Fact-checked by Grok 2 weeks ago

zbMATH Open

zbMATH Open is an open-access comprehensive database and reviewing service for pure and , offering abstracts, expert reviews, and bibliographic data on scholarly publications. Originally founded in as Zentralblatt für Mathematik, it has evolved into the world's longest-running abstracting and reviewing resource in the field, now freely accessible since its relaunch in 2021 under the zbMATH Open banner. Maintained by FIZ Karlsruhe in collaboration with international mathematical societies, it indexes approximately 5 million entries spanning journal articles, books, , and mathematical software. The service employs the (MSC) scheme to organize content, enabling precise searches across mathematical topics, authors, journals, and citations. Key features include advanced search functionalities, links to full-text sources, and a reviewer service that facilitates post-publication quality assessments by domain experts. zbMATH Open promotes discoverability and interconnections in mathematical research by integrating persistent identifiers and references to related software and datasets. Its transition to was supported by funding from the (DFG) and partnerships with entities like the , ensuring sustainability while broadening global access to mathematical literature. This shift addressed prior limitations of subscription models, aligning with broader movements toward open scholarship in STEM fields.

Historical Development

Origins in the Jahrbuch über die Fortschritte der Mathematik

The Jahrbuch über die Fortschritte der Mathematik (JFM) was founded in by Carl Ohrtmann and Felix Müller as the earliest systematic effort to review and classify the entirety of mathematical publications, including applications primarily in physics, with the inaugural volume—covering 838 works from —appearing in 1871. Published annually by Reimer Verlag in and later by Walter de Gruyter after its acquisition, JFM compiled all accessible literature by publication year, striving for exhaustive coverage through expert-authored summaries rather than mere listings. Editorship evolved from the founders to Emil Lampe, followed by Leon Lichtenstein and Aurel Korn; by the 1920s, the assumed responsibility, which enhanced timeliness amid growing publication volumes. For instance, the volume for 1935 (published 1939) encompassed approximately 6,000 entries from around 400 journals, evaluated by more than 200 international referees, reflecting JFM's reliance on a global network of mathematicians for rigorous assessment. This approach established JFM as a foundational resource for tracking mathematical progress, supplanting earlier fragmented efforts and influencing subsequent reviewing services despite production delays that later prompted alternatives like Zentralblatt für Mathematik. Publication ceased after the 67th volume in 1942, amid disruptions, leaving a gap in comprehensive annual reviews that zbMATH's predecessors addressed. The JFM archive, spanning 1868 to 1942, was digitized between 1998 and 2002 through the ERaM project, involving TU Berlin, SUB , and FIZ with funding from the Deutsche Forschungsgemeinschaft (DFG); this converted scanned volumes into a searchable LaTeX-based database including authors, reviewers, titles, and full review texts. Integration of the digitized JFM data into zbMATH occurred in 2004, retroactively standardizing elements such as journal abbreviations, adding DOIs to about 20% of its 223,276 documents, and incorporating early citation linkages for over 6,000 items, thereby extending zbMATH Open's continuous coverage of mathematical literature back to 1868. This incorporation underpins zbMATH Open's historical depth, preserving JFM's original commitment to completeness and expert curation as the bedrock of modern mathematical bibliographic services, now accessible openly since under a CC-BY-SA 4.0 license.

Establishment of Zentralblatt für Mathematik

Zentralblatt für Mathematik und ihre Grenzgebiete was established in 1931 by the mathematician Otto Neugebauer as its founding editor-in-chief, in collaboration with , , and the publisher Ferdinand Springer of Springer Verlag. The initiative involved cooperation with the , reflecting the era's emphasis on centralized mathematical documentation amid Germany's academic prominence. The establishment addressed the accelerating volume of global mathematical publications during the , which had outpaced the capacity of existing review services like the Jahrbuch über die Fortschritte der Mathematik, an annual compilation founded in that struggled with timeliness. Neugebauer aimed to create a more responsive system for abstracting and reviewing current literature, enabling mathematicians to access summaries of works from around the world shortly after publication, thereby fostering international collaboration and oversight in the field. Initially based in and with editorial operations at Springer's premises, the journal launched with a diverse international editorial board that included prominent figures such as Pavel S. Alexandrov and Godfrey H. Hardy, underscoring its ambition for comprehensive coverage beyond German-language sources. It appeared as a monthly publication, producing 18 volumes between and before wartime disruptions, and quickly gained traction as a vital tool for mathematical research despite emerging political challenges in that affected its operations and personnel.

