Fact-checked by Grok 2 weeks ago

Tusheti

Tusheti is a remote, in eastern , situated on the northern slopes of the Mountains within the Kakheti province's Akhmeta Municipality. It encompasses rugged terrain with elevations ranging from 900 to 4,492 meters, including prominent peaks such as Tebulo at 4,492 meters and Diklo at 4,285 meters, and is bordered by the Russian republics of and to the north. The region features deep valleys, waterfalls, and over 230 endemic plant , forming the core of Tusheti , a spanning 83,007 hectares. Known for its isolation—accessible primarily via the Abano Pass at 2,900 meters only during late summer—it preserves ancient traditions, fortified stone towers, and Europe's highest permanent settlement, Bochorna, at 2,345 meters. Geographically, Tusheti's landscape supports a with average temperatures of 3–8°C in winter and 14–15°C in summer, along with annual of 450–900 mm, fostering diverse and . The region divides into four communities—Pirikita, Gometsari, Tsovata, and Chagma—with Omalo serving as the administrative center; it includes around 40 villages, though only about 10 maintain year-round inhabitants, while others are seasonal or abandoned. This sparsity underscores Tusheti's role as a UNESCO tentative , valued for its pristine natural environment and as a trekking destination. Historically, human settlement in Tusheti dates to the Late , with more consistent records emerging from the AD, including defensive towers dating from the medieval period. The area was incorporated into the Kingdom of in the under King Levan, marking the expansion of and the construction of towers in the 17th–18th centuries to counter raids from neighboring and . By the late , architecture evolved to include multi-story dwellings with balconies, reflecting adaptations to the harsh mountainous life. Culturally, Tusheti stands out for its distinct Tush traditions, including livestock breeding focused on sheep and cows, production of renowned Guda cheese, and crafts like knitting woolen socks, hats, and rugs. Festivals such as Lasharoba celebrate pagan roots with songs accompanied by the harmonica, while cuisine features specialties like Tushetian khinkali dumplings and kotori khachapuri bread. Ancient shrines in villages like Shenako and Dartlo, alongside the iconic stone towers, highlight a heritage of self-sufficient mountain communities that blend Orthodox Christianity with pre-Christian elements.

Geography

Location and Borders

Tusheti is a highland historical region situated in the northeastern part of Georgia, centered approximately at 42°30′N 45°30′E, within the Greater Caucasus Mountains. This positioning places it on the northern slopes of the mountain range, emphasizing its remote and elevated character far from major urban centers. The region encompasses an area of about 969 km², making it a compact yet rugged territory dominated by alpine landscapes. Its borders are defined by natural features of the Caucasus: to the north and east, it is delimited by the crests of the Greater Caucasus, adjoining the Russian republics of Chechnya and Dagestan, respectively, across closed international boundaries. To the south, it transitions into the lowlands of the Kakheti region, while to the west, it abuts the adjacent Pshav-Khevsureti area, forming a contiguous highland zone within Georgia. Access to Tusheti is primarily through challenging mountain passes, underscoring its isolation. The main southern entry is via the Abano Pass at 2,826 m elevation, a steep, unpaved route from the Kakheti lowlands near , traversable mainly by four-wheel-drive vehicles during summer months. From the west, the Atsunta Pass provides an alternative trekking route connecting to the region, historically used by locals despite its high altitude exceeding 3,400 m. Historically, Tusheti's passes have functioned as vital corridors across the for seasonal migrations and localized trade, facilitating the annual of shepherds and their livestock between highland summer pastures and lowland winter grazing areas in , a practice dating back centuries. These routes also supported the exchange of goods such as Tushetian Guda cheese and wool, which were transported southward for broader markets.

Terrain and Climate

Tusheti's terrain is characterized by high alpine valleys situated on the northern slopes of the Mountains, encompassing the southern flanks of the Pirikita Range and the inter-mountain depression of the Tusheti plateau. The landscape features rugged peaks reaching up to 4,500 meters, including notable summits such as Tebulo Mountain at 4,493 meters and Diklo (Diklosmta) at 4,285 meters, along with glacial formations from that have shaped moraines and cirques. Deep river gorges, such as those carved by the Pirikita Alazani and Gometsari Alazani rivers, dominate the topography, interspersed with plateaus like the Omalo depression and elevated ridges such as the Speroza and Makratela. The region's hydrology centers on the Alazani River system, with the Pirikita Alazani and Gometsari Alazani serving as primary tributaries that converge near Omalo at approximately 1,600 meters elevation to form the Andi Koysu River, which ultimately drains into the via the Sulak River. Smaller streams, such as the Larovanis-tskali, Khisos-tskali, and Tsovatistskali, feed into these main channels, originating from glacial lakes and highland springs that contribute to seasonal water flows. The area experiences risks of seasonal flooding and associated landslides due to intense spring and summer rainfall, which can exacerbate in the steep gorges and impact highland marshes. Tusheti exhibits a continental highland climate, moderated by its temperate humid influences, featuring long, dry, cold winters and short summers with significant diurnal temperature variations. In representative low-valley areas like Omalo, average annual temperatures hover around 3.5°C, with averages at -9.1°C (extremes reaching -36°C) and at 14.2°C (extremes up to 31°C), while higher elevations experience even colder conditions and persistent snow cover above 3,400 meters. Precipitation is relatively high for the eastern , ranging from 700–900 mm annually in the Pirikita valleys (with peaks up to 1,631 mm at passes like Sakorne), concentrated mainly from to , supporting meadows though increasing variability poses risks to water availability. Elevations in Tusheti span from about 1,500–1,600 meters in the main valleys to over 3,000 meters at high passes like Abano (2,826 meters) and Sakorne, fostering diverse microclimates that transition from forested lower slopes to nival zones with permanent snowfields. This vertical gradient influences local weather patterns, with northern exposures receiving slightly more from adjacent borders, contributing to cooler, wetter conditions in gorges compared to sunnier plateaus.

