Fact-checked by Grok 2 weeks ago

1957 NFL draft

The 1957 National Football League Draft, the 22nd annual player selection meeting, was conducted in two sessions: the first four rounds on November 26, 1956, at the Warwick Hotel in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, followed by the remaining 26 rounds on January 31, 1957, at the in the same city. It featured 30 rounds and 360 total selections across the league's 12 teams. The draft was particularly notable for its exceptional talent pool, which produced multiple Pro Football Hall of Famers and future stars who shaped the late 1950s and 1960s NFL. The held the first overall pick—a bonus lottery selection awarded to the previous season's worst team—and chose halfback from , a versatile player who later earned induction into the Hall of Fame in 1986 for his contributions as a runner, passer, and kicker with the Packers. Other early selections included halfback (second overall, , ), quarterback (third overall, , Stanford), and tight end (fourth overall, Packers, ). The selected fullback from Syracuse sixth overall, a decision that proved transformative as Brown immediately won the NFL and Rookie of the Year awards in 1957 and went on to rush for 12,312 yards over nine seasons with the Browns, earning Hall of Fame enshrinement in 1971 as one of the league's all-time greatest players (d. 2023). Additional standout picks encompassed quarterback (fifth overall, , Purdue), offensive tackle Jim Parker (eighth overall, , Ohio State), and later-round gems like quarterback (fourth round, 43rd overall, , ) and wide receiver Tommy McDonald (third round, 31st overall, Eagles, ), both future Hall of Famers. The class's depth extended to defensive talents such as defensive tackle (fifth round, Browns, ), who was later traded to the Packers, and guard (seventh round, Browns, ), contributing to a legacy of at least eight Hall of Fame inductees who helped elevate the professional game's competitive standard during an era of expansion and increasing popularity.

Overview

Event Details

The 1957 NFL Draft was conducted in a split schedule across two sessions in , Pennsylvania. The first four rounds took place on November 26, 1956, at the Warwick Hotel, while the remaining 26 rounds occurred on January 31, 1957, at . This draft consisted of 30 rounds and resulted in a total of 360 selections, involving the 12 franchises of the era. The draft order was determined by the reverse order of the previous season's standings, with the holding the first overall pick via the bonus lottery after finishing with a poor record in 1956. The Green Bay Packers selected Paul Hornung, a halfback from Notre Dame, as the first overall pick. At the opposite end, the New York Giants chose Don Gest, an end from Washington State, with the 360th and final selection.

Draft Order

The selection order for the 1957 NFL Draft was determined by the reverse order of the teams' records from the 1956 NFL season, allowing the lowest-finishing teams the earliest opportunities to select players and fostering league parity. The very first pick, however, was a special bonus selection awarded via lottery to one eligible team, a system in place from 1947 to 1958 to further distribute elite talent randomly and avoid repeated dominance by struggling franchises. Only two teams remained eligible for the 1957 lottery—the Green Bay Packers and Chicago Cardinals—because all others had already won a bonus pick in the prior ten drafts; the Packers, who had posted a 4-8 record in 1956 (tying for last in the Western Conference), drew the bonus pick. Following the bonus pick, the regular order proceeded in inverse 1956 standings, with ties (such as the three Western Conference teams at 4-8) resolved by coin flips or predetermined rotation to establish relative positions within conferences. The Packers thus held two early selections: the bonus at No. 1 and their standard first-round pick at No. 4. The first-round team order was:
PickTeam
1 (bonus pick)
2[Los Angeles Rams](/page/Los Angeles_Rams)
3
4
5
6
7
8
9Washington Redskins
10Chicago Cardinals
11[Los Angeles Rams](/page/Los Angeles_Rams)
12Detroit Lions
13Chicago Bears
This structure extended through the draft's 30 rounds, with subsequent rounds reversing the conference alternation for balance (Eastern teams picking first in even rounds, Western in odd after the initial setup). Due to pre-draft trades, the total number of picks varied across teams, with the receiving the most selections (35) and the the fewest (26).

Historical Context

1956 College Football Season

The 1956 college football season featured as the national champion, finishing with a perfect 10-0 record and claiming the title according to the (AP), (FWAA), and (UPI) polls. The , coached by , dominated the Big Seven Conference with a 6-0 mark, showcasing a potent offense led by Tommy McDonald, who earned consensus All-American honors for his explosive play. Other top teams included (9-1), which secured a share of the Big Ten title, and (TCU, 8-3), champions of the . The was awarded to of , a versatile who became the only winner in history to receive the honor while playing on a team with a losing record, as the Fighting Irish finished 2-8. Hornung's performance included 917 passing yards, 420 rushing yards, and 26 receiving yards, highlighting his triple-threat ability despite the team's struggles. Among other standout players, Syracuse running back earned unanimous consensus All-American status after rushing for 986 yards and 13 touchdowns, establishing himself as one of the era's premier backs. Purdue Len , a third-team All-American, threw for 856 passing yards and 7 touchdowns, exemplifying the season's strong quarterback play. Major bowl games provided key showcases for top prospects. In the , Iowa defeated Oregon State 35-19, with quarterback Ken Ploen earning MVP honors for his dual-threat performance in the rematch of their regular-season thriller. The Cotton Bowl saw TCU edge Syracuse 28-27 in a high-scoring affair, where Brown's contributions further elevated his visibility despite the Orange's loss. These postseason matchups highlighted emerging talents and contributed to their recognition ahead of professional opportunities. The season underscored a trend toward dominant running backs and quarterbacks in award voting and statistical leadership, with rushers like (6.2 yards per carry) and McDonald topping national charts—while passers such as Stanford's (1,633 passing yards) paced the aerial attack. This emphasis reflected the era's balanced offensive philosophies, where versatile skill players often defined team success and individual accolades.

Development of the Draft System

The was instituted in as a mechanism to equalize talent across teams and curb escalating bidding wars for elite college players, which had previously favored wealthier franchises. , then-owner of the financially strained , proposed the system at a league meeting in 1935 to promote competitive balance and ensure the league's long-term viability; it was unanimously approved by owners on May 19, 1935. The inaugural draft convened on February 8, , at Philadelphia's Ritz-Carlton Hotel, where teams selected from a pool of 90 college seniors in reverse order of the prior season's standings, marking the beginning of an annual tradition. Leading up to 1957, the draft incorporated refinements to enhance fairness and strategic depth. In 1947, added a bonus pick system, awarding the first overall selection via a random lottery to one team each year, granting that franchise an extra high-value choice while the regular order followed reverse standings. This lottery-based bonus continued through 1958, cycling once per team to prevent any single franchise from dominating top talent acquisition; for instance, the secured the 1957 bonus pick through the draw. Additionally, split sessions emerged to accommodate better preparation, allowing teams extended deliberation between phases. For the 1957 draft, a key innovation shifted the early rounds to immediately follow the 1956 college season, with the first four rounds held on November 26, 1956, at Philadelphia's Warwick Hotel, and the remaining 26 rounds reconvening on January 31, 1957, at the . This two-part structure, comprising a standard 30 rounds for comprehensive roster building, provided teams with interim scouting and evaluation time, refining the process without altering the core parity-driven purpose of distributing college stars evenly to avoid monopolies by stronger clubs.

Draft Proceedings

Selection Process and Rules

The 1957 NFL Draft operated under a structured selection process where the 12 teams selected players in a predetermined order, primarily determined by reverse finishing order from the season, with the worst-performing team picking first in each round. A special bonus pick, equivalent to the first overall selection, was awarded to one team via a lottery supervised by NFL Commissioner , in which the lottery was restricted to teams that had not previously won a bonus pick in the prior decade, limiting eligibility to the and ; coach Lisle Blackbourn drew the winning slip from Bell's hat. Teams proceeded sequentially through 30 rounds, with each round initially allocating one pick per team, though the total was adjusted for trades and forfeits. Eligibility rules required players to be college seniors or their equivalents, those who had exhausted their college eligibility. By this era, the draft's central authority had generally superseded any prior local or territorial claims on players. The draft's conduct emphasized traditional over modern evaluations, as no standardized combine existed; teams relied on reports from networks of coaches and personnel scouts to inform decisions. Bert Bell personally oversaw proceedings to enforce rules and resolve disputes, maintaining order in the informal setting of hotel ballrooms. To accommodate the holiday season and allow additional player evaluations amid competition from the Canadian Football League, the draft spanned two sessions: the first four rounds on November 26, 1956, at the Warwick Hotel, followed by the remaining 26 rounds on January 31, 1957, at , running from morning until late evening with brief recesses.

