Fact-checked by Grok 2 weeks ago

September Gurls

"September Gurls" is a song written and performed by of the American rock band , serving as the closing track on their second studio album, Radio City, which was released in February 1974. , formed in in 1971, consisted of Chilton on guitar and vocals, Chris Bell on guitar and vocals (who departed before Radio City), on bass, and Jody Stephens on drums. The song was recorded at in fall 1973 using 3M 16-track machines, with production led by Chilton and studio owner John Fry; it features layered guitars inspired by ' jangly sound, alongside influences from ' "," to which the title pays homage through its deliberate misspelling of "girls." Lyrically, "September Gurls" explores themes of and emotional turmoil, with lines like "September girls do so much / I was your Butch, and you were touched" drawing from Chilton's personal experiences; "Butch" refers to a dog, symbolizing devotion like a following its owner, as explained by Jody Stephens. The track was issued as a in August 1974, backed with "Mod Lang," but like the album, it achieved limited commercial success due to poor distribution by Stax and . Despite initial obscurity, "September Gurls" has been hailed as a masterpiece, influencing artists such as , The Replacements, and , and gaining cult status in the and scenes; it was covered by in 1986 and echoed in Katy Perry's 2010 hit "," which replicated the spelling tribute. Fry later reflected, "I sure did think at the time that if we were going to have a radio hit, that would be it," underscoring its melodic potential amid the band's commercial struggles.

Background and Composition

Writing and Inspiration

wrote "September Gurls" in 1973 as a deliberate to ' 1965 hit "," sharing its thematic focus on idealizing women associated with a particular region or season. The song's title, with its intentional misspelling of "girls" as "gurls," draws from several women in Chilton's who shared September birthdays, including his ex-wife Suzi Chilton and at least two others from his social circle during a period of romantic upheaval. Chilton aimed to fuse the lush, harmonic layers of —evident in the song's chiming guitars and melodic hooks—with a sharper, harder-edged rock sensibility, reflecting Big Star's sonic evolution following the more polished harmonies of their 1972 debut album #1 Record.

Lyrics

The lyrics of "September Gurls," written by , explore themes of youthful romance, longing, and the bittersweet pangs of idealized yet tumultuous love, often tinged with heartache and emotional vulnerability. Drawing from Chilton's personal experiences with multiple relationships, including his ex-wife Suzi and two other women born in , the words evoke a nostalgic specificity to autumn-born women while capturing the turmoil of deception and bad feelings in romance. Lines like "I've been crying all the time" and "I loved you, well, never mind" convey resignation and inner conflict, subverting traditional pop-romance tropes with a barbed, disenchanted edge that reflects Chilton's admission of never having an "easy relationship with a woman that didn't degenerate into some kind of deception or bad feeling." The song follows a straightforward verse-chorus structure typical of , with two s, a repetitive , and a that heightens the emotional intensity through simple, economical phrasing. The first establishes the narrator's devotion and sorrow—" girls do so much / I was your Butch, and you were touched"—before transitioning to the 's , " got it bad," repeated for emphasis to underscore the singer's persistent vulnerability. The second builds tension with anticipatory lines like "Look out, here she comes / She's coming straight at you," portraying the approach of an alluring yet overwhelming love interest, while the dreamily reiterates " girls make me feel so funny," blending with unease in a cycle that mirrors the repetitive emotional loops of longing. Chilton's adds a layer of playful irreverence, notably in the title's phonetic misspelling of "Gurls" to mimic casual pop and evoke an askew worship of women, nodding to influences like ' "" while infusing irony into the idealization. The reference to "Butch," explained by bandmate Jody Stephens as alluding to a loyal dog, symbolizes unwavering attachment amid the song's themes of unrequited or fleeting connection. Overall, the prioritize poetic brevity over elaboration, allowing the raw sentiment of disillusionment to resonate through sparse, evocative .

