Fact-checked by Grok 2 weeks ago

Conference proceedings

Conference proceedings are the published records of papers, abstracts, posters, or presentations delivered at academic conferences, congresses, symposia, or other professional meetings typically sponsored by scholarly societies or associations.^[1] These collections capture cutting-edge research and discussions in specific fields, often serving as an early venue for disseminating innovative ideas before full journal publication.^[2] In academia, conference proceedings play a vital role in scholarly communication by enabling researchers to share preliminary findings, test new methodologies, and engage with peers in less formal settings than peer-reviewed journals.^[1] They facilitate rapid knowledge exchange, allowing attendees and broader audiences to access unpublished or emerging work that advances scientific and societal impact.^[3] For instance, proceedings often highlight novel treatments or interdisciplinary insights, such as those from specialized conferences on respiratory diseases, providing depth through combined reviews and original contributions.^[4] Proceedings are published in diverse formats to accommodate varying levels of detail and accessibility, including full-text papers (known as transactions), abstracts, extended abstracts, or digests of presentations.^[1] They may appear as standalone one-time volumes, serial publications by organizing bodies, special issues in academic journals, or digital collections available online through platforms maintained by societies or publishers.^[2] Print versions resemble books, while electronic formats have become predominant for wider dissemination, though some require direct contact with authors or organizers if not formally published.^[5] The tradition of publishing conference proceedings dates back to at least the mid-20th century in fields like computer science, with systematic records emerging around 1959, though they build on earlier scientific meeting documentation to broaden access beyond participants.^[6] Their significance extends to career development, fostering networking, collaborations, and visibility— for example, a survey found that around 70% of early-career researchers gained insights into unpublished papers at international conferences, with many also learning about alternative methods, leading to joint projects and publications.^[3] In disciplines such as engineering and sciences, proceedings are essential for tracking innovations and best practices, making them indispensable for comprehensive literature reviews.^[2]

Overview and Purpose

Definition

Conference proceedings are published collections of academic papers, abstracts, or summaries of presentations delivered at a specific scholarly conference or workshop, serving as an official record of the event's intellectual contributions.^[7] These compilations typically include full-length research articles, extended abstracts, or shorter summaries, capturing the original work shared by researchers during the conference sessions.^[8] They are compiled from pre-event submissions and released around the time of or shortly after the event, though often available in advance in digital formats, to preserve and disseminate the timely discussions and findings.^[2] Key characteristics of conference proceedings include their close temporal linkage to a single hosting event, which makes them a snapshot of research at a particular moment rather than an ongoing publication series. They are frequently organized around thematic or disciplinary foci, such as artificial intelligence or computer graphics, reflecting the conference's scope and attracting specialists in those areas. Peer review processes vary across proceedings: some undergo rigorous double-blind evaluation similar to journals, while others feature lighter scrutiny, particularly for abstracts, allowing for the inclusion of preliminary or emerging ideas.^[8] This flexibility enables proceedings to document cutting-edge, work-in-progress research that may later evolve into fuller publications.^[9] Prominent examples illustrate these features, such as the proceedings of the Conference on Neural Information Processing Systems (NeurIPS), which annually compile peer-reviewed full papers on machine learning advancements, available in electronic format prior to the event.^[10] Similarly, the ACM SIGGRAPH Conference Proceedings feature technical papers and extended abstracts on computer graphics and interactive techniques, often including visual demonstrations tied to the conference's artistic and scientific presentations.^[11] These volumes highlight how proceedings encapsulate event-specific innovations within focused domains. In distinction from academic journals, conference proceedings represent discrete, event-bound captures of research outputs rather than continuous, serial publications that build cumulatively over time. While journals emphasize in-depth, polished articles subject to extensive revision, proceedings prioritize rapid dissemination of conference content, often with shorter formats and varying review stringency, functioning as immediate archival records of scholarly gatherings.^[12]

Role in Academia

Conference proceedings play a central role in academia by enabling the rapid dissemination of preliminary and cutting-edge research findings. They allow researchers to share novel ideas and results with the scholarly community shortly after presentation, fostering immediate feedback and influencing subsequent studies in dynamic fields. This function is essential for advancing knowledge in areas where delays could hinder progress, such as emerging technologies or experimental sciences.^[13]^[14] Beyond dissemination, proceedings facilitate networking among academics, promoting collaborations, discussions, and the exchange of insights that often lead to refined research directions. They also serve to establish priority in discoveries by providing a timestamped, peer-reviewed record of announcements, which helps researchers claim originality and protect intellectual contributions in competitive domains.^[14]^[15] A key benefit of conference proceedings is their accelerated publication timeline compared to journals, often making content available shortly before, during, or soon after the conference, which contrasts with the months to years required for many journal processes.^[14] This speed ensures timely archival of conference content, preserving the event's intellectual contributions for long-term reference and citation in scholarly work.^[16]^[13] In terms of career advancement, proceedings significantly bolster publication records and are instrumental in hiring, promotions, and tenure evaluations, particularly in fields where they are viewed as primary outlets. For instance, in computer science, top conference publications often hold greater prestige than many journal articles due to rigorous selection and low acceptance rates, serving as a core metric of scholarly productivity.^[16]^[14] The significance of proceedings varies across disciplines; in STEM areas like engineering and computer science, they are highly prestigious primary venues, with organizations such as IEEE publishing proceedings that reach global audiences and underpin technical literature exchange. Conversely, in the humanities, proceedings are generally supplementary, as scholarly communication prioritizes books and book chapters over conference outputs.^[17]^[18]

