Fact-checked by Grok 2 weeks ago

Three Times

Three Times (Chinese: 最好的時光; lit. 'The Best Time') is a 2005 Taiwanese romance written and directed by . The film comprises three distinct love stories set across different eras in —1911 during Japanese colonial rule, 1966 amid post-war martial law, and 2005 in contemporary —each featuring the same lead actors, Shu Qi and Chang Chen, portraying variations of a man and woman navigating romance, separation, and longing. Hou's direction emphasizes long takes, minimal dialogue, and evocative to explore themes of time, , and unfulfilled desire, drawing on Taiwanese history and cultural shifts without overt narrative exposition. The film's structure reflects Hou's signature style, prioritizing atmospheric immersion over plot-driven tension, with the 1911 segment evoking operatic restraint in a brothel setting, the 1966 story capturing youthful pop culture influences like ' music in a billiards hall, and the modern tale addressing urban alienation through fragmented communication. Critically acclaimed for its visual poetry and emotional depth, Three Times holds an 86% approval rating on based on 51 reviews, with praise centered on its lyrical portrayal of love's endurance across temporal and social barriers. awarded it four stars, lauding it as a meditation on yearning rather than , while scores it 82 out of 100 from 22 critics, highlighting its romantic resonance and Hou's mastery of mood. Though not a commercial blockbuster, it solidified Hou's international reputation, following works like , and exemplifies his commitment to historical introspection and subtle humanism in Taiwanese cinema.

Plot

A Time for Love

"A Time for Love," the opening segment of Three Times, is set in 1966 in , , and portrays the innocent budding romance between Chen (), a young man facing imminent military draft, and May (), a hostess at a local billiards hall. The story unfolds against the backdrop of post-war Taiwanese simplicity, capturing the reticent courtship typical of the era's youth, where direct expressions of affection are rare and emotions develop through subtle gestures. The narrative begins with Chen visiting the billiards hall, where he encounters May amid games of involving local patrons and hostesses who wager on shots. Their initial interactions are marked by shyness; , having received his draft notice, initiates contact by writing her a letter, leading to exchanged notes and shared moments in the hall. Key scenes highlight indirect communication, including dedications of popular songs on the jukebox—such as The Platters' "Smoke Gets in Your Eyes" and Aphrodite's Child's "Rain and Tears"—which underscore their growing but unspoken feelings. Over the summer before Chen's departure for service, their relationship progresses through chaste activities reflective of Taiwanese social norms, including bike rides through the city and dances at the hall where they sing together. These moments evoke the unhurried pace of youth in a martial law-era society, emphasizing restraint and the simplicity of everyday locales like pool halls and streets. The farewell occurs as Chen leaves for the army, with their parting infused with quiet longing rather than overt drama. Upon Chen's return after service, he seeks May at the hall but learns she has left; a final glimpse shows her entering a car with another man, concluding the segment on a note of unresolved tenderness and the transient nature of early love. Though presented first in the film, this story occupies the middle chronological position among the three eras—bridging 1911 and 2005—and focuses exclusively on uncomplicated romantic yearning without the constraints of historical upheaval or modern complexities.

A Time for Freedom

The "A Time for Freedom" segment unfolds in 1911 in , a of , amid Japan's colonial administration of , which had been imposed since 1895. It portrays the constrained life of a () in a , where she entertains patrons through singing traditional songs, playing music, and reciting , all while harboring a personal desire to escape her servitude. Her routine is marked by limited agency, as brothel operations under colonial-era social structures prioritize economic utility over individual , reflecting broader oppressions of the time. A key figure in her world is Mr. Chang (Chang Chen), a frequent client who is a married and covert advocate for Taiwanese from rule; their bond forms through silent exchanges of short poems and notes, rendered via intertitles in a style evoking early cinema. Mr. Chang's visits intersect with whispers of revolutionary fervor, including discussions among activists inspired by mainland China's unrest, such as the on October 10, 1911, which ignited the Xinhai Revolution against control. He confides in her about these aspirations for national liberation, paralleling her own quiet yearnings, though their interactions remain subdued and indirect, underscoring the perils of open dissent under surveillance-heavy colonial governance. Tensions peak when the reveals a fellow worker's plan to flee for , prompting Mr. Chang to intervene by negotiating her release from the madam, an effort thwarted by the woman's indispensable value to the establishment's profits. The subtly defies her entrapment through her songs—poignant performances that convey unspoken longing and resilience—and continued correspondence with Mr. Chang, who eventually departs for pursuits, later sending a that evokes their mutual, unfulfilled quests for without altering the 's oppressive dynamics. This segment highlights personal and political constraints without narrative closure, mirroring the era's unresolved colonial tensions.

A Time for Youth

In the 2005 segment set in contemporary , Jing (), a rock singer afflicted with near-blindness in one eye, embodies the fragmentation of urban youth amid modern technology and fleeting connections. She performs in trendy clubs, singing in English to indifferent crowds, while her personal life unfolds through terse text messages and half-spoken encounters that underscore . Jing resides with a jealous female partner who resents her growing involvement with Zhen (), a who idolizes her artistry and initiates a physical . The narrative unfolds in non-linear vignettes, shifting between Jing's epileptic episodes requiring attention, intimate apartment scenes revealing , and nocturnal drives through Taipei's neon-lit streets, including lounges where personal tensions simmer amid public performances. Artistic aspirations surface in Zhen's sessions capturing Jing's , contrasted against her existential weariness and the lover's escalating despair, which manifests in subtle hints of via overheard calls and evasive replies. Unlike the relational stability in prior eras, this era's digital mediation—text exchanges replacing deeper dialogue—amplifies disconnection, culminating in the female partner's off-screen , heralded by a distant thud as Jing reads her computer-screened farewell note. The segment concludes ambiguously with Jing and Zhen on a traversing a bridge, evoking unresolved malaise among early 21st-century youth navigating , illness, and superficial bonds in a hyper-connected yet isolating metropolis.

Production

Development and Conception

_ conceived Three Times as an comprising three distinct love stories set across Taiwanese history—1911 during colonial rule, 1966 in postwar rural , and 2005 in contemporary urban settings—employing the same lead actors, and , to embody romantic pairs in each era. The project reflected Hou's ongoing exploration of time, memory, and relational dynamics, structured to evoke variations on romantic archetypes without rigid narrative progression. Script development emphasized semi-improvisation over conventional plotting, with Chu Tien-wen credited as but minimal written to foster organic performances rooted in Taiwanese cultural elements and Hou's personal recollections, such as youth experiences in pool halls influencing the 1966 segment. This approach aligned with Hou's directorial method, prioritizing actor spontaneity and environmental immersion to capture ephemeral human connections rather than scripted causality. Pre-production spanned 2004 into early 2005, focusing on era-specific research and actor preparation to enable the loose, memory-driven framework, which selected to revisit intimate bonds amid historical shifts while avoiding overt thematic imposition. The film's readiness for its May 2005 premiere at the Film Festival's section underscored this preparatory restraint, prioritizing atmospheric authenticity over detailed blueprints.