History

Early Settlement and Ancient History

Archaeological evidence indicates that human habitation in Tusheti dates back to the , with significant finds uncovered at sites such as Kurekhi hill, where artifacts from the 21st-22nd centuries BCE suggest early pastoralist s focused on mineral resource extraction and ritual practices. Excavations at Nishtako hill have revealed additional layers from the Early , including everyday tools and cult items, confirming the region's role as a outpost for prehistoric communities. These discoveries, primarily from the 1975 expedition led by archaeologist Rusudan Dolaberidze of the , highlight Tusheti's integration into broader networks, though systematic study remains limited. The ancient inhabitants of Tusheti were part of the diverse Caucasian tribal landscape, with the Tush people first referenced in classical sources as the "Touskoi," a group situated between the and neighboring tribes like the Didouri (likely Didos from ). This mention appears in Ptolemy's Geography (2nd century CE), portraying them as one of several proto-Caucasian groups in the northern highlands. Proto-Georgian tribes, associated with the emerging (), began influencing the area during the reign of King Parnavaz I in the 3rd century BCE, marking initial ethnic penetrations into lands previously dominated by Vainakh-speaking groups. Neighboring —ancestors of modern and Ingush—exerted cultural and territorial pressures, as evidenced by historical accounts of inter-tribal interactions and migrations in the southern . Further consolidation occurred in the 3rd-4th centuries CE during the Kingdom of period, with geographical texts referencing "Tush" lands in the highland territories now known as Tusheti. These references, including those in works attributed to (7th century CE), situate the Tush among northern polities, underscoring early ties to Iberian expansions. Oral traditions and local legends preserve accounts of ancient highland clans establishing fortified villages, often invoking mythological figures like the pagan deity Tushol and cosmogonic myths of settlement amid rugged terrain. These narratives, shared through epic tales, reflect foundational clan structures and interactions with neighboring Vainakh groups, blending historical migrations with symbolic origins of communal defense.

Medieval and Early Modern Period

During the medieval period, Tusheti became integrated into the Kingdom of around the 8th to 10th centuries, serving as a strategic defensive frontier against northern invasions from Dagestani and other Caucasian groups. The region's highland clans, known as Tushs, maintained close ties with 's lowland populations, adopting by the and providing military support to the kingdom's rulers. This affiliation positioned Tusheti as a , where local warriors guarded mountain passes and participated in broader defenses, while benefiting from grants such as access to lowland pastures in the Alazani Valley. Tusheti's feudal structure reflected semi-autonomy under Georgian kings, with local lords known as eristavis (dukes) appointed from prominent families like the Choloqashvili to oversee highland clans. These eristavis, often titled mouravis (governors), managed administration and justice through councils like the Patriarchs' Council and general assemblies at sacred sites such as Mirgval Veli, emphasizing over strict feudal obligations. The Tushs, largely free from lowland due to their isolation, focused on and border guardianship, paying tribute in livestock or rather than land-based . In the 16th to 18th centuries, Tusheti faced intensified raids from Dagestani khanates and Chechen groups, prompting the construction of defensive clan towers across villages like Omalo and Keselo. Tush warriors actively resisted these incursions and contributed to efforts against external threats, including dominance in the . A pivotal event was the Battle of Bakhtrioni in 1659, where Tush forces under leader Zezva Gaprindauli allied with rebels to defeat invading troops at the Bakhtrioni Fortress, securing perpetual rights to pastures in the Alvani Valley as a reward for their heroism. This victory, celebrated in epic poetry, underscored Tusheti's role in sustaining regional autonomy amid ongoing conflicts.

Modern Developments

Tusheti was annexed by the in 1801 as part of the Kingdom of Kartli-Kakheti, integrating the region into imperial administration and marking the end of its relative autonomy. During the first half of the , Tushs allied with Russian forces in the (1817–1864), contributing to campaigns against the North Caucasian imamate and helping secure the southern borders, which reduced raids from and . Imperial surveys and exploratory missions laid the groundwork for later documentation, with Tush shepherds maintaining economies centered on sheep breeding and wool trade amid emerging migrations to Kakhetian lowlands due to land policies and natural disasters. Under Soviet rule from 1921 to 1991, Tusheti experienced forced collectivization in , which curtailed private livestock ownership and shifted pastoral economies toward state-controlled collectives, though implementation remained superficial due to persistent patriarchal structures. The scientific expedition, led by ethnographer Sergi Makalatia and documented by traveler A. Dedimov, provided the first systematic study of Tushetian , , and daily life, highlighting the region's and cultural . By the 1950s, repressive resettlement policies relocated many families to the Alvani lowlands, deeming highland villages like Omalo economically unviable, which initiated partial depopulation and abandonment of mountain settlements while Soviet infrastructure—such as schools, roads, and electrification—began to connect the area. Following Georgia's independence in , Tusheti saw a revival of through the resurgence of traditional festivals, shepherding practices, and clan-based , supported by the return of seasonal migrations after the collapse of Soviet subsidies. The 2008 heightened border tensions along Tusheti's northern frontier with Russia's republics, prompting locals to serve as informal border guards amid increased military presence and restricted cross-border movements. As of 2025, ongoing efforts to nominate the Mta-Tusheti cultural landscape for World Heritage status emphasize its unique alpine towers, heritage, and , building on its 2007 inclusion on the tentative list to promote preservation and .

Administrative Divisions

Communities and Villages

Tusheti is traditionally divided into four historical communities, each occupying distinct gorges and valleys along the northern slopes of the Mountains. These communities—Pirikiti in the central region around the Pirikiti Alazani River, Gometsari in the western Tushetis Alazani gorge, Chagma (also spelled Chaghma) in the northeastern area, and Tsovata (or Tsova) in the eastern Tsova gorge—formed the socio-geographical framework of the region, with residents historically tied to specific highland territories for seasonal herding and settlement. The Pirikiti community centers on Omalo, the administrative hub of Tusheti at approximately 1,880 meters elevation, serving as the primary and base for visitors with its cluster of guesthouses and facilities. Nearby in the same gorge lies Dartlo, a settlement renowned for its preserved medieval stone architecture, contributing to Tusheti's inclusion on UNESCO's Tentative List of World Heritage Sites. In the Gometsari gorge, Verkhovani stands out as a key village at around 1,910 meters, notable for housing Tusheti's tallest defensive tower at 17 meters. Further northeast in the Chagma community, Bochorna perches at 2,345 meters near the border, marking it as Europe's highest continuously inhabited settlement despite its sparse year-round population; as of 2024, it has only one permanent resident. Tusheti encompasses over 50 historical settlements scattered across these communities, though many remain abandoned due to mid-20th-century forced relocations and the challenges of high-altitude living, with only about 10 actively used today. These villages typically consist of compact clusters of stone houses and towers on steep, sun-exposed slopes, optimized for defense and protection, and are primarily occupied seasonally from to autumn by transhumant herders who migrate to the highlands for summer pastures. Inter-community relations have long been characterized by alliances for mutual against external raids from the 16th to 19th centuries, exemplified by shared fortified structures like the Keselo fortress overlooking Omalo, and cooperative management of pastures to prevent disputes, as regulated by decrees in the late 18th century.

