Fact-checked by Grok 2 weeks ago

A Dictionary of Modern English Usage

A Dictionary of Modern English Usage is a prescriptive guide to , , vocabulary, and style, written by lexicographer Henry Watson Fowler and first published in 1926 by . The book consists of hundreds of alphabetically arranged entries addressing common usage issues, offering Fowler's opinions on clarity, idiom, and elegance in writing and speech. It reflects Fowler's commitment to practical, straightforward English, drawing on his experience as a teacher and co-author of earlier works like The King's English (1906) with his brother Francis George Fowler. Henry Watson Fowler (1858–1933) was born in , , and educated at and , where he studied . After an unfulfilling career as a , he relocated to in 1903 with his brother to focus on writing dictionaries and usage guides, collaborating on the Concise Oxford Dictionary () and Pocket Oxford Dictionary () before completing A Dictionary of Modern English Usage shortly before his death. The work originated from Fowler's frustration with inconsistent English in and , aiming to equip writers with tools to avoid solecisms and promote idiomatic precision. Upon publication, the dictionary received widespread acclaim for its witty, authoritative tone and became an indispensable for writers, editors, and educators throughout the twentieth century. No book exerted greater influence on British attitudes toward English usage during that era, shaping standards in , , and . Its entries often blend linguistic analysis with Fowler's personal prejudices, such as his disdain for "popularised scientific terms" and advocacy for logical consistency in prepositions. Subsequent editions have updated and expanded the original while preserving its spirit: the second edition (1965), revised by Ernest Gowers, incorporated post-war linguistic changes; the third (1996), edited by Robert Burchfield as The New Fowler's Modern English Usage, addressed global English varieties; and the fourth (2015), under Jeremy Butterfield as Fowler's Dictionary of Modern English Usage, reflects contemporary usage informed by corpus data and includes over 250 new entries. These revisions have ensured the book's enduring relevance as a of reference.

Introduction

Overview and Purpose

A Dictionary of Modern English Usage is a prescriptive to usage and writing, first published in 1926 by (Clarendon Press imprint). Authored by , it serves as an authoritative reference on matters of grammar, syntax, style, and word choice, with the number 815620926 for the original edition; subsequent reprints, such as the 2003 Oxford Language Classics edition, carry 978-0-19-860506-9. Unlike traditional dictionaries that provide word definitions, it focuses exclusively on resolving usage controversies, offering guidance on idiomatic expressions, common errors, and stylistic preferences to aid writers and speakers. The book covers a broad scope of topics central to effective English , including plurals and forms, rules, precise word choice, and preferences for concise constructions over verbose alternatives. It addresses varieties of word meanings, misuses, synonyms, grammatical constructions, and collocations, often through short articles and illustrative examples drawn from and . Fowler emphasizes practical application in everyday talk and writing, distinguishing between formal and informal registers while prioritizing natural over artificial elegance. Its primary purpose is to foster clear and vigorous prose among English speakers, equipping them to avoid unidiomatic phrasing and produce readable, effective communication. Fowler explicitly discourages pedantry, clichés, and overly formal or pompous constructions that obscure meaning, advocating instead for straightforward expression rooted in the living language. By doing so, the work aims to preserve and enhance the vitality of as a tool for precise thought and expression.

