Fact-checked by Grok 2 weeks ago

Quick Change

Quick Change is a 1990 American crime comedy film co-directed by Bill Murray and Howard Franklin in their directorial debuts, with Murray starring as Grimm, a disillusioned urban planner who, disguised as a clown, robs a Manhattan bank alongside his girlfriend Phyllis (Geena Davis) and accomplice Loomis (Randy Quaid), only for their escape from New York City to devolve into a series of escalating mishaps. The screenplay by Franklin adapts the 1981 novel of the same name by Jay Cronley, emphasizing the irony of a meticulously planned heist thwarted by the city's bureaucratic absurdities and eccentric inhabitants. Despite a modest budget and critical acclaim for its satirical take on urban chaos—earning an 84% approval rating on Rotten Tomatoes—the film underperformed commercially, grossing approximately $15 million against a $15 million production cost, yet it has since garnered a cult following for Murray's deadpan performance and the ensemble's comedic timing. Murray's involvement extended beyond acting and directing, as he cited difficulties in securing a preferred director, leading to his hands-on approach, which he later described as one of his most stressful projects. The movie features notable supporting turns by Jason Robards as a pursuing police chief and early appearances by actors like Philip Bosco and Phil Hartman, highlighting its blend of heist genre conventions with character-driven farce.

Background and Development

Literary Origins

The 1990 film Quick Change is adapted from the novel of the same name by American humorist Jay Cronley, first published in 1981 by Doubleday. Cronley, born November 9, 1943, in , established himself as a and of satirical fiction, contributing regularly to the and authoring multiple novels blending humor with thriller elements, including Funny Farm (1982), also adapted into a . His works often drew from everyday absurdities, reflecting his background in and writing, where he penned the syndicated "Good Golf" column. Cronley's Quick Change centers on career criminal Grimm, who orchestrates a bank robbery disguised as a to evade detection, accompanied by his girlfriend and accomplice Lackey. The narrative unfolds as a fast-paced comedic thriller, with the heist's success hinging on a precise escape plan that rapidly deteriorates amid City's bureaucratic obstacles, language barriers, and eccentric inhabitants—elements Cronley amplified for satirical effect. In the introduction to the 2006 University of Oklahoma Press reissue, Cronley described the novel's conception: after nearly a year of plotting struggles, the core idea emerged from envisioning a executing the robbery, transforming a standard trope into a vehicle for humor and urban chaos. This marked his fourth novel, building on his reputation for concise, witty prose that prioritized ironic mishaps over conventional suspense. The book's publication preceded two cinematic adaptations, including a 1985 Hold-Up set in , but Cronley's original retained a distinctly tone rooted in Manhattan's and cultural quirks, without drawing from prior literary sources. Later editions, such as the 1988 Ballantine paperback, sustained interest amid the 's development, though Cronley noted in his writings the challenges of translations diluting the source's rapid-fire narrative.

Prior Adaptations

Hold-Up, released in 1985, was the first cinematic adaptation of Jay Cronley's 1981 novel Quick Change. Directed by Alexandre Arcady, the Franco-Canadian production relocated the story's setting from New York City to Montreal, Quebec, while retaining the core premise of a meticulously planned bank robbery gone awry due to navigational mishaps during the escape. The screenplay, credited to Arcady alongside contributions from Michel Ganz and Francis Veber, emphasized comedic elements amid the heist chaos, with the protagonist Grimm disguising himself as a clown to infiltrate and rob a secure bank, taking hostages to facilitate his exit by blending into a circus parade. Jean-Paul Belmondo starred as Grimm, the jaded robber leading the operation, supported by as his girlfriend Lise—who aids in the scheme—and as the unstable accomplice Lackey, mirroring the novel's trio of characters whose interpersonal tensions exacerbate their predicament. Additional notable cast included and in supporting roles, contributing to the film's blend of and tension as the robbers hijack a and navigate the city's labyrinthine streets, ultimately struggling to leave town despite their initial success in the robbery itself. The film premiered on October 9, 1985, in , grossing moderately at the with a runtime of 112 minutes, and received mixed reviews for its execution of the source material's humor, though praised for Belmondo's charismatic performance in the lead. No other adaptations preceded Hold-Up, which served as the sole prior screen version before the 1990 American , highlighting the novel's appeal for its inversion of tropes where the getaway proves more perilous than the crime. While Hold-Up leaned into comedic sensibilities with exaggerated physical gags and interactions, it faithfully captured the novel's theme of urban disorientation as a causal driver of failure, predating the English-language iteration by five years.