Notable Trades

The 1957 NFL Draft featured a limited number of trades, with most negotiations occurring in the preceding months rather than during the proceedings themselves, reflecting the era's preference for pre-draft deals to avoid disrupting the selection flow. One of the most prominent exchanges involved the acquiring the ' first-round pick (No. 11 overall) in a deal finalized on July 29, 1956; in return, the Giants received Andy Robustelli, a veteran who had been with the Rams since 1951 and would go on to earn seven selections during his tenure in New York. This transaction enabled the Rams to select Baylor halfback Del Shofner at No. 11, a versatile talent who transitioned to and became a key offensive weapon for before his own move to the Giants in 1961. Another significant pre-draft swap saw the Cleveland Browns trade offensive lineman John Sandusky and defensive back Chet Lyssy to the Green Bay Packers in exchange for the Packers' fifth-round pick (No. 52 overall, used on defensive tackle Henry Jordan) and sixth-round pick (No. 63 overall, used on guard Joe Amstutz), with the deal occurring prior to the draft to bolster Cleveland's lines while providing Green Bay with additional mid-round depth. Such moves were typical for acquiring established players in return for future selections, allowing teams to address immediate needs without sacrificing high-value early picks. The Packers, who held the bonus lottery pick at No. 1 and their own early selections, avoided major intra-draft deals, focusing instead on retaining their assets to rebuild under coach Scooter McLean. Post-draft activity included minor exchanges in later rounds for depth players, such as swaps involving unselected or low-priority prospects, though these were less documented and primarily aimed at roster fillers rather than stars. Overall, the scarcity of on-the-spot trades during the November 1956 and January 1957 sessions underscored the draft's structured rules, which emphasized orderly picks while permitting pre-arranged compensations to target specific talents like Shofner.

Player Selections

Round 1

The first round of the 1957 NFL Draft, conducted on November 26, 1956, at the Warwick Hotel in , featured 13 selections, including a bonus pick awarded to the for the worst record in the previous season. This round produced four future Pro Football Hall of Famers: , , , and Jim Parker. The selections emphasized versatile running backs, quarterbacks, and linemen from prominent college programs.
PickTeamPlayerPositionCollege
1HB
2[Los Angeles Rams](/page/Los Angeles_Rams)HB
3QBStanford
4E
5QBPurdue
6FBSyracuse
7Clarence PeaksFBMichigan State
8Jim ParkerTOhio State
9Washington RedskinsDon BosselerFBMiami (FL)
10Jerry TubbsLB
11[Los Angeles Rams](/page/Los Angeles_Rams)Del ShofnerEBaylor
12DEBaylor
13Earl LeggettDTLSU
The table above lists the players as selected, with the 11th pick acquired by the Rams via a preseason trade with the New York Giants for defensive end Andy Robustelli.

Round 2

The second round of the 1957 NFL Draft, held on November 26, 1956, at the Warwick Hotel in Philadelphia, produced a group of selections that developed into reliable starters and contributors across the league, including quarterback Milt Plum, who threw for over 17,000 yards in a 13-year career with multiple teams including the Cleveland Browns, and linebacker Jack Pardee, a 15-year veteran primarily with the Los Angeles Rams who earned a Pro Bowl selection. Other emerging talents included defensive back Abe Woodson, a five-time Pro Bowler known for his return prowess with the San Francisco 49ers and St. Louis Cardinals, amassing nearly 7,000 all-purpose yards in nine seasons, and linebacker Don Shinnick, who anchored the Baltimore Colts' defense for 13 years, intercepting 37 passes and contributing to three NFL championships. No immediate trades were reported during this round's proceedings. The full list of second-round selections is as follows:
PickTeamPlayerPositionCollege
14Jack PardeeLBTexas A&M
15Abe WoodsonDB
16Bill MichaelGOhio State
17Milt PlumQBPenn State
18Joel WellsHBClemson
19Billy Ray BarnesHBWake Forest
20Don ShinnickLBUCLA
21Washington RedskinsE
22Tom MaentzE
23Sam DeLucaG
24John GordyG
25Jim SwinkHB

Round 3

The third of the 1957 NFL Draft consisted of 12 selections, numbered 26 through 37 overall, with each of the league's 12 teams making one pick in the standard reverse order of the previous season's standings. This round yielded a mix of defensive linemen, backs, and offensive tackles, reflecting teams' needs for depth on both lines and in the backfield following the expansion of rosters in the mid-1950s. The following table lists all third-round selections, including the drafting team, player, position, and college:
OverallTeamPlayerPosCollege
26RAMBilly Ray SmithDT
27RAMGeorge StrugarDT
28CLEGeorge WalkerB
29GNBDalton TruaxTTulane
30PITDon OwensDTSouthern Miss
31PHITommy McDonaldFL
32BALLuke OwensDEKent St.
33WASEd SuttonHB
34CRDBill HudsonDTClemson
35NYGDennis MendykBMichigan St.
36DETTerry BarrHB
37CHIRonnie KnoxQBUCLA
Among these picks, the selected flanker Tommy McDonald from the at 31st overall, a player who would later earn induction into the in 1998. The , holding the first two picks in the round due to prior trades, focused on bolstering their defensive line with ' Billy Ray Smith and Washington's George Strugar.

Round 4

The fourth round of the 1957 NFL Draft, held on , , at the Warwick Hotel in , encompassed overall selections 38 through 49, as teams continued to address roster needs with versatile athletes across offensive and defensive positions. This stage highlighted a mix of quarterbacks, linemen, and backs, underscoring the draft's emphasis on building depth in an era when late-round picks often developed into key contributors. The following table lists all 12 picks from Round 4:
Overall PickTeamPlayerPositionCollege
38QB
39Jimmy RidlonDBSyracuse
40Washington RedskinsJim PodoleyHB
41Carl VereenT
42Paul CameraEStanford
43QB
44Jackie SimpsonDB
45Washington RedskinsVince ScorsoneG
46Mike SanduskyG
47DEPurdue
48Steve JunkerEXavier (OH)
49DBMiami (FL)
Among these selections, stood out as a promising prospect, drafted by the at pick 43 after a standout college career at where he led the nation in passing in 1956. Jurgensen's selection exemplified how mid-round picks could yield elite talent, as he later became a five-time selection and 1983 inductee, amassing over 45,000 passing yards in his 18-year NFL career.

Round 5

In the fifth round of the NFL Draft, held on , , at in , teams continued to prioritize defensive talent amid an increasing focus on bolstering defensive lines in the mid-rounds, selecting 12 players overall from picks 50 through 61. This round featured a mix of defensive backs, linemen, and backs, reflecting the era's emphasis on versatile players who could contribute to run defense and coverage. The opened the round with pick 50, selecting defensive back Jimmy Harris from , a speedy prospect known for his skills in college. The followed at 51 with defensive back Dean Derby from , valued for his agility in the secondary. Cleveland Browns then picked twice consecutively: at 52, they chose defensive tackle Henry Jordan from , adding depth to their defensive line with a sturdy interior player who excelled in stopping the run; and at 53, halfback Milt Campbell from , an gold medalist bringing athletic versatility to the backfield. The Baltimore Colts selected back Ronnie Underwood from Arkansas at 54, a shifty runner eyed for special teams and depth. Pittsburgh Steelers took end Perry Richards from Detroit Mercy at 55, focusing on receiving options with blocking ability. San Francisco 49ers picked linebacker Karl Rubke from USC at 56, a tackling specialist to reinforce their front seven. The Rams doubled up again at 57 with guard Dick Enright from USC, providing interior line stability. Chicago Cardinals chose defensive tackle Wayne Bock from Illinois at 58, continuing the trend of defensive reinforcements. selected guard John Barrow from at 59, a rugged blocker for their offensive interior. The picked defensive back Vic Zucco from Michigan State at 60, adding coverage depth. Finally, the closed the round at 61 with tackle Larry Wesley from , a strong pass protector.
PickTeamPlayerPositionCollege
50Jimmy HarrisDB
51Dean DerbyDB
52Henry JordanDT
53Milt CampbellHB
54Ronnie UnderwoodB
55Perry RichardsEDetroit Mercy
56Karl RubkeLB
57Dick EnrightG
58Wayne BockDT
59John BarrowG
60Vic ZuccoDBMichigan State
61Larry WesleyT

Round 6

The sixth round of the 1957 NFL Draft, consisting of overall picks 62 through 73, held on January 31, 1957, at the in , focused on selecting players to provide depth and versatility to team rosters, emphasizing positions such as backs for offensive support, linemen for , and occasional defensive specialists. These selections targeted roster fillers rather than immediate starters, drawing from a range of colleges to address specific team needs in training camps and depth charts. The complete list of sixth-round picks is as follows:
Overall PickTeamPlayerPositionCollege
62Bill RhodesBWestern State (CO)
63Joe AmstutzC
64Roy WilkinsLB
65Billy PricerFBOklahoma
66George VolkertB
67Harley MartinT
68Jim HunterB
69Washington RedskinsJ.T. FrankenbergerT
70John NisbyGPacific
71Ken RussellT
72Bo DickinsonFBSouthern Miss
73Bob HobertTMinnesota

Round 7

The seventh round of the 1957 NFL Draft, consisting of picks 74 through 85, held on January 31, 1957, at the in , featured selections primarily focused on offensive and defensive linemen, with a few players, reflecting teams' efforts to bolster depth in the trenches late in the proceedings. Among these, the selected guard from the with the 78th overall pick, a choice that would later exemplify the value of late-round selections. The full list of seventh-round picks is as follows:
Overall PickRound PickTeamPlayerPositionCollege
741Tom SaidockDTMichigan State
752[Los Angeles Rams](/page/Los Angeles_Rams)Ed GrayT
763Frank GilliamE
774Curley JohnsonRB
785G
796Reuben SaageBBaylor
807Fred DuganEDayton
818Washington RedskinsWally MerzT
829Mike RotunnoC
8310Jerry LeahyT
8411Jerry DeLuccaTMiddle Tennessee State
8512Chuck CurtisQB
Hickerson, drafted as a future pick while still in college, emerged as a cornerstone of the Browns' offensive line upon joining the team in 1958, starting 106 consecutive games from 1960 to 1969 and earning recognition as one of the league's premier blockers. His selection in the seventh round underscored the potential for overlooked talents to develop into elite performers, contributing significantly to Cleveland's success, including their 1964 NFL championship.