Casting and Collaboration

Shu Qi and were selected to portray the lead romantic pair across all three segments, embodying reincarnated souls in distinct eras to underscore thematic continuity amid varying historical contexts. 's casting drew on her prior collaboration with director in (2001), where her nuanced performance demonstrated the range needed to transition from a demure in 1911 to a modern, fragmented urbanite in 2005. , making his first appearance in a film, was chosen for his expressive depth and chemistry with , enabling seamless shifts between a reserved soldier, a brooding pool hall owner, and a detached contemporary musician without disrupting the film's introspective rhythm. Their dual casting facilitated Hou's exploration of eternal yet evolving bonds, with minimal dialogue and reliance on subtle physical interplay to link the stories visually and emotionally. Cinematographer , a frequent collaborator since their debut joint project A Time to Live and a Time to Die (1985), handled the film's imagery, employing long takes and natural lighting to maintain stylistic cohesion across periods. His work in Three Times built on prior efforts like , adapting period-specific textures—such as sepia-toned restraint for and handheld immediacy for 2005—while preserving Hou's signature static compositions that emphasize temporal flow over dramatic cuts. This recurring partnership ensured the film's visual language reinforced narrative fragmentation without sacrificing perceptual unity. Co-writer Chu T'ien-wen, who had partnered with on multiple scripts including , contributed to structuring the non-linear romances, drawing from personal anecdotes to infuse authentic cultural details that bridged the eras. Her involvement highlighted Hou's preference for trusted collaborators in crafting intimate, observation-based storytelling.

Filming Process

for Three Times took place primarily on location in , utilizing sites that mirrored the historical and contemporary settings of each segment. The 1966 "A Time for Love" portion was shot in rural southern areas, including pool halls around , to capture the provincial atmosphere of mid-20th-century . The 1911 "A Time for Freedom" scenes relied on reconstructed practical sets depicting brothels under Japanese colonial rule, drawing from detailed to ensure architectural and cultural fidelity without augmentation. provided the backdrop for the 2005 "A Time for Youth" sequences, incorporating real city streets and interiors to reflect modern fragmentation. Hou Hsiao-hsien's on-set methods emphasized minimal intervention to foster organic performances, with a focus on long takes and static compositions that demanded precise actor movement and environmental control. Mark Lee Ping-bin's setups often held shots for extended durations, requiring crew coordination to avoid disruptions and maintain spatial depth, particularly challenging in confined recreations where lighting and props had to evoke early 20th-century restraint. This approach prioritized temporal realism over rapid cuts, compelling actors like and to internalize gestures through immersion rather than scripted repetition. Period segments involved sourcing authentic costumes and dialects, with sets built to withstand prolonged shoots that simulated historical constraints on movement and interaction.

Cinematic Style and Techniques

Visual Approach and Cinematography

The cinematography of Three Times, handled by in collaboration with director , employs Hou's characteristic long takes and static or minimally moving camera setups to emphasize environmental context over dramatic action. Wide shots predominate, often positioning characters within expansive or detailed surroundings to underscore their place in larger historical and spatial contexts, as seen in the billiards hall sequences of the segment where figures are framed against receding depths of tables and patrons. Shallow is selectively used to isolate subjects from their backgrounds, particularly in intimate moments, creating a sense of emotional or temporal separation; this technique contrasts the confined interiors of the 1911 scenes, with their tight framing and on courtesans amid ornate but restrictive spaces, against the cluttered, fragmented urban compositions of the 2005 settings, where foreground elements compete for visual attention. Natural lighting prevails throughout, drawn from available sources like daylight filtering through windows or ambient interiors, enhancing the observational quality and evoking the eras' atmospheres without artificial enhancement. Slow pans and fluid camera movements, reminiscent of Yasujirō Ozu's contemplative style and the static precision of the Taiwanese New Wave, guide the viewer's gaze across scenes, prioritizing subtle shifts in composition over rapid cuts; these pans often reveal spatial relationships gradually, as in tracking shots through hallways or across rooms that maintain a rhythmic, unhurried pace. The production differentiated textures empirically by shooting the 1911 and 1966 segments on 35mm film for their warmer, grainier analog quality, while the 2005 portion utilized to capture the sharper, more immediate grain of contemporary life, underscoring visual contrasts between past restraint and modern immediacy.

Narrative Structure and Editing

The film adopts an format comprising three self-contained stories presented in non-chronological order: the 1966 segment first, followed by 1911, and concluding with 2005, each running approximately 40 minutes. This deliberate sequencing eschews linear historical progression, instead foregrounding cyclical repetitions in romantic encounters between the same lead actors across disparate eras, thereby underscoring thematic continuities amid temporal disruption. Editing in Three Times emphasizes minimal intervention, with long takes dominating to preserve spatial and temporal integrity over rapid montage. favors extended durations that capture the unhurried flow of mundane events—such as conversations or daily routines—in , allowing viewers to experience the weight of inaction and subtle shifts in relational dynamics without artificial acceleration. This restrained approach, evident in sequences devoid of shot-reverse-shot conventions even in period-specific recreations, prioritizes observational , where cuts serve primarily to transition between vignettes rather than to manipulate emotional peaks. Narrative propulsion relies on visual and performative subtlety rather than overt exposition, omitting voiceovers or didactic intertitles to infer motivations through accumulated gestures, settings, and historical inflections. The episodic segmentation thus constructs a of echoed motifs— longing, societal barriers, existential drift—refracted through era-specific lenses, achieving redundancy-free repetition by varying contextual pressures (e.g., rituals in 1911 versus digital disconnection in 2005) while maintaining structural parallelism in character arcs. This method invites interpretive engagement, as the absence of compels audiences to bridge gaps via , reinforcing the film's meditation on history's fragmented persistence.

Sound Design and Music

Hou Hsiao-hsien employs location-recorded ambient sounds and strategic in Three Times to ground the film's emotional realism, prioritizing natural audio over post-dubbed effects for authenticity across the three eras. Everyday noises—such as pool cues clacking, doors opening and closing, or brushing billiard tables—dominate the 1966 segment's pool hall setting, creating an immersive, lived-in atmosphere that underscores the characters' tentative romance amid routine. Music insertions are sparse and purposeful: Western pop songs like "" (performed by ) and "" (by ) play twice each, evoking the era's cultural influences while heightening moments of longing without overwhelming the scene's naturalism. In the 1911 segment, traditional Chinese music transitions from seemingly non-diegetic to revealed diegetic sources, such as a courtesan's , integrating with the action to reflect constrained personal . Ambient rituals like lighting oil lamps or washing hands and faces recur, their subtle acoustics amplified in long takes, while an ethereal classical piano score evokes the era, mirroring the courtesan's voicelessness through deliberate periods of auditory restraint. The 2005 segment contrasts sharply, blending modern pop from the protagonist's role as a rock singer with text message alerts and stark silences to convey urban and fragmented communication. A discreet off-screen marks a , diegetically tied to the without embellishment, while the absence of the folk-like harmonies from earlier eras amplifies emotional disconnection in a hyper-connected present. This evolution in reinforces Hou's commitment to direct, on-location recording, avoiding artificial to preserve temporal and affective .

