Fact-checked by Grok 2 weeks ago

Anglican Use

The Anglican Use is a liturgical form within the of the that incorporates historic Anglican elements of worship, authorized for communities of former Anglicans entering with the Church while preserving their spiritual and liturgical patrimony. This use allows for the celebration of the sacraments, including the and , drawing from approved texts rooted in the tradition, adapted to conform with Catholic doctrine. Initiated through the Pastoral Provision established by in 1980, the Anglican Use provided a pathway for married Anglican to be ordained as Catholic priests and for personal parishes to employ an Anglican-style , responding to requests from and seeking unity with . This arrangement facilitated over 100 ordinations and the formation of dedicated parishes, utilizing texts like the Book of Divine Worship approved in 2003. The provision's structure emphasized corporate reception while maintaining elements of Anglican heritage as a "precious gift" to the broader Church. The framework expanded significantly with Pope Benedict XVI's 2009 Apostolic Constitution Anglicanorum coetibus, which created —canonical structures akin to dioceses—for Anglican groups transitioning to Catholicism, enabling the retention of liturgical customs alongside observance. The current , Divine Worship: The Missal, promulgated in 2015, standardizes this use across Ordinariates such as the in the United States and in the , blending Cranmerian prose with post-Vatican II reforms. Notable for permitting married under specific conditions, the Anglican Use represents a rare ecumenical accommodation in the , fostering continuity amid doctrinal convergence on issues like papal authority and sacramental theology.

Definition and Canonical Basis

Core Definition

The Anglican Use denotes a liturgical form within the Latin Rite of the that integrates distinctive elements of Anglican worship—such as the poetic cadence, scriptural emphasis, and structural features derived from the —while fully conforming to Catholic sacramental theology and doctrine. This usage enables communities of former Anglicans, upon entering with the , to retain valued aspects of their spiritual patrimony, including traditional English liturgical language and devotional practices, without constituting a separate rite. Initiated through the Pastoral Provision decreed by the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith on June 18, 1980, under , the Anglican Use addressed petitions from married Anglican and seeking Catholic and parish structures that preserved Anglican liturgical heritage. This provision authorized the of such (with exceptions to for those already married) and the approval of a hybrid , initially compiled as the Book of Divine Worship in 1983 by the International Commission on English in the , blending Anglican texts with elements. The framework expanded via the Apostolic Constitution Anglicanorum Coetibus, issued by on November 4, 2009, which erected personal ordinariates—juridically akin to dioceses—for Anglican groups worldwide, granting faculties to celebrate the , sacraments, and using patrimony-specific books alongside the . This patrimony is described as a "precious gift" enriching the universal Church, with ordinariate members maintaining corporate identity through approved liturgical expressions that underscore Catholic orthodoxy.

Canonical Foundations and Structures

The canonical foundations of Anglican Use rest upon the Apostolic Constitution Anglicanorum coetibus, promulgated by on November 4, 2009, which authorizes the establishment of personal ordinariates for groups of Anglicans seeking with the while permitting retention of approved elements from the Anglican liturgical, spiritual, and pastoral patrimony. This constitution serves as the primary juridical instrument, possessing the force of universal ecclesiastical law and drawing authority from the Roman Pontiff's supreme legislative power under Canon 331 of the 1983 Code of Canon Law (CIC). It innovates upon existing canonical models for personal circumscriptions, such as military ordinariates (CIC can. 371 §2), by creating ordinariates tailored to Western Christian traditions outside the Eastern rites. Personal ordinariates are erected by the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith (CDF) within the territory of a bishops' conference, with one or more such entities possible as needed, and each granted public juridic personality akin to a (Article I). Governance follows the , the constitution, and complementary norms approved in forma specifica by the Roman Pontiff, with the CDF exercising oversight (Article II). The —typically a or, if a former Anglican , possibly without episcopal consecration but with equivalent faculties—is appointed by the and holds ordinary, vicarious, and personal power (Articles IV-V), including faculties analogous to those of a under CIC canons 383-398, such as erecting personal parishes (with consent and input from the local ) and admitting married former Anglican clerics to priesthood on a case-by-case basis (Article VI). Structural bodies include a governing of at least six incardinated priests (functioning as presbyteral council and college of consultors per CIC canons 495-502 and 502), a (CIC canons 492-494), and a for advisory input (CIC can. 511; Article X). The collaborates with local diocesan bishops on shared matters like judicial cases (routed to diocesan tribunals unless the ordinariate establishes its own) and priestly formation, which integrates Anglican patrimony with Roman standards under a CDF-approved program (Articles VI, X, XII). Complementary norms, initially issued November 4, 2009, and amended in 2013 (allowing baptized Catholics to join via ordinariate ) and reflected in 2019 revisions, further specify incardination, membership (requiring and initiation rites for ), and the 's episcopal membership (Articles 1-5, 11). These provisions ensure the ordinariate's autonomy in preserving Anglican Use while maintaining unity with the universal Church.

