Fact-checked by Grok 2 weeks ago

Zafrullah Chowdhury

Zafrullah Chowdhury (27 December 1941 – 11 April 2023) was a Bangladeshi , , and activist who founded Gonoshasthaya Kendra in 1972 to deliver affordable, comprehensive healthcare to rural populations, including , , and training programs that served as models for community-based . As a freedom fighter during Bangladesh's 1971 Liberation War, he established frontline medical facilities to treat wounded combatants and civilians, later channeling wartime experiences into postwar health innovations amid widespread devastation. Chowdhury's advocacy extended to pharmaceutical reform, where he spearheaded Bangladesh's 1982 National Drug Policy—the first in to emphasize over branded imports—successfully curbing exorbitant pricing by multinational companies and enabling local generic production to enhance accessibility for low-income groups. This policy, though fiercely opposed by industry interests, marked a causal shift toward self-reliant health systems, drawing on empirical evidence of overpriced drugs' role in perpetuating poverty-related morbidity. His efforts earned recognition including the in 1992 for advancing rural health equity and the for public service. While celebrated for these contributions, Chowdhury encountered political friction, including legal challenges such as a 2015 contempt conviction by Bangladesh's war crimes tribunal for critiquing its proceedings and sporadic accusations of offending religious sentiments, often viewed in context as attempts to stifle dissent amid his advisory roles in opposition alliances. Chowdhury succumbed to complications from in , leaving a legacy of pragmatic, evidence-driven interventions that prioritized causal determinants of over commercial or ideological constraints.

Early Life and Formation

Childhood and Family Influences

Zafrullah Chowdhury was born on December 27, 1941, in Raozan, , in what was then Eastern Bengal of the . At age six, during the 1947 , his family relocated, spending his early childhood in before settling in , which later became . He grew up as one of ten children in a family shaped by modest circumstances and strong patriotic values. His father, Humayun Murshed Chowdhury, served as a noted for his , who emphasized devotion to the motherland and influenced Zafrullah's early sense of national duty. His mother, Hashina , a , played a pivotal role in steering his career aspirations; initially drawn to banking, Zafrullah was persuaded by her to pursue , shaping his lifelong commitment to healthcare. These familial influences, amid the socio-political turbulence of and post-colonial transition, fostered his resilience and focus on service-oriented professions. Zafrullah completed his matriculation at Nabakumar Institution in Bakshibazar, , laying the groundwork for his subsequent medical studies. The emphasis on ethical duty from his father and maternal encouragement toward healing professions directly informed his rejection of personal gain in favor of public welfare, evident in his later .

Medical Education and Initial Political Involvement

Chowdhury completed his pre-medical studies at before entering Dhaka Medical College, where he earned his MBBS degree with distinction in in 1964. In 1965, he relocated to the for postgraduate training, completing specialization in general, orthopaedic, and . At Dhaka Medical College, Chowdhury immersed himself in student politics, associating with leftist ideologies amid growing discontent with Pakistan's rule over East Pakistan. He was elected general secretary of the Dhaka Medical College Students' Union, a position from which he aggressively pursued institutional reform. In this capacity, Chowdhury convened a press conference to publicly denounce corruption at the college hospital, including irregularities in procurement and administration that undermined patient care and education quality. His outspoken activism provoked authorities and nearly resulted in his expulsion from the institution, highlighting the risks of challenging entrenched power structures in Pakistan-era . These early efforts demonstrated his prioritization of accountability and equity in healthcare systems over personal security.

Role in the Liberation War

Participation as a Freedom Fighter

Upon the outbreak of the on March 25, 1971, Zafrullah Chowdhury, then pursuing surgical training in for the Fellowship of the of Surgeons, immediately abandoned his fellowship and returned to his homeland to join the struggle against Pakistani forces. He participated actively as a freedom fighter, initially engaging in operations as part of the efforts. This direct involvement in armed , prior to his shift toward organizing medical support, established his credentials as a combatant in the Bahini-aligned forces, contributing to the broader that harassed Pakistani troops and infrastructure across . Chowdhury's decision to forgo advanced professional training amid the and military crackdown reflected his prior commitment to progressive student politics at Medical College, where he had served as general of the student's . His wartime participation earned him recognition as a war hero, with subsequent national awards acknowledging his role in the , though primary accounts emphasize the high-risk nature of early guerrilla actions in disrupting enemy supply lines and intelligence.

Establishment of Field Hospitals and Medical Aid

During the 1971 , Zafrullah Chowdhury, then a medical student on surgical training in , returned to join the as both a guerrilla fighter and physician. After undergoing guerrilla training in Melaghar, (in present-day , ), he collaborated with fellow doctors to establish a in the liberated border area to provide emergency care for wounded freedom fighters and refugees fleeing Pakistani military operations. The facility, known as the Bangladesh Field Hospital, was outfitted with 480 beds and operated under Sector-2 of the command structure, serving as a critical and treatment center amid ongoing cross-border skirmishes. Lacking formal staff, Chowdhury improvised by recruiting and training local women from nearby villages as paramedics, teaching them basic surgical assistance, wound care, and sterilization techniques using rudimentary resources; this approach addressed immediate manpower shortages and demonstrated the feasibility of community-based medical training in crisis settings. The hospital handled high volumes of casualties, including wounds, injuries, and malnutrition cases, with Chowdhury performing vascular surgeries under austere conditions that foreshadowed his later emphasis on low-cost, adaptable healthcare models. Post-independence, the field hospital's infrastructure and trained personnel formed the nucleus for Gonoshasthaya Kendra, with Sheikh Mujibur Rahman reportedly naming the initiative and allocating land in Savar for its expansion into a permanent rural health network. This wartime effort not only sustained frontline medical support—saving an estimated hundreds of lives through timely interventions—but also validated decentralized aid delivery, influencing subsequent public health strategies in resource-poor environments.