Themes and Motifs

Romantic Bonds Across Eras

In the 1911 segment, "A Time for Freedom," the romantic bond between a and a visiting manifests as a constrained intimacy initiated through transactional encounters in a setting, where social norms of the Japanese-occupied era—encompassing strict gender roles, professional obligations, and arranged marriages—preclude enduring union, culminating in the courtesan's tearful acceptance of an alternative match despite evident emotional attachment expressed via intertitles and restrained gestures like caressing a farewell letter. This dynamic reflects causal influences of feudal hierarchies and occupational limits, observable in scenes of ritualistic proximity such as hair-combing, which underscore physical closeness amid institutional barriers rather than mutual agency. By contrast, the 1966 story, "A Time for Love," depicts youthful flirtations between a billiards attendant and a conscripted , characterized by innocent exchanges like note-passing at a pool hall and a climactic hand-holding during a , influenced by post-war Taiwanese norms allowing greater personal initiative in yet still enforced separations via military drafts and job transience. Social expectations here facilitate observable relational progression through repeated interactions, such as shared ferry rides and pop recitals, linking era-specific freedoms to patterns of tentative physical and emotional approximation without overt consummation. Across all eras, including the vignette of overlapping infidelities among professionals, recurring motifs of unspoken appear in non-verbal cues—evident in the courtesan's silent sobs, the 1966 pair's averted gazes during partings, and modern characters' evasive digital missives—while physical proximity recurs in confined scenes like bedside vigils or vehicle rides, verifying universal dynamics of relational tension independent of technological or normative shifts. These elements, repeated across segments (e.g., thrice-iterated hand-washing or lamp-lighting rituals), highlight observable patterns where social contexts modulate expression but not the persistence of deferred connection.

Historical Constraints and Personal Agency

In the 1911 segment of Three Times, personal agency unfolds amid colonial rule, imposed since 1895 following the , which ceded from Qing China and established a system granting near-absolute authority to Tokyo-appointed officials, thereby curtailing local political and fostering policies over . , central to the era's setting, operated under regulated licensing from the early colonial period, with brothels required to register and prostitutes subjected to mandatory inspections for venereal diseases, a framework that institutionalized the practice but entrenched women's economic dependence through debt contracts or parental pawning, offering scant avenues for exit without external intervention. Early resistance, including armed uprisings in the initial decade of rule, reflected nascent independence sentiments but faced swift military suppression, as forces prioritized over , limiting collective or individual challenges to colonial power structures. Gender roles during this period reinforced patriarchal constraints, with women denied and opportunities largely withheld to prevent unrest, though primary enrollment for girls reached approximately 60% by the colonial era's close, indicating incremental access amid broader subjugation rather than uniform victimhood. Taiwanese women in regulated trades like navigated not only familial obligations but also imperial oversight, where Japanese policies imported elements of licensed systems from the , yet local customs perpetuated intra-family trafficking without equitable , underscoring causal limits on choice tied to economic necessity and colonial extraction rather than inherent helplessness. By contrast, the 1966 narrative occurs under (KMT) rule post-World War II, with enacted in 1949 imposing restrictions on assembly, speech, and press to counter perceived communist infiltration, resulting in military tribunals for civilians and pervasive surveillance that constrained overt political agency. Economic recovery, fueled by U.S.-aided land reforms in the early and export-led growth averaging 8-10% annual GDP increases through the decade, enabled greater personal mobility, as rural-to-urban migration for factory and service jobs expanded opportunities for in livelihoods, diverging from the 1911 era's insular colonial surveillance. For women, the 1947 Constitution's equality clauses provided nominal legal backing, yet patriarchal norms under authoritarian stability limited full realization, with workforce participation rising amid industrialization—reaching over 40% female labor force involvement by the late 1960s—allowing some negotiation of traditional roles through economic contributions, though family duties and state ideology emphasizing Confucian hierarchies persisted as binding factors. This era's structures, while politically repressive, contrasted colonial rigidity by linking agency to market-driven prospects, highlighting how post-war stabilization and growth incrementally loosened historical fetters without erasing power imbalances rooted in regime priorities.

Modernity, Fragmentation, and Alienation

In the 2005 segment titled "A Time for Youth," portrays relational instability through the story of a female pop singer (played by ) entangled in a faltering partnership while pursuing an affair with a male photographer (). Set amid Taipei's bustling urban landscape, the narrative unfolds via fleeting encounters facilitated by , including text messages and emails that substitute for sustained physical or . These digital exchanges, such as the singer's website declaring "No past, no future, just a hungry present," underscore a presentist disconnection, where immediate gratification via gadgets supplants deeper bonds, culminating in the singer's lover's after discovering the —met with the singer's detached numbness. Urbanization exacerbates this fragmentation, as depicted in scenes of clogged cityscapes and high-speed rides through , symbolizing precarious clinging amid rather than communal . Causal factors like pervasive and anonymity erode direct relational commitments, fostering and dissatisfaction; for instance, the affair's via indirect traces highlights how mediated communication obscures , leading to emotional despite physical proximity. This contrasts sharply with the earlier segments' ritual-bound interactions in 1966 and , where social constraints imposed relational continuity, suggesting modernity's empirical trade-offs: expanded personal freedom via technological and urban mobility yields isolation and unresolved tensions, not unalloyed liberation. Critics interpreting the segment's urban anomie as overly pessimistic overlook its causal realism, rooted in observable patterns of digital-era disconnection and city-induced transience, which challenge assumptions of progress as inherently enhancing human fulfillment. The unresolved motorcycle departure into Taipei's indeterminacy encapsulates this, portraying modernity's relational voids as a direct outcome of structural shifts prioritizing individual autonomy over enduring ties.

Cultural and Historical Context

Taiwanese Cinema and Hou Hsiao-hsien's Influences

Hou emerged as a pivotal figure in the Taiwanese cinema movement of the , which emphasized authentic depictions of Taiwanese life, social issues, and cultural identity, diverging from the state-sponsored commercial films of prior decades. This movement, alongside directors like , gained international attention by prioritizing long takes, naturalistic performances, and historical introspection over melodramatic conventions. Hou's early contributions, such as his biographical trilogy in the late , focused on , chronicling personal and familial struggles amid Taiwan's post-war transformations. By the and early , Hou shifted toward more elliptical, introspective narratives that fragmented temporal and spatial continuity, reflecting a maturation in form that culminated in structures. Three Times (2005) represents a refinement of this evolution, distilling recurring motifs of love and constraint across disparate eras into three self-contained vignettes, building on the historical depth of films like (1989) while eschewing overt didacticism. This progression marked Hou's departure from strictly linear social commentaries to contemplative explorations of memory and transience, influenced by the broader decline of the New Wave's initial momentum and his own international collaborations. Hou's stylistic restraint, characterized by deliberate pacing and static compositions, draws notably from Japanese director , whose influence Hou acknowledged after discovering his work in the late 1980s or early 1990s. Ozu's low-angle shots, pillow shots, and emphasis on everyday rituals informed Hou's approach to temporal ellipsis and emotional understatement, evident in the unhurried rhythm of Three Times' segments. This assimilation contributed to Hou's global aesthetic signature, bridging Eastern cinematic traditions without replicating Ozu's domestic focus. The lifting of on July 15, 1987, after 38 years of authoritarian rule, profoundly enabled this artistic trajectory by dismantling censorship barriers, allowing filmmakers like to confront suppressed histories such as the 228 Incident and era. Prior restrictions had confined cinema to escapist genres; post-1987 freedoms facilitated reflective works that interrogated Taiwan's multifaceted identity, with Hou's output exemplifying this shift toward causal examinations of personal agency within historical constraints. Hou's films, including those post-1990s, played a key role in globalizing Taiwanese cinema, securing festival circuit prominence and elevating local narratives to international discourse, with exports rising alongside critical acclaim for arthouse sensibilities. By the , this positioned as a hub for contemplative , with Three Times exemplifying sustained empirical success in bridging domestic introspection and transnational appeal.