Historical Origins

Precursors in Anglican Schism and Ecumenical Contacts

The Anglican schism originated in 1534 with the Act of Supremacy, by which King Henry VIII declared himself Supreme Head of the , severing ties with papal authority primarily to annul his marriage to , though subsequent reigns under (1547–1553) introduced Protestant reforms that entrenched doctrinal divergences from Catholicism. This break created a persistent tension within between Protestant and Catholic impulses, with the latter manifesting in efforts to reclaim pre-Reformation continuity. Early reversions occurred under Mary I (1553–1558), when some Anglican clergy realigned with , but these were individual or temporary, lacking provisions for corporate retention of Anglican liturgical forms. The 19th-century , initiated in 1833 by figures such as and Edward Pusey, revived Catholic doctrinal and liturgical elements within , fostering as a tradition emphasizing , sacraments, and patristic heritage over Reformation innovations. Some Anglo-Catholics, influenced by Newman's 1845 conversion to Catholicism, pursued corporate reunion with to resolve perceived schismatic incompleteness, viewing as a "via media" potentially reconcilable with the universal . This led to the formation of the Order of Corporate Reunion in 1877 by Anglican clergy, including Frederick George Lee, in collaboration with Old Catholic and sympathetic Roman figures, aimed at secretly conferring valid orders to bolster Anglican claims and facilitate eventual unity while preserving Anglican usages. Such initiatives reflected causal drivers like the 1896 Apostolicae Curae, which invalidated Anglican orders due to defects in form and intention during the Edwardine ordinal revisions, prompting compensatory schemes among reunion advocates. Ecumenical contacts intensified in the early with the Malines Conversations (1921–1927), a series of five private meetings in , , convened by Cardinal Désiré-Joseph Mercier and Anglican layman Lord Halifax, involving theologians like Abbé Fernand Portal and Anglican bishop William Temple. These discussions explicitly explored corporate reunion of the with the , proposing structures that would allow retention of Anglican liturgical patrimony, episcopal governance, and spiritual ethos under , contingent on resolving orders and doctrinal issues. Outcomes included draft proposals for an "Anglican Uniate" model, but progress halted amid Anglican internal divisions and Roman insistence on full submission without conditional autonomy. Later efforts, such as interwar reunion schemes and post-World War II dialogues, similarly stalled due to Anglican innovations like remarriage of divorced persons and, by the 1970s, women's ordination in the (first irregularly in 1974, regularized 1976), alienating Anglo-Catholics who sought Catholic refuge while desiring communal preservation of their heritage. These precursors underscored a recurring pattern: Anglo-Catholic aspirations for unity clashing with institutional barriers, paving the way for ad hoc provisions in the late .

Pastoral Provision of 1980

The Pastoral Provision emerged in response to petitions from groups of and in the United States seeking with the amid deepening doctrinal divisions in the , including the irregular priests beginning in 1976. These petitioners emphasized their desire to retain married and elements of Anglican liturgical patrimony, such as traditional forms of worship derived from the , while submitting to papal authority and Catholic doctrine on issues like the male-only priesthood. On June 18, 1980, the Sacred Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith finalized a decree outlining canonical permissions for ordaining married former Anglican priests as Catholic priests in specific dioceses and for authorizing adapted Anglican liturgical rites, which was approved by on June 20, 1980. The decree was communicated in July 1980 to Archbishop John R. Quinn, president of the United States National Conference of Catholic Bishops, who announced its existence publicly on August 20, 1980, during a bishops' meeting. Under the provision, individual Catholic bishops could petition the to ordain qualified married former priests after a period of and formation, with the condition that such priests would serve in existing dioceses rather than forming separate structures. This exception to the Latin Rite's discipline of was granted pastorally to accommodate converts without altering broader Catholic norms, resulting in the establishment of small Anglican Use communities celebrating a hybrid liturgy blending Anglican phrasing and structure with sacraments. The initial implementation focused on the , where over a dozen such parishes formed by the early , though the provision's scope remained limited and case-by-case.

Establishment of Personal Ordinariates

Apostolic Constitution Anglicanorum Coetibus (2009)

The Apostolic Constitution Anglicanorum Coetibus was promulgated motu proprio by on November 4, 2009, to establish personal ordinariates as a canonical structure enabling groups of Anglicans to enter with the corporately while retaining elements of their liturgical, spiritual, and pastoral tradition approved by the . The document's preamble invokes Christ's prayer for unity (John 17:20-21) and notes repeated petitions from Anglican communities prompted by the , framing the as the fullest expression of ecclesial communion per no. 8, in response to ecumenical dialogues and pastoral realities where Anglican groups sought reunion amid doctrinal tensions in their communion. Article I erects personal ordinariates for the lay faithful, clerics, and religious originally of the Anglican tradition who enter , with membership extending to those receiving sacraments there; these ordinariates hold juridic personality equivalent to a and require adherence to the Catechism of the Catholic Church as the sure norm of faith. Governance follows universal , with ordinariates subject to the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith and detailed in complementary norms approved the same day, allowing liturgical celebrations according to a form of the divine worship drawn from the Anglican patrimony and promulgated by the ordinariate governor with approval, alongside the . The , appointed by the Roman Pontiff from a terna proposed by a governing council of at least six , exercises ordinary, vicarious, and personal power, coordinating with local diocesan s; former Anglican clerics may be accepted as candidates for if fulfilling requirements under canons 1026-1032, with married ministers permitted under specific norms, though remains the norm for future and the must be celibate if ordained . Complementary norms elaborate on formation, requiring ordinariate seminarians to follow a dedicated program preserving Anglican patrimony alongside joint training with diocesan candidates, and mandate councils including a finance body for resource management and pastoral consultation with . Members must submit a written request for incorporation, and the structure permits new institutes of rooted in Anglican origins with consent, personal parishes under the ordinary's purview, and ad limina visits every five years. Judicial matters defer to , with options for ordinariate tribunals.

Creation and Governance of Specific Ordinariates

The of was the first established, erected by decree of the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith on January 15, 2011, for former Anglicans in seeking with the . Its creation followed promptly after the November 2009 issuance of Anglicanorum coetibus, enabling corporate reception of Anglican groups while preserving elements of their liturgical and spiritual patrimony. The ordinariate's initial Ordinary, Keith Newton, a former Anglican , was received into the alongside approximately 60 former Anglican and on that date, with Newton granted episcopal character but not episcopal ordination due to canonical provisions for married . The of the Chair of St. Peter was established on January 1, 2012, extending jurisdiction over the and to accommodate Anglican communities in . Headquartered in , , it was erected by the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith under the same , with initial leadership provided by Jeffrey Steenson, a former Anglican conditionally ordained as a Catholic . This ordinariate incorporated existing Anglican Use parishes formed under the 1980 Pastoral Provision, facilitating a smoother transition for groups from continuing Anglican jurisdictions. The of of the Southern Cross was erected on June 15, 2012, primarily for but with provisions extending to , including communities in . Its decree of erection, signed by the Prefect of the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith, William Cardinal Levada, addressed smaller Anglican groups in the region, with the first Ordinary, Harry Entwistle, a married former Anglican bishop, appointed to lead it. Unlike the others, it has operated with fewer parishes due to the dispersed nature of Anglican converts in , focusing on scattered communities rather than large-scale corporate reunions. Each ordinariate functions as a akin to a , governed by an appointed by the Roman Pontiff, who exercises authority over its , , and institutes of according to the norms of Anglicanorum coetibus and complementary provisions. The , who may be a or a with faculties, incardinates former Anglican ministers—often married—into the ordinariate after their reception into and to Catholic , subject to papal dispensation for married . Ordinariates remain subject to the for the of the for erection and oversight, collaborating with local conferences and diocesan on territorial matters such as facilities, while maintaining in liturgical, , and formative aspects of the Anglican patrimony. Governance emphasizes fidelity to Catholic , with the required to consult the local for ordinations and major decisions affecting shared resources.