Recording and Production

Studio Sessions

The recording of "September Gurls" took place in 1973 at in , during the sessions for Big Star's second album, Radio City. The sessions occurred at the studio's facility, following Ardent's relocation in late 1971, and utilized a M56 16-track recorder setup, which allowed for basic tracks to be cut live with minimal overdubs to preserve the band's raw, energetic performance. The track was produced by the band members—Alex Chilton on vocals and guitar, Andy Hummel on bass, and Jody Stephens on drums—with engineering handled primarily by studio owner John Fry, who also assisted on overdubs alongside Hummel and session percussionist Richard Rosebrough. Fry noted that "September Gurls" was likely captured in a single session, with the band tracking the song piecemeal as compositions developed, emphasizing a straightforward approach that limited polish. These sessions unfolded amid significant band tensions following the commercial disappointment of Big Star's debut album #1 Record in 1972, exacerbated by distribution issues between and . Chris Bell's departure from at the end of 1972, driven by creative differences and his eclipsed role, left Chilton in a more dominant creative position, shifting the group's dynamic to a trio and contributing to a rougher, more immediate sound on Radio City. Fry observed that the absence of Bell's studio influence resulted in a less refined style, which inadvertently amplified the album's visceral energy.

Musical Arrangement

"September Gurls" has a runtime of 2:47 and is composed in the key of at a of approximately 114 . The song features a driving anchored by drummer Jody Stephens and Andy , providing a propulsive foundation that exemplifies the power pop genre's energetic pulse. The arrangement opens with a signature chiming mando-guitar line played by on a Vox Mando-guitar, establishing a bright, jangly tone that sets the power pop aesthetic. Layered rhythm guitars, including a main rhythm part overdubbed for depth, interweave with the lead lines to create a dense yet economical sonic texture. Harmonious backing vocals, delivered in a style reminiscent of and influenced by ' vocal harmonies, add a lush, melodic layer that enhances the song's hook-driven appeal. Structurally, the verses build tension through subtle guitar fills and restrained instrumentation, leading into explosive choruses that unleash full-band hooks with emphatic strums and vocal swells. The progression maintains momentum with a brief on the mando-guitar before culminating in a fade-out on repetitive riffs, reinforcing the song's concise and infectious energy.

Release and Promotion

Album and Single Release

"September Gurls" served as the tenth and closing track on Big Star's second studio album, Radio City, released on February 20, 1974, by Ardent Records and distributed through . The song was issued as a standalone later that year in May 1974 under Ardent catalog number ADA-2912, with "Mod Lang"—another track from Radio City—as the B-side. Radio airplay for the single remained limited, attributable to Big Star's emerging status as a niche act amid a dominant and scene. Promotional efforts were constrained by ongoing financial and operational challenges at , which affected distribution and marketing; however, the band performed "September Gurls" in early live sets, including a 1974 radio session, to cultivate grassroots interest among underground audiences.

Commercial Performance

Upon its release as a single in May 1974, "September Gurls" failed to chart on the or any major music lists, hampered by poor distribution from and insufficient radio play for tracks amid the era's dominance of harder rock and genres. The parent album Radio City experienced similarly modest commercial results, selling around 20,000 copies in its initial run due to Stax's financial instability and ineffective national promotion, though the single received some regional airplay in .) In the long term, "September Gurls" attained cult status through subsequent reissues, including the 1992 Rhino Records remastered compilation of #1 Record and Radio City, which spurred renewed sales and broader accessibility during the rise of the format.

Critical Reception and Legacy

Contemporary Reviews

Upon its release as part of Big Star's album Radio City in February 1974, "September Gurls" garnered enthusiastic praise in publications, reflecting the band's despite minimal radio play and sales. In Zoo World, critic Jon Tiven declared Radio City the "" just weeks after its debut, calling it "most assuredly the finest American record since Bob Dylan's " and emphasizing its melodic brilliance and emotional depth, with "September Gurls" standing out for its buoyant energy and hooks. Similarly, Bud Scoppa's review in expressed rare enthusiasm, stating he "haven't heard many albums in the last two years that I like as much as Big Star's Radio City," particularly lauding the title track's "infectious" pop craftsmanship and Chilton's expressive vocals amid the band's overlooked status. Mainstream coverage offered a more tempered but still appreciative take; in , Ken Barnes described "September Gurls" as "a virtually perfect pop number" that captured the album's "shimmering pop delights" and overall high-spirited enjoyment, though he critiqued the record's uneven accessibility, singling out the opener "O My Soul" as a "foreboding, sprawling affair" that disrupted its flow. Throughout the late 1970s and into the 1980s, fanzines amplified the song's reputation in circles, positioning as underground heroes influencing emerging acts.