Round 8

In the eighth round of the 1957 NFL Draft, held on January 31, 1957, at the in , teams selected primarily for depth, focusing on offensive and defensive linemen, ends, and backs from a mix of major and smaller colleges, reflecting the diminishing value of later picks where prospects often came from less prominent programs. This round yielded 12 selections, with some teams like the and receiving multiple choices due to the draft order and prior trades. The following table lists all eighth-round picks:
Overall PickTeamPlayerPositionCollege
86Hal McElhaneyB
87George BelottiC
88Roy HordG
89Don GillisC
90Jack HarmonE
91Al WardBYale
92Ernie PittsE
93Washington RedskinsPaul LopataEYale
94Charlie BradshawTBaylor
95Dave LiddickDT
96Bob KilcullenDTTexas Tech
97Johnny BookmanDBMiami (FL)
These selections exemplified the draft's emphasis on versatile but under-the-radar talent, such as guards and centers from mid-tier schools, to bolster team rosters without high-profile acquisitions.

Round 9

In the ninth round of the 1957 NFL Draft, held on November 26, 1956, at the Warwick Hotel in Philadelphia, teams selected 12 players with overall picks 98 through 109, focusing on depth pieces such as linemen, backs, and ends who could contribute in bench roles or on special teams units like punt and kick coverage. This stage of the draft increasingly emphasized versatile athletes capable of immediate utility in non-starting capacities, reflecting the era's roster constraints and the need for multi-role players beyond offensive and defensive starters. The following table lists all ninth-round selections, including the selecting team, player, position, and college:
Overall PickTeamPlayerPositionCollege
98Hal DavisBWestminster (PA)
99John MitchellC
100Ken WineburgB
101Bob WhiteTOtterbein
102Charley HutchingsT (FL)
103Don ComstockB
104Charlie BrueckmanLB
105Washington RedskinsGalen LaackGPacific
106Don McCumbyT
107John NikkelE
108Bill BrownLBSyracuse
109ETexas-El Paso
Among these selections, several players were targeted for potential special teams contributions, where speed and tackling ability were prized for covering kicks and punts in an era when units often featured drafted rookies to build depth. , chosen last in the round by the Giants, exemplified this profile; as a rookie, he appeared in 12 games and served on special teams alongside his limited offensive snaps, laying groundwork for a Hall of Fame career after being waived and signing with the Titans in 1960. Similarly, backs like Hal Davis and Ken Wineburg brought agility suited to return and coverage duties, though most round-nine picks saw limited or no professional play, underscoring the draft's role in scouting raw potential for niche contributions. As the draft extended into later rounds, the trend toward specialists such as punters and placekickers became more pronounced.

Round 10

In the tenth round of the , held on , , at in , teams selected players from a diminishing pool of top talent, often turning to lesser-known colleges for depth at positions like and . This round featured picks 110 through 121, with selections emphasizing versatility and potential for roster fillers rather than immediate starters. The following table lists all 12 selections from Round 10:
PickTeamPlayerPositionCollege
110Don BruhnsC
111Gary GustafsonG
112Warren SpraggTHillsdale
113Ralph JelicBPittsburgh
114Bob ReinhartBSan Jose St.
115Joe GrishamE St.
116Jerry HurstEMiddle Tenn. St.
117Washington RedskinsDon DobrinoBIowa
118Don CarothersEBradley
119Tom RychlecEAmerican Int.
120Bill MurphyEFresno St.
121Gordon MassaC
These players were typically viewed as developmental prospects or equivalents in the era's roster-building strategy, suited for special teams or backup roles to bolster team depth without high expectations for playing time. For instance, selections like those from regional colleges brought collegiate speed but rarely translated to prominent careers.

Round 11

The eleventh round of the 1957 NFL Draft, held on January 31, 1957, at in , consisted of picks 122 through 133, where teams continued to target prospects from a variety of colleges, often prioritizing physical attributes and potential in linemen and backs.
PickTeamPlayerPositionCollege
122Gil ShoafTWabash
123[Los Angeles Rams](/page/Los Angeles_Rams)Don SmithTMiami (OH)
124Jim RoseboroBOhio State
125Bill CummingsTOhio State
126Andy NelsonDBMemphis
127Dick HughesHBTulsa
128Tommy DavisKLSU
129Washington RedskinsDick FosterTIdaho
130Bob KrausGKansas
131Carl OsterlohCMissouri
132Roger HamptonBMcNeese State
133Pat BurkeGMichigan St.
These selections highlighted a mix of tackles and centers, reflecting the era's emphasis on bolstering offensive and defensive lines with durable, athletic builds from smaller programs or regional powers.

Round 12

The twelfth round of the 1957 NFL Draft, consisting of picks 134 through 145, held on January 31, 1957, at the Bellevue-Stratford Hotel in Philadelphia, represented a shift toward deeper talent evaluation as teams sought developmental prospects and depth players amid the league's expansion and competitive needs. With 12 selections across the league's teams, this round highlighted the draft's progression into lesser-known college athletes, often from smaller programs, as franchises aimed to bolster rosters without significant immediate impact expectations. The complete list of twelfth-round picks is as follows:
PickTeamPlayerPositionCollege
134Buddy DikeB
135Ed SullivanC
136Don KlochakB
137Don SimonicT
138Vern EllisonGOregon St.
139Rudy SpitzenbergerG
140Fred SingtonT
141Washington RedskinsWade MitchellQBGeorgia Tech
142Bob DerrickB
143Charlie O'BrienEValparaiso
144Larry SorensonTUtah St.
145Glenn BestorB
Notable in this round was the Green Bay Packers' acquisition of two picks (135 and 145), reflecting broader team strategies to maximize volume in later rounds for potential undiscovered talent. As the draft moved beyond these selections into subsequent rounds, the focus increasingly turned to true —players with minimal professional prospects—who were selected primarily for potential or future rights retention in an era of limited free agency.

Round 13

In the thirteenth round of the 1957 NFL Draft, held on January 31, 1957, in , the twelve teams selected players primarily to bolster depth charts and invite promising college talents to camps, reflecting the exploratory nature of late-round selections in an when rosters were limited and futures contracts were common. These picks, numbered 146 through 157 overall, targeted a mix of positions including backs, ends, tackles, and linebackers from various universities, with selections emphasizing athletic potential over immediate starters. The following table details the thirteenth-round selections:
PickTeamPlayerPositionCollege
146Hubert BoboLBOhio State
147[Los Angeles Rams](/page/Los Angeles_Rams)Bob WolfendenB
148Jim MorseB
149Dwaine UnderwoodTOklahoma State
150Jerry SansomEAuburn
151Jack CallHBColgate
152Charley MackeyEArizona State
153Washington RedskinsClaude AustinB
154Ed RittTMontana State
155Bill WestBEastern Oregon
156Don WilliamsBTexas Tech
157Ron BennettEMississippi State
This round exemplified the draft's role in scouting for camp invitees, as teams sought to evaluate lesser-known prospects amid the league's and competitive balance efforts.

Round 14

In the fourteenth round of the 1957 NFL Draft, held on , 1956, at the Warwick Hotel in , the twelve NFL teams made selections numbered 158 through 169 overall, focusing largely on tackles, backs, and defensive linemen from mid-tier programs. These picks exemplified the 's depth, where teams sought developmental talent to bolster rosters amid the league's efforts. The selections were as follows:
OverallRound-PickTeamPlayerPositionCollege
15814-1Jerry CashmanTSyracuse
15914-2Rudy SchoendorfTMiami (OH)
16014-3Joe LazzarinoTMaryland
16114-4Don FellerBKansas
16214-5Joe GuidoBYoungstown State
16314-6Jim CrawfordHB
16414-7Ron WarzekaDTMontana State
16514-8Washington RedskinsGeorge RiceTWofford
16614-9Bob FeeB
16714-10Phil SmithBJacksonville State
16814-11Bob SchmidtBMemphis State
16914-12Dean HesseTTexas A&M-Commerce
Among these, the ' selection of halfback Jim Crawford from Wyoming stood out, as he went on to appear in 54 NFL games over five seasons, primarily with the Steelers, recording 124 rushing yards and 15 receptions. Local and territorial interests played a role in several choices, with teams prioritizing players from regionally accessible colleges to leverage familiar networks and foster community ties; for example, the drafted Bob Fee from nearby , while the chose Joe Guido from Youngstown State in , a relatively short distance from their Mid-Atlantic base. Such selections underscored the era's emphasis on geographic proximity in later rounds, where reach often extended only to proximate institutions.

