System of a Down is an Armenian-American heavy metal band formed in Glendale, California, in 1994, consisting of vocalist Serj Tankian, guitarist Daron Malakian, bassist Shavo Odadjian, and drummer John Dolmayan.[1]
The group blends aggressive alternative metal riffs with rapid shifts in tempo, unconventional song structures, and lyrics addressing political themes including war, environmental destruction, and the Armenian Genocide.[2]
Signed to American Recordings, they released their self-titled debut album in 1998, which gained a cult following despite modest sales, before achieving breakthrough success with Toxicity in 2001, an album that debuted at number one on the Billboard 200 and produced hits such as "Chop Suey!" and "Aerials."[3]Toxicity's release shortly after the September 11 attacks amplified its anti-war messages, propelling the band to global prominence with multi-platinum sales.[2]
In 2005, Mezmerize and Hypnotize—companion albums—also debuted at number one on the Billboard 200, marking the band's third such achievement, though internal creative tensions led to a hiatus in 2006.[4]
System of a Down has maintained activism for Armenian causes, including genocide recognition and support during the 2020 Nagorno-Karabakh war, releasing singles "Protect the Land" and "Genocidal Humanoidz" to raise funds and awareness.[5]
The band reunited for tours in 2010 and continues intermittent performances without a new full album, prioritizing live shows and advocacy over studio work.[4]
History
Formation as Soil (1992–1994)
Serj Tankian and Daron Malakian, both of Armenian descent, first met in 1992 at a Los Angeles-area studio despite having attended the same Armenian school in Glendale, California, as children; their eight-year age gap had previously prevented interaction.[6][7] Inspired by shared musical interests, they formed the band Soil that year in Glendale, with Tankian handling vocals and keyboards and Malakian on guitar and backing vocals.[8]The lineup was completed by bassist Dave Hakopyan and drummer Domingo "Dingo" Laranio, establishing Soil as an early progressive metal outfit influenced by the local alternative and heavy music scene.[9] The group rehearsed and performed a small number of local gigs, though no official recordings or demos from this period have been commercially released, leaving surviving material limited to rare rehearsal snippets.[10]Soil disbanded in 1994 following Laranio's relocation to Hawaii and Hakopyan's departure, prompting Tankian and Malakian to seek new collaborators and eventually reconfigure into what would become System of a Down.[9] During its brief existence, the band represented an initial creative outlet for Tankian and Malakian's songwriting, foreshadowing the experimental and politically charged style they would later develop.[8]
Demo Tapes, Renaming, and Label Signing (1994–1997)
Following the dissolution of their prior band Soil in 1994, vocalist Serj Tankian, guitarist Daron Malakian, and bassist Shavo Odadjian—along with drummer Ontronik "Andy" Khachaturian—formed System of a Down in Glendale, California.[11][12] The name originated from a poem written by Malakian titled Victims of a Down, which Odadjian altered by replacing "Victims" with "System" to position the band alphabetically nearer to influential group Slayer in record store bins.[13]Throughout 1995 and 1996, the quartet honed their sound through live performances at Los Angeles-area rock and metal venues while self-producing multiple demo tapes to pitch to record labels.[12] These efforts included an early 1995 untitled demo and subsequent releases featuring raw prototypes of tracks that would later appear on their debut album, such as alternate versions emphasizing aggressive riffs and Tankian's operatic vocal shifts.[11]By 1997, a targeted three-song demo circulated among industry figures, drawing overtures from Maverick Records co-founder Guy Oseary and producer Rick Rubin.[11] The band rejected an offer from Universal, citing the label's predominant emphasis on hip-hop and R&B acts over rock ensembles, and instead signed with Rubin's American Recordings imprint—distributed via Columbia Records—prioritizing his track record with genre-adjacent artists like Slayer.[11] This deal marked the culmination of three years of independent hustling, enabling professional recording sessions later that year.[12]
Self-Titled Debut Album and Early Success (1998–2000)
System of a Down's self-titled debut studio album was released on June 30, 1998, by American Recordings and Columbia Records.[11][14] The record, co-produced by Rick Rubin, was tracked from November 1997 to March 1998 primarily at Sound City Studios in Van Nuys, California.[14] Comprising 12 tracks, it highlighted the band's aggressive fusion of heavy metal riffs, rapid tempo shifts, and Serj Tankian's operatic vocals addressing themes of alienation, war, and hypocrisy. The lead single "Sugar" preceded the album on May 24, 1998, with an EP version following on May 26, 1999; "Spiders" served as the second single.[15][11]Initial commercial performance was modest, with the album reaching number 124 on the Billboard 200 and topping the Heatseekers chart in 1999.[16] Sales accumulated approximately 800,000 units within the first two years, reflecting gradual buildup rather than immediate blockbuster status.[16] Critical reception praised its raw energy and unconventional structures, though some outlets noted its chaotic intensity as polarizing. The singles garnered alternative radio airplay, particularly "Sugar," aiding underground buzz in metal circles.The band's early success stemmed largely from intensive live performances, which solidified their reputation for visceral, high-energy shows. In 1998, they completed over 140 concerts, including a North American headline tour and club dates such as the Metro in Chicago on September 17.[17][18] Touring persisted through 1999 and 2000, encompassing festivals and support slots that expanded their U.S. fanbase amid the nu-metal boom. By late 2000, these efforts positioned the group for major-label escalation, coinciding with initial recording sessions for their sophomore effort.[19][16]
Toxicity, Steal This Album!, and Post-9/11 Rise (2001–2003)