Founding of Gonoshasthaya Kendra

Origins and Core Principles

(GK) originated from a 480-bed makeshift established during the 1971 in Melaghar, Bisramganj, , , operated by Bangladeshi physicians including to treat freedom fighters and refugees. Following , on 27 April 1972, Chowdhury and 22 volunteers and doctors relocated the initiative to Bais Mile in , near , renaming it , or "People's Health Centre," and registering it as a public charitable trust to address the acute rural healthcare needs in war-ravaged . This founding was driven by the recognition of unattended healthcare demands among the rural poor, building directly on wartime medical experiences to create a sustainable model beyond emergency aid. The core principles of GK emphasize self-reliant, people-oriented healthcare delivery tailored to rural communities, prioritizing affordable access for the vulnerable through preventive and curative services, community health insurance scaled to ability to pay, and local production of essential medicines. Central to its philosophy is community involvement, including training predominantly female volunteers as paramedics and health workers to foster empowerment and grassroots leadership, which has notably reduced infant and maternal mortality rates to below national averages in served areas. Chowdhury's vision underscored that "the fate of the poor decides the fate of the country" and that national development hinges on women's advancement, integrating healthcare with broader efforts in education, agriculture, nutrition, and women's rights to promote social equity and economic self-sufficiency without reliance on external dependencies. This holistic approach rejects exploitative models, advocating instead for policy reforms and community-driven solutions to achieve sustainable health outcomes.

Organizational Growth and Service Model

Gonoshasthaya Kendra (GK) originated as a 480-bed established during the 1971 and formally registered as a public in 1972 in , near , initially serving around 50,000 people across 50 villages with basic curative and preventive care delivered through tents and makeshift clinics. By the early 1980s, it had expanded to include sub-centers focused on rural primary healthcare, incorporating training programs that emphasized community-level interventions, marking one of the first such initiatives outside . Over the subsequent decades, scaled significantly, reaching 1.2 million beneficiaries in 608 villages across 17 districts by 2012, supported by 39 primary health centers, five referral hospitals, and two tertiary facilities, with a of 5,450 staff members predominantly from levels. By the 2020s, operations extended to 1.5 million people in 541 villages spanning 20 districts, 32 upazilas, and 56 unions, operating 43 rural sub-centers and six academic hospitals, while integrating services beyond health into , , and disaster management. This growth was sustained through self-financing mechanisms, with approximately 50% of the budget generated internally via user fees scaled to ability to pay, supplemented by schemes covering over one million enrollees and avoiding blanket free services except for the destitute. The service model centers on integrated, community-driven primary healthcare, implementing elements of the Alma-Ata Declaration through preventive measures, , and curative services delivered via local paramedics and village health committees, which prioritize maternal and child health to achieve rates below 32 per 1,000 live births and maternal mortality 42% under the national average of 186 per 100,000. forms a core pillar, with programs training female volunteers as birth attendants, paramedics, and educators, alongside vocational initiatives like Nari Kendra for economic self-reliance. Organizational structure emphasizes and local governance, with village development committees overseeing service delivery and , fostering self-reliant development that extends to pharmaceutical through Gono Pharmaceuticals, established in 1981 to supply affordable essential drugs meeting up to 60% of demand in certain categories. This model has influenced broader policy, including Bangladesh's 1982 National Drug Policy, while maintaining a focus on vulnerable rural populations through rights-based advocacy and adaptive responses, such as interventions in Rohingya refugee camps.

Innovations in Rural Healthcare Delivery

Gonoshasthaya Kendra pioneered the training of paramedics in Bangladesh, introducing the concept in 1977 by educating young women without prior medical backgrounds to deliver primary healthcare services in rural areas. These paramedics underwent six months of foundational training in anatomy, physiology, and primary health care components, enabling them to perform preventive care, basic treatments, and procedures such as mini-laparotomy for female sterilization, which began in 1974. This mid-level cadre of providers extended domiciliary services to underserved villages, covering populations through approximately 160 paramedics and influencing the government's later adoption of similar training models. In 1973, the organization launched Bangladesh's first rural health insurance system, a community-based scheme that charged premiums according to ability to pay—lower rates for the poor and higher for the affluent—to fund equal-quality via a cross-subsidy model with six tiered levels. This micro-insurance approach improved to antenatal and other services among low-income rural women, demonstrating measurable uptake in preventive health measures. The overall model emphasized community involvement in primary healthcare delivery, integrating preventive strategies, maternal and child health programs, and economic cooperatives to address . Operating across hundreds of villages, it reduced maternal mortality rates and rates to one-third to one-half of national averages through targeted interventions like education and on-site supervision. These efforts, serving over one million people via 13 health centers and major hospitals, contributed to global frameworks, including influences on the 1978 Alma-Ata .

Advocacy for Pharmaceutical Reform

Campaign Against Multinational Influence

Zafrullah Chowdhury recognized the dominance of multinational pharmaceutical companies in post-independence Bangladesh, where the market was flooded with unnecessary, harmful, and overpriced drugs, with less than half being essential medicines despite nominal price controls. Through Gonoshasthaya Kendra, which he co-founded in 1972, Chowdhury began producing low-cost essential drugs as an alternative to multinational imports, establishing a dedicated pharmaceutical unit in 1979 to manufacture formulations for primary healthcare at reduced prices. His campaign involved public advocacy and lobbying, including early appeals to Prime Minister in the mid-1970s to develop a local by initially importing drugs from socialist and restricting multinational imports of finished products. Chowdhury highlighted the economic drain from high multinational prices and the health risks of irrational drug combinations and placebos, drawing on his wartime medical experience to argue for self-reliance in pharmaceuticals. Facing resistance from multinationals who propagated against reforms and benefited from lax regulations allowing toll manufacturing and imports of non-essential items, Chowdhury mobilized expert committees and allied with advocates to expose these practices, setting the stage for broader policy changes. This opposition included international pressure, such as from the ambassador in the early , who deemed initial reform proposals "suicidal" to the industry. Despite such pushback, his efforts emphasized causal links between multinational control and inaccessible healthcare, privileging of drug misuse over corporate profit models.

Formulation and Enactment of the 1982 National Drug Policy

Chowdhury, through his organization , advocated for pharmaceutical reforms emphasizing and local production to counter the dominance of multinational corporations, which supplied over 90% of Bangladesh's drugs in the early at inflated prices and with unnecessary formulations. As chief adviser to the expert committee formed by the government, he helped draft recommendations prioritizing a WHO-aligned list of essential drugs, restricting imports of branded non-essentials, and mandating to enhance affordability and access. Facing resistance from multinational firms that lobbied against the reforms, citing potential investment withdrawal, Chowdhury directly persuaded H.M. Ershad of the policy's necessity for national , leveraging evidence from GK's low-cost production models that demonstrated feasibility without foreign dependency. The committee's proposals were approved by the on May 29, 1982, enacting the National Drug Policy alongside the (Control) Ordinance, which banned approximately 1,700 ineffective, hazardous, or redundant previously marketed for profit. The policy required all drugs to be registered with the Directorate General of Drug Administration, enforced quality standards through local testing labs, and incentivized domestic manufacturing by reserving the market for essential drugs, shifting import reliance from 95% in 1981 to under 20% within years. This enactment marked Bangladesh as one of the first developing nations to implement a restrictive essential medicines framework, directly attributing its success to Chowdhury's persistent campaigning and technical input despite initial economic pressures from affected foreign entities.

