A Perfect Contradiction
A Perfect Contradiction is the third studio album by English singer-songwriter Paloma Faith, released on 10 March 2014 by RCA Records.[1] The album marks a continuation of Faith's retro-inspired sound, blending pop, soul, R&B, and Motown influences across its 11 tracks, with production contributions from notable figures including Pharrell Williams, who co-wrote and produced the lead single "Can't Rely on You."[2][3] It explores themes of love, heartbreak, and personal contradiction through Faith's distinctive, theatrical vocals, often drawing comparisons to classic divas like Amy Winehouse and Adele.[2] Commercially, A Perfect Contradiction achieved significant success in the UK, debuting and peaking at number 2 on the Official Albums Chart and remaining on the chart for 85 weeks.[4] The record spawned multiple singles, including "Can't Rely on You," which reached number 10 on the UK Singles Chart, and "Only Love Can Hurt Like This," penned by Diane Warren, which climbed to number 6 and became one of Faith's biggest hits.[4] Additional singles such as "Mouth to Mouth" further supported promotion, contributing to the album's total sales exceeding 600,000 copies in the UK alone and earning 3× Platinum certification from the BPI.[4][5] Critically, the album received generally positive to mixed reviews, with praise for Faith's charismatic delivery and the album's polished production, though some critics described it as formulaic retro-soul lacking innovation.[2] Aggregated scores placed it around 60-70 out of 100 on review platforms, highlighting standout tracks like the Pharrell collaboration and the emotional ballad "Only Love Can Hurt Like This."[6] An expanded edition, A Perfect Contradiction (Outsiders' Edition), followed later in 2014, adding covers and remixes to extend its appeal.[7]Background and development
Announcement
On January 22, 2014, Paloma Faith's management unveiled the title and artwork for her third studio album, A Perfect Contradiction, via an official press release. The artwork depicts Faith portrayed as multiple characters cradling a nude figure of herself wrapped in a white sheet, emphasizing themes of self-reflection and multiplicity.[8][9] The album was announced for release on March 10, 2014, through RCA Records, following her 2012 double-platinum album Fall to Grace. It features collaborations with producers and songwriters including Pharrell Williams, Diane Warren, Plan B, John Legend, Raphael Saadiq, and Sade's guitarist Stuart Matthewman. Faith described the record as a shift from the introspective tone of her prior work, stating, "Its tone is the very opposite of what the last album was… much more a ‘if it’s all gone to shit, fuck it, let’s have a dance’ kind of record."[9][10] The lead single, "Can't Rely on You"—produced by Pharrell Williams—was confirmed for release on February 23, 2014, ahead of the album. This announcement coincided with early promotion, including tour date reveals and pre-order availability, building anticipation for the project's blend of retro soul, pop, and dance elements.[9][10]Recording process
Recording for A Perfect Contradiction began in 2012 and continued through 2014, with Paloma Faith writing much of the material while living in New York City.[9] She aimed to shift from the melancholic tone of her previous album Fall to Grace (2012), drawing on her soul roots to create more upbeat and hopeful tracks that explored love's contradictions without descending into sadness.[11] Sessions took place across multiple locations, including New York, Miami, Los Angeles, and London, allowing Faith to escape the constant public scrutiny in the UK and focus on personal themes.[9][11] Faith collaborated with a diverse array of producers and songwriters to blend vintage soul influences with modern pop elements, incorporating live band instrumentation, girl-group style harmonies, and danceable rhythms.[12] Key contributors included Pharrell Williams, who co-wrote and produced the lead single "Can't Rely on You" during a session where he emphasized embracing life's contradictions—a concept that inspired the album's title.[9][11] Raphael Saadiq handled production on tracks like "Mouth to Mouth" and co-produced "Love Only Leaves You Lonely" with Dylan.[9] Plan B contributed to "The Other Woman," while Diane Warren penned "Only Love Can Hurt Like This," and additional involvement came from John Legend and Stewart Matthewman.[9] Faith described the process as liberating, particularly working with selective and hardworking talents like Williams, who discarded imperfect ideas to ensure quality.[11] The album's sound was shaped by Faith's desire for organic, energetic recordings that reflected real emotional vulnerability, influenced by the Great American Songbook and her experiences in a stable relationship at the time.[12] This approach resulted in a cohesive collection that balanced retro stylings with contemporary production, completed just before the album's release on 10 March 2014.[12]Composition