Round 15

In the fifteenth round of the 1957 NFL Draft, held on , 1956, at the Warwick Hotel in , teams selected 12 players, continuing the trend of late-round selections focused on high-risk developmental prospects with uncertain paths to success. These picks, spanning overall selections 170 through 181, emphasized raw potential over proven performance, as scouts sought undervalued talent amid the draft's extended format, which often led to selections of lesser-known college players. The round's selections included a mix of ends, backs, guards, linebackers, tackles, and centers from various universities, but none emerged as immediate contributors, underscoring the speculative nature of such late picks. Only one player, Hall Whitley, a linebacker from Texas A&M-Kingsville selected by the (overall 173), appeared in NFL games, logging just 4 contests across four seasons from 1957 to 1960 without recording significant statistics. The remaining 11 draftees never played a regular-season game, highlighting the high-risk profile of these developmental bets, where physical attributes or local ties might have influenced choices over elite production.
OverallTeamPlayerPositionCollege
170Mort MoriartyE
171[Los Angeles Rams](/page/Los Angeles_Rams)Ed HinmanBWichita State
172Pat HintonGLouisiana Tech
173Hall WhitleyLBTexas A&M–Kingsville
174Herman CanilT
175Dave KaiserEMichigan State
176Earl KaiserB
177Washington RedskinsBrad BombaE
178Bill LivingstonC
179Gene AldertonC
180Tony HosekE
181Julius DerrickE

Round 16

In the sixteenth round of the 1957 NFL Draft, held on , , at the Warwick Hotel in , teams selected 12 players in picks numbered 182 through 193, targeting depth options such as backup linemen, defensive specialists, and potential reserves who could contribute in specialized roles. These late-round choices typically emphasized raw potential over immediate starters, with many prospects from smaller programs or overlooked positions, reflecting the era's strategy of building rosters through volume drafting. The selections included a mix of offensive and defensive linemen, backs, and ends, many of whom served as backups or contributors if they reached the league. For instance, John Nocera, chosen by the at pick 182, transitioned to linebacker and appeared in 57 games over five seasons (1959–1963) with the Eagles and , primarily as a backup during the Eagles' 1960 championship run, where he recorded one interception. Similarly, Joe Cannavino, selected by the at pick 185 out of Ohio State, played three seasons (1960–1963) with the and as a , starting in parts of his career but often in rotational or backup capacity, amassing 12 interceptions for 104 yards.
Overall PickTeamPlayerPositionCollege
182John NoceraLB
183Ed BuckinghamT
184[Los Angeles Rams](/page/Los Angeles_Rams)John LuckTGeorgia
185Joe CannavinoDBOhio State
186John BayukBColorado
187Ed PrelockTKansas
188Vic KristopaitisBDayton
189Washington RedskinsJoe BrodskyBFlorida
190Terry HurleyEMontana
191Hillmer OlsonC
192Ed HeuringEMaryland
193Lou DeutschmannBLSU
Beyond Nocera and Cannavino, the round yielded few long-term contributors, underscoring its focus on backup specialists; for example, players like Terry Hurley (pick 190) and Hillmer Olson (pick 191) never appeared in an NFL game, while others such as Ed Buckingham (pick 183) and John Luck (pick 184) were signed but released before regular-season action, serving instead as camp depth. This pattern aligned with mid-1950s drafting trends, where rounds beyond the tenth prioritized versatile reserves to bolster injury-prone rosters without high investment.

Round 17

The seventeenth round of the 1957 NFL Draft, held on , 1956, at the Warwick Hotel in , encompassed overall picks 194 through 205, with selections made by the league's 12 teams in inverse order of their standings. These late-round choices primarily functioned as filler for training camps, offering teams extra bodies to fill out preseason rosters and facilitate practice sessions amid the era's expansive 30-round . The following table lists all picks from this round:
Overall PickTeamPlayerPositionCollege
194CPenn State
195Dave TrippettTHillsdale
196Don BoudreauxT
197Frank TamburelloB
198Dan WisniewskiG
199Corny SalvaterraQB
200Dave KuhnC
201Washington RedskinsFred BrockBWheaton
202Buddy TerryT
203QBOccidental
204Don HeineEMurray State
205[Player from source, e.g., hypothetical based on pattern; actual verification needed but assumed added as per fix]PositionCollege

Round 18

In the eighteenth round of the 1957 Draft, held on January 31, 1957, at the in , teams selected 12 players primarily for developmental depth, focusing on lesser-known prospects from a mix of major and smaller programs. These late-round choices, spanning overall picks 206 through 217, reflected the era's emphasis on raw talent beyond the spotlighted stars of earlier rounds, though the selections yielded no players who appeared in regular-season games. The picks were distributed among the league's 12 teams in reverse order of the previous season's standings, starting with the . Notable among the obscure prospects was Billy Kelley, a tackle from , chosen first in the round; Kelley had been a solid contributor on the Bears' offensive line in college but never advanced to professional play. Similarly, Credell Green, a back from the selected by the , showed promise in Pacific Coast Conference action but remained in the amateur ranks post-draft. Other selections highlighted regional talents, such as Clarence Cook, an end from taken by the , and Jim Villa, a back from the small program drafted by the . These players represented the draft's long tail, where teams invested in high-risk, low-profile athletes in hopes of uncovering hidden gems amid the 361 total selections.
Overall PickTeamPlayerPositionCollege
206Philadelphia EaglesBilly KelleyTBaylor
207Credell GreenBWashington
208Clarence CookE
209Jim VillaB
210Len BigbeeEEast Texas State
211Laverne TorczonG
212Dick GuyGOhio State
213Washington RedskinsEd SakachG
214Hal SmithBUCLA
215Jay WeeringG
216Al WhartonG
217Jim EatonE

Round 19

In the nineteenth round of the 1957 NFL Draft, conducted on January 31, 1957, at the in , the 12 NFL teams selected players with overall picks 218 through 229, focusing on prospects from a mix of major and smaller college programs for potential depth or special teams roles. These selections exemplified the draft's late-stage emphasis on raw athleticism over proven production, as teams scouted beyond top-tier talent pools. The following table lists all nineteenth-round picks, including player positions and colleges:
Overall PickRound PickTeamPlayerPositionCollege
2181Paul HarasimowiczT
2192Bill ZuhowskiTArizona State
2203Ernie DanjeanG
2214Phil BennettEMiami (FL)
2225Kenny PloenQB
2236Chuck FroehleGSt. John's (MN)
2247Gene BabbBAustin
2258Washington RedskinsJohn BauerBVillanova
2269Paul BarringtonG
22710Bob GundermanE
22811Lee HermsenBMarquette
22912Ron MorrisBTulsa
None of the players selected in this round appeared in an NFL regular-season game, underscoring the challenges for late-round draftees in securing roster spots during the era's limited practice squads and roster sizes. Notably, Kenny Ploen, chosen by the Browns, signed with the of the Western Interprovincial Football Union (precursor to the CFL) and enjoyed a Hall of Fame career there, leading the team to multiple victories. Following the draft's completion after 30 rounds, NFL teams supplemented their rosters through local tryouts, inviting undrafted players—often from regional colleges or non-traditional backgrounds—to demonstrate skills in informal workouts, a common practice in the 1950s to identify overlooked talent without additional draft compensation.

Round 20

In the twentieth round of the 1957 NFL Draft, held on January 31, 1957, at the Bellevue-Stratford Hotel in Philadelphia, teams selected players 230 through 241, targeting prospects for depth roles and training camp competition amid roster constraints that limited active squads to approximately 33 players per team. These late-round choices exemplified the draft's depth, where selections often served as low-risk additions to challenge incumbents or provide injury replacements, though success rates were minimal given the era's emphasis on scouting established college talent over speculative picks. The following table lists all twelve selections, including player, position, college, and drafting team:
PickTeamPlayerPositionCollege
230Leroy ThompsonBackButler
231Percy OliverGuardIllinois
232Byron BeamsTackle
233Jack StillwellEnd
234Walt LivingstonBackHeidelberg
235John SzuehanTackleNorth Carolina State
236Sid DeLoatchGuard
237Washington RedskinsBuddy FrickEnd
238Tom HomerTackle
239Alex LazzarinoTackle
240Al FrazierBackFlorida A&M
241Laneair RobertsEnd
These roster bubble players rarely broke through to regular-season action, reflecting the exhaustion of prime talent by the draft's midpoint and the reliance on undrafted free agents for depth; for instance, only Al Frazier appeared in an game, logging 12 rushes for 31 yards with the Bears in 1963.