Economic and Health Outcomes

The 1982 National Drug Policy significantly boosted Bangladesh's domestic pharmaceutical manufacturing capacity, enabling local production to meet nearly all essential drug needs by the early 1990s and fostering industry self-sufficiency. Local firms shifted focus to essential medicines, increasing their share in production from 30% in the early 1980s to 80% by 1992, while overall output of allopathic and traditional drugs expanded substantially. This growth curtailed reliance on imports, saving foreign exchange and reducing domestic drug costs through economies of scale and competition among local producers. Economically, the policy transformed into a generics powerhouse, with the sector now supplying over 95% of internal demand and emerging as a net er of pharmaceuticals valued at hundreds of millions annually by the 2020s. and bans on non-essential imports lowered average drug prices, enhancing affordability and contributing to the industry's dominance by local companies over multinationals. However, while scaled, challenges like enforcement and competitiveness persisted, with partly attributed to post-policy exemptions rather than . On health fronts, the policy improved access to for priority needs, such as antibiotics and , by prioritizing a limited list of 120-200 drugs and banning harmful formulations like liquid tetracyclines that posed risks to . This led to broader availability at lower costs, correlating with expanded coverage under programs, though direct causal links to mortality reductions remain indirect and confounded by concurrent factors like alleviation efforts. Government drug expenditure remained low at about 0.36 USD per person annually, but the policy's emphasis on rational use aimed to optimize limited resources for communicable control. Long-term health gains included reduced out-of-pocket burdens for basics, yet irrational prescribing and substandard drugs in unregulated markets limited broader outcome improvements.

Critiques and Long-Term Limitations

Despite initial successes in expanding access to , the 1982 National Drug Policy faced critiques for inadequate enforcement mechanisms, which permitted widespread irrational prescribing and dispensing practices. Unqualified practitioners issued 63% of antibiotic prescriptions, contravening policy mandates for oversight, while over-the-counter sales of restricted antimicrobials remained common due to economic pressures on vendors and limited regulatory monitoring by the of Drug Administration (DGDA). These lapses contributed to incomplete treatment courses and heightened , undermining long-term gains. Quality control emerged as a persistent limitation, with critics noting the absence of mandatory bio-equivalence studies for generic registrations, potentially compromising drug efficacy and safety. Substandard and counterfeit medicines, estimated at up to 10% of pharmaceutical sales, continued to circulate, exacerbated by reliance on low-cost active pharmaceutical ingredients (APIs) imported from India and China without rigorous quality assessments of excipients or APIs themselves. Although substandard drug rates dropped from 36% in 1970 to 2% by 2002, enforcement gaps allowed doubtful-efficacy products and adulteration to persist, eroding trust in local manufacturing. Economically, the policy's restrictions on multinational corporations curtailed foreign investment in (R&D), fostering a generics-dominated with minimal . Bangladesh's 250+ manufacturers prioritized reverse-engineering over novel , lacking targeted incentives for R&D, which limited technological advancement and global competitiveness beyond low-cost exports. , while ensuring affordability for essentials, were faulted for inadvertently incentivizing cost-cutting that risked , particularly for treatments requiring sustained . Overall, these shortcomings highlighted the policy's failure to evolve with regulatory , prompting calls for reforms including stricter licensing and enhanced DGDA .

Political Stance and Public Controversies

Criticisms of Authoritarian Governance

Chowdhury emerged as a prominent critic of authoritarian tendencies in Bangladesh's governance, particularly during the administration under , where he accused the regime of suppressing democratic processes and free expression. In October 2020, he lambasted both the government and the (BNP) for failing to institutionalize and combat , arguing that political rhetoric had not translated into substantive reforms. He specifically condemned the government's policies as gagging public voices and obstructing rights to expression, stating on October 24, 2020, that such measures represented a fundamental denial of democratic norms. Throughout 2020 and into 2021, Chowdhury's statements intensified, portraying the ruling as engaging in conspiracies against the populace and prioritizing empty promises over accountable . On December 5, 2020, he highlighted how major parties pursued devoid of action, leading to systemic failures in upholding . By January 2021, he labeled the a "serial killer" of , citing its role in enabling and eroding , as evidenced by interventions from 42 senior citizens who exposed these lapses. In March 2022, he warned that governmental actions contrary to public will were steering the country toward misguided authoritarian paths. Despite these sharp rebukes, Chowdhury's record included pragmatic engagements with prior military regimes under Ziaur Rahman and Hussain Muhammad Ershad, which drew counter-criticism for perceived inconsistencies in his anti-authoritarian stance; however, in his later advocacy, he invoked the Awami League's own historical commitment to democracy to underscore the regime's deviation from pro-people principles. His critiques emphasized the need for genuine reforms in free speech and institutional accountability, positioning him as a defender against creeping authoritarianism amid Bangladesh's competitive authoritarian dynamics, where elections masked underlying power consolidation. In June 2015, Chowdhury was convicted of contempt of court by Bangladesh's International Crimes Tribunal-2 for publicly criticizing the tribunal's sentencing of British journalist David Bergman to two years' imprisonment for contempt over his comments on the trial of a war criminal. The tribunal imposed a fine of Tk 5,000 and one hour's imprisonment, citing his prior caution in a similar proceeding. When he failed to pay the fine by the deadline, the tribunal issued an arrest warrant on June 18, 2015, which was withdrawn the following day after compliance. Chowdhury later apologized to the Supreme Court, which canceled the fine in September 2015, effectively exonerating him from the penalty. In October 2018, Chowdhury faced a treason charge after remarks on a television criticizing Army Chief General Abu Bilal Mohammad Shafeeul Huq, whom he accused of in politics. The filed a general diary entry that was converted into a sedition case under the penal code, prompting military backlash for "untrue and irresponsible comments." Chowdhury subsequently apologized for his "careless" statements, emphasizing no intent to undermine national institutions. In August 2020, a case was filed against Chowdhury in for allegedly hurting Hindu religious sentiments through comments perceived as derogatory toward their customs. The Metropolitan Magistrate's ordered the of police to investigate the allegations, scheduling a hearing for November 19, 2020, amid claims that his statements incited communal tension. Chowdhury's outspokenness extended to broader political critiques, including demands in July 2022 for the release of detained opposition leaders like BNP chairperson , threatening to mobilize 10,000 people to surround the if unmet. He also condemned in 2022, stating that "no true Muslim" would homes, while attributing attacks to ruling party affiliates. These positions drew rebukes, such as from the in 2021 for criticizing party leaders' integrity.

