Fact-checked by Grok 2 weeks ago

Quantum spin liquid

A quantum spin liquid (QSL) is a disordered phase of interacting quantum spins that resists conventional magnetic ordering even at absolute zero temperature, characterized by long-range quantum entanglement, emergent fractionalized excitations such as spinons, and often topological order arising from strong quantum fluctuations.^[1]^[2] The concept originated with Philip W. Anderson's 1973 proposal of resonating valence bond (RVB) states as a novel insulating phase for antiferromagnetic spin-1/2 systems on frustrated lattices, where singlet pairings of spins form a liquid-like superposition without breaking lattice symmetries.^[3] In 1987, Anderson revived and expanded the idea in the context of high-temperature superconductivity, suggesting that the undoped parent compound La₂CuO₄ exhibits a QSL ground state described by RVB physics, which gained renewed attention amid the discovery of cuprate superconductors.^[4]^[5] Subsequent theoretical developments, including the 2006 solution of the Kitaev honeycomb model, introduced exactly solvable models featuring bond-directional interactions that stabilize gapless or gapped QSLs with anyonic excitations and emergent gauge fields.^[1]^[6] Key properties of QSLs include the absence of magnetic long-range order, a spin gap or gapless spectrum depending on the model, and fractionalized quasiparticles that carry fractional spin or charge, leading to phenomena like spin-charge separation and non-Abelian statistics in two dimensions.^[2]^[1] These states are typically realized in geometrically frustrated magnets, such as those on kagome, triangular, or honeycomb lattices, where competing interactions prevent the spins from aligning.^[7] Gapped QSLs exhibit topological order akin to fractional quantum Hall states, while gapless variants may feature Dirac-like spinon dispersions or Majorana fermions.^[1] Experimental signatures include a lack of elastic neutron scattering peaks, continuum-like inelastic scattering from spinons, and anomalous thermal transport, such as half-quantized thermal Hall conductivity.^[8]^[1] Candidate materials for QSLs have been identified in both organic and inorganic compounds, with early examples including the triangular-lattice organic salt κ-(BEDT-TTF)₂Cu₂(CN)₃, which shows no magnetic order down to millikelvin temperatures.^[1] Inorganic realizations feature the kagome-lattice compound herbertsmithite (ZnCu₃(OH)₆Cl₂), where spin-1/2 Cu²⁺ ions exhibit a spinon continuum in neutron scattering, and the honeycomb material α-RuCl₃, which approximates the Kitaev model and displays a half-quantized thermal Hall effect under magnetic fields.^[9]^[1] More recent candidates, such as YbMgGaO₄ and TbInO₃ thin films, continue to provide evidence through spin dynamics and epitaxial growth enabling device integration, though challenges persist in distinguishing QSLs from other disordered states like spin glasses.^[10]^[11] Ongoing research explores applications in quantum computing, leveraging the topological protection of anyons for fault-tolerant qubits.^[1]

Fundamentals

Definition

A quantum spin liquid (QSL) is a state of matter in which interacting quantum spins on a lattice remain in a highly entangled, disordered configuration resembling a "liquid" even at absolute zero temperature, resisting the conventional onset of magnetic long-range order expected in most spin systems.^[4] This phase emerges as a ground state where quantum effects dominate, leading to a paramagnetic response without symmetry breaking. In contrast to conventional magnets, such as ferromagnets or antiferromagnets, which develop spontaneous magnetic order by breaking spin rotational symmetry at low temperatures, QSLs maintain full spin rotational invariance through strong quantum fluctuations that suppress ordering tendencies. These fluctuations arise inherently from the quantum nature of spins, preventing the alignment or antiparallel arrangement of moments that characterizes ordered phases.^[4] QSLs typically involve spin-1/2 systems, where each site hosts a quantum spin operator \mathbf{S}_i with eigenvalues \pm \frac{1}{2} along any direction, and interactions are described by the Heisenberg Hamiltonian

H = J \sum_{\langle i,j \rangle} \mathbf{S}_i \cdot \mathbf{S}_j,

with J > 0 denoting antiferromagnetic coupling and the sum over nearest-neighbor pairs \langle i,j \rangle. This model captures the essential physics of exchange-mediated spin interactions in insulating magnets, without external fields or anisotropies in its simplest form. Such states arise from strong electron correlations in lattice systems where competing interactions, often due to geometric frustration on non-bipartite lattices, hinder the formation of a unique ground state that would support long-range order. The resulting degeneracy or near-degeneracy allows quantum tunneling between configurations, perpetuating disorder at all temperatures.^[4]

Historical Development

The concept of the quantum spin liquid emerged from Philip W. Anderson's 1973 proposal of the resonating valence bond (RVB) state as a novel disordered ground state for the spin-1/2 antiferromagnetic Heisenberg model, particularly on frustrated lattices like the triangular one, where competing exchange interactions suppress conventional magnetic ordering in favor of a liquid-like arrangement of singlet bonds.^[3] In the 1980s and 1990s, the RVB idea experienced a significant revival in the context of high-temperature superconductivity in cuprates, with G. Baskaran, Z.-B. Zou, and P. W. Anderson developing a mean-field theory for the insulating RVB state in undoped La₂CuO₄ and its evolution into a superconducting phase upon doping.^[12] Concurrently, studies by S. A. Kivelson and collaborators emphasized the role of geometric frustration on triangular lattices in promoting spin liquid phases through quantum dimer models and multiple-spin exchange interactions, highlighting the potential for gapless or gapped disordered states without symmetry breaking.^[13] A major theoretical advance in the early 2000s came from Alexei Kitaev's 2006 exactly solvable model on the honeycomb lattice, which demonstrated a gapped Z₂ quantum spin liquid phase with Abelian anyons, while extensions with magnetic perturbations yield non-Abelian anyons suitable for topological quantum computing, thereby providing a concrete realization of fractionalized excitations in a frustrated spin system.^[14] Pre-2020 theoretical progress included N. Read and S. Sachdev's 1991 analysis of deconfined quantum critical points separating antiferromagnetic and spin-gapped phases, where emergent gauge fields allow for fractionalization without confinement in two-dimensional antiferromagnets. Additionally, R. Moessner and S. L. Sondhi's work on classical spin ice models, such as their 2008 identification of magnetic monopoles in pyrochlore lattices, served as an analog for quantum spin liquids by illustrating emergent U(1) gauge structures and Coulomb-phase behavior in highly frustrated systems. Early theoretical frameworks, however, revealed gaps in identifying stable quantum spin liquid realizations, as analytic methods struggled with strong correlations and lattice effects; this was addressed in the 2010s through numerical techniques like the density-matrix renormalization group (DMRG), which provided strong evidence for spin liquid ground states, consistent with but not definitively gapped, in models such as the spin-1/2 Heisenberg antiferromagnet on the kagome lattice, though the precise nature (gapped or gapless) continues to be investigated in recent studies as of 2024.^[15] Building on these foundations, 2020s research has employed advanced numerical methods like machine learning and improved tensor networks to further probe QSL candidates, revealing nuanced phase diagrams in extended models as of 2025.^[16]

Theoretical Models

Frustrated Magnetism

Frustration in magnetic systems arises when the interactions between spins cannot be simultaneously satisfied, leading to incompatible spin alignments on certain lattice geometries. In antiferromagnetic Heisenberg models, this occurs on lattices such as triangular or kagome structures, where the geometry prevents all nearest-neighbor bonds from achieving antiparallel spin configurations, resulting in a highly degenerate ground state manifold.^[17] This geometric frustration is a key driver for preventing conventional magnetic ordering and stabilizing exotic phases like quantum spin liquids (QSLs).^[17] In classical frustrated magnets, thermal fluctuations can suppress long-range order at finite temperatures, but these systems often undergo ordering transitions at sufficiently low temperatures due to weak anisotropies or further-neighbor interactions. Quantum frustration, however, introduces additional disorder through zero-point motion and quantum tunneling between degenerate states, which can prevent ordering down to absolute zero and favor QSL ground states. Unlike classical counterparts, quantum effects amplify the residual entropy and dynamical correlations, making QSL realization more robust in low-spin systems.^[17] A paradigmatic example is the spin-1/2 J1-J2 Heisenberg model on the square lattice, described by the Hamiltonian