Representations of Taiwan's Past and Present

The film embeds its three romantic vignettes within verifiable historical epochs of , reflecting shifts from colonial subjugation to authoritarian development and democratic integration without allegorical overreach. The opening story, set in 1966 in a rural pool hall in southern , captures the island's post-war modernization under (KMT) rule during (imposed in 1949 and lasting until 1987), a period marked by the White Terror's political controls, including arbitrary detentions and censorship to suppress perceived communist sympathies or independence sentiments. This era coincided with the onset of Taiwan's export-oriented economic boom, driven by land reforms in the 1950s, U.S. aid until 1965, and industrial policies that propelled annual GDP growth rates exceeding 10% from 1962 to 1966, fostering urban migration and consumer culture amid ongoing authoritarian oversight. The depiction includes everyday markers like dialect and modest leisure spaces, underscoring relative stability post-1949 KMT retreat from the mainland, even as remnants of one-party dominance persisted. The middle vignette, transposed to 1911 in a Sanyi brothel under Japanese colonial administration (1895–1945), illustrates cultural through -influenced , codeswitching, and commodified entertainments blending Han Chinese traditions with imposed modernization, such as improved railways and systems that raised to 71% by the 1930s but prioritized imperial assimilation over autonomy. The temporal placement aligns with the mainland's Xinhai Revolution (October ), which ended imperial but had negligible direct impact on -governed , where colonial isolation precluded revolutionary spillover, though period newspapers might have carried distant echoes of Han nationalist stirrings. Representations emphasize constrained personal agency in a stratified society, with patrons and local intermediaries reflecting enforced hierarchies rather than hybrid . The concluding segment, set in 2005 Taipei, portrays urban professionals amid Taiwan's post-martial law (formalized after 1987 lifting of bans), characterized by multiparty elections, expansion, and via WTO accession in 2002, which boosted high-tech exports to 60% of GDP by integrating into supply chains dominated by cross-strait trade despite geopolitical tensions. Economic achievements included a GDP surpassing $15,000 USD, yet realities encompassed from tech sector fragmentation and lingering authoritarian echoes in security apparatuses. The narrative deploys mobile phones, subways, and expatriate encounters to evoke cosmopolitan flux, balancing democratic openness with modern disconnection in a society navigating amid global interdependence.

Reception

Critical Evaluations

Three Times received widespread critical acclaim for its lyrical minimalism and visual poetry, earning an aggregate score of 82 out of 100 on based on 22 reviews, indicating "universal acclaim." On , it holds an 86% approval rating from 51 critics, with the consensus describing it as "slowly paced, understated, and exquisitely shot," praising the film's odes to and longing across eras. Critics consistently highlighted director Hou Hsiao-hsien's restraint in narrative and editing, favoring contemplative long takes over dramatic exposition, though some noted this approach prioritizes aesthetic immersion over broad accessibility. Roger Ebert awarded the film four out of four stars, lauding its "magnificent" depiction of unspoken emotions and the tragedy of unrealized potential in relationships, exemplified by the characters' quiet yearnings in each segment. At its premiere on May 21, 2005, commended Hou's pessimistic worldview and slow rhythms, observing that the film's three vignettes using the same actors effectively meditate on Taiwan's historical shifts, though best suited for audiences attuned to his style. This admiration for formal restraint echoed in other festival responses, where the film's hypnotic structure was seen as a pinnacle of Hou's oeuvre, emphasizing mood and historical rumination over plot-driven engagement. While praised for its beauty and thematic depth, reviewers acknowledged the film's deliberate pacing as a barrier to mainstream appeal, with consensus affirming its superior artistic merit—evident in high scores from outlets like (80/100)—tempered by its demand for patient viewing. Such evaluations underscore a professional divide: exceptional for cinephiles valuing subtlety, yet challenging for those seeking narrative momentum.

Audience and Commercial Feedback

The film garnered modest commercial performance, earning a worldwide box office total of $581,875, including $151,922 in the United States and . Its limited theatrical rollout, primarily through arthouse distributors and circuits rather than wide commercial releases, constrained broader market penetration outside , underscoring its niche appeal over mainstream viability. Viewer reactions reveal a split between dedicated cinephiles and general audiences, with the film's unhurried pacing emerging as a frequent point of contention in user feedback. On , it holds an average rating of 6.9 out of 10 from 6,345 user reviews, where commendations for and Chen's performances and the evocative coexist with complaints of excessive slowness alienating casual viewers. audience score of 71% echoes this divide, with many non-specialist respondents expressing impatience with the contemplative rhythm while arthouse enthusiasts value its immersive historical vignettes. Such responses highlight how the film's stylistic demands—long takes and minimal —favor patient, interpretive engagement over accessible , differentiating popular reception from elevated critical esteem.

Key Criticisms and Debates

Some reviewers have criticized Three Times for its minimalist aesthetic and protracted long takes, arguing that these elements border on affectation and create a rather than immersion, with minimal dialogue exacerbating . Characters across the three vignettes are frequently described as underdeveloped and unpleasantly cold, lacking the depth or relatability needed to sustain viewer investment despite strong performances from leads and . This sparsity extends to the plots, which establish atmospheric periods but devolve into weak, insufficient narratives that prioritize mood over substantive storytelling, rendering segments like the modern-era "A Time for " particularly unengaging. Debates center on the between the film's purported profundity and its , with detractors noting that the glacial pacing—spanning 135 minutes of repetitive motifs—demands undue from audiences without consistently delivering commensurate insights into themes of and . While proponents view the restraint as artistic rigor, critics contend it veers into pretentious obscurity, appealing primarily to art-house enthusiasts tolerant of unconventional forms but alienating broader viewers through indulgent that feels more conceptually ambitious than emotionally resonant. Minor contention arises over cultural specificity, as the film's deep embedding in Taiwanese history, locales, and Minnan dialect—evident in period details from 1911 to 2005—can estrange international audiences lacking contextual familiarity, amplifying perceptions of in its insular, non-universal portrayal of romantic bonds. This has fueled underrepresented complaints that the work's opacity prioritizes auteurial experimentation over communicative clarity, positioning it as a niche exercise rather than a broadly insightful .