Ideological Shifts from Leftism to Nationalism

During his student years at Dhaka Medical College in the 1960s, Zafrullah Chowdhury engaged with leftist political ideologies, serving as general secretary of the Dhaka University Students' Union and participating in anti-colonial and socialist-leaning movements against Pakistani rule. This period reflected broader influences from Marxist and progressive thought prevalent among Bengali intellectuals seeking social equity and independence. Chowdhury's participation in the 1971 Liberation War marked a pivotal turn toward , as he provided medical support to guerrillas, establishing field hospitals and treating wounded fighters, which instilled a commitment to Bengali sovereignty over ideological abstractions. Post-independence, he rejected Mujibur Rahman's 1975 imposition of the (BAKSAL) one-party socialist system, viewing it as a betrayal of democratic and self-reliant ideals forged in the war. In the late 1970s, Chowdhury collaborated with President , founder of the (BNP), to formulate the 1982 National Drug Policy, emphasizing national control over pharmaceuticals against multinational dominance, aligning with Zia's nationalist economic reforms that prioritized local production and reduced foreign dependency. This pragmatic extended to his founding of in 1972, a self-sufficient rural health model promoting community empowerment over . By the 2010s, Chowdhury's opposition to governance—criticized for authoritarianism and erosion of war-era democratic ethos—led him to co-found the BNP-led in 2018, an alliance advocating electoral reforms and national unity against perceived foreign-influenced incumbency. While occasionally critiquing BNP leadership, his involvement underscored a evolved stance favoring nationalist and institutional independence over early leftist collectivism.

Recognition and Global Impact

Key Awards and Honors

Chowdhury received Bangladesh's highest civilian honor, the , in 1977 for founding and pioneering its integrated programs in , , and rural self-reliance. He was granted the award a second time in 2009 specifically for lifetime contributions to social service and innovation. In 1985, the recognized Chowdhury's leadership in developing Bangladesh's 1982 National Drug Policy, which banned 3,000 irrational or non-essential drugs, restricted multinational imports, and fostered local production of affordable generics, thereby expanding access to for the rural poor. This policy, enacted amid opposition from global pharmaceutical firms, prioritized evidence-based formulations over branded imports, reducing healthcare costs by an estimated 50% in subsequent years. The 1992 Right Livelihood Award, known as the "Alternative Nobel Prize," honored his establishment of as a model for community-owned healthcare, including low-cost clinics, factories producing generics at one-tenth the price of imports, and training of doctors to serve underserved populations. Earlier, in 1974, he earned the Swedish Youth Peace Prize for initiating humanitarian medical relief during Bangladesh's liberation war and subsequent crises.

Influence on International Health Movements

Chowdhury's orchestration of Bangladesh's 1982 National Drug Policy, which restricted pharmaceuticals to a list of 150 essential drugs for tertiary care, 45 for primary healthcare, and 12 for community clinics while banning imports of non-essential and harmful formulations, positioned the country as a vanguard in rational drug use amid multinational opposition. This policy aligned with the World Health Organization's 1977 Essential Medicines List but enforced it through local manufacturing mandates and price controls, resulting in stabilized costs, expanded domestic production, and improved access for low-income populations. By demonstrating that a resource-constrained nation could prioritize evidence-based pharmacotherapy over profit-driven imports—destroying stockpiles of 299 harmful products within three months—it challenged global pharmaceutical dominance and informed policy debates on essential medicines in developing contexts. Internationally, Chowdhury advocated for the policy's principles through writings and speeches, critiquing discrepancies between WHO endorsements of essential drugs and pressures from institutions like the favoring deregulation. In his 1992 Right Livelihood Award acceptance, he highlighted how Bangladesh's approach fostered private sector growth in generics while benefiting consumers, arguing against patent extensions that would undermine affordability in the Global South. This testimony contributed to broader movements for national in drug regulation, influencing frameworks for management in low-resource settings by emphasizing cost-effective, locally producible therapies over branded imports. The policy's success—evidenced by Bangladesh's pharmaceutical sector evolving into a net exporter by the 2000s—served as empirical validation for similar reforms elsewhere, underscoring causal links between restricted formularies and equitable health outcomes without compromising innovation. Chowdhury's efforts thus amplified calls for integrated systems, as per the Alma-Ata Declaration, by integrating drug policy with community-level delivery through initiatives like , which trained non-physicians in essential treatments and exported models to regional health advocacy networks.

Final Years and Legacy

Health Decline and Death

Zafrullah Chowdhury suffered from for an extended period, which progressively impaired his health in his later years. His condition worsened significantly in early April 2023, leading to hospitalization in on April 7 due to acute kidney complications, compounded by liver and heart issues. By April 9, medical reports indicated his remained severe, with ongoing multi-organ involvement, though his overall status was described as stable but critical. Chowdhury's decline was exacerbated by a prior infection, which contributed to kidney dysfunction, liver problems, and septicemia, leaving him reliant on with nearly non-functional kidneys. He passed away on April 11, 2023, at age 81 in from complications of . His death marked the end of a life dedicated to advocacy, with tributes highlighting his enduring impact despite the physical toll of his illnesses.

