Fact-checked by Grok 2 weeks ago

Adwaita

Adwaita was a male Aldabra giant tortoise (Aldabrachelys gigantea) that resided at the Alipore Zoological Gardens in Kolkata, India, and is estimated to have lived for approximately 255 years, from around 1750 until his death on March 22, 2006.^[1]^[2] Regarded as one of the oldest known living creatures at the time of his passing, Adwaita—whose name means "the one and only" in Sanskrit—gained international attention for his extraordinary longevity and historical associations.^[3]^[1] Adwaita's life spanned significant historical periods, with legends linking him to Robert Clive, the 18th-century British colonial administrator known as "Clive of India," who reportedly kept the tortoise as a pet before it was donated to what would become the Alipore Zoo.^[1]^[4] Zoo records indicate that Adwaita was officially acquired by the Alipore Zoological Gardens in 1875, though his earlier origins remain a matter of folklore and estimation rather than definitive proof.^[2] He was believed to have been older than other notable long-lived animals and became a symbol of resilience, surviving through the British Raj, Indian independence, and into the modern era.^[5] The tortoise's death was attributed to natural causes related to old age, including a cracked shell and a wound that keepers were unable to treat effectively.^[2]^[1] While his exact age has been debated—some experts question the precision of 18th-century records—Adwaita's story underscores the remarkable lifespan potential of Aldabra giant tortoises, which can exceed 150–200 years in the wild or captivity under ideal conditions.^[5] His legacy endures in zoological history as a testament to conservation efforts and the enduring fascination with animal longevity.

Background and Origin

Acquisition by the Zoo

Adwaita, a male Aldabra giant tortoise, was acquired by the Alipore Zoological Gardens in the early 1870s through a transfer facilitated by British colonial networks.^[6] According to tradition, it was originally gifted to Robert Clive, the British administrator known as "Clive of India," by seafarers who had captured it from the Seychelles Islands, and Adwaita reportedly resided at Clive's villa in Barrackpore for over a century after Clive's death in 1774.^[6] In 1875, Carl Louis Schwendler, a German engineer and the key initiator of the zoo's establishment, arranged for Adwaita's move to the new institution as part of its founding collection, drawn from private menageries and colonial donations.^[6]^[7] The acquisition occurred around 1875, as documented in zoo records, shortly before the official opening of the Alipore Zoological Gardens on January 1, 1876, under British patronage.^[6] The Alipore Zoo's formation exemplified colonial-era animal collection practices, where British officials amassed exotic species from imperial territories to curate public displays that underscored scientific exploration and administrative prestige. Schwendler's private menagerie, supplemented by gifts like Adwaita from estates of figures such as Clive, formed the core of the zoo's early stock, integrating animals sourced from Africa, Europe, and Asia to educate and entertain colonial audiences.^[7]^[8] This approach not only stocked the zoo with diverse fauna but also embedded it within broader imperial efforts to catalog and control nature across the empire.^[8]

Species Characteristics

The Aldabra giant tortoise (Aldabrachelys gigantea) is the second-largest tortoise species in the world, surpassed only by certain Galápagos giant tortoises, and is endemic to the Aldabra Atoll in the Seychelles archipelago of the Indian Ocean.^[9] This species thrives in diverse island habitats, including scrub forests, grasslands, mangrove swamps, and coastal dunes, where its robust build supports a lifestyle adapted to sparse vegetation and seasonal water scarcity.^[10] Physically, adults exhibit a high, domed carapace that measures up to 1.2 meters in length and weighs over 250 kilograms, with males typically larger than females at up to 550 pounds compared to 350 pounds.^[10] The shell is dark gray to black, providing protection and aiding in thermoregulation through heat absorption in the morning and dissipation midday, while thickly scaled legs and a long neck enable access to low-lying foliage.^[10] A notably slow metabolism underpins their longevity, with individuals potentially living over 150 years, far exceeding most reptiles due to efficient energy use and reduced cellular damage accumulation.^[10] ^[11] Behaviorally, Aldabra giant tortoises are primarily herbivorous, grazing on grasses, sedges, leaves, and occasionally browsing woody plants or even scavenging opportunistically, which aids in seed dispersal across their island ecosystem.^[10] They display a largely solitary nature, with individuals ranging from sedentary to covering over 7 kilometers in search of food, though minimal aggression occurs except during breeding competitions among males.^[12] A critical adaptation for arid island survival is their ability to store large volumes of water in the bladder after copious drinking bouts before dry seasons, sustaining them for months without further intake.^[13] Evolutionarily, these tortoises embody K-selected traits suited to stable but isolated island environments, featuring low reproductive rates with sexual maturity delayed until 20–30 years of age and seasonal breeding cycles yielding few offspring per event.^[12] Females lay 9–25 eggs in clutches 1–2 times annually during the wet season, but high juvenile mortality ensures only about 20% reach adulthood, balancing population stability in resource-limited habitats.^[12] This strategy, combined with behavioral thermoregulation—such as basking or seeking shade to maintain core body temperatures around 30°C—enhances resilience to environmental fluctuations on Aldabra.^[11]