Retrospective Recognition

Over the decades, "September Gurls" has garnered substantial retrospective acclaim for its role in defining . In the 2021 update to Rolling Stone's 500 Greatest Songs of All Time, the track ranked at number 180 and was hailed as a power pop classic, capturing the genre's blend of melodic precision and emotional resonance. Music critic John M. Borack further elevated its status in his 2007 book : The Ultimate Power Pop Guide, describing it as the " of the genre"—an essential, flawless exemplar that set the standard for subsequent artists. The song's enduring praise is evident in reevaluations of its craftsmanship, including a nod to Rolling Stone critic Ken Barnes' original 1974 review of Radio City, which called "September Gurls" "a virtually perfect pop number" and has been reprinted and referenced in 1980s compilations and later analyses to underscore its timeless appeal. Scholarly works have similarly recognized Big Star's foundational contributions, as seen in the extensive liner notes and essays of the 2009 anthology Keep an Eye on the Sky, a comprehensive Big Star box set that positions the band—and this track in particular—as pioneers of indie rock through their innovative fusion of pop hooks and raw vulnerability. Into the 2020s, the song continues to feature prominently in critical retrospectives, such as a 2024 Americana-UK article highlighting its profound influence on acts including R.E.M., The Replacements, and by bridging 1970s sophistication with later indie sensibilities.

Covers and Cultural Impact

Notable Cover Versions

One of the most prominent cover versions of "September Gurls" is by , featured on their 1986 album , where bassist provided lead vocals, infusing the track with a polished sound characterized by layered harmonies and jangly guitars. The version contributed to the album's commercial success, which peaked at number 2 on the 200. Superdrag delivered a high-energy, punk-infused rendition titled "September Gurls" in 1996, included as a live B-side on their single "Sucked Out" from the album Regretfully Yours, accelerating the original's tempo to suit the and era with raw guitar distortion and urgent vocals. This take highlighted the song's enduring appeal in underground scenes, and the band frequently performed it live, including during their 1998 tour dates, amplifying its gritty reinterpretation. The Searchers recorded an acoustic-leaning version in 1981 for their album Love's Melodies, softening the power pop edges with their signature British Invasion-style close harmonies and subtle instrumentation, which was later reissued on the 1998 compilation The Sire Sessions (Rockfield Recordings 1979-80) as part of a retrospective highlighting their late-career work. This adaptation emphasized the song's melodic core, blending it seamlessly with the group's Merseybeat roots. In 2011, Dum Dum Girls offered an echoey, cover for The A.V. Club's "A.V. Undercover" video series, transforming the track with reverb-drenched guitars, dreamy vocals, and a shoegaze-inflected haze that evoked the original's wistful tone while updating it for the scene. The performance, led by Dee Dee Penny, showcased the band's raw energy and was praised for capturing the song's emotional intimacy in a lo-fi aesthetic.