Evolution into zbMATH and Digital Transition

In 1990, Zentralblatt für Mathematik und ihre Grenzgebiete released CompactMATH, its inaugural product, which digitized reviews and abstracts from recent volumes, enabling electronic access to the service's content for the first time. This development addressed growing demands for faster retrieval amid expanding mathematical literature, bridging the gap between print-based reviewing and emerging digital technologies. The pivotal digital transition occurred in 1996, when the service launched an internet-accessible , initially branded as MATH and later renamed zbMATH, supplementing the ongoing printed edition. This shift, managed by and the FIZ Karlsruhe, incorporated web-based search functionalities and began integrating digitized historical records, such as those from the predecessor Jahrbuch über die Fortschritte der Mathematik, fully absorbed by 2004. The zbMATH platform thus evolved from a static journal into a dynamic database, covering over 3 million entries by the early 2000s and supporting international editorial contributions. Printed volumes persisted until their discontinuation in 2013, reflecting the dominance of online access and resource reallocation toward enhancing digital features like full-text linking and metadata standardization. This evolution solidified zbMATH's role as a core for mathematical documentation, prioritizing comprehensiveness and timeliness over traditional publishing constraints.

Shift to zbMATH Open and Open Access Model

In response to a 2017 evaluation recommending enhanced accessibility, the Joint Science Conference of the German Federal Government and the German States allocated funding in 2019 to transform zbMATH—a longstanding subscription-based abstracting and reviewing service—into an platform. This initiative, led by FIZ – Leibniz Institute for GmbH, aimed to broaden global access to mathematical literature amid evolving digital research needs and financial pressures on traditional models. Preparatory work commenced in , involving technical upgrades to support unrestricted public access while preserving the database's core functionalities, including abstracts, reviews, and metadata for over 3 million publications spanning pure and since 1868. The transition eliminated paywalls that had previously restricted usage primarily to institutional subscribers, aligning zbMATH with broader movements without altering its editorial independence or content curation processes. zbMATH Open officially launched on January 13, 2021, operated from FIZ Karlsruhe's office, marking the service's rebranding and full availability as a free resource. This shift immediately expanded its user base, enabling researchers worldwide to query and retrieve bibliographic data, expert reviews, and classifications without cost, though full-text access to underlying publications remains subject to publisher licenses. Subsequent enhancements have integrated networks and to further embed zbMATH Open within interoperable mathematical information ecosystems.

Scope and Content

Coverage of Mathematical Literature

zbMATH Open indexes published and peer-reviewed articles, books, , and other formats such as monographs and preprints relevant to . These entries encompass contributions from journals, serials, book series, and proceedings volumes. The database prioritizes peer-reviewed content but has expanded to include preprints, reflecting adaptations to modern dissemination practices in mathematical research. The scope spans all branches of pure mathematics, including algebra, analysis, geometry, and topology, alongside applied mathematics in fields such as physics, engineering, computer science, natural sciences, and medicine. It also incorporates literature on the history and philosophy of mathematics, as well as mathematical education at the university level. Each entry is classified using the Mathematics Subject Classification (MSC) system, which organizes content into hierarchical categories for precise thematic coverage across over 60 major disciplines. As of recent updates, zbMATH Open contains over 5 million bibliographic entries, with publication years ranging from 1826 to 2025. This includes approximately 4.1 million journal or serial articles, 179,000 books or monographs, 150,000 proceedings contributions, and more than 600,000 preprints. Coverage draws from over 5,000 journals and book series, ensuring broad representation of global mathematical output while focusing on quality through selective indexing and expert review.