Assessment of Enduring Contributions and Shortcomings

Chowdhury's most enduring contribution was founding () in 1972, which developed a replicable model of community-based primary healthcare emphasizing trained female paramedics, preventive care, and low-cost services for rural populations. This approach achieved measurable improvements, including an rate of 18.3 per 1,000 live births in GK's catchment areas covering over 600 villages, and integrated micro-health insurance that boosted antenatal care utilization among poor women. GK's expansion into production and programs further sustained , influencing global networks like the People's Health Movement co-founded by Chowdhury in 2000. A pivotal legacy stems from his role in enacting Bangladesh's 1982 Essential Drugs Act, which restricted imports and sales to 150 , banned 1,700 ineffective or hazardous formulations, and fostered a domestic generic that now exports globally while keeping costs low for locals. This policy, though fiercely opposed by multinational firms for undermining protections, demonstrated causal efficacy in curbing and enhancing access, with Bangladesh's pharma sector producing affordable alternatives that persist amid ongoing pressures. Shortcomings include the GK model's confinement largely to its own operational zones, with incomplete national adoption despite proven affordability—healthcare delivery costs at about 4% of conventional systems—due to entrenched bureaucratic and commercial resistances that limited scalability. Chowdhury's intertwining of health advocacy with partisan critiques, such as denunciations of opposition leaders like , provoked retaliatory attacks from political groups, potentially alienating allies and diluting focus on apolitical health expansion. The 1982 drug policy's controversy, including legal challenges from importers, highlighted vulnerabilities to external , though it ultimately prevailed through empirical validation of cost savings over industry claims.

Personal Dimensions

Family Life and Relationships

Zafrullah Chowdhury was born on December 27, 1941, in , Chattogram, as the eldest of ten children to Humayan Murshed Chowdhury, an honest police officer who instilled in him a for his motherland, and an unnamed mother who encouraged his pursuit of medicine over banking. He was survived by four sisters and four brothers. Chowdhury had two marriages. His first produced a daughter, Bristi Chowdhury. In his second marriage, he wed Shireen Huq (also referred to as Shirin Haque or Shirin Parvin Haque), a prominent human rights activist and co-founder of Naripokkho, a women's rights organization in Bangladesh; the couple had a son, Bareesh Hasan Chowdhury (also spelled Barish). This partnership aligned with shared commitments to social justice, though specific details on the timing or circumstances of either marriage remain undocumented in primary accounts.

Philosophical Outlook and Self-Reliance Ethos

Chowdhury's philosophical outlook was profoundly shaped by his experiences during Bangladesh's 1971 Liberation War, where he returned from medical studies in the to serve as a frontline , establishing field hospitals that underscored the need for solutions over external dependencies. This wartime necessity evolved into a core ethos of upon founding (GK) in 1972, an institution dedicated to independent, people-oriented development that prioritized local resource mobilization and community empowerment to deliver healthcare without perpetual foreign aid. He explicitly argued that was essential in Bangladesh's formative years, as accepting aid risked eroding the nation's and fostering long-term subservience to donors. Central to this philosophy was the rejection of donor-driven models in favor of sustainable, self-financing mechanisms, exemplified by GK's diversification into generic drug manufacturing in the 1980s to produce affordable essentials like oral rehydration salts and active pharmaceutical ingredients domestically, thereby reducing import reliance and ensuring economic viability. Chowdhury advocated for grassroots involvement, insisting on "involving the local people" in health initiatives through awareness-raising and capacity-building to cultivate self-sufficiency at the community level, rather than top-down interventions that perpetuated passivity. This approach extended beyond healthcare to broader social structures, promoting skill acquisition for all individuals—irrespective of gender—to achieve personal and communal independence, as reflected in GK's equitable recruitment and training policies that emphasized practical abilities over credentials. His ethos critiqued global aid paradigms for undermining , drawing from first-hand observations of post-war reconstruction where external assistance often prioritized donor interests over local needs, leading him to model GK as a commercially viable entity that generated through , textiles, and pharmaceuticals to fund operations autonomously. While this stance yielded tangible outcomes, such as GK's expansion to serve over 1.5 million patients annually by the without primary donor funding, it also positioned Chowdhury as a to mainstream development , favoring causal linkages between local initiative and enduring progress over subsidized short-term gains.

