Fact-checked by Grok 2 weeks ago

Ralph Metzner


Ralph Metzner (May 18, 1936 – March 14, 2019) was a German-born American psychologist and psychotherapist recognized for pioneering research in psychedelics, consciousness studies, and transformative psychology.
Born in Berlin to a publishing father and Scottish émigré mother amid World War II disruptions, Metzner earned a BA in philosophy and psychology from Oxford University before obtaining a PhD in clinical psychology from Harvard University.
At Harvard, he collaborated with Timothy Leary and Richard Alpert (later Ram Dass) on the Psilocybin Project, conducting experiments to explore psilocybin's effects on perception and cognition, which contributed to early empirical insights into hallucinogens despite subsequent institutional backlash.
Metzner co-authored the influential manual The Psychedelic Experience (1964), adapting the Tibetan Book of the Dead to guide psychedelic sessions, and edited Psychedelic Review to disseminate research findings.
Post-Harvard, he authored over a dozen books, including Maps of Consciousness (1971) on comparative mystical states, Green Psychology (1999) linking ecological awareness to psyche transformation, and The Unfolding Self (1998) on personal growth processes, emphasizing shamanic and alchemical frameworks over mainstream therapeutic models.
He co-founded the Green Earth Foundation to promote harmonizing human-nature relations through education and rituals, served as academic dean and professor emeritus at the California Institute of Integral Studies, and developed practices like "Vision Circles" for collective healing.
Metzner's work bridged empirical psychedelic inquiry with cross-cultural spiritual traditions, influencing transpersonal psychology while maintaining a focus on direct experiential validation amid evolving scientific interest in entheogens.

Early Life and Education

Childhood in Germany and Immigration to the United States

Ralph Metzner was born on May 18, 1936, in , , to Wolfgang Metzner, owner of a publishing house, and Jessie (also known as Jill) Metzner, a Scottish woman who had previously worked for the League of Nations. His early years coincided with the height of the Nazi regime, which had consolidated power by the time of his birth, shaping a childhood marked by the regime's pervasive influence on daily life, education, and culture in the capital. Metzner's family remained in Berlin through World War II, enduring the associated deprivations, bombings, and postwar chaos until 1947, when he was 11 years old. That year, Metzner, his mother, and his two brothers emigrated to , leaving behind the devastated landscape; the siblings, having spoken only during their upbringing, encountered significant language barriers upon arrival in the UK. This displacement exposed the young Metzner to a abrupt shift from continental European intellectual and familial traditions—bolstered by his father's publishing background—to the Anglo-Scottish environment, fostering an early adaptability amid cultural dislocation. In 1958, at age 22, Metzner immigrated to the , eventually naturalizing as a citizen and navigating the challenges of integration, including linguistic and social adjustments for a postwar émigré in mid-20th-century . This transatlantic move marked the culmination of his family's migratory path from Nazi-era through , setting the stage for his American academic pursuits without immediate ties to his continental roots.

Academic Background and Initial Influences

Ralph Metzner completed his undergraduate education at University, obtaining a first-class honours degree in Politics, Philosophy, and Economics in 1958. The philosophy component of this interdisciplinary program exposed him to existentialist thinkers such as and , whose emphasis on individual authenticity, freedom, and the phenomenology of human existence informed his developing orientation toward subjective psychological processes. In 1958, following his graduation, Metzner immigrated to the to pursue advanced studies at , where he earned a Ph.D. in in 1962. This transition from European philosophical traditions to American academic psychology in the late positioned him at the intersection of rigorous empirical methods and nascent inquiries into , with his prior exposure to philosophical texts on —predating direct psychedelic experimentation—cultivating an initial interest in non-ordinary states of awareness through contemplative and literary sources. Early encounters with Eastern thought, via philosophical comparisons in his curriculum, further oriented him toward integrative models of mind beyond strict Western materialism.

Psychedelic Research and Collaborations

Participation in the Harvard Psilocybin Project

Ralph Metzner, a graduate student in psychology at Harvard University, became involved in the Psilocybin Project during its early phases, collaborating with project leaders Timothy Leary and Richard Alpert starting in spring 1961. The initiative, launched in 1960 under the Center for Research in Personality, employed empirical methods to investigate psilocybin's influence on perception, cognition, and personality, administering controlled doses to volunteer subjects in supervised settings. Metzner's participation included facilitating guided sessions with fellow graduate students, where participants ingested to elicit alterations in sensory and . These protocols emphasized pre- and post-session assessments, including questionnaires on subjective experiences, revealing consistent reports of ego dissolution—characterized by temporary loss of self-boundaries and unity with surroundings—as well as short-term enhancements in emotional openness and creative insight. Initial data from these trials, gathered through structured interviews and psychological inventories, documented acute cognitive shifts, such as intensified and reduced analytical rigidity, without evidence of lasting harm in screened volunteers. A key component of Metzner's involvement was the , conducted from late 1961 into 1962, which tested psilocybin-assisted group psychotherapy on 32 inmates to probe its potential for fostering behavioral change. In these sessions, subjects received 5-10 mg doses under therapeutic guidance, yielding empirical observations of profound emotional releases and perceptual expansions, including vivid visual phenomena and diminished fear responses. Follow-up evaluations noted transient improvements in interpersonal trust and self-reflection, though long-term outcomes required extended analysis. These findings were preliminarily outlined in project memos and joint publications, prioritizing quantifiable metrics over interpretive frameworks.