Musical style
A Perfect Contradiction is characterized by a retro-soul sound that draws heavily from 1960s and 1970s influences, blending Motown, doo-wop, and Northern Soul elements with modern pop production.[2] The album features prominent horns, wailing vocals, and lovesick slow jams, creating a nostalgic yet contemporary atmosphere that echoes the style of Amy Winehouse's B-sides in tracks like "Only Love Can Hurt Like This" and "Taste My Own Tears."[2] This retro-soul routine is consistent throughout, with Pharrell Williams' minimal production adding a sleek, funky edge to songs such as "Can’t Rely on You," which samples Northern Soul classics and evokes his work on "Blurred Lines."[13] The album also incorporates jazz and orchestral elements, infusing pop ballads with funky eccentricity and theatrical flair. For instance, "Trouble With My Baby" combines pulsating beats and live-recorded improvisation with a British-accented spoken interlude, delivering a danceable, soul-infused track that highlights Faith's textured, throaty voice.[14] Influences from Otis Redding appear in soulful cuts like "Take Me," while 1980s Michael Jackson-inspired synths drive the upbeat "Mouth to Mouth," merging retro dancehall vibes with clubby pop.[13] Overall, the sound reinvents old-school jazzy soul through nostalgic 1960s/70s beats paired with modern synths, resulting in a versatile mix that transcends strict genre boundaries.[14]Songs
A Perfect Contradiction features 11 tracks on its standard edition, drawing from 1950s doo-wop, 1960s Motown, and 1970s disco and funk sounds to explore the dualities of love, heartbreak, and empowerment.[15] The album opens with the upbeat, Pharrell Williams-produced Can't Rely on You, a confident breakup anthem co-written by Williams that sets a sassy tone with its funky bassline and Faith's bold vocals, marking the first collaboration between the two artists after an impromptu studio session.[12][1] Mouth to Mouth, produced by Raphael Saadiq and co-written by Faith, Saadiq, and Taura Stinson, channels 1980s Michael Jackson-inspired pop with a soulful edge, evolving into a Northern Soul-infused track that highlights Faith's throaty delivery on themes of romantic desperation and revival.[1][13] Take Me, helmed by producer Mr. Hudson and co-authored by Faith, Hudson, and John Legend (as John Stephens), adopts a lighter, playful vibe with horn arrangements, addressing impulsive desire in a relationship.[1] The standout power ballad Only Love Can Hurt Like This, penned by Diane Warren and produced by AC Burrell, became one of the album's biggest hits, with Faith's stratospheric vocals conveying raw emotional vulnerability over swelling strings and piano, drawing comparisons to classic torch songs.[12][2] Other Woman, produced by Plan B (Ben Drew) and co-written by Faith, Drew, and others, shifts to a gritty, bluesy narrative of infidelity, featuring tense guitar riffs and dramatic orchestration that underscore jealousy and betrayal.[1] Taste My Own Tears, a collaboration between Faith and Stuart Matthewman with production by AC Burrell and G'harah "The Soulchild" Degeddingseze, delivers a mid-tempo soul track reflecting on self-inflicted emotional pain, bolstered by smooth horns and introspective lyrics.[1] Trouble with My Baby, co-written by Faith, Steve Robson, and Andrea Martin, is a Motown-esque plea for understanding in a turbulent romance, characterized by its catchy chorus and live-feel rhythm section that evokes 1960s girl-group energy.[1] The Bigger You Love (The Harder You Fall), produced by Dylan Wiggins, amplifies the album's retro funk with its driving beat and Faith's powerful, textured performance, exploring the intensity of deep emotional investment.[2] Impossible Heart, co-written by Faith and Christopher Braide and produced by Braide, offers a piano-driven confessional about unattainable love, blending vulnerability with orchestral swells.[1] Closing the album, Love Only Leaves You Lonely, co-written by Faith, Saadiq, Stinson, and Wiggins and produced by Saadiq and Wiggins, is a melancholic soul ballad that meditates on the solitude following romance, featuring layered harmonies and subtle disco undertones. It's the Not Knowing, co-written by Faith and Matthewman and produced by Dave Okumu, provides a haunting finale with its minimalist arrangement and lyrics delving into the anxiety of uncertainty in love, emphasizing emotional ambiguity.[1]Promotion
Singles