Pre-Production

The screenplay for Quick Change was written by Howard Franklin, who adapted it from Jay Cronley's 1981 novel of the same name. The project originated as and Franklin's collaborative effort, with attached to star in the lead role of Grimm, a frustrated orchestrating a bank heist to fund his escape from the city. Unable to secure a they approved of, including an initial approach to , and Franklin opted to co-direct the film themselves, marking their respective feature directorial debuts. Warner Bros. financed and distributed the production, allocating a budget of $15 million for the endeavor. emphasized the comedic chaos of navigating Manhattan's urban obstacles post-heist, drawing from the novel's premise while tailoring scenes to Murray's style and the ensemble dynamics. Casting proceeded with as Murray's partner and as their accomplice, aligning with the script's requirements for performers capable of amid escalating mishaps.

Production

Filming Locations and Process

Principal photography for Quick Change began on June 13, 1989, in and concluded on September 2, 1989. The production emphasized on-location shooting in and to capture the film's portrayal of 's disorienting urban landscape. Specific locations included the Times Square subway station at and West 43rd Street, at East 41st Street, a bank exterior at 90 and East 40th Street, and 101 . In , filming took place at 117 Street, site of the "Mexican joust" sequence. Airplane interior scenes were staged at Disney-MGM Studios in , diverging from the New York-centric exteriors. Co-directed by and Howard Franklin after unsuccessful efforts to hire an external —such as —the process marked Murray's sole venture into directing. , who also starred as the lead, later described the experience as unenjoyable, citing the dual demands of acting and directing as unappealing enough to deter him from repeating it. Location work in amplified logistical hurdles, with the city's unpredictable environment mirroring the narrative's themes of escalating chaos during the heist and escape sequences.

Direction and Creative Control

Quick Change was co-directed by and Howard Franklin, both making their feature directorial debuts, with Franklin also serving as screenwriter adapting Jay Cronley's 1981 novel of the same name. The duo assumed directing duties after failing to secure a preferred external , having initially approached , who declined the role. , who starred as the protagonist Grimm, produced the film through his company, granting him substantial influence over its creative direction alongside Franklin's scriptwriting contributions. Murray and Franklin divided responsibilities pragmatically during production, leveraging their complementary strengths: Franklin focused on narrative structure and dialogue, while Murray emphasized performance and on-set improvisation to capture the film's sardonic tone critiquing New York City's chaos. This collaborative approach allowed for a tight, efficient shoot, but Murray later expressed dissatisfaction with the directing process, citing its demands as a reason he never helmed another feature. Creative control remained firmly with the co-directors, insulated from studio interference, enabling unorthodox choices like the protagonist's clown disguise during the heist to underscore themes of absurdity and urban alienation. The film's visual style, characterized by location shooting in to heighten realism and comedic tension, reflected Murray's personal frustrations with the city, infusing Grimm's character with autobiographical elements of weary resignation. noted that Murray shaped the lead role as a "crying-on-the-inside" figure, prioritizing subtle emotional undercurrents over overt , which distinguished Quick Change from more formulaic comedies. Despite the hands-on involvement yielding a cohesive vision, the co-directing dynamic highlighted tensions between Murray's improvisational instincts and 's scripted precision, contributing to the film's quotable, character-driven humor.