Co-Authorship of The Psychedelic Experience and Key Experiments

In 1964, Ralph Metzner co-authored The Psychedelic Experience: A Manual Based on the Tibetan Book of the Dead with Timothy Leary and Richard Alpert, adapting the Bardo Thodol's descriptions of postmortem states into a framework for navigating psychedelic-induced altered consciousness. The manual structured sessions into three phases—ego death (chikkhai bardo), visionary experiences (chonyid bardo), and rebirth (sidpa bardo)—emphasizing preparation of mindset (set), physical environment (setting), and verbal guidance to minimize fear and maximize insights into impermanence and interconnectedness. This approach innovated by mapping subjective drug effects onto Eastern phenomenology, providing practitioners with a scripted protocol to elicit controlled mystical states rather than unstructured chaos, as evidenced by session transcripts where guides recited passages to anchor participants amid perceptual dissolution. Metzner's contributions extended to experimental design in the Harvard Psilocybin Project's (1961–1963), where he helped administer to 32 inmates in group therapy sessions modeled on the manual's structure, testing whether induced ego transcendence could foster prosocial shifts and lower . Prior to dosing, Metzner and Weil established baseline rates at through a 1963 analysis of 255 released inmates, revealing a 10-month reincarceration rate of approximately 43% for the general , against which experimental outcomes were benchmarked. Sessions involved 200–400 mg per participant, paired with pre- and post-discussions to process visions of personal flaws and ethical renewal, with initial 10-month follow-up data indicating a 32% rate in the treated group—lower than baseline but confounded by small sample size and lack of randomization. Longer-term evaluations, including a 34-year follow-up by Doblin et al., found no statistically significant overall reduction in compared to controls, though the experimental group's rate of reincarceration for new crimes (7%) was notably lower than for violations alone, suggesting possible targeted effects on behavioral patterns linked to session-induced causal attributions of criminality to ego-bound perspectives. Metzner later critiqued early claims of success, attributing overstated to Leary's selective reporting and inadequate controls, while affirming that structured protocols correlated with participant reports of durable insights—such as diminished —corroborated in qualitative session logs but requiring replication for . These efforts pioneered psychedelic-assisted intervention metrics, prioritizing subjective phenomenology over pharmacological isolation, though methodological limitations like non-blinded administration limited generalizability.

Academic Career and Teaching

Roles at the California Institute of Integral Studies

Ralph Metzner joined the faculty of the California Institute of Asian Studies (later renamed the , or CIIS) in 1975 as a professor in the East-West Psychology program. There, he initially focused on developing graduate-level coursework that bridged Eastern spiritual traditions, Western psychological theories, and explorations of of . By 1979, he advanced to Program Director of East-West Psychology before assuming the role of Academic Dean, positions in which he oversaw administrative expansion and curricular refinements amid the institution's transition to emphasizing integral studies. During the 1980s, Metzner served as Academic Dean for approximately a decade, later taking on duties as Academic Vice President, guiding CIIS through periods of accreditation challenges and programmatic growth in transpersonal education. In these capacities, he contributed to curriculum design that incorporated comparative analyses of shamanic practices, mystical experiences, and cross-cultural psychological frameworks, fostering an academic environment conducive to empirical inquiry into non-ordinary states without reliance on unverified anecdotal reports. His teaching spanned 31 years, during which he mentored cohorts of graduate students through seminars on consciousness dynamics, influencing subsequent generations of researchers in integral psychology up to his retirement in the mid-2000s, after which he held the title of Professor Emeritus.

Development of Transpersonal Psychology Frameworks

Metzner advanced by formulating models that transcended Freudian emphasis on intrapsychic conflicts and defenses, incorporating expanded states of awareness derived from his academic teaching and direct observations of shifts. These frameworks positioned as a domain concerned with experiences beyond the personal , including transformations of that integrate spiritual and existential dimensions. Central to his contributions were heuristic maps of consciousness states, outlined in his 1971 work Maps of Consciousness, which delineated pathways from ego-bound, conditioned perceptions to transpersonal realms of interconnectedness and expanded awareness. Drawing on cross-cultural sources, Metzner analyzed ancient systems—including the Chinese I Ching for hexagram-based perceptual shifts, Indian Tantra for energy-channeling processes, Western Tarot and astrology for archetypal progressions, alchemical stages of purification, and the yoga philosophy of Actualism for actualizing latent potentials—to construct comparative charts of mental landscapes. This approach highlighted distinctions between ordinary egoic states, characterized by fragmentation and cultural conditioning, and transpersonal states involving holistic integration and transcendence of individual identity. Metzner's models of transformation further emphasized evolutionary processes of the , informed by empirical observations from studies of altered and individual reports. In his 1980 "Ten Classical Metaphors of Self-Transformation," he synthesized motifs—such as progression from dream-like to awakening, to , fragmentation to wholeness, separation to oneness, and death to rebirth—into a framework portraying psychological development as an unfolding toward . These metaphors, grounded in analyses of historical texts and contemporary on perceptual changes, illustrated mechanisms for sustained personality restructuring, where individuals exhibited enduring shifts like reduced defensiveness and enhanced perceptual acuity following transformative sequences. Complementing this, his 1998 book The Unfolding Self detailed archetypes and dynamics of such experiences, deriving universal patterns from observed varieties of inner evolution beyond egoic norms.

Contributions to Consciousness and Psychedelic Studies

Theoretical Models of Psychedelic States

Metzner formulated the General Heuristic Model of Altered States of Consciousness to provide a structured phenomenological framework for analyzing psychedelic-induced experiences, derived from clustering analyses of subjective reports identifying eight core features such as perceptual alterations and emotional shifts. This model positions states along three key dimensions: arousal (heightened activation versus sedation), hedonic tone (pleasure versus pain or distress), and expansion-contraction (broadened awareness versus narrowed focus). Psychedelic states, in this schema, typically exhibit high arousal driven by pharmacological action on serotonin pathways, variable hedonic outcomes influenced by dosage and context (ranging from ecstatic to challenging), and profound expansion marked by sensory amplification and cognitive fluidity. Building on session data from controlled experiments, Metzner categorized psychedelic phenomena into sequential phases analogous to the Tibetan s, with the Chonyid Bardo featuring archetypal visions—internal flows of symbolic entities or powers evoking Jungian prototypes like deities or monsters—and the Sidpa Bardo involving unity perceptions, where boundaries dissolve into sensations of cosmic interconnectedness. These categorizations prioritize observable patterns over interpretive , attributing visions to amplified projections rather than literal otherworldly encounters, while underscoring integration difficulties: transient expansions often clash with baseline , risking disorientation or incomplete without reflective practices. In comparing psychedelic states to non-pharmacological alterations like meditative absorption or hypnagogic imagery, Metzner highlighted empirical overlaps in unity motifs and archetypal content, both reflecting innate neural architectures for transcendent processing, yet distinguished by psychedelics' acute intensity and controllability via , which enable replicable access but introduce risks of overwhelm absent in gradual non-drug paths. This causal emphasis grounds experiences in brain-mediated mechanisms—such as activation facilitating perceptual reconfiguration—countering unsubstantiated claims with demands for post-state verification through behavioral and cognitive changes.