Life in Captivity

Habitat and Daily Routine

Adwaita inhabited a spacious outdoor enclosure at the Alipore Zoological Gardens in Kolkata, designed to mimic the tortoise's native island environment of grasses, shrubs, and coastal areas.^[14] This setup allowed for essential thermoregulation. Throughout his over 130 years at the zoo, Adwaita's daily routine followed the typical patterns of Aldabra giant tortoises, who are diurnal and most active during cooler morning and evening hours to avoid midday heat.^[15] He spent time basking in sunlight for thermoregulation—a critical need for the species to maintain body temperature in their tropical origins—before slowly patrolling the enclosure with deliberate movements.^[15] Aldabra giant tortoises tend to forage and rest individually rather than in groups, and captive individuals often pace along enclosure boundaries, a common territorial behavior that helps them map their space.^[16] Interactions with zookeepers were minimal and gentle, often involving routine checks that respected his unhurried pace. The urban zoo environment in Kolkata presented adaptations to the city's tropical climate, characterized by hot summers, heavy monsoons, and mild winters, where Adwaita would increase activity during wet seasons while retreating to shaded spots or withdrawing into his shell during extreme heat or cooler periods.^[14] Enclosure barriers ensured protection from visitor disturbances, allowing him to maintain a low-stress routine amid the bustling metropolitan setting.

Diet and Health Management

Adwaita's primary diet at the Alipore Zoological Gardens consisted of a variety of plant-based foods suited to the herbivorous nature of Aldabra giant tortoises, including wheat bran, carrots, lettuce, soaked gram (chickpeas), bread, grass, and salt. This regimen provided essential fiber and nutrients to support his longevity, with portions adjusted as needed for his advanced age to maintain digestive health and overall vitality.^[17] Health management for Adwaita involved vigilant monitoring by zoo staff and veterinarians, focusing on common age-related concerns in giant tortoises such as mobility limitations and susceptibility to infections. In 1998, approximately eight years before his death, Adwaita developed a leg infection that impaired his movement; a full medical board was promptly convened to administer treatment, demonstrating the zoo's commitment to proactive geriatric care.^[1] Later interventions addressed emerging issues with shell integrity, a critical aspect of tortoise health. In late 2005, Adwaita's shell cracked, resulting in an underlying wound that became infected despite targeted veterinary efforts to treat it. This complication, combined with liver failure, ultimately proved fatal, highlighting the challenges of managing advanced age in reptiles under captive conditions.^[1]^[17]

Age and Longevity

Methods of Age Estimation

The primary method for estimating Adwaita's age relied on historical records from the Alipore Zoological Gardens, where the tortoise was acquired in 1875 from the estate of a British official. These records indicated that Adwaita was already mature upon arrival, suggesting an age of at least 100 years at that time, based on the tortoise's documented transfer from a collection originally associated with the British East India Company.^[2] Cross-referencing these zoo logs with British East India Company archives pointed to a hatch year around 1750, as Adwaita was believed to be one of four Aldabra giant tortoises gifted to Robert Clive, the company's governor, in the mid-18th century during his tenure in India (1750s–1770s). This timeline was supported by consistent historical accounts of the tortoises being imported from the Seychelles islands by British sailors, with Adwaita surviving longer than its companions.^[1]^[2] Physical assessments supplemented these records, including analysis of shell growth rings, known as annuli, on the scutes of the carapace. However, this technique is limited for long-lived species like Aldabra tortoises due to their indeterminate growth pattern, where shell expansion continues slowly throughout life, causing rings to blur and become indistinguishable after approximately 10–15 years. In the early 2000s, herpetologists consulted by zoo officials used size-weight correlations specific to Aldabra tortoises to refine the estimate, comparing Adwaita's dimensions—approximately 1.1 meters in carapace length and over 200 kilograms in weight—to growth data from wild and captive populations, which indicated maturity beyond 150 years. These correlations, derived from longitudinal studies, account for slower growth rates in adulthood but provide only approximate ages for individuals over a century old.^[18] Precise dating faced challenges due to the absence of banding or tagging at the time of Adwaita's capture in the wild, a common practice only implemented for Aldabra tortoises in the 20th century, leaving no direct markers for tracking individual growth from origin. This reliance on indirect historical and morphological evidence underscores the difficulties in verifying extreme longevity in chelonians.^[1] Such estimates align with documented lifespans of other Aldabra tortoises, which typically exceed 150 years in protected environments.^[19]