The lead single from A Perfect Contradiction, "Can't Rely on You", was released on 23 February 2014. Co-written and produced by Pharrell Williams, the track features a funk-inspired sound with retro elements, marking Faith's first collaboration with the producer. It debuted and peaked at number 10 on the UK Singles Chart, spending 16 weeks in the top 100. The song received positive reviews for its upbeat energy and Faith's vocal delivery, contributing to the album's pre-release buzz.[4] "Only Love Can Hurt Like This" followed as the second single on 11 May 2014, written by Diane Warren and produced by Steve Mac. The ballad explores themes of painful love, blending soulful vocals with orchestral arrangements. It became Faith's highest-charting solo single to date, peaking at number 6 on the UK Singles Chart and spending 52 weeks there; it also topped the Australian ARIA Singles Chart and reached number 3 in New Zealand. Critics praised its emotional depth and radio-friendly appeal, with some comparing it to classic Motown ballads.[16] The third single, "Trouble with My Baby", was issued on 11 August 2014, co-written by Faith, Ross Orton, and Todd Terry, and produced by Orton. Drawing on 1960s soul influences with a modern electronic twist, the song addresses relationship frustrations. It peaked at number 68 on the UK Singles Chart. Reception highlighted its catchy rhythm and live performance potential, though it underperformed commercially compared to prior releases.[4] "Ready for the Good Life" served as the fourth single on 7 November 2014, written by Faith, Ian Barter, and others, with production by Jim Jonsin. The upbeat track promotes self-empowerment and optimism, fitting the album's theme of contradictions. It peaked at number 50 on the UK Singles Chart but had limited chart longevity. Reviewers noted its anthemic quality, suitable for live shows.[4] An expanded edition of the album in 2014 included additional singles like "Leave While I'm Not Looking", a Diane Warren-penned ballad released as a promotional single on 8 December 2014, which did not chart but was well-received for its dramatic orchestration. These releases helped sustain the album's momentum into 2015, with overall single sales contributing to A Perfect Contradiction's certification as double platinum in the UK.[4]Tour
To promote A Perfect Contradiction, Paloma Faith launched her third headlining concert tour, simply titled the Paloma Faith Tour (also referred to as the A Perfect Contradiction Tour), beginning on 23 May 2014 in Europe. The tour featured a mix of theatre and arena venues, emphasizing the album's retro soul and motown influences through elaborate staging with big band arrangements and theatrical elements. Initial dates focused on the UK and Europe, with Faith performing tracks from the new album alongside hits from her previous releases, Do You Want the Truth or Something Beautiful? (2010) and Fall to Grace (2012).[17] In March 2014, Faith announced an initial 19-date UK leg for October and November 2014, starting at Sheffield City Hall on 28 October and concluding at London's Eventim Apollo on 25 November, which sold out completely before the album's release. This was followed by a fall 2014 US headline tour announced in September, comprising 10 intimate club and theatre shows from 7 October in Boston at the Paradise Rock Club to 25 October in Los Angeles at the El Rey Theatre, supporting the album's North American rollout. An expanded UK arena tour was revealed in September 2014, running from 14 March 2015 at Newcastle's Metro Radio Arena to 25 March at London's O2 Arena, covering 10 dates including stops in Cardiff, Birmingham, Manchester, and Liverpool; this leg upgraded to larger venues to reflect the album's commercial success, with tickets going on sale immediately. European dates were interspersed throughout 2014, including shows in Germany, the Netherlands, and Ireland.[18][19][20][21] The setlist typically opened with "Can't Rely on You" from A Perfect Contradiction, blending upbeat soul numbers like "Only Love Can Hurt Like This" and "Upside Down" with ballads such as "Picking Up the Pieces" and earlier hits including "Just Be" and "Black & Blue." Faith's performances were characterized by her dynamic stage presence, costume changes inspired by 1960s glamour, and audience interaction, often incorporating storytelling between songs to highlight themes of love and contradiction from the album. Support acts varied by leg, including UK singer-songwriter Foxes on select UK dates and American artist Lianne La Havas opening some US shows.[17][22] Critical reception praised the tour's energetic execution and Faith's vocal range, with reviewers noting the seamless integration of the new material's Motown revival sound into live arrangements. A November 2014 review of her Hammersmith Apollo show highlighted her "incredibly sincere" delivery and strong band chemistry, describing the performance as a "phenomenal" blend of hip-shaking soul and theatrical flair that engaged both longtime fans and newcomers. Similarly, a US review from October 2014 at Seattle's Crocodile venue lauded the intimate setting as transporting audiences to a "1961 dinner club," emphasizing Faith's full-bodied vocals and captivating stage persona. The tour's success contributed to the album's momentum, helping it achieve platinum status in the UK.[23][24][25]Repackaged edition