Practical Applications in Psychotherapy and Shamanism

Metzner conducted over five decades of guided psychedelic sessions, incorporating , , and into both individual and group rituals to facilitate psychological . In these applications, he emphasized meticulous preparation, including clarified intentions, , and psychological screening to mitigate risks, alongside optimized physical environments such as darkened rooms or natural settings to enhance and . For sessions, typically administered in controlled doses during the 1960s Harvard era and later private practice, Metzner employed low-dose psycholytic approaches for ongoing integration or high-dose psychedelic methods for profound state changes, with facilitators providing verbal guidance to navigate ego or visionary content. In applications, drawn from his fieldwork and edited anthology, Metzner advocated hybrid protocols blending indigenous shamanic elements—like icaros (healing songs) sung by facilitators—with Western therapeutic oversight in group circles. Sessions often involved communal ingestion in low-light malocas or adapted urban spaces, followed by purging as a release of emotional blockages, and post-session sharing via talking sticks to process visions of serpents or ancestral figures symbolizing unresolved conflicts. For , derived from toad venom or synthetic sources, he described short, intense vaporized administrations in supportive settings, prioritizing and sitter reassurance to handle overwhelming non-dual states that could evoke terror or unity, as detailed in his explorations of its rapid ego-transcending effects. Cross-cultural integrations featured in Metzner's work included syncretic Brazilian churches like and , where ayahuasca rituals merged Amazonian plant medicine with Christian hymns and structured hierarchies for collective healing, which he observed yielding sustained behavioral shifts in participants with histories of . However, he critiqued Western adaptations for frequent dilutions of ritual discipline, such as ayahuasca tourism lacking authentic shamanic training, which risked amplifying adverse reactions like or incomplete integration without cultural embedding. Self-reported outcomes from these sessions frequently included resolution through visionary confrontations with past wounds, fostering emotional purging, self-forgiveness, and reduced addictive patterns, as in cases of cessation via repeated use or enhanced insight in therapy. Studies of church members under Metzner's purview showed improvements in mood and cognitive function post-ritual, yet he acknowledged variable efficacy, with failures attributed to poor set (resistant mindsets) or setting (unprepared facilitators), underscoring anecdotal limitations and the need for empirical caution over universal claims.

Ecological Activism and Transformational Theories

Founding of the Green Earth Foundation

Ralph Metzner co-founded the Green Earth Foundation, a 501(c)(3) non-profit educational organization, with his wife Cathy Coleman to address the strained relationship between humanity and the natural world through consciousness transformation. The foundation's establishment built on Metzner's earlier work in Green Psychology (1999), which explored psychological barriers to ecological harmony, aiming to foster shifts in awareness that promote respect for all life forms and sustainable human behaviors. By 2002, Metzner was actively serving as its president, directing efforts to integrate insights from shamanism, alchemy, mythology, and eco-psychology into practical environmental stewardship. The organization's core mission emphasized healing planetary imbalances by encouraging nature-based consciousness changes, drawing from empirical observations of how reveal ecological interconnectedness without relying on unsubstantiated anthropocentric narratives. Programs focused on educational initiatives that advocated sustainable practices, such as reorienting human activities toward regenerative cycles informed by and traditions, rather than purely technological fixes. These efforts sought to counteract modern dissociation from nature, prioritizing causal links between individual perceptual shifts and broader preservation over ideologically driven . Early activities under Metzner's leadership included publishing guidelines and resources for entheogenic experiences aligned with ecological ethics, such as Allies for Awakening (2015), which outlined protocols for safe, productive engagements with psychedelics to enhance planetary awareness. The foundation's tax-exempt status supported advocacy for harmonizing human-nature relations, with Metzner receiving no compensation as in filings from 2011 onward, underscoring its focus on mission-driven work amid limited resources. This founding initiative reflected Metzner's commitment to applying first-hand transformative experiences to urgent global concerns, distinct from mainstream academic often critiqued for overlooking factors.

Integration of Psychedelics with Environmental Consciousness

In Green Psychology: Transforming Our Relationship to the (1999), Metzner contended that psychedelic experiences disrupt anthropocentric perceptual filters, unveiling the illusory separation between humans and the that sustains exploitative attitudes toward . He drew on historical and analyses to argue that such states foster a participatory ecological , countering the dominator paradigms of industrial rooted in ego-bound from living systems. Observational accounts from guided psychedelic sessions, as documented in Metzner's clinical and research notes, linked ego-dissolution phenomena—characterized by boundary loss and unity perceptions—to enduring shifts in participants' environmental orientations, including reduced and increased advocacy for preservation. These transformations, Metzner observed, often manifested as causal drivers for behavioral changes, such as voluntary adoption of low-impact lifestyles, predicated on direct experiential insight into interdependence rather than abstract ethical appeals. Metzner further critiqued large-scale industrial extraction and monocultural agriculture as extensions of pathological psychic numbing, proposing psychedelics as tools to inspire regenerative, decentralized alternatives like and biomimicry, which emulate natural over hierarchical control. This integration, he maintained, hinges on causal realism: psychedelic-induced revelations of systemic causality in ecosystems compel reevaluation of human interventions that ignore feedback loops, evidenced by reported post-session commitments to against and .

Criticisms, Controversies, and Risks

Backlash from the Harvard Experiments

The , in which Ralph Metzner served as a alongside and Richard Alpert from 1960 to 1963, encountered severe institutional backlash due to allegations of procedural irregularities and ethical shortcomings. University investigations highlighted the administration of and to undergraduate students without rigorous controls, informed consent protocols, or blinded methodologies, violating academic standards for . On May 27, 1963, Harvard dismissed Leary from its Psychology Department for these lapses, citing failures in supervision and potential endangerment of participants; Alpert faced dismissal on June 14, 1963, following similar charges, including evidence of him providing psychedelics to an undergraduate during a supervised session. Metzner's tangential role in session facilitation and drew administrative scrutiny, though as a non-faculty collaborator, he avoided formal termination, prompting his departure from Harvard amid the project's shutdown. Federal regulatory bodies amplified the fallout, with the (FDA) critiquing the experiments for methodological laxity, such as subjective self-reporting without objective validation and inadequate screening for participant vulnerabilities. The Kefauver-Harris Amendments of 1962 had already mandated stricter evidence of drug safety and efficacy for investigational use, exposing the Harvard efforts as non-compliant with emerging requirements for controlled trials. Reports of adverse events, including acute anxiety reactions and unsupervised "bad trips" among novice users, underscored ethical lapses like unmonitored undergraduate dosing, which critics argued risked psychological harm without therapeutic oversight. These controversies precipitated broader regulatory clampdowns, culminating in the FDA's 1966 emergency scheduling of as a substance with no proven medical value and high potential for abuse, prohibiting non-exempt research and distribution. The decision drew on empirical data from overdose and misuse reports—such as documented cases of hallucinogen-induced and at least one fatality linked to unsupervised ingestion in 1965—compounded by cultural panic over rising recreational abuse and media-amplified incidents of perceptual distortions leading to accidents. This shift effectively halted institutional psychedelic inquiry for decades, with Metzner's early association casting a shadow over subsequent legitimacy claims in the field.