Mathematical Subject Classification System

The Mathematical Subject Classification (MSC) serves as the primary indexing framework for zbMATH Open, enabling systematic categorization of mathematical publications to facilitate discovery and retrieval. Jointly maintained by the editorial teams of and zbMATH, the scheme assigns alphanumerical codes to entries based on their content, with each document typically receiving a primary code for its dominant subject and optional secondary codes for additional aspects. This classification underpins zbMATH Open's search functionality, allowing users to query specific codes—such as 11G05 for elliptic curves over global fields—or browse hierarchical trees from broad fields like (14-XX) to specialized subtopics. MSC2020, the edition adopted by zbMATH Open since its implementation in 2020, comprises 63 primary two-digit classes (00-XX through 97-XX), subdivided into finer levels as needed, covering , applied areas, statistics, and interdisciplinary applications including and physics. For instance, new subcodes in MSC2020 address emerging fields like algorithms (68T07) and (55N99), reflecting mathematical advancements in data-driven sciences while preserving with prior versions for historical searches. Revisions occur roughly every decade through collaborative review processes involving expert mathematicians, ensuring the scheme evolves with the discipline without disrupting established indexing. In practice, zbMATH Open classifies over 3 million entries using , with codes assigned by expert reviewers or derived from author submissions, enhancing precision over keyword-only searches by capturing conceptual hierarchies. The system's open availability via zbMATH Open promotes its use beyond the database, such as in library catalogs and research software, though occasional debates arise over granularity in rapidly expanding areas like , prompting targeted updates in future iterations.

Reviewing and Abstracting Processes

The reviewing and abstracting processes of zbMATH Open ensure comprehensive coverage of mathematical literature through expert contributions and editorial oversight. Publications are indexed from over 5,000 journals, book series, and proceedings, with new issues incorporated within three months of release, often sooner. Abstracts, as concise summaries of content, are prepared as part of initial editorial work and updated daily alongside bibliographic data. These abstracts distinguish from reviews by focusing solely on summarization without evaluation, aiding users in rapid content assessment. Reviews are assigned selectively by zbMATH Open editors to over 8,000 active expert reviewers worldwide, typically with relevant expertise. Selected after indexing, reviews undergo finalization over several months to provide a neutral, balanced description of the work's contents within broader subject developments. Unlike , which precedes publication, zbMATH reviews serve post-publication as informative overviews, noting significant errors, overlaps with prior work, or key references without endorsing or rejecting the material. Reviewers, open to any trained via application, must submit within eight weeks using a dedicated portal or email. Review content emphasizes mathematical substance: a brief account of background, main results, and methods, described non-technically for , with applied papers highlighting core math aspects. Guidelines mandate clear English (or /), standard formatting without tables or diagrams, and lengths scaling with the work's significance—from a few lines to more elaborate text—avoiding verbatim reproduction of author abstracts. Citations to related zbMATH entries (via Zbl numbers) enhance context, supporting precise identification of influences. This process, overseen by FIZ , the , and the Heidelberg Academy of Sciences, maintains quality through editorial selection and neutral evaluation standards.

