weaponry. For instance, a 2021 email from Google's legal team acknowledged risks of the technology enabling violations, including potential Palestinian targeting, while expressing concerns over limited oversight of end-use by authorities. Public statements from officials, including representatives, have described Nimbus as serving "all government bodies," with over 70% of Google's allocation reportedly directed to the Ministry of Defense, undermining claims of civilian exclusivity. Amazon Web Services (AWS), Google's partner in the joint bid, has offered fewer public defenses, generally describing its involvement as providing standard cloud infrastructure to sovereign clients without carve-outs for military applications. AWS executives have highlighted the contract's role in enhancing Israel's cloud sovereignty, with data remaining within the country, but avoided explicit denials of IDF access. Fact-checking efforts, including Wired's analysis of procurement documents, indicate AWS services under Nimbus have been integrated into IDF operations, such as data analytics for targeting, despite the companies' portrayals of commercial intent. Amazon's broader acceptance of defense contracts, including separate deals with Israeli arms firms like Rafael and IAI, further suggests no internal prohibitions aligned with Google's stated limitations.

Impact and Developments

Deployment Outcomes

The deployment of Project Nimbus commenced following the contract award in April 2021, with initial infrastructure setup including the establishment of a Cloud region in . By October 2022, the Israeli National Digital Agency launched a government service platform known as the on this infrastructure, enabling initial migrations of workloads to secure environments. This phase supported the transition of sensitive data repositories for agencies, aiming to reduce reliance on on-premises systems and enhance operational scalability. As of 2024, Project Nimbus facilitated the integration of cloud services into defense-related operations, with reports indicating usage by the for storing intelligence data on residents. State-owned arms manufacturers were mandated to adopt and cloud services under the project, strengthening links between civilian government digitization and military applications. These deployments contributed to Israel's national cloud initiative, described by the as providing efficient services for government entities, though specific metrics on workload migrations or performance gains remain limited in public disclosures. By mid-2025, ongoing implementation raised internal concerns at regarding monitoring capabilities for potential impacts from military uses, underscoring the project's dual civilian-military deployment trajectory. The contract's structure, spanning an initial seven years with potential extensions to 23, positions as a foundational element for Israel's and strategy, integrating with broader national programs for technological advancement.

Broader Geopolitical Implications

Project Nimbus contributes to Israel's digital sovereignty by mandating that government data, including from entities, be processed and stored within Israeli borders under domestic law and stringent security protocols, thereby reducing vulnerabilities to foreign-hosted in a region marked by persistent threats from Iran-backed proxies. This localization aligns with broader efforts to safeguard sensitive operations against cyber incursions and risks, as evidenced by the project's inclusion of the and National Cyber Directorate as participants. The initiative fortifies the U.S.- strategic partnership by embedding advanced and capabilities into 's public sector, leveraging to modernize government functions and enhance with U.S. systems critical for sharing and joint defense initiatives. Signed in 2021 for an initial seven-year term with potential extension to 23 years, the $1.2 billion contract positions within 's global network of 25 regions, elevating its role as a technological vanguard in the amid competition from non-Western providers. In countering China's growing footprint in regional cloud markets—through offerings like —Nimbus exemplifies a deliberate toward U.S.-aligned vendors, ensuring secure less susceptible to influence from or , which could compromise or enable backdoor access. This choice reflects causal priorities in great-power tech competition, where adoption of Western platforms sustains qualitative military and edges for U.S. allies facing threats. Despite employee protests at and alleging complicity in applications, the project's persistence—coupled with projected economic gains of approximately 7,700 and $13.9 billion in GDP addition by 2037—demonstrates resilience against domestic U.S. pressures, prioritizing cohesion over ideological objections often amplified by biased narratives. Such dynamics highlight tech's entanglement in , where contracts like Nimbus set precedents for governments procuring resilient digital tools to navigate adversarial environments without yielding to transnational activist campaigns.