Awards and Recognition

Film Festival Achievements

Three Times premiered in the In Competition section of the 58th on May 13, 2005, where it received a nomination for the , highlighting its artistic merit among international peers. The film's selection underscored director Hou Hsiao-hsien's reputation for contemplative storytelling, though it did not secure the top prize. Following Cannes, it screened at the in September 2005, contributing to its visibility in North American festival circuits. The film also appeared at the in October 2005, further affirming its critical interest in major Western venues. In Asia, Three Times served as the opening night film for the 10th Pusan International (now ) on October 6, 2005, a prominent event for that drew attention to its thematic exploration of love across eras. In 2006, Three Times achieved a notable victory by winning the Golden Apricot Award for Best Feature Film at the 3rd Yerevan International , recognizing its narrative depth and visual poetry from an international jury. This peer-validated accolade, amid broader festival circulation including , marked a key validation of the film's artistic achievements in the post-premiere phase.

Other Honors and Nominations

At the 42nd Golden Horse Awards held on November 13, 2005, Three Times received nine nominations, including for Best Feature Film, Best Director (), Best Leading Actor (), and Best Leading Actress (). The film won Best Taiwanese Film of the Year, recognizing its portrayal of Taiwan's historical and cultural shifts through three interconnected love stories. Additionally, secured the Best Leading Actress award for her performances across the film's three female protagonists, spanning 1911, 1966, and 2005, praised for their nuanced emotional depth. was honored with the Best Taiwanese Filmmaker award, highlighting his contributions to the film's direction and its reflection of Taiwanese identity. 's nomination for Best Leading Actor acknowledged his versatile portrayals of the male lead in each era, though the award went to another film. The film did not receive nominations at the 2006 Asian Film Awards, where other regional productions dominated categories like Best Film and Best Director. Subsequent recognitions have been limited, with no major retrospective industry honors documented beyond its Golden Horse successes, though it has been cited in discussions of pivotal Taiwanese cinematic works for its structural innovation and actor performances.

Legacy and Impact

Influence on Filmmaking

cited Three Times (2005) as a direct structural influence on his film (2016), adopting its format of three distinct chapters to depict the protagonist's life stages, each portrayed by different actors. This approach allowed Jenkins to explore temporal progression through fragmented, non-linear romance and identity narratives, mirroring Hou Hsiao-hsien's use of recurring actors across eras to evoke cyclical human connections. The film's contemplative long takes and minimalistic pacing reinforced Hou's role in slow cinema aesthetics, inspiring directors like , who praised Three Times for its distinctive rhythmic flow akin to other Asian art films. Weerasethakul noted this unhurried tempo as a model for prioritizing atmospheric immersion over plot acceleration, evident in his own works' emphasis on duration and sensory observation. , influenced by Hou's broader oeuvre including the omnibus style revived in Three Times, incorporated similar elliptical storytelling in family dramas, tracing generational echoes without overt exposition. Three Times exemplified anthology formats in Asian by linking three self-contained romantic vignettes across Taiwanese history, building on New Taiwan traditions while adapting them for digital-era production. This segmented structure, blending 35mm for period segments with for the 2005 contemporary tale, encouraged post-2005 experimentation in hybrid media for historical films, as seen in subsequent Asian period pieces favoring authentic textures via mixed formats to differentiate timelines. Taiwanese directors have echoed these romantic historical homages in works exploring personal memory against national change, maintaining Hou's restraint in dialogue and emphasis on environmental detail.

Enduring Interpretations and Cultural Resonance

Scholars have interpreted Three Times as a meditation on Taiwan's evolving social fabric, using romantic relationships across eras as a barometer for broader identity shifts from agrarian rootedness to urban fragmentation. The 1966 segment evokes post-war rural harmony under Kuomintang rule, where courtship unfolds with tactile simplicity amid economic takeoff; the 1911 brothel tale reflects Japanese colonial constraints yet poetic intimacy; and the 2005 storyline captures modern Taipei's alienation, marked by digital mediation and career-driven transience. Academic analyses, such as those in The State of Taiwan Film in the 1960s and 1970s, frame these vignettes as historical prisms, highlighting how modernization eroded communal bonds while preserving cultural continuity in personal longing. This perspective privileges empirical observation of relational dynamics over politicized narratives, underscoring causal links between industrialization and diminished interpersonal depth. Right-leaning critiques, often sidelined in academia's left-leaning , emphasize the film's implicit for traditional hierarchies and familial against contemporary individualism's toll. Where progressive readings might recast historical constraints as , conservative interpreters view the earlier segments' restrained affections as embodying resilient , contrasting the modern episode's relational —evident in the protagonists' text-message non-commitment—as symptomatic of globalization's atomizing effects. Such views align with Hsiao-hsien's oeuvre, which documents Taiwan's transition without romanticizing victimhood, instead tracing causal in how economic correlates with , as noted in stylistic analyses of and disconnection. The film's cultural resonance endures in preserving autochthonous Taiwanese stories amid global homogenization, resonating in retrospectives that affirm its prescience on progress's human costs. By , twentieth-anniversary discussions, including screenings and essays, reaffirm its truth in depicting erosion under neoliberal pressures, countering emphases on grievance with intimate, data-grounded portrayals of societal —such as rising rates paralleling urban migration since the . This focus on verifiable personal narratives bolsters Taiwan's cinematic identity, resisting imported frameworks that prioritize ideological strife over lived .