Liturgical Evolution

Initial Form: Book of Divine Worship

The Book of Divine Worship constituted the first official liturgical provision for Anglican Use Catholics, adapting elements of the Anglican Book of Common Prayer to align with Roman Catholic doctrine and rubrics following the Pastoral Provision of 1980. This book primarily drew from the 1979 edition of the Book of Common Prayer used in the Episcopal Church, incorporating the Roman Canon in place of Anglican Eucharistic prayers and inserting other mandatory Catholic texts, such as the filioque clause in the Creed, while preserving much of the Elizabethan-era English phrasing and structure characteristic of Anglican patrimony. Approved by the Congregation for Divine Worship and the Discipline of the Sacraments on February 22, , the Book of Divine Worship authorized the use of this hybrid liturgy for ordained former Anglican clergy and their communities entering with the . Despite this approval, a printed edition was not released until 2003, published by Newman House Press in , with 974 pages encompassing the Ordinary and Propers, sacramental rites including , , and , and selections from the Divine . In the interim two decades, Anglican Use groups relied on mimeographed or photocopied provisional texts based on the 1983 authorization. The emphasized a sacral, poetic English , retaining "thee" and "thou" pronouns and rhythmic collects from the 1549 and 1662 Prayer Books, blended with post-Vatican II reforms to ensure compatibility with the Novus Ordo Missae. This form facilitated the transition for Anglican converts by maintaining familiar devotional elements, such as the and traditional hymns, while mandating Catholic-specific doctrines like in funeral rites and the of . Employed exclusively in the handful of U.S. Anglican Use parishes under the Pastoral Provision—numbering around a dozen by the early —the Book of Divine Worship remained in limited use until its gradual replacement by the revised Divine Worship: The Missal promulgated in 2015 for the Personal Ordinariates.

Revised Form: Divine Worship: The Missal (2015)

Divine Worship: The Missal, promulgated in 2015, serves as the definitive for the Ordinary Form of Mass within the Personal Ordinariates established under Anglicanorum coetibus, incorporating Anglican patrimony into the . It replaced the provisional Book of Divine Worship of 2003, which had been authorized under the Pastoral Provision for limited U.S. use, by providing a unified, Vatican-approved text for global Ordinariate communities. The missal's development involved collaboration between Ordinariate bishops and the Congregation for Divine Worship and the Discipline of the Sacraments, ensuring conformity to Catholic doctrine while preserving distinctive Anglican elements such as rhythmic prose in collects and poetic scriptural renderings from the and . Approval for liturgical use commenced on the First Sunday of Advent, November 29, 2015, following recognition ad experimentum and subsequent definitive promulgation by ecclesiastical authority. The text draws from the post-Vatican II Order of Mass in the third edition of the (2002 Latin typical edition), adapted with sources including the 1928 and 1962 American Books of Common Prayer, the English Missal, and other Anglican liturgical traditions, totaling over 40 distinct influences harmonized for orthodoxy. Key revisions from the 2003 book addressed inconsistencies, such as standardizing rubrics for the Roman Canon (now the primary Eucharistic Prayer, with options for II-IV), clarifying seasonal propers, and integrating updated saints' feasts compatible with the , while eliminating provisional elements like optional Sarum usages. The missal's structure mirrors the Roman Missal but features Anglican-derived fixed texts, including the Prayer of Humble Access ("We do not presume to come to this thy Table, O merciful Lord...") inserted before Communion and a unique summary of the faith in the Gloria and Creed. Propers retain Elizabethan English cadences, such as "The Lord be with you" responses, and include appendices for Anglican saints like Charles Stuart (martyred 1649) and John Keble (d. 1866), vetted for doctrinal soundness. A 2020 revised edition added propers for St. John Henry Newman following his canonization on October 13, 2019, without altering the core form. Printed editions, such as those from the Catholic Truth Society, include leather bindings, gilt edges, and ribbons for practical parish use, with pew missals derived directly from the approved text. This form underscores the Ordinariates' role in enriching the Roman Rite, as affirmed by the missal's recognitio, which mandates its exclusive use for Ordinariate Masses.