Features and Services

Search and Retrieval Capabilities

zbMATH Open offers a web-based search optimized for mathematical , featuring both multi-line and one-line search modes to facilitate precise querying of its database containing over 3.5 million entries as of . The multi-line search, introduced as the default form in , provides an intuitive for structured queries across documents, authors, serials, and software, supporting operators including AND, OR, and AND NOT to combine terms across multiple fields. One-line search enables flexible, free-text entry with advanced operators such as & (AND), | (OR), ! (NOT), phrase quoting (" "), wildcards (*), and grouping parentheses, allowing searches in fields like titles (ti), authors (au), abstracts (ab), publication years (py), codes (cc or ), DOIs, and journal sources. Specialized mathematical features include formula search for querying mathematical expressions and filtering by primary or secondary classifications, which organize content into over 60 fields and hundreds of subfields based on the 2020 revision. Retrieval from search results includes direct access to abstracts, reviews, bibliographic , and cross-links to over 100,000 full-text articles via integrated platforms like , alongside external DOIs and publisher links. Author searches yield profiles with publication lists, co-author graphs, main research fields, and citation metrics; serials searches provide indexing details, status, issue lists, and subject frequencies; software searches link to swMATH entries with descriptions and usage data. Data export options support formats like for citations, while programmatic retrieval is enabled through a REST for metadata queries via document endpoints and an OAI-PMH for harvesting sets of records, both documented for integration into external tools. Additional tools such as author disambiguation and citation matching enhance accuracy in retrieving and linking related entries.

Data Integration and APIs

zbMATH Open offers programmatic access to its database through multiple APIs, facilitating machine-readable data retrieval and integration into external applications. The REST , launched in , provides endpoints for querying authors, classifications, documents, serials, and software entries, enabling automated searches and data extraction for researchers and developers. This supports structured outputs in formats like , with usage governed by terms that permit software development and integration while protecting underlying copyrights. Complementing it is the OAI-PMH , which allows harvesting of in standard protocols for . A specialized Links API enhances connectivity by interlinking zbMATH records with external mathematical resources, such as the Digital Library of Mathematical Functions (DLMF) and the (OEIS). This API indexes references across approximately 6,330 zbMATH documents containing over 65,000 links to these partners, promoting cross-resource navigation and data enrichment. Additionally, citation matching tools via API support bibliographic verification and linking. On the integration front, zbMATH Open incorporates external datasets to broaden its coverage, including the merger of swMATH software in 2022, which added specialized entries for mathematical software alongside traditional . preprints from designated mathematical categories are systematically indexed, with plans for synchronized data snapshots to align release cycles and ensure consistency. Recent advancements include Graph integration via DataCite, assigning persistent identifiers to entries for improved discoverability, software linking, and traceability of mathematical concepts across publications. DLMF further embeds computational function references directly into zbMATH records, aiding reproducibility in . These efforts position zbMATH Open as a hub for aggregating and exposing linked mathematical data, though API rate limits and data freshness depend on periodic updates from source providers.

Open Access Enhancements and Preprint Inclusion

zbMATH Open transitioned to a fully service in January 2021, funded by the Federal and State Governments of , providing free access to its , reviews, and abstracts covering literature from 1755 onward. This shift enabled the release of data under a CC BY-SA 4.0 license, facilitating reuse while maintaining quality curation standards. Enhancements include integration of over 4.3 million full-text links to resources such as , the platform, and EuDML, with nearly 800,000 full-text articles directly from , bringing total accessible full texts to more than 1 million. Search functionalities were bolstered by an filter, allowing users to refine results by accessibility status, alongside export options for citations in formats like , , AMSRef, and XML. Since December 2024, the platform displays status and license information at the individual article level, extending beyond journal-wide data to support precise resource evaluation. Machine-readable access was improved through including OAI-PMH, Links, and , with the latter recording over 300,000 accesses in 2024 to promote programmatic integration and reproducibility in mathematical research. These features align with principles, earning recognition such as the Demailly Prize in June 2024 for advancing accessible mathematical documentation. Preprint inclusion began in 2024 with the integration of arXiv preprints from selected mathematical subcategories, adding over 200,000 unpublished entries to enhance visibility of emerging research, particularly for early-career mathematicians. These are cataloged as a distinct document type labeled "arXiv" under "Preprints," ensuring clear differentiation from peer-reviewed publications through stable arXiv identifiers, abstracts, and author profiles, without assigning reviews or Mathematical Subject Classification codes unless pre-assigned. Implementation employs a two-step matching algorithm based on DOIs and classifiers, achieving 99.51% precision and 96.89% recall as of December 2023, to merge preprint entries with subsequent published versions, retaining arXiv links as supplementary access points. Withdrawn preprints follow arXiv policies for display, while the system avoids indexing non-mathematical or low-relevance submissions to preserve focus on verifiable contributions. This approach addresses the fact that over one-third of recent mathematics output appears on first, bridging the gap between unpublished work and formal literature without compromising zbMATH Open's emphasis on curated, post-publication .