References

  1. [1]
    Three Times (2005) - IMDb
    Rating 6.9/10 (6,345) Three Times, the latest film from Taiwanese master Hou Hsiao-hsien is a lyrical, sensuous, but disappointing collection of three love stories set in 1911, 1966, ...
  2. [2]
    When a lovely flame dies movie review (2006) - Roger Ebert
    Rating 4/4 · Review by Roger EbertJun 22, 2006 · Three stories about a man and a woman, all three using the same actors. · His subject in “Three Times” is our yearning to love and be loved, and ...Missing: summary | Show results with:summary
  3. [3]
    The Complexity of Minimalism: Hou Hsiao-hsien's Three Times
    May 5, 2006 · Three Times consists of three separate stories, taking place in 1966, 1911 and 2005 respectively, that on the surface deal with love, freedom and youth.
  4. [4]
    Three Times Reviews - Metacritic
    Rating 82% (22) Hou Hsiao-hsien delivers one of the most rapturously beautiful and romantic movies of the year. Told as three love stories, each set in a different era -- a ...<|separator|>
  5. [5]
    Three Times | Rotten Tomatoes
    Rating 86% (51) Amazing. The cinematography of Hou Hsiao-hsien once again embellishes the already beautiful film, like a chocolate syrup-coated cherry topping. Content ...
  6. [6]
    Three Times | Reelviews Movie Reviews
    Rating 3.0 (1) Three Times features minimal dialogue. It is mostly about mood and images, and it moves at a glacial pace. Hou is in no hurry to speed things along. He ...Missing: reception | Show results with:reception
  7. [7]
    History and Love [THREE TIMES] - Jonathan Rosenbaum
    Sep 29, 2024 · Hou Hsiao-hsien's Three Times (2005) is split into three episodes set in Taiwan, each running about 40 minutes and featuring Chang Chen and Shu Qi.
  8. [8]
    Review: Three Times - Slant Magazine
    Rating 3.5/4 · Review by Nick SchagerOct 4, 2005 · ... Times' alluring 1966-set introductory segment “A Time for Love” begins with a sultry, prolonged game of billiards at a local pool hall ...Missing: summary | Show results with:summary
  9. [9]
    Review: Three Times (Taiwan, 2005) - Cinema Escapist
    Three Times may not be a venerated old classic like A City of Sadness, but it is yet another solid, beautiful piece from Hou Hsiao-hsien.Missing: reception | Show results with:reception
  10. [10]
    THREE TIMES – Dennis Schwartz Reviews
    The first episode is entitled A Time for Love. It has the innocent newly drafted soldier Chen play a game of pool with the pretty new pool hall hostess May ...Missing: plot | Show results with:plot
  11. [11]
    Three Times (Zui hao de shi guang) (2006) - PopMatters
    Apr 28, 2006 · “A Time for Love” is set primarily in a small pool hall in Kaohsiung in 1966. It's an odd kind of place, with demure girls playing the local ...Missing: plot | Show results with:plot<|control11|><|separator|>
  12. [12]
    Three Times - Movie Review : Alternate Ending
    Jun 27, 2006 · The story in "A Time for Love" is carried on the back of The Platters' "Smoke Gets in Your Eyes" and Aphrodite's Child's "Rain and Tears ...Missing: plot summary
  13. [13]
    The Films of Hou Hsiao-Hsien - by Michael E. Grost
    Three Times. Three Times (2005) is a trilogy of three stories, each ... The hero of A Time for Love rides a bicycle. There are shots preceding him ...
  14. [14]
    Hou's 'Three Times' stands out in Cannes
    May 23, 2005 · Before going to military service, a young man, played by Chang, spends his time at a billiards halls and falls for one of the girls who works ...Missing: dedication | Show results with:dedication<|control11|><|separator|>
  15. [15]
    Three Times | Movies | The Guardian
    Aug 3, 2006 · It is a movie triptych: three stories from Taiwan, shown out of historical order and spanning the beginning of the 20th century and the beginning of the 21st.Missing: reception | Show results with:reception
  16. [16]
    Three Times - The Asian Cinema Blog
    Aug 11, 2022 · “A Time for Youth” is set in the 2005 urban jungle of Taipei. We saw ripples of Western culture in 1966, but now it's flooded with modernity, ...
  17. [17]
    Three Times - Old Yorker
    Nov 1, 2015 · Halfway through 'A Time for Youth', Jing is revealed to be bisexual and the focus switches to her relationship with a young woman called Micky ( ...
  18. [18]
    Three Times - Variety
    May 21, 2005 · Synthesizing Hou Hsiao-hsien's ambivalent relationship with time and memory, “Three Times” forms a handy connecting arc between the Taiwanese ...Missing: development | Show results with:development
  19. [19]
    Examining romance 'Three Times' - Los Angeles Times
    May 12, 2006 · In lesser hands the first segment, “A Time for Love,” set in 1966 ... A young man, Chen (Chang), meets a young pool hall hostess, May (Shu), in ...Missing: plot | Show results with:plot
  20. [20]
    Toronto Film Festival–“Three Times” - Girish Shambu
    Sep 21, 2005 · While I haven't seen Three Times (I hope I will, though), I like how Hou Hsiao-Hsien, as you mention, didn't really have a script. It's that ...
  21. [21]
    Low-budget, digital cinema has emerged as the new hope for the ...
    Oct 19, 2006 · Actors wildly improvise for hours, while a hand-held camera ... production – namely, Hou Hsiao-hsien's extraordinary Three Times (2005).<|separator|>
  22. [22]
    THREE TIMES - Festival de Cannes
    Three different times,1911,1966,2005, three stories, the same actor and actress, May et Chen, through the movie as a chant of their love of three life times.Missing: development conception Lumière
  23. [23]
    Three Times - Symposiums - Reverse Shot
    Aug 19, 2008 · Because dialogue is excised from its soundtrack, “A Time for Freedom” is the cleanest separation in Three Times between heart and mind. If there ...Missing: plot summary
  24. [24]
    Three Times | Hou Hsiao-hsien | Taiwanese Film Review - YouTube
    Apr 6, 2021 · ... hsien was forced to directed all three parts of "Three Times", utilizing his favorite actress Shu Qi and legendary cinematography Mark Lee Ping ...
  25. [25]
    Three Times (Taiwan, 2005) - UCLA Film & Television Archive
    Director: Hou Hsiao-hsien. Screenwriter: Hou Hsiao-hsien. Cinematography: Mark Lee (Ping-bin). Editor: Liao Ching-sung. Cast: Shu Qi, Chang Chen, Mei Fang ...
  26. [26]
    Three Times (2005) - MUBI
    Three Times is not currently showing on MUBI. Instead, watch The Assassin, also directed by Hou Hsiao-hsien.
  27. [27]
    A CERTAIN SLANT OF LIGHT: THE FILMS OF HOU HSIAO-HSIEN
    SIDE LIT AND GLIMMERING, the billiard balls in the opening sequences of Taiwanese master Hou Hsiao-hsien's new film Three Times, look more like objets d'art ...
  28. [28]
    Smoke Gets in Your Eyes: Hou Hsiao-hsien's Optics of Ephemerality
    May 5, 2006 · In Zui hao de shi guang (Three Times, 2005), Hou Hsiao-hsien reprises the observational, long-take aesthetic that has distinguished his work ...
  29. [29]
    TSPDT - Hou Hsiao-hsien
    Hou is an extraordinary director - gentle, reflective, beautifully composed, inclined to hold his shots in space and duration.<|separator|>
  30. [30]
    Three Times - Symposiums - Reverse Shot
    Aug 19, 2008 · Yet here in this opener, “A Time for Love,” her glamorous and indifferent introduction is as deceptive as that hazy, Wong Kar-wai-sh gauzy ...Missing: summary | Show results with:summary
  31. [31]
    Three Times – 2005 Hsiao-Hsien Hou - The Cinema Archives