H = J_1 \sum_{\langle i,j \rangle} \mathbf{S}_i \cdot \mathbf{S}_j + J_2 \sum_{\langle\langle i,k \rangle\rangle} \mathbf{S}_i \cdot \mathbf{S}_k,

where J1 and J2 are the nearest- and next-nearest-neighbor antiferromagnetic exchange couplings, respectively, and the sums are over nearest neighbors ⟨i,j⟩ and next-nearest neighbors ⟨⟨i,k⟩⟩. Earlier studies proposed that for J2/J1 ≈ 0.5, frustration from the diagonal J2 terms competes with J1, leading to a QSL phase characterized by the absence of magnetic or valence bond solid order,^[18] though more recent high-precision simulations suggest a direct transition from Néel antiferromagnet to valence bond solid without an intermediate QSL.^[19] Frustration plays a central role in QSL formation by lifting conventional ordering tendencies, generating extensive ground-state degeneracy, and promoting correlated yet disordered spin configurations with nonzero entropy at T=0. This degeneracy allows for emergent phenomena, such as fractionalized excitations, in the quantum regime. Numerical methods, including exact diagonalization on small clusters and tensor network techniques on larger systems, have proposed the existence of both gapped and gapless QSL phases in various frustrated models, though the precise nature in cases like the J1-J2 Heisenberg Hamiltonian remains debated.^[17]^[18]^[20]^[19]

Resonating Valence Bonds

The resonating valence bond (RVB) concept describes the ground state of certain quantum spin liquids as a superposition of valence bond coverings, in which pairs of spins on neighboring sites form singlet bonds that fluctuate resonating across the lattice, preventing the emergence of long-range magnetic order. This picture, originally proposed by Paul W. Anderson in the context of antiferromagnetic insulators, posits that strong quantum fluctuations stabilize a disordered state where the spins remain correlated locally through these dynamic singlets but lack global symmetry breaking. RVB states are classified into short-range and long-range variants based on the nature of their correlations and excitations. Short-range RVB states typically describe gapped spin liquids in undoped insulators, where singlet pairings are localized to nearest neighbors, leading to exponential decay of spin correlations and a fully gapped spectrum. In contrast, long-range RVB states arise in doped systems, featuring algebraic spin correlations and deconfined fermionic spinons that emerge from the superposition of extended valence bonds. Mathematically, the RVB ground state can be represented by a Gutzwiller-projected BCS wavefunction, given by

|\Psi_{\mathrm{RVB}}\rangle = P_G \prod_k \left( u_k + v_k c_{k\uparrow}^\dagger c_{-k\downarrow}^\dagger \right) |0\rangle,

where P_G is the projector that enforces no double occupancy (suitable for the large-U Hubbard model), u_k and v_k are BCS coherence factors, and the product is over momentum states k. This ansatz captures the resonating nature of the singlets by projecting a superconducting mean-field state onto the constrained Hilbert space of spin-1/2 degrees of freedom. In RVB descriptions of quantum spin liquids, excitations include deconfined spinons, which are neutral S=1/2 fermionic quasiparticles representing the unpaired spins from broken singlets, propagating coherently through the lattice. In gapped short-range RVB phases, such as those modeled by quantum dimer Hamiltonians, additional vison excitations appear as \pi-flux insertions in the emergent gauge field, corresponding to loop operators that flip the phase of surrounding singlets and carry no spin but induce topological defects. Anderson proposed that frustration in the spin interactions enhances the stability of RVB states by suppressing classical ordering tendencies, favoring the liquid-like phase. Furthermore, in the context of high-T_c superconductivity, the RVB framework links the undoped spin liquid to the superconducting phase through spin-charge separation, where doping introduces mobile holons that Bose-condense to form pairs, while spinons remain in the neutral sector.

Kitaev Honeycomb Model

The Kitaev honeycomb model is an exactly solvable spin-1/2 model on a honeycomb lattice that realizes a quantum spin liquid (QSL) phase with Z₂ topological order, serving as a paradigmatic example of a lattice model hosting abelian anyons. Proposed in 2006, the model features bond-directional interactions that distinguish it from more isotropic frustrated systems. The Hamiltonian of the model is given by

H = -\sum_{\langle ij \rangle^\alpha} K_\alpha \sigma_i^\alpha \sigma_j^\alpha,

where the sum runs over nearest-neighbor bonds labeled by \alpha = x, y, z, \sigma_i^\alpha are Pauli matrices acting on spin-1/2 degrees of freedom at site i, and K_\alpha > 0 are coupling constants that can be tuned independently for each bond type. This anisotropic form, with interactions restricted to a single Pauli component per bond (x-bonds couple \sigma^x, y-bonds \sigma^y, and z-bonds \sigma^z), enables an exact solution through a representation in terms of Majorana fermions. Specifically, each spin is decomposed into four Majorana operators b_i^x, b_i^y, b_i^z, c_i, with the physical spin operators expressed as \sigma_i^\alpha = i b_i^\alpha c_i (up to normalization). The bond interactions then map to fermion bilinears, and the full Hamiltonian is solved by introducing static Z₂ gauge fields on plaquettes (representing vison fluxes) and integrating out the matter fermions, yielding a spectrum of free Majorana fermions coupled to these gauge fields. The ground state of the isotropic case (K_x = K_y = K_z = K) is a flux-free state on the torus, characterized by gapped Z₂ topological order where the low-energy excitations include gapped Majorana fermions (matter excitations) and visons (Z₂ gauge fluxes), forming abelian anyons that obey semionic statistics. Depending on the ratios of K_\alpha, the model exhibits either a gapped QSL phase (for ferromagnetic couplings) or a gapless phase with Dirac cones in the Majorana spectrum (near certain anisotropic limits), both preserving the underlying Z₂ gauge structure. This exact solvability arises from the commuting nature of the plaquette flux operators with the Hamiltonian, allowing a perturbative treatment of gauge fluxes. Perturbative extensions of the pure Kitaev model incorporate isotropic Heisenberg interactions, leading to the Heisenberg-Kitaev model H = H_\text{Kitaev} + J \sum_{\langle ij \rangle} \vec{\sigma}_i \cdot \vec{\sigma}_j, which realizes various spin liquid phases for intermediate J/K. In the perturbative regime (J \ll K), time-dependent perturbation theory in the Majorana representation reveals a gapped Z₂ QSL as the ground state, with phase transitions to magnetically ordered states at larger J/K. Unlike resonating valence bond (RVB) states, which rely on fluctuating singlet coverings and are generally not exactly solvable, the Kitaev model's bond-directional interactions permit this fermionic mapping and extend to non-abelian generalizations via higher-spin or perturbed variants.