References

  1. [1]
    Zafrullah Chowdhury / Gonoshasthaya Kendra - Right Livelihood
    Dr Zafrullah Chowdhury (1941-2023) was a public health activist in Bangladesh, who advanced rural people's access to medical care through Gonoshasthaya Kendra.Missing: biography - - | Show results with:biography - -
  2. [2]
    Zafrullah Chowdhury: surgeon, freedom fighter, and innovator in ...
    Apr 27, 2023 · Zafrullah Chowdhury, a vascular surgeon, went on to co-found Bangladesh's first hospital, train paramedics in a pioneering programme that became the backbone ...Missing: biography - - | Show results with:biography - -
  3. [3]
    Zafrullah Chowdhury, founder of Gonoshasthaya Kendra (GK), has ...
    Apr 14, 2023 · As a young doctor and 'fighter for freedom', Zafrullah had set up a makeshift hospital with friends behind the front line. Once peace was ...
  4. [4]
    Dr Zafrullah Chowdhury: The revolutionary who transformed ...
    Apr 12, 2023 · Bangladesh owes a lot to Chowdhury, whose diligence made his country the first in Asia to adopt a comprehensive drug policy based on the needs of the poor.Missing: biography - - | Show results with:biography - -<|separator|>
  5. [5]
    Leader of people's health - PMC - NIH
    Jun 6, 2024 · Dr Zafrullah Chowdhury passed away in Dhaka on 11 April 2023 after a protracted kidney disease and after spending an eventful and inspiring life ...Missing: biography - - | Show results with:biography - -
  6. [6]
  7. [7]
    [PDF] Dr. Zafrullah Chowdhury
    He was born at Raozan in Chattogram on Dec 27, 1941, Zafrullah passed intermediate (high) school) from Dhaka College after matriculation from Nabakumar ...Missing: biography - - | Show results with:biography - -
  8. [8]
    War crimes tribunal's punishment for Dr Zafrullah Chowdhury angers ...
    Jun 11, 2015 · The war crimes tribunal found Chowdhury guilty of contempt of court over his statement expressing concern for British citizen David Bergman ...
  9. [9]
    Case filed against Zafrullah Chowdhury for 'hurting religious sentiment'
    Aug 19, 2020 · The founder of Gonoshasthaya Kendra, Zafarullah Chowdhury, has been made accused of hurting religious sentiment. A case has been filed against ...
  10. [10]
    Remembering Dr. Zafrullah Chowdhury - Hesperian Health Guides
    Apr 27, 2023 · Dr. Zafrullah Chowdhury, an internationally known public health leader from Bangladesh whose organization, Gonoshasthaya Kendra, was one of the first to ...
  11. [11]
    Dr Zafrullah Chowdhury: A revolutionary's journey | The Daily Star
    Apr 12, 2023 · His father, Humayan Murshed Chowdhury, was an honest police officer and instilled in him love for one's motherland. Zafrullah found his perfect ...
  12. [12]
    Zafrullah Chowdhury obituary | Health - The Guardian
    Jul 10, 2023 · Zafrullah Chowdhury, who has died aged 81, was a public health activist dedicated to making basic healthcare more accessible in rural Bangladesh.Missing: biography - - | Show results with:biography - -
  13. [13]
    Zafrullah Chowdhury, people's doctor and war hero, pioneered a ...
    Apr 19, 2023 · Dr Zafrullah Chowdhury passed away on April 11, 2023 , aged 81, due to Covid complications.<|separator|>
  14. [14]
    Remembering Zafrullah Chowdhury (1941-2023): Reflections on his ...
    Apr 11, 2025 · Dr Zafrullah Chowdhury was part of this generation of pioneers. On his second death anniversary, the author remembers his qualities as a ...
  15. [15]
    Obituary of Dr. Zafrullah Chowdhury - Journal of Medical Evidence
    Dr. Zafrullah Chowdhury, the Bangladeshi public health activist, founder and trustee of Gonoshasthaya Kendra (the People's Health Centre), a rural health-care ...
  16. [16]
    Zafrullah Chowdhury dies - New Age
    Apr 11, 2023 · ... Dhaka Medical College Students' Union. After a turbulent student life, he finished his MBBS degree in 1964 and left for the UK for post ...
  17. [17]
    Dr Zafrullah Chowdhury: The man who walked the talk - The Daily Star
    In a nutshell, Chowdhury was the antithesis of the traditional Bangladeshi political operative, whom the younger generation have learnt to vehemently dislike.Missing: biography | Show results with:biography
  18. [18]
    Dr Zafrullah Chowdhury: A fighter till the end - The Daily Star
    Apr 13, 2023 · Zafrullah's most remarkable contribution after the Liberation War was formulating the drug policy. The pharmaceutical market in independent ...
  19. [19]
    [PDF] Dr Zafrullah Chowdhury - the indefatigable optimist (1941 to 2023)
    Apr 13, 2023 · From when he was a medical student in the early 60s to his final days, he worked tirelessly for extending health and health care to the people ...
  20. [20]
    Chowdhury, Zafarullah - Banglapedia
    Oct 13, 2023 · Zafarullah (1941-2023) physician, Freedom Fighter, social worker, human rights activist, life-long friend of destitute people, pioneer of drug policy.Missing: biography - - | Show results with:biography - -
  21. [21]
    Chowdhury, Zafrullah - The Ramon Magsaysay Award
    Dr. ZAFRULLAH CHOWDHURY was in surgical training in London when the Bangladesh “war of liberation” erupted in 1971. Hurrying home he, with colleagues ...
  22. [22]
    About - Gonoshasthaya Kendra
    Zafrullah Chowdhury was awarded the “Independence Award” to recognize Gonoshasthaya Kendra's innovative family planning and primary health care programs. 1981: ...
  23. [23]
    [PDF] Gonoshasthaya Kendra: - We social movements
    From the Bangladesh Field Hospital during the Liberation War in. 1971 to meeting MDGs 3, 4 and 5: Gonoshasthaya Kendra or the. People's Health Centre has gone ...
  24. [24]
    [PDF] Dr. Zafrullah Chowdhury: A Biographical Sketch of a Health Activist
    Academic Qualifications and Training : M.B.B.S. with distinction in Surgery, Dhaka Medical College, University of Dhaka, 1964.
  25. [25]
    Health - Gonoshasthaya Kendra
    Initially, paramedics receive 6 months of foundation training in basic anatomy, physiology and components of primary health care. On successful completion, they ...Missing: innovations | Show results with:innovations
  26. [26]
    The impact of Gonoshasthaya Kendra's Micro Health Insurance plan ...
    This study assesses the impact of MHI administered by Gonoshasthaya Kendra (GK) on ANC utilization by poor women in rural Bangladesh. We conducted a ...
  27. [27]
    Remembering the good doctor - Third World Network (TWN)
    Third World Resurgence pays tribute to the late Dr Zafrullah Chowdhury, the pioneering Bangladeshi public health activist who provided affordable medical care ...
  28. [28]
    [PDF] Health Sans Multinationals:The Bangladesh Crusade - About CED
    Dr. Chowdhury's involvement in social and political issues dates from his student days when he was an active and vocal member of the Dhaka Medical College ...
  29. [29]
    The legacy of Zafrullah Chowdhury | The Daily Star
    The 480-bed hospital was founded to treat wounded freedom fighters. Among those who established this field hospital were Zafrullah Chowdhury and MA Mobin.<|control11|><|separator|>
  30. [30]
    How Bangladesh's Pharma Revolution Succeeded Against the Odds