Tributes and Influences

The title spelling of Katy Perry's 2010 hit "" was intentionally altered as a homage to Big Star's "September Gurls," a change requested by Perry's manager, who is a fan of the band, following the death of Big Star's earlier that year. This nod not only acknowledged Big Star's influence on but also created a full-circle connection, as "September Gurls" itself drew inspiration from ' harmonic style. "September Gurls" significantly shaped the power pop revival in the 1980s and beyond, inspiring bands like The Replacements, who frequently covered the song live and referenced directly in their track "Alex Chilton" from . , another key beneficiary of Big Star's jangly guitar and melodic approach, incorporated similar elements into their early sound, with members like Mike Mills publicly citing the band's impact. In a live during 's 40th anniversary celebration of their EP at in , on December 14, 2022, Mills joined an all-star ensemble—including and guests like the —to perform "September Gurls," highlighting its enduring resonance within the community. The song's hooks and structure have continued to influence indie rock, as evidenced by its frequent citations in recent media explorations of power pop's timeless appeal. For instance, a September 2025 Substack essay on Remember The Lightning praised "September Gurls" as one of the greatest power pop tracks, emphasizing its chiming guitar riff and singalong melody as blueprints for modern indie songcraft. YouTube retrospectives from 2024, such as live performance uploads and analyses, have similarly lauded its production and emotional depth, drawing millions of views and underscoring its role in shaping genre evolution. Big Star's legacy, including "September Gurls," is further amplified in documentaries like Big Star: Nothing Can Hurt Me (2013), which streams on HBO Max in the 2020s and features interviews with influenced artists like R.E.M.'s Michael Stipe, illustrating the song's broad cultural footprint.