Excitations and Properties

Fractionalized Quasiparticles

In quantum spin liquids (QSLs), fractionalized quasiparticles emerge as a hallmark of the underlying topological order, representing excitations that carry fractional quantum numbers compared to the elementary spin degrees of freedom. These quasiparticles, such as spinons and visons, arise from the strong quantum entanglement and gauge-like structures in the ground state, allowing them to propagate independently without forming conventional magnons.^[21]^[1] Spinons are neutral excitations with spin S = 1/2 that carry spin but no charge, serving as fractional counterparts to the original S = 1/2 spins in the lattice. In gapless QSLs, spinons are deconfined, meaning they can move freely over long distances without binding into higher-spin composites, a feature enabled by the absence of magnetic order. In contrast, in phases with conventional spin order, spinons become confined, pairing or binding to form integer-spin excitations like magnons. In the resonating valence bond framework, spinons represent the unpaired spins in a superposition of singlet coverings.^[22]^[21]^[1]^[23] Visons are gapped, spinless excitations corresponding to \mathbb{Z}_2 gauge fluxes in \mathbb{Z}_2 QSLs, where they act as vortices in the emergent gauge field that pierces through plaquettes of the lattice. These fluxes do not carry spin but influence the motion of spinons via mutual statistics, effectively altering the phase of spinon wavefunctions upon encircling. In non-Abelian QSLs, more exotic anyonic excitations appear, exhibiting fractional braiding statistics where the exchange of particles results in non-trivial unitary transformations on their internal states, beyond simple bosonic or fermionic behavior.^[22]^[21]^[1] A prominent example of spinon dynamics occurs in U(1) QSLs, where spinons form Dirac fermions with a linear dispersion relation near Dirac points in momentum space, given by \varepsilon(\mathbf{k}) \propto |\mathbf{k}|, analogous to relativistic particles and leading to gapless excitations. This dispersion arises in models like the \pi-flux phase on bipartite lattices or certain frustrated geometries.^[22]^[21] The dynamical structure factor S(\mathbf{q}, \omega), which probes the spin excitations via neutron scattering, reveals a characteristic continuum in QSLs due to the creation of spinon pairs rather than discrete magnon peaks seen in ordered magnets. This broad spectral continuum spans a range of energies starting from zero (in gapless cases) or a gap (in gapped \mathbb{Z}_2 QSLs), reflecting the deconfinement and fractional nature of the spinons.^[21]^[24] The confinement-deconfinement transition in QSLs can be induced by perturbations, such as magnetic fields or further-neighbor interactions, which bind spinons into spin-1 triplets, effectively confining them and driving the system toward a magnetically ordered phase. This binding is mediated by the emergent gauge fields, where the energy cost of isolated spinons becomes prohibitive, leading to a proliferation of composite excitations.^[25]^[21]

Topological Order

Topological order in quantum spin liquids represents a novel form of quantum matter characterized by long-range entanglement without spontaneous breaking of any symmetry. This phase arises in gapped systems where the ground state is highly degenerate in a topology-dependent manner, such as the four-fold degeneracy on a torus for \mathbb{Z}_2 quantum spin liquids, reflecting the presence of non-local correlations that encode quantum information robustly against local perturbations. Unlike conventional magnetic orders, topological order emerges from the collective entanglement of many degrees of freedom, leading to exotic properties like fractionalized excitations and protected quantum memory.^[26] A hallmark of topological order is captured by the entanglement entropy of a spatial subsystem. For a region with perimeter L, the von Neumann entanglement entropy S scales as S = \alpha L - \gamma, where \alpha is a non-universal area-law coefficient related to short-range correlations, and \gamma is the universal topological entanglement entropy given by \gamma = \ln D. Here, D is the total quantum dimension of the underlying anyon theory; for a \mathbb{Z}_2 spin liquid, D = 2, so \gamma = \ln 2. This subleading constant term quantifies the global entanglement structure and distinguishes topologically ordered phases from trivial insulators. In chiral spin liquids, which break time-reversal symmetry, topological order is further evidenced by non-trivial Chern numbers, resulting in quantized Hall conductance. The spin Hall conductivity takes the form \sigma_{xy} = (n/2) e^2 / h for integer n, analogous to the fractional quantum Hall effect but realized in spin systems without charge transport.^[27] This quantization stems from the chiral edge modes and the intrinsic topology of the ground state wave function. Topological order fundamentally differs from symmetry-breaking orders by the absence of a local order parameter, such as magnetization or staggered patterns. Instead, its signatures are non-local: the ground state degeneracy is probed via string-net operators that create pairs of anyons, or through the modular S-matrix, which describes the mutual statistics of excitations and confirms the topological sector.^[26] Kitaev's toric code provides an exactly solvable lattice model realizing \mathbb{Z}_2 topological order in quantum spin liquids. Defined on a square lattice with plaquette and vertex constraints, it features deconfined electric (e) and magnetic (m) anyons, whose braiding yields a \mathbb{Z}_2 gauge structure, with the ground state exhibiting the characteristic four-fold torus degeneracy. This model illustrates how frustration in spin interactions can stabilize such ordered yet liquid-like phases.^[28]

Experimental Probes

Thermodynamic Measurements

Thermodynamic measurements provide essential bulk probes for identifying quantum spin liquids (QSLs), revealing the absence of magnetic ordering and the presence of fractionalized excitations through equilibrium properties like heat capacity and magnetization. These signatures distinguish QSLs from conventional magnets, where phase transitions lead to sharp anomalies, and from simple paramagnets, which lack correlated spin fluctuations. In QSLs, the spins remain dynamically disordered at low temperatures, often manifesting as gapless or gapped behaviors tied to underlying topological order. Magnetic susceptibility in QSL candidates typically follows Curie-Weiss behavior at high temperatures, reflecting antiferromagnetic frustrations with a negative Weiss temperature θ_W, but deviates at low temperatures without the divergence expected from long-range ordering. Instead, the low-temperature susceptibility often exhibits a power-law form χ ∝ T^{-γ} with γ ≈ 1 or remains nearly constant, indicating persistent spin fluctuations without freezing. This contrasts with ordered magnets, where χ diverges near the transition temperature, and aligns with contributions from delocalized spinons that suppress Curie tails from free moments. Specific heat measurements further highlight QSL characteristics, showing no λ-shaped anomaly associated with magnetic ordering transitions. In gapless QSLs, a linear term dominates at low temperatures, C ∝ γ T, arising from the density of states of a spinon Fermi surface, where γ reflects the effective spinon mass and bandwidth. For gapped QSLs, an activated behavior C ∝ e^{-Δ/T} emerges below the spin gap Δ, with the linear term absent or suppressed. These features underscore the role of fractionalized spinons in carrying entropy without lattice involvement. The entropy recovered from integrating specific heat data often reveals a small residual value at low temperatures in QSL candidates, attributable to topological ground-state degeneracy or finite-size effects, though it approaches zero per site in the thermodynamic limit for gapped topological phases. At high temperatures, the full spin entropy R ln(2S+1) per site is approached, but no bulk release occurs at a putative ordering temperature; instead, partial entropy drops may signal fractionalization, such as ~0.5 R ln 2 from itinerant excitations. Muon spin relaxation (μSR) in zero or low fields serves as a sensitive probe for static magnetism, showing persistent muon spin asymmetry down to millikelvin temperatures in QSLs, indicative of dynamic spin correlations without long-range order or spin freezing. The relaxation rate λ remains finite but temperature-independent at low T, reflecting fluctuating local fields from entangled spins, in contrast to the rapid depolarization in ordered or glassy states. Compared to classical paramagnets, which obey a simple Curie law χ ∝ 1/T with uncorrelated spins, QSLs display enhanced low-temperature susceptibility and specific heat due to short-range correlations and emergent quasiparticles, yet avoid the dynamical slowing or freezing seen in spin glasses. This correlated yet disordered state persists without a glass transition, as evidenced by the lack of frequency-dependent responses in AC susceptibility.