Cast and Crew

Principal Cast

Bill Murray portrays Grimm, a frustrated New Yorker who devises and executes a bank robbery disguised as a clown, leading his team through escalating comedic mishaps while attempting to escape Manhattan. Murray, known for his deadpan comedic style from films like Ghostbusters (1984), also co-directed the film with Howard Franklin and served as a producer, bringing his improvisational approach to the role. Geena Davis plays Phyllis Potter, Grimm's supportive girlfriend and accomplice, who participates in the heist and navigates the chaotic getaway with resourcefulness amid the group's misfortunes. Davis, fresh from her Academy Award-winning performance in (1988), delivered a performance blending wit and exasperation, contributing to the film's ensemble dynamic. Randy Quaid embodies Loomis, Grimm's loyal but inept best friend and third accomplice, whose bumbling actions exacerbate the post-heist pandemonium in . Quaid's portrayal leverages his established comedic timing from roles in (1983), emphasizing physical humor and obliviousness central to the film's elements.

Supporting Roles and Crew

Philip Bosco portrayed the bus driver, a character whose strict adherence to protocol hinders the protagonists' getaway attempts. Bob Elliott appeared as the bank guard during the initial heist sequence. Phil Hartman played Hal Edison, a boisterous neighbor involved in a chaotic apartment encounter with the robbers. Tony Shalhoub depicted the cab driver, delivering a comedic performance as an immigrant cabbie navigating traffic with . Stanley Tucci featured as Johnny, a mob enforcer in a tense confrontation scene. The film's crew encompassed directors Howard Franklin and , who co-helmed the project. Howard Franklin also penned the , adapted from Jay Cronley's 1981 novel. served as producer. Michael Chapman handled cinematography, capturing the chaotic urban settings of . Alan edited the film, while Randy composed the score.

Plot

Act One: The Heist

Grimm, a disillusioned urban planner portrayed by Bill Murray, initiates the robbery by entering a Manhattan branch of First National City Bank dressed as a clown, complete with a multicolored wig, red nose, oversized shoes, and balloons attached to his wrist. Bank patrons and employees initially react with amusement, mistaking him for a performer or eccentric, which allows Grimm to approach the teller counter unchallenged. He then draws a concealed handgun, fires a warning shot into the ceiling to assert control, and demands all available cash, transforming the laughter into panic and establishing a hostage situation with approximately a dozen captives subdued on the floor. His accomplices, girlfriend (), who poses as an unassuming customer already inside the bank, and associate (), who enters disguised as a workman shortly after, assist in securing the and filling duffel bags with over $1 million in unmarked bills from the tellers' drawers and safe-deposit area. The disguise serves as both amid the absurdity and a psychological tool, delaying any immediate alarm as hostages, including a pompous played by who attempts negotiation, remain intimidated but compliant under threat of violence. Grimm methodically directs the operation, using the balloons to bundle and conceal portions of the loot, ensuring the proceeds without resistance or detection for nearly 20 minutes. With the money loaded, the trio herds the hostages into a back room, ties them up, and exits the bank through a side into an awaiting driven by Swifty, who had positioned it nearby under the guise of routine maintenance. The robbery concludes flawlessly from an execution standpoint, yielding the targeted sum without injury or pursuit at that moment, as Grimm sheds his clown attire en route, convinced the hardest part is complete. This segment underscores the film's premise that robbing the bank proves straightforward compared to navigating City's labyrinthine streets and eccentric inhabitants.

Act Two: The Escape

Following the successful robbery, Grimm, Phyllis, and Loomis emerge from the bank disguised as hostages, carrying the stolen $1.2 million concealed in balloons, but a bank employee's inadvertent car horn alerts pursuing , initiating a frantic dash across to for a flight to . They hail a yellow taxi driven by an immigrant cabbie who speaks little English and navigates erratically through one-way streets, construction barriers, and traffic jams, repeatedly misunderstanding directions and veering off course despite Grimm's mounting frustration. When the cabbie runs a red light, Loomis impulsively leaps from the moving vehicle upon spotting another , propelling himself into a newsstand and sustaining a that slows their progress; the driver initially flees in panic, believing Loomis dead, before returning to retrieve them. Abandoning the cab amid escalating delays, the trio attempts alternative transport, including a rigid who enforces bureaucratic rules and detours them further, while evading NYPD patrols led by Rotzinger, who closes in via radio coordination and eyewitness tips. Complicating their evasion, they stumble into a grocery store mid-robbery by unrelated criminals and later hide in a building occupied by gangsters, narrowly avoiding detection by posing as lost tourists; urban obstacles like parade routes and language barriers with passersby exacerbate the chaos, underscoring Manhattan's labyrinthine hostility to their getaway. In an alley standoff, they mistake an approaching vehicle for police but discover it to be an airport shuttle, providing a temporary reprieve; Phyllis then discloses her pregnancy to Grimm, adding emotional strain as they press toward the terminal.