Skepticism Regarding Psychedelic Efficacy and Cultural Impacts

Despite early enthusiasm for psychedelics in therapeutic and exploratory contexts, including those advanced by researchers like Metzner, subsequent analyses have highlighted limited evidence for sustained long-term in treating psychiatric conditions, with benefits often confined to short-term symptom rather than enduring remission. A 2022 review noted that while acute subjective effects may mimic therapeutic gains, rigorous longitudinal studies frequently fail to demonstrate superior outcomes over or standard therapies for disorders like , raising questions about placebo-driven perceptions of benefit. Critics argue that methodological flaws, such as small sample sizes and reliance on self-reports, undermine claims of transformative , particularly when accounting for high dropout rates and variable individual responses. Concerns over risks, including the induction of , have persisted, with meta-analyses estimating incidence rates of psychedelic-triggered psychotic episodes at 0.6% in randomized controlled trials, though population-level data suggest rarity at 0.002%. Individuals with latent vulnerabilities, such as family , face elevated dangers, prompting routine exclusions from modern trials and underscoring causal links between psychedelics and acute exacerbations or prolonged disorders like (HPPD). Transition rates to chronic from , including psychedelics, reach approximately 21% in first-episode cohorts, challenging narratives of psychedelics as uniformly low-risk catalysts for healing. Culturally, the psychedelic movement, in which Metzner participated through Harvard-affiliated research, faced backlash for fostering hedonistic misuse detached from structured integration, contributing to spikes in adverse outcomes during the ensuing decade. Reports from the era documented increased emergency interventions for bad trips, dependency patterns, and polydrug experimentation in counterculture hubs like , where casual distribution amplified risks without safeguards like set-and-setting protocols. This unchecked proliferation, critics contend, prioritized experiential novelty over accountability, correlating with broader upticks in hallucinogen-related hospitalizations amid waning communal oversight. While psychedelic proponents, including Metzner, emphasized contextual controls to mitigate harms, skeptics maintain that unregulated recreational adoption—prevalent in the post-Harvard era—validated regulatory restrictions, as anecdotal excesses overshadowed empirical safeguards. Government scheduling under the 1970 , classifying and as Schedule I for high abuse potential and lacking accepted safety, reflected these concerns, though overreach in is acknowledged alongside the merits of curbing access to avert public health crises.

Personal Life and Later Years

Marriages, Family, and Private Practice

Metzner married Susan Homer in 1962 while residing in the Millbrook community in , but the union ended in divorce two years later in 1964. He wed Cathy Coleman in 1988, forming a that lasted 31 years and provided a stable personal foundation amid his professional pursuits in consciousness research. The couple raised daughter Sophia Metzner in , where she pursued education locally before becoming a clinical social worker. Coleman also brought stepson Elias Jacobson into the family dynamic, contributing to a blended household that supported Metzner's retreat-oriented lifestyle away from public spotlight. In the late , Metzner transitioned from academic and research roles to establish a private practice in , serving as both therapist and consultant. He maintained this Bay Area-based practice for decades, operating an office in San Rafael and focusing on individualized therapeutic sessions that complemented his broader work in psychological transformation without the constraints of institutional settings. This private endeavor allowed him to balance intensive professional engagements with periodic personal withdrawals, prioritizing depth over publicity.

Health Decline and Death in 2019

In the final year of his life, Ralph Metzner was diagnosed with idiopathic pulmonary fibrosis, a progressive and incurable degenerative lung disease characterized by scarring of lung tissue that impairs breathing and oxygen exchange. The condition advanced over approximately 10 months, leading to his death on March 14, 2019, at age 82 in his home in Sonoma, California. His wife, Cathy Coleman, confirmed the cause as idiopathic pulmonary fibrosis, noting that he passed peacefully in his sleep after a relatively brief battle with the illness. Metzner's longstanding scholarly and therapeutic engagement with themes of , dying, and transitions—explored in his writings on psychedelic experiences, shamanic practices, and psychological —aligned with accounts of his end-of-life demeanor, described by associates as quiet and graceful. This perspective, rooted in his view of as a natural passage rather than an endpoint, informed a composed acceptance during his decline, though no public statements from Metzner himself on his survive in primary records. The immediate aftermath involved his wife at his side, with his passing noted privately among family before broader announcements; his only child, son Ari, had predeceased him in childhood. Coverage appeared in outlets like and , but without immediate large-scale public commemorations or fanfare, reflecting the understated nature of his final days.

Legacy and Influence

Impact on Modern Psychedelic Research

Metzner's collaboration on (1964), co-authored with and Richard Alpert, provided a structured adapting the Book of the Dead for guiding and sessions, emphasizing sequential stages of ego dissolution and reintegration that prefigured modern therapeutic models for psychedelic-assisted . This framework influenced protocols in post-2010 clinical trials, where preparation, dosing, and integration sessions mirror the manual's focus on intentional navigation of to foster psychological breakthroughs. The principle of "set and setting"—the interplay of mindset and environmental context—codified by Metzner, Leary, and Alpert in their 1964 writings, underpins contemporary research designs, including MAPS' phase 3 trials for MDMA-assisted therapy for PTSD, designated as FDA breakthrough therapy in 2017. Metzner's 1980s investigations into MDMA, documented in Through the Gateway of the Heart (1986), highlighted its empathogenic effects for trauma resolution, coining the term "empathogen" and informing MAPS' emphasis on interpersonal trust-building in sessions; MAPS founder Rick Doblin explicitly credited Metzner as a pivotal inspiration for reviving rigorous psychedelic research after the 1970s moratorium. Despite these borrowings, modern studies reveal empirical challenges in scaling early anecdotal successes from Metzner's era, with controlled trials like those for in (e.g., ' 2016 protocol) showing efficacy tied to expectancy and context effects rather than purely pharmacological action, underscoring limits in replicating 1960s uncontrolled outcomes amid stricter FDA requirements for blinding and controls. Metzner's later work on , culminating in The Toad and the Jaguar (2013), continues to inform niche explorations of intense entheogenic states, though broader adoption awaits larger randomized data.