Complementary: Divine Worship: The Divine Office

Divine Worship: The Divine Office, formally titled Divine Worship: Daily Office, constitutes the authorized liturgical text for the in the Personal Ordinariates established under the Anglicanorum Coetibus. It preserves distinctive Anglican patrimony in the structure and language of the offices, drawing principally from the tradition, while integrating scriptural readings, patristic homilies, and hagiographical texts aligned with the . The volume supports both private recitation and communal celebration, facilitating the "daily offering of Morning and Evening Prayer" in parishes and religious communities of the Ordinariates. Development of the book succeeded the 2003 Book of Divine Worship, which provisionally included Anglican-derived offices under the Pastoral Provision, by standardizing and expanding the form post-2009. Publication occurred in two regional editions: the North American Edition, issued by the , and the Commonwealth Edition, released by the Catholic Truth Society on 15 September 2021. These editions accommodate variations in lectionary cycles and proper collects, with the North American version emphasizing compatibility with U.S. liturgical norms. The texts received recognitio from the , confirming their orthodoxy and suitability for Ordinariate use as a complement to Divine Worship: The Missal. Core contents center on Morning Prayer () and Evening Prayer (), featuring the Coverdale Psalter for psalmody, invariant canticles such as the , Benedictus, and , and collects retaining Elizabethan-era phrasing where doctrinally unproblematic. Lesser hours—Prime, , , None, and —are optionally included, with rubrics permitting abbreviated forms for lay use. Seasonal propers encompass Advent, , and feast days, incorporating Anglican hymns and anthems alongside Catholic sanctoral observances. Scriptural readings follow a semi-continuous cycle, supplemented by Office of Readings material from like St. Augustine and St. Leo the Great. This liturgical provision underscores the Ordinariates' role in enriching the universal Church with "treasures of the Anglican tradition," including rhythmic prose and poetic suffrages that foster contemplative prayer, distinct from the post-Vatican II Roman Liturgy of the Hours. Critics within traditionalist circles have noted its retention of certain Reformation-era phrasings, such as in the Litany, as potentially diluting patristic purity, though proponents argue these elements, purged of heterodox implications, enhance devotional accessibility. Membership trends indicate growing adoption, with Ordinariate communities reporting increased Office recitations since 2021, aiding spiritual formation amid conversions.

Distinctive Patrimony and Theological Integration

Retained Anglican Liturgical and Spiritual Elements

The Apostolic Constitution Anglicanorum Coetibus (2009) explicitly authorizes the Personal Ordinariates to employ liturgical books drawn from the Anglican tradition, approved by the , for the celebration of the and other sacraments, thereby preserving the liturgical, spiritual, and pastoral patrimony of the as a means to nourish Catholic faith. This patrimony manifests in Divine Worship: The Missal (promulgated 2015), which integrates elements from historic Anglican sources, including the Book of Common Prayer (1549, 1662, and 1928 editions), while ensuring full conformity to Catholic doctrine. The rite thus retains a distinctive "Anglican inflection" in its sacral vernacular, distinguishing it from the standard . Key liturgical retentions include the use of "Prayer Book English," featuring archaic second-person pronouns such as "thee" and "thou" to evoke a reverent, poetic register refined over centuries in Anglican usage. Traditional Anglican collects, many authored by Thomas Cranmer in the 16th century, are preserved verbatim or with minimal adaptation, alongside sequences like the Summary of the Law, the Comfortable Words (post-absolution exhortations drawn from Scripture), and the Prayer of Humble Access before Communion, which emphasizes penitence in phrasing unique to the Book of Common Prayer. The overall structure echoes pre-Tridentine English rites (e.g., Sarum influences via Anglican intermediaries) blended with post-Reformation Anglican forms, including specific propers, hymns, and psalmody that prioritize rhythmic prose and scriptural resonance over modern simplifications. These elements foster a continuity with Anglican worship's emphasis on dignified ceremonial, choral tradition, and textual fidelity, as approved for Ordinariate use worldwide. Spiritually, the retained patrimony encompasses an Anglican ethos of patristic devotion, wherein early like Augustine and Chrysostom inform and , reflecting the Anglican appeal to as a between and tradition. This includes pastoral practices such as corporate confession with lay participation, robust scriptural lectio in the (Divine Worship: The Divine Office), and devotional emphases on the and sacraments through poetry and prose inherited from Anglican divines, all reoriented to affirm Catholic teachings on the Real Presence and . Such elements serve not as concessions but as enriched expressions of Catholic universality, sharing Anglican-sourced treasures like ' preces privatae or Newman's spiritual writings to deepen communal prayer and evangelization.

Adaptations for Catholic Orthodoxy

The Anglican Use liturgies adapt elements from Anglican sources, such as the and , by subordinating them to norms, ensuring doctrinal conformity in areas like , , and the veneration of saints. A primary adaptation is the normative use of the Roman Canon for the Eucharistic Prayer in both the Book of Divine Worship (1994) and Divine Worship: The Missal (2015), which articulates the oblation of the one sacrifice of Christ and the of the elements, avoiding the memorialist or interpretations possible in Cranmer's 1549 or 1552 prayers that influenced Anglican eucharistic rites. An alternative, Eucharistic Prayer II, is permitted for shorter Masses, but the Roman Canon predominates to safeguard the Church's teaching on the Real Presence and propitiatory sacrifice. Doctrinal safeguards extend to creedal and devotional elements: the includes the clause, affirming the Holy Spirit's procession from the Father and the Son, and is followed by a penitential emphasizing corporate without implying standalone absolution outside . Prayers like the and invocations of saints' are retained from Anglican patrimony but reframed to align with Catholic , excluding any ambiguity on merits or . The Anglicanae Traditiones Commission, established post-2009, reviewed texts from 1549 onward, selecting only those compatible with Catholic faith while discarding Protestant-leaning formulations that could undermine or the sacrificial priesthood. Sacramental adaptations reinforce orthodoxy, as in the rites for , matrimony, and funerals compiled in Divine Worship: Occasional Services (2017), which integrate Anglican phrasing with Roman norms—such as affirming marriage's indissolubility and the of the body—preventing divergences seen in some Anglican revisions permitting or downplaying eschatological . The liturgical preserves Catholic feasts while adapting Anglican seasons like Trinitytide, ensuring no erosion of doctrines like the or . These changes, approved by the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith and Dicastery for Divine , position Anglican Use as a pastoral variant of the , not a hybrid rite, prioritizing causal fidelity to Catholic over ecumenical compromise.