Author and Historical Context

Henry Watson Fowler (1858–1933) was an English schoolmaster, journalist, and lexicographer whose career reflected a commitment to clarifying English usage through practical guidance. Born in , , he was educated at and , where he studied . After graduation, Fowler taught and for seventeen years at in Sedbergh, (now ), but resigned in 1899 due to a principled disagreement with the headmaster over preparing boys for religious confirmation, as he did not profess . He then moved to , where he pursued freelance journalism for four years before relocating to in 1903 with his younger brother, Francis George Fowler (1870–1918), adopting a spartan lifestyle that allowed them to focus on writing. There, Fowler honed his skills as a freelance , contributing literary essays to periodicals, including collections such as Popular Fallacies (1904) and Between Boy and Man (1908). Fowler's lexicographical work began in collaboration with his brother, producing influential texts like The King's English (1906), a manual critiquing common errors in composition, and The Concise Oxford Dictionary of Current English (1911), which he edited. The brothers had planned A Dictionary of Modern English Usage as an extension of their efforts, but Francis's death from in 1918, while serving in the during , left Henry to complete it alone over the following years. Largely self-taught in —despite his , Fowler lacked formal training or academic credentials in —he drew on his experience and journalistic practice to develop the dictionary, dedicating it to his brother's memory. The work was finalized shortly before its publication by in 1926. Fowler's motivations for the dictionary arose from his deep frustration with the inconsistent and often inadequate of English in , where he observed students struggling with amid a dominated by Latin models that poorly suited the idiomatic nature of English. He advocated for a "democratic" of writing—natural, free of pretentious "," and prioritizing living over rigid rules—to make language accessible to journalists, amateurs, and everyday users. This approach reflected his broader aim to counter the era's prescriptivist tendencies, which emphasized correctness amid post-World War I cultural shifts toward standardization. The book's creation occurred in the socio-linguistic context of (1918–1939), a period of social upheaval following the war, with rising prescriptivism in usage guides responding to anxieties over linguistic purity in a democratizing . Literacy rates had soared to approximately 97% for both men and women by the 1920s, driven by compulsory education reforms like the 1918 Education Act, which extended schooling and fueled demand for affordable, practical guides to navigate the expanding world of print media and writing. Traditional grammar education, still heavily influenced by Latin structures since the , was increasingly seen as outdated for , prompting works like Fowler's to offer relevant, non-academic advice for the newly literate masses. Fowler died on , 1933, in Tunbridge Wells, leaving his dictionary as a cornerstone of usage guidance.

Content and Style

Linguistic Approach

Henry Watson Fowler's linguistic approach in A Dictionary of Modern English Usage represents a distinctive blend of prescriptivism and pragmatism, aiming to guide writers toward clear, effective expression while rejecting overly rigid or pedantic impositions on the language. Drawing from his background as a classics teacher, Fowler balanced traditional Latin- and Greek-derived grammatical principles with the realities of modern spoken and written English, prioritizing natural usage that serves communication over artificial elegance or unnecessary complexity. He advocated for "direct and vigorous" writing, criticizing affectation, verbosity, and the pursuit of ornamental style as barriers to clarity, as seen in his disdain for "elegant variation"—the needless substitution of synonyms to avoid repetition—which he deemed a common vice among inferior writers. Fowler critiqued many conventional "rules" as unfounded superstitions, particularly those imported from classical languages without regard for English . He defended the and the placement of prepositions at the end of sentences when they enhanced natural flow, arguing that such constructions were idiomatic and preferable to awkward alternatives forced by misguided prohibitions. For instance, on the , he famously classified English speakers into five groups based on their knowledge and attitudes: (1) those who neither know nor care what it is; (2) those who do not know but care greatly; (3) those who know and approve; (4) those who know and deprecate; and (5) the troublesome few who use it out of a of rather than . This tolerant stance extended to colloquialisms in informal contexts, emphasizing over strict logic, as Fowler believed evolved through habitual use rather than logical consistency or authoritative decree. Central to Fowler's was his recognition of an "infinitude of shibboleths"—minor, often arbitrary usage disputes that served more as markers of or educational than as genuine aids to . He categorized such issues to help readers navigate them practically, distinguishing between undisputed standard forms, reputable yet contested usages, and those deemed controversial, vulgar, or careless. Influenced by his , Fowler nonetheless urged a flexible application of to meet the needs of contemporary English, warning against the "fetishes" of pedants while promoting idiomatic vitality in everyday prose.

Structure and Entry Format

A Dictionary of Modern English Usage is organized alphabetically, with entries covering individual words, phrases, and broader grammatical topics, eschewing traditional dictionary-style definitions in favor of guidance on practical usage. Each entry typically begins with the term printed in bold type, followed by one or more explanatory paragraphs that address common pitfalls, suitable alternatives, and Fowler's prescriptive recommendations for clear and effective expression. The length of entries varies significantly to suit the complexity of the topic: simpler matters, such as rules for hyphenation in compound words, may receive only a single concise sentence or note, while more contentious issues—like the distinction between in forming futures—can extend into multi-paragraph essays exploring historical, idiomatic, and stylistic nuances. This flexible format allows for targeted advice without unnecessary elaboration, enhancing accessibility for writers and speakers seeking quick reference or deeper analysis. Front matter provides foundational guidance on general principles, including dedicated sections on (such as the use of commas, colons, and hyphens) and spelling conventions (with preferences like "grey" over "gray" for ). Unique to the book's design are cross-references, denoted in small capitals (e.g., "See FRENCH WORDS"), which direct readers to related entries for comprehensive understanding, alongside Fowler's distinctive concise, essay-like prose that blends scholarly precision with occasional dry wit. The original 1926 edition comprises over 700 entries across 742 pages, reflecting its comprehensive yet focused scope as a usage guide rather than an exhaustive lexicon.