Governance and Infrastructure

Tusheti forms part of Georgia's region and is administratively within Akhmeta Municipality, with no independent regional of its own. The majority of the area, including its protected landscapes, falls under Akhmeta Municipality, where local self- operates through the municipal sakrebulo (assembly) that includes representatives from Tushetian communities. Local in Tusheti emphasizes involvement in , coordinated by the Akhmeta municipal , which manages the Tusheti Protected through a dedicated established in 2011. This structure integrates traditional practices with formal processes, such as consultations for resource use and among residents, often handled informally through elder-led discussions before escalating to municipal levels. Since the establishment of the Tusheti protected areas in 2003, has involved collaboration between the municipal and the national Agency of Protected Areas (APA), which oversees the Tusheti State Nature Reserve (founded in 1981) and to ensure conservation while supporting local needs like sustainable grazing and . Infrastructure in Tusheti remains rudimentary due to its high-altitude, remote location, with access primarily via a seasonal 4WD track over the Abano Pass at 2,900 meters from the lowlands to Omalo, spanning approximately 50 kilometers and open only from early June to early October depending on weather. There are no railways or major highways connecting the region, limiting year-round vehicular access and relying on footpaths or multi-day treks for internal travel between villages. is provided through installations in main villages like Omalo and Dartlo, serving around 200 households and public facilities since 2016, supplemented by small hydroelectric systems in some areas; in June 2025, a 15 kW station was installed in Bochorna, providing reliable for the first time. Water supply consists of basic communal systems drawing from mountain springs, with running water available in guesthouses but often limited in more isolated settlements. Emergency services depend heavily on operations by the Ministry of Internal Affairs' Border Police, which conducts regular flights for medical evacuations, , and resident support during winter closures. As of 2025, development challenges include enhancing and , addressed through ongoing projects such as the UNDP-supported Plan for Tusheti Protected Areas (2024–2025), which focuses on eco-infrastructure improvements like pasture management and resilience to hazards. EU-funded initiatives under programs like ENPI-FLEG have also supported and border-area eco-infrastructure since the early , aiding local administration in balancing security with .

Demographics

In the late , Tusheti's population was recorded at approximately 4,074 permanent inhabitants according to the 1897 Georgian census, reflecting a associated with traditional economies across 50 villages and over 1,000 households. The figure remained approximately stable around 5,000 into the early , sustained by seasonal practices where families migrated with livestock between highland summer pastures and lowland winter settlements. Soviet-era policies accelerated outmigration from the onward, driven by collectivization, economic pressures, and improved lowland opportunities, reducing the permanent to 101 by the 1989 . This trend intensified post-Soviet collapse, with harsh isolation—exacerbated by the region's six-month annual inaccessibility due to snow-blocked passes—compounding , low birth rates, and limited , leading to further depopulation. A 2011 socio-economic survey documented 63 permanent residents across 17 households, highlighting the shift to predominantly seasonal occupancy. The 2014 recorded 47 permanent residents in the Tusheti administrative . Contemporary patterns underscore this decline, with permanent residents numbering under 100 as of the mid- and recent estimates indicating 10-20 year-round inhabitants as of 2025, while summer populations swell to over 1,000 through returning herders and families engaged in . Economic hardship and geographic barriers remain primary drivers, though tourism growth since the —evidenced by a 54% rise in high-mountain visitors from 2015 to 2022—has fostered slight stabilization. Projections indicate the permanent population will likely remain below 200 through 2030 absent major interventions like upgrades and economic incentives, as high-mountain settlements overall face a 3.07% decline from 2015-2023.

Ethnic Composition and Language

The inhabitants of Tusheti are predominantly the Tush people, a subgroup of ethnic who form the core of the region's demographic identity. The Tush are traditionally divided into two main communities: the Chaghma-Tush, who primarily reside in the central and eastern parts of Tusheti and speak a local dialect of , and the Tsova-Tush, also known as the , concentrated in the village of Tsova and surrounding areas. This ethnic homogeneity reflects Tusheti's historical isolation in the high , where the Tush have maintained a distinct yet integrated cultural framework. The Bats subgroup, or Tsova-Tush, represents a unique linguistic minority within the Tush population, with approximately 500 fluent speakers of the Batsbi language as of recent assessments. Batsbi belongs to the Nakh branch of the Northeast Caucasian language family, sharing linguistic affinities with Chechen and Ingush, yet the Bats people identify strongly as ethnic Georgians and have deep cultural ties to broader Georgian society. Despite these connections, the Bats maintain traditional practices that distinguish them within Tusheti, though intermarriage and assimilation with Chaghma-Tush communities have influenced their social fabric. Beyond the Tush majority, Tusheti experiences a minor influx of ethnic from the lowland regions of eastern , who occasionally settle or work seasonally in the area due to its administrative ties to province. Additionally, Russian border guards have been present intermittently along Tusheti's northern frontier with Russia's republics, stemming from historical bilateral agreements, but they do not constitute a permanent non- population. Overall, no significant non- ethnic groups maintain a lasting presence, preserving Tusheti's overwhelmingly character. Linguistically, the dominant tongue in Tusheti is the Tushetian dialect of , part of the Kartvelian , which serves as the everyday for most Chaghma-Tush residents and facilitates communication across the region. In contrast, Batsbi remains severely endangered, classified as such by due to its declining speaker base and limited intergenerational transmission, exacerbated by broader in Tusheti. Efforts to document and revitalize Batsbi continue through academic fieldwork, underscoring its vulnerability within this linguistically diverse yet Georgian-dominant enclave.