Impact and Challenges

Influence on Mathematical Research

zbMATH Open has significantly facilitated the of mathematical literature by indexing approximately 4.9 million publications spanning from 1755 to 2024, including over 800,000 full-text articles and links to 4.3 million publications, thereby enabling researchers to navigate references, identify relevant works, and explore interdisciplinary connections. Its model, implemented in January 2021, has democratized access to bibliographic data, reviews, and abstracts across pure and , drawing on contributions from over 5,000 journals and 200,000 books. This shift has led to a surge in usage, with 48 million accesses recorded in 2023 and doubled user growth in regions such as the , , and following the transition to free availability. The platform's post-publication review process, comprising more than 1.2 million expert reviews authored by 7,263 active reviewers, provides critical evaluations that contextualize publications without supplanting initial , thereby aiding researchers in assessing quality and amid expanding publication volumes. Integration of the Mathematical Subject Classification (MSC 2020) system standardizes categorization, allowing precise searches and trend analysis that inform research directions and funding decisions within the mathematical community. These features support quality control and trust-building, positioning zbMATH Open as a counter to by highlighting verified mathematical contributions. Advancements such as services—including OAI-PMH (with a five-fold increase in usage from 2021 to 2024) and REST APIs—enable programmatic data retrieval and interoperability with external systems, fostering automated workflows, citation tracking via 50 million linked references, and integration with tools like swMATH for over 40,000 mathematical software entries. This enhances reproducibility and collaboration, as seen in partnerships with repositories like Software Heritage to archive and mitigate , ultimately streamlining research practices and boosting software citation in mathematical outputs. With 1.35 million author profiles linking to external platforms, zbMATH Open promotes networking and impact measurement, contributing to a more connected and efficient global ecosystem.

Criticisms Regarding Review Quality and Sustainability

Some mathematicians have expressed concerns that zbMATH Open's reviews are less detailed or analytically rigorous compared to those in , attributing this to differences in reviewer pools and editorial emphases, with zbMATH summaries often described as more concise and formulaic. The volunteer-driven process, reliant on unpaid contributions from experts, has led to instances of reviewer , with some declining requests to evaluate low-merit published works due to the effort required for minimal perceived impact. Post-publication timing exacerbates these issues, as delays in review production—sometimes months or years after publication—diminish their utility in an era of rapid online preprint dissemination via platforms like , rendering summaries redundant for accessible papers. While zbMATH Open editors perform quality checks, including typo corrections and language edits, the decentralized reviewer community, spanning from PhD students to senior researchers, can result in variability not always mitigated by oversight. Sustainability critiques focus on the open access model's dependence on public funding, primarily from the Leibniz Association since 2021, which replaced subscription revenue but introduces risks of policy reversals amid potential budget constraints. Mathematicians in community forums have voiced reluctance to invest time in reviews without guarantees against future paywalls that could lock away open-era content, arguing this erodes incentives for participation and threatens long-term review volume and upkeep. Such uncertainties are compounded by slower post-2021 reviewer compared to MathSciNet's established base, potentially straining coverage as zbMATH Open indexes over 3.5 million items annually. Despite these, official reports emphasize ongoing enhancements, like algorithmic aids for abstracting, to bolster resilience.