Ongoing Challenges and Future Prospects

Despite initial rollout milestones, such as the establishment of cloud region and the National Digital Agency's launch of the Nimbus government service platform in October 2022, Project Nimbus faces persistent implementation hurdles related to and integration with legacy systems across ministries. Internal assessments as of May 2025 revealed apprehensions over limited oversight mechanisms, with documents indicating the company could not effectively track or restrict downstream applications of its technologies by entities, potentially exacerbating risks in conflict zones. Employee activism remains a significant operational challenge, exemplified by Google's dismissal of 28 workers in April 2024 following protests against the contract's perceived military ties, alongside ongoing campaigns like "No Tech for " demanding termination. These internal disruptions have not halted deployment but have strained corporate resources and , with critics alleging complicity in military operations via mandatory cloud adoption by state-owned arms manufacturers like and . Geopolitical tensions amplify ethical and legal scrutiny, as evidenced by UN reports in 2025 highlighting Nimbus's role in supporting wartime after Israel's internal cloud systems overloaded in October 2023, prompting reliance on Nimbus and supplementary providers like . Advocacy groups, including those tracking corporate accountability, continue to press for contract suspension amid allegations of enabling occupation-related activities, though no verified legal halts have occurred as of October 2025. Looking ahead, Project Nimbus is positioned for expanded utilization in Israel's national cloud infrastructure, with the OECD noting its role in delivering secure services to agencies as of July 2025, potentially incorporating advanced capabilities for efficiency gains. However, sustained protests and international pressure may constrain , particularly if U.S. policy shifts or BDS-influenced efforts intensify, while deepening integrations—such as Google's separate $45 million propaganda amplification contract with Netanyahu's office in 2025—signal broader entrenchment despite unresolved monitoring gaps. Proponents anticipate enhanced operational resilience for civilian and security needs, but causal links to military applications could invite future regulatory challenges under emerging global ethics frameworks.