System of a Down recorded their second studio album, Toxicity, from March to July 2001 at Cello Studios in Hollywood, California, producing over 40 songs during sessions marked by intense creativity and thematic focus on societal critique, drug culture, and personal alienation.[20] The album was primarily produced by guitarist Daron Malakian and vocalist Serj Tankian, with oversight from Rick Rubin, who emphasized the band's raw energy while refining their chaotic blend of metal subgenres.[21] Released on September 4, 2001, via American Recordings and Columbia Records, Toxicity debuted at number one on the Billboard 200 chart the following week, selling 222,000 copies in its first full week amid the immediate aftermath of the September 11 terrorist attacks.[3]The lead single, "Chop Suey!", released August 13, 2001, faced temporary radio bans from Clear Channel stations post-9/11 due to lyrics referencing "self-righteous suicide," which some interpreted as insensitive amid national mourning, though the song retained strong MTV video rotation and eventually peaked at number 76 on the Billboard Hot 100.[22] Despite this controversy, Toxicity achieved rapid commercial success, reaching one million U.S. sales within six weeks and ultimately exceeding 10 million units worldwide, propelled by tracks like "Aerials" and "Toxicity" that resonated with audiences seeking aggressive, politically charged music during a period of heightened global tension.[23] The band's visibility surged through tours including the 2001 Pledge of Allegiance Tour alongside Slipknot and Rammstein, which drew large crowds and solidified their live reputation for high-energy performances blending rapid tempo shifts and multilingual elements.[24]In early 2002, unfinished demos intended for a follow-up album leaked online under the title "Toxicity II," prompting System of a Down to abandon plans for a polished third record and instead compile the material with additional tracks for an impromptu release.[25] Titled Steal This Album!, it was issued on November 26, 2002, embracing the piracy incident with its provocative name and featuring raw, demo-like production that captured the band's spontaneous ethos.[26] The album debuted at number 15 on the Billboard 200, moving 166,000 units in its first week, and has since accumulated over three million equivalent album units globally, though it received mixed reviews for its uneven quality compared to Toxicity.[27] Supported by 2002-2003 tours such as the Australian Toxicity run and headline slots at festivals like Reading 2003, the release extended the band's momentum, with songs like "Innervision" and "Boom!" gaining traction among fans despite limited radio promotion.[16]
Mezmerize, Hypnotize, and Initial Hiatus (2004–2008)
In late 2004, System of a Down entered recording sessions at producer Rick Rubin's The Mansion in Laurel Canyon, California, to develop material initially intended as a double album but released as companion records Mezmerize and Hypnotize.[28] The band composed approximately 30 tracks during these sessions, with production handled by Rubin and guitarist Daron Malakian, continuing their collaboration from prior albums.[29]Mezmerize, the first installment, was released on May 17, 2005, through American Recordings and Columbia Records. It debuted at number one on the Billboard 200, selling over 450,000 copies in its first week in the United States, surpassing the debut performance of their 2001 album Toxicity.[30] Worldwide first-week sales exceeded 800,000 units.[31] The lead single "B.Y.O.B." earned the band their first Grammy Award for Best Hard Rock Performance at the 48th Annual Grammy Awards on February 8, 2006.[32]Hypnotize followed on November 22, 2005, also debuting at number one on the Billboard 200 with 320,000 first-week U.S. sales, making System of a Down the first band since The Beatles to top the chart with two albums in one year.[33]To promote the albums, the band embarked on the extensive Mezmerize/Hypnotize Tour in 2005, encompassing legs across Europe (May–June), North America (summer and fall), Australia (including Big Day Out festival dates), and other regions, with support acts such as The Mars Volta.[34] Performances continued into 2006, including headlining slots at Ozzfest. The tour featured sets blending tracks from the new albums with earlier material, emphasizing the band's high-energy live style amid growing commercial success.In May 2006, following completion of major tour commitments, System of a Down announced an indefinite hiatus, with vocalist Serj Tankian later stating he alone initiated the break to pursue solo endeavors, despite the other members' preference to maintain the band's pace after years of relentless activity.[35] During this period through 2008, Tankian released his debut solo album Elect the Dead on October 16, 2007, while Malakian formed Scars on Broadway, issuing their self-titled album on July 29, 2008; drummer John Dolmayan and bassist Shavo Odadjian also explored individual projects, though no full band activity resumed until later.[36] Drummer Dolmayan later described the hiatus as a "disastrous move" for the band's momentum.[36]
Reunion Tours and Side Projects (2010–2020)
System of a Down announced their reunion on November 29, 2010, after a four-year hiatus, with initial tour dates scheduled for 2011 across North America and Europe.[37][38] The band performed 32 concerts that year, including arena shows in cities like Edmonton on May 10 and Seattle on May 13, as well as festival appearances such as Rock im Park in Germany on June 4.[39][40][41]
Subsequent activity focused on periodic live performances rather than new recordings, with tours remaining sporadic through the decade. In 2015, the band launched the Wake Up the Souls Tour on April 11 in Inglewood, California, comprising seven dates to commemorate the 100th anniversary of the Armenian Genocide, concluding with their first-ever show in Armenia on June 13 in Yerevan.[42] By 2018, they played limited U.S. dates, including October 13 in San Bernardino, marking their first domestic shows since 2015.[43]
Amid these reunions, members pursued individual endeavors. Serj Tankian released the solo album Imperfect Harmonies on September 21, 2010, followed by Harakiri on May 22, 2012, and the orchestral Orca Symphony No. 1 on November 5, 2013, alongside film scores such as for Prometheus Bound in 2011.[44] Daron Malakian and John Dolmayan reformed Scars on Broadway, issuing the album Dictator on July 20, 2018, after a decade-long pause.[45] Shavo Odadjian contributed to the hip-hop project AcHoZeN with Wu-Tang Clan's RZA, which released tracks during the hiatus extending into this period.[46] Dolmayan debuted his collaborative covers project These Grey Men on February 28, 2020, featuring guest vocalists on reinterpreted rock tracks.[47] Despite ongoing tours, no new System of a Down studio material emerged until 2020, reflecting a prioritization of live energy over studio commitments.[48]
Artsakh Benefit Singles, Ongoing Tours, and New Album Prospects (2020–present)