Use of Quotations and Examples

Fowler incorporated quotations from prominent authors such as Shakespeare, Dickens, and various contemporary writers to demonstrate both correct and incorrect English usage within natural contexts, drawing from his vast personal reading to ground his observations in real linguistic practice. These quotations served a deliberate purpose: to offer evidence-based support for his prescriptions, eschewing dry abstract rules in favor of vivid, contextual illustrations that rendered the advice more relatable and memorable for readers. By embedding examples in narrative or rhetorical settings, Fowler emphasized how language functions dynamically, helping users internalize nuances through familiar literary touchpoints rather than rote memorization. Fowler's commentary on these quotations frequently adopted a witty and ironic tone, often branding errant phrases as "a mistake" while delivering sharp, humorous asides that underscored the of the misuse without descending into pedantry. For instance, his critiques highlighted "slipshod extensions" of words like viable, using quoted instances to mock overly loose applications while maintaining an imperious yet engaging authority. This approach not only illuminated stylistic pitfalls but also infused the dictionary with a distinctive dry humor, making complex points accessible and entertaining. The types of quotations varied to suit the entry's focus, including excerpts from to explore stylistic flourishes, samples from to trace evolving modern idioms, and even self-coined phrases where needed to clarify hypothetical scenarios. Fowler struck a deliberate balance between formal literary sources—such as passages from Shakespeare or Dickens—and colloquial examples from everyday speech or periodicals, thereby bridging "high" and "low" varieties of English to promote a more inclusive understanding of usage across registers. The original edition featured over 1,000 such quotations, all sourced from Fowler's , which lent authenticity and depth to his prescriptive framework.

Publication History

Original 1926 Edition

A Dictionary of Modern English Usage was first published in April by at the Clarendon Press in . The volume comprised viii + 742 pages and retailed at 12s 6d. Henry Watson Fowler (1858–1933) completed the manuscript prior to its release, having devoted much of his career to lexicographical work following his collaboration with his brother Francis George Fowler on earlier projects like The King's English (1906). The original edition captured Fowler's distinctive voice—witty, prescriptive, and opinionated—without any posthumous or editorial alterations, relying instead on his personal observations of language rather than systematic corpus analysis. The front matter included a dedication "To the memory of my brother FRANCIS GEORGE FOWLER, M.A.," acknowledging their joint efforts in language scholarship. In the , Fowler articulated his purpose: to combat prevalent errors in English usage that he viewed as obstacles to clear communication, emphasizing a commitment to plain, precise expression over ornate or affected styles. This unmediated presentation of Fowler's judgments on , , and formed the core appeal of the work, distinguishing it as a direct reflection of his lifelong advocacy for straightforward English. Sales exceeded expectations, with print runs escalating rapidly from 10,000 to 20,000 and then 50,000 copies between June and October 1926 alone, cementing its status as an immediate commercial success. Upon publication, the book garnered acclaim in , which praised it as "a work of sterling soundness and essentially English ." This early reception underscored its role as a seminal guide for writers and educators seeking authoritative advice on contemporary usage.