References

  1. [1]
    "September Gurls" at 50: The Meaning Behind a Defining ...
    Mar 30, 2024 · The album's defining masterpiece is “September Gurls,” Alex Chilton's longing heartache set to chiming chords and backed by his perfectly jagged Memphis rock ...
  2. [2]
    Classic Tracks: 'September Gurls,' Big Star - Mixonline
    Jul 3, 2023 · Distributor Columbia all but ignored Radio City, too, when it was released in February 1974, so once again Big Star was left wondering what had ...
  3. [3]
    For The Sake Of The Song: Big Star “September Gurls”
    Aug 19, 2024 · 'September Gurls', from “Radio City”, is one of their most famous tracks and just has a brilliant singalong melody.
  4. [4]
    'Radio City': How Big Star Created The Hit Record That Never Was
    Stylistically, Radio City picked up from where #1 Record left off, blending taut rock'n'roll (“O My Soul”) with dreamy power-pop (“September Gurls”) and ...
  5. [5]
    The Life and Music of Alex Chilton | Pitchfork
    Mar 21, 2010 · What's the best power-pop song ever? "September Gurls" is as good an answer as any. From the weird opening chord progression to the sky-scouring ...
  6. [6]
    Powerpop: 10 of the best | Pop and rock | The Guardian
    Feb 11, 2015 · 4 Big Star – September Gurls​​ “I'd never had an easy relationship with a woman that didn't degenerate into some kind of deception or bad feeling ...
  7. [7]
    Big Star – September Gurls Lyrics - Genius
    September Gurls Lyrics: September girls do so much / I was your Butch, and you were touched / I loved you, well, never mind / I've been crying all the time ...
  8. [8]
    Big Star - September Gurls (Official Lyric Video) - YouTube
    May 8, 2020 · The official lyric video for "September Gurls," from the Big Star album “Radio City.” The 180-gram vinyl reissue of “Radio City” now ...
  9. [9]
    Radio City - Big Star | Album - AllMusic
    Rating 9/10 (1,108) Radio City by Big Star released in 1974. Find album reviews, track lists ... Recording Date. 1973. Recording Location. Ardent Studios, Memphis, TN. Listen ...
  10. [10]
    Classic Tracks: Big Star 'September Gurls'
    including 'September Gurls' — are credited to just Alex Chilton. "The reason why the second album is a ...
  11. [11]
    #1 Record/Radio City by Big Star | Concord - Label Group
    On June 16, Ardent/Stax Records through Concord Music Group will reissue Big Star's #1 Record (1972) and Radio City (1974) albums, completely remastered.
  12. [12]
    September Gurls by Big Star Chords and Melody - Hooktheory
    September Gurls is written in the key of E Major. According to the Theorytab database, it is the 5th most popular key among Major keys and the 5th most popular ...
  13. [13]
    Radio City by Big Star (Album; Line; LILP 4.00270 J) - Rate Your Music
    Rating 3.7 (2) Radio City, an Album by Big Star. Released in 1986 on Line ... B5 September Gurls 2:47. B6 Morpha Too 1:28. B7 I'm in Love With a Girl 1:46. Total length: 35:48.
  14. [14]
    Radio City by Big Star (Album, Power Pop) - Rate Your Music
    Rating 3.8 (7,737) Radio City, an Album by Big Star. Released 20 February 1974 on Ardent (catalog no. ADS-1501; Vinyl LP). Genres: Power Pop. Rated #39 in the best albums of ...
  15. [15]
    LaunchLeft Throwback: Big Star's 'Radio City' (1974) : Rich Tupica
    Feb 27, 2023 · Big Star producer John Fry mixing at Ardent Studios in Memphis, Tennessee. Alex Chilton: On Radio City, [Chris] wrote parts of “O My Soul.Missing: production | Show results with:production
  16. [16]
    Big Star - September Gurls / Mod Lang - Ardent - USA - ADA-2912
    Date: Aug 1974. Format: 7". Collection: I Own It I ... An extended, unreleased edit marked as a proposed single mix later turned up on this Rhino single.Missing: 302 | Show results with:302
  17. [17]
    BIG STAR "September Gurls" LIVE in 1974 @ WLIR - YouTube
    May 24, 2012 · BIG STAR "September Gurls" LIVE in 1974 @ WLIR · Comments.Missing: promotion | Show results with:promotion
  18. [18]
    September Gurls by Big Star - Songfacts
    This paen to "September Gurls" was penned by vocalist Alex Chilton for Big Star's second album Radio City. · Alex Chilton once said of his songwriting: "I really ...
  19. [19]
    Alex Chilton- his solo years - Furious.com
    September gurls do so much. I was your butch and you were touched. I loved you ... Recorded a year later in 1974, with producer and fellow Memphis ...
  20. [20]
    https://www.discogs.com/release/1780721-Big-Star-1-Record-Radio-City
  21. [21]
    BIG STAR: The Great Lost American Pop Band - found! - Elsewhere
    Oct 13, 2009 · ... Big Star, the Memphis band of the early mid-70s led by cult figure Alex Chilton, who'd come to prominence in the 60s as the teenage singer ...
  22. [22]
    Big Star interviews, articles and reviews from Rock's Backpages
    Big Star: 'September Gurls' (Privilege 1002). Review by Marty Cerf ... So says Alex Chilton, inspirational genius behind Seventies legends BIG STAR ...
  23. [23]