In response to the 2020 Nagorno-Karabakh War, System of a Down released two new singles, "Protect the Land" and "Genocidal Humanoidz," on November 5, 2020, marking their first original music in 15 years.[49][50] All proceeds from the singles were directed to the Armenia Fund to aid humanitarian efforts in Artsakh, raising over $600,000 within weeks and approaching $1 million by December 2020.[51][52] Frontman Serj Tankian described the effort as transcending band egos, emphasizing its urgency amid the conflict's atrocities.[50]Post-2020, System of a Down gradually resumed live performances after pandemic-related hiatuses, including festival appearances and select dates in Europe and North America. In 2025, the band launched a major North American stadium tour on August 27, co-headlining with Deftones and supported by acts like Korn and Avenged Sevenfold, with shows at venues such as MetLife Stadium in East Rutherford, New Jersey (August 27–28), Soldier Field in Chicago (September 17), and Rogers Stadium in Toronto (September 3 and 5).[53][54] These outings featured expanded setlists incorporating the 2020 singles alongside classics, drawing large crowds and sustaining the band's draw despite limited output.[55]Prospects for a sixth studio album remain uncertain as of October 2025, with no full-length release forthcoming despite the 2020 singles sparking speculation. Drummer John Dolmayan outlined prerequisites in July 2025, including structured songwriting sessions and compromise on creative visions to overcome longstanding tensions.[56] Guitarist Daron Malakian expressed frustration over stalled progress but openness to new material if band dynamics align, while Tankian stated in March 2025 that no album is currently written and emphasized waiting until conditions feel right organically. [57] Internal divisions, publicly aired since 2018, continue to hinder unified efforts, though Tankian affirmed in August 2025 he is not opposed to future collaboration.[58]
Musical Style and Artistry
Influences and Comparisons
System of a Down's sound incorporates elements from heavy metal pioneers such as Black Sabbath and Slayer, alongside punk rock, jazz fusion, and traditional Armenian music, creating a distinctive blend of aggression and eclecticism.[59] Guitarist Daron Malakian has highlighted 1980s thrash metal acts like Slayer and Metallica as formative, in addition to classic rock influences from The Beatles, John Lennon, and David Bowie.[60] The band's broader palette draws from hip-hop rhythms, Eastern European folk traditions, and avant-garde jazz improvisation, which contribute to their unpredictable structures and vocal experimentation.[61]Vocalist Serj Tankian has referenced early exposures to diverse genres, including classical and experimental music from his youth, which informed his operatic and scat-like delivery.[62] These influences manifest in the integration of Middle Eastern scales and modal structures, particularly evident in tracks evoking Armenian heritage amid heavy riffs.[63] The result is a fusion that prioritizes thematic intensity over conventional songcraft, distinguishing their output from standard nu-metal contemporaries.Comparisons often liken System of a Down to Rage Against the Machine for shared anti-establishment lyrics and rhythmic fusion of rap-inflected vocals with metal instrumentation, though SOAD's style veers more toward absurdity and cultural specificity.[64] Their experimental edge draws parallels to Faith No More and Mr. Bungle in terms of genre subversion and theatricality, yet SOAD amplifies political urgency with shorter, more chaotic compositions.[65] Unlike peers such as Korn or Slipknot, who emphasize groove and industrial repetition, System of a Down's rapid tempo shifts and satirical bent position them as outliers in late-1990s alternative metal, influencing subsequent acts in progressive and politically charged subgenres.[66][64]
Song Structures, Instrumentation, and Production Techniques
System of a Down's song structures deviate from conventional verse-chorus formats, relying instead on riff-driven compositions with abrupt shifts between aggressive breakdowns, melodic refrains, and experimental interludes to evoke chaos and intensity. Many tracks center on C minor tonality, drawing from Phrygian, Aeolian, and harmonic minor scales, often with chromatic elements for dissonance.[67] Odd time signatures, such as 5/4, 7/8, and 9/8, feature prominently in "judjud" sections—high-energy hardcore rhythms—creating rhythmic unease; for example, "Question!" transitions through 9/8, 5/4, 4/4, and 3/4.[67][68] "Chop Suey!" exemplifies this with its intro chord progression leading to a judjud verse, chromatic riff, and soaring chorus.[67]The band's core instrumentation includes electric guitars, bass, drums, and vocals, with guitars tuned to drop C (CGCFAD) on early albums like the self-titled debut and Toxicity, shifting to drop C# for Mezmerize and Hypnotize to heighten aggression.[69][70]Daron Malakian employs Ibanez Iceman models (e.g., custom IC 300), Gibson SGs, and amps like Marshall 100-watt Plexi heads or Mesa Boogie Rectifiers, augmented by effects such as Boss DD-6 delay and MXR Phase 90 for layered textures.[70] Shavo Odadjian's bass mirrors guitar tuning in drop C (CGCF), emphasizing doubled riffs, while John Dolmayan's drumming delivers syncopated patterns suited to odd meters.[71]Serj Tankian provides versatile vocals—ranging from guttural screams to operatic highs—and keyboards, with occasional ethnic instruments like duduk in "Aerials," sitar, oud, mandolin, and 12-string guitars incorporating Armenian folk elements.[72][73]Production techniques, guided by Rick Rubin from the 1998 self-titled album onward, prioritize raw capture of the band's live energy through dry, unprocessed tracks, natural drum recordings, and minimal artificial reverb to maintain dynamic range and aggression.[74][75] Rubin facilitated improvisational moments, such as Serj Tankian's spontaneous "Father! Father! Father!" bridge in "Chop Suey!" during Toxicity sessions, preserving the organic creative process over polished overdubs.[76] This approach, evident in albums like Toxicity (recorded April–June 2001 at Cello Studios), amplifies the interplay of heavy distortion, clean tones, and vocal extremes without excessive compression.[77]
Lyrical Themes and Composition Process