    regarded as the father of Bangladesh's drug policy — summarised the principles ...
  31. [31]
    Zafrullah fought to ensure healthcare for commons: speakers
    Sep 4, 2023 · However, multinational companies stood against it and spread propaganda against the policy, he added. Sayedur Rahman said that the drug ...Missing: campaign | Show results with:campaign
  32. [32]
    Demystifying health care - PMC
    The centre soon enrolled poor village women with no education into its paramedics training programme. But producing skilled paramedics was only part of the ...
  33. [33]
    (PDF) Bangladesh pharmaceutical policy and politics - ResearchGate
    ... Zafrullah Chowdhury, hero of Bangladesh's. independence war, a recipient of the ... National Drug Policy. December 1987 · Journal of the Association of ...<|control11|><|separator|>
  34. [34]
    (PDF) A Study on the National Drug Policies of Bangladesh to ...
    PDF | Bangladesh approved the proposal for a National Drug Policy on May 29, 1982. We know that such drug policies are developed gradually over a period.
  35. [35]
    [PDF] National Drug Policy, 1982
    Mar 10, 1986 · The 1982 policy aimed to prioritize essential drugs, remove harmful products, and increase local production, implemented by banning 1656 drugs.
  36. [36]
    Bangladesh National Drug Policy 1982-2016 and ...
    Jun 19, 2019 · Bangladesh NDP 1982 is an epoch-making event in the history of Bangladesh. ... Revise the 1940 Drugs Act to include: a. A registration ...
  37. [37]
    A revolutionary policy for the pharmaceutical of Bangladesh
    Dec 10, 2020 · In 1982, the Bangladesh government introduced a radical and far-reaching National Drug Policy to curtail the abuses of pharmaceutical companies ...
  38. [38]
    'Singing about the Dark Times': Bangladesh Drug Policy - jstor
    Lessons from Bangladesh by Zafrullah Chowdhury; Vistaar Publications, New ... the National Drug Policy (1982) however continued thanks to the newly ...
  39. [39]
    Report of the expert committee for drugs - Bangladesh - ScienceDirect
    The new policy is expected to save annually considerable amounts in foreign exchange and in domestic drug costs. This will allow the Government and health ...
  40. [40]
    Evolution of the Pharmaceutical Industry Bangladesh, 1982 to 2020
    Jan 26, 2021 · ... essential medicines. Many developing ... The rise of the pharmaceutical industry in Bangladesh is attributed to the Drug Ordinance of 1982.
  41. [41]
    The rise and impact of Bangladesh's pharmaceutical industry - DHL
    Mar 10, 2024 · ... essential medicines, particularly through the ... Bangladesh is projected to maintain its dominance in the global generic medicine market.
  42. [42]
    Drug Policy Comparison 1982 2016 Full Assignment | PDF - Scribd
    5. Economic and Public Health Contributions. - The 1982 policy dramatically lowered drug prices and increased access to essential medicines,<|separator|>
  43. [43]
    [PDF] EVOLUTION OF THE PHARMACEUTICAL INDUSTRY IN ...
    Jul 15, 2020 · The rise of the pharmaceutical industry in Bangladesh is attributed to the Drug Ordinance of 1982. This created a market for the local firms for ...<|separator|>
  44. [44]
    National drug policy reform for noncommunicable diseases in low ...
    Bangladesh is one of the pioneer countries to develop a national drug policy, launching its first in 1982. Based on the WHO essential medicines concept, the ...
  45. [45]
    [PDF] MEDICINES IN HEALTH CARE DELIVERY BANGLADESH
    Government expenditure on drugs remains extremely low (about 0.36 USD/person/year). According to national policy,. 70% of drugs are supplied by the Essential ...
  46. [46]
    Therapeutic drug use in Bangladesh: policy versus practice
    Abstract. The National Drug Policy (NDP), 1982, of Bangladesh was expected to make available essential, good quality drugs at affordable prices.Missing: outcomes | Show results with:outcomes
  47. [47]
    Barriers and facilitators to adherence to national drug policies on ...
    Compliance with this policy is poor; prescribing antibiotics by unqualified practitioners is common and over-the-counter dispensing widespread. In Bangladesh, ...
  48. [48]
    Bangladesh's drug policy needs major repair | The Daily Star
    Bangladesh's first Drug Policy was adopted in 1982. Among several reasons, the primary one was to make World Health Organization (WHO) recommended essential ...
  49. [49]
    Bangladesh's battle with fake and low-standard medicine
    Nov 4, 2013 · Near 10 percent of pharmaceutical sales in Bangladesh may be linked to counterfeit or sub-standard contraband medicine, outlawed, but still flowing.
  50. [50]
    [PDF] Technological Readiness of Bangladesh's Pharmaceuticals Industry
    Restrictions on MNCs in Bangladesh in 1982. (Ministry of Law, Justice and Parliamentary Affairs, 1982) made it impossible for them to produce even basic ...
  51. [51]
    Rising pharmaceutical innovation in the Global South
    Nov 27, 2023 · The absence of targeted public policies for pharmaceutical innovation was raised as a challenge in Bangladesh and Colombia. In Bangladesh, ...
  52. [52]
    Zafrullah slams govt, BNP for failure to ensure democracy - New Age
    Oct 2, 2020 · Gonoshasthaya Kendra trustee Zafrullah Chowdhury on Friday criticised both the government and the opposition Bangladesh Nationalist Party ...
  53. [53]
    Zafrullah criticises govt, BNP for failure to ensure democracy and ...
    Oct 2, 2020 · Alleging that India always neglected the interests of the people of Bangladesh, he urged the government to tell courageously to India to take ...
  54. [54]
    No democracy in country now, govt gagging people's voice
    Oct 24, 2020 · Dr Zafrullah said it is the government's wrong policy to gag people's voice and create obstacles to people's right to expression. "All the works ...Missing: authoritarian | Show results with:authoritarian
  55. [55]
    Zafrullah accuses govt of conspiring against people - New Age
    Dec 5, 2020 · He accused political parties of doing politics of mere rhetoric. He said that their words did not translate into deeds and that was why ...
  56. [56]
    Zafrullah calls EC a 'serial killer' of democracy
    Jan 29, 2021 · “Forty-two senior citizens have clearly shown that they have killed democracy. Not only that, they are indulged in corruption,” said Dr ...Missing: authoritarian | Show results with:authoritarian<|separator|>
  57. [57]
    Government heading in wrong direction: Zafrullah - Just News BD
    Mar 25, 2022 · Zafrullah, also the chairman of Bhasahni Onusrari Parishad, said that government activities that were going against the will of the people also ...
  58. [58]
    Dr Zafrullah Chowdhury: The man who walked the talk | Daily Star
    He has been, throughout his life, a vocal critic of authoritarian trends and a fierce advocate for democratic reforms, free speech, and the rule of law ...
  59. [59]
    Rise of Competitive Authoritarianism in Bangladesh
    Jul 13, 2020 · First, the denial of the multi-party system was a coercive and aimed at maintaining political order, which resulted into deep antagonism between ...