Culture

Traditions and Customs

The Tush people of Tusheti practice a form of religious syncretism where Orthodox Christianity, adopted in the 8th–9th centuries, coexists with pre-Christian pagan elements, including rituals honoring mountain spirits known as jvari through shrines called khati. These khati serve as sacred sites for offerings and prayers, often restricted to men and guarded by designated individuals called khelosani, reflecting a blend of Christian saints and ancient deities like Karate and Kopala. A notable pre-Christian holdover is the avoidance of pork, considered unclean and associated with bad luck, which persists despite the Orthodox faith and ties to ancient pastoral taboos. Festivals in Tusheti emphasize communal rituals that merge Christian holidays with pagan practices, such as Atengenoba, a cycle of summer celebrations beginning around 100 days after and extending into late or early . This event, dedicated to Saint Athenogenes, involves brewing sacred (aludi) in designated huts by men only, animal sacrifices at khati shrines, horse races, and separate feasting for men and women, all coordinated by an elected shulta host. Other festivals like Lasharoba in Shenako include week-long rites with sacrifices and races to honor protective spirits, while Tushetoba in Omalo celebrates shepherds through crafts, music, and feasts. Social customs revolve around clan and village brotherhoods, fostering hospitality through elaborate feasts where guests are welcomed with toasts led by a and shared meals emphasizing communal bonds. Gender roles are pronounced in herding and rituals, with men traditionally dominating and access, though women manage production and duties; menstruation bars women from sacred sites to preserve harmony. Oral heritage is preserved through epic songs and proverbs recited during festivals and gatherings, recounting historical events like the Battle of Bakhtrioni in 1659, which honors Tush heroes such as Zezva Gaprindauli and reinforces collective identity. These narratives, sung in the Tushetian dialect, blend with , transmitted across generations to maintain cultural amid seasonal migrations.

Architecture and Arts

Tusheti's architecture is characterized by its style, adapted to the rugged alpine terrain of the Mountains, featuring fortress-like structures designed for defense and communal protection. The region is renowned for its defensive towers, known as koshki, which served as watchtowers and fortifications against invasions from neighboring tribes, often reaching heights of up to 20 meters and dating primarily to the 17th and 18th centuries. These towers, along with residential stone houses called sakhli—characterized by flat roofs and multi-story designs—form the core of Tushetian settlements, particularly in villages like Dartlo, where they create a clustered layout that enhances mutual defense and integrates seamlessly with steep slopes. Buildings are constructed using local materials such as layered slate stone for walls and wood for structural elements like balconies and roofs, allowing for dry-stone techniques that withstand harsh weather while adapting to the through terraced foundations. This architectural ensemble exemplifies a of high integrity, recognized on UNESCO's Tentative World Heritage List since 2007 under the entry "Mta-Tusheti," which highlights the authenticity of its fortress-like residential buildings and their harmony with the natural environment. Villages such as Dartlo, with their dense groupings of towers and houses perched on rocky outcrops, illustrate this protective clustering, where structures are positioned to overlook valleys and support communal vigilance. Tushetian arts reflect the region's pastoral and spiritual life, with traditional crafts emphasizing functionality and . Wood carving adorns household items like furniture and utensils, featuring intricate geometric patterns and that add decorative elements to everyday objects. weaving, using local sheep's wool, produces durable clothing such as tunics and nabadi cloaks, often incorporating simple motifs like solar symbols and crosses for protection and identity. Icon painting graces the interiors of historic churches, such as those in Tusheti's sacred sites, where 17th-century examples depict religious figures in a blending Byzantine influences with local traditions. Preservation efforts for Tusheti's architectural and artistic heritage have intensified since the early 2000s, with restorations of key sites like defense towers and churches undertaken between 2006 and 2011 to maintain structural integrity and promote cultural continuity. Ongoing initiatives, including projects by the World Monuments Fund since 2017 that focus on sites like Keselo and community workshops on heritage restoration as of 2021, continue to support these efforts. The Tusheti Protected Areas Management Plan emphasizes sustainable rehabilitation, including the development of traditional architectural standards and community involvement in maintenance. However, ongoing depopulation—exacerbated since the 1950s by seasonal migration and economic shifts, leaving only about 40 permanent winter residents—poses significant threats, as reduced local stewardship risks the deterioration of unoccupied structures and the loss of artisanal knowledge.

Economy and Tourism

Traditional Economy

The traditional economy of Tusheti revolves around , with sheep and herding forming the cornerstone of subsistence for local communities. This practice sustains a significant portion of the , providing essential resources for daily needs and limited exchange. Central to this economy is seasonal , where herders drive flocks of sheep and —often numbering in the hundreds per farm—from highland summer pastures in Tusheti to lowland winter grazing areas in the Alazani Valley, including Alvani. These migration rights trace back to grants by Kakhetian kings in the 16th and 17th centuries, in recognition of Tushetian military support. Journeys typically span several days on foot, covering rugged terrain to access milder winter conditions. Primary products from herding include Tushetian Guda cheese, a hard, sheep's milk variety ripened in traditional bags (guda), which embodies centuries-old production techniques passed down through generations. from local breeds supports textile weaving, yielding durable fabrics for clothing and trade, while limited and for wild herbs supplement household resources. These outputs emphasize self-sufficiency, with cheese and historically comprising the bulk of surplus production. In the pre-Soviet period, Tushetians engaged in regional , exporting cheese, , and sturdy mountain to and beyond, including to , where these goods fetched value in lowland markets. Horses facilitated transport of products across difficult paths, bolstering economic ties until collectivization in the Soviet era shifted operations to state farms, curtailing independent . Contemporary challenges threaten this system, including climate variability that exacerbates and in winter pastures, leading to diminished vegetation and smaller herd sizes—averaging around 800 sheep per farm as of 2013. Post-1991, the dissolution of Soviet collectives has disrupted self-sufficiency, introducing volatile pasture leasing costs (up to GEL 10,000 per season) and inadequate , compelling many herders toward diversification while striving to preserve traditions.