System of a Down's lyrics, predominantly authored by vocalist Serj Tankian, confront political injustices, historical atrocities, and societal contradictions through a mix of direct critique and surreal imagery. Recurring motifs include opposition to war and imperialism, exemplified in "B.Y.O.B." (2005), which juxtaposes combat's brutality against civilian escapism amid the Iraq War.[12] The Armenian Genocide, a personal touchstone for the Armenian-American band members, permeates tracks like "P.L.U.C.K." (1998) and "Holy Mountains" (2005), invoking the 1915 events and calls for recognition.[12] Broader social commentaries address governmental manipulation and capitalism in "Chic 'N' Stu" (2001), drug abuse and alienation in the self-titled debut's material, suicide and martyrdom in "Chop Suey!" (2001), religious extremism, depression, and issues like illegal immigration in "I-E-A-I-A-I-O" (2001).[12]The band's songwriting process centers on guitarist Daron Malakian's initiation of musical foundations, typically via spontaneous riffs or hummed melodies that evolve into full structures. For instance, "Aerials" (2001) stemmed from a riff derived from an internal melody, later layered with dynamics during band rehearsals.[78] "Chop Suey!" began as a rudimentary riff, expanded through added vocal lines and abrupt shifts in tempo and intensity via collective input.[78] Tankian traditionally supplies lyrics to these frameworks, fitting thematic content to the music's angular rhythms, though bassist Shavo Odadjian contributes riffs that the group develops.[79]Over time, roles blurred: Tankian advanced in composing complete pieces, while Malakian took greater lyric shares, particularly on Mezmerize (2005) and Hypnotize (2005).[80] Collaboration involves refining ideas collectively—if Malakian presents a chorus-heavy demo, Tankian adds verses or arrangement tweaks; reciprocal adjustments apply to Tankian's submissions.[79] This method yielded the band's five studio albums, though post-2005 sessions revealed tensions, with Tankian advocating looser jamming over Malakian's pre-formed songs, stalling new material until 2020's Artsakh benefit singles.[80]
Political Engagement and Activism
Advocacy for Armenian Genocide Recognition and Artsakh Conflicts
System of a Down, composed of members of Armenian descent, has engaged in sustained advocacy for the recognition of the Armenian Genocide, the systematic massacres and deportations perpetrated by the Ottoman Empire against Armenians from 1915 to 1923, resulting in an estimated 1.5 million deaths.[81] In May 2001, the band urged fans to contact President George W. Bush to properly commemorate the genocide and initiated a charity auction to support the Armenian National Committee of America's (ANCA) recognition efforts.[82] This activism extended to a three-day advocacytour in Washington, D.C., in May 2006, where vocalist Serj Tankian and drummer John Dolmayan met with lawmakers to press for U.S. congressional acknowledgment.[83]In April 2015, band members joined Representative Adam Schiff in discussions emphasizing the moral imperative of recognizing the genocide to counter Turkish denialism and maintain credibility in addressing contemporary atrocities.[84] The group organized a tour that year to mark the genocide's centennial, framing performances as acts of remembrance and resistance against historical erasure.[85] Tankian, through his nonprofit Axis of Justice co-founded with Tom Morello in 2003, has amplified these efforts, leveraging the band's platform to highlight the genocide's under-recognition due to geopolitical pressures, including Turkey's opposition.[86][87]Regarding the Artsakh (Nagorno-Karabakh) conflicts, System of a Down mobilized in response to the 2020 war between Armenia and Azerbaijan. On November 6, 2020, the band released "Protect the Land" and "Genocidal Humanoidz," their first new material in 15 years, with all proceeds directed to the Armenia Fund for humanitarian aid in the region.[88] These tracks explicitly condemned Azerbaijani aggression and what the band described as war crimes, including attacks on civilian areas.[89] By November 12, 2020, the initiative had raised $600,000 for relief efforts amid the displacement of over 90,000 Armenians from Artsakh.[90]The band's unified stance on Artsakh contrasted with occasional internal political divergences, yet all members—Tankian, guitarist Daron Malakian, bassist Shavo Odadjian, and Dolmayan—participated in the 2020 singles and fundraisers.[91] Tankian continued individual advocacy, such as in August 2023 when he publicly urged the band Imagine Dragons to address Azerbaijan's blockade of Artsakh, which exacerbated humanitarian crises leading to the region's 2023 demographic collapse.[92] This support underscored the band's commitment to Armenian self-determination in Artsakh, framing the conflicts as extensions of historical genocidal patterns denied by Azerbaijan and its allies.[93]
Broader Anti-War, Environmental, and Social Critiques
System of a Down has consistently incorporated anti-war themes into their music, particularly in opposition to the U.S.-led invasion of Iraq in 2003. The song "Boom!" from their 2002 album Steal This Album! critiques the prioritization of military spending over humanitarian needs, with lyrics highlighting how funds for bombs exacerbate global suffering rather than addressing poverty or illness.[94] The accompanying music video, directed by Michael Moore and released in March 2003, featured footage from anti-war protests and explicitly condemned the impending Iraq War as a misuse of resources.[95] Similarly, "B.Y.O.B." from the 2005 album Mezmerize satirizes the hypocrisy of leaders who advocate war while avoiding personal risk, reflecting widespread anti-war sentiment during the conflict's escalation.[96]Vocalist Serj Tankian extended these critiques through Axis of Justice, a non-profit organization he co-founded with Tom Morello in 2002 to mobilize musicians and activists against war, poverty, and injustice.[87] The group organized concerts and panels addressing the human and economic costs of militarism, emphasizing grassroots efforts to influence policy. Tankian has linked military actions to environmental degradation, noting in 2008 that conflicts like those in the Middle East inflict lasting damage on ecosystems through resource extraction and destruction, an under-discussed consequence of foreign policy.[97]On environmental issues, Tankian has advocated for sustainable practices in the music industry, proposing innovations like holographic touring to reduce carbon emissions from live performances.[98] He argues that environmental reforms drive broader societal shifts, including economic and political changes, as seen in his 2012 solo album Harakiri, which critiques consumerism's role in ecological harm.[99]Axis of Justice has incorporated environmental justice into its platform, connecting habitat destruction to systemic inequalities perpetuated by corporate and governmental priorities.[100]Social critiques in System of a Down's lyrics target capitalism's excesses, state authoritarianism, and media manipulation. Tracks like "Prison Song" from Toxicity (2001) expose the U.S. prison system's role in profiting from the drug war's racial disparities, framing incarceration as a tool of control rather than rehabilitation. The band condemns fascism and imperialism as extensions of unchecked power, with songs decrying how economic systems fuel violence and alienation. Tankian's activism through Axis of Justice further addresses these by fostering dialogues on human rights abuses tied to economic exploitation.[101]