Additional content
The Outsiders' Edition of A Perfect Contradiction, released in November 2014, incorporates four tracks absent from the original March 2014 album, expanding its exploration of soul-infused pop with themes of resilience, love, and transformation. These additions include three newly recorded songs—"Beauty Remains", "Ready for the Good Life", and "Leave While I'm Not Looking"—alongside a rearranged solo version of "Changing", originally a 2013 collaboration with drum and bass duo Sigma.[26][27] "Beauty Remains", co-written by Paloma Faith, Fyfe Dangerfield, and Bernard Butler with production by Bernard Butler, serves as an uplifting ballad emphasizing enduring beauty amid hardship, and was issued as the edition's third single on 29 March 2015.[28] "Ready for the Good Life", released on 7 November 2014 as the lead single from the repackaged album, features an optimistic funk-soul vibe co-written by Faith, Klas Åhlund, Adam Baptiste, Måns Wredenberg, and Linus Wiklund with production by Åhlund, peaking at number 68 on the UK Singles Chart.[29][30] "Leave While I'm Not Looking", written by Diane Warren with production by Komi, JL, and Burrell, delivers a dramatic orchestral pop narrative on heartbreak and preemptive farewell, released as a promotional single from the edition on 8 December 2014 that did not chart.[31] The inclusion of these tracks, alongside the reimagined "Changing"—a piano-led rendition stripping back the electronic elements of its prior incarnation—allowed Faith to revisit personal motifs while aligning with the album's core Motown and retro influences. This repackaging not only refreshed the project amid ongoing promotion but also highlighted Faith's songwriting evolution, with the new material receiving airplay on BBC Radio 2 and integration into her live performances during the 2015 tour.[26]Release details
The repackaged edition of A Perfect Contradiction, subtitled Outsiders' Edition, was released on 10 November 2014 in the United Kingdom. Issued by RCA Records, a division of Sony Music Entertainment, it was distributed in multiple formats including a standard single-disc CD (catalogue number 88843 09537 2) and a deluxe two-disc edition (catalogue number 88843 09538 2) featuring a slipcase. The deluxe version included the original album tracks plus nine live recordings from Paloma Faith's performance at the BBC Proms 2014. Digital download and streaming versions of the expanded edition, comprising 24 tracks, were made available through platforms such as iTunes and Apple Music.[26][32][7]Reception
Critical reception
Upon its release, A Perfect Contradiction received generally favourable reviews from critics, earning a Metascore of 66 out of 100 on Metacritic based on 10 reviews, indicating generally favorable approval.[6] Reviewers frequently praised Faith's powerful, distinctive vocals and the album's energetic blend of retro soul, R&B, and disco influences, drawing from 1960s and 1970s aesthetics.[2][33] The album's production, featuring collaborations with artists like Pharrell Williams, John Legend, and Raphael Saadiq, was highlighted for its polished and upbeat execution, with tracks like "Only Love Can Hurt Like This" and "Can't Rely on You" noted as standouts for their catchy hooks and danceable grooves.[33][13] Critics appreciated Faith's ability to infuse modern pop sensibilities into vintage sounds, creating an exuberant and vibrant listening experience that showcased her maturation as a performer.[34] However, some reviewers found the retro formulaic and lacking innovation, with repetitive Motown-inspired elements and horns becoming grating over the course of the record.[2][35] Despite these criticisms, the album's consistency and Faith's charismatic delivery were seen as strengths, positioning it as a solid follow-up to her previous work, though not a groundbreaking evolution.[33] Lower scores, such as Drowned in Sound's 4/10, emphasized its familiarity bordering on flavourlessness, while more positive takes like Q Magazine's 80/100 lauded its disco-diva persona and vocal prowess.[35][6] Overall, the reception underscored Faith's reliability as a retro-pop artist capable of delivering enjoyable, if conventional, soul-infused pop.[34]Commercial performance