Modern Tourism and Conservation

Tourism in Tusheti has evolved from a niche activity focused on trekking in the , when the region was largely isolated following the Soviet Union's collapse, to a significant draw for adventure seekers by the . Early visitors were primarily hardy exploring remote trails, but numbers grew steadily, driven by improved regional promotion and infrastructure. As of 2018, annual visitors exceeded 15,000, reflecting a 10% rise from 2017 and highlighting Tusheti's appeal through attractions like trails to the dramatic Chaukhi Massif, known for its jagged peaks and alpine scenery accessible via multi-day routes from nearby areas. This growth has positioned Tusheti as a premier destination for nature-based within 's high mountains, with numbers continuing to increase in line with national trends (over 5 million international visitors to in 2024). Access to Tusheti remains challenging due to its remote location, with the primary route involving rugged jeep tours from , taking 8-10 hours over the Abano Pass, which is only open from to October. Visitors typically arrange 4WD transport through local operators, often including professional guides for safety on the unpaved roads and to navigate weather-related risks. In Omalo, the main entry village, basic facilities such as guesthouses and homestays provide accommodation, with guided tours essential for exploring trails and villages like Dartlo and Shenako, ensuring compliance with seasonal access restrictions. Conservation efforts have intensified post-2015 to balance tourism growth with , supported by the -Georgia Agreement's commitments to and sustainable practices. The Georgian government, in collaboration with the and organizations like UNDP, has implemented programs for eco- management in Tusheti Protected Areas, including visitor limits to mitigate from foot traffic on sensitive trails. These initiatives feature zoning plans and a proposed tourism levy to fund habitat restoration and trail maintenance, promoting low-impact activities while preserving the region's cultural and . Ongoing projects as of 2024 include climate adaptation planning for protected areas. Economically, serves as the dominant seasonal driver in Tusheti, generating substantial income during the short and creating in guiding, homestays, and transport, which support rural livelihoods and reduce outmigration by supplementing traditional economies. This sector's expansion has accelerated , though is key to avoiding overburdening limited resources.

Protected Areas

Tusheti

Tusheti was established on April 22, 2003, as one of eight new protected areas approved by the under the Law on the Establishment and Management of Specially Protected Areas. Covering 83,453 hectares, it forms a core component of the broader Tusheti Protected Areas, which include buffer zones and total approximately 113,660 hectares across the , state , and protected landscape. This designation marked a significant step in Georgia's post-Soviet efforts, integrating the pre-existing Tusheti State (founded in 1981) into a unified framework for highland protection. The park is administered by the Agency of Protected Areas (APA) of , a governmental body under the Ministry of Environmental Protection and Agriculture, which oversees daily operations, enforcement, and . employs a system to balance and human activity, including strict protection zones (12,678 hectares as per the 2012 ) for undisturbed , traditional use zones (56,789 hectares as per the 2012 ) allowing sustainable and cultural practices, and limited visitor and administrative zones. The APA's territorial administration in Omalo coordinates these efforts, supported by a 2012-2018 developed with UNDP and assistance, emphasizing adaptive strategies for and community involvement. The primary objectives of the park center on safeguarding highland ecosystems, including alpine meadows and forests, while preserving cultural and historical sites integral to Tushetian heritage, such as medieval towers and sacred groves. Since the early 2000s, research programs have been integral, with APA-led initiatives focusing on biodiversity monitoring, habitat assessment, and species population studies, often in collaboration with international partners like the Caucasus Nature Fund. These efforts utilize established trails for ecological surveys and patrolling, with 12 designated routes—three of which are fully equipped—facilitating data collection on environmental changes. Key infrastructure includes ranger stations in Omalo, the park's administrative hub, along with outposts at sites like Samkhevi and Speri, enabling year-round monitoring despite seasonal access limitations. These stations support enforcement against and , while promoting low-impact visitor activities that align with broader tourism conservation goals.

Biodiversity and Environmental Significance

Tusheti's is characterized by a rich variety of adapted to its high-altitude environments, including meadows that support numerous endemic such as the Caucasian rhododendron (Rhododendron caucasicum), which forms distinctive thickets in subalpine zones. The region hosts over 1,000 across 92 families, representing a significant portion of Georgia's floral . (Betula spp.) and (Pinus spp.) forests dominate lower elevations, extending up to approximately 2,500 meters, where they transition into open meadows that provide critical habitats for herbaceous and serve as seasonal foraging grounds. The fauna of Tusheti includes several iconic species emblematic of the Caucasus ecoregion, such as the Caucasian chamois (Rupicapra rupicapra caucasica), brown bear (Ursus arctos), and golden eagle (Aquila chrysaetos), which thrive in the diverse terrains from forested slopes to rocky peaks. Rare ungulates like the East Caucasian tur (Capra cylindricornis), a wild sheep adapted to steep cliffs, and the bezoar ibex (Capra aegagrus), face ongoing population pressures but persist in isolated herds. The area also supports migratory birds, including falcons (Falco spp.) and lammergeiers (Gypaetus barbatus), which utilize Tusheti's valleys and passes during seasonal movements. Ecologically, Tusheti plays a vital role as a watershed for the Caspian Sea basin, with its rivers, such as those feeding the Andi Koisu, contributing to the hydrological systems that drain eastward into the Caspian, supporting downstream ecosystems and water resources. The region's birch-pine forests and high alpine meadows function as carbon sinks, sequestering atmospheric CO₂ through vegetation growth and soil storage, thereby mitigating regional climate impacts. However, Tusheti's ecosystems exhibit high vulnerability to climate change, with observed warming trends in eastern Georgia exceeding 0.1°C per decade since the late 20th century, leading to shifts in species distributions and increased risks to cold-adapted flora and fauna. Conservation efforts in Tusheti have focused on addressing key threats like and habitat degradation, with designations contributing to reduced illegal through enhanced and community involvement. Recent initiatives include programs for mountain ungulates such as the East Caucasian tur, targeting priority s to assess populations fragmented by historical pressures. In April 2024, the Tusheti was expanded by 2,245 hectares to a total of 34,280 hectares. These measures, supported by international partnerships, underscore Tusheti's global value as a in the .