Internal Band Divisions and Public Political Statements
System of a Down's members exhibit a range of political ideologies, with vocalist Serj Tankian identifying as left-leaning and supportive of figures like Bernie Sanders, while drummer John Dolmayan aligns with conservative positions, including vocal endorsement of Donald Trump.[102][103]GuitaristDaron Malakian occupies a more centrist or moderately left-leaning stance, expressing support for gun rights as essential tools, and bassist Shavo Odadjian remains largely apolitical in public discourse.[104][105] These differences have surfaced publicly, particularly during U.S. election cycles, highlighting tensions despite the band's shared anti-war and Armenian advocacy roots.[106]Dolmayan and Tankian represent the most divergent views, with Dolmayan praising Trump in 2020 as "the greatest friend to minorities" and, as recently as March 2025, stating that Trump "brings a little sanity back" to the U.S., contrasting the band's progressive lyrical critiques of authority.[107][103] Tankian, who called for Trump's resignation in June 2020 amid protests, has described their positions as "polar opposite ends" of American politics and labeled Trump supporters who admire System of a Down's music as hypocrites for ignoring the band's anti-establishment themes.[108][109] Despite this, both have emphasized personal respect and civil dialogue; Dolmayan noted in June 2020 that conversations with Tankian remain "civil" and mutually enlightening, while Tankian affirmed in 2021, "I love and respect John very much," though not his political views.[106][110]Public exchanges have occasionally escalated, such as a 2019 argument captured on video between Dolmayan and Tankian over Trump, and Dolmayan's 2020 social media defenses of his right-leaning posts amid band tensions.[111][112] Dolmayan has clarified that individual statements do not represent the group, stating in September 2020, "I don’t speak for any of the individuals except for myself and neither does Serj."[112] Tankian echoed this in a March 2021 interview, acknowledging internal political tension as a source of the band's truthful edge but prioritizing unity on core issues like the Armenian Genocide and Artsakh conflicts.[113]These divisions have not derailed joint activism; the band released "Protect the Land" and "Genocidal Humanoidz" in November 2020 to support Artsakh amid Azerbaijani attacks, demonstrating alignment on ethnic Armenian causes despite U.S. political rifts.[113] Dolmayan has argued his conservatism complements the band's skepticism of government overreach, while Tankian maintains that broader left-wing critiques better embody their anti-authoritarian ethos, though both avoid letting differences halt performances or shared heritage advocacy.[114][110]
Controversies and Criticisms
Post-9/11 Media Backlash and Censorship Attempts
System of a Down's second studio album, Toxicity, was released on September 4, 2001, one week before the September 11 terrorist attacks.[21][20] The lead single, "Chop Suey!", originally titled "Suicide" during recording but renamed to evade potential radio restrictions, featured lyrics critiquing religious hypocrisy and judgment toward death, including the chorus line "I don't think you trust / In my self-righteous suicide."[115][116] In the immediate aftermath of the attacks, these lyrics drew scrutiny for their references to suicide and violence, amid widespread sensitivity to content evoking terrorism or self-harm.[117][115]On September 17, 2001, Clear Channel Communications, then the largest U.S. radio broadcaster, issued an internal memorandum to its over 1,200 stations suggesting they avoid airing a list of 166 "lyrically questionable" songs potentially unsuitable for the national mood.[118][119] "Chop Suey!" appeared on this list alongside tracks like AC/DC's "Dirty Deeds Done Dirt Cheap" and Nirvana's "Come as You Are," primarily due to its suicide-themed refrain, which some interpreted as paralleling the hijackers' actions.[120][119] The memo, drafted by an airplay specialist without executive mandate, framed the selections as precautionary rather than prohibitive, but it prompted voluntary self-censorship across stations wary of public backlash.[118][119]As a result, "Chop Suey!" was temporarily pulled from rotation on many Clear Channel outlets and other networks, delaying its mainstream breakthrough despite pre-9/11 buzz.[22][24] This episode exemplified broader post-9/11 media caution, where broadcasters preemptively sidelined provocative rock and metal content to align with patriotic sentiments and avoid accusations of insensitivity.[117] Band members later reflected on the irony, with vocalist Serj Tankian noting in interviews that the song's themes addressed domestic hypocrisy rather than endorsing violence, yet the timing amplified perceptions of controversy.[24] Ultimately, heavy MTV video airplay circumvented radio hurdles, propelling "Chop Suey!" to No. 1 on the Billboard Alternative Songs chart by March 2002.[22][24]
Interpersonal and Ideological Conflicts Among Members