Reception, Achievements, and Criticisms

Achievements in Conversions and Liturgical Enrichment

The establishment of the Personal Ordinariates under Anglicanorum Coetibus has enabled the corporate reception of Anglican clergy and communities into full Catholic communion, preserving their distinctive patrimony as an incentive for conversion. In the United States and , the Ordinariate of the , erected in 2012, grew to encompass 11,255 faithful, 81 priests, and seven seminarians by August 2024, reflecting sustained expansion from initial Anglican groups seeking unity with Rome. This structure facilitated the entry of entire parishes, such as those from the and Continuing Anglican bodies, distinguishing it from isolated individual conversions and providing clerical continuity through the ordination of former Anglican ministers. In , the of , formed on January 15, 2011, incorporated around 900 initial converts, including 50 clergy announced in November 2010, with membership reaching approximately 1,850 lay faithful and 97 priests by 2019. The Australian ordinariate, established in 2012, similarly absorbed groups like the Traditional Anglican Communion, contributing to modest but targeted influxes amid broader Anglican dissatisfaction with doctrinal shifts on issues such as and . These achievements underscore the ordinariates' role in fulfilling repeated Anglican petitions for reunion, as noted in the itself, without diluting Catholic orthodoxy. Liturgically, the Anglican Use has enriched the by integrating select Anglican elements—such as the rhythmic prose of the and a profusion of Scripture—into a revised form, as formalized in Divine Worship: The promulgated on Advent 2015. This , the first original for the Latin since the post-Vatican II reforms, restores pre-Reformation English Catholic traditions preserved in Anglican sources, offering the universal Church a poetic, reverent alternative that emphasizes eucharistic centrality and choral prayer like Evening Prayer. Its adoption has promoted "mutual enrichment," attracting Latin-Rite Catholics to its sacral language and structure, thereby broadening liturgical options without supplanting the ordinary form. This development, hailed as a "momentous" contribution to Catholic , demonstrates how Anglican patrimony can vitalize Roman liturgical expression while ensuring doctrinal fidelity.

Criticisms from Traditional Catholic and Remaining Anglican Viewpoints

Traditional Catholics have expressed reservations about the Personal Ordinariates' approach to the of former Anglican , emphasizing the enduring declaration in (1896) that Anglican orders are "absolutely null and utterly void" owing to defects in form and intention, a position reaffirmed in subsequent documents such as Ad Tuendam Fidem (1998) and (2000). The practice of conditional —administered only sub conditione to those uncertain of their prior validity—is seen as untenable, as it requires the to assess individual cases amid Anglicanism's historically deficient sacramental intent, as evidenced by the (1570), thereby introducing ambiguity into conversions and potentially eroding the clarity of full submission to Catholic authority. Liturgically, the Anglican Use, particularly as codified in Divine Worship: The Missal (promulgated 2015), draws criticism for its hybrid character, blending Cranmerian texts with post-Vatican II elements like Eucharistic Prayer II, Memorial Acclamations, and a Novus Ordo-style ; detractors label this a "frankenliturgy," arguing it produces a disjointed that neither faithfully retrieves pre-Reformation Anglican patrimony nor aligns with the integrity of the traditional Roman liturgy. Such integrations, including the relocation of feasts like the to Sundays and the imposition of a // hierarchy, are faulted for imposing non-Anglican structures that compromise the purported goal of preserving a distinct spiritual heritage. Objections also extend to nomenclature, with some Catholics decrying the retention of "Anglican" descriptors for the Ordinariates' communities and , as the evokes Protestant origins tied to the and Henry VIII's schism, fostering confusion among the faithful who perceive it as endorsing a "Protestant Catholic" hybrid incompatible with Roman orthodoxy; official documents like Anglicanorum Coetibus (2009) avoid such labeling, favoring terms that underscore full Catholic communion. Among remaining Anglicans, especially traditionalists within the Church of England or continuing jurisdictions, the Ordinariates are critiqued for precipitating schism and depleting conservative ranks, with initial UK defections of approximately 900 laity and 60 clergy by 2011 intensifying debates over women's ordination and doctrinal drift, though some bishops, like Christopher Hill of Guildford, welcomed the departures as a "sigh of relief" that alleviated parish tensions and allowed focus on broader Anglican priorities. Critics contend this structure incentivizes fragmentation, portraying Anglicanism as structurally deficient in retaining its patrimony without Roman oversight, and question the authenticity of the retained elements under papal jurisdiction, which mandates assent to doctrines like Marian dogmas that diverge from historic Anglican formularies.

Current Implementation and Prospects

Operational Ordinariates and Membership Trends

The three operational personal ordinariates established under the apostolic constitution Anglicanorum coetibus are the for former Anglicans in the United States and Canada (erected January 1, 2012), the for (erected January 15, 2011), and the for and associated territories including and (erected June 8, 2012). These structures function as diocesan equivalents, led by an with faculties (though not always a until recent appointments), and serve Anglicans entering with the [Catholic Church](/page/Catholic Church) while retaining elements of their liturgical patrimony. Membership across the ordinariates remains modest relative to broader Catholic populations but shows targeted growth in clerical and lay adherence. The Ordinariate of the reported 11,255 faithful, 81 priests, and seven seminarians as of 2024, supporting over 40 parishes and missions primarily in . In contrast, the Ordinariate of had approximately 97 priests and 1,850 lay members in 2019, with communities centered on fewer, established groups in the UK. The smallest, the Ordinariate of Our Lady of the Southern Cross, comprised 15 priests and two deacons in 2019, reflecting limited scale in and . Trends indicate steady, albeit incremental, expansion driven by individual conversions and clerical s rather than mass group entries, with the North American ordinariate demonstrating the most vitality through new formations and recruitment. Overall clerical numbers have increased to over 100 across the ordinariates since inception, fostering dedicated Anglican Use communities amid declining Anglican affiliations globally. Challenges include sustaining growth in regions with entrenched Anglican resistance and integrating former under conditional norms, yet the model persists as a niche provision for patrimony preservation without broader Catholic assimilation pressures.