    Jul 3, 2020 · A great shot here incorporates HHH's color schemes (green in section 1, red in section 2, blue in section 3), the depth field with the doors as a framing ...
  32. [32]
    Three Times (2005) | One Shot - WordPress.com
    Dec 17, 2012 · ... cinematographer of that movie, it was Mark Lee Ping Bin! (who apparently is the favorite cinematographer of Hou Hsiao-Hsien). So, not only am ...Missing: bing | Show results with:bing
  33. [33]
    The ultimate guide to Hou Hsiao-Hsien – part 3 | easternkicks.com
    Feb 3, 2016 · The shots with the camera being on ground level and the ones with the trains are actually a tribute to Ozu. In 2005, Hou shot Three Times. I ...
  34. [34]
    “A Time for Celebration”: Hou Hsiao-hsien's “Three Times” - IndieWire
    Apr 24, 2006 · “Three Times” opens in a pool hall in 1966. The Platters' “Smoke Gets in Your Eyes” serenades the players; nostalgia suffuses the scene ...
  35. [35]
    What does Hou Hsiao-Hsien achieve through the use of the long ...
    Oct 27, 2024 · One of the foremost features of realist editing in cinema is directors' utilization of particularly long takes, which are meant to ensure ...
  36. [36]
    (DOC) Hou Hsiao Hsien's long take - Academia.edu
    This research investigates Hou's long take methodology, its historical significance, and its impact on contemporary cinema. A structured approach including ...
  37. [37]
    Three Times (2005) - Soundtracks - IMDb
    Music by Jerome Kern with lyrics by Otto A. Harbach. Performed by The Platters. Rain and Tears. Written by Johann Pachelbel, Boris Bergman and Vangelis.Missing: 1911 classical
  38. [38]
    Three Times (Zui hao de shi guang) - Reeling Reviews
    While the first episode, the 1966 set "A Time for Love," is the most completely satisfying, each different pairing has something unique and fascinating to offer ...Missing: plot summary
  39. [39]
    'Three Times' Tells Three Stories of Love, Each Illuminated by an ...
    Apr 26, 2006 · 'Three Times' Tells Three Stories of Love, Each Illuminated by an Inner Light ... " But like the 2001 film, in which Shu Qi played another ...Missing: details | Show results with:details
  40. [40]
    How Japan Nurtured Taiwan's Colonial Economy - by Jon Y
    The Geopolitics of Taiwan Under Japanese Rule. At the turn of the 20th century, Japan sought to enter the ranks of the European colonizing nations. The way ...
  41. [41]
    Taiwan - 1914-1918 Online
    May 13, 2019 · The general arc of Japanese rule in Taiwan was from a highly militarized form toward civilian—though not popular—control, whereas debates over ...<|separator|>
  42. [42]
    Surviving on the Edge: Korean Brothels in Colonial Taiwan
    May 9, 2017 · Legislation stipulated that brothels and prostitutes had to be registered, and prostitutes had to undergo regular checks for sexually ...
  43. [43]
    [PDF] Standing in the Gap of Society: Korean Prostitutes in Colonial Taiwan
    State-regulated prostitution in Taiwan and Korea began only under. Japanese colonial rule. In the early colonial era, the Japanese government simply imposed.
  44. [44]
    https://oxfordre.com/asianhistory/display/10.1093/acrefore/9780190277727.001.0001/acrefore-9780190277727-e-376
  45. [45]
    Transformation of Women's Status in Taiwan, 1920-2020
    Mar 17, 2023 · During the Japanese colonial era, women had no right to vote. However, after lifting martial law in 1987, Taiwan emerged as a vibrant democracy.
  46. [46]
    Diversity in Taiwan - EUROVIEW
    Oct 22, 2021 · By the end of the Japanese era, 60% of girls were going to school, although higher education was heavily restricted for fear of generating ...Missing: period | Show results with:period
  47. [47]
    [PDF] The Comfort Women and State Prostitution
    May 15, 2018 · Japan's prewar system of government-approved prostitution (kōshō seido) was based on the inspection, certification, and licensing of brothels in ...
  48. [48]
    Taiwan (11/02) - State.gov
    Since ending martial law, Taiwan has taken dramatic steps to improve respect for human rights and create a democratic political system. Almost all restrictions ...
  49. [49]
    Martial Law - OFTaiwan
    During this period of martial law, there were no political parties, no human rights, and no free speech. Civilians were tried in military court, people's ...
  50. [50]
    Taiwan's Miracle Development: Its Economy over a Century
    Aug 20, 2024 · It is well known that, since World War II, Taiwan has achieved two miracles, an “economic miracle” and a “political miracle.”
  51. [51]
    [PDF] The Social and Political Bases for Women's Growing ... - CORE
    Politically, the results of the KMT regime for women were in between those of Eastern Europe/Soviet Union and Latin America. The 1946 Constitution guaranteed ...
  52. [52]
    Women's Labour, Kinship, and Economic Changes in Jinmen in the ...
    As mentioned earlier, in the late 1960s the KMT proposed a campaign aimed at preserving and protecting traditional Chinese culture against an opposing such ...
  53. [53]
    THREE TIMES (Hou Hsiao-hsien, 2005) - Dennis Grunes
    Mar 4, 2008 · Each in its way is a romance, and perhaps the most extraordinary thing about the film is that each segment ends in a suspended state, unresolved.Missing: analysis fragmentation alienation
  54. [54]
    The many voices behind Taiwan New Cinema - BFI
    May 9, 2025 · Taiwan New Cinema is often discussed as an auteur-led movement, largely framed around internationally acclaimed directors like Hou Hsiao-hsien and Edward Yang.
  55. [55]
    https://www.criterion.com/current/posts/7989-taiwanese-new-waves-in-new-york
  56. [56]
    Hou Hsiao-hsien, Anthologized - Fandor Keyframe
    Hou Hsiao-hsien, Anthologized. Fandor Staff,; November 9, 2014. THREE TIMES. 'Three Times' ... which was commissioned for the 60th Cannes Film Festival.<|separator|>
  57. [57]
    Masters of Modern World Cinema: Hou Hsiao-Hsien (Part 2)
    Oct 31, 2018 · Following the humanist stance of his biographical trilogy of coming-of-age films and the decline of the Taiwan New Cinema (both discussed in ...
  58. [58]
    Café Lumière as Hou Hsiao-Hsien's Own and as a Homage to ...
    In Café Lumière, Ozu is but one of Hou's influences. ... Café Lumière is and will always be recognized as a Hou Hsiao‐Hsien film made in the true essence of ...
  59. [59]
    Train to Somewhere: Hou Hsiao-hsien Pays Sweet Homage to Ozu ...
    Apr 30, 2005 · Much has been made of the parallels, if not direct influences, between Ozu's and Hou's work. Hou apparently only discovered Ozu in the late ...
  60. [60]
    A City of Sadness: Hou Hsiao-hsien On Post-War Taiwan - Asap Art
    Jul 15, 2024 · ... 1987, when martial law was lifted. With it, A City of Sadness became the first movie to focus on this tumultuous era of Taiwan's history ...
  61. [61]
    Island on the Edge: Taiwan New Cinema and After - jstor
    This is the first English-language anthology on the Taiwan New Cinema and its legacy. It is an exciting collection which covers all the major filmmakers from ...
  62. [62]
    [PDF] “The Taipei Experience” in the Post Taiwan New Cinema Ellen Y
    As the globalization of Taipei accelerates, the discussion of a Taiwanese identity is confronted by the massive transformation of the Taipei cityscape, in which.
  63. [63]
    White Terror Period - National Human Rights Museum
    Martial Law was promulgated in Taiwan by Taiwan Garrison Command on May 19th and was effective on the following day. Statutes for the Punishment of Rebellion ...
  64. [64]