Posthumous Recognition and Ongoing Debates

Following Metzner's death in 2019, his widow Cathy Coleman edited the 2024 biography Ralph Metzner, Explorer of Consciousness: The Life and Legacy of a Psychedelic , which incorporates archival materials including personal correspondence, unpublished writings, and records from his Harvard-era experiments to portray his evolution from psychedelic researcher to explorer integrating Eastern philosophies and . The volume, foreworded by neurobiologist E. Presti, emphasizes Metzner's cautionary approaches to psychedelics, such as structured set-and-setting protocols, distinguishing his legacy from more unstructured experimentation. This publication has coincided with heightened attention to Metzner's foundational texts, like his co-authorship of (1964), amid the , where randomized controlled trials since 2020 have reported psilocybin-assisted therapy yielding sustained reductions in severity for up to 12 months in some participants compared to controls. Proponents credit early figures like Metzner with inspiring modern protocols that prioritize therapeutic integration, potentially extending to treatment-resistant PTSD and via serotonin receptor agonism mechanisms observed in studies. However, debates surrounding Metzner's era persist, with critics arguing that romanticized narratives of psychedelic exploration—echoed in some advocacy—understate causal risks like acute exacerbation in vulnerable individuals or long-term attribution of mystical experiences to unverifiable metaphysical claims rather than effects. Commercialization concerns have intensified post-2019, as influxes into psychedelic startups raise fears of profit-driven dilution of rigorous, non-indigenous contexts Metzner engaged, potentially eroding traditional ceremonial frameworks through patenting of plant-derived compounds and scaled, decontextualized therapies. While empirical data supports targeted applications, skeptics highlight insufficient mechanistic clarity and historical ethical lapses as barriers to broader credibility, urging first-principles scrutiny over enthusiasm.

Publications and Media

Major Books and Writings

Metzner's most influential early work was the co-authorship of : A Manual Based on the Tibetan Book of the Dead, published in 1964 with and Richard Alpert, which presented a structured protocol for guiding and sessions through stages analogous to the Tibetan realms, emphasizing preparation, surrender, and integration to facilitate ego transcendence based on session observations. This text drew from controlled administrations in research settings, prioritizing navigational maps derived from participant reports over speculative metaphysics. In 1971, Metzner published Maps of Consciousness, an early comparative framework charting diverse across traditions like , , and , informed by phenomenological data from entheogenic and meditative practices to delineate pathways of psychological expansion. The book advanced empirical mapping of levels, critiquing reductionist models by integrating cross-cultural evidence of transformative mechanisms. Later, Green Psychology: Transforming Our Relationship to the Earth appeared in , examining ecological disconnection through archetypal and alchemical lenses, with arguments grounded in historical patterns of human-nature interaction and calls for supported by observational insights into perceptual shifts. As editor of The Psychedelic Review from onward, Metzner compiled issues featuring firsthand empirical reports on substance-induced states, alongside analyses of their cognitive and perceptual effects, fostering a repository of that prioritized verifiable session outcomes over ideological narratives. This editorial curation highlighted causal links between dosage, mindset, and experiential outcomes, influencing subsequent phenomenological studies.

Discography and Musical Contributions

Metzner contributed to the audio adaptation of , a 1966 guide co-authored with and Richard Alpert (later ), which was released as a cassette in 1991 featuring guided readings intended to navigate psychedelic states based on the Tibetan Book of the Dead. This recording served as an auditory companion for therapeutic and exploratory sessions, emphasizing structured consciousness expansion through spoken instructions overlaid with minimal soundscapes. In the 1970s, Metzner produced Soul Journeys: Two Guided Meditations, a cassette album offering narrated paths for inner exploration, blending his psychological insights with ambient audio elements to facilitate meditative states in clinical and personal settings. Later collaborations integrated Metzner's narrations with original compositions focused on transformative themes. The 2005 album Bardo Blues, featuring Metzner, incorporated his spoken elements into blues-infused tracks exploring death and rebirth motifs akin to bardo transitions. In 2012, Spirit Soundings with composer Kit Walker presented three tracks—"Triune Time Wave," "Ayahuasca Serpent Vision," and "Omens For Our Planetary Future"—combining Metzner's ecological and visionary narrations with electronic and organic sound design to evoke planetary consciousness and environmental harmony. A notable 2018 release, Völuspa with percussionist Byron Metcalf, featured Metzner's of the ancient prophetic poem over Metcalf's rhythmic soundscapes enhanced by Hemi-Sync beats, designed for immersive listening to induce addressing apocalyptic and regenerative cycles, often applied in therapeutic contexts for ecological awareness. These works underscored Metzner's approach to audio as a medium for fusing music, mythology, and to support guided without reliance on substances.