During the recording of the band's 2001 album Toxicity at Cello Studios in Hollywood, interpersonal tensions escalated into physical altercations between guitarist Daron Malakian and drummer John Dolmayan, stemming from creative frustrations under producer Rick Rubin.[121] Dolmayan punched Malakian, splitting his lip, after which Malakian retaliated by smashing a microphone stand over Dolmayan's head; both required stitches at a hospital.[121] Bassist Shavo Odadjian and vocalist Serj Tankian witnessed the incident, with Odadjian expressing concern over the violence, though the pair later reflected on it as a "cool moment" amid their intense passion.[121] Separate arguments nearly turned physical over lyrics in the track "Needles," underscoring early strains in the collaborative process.[121]These dynamics contributed to the band's indefinite hiatus announced on May 9, 2006, after the release of Mezmerize and Hypnotize, as internal fighting intensified over the group's direction.[35] Tankian later took sole responsibility, stating the break allowed him to pursue solo projects amid burnout, while affirming, "We were just fighting too much. Everybody had their own ideas of what the band should be doing."[35] Malakian described it as a "natural thing" due to exhaustion but noted differing visions, saying, "Daron and I have very different ideas about music," which complicated alignment on new material.[35] Songwriting conflicts persisted post-reunion in 2010, with Tankian evolving from lyric-focused contributions to fuller compositions, often requiring mutual revisions with Malakian, though he emphasized ongoing mutual respect despite challenges in consensus.[79]Ideological clashes, particularly political, became public in the late 2010s via social media, highlighting divisions between Dolmayan and Tankian. Dolmayan expressed right-leaning views, including support for Donald Trump—voting for him in 2024 and praising him for restoring "sanity" to politics—and criticism of movements like Black Lives Matter and calls to defund police.[122] Tankian, aligning with left-leaning positions, critiqued Trump supporters as hypocritical given the band's early anti-establishment lyrics and opposed Dolmayan's stances on policing.[123] Tankian described their differences as "extremely polarized" but affirmed Dolmayan as a "stalwart ally" in Armenian advocacy, stating, "I love and respect him irrespective of our... differences," and viewing the tension as enriching the band's identity without derailing tours.[123]Dolmayan attributed stalled albums partly to Tankian's intensifying focus on politics, claiming it overshadowed broader themes like love and death, and that Tankian grew "more crazy" and singularly invested, creating drama that strained friendships.[122] He expressed doubt over future reunions for recording, preferring live performances to avoid further conflict, and noted Tankian has not fully committed to the band in years.[122] Despite this, the group collaborated on "Protect the Land" and "Genocidal Humanoidz" in November 2020 for Nagorno-Karabakh, demonstrating selective unity on shared ethnic causes amid broader rifts.[123]
Reception of Activism and Selective Outrage Claims
Critics have accused System of a Down's activism of exhibiting selective outrage, particularly in its intense focus on Armenian-related issues such as genocide recognition and the Artsakh conflicts, while appearing less vocal on comparable global atrocities affecting other groups, such as the Uyghurgenocide in China or Rohingya persecution in Myanmar.[124] This perception stems from the band's heritage-driven advocacy, with frontman Serj Tankian, a descendant of genocide survivors, leading campaigns like the 2005 "Axis of Justice" tour aimed at "ending all genocide," yet subsequent efforts remaining predominantly Armenia-centric.[125] Detractors argue this prioritization reflects ethnic bias over universal anti-genocide principles, though the band counters that their platform amplifies underrepresented Armenian narratives often ignored by mainstream outlets.[126]A prominent flashpoint occurred on June 16, 2020, when Tankian publicly labeled fans who enjoy the band's anti-authoritarian music yet support Donald Trump as "hypocrites," citing lyrics from the unreleased demo "Temper" that decry blind patriotism and warmongering.[127][109] This statement drew backlash from conservative listeners and even bandmates, highlighting internal ideological rifts: drummer John Dolmayan, a vocal Trump supporter, expressed hope that Tankian was "misunderstood," emphasizing personal respect despite political divergence.[128] Tankian later clarified his respect for Dolmayan's character but firm disagreement with his conservatism, underscoring how such public clashes fuel claims that the band's unified anti-war image masks selective internal outrage, where members critique U.S. imperialism but diverge on domestic politics or allied nations' actions.[110]Guitarist Daron Malakian has himself invoked selective outrage in critiquing external movements, as in April 2024 when he addressed U.S. college campus protests against Israel, noting their failure to equally condemn Azerbaijan's aggression in Artsakh or acknowledge Adolf Hitler's cited precedent of the unpunished Armenian Genocide (1.5 million deaths in 1915).[129] Malakian attributed this disparity to underlying antisemitism rather than principled consistency, positioning the band's Armenian advocacy as a corrective to such oversights.[129] Critics of the band, however, extend this logic inward, arguing that SOAD's outrage amplifies Western-targeted critiques (e.g., Iraq War opposition via "B.Y.O.B." in 2005) while downplaying authoritarian regimes unfriendly to Armenian interests, revealing a pragmatic selectivity informed by geopolitical self-interest over impartial humanism. These tensions have polarized reception, with supporters viewing the activism as authentically rooted in lived trauma and anti-establishment ethos, while skeptics decry it as performative or inconsistently applied amid band fractures.[130]
Legacy and Influence
Commercial Achievements and Chart Performance
System of a Down achieved significant commercial success, selling over 40 million records worldwide across their five studio albums.[131] Their breakthrough came with the 2001 album Toxicity, which debuted at number one on the Billboard 200 chart after selling 222,000 copies in its first week, eventually certified triple platinum by the RIAA for three million units shipped in the United States.[3][132] The album's lead single, "Chop Suey!", reached number one on the Billboard Mainstream Rock chart and propelled the band to mainstream recognition amid post-9/11 radio play restrictions.[4]In 2005, the band released twin albums Mezmerize and Hypnotize, both debuting at number one on the Billboard 200, with Mezmerize selling 322,000 copies in its opening week.[4][30] "B.Y.O.B." from Mezmerize peaked at number 27 on the Billboard Hot 100 and earned a Grammy for Best Hard Rock Performance, while "Hypnotize" topped the Alternative Songs chart.[16] Tracks like "Aerials" from Toxicity also reached number one on the Alternative Songs chart, underscoring the band's dominance in rock formats.[131]
Album
Release Date
Billboard 200 Peak
US Certification (RIAA)
System of a Down
June 30, 1998
#128
Platinum (implied from multi-platinum mentions)[133]
Toxicity
September 4, 2001
#1
3× Platinum[132]
Steal This Album!