Historical Development

Origins

Early precursors to conference proceedings appeared in the 17th and 18th centuries through publications of scientific societies that recorded meeting discussions, such as the Royal Society of London's Philosophical Transactions, launched in 1665, which disseminated communications and experiments from its assemblies.^[19] However, the formal origins of dedicated conference proceedings trace to the 19th century, accelerating amid the Industrial Revolution as advancements in transportation and communication enabled larger professional gatherings in fields like engineering and medicine. Professional organizations hosted regular meetings, leading to the publication of contributed papers and debates as proceedings. For instance, the Institution of Mechanical Engineers, founded in 1847 in Birmingham, began issuing proceedings from its inaugural sessions, capturing innovations in steam power, machinery, and manufacturing processes central to industrial progress. In medicine, practitioners convened to address epidemic diseases and surgical techniques, with proceedings serving as vital records for advancing clinical knowledge amid rapid urbanization and public health challenges. Significant milestones included the first dedicated international congresses, whose proceedings marked a shift toward global collaboration. During the 1867 Exposition Universelle in Paris, several congresses were held, including the inaugural International Medical Congress (August 16–28), which drew over 1,000 delegates from 30 countries to discuss topics like microscopy and hygiene; its proceedings were compiled into multilingual volumes for widespread distribution.^[20] Another landmark was the evolution of disciplinary series in mathematics, exemplified by the American Mathematical Society—formed in 1894 from the New York Mathematical Society established in 1888—which launched its Bulletin in 1891 to publish abstracts and full papers from meetings, establishing a model for ongoing proceedings in pure and applied mathematics.^[21] The 20th century saw further proliferation, particularly after World War II, as international collaboration grew in sciences and engineering. In computer science, the tradition of publishing proceedings dates to the mid-20th century, with systematic records emerging around 1959 through events like the Symposium on Information Theory, providing early venues for sharing foundational work in computing and automation.^[6] Initially, these proceedings were produced in simple, accessible formats such as bound volumes or standalone pamphlets, frequently self-published by conference organizers or sponsoring societies to minimize costs and expedite sharing among limited audiences. This approach prioritized archival preservation over commercial distribution, with print runs often numbering in the hundreds and distributed via society memberships or direct sales.

Evolution in the Digital Age

The evolution of conference proceedings in the digital age began in the late 1980s and 1990s with the introduction of electronic distribution methods, transitioning from traditional print formats to more accessible media. Pioneering efforts by organizations like the Association for Computing Machinery (ACM) led to the adoption of CD-ROMs for disseminating proceedings, which allowed for multimedia integration and easier portability compared to bulky print volumes. For instance, ACM SIGGRAPH experimented with CD-ROM publications in 1990 and 1992, followed by full conference proceedings on CD-ROM by the mid-1990s, marking a significant shift toward digital accessibility for researchers worldwide. In the 2000s, the transition accelerated with the widespread adoption of online platforms for PDF uploads and web-based archives, enabling real-time access and searchability. A key milestone was the official launch of IEEE Xplore in May 2000, which digitized and hosted thousands of conference proceedings alongside journals and standards, revolutionizing how engineers and scientists retrieve technical literature through keyword searches and metadata filtering.^[22] This era saw major publishers like ACM and IEEE fully embracing web archives, reducing production costs and expanding reach beyond physical distribution limitations. From the 2010s to the present, conference proceedings have integrated deeply with preprint servers like arXiv, where authors upload manuscripts before or alongside formal proceedings to accelerate dissemination while adhering to conference policies. arXiv facilitates this by supporting submissions of entire proceedings indices, allowing for organized digital collections that link preprints to final versions and enhance discoverability across disciplines such as computer science and physics.^[23] The COVID-19 pandemic catalyzed hybrid models, with virtual conferences surging post-2020 and boosting digital proceedings; for example, major events shifted entirely online in 2020, resulting in archived video presentations, interactive sessions, and perpetual web access that sustained global collaboration even after restrictions lifted. As of 2025, hybrid formats persist, with platforms like Zoom and dedicated conference software enabling broader participation, while open access initiatives continue to evolve.^[24] Key events underscoring this digital transformation include the 2018 launch of Plan S, an open access mandate by cOAlition S that pressured funders to require immediate, unrestricted access to peer-reviewed outputs, including conference papers, often via preprint repositories or version-of-record OA.^[25] Simultaneously, the 2010s witnessed a rise in concerns over predatory conference proceedings, where exploitative organizers used digital tools to proliferate low-quality events and publications, eroding trust and prompting initiatives like blacklists and verification guidelines from academic bodies.^[26]

Production Process

Paper Submission and Review

The paper submission process for conference proceedings begins with a call for papers issued by organizers, which specifies the conference themes, submission guidelines, and deadlines. Submissions are typically due several months before the conference to allow sufficient time for review and scheduling. Authors prepare manuscripts adhering to format requirements, often limited to 6-10 pages including figures and references, using templates provided in styles like LaTeX or Word to ensure consistency.^[27] These submissions are handled electronically through dedicated platforms that facilitate anonymous uploads and metadata entry. The review process employs peer review mechanisms, most commonly single-anonymous (where reviewers know authors' identities but not vice versa) or double-anonymous (blinding both parties), conducted by a program committee of domain experts.^[28] Program committee members, appointed by the technical program chair, evaluate submissions based on criteria such as originality, relevance to the conference theme, technical soundness, novelty, validity of methods, clarity of presentation, and potential impact.^[28] Acceptance rates in competitive fields like computer science or engineering typically range from 20% to 50%, with highly selective venues often below 30%.^[29] Revisions may be requested for conditionally accepted papers to address minor issues before final approval. Conference organizers, including track chairs, play a central role in managing the process, assigning submissions to reviewers based on expertise and overseeing discussions to resolve discrepancies.^[28] Platforms such as EasyChair and Microsoft CMT are widely used to automate assignment, track reviews, and compile scores, streamlining operations for large volumes of submissions. Selected papers then proceed to editing for inclusion in the proceedings.