Debates on Preprint Indexing and Peer Review Standards

zbMATH Open initiated the indexing of relevant arXiv preprints in early 2024 to broaden access to emerging mathematical research and align with open access principles, displaying these entries alongside traditional peer-reviewed publications while providing filters to differentiate unpublished items. This expansion addresses the timeliness gap in mathematics literature, where preprints often precede journal publication by months or years, enabling earlier discovery without paywalls. However, preprints indexed from undergo no formal prior to inclusion, contrasting with zbMATH Open's core of curating through expert post-publication reviews and abstracts. Unlike published items, metadata is not corrected for errors, and withdrawn arXiv submissions are flagged but remain visible, raising concerns about propagating inaccuracies or unvetted claims in a database historically valued for . This approach has sparked discussions on formulating indexing criteria that preserve zbMATH Open's scope amid arXiv's absence of editorial gatekeeping, with some questioning whether automated or heuristic selection suffices for mathematical rigor. Comparisons with , which adheres strictly to peer-reviewed sources and excludes preprints, highlight differing philosophies: zbMATH Open prioritizes comprehensiveness and openness, potentially at the expense of uniform verification, while critics argue that conflating reviewed and unreviewed works erodes user trust in the database's reliability for assessing validity. Proponents counter that mathematics benefits from arXiv's community-driven scrutiny, where informal feedback often approximates , and zbMATH Open's post-indexing reviews can still apply selectively to mitigate risks. Nonetheless, the policy underscores broader tensions in , where rapid dissemination via preprints challenges traditional standards without fully supplanting them.