Recent Developments and Potential Future Challenges

In June 2024, the in the received its first ordinary bishop, David Waller, ordained as titular Bishop of in on June 22. This appointment, supported by Cardinal , prefect of the Dicastery for Divine Worship, underscored the Vatican's ongoing commitment to the ordinariates amid broader liturgical restrictions elsewhere in the Church. Waller's installation addressed long-standing administrative needs, as previous leaders held only apostolic delegate status, limiting ordinations and governance. The Ordinariate of the in the United States and has shown signs of expansion, with reports of steady influxes from Anglican and continuing Anglican communities, contributing to its characterization as "" by late 2024. High-profile conversions persisted, such as that of former Anglican Richard Pain of , who entered on July 2, 2023, reflecting ongoing appeal amid Anglican internal divisions. Preparations for the 2025 Jubilee Year included tailored liturgical resources, such as an updated Ordo incorporating ordinariate-specific observances alongside universal Church elements. Looking ahead, the ordinariates face challenges in maintaining momentum as source Anglican bodies experience membership stagnation or decline, potentially limiting the pool of converts while demanding proactive outreach beyond traditional networks. Their small scale—typically numbering in the low thousands per ordinariate—poses risks of administrative strain, particularly with aging leadership and reliance on married clergy, whose succession remains confined to Anglican patrimony candidates under . Preservation of distinctive elements like Divine Worship could encounter tensions from evolving Roman liturgical norms or local diocesan integrations, though recent affirmations suggest short-term stability. Broader ecumenical shifts, including fractures, may indirectly bolster ordinariate viability by highlighting Catholic doctrinal coherence, but sustained growth will hinge on demonstrating the patrimony's vitality to younger Catholics unfamiliar with Anglican roots.