References

  1. [1]
    About Nimbus Cloud Me In - Gov.il
    Apr 30, 2023 · The Nimbus project is a strategic Government project, which enables the provision of public cloud services for Government Ministries and associated units.
  2. [2]
    the "Project Nimbus": the Amazon AWS (Amazon Web Services ...
    Aug 1, 2023 · The "Project Nimbus" is designed to provide a comprehensive response to the provision of cloud computing services for the Israeli government.
  3. [3]
    Google Cloud selected to provide cloud services to digitally ...
    May 26, 2021 · The Accountant General of Israel, Mr. Yali Rothenberg, congratulates Google on their winning bid in the first tender of "Project Nimbus", a ...
  4. [4]
    Project Nimbus - National Cloud Infrastructure - OECD.AI
    Jul 9, 2025 · Project Nimbus is Israel's national cloud initiative to provide secure and efficient cloud services for government agencies.
  5. [5]
    The Hidden Ties Between Google and Amazon's Project Nimbus ...
    Jul 15, 2024 · “The Nimbus contract is for workloads running on our commercial cloud by Israeli government ministries, who agree to comply with our Terms of ...
  6. [6]
    Google Contract Shows Deal With Israel Defense Ministry | TIME
    Apr 12, 2024 · Project Nimbus is a controversial $1.2 billion cloud computing and AI agreement between the Israeli government and two tech companies: Google ...Missing: details | Show results with:details<|separator|>
  7. [7]
    Documents Contradict Google's Claims About Its Project Nimbus ...
    Dec 2, 2024 · A previously undisclosed email and new documents show the Project Nimbus deal isn't covered by Google's general terms of service.
  8. [8]
    Nimbus Tender
    The Nimbus project began at the start of 2019, and is intended to provide a comprehensive framework for the provision of public cloud services to the ...
  9. [9]
    Google, AWS win $1.2 billion Israel Nimbus tender for cloud services
    Apr 22, 2021 · US tech giants Google and Amazon Web Services have won a NIS 4 billion ($1.2 billion) tender to provide cloud services to Israeli government agencies.
  10. [10]
    Israel signs cloud services deal with Amazon, Google | Reuters
    May 24, 2021 · Nimbus is a multi-year project intended to provide a comprehensive solution for the provision of cloud services to the government, the defence ...Missing: timeline | Show results with:timeline
  11. [11]
    Amazon, Google reportedly oust Microsoft, Oracle in massive Israel ...
    Mar 31, 2021 · The tender for setting up the data center, which is one of four tenders to be issued by the Nimbus project, was open only to international tech ...<|separator|>
  12. [12]
    Google and Amazon win Israel's NIS 4b. Nimbus cloud tender
    Apr 21, 2021 · The Nimbus Project is intended to provide a comprehensive and in-depth solution for the provision of cloud services to the government, ...
  13. [13]
    Providers of Cloud Services to the Government in the Nimbus ...
    May 24, 2021 · Amazon (AWS) and Google are the winners of the Tender to provide cloud services to the Government in the first part of the Nimbus Project.
  14. [14]
    AWS, Google Win $1B Israeli Government Cloud Migration Project
    Apr 26, 2021 · Israel is inviting local companies to submit bids for cloud migration support work and planning to launch a follow-on tender process for the ...
  15. [15]
    Amazon, Google to employ thousands in Israel for massive Nimbus ...
    May 25, 2021 · The project includes four phases: 1) purchase and construction of the cloud infrastructure, 2) formulation of the government policy for ...
  16. [16]
    The Government of Israel Transitions to Cloud - the Nimbus Project
    Publish Date: 26.10.2022. nimbus-landingzone. Following publication on the commencement of activities in Google's Israeli region last week ...
  17. [17]
    Google Worried Israeli Contract Could Enable Human Rights ...
    Dec 3, 2024 · In 2022, the Pentagon awarded its $9 billion Joint Warfighting Cloud Capability contract to Google, Amazon, Microsoft and Oracle. Image. Thomas ...<|control11|><|separator|>
  18. [18]
    What is Project Nimbus, and why are Google workers protesting ...
    Apr 23, 2024 · Known as Project Nimbus, the joint contract between Google and Amazon signed in 2021 aims to provide cloud computing infrastructure, artificial intelligence ( ...
  19. [19]
    Project Nimbus Contract Ties Google, Amazon to Israel Arms Firms
    May 1, 2024 · Google and Amazon are both loath to discuss security aspects of the cloud services they provide through their joint contract with the Israeli government.
  20. [20]
    Google Worried It Couldn't Control How Israel Uses Project Nimbus ...
    May 12, 2025 · Google has long defended Project Nimbus by stating that the contract “is not directed at highly sensitive, classified or military workloads ...Missing: details | Show results with:details
  21. [21]
    Google Stakeholders Alarmed By Ethical Challenges of Contract ...
    Dec 12, 2024 · The contract included rights for Google to suspend customers for policy violations but excluded safeguards against surveillance or weapon- ...
  22. [22]
    Project Nimbus - Wikipedia
    Project Nimbus has four planned phases: the first is purchasing and constructing the cloud infrastructure, the second is crafting government policy for moving ...
  23. [23]
    Internal Google documents reveal concerns about its cloud contract ...
    Dec 3, 2024 · Google officials had concerns about potential human rights violations that might be linked to its $1.2 billion contract with the Israeli government.Missing: value exclusions
  24. [24]
    AWS to Open Data Centers in Israel - Business Wire
    Jun 11, 2021 · “We congratulate AWS on their winning bid in the first tender of Project Nimbus, a multi-year flagship project led by the Israeli Government ...
  25. [25]
    https://www.cloudride.co.il/blog/project-nimbus-israel-shaping-the-public-sectors-future-with-cloud-innovation
  26. [26]
    Project Nimbus Israel: Reforming Public Sector with Cloud Innovation
    Jan 23, 2024 · Launched in April 2019, this project aims to provide comprehensive cloud solutions for the government, defense establishment, and various other ...
  27. [27]
    The Google company activated for the first time the local cloud zone ...
    Oct 20, 2022 · The Government of the State of Israel moves to the cloud - the Nimbus project: The Google company activated for the first time the local cloud ...Missing: specifics | Show results with:specifics
  28. [28]
    Documents Reveal Advanced AI Tools Google Is Selling to Israel
    Jul 24, 2022 · The Israeli Finance Ministry announced the contract in April 2021 for a $1.2 billion cloud computing system jointly built by Google and Amazon.
  29. [29]
    Nimbus Cloud Me In - Gov.il