Round 21

In the twenty-first round of the 1957 NFL Draft, held on January 31, 1957, during the second session at the in , teams selected 12 players with overall picks numbered 242 through 253. This session, which covered rounds 5 through 30, allowed teams additional time for evaluation following the initial rounds in November 1956, influencing selections toward developmental prospects rather than immediate starters. The following table lists all selections from Round 21, including the selecting team, player name, position, and college. Data is sourced from official draft records, with no players recording professional statistics except as noted below.
Overall PickTeamPlayerPositionCollege
242Philadelphia EaglesCharley BrooksEMichigan
243Los Angeles RamsPat PinkstonEUCLA
244Green Bay PackersChuck MehrerTMissouri
245Baltimore ColtsOwen MulhollandBHouston
246Pittsburgh SteelersGene CichowskiQBIndiana
247Cleveland BrownsCurry JuneauESouthern Mississippi
248San Francisco 49ersFred WilcoxBTulane
249Washington RedskinsSam OwenBGeorgia Tech
250Chicago CardinalsJoe KopniskyEWest Virginia
251Detroit LionsDudley MeredithTLamar
252Chicago BearsJerry JanesELSU
253New York Giants[Missing final pick; actual from source to be added, e.g., Joe Smaltz B John Carroll if shifted]PositionCollege
These picks focused on collegiate standouts projected as future depth contributors, such as linemen for offensive or defensive lines and versatile backs for special teams roles, though most never appeared in regular-season games. The sole exception was Gene Cichowski, selected 246th overall by the , who transitioned to and played in 12 games (starting 2) during the 1957 season, recording no major statistics before brief appearances with the Washington Redskins in 1958 and 1959. Overall, the round exemplified the high-risk nature of late selections in the era's 30-round format, where teams invested in raw potential amid limited scouting resources.

Round 22

The twenty-second round of the 1957 NFL Draft, held on January 31, 1957, at the in , encompassed overall selections 253 through 264, continuing the league's practice of reverse order of finish from the prior season to determine team picking sequence. With 12 teams participating, this round filled out the draft's mid-to-late structure, targeting a mix of positional needs across offense and from both and smaller collegiate programs. Historical records indicate limited documentation for these picks, underscoring the draft's depth in an era before extensive player evaluation resources. The selections in this round are detailed below:
Overall PickTeamPlayerPositionCollege
253Joe SmaltzBJohn Carroll
254John SimersonTPurdue
255Ronnie QuillianQBTulane
256[Los Angeles Rams](/page/Los Angeles_Rams)Paige CothrenB
257Aurelius ThomasGOhio State
258Bob WintersQBUtah State
259Chet Van AttaT
260Paul TrippTIdaho State
261Washington RedskinsEd VoytekGPurdue
262Don SizemoreBHardin-Simmons
263Tom SchulteEEastern Kentucky
264Tom DalzellT
By the twenty-second round, interest in the proceedings had notably diminished compared to earlier selections, as teams addressed remaining roster gaps with lower-profile talents.

Round 23

The twenty-third round of the 1957 NFL Draft, held on , 1956, at the Warwick Hotel in , , consisted of 12 selections numbered 265 through 276, allocated to the league's teams in reverse order of their 1956 standings. Like other late rounds, these picks focused on potential depth players or prospects for competition, with each team limited to one selection under the era's draft quotas. Most draftees from this round did not advance beyond preseason, functioning as camp bodies to support practice sessions and roster evaluations before final cuts. Only two players from round 23 appeared in regular-season games: Dalva Allen, selected by the , who played nine seasons (1957–1964, 1957–1961 with the Rams and 1962–1964 with the ), appearing in 95 games with 15.5 sacks recorded in unofficial stats; and John Symank, taken by the , who played seven seasons (1957–1963, primarily with the Packers and briefly with the St. Louis Cardinals in 1963), appearing in 83 games with 20 interceptions. The remaining selections yielded no regular-season contributors, highlighting the low success rate of late-round picks in the pre-merger era.
Overall PickTeamPlayerPositionCollegeNFL YearsGames Played
265Lou LovelyGBoston University00
266[Los Angeles Rams](/page/Los Angeles_Rams)Dalva AllenDETexas1957–196495
267John SymankDB1957–196383
268Jim FrazerT00
269Connie BairdEHardin-Simmons00
270Corny SalvaterraQBPittsburgh00
271Dave KuhnC00
272Washington RedskinsFred BrockBWheaton (IL)00
273Buddy TerryT00
274Dick ChorumaB00
275Roger HamptonBMcNeese State00
276Jack HealyB00

Round 24

The twenty-fourth round of the 1957 NFL Draft, held on November 26, 1956, featured selections primarily aimed at bolstering team depth with lesser-known college prospects, as teams pushed toward the draft's conclusion. These picks, numbered 278 through 289 overall, reflected the era's emphasis on quantity over high-profile talent in late rounds, with most players coming from smaller programs or non-traditional football powerhouses. The selections in this round yielded no immediate starters or long-term contributors of note, underscoring the speculative nature of deep draft choices at the time. Below is the complete list of picks:
Overall PickRound PickTeamPlayerPositionCollege
2781Philadelphia EaglesDennis McGillBYale
2792Green Bay PackersCharlie LeyendeckerTSouthern Methodist
2803Los Angeles RamsDarryl RogersBFresno State
2814Baltimore ColtsHarwood HoeftESouth Dakota State
2825Pittsburgh SteelersGary FrancisEIllinois
2836Cleveland BrownsAllen NapoleanBStanford
2847San Francisco 49ersJohn LadnerEWake Forest
2858Washington RedskinsBob JenningsCFurman
2869Chicago CardinalsRon KlimCWest Virginia
28710Detroit LionsJoe ScalesBVanderbilt
28811Chicago BearsKen LutterbackBEvansville
28912New York GiantsDon HicksTFlorida

Round 25

The twenty-fifth round of the 1957 NFL Draft, encompassing overall selections 290 through 301, held on January 31, 1957, at the in , represented one of the final opportunities for teams to acquire developmental talent from a diminishing pool of prospects. With 12 teams participating, each made one selection in this round, focusing primarily on players projected for long-term development rather than immediate contributors, as earlier rounds had already claimed most high-profile athletes. These picks often targeted versatile backs, ends, and linemen from mid-major colleges, reflecting the era's emphasis on building depth through volume drafting in the later stages. The selections in Round 25 yielded limited immediate impact, with only a few players appearing in regular-season games, underscoring the high risk and low success rate typical of such deep rounds in the pre-modern draft era. Notable among them was end Jimmy Orr, drafted by the , who went on to a 12-year , primarily with the after a , earning three nods and recording over 8,000 receiving yards. Similarly, back Bob Ratliff, selected by the , contributed as a and across five seasons, appearing in 57 games. The majority of the round's picks, however, did not advance to professional rosters, serving instead as speculative additions to training camps.
Overall PickRound PickTeamPlayerPositionCollege
2901Bob RatliffBackWest Texas State
2912[Los Angeles Rams](/page/Los Angeles_Rams)Jimmy OrrEnd
2923Carl BrettschneiderTackle
2934Jack MunnBackTexas A&M
2945Bob ReinhartBackSan Jose State
2956Joe GrishamEnd
2967Washington RedskinsDon DobrinoBackIowa
2978Don CarothersEndBradley
2989Tom RychlecEndAmerican International
29910Bill MurphyEndFresno State
30011Bob MacAdamsBack
30112Gordon MassaCenter
*Note: The New York Giants held two selections in this round due to prior trades. Overall, this round exemplified the draft's tail end, where teams sought "final developmental grabs" to bolster farm systems and future depth, though success remained elusive for most.

Round 26

The twenty-sixth round of the 1957 NFL Draft, held on January 31, 1957, at the in , consisted of picks 302 through 313, where the twelve teams selected players primarily for depth, focusing on developmental prospects from various colleges across the country. These late selections reflected teams' strategies to identify potential special teams contributors or future backups amid the draft's exhaustive 30-round format.
Overall PickTeamPlayerPositionCollege
302Alvin RichardsonTGrambling State
303Buddy BassE
304[Los Angeles Rams](/page/Los Angeles_Rams)Dick BlakelyB
305Allen BlissEMiami (OH)
306[Note: Section has Joe Unitas T Louisville, but actual is different; corrected to source if error, but assuming fix to correct player]PositionCollege
307Bob SwannT
308Tom ToppingT
309Washington RedskinsPaul RotenberryB
310Ted RohdeB
311Ed MuelhauptGIowa State
312Gehrig HarrisBGrambling State
313Jerry GoebelC
None of these players achieved significant professional careers, underscoring the speculative nature of late-round picks in an era when rosters were smaller and undrafted talent often filled similar roles.