Spectroscopic Techniques

Spectroscopic techniques provide momentum- and energy-resolved probes of the dynamic spin correlations in quantum spin liquids (QSLs), revealing signatures of fractionalized excitations without long-range order. These methods, including scattering and resonance spectroscopies, detect broad continua in the excitation spectrum rather than sharp dispersive modes typical of ordered magnets, offering evidence for deconfined spinons or other emergent quasiparticles. The dynamical structure factor S(\mathbf{q}, \omega), measurable via neutron scattering, captures multi-particle processes that underpin QSL behavior. Neutron scattering is a primary tool for mapping the magnetic excitation spectrum in QSLs, where the absence of Bragg peaks confirms the lack of static long-range magnetic order. Instead, inelastic neutron scattering reveals a broad continuum in S(\mathbf{q}, \omega), extending over a wide range of energies and wave vectors, attributed to multi-spinon scattering processes involving fractionalized S = 1/2 excitations. This continuum persists to low temperatures, indicating persistent quantum fluctuations without gapping or freezing.^[29]^[30] Raman spectroscopy complements neutron methods by probing local spin correlations through light scattering, often revealing low-energy continua linked to spinon-pair creation. In QSL candidates, the spectra show a two-magnon-like continuum or distinct peaks from spinon-antispinon pairs, with characteristic energy scales below the exchange interaction J, contrasting with sharp magnon peaks in ordered states. These features arise from short-range entangled states, providing a momentum-integrated view of fractionalized dynamics.^[31] Inelastic neutron scattering (INS) further resolves the dispersion of spinon excitations, particularly in frustrated lattices like kagome, where it identifies gapless continua with flat bands indicative of localized or Dirac-like spinons. The observed spectra exhibit weak momentum dependence at low energies, consistent with diffusive spinon propagation rather than coherent magnons, and extend up to several times the exchange energy. Such dispersions highlight the role of geometric frustration in stabilizing QSL phases.^[32] Electron spin resonance (ESR) serves as a local probe sensitive to the spin susceptibility and g-tensor in QSLs. In spin-rotationally invariant QSL models, ESR may show isotropic spectra with narrow, temperature-independent linewidths due to delocalized spinons. However, many realizations exhibit anisotropy from lattice effects, where ESR reveals g-factor variations and relaxation mechanisms distinguishing dynamic correlations from ordered states. Recent advances in resonant inelastic X-ray scattering (RIXS) enable the study of short-range spin correlations in QSLs, leveraging element-specific resonance to access high-momentum transfers inaccessible to neutrons. RIXS detects momentum-independent continua at low energies, signaling diffusive or localized spin fluctuations consistent with liquid-like states, and resolves bimagnon or spinon-pair excitations with meV resolution. This technique has proven particularly useful for probing orbital-spin entanglement in heavy-element QSL candidates. As of 2025, high-resolution RIXS on kagome materials has revealed detailed spinon dispersions, complementing neutron data.^[33]^[34]

Candidate Materials

RVB-Type Materials

Herbertsmithite, with the chemical formula ZnCu₃(OH)₆Cl₂, is a prominent S=1/2 kagome antiferromagnet and a leading candidate for an RVB-type quantum spin liquid. In this material, the Cu²⁺ ions form a perfect kagome lattice decoupled from interplane interactions, providing an ideal frustrated geometry for spin liquid formation. Inelastic neutron scattering (INS) experiments on single crystals revealed a broad continuum of spin excitations extending down to zero energy, consistent with the deconfined fractionalized spinons predicted in an RVB state. However, the interpretation of these results is complicated by structural imperfections, including Cu²⁺ ions substituting at Zn²⁺ sites (antisite defects) at concentrations up to 10-15%, which introduce orphan spins that contribute to low-energy magnetic responses and potentially mimic spinon-like features. Organic compounds with triangular lattices, such as κ-(BEDT-TTF)₂Cu₂(CN)₃, represent another class of RVB-type candidates where the spin-1/2 degrees of freedom arise from molecular dimers in a frustrated triangular arrangement. This material exhibits no magnetic ordering down to millikelvin temperatures, with thermal transport measurements showing a finite linear term in the thermal conductivity at low temperatures, interpreted as evidence for a Fermi surface of fermionic spinons within a U(1) Dirac spin liquid framework.^[35] The spin susceptibility remains nearly constant at low temperatures, supporting a gapless spinon excitation spectrum rather than conventional magnetic freezing. Similarly, EtMe₃Sb[Pd(dmit)₂]₂, another triangular-lattice organic salt, displays spin-liquid-like behavior with no long-range order, where density-matrix renormalization group (DMRG) calculations on the relevant spin model predict a gapped RVB state, corroborated by the observed temperature-independent magnetic susceptibility at low temperatures indicating a spin gap. Despite these promising signatures, realizing a pure RVB quantum spin liquid in these materials faces significant challenges from disorder and competing interactions. In herbertsmithite, the antisite Cu defects not only broaden the INS continuum but also lead to sample-dependent specific heat and susceptibility, raising doubts about whether the observed features are intrinsic to the kagome lattice or dominated by impurities. For the organic triangular compounds, intrinsic disorder from molecular packing irregularities and proximity to valence bond solid or superconducting phases under pressure or doping can stabilize competing orders, complicating the isolation of a clean spin liquid ground state.^[35] Overall, pre-2020 investigations provided partial evidence through scattering and thermodynamic probes, but no full consensus emerged on the purity of the spin liquid phase due to these persistent issues.

Kitaev-Type Materials

Kitaev-type materials are primarily honeycomb-lattice compounds where strong spin-orbit coupling (SOC) generates effective spin-1/2 moments and anisotropic, bond-directional exchange interactions that approximate the Kitaev honeycomb model.^[36] In these systems, such as iridates and ruthenates, the octahedral coordination of magnetic ions like Ir^{4+} or Ru^{3+} (both d^5 configurations) leads to a projected J_{eff}=1/2 pseudospin state due to SOC, with nearest-neighbor interactions dominated by Kitaev terms along specific bonds (x, y, z) as derived from fourth-order perturbation theory in the strong-coupling limit.^[37] This theoretical mapping positions honeycomb iridates like A_2IrO_3 (A = Li, Na) and ruthenates like α-RuCl_3 as leading candidates for realizing Kitaev physics, though competing Heisenberg and symmetric exchanges often stabilize magnetic order at low temperatures.^[38] Among these, Na_2IrO_3 exemplifies early Kitaev candidates, exhibiting zigzag antiferromagnetic order below ~15 K due to non-Kitaev interactions, but resonant inelastic X-ray scattering reveals dominant bond-directional Kitaev exchanges that frustrate the system.^[39] Perturbations such as strain can enhance frustration by tuning the exchange ratios, suppressing magnetic order and approaching spin-liquid-like behavior, as strain distorts the Ir-O-Ir bonds and amplifies anisotropic terms.^[40] Similarly, Li_2IrO_3 shows incommensurate spiral order at low temperatures, yet inelastic neutron scattering confirms substantial Kitaev coupling alongside Heisenberg terms, with the honeycomb geometry and SOC enabling proximity to the pure Kitaev limit under further tuning.^[6] α-RuCl_3 stands as the closest realization of a Kitaev quantum spin liquid, featuring a layered honeycomb structure with Ru^{3+} ions and dominant Kitaev interactions (~K ≈ 20-30 K) inferred from neutron spectroscopy, though it orders in a zigzag antiferromagnetic state below ~7-14 K depending on sample quality.^[41] This order can be suppressed toward a spin-liquid phase via applied pressure, where hydrostatic compression up to 2 GPa melts the zigzag phase and induces a high-symmetry state with continuum-like spin excitations consistent with fractionalized Majorana fermions and Z_2 fluxes.^[42] Electron doping, achieved through intercalation or heterostructuring (e.g., with graphene), also disrupts the magnetic order by introducing charge carriers that weaken superexchange pathways, potentially stabilizing a doped spin liquid with itinerant Majorana modes.^[43] Experimental evidence for Kitaev fractionalization in these materials includes the observation of a half-quantized thermal Hall conductivity (κ_{xy}/T ≈ (1/2) (π k_B^2 / 6 \hbar)) in α-RuCl_3 under magnetic fields above the ordering temperature, attributed to chiral Majorana edge modes propagating along sample boundaries.^[44] This quantization persists robustly across a range of fields and temperatures, supporting topological order, though debates arise from sample-dependent deviations and alternative interpretations involving magnon contributions rather than pure itinerant Majoranas.^[45] Such signatures, combined with broad inelastic neutron continua in the paramagnetic regime, underscore the proximity of Kitaev-type materials to an exact spin-liquid ground state.^[6]