References

  1. [1]
    Tusheti - Georgian Travel Guide
    Tusheti is a historic region in Georgia, located in Kakheti, with stunning summits, unique cultural heritage, and the highest settlement in Europe, Bochorna.
  2. [2]
    Tusheti Region | Location, history, culture, travel offers and tips
    Geography. Tusheti is located in the mountains of the Caucasus and has several peaks such as Tebulo (4492 m), Diklo (4285 m) and Borbalo (3294 m).
  3. [3]
    Tusheti - Kakheti, Georgia - Mapcarta
    Description: geographic region ; Location: Kakheti, Georgia, Caucasus, Asia ; Latitude. 42.5° or 42° 30′ north ; Longitude. 45.5° or 45° 30′ east ; Open location ...Missing: coordinates | Show results with:coordinates
  4. [4]
    Tusheti - Tips and information for travellers - Enjoy Georgia
    ... borders two republics of the Russian Federation, Dagestan and Chechnya. Administratively, it is part of Kakheti. General information. Area: 969 km2Missing: size coordinates
  5. [5]
    Tusheti - One Of Georgia's Most Beautiful Regions
    Aug 28, 2018 · It is bordered by Dagestan to the east, Pshavi and Khevsureti to the west, Chechnya to the north, and Kakheti to the south.Missing: coordinates Pshav-
  6. [6]
    Tusheti (more than a travel guide) - Caucasus Trekking
    Lying deep in the mountains, this is the most isolated region of Georgia - to the north and east stretch closed Chechen-Daghestani borders, to the west, behind ...Missing: coordinates | Show results with:coordinates
  7. [7]
    A rare look at a perilous journey in the Caucasus Mountains
    May 27, 2021 · Ever since, the annual migration to Tusheti has been a way of life. ... “Historically, women in Tusheti learned martial arts alongside men ...
  8. [8]
    None
    Summary of each segment:
  9. [9]
    Tusheti National Park - PeakVisor
    Tusheti National Park ; Tebulosmta · 4 492 m · 2 133 m ; Mount Diklosmta. 4 285 m · 1 279 m ; Komito. 4 261 m · 666 m ; Danosmta. 4 175 m · 484 m ; Tushetskiy khrebet. 4 ...<|separator|>
  10. [10]
    The Andi Koisu River - TbilisiTrips
    Sep 27, 2025 · Explore the Andi Koisu river system, born from the Pirikita and Tushetis Alazani rivers in Tusheti National Park, Georgia.
  11. [11]
    [PDF] CC Adaptation Plan for the Tusheti Protected Areas
    and severity of extreme events (rain, flooding, landslides and mudflows, etc.) ... Develop Fire Risk Maps for Tusheti. PAs and Tusheti PL (including alpine- and ...
  12. [12]
    [PDF] Climate Change in the South Caucasus - Zoï Environment Network
    As part of the National Communication study, the average annual temperature and precipitation anoma- ... Tusheti. Mtiuleti. Pshavi. Shida. Kartli. Kakheti. Kvemo.
  13. [13]
    History - National Park of Tusheti
    The earliest historical data about Tusheti refers to the III century B.C., the period of reign of the first King of Georgia Parnavaz, the enlightener of the ...
  14. [14]
    History - Tusheti
    From the 16th-17th century, Tusheti was facing raids from Dagestan and Chechnya. In defence, the Tushs got their clan towers built (as was the case of other ...
  15. [15]
    [PDF] Mythological Parallels in Georgian and Chechen Legends
    Oral texts of the Caucasian peoples, including Georgian and Chechen traditions, transmit mythological representations connected with hunting, with similar ...<|control11|><|separator|>
  16. [16]
    prof. topchishvili on the batsbi - batsav
    In the Georgian historical documents the Tsova-Tush is first mentioned in one of the law monument of 1754. It says that the governor (state official) of Tusheti ...
  17. [17]
    Annexation of Georgia by the Russian Empire: 19th Century ...
    In 1801, following the death of George XII, the Russian Empire unilaterally annexed the kingdom. This act was met with resistance from many Georgians who valued ...Missing: Tusheti | Show results with:Tusheti
  18. [18]
    Crises around Concepts of Hospitality in the Mountainous Region of ...
    The patriarchal structures of the communities there persisted, and collectivization was carried out only superficially. In fact, even Soviet law was only ...
  19. [19]
    Florian Mühlfried — “Seeing for a State: Policing the Border between ...
    Tushetians, initially not interested in policing the border, became the first official border guards after the Soviet Union's collapse, initially in Soviet ...
  20. [20]
    Mta-Tusheti - UNESCO World Heritage Centre
    It is one of the most ecologically unspoiled regions in Caucasus. Mta-Tusheti vernacular architecture in general and fortress-like residential buildings in ...
  21. [21]
    [PDF] Roland Topchishvili Svaneti and Its Inhabitants (Ethno-historical ...
    ... Tusheti included four communities or territorial entities (before that – 8 communities). They are: Tsova, Gometsari, Chaghma, Pirikiti. The Tushs who lived ...
  22. [22]
    Tusheti - Protected Area in Georgia Europe
    The adventurous tourist route of Tusheti will pass through beautiful, misty valleys: Chaghma valley, Pirikita Alazani valley, Gometsari valley and their ...Missing: Chivitsera | Show results with:Chivitsera
  23. [23]
    Verkhovani Map - Village - Kakheti, Georgia - Mapcarta
    Verkhovani is a village in Kakheti, Georgia and has an elevation of 1,910 metres. Verkhovani is situated nearby to the village Koklata, as well as near Alisgori ...
  24. [24]
    Keselo Fortress: A 12th Century Stronghold in the Scenic Tusheti ...
    The fortress was built during the 12th century by the local rulers of Tusheti as a defensive stronghold against invaders. The architecture of the fortress ...Missing: alliances | Show results with:alliances
  25. [25]
    None
    ### Summary of Tusheti Governance and Local Self-Government
  26. [26]
    How To Visit Tusheti National Park, Georgia's Most Beautiful And ...
    Mar 24, 2025 · Tusheti is a historical region of Georgia, scattered on the southern slopes of the Caucasus mountains up to 4800 meters above sea level.Missing: precipitation | Show results with:precipitation
  27. [27]
    Omalo to Shatili Trek (a complete guide) - Caucasus Trekking
    Jul 22, 2025 · The trek follows an old shepherd's path connecting both regions. The first two days are spent mostly on jeep road connecting villages of Tusheti ...Missing: infrastructure | Show results with:infrastructure
  28. [28]
    Solar panels bring electricity to Georgia's mountainous Tusheti region
    Jul 15, 2016 · In Tusheti, 200 families are receiving electricity via solar panels. The new system is also installed in 6 public and administrative institutions.
  29. [29]
    Attracting More Tourists to Tusheti's Mountainous Villages