Editing and Compilation

Once the papers have been selected through peer review, the editing and compilation phase begins, where proceedings editors—typically the conference chairs or designated editorial board members—oversee the transformation of individual accepted manuscripts into a unified publication. These editors ensure that all contributions adhere to the conference's stylistic and formatting standards, often coordinating with authors to incorporate minor revisions. In some cases, particularly for post-conference proceedings, revisions may incorporate feedback from presentations at the event. Editors play a pivotal role in maintaining the overall coherence of the proceedings, including the integration of diverse topics under a common theme. The compilation process involves several standardized steps to assemble the volume. Editors first enforce uniform layouts using tools like LaTeX templates provided by the publisher, which dictate font sizes, margins, and citation styles to achieve consistency across papers. Front matter, such as the table of contents, preface outlining the conference's scope, and lists of organizers and reviewers, is then added, followed by back matter including author indices and sometimes errata sections. This phase includes merging supplementary materials like abstracts or keywords into a searchable format, ensuring the final product reflects the conference's intellectual output. Many proceedings are compiled and made available before the conference begins, especially in fields like computer science, while others are published post-event. Quality assurance is integral to this stage, encompassing copyediting for grammatical consistency, factual accuracy, and adherence to ethical standards. Proceedings undergo plagiarism detection using software like iThenticate, and editors verify compliance with publisher guidelines on image resolutions and data permissions to prevent legal issues. This rigorous checking minimizes errors that could undermine the publication's credibility, often involving multiple proof rounds with authors. Proceedings publication timelines vary by field and publisher: some are finalized weeks before the conference for pre-event availability, while post-conference compilation can take from 1 to 6 months, balancing timely dissemination with quality control.

Publication Models

Traditional Publishing

Traditional publishing of conference proceedings involves established academic presses and commercial entities that produce physical volumes through contractual agreements with conference organizers. These models emphasize rigorous editorial oversight, distribution via libraries and institutions, and integration into scholarly catalogs, often resulting in citable volumes with assigned ISBNs. Publishers such as Springer, Elsevier, and university presses have long dominated this space, handling everything from compilation to printing and sales. Key publisher types include academic societies partnering with specialized imprints, university presses, and commercial entities. For instance, Springer's Lecture Notes in Computer Science (LNCS) series, launched in 1973, has become a cornerstone for computer science proceedings, publishing more than 600 volumes annually through collaborations with societies like the International Federation for Information Processing (IFIP).^[30] Commercial publishers like Elsevier offer series such as Procedia, which compile high-quality proceedings across disciplines, providing fast yet structured dissemination via print and controlled digital access.^[31] University presses, including Cambridge University Press, also produce proceedings as part of their scholarly output, often focusing on interdisciplinary or humanities-based conferences through selective acquisitions. Academic societies, such as the IEEE or ACM, frequently outsource production to these publishers to leverage their expertise while maintaining oversight. The publishing process begins with conference organizers submitting a proposal to the publisher, outlining the event's scope, expected volume, and peer-review standards; upon approval, a contract is signed detailing rights, timelines, and responsibilities. The publisher then assigns an ISBN to the proceedings volume, compiles accepted papers into a cohesive book format, and oversees editing, typesetting, and proofreading. Revenue in traditional models derives from page charges levied on authors or sponsors, sales of printed copies, and institutional subscriptions to publisher series or databases that include proceedings access. For example, organizers may cover production costs through conference fees, while publishers like Springer impose no direct publication fees for non-open access proceedings but generate income via sales and bundled subscriptions.^[32] Elsevier similarly relies on subscription packages for libraries, where proceedings form part of broader collections sold annually.^[31] Traditional publishing confers prestige through association with reputable imprints, enhancing the perceived quality and discoverability of proceedings in academic libraries and citation indices. However, it incurs high costs for organizers—often thousands of dollars for editing and printing—and introduces delays of up to six months from final submission to print availability, due to production timelines.^[33] These models, while enduring, face pressures from shifts toward open access alternatives that prioritize broader dissemination.^[8]

Open Access and Alternatives

Open access models for conference proceedings have emerged as key approaches to enhance accessibility and dissemination of research outputs. In the gold open access (OA) model, proceedings are published immediately and freely available through the publisher's platform, typically funded by article processing charges (APCs) paid by authors, institutions, or conference organizers. APCs for conference papers often range from $500 to $2,000, depending on the publisher; for instance, the Association for Computing Machinery (ACM) charges $700 for members and $1,000 for non-members per proceedings article under its gold OA option.^[34] This model contrasts with traditional subscription-based publishing by shifting costs from readers to producers, enabling barrier-free access while covering editorial, peer-review, and hosting expenses.^[35] Green open access complements gold OA by allowing authors to self-archive versions of their conference papers in institutional or subject repositories, such as arXiv or institutional archives, without direct publisher fees. Many conference publishers, including ACM and IEEE, permit self-archiving of the accepted manuscript or final version with appropriate embargoes, often requiring a citation back to the original proceedings.^[36] This route promotes wider dissemination, particularly for proceedings not published under gold OA, and aligns with funder requirements for public access.^[37] Alternatives to commercial gold and green models include self-publishing proceedings directly on conference websites or integrating preprints with digital object identifiers (DOIs) via platforms like Zenodo, which provides persistent identifiers and long-term preservation at no cost.^[38] Diamond open access, a no-fee variant often supported by academic societies or institutions, enables free publication and access without APCs; for example, society-sponsored conferences in fields like mathematics publish proceedings openly through community-funded models.^[39] These approaches, exemplified by platforms like OpenProceedings.org, allow organizers to retain control and avoid commercial dependencies.^[40] Policy drivers have accelerated adoption, notably the U.S. National Science Foundation's (NSF) public access policy effective January 2016, which mandates submission of juried conference papers from funded research to the NSF Public Access Repository within 12 months of publication.^[41] Similar mandates from other funders, such as Plan S in Europe, have propelled growth; the share of open access scholarly outputs, including conference proceedings, rose from approximately 22% in 2015 to 47% by 2024,^[42] effectively more than doubling the volume of OA proceedings. For example, ACM is transitioning to a fully open access publishing model by the end of 2025.^[34] Despite these advances, non-traditional models face challenges in maintaining quality control, as self-publishing or low-barrier platforms may lack rigorous peer review. Predatory publishers and conferences exacerbate this by soliciting submissions with promises of rapid OA publication for fees, often delivering substandard or fabricated proceedings that undermine scholarly integrity.^[43] Organizers must vet platforms and enforce transparent review processes to mitigate these risks.^[44]