Verification and Controversies

In 2006, officials at the Alipore Zoological Gardens in Kolkata claimed that Adwaita had reached an age of approximately 255 years at the time of his death, basing this estimate on historical records indicating the tortoise was brought from the Seychelles by British colonial officer Robert Clive around 1750.^[1] These records, preserved by the zoo since Adwaita's arrival in 1875, suggested he was already mature upon acquisition, but their origins in 18th-century colonial documentation remain unverified and potentially incomplete.^[2] The claim quickly drew skepticism from herpetologists and conservation experts, who highlighted the challenges of relying on anecdotal historical accounts for species like Aldabra giant tortoises, where precise birth records are rare due to their wild origins and long lifespans. Experts have emphasized that without direct evidence like growth ring analysis or genetic markers, such extreme age estimates risk overstatement, potentially inflating perceptions of tortoise longevity beyond documented cases.^[20] To address the doubts, zoo authorities proposed radiocarbon dating of a shell sample shortly after Adwaita's death, aiming to establish a more scientific basis for the age claim; however, this approach was ultimately deemed impractical, as tortoise shells accrete material over decades, yielding ambiguous results that reflect average incorporation rather than the animal's total lifespan. Although carbon dating was proposed in 2006, no results have been published, leaving the 255-year figure unsubstantiated in peer-reviewed literature.^[1] Media reports in the wake of the announcement amplified the debate, with outlets like BBC and CBS initially presenting the story as a record-breaking longevity milestone, only for subsequent coverage to underscore the evidentiary gaps and compare it unfavorably to verified tortoise ages, such as that of Jonathan, whose 190+ years are supported by photographic and archival continuity.^[2] This publicity highlighted broader issues in zoo record-keeping for historic animals, prompting calls for standardized verification protocols in herpetological studies.^[21]

Death and Aftermath

Cause and Circumstances of Death

Adwaita was found dead by zoo keepers on March 22, 2006, at the Alipore Zoological Gardens in Kolkata, India.^[1] The cause of death was liver failure, as reported by Indian authorities.^[22] Several months prior to his passing, Adwaita's shell had cracked, leading to the development of a wound.^[1] In response, zoo officials preserved the tortoise's shell, which measured approximately 13 feet (4.0 m) in circumference, for potential carbon dating to verify his age.^[23] The event was described as an emotional moment for zoo staff, who buried him in the hospital compound.^[23]

Scientific Examination and Legacy

Following Adwaita's death, zoo veterinarians conducted a post-mortem examination, determining the cause as liver failure complicated by an infected wound from a cracked shell that had developed months earlier. This assessment highlighted physical deterioration associated with advanced age in giant tortoises.^[1]^[22] The tortoise, which weighed over 500 pounds (230 kg), had a massive shell measuring approximately 13 feet (4.0 m) in circumference, which was carefully preserved by Alipore Zoo staff for scientific analysis. Officials planned to subject the shell to carbon dating to verify the estimated age of around 255 years, providing potential data on growth rings and environmental history in Aldabra giant tortoises. Although detailed results from this process remain unpublished, the preservation effort underscores efforts to document extreme longevity in reptiles. However, the extraordinary age estimate remains unverified by scientific means, relying instead on historical zoo records.^[23]^[2] Adwaita's lifespan has contributed to herpetological understanding of maximal tortoise longevity, serving as a benchmark case that informs research on reptile senescence and age-related physiological limits.^[20] Within Alipore Zoo's records, Adwaita symbolizes over a century of institutional history, with its preserved shell displayed as a key artifact that highlights the zoo's role in long-term animal husbandry. This legacy continues to draw researchers and visitors, reinforcing Adwaita's status as an emblem of zoological heritage.^[23]