    [PDF] Taiwan Miracle Redux: Navigating Economic Challenges in a ...
    to wonder whether Taiwan's democratic institutions are capable of delivering the same kinds of economic successes delivered by the KMT during the martial law.<|separator|>
  65. [65]
    Becoming Japanese: Colonial Taiwan and the Politics of Identity ...
    In Becoming Japanese, Leo Ching examines the formation of Taiwanese political and cultural identities under the dominant Japanese colonial discourse.
  66. [66]
    (PDF) 'Nothing changes' in Hou Hsiao-hsien's 'Three Times'
    May 30, 2021 · PDF | Three Times (2005) is Hou's second film starring Shu Qi wherein she journeys through Taiwan's recent historical periods.Missing: motivations anthology
  67. [67]
    NGOs, the state, and democracy under globalization: The case of ...
    Aug 25, 2005 · Hsiao, H. H. M. (2005). NGOs, the state, and democracy under globalization: The case of Taiwan. In Civil Life, Globalization and Political ...
  68. [68]
    Economic Globalization Under a New Cold War - MIT Press Direct
    Oct 1, 2024 · Politically, Taiwan transitioned from a one-party system under the KMT to a multiparty democracy system after lifting restrictions on party ...Abstract · Introduction · Taiwan's economic and... · The U.S.–China competition...<|separator|>
  69. [69]
    Three Times critic reviews - Metacritic
    As such, it's an interesting essay but certainly a minor work from a master. It's simply one of the most beautiful films he's (Hou Hsiao Hsien) made to date.Missing: score | Show results with:score
  70. [70]
    Three Times - Movie Review - Stylus Magazine
    Set in a brothel in 1911, Hou fans will immediately note the similarities to his 1998 masterpiece, Flowers of Shanghai. Personally, I find the differences ...Missing: reconstructed | Show results with:reconstructed
  71. [71]
    Film review: 'Three Times' is too much - Deseret News
    the last one — is definitely the least interesting of the ...<|separator|>
  72. [72]
    Awards - Three Times (2005) - IMDb
    Chang Chen and Shu Qi in Three Times (2005). 2006 Nominee VVFP Award. Best Film. 7th place. · Chang Chen and Shu Qi in Three Times (2005). 2005 Winner VVFP Award.Missing: rating | Show results with:rating<|separator|>
  73. [73]
    Three Times (2005) - Release info - IMDb
    Chang Chen and Shu Qi in Three Times (2005). Release info. Three Times. Jump to ... (Toronto International Film Festival). Hong Kong. September 29, 2005 ...
  74. [74]
    2005 Pusan International Film Festival Report - Koreanfilm.org
    Nov 19, 2005 · The opening night film Three Times by Hou Hsiao-Hsien, in contrast ... awards in the West through the Rotterdam or Berlin Film Festivals.<|separator|>
  75. [75]
    Pusan fest pops with fans, Hou pic - Variety
    Pusan fest pops with fans, Hou pic. Fest celebrates 10th anni with 'Three Times' preem. By Derek Elley.
  76. [76]
    guests - Golden Apricot
    Among the main winners of the festival there were Ararat by Atom Egoyan, 2004, The Sun by Aleksandr Sokurov, 2005, Three Times by Hou Hsiao-hsien, 2006.
  77. [77]
    Golden Apricot Yerevan International Film Festival (2006) - IMDb
    7.9 (1.9K) Rate. Best Film. [object Object]. Winner. Three Times. 6.9 (6.3K) Rate. Hsiao-Hsien Hou. Silver Apricot - Special Prize. Edit. Best Documentary.
  78. [78]
    Three Times - New Zealand International Film Festival
    Three Times 2005. Zuihaode shigang. Directed by Hou Hsiao-hsien. The great ... Cannes (In Competition), Toronto, New York 2005; Rotterdam 2006. Elsewhere.Missing: premiere | Show results with:premiere
  79. [79]
    'Kung Fu Hustle' wins at the Golden Horse - China Daily
    Nov 14, 2005 · Actress Shu Qi took one of top prizes for Taiwan for her leading role in "Three Times," featuring three stories set in three different times but ...
  80. [80]
    HK Blockbusters Dominate Golden Horse Awards - China.org.cn
    Nov 15, 2005 · Legendary Taiwanese auteur Hou Hsiao-hsien's Three Times lost to Chow despite nine nominations. (Xinhua News Agency November 15, 2005) ...
  81. [81]
    Three Times - Wikipedia
    Three Times is a 2005 Taiwanese film directed by Hou Hsiao-hsien. It consists of three separate stories of romance, set in different eras, using the same ...
  82. [82]
    'Kung Fu Hustle' wins five Golden Horse awards | CBC News
    Nov 14, 2005 · Hou Hsiao-hsien, director of Three Times, was honoured with the Best Taiwanese Film-Maker award. "Making movies with Hou (Hsiao-hsien) is really ...
  83. [83]
    HK stars gallop away from the pack at Golden Horse awards
    Nov 14, 2005 · Director Hou Hsiao-hsien also won the award for best film worker for his Three Times. Advertisement. Kung Fu Hustle, the action-comedy by ...
  84. [84]
    Kung Fu Hustle rides off on Golden Horse | Movies | The Guardian
    Oct 19, 2005 · ... Hou Hsiao-Hsien's Three Times, with eight nominations including best film, best director, best actor and best actress. The Golden Horse ...
  85. [85]
    Golden Horse Awards 2005: Blockbuster Action Comedy
    Hou Hsiao-Hsien – Three Times * Stephen Chow – Kung Fu Hustle. Best Actor Tony Leung Ka Fai – Election Chang Chen – Three Times Chen Khen – A West Lake ...<|separator|>
  86. [86]
    Three Times (最好的時光) (2005) - LoveHKFilm.com
    As could be expected with any art film, Hou Hsiao-Hsien's Three Times is not for everyone. ... • Nomination - Best Director (Hou Hsiao-Hsien) • Nomination ...
  87. [87]
    Three Times (2005, Hou Hsiao-hsien) - Deeper Into Movies
    Three Times (2005, Hou Hsiao-hsien). February 4, 2010 by Brandon·Comments Off on Three Times (2005, Hou Hsiao-hsien) ... Shanghai and Goodbye South, Goodbye) but lately I've decided that those two ...
  88. [88]
    10 Directors to Watch: Barry Jenkins on 'Moonlight' - Variety
    Jan 3, 2017 · ... inspired by the Hou Hsiao-Hsien film “Three Times,” deciding to divide the structure into three chapters played by separate actors. Related ...
  89. [89]
    6 films you should watch before you see Moonlight - BFI
    Feb 10, 2017 · Three Times (2005) ... Breaking down Moonlight into three chapters is one of the many inspired ideas that Jenkins adopts in the film – and also ...<|separator|>
  90. [90]
    Thai director Apichatpong Weerasethakul brings 'Syndromes and a ...
    ... Hou Hsiao-Hsien ("Three Times," "Flowers of Shanghai"). He likes the way those filmmakers "have their own rhythm," and set out to discover his own style ...
  91. [91]
    THE BEST OF TIMES The Films of Hou Hsiao-Hsien - The Brooklyn ...
    Drawing upon the histories of colonialism, martial law, and post-martial law in Taiwan, Hou's style is marked by his nostalgia for the “Orphan of Asia,” its ...Missing: settings | Show results with:settings<|separator|>
  92. [92]
    [PDF] The State of Taiwan Film in the 1960s and 1970s - HKU Press
    A reevaluation of Taiwan's filmmaking tradition is most evident in Three Times in the most trying of segments for first-time viewers, due to the intensity of ...
  93. [93]
    [PDF] UC San Diego Electronic Theses and Dissertations - eScholarship
    Three Times…………………………………………………….…….. 38. A Time for Freedom………….…………………………………….… 39. A Time for Love ... bike-ride-through-the- countryside scene. Then the ...
  94. [94]
    The Triptych - Marshall and the Movies
    May 8, 2025 · But file Hou Hsiao-Hsien's Three Times somewhere in the back of your memory to seek out the next time it is streamable (or perhaps you see it in ...Missing: modernization critique<|separator|>