Formats and Accessibility

Physical and Print Formats

Conference proceedings in physical form have traditionally been produced as bound books, providing a tangible record of presented research. These are commonly issued as single-volume paperbacks or hardcovers, with glossy covers to enhance durability and visual appeal. For larger conferences, such as those organized by IEEE or ACM, proceedings are often compiled into multi-volume sets to accommodate extensive content, allowing for organized thematic or session-based divisions.^[32]^[45] Production of print proceedings involves standardized printing specifications to ensure readability and cost-efficiency. Pages are typically formatted to standard sizes like 8.5 x 11 inches (US Letter) or A4, with black-and-white interiors to minimize expenses while maintaining clarity for text-heavy academic content. Binding options include perfect binding using hot-melt adhesive for paperbacks, which provides a flexible spine suitable for frequent reference, or hardcover casing for more archival-quality volumes. Covers often feature one- to four-color printing on glossy or matte foil-laminated stock, contributing to a professional appearance.^[46]^[47]^[45]^[48] Distribution of physical proceedings has historically included on-site provision to attendees at the conference venue, with some organizers mailing copies to registered participants post-event for broader accessibility. Publishers like Shaker Verlag and Springer Nature sell these volumes through booksellers such as Amazon, making them available to non-attendees. Academic and research libraries routinely archive print proceedings for long-term preservation and scholarly access.^[49]^[50]^[5] Since the 2010s, the use of print proceedings has declined significantly in favor of digital alternatives, driven by the rise of online publishing platforms and cost reductions in electronic dissemination. This shift reflects broader trends in academic communication, where print circulation in research libraries dropped by nearly half between 2009 and 2015. Environmental concerns have accelerated this trend, as printing contributes to a notable carbon footprint through paper production and transportation. In the 2020s, sustainability guidelines from organizations like IEEE and the European Virtual Institute for Resources recommend minimizing print runs, opting for recycled paper when necessary, and prioritizing digital formats to significantly reduce emissions compared to physical distribution.^[51]^[52]^[53]

Digital and Online Formats

Digital conference proceedings are primarily disseminated in electronic formats that facilitate widespread access and integration with online tools. The most common formats include Portable Document Format (PDF) for fixed-layout preservation of original typesetting and HyperText Markup Language (HTML) for web-based viewing, enabling responsive design across devices.^[54]^[55] These formats often incorporate interactive elements such as hyperlinks to references, datasets, or supplementary materials, and in advanced cases, multimedia supplements like embedded videos or interactive figures to enhance reader engagement beyond static text.^[56] While less prevalent in traditional proceedings, the EPUB format is occasionally employed for reflowable, device-agnostic presentations, particularly in interdisciplinary or educational conferences where dynamic content adaptation is prioritized.^[57] Key platforms for hosting and accessing digital proceedings include publisher-specific portals like the ACM Digital Library, which archives millions of computing-related papers and proceedings in searchable formats, and IEEE Xplore, a comprehensive database for engineering and technology content.^[58] Open repositories such as HAL, a French open archive platform, and CORE, a global aggregator of open access research outputs, further democratize access by collecting and indexing proceedings from various sources, often without subscription barriers.^[59]^[60] Mobile applications, exemplified by the ACM Digital Library app available for iOS and Android, allow users to download and browse proceedings offline, supporting features like personalized reading lists and conference program integration.^[61] Accessibility in digital proceedings is enhanced through features designed to comply with standards like WCAG 2.1, including tagged PDFs and semantic HTML structures that ensure compatibility with screen readers for visually impaired users, allowing navigation via headings, alt text for images, and audio descriptions for complex visuals.^[62]^[63] Digital Object Identifiers (DOIs) provide permanent, resolvable links to proceedings, ensuring long-term discoverability regardless of hosting changes. Version control mechanisms, such as those outlined by Crossref, enable tracking of updates or errata through versioned DOIs or metadata flags, maintaining the integrity of evolving scholarly records without disrupting citations.^[64] By 2024, over 40% of global conference papers and proceedings were available via gold open access routes, reflecting a broader trend toward near-universal digital publication as print formats decline in favor of electronic dissemination.^[65] Emerging trends include AI-enhanced search capabilities, such as semantic indexing pilots in platforms like Semantic Scholar, which leverage natural language processing to match queries with conceptual content in proceedings, improving retrieval accuracy for interdisciplinary research.^[66]