Cultural and Scientific Significance

Role in Conservation Awareness

Adwaita's death in March 2006 garnered significant international media attention, including coverage from outlets like the BBC and CBS News, which highlighted his extraordinary lifespan and origins as an Aldabra giant tortoise. This publicity helped draw global focus to the vulnerabilities of the species, which faces ongoing threats from habitat loss due to agricultural expansion and development, as well as poaching for meat and shells in some regions.^[1]^[2]^[24] The Alipore Zoological Gardens, where Adwaita resided for over a century, leveraged his fame through educational initiatives aimed at raising awareness about tortoise conservation. The zoo's mission emphasizes wildlife preservation and public education, including programs that promote captive breeding for endangered species like the Aldabra giant tortoise, with efforts to obtain new individuals from Seychelles to support such initiatives following Adwaita's passing.^[25]^[6] Adwaita's narrative also underscored the precarious status of giant tortoises, classified as Vulnerable by the IUCN Red List, contributing to broader advocacy for their protection. This visibility has aligned with increased emphasis on safeguarding habitats like the Aldabra Atoll, a UNESCO World Heritage Site, where conservation funding and management by organizations such as the Seychelles Islands Foundation support anti-poaching measures and habitat restoration.^[26] The tortoise's story boosted visitor interest at Alipore Zoo, contributing to record attendance figures, such as over 110,000 visitors on a single day in 2018, as his legacy continues to attract crowds eager to learn about historic and endangered animals.

Comparisons to Other Historic Animals

Adwaita, an Aldabra giant tortoise estimated to have lived approximately 255 years until its death in 2006, stands as one of the most extraordinary cases of longevity among recorded animals, though its age remains unverified due to incomplete historical records.^[27] In comparison, Jonathan, a Seychelles giant tortoise residing on the island of St. Helena, is the oldest known living land animal as of 2025, having hatched around 1832 and thus reaching an estimated age of 193 years.^[28] Unlike Adwaita, whose age estimate relies on anecdotal evidence from its arrival at the Alipore Zoo in Kolkata in the late 19th century, Jonathan's longevity is supported by documented importation records from 1882, when he was already mature, establishing a minimum age with greater certainty.^[29] Historical parallels to Adwaita's claimed lifespan include Tu'i Malila, a radiated tortoise presented to the Tongan royal family by Captain James Cook in 1777, which died in 1965 at a verified age of 188 years, making it the longest-lived tortoise with documented birth records at the time.^[30] Additionally, anecdotal claims from historical Chinese records describe pond turtles and tortoises in imperial gardens exceeding 200 years, such as reports of specimens living over two centuries under protected conditions, though these lack modern verification and are often based on oral traditions rather than precise documentation.^[31] These cases highlight a pattern in tortoise longevity records, where exceptional ages are frequently tied to human intervention, contrasting with shorter wild lifespans limited by environmental threats. A key difference between Adwaita and contemporaries like Jonathan lies in their environments: Adwaita spent its later decades in an urban zoo setting in Kolkata, exposed to controlled but potentially stressful conditions including pollution and limited space, whereas Jonathan inhabits a more naturalistic island habitat on St. Helena with ample vegetation and minimal human disturbance, potentially contributing to his ongoing vitality.^[32] Tu'i Malila, similarly, benefited from royal protection in Tonga, akin to a semi-captivity that shielded it from predators and resource scarcity prevalent in the wild habitats of radiated tortoises in Madagascar.^[27] These comparisons underscore broader challenges in verifying animal ages, particularly between captivity and wild settings; captive animals like Adwaita often outlive wild counterparts due to veterinary care and protection from predation, but age claims suffer from gaps in early records, while wild or semi-wild individuals like Jonathan benefit from stable ecosystems that promote slow metabolism and resilience, though precise tracking remains difficult without human observation.^[33] Adwaita's age controversies, stemming from unconfirmed origins possibly linked to the era of Robert Clive, exemplify how such verification issues persist across historic tortoise records.^[27]