A Perfect Contradiction debuted at number two on the UK Albums Chart upon its release on 10 March 2014, marking Paloma Faith's highest charting album at the time and held by her previous release Fall to Grace which also peaked at number two.[4] The album remained on the chart for 85 weeks, demonstrating sustained popularity driven by successive single releases.[4] It was certified double platinum by the British Phonographic Industry (BPI) on 20 February 2015 for shipments exceeding 600,000 units in the UK, with total sales surpassing 635,000 copies; it became Faith's best-selling album and the sixth highest-selling album of 2014 overall, as well as the top-selling album by a female artist that year.[36] Following Faith's win for British Female Solo Artist at the 2015 BRIT Awards, album sales surged by 130 percent in the subsequent tracking week.[37] Internationally, the album achieved notable success, particularly in Australia where it peaked at number four on the ARIA Albums Chart after climbing from number 15, boosted by the number-one single "Only Love Can Hurt Like This," and spent 22 weeks in the top 50.[38] It ranked at number 29 on the ARIA year-end albums chart for 2014 with over 35,000 copies sold.[39] In New Zealand, A Perfect Contradiction reached number nine on the Top 40 Albums Chart and placed at number 48 on the year-end chart.[40] The album also entered the top ten in Ireland at number eight and charted in other European territories including the Netherlands (number 41) and Switzerland (number 91), reflecting its broader appeal beyond the UK market.[41]Credits
Track listing
The standard edition of A Perfect Contradiction consists of 11 tracks, blending soul, pop, and R&B influences.[42]| No. | Title | Writer(s) | Length |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1. | "Can't Rely on You" | Pharrell Williams, Paloma Faith | 3:15 |
| 2. | "Mouth to Mouth" | Paloma Faith, Raphael Saadiq, Taura Stinson | 4:24 |
| 3. | "Take Me" | Paloma Faith, Mr. Hudson, John Stephens | 3:10 |
| 4. | "Only Love Can Hurt Like This" | Diane Warren, Paloma Faith | 3:53 |
| 5. | "Other Woman" | Paloma Faith, Ben Drew, Eric Appapoulay, Kieron McIntosh | 3:09 |
| 6. | "Taste My Own Tears" | Paloma Faith, Stuart Matthewman | 3:03 |
| 7. | "Trouble with My Baby" | Paloma Faith, Steve Robson, Andrea Martin | 3:00 |
| 8. | "The Bigger You Love (The Harder You Fall)" | Paloma Faith, Taura Stinson | 3:02 |
| 9. | "Impossible Heart" | Paloma Faith, Christopher Braide | 4:32 |
| 10. | "Love Only Leaves You Lonely" | Paloma Faith, Raphael Saadiq, Taura Stinson | 4:33 |
| 11. | "It's the Not Knowing" | Paloma Faith, Stuart Matthewman | 3:30 |
Lead Artist and Vocals
Paloma Faith performed lead vocals on all tracks of A Perfect Contradiction.[43]Producers
The album features production contributions from several key figures, including:- Pharrell Williams (tracks 1, 12)
- Raphael Saadiq (tracks 2, 10)
- Mr. Hudson (track 3)
- AC Burrell (tracks 2–6, 8, 9)
- G'harah Degeddingseze (tracks 2–6, 8, 9)
- Plan B (track 5)
- Dylan (tracks 8, 10)
- Christopher Braide (track 9)
- Dave Okumu (track 11)
- Stuart Matthewman (track 15)
Musicians and Instrumentation
Notable musicians include:- Seye Adelekan – guitar (tracks 2, 3)
- Steve Payne – guitar (track 6)
- Luke Potashnick – guitar (track 7)
- Tom Wright Goss – guitar (track 5)
- Rory More – Hammond organ (track 3)
- Kieron McIntosh – keyboards, organ, trumpet (track 5)
- Eric Appapoulay – drums, Hammond organ (track 5)
- Joy Joseph – percussion (track 3)
- Dylan – additional keyboards (track 2); all instruments (tracks 8, 10)
- Dave Okumu – all instruments (track 11)
- Stuart Matthewman – all instruments (track 15)
- Rob Mathes – organ (track 15)
- James Gardiner-Bateman – alto and baritone saxophone (tracks 3, 8)
- Trevor Mires – trombone (tracks 3, 8)
- Tom Rees-Roberts – flugelhorn, trumpet (tracks 3, 8)
- Cochemea Gastelum – baritone saxophone (track 7)
- Neal Sugarman – tenor saxophone (track 7)
- Dave Guy – trumpet (track 7)
Backing Vocals
Backing vocals were provided by:- Taura Stinson (tracks 2, 8, 10)
- Joi Gilliam (tracks 2, 10)
- Paloma Faith (track 8)
- Obenewa Aboah (track 5)
- Ben Drew (track 5)
- Andrea Martin (track 7)
Engineering and Mixing
Engineering credits include:- Andrew Coleman (track 1)
- Tom Hough (tracks 3, 9, 11)
- Mario Luccy (track 4)
- Sam Miller (track 7)
- Alalal (track 5)
- Mike Horner – assistant engineer (track 5)
- Gabriel Roth – horns recorded (track 7)
- Simon Guzmán, Wayne Gordon – horns assistant recorded (track 7)
- Justin Merrill (general assistant)
- Chris Galland – assistant (general)
- Manny Marroquin (tracks 2–6, 8, 10)
- Mike Larson (track 1)
- Dan Parry (tracks 7, 9, 11)
- Simon Gogerly (track 15)
Other Technical Roles
- A&R: Colin Barlow, Joe Iddison
- Mastered by: John Davis
- Photography: David Standish