References

  1. [1]
    Green Earth Foundation
    NEW! Ralph Metzner, Explorer of Consciousness: The Life and Legacy of a Psychedelic Pioneer · Ralph Metzner ​ · May 18, 1936 - March 14, 2019 ​.
  2. [2]
    Ralph Metzner, Ph.D. - Synergetic Press
    Ralph Metzner, PhD, (1936-2019) was a world-renown pioneer in the study of consciousness and transformative experience.
  3. [3]
    Ralph Metzner, Bay Area expert on hallucinogens, death and ...
    Mar 22, 2019 · Metzner was born in Berlin on May 18, 1936. His father was a publisher, and his mother an emigrant from Scotland. During World War II, the ...Missing: biography | Show results with:biography
  4. [4]
    [PDF] A MEMORIAL TRIBUTE TO RALPH METZNER
    Dec 9, 2019 · Ralph Metzner was a visionary alchemical explorer, rigorous academic scholar, and uniquely gifted shamanic teacher.Missing: biography | Show results with:biography
  5. [5]
    Ralph Metzner, Explorer of Consciousness - Inner Traditions
    Renowned as a pioneering psychologist, psychedelic elder, alchemical explorer, and shamanic teacher, the late Ralph Metzner (1936–2019) contributed profoundly ...
  6. [6]
    About Ralph Metzner - Green Earth Foundation
    Ralph Metzner, Ph.D. was a recognized pioneer in psychological, philosophical and cross-cultural studies of consciousness and its transformations.
  7. [7]
    Ralph Metzner, LSD and Consciousness Researcher, Dies at 82
    Apr 4, 2019 · Ralph Metzner, a psychotherapist who began his career working with Timothy Leary on controversial studies at Harvard involving LSD and other drugs,
  8. [8]
    Metzner, Ralph | Archives and Special Collections - Purdue University
    The Harvard Psilocybin Project memos, reports and meeting minutes (1 folder; circa 1961-1962) documents the therapeutic use of psilocybin on inmates at the ...
  9. [9]
    The Roots of War and Domination by Ralph Metzner (Ebook)
    Dec 20, 2023 · I was born in 1936 in Germany and lived there with my family, until 1947, after which my two brothers and I emigrated to Britain, with my mother ...Missing: Nazi era
  10. [10]
    [PDF] The Maternal Mythic Milieu of Ralph Metzner - Alastair McIntosh
    Ralph was 10 when we first came to the UK and I was 8. Neither of us spoke a word of English. All our childhood days were spent in Berlin where we only spoke ...
  11. [11]
    Ralph Metzner Obituary (1936 - 2019) - Legacy Remembers
    Mar 29, 2019 · There he obtained a First Class Honours Degree in Politics, Philosophy and Economics. He subsequently attended Harvard University 1958 – 1962 ...Missing: subject | Show results with:subject
  12. [12]
    None
    ### Summary of Ralph Metzner's Academic Background and Early Influences
  13. [13]
    Harvard Psilocybin Project – Drug Times - Beezone Library
    Metzner was fascinated. But he was also scared of drug addiction. So he did the logical scientific thing: he perused the literature and found, much to his ...<|separator|>
  14. [14]
    Ralph Metzner, Ram Dass, and David McCelland - Beezone Library
    His work on the need for achievement, the Protestant ethic. The Harvard Psilocybin Project 1960-1962. Summer, I960. Timothy Leary takes visionary mushrooms, ...
  15. [15]
    [PDF] FINDING AID TO THE HARVARD PSILOCYBIN PROJECT MEMOS ...
    Ralph Metzner was resistant to Leary's project; however, he researched psilocybin and other drugs concluded that the drugs were not completely dangerous ...
  16. [16]
    Center for Research in Personality at Harvard – Early Writings
    This paper is a product of the joint efforts of Richard Alpert, Michael Kahn, Timothy Leary, George Litwin, Ralph Metzner and Gunther Weil, and these ...<|control11|><|separator|>
  17. [17]
    Dr. Leary's Concord Prison Experiment: a 34-year follow-up study
    The original study involved the administration of psilocybin-assisted group ... Ralph Metzner and Gunther Weil. The results of the follow-up study ...
  18. [18]
    [PDF] The Psychedelic Experience.Pdf - Leathersmithe
    The authors were engaged in a program of experiments with LSD and other psychedelic drugs at Harvard. University, until sensational national publicity, unfairly ...
  19. [19]
    [PDF] Reflections on the Concord Prison Project and Follow-up Study
    cally negative result we reported in the study, and talked about the project as if we lowered the recidivism rate. A. In this sense, I'm grateful to have ...
  20. [20]
    "Predicting Recidivism: Base-Rates for Massachusetts Correctional ...
    Ralph Metzner and Gunther Weil, Predicting Recidivism: Base-Rates for Massachusetts Correctional Institution Concord, 54 J. Crim. L. & Criminology 307 (1963).Missing: Prison Project results<|separator|>
  21. [21]
    (PDF) Dr. Leary's Concord Prison Experiment: A 34-Year Follow-up ...
    Aug 9, 2025 · Recidivism rates did not improve at follow-ups, although the authors found that recidivism for new crimes was significantly lower than that of ...
  22. [22]
    The Psychedelic Renaissance and Its Forensic Implications
    Sep 1, 2025 · Leary's colleague Ralph Metzner, who was a graduate student at the time, acknowledged the errors and attributed them to a halo effect ...
  23. [23]
    California Institute of Integral Studies: Out in Front on Psychedelic ...
    Feb 11, 2015 · Ralph Metzner, after earning his PhD, began teaching psychology at CIIS in 1975, and eventually served the Institute as both the academic dean ...
  24. [24]
    A Brief Unexpurgated History of th" by Ralph Metzner
    In this presentation, former CIIS faculty member, Academic Dean, and Academic Vice President will share his account of a thirty year span of CIIS history.Missing: roles | Show results with:roles
  25. [25]
    Sebastiani event to celebrate life of seminal consciousness explorer ...
    Nov 4, 2024 · Sebastiani Theatre will host an event, “Ralph Metzner: The Life and Legacy of a Psychedelic Pioneer,” to celebrate the book release, at 5 p.m. ...Missing: PPE | Show results with:PPE
  26. [26]
    States of Consciousness and Transpersonal Psychology
    The purposes of this chapter are (a) to situate current thinking on consciousness in the field of transpersonal psychology, (b) to formulate a distinction ...
  27. [27]
    Maps of Consciousness - Inner Traditions
    Explores six ancient yet timeless systems for exploring the mind: the I Ching, Tantra, Tarot, astrology, alchemy, and the yoga philosophy of Actualism.
  28. [28]
    [PDF] TEN CLASSICAL METAPHORS OF SELF-TRANSFORMATION
    Ralph Metzner. San Francisco,California. Philosophers, social scientists, futurists and others have argued that not only are we in a period of accelerating ...
  29. [29]
    The Unfolding Self: Varieties of Transformative Experience
    Metzner goes beyond his roots in transpersonal psychology to uncover universal structures of spiritual transformation. Readers who immerse themselves in these ...