References

  1. [1]
    About - zbMATH Open
    zbMATH Open (formerly known as Zentralblatt MATH) is the world's most comprehensive and longest-running abstracting and reviewing service in pure and applied ...Overview · User interface · Scientific and editorial boards · The years 1933–1945
  2. [2]
    Frequently Asked Questions - zbMATH Open
    zbMATH Open is the world's most comprehensive and longest-running abstracting and reviewing service in pure and applied mathematics.
  3. [3]
    zbMATH Open | FIZ Karlsruhe
    zbMATH Open is an information service for mathematics with networked information on mathematical topics, authors, publications, references, and software.<|separator|>
  4. [4]
    Documents Search - zbMATH Open
    On October 28 from 08:00am-11:00am UTC, some of our services will be disrupted due to planned maintenance work. The main site should continue to work, but some ...AuthorsReviewer ServiceSerials SearchClassificationAbout
  5. [5]
    An Overview of zbMATH Open Digital Library - arXiv
    Oct 9, 2024 · The goal of zbMATH Open is to provide all peer-reviewed mathematical research data. Under this category, many domains provide mathematical ...
  6. [6]
    zbMATH Open : the first resource for mathematics - RNBM
    Apr 13, 2021 · zbMATH Open is the online version of the oldest math bibliographic database, providing reviews, bibtex entries, and links to digital ...
  7. [7]
    The “Jahrbuch über die Fortschritte der Mathematik” as a part of ...
    2021 marks the 150th anniversary of the publication of the first volume of the “Jahrbuch über die Fortschritte der Mathematik” (JFM), as well as the transition ...JFM digitisation · Integration of JFM into zbMATH · JFM as part of zbMATH Open
  8. [8]
    Zentralblatt MATH - ZMATH Online Database - History
    The Jahrbuch über die Fortschritte der Mathematik. This annual periodical started its publication 1869 in the programme of the publishing house Reimer Verlag, ...
  9. [9]
    Otto Neugebauer - American Mathematical Society
    Oct 1, 2020 · Otto Neugebauer was the founder and first editor-in-chief of both Zentralblatt für Mathematik und ihre. Grenzgebiete and Mathematical Reviews ...
  10. [10]
    [PDF] An Overview of zbMATH Open Digital Library - arXiv
    Oct 9, 2024 · zbMATH Open is a comprehensive, open-access database of mathematical publications, serving as a platform for finding and connecting ...
  11. [11]
    The Transition of zbMATH Towards an Open Information Platform for ...
    zbMATH1 (formerly Zentralblatt für Mathematik) has long been a comprehensive service with information on mathematical publications, authors and references, as.
  12. [12]
    New open access platform for mathematics launched online
    With its funding decision in 2019, the Joint Science ...
  13. [13]
    The Role of MathSciNet and zbMATH Open in the Open Access ...
    Aug 5, 2025 · This shift toward OA is driven in part by financial pressures: traditional subscription-based models are becoming less viable due to the global ...
  14. [14]
    The transition of zbMATH towards an open information platform for ...
    The vision of zbMATH Open as an open service for mathematics research. Here we give a report of the achievements since then.
  15. [15]
    New Open Access Platform for Mathematics launched online
    Jan 13, 2021 · Start of zbMATH Open: As of now, the renowned international information service will be available free of charge.
  16. [16]
    The Transition of zbMATH Towards an Open Information Platform for ...
    The transition towards an Open Data Platform enabled zbMATH Open to build a network of open resources. Important components in the evolving information system ...
  17. [17]
    zbMATH Open: new features and achievements in 2024
    Jan 11, 2025 · Currently, zbMATH Open contains around 5 million bibliographic entries with reviews or abstracts drawn from more than 5,000 journals and book ...
  18. [18]
    Mathematics Subject Classification – MSC2020 - zbMATH
    Mathematics Subject Classification – MSC2020​​ MSC2020 is the latest revision of the Mathematics Subject Classification (MSC), jointly published by Mathematical ...
  19. [19]
    [PDF] MSC2020-Mathematics Subject Classification System - zbMATH
    00 General and overarching topics; collections. 01 History and biography. 03 Mathematical logic and foundations. 05 Combinatorics.
  20. [20]
    Mathematics Subject Classification 2020 (MSC2020)
    In addition to the -08 classes, and not including classes from 03 (Mathematical logic and foundations) or 68 (Computer science), there are 58 classes referring ...
  21. [21]
    Mathematics Subject Classification 2020
    Mar 2, 2020 · Mathematical Reviews and zbMATH are now using. MSC2020 as their classification schemes. We welcome and encourage the community also to adopt ...
  22. [22]
    [PDF] Guide for Reviewers - zbMATH
    Nov 1, 2024 · A review of a mathematical work should give a brief and clear account of its contents, ideally presenting some background, the main results and ...
  23. [23]
    General Help - zbMATH Open
    For searching in zbMATH Open you may employ the multi-line search for documents, authors, serials or software respectively.
  24. [24]
    Authors Search - zbMATH Open
    Here you find publications, co-authors, main fields, and citation profiles for authors in zbMATH Open.
  25. [25]
    Serials Search - zbMATH Open
    Here you find information about indexing and open access status, issue lists, frequent authors and subjects, and citation profiles for serials in zbMATH Open.
  26. [26]
    Tools & Resources - zbMATH Open