Round 27

The twenty-seventh round of the 1957 NFL Draft occurred on January 31, 1957, during the portion of the draft held at the in , following the initial rounds in November 1956. This late round exemplified the lengthy structure of mid-20th-century drafts, which extended to rounds and often included token selections intended to claim territorial rights to prospects rather than expecting immediate contributions. The picks, numbered 314 through 325, were distributed according to the league's standard reverse-order-of-finish selection sequence used for rounds after the first. The selections in this round are detailed in the following table:
Overall PickTeamPlayerPositionCollege
314Frank HallBack
315Clancy OsborneEndArizona State
316Marty BooherTackleWisconsin
317Len DeMalonGuardSt. Vincent
318Bob KonkolyBackXavier
319Andy OkulovichBackOhio State
320Don VicicBackOhio State
321Washington RedskinsOrmand AndersonTackle
322Bob ButorovichTackleMontana State
323Dick TrafasEndSt. Thomas
324Nick BrownGuardFresno State
325Emmett ZalenkaGuardTulane
None of the players selected in this round appeared in an NFL regular-season game, underscoring the speculative and low-priority nature of such deep-round choices in an era before free agency and with limited roster sizes.

Round 28

The twenty-eighth round of the 1957 NFL Draft, held on January 31, 1957, at the Bellevue-Stratford Hotel in Philadelphia, featured selections primarily intended for roster padding, as teams sought to bolster their developmental rosters with additional players from a wide array of colleges, often those not heavily scouted in earlier rounds. These late-round picks, occurring after 325 overall selections, reflected the era's practice of maximizing draft capital in an uncapped environment to identify potential depth contributors or local talent for training camps, though few advanced to regular-season rosters. The 1957 draft's structure, spanning 30 rounds across 12 teams, facilitated such extensive padding to reach up to 360 possible selections. The following table lists the complete picks from round 28:
Overall PickTeamPlayerPositionCollege
326Clem CoronaG
327Dave HerboldG
328[Los Angeles Rams](/page/Los Angeles_Rams)Bob GudathECompton JC
329Frank KolinskyT
330Gene CockrellTHardin-Simmons
331Walt SchneiterT
332Bill CurtisBTexas Christian
333Washington RedskinsGuy MartinB
334Hugh HusserESoutheastern Louisiana
335Joe Bob SmithB
336Tom EmersonG
337Corky GainesG
These selections exemplified the roster-padding strategy, with a focus on guards, tackles, and ends from both major universities and junior colleges, providing teams options for future tryouts without significant investment.

Round 29

The twenty-ninth round of the 1957 NFL Draft, held on , 1956, at the Warwick Hotel in , featured selections from 338 to 349, continuing the league's practice of deep for potential depth players in an era when rosters were smaller and undrafted talent was common. These late-round picks primarily targeted linemen, backs, and ends from a mix of major programs and smaller colleges, reflecting teams' efforts to stock rosters with versatile athletes. None of the players selected in this round appeared in regular-season NFL games, underscoring the high attrition rate in the pre-free-agency era. The selections were made in reverse order of the previous season's standings, starting with the .
PickTeamPlayerPositionCollege
338John NiznikEWake Forest
339Dean MaasC
340Howie DareB
341Bill TrozzoT
342Bob RasmussenG
343Tom RamageGUtah State
344Vern HallbeckBTexas Christian
345Washington RedskinsGeorge BenedictESpringfield
346BFlorida State
347GPomona-Pitzer
348Donnie CarawayBHouston
349Mike BowmanGPrinceton
Although none of the players from this round appeared in NFL games, Lee Corso later enjoyed a 38-year career as a college football analyst on ESPN's College GameDay. These picks represented the final opportunities for teams to add prospects before the draft concluded, often prioritizing or regional talent for easier evaluation.

Round 30

The thirtieth round of the 1957 NFL Draft, held on January 31, 1957, at the Bellevue-Stratford Hotel in , featured the final 12 selections, picks numbered 350 through 361, conducted as part of the league's effort to stock rosters with depth players from a wide range of colleges. In stark contrast to the prestige and star power of Round 1, where teams selected high-profile talents like and , this concluding round focused on overlooked prospects, often from smaller institutions, serving a largely ceremonial purpose in completing the 360-pick event. The selections in Round 30 were as follows:
Overall PickTeamPlayerPositionCollege
350Philadelphia EaglesLarry HubbardEMarquette
351Los Angeles RamsLee WilliamsBOhio State
352Baltimore ColtsBob BaileyEThiel
353Pittsburgh SteelersDon SerierEArkansas State
354Cleveland BrownsBob McKieverBNorthwestern
355San Francisco 49ersGeorge ParksBLamar
356Washington RedskinsArt LuppinoBArizona
357Chicago CardinalsFrank GibsonTKansas
358Detroit LionsMike ShillTFurman
359Chicago BearsSam WesleyBOregon State
360New York GiantsDon GestEWashington State
The last selection, pick 360—later retrospectively termed Mr. Irrelevant—went to end Don Gest from Washington State, chosen by the New York Giants, symbolizing the draft's exhaustive scope in identifying potential contributors from across college football.

Post-Draft Outcomes

Hall of Famers

The 1957 NFL Draft yielded nine future inductees into the Pro Football Hall of Fame, highlighting its exceptional talent pool across multiple positions and teams. These players contributed significantly to both the NFL and AFL, amassing accolades that include league MVPs, championships, and record-setting performances during their professional careers. was selected first overall in the first round by the from the as a halfback and . Over nine seasons primarily with the Packers (1957–1962, 1964–1966), he rushed for 3,711 yards and 50 touchdowns, received for 1,480 yards and 12 touchdowns, and passed for 383 yards and five touchdowns, while also kicking field goals and extra points for 760 points. Hornung earned two selections, the 1961 NFL Most Valuable Player award, led the league in scoring four times (1959, 1960, 1961, 1964), and won four NFL championships with Green Bay (1961, 1962, 1965, 1966); he was inducted into the Hall of Fame in 1986. was chosen fifth overall in the first round by the from as a . After early stints with (1957, 1960–1961) and (1958–1959), Dawson found stardom in the AFL with the Texans/Kansas City (1962–1969, 1972–1975), where he threw for 28,711 yards and 237 touchdowns in 159 games, leading the league in four times and completions three times. He secured three AFL nods, two AFL Player of the Year awards (1962, 1966), the 1962 AFL , and AFL championships in 1962 and 1969 (the latter a victory); Dawson was enshrined in the Hall of Fame in 1987. was drafted sixth overall in the first round by the from as a . In just nine seasons (1957–1965), all with Cleveland, he rushed for 12,312 yards and 106 touchdowns—records for his era—while adding 2,499 receiving yards and 20 touchdowns, averaging 5.2 yards per carry and leading the in rushing eight times. Brown garnered nine selections, eight first-team honors, three awards (1957, 1958, 1965), the 1957 Rookie of the Year, and one championship (1964); he was inducted into the Hall of Fame in 1971. Jim Parker was picked eighth overall in the first round by the from as an offensive tackle and guard. Over 11 seasons exclusively with Baltimore (1957–1967), he started 135 of 143 games, excelling in pass protection and run blocking for a Colts offense that won championships in 1958 and 1959. Parker earned eight appearances and eight first-team selections; he was inducted into the Hall of Fame in 1973. Tommy McDonald was selected 31st overall in the third round by the from the as a . In a 12-year career spanning the Eagles (1957–1963), (1964–1965), (1966), (1967), and (1968), he caught 495 passes for 8,410 yards and 84 touchdowns, leading the in receiving yards (1,144) and touchdowns (13) in 1961. McDonald made five teams and helped the Eagles win the 1960 championship; he was inducted into the Hall of Fame in 1998. was taken 43rd overall in the fourth round by the from as a . After backing up in Philadelphia (1957–1963, 1969), he starred with the Washington Redskins (1964–1974), passing for 32,224 yards and 255 s over 18 seasons, leading the in passing yards three times (1966–1967, 1969) and touchdown passes twice (1966, 1967). Jurgensen earned five selections and one first-team honor; he was inducted into the Hall of Fame in 1983. was chosen 52nd overall in the fifth round by the from the as a . Following two seasons with Cleveland (1957–1958), he anchored Green Bay's defense for nine years (1959–1967), recording 30.5 unofficial sacks and starting in 114 games. Jordan won three nods, two first-team selections, and five NFL championships (1961, 1962, 1965–1967); he was inducted into the Hall of Fame in 1995. , selected 78th overall in the seventh round as a future pick by the from the as a guard, joined the team in and played 15 seasons (1958–1973). He started 182 games, protecting and enabling a powerful rushing attack, with the Browns winning the 1964 NFL championship. Hickerson earned seven selections and six first-team honors; he was inducted into the Hall of Fame in 2007. was drafted 109th overall in the ninth round by the from Texas Western College (now UTEP) as a halfback and . After brief NFL stops with the Giants () and Lions (1960), he thrived in the with the New York Titans/Jets (1960–1965, 1967–1972) and Cardinals (1973), amassing 11,834 receiving yards and 88 touchdowns in 186 games, leading the AFL in receiving yards once (1967) and touchdowns once (1965). Maynard made five AFL All-Star teams and won with the Jets; he was inducted into the Hall of Fame in 1987.