November 26, 2002
#15
Gold[134]
Mezmerize
May 17, 2005
#1
Platinum[16]
Hypnotize
November 22, 2005
#1
Platinum[16]
The band's 2020 non-album singles "Protect the Land" and "Genocidal Humanoidz" debuted at numbers one and two on the Billboard Hot Hard Rock Songs chart, driven by 2.7 million U.S. streams for the former in their first tracking week.[135] Overall U.S. album equivalent sales exceed 12 million units, with Toxicity accounting for the majority at approximately 8.8 million pure sales equivalents.[134][16]
Critical and Cultural Impact
System of a Down's music garnered positive critical reception for its aggressive fusion of metal subgenres, Armenianfolk influences, and politically charged lyrics, with the 2001 album Toxicity achieving a Metacritic aggregate score of 73 out of 100 from nine reviews, reflecting acclaim for its production density and thematic depth on issues like the prison-industrial complex.[136] Pitchfork's review emphasized the album's heavy distortion and lucid critiques, such as in the opening track's condemnation of incarcerating minor drug offenders to fuel private prisons.[137] The band's self-titled 1998 debut was praised by Drowned in Sound for generating "instantaneous euphoria" through its "hyper kinetic fast cut shock-punk-metal madness," produced by Rick Rubin.[138]Sputnikmusic highlighted the debut's unhinged transitions and raw energy as hallmarks of the band's early style.[139]Subsequent releases like Mezmerize (2005) and Hypnotize (2005) maintained strong reviews for pushing boundaries in alternative metal, though Kerrang! ranked them below Toxicity while still deeming all albums "brilliant" for their consistent innovation amid political fury.[140] Critics often noted the band's evolution from chaotic aggression to more structured experimentation, attributing this to influences spanning thrash, punk, hip-hop, and Eastern European music, which distinguished them from nu-metal peers.[61]Culturally, System of a Down radicalized metal audiences toward anti-establishment views, particularly anti-war stances, with Toxicity's release coinciding with post-9/11 scrutiny and songs like "B.Y.O.B." serving as protest anthems criticizing U.S. military recruitment and hypocrisy in global conflicts.[141][142] Tracks such as "Boom!" (2002) emerged as fierce anti-Iraq War symbols, amplifying opposition during global demonstrations.[143] The band's Armenian heritage infused their work with genocide-themed advocacy, elevating awareness among non-diaspora listeners through eclectic soundscapes that blended heavy riffs with folk motifs.[144]Their stylistic quirks—rapid tempo shifts, dual vocals, and satirical edge—influenced subsequent acts in alternative and nu-metal scenes, with Kerrang! identifying them as a foundational gateway for bands adopting "quacky" elements and political lyricism.[66] This impact extended to broader media, where songs underscored critiques of propaganda and media manipulation, as in "Hypnotize," referencing events like Tiananmen Square protests.[145] Overall, their output fostered a legacy of using music for tactical disruptions in public discourse on war, environment, and authoritarianism.[146]
Criticisms of Musical Evolution and Stagnation
System of a Down has faced criticism for its prolonged creative hiatus, with no full-length studio album released since the companion records Mezmerize and Hypnotize in 2005, despite sporadic live activity and a pair of singles in 2020.[147][91] This nearly two-decade gap has been attributed primarily to internal creative differences, particularly vocalist Serj Tankian's push for musical progression against resistance from other members to deviate from the band's established formula of rapid, politically charged nu-metal and alternative metal structures.[80] Tankian has described this reluctance as rooted in fear of abandoning a successful approach, stating, "When you’ve succeeded with a certain formula, you don’t want to change it... That is called fear."[148] He emphasized his commitment to evolution, noting, "I believe in progression. I don’t believe in things staying the same way, for music’s sake," and expressed regret that these divides prevented fans from receiving new material.[80]Efforts to address the stagnation, such as Tankian's 2018 "manifesto" proposing egalitarian songwriting credits and decision-making to foster innovation, failed due to opposition from bandmates, including guitarist Daron Malakian.[149] Tankian recounted, "They don’t want to change. And that’s perfectly legitimate," highlighting how prior successes with the original dynamic—Malakian handling most music and Tankian lyrics—discouraged shifts despite Tankian's support for reciprocal experimentation.[149] Similar impasses derailed recording sessions in 2016–2018, where disagreements over roles and direction led Tankian to withdraw rather than revert to unfulfilling methods.[147] Even Hypnotize drew contemporary critiques for internal monotony, with reviewers noting "stagnation and monotony are ubiquitous in at least half of the songs."[150]Fans have echoed these concerns, expressing widespread disappointment over the band's reliance on touring reproductions of early 2000s material without substantive innovation, fueling speculation and frustration after repeated teases of new work.[147] Malakian has countered hesitation stems from avoiding potential fan backlash to evolved sounds, underscoring a cycle where preservation of legacy impedes forward momentum.[58] The 2020 singles, while timely responses to the Nagorno-Karabakh conflict, represented Malakian-led compositions with limited Tankian input, further illustrating unresolved tensions rather than a breakthrough in collective evolution.[147]
Band Members
Current Lineup
The current lineup of System of a Down comprises Serj Tankian as lead vocalist, Daron Malakian as lead guitarist and backing vocalist, Shavo Odadjian as bassist and occasional vocalist, and John Dolmayan as drummer.[54][151] This formation has been consistent since the band's inception in 1994, with no personnel changes reported as of 2025.[152] The members continue to perform together, including on the 2025 North American stadium tour featuring support acts such as Deftones, Korn, and Avenged Sevenfold.[153]