    Jan 8, 2018 · Almost all locals in Tusheti have a guesthouse. In the hotels, there is electricity and running hot/cold water; in the villages, you will find ...
  30. [30]
    Border Aviation
    Border Police helicopter operates regular flights to Tusheti. After scheduling regular flights to help the local population during the autumn-winter period ...
  31. [31]
  32. [32]
    Kakheti Mountains - PeakVisor
    The highest peak in Kakheti is Tebulosmta (4,492m). Tusheti, a remote part of Kakheti, has unique culture, and is home to the Tush people.
  33. [33]
    Some Demographic Trends in Borderline Regions of East Caucasus ...
    Jan 10, 2020 · While data on migration are lacking, the natural growth rate dropped from about −5‰ to −14‰, due to a combined decrease in the number of women ...
  34. [34]
    [PDF] Some Demographic Trends in Borderline Regions of East Caucasus ...
    After the collapse of the Soviet Union, the population decreased and was 3.7 million people by 2014 due to various factors (National Atlas of Georgia., 2018) ...
  35. [35]
    None
    Summary of each segment:
  36. [36]
    None
    Summary of each segment:
  37. [37]
    Rhythm of life: Nomads in the Greater Caucasus mountains
    Mar 3, 2017 · Traditionally, the Tusheti – a population of ethnic Georgians – are sheep herders. Due to the tough living conditions of their land on the ...
  38. [38]
    Tusheti, Georgia | North Caucasus Land
    May 6, 2014 · Tusheti is a historic region in NE Georgia inhabited by Tush people – who are divided into Chagma-Tush (speaker of local Georgian dialect) and Tsova-Tush or ...
  39. [39]
    About Tusheti - nateii
    Tusheti is notable for is biological diversity, wild landscapes, complex history, and hospitable people. Located on the northern slopes of the Greater Caucasus ...Missing: migrations trade
  40. [40]
    Georgia: Goodbye to a Language? - Chai Khana
    Feb 7, 2019 · For centuries the Batsbi proudly populated the highlands of Tusheti, in north-eastern Georgia. Their language, Bats - also known as Tush-Tsova ...
  41. [41]
    Language use among speakers of Tsova-Tush. A field study in the ...
    Aug 3, 2025 · The aim of the study is to map patterns of language use and language choices in the family and local community in different settings and domains ...
  42. [42]
    The Batsbi? - batsav
    The second theory has it that the Batsbi crossed the Greater Caucasus range from Ingushetia in the seventeenth century and eventually settled in Tusheti, and ...
  43. [43]
    Svans guarding Tusheti: A weekend with Georgian border guards
    Aug 5, 2008 · There are tens of forlorn villages scattered throughout Tusheti as logistics remain a large problem. The border guards count 5 000 in their ...Missing: Minorities Kakhetian
  44. [44]
    Tushetians - Tom Pinnegar
    Georgia is a fascinating country linguistically and anthropologically. Although the Tsova-Tushetian language is of the Nakh family, related to Chechan and ...
  45. [45]
    Language and Script - TPG Travel Promotions Georgia
    Some examples are as follows: Northeast dialects like Tushetian (Tušuri, თუშური) spoken in Tusheti, Mokhevian (Moxevuri, მოხევური), spoken in Khevi; two of ...
  46. [46]
    New publication on Tsova-Tush language use - Karina Vamling
    Sep 6, 2025 · The aim of the study is to map patterns of language use and language choices in the family and local community in different settings and domains ...
  47. [47]
    Religion, philosophy and mythology :: Tusheti - Webnode
    The Tusheti religion and mythology are strongly influenced by dualism with emphasis on harmony of two opposite principles.Missing: oral clans
  48. [48]
    Tushetian Festivals | Georgian Travel Guide
    Nov 17, 2021 · Atnigenobebi - the cycle of summer cult fests in Tusheti - is special among the traditional Tushetian festivals. It begins on the 100th day after Easter.
  49. [49]
    The Woman Keeping Georgia's Ancient Horse Migration Alive
    Oct 28, 2022 · "Tusheti was full of people, livestock, and lots of hard work. We had to milk cows, make butter, cheese, and cultivate potatoes. We had to ...Missing: trade | Show results with:trade
  50. [50]
    Kidnapping Custom Makes a Comeback in Georgia - NPR
    May 14, 2006 · An old custom is experiencing a revival. Women are being kidnapped and held for a night by men who want to marry them, thereby making eventual nuptials a ...Missing: Tusheti | Show results with:Tusheti
  51. [51]
    Festivals and rites - Tusheti - Webnode
    It commemorates the famous battle at Bakhtrioni in 1659 and brave Tush hero Zezva Gaphrindauli. In the past the festival was celebrated at the time when ...<|control11|><|separator|>
  52. [52]
    Georgian women's song Vol. II - Ensemble Mzetamze - Face Music
    I was watching you from Bakht'rioni* / pretty Tushetian woman. I have opened my heart to you / but you are hiding your feelings. - *Bakht'rioni: a fortress ...
  53. [53]
    Sustainability Issues of Tushetian Towers | World Scientific Reports
    Jul 7, 2025 · The towers ensured the defense and security of Tusheti from attacks by neighboring tribes. Published. 2025-07-07. How to Cite. Maia Tchanturia ...Missing: alliances | Show results with:alliances
  54. [54]
    Unique architecture of Tusheti
    Tusheti is widely known for its landscape architecture. Settlements on the mountain slopes, mainly 7 types of buildings can be distinguished: defensive tower, ...Missing: sakhli koshki
  55. [55]
    Tusheti | The Architecture of the Mountain Villages – Geographien
    Jul 26, 2023 · Most fortified summer settlements in Tusheti were built on avalanche-proof, sun-exposed, rocky slopes, making it easier to defend the territory ...<|control11|><|separator|>
  56. [56]
    Vernacular Architecture of Tusheti - Georgia About
    Mar 29, 2014 · Tusheti's architecture uses dry construction with stone, slate roofs, and decorated timber. Houses have two floors, and towers are for ...Missing: feudal eristavis
  57. [57]
    Georgian Traditional Clothing - Advantour
    Tusheti's highland inhabitants were known for their use of wool in making clothes, shoes and rugs, with solar symbols and crosses regularly employed in their ...<|separator|>
  58. [58]
  59. [59]
    (PDF) Ethno-cultural resources and perspectives of the development ...
    May 3, 2017 · Our main goal is to evaluate ethno-cultural recourses and their perspectives in Tusheti. Region characterized by the strict natural condition ...
  60. [60]
    [PDF] Local livelihood assessment of Tush Shepherds traditionally using ...
    According to herders, 175 tons of wool can be procured during the spring and summer periods; in spring only the sheep, which have no lambs and are physically ...Missing: abandoned | Show results with:abandoned
  61. [61]