    Big Star: Radio City (Ardent ADS-1501). By Ken Barnes : Articles, reviews and interviews from Rock's Backpages.
    ### Summary of Ken Barnes' Review of Big Star: Radio City (Rolling Stone, April 1974)
  24. [24]
    The 500 Greatest Songs of All Time
    - **Description**: "September Gurls" by Big Star is listed among the 500 Best Songs of All Time by Rolling Stone.
  25. [25]
    https://www.rollingstone.com/music/music-album-reviews/radio-city-249440/
  26. [26]
    CD Review: Big Star, “Keep an Eye on the Sky” - Popdose
    Oct 6, 2009 · Alec Palao sets the record straight with extensive well-researched track notes, on an album by album basis. The book's photos, many never seen ...
  27. [27]
    The Bangles – September Gurls Lyrics - Genius
    January 2, 1986. September Gurls Is A Cover Of. September Gurls by Big Star. Tags. RockPopCoverPop RockPower Pop (Rock). Expand. The Bangles - Topic. September ...<|separator|>
  28. [28]
    About chart-topping band The Bangles
    In addition to her incredible basslines, Michael sang lead on many Bangles tracks including their cover of 'September Gurls', as well as her self-penned ...
  29. [29]
    Bangles - September Gurls - uk-charts.com
    BANGLES - SEPTEMBER GURLS (SONG). Year: 1985. Music/Lyrics: Alex Chilton. Producer: David Kahne. Cover version of: Big Star - September Gurls. AVAILABLE ON ...<|separator|>
  30. [30]
    Performance: September Girl by Superdrag | SecondHandSongs
    September Girl by Superdrag was written by Alex Chilton and was first released by Big Star in 1974. Superdrag released it on the single Sucked Out in 1996.
  31. [31]
    https://www.discogs.com/release/3380031-The-Searchers-The-Sire-Sessions-Rockfield-Recordings-1979-80
  32. [32]
    https://secondhandsongs.com/performance/145719/all
  33. [33]
    Performance: September Gurls by The Searchers | SecondHandSongs
    September Gurls by The Searchers was written by Alex Chilton and was first released by Big Star in 1974. The Searchers released it on the album Play for ...
  34. [34]
    "September Gurls" (Big Star cover) - Pitchfork
    Mar 29, 2011 · Dum Dum Girls recently covered Big Star's stone-cold power-pop classic "September Gurls" for the A.V. Club's "A.V. Undercover" video series.
  35. [35]
    Watch: Dum Dum Girls Pay Homage To Big Star With 'September ...
    Looking cool in their shades (as always) the Girls chose the Big Star classic “September Gurls”, recently featured here in a dreampop treatment ...
  36. [36]
    The Meaning Behind "California Gurls" by Katy Perry and What the ...
    Feb 20, 2024 · The song's spelling is a nod to Big Star's “September Gurls,” which came about through her manager. ... California girls but later changed it to ...
  37. [37]
    The Number Ones: Katy Perry's "California Gurls" (Feat. Snoop Dogg)
    Jun 28, 2023 · The title of "California Gurls" is Katy Perry's salute to Chilton and to Big Star's classic 1974 song "September Gurls." Perry wasn't a huge Big ...
  38. [38]
    https://www.culturesonar.com/big-star-an-appreciation/
  39. [39]
    Big Star: An Appreciation - CultureSonar
    Sep 27, 2023 · They've also had enthusiastic support from the groups they've influenced, such as R.E.M., Evan Dando, and The Replacements, who recorded a song ...
  40. [40]
    Big Star – “September Gurls”
    Sep 1, 2024 · “September Gurls” by Big Star. They released the album “Radio City” in February 1974 and hoped this time, things would go better. But they didn ...
  41. [41]
    Mike Mills and Peter Buck Join All-Star R.E.M. Tribute to Chronic Town
    Dec 16, 2022 · And then Mills closed things out singing Big Star's “September Gurls” backed by most of the evening's performers. Michael Stipe and Bill Berry ...
  42. [42]
    R.E.M.'s Peter Buck and Mike Mills Reunite at 40th Anniversary Gig
    Dec 15, 2022 · The show's finale brought a big crew onstage to do a cover of Big Star's “September Gurls” together. And, the cherry on top: Proceeds of the ...
  43. [43]
    September Gurls & December Boy's - Remember The Lightning
    Sep 16, 2025 · Big Star's “September Gurls” is easily one of the best power pop songs of all time. The chiming mando-guitar that opens the track might be ...<|control11|><|separator|>
  44. [44]
    Mike Mills / Big Star Quintet: "September Gurls" (10/5/2024 - YouTube
    Oct 6, 2024 · Mike Mills / Big Star Quintet: "September Gurls" (10/5/2024; San Francisco, CA). 1.4K views · 1 year ago GREAT AMERICAN MUSIC HALL ...more ...Missing: 2025 Substack retrospective
  45. [45]
    Nothing Can Hurt Me” is now streaming on HBO Max ⭐️ - Facebook
    Jul 15, 2025 · The documentary “Big Star: Nothing Can Hurt Me” is now streaming on HBO Max.Missing: 2020s | Show results with:2020s
  46. [46]
    Watch Big Star: Nothing Can Hurt Me | HBO Max
    This documentary looks back at the group's story and music through interviews and footage. Starring: Michael Stipe, Jody Stephens, The Replacements, Robyn ...Missing: 2020s | Show results with:2020s