Act Three: Resolution

Exhausted and battered from their odyssey through Manhattan's chaos, Grimm, Phyllis, and Loomis finally approach John F. Kennedy International Airport, with Loomis limping from a gunshot wound sustained during an earlier confrontation with mobsters. In a narrow escape, they commandeer an airport luggage vehicle in a dark alley, mistaking it initially for pursuing police, which inadvertently aids their ingress to the terminal. Phyllis discloses to Grimm that she is pregnant, heightening their desperation to flee with the stolen $1 million strapped beneath their clothing. At the airport, the trio splits up to evade detection: Grimm and Loomis proceed to the gate while Phyllis lags behind. They navigate security checkpoints, concealing the cash effectively despite the metal detectors, and board their flight bound for . Meanwhile, Police Chief Rotzinger, leading the pursuit, confronts Lombino, a mafia boss encountered earlier in the robbers' misadventures, erroneously identifying him as Grimm due to superficial resemblances in appearance or disguise remnants. A ensuing scuffle distracts authorities, enabling to rejoin her accomplices from the lavatory undetected. As the plane departs, Rotzinger arrests Lombino, securing a by apprehending the mobster but allowing the bank robbers to slip away unscathed with the loot. The film concludes with the trio's successful evasion, underscoring City's labyrinthine anarchy as both obstacle and unwitting ally in their resolution.

Release and Commercial Performance

Premiere and Distribution

Quick Change was theatrically released in the United States on July 13, 1990, distributed by in a wide opening on over 1,300 screens. The studio handled domestic distribution, leveraging its established network for comedy films featuring high-profile stars like Internationally, the film rolled out progressively, with releases in on November 1, 1990; on December 6, 1990; and and on January 4, 1991, among other markets, primarily under oversight. distribution followed, including VHS availability in by February 1991, with later DVD and Blu-ray editions issued by Warner in 2006 and 2021, respectively.

Box Office Results

Quick Change was produced on a budget of $17 million. Distributed by Warner Bros., the film premiered in wide release on July 13, 1990, across 1,596 screens, generating $4,700,960 in its opening weekend, which accounted for approximately 30.8% of its total domestic gross. The movie's domestic box office performance yielded a cumulative gross of $15,260,154, with no significant international earnings reported, for a worldwide total of $15,260,154. This result positioned it as the 87th highest-grossing film domestically in 1990. Despite earning 3.25 times its opening weekend figure, the final tally fell short of recouping the production budget, contributing to its classification as a commercial underperformer.
Financial MetricAmount
Production Budget$17 million
Opening Weekend Gross$4,700,960
Domestic Gross$15,260,154
Worldwide Gross$15,260,154