Revised and Subsequent Editions

The second edition of A Dictionary of Modern English Usage, published in 1965 and edited by , retained much of H. W. Fowler's original wit and structure while introducing updates to reflect post-war linguistic developments. Gowers added entries on emerging words and usages, such as those influenced by technological and social changes, and moderated some of Fowler's more prescriptive judgments to adopt a slightly more descriptive tone. This edition was reprinted in 1983 and 1987, maintaining its accessibility without major alterations. The third edition, titled The New Fowler's Modern English Usage and released in 1996 under the editorship of Robert Burchfield, marked a significant expansion and modernization, growing to 864 pages from the original's 742. Burchfield, drawing on his experience as chief editor of the (OED), incorporated data from , including the , to provide evidence-based analysis of contemporary usage patterns. A revised version followed in 2004, further refining entries with updated examples from global English varieties. Jeremy Butterfield edited the fourth edition, published in 2015 as Fowler's Dictionary of Modern English Usage, which extended to 928 pages and addressed 21st-century challenges such as digital communication styles, including and influences. Butterfield emphasized globalization's impact on English, incorporating notes on non-native varieties and practices, such as the acceptance of singular "they" for . As of 2025, this remains the most recent full edition. An abridged pocket edition, first compiled in 1999 by Robert Allen, condensed the core content for portability, offering over 4,000 entries on , style, and contentious issues in a compact format. A second edition of the pocket version appeared in 2008, updated with insights from the to ensure relevance without the full volume's depth. Across these revisions, the dictionary evolved from Fowler's predominantly prescriptive stance toward a more descriptivist framework, informed by empirical data rather than opinion alone. Later editions added dedicated notes on divergences and excised outdated entries, such as those prescribing rigid rules for titles like "Mrs.," to align with modern social norms. Burchfield's reliance on OED resources and Butterfield's attention to underscored this shift, making the work a dynamic guide to evolving usage.

Reception and Legacy

Critical Reception

Upon its publication in 1926, A Dictionary of Modern English Usage received widespread acclaim for its witty and practical approach to English style and grammar. The Observer described it as "probably the most remarkable book ever devoted to the art of expression in English," praising its humor and utility as an indispensable guide. The Times of London called it "fascinating, formidable," highlighting its authoritative tone and memorable insights. However, some early critics noted its strong British orientation, with Fowler emphasizing "natural" usage suited to the "normal Englishman," which reflected a perspective potentially limiting for non-British readers. In the mid-20th century, revisions of the work continued to garner positive responses, though not without debate. The 1965 second edition, revised by Sir Ernest Gowers, was lauded for updating Fowler's original while preserving its essence, with reviewers appreciating the modernization that made it more accessible to contemporary audiences. In contrast, the 1996 third edition under Robert Burchfield faced criticism for diluting Fowler's distinctive voice and quirky personality, with some scholars arguing that the extensive rewriting diminished the personal flair that defined the original. Academically, the book has been valued for its enduring contributions despite certain dated elements. Linguist , in his introduction to the 2009 reprint of the first edition, emphasized its lasting relevance as a on usage, while noting Fowler's resistance to gender-neutral innovations, such as endorsing "himself" generically and coining terms like "doctress" for women professionals—views now seen as outdated amid evolving norms. Negative critiques have also addressed accusations of classism, as Fowler's preference for "educated" or "standard" usage often aligned with upper-middle-class conventions, potentially marginalizing other dialects and social groups. The dictionary's influence persists in literary and journalistic circles, earning spots on prestigious lists such as the 2014 compilation of the 100 best books of the . A 2025 New Yorker article described it as a "style bible" for journalists, particularly at the magazine itself, where it shaped editorial standards for over a century under figures like . Across editions, sales have exceeded one million copies, underscoring its commercial and cultural impact.

Influence on Usage Guides

Fowler's A Dictionary of Modern English Usage established a prescriptive that profoundly shaped subsequent English usage guides and style manuals, serving as a for clarity, , and opinionated guidance on language matters. Its influence extended to University Press's own resources, such as New Hart's Rules, which references Fowler's work in its bibliography and recommended readings for usage advice. The book became a cornerstone for editorial practices in , including newspapers like The Times and broadcasters such as the , where it functioned as a standard reference for stylistic consistency well into the late 20th century. In comparisons with modern counterparts, Fowler's guide stands out for its humorous, essay-like entries that deliver sharp critiques of linguistic excesses, contrasting with Bryan A. Garner's , which adopts a more systematic, data-driven approach informed by and a Language-Change Index to track evolving conventions. While Fowler's original 1926 edition relied on and personal judgment, often prioritizing with a light touch of irony, Garner's volumes—beginning with A of Usage in 1998—emphasize variants and blend prescriptivism with descriptivist insights, making it less idiosyncratic but more empirically grounded. Modern adaptations of Fowler's work include the fourth edition, edited by Jeremy Butterfield and published in , which incorporates contemporary usage trends and is available in digital formats like ebooks for broader accessibility. It receives brief citations in authoritative style guides, such as , particularly for topics like double possessives and relative pronouns. The book's legacy in global English is evident in later editions' coverage of varieties from , , , and , influencing debates on standardizing "proper" forms against more inclusive, regionally adaptive language practices since the early . Fowler's distinctive witty usage notes, often termed "Fowlerisms" for their memorable aphorisms on pedantry and , have permeated educational materials, with excerpts featured in textbooks and recommended for teaching to students and writers. As of 2025, despite the rise of descriptivist , the guide retains relevance in publishing houses and editorial workflows, as highlighted in recent analyses of its enduring role in outlets like .