  30. [30]
    Classification schemes of altered states of consciousness
    Around 1986, Ralph Metzner developed a classification scheme that mapped ASCs based on two dimensions: first, how subjectively energetic, or aroused, they ...
  31. [31]
    Psychedelic, Psychoactive, and Addictive Drugs and States of ...
    This chapter examines the states of consciousness induced by hallucinogens or psychedelic drugs in the framework of a general model of altered states of ...
  32. [32]
    Psychedelic, Psychoactive, and Addictive Drugs and States of ...
    This chapter examines the states of consciousness induced by hallucinogens or psychedelic drugs in the framework of a general model of altered states of ...
  33. [33]
    Entheogenesis: Toward an Expanded Worldview for Our Time
    One, it connects psychedelic drugs with other modes of consciousness expansion, such as meditation and creative visioning; and two, it suggests contrasting ...
  34. [34]
    Ralph Metzner - The Guiding Presence
    He wanted to protect the integrity of the inner healing trajectory, lest the external influences of the sitter hijack the consciousness and direction of the ...Missing: existentialism | Show results with:existentialism
  35. [35]
    Hallucinogenic drugs and plants in psychotherapy and shamanism
    Western psychotherapy and indigenous shamanic healing systems have both used psychoactive drugs or plants for healing and obtaining knowledge.Missing: practical | Show results with:practical
  36. [36]
    [PDF] ATHERTON PRESS
    attempt to provide a series of guided psychedelic sessions for prepared ... Timothy Leary, George Litwin, and Ralph Metzner, "Reactions to Psilocybin.
  37. [37]
    Green Psychology - Inner Traditions
    Free delivery over $35 30-day returns... Green Earth Foundation. Dr. Metzner is the author of numerous books, including Overtones and Undercurrents and Searching for the Philosophers' Stone.<|control11|><|separator|>
  38. [38]
    The Albert Hofmann Foundation Report – Summer 2002 ...
    He is president and co-founder of the Green Earth Foundation (http://www.greenearthfound.org/ ), a non-profit educational organization devoted to healing ...
  39. [39]
    The Split Between Spirit and Nature in European Consciousness
    Ralph Metzner is the founder and president of the Green Earth Foundation ... 2000 years of Christianity, plus Judaism and Islam. These traditions have ...
  40. [40]
    Green Earth Foundation - Nonprofit Explorer - ProPublica
    Green Earth Foundation. Sonoma, CA; Tax-exempt since April 2025; EIN: 68-0157926. Subscribe.Missing: date | Show results with:date
  41. [41]
    In Memoriam, Dr. Ralph Metzner (1936-2019) - Synergetic Press
    Mar 20, 2019 · Dr. Ralph Metzner passed away peacefully in his sleep earlier this week, March 14, 2019. He was truly an asset to this planet and will be greatly missed by us ...
  42. [42]
    Green Psychology: Transforming Our Relationship to the Earth
    Jun 1, 1999 · In Green Psychology Ralph Metzner explores the history of this global ... drugs Earth Goddess ECOLOGICAL AGE ecological worldview ...<|separator|>
  43. [43]
    Eco-Psychology and Plant Teachers: Ralph Metzner's Green Earth ...
    Jan 11, 2016 · We publish unique and paradigm-shifting ideas in subjects such as ecology, sustainability, psychedelics, consciousness, and environmental and ...
  44. [44]
    Ecopsychology Restoring the Earth, Healing the Mind
    Ralph Metzner discerns significant parallels between dysfunctional environmental behavior and familiar psychopathological patterns like denial, psychic ...
  45. [45]
    Green Psychology: Transforming our Relationship to the Earth
    ... Green Earth Foundation. Dr. Metzner is the author of numerous books, including Overtones and Undercurrents and Searching for the Philosophers' Stone. Read ...Missing: incorporation | Show results with:incorporation
  46. [46]
    Ecology of Consciousness with Dr. Ralph Metzner - - Synergetic Press
    Nov 30, 2018 · author Birth of a Psychedelic Culture consiousness drug drugs LSD psychedelic psychedelic culture psychedelics psychotherapy Ralph Metzner Ram ...Missing: neurochemical realism
  47. [47]
    The Science of the Psychedelic Renaissance - The New Yorker
    May 29, 2018 · ... Leary and Alpert's 1964 book with their Harvard collaborator Ralph Metzner. In 1965, Leary and Alpert went on a lecture tour, but it wasn't ...
  48. [48]
    [PDF] Timothy Leary's legacy and the rebirth of psychedelic research
    The book, called The Psychedelic. Experience, was co-authored by Richard Alpert and Ralph Metzner, the dynamic duos' leading graduate student at Harvard. Their ...Missing: protocols | Show results with:protocols
  49. [49]
    [PDF] Prohibited or regulated? LSD psychotherapy and the United States ...
    LSD research first came under government control in 1963, after the Kefauver-Harris Drug. Amendments of 1962 amended the 1938 Federal Food, Drug, and ...
  50. [50]
    [PDF] Not Groovy Man: Psilocybin's Long and Complicated History with the ...
    May 3, 2022 · LSD, psilocybin, and psilocin illegal at the federal level.186 Shortly after, the Controlled Substances Act of 1970 (“CSA”)187 was passed, which ...
  51. [51]
  52. [52]
    The popularity of microdosing of psychedelics - Harvard Health
    Sep 19, 2022 · Skeptics are worried that uncontrolled access to these drugs might affect patients with mental illness, or might even precipitate mental illness ...Missing: efficacy | Show results with:efficacy
  53. [53]
    Disentangling the acute subjective effects of classic psychedelics ...
    May 14, 2024 · Recent research with classic psychedelics suggests significant therapeutic potential, particularly for neuropsychiatric disorders.
  54. [54]
    Modern Psychedelic Microdosing Research on Mental Health
    Jan 16, 2024 · There is a growing body of evidence suggesting a positive correlation between psychedelic microdosing and improved mental well-being.Missing: efficacy | Show results with:efficacy
  55. [55]
    Reconsidering evidence for psychedelic-induced psychosis
    Persons with schizophrenia are excluded from psychedelic-assisted therapy due to concerns about the risk of triggering or worsening psychosis.
  56. [56]
    Ethical and Practical Considerations for the Use of Psychedelics in ...
    Mar 29, 2023 · To address the concern that psychedelics may precipitate psychosis, clinical trials on psilocybin and MDMA typically use a personal or family ...
  57. [57]
    Potential Therapeutic Effects of Psilocybin - PMC - PubMed Central
    Jun 5, 2017 · Individuals with current psychosis or who are at risk for psychotic disorders are thought to be at increased risk for prolonged psychiatric ...