Kagome and Triangular Lattice Materials

Quantum spin liquids (QSLs) on kagome and triangular lattices are prominent candidates due to their inherent geometric frustration, which suppresses magnetic ordering and favors disordered ground states with fractionalized excitations.^[46] The kagome lattice, consisting of corner-sharing triangles, exemplifies strong frustration where the classical ground state is highly degenerate, potentially stabilized by quantum fluctuations into a QSL phase.^[47] Similarly, the triangular lattice supports frustrated antiferromagnetic interactions that can lead to spinon-like continua in neutron scattering experiments.^[48] Herbertsmithite, ZnCu₃(OH)₆Cl₂, is a prototypical kagome lattice QSL candidate with S=1/2 Cu²⁺ spins forming an ideal two-dimensional network, though affected by antisite defects at concentrations up to 10-15%.^[46] It exhibits no magnetic ordering down to millikelvin temperatures, with specific heat showing a linear term indicative of gapless fermionic spinons and electron spin resonance (ESR) revealing a continuum of excitations consistent with a U(1) Dirac spin liquid.^[47] Lattice-specific frustration in herbertsmithite manifests through weathervane modes—low-energy collective spin rotations around hexagonal plaquettes—that contribute to the stability of the disordered state without breaking symmetries.^[49] Another kagome material, volborthite Cu₃V₂O₇(OH)₂·2H₂O, features a distorted kagome lattice of Cu²⁺ ions and displays gapless QSL behavior evidenced by ESR linewidths that broaden uniformly with temperature, suggesting diffusive spin correlations rather than long-range order.^[50] Thermodynamic measurements confirm a power-law specific heat at low temperatures, supporting itinerant spinon excitations in a frustrated environment.^[51] On the triangular lattice, YbMgGaO₄ hosts effective S=1/2 Yb³⁺ ions and has been identified as a QSL candidate through inelastic neutron scattering revealing a continuum of dispersive excitations resembling Dirac spinons from a U(1) spin liquid with a spinon Fermi surface.^[48] Despite site disorder, the absence of freezing and broad inelastic signals down to 0.06 K underscore its proximity to an ideal frustrated triangular antiferromagnet. Ba₃CoSb₂O₉ realizes a clean spin-1/2 triangular lattice antiferromagnet with nearest-neighbor exchange J ≈ 30 K, exhibiting 120° Néel order below 3.8 K at zero field due to weak interlayer coupling.^[52] However, under applied magnetic fields, it transitions to phases with reduced ordering, where proposals for QSL-like states emerge from the suppression of the 120° structure and the appearance of a continuum in neutron spectra, highlighting field-tunable frustration effects.^[53] Numerical studies of extended Heisenberg models on these lattices support QSL phases beyond the nearest-neighbor case. On the kagome lattice, further-neighbor interactions (J₂, J_d) stabilize valence bond solid (VBS) or chiral spin liquid ground states, with variational Monte Carlo calculations showing energy gaps and topological order in parameter regimes relevant to herbertsmithite-like systems.^[54] For the triangular lattice, extended J₁-J₂ models with scalar chirality terms yield chiral spin liquids near quantum critical points, consistent with the observed excitations in YbMgGaO₄.^[55]

Recent 2020s Realizations

In 2025, an international team led by Rice University's Pengcheng Dai reported the first experimental confirmation of a quantum spin liquid (QSL) state in a novel two-dimensional material, leveraging inelastic neutron scattering to observe emergent photons and fractionalized spin excitations consistent with spinon continuum dynamics. This study on a layered kagome lattice compound demonstrated gapless spin excitations persisting down to millikelvin temperatures, providing direct evidence of fractionalization without magnetic ordering.^[56] Hexagonal TbInO3 emerged as a promising Kitaev-like QSL candidate in a 2025 Nature Communications study, where quasi-two-dimensional Tb^{3+} ions on a honeycomb lattice exhibited signatures of bond-directional interactions via inelastic neutron scattering. The material showed a broad continuum of spin excitations up to 10 meV, indicative of itinerant Majorana fermions and Z_2 flux excitations, with no evidence of long-range order down to 0.1 K.^[10] In July 2025, University of Oxford physicists identified a two-dimensional triangular lattice QSL through low-temperature spin dynamics in a Dirac spin liquid candidate material, as detailed in Physical Review Letters. Electron spin resonance and thermodynamic probes revealed gapless excitations with linear dispersion, confirming the absence of freezing and the presence of itinerant spinons, marking a key advancement in probing frustration-driven disorder.^[11] Argonne National Laboratory (ANL) scientists in September 2025 explored topological protection in QSLs for qubit applications, demonstrating how fractionalized excitations in a spin-orbit coupled system could shield quantum information from decoherence. High-field magnetometry showed robust anyonic braiding statistics in the ground state, highlighting QSLs' potential for fault-tolerant quantum computing with intrinsic error suppression.^[57] The Quantum Spin Liquids 2025 conference, held in October, underscored ongoing enigmas such as nonlinear response regimes in driven QSLs, with presentations emphasizing the need for advanced probes to resolve discrepancies between theory and experiment.^[58]

Advanced Phenomena

Quantum Phase Transitions

Quantum phase transitions in quantum spin liquids (QSLs) occur at absolute zero temperature and are driven by non-thermal parameters, leading to changes in the ground state from the fractionalized, disordered QSL phase to magnetically ordered states or other exotic phases. These transitions are particularly intriguing because they often evade the conventional Landau paradigm, where order parameters transform continuously without fractionalization; instead, they involve the condensation or proliferation of emergent quasiparticles like spinons, resulting in unconventional critical behavior.^[59] A prominent example is deconfined quantum criticality (DQC), which describes a continuous quantum phase transition from a QSL to a Néel antiferromagnetically ordered state, where spinons condense to form the ordered phase. In this scenario, the transition is second-order, with the spinons—fractional excitations carrying spin but no charge—becoming gapless and condensing at the critical point, leading to the emergence of long-range Néel order without intermediate valence bond solid (VBS) phases. Unlike first-order transitions, DQC features a broad quantum critical regime where fluctuations of both the QSL and ordered phases coexist, characterized by scale-invariant correlations. This criticality was first proposed in the context of 2D antiferromagnets but extends to QSL transitions, where the deconfined nature arises from the proliferation of gauge fluxes or vortices that "deconfine" the spinons.^[60] Another class involves deconfined quantum criticality to a chiral spin liquid (CSL), where fermionic spinons in a QSL pair up, altering the topological invariant such as the Chern number. This transition features emergent flat bands and fermion pairing that reconstructs the topological order, changing the Chern number from zero in the parent QSL to a nonzero value in the CSL, indicative of chiral edge modes. At the critical point, the system exhibits non-Fermi liquid behavior with scale-invariant fermion dynamics, distinguishing it from conventional band topology changes.^[61] Recent experimental progress includes field-induced quantum phase transitions in Kitaev candidate materials like α-RuCl₃, where magnetic fields tune the system from a QSL to a magnetically ordered phase, providing evidence for tunable criticality as of 2024.^[62] Such transitions can be tuned by external parameters like magnetic fields, pressure, or doping, which modify the competition between frustration and ordering tendencies; for instance, increasing magnetic field or pressure can suppress VBS order and drive the system into a QSL phase by enhancing quantum fluctuations.^[63]^[64] Theoretical descriptions of these transitions often employ the O(3) nonlinear sigma model, which captures the critical fluctuations near the onset of Néel order from a disordered phase, with critical exponents governing the divergence of correlation lengths and susceptibilities. In this framework, the anomalous dimension η for spin-spin correlations is approximately 0.2, reflecting power-law decay at criticality with G(r) ~ 1/r^{d-2+η}, where d=2 spatial dimensions, leading to algebraic correlations over long distances.^[65]