  60. [60]
    Arrest order for Zafrullah | The Daily Star
    Jun 19, 2015 · The court on June 10 found Zafrullah guilty of contempt and imprisoned him at the tribunal for an hour for criticising the punishment of ...
  61. [61]
    ICT recalls arrest warrant against Zafrullah | The Daily Star
    A tribunal in Dhaka today recalled the arrest warrant against Gonoshasthaya Kendra founder Zafrullah Chowdhury for non-payment of a fine it had imposed on ...
  62. [62]
    Zafrullah apologises, SC cancels his fine | The Daily Star
    Supreme Court scrapes International Crimes Tribunal-2 ruling imposing Tk 5000 fine on Gonoshasthaya Kendra founder Zafrullah Chowdhury for contempt of court
  63. [63]
    Bangladesh: Activist Zafrullah Chowdhury charged with treason for ...
    Oct 16, 2018 · The Bangladesh Army filed a general diary against Chowdhury on Thursday. “The general diary was converted into a treason case on Sunday ...
  64. [64]
    Bangladesh: Beware of what you say on talk shows - DW
    Oct 26, 2018 · The statement incensed Bangladesh's military establishment, which lashed out at Chowdhury for making "untrue and irresponsible comments." The ...
  65. [65]
    Zafrullah apologizes for comments on army chief - Daily Sun
    Pro-BNP professional and Gonoshasthya Kendra founder Dr Zafrullah Chowdhury on Saturday apologised over his 'careless' remarks on current Army Chief General ...
  66. [66]
    Zafrullah sued for 'hurting religious sentiment' - New Age
    Aug 19, 2020 · A case filed against Gonoshasthaya Kendra founder Dr Zafrullah Chowdhury on charges of hurting religious sentiment of Hindus.Missing: challenges | Show results with:challenges
  67. [67]
    Dr Zafrullah sued for hurting religious sentiment - Dhaka Tribune
    Aug 19, 2020 · Gonoshasthaya Kendra founder Dr Zafrullah Chowdhury has been sued for reportedly hurting the religious sentiments of the country's Hindu communities.
  68. [68]
    Will surround High Court with 10,000 people if political activists not ...
    Jul 3, 2022 · Gonoshasthaya Kendra founder Dr Zafrullah Chowdhury has demanded the release of all political activists, including BNP chairperson Khaleda ...Missing: challenges | Show results with:challenges
  69. [69]
    No true Muslim can set fire to someone's house: Dr Zafarullah
    Jul 18, 2022 · Condemning the incidents of communal violence, he said, "The poor are being oppressed because of the minority label. We all have to work ...
  70. [70]
    BNP censures Zafrullah for criticising party - New Age
    Sep 23, 2021 · He said that Zafrullah's comments about the party leaders were not acceptable. He claimed that the remarks of Zafrullah were ill motivated. 'He ...Missing: outspoken | Show results with:outspoken
  71. [71]
    Of a health icon and a freedom fighter - Dhaka
    Mar 9, 2018 · He studied Medicine in Dhaka Medical College, where he got involved with leftist political ideologies. As the general secretary of the Dhaka ...
  72. [72]
    [PDF] Organising and representing the poor in a clientelistic democracy
    Dec 16, 2016 · This was established in 1972 by Dr Zafrullah Chowdhury, a medic and left-wing community activist who had fought in the war against Pakistan.
  73. [73]
    A giant who walked amongst us - New Age
    Apr 13, 2023 · Even in the early days, Zafrullah was one of the few who refused to join Mujib's one-party system, Bangladesh Krishak Sramik Awami League.
  74. [74]
  75. [75]
    Dr Zafrullah Chowdhury no more - UNB
    Apr 11, 2023 · He did play a key role in the formation of BNP-led Jatiya Oikyafront before the 2018 election, and towards the end became known as a critic of ...<|separator|>
  76. [76]
    Awards Of GK - Gonoshasthaya Kendra
    Dr. Zafrullah Chowdhury was awarded the “Independence Award” to recognize Gonoshasthaya Kendra's innovative family planning and primary health care programs.
  77. [77]
    Dr Zafrullah Chowdhury, who championed access to healthcare in ...
    Apr 12, 2023 · Chowdhury, who founded the healthcare organisation Gonoshasthaya Kendra, received the Right Livelihood Award in 1992. “Dr Chowdhury had a ...Missing: key | Show results with:key
  78. [78]
    Acceptance speech - Zafrullah Chowdhury / Gonoshasthaya Kendra
    3. Although Gonoshasthaya Kendra's health programme aimed to provide domiciliary health care to rural poor households on a priority basis, we soon found that ...Missing: healthcare | Show results with:healthcare
  79. [79]
    Book reviews - Oxford Academic
    Zafrullah Chowdhury (1995) London: ... Chowdhury was also a key advisor to the government when it formulated its pioneering. National Drug Policy and Drug ...
  80. [80]
    Dr Zafrullah seriously ill, hospitalised - The Business Standard
    Apr 7, 2023 · "Dr Zafrullah Chowdhury is seriously ill. He has been suffering from kidney complications for a long time. In the last few days, he has been ...Missing: decline | Show results with:decline
  81. [81]
    Zafrullah Chowdhury's health condition unchanged - New Age
    Apr 9, 2023 · Quoting physicians, GK press adviser Jahangir Alam Mintu, said that besides the kidney failure he was suffering from liver and heart problems.Missing: decline illness
  82. [82]
    People's doctor no more - Dhaka - The Daily Star
    Apr 12, 2023 · Doctors said his liver and kidneys suffered much since he was infected with Covid-19. Zafrullah was alive with almost two dysfunctional kidneys ...Missing: decline | Show results with:decline
  83. [83]
    Health - Gonoshasthaya Kendra
    Major improvements have been observed in the GK catchment area for the following health indices, such as IMR (Infant Mortality Rate) came down to 18.30 /1000 ...
  84. [84]
    Zafrullah Chowdhury ripped into Tarique Rahman. Then he comes ...
    Jun 26, 2021 · Dr Zafrullah Chowdhury has come under fire from a group of Chhatra Dal activists over his remarks on Tarique Rahman, the acting chairman of BNP.
  85. [85]
    Dr Zafrullah: Politicians who denounced me even lack the qualities ...
    Sep 10, 2021 · Gonoshasthaya Kendra founder Dr Zafrullah Chowdhury has blasted the politicians who denounced him for his recent remarks on the decision of appointing Tarique ...
  86. [86]
    Zafrullah Chowdhury - The Lancet
    May 20, 2023 · Surgeon, public health activist, and champion of health equity. Born on Dec 27, 1941 in what is now Raozan, Bangladesh, he died from chronic kidney disease ...Missing: biography - - | Show results with:biography - -
  87. [87]
    Remembering Zafrullah Chowdhury (1941-2023): Reflections on his ...
    Apr 11, 2025 · Remembering Zafrullah Chowdhury (1941-2023): Reflections on his second death anniversary. S Srinivasan. Published online first on April 11 ...
  88. [88]
    “Involve the local people” - dandc.eu
    Oct 15, 2016 · Health care is not something that must be left to doctors and drug companies, argues Zafrullah Chowdhury, the founder of a rural health-care ...
  89. [89]
    Our one and only Zafrullah Bhai | The Daily Star
    Apr 12, 2023 · He believed everyone irrespective of gender should learn skills that would make them self-reliant. His recruitment policy was fair, non- ...