References

[1]
South Asia | 'Clive of India's' tortoise dies - BBC NEWS
Mar 23, 2006 · Adwaita, "the only one" in Bengali, was found dead by keepers in Alipore Zoo on Wednesday. His shell cracked some months ago and a wound had ...
[2]
250-Year-Old Tortoise Dies In India - CBS News
Mar 24, 2006 · "According to records in the zoo, the age of the giant tortoise, Addwaita, who died on Wednesday, would be 250 years approximately," said zoo ...
[3]
Adwaita (1750-2006) - Memorials - Find a Grave
Adwaita (meaning "one and only" in Sanskrit), also spelled Addwaita, was a male Aldabra giant tortoise that lived in the Alipore Zoological Gardens of Kolkata, ...
[4]
Clive and his Pet Tortoise - MANAS - UCLA
Last month, on March 23rd, a male Aldabra Giant Tortoise by the name of “Adwaitya” died at the Alipore zoo in Calcutta. ... The oldest documented living animal is ...
[5]
4 oldest tortoises - Petcover Group
Oct 31, 2019 · Adwaita. Is an Aldabra Giant Tortoise who is believed to have lived for about 250 years until he passed away in 2006. Adwaita spent majority of ...
[6]
13 years later, zoo to get giant tortoises again | Kolkata News
Nov 27, 2012 · Three died and Adwaita was transferred to the Alipore zoo in 1875 by Carl Louis Schwendler, the founder of the zoo. End of Article. FOLLOW US ...
[7]
The Alipore Zoo: A surgeon's vision, an electrician's initiative and a ...
Dec 27, 2023 · While living in Calcutta, Schwendler had built up a small private menagerie as well. In 1873, at a meeting of the Asiatic Society, Schwendler ...
[8]
How Alipore Zoo was born, and how it could have been born earlier!
Aug 10, 2022 · The initial stock of animals came from the private collection of Carl Louis Schwendler, a German electrician working for Indian Railways, and ...
[9]
Zoological Garden - an overview | ScienceDirect Topics
Alipore Zoo was a colonial zoo with American and European animals, as well as animals from other colonial regions. Like all zoos, it kept animals that ...
[10]
Aldabra Tortoise - Chattanooga Zoo
The Aldabra tortoise is the second largest land tortoise, with a long lifespan, found on Aldabra island, and is the only remaining of 18 former species.
[11]
Aldabra tortoise | Smithsonian's National Zoo and Conservation ...
One of the world's largest land tortoises, Aldabra tortoises can reach sizes of up to 550 pounds and ages of up to 150 years old. They are native to Aldabra ...Missing: Aldabrachelys | Show results with:Aldabrachelys
[12]
Patterns of activity and body temperature of Aldabra giant tortoises ...
Here, we describe activity and body temperature fluctuations of Aldabra giant tortoises (Aldabrachelys gigantea Schweigger 1812) in both their natural habitat ...
[13]
The growth, ecology and population structure of giant tortoises on ...
Breeding is seasonal and the males select partners from within a limited size range of tortoises. Most mating attempts are unsuccessful. On Aldabra, tortoises ...
[14]
Island rewilding with giant tortoises in an era of climate change
Oct 22, 2018 · On Aldabra, before the dry season Aldabra giant tortoises drink copiously and can hold water in their bladder for several months; they will only ...Missing: storage | Show results with:storage
[15]
wildlife | Alipore Zoo turns 150: A historical lens on Calcutta's iconic ...
Dec 1, 2024 · Pointing to a swing stand inside their enclosure, the Alipore ... Adwaita. “After he (Adwaita) passed away in 2006, his native country ...<|control11|><|separator|>
[16]
https://tortoisegroup.org/is-your-tortoise-pacing/
[17]
Is Your Tortoise Pacing?
Feb 25, 2017 · They often turn inward, half climbing on the wall and scraping their shells. This is normal behavior for a tortoise, even if it drives you crazy ...Missing: Adwaita Alipore solitude
[18]
Zoological Garden, Alipore, Kolkata - West Bengal Zoo Authority
India's oldest formally stated zoological park and a big tourist attraction in Kolkata, West Bengal. It has been open as a zoo since 1876, and covers 18.811 ha ...Animal Adoption · Zoo Map · Fees & Zoo Hours · About The Zoo