Citation and Impact

Citation Practices

Conference proceedings are cited in academic writing following established style guides to ensure clarity and consistency. These citations typically treat individual papers within proceedings as chapters in an edited book or journal articles, depending on the publication format, while whole proceedings may be cited as books. Accurate citation helps distinguish conference contributions from journal publications and facilitates retrieval.^[67]^[68] In the American Psychological Association (APA) style, a paper from conference proceedings is cited with the author's name, publication year, paper title, editors of the proceedings, proceedings title, page range, publisher, and DOI if available. For example: Author, A. A. (Year). Title of paper. In E. E. Editor (Ed.), Title of proceedings (pp. xx–xx). Publisher. https://doi.org/xxxx. If the proceedings are published in a journal, the citation resembles a journal article format, including volume and issue numbers.^[67] The Modern Language Association (MLA) style formats citations for conference papers by listing the author's name, paper title in quotation marks, conference title including date and location, editors if applicable, publisher, publication year, page range, and DOI or URL. For instance: Author Last Name, First Name. "Title of Paper." Conference Title, Conference Date and Location, edited by Editor First Name Last Name, Publisher, Year, pp. xx-xx. DOI. When citing an entire proceedings volume edited by others, the editors are listed first as authors.^[68] Chicago style, in its notes and bibliography system, treats a paper in published proceedings like a chapter in an edited book, including author, paper title, editors, proceedings title, conference details (such as name, date, and location), publisher, year, page range, and DOI. An example entry: Author First Name Last Name, "Title of Paper," in Title of Proceedings: Subtitle if Any, ed. Editor First Name Last Name (Place of Publication: Publisher, Year), xx–xx, https://doi.org/xxxx. The author-date variant follows a similar structure in reference lists.^[69] Unique elements in citing conference proceedings include specifying the conference's location and date to contextualize the event, as well as incorporating a DOI or other persistent identifier for digital accessibility when available. For edited volumes, which are common for proceedings, the editors' names precede the title in the citation to acknowledge their role in compilation. These details help differentiate proceedings from other publication types and aid in locating the source.^[67]^[68]^[69] Best practices emphasize citing specific papers rather than the entire proceedings unless referencing the collection as a whole, as this provides precise attribution to individual contributions. Researchers should prioritize using DOIs or stable URLs over temporary links to ensure long-term access, and verify all elements against the original source for accuracy. When proceedings are part of a series, including the series name and number enhances specificity.^[70]^[71] Common pitfalls in citing conference proceedings involve omitting key details like conference location, date, or page numbers, which can lead to ambiguity in identifying the exact source amid similar titles across years or venues. Failing to italicize proceedings titles or misplacing editors' names in edited volumes also disrupts standardization. Additionally, assuming all proceedings have DOIs without checking can result in incomplete digital references.^[72]^[73]

Indexing and Metrics

Conference proceedings are indexed by major multidisciplinary databases such as Scopus, which includes original conference papers as long as they meet eligibility criteria like peer review and relevance to the field.^[74] Similarly, the Web of Science Conference Proceedings Citation Index covers proceedings from significant events across sciences, engineering, and social sciences, enabling citation tracking for presented research.^[75] Google Scholar broadly indexes conference papers alongside journals and books, providing free access to citations and full texts where available. In computer science, the DBLP Computer Science Bibliography serves as a specialized database, cataloging over 8 million publications.^[76] Key metrics for assessing conference proceedings include citation counts, which measure the influence of individual papers or entire volumes by tracking how often they are referenced in subsequent works.^[77] The h-index, adapted for proceedings series, quantifies impact by identifying the largest number of papers in a series that have at least that many citations each; for example, the ACM International Conference Proceeding Series reports an h-index of 164.^[78] Altmetrics complement traditional citations by capturing alternative impacts, such as downloads, social media shares, and mentions in policy documents, offering a broader view of engagement beyond academia.^[79] Conference ranking systems like CORE, managed by the Computing Research and Education Association of Australasia, classify computer science events from A* (highest) to C based on peer assessments and impact factors.^[80] In Brazil, the Qualis system ranks conferences using h-index and other indicators to evaluate quality across disciplines, influencing national academic assessments.^[81] These indexing and metrics play a crucial role in academic evaluation, informing tenure reviews by demonstrating a researcher's engagement and productivity through indexed proceedings.^[82] They also factor into funding decisions, where citation data and rankings signal potential impact in grant proposals, particularly in fields like computer science where conferences are primary publication venues.^[83] However, limitations persist, including field-specific biases that undervalue proceedings in humanities or biomedicine compared to journals, potentially disadvantaging interdisciplinary work.^[83] Recent developments enhance tracking and integrity, with ORCID integration allowing authors to link proceedings to persistent identifiers for seamless author disambiguation across platforms like European Proceedings.^[84] Emerging blockchain applications in the 2020s, such as hash-based provenance systems, aim to verify the authenticity and tamper-proof history of research files in proceedings, addressing concerns over data integrity in collaborative environments.^[85]