Reception

Initial Critical Reviews

Upon its release on July 13, 1990, Quick Change received mixed reviews from critics, with praise for its inventive premise and Bill Murray's performance tempered by criticisms of uneven pacing and stereotypical elements. awarded the film three out of four stars, describing it as "a funny but not an inspired comedy" that benefits from the chaotic energy of as a character, though he noted potential issues from its dual directorial credits—Howard Franklin and Murray himself—contributing to a lack of full cohesion. The New York Times' Janet Maslin panned the film as "clunky" and overly reliant on "stereotypical comedy," arguing that despite Murray's personal investment in adapting Jay Cronley's novel, it failed to elevate beyond familiar heist tropes and lacked the sharpness of his stronger vehicles like . In contrast, the Los Angeles Times highlighted its "giddy getaway" appeal, commending the city-specific humor that satirized urban dysfunction and the ensemble's timing in sequences like the post-heist taxi chase. Rolling Stone dismissed it as "derivative and blindingly dull," faulting the script for predictable gags and Murray's subdued persona for not compensating for thin plotting amid the ensemble's broader antics. The Deseret News offered a more favorable take, calling it a "delightful romp" where supporting players like Randy Quaid and Jason Robards stole scenes, enhancing Murray's understated robbery satire. Overall, initial assessments reflected divided opinions on whether the film's structural ambition—shifting from heist execution to absurd escape—delivered consistent laughs or devolved into farce.

Retrospective Assessments

In subsequent decades, Quick Change has garnered reappraisal as an underrated , particularly among enthusiasts of Murray's oeuvre, with commentators highlighting its incisive portrayal of chaos and Murray's understated exasperation as a bank robber navigating Manhattan's absurdities. A analysis described the film as a "neglected gem," commending Murray's extended comedic routines—such as his encounters with eccentric cab drivers and street performers—while noting the deliberate pacing that builds to a payoff in the third act's escalating mishaps. Similarly, a framed the movie as a "harshly critical " against City's dysfunction, contrasting its cynicism with more romanticized depictions in contemporary media and crediting the script's site-specific humor for amplifying the heist's comedic entropy. Later assessments have positioned Quick Change as one of Murray's most revealing works, with a arguing it functions as his most autobiographical , his own frustrations with production (stemming from the project's origins in a novel he optioned and his co-directorial role after clashing with potential directors like ). This view aligns with a 2014 endorsement calling it "the closest to capturing what makes Bill Murray work," emphasizing the blend of dry wit, dramatic tension, and spontaneous-seeming improvisation that distinguishes it from his more formulaic 1980s output. A 2014 career overview further lauded the 's "old-school sense of comic craftsmanship," where Murray anchors the ensemble without overshadowing co-stars Geena Davis and Randy Quaid, allowing set pieces—like the clown-disguised getaway—to unfold with precise timing amid the city's bureaucratic and linguistic barriers. Despite its initial box-office underperformance, retrospective commentary in upon a Blu-ray release reaffirmed its status as a "hidden gem" with enduring appeal for viewers appreciating anxiety-fueled humor, attributing sustained interest to home-video availability and Murray's rather than widespread theatrical success. These evaluations contrast with the film's muted commercial legacy, suggesting that its appreciation has grown through niche rediscovery, though it remains less canonized than Murray's hits like (1993), with no major studio re-release or anniversary editions as of 2025.

Audience and Commercial Legacy

Quick Change initially struggled to connect with mainstream audiences upon its 1990 theatrical release, but it gradually built a dedicated following through and exposure. Released on in 1991 by Warner Home Video, the film found renewed interest among viewers seeking offbeat comedies, particularly fans of Bill Murray's style. This appeal transformed it into a favorite, praised in retrospective discussions for its sharp of chaos and ensemble dynamics involving and . Audience metrics underscore this shift: on , it holds a 71% score (Popcornmeter), reflecting consistent positive feedback from viewers who appreciate its quotable and escalating over time. User reviews often highlight its underrated status, with comments noting the film's entertainment value despite lacking blockbuster marketing, attributing its longevity to word-of-mouth among aficionados. Later formats, including a 2006 DVD edition and Blu-ray releases, have sustained accessibility, enabling periodic rediscovery via streaming platforms like . Commercially, the film's legacy remains niche rather than expansive, lacking significant or remakes but benefiting from Murray's enduring star power in repertory screenings and communities. Its home media iterations have ensured modest ongoing revenue without achieving the scale of Murray's hits like , yet they affirm a persistent, if specialized, market viability tied to appreciation.