    Tushuri Guda. Better Times Ahead for One of Georgia's Oldest, Most ...
    For a cheese with a long past, Tushuri guda seems ready and willing to adapt to the modern world without losing touch with its heritage. And judging by the ...Missing: UNESCO 2019
  62. [62]
    Tushuri Guda: Better Times Ahead for Georgia's Abused Cheese?
    Sep 10, 2018 · Produced in the remote mountainous region of Tusheti, Tushuri guda takes its name from the sheepskin sack in which the raw-milk cheese is traditionally ripened.Missing: cultural | Show results with:cultural
  63. [63]
    Tusheti Sheep - Arca del Gusto - Slow Food Foundation
    Tusheti sheep are bred for meat, wool, and dairy in eastern Georgia. They are small, with white wool, and produce milk for cheese. They are semi-nomadic and ...Missing: economy goat
  64. [64]
    Tusheti| Georgia | Luxe and Intrepid Asia - Remote Lands
    The intrepid seeking the best of Georgia's wild side will find it in Tusheti, where a landscape of tall peaks, deep forges, and high waterfalls studded with ...
  65. [65]
    [PDF] The economics of pasture management in Georgia - ELD Initiative
    It is host to 40% of all agricultural holdings, whilst an estimated 65% of the sheep and goats owned in Georgia are based there (GeoStat 2016). The ELD ...
  66. [66]
    22 Things to Know Before You Visit Tusheti, Georgia - Wander-Lush
    Sep 5, 2025 · Tusheti is located in the Greater Caucasus mountains in Georgia's far north-east, around 200 kilometres from Tbilisi.Missing: coordinates Pshav- Atsunta
  67. [67]
    Tourism and Rural Development: The Case of Tusheti - ISET-PI
    Oct 24, 2014 · Too much investment may strip Tusheti of its uniqueness. Too little of it may carry risks for health and the environment. THE EMERGENCE OF A ...
  68. [68]
    [PDF] Connecting Tusheti | Internet Society
    Dec 2, 2018 · Traditionally, the Tushs were sheep herders who made cheese and high-quality wool for export. Sheep and cattle breeding are still the.
  69. [69]
    From Juta to Roshka via Chaukhi pass
    Apr 6, 2025 · The popular trail connecting Kazbegi region with Khevsureti. It is compelling due to a proximity of imposing Chaukhi massif with its seven sharp peaks.
  70. [70]
    The BEST Tusheti, Georgia Jeep & 4WD tours 2025 - GetYourGuide
    Starting from $315.00 Rating 5.0 (27) Travel from Tbilisi to Omalo, Diklo, Shenako, and Dartlo, and enjoy the services of a professional guide-driver. Day 1: Start your journey with a scenic drive ...
  71. [71]
    Tusheti Jeep Tour - Delica Club Georgia
    We offer you unforgettable Tusheti Jeep Tour . Travel with Delica Club Georgia and discover this ancient land rich with adventures, history and culture.
  72. [72]
    Georgia - Country Profile - Convention on Biological Diversity
    May 8, 2014 · The Georgia/European Union Association Agreement (June 2014) includes important commitments for the conservation of species and habitats and the ...
  73. [73]
    [PDF] Finance Opportunity Analysis for the Georgian Protected Areas System
    It is focused somewhat more on non-tourism instruments or income generation opportunities as feasibility studies of mostly tourism income generating activities ...
  74. [74]
    National Park of Tusheti
    ### Summary of Tusheti
  75. [75]
    Tusheti National Park is located on the Eastern Caucasus
    Tusheti National Park, created to preserve landscapes, is a large, high-altitude protected area in eastern Georgia, with a severe climate and a challenging ...<|control11|><|separator|>
  76. [76]
    Tusheti National Park - nationalparks.ge
    ... Tusheti, Village Omalo / Village lower Alvani, Akhmeta Municipality ... Ranger · Ranger Centers · Ranger Information. sign up for newsletter subscribe. Follow Us.
  77. [77]
    Tusheti Protected Areas - Caucasus Nature Fund
    230 endemic species of plants are found in the region; Red birch, Caucasian fritillaries and Caucasian rhododendron are among them. CNF Support. Supported since ...
  78. [78]
    [PDF] High mountain flora of Pirikiti Khevsureti and Tusheti (NE Greater ...
    212 species are endemic. They compose 35.3% of the flora on the studied area. Different numbers of endemic species are present in different floristic complexes.
  79. [79]
    Tusheti National Park - nationalparks.ge
    The total area of broad leaf forests is not more than 1400 hectares. Subalpine forests totally cover 6200 hectares. The upper lower zone of the forest ...
  80. [80]
    (PDF) Tusheti and its forests - a unique case of local governance in ...
    Aug 6, 2025 · Tusheti Protected Landscape is unique within the protected areas of Georgia in that it is managed by the local selfgovernment, Akhmeta ...Missing: jvari | Show results with:jvari
  81. [81]
    TUSHETI FOREST BIODIVERSITY AND ITS ECOLOGICAL ...
    Nov 9, 2021 · Unique pine trees occupy a large part of the total area of Tusheti protected landscape. Subalpine birch and pine forests are also common in ...Missing: count | Show results with:count<|separator|>
  82. [82]
    Tusheti Protected Areas - Caucasus Nature Fund
    Its virgin pine forests, vast alpine pasturelands and snowy mountain peaks host a variety of plant and animal life (East Caucasian Tur, Chamois, Bezoar Goat, ...Missing: wildlife | Show results with:wildlife
  83. [83]
    Tusheti - WiseWay Tours Website
    The journey involves traversing a challenging yet scenic mountain road that crosses the Abano Pass at an elevation of 2,850 meters. This road, open from late ...
  84. [84]
    [PDF] Eastern Tur (Capra cylindricornis)
    Hence, the total tur population in Tusheti is estimated at 1,519 individuals. This assessment covered almost all areas with suitable tur habitats within ...
  85. [85]
    TUSHETI PROTECTED AREAS - TUSHETILAND Travel
    ... Georgia, flows to Dagestan, where this river is called as Andis Koisu and finally flows into the Caspian Sea. Tusheti Protected Areas cover Tusheti Strict ...
  86. [86]
    Georgian climate change under global warming conditions
    The largest centers and areas of strong warming, where decadal trend of mean annual air temperature was more than 0.1 °C, are found in eastern Georgia. This is ...Missing: Tusheti | Show results with:Tusheti
  87. [87]
    Identifying priority areas for restoring mountain ungulates in the ...
    Sep 19, 2020 · Our study shows how restoration planning is possible in the face of multiple threats and scarce data. For bezoar goats in the Caucasus, we ...
  88. [88]
    [PDF] status and protection of globally threatened species in the caucasus
    Another additional threat is the expected climate change that would entail change and fragmentation of ranges and would enhance negative impact of other factors ...