References

[1]
Conference Proceedings - Library Guides at Penn State University
Jun 21, 2024 · A conference proceeding is the published record of a conference, congress, symposium, or other meeting sponsored by a society or association.
[2]
Conference Proceedings & Papers: Home - Research Guides
Oct 3, 2025 · A conference proceeding is the published record of a conference of an association, society, or group. · Conferences go by many different names.Missing: definition | Show results with:definition
[3]
What are the social and scientific benefits of participating at ... - NIH
Academic conferences can be seen as significant vehicles for generating scientific and societal impact. The aim of this article is to explore the perceived ...
[4]
Why Publish Scientific Meeting Proceedings? - PMC - NIH
The reason for publishing information exchanged at a scientific meeting is to make the proceedings available to a wider audience than the meeting participants.
[5]
Journals and conference proceedings - Yuma, Information Literacy ...
Jul 22, 2025 · While the earliest journals reported on scientific and philosophical matters, over time journals were created to disseminate research findings ...<|separator|>
[6]
[PDF] Author-Based Analysis of Conference versus Journal Publication in ...
(2) Conference publications in DBLP appeared first in 1959, while the record of journal publications go back to 1936. For the purpose of comparing ...
[7]
What is a Conference Proceedings - IEEE Events
It is a collection of documents, paper or electronic, which corresponds to the technical presentations given at the conference along with additional information ...Missing: scholarly | Show results with:scholarly<|control11|><|separator|>
[8]
Guest Post - Everything* You Ever Wanted to Know about ...
Jan 30, 2020 · Papers in conference proceedings contain original/primary research results, published as full or short papers. These papers are peer reviewed by ...
[9]
Grey literature: Conference proceedings - University Library
Conference proceedings are a collection of abstracts and papers presented at conferences. They often present preliminary research findings.
[10]
NeurIPS Proceedings
In 2021, NeurIPS introduced a new track, Datasets and Benchmarks. The first year of that track, 2021, has its own proceedings, accessible by the link below.NeurIPS 2020 · NeurIPS 2019 · NIPS 2017 · Book
[11]
SIGGRAPH '22: ACM SIGGRAPH 2022 Conference Proceedings
In this work, we compared six recent single image HDR reconstruction (SI-HDR) methods in a subjective image quality experiment on an HDR display.
[12]
Conference proceedings vs. journal papers
Oct 15, 2024 · Conference proceedings are meant to report and provide a concise written record on what was presented at scientific conferences.
[13]
Summer Undergraduate Research Institute (SURI): Digital Research ...
Sep 9, 2025 · Conference proceedings provide a way for researchers to share their results more quickly than through journal publication. For some fields, e.g ...
[14]
Why are proceedings so important in computer science? | For Librarians | Springer Nature
### Summary of the Importance of Conference Proceedings in Computer Science
[15]
What Defines “Priority Of Discovery” In The Life Sciences? - ASAPbio
Feb 10, 2016 · We break down “priority of discovery” into two steps: 1) disclosure, in which the discovery is released from an individual or small group of scientists to the ...
[16]
[PDF] Michael Ernst Computer Science & Engineering University of ...
In fact, conference papers are arguably more prestigious than journal publications: oftentimes, conferences have higher stan- dards and lower acceptance rates. ...<|separator|>
[17]
Benefits of Publishing with IEEE - IEEE Author Center Conferences
IEEE is a trusted source for researchers in academia, industry, and government. By publishing with IEEE, you will get the global prestige that high-quality ...
[18]
Suggestions to Enhance Bibliometric Comparisons Across Disciplines
In the humanities, however, conference presentations much less frequently are published as conference proceedings, and therefore do not become bibliometric ...
[19]
History of Philosophical Transactions | Royal Society
Philosophical Transactions is the world's first and longest-running scientific journal. It was launched in March 1665 by Henry Oldenburg.Missing: conference | Show results with:conference
[20]
International Congress Of Medicine 1867 And Some Of The ... - jstor
The International Medical Congress of 1867, the first of its kind, was held in Paris from Friday 16 August to Wednesday. 28 August.
[21]
American Mathematical Society - MacTutor - University of St Andrews
The American Mathematical Society started its existence as the New York Mathematical Society which was founded in 1888.
[22]
IEEE Xplore Digital Library Reaches Five Million Documents | Innovate
Oct 24, 2019 · In May 2000, the IEEE Xplore Digital Library was officially launched and would go on to become one of the leading resources of scientific ...
[23]
Submit a Paper List for Conference Proceedings - arXiv info
The simplest way to make a proceedings or index entry is to create an HTML submission using special LIST:arXiv:YYMM.NNNN or LIST:arch-ive/YYMMNNN.Missing: integration | Show results with:integration
[24]
Virtual and the Future of Conferences - Communications of the ACM
Jan 19, 2024 · During the COVID-19 pandemic, conferences quickly transitioned to virtual. Based on our own virtual conference experiences and a survey we ...
[25]
'Plan S' and 'cOAlition S' – Accelerating the transition to full and ...
Plan S is an initiative for Open Access publishing that was launched in September 2018. The plan is supported by cOAlition S, an international consortium of ...About · About cOAlition S and Plan S · Plan S Principles · Diamond Open Access
[26]
The Alarming Rise of Predatory Conferences - Eos.org
Sep 15, 2022 · More recently, there has been an increase in the occurrence of similarly predatory (or “fake”) conferences across numerous scientific ...<|separator|>
[27]
Understanding Academic Conference Paper Submission Deadlines ...
Timely Review Process: Conference organizers need time to evaluate the quality of the submitted papers and select those that align with the conference theme.
[28]
Conference Paper Format: A Step-by-Step Breakdown
Aug 24, 2025 · Find out how using the correct conference paper format improves acceptance. Simple formatting choices can make your work polished and ...