Controversies

On-Set Allegations of Misconduct

alleged that harassed her during the filming of Quick Change in 1990, including incidents of where he screamed at her both privately and in front of the crew. She detailed in her 2022 memoir Dying of Politeness that Murray followed her from her trailer to the set one day, yelling at her for being late despite her waiting on wardrobe assistance, an episode she described as making her feel "very powerless" and wish she had walked out. Davis further recounted that during a promotional appearance for the film on The Arsenio Hall Show, Murray grabbed her dress and pulled down the top to expose her bra, an action she said left her frozen in shock while the audience laughed. She attributed the overall dynamic to Murray's status as co-director and lead actor, which she believed enabled such behavior without immediate repercussions. In response to these and other past allegations resurfacing in , Murray stated in a 2025 interview that the world would have evidence if he were "an absolute monster," dismissing claims against him as exaggerated while acknowledging his "" persona sometimes crossed lines. Separately, child actor , who appeared in a minor role, alleged that Murray grabbed him by the ankles and dropped him into a garbage bin on set, describing the incident as frightening in retrospect amid broader scrutiny of Murray's conduct. No formal complaints or production halts were reported from Quick Change at the time, unlike later projects involving Murray.

Cultural Impact and Legacy

Influence on Heist Comedy Genre

Quick Change innovated within the heist comedy subgenre by depicting the as a swift, unproblematic , redirecting narrative tension toward the protagonists' farcical odyssey across Manhattan's congested streets and eccentric inhabitants en route to the airport. This reversal of expectations—contrasting meticulous planning typical of films like with improvised survival against mundane urban hurdles—underscored the genre's potential for on logistical rather than criminal ingenuity. Critics such as praised this structure, observing that "the bank is the first act of the movie, and it's fun. Then the real movie starts" with the escape, highlighting how the film's humor emerges from escalating absurdities like unreliable taxis and disoriented navigation. Retrospective analyses have echoed this, positioning the movie as a model for comedies that exploit post-crime disarray for laughs, though its box-office disappointment on July 13, 1990, curtailed immediate emulation. The film's , evidenced by recommendations alongside genre staples, reflects a lingering appreciation for its meta-awareness of conventions, such as the disguise enabling seamless and disguise swaps amplifying comedic irony. Comparisons to later works like (2006) note structural reminiscences in setups turning chaotic, suggesting indirect ripples in broader crime narratives, albeit adapted to tones rather than pure comedy. Overall, Quick Change enriched the subgenre's palette with New York-specific absurdity, fostering niche endurance over transformative dominance.

Bill Murray's Filmography Context

Quick Change (1990) served as Bill Murray's only directorial credit to date, with him co-directing alongside screenwriter Howard Franklin, who adapted Jay Cronley's 1981 novel of the same name. Murray viewed directing as central to the process, likening it to being a involved in every play, and undertook the role after other preferred directors declined the project. This debut occurred amid Murray's established comedic , honed through a decade of lead roles emphasizing wry detachment amid chaos, but represented a shift toward greater creative control following high-profile star vehicles. Murray's ascent in the late and featured breakthrough comedies like Meatballs (1979), where he played a camp counselor, and (1980), a that cemented his status. Subsequent hits included the army comedy Stripes (1981) and the (1984), the latter grossing over $295 million worldwide and spawning a 1989 sequel. These successes, alongside holiday vehicle Scrooged (1988), positioned Murray as a box-office draw capable of blending with ensemble dynamics, though he expressed frustration with development pressures and sought projects allowing personal input, as evidenced by his European hiatus post-Ghostbusters. In Quick Change, Murray reprises his archetype of the beleaguered —here a frustrated turned robber—navigating New York's absurdities post-heist, echoing the escalating mishaps of Stripes but with added layers of marital tension and city . The film's understated humor, which Murray favored over more bombastic efforts like , underscored his preference for character-driven amid a summer slate dominated by action spectacles. Post-Quick Change, Murray returned to acting leads in What About Bob? (1991) and (1993), the latter earning critical acclaim for blending comedy with philosophical depth, while forgoing further directing amid admissions that the experience demanded exhaustive attention to minutiae.