  58. [58]
    Transition of Substance-Induced, Brief, and Atypical Psychoses to ...
    Oct 16, 2019 · This study found that 21% of people with first-episode substance-induced psychosis received a later diagnosis of schizophrenia or ...Results · Subgroup Analysis · Cannabis And Transition To...
  59. [59]
    LSD and The Hippies: A Focused Analysis of Criminalization and ...
    Jan 5, 2023 · First, I will investigate the claim that LSD has a high potential for abuse. In the article “Psychedelic Drugs in Biomedicine,” Kyzar argues ...
  60. [60]
    A Journey to the Haight Ashbury in the Sixties - ResearchGate
    Aug 9, 2025 · Situated within a milieu that did not adequately support the importance of integration, however, cases of misuse and abuse continued and led to ...
  61. [61]
    [PDF] Psychedelic Sensationalism: An Analysis of the Schedule
    Psilocybin was not the only highly criticized drug during the late 1960s. Drug abuse was a major health issue at this time, which prompted the passage of the ...
  62. [62]
    Beyond Set and Setting: A New Understanding of Psychedelics ...
    Jul 3, 2017 · ... Ralph Metzner in 1963. The idea of set and setting was a radical development in identifying non-pharmacological factors that influence how ...
  63. [63]
    Avoiding the Mistakes of the War on Drugs | Graduate Studies | MUSC
    Jun 12, 2024 · Drugs like LSD, psilocybin and marijuana were placed into Schedule 1—defined by high potential for abuse, no medical use and lack of accepted ...
  64. [64]
    [PDF] Drug Set and Setting - Zinberg N - Southwest Recovery Alliance
    Initially I was concerned, like most other people, with drug abuse, that is, with the users' loss of control over the drug or drugs they were using. Only after ...
  65. [65]
    Ralph Metzner, Explorer of Consciousness - Everand
    Oct 1, 2024 · Ralph's childhood was enmeshed with the suffering and deprivation of World War II as he was born in 1936 in Berlin and remained there until the ...Missing: era | Show results with:era
  66. [66]
    Ralph Metzner, Explorer of Consciousness: The Life and Legacy of ...
    Cathy Coleman, Ph.D., was Ralph Metzner's wife of 31 years. A former dean of students at California Institute of Integral Studies, president of Kepler College, ...Missing: marriages | Show results with:marriages
  67. [67]
    Astrologer, Author, Mother, Wife of Psychedelic Pioneer Ralph Metzner
    Oct 30, 2024 · Cathy's very multi-faceted career and continuing activities include earning a doctorate in East-West Psychology from the California Institute of ...Missing: curriculum | Show results with:curriculum
  68. [68]
    Ralph Metzner Obituary (1936 - 2019) - Sonoma, CA - Legacy.com
    Mar 29, 2019 · Ralph Metzner, a recognized pioneer of psychological, philosophical, and cross-cultural studies of consciousness, died March 14, 2019, at his ...
  69. [69]
    [PDF] Containment Matters: Set and Setting in Contemporary Psychedelic ...
    Leary, Ralph Metzner and Richard Alpert in 1964: “the nature of the experience depends almost entirely on [mind]set and setting. Set denotes the preparation ...
  70. [70]
    The Nature of the MDMA Experience and Its Role in Healing ...
    The research with psychedelic drugs carried out during the 1960šs led to the hypothesis, widely accepted by workers in the field, that psychedelics are ...<|separator|>
  71. [71]
    In Memory of Ralph Metzner, Ph.D.
    Mar 15, 2019 · Ralph was a major inspiration to many, me included. His work contributed in a major way to the current renaissance of psychedelic research.Missing: key | Show results with:key
  72. [72]
    What are set and setting: Reducing vagueness to improve research ...
    May 26, 2025 · Perhaps a finding that some set or setting factor has larger effects on psychedelic outcomes than on outcomes of many other interventions would ...
  73. [73]
    Evidence Brief: Psychedelic Medications for Mental Health ... - NCBI
    Psilocybin-assisted psychotherapy may reduce depression severity and lead to sustained remission for some participants at 12 months compared to wait list ...
  74. [74]
    Psychedelics in Psychiatry—Keeping the Renaissance From Going ...
    Recent studies have produced findings suggesting psychedelics may demonstrate substantial efficacy for serious psychiatric conditions such as mood and substance ...
  75. [75]
    The historical opposition to psychedelic research and implications ...
    Nov 21, 2024 · The lack of mechanistic understanding of psychedelics is another scientific criticism that limits the credibility of the field. It is difficult ...
  76. [76]
    Psychedelic Commercialization: A Wide-Spanning Overview of the ...
    Some of the most foundational critiques of the psychedelic industry are rooted in narratives of the history of colonization and the ethics of indigenous ...Missing: pseudoscience | Show results with:pseudoscience
  77. [77]
    The psychedelic renaissance and the limitations of a White ...
    The limitations are that indigenous and minority contributions are often not supported, and there is a lack of diversity in research, with most participants ...Missing: commercialization pseudoscience
  78. [78]
  79. [79]
    Maps of Consciousness: Metzner, Ralph: 9780025844704: Amazon ...
    Publication date. January 1, 1972 ; ISBN-10. 0025844709 ; ISBN-13. 978-0025844704 ; Edition, Second Printing ; Item Weight, ‎1.75 pounds.Missing: Psyche | Show results with:Psyche
  80. [80]
  81. [81]
    The Psychedelic Review Archives 1963-1971
    Notes on Current Psychedelic Research, Ralph Metzner. Letter to the Editor · Book Reviews · Notes on Contributors. Psychedelic Review - Issue 10. Psychedelic ...
  82. [82]
  83. [83]
    Sounds from the Bardo - Psychedelic Sangha
    Sounds from the Bardo is an album-based series of immersive journeys produced by Psychedelic Sangha. Each Bandcamp digital album is a unique sensory adventure.Missing: discography | Show results with:discography
  84. [84]
  85. [85]
    Ralph Metzner | Spotify
    Listen to Ralph Metzner on Spotify. Artist · 2 monthly listeners ... Albums. Bardo Blues. Album • 2005. Featuring Ralph Metzner. Ralph Metzner ...Missing: audio | Show results with:audio
  86. [86]
    Spirit Soundings | Ralph Metzner with Kit Walker | Ralph Metzner
    Free deliverySpirit Soundings by Ralph Metzner with Kit Walker, released 10 March 2012 1. Triune Time Wave 2. Ayahuasca Serpent Vision 3. Omens For Our Planetary Future ...Missing: audio | Show results with:audio
  87. [87]
    Völuspa | Ralph Metzner & Byron Metcalf - Bandcamp
    $$191.94 Free deliveryJul 23, 2018 · Digital Album · Includes unlimited streaming via the Bandcamp app, plus download in mp3, FLAC and more · Download available in 16-bit/44.1kHz.Missing: audio | Show results with:audio
  88. [88]