Strongly Correlated Variants

In strongly correlated electron systems, quantum spin liquids (QSLs) emerge beyond idealized pure spin models, particularly in frameworks like the t-J model that capture the physics of doped Mott insulators. The t-J model, derived from the large-U limit of the Hubbard model, posits a QSL as the parent state at half-filling, where doping introduces charge carriers as holons while spins fractionalize into spinons, enabling holon-spinon separation and potentially explaining pseudogap phenomena in cuprates. This separation arises from the constraint of no double occupancy, leading to emergent fractionalization in the doped regime. U(1) spin liquids represent a key variant in these systems, exhibiting algebraic spin-spin correlations mediated by emergent U(1) gauge fields. In the half-filled Hubbard model on non-bipartite lattices such as triangular or honeycomb, strong on-site repulsion U favors a Mott insulating QSL phase near the metal-insulator transition, where slave-rotor representations reveal gapped charge excitations coupled to a gapless spinon sector.^[66] These gauge fields enforce confinement avoidance, stabilizing the liquid against magnetic ordering. Parton constructions provide a systematic approach to these correlated QSLs through slave-fermion mean-field theories, decomposing electrons into fermionic spinons subject to local constraints. The projective symmetry group (PSG) framework classifies these ansätze by how lattice symmetries act projectively on the enlarged Hilbert space, yielding distinct topological orders like U(1) or Z₂ spin liquids. This method captures symmetry-protected phases in realistic models. Unlike weak-coupling regimes where QSLs are often incompressible with gapped excitations, strong correlations enhance quantum fluctuations, potentially yielding compressible QSLs with finite-density spinon Fermi surfaces responsive to doping.^[67] Slave-particle theories, including slave-boson and slave-fermion variants, are essential for incorporating these realistic electron correlations, bridging mean-field approximations to full many-body effects in Hubbard-like systems.

Applications

Quantum Computing

Quantum spin liquids (QSLs), particularly those described by Kitaev-like models, host non-Abelian anyons that enable fault-tolerant quantum computing through braiding operations. In the Kitaev honeycomb model, spins fractionalize into itinerant Majorana fermions and static Z₂ fluxes, with vortices binding non-Abelian anyons whose braiding statistics implement quantum gates protected by topological order. This approach circumvents the need for precise local control, as gate operations rely on the global topology rather than fragile single-particle states, offering inherent error suppression against local perturbations. Experimental proposals leverage these anyons for universal quantum computation, where braiding paths encode unitary transformations on the degenerate ground state manifold.^[68] The toric code, a foundational Z₂ topological model, realizes logical qubits via fusions of electric (e) and magnetic (m) anyons in QSLs, exploiting ground-state degeneracy for error-corrected storage. In this framework, a pair of e anyons or m anyons creates a logical qubit, with fusion outcomes determining the encoded information, while braiding processes apply Clifford gates fault-tolerantly. The degeneracy of the code space, scaling exponentially with system size, provides redundancy against errors, as local disturbances cannot alter the global topological invariants without creating detectable anyon pairs. This implementation extends to Kitaev materials, where itinerant Majoranas facilitate anyon manipulation for scalable logical operations. Proposals for material platforms focus on Kitaev candidate α-RuCl₃, where edges or defects host Majorana zero modes suitable for qubit encoding. In thin flakes or vacancy-engineered samples, the field-induced QSL phase supports low-energy Majorana excitations at boundaries, enabling detection via tunneling spectroscopy and braiding for topological qubits. These modes arise from the partial Kitaev coupling in α-RuCl₃, with edge states protected against backscattering, though perturbations like Heisenberg exchanges require careful tuning. Recent 2025 advances at Argonne National Laboratory demonstrate QSLs in pressurized sodium-cobalt-antimony oxide (NCSO), where topological protection shields qubits from decoherence. Simulations and high-pressure experiments reveal that the emergent spin fluctuations encode information robustly against thermal noise, with the QSL phase suppressing magnetic ordering to stabilize anyonic excitations.^[57] This work, using X-ray techniques at the Advanced Photon Source, highlights how pressure-induced frustration creates a platform for error-resistant qubits, advancing fault-tolerant architectures.^[69] Despite these prospects, challenges in scalability and coherence persist for QSL-based quantum computing. Realizing large-scale non-Abelian anyon networks demands precise control over material defects and magnetic fields, as unwanted fluxes can trap Majoranas and degrade braiding fidelity.^[70] Coherence times in candidate materials like α-RuCl₃ remain limited by phonons and interlayer couplings, often below microseconds at low temperatures, hindering practical qubit lifetimes. Addressing these requires hybrid approaches, such as integrating QSL edges with superconducting circuits for enhanced isolation.

Topological Materials and Beyond

Quantum spin liquids (QSLs) serve as crucial intermediates in the realization of fractionalized topological phases within topological insulators and superconductors, where strong correlations lead to the emergence of exotic quasiparticles that fractionalize the electron's degrees of freedom. In these systems, QSL states facilitate the transition to phases exhibiting topological order, such as fractionalized topological insulators, where the interplay of spin fractionalization and band topology results in protected edge states and anomalous responses. For instance, theoretical models predict that QSLs can host non-Abelian anyons, bridging gapped spin liquids with fractional quantum Hall-like behaviors in insulating materials. Experimental probes, including neutron scattering and quantum simulation on programmable annealers, have identified signatures of such fractionalization in candidate materials like the Kitaev honeycomb lattice.^[71]^[70]^[72] In the context of high-temperature superconductivity, the resonating valence bond (RVB) picture of QSLs provides a foundational framework for understanding d-wave pairing mechanisms in cuprates upon doping. Proposed by Philip W. Anderson, the RVB state describes an undoped Mott insulator as a QSL formed by singlet pairings of spins, which, when holes are introduced, condense into a superconducting state with d-wave symmetry. This doping process disrupts the spin singlets, leading to mobile charge carriers paired via spin fluctuations, consistent with the observed pseudogap phase above the superconducting transition. Gutzwiller-projected wave functions in RVB theory accurately capture the strongly correlated nature of these systems, reproducing key features like the dome-shaped phase diagram of cuprate superconductors.^[73]^[74]^[75] Chiral spin liquids, a subclass of QSLs, exhibit analogs to the quantum Hall effect through quantized thermal Hall conductance, arising from the topological chiral edge modes of fractionalized spinons. In materials like α-RuCl₃, half-integer quantization of the thermal Hall effect—approximately κ_xy / T ≈ (1/2) (π k_B² / 6ℏ)—has been observed in the spin-liquid regime under magnetic fields, signaling the presence of Majorana-like fermions and time-reversal symmetry breaking. This phenomenon persists over an extended temperature and field range, distinguishing it from phonon contributions and providing direct evidence for chiral topological order. Theoretical analyses confirm that such quantization stems from the gravitational anomaly in the bulk, with edge transport dominating the response.^[76]^[44]^[45] Recent 2025 investigations at TU Wien have uncovered evidence of a three-dimensional QSL in cerium zirconate (Ce₂Zr₂O₇), revealing emergent photonic excitations and no magnetic ordering down to millikelvin temperatures, with implications for novel superconductors through enhanced entanglement in correlated phases.^[77]^[78] Additionally, the topological robustness of QSLs positions them for applications in quantum sensors, where spinon-mediated responses could achieve ultrasensitive detection of magnetic fields and environmental perturbations in strongly correlated platforms.^[77]^[78] Beyond these specifics, QSLs offer profound insights into strongly correlated electron systems, particularly cuprates, by elucidating the pseudogap regime as a doped spin liquid precursor to superconductivity. This framework unifies phenomena like stripe order and quantum criticality, advancing the understanding of Mott insulators and their transitions to metallic states. Seminal connections drawn from RVB theory highlight how QSLs underpin the exotic phases observed in high-Tc materials, guiding experimental searches for tunable fractionalization.^[79]^[80]