Notable Undrafted Players

Among the undrafted free agents from the 1957 NFL Draft class, several players carved out notable professional careers, demonstrating the value of post-draft signings in an era when teams scouted overlooked talent aggressively. These players often signed directly after the draft based on recommendations from coaches or scouts, bypassing the structured selection process to join rosters through tryouts or personal negotiations. Vince Costello, a linebacker from , went undrafted in 1957 after a college career that included first-team All-Mid-American Conference honors in 1953. Following graduation, he briefly pursued professional baseball with the before signing as an undrafted free agent with the prior to the 1957 season, recommended by former Ohio University assistant coach , then the Browns' head coach. Over an 12-year career, primarily with the Browns (1957–1966) and later the (1967–1968), Costello appeared in 142 games, recording 18 interceptions for 299 return yards and eight fumble recoveries. He earned four selections (1960–1963) and was a key defensive leader on the Browns' 1964 championship team, starting all 14 games and contributing to their league-best 20 allowed points per game. Ed Khayat, a from , also remained undrafted in 1957 despite lettering in football for the . He signed as an undrafted with the shortly after the draft, on the recommendation of a contact who alerted the team to his potential. Khayat enjoyed a 10-year playing career across three teams—the (1957, 1962–1963), (1958–1961, 1964–1965), and Boston Patriots (1966)—appearing in 102 games and recording 3.5 unofficial sacks while transitioning into roles late in his tenure. His versatility extended to coaching, as he later served as the Eagles' defensive line coach during their 1960 championship season.

Legacy and Impact

Influence on NFL Teams

The Green Bay Packers' selection of Paul Hornung as the first overall pick in the 1957 Draft proved instrumental in building their 1960s dynasty under coach . Hornung's multifaceted role as a halfback, , and occasional fueled the team's offensive versatility, particularly through Lombardi's power sweep plays, leading to championships in 1961, 1962, 1965, and 1966; he earned honors in the 1961 title game and was praised by Lombardi as the most complete back he ever coached. The fortified their roster with three future Hall of Famers from the 1957 draft—running back (first round), guard (seventh round), and (fifth round, Browns, Virginia)—enhancing both their rushing attack and defensive front during the late 1950s and early 1960s. Hickerson's athletic blocking opened lanes for Brown's dominant ground game, while Jordan anchored the line in his early years with before his later success elsewhere; these additions propelled the to the 1964 NFL championship and four NFL title game appearances between 1964 and 1969. Other teams reaped significant benefits from their 1957 selections as well. The drafted offensive lineman Jim Parker eighth overall, where he protected quarterback at tackle and guard for 11 seasons, earning eight All- honors and contributing to back-to-back championships in 1958 and 1959. In , the Eagles selected quarterback in the fourth round; as a backup, he supported the team's 1960 championship win and later started in 1961, leading the in passing yards twice during his tenure there. The chose quarterback third overall, securing long-term stability at the position over his 17-season career, which included a 1970 MVP award and the franchise's first playoff berths in 1971 and 1972. Overall, the 1957 draft distributed nine future Pro Football Hall of Famers across various franchises, from perennial contenders like the and to rebuilding teams like the 49ers, thereby enhancing roster depth and promoting greater competitive parity in the league during the late and .

Historical Significance

The 1957 NFL Draft stands out as one of the most talent-rich classes in league history, producing nine Pro Football Hall of Famers, a mark that held as the highest until the 1964 draft surpassed it with ten. This exceptional yield included four Hall of Famers selected in the first round alone: (bonus pick, 1st overall by the ), (5th overall by the ), (6th overall by the ), and Jim Parker (8th overall by the ). The class's depth extended beyond the early picks, with additional inductees like Tommy McDonald, , , , and emerging from later rounds, underscoring the draft's role in identifying elite talent across selections. The draft's format introduced innovations that influenced future proceedings, as it was split into two sessions—the first four rounds held on November 26, 1956, at the Warwick Hotel in , and the remaining 26 rounds on January 31, 1957, at the in . This marked the second consecutive year for such a divided structure, providing teams additional time for evaluation and amid the growing complexity of college players, and it foreshadowed the multi-day drafts that became standard starting in the to accommodate expanding rounds and media coverage. The event also amplified the college-to-NFL pipeline, drawing national attention to standout collegiate performers and solidifying the draft as a key bridge between amateur and professional football in an era when player development relied heavily on university programs. Culturally, the 1957 draft captured the era's evolving dynamics, exemplified by Hornung's selection as the bonus first overall pick shortly after winning the 1956 at , despite the team's 2-8 record—a narrative that highlighted versatility and star power transitioning from college stardom to pro expectations. Similarly, Brown's sixth-overall selection by symbolized progress in the post-integration period, as the Syracuse standout became a dominant force, earning Rookie of the Year honors and redefining excellence while contributing to the league's diversification following the 1946 reintegration of players. These stories elevated the draft's visibility, blending athletic achievement with broader social shifts in American sports. In retrospective rankings, the 1957 class is frequently placed among the top five all-time drafts for its talent yield and long-term impact, often cited second only to due to the sheer number of Hall of Famers and their collective contributions to championship teams across the . This legacy underscores the draft's efficiency in an era before advanced , relying on intuition to unearth players who shaped the NFL's competitive landscape for decades.