Former Members and Contributions
Ontronik "Andy" Khachaturian served as System of a Down's co-founding drummer from the band's early formation in 1993 through 1997, contributing percussion to its initial demos and live performances during the pre-label phase.[154] Khachaturian, who had previously collaborated with guitarist Daron Malakian in high school bands, helped shape the group's raw, aggressive rhythmic foundation evident in tracks like early versions of "Sugar" performed live in 1996.[155] He has stated that he composed drum parts for several songs that appeared on the band's debut album and Toxicity, though these were refined and recorded after his departure.[154]Khachaturian exited the band in 1997 following a wrist injury sustained during Jeet Kune Do training, which impaired his ability to perform.[156] His replacement, John Dolmayan, joined shortly thereafter, stabilizing the lineup for the band's major-label breakthrough. Post-departure, Khachaturian formed The Apex Theory (later MT. Helium), incorporating former Soil bassist Dave Hakopyan—who had briefly played bass in System of a Down's precursor incarnation Soil around 1993 before Shavo Odadjian's recruitment.[157]No other individuals are documented as having served in official capacities with System of a Down beyond these early transitional roles, with the core quartet maintaining continuity since 1997.[152]
Discography
Studio Albums
System of a Down, the band's eponymous debut studio album, was released on June 30, 1998, by American Recordings. It peaked at number 124 on the US Billboard 200.[11] The album was certified gold by the RIAA on February 2, 2000, for shipments of 500,000 units.[11][158]Toxicity, the second studio album, arrived on September 4, 2001, debuting at number 1 on the Billboard 200.[16] It was certified triple platinum by the RIAA in November 2002 for three million units shipped.[159]Steal This Album!, released on November 26, 2002, comprised reworked versions of tracks leaked online prior to recording. It debuted at number 15 on the Billboard 200, selling 166,000 copies in its first week.[26]Mezmerize, the fourth studio album and first half of a double album project, was issued on May 17, 2005, debuting at number 1 on the Billboard 200 with 453,000 copies sold in its opening week. It has been certified platinum by the RIAA.[160]Hypnotize, the concluding half of the double album, followed on November 22, 2005, also debuting at number 1 on the Billboard 200. It was certified platinum by the RIAA on December 13, 2005.[161]The five albums have collectively generated over 36 million equivalent album sales worldwide.[16] The band has sold more than 40 million records globally.[162]
Singles and EPs
System of a Down's singles primarily promote their studio albums, with releases spanning from 1999 to 2020, often featuring politically charged themes aligned with the band's activism. Early singles like "Sugar" (May 1999) and "Spiders" (October 1999) from their self-titled debut achieved modest radio play but built underground momentum.[1] The breakthrough came with Toxicity (2001), yielding "Chop Suey!" (August 13, 2001), which peaked at number 76 on the USBillboard Hot 100 and number 17 on the UK Singles Chart, alongside "Toxicity" (October 2001, US Hot 100 number 70, UK number 25) and "Aerials" (June 2002, US Hot 100 number 55, UK number 34; number 1 on US Alternative Songs).[163][162]"Innervision" followed in November 2002 as a promotional single.[1]The 2005 dual releases Mezmerize and Hypnotize produced further hits, including "B.Y.O.B." (March 29, 2005, from Mezmerize; US Hot 100 number 27, number 1 on US Alternative Songs) and "Question!" (July 2005; UK number 41).[163][162] From Hypnotize, "Hypnotize" (November 22, 2005; US Hot 100 number 57, UK number 48; number 1 on US Alternative Songs), "Lonely Day" (February 13, 2006), and "Vicinity of Obscenity" were issued, with "Cigaro" and "Kill Rock 'n Roll" (2006) serving as promotional tracks.[1][163] In 2020, amid the Nagorno-Karabakh conflict, the band released "Protect the Land" and "Genocidal Humanoidz" (November 6, 2020) as a double single, which debuted at numbers 1 and 2 on the Billboard Hot Hard Rock Songs chart, raising over $600,000 for Armenian relief via proceeds.[135] Cumulative single sales exceed 20 million units equivalent, led by "Chop Suey!" at approximately 6.5 million.[16]
The band has released few standalone EPs, often bundling b-sides or live tracks with singles in EP formats for promotional purposes. Notable examples include the "Lonely Day" EP (May 2006) and "Vicinity of Obscenity / Lonely Day" EP (2006), both tied to Hypnotize tracks, featuring remixes and rarities.[1]"Sugar" was also issued in EP form in 1998 with demo elements.[164] These releases supplemented album cycles rather than functioning as primary outputs, with limited commercial charting.[1]
Awards and Nominations
System of a Down has received one Grammy Award from four nominations, primarily recognizing their hard rock and metal performances. The band's single "B.Y.O.B." from the 2005 album Mezmerize won Best Hard Rock Performance at the 48th Annual Grammy Awards on February 8, 2006.[165][32] Earlier nominations included "Chop Suey!" for Best Metal Performance at the 44th Annual Grammy Awards in 2002, "Aerials" for Best Hard Rock Performance at the 45th Annual Grammy Awards in 2003, and "Lonely Day" for Best Hard Rock Performance at the 49th Annual Grammy Awards in 2007.[166][32][165]The band earned multiple nominations at the 2005 Kerrang! Awards, leading the field alongside Muse in categories such as Best Album for Mezmerize, Best Single, Best Video, Best Live Band, and Best Band on the Planet.[167]At the MTV Video Music Awards, System of a Down received a nomination for "Chop Suey!" in 2002, and the "B.Y.O.B." music video was nominated for Best Editing in 2005.[168][169]Additional nominations include Modern Rock Artist of the Year at the Billboard Music Awards.[170]