References

  1. [1]
    A Dictionary of Modern English Usage - H. W. Fowler
    Free delivery 25-day returnsIt rapidly became the standard work of reference for the correct use of English in terms of choice of words, grammar, and style.
  2. [2]
    H. W. Fowler, the King of English - The New York Times
    Dec 10, 2009 · His full name was Henry Watson Fowler, and he lived from 1858 to 1933. He was educated at the Rugby School and at Balliol College, Oxford ...
  3. [3]
    Amazon.com: The Warden of English: The Life of H.W. Fowler
    30-day returnsThis poignant biography of H.W. Fowler appears on the 75th anniversary of the publication of his Modern English Usage, a work revered by writers everywhere.
  4. [4]
    A dictionary of modern English usage | WorldCat.org
    A dictionary of modern English usage. Author: H. W. Fowler. Print Book, English, 1926. Edition: View all formats and editions.
  5. [5]
    H. W. Fowler, the Autocrat of English Usage | The New Yorker
    Sep 22, 2025 · “A Dictionary of Modern English Usage” was finally published in April, 1926, at a length of seven hundred and forty-two tightly packed pages, ...
  6. [6]
    FOWLER'S MODERN ENGLISH USAGE - Ooligan Press
    Feb 2, 2022 · It doesn't have the definition of words like a dictionary but rather explains how to use words whose usage can be confusing or problematic, ...
  7. [7]
    The Fowler Collection - Ibiblio
    Fowler began his career by teaching English grammar for seventeen years at a Yorkshire secondary school for boys. When offered a promotion to housemaster, he ...Missing: self- lexicographer credentials
  8. [8]
    H. W. Fowler (Henry Watson Fowler) Biography - JRank Articles
    English lexicographer and grammarian, born in Tonbridge, Kent, educated at Balliol College, Oxford. After retiring as a schoolmaster on an issue of ...
  9. [9]
    How English became English – and not Latin | OUPblog
    Feb 4, 2016 · English grammar has been closely bound up with that of Latin since the 16th century, when English first began to be taught in schools.
  10. [10]
    The British and Reading: a short history - BookBrunch
    Nov 24, 2021 · Britain may not be topping the reading charts, but it does have a long tradition of literacy and enthusiasm for the printed word.
  11. [11]
    Elegant Variations and All That - The Atlantic
    Dec 1, 1996 · Fowler's Dictionary of Modern English Usage, the Oxford University ... vigorous writing propelling the book through three editions; it remains in ...
  12. [12]
    Elegant Variations and All That - 96.12 - Penn Linguistics
    Fowler's Dictionary of Modern English Usage, the Oxford University Press ... Fowler begins his essay on the split infinitive thus: The English-speaking ...
  13. [13]
    Henry Fowler and his eighteenth-century predecessors
    Dec 14, 2009 · He does have an entry in the Oxford Dictionary of National Biography (ODNB), where he is described as a “lexicographer and grammarian”. The ...
  14. [14]
    Full text of "A Dictionary Of Modern English Usage" - Internet Archive
    ... FOWLER, M.A. Cantab. WHO SHARED WITH ME THE PLANNING OF THIS BOOKl^ BUT DID ... Pedantry Perfect infinitive Period in abbrevia- tions Periphrasis per pro{c).
  15. [15]
    A dictionary of modern English usage : Fowler, H. W. (Henry Watson ...
    Sep 14, 2009 · Publication date: 1965. Topics: English language, Philology, Ingles (Dicionarios). Publisher: New York, Oxford University Press.
  16. [16]
    The new Fowler's modern English usage /
    Title. The new Fowler's modern English usage / first edited by H.W. · Author. Fowler, H. W. · Edition. Third edition. / edited by R.W. · Description. xxiii, 864 ...Missing: count | Show results with:count
  17. [17]
    Time for a new (but not 'New') Fowler | English Today