[29]
Understand Peer Review - IEEE Author Center Conferences
Learn what happens between submission and decision. IEEE offers insight into peer review and the decision-making process for conference papers.
[30]
Conference Paper Selectivity and Impact
Jun 1, 2010 · Papers in highly selective conferences—acceptance rates of 30% or less—should continue to be treated as first-class research contributions with ...<|separator|>
[31]
[PDF] A Comparative Review of Conference Management System
Dec 31, 2024 · This article presents a comprehensive review of commonly used CMS platforms such as EasyChair, ConfBay, OpenConf, Microsoft CMT, COMS, and EDAS.
[32]
https://www.springernature.com/gp/authors/publish-a-book/step-by-step-conference-proceedings
[33]
Procedia - Elsevier
Procedia is Elsevier's online collection of high-quality conference proceedings, offering a fast and cost-effective way to publish papers.
[34]
Conference Proceedings | Publish your research - Springer Nature
Springer Nature is a leader in publishing proceedings, with over 2000 titles available per year. You can benefit from our experience and services.Missing: bound self-
[35]
AIP Conference Proceedings
Our conference proceedings program reports the findings presented at scientific meetings from large international conferences to small specialist workshops.Conference Proceedings Team · Re-use of Proceedings Articles · All Issues
[36]
How Long Does It Take to Publish a Conference Paper?
Sep 15, 2025 · Journal publications typically take longer, often ranging from six months to two years. This is because they go through more detailed reviews, ...
[37]
Open Access Publication & ACM
Open Access Pricing – APC Fees. The pricing below is valid for all APC-Eligible Articles published in ACM hybrid and gold open access publications: Authors ...<|control11|><|separator|>
[38]
Open Access Publishing: Article processing charges
Oct 10, 2025 · Article processing charges (APCs) are levied by publishers to authors who wish to publish their articles open access.
[39]
Author Rights & Responsibilities - ACM Authors Portal
ACM authors can choose exclusive or non-exclusive rights, post pre-prints, self-archive, reuse their work with citation, and retain perpetual rights.
[40]
https://openproceedings.org/
[41]
Zenodo
Open repository for EU-funded research outputs from Horizon Europe, Euratom and earlier Framework Programmes.EU Open Research Repository · Research. Shared! Sign up today · About · PoliciesMissing: conference | Show results with:conference
[42]
Diamond Open Access | Plan S - cOAlition S
Diamond Open Access refers to a scholarly publication model in which journals and platforms do not charge fees to either authors or readers.Missing: proceedings | Show results with:proceedings
[43]
OpenProceedings.org
Publish your Conference Proceedings in Open Access. Copyright and Open ... All we require from the authors is that they grant a publishing license ...Missing: self- | Show results with:self-
[44]
NSF Public Access Initiative | NSF - National Science Foundation
The US National Science Foundation's Public Access Initiative ensures the outputs of NSF-funded scientific research are made publicly available to the greatest ...Nsf's Public Access Policy · Data Management And Sharing... · Nsf Funding For Public...Missing: proceedings | Show results with:proceedings
[45]
Open Access Trends in Scholarly Publishing 2015–2024
May 15, 2025 · From 2015 to 2023, the share of OA publications steadily increased from 22% to a peak of 59%. This upward trajectory underscores the growing ...
[46]
The Perils of Predatory Journals and Conferences - PMC
Predatory journals and conferences are dangerous developments that may ruin scientific progress because they sacrifice quality for profit.
[47]
How is open access accused of being predatory? The impact of ...
Sometimes, predatory journals have fake editorial boards (Sorokowski, Kulczycki, Sorokowska, & Pisanski, 2017), or they use quasi-impact factors calculated in ...
[48]
Publication - Conference proceedings - Shaker Verlag
Matte or glossy foils are available. In addition to the standard softcover, we also offer English brochures with side-folding covers. The cover board and book ...
[49]
Paper Format for Conferences - IEEE Industrial Electronics Society
If you are using the templates, you should not have to worry about sizes or spaces. The allowed pages sizes for papers are two: US Letter and ISO A4. Both are ...
[50]
[PDF] SIGCHI Conference Proceedings Format | CHI 2018 - ACM
Papers and notes may use color figures, which are included in the page limit; the figures must be usable when printed in black-and-white in the proceedings. The ...
[51]
Perfect Bound Book Printing
Do you offer perfect binding for self-published authors? Yes, we work extensively with self-published authors who want professionally manufactured books.Professional Square Spine... · Perfect Bound Book... · Our Perfect Bound Printing...
[52]
Preparing Conference Proceedings for Attendees | IEEE
The Publication Chair decides whether to distribute the proceedings or other publications at the conference. You can choose the format, such as print, CD, DVD, ...
[53]
Should I always expect to receive proceedings at conferences?
Nov 7, 2019 · Yes, giving out proceedings to participants is a tradition to make sure they have access to the papers during the conferences.Why was it mandatory to attend a conference in person while ...How did conferences "work" before the e-mail era?More results from academia.stackexchange.com
[54]
Less Than Meets the Eye: Print Book Use Is Falling Faster in ...
Aug 21, 2017 · Between 2009 and 2015, total initial circulations in ARL libraries fell by almost half (from 36 million to 19 million).
[55]
IEEE Event Sustainability Guide - IEEE CEE
Using digital programs and proceedings rather than printed copies can greatly reduce the carbon footprint of the event as well as reduce the budget for those ...
[56]
[PDF] Tips for organising environmentally friendly conferences Format:
This document outlines how researchers and research funders can reduce the environmental impact of their conferences/events/meetings. The EViR Sustainability ...
[57]
General Instructions for Proceedings Volumes - ACM
The metadata supplied in the enhanced format will be used to create the final publication output formats (HTML/PDF) from The ACM Production System (TAPS) and ...Missing: EPUB | Show results with:EPUB