[19]
The Oldest Tortoises In The World / Did You Know?
Adwita, which means 'one and only, or unique,' in Bengali, is thought to be the longest living Aldabra Giant Tortoise ever. He was a male, supposedly born about ...<|control11|><|separator|>
[20]
How to Tell a Turtle's Age – 7 Methods for Estimating Age - All Turtles
Dec 9, 2020 · Much like the rings on a tree trunk, a turtle's shell can show growth rings on each scute (the individual plates that make up the carapace).
[21]
Aldabra tortoise (Aldabrachelys gigantea) longevity, ageing, and life ...
One male specimen called "Adwaita" was reported to have been anywhere between 150 and 255 years of age when he died at Alipore Zoo in Calcutta, India. Allegedly ...
[22]
All but Ageless, Turtles Face Their Biggest Threat: Humans
Dec 12, 2006 · Last March, a giant tortoise named Adwaita said to be as old as 250 years died in a Calcutta zoo, having been taken to India by British sailors, ...
[23]
Top 5 longest living turtles in the world that span centuries
May 23, 2025 · Adwaita, an Aldabra giant tortoise, reportedly lived to be around 255 years old before his death in 2006 at the Alipore Zoo in Kolkata, India.
[24]
Slow going! Tortoise dies after 250 years - NBC News
Mar 23, 2006 · A giant aldabra tortoise thought to be around 250 years old has died in the Kolkata zoo of liver failure, Indian authorities said on Thursday.
[25]
The Sunday Tribune - Spectrum
Apr 2, 2006 · Sunday, April 2, 2006 ... died at the Alipore Zoological Garden in Kolkata on March 22. THE world's oldest living tortoise died in Kolkata on ...
[26]
Giant tortoise genomes provide insights into longevity and age ... - NIH
Giant tortoises are amongst the longest-lived vertebrate animals and as such provide an excellent model to study traits like longevity and age-related ...Missing: Adwaita | Show results with:Adwaita
[27]
Aldabra Tortoise Fact Sheet | Blog | Nature - PBS
Oct 4, 2023 · Aldabra tortoises are listed as “Vulnerable” by the IUCN Red List of Threatened Species. Conservation Efforts: The Aldabra tortoise was one ...Appearance · Geography · Threats
[28]
About The Zoo - Zoological Garden, Alipore, Kolkata
The mission of the Zoological Garden, Alipore is "Conservation of wild animals from India and abroad with special reference to the wet land fauna and education ...Missing: Adwaita programs
[29]
https://www.guinnessworldrecords.com/news/2023/11/worlds-oldest-living-land-animal-jonathan-turns-191-years-old-761854
[30]
8 Oldest Tortoises in the World
Mar 18, 2025 · Adwaita (c.1750 – 2006). Oldest Age Reached: 250 years old. Last Location: Alipore Zoological Gardens in Kolkata, India Species: Aldabra ...
[31]
Jonathan | Oldest Tortoise, History, Life, Fame, Trivia, & Facts
Oct 28, 2025 · Weighing 400 pounds (180 kg), Jonathan is cared for by veterinarian Joe Hollins, who, after arriving on Saint Helena in 2009, found Jonathan in ...
[32]
World's oldest living land animal, Jonathan, turns 191 years old
Nov 30, 2023 · Jonathan, the world's oldest living land animal, is now 191 years old. He is believed to have been born c. 1832, based on the fact that he was fully mature.
[33]
EDGE of Existence — Possibly the most famous radiated tortoise in ...
Jun 23, 2018 · She died in 1965 of natural causes, with her age estimated at 188 years old, making her the longest-lived tortoise whose age has been verified.
[34]
Asia's Turtle Tragedy - National Wildlife Federation
Feb 1, 2006 · They say this Asian icon of longevity, happiness and wisdom, having survived more than 200 million years and outlived the dinosaurs, is being ...
[35]
These Animals Lived Longer In Captivity Than They Ever Could In ...
Colo became a beloved ambassador for her species, helping raise awareness about conservation efforts worldwide. 2. Adwaita The Aldabra Giant Tortoise. Adwaita ...
[36]
How Long Do Tortoises Live? - Britannica
Oct 4, 2025 · Tortoises can live for more than 60 years, some as long as 100–250 years in captivity. However, extreme ages can be hard to verify.Missing: legacy studies