    Apr 30, 2023 · The Nimbus project is a flagship project and a key anchor in the implementation of the Israeli Government's cloud policy.
  30. [30]
    'Order from Amazon': Tech giants storing mass data for Israel's war
    Aug 4, 2024 · In 2021, Israel signed a joint contract with Google and Amazon called Project Nimbus. The stated goal of the tender, worth $1.2 billion, was ...Missing: bidding | Show results with:bidding
  31. [31]
    [PDF] Nimbus CCoE Cloud Migration Webinar - Gov.il
    Feb 22, 2022 · Executing just regular “Lift-and-Shift” of systems will not bring the desired cost savings – actual optimization is required, but for which ones ...
  32. [32]
    Google fires 28 workers over Project Nimbus contract with ... - NPR
    Apr 19, 2024 · The project is a $1.2 billion contract to supply Israel with cloud computing services. As someone who's opposed to the war in Gaza, Montes says ...Missing: implementation | Show results with:implementation<|control11|><|separator|>
  33. [33]
    Google Workers Protest Cloud Contract With Israel's Government
    Apr 16, 2024 · No Tech for Apartheid also published an open letter cosigned by 18 other organizations that demands Google and Amazon immediately cancel their ...
  34. [34]
    Workers accuse Google of 'tantrum' after 50 fired over Israel contract ...
    Apr 27, 2024 · Tech giant fired number of people who protested against $1.2bn Project Nimbus, which supports Israeli military and government.<|separator|>
  35. [35]
    UPDATED: AWU-CWA Statement Following Termination of Workers ...
    Apr 25, 2024 · The protests culminated in nine Google workers arrested and forcibly removed from company premises. Roughly two dozen workers, including some ...
  36. [36]
    Google fires 28 workers for protesting $1.2 billion Israel contract
    Apr 18, 2024 · The protests were led by No Tech for Apartheid, a group of tech workers who have been demanding Amazon and Google drop their Project Nimbus, ...
  37. [37]
    Internal opposition to Google/Amazon "Project Nimbus" for allegedly ...
    In November 2023, workers of Google and Amazon continue to organize and protest against "Project Nimbus" deal with Israeli government.
  38. [38]
    Amazon suspends engineer who urged colleagues to oppose Israel ...
    Sep 12, 2025 · Project Nimbus is a $1.2 billion multiyear cloud‐computing deal awarded in 2021 to Google and Amazon to provide cloud infrastructure, AI and ...
  39. [39]
    Amazon suspends worker who denounced contracts with Israel
    Sep 24, 2025 · Amazon suspended software engineer Ahmed Shahrour hours after he published an open letter criticizing Israel.
  40. [40]
    Amazon fires Ahmed Shahrour for protesting company's work with ...
    Oct 13, 2025 · Ahmed Shahrour, a Palestinian engineer who worked for Amazon's Whole Foods business, was fired on Monday after being suspended last month.
  41. [41]
    Amazon faces mounting opposition from its workers for secretive ...
    Amazon faces mounting opposition from its workers for secretive "Project Nimbus" deal with Israel, possibly providing tech for Israeli forces; Incl. Co. comment.
  42. [42]
    Correcting the Record: Facts and Myths about Project Nimbus
    Dec 9, 2024 · Project Nimbus' contract states that is *not* subject to regular Google Cloud's Terms of Service, which would prohibit using Google's ...Missing: exclusions | Show results with:exclusions
  43. [43]
    Companies Profiting from the Gaza Genocide
    Since 2021, Google has been providing cloud services to the Israeli government under Project Nimbus, a $1.2 billion contract it shares with Amazon.
  44. [44]
    We are Google and Amazon workers. We condemn Project Nimbus
    Oct 12, 2021 · Project Nimbus is a $1.2bn contract to provide cloud services for the Israeli military and government. This technology allows for further ...
  45. [45]
    Why This Google Shareholder Wants an End to Project Nimbus
    Jun 2, 2022 · The contract also provides data support to the Israel Land Authority (ILA), which according to Human Rights Watch, uses discriminatory policies ...
  46. [46]
    Leaked documents reveal Google's alleged awareness of human ...
    Leaked documents reveal Google's alleged awareness of human rights risks in Israel's Project Nimbus deal. Allegations.Missing: exclusions | Show results with:exclusions
  47. [47]
    Google rushed to sell AI tools to Israel's military after Hamas attack
    Jan 21, 2025 · Google has previously said that the Nimbus contract with Israel's government is “not directed at highly sensitive, classified, or military ...
  48. [48]
    Internal Google documents reveal early human rights concerns over ...
    Dec 3, 2024 · Internal Google documents reveal early human rights concerns over controversial Project Nimbus contract with Israel. Read more. "Internal ...Missing: exclusions | Show results with:exclusions
  49. [49]
    Amazon suspends engineer who protested company's work with Israel
    Sep 11, 2025 · Amazon hasn't acknowledged the Nimbus contract beyond stating that it provides technology to customers "wherever they are located." Google has ...
  50. [50]
    https://responsiblestatecraft.org/amazon-israeli-military/
  51. [51]
    Report: IDF using Amazon cloud to store intel on 'everyone' in Gaza
    The stated goal of the tender, worth $1.2 billion, was to encourage government ministries to transfer their information systems to the public cloud servers of ...
  52. [52]
    [PDF] National Program for Artificial Intelligence
    The Program is intended to create a toolbox and organizational environment that will later facilitate AI development and the securing of Israel's leading status ...
  53. [53]
    Clouds of Competition—China's Rise in the Middle East Cloud Market
    May 26, 2025 · In 2021, as part of the government-led Project Nimbus initiative, AWS and Google were selected to establish secure public cloud ...
  54. [54]
    Israel's leading arms makers required to use Google & Amazon ...
    May 1, 2024 · Project Nimbus also establishes its own links between the Israeli security establishment and the American defense industry.
  55. [55]
    From economy of occupation to economy of genocide - UN.org.
    To learn more about Special Procedures of the UN Human Rights Council and the Question of Palestine, click here to visit the dedicated webpage.
  56. [56]
    [PDF] UK corporate accountability network reiterates UN call for legal ...
    Aug 27, 2025 · a. $1.2 billion contract (Project Nimbus) – largely funded through Ministry of. Defense expenditure – to provide core tech infrastructure.”.<|control11|><|separator|>
  57. [57]
    Google's $45 Million Contract With Netanyahu's Office to Spread ...
    Sep 3, 2025 · Google is in the middle of a six-month, $45 million contract to amplify propaganda with Netanyahu's office. The contract describes Google as ...<|separator|>