[58]
Preparing Conference Proceedings for Publication - IEEE
If you plan to submit your conference proceedings for inclusion in the IEEE Xplore Digital Library, your papers must be in IEEE Xplore–compliant format.
[59]
Beyond PDF and ePub: toward an interactive textbook
This paper describes a new and unique vision for electronic textbooks. It incorporates a number of active components such as video, code editing and execution.Missing: elements | Show results with:elements
[60]
Best eBook Format for Publishing (Guide-2025) - Kitaboo
May 24, 2024 · Best Formats for Publishing eBooks · ePub · PDF and Interactive PDF · MOBI · DOCX · RTF · ODT · HTML5.Missing: proceedings | Show results with:proceedings
[61]
ACM Conference Proceedings
Conference proceedings capture the cutting edge of innovation across the spectrum of computing fields by publishing refereed research findings and invited ...
[62]
Home - Archive ouverte HAL
### Summary of https://hal.science/
[63]
The world’s largest collection of open access research papers
### Summary of CORE Content
[64]
ACM Digital Library - Mobile Databases and Resources
Oct 14, 2025 · To access ACM Digital Library remotely, create a free ACM Web Account, log in to activate remote access, and log in to the app. Remote access ...
[65]
Web Content Accessibility Guidelines (WCAG) 2.1 - W3C
May 6, 2025 · Web Content Accessibility Guidelines (WCAG) 2.1 covers a wide range of recommendations for making web content more accessible.User Agent Accessibility · WCAG21 history · Introduction to Understanding... · ErrataMissing: proceedings | Show results with:proceedings
[66]
Accessibility Guide for Authors - SIGCHI
Aug 15, 2024 · This guide aims to support authors submitting to a SIGCHI venue in creating accessible submissions and final publications that can be read by reviewers.
[67]
Version control, corrections, and retractions - Crossref
Version control is the management of changes to a document, file, or dataset. Versions of a document may include the following: Draft Preprint - early draft ...
[68]
Uptake of Open Access (OA) - STM Association
The compound annual growth rate (CAGR) for all articles, reviews, and conference papers from 2014 to 2024 is 4% and the number of these has more than doubled, ...
[69]
Semantic Scholar | AI-Powered Research Tool
Semantic Scholar uses groundbreaking AI and engineering to understand the semantics of scientific literature to help Scholars discover relevant research.Semantic Reader · Academic Graph API · Semantic Reader Project · API OverviewMissing: conference | Show results with:conference<|control11|><|separator|>
[70]
Conference proceeding references - APA Style
This page contains reference examples for conference proceedings, whether published in a journal, as a book, or as a book chapter.
[71]
How do I cite conference proceedings? - MLA Style Center
Mar 19, 2018 · To cite conference proceedings, follow the MLA format template. The example below lists the editors (as “Author”), the title, the publisher, and the date of ...
[72]
Conference papers - Chicago 17th edition notes and bibliography
A paper included in the published proceedings of a meeting may be treated like a book chapter. If published in a journal, it is treated as an article.
[73]
Citing conferences: APA (7th ed.) citation guide - SFU Library
Published conference proceedings may be cited either like chapters in edited books (first example) or like journal articles (second example). This will depend ...<|control11|><|separator|>
[74]
APA (7th Edition) Referencing Guide: Conference Papers
Sep 18, 2025 · Format. Author, A. A. (Date). Title of paper. In A. Editor & B. Editor (Eds.), Title of proceedings (page numbers). Publisher. DOI OR URL if ...
[75]
Citing a Conference Paper in APA Style | Format & Examples - Scribbr
Nov 6, 2020 · An APA conference paper citation includes the words "Paper presentation" in square brackets, and details of the conference.
[76]
How to Cite Conference Proceedings in APA - Aithor
Sep 14, 2025 · 1. Print Proceedings. Format: Author, A. A. (Year). Title of paper. In E. E. Editor (Ed.), Title of proceedings (pp. xx–xx). Publisher.
[77]
https://deakin.libguides.com/research-metrics/conference-paper-citation-count
[78]
WoS Conference Proceedings Citation Index - Clarivate
Monitor the influence of research presented at conferences with the Web of Science Conference Proceedings Citation Index. Find out more.
[79]
Conference paper citation counts - Research metrics help guide
Aug 11, 2025 · A count of the citations received by a conference paper. Citations are widely regarded as key indicators of the usage and impact of the cited publication.
[80]
ACM International Conference Proceeding Series - Scimago
H-Index. 164. Publication type. Conferences and Proceedings. ISSN. -. Coverage. 1993, 1996-1997, 1999-2023. Information. Homepage. Scope. The ACM International ...
[81]
Journal Articles and Conference Proceedings - Research Impact ...
Oct 14, 2025 · This section covers the resources to find metrics for journal articles (including preprints) and conference papers.<|separator|>
[82]
CORE Rankings Portal - core.edu.au
The CORE Conference Ranking provides assessments of major conferences in the computing disciplines. The rankings are managed by the CORE Executive Committee.
[83]
Conference Ranks
Overview of international conferences rankings to quickly assess the scientific impact of conferences.
[84]
Importance of Conference Proceedings in Research Evaluation
Jun 28, 2025 · Conference proceedings help researchers share early ideas, get feedback, and build networks. They provide public records, increase citations, ...
[85]
[PDF] The Importance of Conference Proceedings in Research Evaluation
In this paper we 1) review the current practices of using conferences in the research evaluation; 2) identify scientific disciplines, where conference ...<|separator|>
[86]
ORCID, research, researchers, institutions - European Publisher
European Proceedings has now integrated ORCID into its online publication and submission systems. It is mandatory to provide an ORCID ID for first authors and ...
[87]
Preserving File Provenance Using Principles of Blockchain to ...
The paper focuses on capturing and verifying input and output data file provenance using the principles of blockchain. The technique stores the hashes of data ...