    Judging by the decreasing time between editions of 'Fowlers' it would seem so: thirty-nine years between Fowler's Dictionary of Modern English Usage (1926, from ...<|separator|>
  18. [18]
    The New Fowler's Modern English Usage - Amazon.com
    The New Fowler's Modern English Usage [R. W. Burchfield, Henry Watson Fowler] on Amazon ... A Dictionary of Modern English Usage: The Classic First Edition ( ...Missing: prescriptivism | Show results with:prescriptivism
  19. [19]
    Fowler's Dictionary of Modern English Usage - Walmart.com
    Jun 1, 2015 · Buy Fowler's Dictionary of Modern English Usage at Walmart ... Page Count: 928. View all item details. Specs. Book format. Hardcover.
  20. [20]
    Fowler's Modern English Usage, Fourth Edition - WorldWideWords.org
    Apr 25, 2015 · Jeremy Butterfield, Fowler's Dictionary of Modern English Usage, Fourth Edition, published March 2015 (UK and Australia), April 2015 (Canada), June 2015 (US)
  21. [21]
    Fowler's Dictionary of Modern English Usage - Jeremy Butterfield
    Free delivery 25-day returnsFowler's Dictionary of Modern English Usage is the world-famous guide to English usage, loved and used by writers, editors, and anyone who values correct ...
  22. [22]
    Pocket Fowler's Modern English Usage (Oxford Quick Reference)
    30-day returnsThis invaluable reference work offers the best advice on English usage, drawing on the unrivalled resources of Oxford's English Dictionaries program and ...
  23. [23]
    Review: A Dictionary of Modern English Usage, by H.W. Fowler
    Mar 26, 2010 · Review: A Dictionary of Modern English Usage, by H.W. Fowler ... When he ransacked Henry Watson Fowler's guide to English usage in ...
  24. [24]
    Putting Fowler Back in Fowler's - Hoover Institution
    Liam Julian on A Dictionary of Modern English Usage by H.W. Fowler and edited by David Crystal. ... The author of Modern English Usage, Henry Watson Fowler ...
  25. [25]
    A Dictionary of Modern English Usage: The Classic First Edition
    30-day returns" -- New York Times Book Review. "Readers will find themselves flipping pages, gaining knowledge, and discovering a new appreciation for the English language.Missing: Literary | Show results with:Literary
  26. [26]
    100 Best Non-Fiction Books of the 20th Century (and Beyond) in ...
    Apr 4, 2014 · Henry Watson Fowler: A Dictionary of Modern English Usage. Roger Fry: Cezanne: A Study of His Development. Northrop Frye: An Anatomy of ...
  27. [27]
    Burchfield on Usage: Remaking Fowler's Classic - jstor
    A Dictionary of Modern English Usage. By H. W. Fowler. 2nd ed. New. York: Oxford UP. Lehmann-Haupt, Christopher. 1996. "To Praise Fowler and to Bury Him.
  28. [28]
    [PDF] The Oxford Guide to Style
    ... Fowler's Modern English Usage, 3rd edn. (Oxford: OUR. 1998). Judith Butcher, Copy-Editing: The Cambridge Handbook for Editors, Authors and.
  29. [29]
    [PDF] Rhetoric in Garner's and Fowler's Usage Manuals - Schwa
    In this paper I will compare Bryan Garner's 2009 Garner's Modern Ameri- can Usage with Fowler's 1926 A Dictionary of Modern English Usage to analyze their ...
  30. [30]
    A Q&A with Bryan Garner, "the least stuffy grammarian around"
    Jan 27, 2023 · Some people ask why we need a new edition of Garner's Modern English Usage after only six years. “People who say they're sticking to the ...
  31. [31]
    Fowler's Dictionary of Modern English Usage - Amazon.com
    Fowler's Dictionary of Modern English Usage is the world-famous guide to English usage, loved and used by writers, editors, and anyone who values correct ...Missing: digital | Show results with:digital
  32. [32]
    Possessives and Attributives - The Chicago Manual of Style
    The double genitive (or double possessive) has long been correct. Even the old Fowler's Modern English Usage included it among the “sturdy indefensibles.”