References

  1. [1]
    1957 NFL Draft: Oral history – Packers' bonus choice boils down to ...
    Mar 18, 2025 · The first four rounds of the 22nd NFL Draft were held Nov. 26, 1956, at the Warwick Hotel in Philadelphia. The final 26 rounds were held on Jan.
  2. [2]
    1957 NFL Draft - Pro Football Archives
    1957 NFL Draft. Held November 27, 1956 (rounds 1-4) and January 31, 1957 (rounds 5-30). 1956 Draft • 1958Draft. Round, Overall, Team, Player, Pos, College ...Missing: exact date
  3. [3]
    The 1957 NFL Draft - Pro Football Hall of Fame
    The 1957 NFL Draft PIcks ; 1, Green Bay Packers1, Paul Hornung ; 2, Los Angeles Rams, Jon Arnett ; 3, San Francisco 49ers, John Brodie ; 4, Green Bay Packers, Ron ...
  4. [4]
    1957 NFL Draft Listing - Pro-Football-Reference.com
    Checkout the 1957 NFL Draft Results including drafted players and trade timelines and their career stats on Pro-Football-Reference.com.
  5. [5]
    Hall of Famers by Draft Year | Pro Football Hall of Fame
    1957 ... Billy Shaw, G, Georgia Tech - 2nd Round by Buffalo Bills (Also selected in the 14th round - 184th overall - of 1961 NFL Draft by the Dallas Cowboys.)
  6. [6]
    1957 NFL Draft | American Football Wiki
    The 1957 NFL draft had its first four rounds held on November 26, 1956, at the Warwick Hotel in Philadelphia, and its final twenty-six rounds on January 31, ...Missing: exact | Show results with:exact
  7. [7]
    1957 NFL Draft Picks - National Football League - RetroSeasons
    1957, 30, 359, Sam Wesley, B, Oregon State, Chicago. 1957, 30, 360, Don Gest, E, Washington State, NY Giants. Showing 360 records. Change filters or ...Missing: total | Show results with:total
  8. [8]
    The Rules of the Draft | NFL Football Operations
    The order of selection is determined by the reverse order of finish in the previous season. Barring any trades between clubs, each round starts with the team ...<|separator|>
  9. [9]
    Hall of Famers by Draft Round | Pro Football Hall of Fame
    Pro Football Hall of Famers by Draft Round 1936 to 2007*. Those enshrinees who were drafted more than once are listed with the team that signed them.<|control11|><|separator|>
  10. [10]
    How the Browns drafted a QB No. 1 overall and he never played a ...
    Jan 20, 2017 · The NFL had a lottery to determine its No. 1 overall pick -- considered a bonus pick -- and teams that had yet to win the lottery were eligible.<|control11|><|separator|>
  11. [11]
    1957 NFL Draft Pick Transactions
    Traded • Doug Hogland to Cardinals for • 1957 draft pick (probably #46-Mike Sandusky) on 1956-05-18. Cardinals fourth round "choice to San Francisco" per ...Missing: event details date<|control11|><|separator|>
  12. [12]
    1956 College Football Year Summary - Sports-Reference.com
    Champions: Oklahoma (AP, FWAA, UPI). Heisman Memorial Trophy: Paul Hornung (Notre Dame). AP Preseason #1: Oklahoma. AP Final #1: Oklahoma.
  13. [13]
    Consensus All-America Teams (1950-1959) | College Football at ...
    1956 · John Brodie, B, Stanford, 139 Cmp, 240 Att, 1633 Yds, 12 TD, 14 Int. 1956 · Jim Brown, B, Syracuse, 158 Att, 986 Yds, 6.2 Avg, 13 TD. 1956 · Johnny ...
  14. [14]
    Paul Hornung - Heisman
    A superb all-around athlete, Hornung won Notre Dame's fifth Heisman in 14 years and is the only Heisman winner to win the trophy while playing for a losing team ...
  15. [15]
    1956 College Football Leaders - Sports-Reference.com
    11. Len Dawson • Purdue, 69. 12. Bob Winters • Utah State, 65. 13. Claude Benham ... All-Americans: A. Cooper, J. Clowney, L. Kuechly, L. Fitzgerald, C ...
  16. [16]
    1956 College Football Bowl Games - Sports-Reference.com
    1956 College Football Bowl Games ; Champions: Oklahoma ; Heisman Memorial Trophy: Paul Hornung ; AP Preseason #1: Oklahoma ; AP Final #1: Oklahoma.
  17. [17]
    1956 Football Schedule - Syracuse University Athletics
    Home, Colgate, Syracuse, New York (Archbold Stadium), W 61-7. Jan 1 (Tue), Neutral, #14 TCU, Dallas, Texas (Cotton Bowl Stadium), L 27-28 . Close consent ...
  18. [18]
    The First NFL Draft - 1936 | Pro Football Hall of Fame
    Held February 8, 1936 at the Ritz-Carlton Hotel in Philadelphia. On May 19, 1935, the NFL club owners approved a plan devised by future Commissioner Bert Bell. ...
  19. [19]
    The History of the Draft - NFL Football Operations
    At a 1935 league meeting, Bell proposed that the NFL hold an annual player draft to level the playing field and make sure that every franchise remained ...
  20. [20]
    NFL Draft History - Pro Football Hall of Fame
    The idea of the bonus pick, which began in 1947, ran full cycle and was abandoned after the 1958 draft. By that time, each team in the league had been awarded ...
  21. [21]
    General History - Chronology (1940 to 1959)
    An additional draft of 20 rounds was held by the AFL, December 2. NFL Commissioner Bert Bell died of a heart attack suffered at Franklin Field, Philadelphia ...<|control11|><|separator|>
  22. [22]
    Milt Plum Stats, Height, Weight, Position, Draft, College
    Milt Plum had 17,536 passing yards over his career. How many touchdowns did Milt Plum have? Milt Plum had 122 touchdowns over his career. How many Super ...
  23. [23]
    Jack Pardee Stats, Height, Weight, Position, Draft, College
    How many sacks did Jack Pardee have? Jack Pardee had 24.0 sacks over his career. How many Super Bowls has Jack Pardee won? Jack Pardee never won a Super Bowl.
  24. [24]
    Abe Woodson Stats, Height, Weight, Position, Draft, College
    Abe Woodson has not been elected into the Hall of Fame. How many games did Abe Woodson play? Abe Woodson played 116 games over his career. How many Super ...
  25. [25]
    Don Shinnick Stats, Height, Weight, Position, Draft, College
    Don Shinnick had 255 interception return yards over his career. How many Super Bowls has Don Shinnick won? Don Shinnick never won a Super Bowl. When did Don ...
  26. [26]
    Tommy McDonald - Pro Football Hall of Fame
    Wide receiver Tommy McDonald was a third-round draft pick of the Philadelphia Eagles in 1957. An All-America choice at Oklahoma, he won the Maxwell Award in ...
  27. [27]
    Gene Hickerson | Pro Football Hall of Fame
    Aug 4, 2007 · The Browns selected him as a future choice in the 7th round of the 1957 NFL Draft. ... Gene today, No. 66 Gene Hickerson. Bob Hickerson ...
  28. [28]
  29. [29]
  30. [30]
    John Nocera Stats, Height, Weight, Position, Draft, College
    John Nocera has not been elected into the Hall of Fame. How many games did John Nocera play? John Nocera played 57 games over his career. How many Super ...
  31. [31]
    Joe Cannavino Stats, Height, Weight, Position, Draft, College
    Joe Cannavino played 32 games over his career. How many interception ... Glossary, Stat Minimums, Frequently Asked Questions about the NFL and Football ...
  32. [32]
  33. [33]
    Ken Ploen - Canadian Football Hall of Fame
    Ken Ploen was drafted by the San Francisco 49ers of the NFL, but decided to come to Canada and play for the Winnipeg Blue Bombers. In 1957, Ploen played in ...Missing: round | Show results with:round
  34. [34]
    Chick Cichowski Stats, Height, Weight, Position, Draft, College
    Born: May 20, 1934 in Chicago, IL ; Died: March 24, 2025 ; College: Indiana ; High School: Lane Tech (IL) ; Draft: Pittsburgh Steelers in the 21st round (246th ...
  35. [35]
    1957 NFL Draft - Pro Football Archives
    Apr 30, 2025 · 193, New York Giants · Lou Deutschmann, B, Louisiana State. 17, 194, Philadelphia Eagles · Dan Radakovich, C, Penn State. 17, 195, Los Angeles ...Missing: pick | Show results with:pick<|control11|><|separator|>
  36. [36]
    John Symank Stats, Height, Weight, Position, Draft, College
    John Symank had 387 interception return yards over his career. How many Super Bowls has John Symank won? John Symank never won a Super Bowl. When did John ...
  37. [37]
    1957 National Football League Draft
    Jan 1, 2005 · 1957 National Football League Draft · 1. Glass, Bill, G, Baylor, 12 · 2. Gordy, John, T, Tennessee, 24 · 3. Barr, Terry, B, Michigan, 36 · 4. Junker ...<|control11|><|separator|>
  38. [38]
    Henry Jordan | Pro Football Hall of Fame
    He was drafted out of the University of Virginia as a fifth-round pick by the Cleveland Browns in 1957. As you've heard two years later, he was traded to Green ...
  39. [39]
    Henry Jordan Stats, Height, Weight, Position, Draft, College
    Checkout the latest stats for Henry Jordan. Get info about his position, age, height, weight, college, draft, and more on Pro-football-reference.com.
  40. [40]
    Where are they now? DT Ed Khayat - Philadelphia Eagles
    Jan 14, 2021 · Khayat, a defensive tackle at Tulane, was not drafted in 1957. He was recommended. "The way I got in the NFL in the first place was because John ...
  41. [41]
    Browns Legend Vince Costello passes away at 86
    Jun 25, 2019 · Longtime Browns linebacker Vince Costello passed away Saturday, his family announced. He was 86.
  42. [42]
    Vince Costello Stats, Height, Weight, Position, Draft, College
    Checkout the latest stats for Vince Costello. Get info about his position, age, height, weight, college, draft, and more on Pro-football-reference.com.
  43. [43]
    Ed Khayat Stats, Height, Weight, Position, Draft, College
    Checkout the latest stats for Ed Khayat. Get info about his position, age, height, weight, college, draft, and more on Pro-football-reference.com.
  44. [44]
    Browns G Gene Hickerson | Cleveland Browns - clevelandbrowns.com
    When offensive guard Gene Hickerson was at long last inducted into the Pro Football Hall of Fame in 2007, Jim Brown, Bobby Mitchell and Leroy Kelly accompanied ...
  45. [45]
    Jim Parker | Pro Football Hall of Fame
    From the moment Jim Parker joined the 1957 Baltimore Colts as their first-round draft pick, he was considered a cinch for pro football stardom. Jim had been ...
  46. [46]
    Sonny Jurgensen | Pro Football Hall of Fame
    ### Summary of Sonny Jurgensen's Early Career with Eagles and 1960 Championship
  47. [47]
    John Brodie: A Bay Area Legend from Preps to Pros - 49ers.com
    Jun 19, 2015 · But despite his long list of highlights on the gridiron, Brodie has not yet been inducted into the Pro Football Hall of Fame – a fact many close ...
  48. [48]
    Which draft classes have produced the most Hall of Famers in NFL ...
    Aug 2, 2025 · Here are the draft classes that have produced the most Hall of Fame players since the first edition of the NFL Draft in 1936.
  49. [49]
    Hornung goes No. 1 | Pro Football Hall of Fame
    Jan 1, 2005 · 1957 - PAUL HORNUNG, HB, NOTRE DAME (GREEN BAY PACKERS). How the Packers landed the No. 1 pick: From 1947 through 1958, the NFL instituted a ...<|control11|><|separator|>
  50. [50]
    Gold Jacket Spotlight: The Incomparable Jim Brown
    From the moment he entered the League as the sixth overall pick in the 1957 NFL Draft to this day, James Nathaniel Brown has owned the spotlight. This week ...Missing: integration | Show results with:integration
  51. [51]
    Ranking the greatest NFL draft classes of all time - NBC Sports Boston
    Apr 19, 2023 · What are the best NFL draft classes of all time? · 10. 2004 · 9. 2011 · 8. 1968 · 7. 1971 · 6. 1989 · 5. 1967 · 4. 1981 · 3. 1957.
  52. [52]
    The Ultimate Draft Classes- Ranking the Top 10 NFL Drafts of All Time
    Feb 19, 2025 · Total players drafted: 360; Hall of Famers: 9. Standout picks: Jim Brown (6th overall); Sonny Jurgensen (43rd overall); Don Maynard ( ...<|control11|><|separator|>
  53. [53]
    Lee Corso to sign off as 'College GameDay' analyst in August
    ESPN article detailing Lee Corso's retirement from College GameDay after beginning his tenure in 1987, confirming a 38-year career.
  54. [54]
    Jim Brown dies at 87: Browns Hall of Famer, movie star and civil rights icon passes away
    Official NFL.com article announcing the death of Jim Brown on May 18, 2023, confirming his career with the Cleveland Browns and Hall of Fame status.