    zbMATH Open provides tools like Author Disambiguation, Co-Author Distance, and Citation Matching, and resources such as REST API, OAI-PMH API, and GitHub.
  27. [27]
    https://zbmath.org/tools-and-resources/
  28. [28]
    A REST API for zbMATH Open access - EMS Press
    In 2023 a new option was added, a so-called REST API, which makes the data available in a machine-readable fashion, for automated use by researchers. We will ...Missing: integration | Show results with:integration
  29. [29]
    zbMATHOpen/zbRestApiClient: a REST api for zbMATH ... - GitHub
    A REST api for zbMATH Open, currently with endpoints for authors, classifications, documents, serials and software.
  30. [30]
    Terms & Conditions - zbMATH Open REST API
    FIZ Karlsruhe grants Users the right to use the zbMATH Open API Service to develop and test software applications (hereinafter "Applications") and to integrate ...
  31. [31]
    [PDF] zbMATH Open: API Solutions and Research Challenges - CEUR-WS
    Abstract. We present zbMATH Open, the most comprehensive collection of reviews and bibliographic metadata of scholarly literature in mathematics.
  32. [32]
    Advancements in zbMATH Open for Enhanced Mathematical ...
    zbMATH Open offers connection to external partners, DLMF and OEIS, via its Links API by indexing approximately 6,330 documents containing 65,069 references to ...
  33. [33]
    Sustaining the swMATH project: Integration into zbMATH Open ...
    Through the new API, research software programs and their metadata will be easily accessible. This component will be exposed so that one can use it to convert ...
  34. [34]
    Mapping Mathematics - Integrating zbMATH Open and the PID Graph
    Jun 24, 2025 · This integration facilitates advanced discoverability, interlinks mathematical research software with broader scientific outputs, and extends the reach of ...
  35. [35]
    Open access status and licences in zbMATH Open | EMS Magazine
    Since December 2024, zbMATH Open displays open access and licence information not just on a journal level but also for individual articles.
  36. [36]
    zbMATH Open – Where do we stand and what's next? - EMS Press
    Nov 15, 2024 · In the early 1990s, after the Zentralblatt had become available electronically on CD, there were discussions in my institute whether we should ...
  37. [37]
    The extension of zbMATH Open by arXiv preprints | EMS Magazine
    zbMATH Open has started a new feature – relevant preprints posted at arXiv will also be displayed in the database.
  38. [38]
    [2410.06948] An Overview of zbMATH Open Digital Library - arXiv
    Oct 9, 2024 · Mathematical research thrives on the effective dissemination and discovery of knowledge. zbMATH Open has emerged as a pivotal platform in this ...
  39. [39]
    https://arxiv.org/abs/2410.06948
  40. [40]
    Advancements in zbMATH Open for Enhanced Mathematical ...
    Jul 17, 2024 · zbMATH Open offers connection to external partners, DLMF and OEIS, via its Links API by indexing approximately 6,330 documents containing 65,069 ...
  41. [41]
    Examples of ZBMath reviews that motivated you to read the paper
    Dec 4, 2023 · I think ZBMath or MathSciNet reviews should aim to give a factual and neutral account of the results of the paper in question.Missing: abstracts | Show results with:abstracts
  42. [42]
    The Zentralblatt asked me to review a worthless paper, what to do?
    Jul 17, 2024 · I spent a bunch of time carefully reviewing each and gave the authors extensive feedback (this was explicitly acknowledged in both papers).Missing: criticisms | Show results with:criticisms
  43. [43]
    I quit (from MathSciNet and ZbMath) - Noncommutative Analysis
    Oct 13, 2017 · Several months ago I informed both MathSciNet as well as Zentralblatt that I would like to stop reviewing papers for these repositories.Missing: criticisms | Show results with:criticisms
  44. [44]
    Quality control at zbMATH - EMS Press
    Finally, we also monitor the quality of the reviews themselves. Each review is edited by at least one editor to make sure that the number of typos and language.
  45. [45]
    Sustainability of ZBmath unrestricted access - MathOverflow
    Sep 24, 2020 · ZBmath (formerly Zentralblatt für Mathematik) will become "Open access" in 2021 (see for instance at EMS site and at FIZ Karlsruhe site). It ...
  46. [46]
    [PDF] arXiv:2401.08297v1 [cs.DL] 16 Jan 2024
    Jan 16, 2024 · The first and fore- most condition for integrating unpublished arXiv preprints into zbMATH Open must be that they are clearly distinguish- able ...
  47. [47]
    The extension of zbMATH Open by arXiv preprints - EMS Press
    If so, how should one formulate a sound in- dexing policy that matches closely the zbMATH Open scope despite the lack of a formal peer review process at arXiv?
  48. [48]
    Mathematical Reviews - AMS
    This scheme, developed by the two reviewing databases, Mathematical Reviews® and Zentralblatt MATH, is used by them to classify book and article listings.Missing: preprints | Show results with:preprints<|separator|>
  49. [49]
    Guest Post: Preprints Serve the Anti-science Agenda – This Is Why ...
    Apr 17, 2025 · Preprints are like blog posts that carry most of the markers of rigorously peer-reviewed articles. They are designed to look and feel credible.
  50. [50]
    A conceptual peer review model for arXiv and other preprint databases
    Feb 6, 2019 · This paper evaluates and identifies two weak points of Community Peer Review and proposes a new peer review model – Self-Organizing Peer Review.Missing: debate | Show results with:debate