References

  1. [1]
    Anglicanorum coetibus Providing for Personal Ordinariates for ...
    Nov 4, 2009 · Providing for personal ordinariates for Anglicans entering into full Communion with the Catholic Church.
  2. [2]
    Divine Worship: The Missal - Ordinariate of the Chair of Saint Peter
    Dr. Brand: Divine Worship: The Missal is representative of the Anglican tradition, as expressed in many different countries, conformed to the Catholic faith. It ...
  3. [3]
    Pastoral Provision – Petition for Ordination as Roman Catholic Priests
    The Pastoral Provision has over a thirty year history of assisting individual Episcopal priests answer the call to enter into full communion with the Catholic ...History · Discernment of Priestly Vocation · FAQs · Steps of the Process
  4. [4]
    Anglicanorum coetibus Providing for Personal Ordinariates for Anglicans Entering into Full Communion with the Catholic Church (November 4, 2009)
    ### Key Provisions on Liturgical Use and Heritage Preservation
  5. [5]
    40th Anniversary of the Pastoral Provision and the Anglican Use
    Jun 16, 2020 · While the Anglican Use took shape in the 1980s, its actual publication in the Book of Divine Worship didn't occur until 2003, and as is now well ...
  6. [6]
    Complementary Norms for the Apostolic Constitution Anglicanorum ...
    Nov 4, 2009 · ... Anglicanorum coetibus. §2. The Ordinary is a member of the respective Episcopal Conference. Article 3. The Ordinary, in the exercise of this ...
  7. [7]
    Complementary Norms for the Apostolic Constitution Anglicanorum ...
    Mar 19, 2019 · ... Anglicanorum coetibus. § 2. The Ordinary is a member of the respective Episcopal Conference. Article 3. The Ordinary, in the exercise of this ...
  8. [8]
    History - The Order of Corporate Reunion
    The Order of Corporate Reunion was established in 1874 to promote the restoration of the Church of England to apostolic unity with the universal Church.Missing: 1980 | Show results with:1980
  9. [9]
    CATHOLIC ENCYCLOPEDIA: Anglican Orders - New Advent
    And the practice thus initiated during the reign of Mary was adhered to ever afterwards, when Anglican clergymen came over to the Catholic Church and sought ...
  10. [10]
    History of the OCR — Order of Corporate Reunion
    The history of the Order of Corporate Reunion (OCR) is intimately connected to the Oxford Movement, the Roman Catholic Church, the Anglican Church, and the Old ...
  11. [11]
    Roman Catholic Corporate Reunion Succession
    The dispute over the validity of Anglican orders produced a desire among some in the Church of England for orders that Rome would be compelled to acknowledge as
  12. [12]
    1921-1927 - Malines conversations group
    The Malines Conversations, held in Mechelen (Malines) Belgium from 1921 to 1927, were a series of five church unity conversations exploring possibilities of ...
  13. [13]
    The Maline Conversations - Garrowby Churches
    The Malines Conversations were a series of five informal ecumenical conversations held from 1921 to 1927 which explored possibilities for the corporate reunion
  14. [14]
    [PDF] The History of the 1980 Anglican Pastoral Provision
    Influences on the Pastoral Provision​​ conceived as an ecumenical initiative in the spirit of Vatican council ii, its establishment reflected the character of ...
  15. [15]
    New ordinariate and 1980 pastoral provision: An analysis
    Jan 23, 2012 · The 1980 provision was aimed chiefly at meeting requests of individual Anglican clergy. It allowed exemptions from celibacy for those who were married.
  16. [16]
    [PDF] Into Full Communion Pastoral Provision for former clergy of the ...
    These decisions were approved by His Holiness Pope John Paul II in the audience granted to the undersigned Cardinal Prefect of the Congregation on June 20, 1980 ...
  17. [17]
    History - Pastoral Provision
    The Delegate developed a proposal that defined the process by which married former Episcopal clergymen, sponsored by a diocesan bishop, could become priests.
  18. [18]
    The Pastoral Provision for Roman Catholics in the U.S.A.
    Aug 18, 2011 · The decree of the Congregation was approved by Pope John Paul II on June 20. 1980 and communicated to Archbishop Quinn as the President of ...
  19. [19]
    Pastoral Provision in the Catholic Church Might Offer Hope to ...
    Called a “pastoral provision,” the arrangement allows Anglican clergy and lay people to retain their Anglican heritage and traditions but enter into full ...
  20. [20]
    How does the Pastoral Provision work? - Catholic Telegraph
    Jul 3, 2014 · The Pastoral Provision, approved by Pope St. John Paul II in 1980, provides a framework wherein a former Episcopal priest may be ordained, after a time, as a ...
  21. [21]
    The Anglican Rite - Crisis Magazine
    Jul 1, 2007 · When the Pastoral Provision was first established in 1980, permission for married Protestant pastors to be ordained was only part of the plan.
  22. [22]
    U.S. Catholic ordinariate for former Anglicans formed
    Jan 2, 2012 · More than a dozen Catholic communities of Anglican Use have been formed under that pastoral provision since 1980, including several that are ...
  23. [23]
    Anglicanorum Coetibus: Questions & Answers | USCCB
    This is an apostolic constitution issued by Pope Benedict XVI in November 2009 that authorized the creation of ordinariates, geographic regions similar to ...Missing: summary | Show results with:summary
  24. [24]
    Fully Catholic, Anglican tradition
    The Ordinariate was established on 15 January 2011 as a direct result of the Apostolic Constitution, 'Anglicanorum coetibus' issued by Pope Benedict XVI. As ...Our Mission · What Is The Ordinariate? · About The Ordinariate
  25. [25]
    Our Story - The Personal Ordinariate of Our Lady of Walsingham
    The Personal Ordinariate of Our Lady of Walsingham was erected by decree of the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith on the same day, and the then Fr ...An Invitation From The Pope · Received Into Full Communion · A Bishop For The Ordinariate
  26. [26]
    Press Release - Ordinariate of the Chair of Saint Peter
    Nov 24, 2015 · The Personal Ordinariate of the Chair of St. Peter was established by Pope Benedict on Jan. 1, 2012, with its headquarters located in Houston, ...Missing: date | Show results with:date
  27. [27]
    Anglican Patrimony in the Catholic Church | Houston, Texas
    Anglicanorum coetibus (Groups of Anglicans, Nov. 4, 2009) is the Apostolic Constitution of Pope Benedict XVI that established “Personal Ordinariates” for ...
  28. [28]
    [PDF] Personal Ordinariate of the Chair of St. Peter - usccb
    Feb 18, 2013 · The Personal Ordinariate of the Chair of St. Peter is a national structure for former Anglican communities seeking to become Catholic, ...
  29. [29]
    Personal Ordinariate of Our Lady of the Southern Cross
    Type of Jurisdiction: Personal Ordinariate · Erected: 15 June 2012 · Immediately Subject to the Holy See · Depends on: Dicastery for the Doctrine of the Faith ...
  30. [30]
    About Us | The Personal Ordinariate of Our Lady of the Southern Cross
    The Personal Ordinariate of Our Lady of the Southern Cross was erected by Pope Benedict XVI with the the Decree of Erection signed by William Cardinal Levada.
  31. [31]
    Head of Australian ordinariate to step down - The Pillar
    Apr 21, 2023 · The Personal Ordinariate of Our Lady of the Southern Cross was created on June 15, 2012, in the wake of Pope Benedict XVI's 2009 apostolic ...
  32. [32]
    [PDF] The Holy See
    Mar 19, 2022 · It is also responsible for erecting military Ordinariates as well as personal Ordinariates for the Anglican faithful who enter into full ...
  33. [33]
    Fr. Christopher Phillips on the Ordinariate Liturgy
    Oct 7, 2011 · Philiips details some of the history of the Book of Divine Worship (the liturgical book used by Anglican Use Catholics of the "Pastoral ...
  34. [34]
    Review: Divine Worship Daily Office (North American Edition)
    Jul 29, 2021 · The Book of Divine Worship, approved in 1983 and published twenty years later was really only a version of the 1979 Prayer Book with the Roman ...<|separator|>
  35. [35]
    The Book of Divine Worship: Being Elements of the ... - Amazon.com