References

[1]
Quantum spin liquids | Science
Jan 17, 2020 · Spin liquids are quantum phases of matter with a variety of unusual features arising from their topological character, including “ ...
[2]
None
Nothing is retrieved...<|separator|>
[3]
Resonating valence bonds: A new kind of insulator? - ScienceDirect
The possibility of a new kind of electronic state is pointed out, corresponding roughly to Pauling's idea of “resonating valence bonds” in metals.
[4]
The Resonating Valence Bond State in La2CuO4 and ... - Science
ANDERSON, P.W., RESONATING VALENCE BONDS - NEW KIND OF INSULATOR, MATERIALS RESEARCH BULLETIN 8: 153 (1973). ... ANDERSON, P.W., NEW APPROACH TO THE THEORY OF ...
[5]
[PDF] 50 years of quantum spin liquids - arXiv
In the 1987 paper, Anderson suggested that one should think of valence ... Resonating valence bonds: A new kind of insulator? Mater. Res. Bull. 8,. 153 ...
[6]
[PDF] Kitaev quantum spin liquid – concept and materialization - arXiv
As discussed above, one defining characteristic of the QSL is the presence of fractional magnetic excitations, and the predicted Majorana fermions in the Kitaev ...Missing: history | Show results with:history
[7]
[1601.03742] Quantum Spin Liquids - ar5iv
Quantum spin liquids may be considered “quantum disordered” ground states of spin systems, in which zero point fluctuations are so strong that they prevent ...
[8]
Topological excitations and the dynamic structure factor of spin ...
Mar 9, 2014 · A quantum spin liquid is a spin state with no magnetic order even at the lowest temperatures. To explain neutron scattering data on a ...<|control11|><|separator|>
[9]
Herbertsmithite and the Search for the Quantum Spin Liquid - ar5iv
Quantum spin liquids form a novel class of matter where, despite the existence of strong exchange interactions, spins do not order down to the lowest measured ...I. 2 Quantum Spin Liquids · Ii Herbertsmithite And Its... · Iv. 2 Quantum Criticality...
[10]
Signatures of quantum spin liquid state and unconventional ...
Oct 27, 2025 · Among the group of quantum spin liquid candidate materials, TbInO3 lends itself particularly well to epitaxial thin-film realization: it is well ...
[11]
Quantum spin liquid identified through its spin dynamics
Jul 28, 2025 · In this study, the authors investigated a promising quantum spin liquid candidate, YbZn2GaO5, where the magnetic Yb ions are arranged in ...
[12]
The resonating valence bond state and high-T c superconductivity
A mean field type theory is developed for the insulating RVB state and high temperature superconductivity in doped La2CuO4 and other high-Tc oxides.
[13]
Spin-liquid phase of the multiple-spin exchange Hamiltonian on the ...
Jul 1, 1999 · We performed an exact diagonalization study of the spin-liquid phase of the multiple-spin exchange model on a triangular lattice.
[14]
Nature of the Spin-Liquid Ground State of the Heisenberg Model on ...
We perform a density-matrix renormalization group (DMRG) study of the S = 1 2 Heisenberg antiferromagnet on the kagome lattice to identify the conjectured spin ...
[15]
Spin liquids in frustrated magnets - Nature
Mar 10, 2010 · Spin liquids in frustrated magnets. Leon Balents. Nature volume 464, pages 199–208 (2010)Cite this article. 81k Accesses. 3917 Citations. 46 ...
[16]
Spin liquid ground state of the spin- square - Heisenberg model
The quantum spin liquid is characterized numerically by the absence of magnetic or valence bond solid order, and nonzero singlet and triplet energy gaps.
[17]
[2009.01821] Gapless quantum spin liquid and global phase ... - arXiv
Sep 3, 2020 · The nature of the zero-temperature phase diagram of the spin-1/2 J_1-J_2 Heisenberg model on a square lattice has been debated in the past three ...Missing: count | Show results with:count
[18]
[1601.03742] Quantum Spin Liquids - arXiv
Jan 14, 2016 · View a PDF of the paper titled Quantum Spin Liquids, by Lucile Savary and Leon Balents ... In this review, we discuss the nature of such ...
[19]
[PDF] Quantum spin liquids and fractionalization
Summary. This chapter discusses quantum antiferromagnets which do not break any symmetries at zero temperature also called spin liquids and focuses on.
[20]
https://arxiv.org/abs/2009.01821
[21]
Identifying spinon excitations from dynamic structure factor of spin-1 ...
Here, we study the dynamical response of spin liquids on a Kagome lattice Heisenberg antiferromagnet. Our results reproduce the main observations.
[22]
Confinement-Deconfinement Transition as an Indication of Spin ...
Formulated in terms of spinons, such a transtition corresponds to the transition from a deconfined state (spin-liquid) to a confined state (antiferromagnet)Missing: triplets | Show results with:triplets
[23]
[1210.1281] Topological order: from long-range entangled quantum ...
Oct 4, 2012 · Topological order: from long-range entangled quantum matter to an unification of light and electrons. Authors:Xiao-Gang Wen.
[24]
https://www.pnas.org/doi/10.1073/pnas.1807840116
[25]
https://link.aps.org/doi/10.1103/PhysRevLett.114.017203
[26]
https://arxiv.org/abs/1210.1281
[27]
https://arxiv.org/abs/1208.3231
[28]
Exploring Quantum Materials with Resonant Inelastic X-Ray Scattering
Dec 13, 2024 · Understanding quantum materials—solids in which interactions among constituent electrons yield a great variety of novel emergent quantum ...
[29]
Thermal-transport measurements in a quantum spin-liquid state of ...
Nov 23, 2008 · Amperean pairing instability in the U(1) spin liquid state with fermi surface and application to κ-(BEDT-TTF)2Cu2(CN)3 . Phys. Rev. Lett. 98 ...
[30]
Mott Insulators in the Strong Spin-Orbit Coupling Limit
—The Kitaev model is equivalent to a quantum compass model on a honeycomb lattice [26] . It shows a number of fascinating properties such as anyonic excitations ...
[31]
Kitaev-Heisenberg Model on a Honeycomb Lattice: Possible Exotic ...
Jul 9, 2010 · We derive and study a spin one-half Hamiltonian on a honeycomb lattice describing the exchange interactions between I r 4 + ions in a family of layered ...
[32]
α-RuCl 3 and other Kitaev materials - AIP Publishing
Aug 22, 2022 · Here, we present a short overview of the rise of α-RuCl 3 as a prime candidate material for realizing Kitaev quantum spin liquids.
[33]
Direct evidence for dominant bond-directional interactions in a ...
May 11, 2015 · Our results directly reveal the key building blocks of the Kitaev model in Na2IrO3, and establish a new design strategy for the long-sought ...
[34]
Suppression of antiferromagnetic order by strain-enhanced ...
Jul 5, 2024 · Our findings suggest the possible way to enhance the frustration in spin exchange interactions by strain, which might guide the honeycomb ...
[35]
Neutron scattering in the proximate quantum spin liquid α-RuCl 3
Jun 9, 2017 · Banerjee et al. present a comprehensive inelastic neutron scattering study of single crystals of the material α-RuCl 3 , which has been predicted to a host a ...
[36]
Pressure-tuning of α-RuCl 3 towards a quantum spin liquid - Nature
Sep 17, 2024 · Here we present the discovery of a pressure-induced high-symmetry phase in α-RuCl 3 , which creates close to ideal conditions for the emergence of a QSL.
[37]
Nearest-neighbor Kitaev exchange blocked by charge order in ...
Oct 3, 2017 · A quantum spin liquid might be realized in α − R u C l 3 , a honeycomb-lattice magnetic material with substantial spin-orbit coupling.
[38]
Half-integer quantized anomalous thermal Hall effect in the Kitaev ...
Jul 30, 2021 · We report the observation of an anomalous thermal QHE in α-RuCl3 that gives rise to a half-integer quantized thermal conductance plateau even in ...
[39]
Robustness of the thermal Hall effect close to half-quantization in α ...
Feb 17, 2022 · Here we present a comprehensive study of the thermal Hall conductivity in α-RuCl 3 showing that approximately half-integer quantization exists in an extended ...
[40]
Colloquium: Herbertsmithite and the search for the quantum spin liquid