    Book details · Print length. 974 pages · Language. English · Publisher. Newman House Press · Publication date. January 1, 2003 · Dimensions. 10 x 6.8 x 2.6 inches.<|separator|>
  36. [36]
    The Anglican Use Mass - Held By His Pierced Hands
    Sep 20, 2012 · The Anglican use Mass celebrated by the Ordinariate is not a rite distinct from the Roman rite the way that the Melkite or Ruthenian is.Missing: definition | Show results with:definition<|separator|>
  37. [37]
    A Defense of the Ordinariate Liturgy's Authenticity
    Aug 14, 2021 · Some have concerns about the nature of the Book of Divine Worship ... This is partly due the peculiar history of Anglo-Catholic groups within the ...
  38. [38]
    A Defense of the Anglican Ordinariate in the Catholic Church
    May 30, 2022 · In the Catholic Church, the Anglican Ordinariate essentially refers to former Anglican, now-Catholics who have brought many (not all) of ...
  39. [39]
    Introducing Divine Worship: the Missal - An FAQ on the Ordinariate ...
    Nov 4, 2015 · Wednesday, November 04, 2015. Introducing Divine Worship: the Missal - An FAQ on the Ordinariate Missal. Gregory DiPippo. Today is the sixth ...
  40. [40]
    https://www.ctsbooks.org/product/divine-worship-the-ordinariate-missal/
  41. [41]
    Liturgy | Houston, Texas - Ordinariate of the Chair of Saint Peter
    Divine Worship: The Missal is the Ordinariate's book of liturgical texts for the celebration of Mass. The missal has been approved and promulgated by the ...
  42. [42]
    Divine Worship: Daily Office - CUAPress
    This book is intended not only for the private devotion of individuals, but also for the establishment of the daily offering of Morning and Evening Prayer in ...
  43. [43]
    https://www.ctsbooks.org/product/daily-office/
  44. [44]
    Divine Worship: Daily Office - Real Clear Catholic
    Apr 28, 2022 · It's a Vatican-approved version of the Divine Office (or Liturgy of the Hours) that's based exclusively on the English Patrimony.
  45. [45]
    Divine Worship : Daily Office — A short guide
    This post is a potted précis of how to pray the Offices, either in a short form or in the Prayer Book tradition. It's for laypeople: clergy know what to do!
  46. [46]
    Anglican Tradition Enriches Catholic Devotion in the Daily Office
    Nov 24, 2024 · The Liturgy of the ... Each psalm and canticle has its Latin title, meaning there's more Latin in the Anglican use than in the Latin Rite.
  47. [47]
    Ordinariate 'Commonwealth' Daily Office to Inspire Prayer ...
    Divine Worship: Daily Office (Commonwealth Edition) will be available later in 2021. Given the current situation, this is as precise as it gets at present, but ...
  48. [48]
    [PDF] Volume LI October 2015 - usccb
    The first book approved under the new provisions of Anglicanorum cœtibus was the. 2014 Divine Worship: Occasional Services, containing rituals for baptisms, ...
  49. [49]
    None
    ### Summary of Doctrinal/Theological Adaptations in Divine Worship
  50. [50]
    Ordinariate Use unites Anglican tradition to Catholic Church
    Oct 15, 2013 · The introduction of a new Ordinariate Use liturgy for groups of former Anglicans is uniting some of their old traditions to the fullness of the Catholic Church.
  51. [51]
    What is the Ordinariate of the Chair of Saint Peter and why is it ...
    Aug 12, 2024 · Just over 10 years after its founding, the Ordinariate of the Chair of Saint Peter numbers 11,255 faithful, 81 priests, seven seminarians, and ...
  52. [52]
    50 clergy to join ordinariate | Thinking Anglicans
    Nov 14, 2010 · “The Catholic Church will announce this week that 50 Anglican clergy are defecting to Rome following the Church of England's moves to introduce ...
  53. [53]
    The UK Ordinariate and resistance to the Synod - Where Peter Is
    Nov 11, 2022 · Recent figures have shown that their numbers are modest. In 2019 the OOLW was reported to have 97 priests and 1,850 lay members, meaning that ...
  54. [54]
    Our Lady's Dowry: New Ordinariate Missal Makes Advent History
    Nov 27, 2015 · The new Divine Worship missal restores all of England's Catholic patrimony from Anglican tradition and is the Holy Father's gift to them and the entire Church.
  55. [55]
    Why Divine Worship: The Missal is so Important - Chant Café
    Nov 12, 2015 · The Missal is important as the first original missal since 45 years, integrating pre-Tridentine elements, and as a result of Pope Benedict XVI' ...
  56. [56]
    Our Prayer and Liturgy
    Rooted in the Catholic faith and enriched by the Anglican tradition, Divine Worship offers a reverent, poetic, and Scripture-filled approach to the Mass and the ...
  57. [57]
    Over 12 years, Pope Francis made a significant impact on the ...
    May 1, 2025 · The ordinariates' “Divine Worship” liturgical books authorized by Pope Francis “represent a momentous development in the history of Catholic ...Missing: influence | Show results with:influence
  58. [58]
    The Invalidity of Anglican Orders and the Ordinariate of the Chair of ...
    Sep 22, 2013 · Second, the view that Anglican orders could be valid is especially inconsistent with Catholic conversion. Third, conditional ordination would ...
  59. [59]
    On Use of the Word “Anglican” in Reference to the Ordinariates
    Jan 15, 2019 · Some Catholics have no problem with using the word “Anglican” as a prefix to describe the type of liturgy and customs associated with such ordinariates.
  60. [60]
    Common sense about the Ordinariate | Thinking Anglicans
    Apr 24, 2011 · ... Ordinariate offers these 900 converts that the RC church before the ordinariate didn't. Why did they wait for the ordinariate if they ...
  61. [61]
    Vatican issues updated norms for personal ordinariates
    The ordinariates are led by an ordinary, who has the powers of a bishop, but may not necessarily be ordained a bishop. If the cleric chosen is a married former ...
  62. [62]
    [PDF] The Ordinariate Observer
    The presbyterate of the Ordinariate of Our Lady of the Southern Cross is comprised of 15 priests(including Msgr. Reid) and two deacons. The Southern Cross ...
  63. [63]
    The ordinariate has grown significantly in the past 13 years - Facebook
    it has more than 100 clerics, and a big place in the life of the Church in the ...Growth of Anglican Ordinariate Communities Across the GlobeAnglican Church Decline and Ordinariate Growth - FacebookMore results from www.facebook.comMissing: operational | Show results with:operational
  64. [64]
    Why the Ordinariates? - Crisis Magazine
    Aug 18, 2022 · Under persecution and defeat, their liturgical and intellectual life suffered. Rather than much outward display, they instead reflected an ...
  65. [65]
    British bishop's historic ordination shows Rome's strong support for ...
    Jun 26, 2024 · Bishop David Waller delivers his first homily as bishop of the London-based Personal Ordinariate of Our Lady of Walsingham, in Westminster Cathedral, London.<|control11|><|separator|>
  66. [66]
    Ordinariate is here to stay, declares cardinal - Church Times
    Jul 5, 2024 · A senior Vatican official has given fresh backing to the Personal Ordinariate of Our Lady of Walsingham, the diocese created in 2011 for Anglicans.Other Stories · Dr Jo Bailey Wells To Aid... · World<|separator|>
  67. [67]
    The UK ordinariate is getting a bishop. But what exactly is it?
    Jun 19, 2024 · A bishop can ordain men to the priesthood for the personal ordinariate, while a monsignor must arrange for a bishop to preside at ordinations.Missing: trends | Show results with:trends
  68. [68]
    What is the Ordinariate of the Chair of Saint Peter and why is it ...
    Aug 12, 2024 · The Ordinariate of the Chair of Saint Peter is a unique diocese in the Catholic Church, offering a pathway for former Anglicans to join the ...Missing: trends | Show results with:trends
  69. [69]
    Anglican ordinariate - Latest news
    The Right Rev. Richard Pain, who served as the Anglican Bishop of Monmouth, will join the Catholic Church on Sunday, July 2, 2023.
  70. [70]
    Ordo | Houston, Texas - Ordinariate of the Chair of Saint Peter
    Jubilee 2025 · Holy Days of Obligation · Special Days in the Life of the Ordinariate · Ember Days · Ordo · Divine Worship: The Missal · Divine Worship: Daily Office ...
  71. [71]
    https://www.pillarcatholic.com/p/whats-happening-to-the-anglican-communion