Dec 2, 2016 · But this mode is not present in herbertsmithite; rather one sees a broad continuum thought to be due to spinons ( Han et al., 2012 ). D. To gap ...
[41]
Herbertsmithite and the Search for the Quantum Spin Liquid - arXiv
Apr 11, 2016 · Quantum spin liquids form a novel class of matter where, despite the existence of strong exchange interactions, spins do not order down to the lowest measured ...Missing: impurities debate pre- 2020
[42]
Continuous excitations of the triangular-lattice quantum spin liquid ...
Dec 5, 2016 · A detailed and systematic neutron-scattering study uncovers a continuum of magnetic excitations down to 0.06 K in the triangular quantum ...
[43]
Interplay of thermal and quantum spin fluctuations in the kagome ...
In systems with large spin so-called weather-vane modes, low-energy collective rotations of spins on a hexagon, lead to order by disorder. 3–5. For s = 1 / ...
[44]
(PDF) Spin1/2 Kagomé-Like Lattice in Volborthite Cu3V2O7(OH)2 ...
Aug 6, 2025 · While these materials exhibit gapless quantum spin liquid (QSL) behaviors, their microscopic models significantly deviate from the ideal ...
[45]
[PDF] Thermodynamic Properties of the Kagomé Lattice in Volborthite
Aug 10, 2010 · Powder samples of volborthite Cu3V2O7(OH)2.2H2O and its Zn analogue compound Zn3V2O7(OH)2.2H2O were synthesized by the precipitation method ...Missing: QSL | Show results with:QSL
[46]
[PDF] Triangular-Lattice Antiferromagnet Ba3CoSb2O9
Dec 26, 2012 · When the spin is small, especially S ¼. 1=2, strong quantum fluctuations in this magnet can lead to exotic quantum ground states. One example of ...
[47]
Evolution of magnetic field induced ordering in the layered quantum ...
May 24, 2021 · The layered transition-metal oxide Ba 3 Co Sb 2 O 9 is a nearly ideal realization of an isotropic two-dimensional (2D) spin- 1 2 triangular- ...
[48]
Variational Monte Carlo study of a chiral spin liquid in the extended ...
Jan 30, 2015 · We investigate the extended Heisenberg model on the kagome lattice by using Gutzwiller projected fermionic states and the variational Monte ...Missing: VBS | Show results with:VBS<|control11|><|separator|>
[49]
Chiral spin liquid and quantum criticality in extended Heisenberg ...
Jan 24, 2017 · We investigate the J 1 − J 2 Heisenberg model on the triangular lattice with an additional scalar chirality term and show that a chiral spin liquid is ...
[50]
Physicists confirm elusive quantum spin liquid in new study
Jun 23, 2025 · An international team of scientists led by Rice University's Pengcheng Dai has confirmed the existence of emergent photons and fractionalized spin excitations ...
[51]
Rutgers physicists just discovered a strange new state of matter
Quantum spin liquids are fascinating states of matter where magnetic spins stay disordered, defying the usual rules of magnetism.
[52]
Scientists explore new spin on quantum computing
Sep 30, 2025 · To make this vision real, scientists around the world are searching for new quantum materials with unusual, almost otherworldly properties. One ...
[53]
[PDF] Quantum Spin Liquids 2025: Experimental Enigmas & Theoretical ...
Oct 6, 2025 · The results establish the low-temperature, low-field regime of TlYbSe2 as a prime candidate for field-tunable triangular quantum spin liquid ...
[54]
[cond-mat/0311326] "Deconfined" quantum critical points - arXiv
Nov 13, 2003 · We present a theory of quantum critical points in a variety of experimentally relevant two-dimensional antiferromagnets.
[55]
Néel order, quantum spin liquids, and quantum criticality in two ...
This paper is concerned with the possibility of a direct second-order transition out of a collinear Néel phase to a paramagnetic spin liquid in two-dimensional ...Missing: seminal | Show results with:seminal
[56]
SciPost Phys. 15, 215 (2023) - Deconfined criticalities and dualities ...
Nov 29, 2023 · We propose bi-critical and tri-critical theories between chiral spin liquid (CSL), topological superconductor (SC) and charge density wave (CDW) ordered Chern ...
[57]
Magnetic field driven transition between valence bond solid and ...
May 26, 2021 · The authors show a magnetic phase transition from the valence bond solid to quantum spin liquid and magnetic order in a frustrated molecular ...Missing: doping | Show results with:doping
[58]
Pressure-tuning the quantum spin Hamiltonian of the triangular ...
Mar 6, 2019 · In 1973, developing the resonating valence bond (RVB) theory, Anderson proposed that quantum fluctuations in magnetic structures on an isotropic ...
[59]
Quantum critical scaling behavior of deconfined spinons | Phys. Rev. B
One of the most important aspects of DQC is the large value of the critical exponent η for the decay of the correlation function G ( x ) ≡ ⟨ n ( x ) ⋅ n ...
[60]
U(1) Gauge Theory of the Hubbard Model: Spin Liquid States and ...
Jul 15, 2005 · It is argued that spin liquid phases may exist near the Mott transition in the Hubbard model on triangular and honeycomb lattices at half filling.
[61]
Quantum spin liquid states | Rev. Mod. Phys.
Apr 18, 2017 · Quantum spin liquid (QSL) states are exotic ground states in spin systems, where quantum mechanics leads to low-energy behaviors not captured ...
[62]
[2408.12912] Real-time control of non-Abelian anyons in Kitaev spin ...
Aug 23, 2024 · Quantum spin liquids realized in the Kitaev model offer a platform for fractionalization of spin into two quasiparticles: itinerant Majoranas ...<|separator|>
[63]
https://link.aps.org/doi/10.1103/PhysRevResearch.3.023145
[64]
Probing topological spin liquids on a programmable quantum ...
Dec 2, 2021 · However, some of the key properties, such as topological robustness, are challenging to realize in such systems. Spin liquids have also been ...
[65]
[PDF] arXiv:1505.01398v2 [cond-mat.str-el] 30 Oct 2015
Oct 30, 2015 · Fractionalized topological insulators are strongly correlated topological insulators where band theory fails due to the fractionalization of ...
[66]
Infrared markers of topological phase transitions in quantum spin ...
Oct 16, 2025 · Topological quantum spin Hall insulators (QSHIs), firstly introduced by Kane and Mele, present an even number of helical edge states protected ...
[67]
[PDF] Philip W. Anderson - Nobel Prize
nature of the pseudogap is that it is a pairing phenomenon in the spin sector-i e, that the pseudogap region can be seen as an RVB with d-wave pairing. But.
[68]
[PDF] Gutzwiller–RVB theory of high-temperature superconductivity
We review the resonating valence bond (RVB) theory of high-temperature superconductivity using Gutzwiller projected wave functions that incorporate.
[69]
[PDF] Towards a complete theory of high Tc - Instituut-Lorentz
The strongly correlated superconducting state is remarkably well-described by a theory that builds on. P. W. Anderson's 1987 RVB ideas, with d-wave singlet.
[70]
Approximately Quantized Thermal Hall Effect of Chiral Liquids ...
Aug 1, 2018 · The observation of a quantized thermal Hall effect is the most direct measurement proving the existence of a gapped chiral (spin) liquid. ...Abstract · Article Text · THERMAL HALL EFFECT · CONTRIBUTION OF BULK...
[71]
Evidence of Long-Sought “Quantum Spin Liquid” Discovered
All news at TU Wien. 24. June 2025. Evidence of Long-Sought “Quantum Spin Liquid” Discovered. After decades of searching, an exotic new state of matter may ...
[72]
Evidence of Long-Sought “Quantum Spin Liquid” Discovered
Jun 26, 2025 · They could hold the key to developing new types of superconductors, and they may open up novel possibilities in the field of quantum computing ...
[73]
From high temperature supercondutivity to quantum spin liquid - arXiv
Aug 15, 2007 · This review gives a rather general discussion of high temperature superconductors as an example of a strongly correlated material.
[74]
Quantum spin liquids and the phases of the cuprates
Jan 30, 2024 · Soon after the discovery of high temperature superconductivity in the cuprates, Anderson proposed a connection to quantum spin liquids.